Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
IMPROVINGWASTEMANAGEMENTINNON-MARKETHOUSING:
Challenges,strategies,andrecommendations
togettozerowaste
PreparedbyAndrewR.MartinGreenestCityScholar,CityofVancouver
MCRPCandidate,SCARP,UBCAugust,2016
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This report was made possible thanks to the support of numerous waste managemententhusiasts at the City of Vancouver, as well as at many other municipalities, regionalgovernments,housingauthorities,nonprofits,andwastemanagementcompanies.Inparticular,Iwouldliketothankthefollowingindividualsfortheirgenerosityinsharingtheirvaluabletimeandinsights:AngieNicolás,AnnaDyer,BrianBeck,BrianButt,BrianWong,CharlotteUeta,CelineMauboules, Donna Taylor, Doug Schell, Doris Chow, Faisal Mizra, George Simpson, HannaMusslic,JeffWint,JimHeeps,JonathanMcDermott,JordanParente,KathleenBelton,KatrusiaBalan,KennySiu,LauraBarreca,LinhHuynh,LizBlakeway,MartaSanchez-Blasco,MonikaCzyz,Ruben Anderson, Ryan Wong, Sandra Mills, Sepideh Datoobar, Shannon Hadley, ShaunMcKibben,SherriMatt,SuzannZimmering,TinaWinberg,TraceyTobin,andUlrykeWeissgerber.IamalsoverygratefultoTerryFultonatMetroVancouverandtheteamatTetraTechfortheircollaboration in conducting awaste audit for this study. Finally, a special thank you to theGreenestCityScholarsprogramcoordinatorsJenniferWahl,KatieDollingandKarenTaylor,tothe SolidWasteManagement team at the City of Vancouver, and especially tomymentor,PatrickChauo,forhiscontinuoussupportthroughoutmyresearch.
Image:TheVancouverLandfill,inDelta.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing3
TABLEOFCONTENTS
EXECUTIVESUMMARY..........................................................................................................................4
Acronyms&Definitions......................................................................................................................12
INTRODUCTION..................................................................................................................................13Projectbackground.................................................................................................................................13Scope......................................................................................................................................................14Methods.................................................................................................................................................16Limitations..............................................................................................................................................17
CONTEXT............................................................................................................................................18PolicydirectivesfromtheCityofVancouver..........................................................................................18Rationaleforthisstudy...........................................................................................................................18Backgroundontheissue........................................................................................................................20
KEYFINDINGS.....................................................................................................................................23I.Residentengagementandmotivationsforwastesorting...................................................................23II.Wastemanagementsystemuserinterface........................................................................................33III.Wastestreamcontamination............................................................................................................37IV.Wastestorage....................................................................................................................................45V.Bulkywastemanagementandillegaldumping..................................................................................50VI.Supportingandbuildingrelationshipswithbuildingstaff.................................................................55VII.Hauler-relatedissues........................................................................................................................58VIII.Budgetlimitationsforbuildingoperators.......................................................................................61
ASSESSINGWASTEVOLUMES..............................................................................................................66Estimatingsectorwastevolumes...........................................................................................................66Wasteaudits...........................................................................................................................................70
RECOMMENDATIONS.........................................................................................................................74Shortterm(by2020)..............................................................................................................................74Longterm(beyond2020).......................................................................................................................78
AREASFORFURTHERRESEARCH.........................................................................................................80
REFERENCES.......................................................................................................................................81Articles,booksandwebsites..................................................................................................................81Interviewsandwritteninputs................................................................................................................86
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
4
EXECUTIVESUMMARY
PROJECTBACKGROUND
Thegoalofthisstudyistosupportthelongtermvisionofzerowaste.AdvancementsareguidedbypoliciesfromtheCityofVancouver’sGreenestCityActionPlan,includingadirectivetoreducesolidwastegoingtolandfillorincineratorby50%from2008levelsby2020.Duetogenerallylowparticipation rates in zero waste programs, waste management systems in the non-markethousingsectorwereidentifiedasneedingcloserstudytounderstandprevailingneeds,challenges,andopportunitiesforsupport.Wastemanagementstreamsexploredinthisstudyincludeprogramsfororganics,recycling,garbage,andbulkywaste.Housingtypesstudiedincludeshelters,SROs,supportivehousing,andnon-marketrentalhousing,whichtogethertotal634sitesorapproximately13%ofVancouver’smulti-unitresidentialbuildingsites.Asetofstrategieswascompiledthroughaliteraturereviewandextensivediscussionswithkeystakeholdersincludingbuildingmanagers,housingoperators,wastehaulers,andmunicipal®ionalgovernmentstaff.InputwassoughtprimarilyfromorganizationsintheVancouverregion,andadditionalcasestudieswereobtainedfromToronto,Seattle,SanFranciscoandCopenhagen.Finally,asetof25recommendationswasdevelopedfortheCityofVancouver.Giventhemulti-jurisdictionalnatureofwastemanagementintheregion,manyoftheserecommendationswillrequireextensivecollaborationwithotherlevelsofgovernment,aswellaslocalbusinessesandnon-profitorganizations,inordertobeimplemented.Manyrecommendationsapplytoallmulti-unitresidentialbuildings.Theapproachtakeninthisresearchemphasizesthecomplexityandprevailinginequitiespresentinwastemanagementsystems.Bythenatureoffocusingonbuildingsthathouseindividualswithbarriers,itistobeexpectedthatcustomizedapproachesandextrasupportarerequiredinordertoseeprogramimprovements.Uptothispoint,therearenoprogramsinplaceattheCitythatspecificallyaddresstheneedsofthissector.NumerousstakeholdersmadecleartheirreadinesstocollaboratewiththeCityonimprovingwastemanagementintheirbuildings.Manycitiesandhousingprovidersgloballyarestrugglingwiththesameissues.Thisreportisafirststep,butfurtherstudyonthistopicissorelyneededinVancouverandinternationally.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing5
KEYFINDINGS
Listedbelowaretheprevailingchallengesfacingwastemanagementprograms innon-markethousing. In the full report, findings are organized according to challenge type, including adiscussionofeachchallengewithcasesandstakeholderinputs,andsuggestedrecommendationsspecific to the City of Vancouver. The 19 challenge areas are sorted into eight thematicgroupings,andarenumberedinthefullreportastheyarebelow.
I. RESIDENTENGAGEMENTANDMOTIVATIONSFORWASTESORTING
Numerous hurdles can exist that prevent residents from participating inwastemanagementsystems. Insight into the personal barriers facing residents is essential to develop anunderstandingoftheirneedsandpreferences,sothatsystemsaredesignedtomeetresidents“where theyareat”. Thedevelopmentofpositive rolemodels anduseof feedbacksonuserbehaviourcanbeeffectivehere.
II. WASTEMANAGEMENTSYSTEMUSERINTERFACE
Inmanybuildings,key infrastructuralelementsaremissingor insufficient. Bestpracticesareoftennotemployedindevelopingnewsystems,andoverlookedsystemmaintenanceiscommonduetoothermorepressingprioritiesandalackoffunding.Systemsshouldbedesignedtobeintuitiveanduser-friendly,complementedbyinformativeinstructionandregularprompts.
Keychallenges:1. Forresidentsin“survivalmode”wastesortingmaynotbefeasible,andhousingoperatorsmustmeetresidentswheretheyareat.2. InallMURBs,wastedisposalisanonymousandthussortingisoptional.3. Wastemanagementprogrameducationforresidentsmustbedeliveredstrategically.4. Residentsdonotmaintainlong-termcommitmenttosortingwaste.
Keychallenges:5. Wastesortingisnotconvenient.6. Accessmaybedifficultforresidentswithphysicalbarriers.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing6
III. WASTESTREAMCONTAMINATION
Whenthereiscontaminationinwaste,buildingoperatorsenduppayingmoreforwasteservices.Haulerswill typicallychargecustomersdirectlyorabsorbthecostupfrontandrecoup it laterwhenservicepricing is renegotiated. Manybuildingstaff feel ill-prepared to implementnewwastestreams,withconcernsthattheywillnotbecosteffective.Hazardouswasteingarbage,especiallysyringes,canbeimprovedthroughbetterdisposalbinplacement,butbuildingsthatproducethiscontaminatedgarbageneedregulationrelaxationsandsupport.
IV. WASTESTORAGE
Numerousproblemsarisewhenwasteisstoredinoutdoorpublicareas,includingbininfiltration,messes,anddamage.Somebuildingshavenospaceforadequatewastestoragefacilities,eveninpublicareas.Insomealleys,substantialconcentrationsofdumpsterscancausemissedpickupsandinefficiencies.Newmodelsforwastestorage,includingfront-doorwasteremoval,sharedwastebins,undergroundbins,andshared in-vessel composting systemsmayhelp toaddressthese challenges for some buildings. Including social and environmental procurementpreferencesinwastehaulerRPFscanbringvalue-addedcommunitybenefits.
Keychallenges:10. Wastestorageinoutdoorpublicareascreatesissues.11. On-siteorganicsmanagementdependsonchampions.
Keychallenges:7. Somebuildingshavenoorganicsorrecyclingserviceatall.8. Hazardouswasteingarbagecreatesissuesatmultiplestages.9. Contaminationruinsthevalueoforganicsandrecycling.
Image:AtypicalalleywithmanydumpstersandbinsintheDowntownEastside.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing7
V. BULKYWASTEMANAGEMENT&ILLEGALDUMPING
Disposingofbulkywasteaccordingtoregulations isoftenprohibitivelydifficultandcostly forresidentsandbuildingoperators. Prevalenceof illegaldumpinghas increased significantly inVancouver inrecentyears,andhasbecomeacommonplacewayofdealingwithbulkywaste.Non-markethousingsitesareaprimarytarget,substantiallyincreasingtheirwastemanagementcosts.NewbulkywastemanagementservicesofferedbytheCitycouldhaltthistrend.
VI. SUPPORTING&BUILDINGRELATIONSHIPSWITHBUILDINGSTAFF
Wastemanagementisoftennotapriorityforbuildingstaff,duetomorepressingissuesandlackofmotivation.This,compoundedbyhighstaffturnover,meansbuildingstaffneedmorededicatedsupportandtraining.ThereispotentialfornewextensionsofCitywastehaulingservicestomeetunmetneeds.
VII. HAULER-RELATEDISSUES
There aremixed reviews of haulers: some operators praise their hauler for extra supportiveservicesprovided,whileotherslambastetheirhaulerforunfairbindingcontracts,mischarges,andprovidinginaccuratedata.Haulersfacetheirownchallenges,includinghealthhazardsandinaccessibilityofbins.Thereisgoodpotentialtogrowsocial-purposehaulers,andimprovewastedatacollectionefforts.
Keychallenges:12. Law-abidingbulkywastemanagementcomeswithsignificantbarriers.13. Illegaldumpinghasbecomecommonplace.
Keychallenges:14. Buildingstaffneedmoretrainingandsupport.15. Buildingtrustandimprovingcityservices.
Keychallenges:16. Issueswithpick-ups.17. Addressingsenseofdistrustandfrustrationwithhaulers.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing8
VIII. BUDGETLIMITATIONSFORBUILDINGOPERATORS
There is an inappropriate distribution of costs: buildings with high contamination rates,prevalence of hoarding, and illegal dumping tend also to be themost challenged to pay foradditionalwastehaulingcostsandfines.Manyhousingorganizationsthatoffermealprogramsareforcedtoacceptunwantedfooddonations,whichincreasestheiroperationalcosts,disposalcosts,andtheoverallvolumeoffoodwaste.
Keychallenges:18. Somenon-marketbuildingoperators faceadditional systemicandsituationalchallenges
thatputthematadisadvantagerelativetootherbuildings.19. Aninefficientpracticeof“fooddonations”putsmealprovidersinadifficultsituation.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing9
42%
13%
45%GarbageRecyclingCompostablematerials
22%
20%58%
WASTEAUDITS
ThegarbagefromfourCity-servicedSROsandoneseniorshousingcomplextogetherwasaudited,andwasfoundtocontain78%contamination(materialthatcouldhavebeendivertedfromthegarbage).AsimilarauditwasconductedwithgarbagefromMetroVancouverHousingCorporationsiteslocatedintheCityofVancouver,whichcontained58%contamination.TherelativelyhighcontaminationratefromtheSROsandseniorshousingsuggestsalackofwastediversionprograms.Contaminationratesforbothgroupsindicatethereissignificantroomforimprovementindiversionprogramsacrossthenon-marketsector.
Compositionofauditedgarbagebymaterialtype:
RECOMMENDATIONS
ThefollowingarerecommendationsfortheCityofVancouver,howevermanyofthemrequirecollaborationwith external organizations for implementation. In order to reach zerowaste,many of these recommendations will have to be implemented at some point in the future.Recommendationsarerankedinorderoffeasibilitystartingwiththeeasiesttoimplementatthetop,howeveritisthemorechallengingpolicyandsystemschangesfurtheralonginthelistthatstandtohavethelargestimpactonwastediversion.
SHORTTERM(BY2020)
1. Update theCityofVancouverGarbageandRecycling StorageFacilityDesignGuidelines toincludeexamplesofwastemanagementbestpractices(seeChallenge5).
2. Revisewastebinvolumeallocationguides,forbothCityofVancouverandMetroVancouver(seeAssessingSectorWasteVolumessection).
FiveCity-servicedhousingsites
MetroVancouverHousingCorporationsites
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing10
3. EncouragesocialandenvironmentalprocurementpreferencestobeincorporatedinhaulerRFPs(seeChallenge17).
4. Encouragepublicsyringedisposalboxestobeemptiedandmaintainedmorefrequently(seeChallenge8).
5. Create a dedicated Zero Waste Community Engagement Team within the Solid WasteManagementDivisionsolelyfocusedonengagingbuildingstaffandresidents.
6. CreateaprogramthatproactivelyprovidesfreewastemanagementsystemconsultationtoMURBbuildingstaff,administeredbytheZeroWasteCommunityEngagementTeam.
7. CreateaprogramthatprovidesfreetrainingforMURBbuildingstaff,administeredbytheZeroWasteCommunityEngagementTeam(seeChallenge14).
8. Createinitiativesthatbuildmomentumaroundzerowasteideals,administeredbytheZeroWasteCommunityEngagementTeam.
9. CreateaRecyclingAmbassadorsprogramwithvolunteerresidents,administeredbytheZeroWasteCommunityEngagementTeam.
10. EncourageBCHousing to specifically fund bulkywaste diversion efforts for shelters (seeChallenge7).
11. Aggressivelytargetandreduceillegaldumping(seeChallenge13).
12. Initiateapilotofsharedwastebins,implementedbyathirdparty(seeChallenge10).
13. Implementapilotof communitypreferredserviceagreements fororganicsand recyclingcollectionfromnon-marketbuildingsandkitchenswithsmalloutputs(seeChallenges10&19).
14. ExpandtheselectionofwastehaulingservicesofferedbytheCity(seeChallenge15).
15. ImplementaCity-operatedbulkywastecollectionprogram(seeChallenge12).
16. Encourage Metro Vancouver to remove syringes from the banned materials list (seeChallenges8&18).
LONGTERM(BEYOND2020)
17. Encourage Metro Vancouver to require waste haulers to collect and disclose data (seeChallenge17).
18. Encourageallwastebagstobeclear(seeChallenges2&16).
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing11
19. Introduce requirements for new buildings and major redevelopments to follow wastemanagement best practices as part of the development permit application process (seeChallenge5).
20. To improve occupational health and safety standards for hauler workers, work towardsavoidingdirectcontactwithbaggedgarbagewaste.
21. EncourageMetroVancouvertostandardizerecyclingpracticesintheregion(seeChallenge3).
22. Collaborate with government partners to create a fund for waste managementinfrastructureandserviceimprovementsfornon-marketbuildings(seeChallenges5&7).
23. EncourageMetro Vancouver to implement policies that permit contamination surchargeexemptionsforspecificnon-marketbuildings(seeChallenge1).
24. Supporttheestablishmentofalow-costfoodterminal(seeChallenge19).
25. Openasmallscaleresident-onlytransferstationnearareasofhighpopulationdensity(seeChallenge12,andimagebelow).
Image:PlansforanewresidentialtransferstationintheurbanneighbourhoodofSydhavn,Copenhagen(photocredit:BjarkeIngelsGroup).
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
12
ACRONYMS&DEFINITIONS
• BIA:BusinessImprovementAssociation-anareadesignatedbymunicipalcouncilinwhichbusinessescancollaboratetopromotetheirdistrict.
• CBSM:CommunityBasedSocialMarketing -abehaviourchangestrategythatpromotesinitiativesdeliveredatthecommunitylevelwithfocusonremovingbarrierstoanactivitywhilesimultaneouslyenhancingthebenefits.
• TheCity:referstotheCityofVancouver,unlessotherwiseindicated.• DTES:TheDowntownEastside-ahistoricneighbourhoodinVancouver,boundedbythe
neighbourhoodsofGastown,ChinatownandStrathcona.• EPR: Extended Producer Responsibility – a strategy that makes the manufacturer or
distributorofaproductresponsibleformanagingandpayingfor itstake-back,recyclinganddisposalattheendofitslifecycle.
• GCAP:GreenestCityActionPlan-astrategicpolicyoftheCityofVancouver.• Hauler:acompany,municipaldepartment,ornonprofitorganizationthatiscontractedto
removewastefromabuildingandtransportittoawastetransferstation.• MURB: Multi-Unit Residential Building - a residential building with five or more units,
commonlyreferredtoasan“apartmentbuilding”.• MVHC:MetroVancouverHousingCorporation-thepublichousingagencyoperatedbythe
regionalgovernmentofMetroVancouver.• Non-market:aresidentialbuildingwheretheunitsarenotsoldorrentedonthegeneral
realestatemarket,andhavecontrolsoneligibilityfortenancy.• Operator: a company or nonprofit organization that manages and coordinates the
operationsofaresidentialbuilding,sometimesoncontractwithapublichousingagency.• Organics: food scraps, yardwaste,andcompostablematerials that canbedecomposed
throughanindustrialcompostingprocess.• Publichousing:aresidentialbuildingthatisfundedprimarilybygovernmentagencies.• RFP:RequestforProposals-asolicitation,oftenmadethroughabiddingprocess,byan
agencyorcompanyinterestedinprocurementofacommodity,serviceorvaluableasset,topotentialsupplierstosubmitbusinessproposals.
• SHA: The SeattleHousingAuthority - the largest public housing agency in King County,Washington.
• SRO:SingleRoomAccommodationorSingleRoomOccupancyHotel-atypeof low-costresidentialbuildingwhereresidentshaveasimpleprivatebedroomwithaccesstosharedbathroomsandsometimesasharedkitchen.
• Wastediversion:divertingeligiblewastefromgarbageforreuse,recyclingorcomposting.• Waste streams: the available disposal programs for different types of waste, including
garbage,organics,cardboardrecycling,glassrecycling,mixedrecycling,etc.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
13
INTRODUCTION
PROJECTBACKGROUNDZerowasteisaphilosophy,ameanstoanendthatencouragesustostopandthinkabouthowandwhywasteisgenerated. Zerowasteisalsoasystemsgoal,toclosethelinearprocessofharvest-production-consumption-disposalsothatallwasteisreused.Thisgoaliseasilydefined,yetthepathtoreachitisaffectedbynumerousuncertaintiesincludinghumanbehaviourandpolitical trends. The goal of this report is to support the long term vision of zerowaste, byidentifying challenges, sharing strategies, and proposing interventions that recognize thecomplexityandprevailinginequitiesinpresentwastemanagementsystems.Partofdevelopinganequitablestrategyforzerowastemeansrecognizingthediversityofneedsandabilitiesofparticipantsinthesystem.Wherethetermequalitysuggeststhatallparticipantsshouldbetreatedequally,equitysuggeststhatsomeparticipantsexperiencesystemicimpactsthat negatively affect their ability to participate, and thus compensatorymeasures must beemployedinorderforthemtohaveanequalshotatparticipatinginthesystem.Inthetermsofthisproject,thismeansthatindividualswithbarriersneedmoresupportandconsiderationinorder to facilitate theireffectiveparticipation inzerowasteprograms. This isa foundationalprincipleonwhichthisreportisbased.ThegoalforMetroVancouverandits21municipalitiesshouldbe:toachievezerowastethroughtheimplementationandoperationofequitableandefficientwastemanagementprograms.Thismeansthatprogramsmustbeadaptedtomeettheneedsandabilitiesoftheirparticipants;to“meetpeoplewherethey’reat”.Theimpetusbehindthisreportrecognizesthatfewspecializedprogramsexistthataretailoredtotheneedsofmarginalizedparticipants.Understandingtheneedsandabilitiesofpeoplewhoarethemostchallengedtoparticipateinwastemanagementprogramsrequiresagreatdealofinsight,access,andstudy.Inconductingtheliteraturereviewandspeakingtoprofessionalswhograpplewiththesechallenges,itbecameevident that this focused fieldhas aprofound lackof research. What is presentedhere is acompilationoflearningsfromotherswhoworkinthefield.Mostoftheideassharedherearenot the author’s own, but rather a collection of the diverse perspectives shared throughinterviews with building managers, waste haulers, municipal and regional waste programplanners, non-market housing operators, environmental educators, waste system inspectors,wastemanagementconsultants,andbehaviourchangespecialists.Through this research, it has become evident that numerous cities, housing agencies andbuildingsarestrugglingwithsimilarissues.Somehavedevelopeduniquestrategies,whichmayinspirenewprogramsandsuccesselsewhere.Manyoftheissuesdiscussedherearenotuniquetonon-markethousingfacilities,butaffectotherMulti-UnitResidentialBuildings(MURBs)andhousingtypestoo.Withinnon-markethousingfacilitiesthereisawiderangeofcapacitiesand
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
14
needs, and the issues discussed here represent the spectrum of challenges across differentbuildingtypes.Aneffectivewastemanagementplanrequiresthedeploymentofmanymulti-facetedstrategiesover time: from systems changes at the source, such as California’s ban on plastic bags, toparadigm-shiftingeducationaloutreachanduser-friendlysystemdesign.Ifdeployedintherightway,zerowastestrategiescandomorethaneliminategarbageandresultingpollution;theycanalsohavepositivesocietalexternalities,includingbuildingcommunitypartnerships,supportinginnovation,reducingoperationalcosts,andcreatingmoregreenjobs.1Guidingthisresearcharefouroverarchingquestions:
1. What are the prevailing challenges facing different types of non-market multi-unitresidentialbuildingsinimplementingzerowasteprograms?
