20
®9®131 5 ll-') c , .r? a- IM jUl. 2 0 2009 CLERK OF COURT SUPREME COURT OF OHIO

IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

®9®131 5ll-')c , .r? a-

IM

jUl. 2 0 2009CLERK OF COURT

SUPREME COURT OF OHIO

Page 2: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

0-111 R-2r-J1

sff

^^) (/) 4) -<"^3A'Y.^e^` G..^4e-4 .1^, _.,G?'2^.^r.°•^ ..-? ^^^ CP 3` " ^^_ . . . . ^ r . r . . /

, -' 7`2? ^n - -. .-- . - _ ,.,^....^ t.e^}^c 4^

4C LcW 73(4' ^J^st^dra irrrr^rccp ^ ^L^r ,e^c:^ erl^r d /ite^,J P

Page 3: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

V,r,Qa, &,^

Page 4: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

^ir -^''Z^ ,^2^ ^, z^ .^^cZ^, ^• ^^1^CJE^^cc^r^^at..^^' ^ ^^ :' G^._^

, - el.,01^G:.fC..

z / ^ a .tC,,^.i"`t^s' 's^`1-^^;,<^^.•^',.e?^:,d"d"e<{ ',t^' ,c°f e`r .e:..^'. ^h.k';it-(,^ .

^ 1^ ^ ^P .•2C^^ ^^ ^/^^ `^c.trrJ / c^^.t.) fi

^^e eo ^,Ae ,wyd^^^e,4v,

OA

..Cill.^^^Z'..^ C.C"•rC GE-J'^ ^"a^

.r^'

Lt/.• e-a.;"j . anV

et

"O&Cwo" ' 4/vct4

^ZL _rC^c^^+ ,G?^E GC/,rI/2^^ o^ ^-^t^ ^^C^^e ^.^ ^^ -J^•^t^.^^^

Ci)

.c^6 r.`?^.,-t ^°4~Gc.l 2

Page 5: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

_^::"'^3;,'s,r ^,^?_e'.i1d'Y3F

,.A?r „ea4-r 11::..aA°Rk°^

^FE".L.^ ,/^y`l^c^zt%,^F= ^1^^1fi ^.c^ay.+'^ _t-.r•

^ :^.^ ^^.^ Lf?^ ^^ . ^^^ u ^ 1^s^ri..r? t•

.s-.'..;i^...a6 .^.^-^Z^ 3`^

610.a

GW 41441^rt A 4,V'x4V 44.P

t_°.1...,..d^ .;t.`f`L!'s'd,•

^^^^^^.'e

^^^^4 d^ ^ ^'O ' . /_ . . . . d -77-_

Page 6: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

2r.r•t.r JG^ ^

^^^r c^ %2.^4 c

ft, ^2:cL.,

GG.d^0 . 1 ^°'^'r ,

^..^^4112.e

16 we-^W.^AZJIJ IaAwa^O^4t_ty Z1,411-

l

_ ,^, ^.;'^,:

/..t=^,.i.+°.^3A'^..E'Ct^='^ .f^ ^L^i^

^,.^ ^ ^^ /J&O/

.^3-.....v:-s^^'c. m=_.r%...^:

Page 7: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

4)tAoAev

^fs`,i`,j

^! , cj•<3y_

i,C I.xAy1 /J.: ,x`„.:tlje$3--o,

ey^^4.^^^vw f A

A

I

Page 8: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

6:f

e^^

%7 ^Ii ^^.t^ ^^Lt^e 37?'2d2' ^^^^ .^Y7

^r'.X' ;^ ^r a^^ l.c^.,^J -.^^4?-^"4R- . :+•^°^ ^^ ^ ^^.^^ '«^.L.^,G•Cse°/

4^'2.L^D C? ^/f /- .1,/X.e;7

) c.^ e^; f^

d>,^(/^^a^ E'^2.L^ ^7...C,^^.,^.•^.t.t'^^' ^7G^i^^ s''"I"T.67?d2.s^^.e2.^4 r^.^+'^:.-:s' s,^"^^x^

fi'6"1&2^.< .v°^`^ ^i^ r ^^^/ ^rZ^Gta^`it . Cl^-erP KQ ^^ s"^-^•fi,Y^ ^' /^^GtClL .^.e,^.^°.G•CaA^i

^j^LL ^ c J! c r t% ^'^C ? ^ l2- .k? ,/^•a'^^ l,Oaa .e2'4 %1 Q^s"^

^,€'..2 ;i+'. ,s+°7 ^ ^1•fwd ,..G.^.L.^°...^` . ,r^ E&^' ., '^,.,^'.4:2,^d,.^ ...G^'y'1

