Upload
valentino-pellegrino
View
223
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
1/25
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
2/25
Nkjnmo
• Hgppg mckmottugao 7
• Nktrcjuzncko 2
• Ag insnmg joaag anbortä6 jotorhnknshc vs nkjotorhnkgzncko :
• Jgkto6 anborc grbntrnc o prosmnokzg jnvnkg 5
• Lgkt6 anbortä o aoeeo hcrgao
• !cppor6 "kuvcao# o "crcacen#$ ag scauzncko joa juganshc 77
• Nktrcjuzncko ga %!grgjnso Acst% 7:
• >gkg$ a%orco joaag anbortä 7'
• >gk gkj %()o *crsgnr%6 t)o +,rcknm )orc 7-
• .ustgvo Jcr/ o ag soksnbnantä rchgktnmg 24
• +nbancerging 2:
7
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
3/25
Nktrcjuzncko
Nk uostn mnkuo trgvgeangtn gkkn jg anmogao ag hng porsckg$ koa boko o koa hgao$ sn /
ovcautg prcickjghokto o jn mcksoeuokzg sn sckc svnauppgtn n hnon nktorossn o ao hno
ghbnznckn Jg uk%nkigtugzncko ugsn roanencsg por ag smnokzg$ sckc pgssgtc g kutrnro
uk%nktorosso pn= vnvnjc vorsc na hckjc g ho mnrmcstgkto$ enukeokjc$ sporc
joinkntnvghokto$ gaao juo pgssnckn suaao ugan prceottc jn ojninmgro na hnc gvvoknro6 ag
pcantnmg o a%omckchng aac stossc hcjc$ )c gvutc a%cppcrtukntä jn giinkgro n hnon eustn
porsckgan$ nk pgrtnmcagro rnsmcprokjc ag boaaozzg joaa%grto o joaag muaturg uhgknstnmg
Jurgkto uostc pormcrsc nktorncro$ sckc stgtn juo$ su tuttn$ n uosntn su mun pn= sposscsn / sciiorhgtg ag hng rnmormg inacscinmg Jnc osnsto? *csg jnstnkeuo kcn uchnkn jgaao
hgmm)nko?
!ur rnkukmngkjc gaag prosukzncko jn smcprnro ag vorntä gsscautg m)o sn moag jnotrc tgan
uostnckn$ m)o jg sohpro )gkkc tcrhoktgtc na poksnorc joaa%uchc o m)o gkmcrg g
aukec mcktnkuorgkkc g igrac$ )c tuttgvng trcvgtc ukg rnspcstg nk ergjc jn pagmgro
a%gppotntc joaag hng hokto
*n9 m)o rokjo a%uchc uknmc koaa%uknvorsc / ag igmcatä m)o jä na tntcac g uostg
trgttgzncko$ na Anborc rbntrnc$ ergzno gaag ugao mn / rosc pcssnbnao a%gttc osmausnvc joaag
jomnsncko Ag kcstrg gutcmcsmnokzg mn rokjo nkigttn nk ergjc jn ohgkmnpgrmn jgaag
hgtorng$ mchpnokjc joaao smoato mcksgpovcan o nkjnpokjoktn jgaao icrzo mnrmcstgktn
Na Anborc rbntrnc$ tuttgvng$ mn mcstrnkeo$ g hnc pgroro$ g rninutgro na pcstuagtc joaag kck
osnstokzg jn Jnc o g prokjoro nk mcksnjorgzncko a%npctosn m)o mn sng jgvvorc uk%oktntä
suporncro m)o )g josnekgtc a%uchc mcho jostnkgtgrnc jn ukg mckjnzncko prnvnaoengtg
rnspottc ga rostc joaag kgturg J%gatrckjo$ na Anborc rbntrnc trcvg suiinmnokto rnsmcktrc
koaa%ovnjokzg ohpnrnmg$ g jniiorokzg joaa%gtonshc$ m)o pu9 ossoro scstokutc scatgktc nk