2. Whataretheprevailingchallengesfacedbyspecificdemographicswithbarriersthatmayinhibittheirparticipationinzerowasteprograms?
3. Whatstrategiescanbeusedtoimprovezerowasteprogramgoalsinnon-marketmulti-unitresidentialbuildingsandfordemographicswithbarriers?
4. Howmuchwasteisgeneratedfromnon-marketMURBsinVancouver?
SCOPE
BUILDINGTYPESThis research examines waste management practices in non-marketMURBs. “Non-market”indicatesunits inbuildingsthatarenotpartofthewiderrentalhousingmarketbecausetheyhavepoliciesthatrestrict tenancy; this includesshelters,supportivehousingunits,andrentalapartmentsthatareownedbynonprofitorganizationsandgovernmentagenciesthatreserveunits for tenants who have disabilities, special needs, and/or incomes below a specifiedthreshold.ThisstudyalsoincludesSingleResidentOccupancyhotels(SROs),someofwhichareprivatelyownedandapartofthewiderrentalhousingmarket,butare includedbecausetheytypicallyhouseindividualswhoarereceivinggovernmentfundedshelterallowances.Itmaybeeasiertotermallofthesebuildingtypesas“low-income”,butsuchterminologyisdiscouragedduetoprevailingstigmatizationandambiguityof theterm. For thesakeof thisstudy,“non-market” is the terminology used, because it more accurately identifies the fact that thesebuildings arenot in the standard rentalmarket, but rather are in a categoryof housing thatreceivesspecializedsupportduetotheneedsofindividualswholivethere.
1CityofVancouver(2016):http://vancouver.ca/news-calendar/vancouver-takes-next-step-to-becoming-a-zero-waste-community-by-2040.aspx
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
15
Moreexpansivedefinitionsofthefourprimaryhousingcategoriesincludedinthisstudyareasfollows:
• Sheltersprovidetemporaryaccommodationsforhomelessindividualsandthoseat-riskofhomelessness.Somesheltersalsooffermealprograms.
• Single Resident Occupancy Hotels (SROs) provide short-term or long-termaccommodationinsinglerooms,typicallywithoutprivatebathroomsorkitchens2.Thesearetypicallythelowest-costaccommodationsavailableforrentintheCityofVancouver.SROscanbebothprivatelyandpubliclyowned.
• Supportivehousingcanincludemultipletypesofspecializedaccommodationfor:o Adultsatriskofhomelessnesso Womenfleeingviolenceo Seniorso Individualswithphysicaldisabilitieso Individualswithmentalhealthchallengeso Individualsinaddictionsrecoveryprograms
• Non-marketrentalhousingcanincludemultipletypesofaccommodation:o Subsidizedhousingwithrentgearedtoincome,forindividualsandfamilieswho
arelow-income,disabled,over55,orhaveAboriginalancestry.o MURBsownedbygovernments,nonprofitorganizationsandcooperatives,which
mayhaveamixofsubsidizedandunsubsidizedunits,andwhichhaverestrictionsfortenanteligibility.
Whilethesecategoriescapturethekeycharacteristicsofbuildingtypes,therearemanyothervariables thataffect thecapacityofbuildings toengage inwastemanagementprogramming,including:thenaturesofindividualtenants,theinclinationsofbuildingstaff,buildinglocation,funding mechanisms, association with a housing organization and the support mechanismsprovided, age and nature of the building structures, waste storage areas available, years ofoperation of the building, andmore. It can be helpful to think of non-market housing as acontinuum, where each area of the continuum requires different approaches to achievesuccessfulprogramimplementation. Thefigurebelowshowstherelativepositioningofsomeexamplesofhousingfacilitiesexaminedduringthisstudy;ingeneral,buildingsthatareorientedforlonger-termtenurestendtohavemoredevelopedzerowasteprograms.
2BCHousing(2016):SingleRoomOccupancyHotels
Figure:HousingContinuumfromtheCityofVancouverHousingandHomelessnessStrategy2012-2021.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
16
Acomparisonofexamplesofhousingtypesbywasteprogramanddurationoftenure:
WASTESTREAMS Thisresearchexamineswastemanagementprogramsformultiplewastestreamsincluding:
• Organics: including food scraps, food soiled paper, yard waste, and compostablepackaging.
• Recycling:includingpaper&newsprint,cardboard,glass,metalandplasticcontainers.• Garbage• Bulkywaste: includingfurniture,mattresses,appliances,andother large itemsthatdo
notfitintypicalwastebinsorwhichrequirespecialrecycling.
METHODSTheresearchforthisreportincludedinputsfromseveralsourcesincluding:• Aliteraturereviewofrelevantresearchandpublishedarticlesfromthepast20years.• Reports, studies, policy documents, general literature and websites produced by
municipalities, regional governments, nonprofit agencies, waste haulers, previousstudentresearchers,buildingoperatorsandwastemanagementconsultants.
• Direct input from localmunicipalities andMetro Vancouver throughmeetings, phoneinterviewsandemails. Throughthesechannels,23municipalities inMetroVancouverwerecontacted,ofwhichfiveprovidedinputforthisresearch.
• ThreemunicipalitiesandhousingagenciesoutsideoftheVancouverregionprovidedinputthroughphone interviews, emails, and shared literature. They included: TheCitiesofTorontoandCopenhagen,aswellastheSeattleHousingAuthority.
Non-marketrental
Supportivehousing
SROs
Shelters
• Housingforwomen-leadfamilies
• MetroVancouverHousingCorporationsites
• Long-termprivateSROs
• Co-operativehousing
• Seniorshousing• Transitionhouses
Implem
entatio
nofze
ro
wasteprogram
s
Typicaldurationoftenure
• Supportivehousingforindividualswithmentalhealthchallenges
Non-marketrental
• Low-barrierhousingforrecentlyincarceratedindividuals
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
17
• Directinputobtainedthroughin-personinterviewsandphoneinterviewswitheightCityof Vancouver staff, sixbuildingmanagers and operationsmanagers, two haulers, andthreethirdpartyconsultants.
• A waste audit conducted in collaboration with Metro Vancouver and TetraTechConsulting,accordingtowasteauditmethodologiesemployedbythosetwopartners.
• Note:buildingresidentswerenotdirectlyengagedinthisresearch.Thiswasduetothesensitivity and ethics requirements required for such research, and because sufficientstudiesalreadyexistthathaveengagedresidentsandadequatelyconveytheirneedsandperspective. The focus of this study is to gain insights from keydecisionmakers andpower-holders in waste management systems, so interviews with these stakeholderswereprioritized. However,futureresearchonthistopicshouldworkto includedirectinputfromthisessentialstakeholdergroup.
LIMITATIONSTheprimarylimitationsinconductingthisresearchwere:• Finding and communicating with professionals in other cities and housing agencies
outsideofmetroVancouver.Thiswasduetothenatureofcold-callingstaffduringthesummermonthswhenpeople areprone to takeholidays, and thedifficulty in findingrelevantcontacts.
• Getting truthful insights and the full picture from interviewees. As the author wasworkingfortheCityofVancouver,respondentsmayhavebeenhesitanttofullydisclosesomeof the issuesorpractices takingplace in thebuildings theyareassociatedwith,becausetheseactionsarenotincompliancewithregulations.
• Findingacademicliteratureandarticlesonthetopicthathavebeenpublishedinthepast20years.Therehasbeensurprisinglylittleacademicresearchdoneinrecentdecadesonstrategies for improved waste management, especially with a focus on non-markethousing. Numerous studies exist that examinewastemanagement in the developingworld,andmeasuretheefficacyofrecyclinginitiativesinhousinginthe1990s,butfewrelevantrecentstudiescouldbefound.
• The metro Vancouver-centric focus of the research, which makes the findings lessapplicabletootherregions.ThedeliverablesofthisreportarefortheCityofVancouver,andthusthefocusisnaturallyVancouver-centric.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
18
CONTEXT
POLICYDIRECTIVESFROMTHECITYOFVANCOUVERThisresearchendeavourstosupportprogressivedirectivesdevelopedbytheCityofVancouverthatactivelyshapethetrajectoryofsolidwastemanagementprogramsinthecity.Thefollowingarethetwomostrelevantpolicydirectives.GREENESTCITYACTIONPLANThe Greenest City Action Plan (GCAP) seeks to “reduce solid waste going to the landfill orincineratorby50%from2008levelsby2020”.Thepriorityactionsfor2015-2020are:
• Action4.1:increaseoveralldiversionoforganicsbycontinuingtosupporttheexpansionoffoodscrapsrecyclingtoallsectorsandsupportMetroVancouver’s2015disposalbanoforganicmaterialstolandfillandincineratorthrougheducationandenforcement.
• Action4.4:supportMetroVancouver’sZeroWasteChallengethroughthedevelopmentofeducationandenforcementstrategiesforallsectors,withafocusonwastepreventionandmaterialreuse.
ZEROWASTE2040InrecognizingthatcurrentGCAPtargetsonlyextendto2020,onJune1st2016,VancouverCityCouncilapprovedamotionregardingthedevelopmentofaZeroWasteStrategy,referredtoasZeroWaste2040,thatemphasizesthelongtermgoalof100%materialrecovery,orzerowaste.Thezerowaste2040strategyiscurrentlyindevelopment.RATIONALEFORTHISSTUDY
EXISTINGZEROWASTEPROGRAMSSince2010,Vancouverhasreducedtheamountofsolidwastesenttolandfillorincineratorby23%,almosthalfwaytothe2020goal.3Thishasbeenachievedthroughanexpansionofzerowasteprograms,includinganexpansionofacceptedmaterialsincurbsiderecyclingandtheroll-outoforganicspickupservices. Asof spring2016,all sites in theCityofVancouverarenowrequiredbyby-lawtohaveorganicsandrecyclingdisposalprograms.Thischangecomplementsexisting regionaldirectives fromMetroVancouver thatbanorganicsand recyclablematerialsfromthegarbagestream.
3CityofVancouver(2016):http://vancouver.ca/news-calendar/vancouver-takes-next-step-to-becoming-a-zero-waste-community-by-2040.aspx
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
19
Attheregions’transferstations,contaminationsurchargesforgarbagearesetat50%ofthetotalweight-based tipping fee, and $50 per item for Banned Hazardous and Operational ImpactMaterials(hazardouswastes)andBannedProductStewardshipMaterials(refundablebeveragecontainers).IntheCityofVancouver,inspectorscanlevyfinesfornotfollowingrequiredwastemanagementprocedures,includinginfractionssuchas:
• Residential: garbage cart cannot close, cart overflow, no recycling program, non-compliant recyclingplan, noorganicsplan, non-organics in green cart, andprohibitedmaterialsingarbage.
• Commercial:containerleak,containerinpoorcondition,failuretokeepcontainerclean,failuretodisplayaddress,failuretoprovideasecurelock,collectionvehicleleaking.
• Other:unlicensedcontaineronthestreet,puttinggarbageinapublicreceptacle,failuretoobeyapreviousorder.
Presently,finesarerarelyleviedagainstsiteoperatorsbecauseofthelengthyprocessinvolvedin issuing tickets, and because the City is taking a gentler approach by issuingwarnings andproviding support insteadof applying penalties for noncompliance. However, thismay soonchange.Newbylawsintroducedin2016willallowstreetuseinspectorstoissuesticketsswiftlyusing theMunicipal Ticketing Information system (MTI). Inspectors are being trained in thisprocessnow,andthesystemisexpectedtobeactiveinthefallof2016.Theextenttowhichnewfineswillbeappliedunderthissystem,however,isstillyettobedecided.
LOOKINGATNON-MARKETBUILDINGSThe City of Vancouver has over 5000MURBs, of which 13% (634 buildings) are non-marketMURBs.Manyofthesenon-marketMURBshavelargenumbersofunitsandhighdensities,sotheproportionofunitsintheCitythatareinnon-marketMURBsislikelyhigherthan13%.Asthecitycontinuestogrowinpopulation,MURBswillincreaseasashareofhousingstock,andthusstrategiestoimprovewastemanagementprogramsinMURBsareessential.Non-market
Figure:progressinVancouvertowardsthezerowastegoal(source:Cityzerowastewebsite).
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
20
housing sectors are not exempted from disposal bans, andmany buildings are struggling toimplementzerowasteprogramstocomplywithregulations.Developingasetofrecommendedapproacheswill enable theCity to reachoutandassist thesebuildingswith their zerowasteneeds.Improving waste management programs in non-market housing not only decreases garbagevolumesandhelpsmeetregionaldirectives,butalsohasamyriadofotherbenefitsincluding4:
• Creatingsavingsinlongtermbuildingutilitycosts• Creatinghealthycommunitiesbyprovidinghighqualityandsecurelivingenvironments• Strengtheningcommunitiesbyengagingtenantsinenvironmentalinitiatives• Leading the way for sustainability initiatives in the social housing and residential
developmentcommunity• Reducingindividuals’environmentalfootprints
BACKGROUNDONTHEISSUE
UNDERSTANDINGBARRIERSAllpeoplehavepersonalbarrierstovaryingextents.However,residentsinnon-markethousingtendtohavemorenumerousandmorechallengingbarriersthanresidentsinmarkethousing.Thisisbecauseindividualswithsignificantbarriersaremorelikelytofacepersonalhardship,havelow- or no-income, and experience unpredictable life circumstances which makes securingtenancyinmarketrentalhousingmoredifficult.Thepurposeofnon-markethousing,intheory,istoprovidespecializedresidentialfacilitiesandsupportsthatmeettheneedsofindividualswithbarriers, so they have homes where they can thrive. Some housing providers and buildingsspecialize in supporting residents with specific types of barriers; common barrier typesencounteredinthisstudyinclude:
• Mentalhealthchallenges,includingdepressionandanxiety• Substanceaddiction• Physicaldisabilities• Previousincarceration• Oldage,dementia,andlimitedmobility• LimitedabilitytocomprehendEnglishlanguage• Limitedknowledgeoflocalculturalnorms• Havingyoungchildren• Dependenceonexternalorganizationsforsustenanceandincome,overwhichindividuals
havenocontrol• Stigmaandprejudiceduetoanindividual’sgender,race,occupation,culture,language,
sexualorientation,physicalability,personalhabits,appearanceandsocialstatus• Loneliness,andalackofpersonalconnectionsandsupportnetworks
4BCHousing(2015):TenantEngagementonSustainabilityGuide.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
21
Developingbarriersisnotachoice;theyareoftenaproductofsystemicinjusticeandinequality,inasocietalsystemthatperpetuatesmarginalizationandviolenceagainstthosewholivewithbarriersandinpoverty.ManyofthesebarriershavedevelopedpowerfulstigmasinVancouversociety. These barriers put individuals at a disadvantage in reaching their potential andparticipating inallaspectsofsociety, includingintheirresponsibilitiesastenantstosorttheirwaste. Developing an understanding of the implications of specific barriers on individuals’behaviourandneedsisessentialinordertodevelopprogramsthatcansupporttheseindividualseffectively. Up to this point, no comprehensive waste management strategies have beendevelopedbytheCityofVancouvertoworkwiththespecificneedsofindividualswithbarriersandthenon-marketbuildingstheylivein.
PREVAILINGPARADIGMSANDBEHAVIOURCHANGEWastemanagement isonesystemwithina largersocietalsystemthat isshapedbyprevailingparadigms. There are numerous key paradigms that strongly influence the way wastemanagementsystemshaveevolved,especiallyinthenon-markethousingsector,forexample:
• Peoplewhodonotsorttheirwastearelazyandincompetent.• Poorpeopledon’tcareabouttheenvironment.• Peoplewhoillegallydumpbulkywasteareimmoral.
These paradigms antagonize and assign fault to the individual. Assumptions aremade thatindividualslivinginsomenon-markethousingdonotcareaboutmanagingtheirwaste.However,these people are just doing their best given their limited resources, personal barriers, lifepressures,andthesystemtheyhavetoworkwithin.Rather,weshouldask:whatisitaboutthecontextoftheirlivingsituation,theirpersonalbarriers,andthesystemstheyoperateinthatshapetheirbehaviour?Individualswith barriers are just as passionate and capable as anyone else. However, theseindividualsaremoreoftennegativelyaffectedanddrainedbythesystem,whichcansaptheirenergyforextrawastemanagementefforts.Thisrealityextendstoallpeople:cognitiveenergyisaresource,whichislimited,andthusspentselectively.Forthisreason,anywastemanagementsystemmustbedesignedtobecognitivelylightweightsothatdesiredbehaviourisaseffortlessasflickingalightswitch.Here,weshiftthefocusofblameformalfunctionsfromtheusertothesystem:“ifthere’saproblem,it’sbecauseyoursystemiswrong”5.
5QuotefrominterviewwithRubenAnderson.
“Thestartingassumptioninbehavioralpsychologyshouldbethat:consciousnessdoesn’tplayaroleinhumanbehaviour.”
-Dr.RobertProvine,ProfessorofPsychology,UniversityofMarylandinBaltimore
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
22
Idealsystemsarethosethataresocognitivelylightweightthattheyareintuitive:theusercanproperly use the system without priorinstruction. These are called compassionatesystems, because they work with and notagainst the existing behaviours of users. Intheory, by studying users well enough, theytellyouhowthesystemshouldbedesigned.Whilethismayseemadauntingchallenge, itexplains why so many awareness-basedbehavior change campaigns have provenfutile; in many instances it is actually theinfrastructure or system design that is theprimary issue, which is more difficult toaddress,butdoingsomayprovesignificantlymoreeffectiveinincreasingwastediversion.Supportingresidentstoachievehousingwithdignityisacoreobjectiveofnon-markethousing,andwastemanagementprogramsmustbecustomizedtocreatedignifiedlivingenvironments.
“Itshouldbeeasytodotherightthing.Wastedisposalandseparationshouldbeaccessibleregardlessoftypeofhousingorparticularneeds.Householdsshouldhavegoodfacilitiesfordepositingbulkywasteavailabletothem.Bulkywasteroomsinapartmentblockshelpresidentstodepositbulkywasteeasilyeveniftheydonothaveacar.”
-CityofStockholmWastePlan,2013-2016
Figure:“99.99%ofourbehaviourisshapedbyourcontext,andthesystemsinplacethere”-RubenAnderson.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
23
KEYFINDINGSBelow, thekey findingsof this study identify theprevailingchallenges towastemanagementprogramsinnon-markethousing.Findingsareorganizedaccordingtochallengetype,includinga discussion of each challenge with cases and stakeholder inputs, and suggestedrecommendationsspecifictoVancouver.The19challengeareasaresortedintoeightthematicgroupings,asfollows:I.Residentengagement&motivationsforwastesorting 1.Forresidentsin“survivalmode”wastesortingmaynotbefeasible,andoperatorsmust
meetresidentswheretheyareat. 2.InallMURBs,wastedisposalisanonymousandthussortingisoptional. 3.Wastemanagementprogrameducationforresidentsmustbedeliveredstrategically. 4.Residentsdonotmaintainlong-termcommitmenttosortingwaste.II.Wastemanagementsystemuserinterface 5.Wastesortingisnotconvenient. 6.Accessmaybedifficultforresidentswithphysicalbarriers.III.Wastestreamcontamination 7.Somebuildingshavenoorganicsorrecyclingserviceatall. 8.Hazardouswasteingarbagecreatesissuesatmultiplestages. 9.Contaminationruinsthevalueoforganicsandrecycling.IV.Wastestorage 10.Wastestorageinoutdoorpublicareascreatesissues. 11.On-siteorganicsmanagementdependsonchampions.V.Bulkywastemanagement&illegaldumping 12.Law-abidingbulkywastemanagementcomeswithsignificantbarriers. 13.Illegaldumpinghasbecomecommonplace.VI.Supporting&buildingrelationshipswithbuildingstaff 14.Buildingstaffneedmoretrainingandsupport. 15.BuildingtrustandimprovingcityservicesVII.Hauler-relatedissues 16.Issueswithpick-ups. 17.Addressingsenseofdistrustandfrustrationwithhaulers.VIII.Budgetlimitationsforbuildingoperators 18.Somenon-marketbuildingoperatorsfaceadditionalsystemicandsituationalchallenges
thatputthematadisadvantagerelativetootherbuildings. 19.Aninefficientpracticeof“fooddonations”putsmealprovidersinadifficultsituation.I.RESIDENTENGAGEMENTANDMOTIVATIONSFORWASTESORTINGWhen designing resident engagement programs, material must be delivered in a way thatmatches the nature of the participants, and that takes into consideration the internal social
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
24
dynamics and networks of the participants themselves. 6 Resident engagement programstypicallyhavetwogoals:
1. Buildingbuy-inbydemonstratingtoparticipantswhyitisimportantthattheyparticipateinwastemanagementprograms. This includes showingparticipantswhere theirwastegoesaftertheythrowitaway,andhighlightingenvironmentalissues.