(^••fiF6'

fdJ€^^^/"f"n-e d(d..^'si^t-^'^.^ /^d ^C. ^?^.^ ^c,.s^.&.4^P^X .+``m^'Z.ti.'•^..^.C.^^ ^ 3'..alaA 4yrI

so s,

^^^zJ.^Ga^^(/1^p •^l^...^ ^/'^u.a.p^+^^_^, ^'^C 7^t' . ^^-^°-^''

^^^ 4v," 0-^-l e, -A4z--7UJaccA( A"Lorrto c^<

,^ ^-zw ^^ ^a^^ ^^ 7^

'i^ ^ ^ ^.^ ^^

aOa

(5)

Page 9: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

s }} J r ¢,^s ^L ^ // ^// / ^

( L2»L!..Y..P" ^®^3'^'r2.ft.P.i1.R-,1

..f^ !^ ^,^ . 4g ^' r j / (d ^ -3

e*J ,D-o,°'_' $,>/ ^

f ..d''-^vza,:

i

• .^^^,.^ .

^ ^^lle- 1)

!^.t1Lv^ Gr_.CC..z1 ^^F'

. ,, G^-/lx^ r1

,g ^_r• ^.^. fy

e/.*.r? C{ e...1'"(:ca,.ap

Page 10: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

i

^."'^,.C{-i.".-¥°"r'^`.o"";'r°'?:"^v .•.

y ..'-v .`:=t ^" a.0- ^ d'' 4o.°

ntiA1^ ^^ L°•eLi'r ....

,r'^.? /'t1 ae.1t j..t p

^¢f..^ ^-d °'^^j`^^ t 3i1^{^'^^

ev

,6:al'1 d.0• .;.J' , .r^7

^-t I ta^^ atA,

^"^to^,, ..^^ (::^{u^^-

^,`^ ^.^ ^^^ ^' ZZ. G

. _ ^..I d ,. ^,^

`t^ ^IUAW .

:.y u^^^ ^'^v`^i ^ i...t..'r•<.

C:C.f^^'ie^{ .F.'•J

^ e,4 &,*

Page 11: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

C3 e,;,- t

^,l.c:6,4.sy^' t^Y,

^ f' ,^ F Ca ^f tZ 3^^ r^ Gt1 z3 r- 3Ld/A^ v^ 7 ,Q ^ eF1^^,Qa^f ^/t^o c? yry , c2L c-wt

^.' ^^^^ ^^%Q 3/ ^^^^' ^T^^^. .a,^^ .^^.o^^.^,a..^ ^^ ^

. JC^)iu J ^a^ . ^'-^`r r^2r^ ^^ _1,^3 e°r'•"-c a ^ 3'r.t^^P l.eR ^.P,r- ^` fd u^^Z U3i2f^ !'^e c^u^^o^tq ,, ,3

`'' ^/JIG/ J^ (J--^i.1 D^L-C (^V^QL/^'J^J'I ^^C.-Q , , '^C_7.C.^/^!?2Q3Y. C^(u'Ji

,lr9^

^ flq L^ ^. ^ Qel gs (/993),

z^^ ,^^ ^-•^ ^^;^^^-^; ^ ^^ ^^^ ^. ^-^^^ ^^^`3 f!1 3b r`u a^.

y0 ^ 4^0. 3o' 59o, 591 .^l. ^ dd ^ 3^ m 9v:1,

Page 12: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

CJ7Z -e

^ r sr 3f}

/. f.A-^ i.^'f t' fFA•rtF;.s

/C/V3..A'^ / i- ^^

^ ^ ^ ,+ ^ e/ /l

^^^ //, ^.JQ/Ely?a^2ri-ns°'r"^^.^^ ^. ^:...'':!l..c•{ t

NC.._. ^.r^f...? c^ ^`-r^ P^^GF ^ CQ^ C.../^^r3 ^e" ...L^2'a , c?e^^'?^ ^t^% ^rJ°^ ...^ ^ .J^ >f^f"• E°.".p

jF ^ _.G7,7 &?,(?

r f

,^^^.,2L^12'Y^.-^"f ^.>^^"""^a^•^^''w:('^ Ir'^.^d'"f.^e^"''.K.r`3" /Q.Qi^.t-O fGL/,L-

C-2 LZ/3

p'

^^^^^ ^• ^2ar^^..23.^-,. ^U^

/t4 cnv-^^,a,,Zf° ^.^'°^ &J, --^ , ,ouyo,^,--^ f^ 7'; F4 F^d g r 7 . ^ ^ ^^^___, ; --^^^ u-,

j^ ^ .QAA..4^'1

do

G?4i G^^r /3l/j •^al ^^'^ .7/3 1,37^ 13Fr3(/9e3)^

4,, 65y 1,1)6 7, /^)/,2 -/34'-"0T7

e--,4^C9)

'(

„v

^}: ^fp.•°ti7F'=r'1^

...^t

,: ;f= <aC

^t Gr°12 t.p (f/

Page 13: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

t/ -/ , f ,^j ^''^ ^ ..^,E ..,^caa'...i^. °^e_...r^,,^^! r.. ^ -----. . . --- '

_..!