vng joa tuttc npctotnmg
Jn soeuntc trgttor9 jukuo joa ickjghoktc smnoktninmc joaag anbortä$ kckm)0 jn mcho
ossg sn mcaacmg nk gamuko tgppo jn uoa aukec pormcrsc m)o / ag stcrng joa poksnorc
uhgkc
2
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
4/25
>
CkoigtgaZroot`orostgkjsciLkcwaojeomgaa'j
Icrbnjjokt`ohtctgsto6Lkcwaojeoicrbnjj'k3
]uspnmncus,rogsckaoss.U`s`cuajt`nr!crj
"k#not`oht`gt3mgkntbosnktc$kcw,
%gkntbojogt`3gkjjct`ockoastgkj
&ekcrgkmo,nst`gtt`nr`gppnostgto,
Z`oprccicit`nrcbojnokmogkjt ǹrignt`3:'7:'24
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
5/25
Ag insnmg joaag anbortä6
jotorhnknshc vs nkjotorhnkgzncko
1ck ossokjc g hnc pgroro pcssnbnao trgttgro nk hgknorg nktoaaottugahokto mcrrottg uk
ugasngsn grechoktc sokzg m)o ossc vokeg scrrottc jg scanjo bgsn smnoktninm)o$ nktokjc
nknzngro uostg jnssortgzncko prosoktgkjc ag uostncko joa Anborc rbntrnc koa mcktostc
juganstnmc nk mun / mckinkgtc jgaag insnmg mcktohpcrgkog Na juganshc nk uostncko /
jgtc jg juo mckmoznckn por mortn vorsn gktntotnm)o joaag rogatä6 na jotorhnknshc
hommgknmnstg o a%nkjotorhnkgzncko
*ckvnktc igutcro joaag prnhg vnsncko / na moaoborrnhc
insnmc tocrnmc &top)ok 8g;3nke$ m)o joa suc gtonshc
kocpcsntnvnstg )g jg sohpro igttc ukg bgkjnorg Dean
ospcko ag prcprng nktorprotgzncko joa mckmottc jn
Anborc rbntrnc nk hgknorg ospanmntg o poroktcrng$ ugsn
rgsoktgkjc ag agpnjgrnotä$ koa sgeenc %Na ergkjo jnsoekc%
joa 2474 8g;3nke sn gppoaag un ga prnkmnpnc jn !norro
&nhck Agpagmo somckjc mun$ jgtc ac stgtc joaa%uknvorsc g uk mortc nstgkto$ uk nksnoho
mchpaotc jn aoeen jotorhnkorobbo tctgahokto sng na iuturc m)o na pgssgtc Jga
hchoktc m)o a%uchc vnvo koaa%uknvorsc$ uostg aoeeo kck pu9 kck vgaoro gkm)o por
ossc 1ckcstgkto gbbnghc a%nhprossncko jn pctor prokjoro anborghokto joaao
jomnsnckn$ jukuo$ n prcmossn bncacenmn m)o sn hgkniostgkc koa kcstrc morvoaac sckc
ecvorkgtn jgaao aoeen joaag insnmg o joaag m)nhnmg$ o portgktc rnsuatgkc nkovntgbnahoktoprojotorhnkgtn D% unkjn jniinmnao$ somckjc ac smnokzngtc nkeaoso$ nhhgenkgro mcho
pcssg cporgro na Anborc rbntrnc so na kcstrc mchpcrtghoktc / jotorhnkgtc jgaag aoeeo
insnmg !ortgktc$ oean mckmaujo m)o a%uchc kck / gatrc m)o ukg hgmm)nkg bncacenmg o
m)o na Anborc rbntrnc / scatgktc uk%naausncko mrogtg jgaag kcstrg hokto *n9 jn mun
8g;3nke kck tnoko mcktc nk uostg g prnhg vnstg nhpommgbnao gkgansn$ tuttgvng$ /
joaa%nktrnksomg nkjotorhnkgzncko joaag kgturg$ vgrgtg nk pgrtnmcagro$ koa somcac smcrsc$
:
]top`ok @gwlnke