2. Instructingparticipantsonhowtocorrectlyusetheirwastemanagementsystem,includinghowtosort,thelocationsofbins,commonmistakes,etc.Whilesomeinstructionisalwaysnecessary to introduceparticipants to anewprogram, awell-designed system requiresminimalinstructionandshouldbeself-explanatory.
Successdependsonparticipantsfeelingthatthesystemtheyarebeingaskedtoparticipateinhas been designed with their needs and preferences in mind. A system that antagonizesparticipants and makes them feel resentful will not get far. This is why an equitable andcompassionate systems approach is important, so that waste management programs aredesignedbasedonthenaturesofusers.Itisalsoessentialtohavepositivebehavioralrolemodelsineverysocialnetwork(orbuilding).It starts with the building staff, and extends to early adopters. It can also include groupinfluencers:thepeoplewhoarewell-connectedinthebuildingandinfluencethebehaviourofothers.Gettingthesegroupsofpeopleonboardcanmakeorbreakanewsystem.1.FORRESIDENTSIN“SURVIVALMODE”WASTESORTINGMAYNOTBEFEASIBLE,ANDOPERATORSMUSTMEETRESIDENTSWHERETHEYAREAT.
Discussion:Forindividualswithsignificantbarrierswhoareina“survival-basedlifestyle”,adheringtowastemanagementguidelinesistheleastoftheirconcerns.Justgettingtenantstoremovewastefromtheir rooms, and in extreme cases to stop tossing waste out of their windows, are primary6AlexPentland’sresearchteamatMITstudiesthesubtle,subconsciouscommunicationbetweenpeople,andhowthisinfluencestheirbehaviouranddecisionmaking.Thisfieldofnetworkscience“triestounderstandpeopleinthecontextoftheirsocialnetworksratherthanviewingthemasisolatedindividuals”.IntheirbookHonestSignals(2008),theydiscussthepowerofdirecthumaninteraction,andexplainthatanyattempttoinfluencethebehavioursanddecisionmakingofagroupmustconsiderthesocialdynamicsofthatgroup,thekeyinfluencers,andsubconsciouscommunicationhabits.
Challenges:
Wastemanagementisnotapriorityforresidents,especiallywhenin“survivalmode”.Someresidentsarechallengedtoremovewastefromtheirrooms,letalonesorttheirwaste.Ineverybuildingthereisaspectrumofbarriersandcapacitiesofresidents.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
25
concernsforbuildingstaff.Forthisreason,manybuildingsthathouseindividualswithsignificantbarriershaveonlysinglestreamwasteservice.Therewillalwaysbesomepeoplewhowillnotchange,orwhochangeveryslowly,duetopersonalbarriers.Theneedsandrealitiesoftheseindividualsmustberespectedandaccommodated,andeffortsmadetomeetpeoplewheretheyareat. Thismeansalteringregulationsandprovidingspecializedsupportstobuildingswheretheseindividualslive,sothatbuildingstaffcanbettersupporttheirresidents.
Ineverybuildingthere isaspectrumoftenantswithvaryingbarriersandcapacities,manyofwhomdowanttoparticipateinwastesorting.Effortsshouldfocusonthesepeopleandthevastmiddle ground of people who are open-minded to adopting new habits. Building goodrelationshipsbetweenresidentsandbuildingstaffisthemostessentialcomponentofcreatingenvironmentswhereresidentsfeelsupportedtoengageandchangetheirhabits.Thismeansnotputtingstaffinasituationwheretheyhavetopoliceresidents’wastemanagementhabits.Inmanycases,buildingstaffcannotusefinesorthreatstochangetenantbehaviour,duetolow-barrierandhousingfirstpolicieswhichprotecttenanciesandprohibitevictionexceptincasesofviolence.Ahighturnoveroftenantsmeansonetenantmaymovethroughmultiplebuildingsatdifferenttimes.Thisisacommonfeatureofmanynon-marketbuildings,andaddsanadditionallayerofcomplexity inestablishingeffectivewastemanagementprograms,aseachbuildingmayhavedifferent programs in place. Encouraging system standardization across the region is animportantstep,whichisdiscussedfurtherunderChallenge3.
“Somepeopledowanttomakechangesintheirlives,oncethey’reoutofsurvivormode.Wemeetpeoplewherethey’reat.”
-GeorgeSimpson,RainCityHousing
Recommendations:
• EncourageMetroVancouvertocreateallowancesindisposalbanregulationsfornon-marketbuildingsthathouseindividualswithsignificantbarriers.BuildingoperatorscouldapplydirectlytoMetroVancouverforexemption,withspecialbagstickersorprintedbagsissuedbyMetroVancouverdirectlytotheapprovedbuildingsforusetoidentifytheirwasteinthestream.Thiswouldallowhaulerstoreduceservicecostsforthesebuildingsbecauseofreducedcontaminationsurcharges.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
26
2.INALLMURBS,WASTEDISPOSALISANONYMOUSANDTHUSSORTINGISOPTIONAL.
Discussion:Forresidentsindetachedhouseswithindividualwastebins,improperwastemanagementresultsindirectfeedbackintheformofamissedpickupandinformationaltagattachedtothebin.InMURBs this is not so due to the use of shared waste receptacles. Providing feedback oncontaminationandwastevolumesisimportantinordertoencouragebehaviourchanges.Feedbackloopsareneeded,sothatresidentscanseetheimpactsoftheiractionsandfeeltheyareworkingtowardsarecognizablegoal.Thereareseveralwaysthiscanbeachieved:
• Building Managers can request detailed waste volume information from their haulerand/orwastelevelscanbetrackedinternally.
• BuildingManagerscandisplaythisinformationpublicly,suchasonaboardinthewasteroomor lobbydisplaying“contamination incidents thismonth in thisbin”or“garbagevolumesthismonthcomparedtothelastfourmonths”,etc.
• Whenthere iscontaminationorproblemsinthetrashroom,takeapicture. Sendoutmonthlylettersoremailstotenantsexplainingtheissueinaconstructiveway,andposttheimagewithremindersinthewasteroom.
• Provideanincentivechallengetobuildingresidents,forexample:“ourbuildingissavingup for a foosball table by reducing ourwaste charges. Please do your part to avoidcontaminationwhenyouthrowoutyourwaste,andsavingsfromreducedwastecostswillgotowardsthisnewamenityforthewholebuilding.”
• Makeitknowninthewasteroomhowmuchthebuildingischargedfordifferenttypesofcontamination,andeverytimethebuildingischargedbythehaulerforcontamination,makeitknown:“extrachargeslastmonthduetocontamination:$_.__”.
CASE:TheBCCooperativeHousingFederationprovideswastemanagementsupporttoco-ops,includingpresentationsonhowtoimproveprograms,andcoordinatinggrouphaulercontacts.Allco-opshaveaninternalrecyclingcommittee,andCBSMisusedeffectivelywitheducationalcampaigns among residents. Co-opmembers see direct financial benefits ofmanaging theirwasteeffectivelybecausewastediversionandreducedcontaminationresultsinlowermonthly
Challenges:Residentsdisposeofwasteanonymously,thereisnofeedbackorrepercussionsfortheiractions,anditisdifficulttoidentifywhoiscausingcontamination.
Residentsarenotfinanciallymotivatedtosortwaste,itismucheasiertojustthrowitallinthegarbage.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
27
fees.Thereisastrongincentivetocorrectlysortwaste,andextensiveresourceswithineachco-optosupportresidentsindoingso.CASE: In Copenhagen, all waste streams are only accepted in clear bags to discouragecontamination.
Recommendations:
• Intrainingswithbuildingstaff,encouragethemtoimplementresidentfeedbackloops(seeabovelist).
• Requireallwastebagstobeclear,forsubtleanti-contaminationpressure.• Createacity-orregion-widecompetitionforbuildingstoreducetheirgarbage
volumesandcontaminationlevels,basedondataprovidedbyhaulers.See“TheMayor’sToweringChallenge”intheCityofToronto,asanexample.
Image:Eye-catchingpromotionalimageryusedbytheCityofCopenhagen.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
28
3.WASTEMANAGEMENTPROGRAMEDUCATIONFORRESIDENTSMUSTBEDELIVEREDSTRATEGICALLY.
Discussion:StartingoffrightSettingcommunityexpectationsandpositivebehavioursrightfromthestart,whenresidentsfirstmove in is essential. Residents should be given an orientation to the building’s wastemanagementsystems,alongwithapackageofmaterialsthatclearlyexplainthesystemintheirownlanguage,sothatexpectationsareclearlysetandanyquestionscanbeanswered.CASE:AttheBudzey,asupportivehousingfacilityoperatedbyRainCityHousing,residentssignaprogramagreementwhentheymovein,whichisasoftdocumentthatsetsgroundrulesonhowtobeagoodneighbour.Here, residentsagreeto“putyourgarbage in thebinsasprovided -pleasedonotthrowanythingfromyourwindows.Recycleyourcontainersandpaperproducts.Greenwastemustbeseparatedfromyourregulargarbage.Binsandreceptaclesareprovidedinthe garbage room in thebasement. If you need acontainer for your green wastepleaseaskstaff.”StandardizationandvisualsThe visual language of thesystem must be intuitive andcomplete, using standardizedcolours,icons,andsignageinalllanguagesspokenbyresidents.
Challenges:Thereishightenantturnover,andnewresidentsarenotgivennecessaryinformationandmaterialstomakenewsortingsystemseasyforthemrightatthebeginning.Thereisalackofregion-wideconsistencyinwastemanagementsystems,soeachMURBhasdifferentwastemanagementprocedures,whichresidentsareexpectedtore-learnwhentheymove,includingforbulkywaste.
Residentswithbarriersdon’tshowuptoevents.
Image:TheBudzey,asupportivehousingfacilityoperatedbyRainCityHousing.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
29
CASE:MetroVancouverHousingCorporation(MVHC)recentlychangedtothreestreamweeklypickupserviceprovidedbyasinglehauleracrossalloftheirproperties.ThisstandardizationofservicehelpseasethetransitionfortenantswhomovebetweenMVHCproperties.UniqueapproachesfordifferentdemographicsNumerousstudies, includingthoseconductedbybothCityofVancouverstaff7andEmilyCarrstudents8,allconfirmthe importanceof face-to-facecontactwiththecommunityand liaisingthroughbuildingchampionsasthemosteffectivemethodsfordelivering information. Wastemanagementprogramsarehighlyinfluencedbyacculturation,andunderstandinghowdifferentculturalgroupsviewwastecanbekeytoengagingresidentseffectively.Itisalsoimportanttoidentifywho are the groupswhodonot showup toevents and meetings, and how they prefer to bereached. In cases where there are residents withmental health challenges, workshop leaders shouldhavesensitivitytrainingtoappropriatelyengagewiththese groups. BC Housing has developed a toolkitwhichincludesguidesforresidentengagement.
7CityofVancouver(2009):WestEndIllegalDumpingProject.8CompostCollective(2012):FinalReport.
Image:StandardizediconsandcolourssetbyMetroVancouver.
“Insomecountries,thereisatraditionofcaringforareasaroundandbetweendwellings,whilst,inothers,thisisnotthecase.Suchgeneralattitudesaffectthewillingnesstoparticipatelocally.”
-Report:UNHabitat(1989):CommunityParticipation-SolidWasteManagementin
Low-IncomeHousingProjects.
Image:AMVHCflyerinChineseexplaininghowtousetheneworganicsrecyclingprogram.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
30
CASE: At the Seattle Housing Authority, resident education initiatives inMURBs start with acommunitymeetingwithfood,aninteractivegame,andlanguageinterpretersforalllanguagesneededinthatbuilding.FlyersaregivenoutinEnglishandlanguagesspokenbyresidents.Theturnoutvaries,aseachbuilding isquitedifferent,anddependsonthesocialdynamic ineachbuildingassomepeopledon’tfeelwelcomeincommunitymeetings.
Recommendations:
• Trainingsforresidentsmustbeofferedcontinuously,especiallyinbuildingswithhightenantturnover.Thisisalreadyrequiredunderthecurrentsolidwastebylaw,wherebuildingsarerequiredtoprovideeducationtonewtenantsaboutrecyclingandorganicsdiversion,andmustremindtenantsannuallyaboutwastemanagementsystemsinthebuilding(clauses5.15and6.7A.4inthebylaw).Remindbuildingstaffofthis,andprovidesupportthroughnew“accountmanagers”.
• Encouragebuildingstohaveacomprehensiverecyclingeducationprocessfornewresidents.Includeguidelinesforrecyclinginthetenantprogramagreement.Provideanoptionalkitforallnewtenantsthatisofferedbythebuildingmanagerwhentheymovein,whichincludescomprehensivestandardizedinstructionsinmultiplelanguagesonhowtousethewastesystemcorrectly,aswellasin-unitwastesortingcontainers.
• EncourageMURBstoprovidewaste-relatedfeedbackinformationtoinformresidentsoftheprogressoftheirdiversionefforts,andrelatedenvironmentalimpacts.Suchinformationcouldbeprovidedattheentrancetocommonwasterooms.Waste-relatedfeedbackinformationcouldalsobeprovidedwhereotherbuildingnewsiscommunicated,suchasinlobbiesandelevators.
• Extensivesignage(includinghand-outs,postersandbinstickers)shouldbeprovidedforfreetobuildingstoencouragepeopletocorrectlyseparateorganicsandrecycling.ThisisalreadyavailablefromtheCitywhenrequested,butAccountManagerscouldproactivelyhandoutthismaterialwhereneeded.
• EncourageMetroVancouvertocontinuetoengageandcollaboratewithmunicipalitiestostandardizerecyclingpracticesacrosstheregion.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
31
4.RESIDENTSDONOTMAINTAINLONG-TERMCOMMITEMENTTOSORTINGWASTE
Discussion:EmpoweringindividualswithbarriersThecreationofprogramsthatperpetuatepeer-to-peerrolemodelingcanbehighlyeffectiveinengrainingpositivewastesortingbehaviors. Low incomebuildingsarenotexemptfromthis:everyonehasrolemodelsandrelationshipswiththeirneighbours.Inmanynon-marketbuildingsthereisawidespectrumofdifferentpeoplelivinginonebuilding,withverydifferentlevelsofpersonalagencyandbarriertypes.Byempowerresidentsandgivingthemtheopportunitytobechampions in their buildings, people who are more inclined to participate in waste sortingprogramsmaybecomerolemodelsforothers.CASE: In most buildings run by the nonprofit operator Community Builders, tenants areempowered to fulfill much of the buildings’ internal needs, including janitorial and waste
Image:Ineffectiveinformationalsignagebesideagarbagebininasupportivehousingfacilityforresidentswithmultiplebarriers.
Challenges:Residentsdonotfeelasenseofownershipoverwastemanagementinitiatives.Afteraperiodofcommunityengagement,contaminationlevelsgobackup.
Asenseofdutytowardswastesortingbehavioursisnotculturallyingrained.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
32
managementservices,usingthis“bottomup”approachtoengagetenantsandbuildasenseofresponsibilityfortheirlivingenvironments.AmbassadorprogramsTherearenumerousexamplesofprogramsthatgiveresidentstheopportunitytoberolemodelsfor theirneighbours. Theseprogramsempower residents,buildneighbour relationships,anddelivereducationalmaterialsinformatsappropriatefortheresidents’demographic.Theyalsobuildmomentum to helpwaste diversion programming continue beyond the end of specificresidenteducationalinitiatives.CASE:AttheSeattleHousingAuthority(SHA),beforerollingoutanewprogramtoall,focusisgiventobuildingparticipationandreducingcontaminationinasmall,willinggroupsfirst,whobecomerolemodelswhenprogramsarefullyrolledout.CASE: The City of Toronto’s 3Rs Ambassadors program offers free six-hour training and freematerials in17 languages foranyone interested inbecominganambassador for theirMURB.Trainingsareofferedmonthly,wheretypically10-15volunteersattend,andtheprogramnowincludesover300volunteerAmbassadors.ThelongtermgoalisforeveryMURBintheCityofTorontotohaveatleastoneAmbassador.CASE:Thereare28MVHCsiteswithtenantassociations(outofatotal49sites)whoareinvitedto an annual tenant association conference. Tenants make pitches to their fellow residentrepresentatives for$30,000worthof grants for recyclingprojects at theirbuildings, andalsocelebrateresidentrecyclingchampions.
Images:TheVancouverSouthTransferStationandtheVancouverLandfill.Informingresidentsofwheretheirwasteendsupisanimportantpartofbuildingawarenessaroundtheimportanceofzerowaste.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
33
II.WASTEMANAGEMENTSYSTEMUSERINTERFACE5.WASTESORTINGISNOTCONVENIENT.
Discussion:Aneffectivewastemanagementsystemrequiresconveniencewhensortingwaste in-unitandwhen depositing waste in common receptacles. The user interface of the system must beintuitiveanduser-friendly.Insomebuildingsvisitedforthisstudy,organicsandrecyclingbinsweremissingcompletely,andmanybinshadnosignageatall.
Recommendations:
• Recruitandtrainvolunteerstojoinanofficialcitizen-poweredmovementsupportingzerowasteprograms.ThisprogramcouldbebrandedasanextensionoftheKeepVancouverSpectacularprogram.Suchaprogramcouldinclude:
o FreetrainingworkshopsforMURBresidents.o AllocatefundingtoprovidesmallgrantstoRecyclingAmbassadorteams,
whichcanbedeliveredthroughtheexistingGreenestCityNeighbourhoodSmallGrantsprogram.Thesegrantscancovercostssuchasprinting,translation,workshoporganization,etc.
o ProvidesupportivematerialstovolunteerstorunresidentengagementprogrammingintheirownMURBs.
Challenges:Residentsdonothavebinsintheirunitstosorttheirwasteinto;sometimesbinsaresuppliedwhenbuildingsareopenedbutthennoreplacementsareprovided.Garbagereceptaclesaremucheasiertoaccessthanorganicsandrecyclingreceptacles.Wasteroomsarenotuserfriendly,andhavemissingelementsincludingbins,signage,andlanguages.
Manyresidentsreportneverreceivinginformationonorganicsorrecyclingprograms.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
34
TheCityformerlyprovidedfreebluetotebagswithrecyclinginstructions for MURBs. Sometimes these materials areprovided by building funders when a building opens, butreplacement supplies are not provided. Residents withbarriersareoftenunabletoprovidetheirownbins;purchasingfour-litericecreampails,forexample,isunlikelyduetolackoffunds,freezerspace,andhealthissues.CASE: In Toronto, in-unit blue recycling bags and kitchencatchers for organics have been available for free for allresidents since 2009. Toronto Community Housing (TCH)Superintendentscanrequestupto10%replacementofbinsandbagsperyear,whichtheystockon-site.InnewTCHsiteredevelopments, specific space in each kitchen has beencreatedformulti-binwastesorting.
Creating a pleasant andintuitiveexperience inwasteroomsisalso important. Inthepilot study currently in progress at TCH, user interfaceimprovements at each site included improved signage withwastediversion-specificbulletinboards,betterstickersforin-unitbinsand largemetal-backedposters forcommonwastereceptacles.TwonewlybuiltTCHbuildingshaveincorporateda3-streamwastechutesystemsoneachfloortomakewastedisposalmoreconvenientforresidents.CASE: In Toronto, new mid- and high-density residentialbuildingsarerequiredtofollowTorontoGreenStandardTier1guidelines,
whichinclude:requirementsfor 3-streamsorting that isas convenient
as garbage disposal, waste room accessibilitystandards,andaminimum10m2storageareaforbulkywasteandadditionaldiversionprograms.VoluntaryTier2guidelinessuggestprovisionofseparatedcabinetspaceinallkitchensuitesfor3-stream segregated collection, as well as adedicatedcollectionareaorroomforhouseholdhazardous waste and/or electronic waste.BuildingsthatimplementTier2suggestionscanqualify for reduced development fees. Several
Image:Toronto’sversionofa“recyclinglounge”,withhatchesthattransportwastetoanotherroomoutofsight(photocredit:TorontoCommunityHousing).