°

s^ylfd7 ^ /

eCt f

,0, 6^74,) ;^6 ^ i-.C^^3C d7? ) a ^ ^Q ^^

4w

'^ .^ . o^r^ .^. d 6!^_^ ^^

a2 73/. of 4^ ^^.^

^ ^lexrAi^p

( ► U^

Page 14: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

^^'^. ,^1•z

^^ •^,^rzr^^e

,ZXW Jla^-#-1

/^ e•a r^ l do^zY;s/ . ^P a -

^^^^^^^ ^^^j r4D24

.c/u^ Z.,-^^ bt/es^%' ^ ^^ ^ ^ ^ ^, ^ ^^ ,^.^►^

40,377

^,cr^d .,^.Gt4^ 7g8' (P^

Page 15: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

/P

1/^ k/^+c,j f.'^]^,t ` 5F o'J'IE'ft?r?, ,/

ce- ,/Iu^q r ,,g^^ k v` 49^-.•al,^'. . T,ti^i6, vL^1r^ v t^

C4CS7G?,6^l 4^4,6rr 47'- Vle cJ^ ^ex/^^ %^ cA

; ^^ltklllE,

ibrr ^' lvr``C ;7b 7-4Al6-

^ ^/ ^^^^^d ( d ^x z(z 'ZFJsr`51^^e !J ^n 0^/p,at/af E. /CJ eAA/ E"i f J'Qt/ a

µ77vv7" Tfl^-S^

-6®J

7 7a1Xc- srt^/' l ^::^=r'^

F7f` 75 11E

• t^^Ttth"rc(trJ 73 °^j t` .-5o

Page 16: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

CpC ^; • Hiy -i-(;iF?

'o k-,^ t', k, S tr

9i^ Ij C7 :.t; ^'^! fi^t ^.Pr! :

"r" ":.^ ^:.,o A':4

.nca tlrLi 6,

T6 (R^, te;Twg

d./ ^.:< 3

C .'t^'--" l>\.,) N M c, Cou

Da.i: k fvl,iL. A Co

^E^A-Tfl/L- (47 -l`I}51 HA /d ^^ 5

To Us6. w^57H(-':^fl t),UeePA&Lr6tn T^)Fq 'ME.rrz t4rtft°lpl^ `T(-,4 ^,0r4C: !^ tc,.

Pop t4 I 14-r, C.'^iU i

q) 'Ll poAl^5ttlz°rq Qtwf-a^ YyltmUt,1oE 2 T H eg o - r ^P f l ^ 5 4.rp I=4 Af^^ 4 e-,

.^^

F zq,B.

Ib^ RG(A°i°Of^ L=o I^EPt^^E TO Cia WNErU"po4s:^ ^^^^odba,dl7';s D=-oTAke- Acrmo,^l ^.6AzxlSr JVIE .Tn.I rqa-T'd4FCL

^`e^ ke:60mm C-n.t() -Z&f G,?6R5 E ZA^ fM( 66c.^r-Ay dv "i^ q Co w-t d^ A 154n^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& ► 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo 3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT

(?vP^(^E^^^(JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"')^He2^ Or^^i^ r^er^^^r^^ ^Ac CUG&t r^c^RE f^l^I^ ^^a^1^^eJrr^wrr v ^a► ^Iq2g' Eu6ht mcaE- izOEl T& tC=tf nne zIJ z-(,s

Page 17: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

.^! ^^ t0 NafV(

1^^^^o ryl q

OA-,A°T't I I

10 iAAVC= fv O° t R Ac4€

&5fta Od "Me-- Ali^^)C-O Ime-a^^riN E- ^'l i

! W) rnrwTaAcq R AM14( ^A6 !`,9^^ Wrti OT90'K S`^R, ► fl&l€"t^e-

R

e-A

A,).r.6 "P"cj V.

r m^^z2c^JA^1^l()As:13 NAmtLtnAd, f,7`, -TCFt°rim Q# WAM-7"6

04(Ta'aLJ : - t . ti ^ T G ? R tr- T ( J ) A I [ QW -T^ e Vti -rO R (" ^-`

M ^; mt^('^o mmat, G , -T , pop k ( iqT'=Oa.l "C(fW TH E4 wa. t i 5M 0 m & 'ro

`ML(k a I ,r i

A mR^

!14) LzE:-uTc,tf4xt T. .^ci;rm'ra4, P,I, Q6, e-OAx2rhA4, lis °CIAC- 6ao6^ WNa

RL e-OnArKG-n(0S R-C(fkTCJ t2. J`c"Cufz.=r^ ^n ►Cf?^f^^C T^

Cc,Ar. n) C°'Yz PAGt :