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
6/25
jga Gprnkmnpnc j%nkjotorhnkgzncko jn 8onsokboreB Dssc pcko jon anhntn nkvganmgbnan gaag
kcstrg mckcsmokzg jon iokchokn insnmn g anvoaac ugktnstnmc$ n ugan jnvoktgkc$ jukuo$ g
jniiorokzg jn ugktc promojoktohokto stgbnantc jgaag insnmg ko;tckngkg$
nkjotorhnkgbnan
Mkg snekninmgtnvg trgspcsnzncko jn ugktc gppokg giiorhgtc sn trcvg koa sgeenc
%*ormgkjc Jnc koaa%uknvorsc% (cj's)kn#orso
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
7/25
Ct`orsgpgrtsgtckg+naarotnr'j,
kt`cue`tshcrooao#gto,gkjrogsck'j`ne`
Circ#njokmo,Icro$kcwaojeo,UnaagkjIgto,
In-tIgto,iroownaa,icro$kcwaojegbscauto, kjicukjkcokj,nkwgkjrnkehg/osacst.2''5'7
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
8/25
Jgkto6 anborc grbntrnc o prosmnokzg jnvnkg
Na jnbgttntc ekcsocacenmc suaag rogao kgturg joa
Anborc rbntrnc kck / mcsg m)o rneugrjgscatgktc kcn hcjorkn Euostg strgcrjnkgrng
igmcatä joaa%uchc )g jg sohpro susmntgtc
mcktrcvorsno$ gkm)o nk opcm)o ao mun prgtnm)o
jn poksnorc jchnkgktn sn jnsmcstgvgkc
kottghokto jgaag icrhg hoktns smnoktninmg
Mk m)ngrc osohpnc jn ugktc gppokg
giiorhgtc / ag mcktrgjjnzncko vokutgsn g
mrogro koaag tocinacscing smcagstnmg jn opcmg
hojnovgao$ trg na mckmottc jn Anborc rbntrnc o
na jcehg joaag prosmnokzg jnvnkg
Euostc promnsc tohg / jnsmussc gkm)o jga
schhc pcotg Jgkto ane)norn$ nk uoaa%nkgrrnvgbnao mckmoktrgtc jn smnbnao uhgkc m)o /
ag %Jnvnkg *chhojng% Nk pgrtnmcagro$ sckc juo n mgktn jn uost%cporg m)o giircktgkc nk
hgknorg gpprcickjntg na prcbaohg joaag vcacktä joaa%uchc 1oa sojnmosnhc mgktc joa
!uregtcrnc$ Jgkto giinjg gaag ineurg jn Hgrmc Achbgrjc$ gppgrtokokto gaag mcrknmo
joean nrgmckjn$ na mchpntc jn naaustrgro mcho ao gznckn uhgko kck vokegkc jotorhnkgto
jgean gstrn$ hg rnspckjgkc gaao jomnsnckn gutckcho joean uchnkn stossn
4cnm`o#n#otocekomgenckromgto
pursuscgamnoac,purmchosotuttc
hc#ossosomcjnkomossntgto.
]omcs7icsso,nk#cnicrgjnstruttc
anborcgrbntrnc,okckicrgenustn/ng
porbokaotn/ng,oporhgaog#orauttc. 552<
5
Nkmcktrc mck Mgmmngeunjg (Hcobnus)
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
9/25
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
10/25
Lgkt6 anbortä o aoeeo hcrgao
*ck ac smcpc jn rnscavoro a%gktnkchng otnmg jottgtg jgaa%nhpcssnbnantä jn mcknuegro ac
sicrzc jn ossoro vnrtucsn o ag rnmormg joaag ioanmntä$ rgeenukeokjc mcs na schhc boko$
Lgkt$ mcaacmgkjcsn nk ukg trgjnzncko jn poksnorc m)o vg jg !agtcko ga mrnstngkosnhc$
GpcstuagB uk hckjc koaa%gajnaä nk mun sng pcssnbnao roganzzgro ag sujjottg ougzncko