Image:GarbagepilesupbecomingdifficulttomanageinanSRO.
Image: The City of Toronto’sfree in-unit recycling bags,complete with standardizedinformational icons (photocredit: Toronto CommunityHousing).
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
35
newbuildingsinTorontohaveincludedaversionofthe“recyclinglounge”,whichincludesoneroomwiththreehatchesinthewallwhereresidentsgotodeposittheirwaste,withchutesthattransferthewasteintoaseparateadjacentroomoutofsight.CASE:InCopenhagen,allMURBsarerequiredtohavewastemanagementplansandreceptaclesor spaces for: garbage, cardboard, paper, hard plastic, batteries, metal, small electronicequipment, bulky waste, large electronic equipment, (sometimes) bottles and glass, and(sometimes)afreeitemexchangearea.Hazardouswasteisgiventothebuildingmanagerwhichisthenpickeduponcepermonth.
Garbage bins should always be placed to be more convenient to access than organics andrecyclingbins,howevertherelativeconvenienceofeachbintypemustbeconsidereddependingontheusers’tendencies.
Images: In Copenhagen, multiple well-labelled colour-coded bins are provided to MURBs to makerecyclingeasierforresidents(photocredit:CityofCopenhagen).
Recommendations:• CollaboratewiththeProvincialGovernment,MetroVancouverandMMBCtoprovide
freeorganicskitchen-catchersandbluerecyclingtotebagstoallMURBSrespectively,andallowbuildingstafftoorderupto10%replacementperyearforfree.Encouragethesein-unitbinsfororganicsandrecyclingtobecomestandardrequireditemsinalllivingspacesaspartofstandardleaseagreements,assmokedetectorscurrentlyare,sothatreplacementsbecomeunnecessaryovertime.
• Continuetoprovidefreestandardizedstickersandposterstobuildingstafffordistributiontotenantsandforpostingincommonwasterooms.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
36
6.ACCESSMAYBEDIFFICULTFORRESIDENTSWITHPHYSICALBARRIERS.
Discussion:Dumpstersarenotoriouslynotuserfriendly,especiallyforresidents with physical barriers including: seniors, kids,andpeoplewithphysicaldisabilities.Lidscanbetooheavyordifficulttoopen,binedgescanbetootalltogetwasteinto, and waste can be heavy and cumbersome to lift.Whilesomeorganizationshavereplacedmetaldumpsterlidswithplasticlids,sometimesthesearestilltooheavyorarenotpermittedduetofirehazardregulations.
Challenge: Dumpstersaredifficulttouseforsomeresidentswithphysicalbarriers.
Whenbinsarestoredinalleysordistantwasterooms,accessingbinscanbedifficultforsomeusersduetodistance,physicalimpediments,andpersonalfears.
Images:ArecyclingbinataSeattleHousingAuthoritysitewhichhasbeenmodifiedtomakeitmoreaccessibletoresidentswhoarechallengedtouseadumpster.
• AddlanguageandvisualexamplestotheCityofVancouverGarbageandRecyclingStorageFacilityDesignguidelinesthatencouragewasteroombestpractices,including:
o Standardizedcolour-codedwallsectionswithcorrespondingbins.o Garbagereceptaclesplacedtobeslightlymoreconvenientthanreceptaclesfor
otherstreams.o Designatedspaceforbulkyitems,electronics,batteries,andhazardouswaste.o Creatingexchangecentresinbuildingstofacilitatere-useofgoodsthatarestill
ingoodcondition.o Separationofuser-accessiblecommonspacefromroomwherewasteisstored,
byconnectingchutes(“recyclinglounge”).• Createcleardesignguidelinesforrenovationsandnewconstructionthatpresentbest
practicesforwastemanagement,includingspecificspaceforin-unitwastesortingbins.• Encourage,andeventuallyrequire,allMURBstohavecomprehensivewaste
managementplans,includingdesignatedspaceson-sitetomanage:garbage,organics,cardboard,paper,mixedrecyclablecontainers,glass,EPRprograms(i.e.batteries,smallelectronics),bulkywaste,andhazardouswaste.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
37
CASE:InSHAtownhomes,disabledresidentscanputtheirbinsbehindtheirbackdoorforpick-up.InMURBs,dumpstersandbinshavebeenmodifiedtobehandicap-accessible.CASE: Three TCH buildings for seniors are considering implementing a door-to-door organicscollectionserviceforresidentswithseveremobilityissueswhoareunabletoleavetheirunits.This service has the added benefit of allowing waste collection staff to check bins forcontaminationandprovidetargetededucation.
III.WASTESTREAMCONTAMINATIONWhenthereiscontaminationinwaste,buildingoperatorsenduppayingmoreforwasteservices.Somehaulerschargecustomersdirectlywhenthereiscontamination,addingtheinstanceasaline item in their invoice. Other haulers absorb the cost upfront and recoup it later, ascontaminationlevelsaretakenintoaccountwhenservicepricingisrenegotiatedatthestartofanewserviceterm.
Recommendations:
• Whendumpstersareincludedinnewbuildingdesigns,ensuretherearemechanismstomakethemmoreaccessible,includingramps,orhatchesinthesideofdumpsters.Alternatively,encouragebuildingstobuilddesign“recyclinglounges”withhatchesinthewallthatcarrywastetodumpstersinanotherroom,orundergroundwasteunitswithlowreceptacles.
Images:Contaminationishighlyvisibleinsidethiscleargarbagebagfromasupportivehousingfacility,whichcontainssyringes,refundablebeveragecontainers,electronics,andnumeroustypesofrecyclables.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
38
7.SOMEBUILDINGSHAVENOORGANICSORRECYCLINGSERVICEATALL.
Discussion:Asmanyhousingorganizations and shelters in theDTESoffermealprograms,understandingwastechallengesassociatedwithmealpreparationisessentialtomanagingtheirorganicswasteprograms9.BuildingOperatorRainCityhassuccessfullyimplementedorganicscollectionforallkitchenwastefrommealprogramsintheirbuildings.Manyoperatorscomplainthatimplementingorganicsandrecyclingprogramsintheirbuildingsisnotcosteffective,especiallywhentherearenoincentivesorresourcestosupportthem.InTorontoandCopenhagen,servicefeesfororganicsandrecyclingpick-upareimbeddedincitywaste fees, sonoadditional feesarecharged for theseservices. ThisapproachcouldnotbeimplementedinVancouverwithoutaregionalwaste-containmentby-law.
9FormoreinformationontheneedsofmealserviceorganizationsintheDTES,seereportsfromtheDTESKitchenTablesProject.
Challenges:Somebuildingshavemealprogramswithanon-sitekitchen,butnocompostservice.Manybuildingsdonothavesufficientincentiveorsupporttosetupwastediversionprograms.
Forseasonalshelters,residualwastesareimproperlydisposedofasgarbageattheendoftheseasonduetolimitedresources.
Images:AsharedkitcheninanSROlackscompostandrecyclingreceptacles,andagarbagebagfromanotherSROiscompletelyfullofrecyclables.Whenbuildingshaveonlysingle-streamwasteservice,residentshavenooptionbuttoputeverythinginthegarbage.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
39
Refundable beverage containers are alsocommonly found in garbage, as most buildingshave no receptacles in which to deposit theseitems.Some buildings appear to have recycling andorganics pickup services, but these bins actuallybelongtootherbuildingsandhavebeenmovedbyresidents. Building staff are then tasked withreturning these bins to their rightful owners,thoughmanybinslackidentification.Bicyclepartsareacommonbulkyitemleft incommonspaces,whicharetypicallycollectedbybulkywastehaulerswithotherwasteandputintogarbage.
In shelters, individualsbringa lotof scavengedmaterialsinwiththem.Whenseasonalsheltersclose in the spring there are large volumes ofwasteconcentratedthere.Thiswasteallgoestothe garbage, as shelter staff do not have theresourcesneededtoseparatethiswaste.
Image:Acollectionofrecyclingbinsthathavebeentakenfromothersitesanddepositedinthecommonspaceofanonprofitsupportivehousingfacility.
Images:Apileofbicyclesinthecommonspaceofasupportivehousingfacility,andunhelpfulsignageinanSRO.Bikepartsareacommonbulkywasteitemthattypicallylackaneffectivewastemanagementplan.
Image:WhilethisSROhasrecyclingbinsinthewasteroomthatareusedbyresidents,thereisnorecyclingpickupservice,soallrecyclingiscollectedwiththegarbage.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
40
8.HAZARDOUSWASTEINGARBAGECREATESISSUESATMULTIPLESTAGES.
Discussion:Insomebuildingswherethere ishighvolumeofsyringewaste, therearenotenoughsyringedisposalboxesortheseboxesarenotplacedinstrategiclocations.Withoutimprovementstotheprovision of syringe disposal boxes, individuals who put syringes in garbage receptacles areunlikelytochangetheirbehavior. Theyarenotmotivatedbythe$50finepersyringethat is
Challenges: Hazardouswasteingarbage,especiallysyringes,isdangerousforwastehandlersandincurscontaminationsurcharges.Highchargesencouragehaulerstodisposeofcontaminatedwasteoutsideoftheregion.Manybuildingshaveinsufficientsyringedisposalboxes.Cleargarbagebagsmakecontaminationmorevisibletoinspectors,butarerequiredforuseinsomesupportivehousingfacilities.Surchargesforitemsidentifiedasbannedhazardousandoperationalimpactmaterialsarelikelytoincreaseinthenearfuture.Ifthereisnoon-siteprogramfornon-medicalhazardouswaste,tenantsaremorelikelytodisposeoftheseitemsingarbage.
Recommendations:• Manynon-marketbuildingsneedspecializedsupporttointroduceorganicsand
recyclingprograms.Ajointly-fundedprogramshouldbecreatedbetweenMetroVancouver,theCityofVancouver,andMMBCtoofferfreecustomizedwastemanagementconsultingtobuildingstaff,tohelpthemset-upprogramsinbuildingsthatcurrentlyhavenoservice.
• CollaboratewiththeProvincialGovernment,MMBC,andMetroVancouvertocreateafundtosupportwastemanagementprogramimprovementsinnon-markethousingfacilities.Buildingoperatorscouldapplyforgrantsforspecificprojects,withmonitoringandreportingrequirements.
• SeasonalsheltersfundedbyBCHousingshouldberequiredtobudgetforwastesortingatthetimeofshelterclosurestoimprovediversionrates.
• Encouragehaulerstopartnerwithlocalnonprofitcommunitybikeshopstodivertbicyclepartsfromhauledbulkywaste.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
41
applied to haulers at transferstations, and subsequentlypassedontobuildingoperators,becausetheydonotreceiveanynegative feedbacks from this.Syringedisposalboxes inpublicalleys are often full and thusunusable,resultinginindividualsdisposing of syringes directlyintodumpsters,orleavingthemonthestreet.MetroVancouver’scurrent2015TippingFeeBylawincludesabanonhazardousandoperationalimpactmaterials, includingsyringesandexcrement, intended todiscouragedisposalof thesematerialsinmunicipalsolidwaste.However,MetroVancouverisconsideringeasingthebanon
excrementandfindingwaystomanageitsafely,duetoitsincreasingprevalenceinthewastestream.Asimilarapproach could be used to address the presence ofsyringesinthewastestream,fromspecificcustomers.Most haulers encourage the use of black or opaquewaste bags to hide contamination, while in somesupportivehousingfacilities,clearbagsarerequiredinorder to protect tenant support workers. Clear bagsincrease the visibility of contamination and bannedmaterials ingarbage, resulting inahigher incidenceofsurchargesfromMetroVancouverinspectors.Surchargesforbannedmaterialsmaysoonbeincreased,
accordingtotheProposed2017TippingFeeBylawChanges:“DisposalbansonanysingleitemslistedunderBannedHazardousandOperationalImpact Materials or Banned ProductStewardshipMaterialsareenforcedthroughaflat $50 surcharge for each occurrence... Anincrease in that flat fee could provide anincreased incentive for residents and otherhaulers to divert such materials. The $50surcharge has remained constant since 2009.Considering inflation increases since 2009, anappropriatecurrentsurchargewouldbeintherangeof$65.”Costlybansencouragehaulerstodisposeofwasteattransferstationsoutsideoftheregionaljurisdiction.
Image:Asyringeinthegarbage,acommonoccurrenceinsomebuildings.
Image:Asyringedisposalboxinapublicalley,inneedofemptying.
Image:AsyringedisposalboxinasharedwashroominanSRO.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
42
CASE:InTCHbuildings,hazardousandelectronicwastecanbegiventoaBuildingManagerforstorageinalockedroomuntilpickup.BuildingManagerscanthencalltheCitytoarrangefreehazardouswastepickupviathe“toxictaxi”.ForallMURBsinCopenhagen,hazardouswasteisgiventothebuildingmanagerwhothenholdsitforaspecialtruckthatcomesbyforpickuponcepermonth.
Recommendations:• Improvesyringedisposalprogramsinrelevantbuildings.Requirebuildingoperators
toaffixsyringedisposalboxesineverysharedwashroom,besideeverygarbagebin,andallowresidentstokeeponeintheirroomiftheydesirewhichtheycanthenexchangeforanemptyonefrombuildingstaff.
• Improvethefrequencyofmaintenanceandofpublicsyringedisposalboxes.• EncourageMetroVancouvertoremovesyringesfromthelistofhazardousbanned
materialssothattheynolongerincura$50fineperitem.Customersshouldstillbestronglyencouragedtoseparatesyringesfromgarbage.
• Requirebuildingsthatregularlyhavehazardouswasteingarbagetousehigh-visibilityidentifierstomarkbags,thusalertinghandlerstotheirpotentialdanger;thiscouldincludetintedbags,stickers,ormarkedtape.
• RequireallgarbagebagsdepositedatMetroVancouverdisposalfacilitiestobeclear.
Residentsdisposeofsyringesingarbage
Haulercollectsgarbageanddeliverstotransferstation
AtMetroVancouvergarbagetransferstations,inspectorsmayfinehaulersforpresenceofbannedhazardouswaste
Haulerspassfinesontobuildingoperators,orareforcedtoabsorbfinesforoperatorswithfixedfunding
Buildingoperatorshavenomechanismstoenforcebansonresidents
Theincompletefeedbackloopofhazardouswastebansinnon-markethousing
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
43
9.CONTAMINATIONRUINSTHEVALUEOFORGANICSANDRECYCLING
Discussion:Numerousoptionsexistforresidentstomanagethe“ickfactor”oftheirorganicswaste,howevermost of these options have barriers: freezingwaste requires having access to a freezerwithadequatefreezerspace,andmostotheroptionsrequireuserstopurchaseinputs.Especiallyforindividualswhoproduce little foodwasteand/orhave limitedkitchenaccess, theextraeffortrequiredtomanagetheirorganicwastemayseemimpractical.CASE:InMURBsinmanyotherjurisdictions,allcompostbinsincommonwasteroomsarelinedwithcompostablebags.InCopenhagenandmanyEuropeancities,allorganicswastemustbebaggedbyuserswhendepositedinreceptacles,whichislaterde-baggedatprocessingfacilities.CASE:TheSeattleHousingAuthorityhastrialedsupplyingpermittedbiodegradablebagsforfreetoresidentsthroughdispensersincommonwasterooms,withgooduptakefromresidents.Bagswerepurchased throughEcosafe (aSurrey-basedcompany)andcostapproximately$160permonthfor100units.Whengarbagereceptaclesarelocatedinremote corners of buildings, they aremore susceptible to contamination.Receptacles located in central commonareasputsubtlepressureonresidentstosort waste correctly and typically havelowercontaminationrates.
Challenge:Contaminationofplasticbagsinorganicsbinsiscommon,asresidentsprefertobagorganicwastetoavoidsmellsandcontact.
Highlycontaminatedloadsoforganicsandrecyclingaredisposedasgarbage,withassociatedcontaminationfees.
Image:Anorganicsbinwithalinerandfreein-unitbinlinershelptokeepbinstidyinanSHAbuilding.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
44
Image:garbagebinsinanonprofitSROarecentrallylocated,whichdecreasescontaminationduetosubtlepeerpressure.
Recommendations:• Pilotaprogramtosupplyresidentsatprivatelyservicedbuildingswithfree
compostablebagsfortheirorganicswaste,throughadispenserinaneasily-accessiblecommonspace.Considerprovidingthisservicetoothernon-marketbuildingsthatexperiencechallengesinorganicsprogramuptake.
• Providebinplacementconsultationtobuildings,andencouragebinstobelocatedincentralareas.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
45
IV.WASTESTORAGE
10.WASTESTORAGEINOUTDOORPUBLICAREASCREATESISSUES.
Discussion:Many MURB staff complain of bins beingfrequently broken into and damaged, andsome building operators believe recycling isnot possible due to constant bin infiltrationwhenbinsarestoredinalleys,especiallyintheDTES. Haulers are responsible for replacingbroken locks and wheels, but often it takesthem considerable time to complete theserepairs,andinthemeantimelargemessescanaccumulate. Operators are occasionallychargedbyhaulerswhenthishappens,butarepowerless in these situations and have noalternatives.CASE:AtoneMVHCsite, receptacleswereswitched fromcentralizeddumpsters to individualcurbsidebinsinordertomakeresidentsmoreresponsibleforcontamination,andtoremovethefocalpointforillegaldumping.Ifthereiscontaminationinthebins,thentheyarenotpickedup.
Challenges:Securedwastebinsinpublicareasarefrequentlybrokenintoorleftunlocked.Numerousproblemsarisewhenwasteisstoredinoutdoorpublicareas:wasteispiledontopofbins,wastegetsopenedandrifledthroughbybinners,pestswillopenbagsofgarbageifexposed,andbinsbecomeatargetforillegaldumping.Thisistrueforbinsinallies,outdoorparkinglots,andlargehousingsiteswherebinsarestoredontheedgeoftheproperty.Somebuildingshavenospaceforadequatewastestoragefacilities,eveninpublicareas,sospecialarrangementsmustbemadewithhaulers,whichtypicallyhaveassociatedissues.
Insomealleysandpublicareas,thereisinsufficientspacetostoreallofthedumpstersneededbyneighbouringbuildings.Themoredumpstersthereare,thegreaterchancethatadisposaltruckmaybeunabletoenterthealleytocollectwaste,causinginefficienciesandmissedpick-ups.
Image:Anoverflowingunsecuredgarbagedumpster(photocredit:DonnaTaylor).
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
46
Theincreasedcostofprovidingandservicingtheextrabinsiscompensatedbydecreasedcostsforillegaldumpinganddecreasedcontaminationrates.CASE: The Strathcona BIA currently coordinates an extended waste pick-up service for itsmemberscalledRecycleinStrathconawhichlaunchedinNovember2015.TheserviceisofferedthroughacommunitypreferredserviceagreementbetweentheenlistedBIAmembersandtwolocalcompanies:RecyclingAlternative(alargelocalhauler),andShiftDelivery(abicycle-poweredcargo delivery company). The service provides small to large recycling pickup services fornumerouswastestreamsatareducedrate.TheStrathconaBIAisalsointerestedinsupportingatrialofsharedwastebinsforneighbouringsitesonparallelblocksthatshareanalley. Sharingbinshasthebenefitsof:reducinghaulingcosts,reducingthenumbersofdumpstersandclutter,reducingthenumberoftrucksvisitingthealleys, and making the alleys more attractive for other uses. Specialized shared organicscontainerscandecreasesmellsandpests,andprocessorganicsonsitetodecreasevolume,thusreducingthefrequencyofpickups.Sharedbinsystemsalsoappealtobusinesseswithverysmallorganicsandrecyclingwasteoutputs,whosevolumesarenotlargeenoughtowarrantindividualwastecontractsforthesestreams.TheYaletownBIAisexploringsimilarconceptstoreducethenumbersofbinsonstreets,duetoconcernsthattheyareunsightly,createcrowding,andattractcrimeandinformalshelters.SharedundergroundautomatedwastebinsarecommonplaceinnumerousEuropeancities,andaddressseveralprevailingwastestorageissues.Thewasteisstoredoutofsight,inaunitthatispest-proofand inaccessible tobinners,andeasily sharedamongmultipleneighbouringusers.Depositingwasteintothebinscanberestrictedbykey-cardaccesswithchargespervolumeorweight,ormadeopentoallusers.Thewastevolumeinbinscanbemonitoredremotelysothatbinsareonlyemptiedwhenneeded,improvingefficiencyofpickups.Binscanbeinstalledinjust
Image:undergroundwastestoragecontainersinuseintheNetherlands(photocredit:EureteEnterprises).
