14
Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Bonneville Power Administration Administration

Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

Increasing Access to the Grid

NIPPCSeptember 8, 2005

Brian SilversteinBrian SilversteinVP, Operations and PlanningVP, Operations and PlanningBonneville Power AdministrationBonneville Power Administration

Page 2: Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

2

Increasing Access to the Grid

Expand the Pie

Increase Utilization

Coordinated Planning

Page 3: Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

3

Page 4: Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

4

2001: Network Constraints

Page 5: Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

5

Infrastructure Program

To address the region’s transmission needs, BPA developed a transmission infrastructure program in 2001 to focus on: Maintaining reliable transmission service to

population centers. Restoring or enhancing transfer capability across

key paths. Providing margin so the system can be

maintained. Evaluating and investing in non-wires alternatives.

Page 6: Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

6

Infrastructure Accomplishments

First major line construction in the Northwest since 1987.

Invested more than $1 billion over four years. Two 500-kV lines completed, one under way. Modernized the nation's largest direct current

terminal (Celilo Converter - 3100 MW). Several projects to upgrade local load service.

Page 7: Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

7

M o n t a n a

I d a h oO r e g o n

W a s h i n g t o nGrand Coulee-Bell 500 KVTransmission Line ProjectApril 2003-Dec 2004

Northern IdahoReinforcement

Schultz Series CapacitorsMarch 2003-Nov 2004

PearlTransformer

ProjectDec 2002-Dec 2003

OlympicPeninsula

Reinforcement

1-5 CorridorGeneration Addition

Kangley-Echo Lake 500 KVTransmission Line ProjectJuly 2003-Dec 2003

Puget Sound Area500/230 KV

Transformer

Schultz-Hanford Area

3

SW WashingtonNW Oregon Reinforcement Portland Area

Reinforcement

Swan ValleyGoshen Rebuild

Lower ValleyReinforcement

Anderson RanchMountain Home RebuildSouthwest Oregon

Coast Reinforcement

AlbanyEugeneRebuild

Celilo ModernizationWinter 2001-June 2004

West of McnaryWest of Slatt

Raymond-Cos

Status of BPA Infrastructure Additions

CompletedUnderwaySubstationProject Completed

BPATransmission Lines

IndianReservation

On HoldProposedSubstationProject Completed

Page 8: Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

8

2005: Network Constraints

Page 9: Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

9

Non Wires Solutions

Potential Measures Demand response Energy efficiency Distributed generation Appropriately sited large generation

Objectives Find least-cost solutions to transmission limitations Provide equivalent reliability to a transmission fix Benefits of transmission deferral

Time value of money Option value of delaying costly investments

Page 10: Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

10

Path Utilization Example

Cumulative Frequency Distribution2001- 2005 Jul-Oct Heavy Load Hours Only

West of McNary

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%

PERCENT OF TIME LOADINGS AT OR ABOVE MW VALUE

MW

Jul-Oct

Page 11: Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

11

Increase Utilization

Flow-based ATC methodology Constraint Schedule Management New products and services

Conditional firm Redispatch

Better remarketing of unused rights Strategic use of nonfirm and short-term firm

Page 12: Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

12

Transmission Buying Strategy for Wind

0

25

50

75

100

Traditional Strategic

MW

Nonfirm

ST Firm

LT Firm

Average Output

Peak Output

Sel

l W

hen

No

t N

eede

d

Bu

y W

hen

Nee

ded

Page 13: Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

13

Integrated Planning Concept

Objective: Achieve an adequate and least-cost plan in a functionally separated industry.

Premise: Most commitments to long-term transmission, particularly those that require expansion, are tied to utility power purchase agreements.

Concept: Establish a coordinated planning cycle that links individual utility resource planning with a region-wide transmission open season.

Benefits: Improves our ability to develop transmission when needed. Provides for a regional adequacy assessment.

Page 14: Increasing Access to the Grid NIPPC September 8, 2005 Brian Silverstein VP, Operations and Planning Bonneville Power Administration

14

Integrated Planning Concept

Start/Finish

ResourcePlanning

TransmissionPlanning

Integrated Txm Plan

TxmCommitments

TxmOpen

Season

RegionalAdequacy

Assessment

IRP

RFP

Utility Resource

Plan

Locational E

xpansion Costs