Lgkt icrhuag jukuo n tro pcstuagtn joaag rgenck
purg prgtnmg$ prcpcsnznckn kck jnhcstrgbnan$ boks
osneokzo nktorko joaag hcrgao m)o vokeckc
ghhosso ga inko jn rokjoro pcssnbnao ag rogatä joaag
hcrgao stossg
N prnhn juo pcstuagtn gj ossoro icrhuagtn sckc
a%nhhcrtgantä joaa%gknhg o a%osnstokzg jn Jnc
mmgktc g uostn juo pcstuagtn GroanencsnB$ Lgkt
pcko na pcstuagtc joaag anbort= Euostg / nkigttn
mckmopntg mcho ag mckjnzncko stossg joaa%otnmg$ ag
ugao$ koa hchoktc nk mun prosmrnvo na jcvoro$
prosuppcko gkm)o m)o sn pcssg genro c hokc nk mckicrhntä gj ossc
&o koaa%crjnko cktcacenmc ag anbortä / mckjnzncko joaag hcrgantä$ koaa%crjnko
ekcsocacenmc nkvomo na rgppcrtc sn nkvorto oj / ag aoeeo hcrgao g mcstntunro na
prosuppcstc joaag anbortä6
"
ag anbortä / sokzg jubbnc ag rgtncossokjn joaag aoeeo hcrgao$ hg F ag aoeeo hcrgao/ ag rgtncmcekcsmokjn joaag anbortä #
*rntnmg joaag rgenck prgtnmg$ G!roigznckoB
Lgkt scttcankog mcho a%uchc kck pctrobbo sgporo jn ossoro anborc so kck sn smcprnsso
cbbanegtc g soeunro ag aoeeo hcrgao6 so vn / ukg aoeeo hcrgao m)o prosmrnvo na jcvoro$
jovo por icrzg ossormn ag anbortä !ormn9$ kckcstgkto Lgkt sng mckvnktc joa
Nhhgkuoa Lgkt
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
11/25
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
12/25
!cppor6 "kuvcao# o "crcacen#$
ag scauzncko joa juganshc
Lgra !cppor giircktg na prcbaohg joaag anbortä
trgspckokjcac koa rgppcrtc trg hokto o mcrpc$ m)o oean
mcksnjorg na pn= grjuc jn tuttg ag inacscing o m)o sn rninutg
jn rnscavoro nk m)ngvo hgtornganstnmg Nkigttn$ pcnm)0
a%gutcmcsmnokzg uhgkg mcstntunsmo ukg trg ao mcso "pn=
strgcrjnkgrno o strgbnangktn koaa%uknvorsc#$ ukg tocrng
joaag kck osnstokzg joaag mcsmnokzg "kck / jg prokjoro
pn= sornghokto jn ukg tocrng joaag kck osnstokzg joaag
hgtorng#
nigmokjcsn g ukg scrtg jn juganshc mgrtosngkc jopurgtc jgaa%njog jn scstgkzg$ !cppor
jniokjo uk juganshc bgsgtc suaa%npctosn somckjc mun hokto o mcrpc$ pur icrhgkjc
juo KhckjnK jnstnktn$ rnsuatgkc nk uk rgppcrtc jn gzncko romnprcmg Nktorvokokjc suaag
enä trgttgtg jnsputg trg nkjotorhnknstn o jotorhnknstn$ !cppor pgrag jn "kuvcao# o
"crcacen# *ck ag prnhg nhhgenko nktokjo gaaujoro g snstohn insnmn gatghokto
nrroecagrn$ jnscrjnkgtn o pn= c hokc nhprovojnbnan *ck ag somckjg nktokjo gaaujoro g
snstohn insnmn roecagrn$ crjnkgtn o gatghokto provojnbnan Org$ so mck 1o;tck / provgasg
ag tosn jotorhnknstnmg$ somckjc ag ugao tutto ao kuvcao sckc crcacen$ mck na mrcaac joaag