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
47
oneday,requirenowiringduetosolarpaneloperation,andcanbeconfiguredforside-unloadingor overhead-crane-unloading depending on space restrictions and the collection vehicleavailable.Thisfully-automatedbinunloadingsystemalsoreducessanitationcrews’exposuretowaste,andcanbeoperatedbyacrewofone.Thebinsaremuchlessaestheticallyintrusivethandumpsters,andthereforecanbeplacedinmorecentral,high-visibilityareas,whichmakesthemmoreaccessible for residents, puts subtlepressureon residents to sort correctly, anddetersillegaldumping.CASE:CleanStartisalocalsocialenterprisethatprovideswastepickupservicestobuildingsusinga“frontdoor”manualwasteremovalmodel,wherewasteiscollectedfrequentlyfrommultiplebinswithineachbuilding. Buildingsare serviced fourdaysperweek, andbuilding staff thenmanagewastebetweenservicedays.
Metro Vancouverwaste room design guidelines recommend that newmulti-family buildingsinclude“FlexSpace”aspartofcentralizedrecyclingstoragespace,“forstorageofotherreusableorrecyclablematerialsthatmaybeaddedtocollectionservicesovertime,inadditiontogarbageandrecyclingstoragespace”;here,thisflexspaceissuggestedtobeanadditional50%ofthespace allocated for garbage and recycling storage. These guidelines are suggestions formunicipalities, as an addition to existingmunicipal bylaws. Such flex space also permits thecreationofdesignatedbulkywastedepositareas.
Image:“front-door”wasteremovalinanSROmeansbagsaremanuallyhauledfromeachfloor.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
48
Recommendations:Note:Athirdpartycoordinator,suchastheBCNonprofitHousingAssociation,wouldbeneededtofacilitatethefollowingpilots.TheCitycaninitiateandprovideindirectsupport.
• Createapilotofcoordinatedwastemanagementzones,whereonehauleriscontractedtoprovideservicestoagroupofneighbouringsites.ApartnershipbetweentheCity,theBCNonprofitHousingAssociation,andthelocalBIAcouldbeestablishedtoprovideservicestobothbusinessesandhousingfacilities.Suchapilotcouldstartsmall,withjustonefullblock,andlaterbeexpandedtoincludelargerneighbourhoodareas.Thefollowingaresiteswherethispilotcouldbeexplored:
o Sitessharingthealleybehindthe600blockofAlexanderStreetandPowellStreetbetweenPrincessAveandHeatleyAve(recommendedbytheStrathconaBIA).
o Currentlythereare43sitesreceivingspecialWednesdaynightgarbagecollectionfromtheCity,duetotheirlimitedcapacityforon-sitewastestorage.Manyofthesesitesareinverycloseproximity(seemapbelow).
o AredesignofBloodAlleyiscurrentlyunderway,andwouldbenefitfromareductioninthenumberofdumpsters.
o OtherareasofhighdumpsterconcentrationinGastown,Strathcona,theDTES,andYaletown.
• Implementapilotofsharedundergroundautomatedwastestoragebins.Opportunitiesforpilotinstallationsinclude:upcomingMVHCandBCHousingsiteredevelopments,andthesitesmentionedaboveforcoordinatedwastemanagementzones.
• Considerusingin-vesselvolume-reducingorganicsunitsinsharedbinpilots,toreducepickupfrequency,andpreventsmellandpestexposure.
• Wheresharedbinsarenotpossible,andorganicsorrecyclingvolumesarelow,engageathirdparty(suchastheBCNonprofitHousingAssociation)tocoordinatecommunitypreferredserviceagreementsbetweenhaulersandnon-marketbuildings&kitchenstoenablethemtoparticipateinmorecost-effectiveorganicsandrecyclingpickupservices.Theservicecouldbeofferedinareaswithhighconcentrationsofnon-marketbuildingsandcommunitykitchens,suchastheDTES.
• EncouragesocialandenvironmentalprocurementpreferencestobeapartofallwastehaulerRFPs,sothatpointsaregivenforhaulersthatcanprovidetheseadditionalbenefitssuchasrequirementstohirelocalworkersandindividualswithbarriers,aswellasuseoflow-andno-emissionsvehiclesandbicycles.Alternatively,RFPwriterscanincorporateavaluepropositionatthebeginningofanRFP,withapreferenceforbusinessesthatemphasizeasocialreturnoninvestment.AddlanguagetothiseffectontheCity’s“FindaHauler”webpage.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
49
11.ON-SITEORGANICSMANAGEMENTDEPENDSONCHAMPIONS.
Discussion:On-site organics management systems can take many forms, including: simple low-capacitythree-bin systems,more advanced systems that break down organics to reduce volumes forhauling,aswellascompletein-vesselanaerobicandaerobicsystemsthatproducefood-gradecompostandcancapturemethane.Morecomplexsystemscanbecomefeasiblewhencostsaresharedacrossmultipleorganizationsorlargehousingfacilities,butallrequirededicatedandwell-traineduserstomanagethesystemseffectively.Withthe introductionofregion-wideorganicspickupandprocessing,on-sitesystemsare lesspopular. However, shared systems that quickly breakdown organics to reduce volumes forhaulingmaybeeffective,especiallyforshared-bininstallations.
Map:LocationofsitesreceivingspecializedWednesdaynightgarbagecollectionfromtheCity.
Challenge:
On-siteorganicsmanagement(composters),canfailwithoutproperusertraininganddedicatedchampions.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
50
CASE: At two MVHC sites, in-vessel organics management systems were trialed with mixedresults.Inorderforsuchsystemstoworktheremustbeadedicatedstaffpersonandteamofwell-trainedresidentvolunteers.Inonecase,withstaffturnoverthenewstaffdidnotsharethesamepassionfortheproject,andsystemfailureresulted.Simplelow-capacitythree-bincompostsystemshavebeen run successfully at severalhousing sites, and continue tobemanagedbyresidentgardeners.CASE:UnionGospelMission(UGM)usesanon-sitein-vesselcompostingunitprovidedbyhaulerRecyclingAlternative.Theunitreducesfoodwastevolumesby80%within24hours,resultinginsignificantlyreducedfrequencyofpickups.Thenon-foodgradecompostisthentruckedtoanindustrialcompostingfacilitytocompletetheprocess.Thesystemiscontained,andissmell-andpest-proof.
V.BULKYWASTEMANAGEMENTANDILLEGALDUMPINGDisposingofbulkywasteaccordingtoregulations isoftenprohibitivelydifficultandcostly forresidentsandbuildingoperators. Prevalenceof illegaldumpinghas increased significantly inVancouverinrecentyears,andhasbecomeacommonplacewayofdealingwithbulkywaste.12. LAW-ABIDING BULKY WASTE MANAGEMENT COMES WITH SIGNIFICANTBARRIERS.
Discussion:Properlydisposingofbulkywaste isamajorchallengeforresidents,especiallythosewhoarelowerincomeandwithoutaccesstoalargevehicle.Whenthereisnocity-wideprogramforbulky
Recommendations:
• Considerusingin-vesselvolume-reducingcompostingunitsinsharedbinpilots,toreducepickupfrequency,andpreventsmellandpestexposure.
Challenges:Carownershipratesaredeclining,makingVSTSinaccessibleforbulkywastedisposal,andhiringbulkywastehaulersiscostprohibitiveformanyhouseholds.
Responsiblebulkywastemanagementcomeswithanimmensecostforbuildingswithlimitedoperatingbudgets.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
51
waste,eachMURBmayormaynothavetheirownprogram,withmixedefficacyincommunicating those programs totenants. In some MURBs with tightbudgets, building staff direct tenants toabandonbulkywasteoncitypropertysothey can call for freepickup inorder toavoidpayingforahauler.CASE: At buildings run by The BloomGroup,residentscoordinatewithbuildingstaff to arrange bulky waste pickupdirectlyfromunits,duetotherebeingnostorage space in buildings. At buildingsrun by RainCity Housing, each buildingtypically receives 1-2 bulky waste pick-upspermonth,orwhenahoarderroomneedstobeemptied.CASE:AtMVHCsitesinVancouver,bulkywastemanagementcostshavesteadilyincreasedoverthepastfouryears.Inthatperiod,asuccessful‘cleanupday’programwasimplementedatthreeVancouversitesin2012andscaleduptosixsitesin2015,whichreducedabandonedwasteatthose sites (see this link for more information). Annual cleanup days give residents theopportunity to exchange unwanted bulky items, build community connections, participate inwastemanagementeducationprograms,anddisposeoftheirbulkywasteinaresponsibleway.CleanupdayeventsaretypicallycombinedwithacommunityBBQmeal,andthewasteishauledawayat theendof theday. MVHC is challenged toabsorb the increasingcostsof removingillegallyabandonedwaste(seetablebelow),whichisoftendumpedbesidewastebinsontheedgesofhousingsitesbynon-residents.
Image:apileofbulkywasteinasecuredspacebehindasupportivehousingfacility.Muchofthiswastecouldbediverted.
MVHCbulkywasteremovalcostsforsitesintheCityofVancouverfrom2012-2015
2012 2013 2014 2015Totalwastecosts,allsites $27,725.15 $41,058.65 $39,703.72 $52,233.47Totalabandonedwastecosts $26,015.77 $34,893.65 $34,977.42 $43,717.75Average,abandonedwastecostsperbuilding
$1,734.38 $2,326.24 $2,331.83 $2,914.52
Average,abandonedwastecostsperunit
$31.68 $41.35 $40.03 $46.81
Totalcleanupdaycosts $1,709.38 $6,165.00 $4,726.30 $8,515.72Average,cleanupdaycostsperbuilding
$569.79 $1541.25 $945.26 $1419.29
Average,cleanupdaycostsperunit $15.67 $14.67 $8.79 $22.42
Datasource:UlrykeWeissgerber,SupervisorofTenantPrograms,MVHC.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
52
Many cities have bulky waste pickupservices, with variations in frequencyandpricing structure. Someexamplesof current bulky waste managementprogramsinclude:• TheCityofToronto:providesfree
bulky waste pick-up weekly onrecyclingday,andwillsendastaffmember out to MURB sites todetermineanappropriatesitefordepositingbulkywasteforpickup.
• TheCityofSanFrancisco:offersallresidents two free bulky wastepickupdayspermonth.
• TheCityofCopenhagen:requiresallMURBstohaveadesignatedroomorplaceforbulkywaste,whereitcanbestoreduntilspecifiedfreecollectiondays,whichoccurfourtimesperyear.Rowhousesanddetachedhousesalsogetfreebulkywastepickupfourtimesperyear.
• InSeattleatSHAsites,abulkywastepick-upserviceisofferedtobuildingmanagersbytheSHA,charging$17.54peritemincludingmattresseswhichmustbewrappedforbedbugs,and$22.22peritemforlargeappliances.
In2006therewereapproximately2200abandonedmattressespickedupintheCity of Vancouver, and in 2015 therewereover800010.Manymattressesaredisposed of due to bedbugs and hightenant turnover. Metro Vancouver iscurrentlyinvestigatingtheplausibilityofincluding mattresses in a future EPRprogram.
10InterviewwithJimHeeps,SuperintendentofStreetCleaning,CityofVancouver
Image:mattressespiledupfordisposalinasecuredareabehindasupportivehousingfacilityarebaggedduetobedbugcontamination.
Image:amapofthe11recyclingstationsforresidents,spreadacrosstheCityofCopenhagen(indicatedbythelargeblackandreddots).
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
53
CASE: In Copenhagen there are elevenrecycling centres across the city whereresidents can take excess waste, anddelivery by bicycle is highly encouraged.Bulkywasteisacceptedforfreeattheserecycling centers which have very user-friendly signage, numbered wastestreams that do not change, andattendantsonhandtoanswerquestions.Therearefive“RecyclingStations”whichaccept 36 streams of recycling, and six“Collection Points” which accept 12streams, including: hazardous waste,electronics, household appliances, bulkywaste (furniture, mattresses, woodboards, carpets, etc), mixed metals,paper, cardboard, glass, PVC, treatedwood,hardplastics,andtextiles.Therearealsore-usecenters,whereresidentscanexchangeunwantedhousehold items, andone experimentalwaste-reuse design lab called “Goldmine”wherenewproductsarebuiltfromupcycledwaste.
Recommendations:• Implementrecommendationsfromthe2008staffreportonbulkywaste,starting
withtheimplementationofapilotbulkywastepickupserviceinVancouver,withtheintentiontoscale-uptheprogramtoincludeallresidentialbuildings.
o Regularannualbulkywastedisposaldaysgivetheopportunityforresidentstoplantolookforfreeitemsonthosedays,andgivesthecityadaytofocusdeliveryofwaste-reductionmessaging.
• EncourageallMURBstohaveabulkywastemanagementplanincludingadesignatedbulkywastedrop-offareaintheirbuildingsoranoptionforresidentstoleavebulkywastewithbuildingstaff.
• Offerfreebulkywastepickupforallnon-markethousingsites,especiallythosethathouseresidentswithmultiplebarriers.
• Explorethefeasibilityofopeningasmalltransferstationforresidentialwasteandspecializedrecyclingprograms,locatedclosetohigh-densityneighbourhoodssuchasintheFalseCreekFlats.Thiscentrecouldbeahubforrecyclingeducationprogramming,includeafreeitemexchangespace,awasteup-cyclingdesignworkshop,andbeadistributionpointforwastemanagementmaterials.
Image:recyclingstationsinCopenhagenhave36clearlyidentifiedrecyclingstreams,including31:householdappliancesandelectricalequipment,32:monitors,36:cables,and24:lightbulbs.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
54
13.ILLEGALDUMPINGHASBECOMECOMMONPLACE.
Discussion:Social norming indicates that peoplewill dowhat they seeothers getting awaywith, and soabandonedwastecanaccumulatequickly.Therefore,bulkywastepickupturn-aroundtimesareveryimportant.CASE:Burnabyhasamulti-prongedapproachtotackleillegaldumping:
• Crews make regular weekly visits to frequent illegal dumping sites, unprompted bycomplaints,topreventaccumulation.
• Thereweresignificantreductionsinillegaldumpingonceamandatorybulkyitempickupprogramwasimplemented,evenwherebuildingsalreadyhadprivatehaulers.
• Burnabyhaspurchasedsixhighdefinitionsecuritycamerastomonitor illegaldumpinghotspots(costingapproximately$5000-$6000each).Theycansetpolygonstomonitorspecificactivityareas,canalertstaffofactivity,livefootagecanbeviewedremotely,andthey can easily capture license plates. They swap the cameras through different hotspots, as they takeonly 20minutes to install. Camerashavebeenhighly effective inreducingdumping.
CASE:AspartofthecurrentTCHpilot,programswereimplementedtocombatillegaldumpingat20housingsites, including: installationofsecuritycameras, improvinglightinginhotspots,andhiringsecurityguardsformove-outtimeswhenSuperintendentsarenotonsite.
Challenges:ResidentsandbuildingstaffhavelearnedthattheCitywillpickupabandoneditemsforfree.Thissystemrewardspeoplewhobreaklitteringlaws.
Illegaldumpingoftenoccursonnon-markethousingsitesfrompeopleoutsideofthehousingcommunity.Illegaldumpingisalsocommononorarounddumpstersinpublicareas,whichaccumulatesquicklyifnotcleanedupquicklybytheCity.
Recommendations:
• Useamulti-prongedapproachtoreduceillegaldumping,including:o Installhigh-definition,moveablecamerastoaidinmonitoringillegal
dumpinghotspots.o Improvelightingathotspots.o Implementacity-widebulkywastepickupprogram.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
55
VI.SUPPORTINGANDBUILDINGRELATIONSHIPSWITHBUILDINGSTAFF
14.BUILDINGSTAFFNEEDMORETRAININGANDSUPPORT.
Discussion:BuildingManagersandStaffholdthepowertoimprovingwastemanagementinbuildings,andengagingtheminasupportivewayisthekeytoimprovingdiversion.Stafftrainingisespeciallyimportantbeforetheintroductionofanynewprograms,andshouldbeofferedwellinadvanceofresidentengagementefforts.Somehaulersdoofferbuildingstafftrainingforafee,butmostbuildingoperatorsarenotinclinedtopayforthisservice.CASE:TorontoCommunityHousing(TCH)isthelargestsinglewasteserviceclientoperatingabout8%ofallTorontoMURBs.Duetothechallengesthatariseinservicingthesebuildings,theCityofTorontohasdedicatedresourcesandstaffspecificallytoworkingwithTCHtoaddresswastemanagementneeds.Also,anew“CustomerServiceandWasteDiversionImplementationUnit”wasestablishedundertheCollectionsandLitterOperationsgroupwithaboutfivestaff“AccountManagers”. Every MURB in the City is assigned to an Account Manager, who offers freeconsultationandsupport tobuildingstaff including trainings, lobbydisplays, troubleshooting,andwastemanagementsystemdesign.TheprogramallowsAccountManagerstobuildongoingrelationshipswithbuildingstaff,anddevelopacompleteunderstandingofabuilding’sneeds.TheCityofTorontooffersfreewastemanagementtrainingtoallMURBstaffatanannualtrainingevent. A “train the trainer”workshop format isused toequipMURBstaffwith strategies toeducatetheirtenants.ThetrainingeventsarefundedinpartbytheContinuousImprovement
Challenges:Thereishighstaffturnover,andbuildingstaff(includingBuildingManagersandSuperintendents)lacksufficienttrainingandsupportonwastemanagement.Inmanycases,wastemanagementisnotapriorityforbuildingstaff,duetomorepressingissuesandlackofmotivation,sotheydonotencourageresidentstosortorreducewasteaccumulationinprivaterooms.Theyneedlotsofsupport,andprogramsneedtobe‘servedonasilverplatter’.Externalcontractorsworkinginnon-marketbuildingsmaylacktrainingandknowledgeofthebuilding’swastemanagementsystem,causingcontamination.Thereispotentialtohiremoreresidentstoimprovewastemanagementintheirownbuildings.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
56
Fund,afundingprogramcreatedthroughapartnershipbetweenWasteDiversionOntario,theCityofToronto,andStewardshipOntario.AspartofanewCityofTorontoinitiative(inconjunctionwithapilotstudy),550TCHbuildingstaffweretrainedat20half-dayworkshops,whichwillcontinuebeyondthecompletionofthepilot. InTCHbuildingsthereisnofinancial incentivefortenantsandstaffatTCHbuildingstoreducegarbagevolumesbecausethebillforwasteservicesgoesdirectlytotheTCHheadoffice.Inorderto improvefeedbacktobuildingmanagersandresidents,CityAccountManagersarecreatinganew“reportcard”feedbackprogramforbuildingstaffthatwilldetailwastevolumes,prevailingcontaminationissues,andotherissuestobringtotheirattention.CASE: The former North Shore Recycling Program included outreach, follow-up andtroubleshootingsupportsforMURBsinthreemunicipalities.Today,theCityofNorthVancouvercontinues with their Zero Waste Ambassadors program, which “can provide additionalinformation,supportandresourcestohelpincreaserecyclingandfoodscrapsdiversioninyourbuilding.Wecanalsovisityourbuilding toassessyour recyclingneeds,educate residentsonproperrecyclingandhelpyouwithsignageandposters.”CASE:InPeelRegion(Ontario),thePublicWorksdepartmenthasimplementedanRFIDsystemforwaste collection reporting, complementedbya report card feedbackprocess forbuildingmanagers,toinformthemoftheirbuilding’sperformanceandwastecollectionhistory.Many buildings house unemployed residents, some ofwhom are keen to take on additionalresponsibilityintheformofsmallwastemanagementjobsforpay.Hiringtenantscanbeagoodwaytoincreasesupporttobuildingstaffforexpandedwastemanagementprograms,andbuildsupportandempowermentamongresidents.
Recommendations:• CreateaprogramattheCitythatproactivelyprovidesfreeandcomprehensive
buildingstaffsupportservices.ThiswouldincludefreeannualtrainingsforallMURBstaff,ateamofdedicatedCitystafftoprovideone-on-onesupportandbuildrelationshipswithbuildingstaff,implementationtoolsforbuildingstaff,andfreeengagementprogrammingforresidents.
• MasterRecycleriscurrentlydevelopingastafftrainingworkshopforBCHousing,whichshouldbereplicatedforallbuildingmanagersandstaffintheregion.Theworkshopcouldbemadeintoavideoorinteractivetrainingwebsiteandwidelydistributed.
• TrainingandsupportcanbedirectedthroughorganizationssuchastheBCBuildingOwnersandManagersAssociation,theBCApartmentOwnersandManagersAssociation,andtheWasteManagementAssociationofBC.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
57
15.BUILDINGTRUSTANDIMPROVINGCITYSERVICES.