Page 18: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

;-j-tl ;te1

Tt3 te) (-^ 5

^._.^\f 4

1ltaA.^4)u) To qAvC F`^^ L=F'F La.^^OKt ;°Y,;.ta li L ^ ^^^ r V jCf;^ttEb^J^A^$ 774^ ^,z, Me CvL4('Lr. !qi^ .^C.G rilkd^l4 (4tj-_jt"'^»"'°^^`P?4 To

1fb 1^ - ` ry '1nt-eft t^"t t4O(.+.1 6fe-tAtft"°LP :nl^r?^°^.^r Ri'r 4,,r)bo AS 6r^T% A&io ry1o2..a(^"a L,^NXS4, ^0=0^ ^4c--P1RT Okr

I^^4.5 14 Ia8'AL)

A

d HAS (-ILt1R-klL-.nCTCU^-b a-:ntTU -T'Ra.y

^j Vtjo(.,) GNvto.f o faE Ret71 TF^r!s P12,x S oA

auT' 51`itI Tk^ Ct^nl^c^c^u51^^ A E P"E , rkf^EV0 7kv T^ a Ln"- iv1c- kXtle t3 i

19) As A Rcrsuir 2. Mvio eueAj PrAft Psr rv-)l ^,e>APe 'rq Pra..^^ t-)11 oPLjAapero 5rAi1`WS A('fi:htr,5/ Co4t2JXT=tw( At

Q..U) RESPOeO060,lT' ..^m-t°t°64 'k^^^ 04y ^^^^t^^^C ►^ 74-ms

^t^^ A rAeae l, rnuAq'NS r^^^^ ^^s i+I96(4f5^( A(Roc~d^' ^^ ►^'^4t^i63^^r1 ^^ Ce4r:f^ ^'Vt^^

on -i.til --mt- rYat3R.lTR oP 4^GC.Ae ^ Li, .U.6tY1 AO Q;L1) R:G*tK Yh end ^ ^O

P\F-6pQn.lAEn,tT 6hAaTf4, A5 p jAAUE6, TO -' '"(Zpetat~ly Yn6

To c^^E-,O^m1 Popu^^A-^^bL( 47 TAe veRy ptz^5,o,^ ^^^6,P-^ TRC

Page 19: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

0/4 R-)aT"o(lD(^^CrLT--^^AT^t-f3 ('y^ 'TlAt' `-^(^a,^t

>R^ i^^q kn^boo rn^ bu^ a:s ;

^^^ REIATOra !do s A! rzt-Aby ^riti ( Lo i

j-Z^^ rq-() `rta E^eOA.i

Po(2. ^,.^U C

^oT 6U04

C600,S-(- Ai4 !q(T-f:RnI A i:.Ij: C16^ P'(Ptm^n^'.dd-oQ.X C

t'^b ( ^e 1-:2:0c` L4e.s-ro/)^ ,t€..r s 1,

^83) ^e^w. 7^f& Al6ovt^ Rc,:/A60rj erx"'! 'Pf ) Tt-6-s _r6 t,,3h^^ RE'I147

&lcCf^s Rc-;5Pofoo"^ 6rr-LrT+4 i^ Qo 1-6'5A^01a "-^x€Hvk^r T°1C 0103 Plzr^ec-^55 'n^^aiA A4 s ('C 9- pA P Ek,^^^^^

^^^ FbuT r^^ ^(ks^^^Fj), Re5Po^uoc,:Ajz,5 6n-=T^ m,^rV,oed moaaoo- pw2Poisei^ Ppoi^^^ ^^rswrQ^ ^ ^^^^^&HiAvV

P^rP+^,^^b^^t ro P ,^n^a,^^ r^^ ^^^^^ r^ ^c+A^+c5 s OF rl ^L ArY\tAR6J EQ EO ^AEej^ AT Vy)p(d,15 p^^3

^s) ^EIPTo a, EAa^^-t1eo To -n4e ec(.:LeF 5o,4(.irar .a4tr THeCon1p(a=mr

°Ve ffwsaRn$T Cnwtp Ir+znAT IAcQae6s&s v L. ^ v-54 RelA°°rok,.!S w^Cq

R=S Cou2T RGT^S xnR Et`n^i2.C,la1Cq ^FSl^an..f,

Page 20: IM - Supreme Court of Ohion^bwa JkSZ`^^^^ 5& 4=^J6 Me T-v Mo3cF LAAJ6Er2cau5 PRX-Sp40 RPic(Ar.^e,J AT JP6 :5ouphru CJ^^ ^^^6cr=OA1N( F'Ac=f-rr^ (P,5t^a,e, p,"') (?vP^(^E^^^(^He2^ Or^^i^

^^^ 33 A, F40R^l^^^q^ Fft

^^ 42-04^^^ ^ ^^^ &OV