insnmg magssnmg o mck na screoro joaag tocrng jon ugktn )g inkntc por giiorhgrsn ag
mckvnkzncko nkjotorhnknstnmg somckjc ag ugao tuttn ean crcacen sckc kuvcao D pcnm)0 najotorhnknshc$ scstokokjc m)o tuttn ean ovoktn joa hckjc insnmc sckc projotorhnkgtn
mck gsscautg promnsncko kon acrc jottgean nkinkntosnhgan$ jnstrueeo cekn njog jn
mrogtnvntä$ ko soeuo m)o a%nkjotorhnknshc rgpprosoktg uk prorounsntc komossgrnc$
gkm)o so kck gkmcrg suiinmnokto$ por cekn jcttrnkg joaag anbortä Nkigttn a%ghhnssncko
joa mgsc kck enustninmg$ jn por so stossg$ na mckmottc jn Anborc rbntrnc Oppckokjcsn g
uk tnpc jn nkjotorhnknshc m)o sn anhntg g scstntunro na sohpanmo mgsc gaag sohpanmo
77
Lgra Tcppor
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
13/25
mcksouokzngantä$ !cppor giiorhg m)o mn9 jn mun kcn komossntnghc por ag mchproksncko
joa mchpcrtghoktc uhgkc rgznckgao / ugamcsg jn kgturg nktorhojng trg na mgsc
poriottc o na jotorhnknshc poriottc$ ugamcsg jn nktorhojnc trg ao kuvcao poriotto o n
poriottn crcacen
*ormgkjc jukuo jn hcstrgro m)o mcsg jnstnkeug spomninmghokto ag anbortä joaa%genro
uhgkc nktoaaneokto jga horc mchpcrtghoktc$ mgsugao o nhprovojnbnao$ m)o
mgrgttornzzg nk vgrnc hcjc n snstohn kgturgan$ !cppor enukeo gaag tosn somckjc mun ag
anbortä rnsnojo koa "mcktrcaac pagstnmc# joa mchpcrtghoktc trghnto n prnkmnpn joaag
rgznckgantä mrntnmg Nk gatro pgrcao$ por !cppor$ pcssckc ossoro mcksnjorgtn anborn uon
snstohn cregknmn mchpaossn$ mcho ean ossorn uhgkn$ m)o rnmormgkc ao scauznckn por ao acrc
osneokzo vntgan soaoznckgkjc oktrc uk nksnoho jn toktgtnvn c npctosn jn scauzncko o m)o
hottckc mcksgpovcahokto gaag prcvg tgan toktgtnvn c npctosn$ koaa%nktoktc jn igro
ohoreoro na prnhg pcssnbnao n acrc ovoktugan jniottn
72
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
14/25
7>
9njstmghot`nrhne`tgrghcukt,gkjsoohj
ackot`'ktgecknstci+og#'k,kcraoss
Z`gk+oaasjrogj"hporcurwnt ̀pchp]uprogh,
kj(cj5an$onhntgtoj]tgto0 ǹhrcukj
(acbociinorno]orgp`nhnkmacs'j Unt`brne`tnhbag/ckrno,gkj`crroktrhs.2'4-'7>
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
15/25
Nktrcjuzncko ga %!grgjnso Acst%
.nuktn gaa%npctosn pcpporngkg$ m)o / g hnc enujnznc ag pn=
rgenckovcao oj osgurnokto irg tutto uoaao gj ceen
icrhuagto$ nktokjc crg spcstgro na icmus jn uostg
trgttgzncko suaa%cporg aottorgrng m)o pn= jn tutto hn )g
oktusngshgtc$ rnusmokjc g igr ohoreoro ukc spnrntc
rchgktnmc spossc sopcatc scttc jurn strgtn jn irojjozzg