Discussion:Severalbuildingoperatorsindicatedthatenrollinginanorganicsorrecyclingpickupprogramdidnotsignificantlyreducetheirgarbagevolumesandgarbagehaulingcosts,andthusthechangewas far from cost effective. Measures should be taken to improve the cost effectiveness ofimplementingmulti-streamwastesystems.Also,buildingsneedmorespecializedsupporttoroll-outtheseprogramssuccessfully,includingstafftrainingandtenantengagement.When illegal shelters are constructed in alleys, they cause safety and fire issues for adjacentbuildings.Whentheyaredismantled,thePoliceareresponsibleformanagingthepeople,andCitycrewsareresponsibleformanagingtheleftoverwaste.Somebuildingsareconcernedthattheseillegalsheltersarenotdealtwithquicklyenough,andwouldliketoseeaquickerresponsetimefromtheCity.Becausemanynon-markethousingfacilitiesbecomemagnetsforabandonedwaste,thesesitesshouldbeprioritizedwhentheyrequestapickupforabandonedwaste.CASE:TheCityofSanFranciscooffersextendedservicesforwastepickupforafee,includingkeyservice,distanceandelevationservices.WiththeupcomingupdateoftheMunicipalTicketingInformationsystemtoincludeprovisionsforsolidwastemanagementby-lawenforcement,organizationsthathaveahistoryofviolationsshouldbegivenadvancewarningofwhenthenewprogramwillcomeintoeffect,alongwithalistofregulationsandsuggestionstohelpthemachievecompliance.Thisway,theyaregivenfairwarning,whichmaybeeffectiveinmovingthemtoaction.
Challenges:SomebuildingoperatorsdistrusttheCityandMetroVancouver,astheyseetheimplementationofmandatoryorganicsdiversionprogramsasthecreationofanewlucrativebusinessforprivatehaulers,wherecontaminationisinevitableduetothecapacityofoperators,staff,andresidents.Illegalshelterconstructionbesidedumpstersinpublicareascausesfirehazardsandabacklogofwaste,andisnotdealtwithquicklyenoughbytheCityandPolice.TheCitydoesnotofferspecializedwastepickupservices(carry-out,dumpsters,etc).
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
58
VII.HAULER-RELATEDISSUESThereareverymixedreviewsofhaulers:someoperatorspraisetheirhaulersforextrasupportiveservicesprovided,whileotherslambastetheirhaulerforunfairbindingcontracts,mischarges,andprovidinginaccuratedata.16.ISSUESWITHPICK-UPS.
Recommendations:• Incentivizingbuildingstoenrollinorganicsandrecyclingcollectionprogramscanbe
helpedthoughtheimplementationofsharedbinsandcommunitypreferredserviceagreements,whichlowerservicecosts.
• Givesupportandpreferentialtreatmenttohaulersthatsupportthelocalcommunity(throughsocialenterprisemandates,andhiringindividualswithbarriers)andenactbestpractices(suchasusinglow-emissionsvehiclesandprovidingextrasupportstocustomers).
• ReachouttoorganizationsthathaveahistoryofbylawviolationstoinformthemofupcomingchangesintheMTIsystem,andprovidethemwithsuggestionstohelpthemachievecompliance.
• Prioritizenon-marketbuildingsforabandonedwastepickups,especiallywhenillegalsheltersrequireremoval.Explorethefeasibilityofofferingfreeorreduced-pricebulkywastepickupforbuildingsthataccumulateabandonedwastefromelsewhere.
• Explorethefeasibilityofofferingmultiplelevelsofwastepickupservice,suchascarry-outservices,anda“platinum”servicethatcouldincludeorganicsbinlinersandbinwashing.
Challenges:Incorrectbin-sizingandmissedpick-upsresultinoverflowingbinsandcontamination.Ifbinsarevisiblycontaminated,somehaulerswillnotpickupwaste,requiringbuildingmanagerstopayforamoreexpensivewasteremovalservice.Haulersareoccasionallychallengedtogetaccesstowherebinsarelocated,duetolayersofbuildingsecurityandscarcityofbuildingstaff.Haulersareexposedtonumeroushealthhazardswhenhandlingwaste.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
59
Discussion:Numerous issues can cause a missed pickup,includingbuildingstaffforgettingtoputbinsouton the right day, bin access being blocked bydelivery trucks or other waste trucks,contamination,bulkywasteblockingbinaccess,orwastepiledtoohighonbins.Missedpickupscausesignificant issuesforbuildings,especiallybuildings with many units. And when thegarbagebinsgetfull,residentsaremorelikelytopile up garbage or put it into bins for otherstreamscausingcontamination.Haulers are exposed to numerous healthhazardswhenhandlingwaste,whichcouldbemitigatedthroughimprovedwastemanagementpractices.Hazardsinclude:leakybags,bagscontainingsharphazardouswaste(syringes,knives)thatcanpokethroughbags,pests(cockroaches,bedbugs),mold-infestedwaste,andoverweightbagsandbins.
17.ADDRESSINGSENSEOFDISTRUSTANDFRUSTRATIONWITHHAULERS.
Discussion:Manybuildingoperatorsexpressedfrustrationwithfeelingtrappedbysomehaulers’restrictivecontractsthatcontainauto-renewalclauses,smallwindowsforcontracttermination,andhighcontract cancellation fees. While other building operators appreciate their haulers, citing
Recommendations:
• Improvehaulersafetybyrequiringclearbagsforallgarbage,andrequirebuildingstousesmallerbinsespeciallywhenbinsareemptiedmanually.
Image:agarbagebaginfestedwithcockroaches.
Challenges:Haulersdonotfulfilltheircontractualobligations,provideinsufficientorincorrectdatatocustomers,andprovidemorewastehaulingservicethanisnecessary.
Thereismorepotentialforhaulerstohirepeoplewithbarriers,especiallythosethatservicebuildingsintheDTES.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
60
contract flexibility, courtesy waste audits,staff training,andprovisionof totesaskeybenefits.CASE:CleanStartBCisanexampleofasocialenterprisehaulerthatbringsaddedbenefitstothecommunitiestheyserve.Theyactivelyhireindividualswithbarriers,someofwhomlive in non-market housing. Not only arethey bringing good employmentopportunitiesbacktothecommunitiestheyserve,becauseoftheirlivedexperiencetheiremployeeshaveadeeperunderstandingofthe uniquewaste needs of these buildingsand how best to manage their wasteeffectively.Theircustomershaveexpressedadesireforanexpansionofnonprofit,communitybenefit-orientedhaulers.Some haulers have a tendency to over-prescribe garbage service, while under-prescribingorganics and recycling. This is inpartbecausegarbage service is typicallymore lucrative forhaulers.
Image:ACleanStartBCwastetruckoutforpickups.
Recommendations:
• Encourage the growth of nonprofit, social enterprise, and cooperatively-ownedhaulers.EncouragesocialandenvironmentalprocurementpreferencestobeapartofallwastehaulerRFPs,sothatpointsaregivenforhaulersthatcanprovidetheseadditionalbenefitssuchasrequirementstohirelocalworkersandindividualswithbarriers,aswellasuseoflow-andno-emissionsvehiclesandbicycles.Alternatively,RFPwriterscanincorporateavaluepropositionatthebeginningofanRFP,withapreferenceforbusinessesthatemphasizeasocialreturnoninvestment.
• AddlanguagetothiseffectontheCity’s“FindaHauler”webpage.• Investigatepotentialtoimplementlegislationattheprovinciallevelthatprotectthe
rightsofwasteservicecustomers,togivethemmorepowertonegotiateandendcontractswithproblematicwastehaulers.
• RequireallhaulersoperatinginMetroVancouvertocollectandprovidewastedata(weights,volumes,andcontaminationprevalence)tocustomers,andtomunicipalandregionalauthorities.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
61
VIII.BUDGETLIMITATIONSFORBUILDINGOPERATORS
18. SOME NON-MARKET BUILDING OPERATORS FACE ADDITIONAL SYSTEMIC ANDSITUATIONALCHALLENGESTHATPUTTHEMATADISADVANTAGERELATIVETOOTHERBUILDINGS.
Discussion:Thestrengthofanegativefeedbackloopmustbesetrelativetothebehaviouritisdesignedtocorrect11,meaningthatregulationsthataredesignedtocreatenegativefeedbackloopstomodifybehaviours,suchascontamination finesandtipping fees,musthaveappropriateseveritybutalsomustreachthepeoplewho’sbehaviourtheyareattemptingtomodify.Finesforsyringes,forexample,donothingtochangebehaviour,butdoputgreatstrainonnonprofithaulersandbuildingoperatorswhoarealreadystretched.Forhaulerswhoservicebuildingsthatproducecontaminatedwaste,theyarecaughtinadifficultpositionbecausethecontaminationcannotbeeffectivelydecreased,andfrequentdisposalsurchargesincreasecostswhilebuildingswithfixedfundingareunabletopaymorefordisposal.11Meadows(1997):PlacestoInterveneinaSystem.
Challenges:Whenservicingabuildingwithfixedfunding,haulerscannotpassfinesontobuildingoperators,andittendstobethebuildingswithhighercontaminationratesthatalsocannotaffordincreasedwastedisposalfees.Thereisaninappropriatedistributionoffines:additionalcostsareoftenhandedtotheorganizationsmostchallengedtopaythem(finesforhazardousmedicalwaste,contamination,removinghoarders’waste,andlargeamountofbulkywaste). Neworganicsdisposalprogramfeesarenotsufficientlyoffsetbyadecreaseingarbagevolumesanddisposalfeesinmanybuildings,andthesebuildingsdonothaveenoughresourcestoimprovediversionrates.Buildingswithfixedbudgetscannotaffordimprovedwastemanagementsystems.Implementationofnewfineprogramswillbeprohibitivefortheoperationalbudgetsofsomebuildings.Inbuildingswhereresidentscollectandhoardabandonedwaste,buildingoperatorsarestretchedtocovercoststodealwithsuchwaste,whiletheCitysavesmoneyasvolumesofabandonedwastearereducedinpublicareaselsewhere.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
62
InmanySROs,wastecartsarestoredinhallwayswhichpresentafirehazard.Oftenthereisnoofficialinternalsystemforcollection,andtenantsarepaid$5totakebinsdowntothealleywhenfull.ManySROshaveverytightbudgetsandarenotinterestedintakingextraeffortforwastemanagement.CASE: In Portland, San Francisco, andNew York, public housing authorities are exempt fromorganicsdiversionprograms.InToronto,TorontoCommunityHousingbuildingsreceivespecialsupportfromtheCitytoincreasetheirparticipationintheCity’swastediversionprograms.InCopenhagen, public housing buildings are required to participate fully in the City’s wastediversionprograms,butreceivenoextrasupport.Allhousingoperatorshaveseenrecentrisingwasteservicescosts.Oneoperatorsharedtheircostdata,whichshowedsignificantvariabilityincostsoverthepastfiveyears,withcostspeakinginthemostrecentperiod(seechartbelow).
Duetothenatureoftenantsinsomelow-incomebuildings,especiallythoselocatedclosetotheHastingsStreetMarkets,hoardingofcollectedabandonedwaste iscommon. Somebuildingsbecomecentersofconcentratedabandonedwastebecauseofthis,andbuildingoperatorsarechallengedtokeepontopofbulkywastemanagementandassociatedcosts.
Recommendations:
• Reconsider theway fines and fees are applied to non-market buildings. Exploremechanisms to reduce or eliminate fines for these building types, and insteadimplementfeedbackloopsthatdirectlyaffectresidents’behaviour(seeChallenges1and2).
$13,312$11,557 $10,522
$12,818
$17,942
$-
$4,000
$8,000
$12,000
$16,000
$20,000
2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 2015-16
Wastehaulingcostsperbuildingforanonprofithousingoperator
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
63
19.ANINEFFICIENTPRACTICEOF“FOODDONATIONS”PUTSMEALPROVIDERSINADIFFICULTSITUATION.
Discussion:Thereare25organizationsofferingregularfreeorlow-costmealsinVancouver12,andupto133organizations offering infrequent free or low cost meal programs in Vancouver 13 . “Mostorganizationsthatacceptfooddonationsarenon-profitsoperatingonverylimitedbudgetsandresourcestoreceive,sort,storeandusedonatedfooditems.Thereisacertaincostassociatedwitheachsteptousethedonatedfooditems”.DorisChow,Managerof theDTESKitchenTablesProject,explains that supermarketorganicswaste, rebranded as “food donations”, can be burdensome for nonprofit kitchens to accept.While volume data has not been recorded due to resource constraints, nonprofits haveanecdotally identifiedan increase infoodwastedumpingsincethe introductionoftheMetroVancouverorganicsban.AstudycommissionedbyLOCOBCin2010onDTEScommunitymealprogramsestimatedtherewaspotentialtodivertapproximately60tonnesoffoodwaste.Atthattime,onlyonekitchenintheirstudywascompostingorganicwaste;participationinorganicsrecyclinghassinceincreased,buta followupstudycould identifyareas for improvement. Forsmallerkitchens, the reportsuggestedagroupsolutioncouldbesoughttomakeorganicsrecyclingmorecosteffective.
12CityofVancouver(2015):Food-Free13VancouverCoastalHealth(2013):FreelowcostandcommunitymealsinVancouver
Challenge:
Manyhousingorganizationsthatoffermealprogramsdependonfooddonations,butgettrappedinasituationwheretheyareforcedtoacceptunwanteddonations,whichincreasestheiroperationalcosts,disposalcosts,andtheoverallvolumeoffoodwaste.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
64
Thereportsuggeststhatbettercoordinationandcommunicationamongkitchens,andbetweendonors and kitchens, could reduce foodwaste generated and thus reducedisposal and foodtransportationcosts.Presently the federalgovernment isexploringnewtax incentives to increase fooddonations,taking inspiration from new legislation in France thatmandates all edible food waste to bedonated. However, focus should be given first to establishing effective food distributionnetworkstomanagecurrentfooddonations,beforedonationvolumesareincreased.
“Manysites,eventhosewithpurchasingbudgets,receivefooddonations.Althoughmuchofthefoodisedible,someisnot,eitherduetopestexposureorduetoproductspoilage,andmust immediatelybedisposed.Manydonorshaveanall-or-nothingpolicy,andsokitchensfeelpressuredtotakefoodthataddsheavilytotheirwastedisposalcosts.Manyofthesitesmakegooduseofproductstheycannotuse,relyingonextensivenetworkstoredistributeexcessediblefooddonations.Otherscannotredistributeitaseffectively.Atsiteswherethedisposalofdonatedfoodaddssignificantlytodisposalcosts,staffshouldbeinvestigatingthetotalcostofacceptingfooddonationsandcreatingthebusinesscaseforpurchasingthematerialstheyneedratherthanpayingfordisposalofexcessfood.Oneissuewiththis,however,isthatsometimesfooddonorsofferotherproducts(disposabledinnerware, cleaners, etc.), and refusing to accept donated food can compromise therelationshipwiththedonor.”
- AmyRobinson, LOCOBusinessNetwork Society of BC (2010):GreeningDTES CharityKitchens,(Draft)FinalReport.
“Theproblemoffeedingpeopleinthisregionisnotafoodshortageissue,butratherafooddistributionissue”
-DorisChow,ProjectManager,DTESKitchenTablesProject
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
65
Recommendations:• CommissionastudythatfollowsuponLOCOBC’s2010studytoexaminewaste
streamvolumesandmanagementpracticesinDTEScommunitykitchens,andidentifyopportunitiestoreducewaste.Thisstudyshouldalsolookatpotentialforcommunityorganizationsthatacceptfooddonationstochargeforredistribution,apracticethatiscurrentlyprohibitedinsomecontexts(suchasforNewHopeCuisine,aformerprojectoftheSalvationArmy)butallowedfororganizations(suchasQuestFoodExchange).Thestudycouldalsoexploretheprevalenceofdisposablecutleryanddishesinmealserviceprograms,andhowtoreducetheiruse.
• UsetheStrathconaBIA’smodelofRecyclinginStrathconatoprocureacommunitypreferredserviceagreementwithalocalhaulertomakeorganicsrecyclingmorecosteffectiveforsmallerkitchens.Theservicecouldbeofferedinareaswithhighconcentrationsofcommunitykitchens,suchasintheDTES.
• Explorethefeasibilityofsettingupalow-costfoodterminaltocentralizethemanagementoffooddonationsandtocreateamarketforB-gradelocalproduce.
o Suchafacilitycouldincorporatenecessaryinfrastructuresuchas:vehicledocks,walk-infridgeandfreezerspace,spaceforprocessingfoodintovalue-addedfoodproducts,efficientwastemanagement,andlow-emissionsvehiclestomoveproduct.
o Itcouldalsoprovideaddedbenefitssuchas:hiringlocalresidentswithbarriersforskillsdevelopment,givingpowertokitchenstocollaborateandsaynotoinappropriatefooddonationsthusreducingtheircosts,facilitatethepurchasingoflocalB-gradeproducewhichalsoreducesfoodwasteonlocalfarms,enablegrouppurchasingdiscounts,streamlinefoodprocurementcreatingcostandstaffefficienciesforbothpurchasedanddonatedfood,increaseaccesstofresh,healthyandaffordablefoodforresidentsintheDTES,andsellingdirecttolow-incomecustomersthroughadiscountcommunitysupermarketand/orcafeteria.
o Supportforsuchastudycouldbesoughtfrom:theBCMinistryofAgriculture,theVancouverCoastalHealth,theBCCentreforDiseaseControl,andtheVancouverFoodPolicyCouncil.
o Forinspiration,thestudyshouldlookto:- TheOntarioFoodTerminal,aninitiativeoftheOntarioMinistryof
Agriculture,whopartnerswithalocalnonprofittodistributeB-gradeproduce.
- DailyTableinBoston,alow-costnonprofitfoodretailer,whoresellsdonatedanddeeplydiscountedfoodaswellassellingpreparedmeals.
- TableMatters,anonprofitinNorthVancouverthatengagesinfood-relatedcommunitydevelopmentprojectsincludingpreventingfoodwastebyprocessingfooddonationsintofrozenmeals.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
66
ASSESSINGWASTEVOLUMES
ASSESSINGSECTORWASTEVOLUMES
There are 634 non-markethousing sites in the City ofVancouver, according tointernalCityrecords(seemapabove for their approximatedistribution). The followingsection provides data onactual and estimated wastevolumesforeachnon-markethousingsector.Notesondataaccuracy:• These measures are
proxies for actual wastevolumes, as volumes ofactual waste disposed ofarelessthanthetotalbincapacity that is providedandpaidfor.
• Recycling service volumesarehighbecauseeverybuildinghasaminimumofthree360literbins(oneforeachpaper,mixedcontainers,andglass),andactualwastevolumesarelikelymuchless.
• DataisbasedonCityhaulingservicedata,andsodoesnotincludewastevolumedatafromotherhaulers.Thishasasignificantimpactondataaccuracy,assomebuildingsmayreceiveonlyoneortwowastestreampickupservices,resultinginabnormallyhighwastevolumesinsome streams. This limitationhasbeenaccounted for in the sectionComprehensiveCityservice, where data is provided for buildings that receive City waste pickup for all threestreams.
Shelters(seetablebelowfordatasummary)
Thereare24sheltersinVancouveraccordingtoanannuallyupdatedlistprovidedbytheGreaterVancouverShelterStrategy.DuringthehomelesscountonMarch10th,2016,therewere1308people counted in shelters including year-round shelters, winter & HEAT shelters, transitionhouses,detoxcentres,safehouses,andsheltersforyouth.• TheCityofVancouverprovidesrecyclingservicetofiveshelters,whichhaveacombinedtotal
of372beds.Nogarbageororganicsservicesarecontracted,sonofurtherdataisavailable.
Map:Distributionofnon-markethousingsitesinVancouver,2015(mapcredit:HoomanShahrokhi).
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
67
• Duetotheverylimiteddataavailableforshelters,weareunabletomakeanyestimatesonwastevolumesproduced.Table:Summaryofwastevolumesinshelters
Shelters Numberof
buildingsservicedbytheCity
Correspondingnumberofunits(beds)servicedbytheCity
Totalcartcapacityvolumeallocatedperweek(litres)
Averagecartcapacityvolumeallocatedperunitperweek(litres)
Numberofbuildingsinsector
Estimatedtotalsectorcartcapacityvolumeallocatedperweek(litres)
Garbage - - - -24
Organics - - - - Recycling 5 372 - -
SROs(seetablebelowfordatasummary)Thereare110SROsinVancouverbasedoninternalCitydata,totaling4406units.• TheCityofVancouverprovidesbothgarbageandorganicspick-upserviceto17buildings,
totaling217units,withcombinedvolumesof10860litresperweekofgarbageand2940litresperweekoforganics. TheCityalsoprovidesrecyclingpickuptotwobuildings,totaling40units,andtheservicevolumeisunknown.
• OfallCity-servicedSROs,theaverageSROunitisservicedwith50.0Lperweekofgarbagepick-upservice,and13.5Loforganicspick-upservice.
• IfallSROunitsinVancouverwereservicedtothesamelevelastheaverageofSROswithCityservice,thetotalweeklyservicevolumewouldbe220,300Lperweekofgarbage,and59,481Loforganics.
Table:SummaryofwastevolumesinSROs
SROs Numberof
buildingsservicedbytheCity
Correspondingnumberofunits(beds)servicedbytheCity
Totalcartcapacityvolumeallocatedperweek(litres)
Averagecartcapacityvolumeallocatedperunitperweek(litres)
Numberofbuildingsinsector
Estimatedtotalsectorcartcapacityvolumeallocatedperweek(litres)
Garbage 17 217 10,860 50.0110
220,300Organics 17 217 2,940 13.5 59,481Recycling 2 40 - -
Supportivehousingandnon-marketrental(seetablebelowfordatasummary)Duetoconstraintsonthedataavailable,datasetsforsupportivehousingandnon-marketrentalarecombined.Thereare500non-marketMURBs(includingsupportivehousing)inVancouveraccordingtointernalCitydata,totaling25,621units.• TheCityprovidesgarbagepickupserviceto41buildings,totaling1510units,withcombined
servicevolumesof183,915L.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
68
• TheCityalsoprovidesorganicspickupto123buildings,totaling5100units,withcombinedservicevolumesof186,360L.