mgamcagktoA%cporg nk uostncko / na %!grg nso Acst% pcohg opnmc nk vorsn smncatn smrnttc jg Cc)k
Hnatck o pubbanmgtc koa 75$ m)o rgmmcktg a%opnscjnc bnbanmc joaag mgjutg joaa%uchc6
ag toktgzncko jn jghc oj Dvg g cporg jn >gkg o ag acrc mgmmngtg jga engrjnkc
joaa%Djok
1ck pu9 ossoro uk mgsc m)o na mgrjnko inacscinmc su mun sn svnauppg uost%cporg sng
prcprnc na Anborc rbntrnc$ mckmottc m)o$ por na hcjc rnvcauznckgrnc nk mun / un
prosoktgtc o scstokutc$ rokjo na %!grgjnsc !orjutc% uk puktc jn svcatg jn tuttc na
poksnorc cmmnjoktgao
!or pgenko o pgenko pctron pgragro jn mcho nk uost%cporg Hnatck mchbgttg ag tocrng
mgavnknstg joaag projostnkgzncko$ rnvokjnmgkjc na rucac joaag anbortä g jnsmgpntc
joaa%gsscautc mcktrcaac jn Jnc sua mrogtc o jn mcho oean toktn inkc gean uatnhn vorsn joa
pcohg jn mckmnangro uost%njog mck ag kczncko jn !rcvvnjokzg
Euostn tohn rnsuatorobborc por9 rnjckjgktn rnspottc gean grechoktn enä trgttgtn ink un$
o por uostc hctnvc )c jomnsc jn sciiorhgrhn su ukc jon jnbgttntn pn= nhpcrtgktn jn
uost%cporg$ uoaac m)o ructg gttcrkc ga porsckgeenc jn >gkg
n hnon cmm)n oean gppgro un$ pn= m)o hgn$ Gpcrtgtcro jn aumoB$ ergzno gaag sug gsscautg
mgpgmntä jn susmntgro koa aottcro uk nrroirokgbnao josnjornc jn gttnkeoro gaag pn=
horgvneancsg joaao ugantä joaa%uchc6 ag suporbng
7:
c`k Hnatck
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
16/25
>gkg$ a%orco joaag anbortä
Tnk jgn prnhn juo anbrn joa pcohg$ >gkg
ohoreo mcho ukg spaokjnjg ineurg m)o
hcatn mrntnmn$ g pgrtnro jga porncjc
rchgktnmc inkc gn prnhn jomokkn joa @@
somcac$ )gkkc gsscmngtc gn ergkjn orcn
joaa%opnmg magssnmg *ck a%nknznc nk hojngs ros
tnpnmc joa eokoro opnmc$ Hnatck ciiro g
>gkg ag smokg nknzngao$ m)o sn mckmoktrg
nkigttn suaa%Nkiorkc o suean gkeoan mgjutn$ o
nktrcjumo na pcohg gttrgvorsc na suc puktc
jn vnstg *gmmngtc jga !grgjnsc jcpc ossorsn
rnboaagtc g Jnc$ >gkg ickjg ukg mnvnatä koaa%Nkiorkc o pcn nktrgprokjo uk vngeencaukec o jniinmnao vorsc na pgrgjnsc torrostro Na suc gspottc prcvcmg jg subntc uk
mortc igsmnkc koa aottcro6
koaa'gspottcg#o#g
*ugamcsgjoaagaumocrnenkgrng67'72<
%cs7csmurgtc,purornspaokjo#g
a'rmgkeoacsueangatrn,omnmgtrnmn
jniuahnknhcstrg#gsuaagigmmng 7'47<
Na >gkg jn Hnatck kck pcssnojo jukuo uoaag joicrhntä joa mcrpc m)o susmntn
nk kcn rnpuekgkzg c jnseustc$ kck mn sckc ao mcrkg$ ag mcjg o ag enbbcsntä tnpnm)o
7'
]gtgkg rns!oeang ean gkeoan rnboaan
("# $aglo)
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
17/25
joaa%nmckcerging trgjnznckgao
>gkg / uk ossoro creceancsc o cstnkgtc$ uk rnboaao m)o pgrag mck oktusngshc
trgsmnkgkto joaag sug "vcacktä nkvnkmnbnao# o m)o utnanzzg uk ankeugeenc jn sinjg
mcktrc ag tnrgkkng jn Jnc Hg uostc rnboaao jovo gkm)o rnmckcsmoro
a%ckknpctokzg joa suc gvvorsgrnc6 ugkjc nk uk prnhc hchoktc hgaojnmo
"a%ghcro anborc jga *noac mckmossc g tuttn nk ueugao hnsurg# :-< jg Jnc porm)/
kck ean )g nhpojntc jn mgjoro$ >gkg mck inorozzg$ o koa kcho joaag vorntä$ so ag
prokjo subntc jcpc mck so stossc6
9gaojottc
nk#omotu,porm`2mcktrcjnaun,
anborghokto,agtug#cackt=
smoaso*uoaacjnmun,enustghokto,
gjossctnaghoktn. :572<
*ck na prcmojoro joaa%cporg$ mn sn rokjo mcktc m)o
a%ghhnssncko joaa%ckknpctokzg jn Jnc / a%uknmc hcjc
nk mun >gkg pu9 enustninmgro ga suc creceanc ag
smckinttg Ag rosnstokzg orcnmg gssuho sohpro pn= ag
icrhg jn mnomg mgpgrbnotä6 >gkg josnjorg
jnsporgtghokto mrojoro jn ossorsn gutcmrogtc$ hg
a%nhhgenko joaag prcprng ergkjozzg jornvg
jnrottghokto jga suc schhc kohnmc Dean scekg jn
"ecjoro$ nksnoho ga o joa mnoac$ j%uk nhporc jnvnsc#
:777
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
18/25
Eugsn mcho g vcaormn mchukuo rnmcrjgro mcstgktohokto mcho >gkg icsso$ uk
tohpc$ a%gkeoac pn= eacrncsc jn Jnc$ buckc o kck hganekc$ Hnatck mo ac prosoktg
spossc nk rniornhoktc gaag sug promojokto boaaozzg6
rmgkeoacgkmcrg,bokm`2nkpgrto,
poragmgjutg,snicssocsmurgtc
a'ommosscjoaageacrng. 7'2:<
!orvoknghc mcs gaa%njog somckjc mun na hgao kck / uk gttrnbutc ossokzngao$
ugamcsg m)o osnsto nk s0$ hg / nkvomo ugamcsg m)o vnoko smoatc$ m)o gensmo
gttrgvorsc na Anborc rbntrnc nk cppcsnzncko mcksgpovcao gaag vcacktä jn Jnc
Na igsmnkc o ag icrzg joa porsckgeenc jn >gkg sckc nkigttn strgcrjnkgrnghokto
aoegtn gaag sojuzncko osormntgtg jga Anborc rbntrnc
>gkg kck )g smghpc ugkjc jovo mchbgttoro mcktrc ag iurng jnvnkg$ hg koaag
sug vcacktä / anborc o koaag sug hokto / suprohc
!ghoktostgnksostossg,onksostossg
pu:igrojoaa'nkiorkcukpgrgjnsc,
c#nmo#orsg.>.
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
19/25
>gk gkj %()o *crsgnr%6 t)o +,rcknm )orc
kjt`cue`tt`o#cnmociwrgt ̀gsgmrojmgaa,
Zcpgt`onkGurnoscischockgaa.
+o$kow`nhsoaig#naagnkBbut`ojooh'j
Z`orostkcbottort`gkt`ot`nke`osooh'j0
kjsmcrk'jt`obostgs`pcmrntosw`c`nj
Z`csojoojst`obcajorspnrntpagnkajnj.
+o $kow `nhsoai otosto , but `o $kow
Z`o `ogrts t`gt acgt`' `nh, mrcum`' gk rog o tcc.
!cko,wnaj,gkjstrgkeo,`ostccjgan$oo-ohpt
Irchgaagiiomtnckgkjirchgaamcktohpt6
+nskghomcuajsgjjok,gkj`nsgmtssurprnso0
&utt`ot`gtiogr'j`nhjgrojkcttcjospnso.