• The City provides recycling service to 366 buildings totaling 20,654 units, and totalingapproximately1866360-literbins,whichtotals671,760litresofservicevolume.
• OfalltheCityservicedbuildings,theaverageunitisservicedwith123.8Lofgarbagepick-upservice,48.0Loforganicspick-upservice,and57.8Lofrecyclingservice.
• Ifallnon-marketrentalandsupportivehousingunitsintheCitywereservicedtothesamelevelastheaverageofbuildingswithCityservice,thetotalweeklyservicevolumewouldbe:3,171,880Lforgarbage,1,229,808Lfororganics,and1,480,894Lforrecycling.
Table:Summaryofwastevolumesinsupportivehousingandothernon-marketrentalbuildings Supportivehousingandnon-marketrental Numberof
buildingsservicedbytheCity
Correspondingnumberofunits(beds)servicedbytheCity
Totalcartcapacityvolumeallocatedperweek(litres)
Averagecartcapacityvolumeallocatedperunitperweek(litres)
Numberofbuildingsinsector
Estimatedtotalsectorcartcapacityvolumeallocatedperweek(litres)
Garbage 41 1510 183,915 123.8500
3,171,880Organics 123 5100 186,360 48.0 1,229,808Recycling 366* 20,654* 671,760* 57.8* 1,480,894*
*Note:Theseamountsareapproximateestimates,asafewbuildingsareservicedwithsmallbluebins,andwerethereforearenotincludedinthefigures.ComprehensiveCityservice:allthreestreams(seetablebelowfordatasummary)Thereare12buildingsitesthatreceivecomprehensivegarbage,organicsandrecyclingserviceallfromtheCity,andforwhichthereiscompleteandaccuratedateonservicevolumes.Nineofthese 12 sites are co-op housing associations, and the others are run by nonprofit housingsocieties.• Thesesitesareprovidedwithveryhighvolumesoforganicsandrecyclingservice,because
they likelyhavewell-establishedwastesortingprograms inplace. Actualwastevolumes,especiallyforrecycling,arelikelymuchlowerthanthevolumesindicatedherebecausethetotalservicevolumesarebasedonbinsize,notonactualwastevolumesproduced.
• OfallthecomprehensiveCityservicedbuildings,theaverageunit isservicedwith46Lofgarbagepick-upservice,39Loforganicspick-upservice,and163Lofrecyclingservice
• Ifallnon-marketrentalandsupportivehousingunitsintheCitywereservicedtothesamelevelastheaverageofbuildingswithcomprehensiveCityservice,thetotalweeklyservicevolumewouldbe:1,178,566 litres forgarbage,999,219 litres fororganics,and4,176,223litresforrecycling.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing69
Table:Summaryofwastevolumesinsupportivehousingandothernon-marketrentalbuildingsbasedondatafrombuildingswithcomprehensiveCityservice
Supportivehousingandnon-marketrental,withcomprehensiveCityserviceNumberofbuildingsservicedbytheCity
Correspondingnumberofunits(beds)servicedbytheCity
Totalcartcapacityvolumeallocatedperweek(litres)
Averagecartcapacityvolumeallocatedperunitperweek(litres)
Numberofbuildingsinsector
Estimatedtotalsectorcartcapacityvolumeallocatedperweek(litres)
Garbage 12 257 12,420 46*500
1,178,566Organics 12 257 12,660 39* 999,219Recycling 12 257 23,040 163* 4,176,223
*Note:averagesarecalculatedfirstforeachbuilding,thentheamountsforeachbuildingareaveragedtogether.
OBSERVED NON-MARKET WASTE VOLUMES & RECOMMENDED MURB VOLUME ALLOCATIONS
Both non-comprehensive and comprehensive City-serviced buildings have similar total cart capacity volumes of 230 litres and 248 litres allocated per unit per week. However, the diversion rates are very different, and these two categories cannot be directly compared because data from non-City haulers is unavailable for buildings without comprehensive City pickup service, so there are likely other waste stream volumes unaccounted for in these tabulations (for example, a building that receives City service for garbage may or may not have another hauler providing organics and recycling pickup). However, by comparing data from these two housing groups we can get a sense of the range of actual service volumes in the non-market sector.
In the chart below, service volume data from non-market housing is displayed beside recommended volume allocations for all MURBs; it is important to note that these data sets are not directly comparable because the average MURB has very different characteristics from non-market housing sites, so it is to be expected that their waste volumes are inherently different. However, the stark difference between recommendations for MURBs and actual service volumes for non-market housing should be taken into consideration: a separate cart capacity volume allocation guide should be madefor non-market housing, to support non-market buildings in implementing new organics or recycling services where none yet exist.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing70
*Wherearangeofbinvolumesorunitswasrecommended,themidpointoftherangewasusedforcalculations;assumespresenceofadedicatedcardboardbin,andlowestrecyclinglevels.
WASTEAUDITS
WASTEAUDITOFFIVECITYSERVICEDSITES
Five non-market housing sites that receive City garbage pickup service were selected toparticipateinaMetroVancouverWasteaudit.Theanalysisfoundthat78.4%ofmaterialcouldhavebeendiverted.ThewastewasanalyzedbyTetraTechConsultingattheVancouverSouthTransferStationonJuly7th2016. Housingsiteswereselectedbecausetheyareservicedbyasingletruckroute.Alltogetherthefivesitescontain186units.OneofthesitesreceivesCityorganicspickupservice,butthatistheonlynon-garbagepickupserviceprovidedbytheCitytothese five buildings; it is likely that theydonot contract additional services for organics andrecycling,howeverthisisnotconfirmed.Garbagevolumedataisbasedonservicecontractsandislikelyanover-estimateoftotalvolumesassomeofthisgarbageisputoutinbags.
124
46
95
15
48
39
58
9
58
163 14
37
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Cityservicednon-marketbuildingswithout
comprehensiveservice
Cityservicednon-marketbuildingswith
comprehensiveservice
SuggestedCityofVancouverbinvolumeallocationsforMURBs
SuggestedMetroVancouverbinvolumeallocationsforlarge
MURBs*
Wastevolum
einlitresperunitp
erweek
Estimated cart capacity volumes for non-market MURBs and recommendedcart capacity volumeallocations for all MURBS
Garbage Organics Totalrecycling
Recommendedvolumeallocations,frompublished guides
Actualcontractedvolumeallocations,frominternalCitydata
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
71
Table:SummaryofcontractedwasteservicevolumesfromthefiveCityservicedsites Buildingtype Number
ofunitsGarbageservicevolume(litres)
Organicsservicevolume
Recyclingservicevolume
EuropeHotel NonprofitSRO 84 5400 - -AlexanderResidence Seniorshousing 30 7875 - -RossHouse SRO 24 1260 - -CreeksideStudentResidence
PrivateSRO 22 720 120 -
MountEverestRooms PrivateSRO 26 240 - -Wasteauditresults:• 198.23kgofwastefromloadwassampled,weighed,andsortedinto142wastecategories.• Thesamplecontained:21.6%garbage,19.8%recycling,56.7%compostablematerials,and
1.9%refundable-depositrecycling.
FiveCityservicedsites:toptenmaterialsingarbagebyweight
Bakedgoods(12.9%)
Unavoidablefoodwaste(12.6%)
Smallyardwaste(8.4%)
Compostablepaper(7.7%)
Wholefruitsandvegetables(6.2%)
Platescrapingsandunfinishedmeals(5.3%)
Naturalfiberclothing(4.0%)
Clothingandaccessories(3.8%)
Fines(2.7%)
Packagingbagsandfilm(2.6%)
Other
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
72
WASTEAUDITOFMVHCSITESINVANCOUVERGarbageloadsfromnineMVHCsiteswereanalyzedonJuly5th2016byTetraTechConsulting.Theanalysisfoundthat58.3%ofthematerialinthegarbagecouldhavebeendiverted.• The nine sites are all located in the City of Vancouver: Habitat Villa, Strathearn Court,
AshdownGardens,HeatherPlace,TivoliGardens,EuclideSquare,HemlockCourt,KellyCourt,&SemlinTerrace.Allsitesreceivethree-streamwastepickupfromaprivatehauler.
• 101.76 kgwas sampled,weighedand sorted into142 categories. The sample contained:41.7%garbage,12.8%recycling,45.4%compostablematerials,and0.1%refundable-depositrecycling.
MVHCVancouversites:toptenmaterialsingarbagebyweight
Unavoidablefoodwaste(14.4%)Compostablepaper(12.4%)Platescrapingsandunfinishedmeals(8.9%)Consumablespackagingbagsandfilm(6.4%)Householdtextiles(5.0%)Petwaste(5.0%)Diapers(3.8%)Durableplasticproducts(3.1%)Householdhygieneproducts(3.1%)Newsprint(2.7%)Other(35.2%)
Images:BakedgoodswerethelargestsinglewastetypeintheauditofgarbagefromthefiveCityservicedsites,andthecrewfromTetraTechConsultingsortingthewaste.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
73
SUMMARYOFWASTEAUDITS
*ThemethodsusedtodeterminedataforBCHousingmaybedifferentfromthemethodsemployedfordataintheprevioustwosets.14The chart above summarizes aforementionedwaste audit data, showing the composition ofgarbagesamples.Inallcases,morethanhalfofsampledgarbagecontainedwastethatcouldhavebeendiverted,with45%-57%beingcompostablematerial.Therelativelylargeportionofcompostable material compared to the smaller portion of recycling is explained by theconsiderabletimeittakesfornewdiversionprogramstobecomeeffective:organicsprogramsarerelativelynewcomparedto long-establishedrecyclingprograms. Evidently there ismuchroomforimprovementinalldiversionprograms,andsomehousinggroupsaredoingmuchbetterthanothers.BoththeMVHCVancouversitesandBCHousingsitesappeartobedivertingmorewastethantheaverageMetroVancouverMURB(where26%ofgarbagecompositionisactuallygarbage15), while the five City serviced sites lag behind likely due to a lack of organics andrecyclingcollectionprograms.
14BCHousingandDillonConsulting(2016):TenantEngagementonSustainability:FocusingonWasteReductionandDiversion15MetroVancouver(2015):2015WasteMonitoringProgram
22%42% 36%
57%
45%47%
22% 13% 17%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
WasteauditoffiveCityservicedsites(2016)
WasteauditofMVHCVancouversites(2016)
BCHousingbuildings(2014)*
Compositionofgarbageinselectedhousinggroups
Garbage CompostableMaterial Recycling
26% oftheaverageMetroVancouverMURB'sgarbagestreamisactuallygarbage(2015)15
Contaminationingarbage79%
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
74
RECOMMENDATIONSTheserecommendationshavebeencompiledfortheCityofVancouver,howevermostofthemrequirecollaborationwithexternalorganizationsforimplementation.Allzerowasteprogramsshould emphasize relationship-building among the stakeholders involved. It is only throughfostering relationships across service hierarchies that we can build the trust, sense ofaccountability,andcollaborativespiritthatisneededforeffectiveprogramimplementation.Inordertoreachzerowaste,manyoftheserecommendationswillhavetobeimplementedatsomepointinthenearfuture.Recommendationsarerankedinorderoffeasibilitystartingwiththe easiest to implement at the top, however it is themore challenging policy and systemschangesfurtheralonginthelistthatstandtohavethelargestimpactonwastediversion.SHORTTERM(BY2020)1. UpdatetheCityofVancouverGarbageandRecyclingStorageFacilityDesignGuidelinesto
includeexamplesofwastemanagementbestpractices(seeChallenge5).• AddlanguageandvisualexamplestotheCityofVancouverGarbageandRecyclingStorage
FacilityDesignguidelinesthatencouragewasteroombestpractices,including:o Standardizedcolour-codedwallsectionswithcorrespondingbins.o Garbage receptacles placed to be slightlymore convenient than receptacles for
otherstreams.o Designatedspacesforbulkyitems,electronics,batteries,andhazardouswaste.o Creatingexchangecentresinbuildingstofacilitatere-useofgoodsthatarestillin
goodcondition.o Separationofuser-accessiblecommonspacefromroomwherewasteisstored,by
connectingchutes(“recyclinglounge”concept).o Includeflexspaceinanticipationofadditionalwastestreamsortingrequirements.o Considerations for accessibility needs, especially when dumpsters will be used.
Ensure there aremechanisms tomake them accessible to people with physicaldisabilities,includingramps,orhatchesinthesideofdumpsters.(seeChallenge6)
• Alsoincludedesignguidelinesformulti-streamin-unitwastestoragespace.2. Revisewastebinvolumeallocationguides,forbothCityofVancouverandMetroVancouver
(seeAssessingSectorWasteVolumessection).• Createvolumeallocationguidesspecificallyfornon-marketbuildingsthataresettingup
neworganicsorrecyclingprograms.3. Encouragesocialandenvironmentalprocurementpreferencestobeincorporatedinhauler
RFPs(seeChallenge17).• Encouragesocialandenvironmentalprocurementpreferencestobeapartofallwaste
haulerRFPs,sothatpointsaregivenforhaulersthatcanprovidetheseadditionalbenefitssuchasrequirementstohirelocalworkersandindividualswithbarriers,aswellasuseof
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
75
low-andno-emissionsvehiclesandbicycles.Alternatively,RFPwriterscanincorporatea valueproposition at thebeginningof anRFP,with apreference forbusinesses thatemphasizeasocialreturnoninvestment.
• AddlanguagetothiseffectontheCity’s“FindaHauler”webpage.4. Encouragepublicsyringedisposalboxestobeemptiedandmaintainedmorefrequently(see
Challenge8).• TheStreetCleaningTeamshouldestablishaconnectionwithVancouverCostalHealthto
report syringe disposal boxes that are in need of attention, and to encourage morefrequencymaintenance.
5. Create a dedicated Zero Waste Community Engagement Team within the Solid Waste
ManagementDivisionsolelyfocusedonengagingBuildingStaffandResidents.• ResponsibilitieswouldincludetrainingandconsultingwithBuildingStaff,runningpublic
educationcampaigns,andrecruitingandassistingresidentvolunteersinMURBstocreateeffectiverecyclingprograms.
• Theseindividualsshouldhaveknowledgeofwastemanagementsystems,aswellasskillsinfacilitation,coaching,organization,andprojectmanagement.
• ThisinitiativecouldalsobeadministeredandfundedthroughapartnershipwithMetroVancouver.
6. Createaprogramthatproactivelyprovidesfreewastemanagementsystemconsultationto
MURBBuildingStaff,administeredbytheZeroWasteCommunityEngagementTeam.• Supportforbuildingstaffcouldincludetraining,implementationtools,andone-on-one
consulting,withanemphasisonrelationshipbuilding.Focusareasinclude:o Helping staff to develop waste management plans that bring buildings into
compliance with existing bylaws, including setting up recycling and organicsdiversionprograms(seeChallenge7).
o EncouragingbuildingstosetupwastemanagementplansforEPRprogramitems,hazardouswaste,andbulkywaste(SeeChallenge12)
o Providing materials and guidance on how to educate residents about wastediversionprograms inthebuilding,tohelpthembe incompliancewithclauses5.15and6.7A.4inSolidWasteBy-Law8417(seeChallenge3).
o Proactively distributing free informational flyers, posters and bin stickers toBuildingStaffasneeded.
o Implementinginformationalfeedbackloopstoinformresidentsoftheprogressoftheir diversion efforts and related environmental impacts, through bulletinboards,emails,and-outs,etc(seeChallenges2&3).
o Advising Building Staff on syringewastemanagement and bin placement bestpractices(seeChallenge8).
o Advising staff on waste room configuration best practices, including binconfiguration(seeChallenges9&12).
• Each building would be assigned to one staffmember where they can receive direct
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
76
supportformthesamepersonwhounderstandstheircase.• Start with consulting high-densityMURBs and buildings that have a history of bylaw
violations,andinformthemofupcomingchangesintheMTIsystem.7. CreateaprogramthatprovidesfreetrainingforMURBBuildingStaff,administeredbythe
ZeroWasteCommunityEngagementTeam(seeChallenge14).• OfferonefreeannualtrainingworkshopopentoallMURBstaff.• CreatetrainingresourcesforBuildingstaffincludingatrainingmanual,andonlinevideos
orinteractivetrainingwebsite.• Training and support can be directed through organizations such as the BC Building
OwnersandManagersAssociation,theBCApartmentOwnersandManagersAssociation,andtheWasteManagementAssociationofBC.
• Reachouttonon-profittrainingorganizationMasterRecyclerforadvisingonthis.8. Createinitiativesthatbuildmomentumaroundzerowasteideals,administeredbytheZero
WasteCommunityEngagementTeam.• Createacity-orregion-widecompetitionforbuildingstoreducetheirgarbagevolumes
andcontaminationlevels,basedondataprovidedbyhaulers.See“TheMayor’sToweringChallenge”intheCityofToronto,asanexample(seeChallenge2).
• Similarly,createacity-orregion-widecompetitionforschoolstoreducetheirgarbagevolumesandcontaminationlevels.
• Designspecificawarenesscampaignsthatarereleasedannuallyonthesameday,suchasEarthDay.
9. CreateaRecyclingAmbassadorsprogramwithvolunteerresidents,administeredbythe
ZeroWasteCommunityEngagementTeam.• Recruitandtrainvolunteerstojoinanofficialcitizen-poweredmovementsupportingzero
wasteprograms.ThisprogramcouldbebrandedasanextensionoftheKeepVancouverSpectacularprogram.Suchaprogramcouldinclude:
o FreetrainingworkshopsforMURBresidents.o AllocatefundingtoprovidesmallgrantstoRecyclingAmbassadorteams,which
canbedeliveredthroughtheexistingGreenestCityNeighbourhoodSmallGrantsprogram. Thesegrants cancover costs suchasprinting, translation,workshoporganization,etc.
o Provide supportive materials to volunteers to run resident engagementprogrammingintheirownMURBs(seeChallenge4).
10. EncourageBCHousingtospecificallyfundbulkywastediversioneffortsforshelters
• Seasonal shelters funded by BC Housing should be required to budget staff time orcontractorstosortremainingbulkywastewhensheltersareclosedtoimprovediversionrates(seeChallenge7).
• Encouragehaulerstopartnerwithlocalnonprofitcommunitybikeshopstodivertbicyclepartsfromhauledbulkywaste.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
77
11. Aggressivelytargetandreduceillegaldumping(seeChallenge13).
• Installhigh-definition,moveablecamerastoaidinmonitoringillegaldumpinghotspots.• Improvelightingathotspots.
12. Initiateapilotofsharedwastebins,implementedbyathirdparty(seeChallenge10).
• Athirdpartycoordinator(suchastheBCNonprofitHousingAssociation)wouldbeneededtofacilitatethefollowingpilots.TheCitycouldinitiateandprovideindirectsupport.
• Createapilotofcoordinatedwastemanagementzones,whereonehauleriscontractedtoprovideservicestoagroupofneighbouringsites.ApartnershipbetweentheCity,theBC Nonprofit Housing Association, and the local BIA could be established to provideservicestobothbusinessesandhousingfacilities.Suchapilotcouldstartsmall,withjustone full block, and later be expanded to include larger neighbourhood areas. Thefollowingaresiteswherethispilotcouldbeexplored:
o Sitessharingthealleybehindthe600blockofAlexanderStreetandPowellStreetbetweenPrincessAveandHeatleyAve(recommendedbytheStrathconaBIA).
o Currentlythereare43sitesreceivingspecialWednesdaynightgarbagecollectionfromtheCity,duetotheir limitedcapacity foron-sitewastestorage. Manyofthesesitesareinverycloseproximity(seemapofsitesunderChallenge10).
o A redesign of Blood Alley is currently underway, and would benefit from areductioninthenumberofdumpsters.
o Otherareasofhighdumpsterconcentration inGastown,Strathcona, theDTES,andYaletown.
• Implementapilotofsharedundergroundautomatedwastestoragebins.Opportunitiesforpilotinstallationsinclude:upcomingMVHCandBCHousingsiteredevelopments,andthesitesmentionedaboveforcoordinatedwastemanagementzones.
• Considerusing in-vesselvolume-reducingorganicsunits insharedbinpilots, toreducepickupfrequency,andpreventsmellandpestexposure(seeChallenges10&11).
13. Initiate a pilot of community preferred service agreements for organics and recycling
collectionfromnon-marketbuildingsandkitchenswithsmalloutputs(seeChallenges10&19).• Wheresharedbinsarenotpossible,andorganicsorrecyclingvolumesarelow,engagea
third party (such as the BC Nonprofit Housing Association) to coordinate communitypreferredserviceagreementsbetweenhaulersandnon-marketbuildings&kitchenstoenablethemtoparticipateinmorecost-effectiveorganicsandrecyclingpickupservices.Theservicecouldbeofferedinareaswithhighconcentrationsofnon-marketbuildingsandcommunitykitchens,suchasintheDTES.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
78
14. ExpandtheselectionofwastehaulingservicesofferedbytheCity(seeChallenge15).• Explorethefeasibilityofofferingmultiplelevelsofwastepickupservice,suchascarry-out
services,dumpsters,anda“platinum”servicethatcouldincludeorganicsbinlinersandbin washing. Consider expanding City hauling services to new types of clients asopportunitiesarise.
15. ImplementaCity-operatedbulkywastecollectionprogram(seeChallenge12).
• Implementrecommendationsfromthe2008staffreportonbulkywaste,startingwiththeimplementationofapilotbulkywastepickupserviceinVancouver,withtheintentiontoscale-uptheprogramtoincludeallresidentialbuildings.
o Regular bulky waste disposal days give the opportunity for residents to planahead,lookoutforfreeitemsonthosedays,andgivesthecityaperiodtofocusdeliveryofwaste-reductionmessaging.
• Regardlessof the implementationof a city-wide collectionprogram, considerofferingfree bulkywaste pickup for all non-market housing sites, especially those that houseresidentswithmultiplebarrierswherescavengedwastetendstoaccumulate.
16. Encourage Metro Vancouver to remove syringes from the banned materials list (see
Challenges8&18).• Encourage Metro Vancouver to remove syringes from the list of hazardous banned
materialssothattheynolongerincura$50fineperitem,recognizingthatthesepenaltiesdonotimpactthebehaviourofpeoplewhoputsyringesingarbagebutratherpenalizebuildingoperators.Usersshouldstillbestronglyencouragedtoseparatesyringesfromgarbage(seeChallenge8).
• Inlieuofaban,focusenergyonchallengedbuildingsbycreatinganddistributingmoreeffectivesignage,advisingbuildingstaffonbestpracticesinplacementofsyringedisposalboxes,andimplementingnewinformativefeedbackloops.
LONGTERM(BEYOND2020)17. EncourageMetroVancouvertorequirewastehaulerstocollectanddisclosedata
• Require all haulers operating in Metro Vancouver to collect and provide waste data(weights,volumes,andcontaminationprevalence)tocustomers,andtomunicipalandregionalauthorities(seeChallenge17).
18. Encourageallwastebagstobeclear.
• Encourage haulers and MURB building staff to use clear waste bags, especially forgarbage. This creates subtle anti-contamination pressure and protects the health ofwastemanagementworkers(seeChallenges2&16).
• Encourage Metro Vancouver to explore the feasibility of implementing a bylaw thatrequiresallbaggedwastetobeinclearbags.
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
79
19. Introduce requirements for new buildings andmajor redevelopments to follow waste
managementbestpracticesaspartof thedevelopmentpermitapplicationprocess (seeChallenge5).• Add languageto theexistingBuildingBylaws to requirenewbuildings to followwaste
managementbestpracticesintheirdesigns,similartothewayelectricvehiclechargingrequirementswererecentlyimplemented.
• Consider creating multiple levels of “green design standards” in waste managementfacilitybestpractices,wherebuildingsareincentivizedtoimplementimproveddesigns.
20. Toimproveoccupationalhealthandsafetystandardsforhaulerworkers,worktowards
avoidingdirectcontactwithbaggedgarbagewaste.• New technical solutions should be tried, and automated collection systems should
continuetodevelop.• Binhoppersshouldberequiredforallwastetruckstoavoidworkershavingtoliftwaste.• Wherewasteishauledmanually,maximum180litercartsshouldbeused.
21. EncourageMetroVancouvertostandardizerecyclingpracticesintheregion.
• EncourageMetroVancouvertocontinuetoengageandcollaboratewithmunicipalitiestostandardizerecyclingpracticesacrosstheregion(seeChallenge3).
22. Collaborate with government partners to create a fund for waste management
infrastructureandserviceimprovementsfornon-marketbuildings.• CollaboratewiththeProvincialGovernment,MMBC,andMetroVancouvertocreatea
fund to support waste management program improvements in non-market housingfacilities. Building operators could apply for grants for specific projects,whichwouldincludemonitoringandreportingrequirements.WastemanagementconsultingprovidedbytheproposedZeroWasteCommunityEngagementTeamcouldhelptoidentifyprojectseligibleforgrantsupport(seeChallenge7).
• CollaboratewithMetroVancouverandMMBCtoprovidefreeorganicskitchen-catchersandbluerecyclingtotebagstonon-marketbuildingsuponrequest,andallowbuildingstafftoorderupto10%replacementperyear.Encouragethesein-unitbinsfororganicsand recycling to become standard required items in all living spaces as part of leaseagreements,sothatreplacementsbecomeunnecessaryovertime(seeChallenge5).
23. EncourageMetroVancouvertoimplementpoliciesthatpermitcontaminationsurcharge
exemptionsforspecificnon-marketbuildings.• EncourageMetroVancouver tocreateallowances indisposalban regulations fornon-
marketbuildingsthathouseindividualswithsignificantbarriers.BuildingoperatorscouldapplydirectlytoMetroVancouverforexemption,withspecialbagstickersorprintedbagsissuedbyMetroVancouverdirectly to theapprovedbuildings foruse to identify theirwasteinthestream.Thiswouldallowhaulerstoreduceservicecostsforthesebuildingsduetoreducedcontaminationsurcharges(seeChallenge1).
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
80
24. Supporttheestablishmentofalow-costfoodterminal(seeChallenge19).
• Explore the feasibility of setting up a low-cost food terminal to centralize themanagementoffooddonationsandtocreateamarketforB-gradelocalproduce.
25. Openasmallscaleresident-onlytransferstationnearareasofhighpopulationdensity.
• Explore the feasibility of opening a small transfer station for residential waste andspecializedrecyclingprograms,locatedclosetohigh-densityneighbourhoodssuchasintheFalseCreekFlats.Thiscentrecouldbeahubforrecyclingeducationprogramming,include a free item exchange space, a waste up-cycling design workshop, and be adistributionpointforsupportivewastemanagementmaterials(seeChallenge12).
AREASFORFURTHERRESEARCHThis study is only an initial step in understanding the complexity that surrounds wastemanagementinnon-marketbuildings,andMURBsingeneral.Thestarklackofexistingacademicresearchonthemattermakesevidenttheneedformorestudyonthistopic,especiallyasweimplementnewstrategiestogettozerowasteoverthenextdecades.
• FollowuponLOCO’s2010 study toexaminewaste streamvolumesandmanagementpracticesinDTEScommunitykitchens,andidentifyopportunitiestoreducewaste.(seeChallenge19).
• Moreextensivefuturewasteauditsacrossdifferenthousingtypescouldproducedetaileddatatofocuswastemanagementstrategies.Thiscouldbecombinedwithstudiesthatengageandcollectinputfromcorrespondingbuildingresidents.
• BCHousingandBCHealthyCommunitieshavepartneredwithTheCentreforSustainableDevelopmentatSFUtoresearchimprovementstowastemanagementinsocialhousing.Thereisgoodpotentialforcollaborationandconsultationonrefiningthesetopicareas,whichinclude:
o How to develop long term tenant capacity and concurrently identify effectivedriversforlongtermchangeinsustainabilitybehaviour(specificallyfocusingonwastediversion)amongsocialhousingtenantsinBC?
o HoweffectiveisCBSMwhenappliedtowastediversioninasocialhousingsetting,andhowmightthiscomparetothegeneralpopulation?
o Whatarethemosteffectivedriversforalongtermchangeintermsofadoptionofasustainabilitybehaviorspecificallyfocusingonwastediversionamongsocialhousingtenants inBC?Howcantenantcapacityatsocialhousingsitesbebuiltthroughlinkingfoodsecurityandsustainability?
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
81
REFERENCES
ARTICLES,BOOKSANDWEBSITES
AmagerResourceCentre.(2016).Sådansortererdu(“Howtosort”).Retrievedfromhttps://www.a-r-c.dk/privat/saadan-sortAnderson,R.(2015).TheCompassionateSystemsTheoryofChange.Retrievedfromhttp://www.smallanddeliciouslife.com/the-compassionate-systems-theory-of-change/BCCentreforDiseaseControl.(2015).IndustryFoodDonationGuidelines.Retrievedfromhttp://www.bccdc.ca/resource-gallery/Documents/Guidelines%20and%20Forms/Guidelines%20and%20Manuals/EH/FPS/Food/Food%20Donation%20Guidelines%20Complete.pdfBCHousing.(2015).TenantEngagementonSustainabilityGuide:forsocialhousingproviders;focusonwastereductionanddiversion,Version1.Richmond,BC:DillonConsulting.Retrievedfromhttp://www.bchousing.org/resources/Partner_Resources/Ongoing_Maintenance/Waste_Diversion_Guide.pdfBCHousing.(2015).TenantEngagementonSustainabilityFacilitator’sHandbook:forsocialhousingproviders;focusonwastereductionanddiversion,Version1.Richmond,BC:DillonConsulting.Retrievedfromhttp://www.bchousing.org/resources/Partner_Resources/Ongoing_Maintenance/Waste_Diversion_Facilitator_Handbook.pdfBCHousing.(2016,April7).TenantEngagementonSustainability:FocusingonWasteReductionandDiversion.Richmond,BC:DillonConsulting.Retrievedfromhttp://www.rcbcconference.ca/uploads/3/8/4/1/38412063/3--tenant_engagement_on_sustainability.pdfBCHousing.(2016).SingleResidentOccupancyHotels.Retrievedfromhttp://www.bchousing.org/Initiatives/Access/SRO
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
82
BCHousing.(2016).SupportiveHousing.Retrievedfromhttp://www.bchousing.org/Options/Supportive_HousingBirley,D.,Murton,P.,Phillips,P.&Tudor,T.(2007).AKeyUKIssue:ManagingMunicipalSolidFoodWaste–ACaseStudyfromHackney,London.JournalofSolidWasteTechnologyandManagement,33(1).Bentley,A.(2011).I’llhavewhatshe’shaving.Cambridge,MA:TheMITPress.CityofCalgary.(2012).Multi-FamilyDiversionProgramBestPractices.Guelph,ON:StantecConsultingLtd.Retrievedfromhttp://www.calgary.ca/UEP/WRS/Documents/WRS-Documents/Multi_Family_Best_Practices.pdf?noredirect=1CityofStockholm.(2013).WastemanagementplanforStockholm2013-2016.Retrievedfromhttp://www.stockholmvatten.se/globalassets/pdf1/riktlinjer/avfall/avfallsplan/avfallsplanen_eng_webb.pdfCityofToronto.(2013).Staffreport:Greenbinimplementationinmulti-residentialbuildingsandwastereduction/diversioneducationinitiatives.Retrievedfromhttp://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2013/pw/bgrd/backgroundfile-59186.pdfCityofToronto.(2016).FinalLongTermWasteManagementStrategy.Retrievedfromhttp://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2016/pw/bgrd/backgroundfile-94037.pdfCityofVancouver.(2008).CityofVancouverBulkyItemCollectionProgram:PreliminaryDiscussionReport.CityofVancouver.(2009).WestEndIllegalDumpingProject.CityofVancouver.(2011).HousingandHomelessnessStrategy2012-2021.Retrievedfromhttp://vancouver.ca/files/cov/Housing-and-Homeless-Strategy-2012-2021pdf.pdfCityofVancouver.(2012).Garbageandrecyclingstoragefacilitydesignsupplement.Retrievedfromhttp://vancouver.ca/files/cov/Garbage_and_Recycling_Storage_Facility_Supplement.pdfCityofVancouver.(2015).Food-free.Retrievedfromhttp://vancouver.ca/files/cov/low-cost-food.pdf
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
83
CityofVancouver.(2016,June7).Subject:ZeroWaste2040,MemorandumtoMayorandCouncil,fromJerryDobrovolny,CityEngineer/GeneralManager.CityofVancouver.(2016).Vancouvertakesnextstepstobecomingazerowastecommunityby2040.Retrievedfromhttp://vancouver.ca/news-calendar/vancouver-takes-next-step-to-becoming-a-zero-waste-community-by-2040.aspxCityofVancouver.(2016).AdministrativeReport,subject:EnhancedSolidWasteManagementandDiversionBy-LawAuthority.Retrievedfromhttp://council.vancouver.ca/20160203/documents/cfsc7.pdfCityofVancouver.(2016).SolidWasteBy-LawNo.8417.Retrievedfromhttp://former.vancouver.ca/bylaws/8417c.PDFCityofVancouver.(2016).Preventfoodwasteatyourbusiness.Retrievedfromhttp://vancouver.ca/doing-business/prevent-food-waste.aspxCompostCollective.(2012).FinalReport.Retrievedfromhttp://citystudiovancouver.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/Compost-Collective-Final-Report.pdfDowntownEastsideKitchenTablesProject.(2010).FinalReport&ActionPlan.Retrievedfromhttp://dteskitchentables.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/DTES-Kitchen-Tables-Community-Action-Plan-Phase-1-FINAL-REPORT.pdfEuropeanUnion.(2013).Copenhagen:EuropeanGreenCapital2014.Luxembourg:PublicationsOfficeoftheEuropeanUnion.Retrievedfromhttp://ec.europa.eu/environment/europeangreencapital/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/ENV-13-004_Copenhagen_EN_final_webres.pdfFutureproof.(2009).UsingCommunityBasedSocialMarketingtoincreaserecyclinginmulti-familybuildings.GreaterVancouverShelterStrategy.(2015).ShelterDirectory.Retrievedfromhttp://www.gvss.ca/PDF-2014/Shelters%20list%20150917.pdfMThomsonConsulting.(2016).VancouverHomelessCount2016.Retrievedfrom
http://vancouver.ca/files/cov/homeless-count-2016-report.pdf
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
84
McKenzie-Mohr,D.(2011).FosteringSustainableBehaviour.GabriolaIsland,BC:NewSocietyPublishers.Meadows,D.(1997).PlacestoInterveneinaSystem.WholeEarth,Winter1997.Retrievedfromhttps://center.sustainability.duke.edu/sites/default/files/documents/system_intervention.pdfMetroVancouver.(2016).AboutFoodScrapsRecycling.Retrievedfromhttp://www.metrovancouver.org/services/solid-waste/food-scraps-recycling/background-implementation/Pages/default.aspxMetroVancouver.(2014).On-siteOrganicsManagementOptionsReview.MetroVancouver.(2013).GreaterVancouverSewerageandDrainageDistrict,BylawNo.280,2013;Abylawtoregulatemunicipalsolidwasteandrecyclablematerials.Retrievedfromhttp://www.metrovancouver.org/services/solid-waste/SolidWastePublications/ProposedBylawNo280-submittedtoProvince2013.pdfMetroVancouver.(2016).Proposed2017TippingFeeBylawChanges,fromAndrewMarrtotheGVS&DDBoard,datedJuly8,2016.MetroVancouver.(2016).2015DisposalBanInspectionProgramUpdate,fromBrandonHototheZeroWasteCommittee.MetroVancouver.(2011).TheBlueBook-Draft.MetroVancouver.(2015).TechnicalSpecificationsforRecyclingandGarbageAmenitiesinMulti-familyandCommercialDevelopment.MetroVancouver.(2016).Guidetoestimatetherecyclingandgarbagebinsyourcomplexneedsforweeklycollection.Retrievedfromhttp://www.metrovancouver.org/services/solid-waste/SolidWastePublications/RecyclingGarbageBinMatrixwithoutsinglestream.pdfMetroVancouver.(2015)2015WasteCompositionMonitoringProgram.Retrievedfromhttp://www.metrovancouver.org/services/solid-waste/SolidWastePublications/2015_Waste_Composition_Report.pdfMollard,M.&Wong,C.(2014).VancouverTrashTalkFinalReport.Retrievedfromhttps://vancouvertrashtalk.files.wordpress.com/2012/08/finalreport-july312014.pdf
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing
85
Nicolás,Angie.(2014).BuildingVolunteerismCapacitytoSupportWasteReductionatSpecialEvents.Retrievedfromhttps://sustain.ubc.ca/sites/sustain.ubc.ca/files/GCS/FINAL_ANGIE_AN_GCScholar_Report_2014_Zero_Waste_Volunteers_Events.pdfPearson,H.,Dawson,L.,&RadeckiBreitkopf,C.(2012).RecyclingAttitudesandBehavioramongaClinic-BasedSampleofLow-IncomeHispanicWomeninSoutheastTexas.PLoSONE,7(4),e34469.Retrievedfromhttp://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0034469Pentland,A.(2008).Honestsignals:howtheyshapeourworld.Cambridge,MA:TheMITPress.RainCityHousingandSupportSociety.(2016).ProgramAgreement,TheBudzey.RegionofPeel.(2013).ProfessionalServicestosupply,installandintegrateradiofrequencyidentification(RFID)systemforwastecollectionreporting.Retrievedfromhttps://www.peelregion.ca/council/agendas/pdf/2013/wm-4a.pdfLOCOBusinessNetworkSocietyofBC.(2010).GreeningDTESCharityKitchens,(Draft)FinalReport.Roy,R.,Caird,S.&Potter,S.(2007).Peoplecenteredeco-design:consumeradoptionoflowandzerocarbonproductsandsystems.GoverningTechnologyforSustainability.London,UK:Earthscan.SeattleHousingAuthority.(2014).QuickFacts.Retrievedfromhttps://seattlehousing.org/about/pdf/SHAFactsheet.pdfStrathconaBusinessImprovementAssociation.(2015).RequestforProposals–PreferredZeroWasteServiceProvider.UnitedNationsCentreforHumanSettlements(Habitat).(1989).CommunityParticipation-SolidWasteManagementinLow-incomeHousingProjects:TheScopeforCommunityParticipation.Nairobi,Kenya:UNHabitat.Retrievedfromhttp://www.chs.ubc.ca/archives/files/community%20participation%20in%20solid%20waste%20management%20in%20low%20income%20housing%20projects.pdf
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing86
VancouverCoastalHealth.(2013).FreelowcostandcommunitymealsinVancouver.Retrievedfromhttps://www.vch.ca/media/Free-Low-Cost-and-Community-meals-in-Vancouver-final-May-1-2013.xls
WashingtonStateRecyclingAssociation.(2014).Sortingitout:TheStateofMultifamilyRecyclinginWashingtonState.Retrievedfromhttp://c.ymcdn.com/sites/www.wsra.net/resource/resmgr/Multifamily_Study/Sorting_it_Out-The_State_of_.pdf
WasteDiversionOntario.(2011).Bestpracticesforthestorageandcollectionofrecyclablesinmulti-residentialbuildings.Retrievedfromhttp://cif.wdo.ca/pdf/reports/219/report_219.pdf
INTERVIEWSANDWRITTENINPUTS
AngieNicolás,MasterRecycler
AnnaDyer,RecyclingandWasteReductionAnalyst,SeattleHousingAuthority
BrianBeck,CityofVancouver
BrianButt,HousingPolicy,CityofVancouver
BrianWong,SolidWasteManagement,CityofVancouver
CelineMauboules,HousingPolicy,CityofVancouver
CharlotteUeta,ProjectLead,SolidWasteManagementServices,CityofToronto
DonnaTaylor,StreetInspections,CityofVancouver
DougSchell,WasteManagementCoordinator,BCHousing
DorisChow,ProjectManager,DTESKitchenTablesProject
GeorgeSimpson,OperationsManager,RainCityHousing
HannaMusslic,LandfillOperations,CityofVancouver
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing87
JeffWint,DispatchandCustomerService,RecyclingAlternative
JimHeeps,StreetCleaning,CityofVancouver
JordanParente,SolidWasteManagement,CityofVancouver
KathleenBelton,GreenPrograms&ServicesCo-opStudent,EngineeringDepartment,CityofDelta
KatrusiaBalan,ProjectLead,SolidWasteManagementServices,CityofToronto
KennySiu,SUCCESSBC
LauraBarreca,BusinessDevelopmentManager,CleanStartBC
LinhHuynh,CityofRichmond
LizBlakeway,DistrictofNorthVancouver
MartaSanchez-Blasco,FacilitiesManager,TheBloomGroup
MonikaCzyz,HousingPolicy,CityofVancouver
MunicipalWasteReductionCoordinatorsCommittee,MetroVancouver
PatrickChauo,SolidWasteManagement,CityofVancouver
RubenAnderson,Futureproof
SandraMills,SolidWasteManagement,CityofVancouver
ShannonHadley,CorporationofDelta
ShaunMcKibben,CityofVancouver
SherriMatt,Operations,RainCityHousing
SepidehDatoobar,EureteTechnologies
Report:ImprovingWasteManagementinNon-MarketHousing88
TerryFulton,MetroVancouver
TinaWinberg,TechnicalandEnvironmentalDepartment,CityofCopenhagen
TraceyTobin,CityofBurnaby
UlrykeWeissgerber,MetroVancouverHousingCorporation
And special thanks to Scott and Victor from CleanStart BCfor allowing me to tag along for what was a very insightful day.