. +,rck$ Z`o%crsgnr,72>25:
Wnt) )ns anio gkj )ns ;cr3s .ocreo .crjck +,rck
pcpuagrnzoj t)o %+,rcknm )orc%$ g hccj,$ rostaoss gkj
h,storncus chgktnm roboa ;)c )njos scho )crrnbao snk cr
somrot nk )ns pgst 8o ns m)grgmtornsoj b, prcuj
nkjnvnjugansh gkj roRomts t)o mckvoktnckga hcrga ruaos ci scmnot,
Nk t)ns pcrtrgnt ci *ckrgj$ t)o hgnk m)grgmtor ci Z`o
%crsgnr $ +,rck gjjs tc gaa t)o t,pnmga oaohokts ci )ns )orc
t)o h,t) ci t)o cutag;$ g roboa ;)c pagmos )nhsoai cutsnjo gkj gegnkst scmnot,
()o prctgecknst anvos surrcukjoj b, gk gthcsp)oro ci h,stor, gkj ackoankoss$ )o
nssuos g hgekotnm m)grh$ g sokso ci jchnkgkt suporncrnt, ;)nm) subRuegtos t)cso
7-
Eocreo $'rck
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
20/25
;)c stgkj nk irckt ci )nh gkj pagmos )nh gbcvo mchhck hgk3nkj
Acgt)oj b, gk,cko$ nk turk )o )gtos t)o hok ;)c surrcukj )nh gkj mcksnjors )ns
;rgt) gegnkst t)oh gs g "sgmroj mgaa#$ nkjumnke )nh tc hg3o ovor,cko pg, t)o iguats
ci io;
Nt ns snhpao tc romceknso nk t)ns ineuro t)o h,t) ci t)o igaaok gkeoa ()o eunat t)gt hgr3s
)nh$ an3o t)o cko ci t)o inrst roboa$ Aumnior$ ns gk okcrhcus snk ci prnjo +ut jospnto
t)gt$ Rust an3o >gk$ )o hgnktgnks gaa )ns kcbnant,$ gppogrnke ergkj ovok nk ovna$
"hgRostnm t)cue) nk runk#
7
Mckrgj t`o Mcrsgnr (@# orkot)
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
21/25
.ustgvo Jcr/ o ag soksnbnantä rchgktnmg
.ustgvo Jcr/ &trgsburec 7->2 !grnen 7-->< iu uk
grtnstg irgkmoso joa tgrjc chgktnmnshc Dean iu ukc
jon pn= prcjnencsn grtnstn joa @N@ somcac ppokg
unkjnmokko$ nktrgproso ukg mgrrnorg jn mgrnmgturnstg
prnhg o jn naaustrgtcro prciossncknstg pcn m)o ean
prcmur9 ighg nktorkgznckgao prnhg jn jojnmgrsn
gkm)o gj gatro icrho j%osprossncko grtnstnmg$ mcho ag
pntturg o ag smuaturg
Nk vosto jn naaustrgtcro$ Jcr0 sn / hnsurgtc mcn pn=
nhpcrtgktn tostn aottorgrn Ag +nbbng$ Jgkto$ rncstc$ *orvgktos$ Hnatck$ &)g3ospogro$
8uec$ +gazgm$ !co
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
22/25
27
@ne` ck g t`rcko c& g rc'ga stgto+ w`nm` &gr , Cuts`cko t`o wogat` c& Crhus gkj c& Nkj
(-#./-)
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
23/25
22
4cw tc t`o gsmokt c& t`gt stoop sg!geo `naa , ]gtgk `gt` 7curko'2j ck+ poksn!o gkj sacw
(=#.:-/?)
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
24/25
2>
9kj soohs g hc!nke agkj5 gkj gt `ns enaas , rgws nk+ gkj gt `ns trukl spcuts cut+ g sog
(:#=.0/>)
8/19/2019 IL LIBERO ARBITRIO - Tesina
25/25
+nbancerging
• Cc)k Hnatck$ grgjnscorjutc$ g murg jn Tgbnc *nmorc$ trgjuzncko jn
cbortc !nuhnkn$ 244$ +chpngkn
• &top)ok 8g;3nke$ aergkjojnsoekc$ 2477$ Hckjgjcrn
• O;ok .nkeornm)$ %ormgkjcMnckoaa'ukn#orsc$ 2445$ Ankjgu
• Jgkto ane)norn$ !gMn#nkg%chhojng$ g murg jn aossgkjrc Hgrm)n$ 244$
!grgvng
• 1 bbgekgkc$ . Tcrkorc$ !grnmormgjoapoksnorc$ 2472$ !grgvng
• Acrj +,rck$ ]oaomtojpcohs$ 244$ Wcrjs;crt) Djntncks
• H &pngzzn$ H (gvoaag$ H Ag,tck$ oricrhor%uaturoJ!ntorgturo$ 2472$
_gknm)oaan
• . +gajn$ & .nussc$ H gzottn$ . _gmmgrng$ apngmorojontostn $ 2472$
!grgvng
• . *rnmmc$ T Jn (ocjcrc$ tnkorgrnckoaa'grto$ 2472$ _gknm)oaan
• .ustgvo Jcr/$ aaustrgtncksicrOgrgjnso!cst $ 7>$ Jcvor !ubanmgtncks
2: