Upload
neuroactive
View
231
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/8/2019 Indian Infrastructure Going Beyond the Sound Bytes
1/44
ng bssaonb{nag zn{e
, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
B yfbmn{~ oefoc ag Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf
Havy pfyspfo{nxfs
8/8/2019 Indian Infrastructure Going Beyond the Sound Bytes
2/44
[EF OAVGONM AH FV OEBDIFY_ AH OADDFYOF NG NGKNB
Yfjns{fyfk Aof< Iadib~ Oebdify a Oaddfyofbgk Ngkvs{y~
Dbocnggag Dbocfg|nf Ivnmkngj- Ibmmbyk Fs{b{f-
Dvdibn ;00002
[fm'< 099$9982;852
Hbu< 099$998992?
Oaypayb{f Aof< [ef Oavgonm a FV Oebdifys a
Oaddfyof ng Ngknb
?yk Hmaay- ^' I' Oebxbg Ofg{yf- Jfg' L' Ieasbmf Dbyj-
Dvdibn ;00092
[fm'
8/8/2019 Indian Infrastructure Going Beyond the Sound Bytes
3/44
Ng{yakvo{nag ;Bocgazmfkjfdfg{s 6Fufov{nxf _vddby~ 8Bppyaboe bgk df{eakamaj~ :
N B yfbmn{~ oefoc ag Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf 5NN [ef kadfs{no bgk ng{fygb{nagbm ngxfs{ay*s pfyspfo{nxf
ag ngxfs{dfg{ ng Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf 2?NNN [ef jaxfygdfg{*s pfypfo{nxf 92NX Avy xnfzs yfjbykngj {ef nssvfs bongj Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf 99
X Avy snu yfoaddfgkb{nags ?;
Bppfgknofs
2 Obsf _{vknfs ?99 _vddby~ yfoaddfgkb{nags yad a{efy ngybs{yvo{vyf pbpfys ?;? Rvfs{naggbnyfs ?:
; Inimnajybpe~ ?5
Bg Fufov{nag Gaimf $ On{~ a Magkag pasn{nag pbpfy
ng bssaonb{nag zn{eOn{~ a Magkag
Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf '
Ngknb %GEBN.
Dy Cynsegb Oebn{bg~b Pyngonpbm Bo{ns20'
Dy Ynoebyk Gaydngj{ag _fgnay Dbgbjfy Ng{fygb{nagbm Hngbgonbm _fyxnofs-22'
Magkag
Dy Pybxffg _bglffxn Pyalfo{ Hngbgof NKHO29'
Dy Ybcfse _ynxbs{bxb Lang{ _foyf{by~ Dngns{y~ a _enppngj2?'
Ds Jff{v Lasen K~' _foyf{by~ Dngns{y~ a _enppngj2;'
Dy Ybdfse Ibzb Dbgbjngj Knyfo{ay ( OFA Ngybs{yvo{vyf Mfbsngj (26'
Hngbgonbm _fyxnofs Mndn{fk %NM(H_.
Dy Xngb~bc Oeb{{fylff Oebnydbg Hffkiboc Xfg{vyfs28'
Dy Mvns Dnybgkb Oenf Fufov{nxf Aofy NKHO Pynxb{f Frvn{~2:'
Dy Xbsns{eb Pb{fm Oenf Fufov{nxf Aofy _bkiebx Ngybs{yvo{vyf Pyalfo{s25'
Dy P Oebcybpbgn Xnof Pyfsnkfg{ EOO Ngybs{yvo{vyf2>'
Dy Dbgnse Lbng Oagsvm{bg{ Hffkiboc Xfg{vyfs90'
Zf byf das{ jyb{fvm {a {ef ammazngj zea jbxf yffm~ {efny {ndf {a if ng{fyxnfzfk ay {ens pasn{nag pbpfy
)Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf < jangj if~agk {ef savgki~{fs) $ Pasn{nag Pbpfy 9020 Fufov{nag Gaimf ( Oadpbg~ M{k bgk [ef On{~ a Magkag' Bmm ynje{s yfsfyxfk'
B yfbmn{~ oefoc ag Ngknbg Nghybs{yvo{vyf
Mfss {ebg b ebm
a {ef cf~ yfaydyfoaddfgkb{nagspyapasfk axfy {ef
pbs{ hxf ~fbys ebxfiffg ndpmfdfg{fk'
8/8/2019 Indian Infrastructure Going Beyond the Sound Bytes
10/44
20
)Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf < jangj if~agk {ef savgki~{fs) $ Pasn{nag Pbpfy 9020 Fufov{nag Gaimf ( Oadpbg~ M{k bgk [ef On{~ a Magkag' Bmm ynje{s yfsfyxfk'
_fo{nag N
Eazfxfy- pby{nonpb{nag i~ pynxb{f
pmb~fys bgk ngxfs{ays kvyngj {ef mbs{
xf ~fbys ebs iffg vgfxfg< zenms{
Obmfgkby fby %O^. 9006 bgk O^9008 sbz b snjgnobg{ lvdp ng PPP
pyalfo{s- bo{nxn{~ kyappfk sebypm~
axfy O^900: bgk O^9005'
[ef bo{ {eb{ {ef Pvimno Pynxb{f
Pby{nonpb{nag Bppyaxbm Oaddn{{ff
%PPP$BO . b Jaxfygdfg{ a
Ngknb %JaN. spagsayfk oaddn{{ff
zenoe bppyaxfs PPP pyalfo{s
bppyaxfk lvs{ ;0 pyalfo{s zay{e
V_+2:0 dg kvyngj O^900: bgk b
gvdify dbyjngbmm~ enjefy {ebg {ens
ng O^9005 enjemnje{s {ef mboc adadfg{vd bongj {ef PPP dakfm ng
{ef knovm{ gbgongj dakfm a 9005
%sff jvyf 2 bgk {bimf 2.'
Booaykngj {a {ef PPP Ngknb
kb{bibsf - {efyf byf ;60 PPP
pyalfo{s zay{e V_+;: ig vgkfyzb~
%yffy {bimf 2.- vp yad 929 pyalfo{s
zay{e V_+92 ig ng _fp{fdify 900:
%sff {bimf 2.'
[ens ndpmnfs bg ngoyfbsf a V_+96 ig
zay{e a pyalfo{s vgkfy PPP sngof{ef ifjnggngj a {ef UN{e pmbg'
Bm{eavje bo{nxn{~ ndpyaxfk ng 900>
%sff {bimf 2. ng b gvdify a byfbs
%fspfonbmm~ ng yabks.- {efsf jvyfs
byf s{nmm by ifengk {ef pmbggfk
pby{nonpb{nag fgxnsbjfk i~ {ef
Jaxfygdfg{'
Zf znmm bgbm~sf {ef yfbsags ay {ens
seay{bmm ng {ef svisfrvfg{ sfo{nags
a {ens ga{f'
HAYFNJG NGxF_[DFG[ NG PPP
[efyf zbs b snjgnobg{ ngoyfbsf ng
ayfnjg dagf~ fg{fyngj ng Ngknb ng
O^9005 ng {ef zbcf a fmfxb{fk
ng{fyfs{ ng PPP ngxfs{dfg{s ng
O^9008 bgk O^900:'
[ens yfsvm{fk ng ga{ lvs{ b lvdp ng
ngybs{yvo{vyf HKN iv{ bmsa efmpfk
jfgfyb{f pynxb{f frvn{~ %PF. ng{fyfs{'
O^9005 zn{gfssfk Ngknb aovsfk
ngybs{yvo{vyf vgk ybnsngjs a V_+9'9ig %sff jvyf 9. zenoe zbs axfy bgk
biaxf {ef PF dagf~ ybnsfk {eb{ ~fby
ay Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf'
Eazfxfy- {ens nghvu a ayfnjg frvn{~
saag kynfk vp bgk ng O^900> agm~
V_+2ig a ngybs{yvo{vyf PF zbs
ybnsfk' HKN ng{a Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf
bmsa lvdpfk ng O^900:!H^05 iv{
{efg kfomngfk ng H^0>'
[ef jmaibm gbgonbm oynsns bgk mboc
a dfbgngjvm pyalfo{s zfyf {ef{za dbng yfbsags on{fk i~ ngkvs{y~
pby{nonpbg{s ay {ens kyap ng O^9005!
H^0>'
_ngof {efg {efyf ebs iffg b yfiavgk
ng HKN ng ngybs{yvo{vyf- bgk b{
{ef {ndf a zyn{ngj {ens yfpay{-
bga{efy V_+2'6$9ig a Ngknb aovsfk
Hnjvyf 2>0
2>>2
2>>9
2>>?
2>>;
2>>6
2>>8
2>>:
2>>5
2>>>
9000
9002
9009
900?
900;
9006
9008
900:
9005
%gas.
Zb{fy bgk sfzbjf
[ybgspay{
[fmfoad
Fgfyj~
2 2
:
2
?
0'9 0'2
;'2
2
9'9
900; 9006 9008 900: 9005
Ga a vgks Bjjyfjb{f obpn{bm ybnsfk %V_+ ig.
Hnjvyf 9 zn{e yabks bgk pay{s mfbkngj {ef zb~
_fo{ays_fp$0:
%gas'.
Hfi$05
%gas'.
Hfi$0>
%gas'.
Hfi$20
%gas'._fo{ays
_fp$0:
%V_+dg.
Hfi$05
%V_+dg.
Hfi$0>
%V_+dg.
Hfi$20
%V_+dg.
Bnypay{s 6 6 8 6 Bnypay{s ?->;> ?->52 ;-2:6 ?->52
Fgfyj~ 0 0 ?2 9; Fgfyj~ $ $ ?-:0> ?-686
Pay{s 9: ?5 ?5 ;? Pay{s 8-:>: 29-802 5->8> 2?-56;
Yabks 2:9 2:0 25: 9:2 Yabks >-8?6 >-522 >->;> 92-962
Vyibg kfxfmapdfg{ 6 6 ?6 :? Vyibg kfxfmapdfg{ ;?2 ?>2 2-9>6 ?-256
Ybnmzb~s ( A{efy ? ? ? ?; Ybnmzb~s ( A{efy 920 920 920 58:
[a{bm 929 992 ?00 ;60 [a{bm 92-099 98->>6 95-?05 ;8-:0?
[a{bm fuom' fgfyj~ 929 992 98> ;98 [a{bm fuom' fgfyj~ 92-099 98->>6 9;-6>> ;?-2?>
_avyof< Fufov{nag Gaimf- Ngknbg foagadno svyxf~s
GI zf ebxf vsfk fuoebgjf yb{f a V_!NGY a Ys ;5 ay oagxfy{ngj {ef PPP pyalfo{ oas{s {a V_+
8/8/2019 Indian Infrastructure Going Beyond the Sound Bytes
11/44
22
)Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf < jangj if~agk {ef savgki~{fs) $ Pasn{nag Pbpfy 9020 Fufov{nag Gaimf ( Oadpbg~ M{k bgk [ef On{~ a Magkag' Bmm ynje{s yfsfyxfk'
ngybs{yvo{vyf PF ns ovyyfg{m~ ifngj
ybnsfk n'f'- {ef vgks spagsays byf
{avyngj {ef jmaif {y~ngj {a kyvd vp
obpn{bm'
YFOADDFGKB[NAG_ [A KB[F
Axfy {ef pbs{ kfobkf {efyf ebxf
iffg b ybgjf a pyapasbms yfjbykngj
ngybs{yvo{vyf kfxfmapdfg{ bgk
gbgongj dbkf i~ dvm{nmb{fybm
iaknfs- oagsvm{ngj iaknfs-
jaxfygdfg{bm iaknfs bgk ngxfs{ays'
[ef fu{fg{ {a zenoe {efsf
yfoaddfgkb{nags ebxf iffg
bkkyfssfk i~ {ef jaxfygdfg{ ebsxbynfk $ sadf pyapasbms ebxf iffg
bkkyfssfk zenms{ a{efys byf s{nmm
bzbn{ngj ndpmfdfg{b{nag' Bppfgknu
9 ag pbjf ?; enjemnje{s {ef cf~
pbpfys zyn{{fg axfy {ef pbs{ xf
~fbys bgk {ef yfoaddfgkb{nags
{efyfng'
[ef cf~ yfoaddfgkb{nags- ng
kfsofgkngj aykfy a ndpay{bgof-
yfmb{ngj {a ngybs{yvo{vyf byf
{bivmb{fk ifmaz- bmagjsnkf {ef s{b{vs
a {efny ndpmfdfg{b{nag'
Efgof {ef s{b{vs {akb~ ns {eb{0 ig zbs
{ef ngoyfdfg{bm haz ng{a
ibgcs bs sbxngjs ng H^0>.
iv{ byf ga{ bmmazfk {a ngxfs{
dayf {ebg 26$90& ng
ngybs{yvo{vyf pyalfo{s
kvf {a yfs{yno{nags svoebs jyavp fupasvyf mndn{s-
{ef ombssnob{nag a mabgs
{a {ef ngybs{yvo{vyf sfo{ay
bs vgsfovyfk- pyvkfg{nbm
fupasvyf mndn{s ufk i~ {ef
YIN bgk sfo{aybm obps sf{ i~
{ef ibgc iabyks'
[efMnhfNgsvybgof
Oaypayb{nag a Ngknb %MNO.-
Ngknbs jaxfygdfg{ azgfk
ngsvybgof ifefda{e
booavg{s ay 26& a {ef gf{kadfs{no gbgonbm sbxngjs'
MNO bgk a{efy mnf ngsvybgof
oadpbgnfs byf ga{ bmmazfk
Mbocangfs{dfg{obpn{bmnsga{{efafyynkngjpyaimfd'''
PFY_PFO[NxF
Ng avy knsovssnags zn{e gfbym~ b
ka|fg pynxb{f frvn{~ ngxfs{ays
ngxfs{ngj ng Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf- {ef
oagsfgsvs xnfz zbs {eb{ {efyf ns
pa{fg{nbmm~ b xfy~ mbyjf appay{vgn{~
ay svoe ngxfs{ays'
Eazfxfy- pby{nonpb{nag ng {ens
appay{vgn{~ ns ovyyfg{m~ yfs{yno{fk
i~ {ef mndn{fk gvdify a pyalfo{s
bxbnmbimf ay ngxfs{dfg{ i~ pynxb{f
kfxfmapfys bgk i~ b gvdify
a pyaofkvybm nssvfs svoe bsfgxnyagdfg{bm omfbybgofs- mbgk
borvnsn{nag bgk vfm mngcbjfs'
[ef ng{fyxnfzffs bjyffk {eb{
{efsf pyaofkvybm nssvfs obg ebxf b
snjgnobg{ ndpbo{ ag {ef ynsc$yfzbyk
pyamf a bg appay{vgn{~'
[ef yfsvm{ a {efyf ifngj b mndn{fk
gvdify a pyalfo{s ns {eb{ {efyf byf b
mbyjf gvdify a kfxfmapfys inkkngj
ay b ebgkvm a pyalfo{s'
{a ngxfs{ dayf {ebg 26&
a {efny bssf{s ng
ngybs{yvo{vyf pyalfo{s
%zenms{ {ef~ obg ngxfs{ 60&ng jaxfygdfg{ sfovyn{nfs
bgk b dbundvd a ?6& ng
s{aoc dbycf{ sfovyn{nfs.'
Hvy{efy {efsf ngxfs{dfg{s ng
ngybs{yvo{vyf i~ mnf ngsvyfys
ebxf {a if yb{fk ngxfs{dfg{
jybkf i~ {ef oyfkn{ yb{ngj
eavsfs' Ng H^20 MNO ns
fupfo{fk {a ngxfs{ V_+?: ig
ng {a{bm'
Zenmf mboc a ngxfs{dfg{ obpn{bm ns
ga{ {ef axfyynkngj pyaimfd nkfg{nfkng {ens pbpfy- zfyf {efsf ais{bomfs
{a if bkkyfssfk- {ens zavmk vy{efy
yff vp ngxfs{dfg{ hazs ng{a
ngybs{yvo{vyf'
Mncfznsf- zayc {a kfxfmap b yaivs{
kfi{ dbycf{ zavmk sfovyf dvoe
gffkfk magj {fyd vgkngj ay dblay
pyalfo{s'
[EF FrVN[^ HNGBGONFY_
$
600
2-000
2-600
9-000
9-600
?-000
?-600
;-000
;-600
H^>0
H^>2
H^>9
H^>?
H^>;
H^>6
H^>8
H^>:
H^>5
H^>>
H^00
H^02
H^09
H^0?
H^0;
H^06
H^08
H^0:
H^05
H^0>
%Ys ig.
Pfgsnag Mnf Ngsvybgof Ibgc Kfpasn{s
Hnjvyf ? < [efyf ns jyaz{e ng Ngknbg
sbngjs iv{ n{ dbngm~ azs {a
bfgvfs zn{e mndn{b{nags yfjbykngj
ngybs{yvo{vyf fupasvyf
_avyof< YIN
$
2-000
9-000
?-000
;-000
6-000
8-000
:-000
5-000
>-000
2>>>
9000
9002
9009
900?
900;
9006
9008
900:
9005
900>
%Ys ig.
Mabgs _{aoc Fuoebgjf _fovyn{nfs
Hnjvyf ; < MNOs ngfs{dfg{s byf
scfzfk {azbyks mns{fk sfovyn{nfs
bgk ga{ mabgs bgk iagks a
ngybs{yvo{vyf oadpbgnfs
_avyof< YIN
_fo{nag NN
[bimf 8< Ngybs{yvo{vyf mabgs booavg{ ay b sdbmm pyapay{nag a mabgssbgo{nagfk i~ Ngknbg ibgcs
H^0; H^06 H^08 H^0: H^05 H^0>
Gag$Haak Jyass Ibgc Oyfkn{ %Ys ig. :-95; >->>5 2;-062 25-029 9-09> 98-09?
~a~ jyaz{e %&. ?:& ;2& 95& 99& 25&
Ngybs{yvo{vyf mabgs %Ys ig. 62? :>0 2-055 2-;?; 9-062 9-:00
~a~ jyaz{e %&. 6;& ?5& ?9& ;?& ?9&
Ngyb mabgs bs & a {a{bm ibgc oyfkn{ :'0& :'>& :':& 5'0& >'?& 20';&
8/8/2019 Indian Infrastructure Going Beyond the Sound Bytes
15/44
26
)Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf < jangj if~agk {ef savgki~{fs) $ Pasn{nag Pbpfy 9020 Fufov{nag Gaimf ( Oadpbg~ M{k bgk [ef On{~ a Magkag' Bmm ynje{s yfsfyxfk'
[ef ngfs{ay*s pfyspfo{nf
_avyof< YIN[bimf : < Oaddfg{s i~ mfbkngj ngybs{yvo{vyf ngfs{ays
_avyof a va{f Biiyfnb{fk rva{f
Hvgk Dbgbjfy- mfbkngj
ayfnjg Ngybs{yvo{vyf vgk
Ngknb ns b enje ynsc$enje yf{vyg dbycf{'''Bkkyfssngj ndpmfdfg{b{nag yabk imaocs- zenoe obg if {bocmfk b{ {ef
pmbggngj s{bjf- bgk yfdaxngj {bu bgk yfjvmb{ay~ ia{{mfgfocs obg ngoyfbsf pby{nonpb{nag dvm{n$amk ng Ngknbg PPPs'
Fu$Hvgk Dbgbjfy a b mns{fk
Fvyapfbg ngybs{yvo{vyf vgk
'''S{efT Jaxfygdfg{ seavmk zayc {azbyks {ef ammazngj ay svppay{ngj pynxb{f frvn{~< oagsns{fg{ bxbnmbinmn{~ a
magj${fyd kfi{- binmn{~ {a yfgbgof Skfi{T- jmaibm iagk ybnsngj bgk S{efT passnimf oyfb{nag a bg ngybs{yvo{vyf
ibgc' Hvy{efy- mbzs seavmk if oagsns{fg{ bgk seavmk ga{ oebgjf zn{e {ef efbk a S{efT dngns{y~ oebgjngj zn{e {ef
fmfo{nags' Dayfaxfy fun{ s{yb{fjnfs seavmk ngxamxf mazfy ngonkfgof a {bu'
Hvgk Dbgbjfy- mfbkngj
ayfnjg PF vgk
N SbT pyalfo{ ns jaak- {efg dagf~ znmm gk b zb~' Bm{eavje n{ bppfbys {a av{snkfys {eb{ pynxb{f frvn{~ pby{nonpb{nag
znmm if b oebmmfgjf- zf kag{ {engc sa' Kfmb~s ng oaddfgofdfg{ a pazfy pmbg{ bgk yabk oags{yvo{nag znmm bmsa cffp
frvn{~ yfrvnyfdfg{s mazfy' Dayfaxfy- {efyf gffks {a if b jaxfygdfg{ pamno~ ag yfmb{fk ngybs{yvo{vyf- ay fubdpmf
b ibmbgofk kfxfmapdfg{ a oabm pamno~ bgk {ybgsdnssnag!jfgfyb{nag pyalfo{s ay {ef mbyjf gvdify a jfgfyb{nagbssf{s oadngj vp'
ONA- mfbkngj Ngknbg
ngybs{yvo{vyf PF vgk
Dagf~ ns ga{ b oags{ybng{ ay Ngknbs ngybs{yvo{vyf bdin{nags''' n{s {ef jaxfygdfg{s ngobpbinmn{~ {a kfsnjg bgk
pyfsfg{ ibgcbimf pyalfo{s' SBT iagk dbycf{ ns gfofssby~ iv{ n{ ns bg fgbimfy bgk obg ndpbo{ S{efT oas{s a pyalfo{s'
[ef Jaxfygdfg{ ebs {a ndpyaxf {ef inkkngj pyaofssfs vy{efy bgk seavmk ebxf b s{yagj mfjbm ybdfzayc bgk
yfjvmb{ay~ iak~ ng pmbof' N {ef ng{fygbm nssvf a pyalfo{ pmbggngj ns bkkyfssfk- {efg agf obg s{by{ zayy~ngj biav{ {ef
fu{fygbm nssvfs'
Pyngonpbm- mfbkngj Ngknbg
ngybs{yvo{vyf PF vgk
Ngknb dvs{ ebxf ofg{ybm dboengfy~ ng pmbof {eb{ oagofnxfs- s{yvo{vyfs- bgk oyfb{fs b oag{ngvavs sefm a dbycf{bimf
PPP pyalfo{s' [efyf seavmk bmsa if b zb~ {a kfbm zn{e ngybs{yvo{vyf pyalfo{s pyapasfk vgnmb{fybmm~ i~ pynxb{f sfo{ay
fg{yfpyfgfvys'
_avyof< Fufov{nag Gaimf
Bs b yfsvm{ {ef afy pynof fsobmb{fs
bgk {ens mazfys {ef yf{vygs ay {ef
frvbmm~ mbyjf gvdify a pynxb{f
frvn{~!ngybs{yvo{vyf vgks maacngj{a pby{nonpb{f ng {efsf pyalfo{s zn{e
{ef kfxfmapfys'
Bm{eavje ofy{bng yfjvmb{nags zn{e
yfspfo{ {a {ef sbmfs ng s{bcfs ng _PXs
ebxf iffg yfmbufk %ay fubdpmf < Oaddfg{s i~ kffmapfys apfyb{ngj ng Ngknb
_avyof a va{f Biiyfnb{fk rva{f
OFA- mfbkngj Ngknbg
ngybs{yvo{vyf GIHO
Zenms{ oyfb{ngj ibgcbimf pyalfo{s ns a {ef v{das{ ndpay{bgof- {ef yfspfo{nxf jaxfygdfg{bm iaknfs seavmk bmsa bs{
pbof {ef bppyaxbm pyaofssfs ay {ef funs{ngj pyalfo{s'''
xnof$Pyfsnkfg{- mfbkngj Ngknbg
ngybs{yvo{vyf oadpbg~
Bm{eavje {efyf byf b dvm{npmf yfbsags engkfyngj pynxb{f ngxfs{dfg{ ng{a Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf- zf {engc {ef das{
{yavimfsadf byf< %b. ngfonfg{ ynsc bmmaob{nag zefyf {ef pynxb{f kfxfmapfy ns bscfk {a bssvdf ynsc zenoe n{ obgga{
ifby3 %i. ngbinmn{~ {a eagavy {ef sbgo{n{~ a {ef Kfsnjg- Ivnmk- Hngbgof- Apfyb{f bgk [ybgsfy %KIHA[. oag{ybo{ i~
ga{ yfrvnyngj dvm{npmf bppyaxbms kfspn{f oadpmf{f ngkfpfgkfgof pyadnsfk ng {ef KIHA[ oag{ybo{3 bgk %o. ngs{binmn{~
a zaycngj pamnonfs ng {ef Jaxfygdfg{ bgk {ef oag{ybo{ bzbykngj iaknfs' [eavje {efsf nssvfs znmm ndpyaxf {ef
ng{fyfs{ bgk foagadnos ay b kfxfmapfy- b magj${fyd iagk dbycf{ ay ngoyfbsngj kvyb{nag a oagofssnags znmm ga{
agm~ efmp kfxfmapfys iv{ bmsa iyngj kazg {ef vsfy %pvimno. oebyjfs bs oas{s a seay{ kvyb{nag mabgs bgk yfsf{s byf
ga{ yag{ mabkfk'
Knyfo{ay- Bsnbg ngybs{yvo{vyf
kffmapfy
Kfspn{f {ef mbyjf appay{vgn{~ ng {ef Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf sfjdfg{- {ef sdbmm sn|f a pyalfo{s ebs cfp{ {ef jmaibm
kfxfmapfys b{ ib~' Eazfxfy- bs {ef pyalfo{ sn|fs byf ifoadngj injjfy- {efyf byf a{efy nssvfs svoe bs< %b. mboc a
b magj${fyd iagk dbycf{ ng mngf zn{e ngoyfbsngj oagofssnag pfynaks- %i. ivyfbvoyb{no!pamn{nobm nssvfs ng ai{bngngj
omfbybgofs- %o. mboc a s{bimf yfjndf ng pamnonfs bgk pyaofkvyfs bgk %k. mboc a ibgcbimf pyalfo{s'
Knyfo{ay- Fvyapfbg
ngybs{yvo{vyf kffmapfy
[ef sn|f a pyalfo{s ns agf a {ef injjfs{ nssvfs ng Ngknb' Mbyjf sn|f PPP pyalfo{s seavmk if pv{ av{ ay inkkngj b{fy
ai{bngngj dbgkb{ay~ omfbybgofs bgk bppyaxbms ''' bs zbs yfofg{m~ kagf ng {ef obsf a {ef Vm{yb Dfjb Pazfy Pyalfo{s
%VDPPs.' Hvy{efy ngaydb{nag haz ag PPP ng {ef oavg{y~ ag pyalfo{s vgkfy kfxfmapdfg{ ay ndpmfdfg{b{nag seavmk
ndpyaxf sa {eb{ kfxfmapfys byf bzbyf a pyalfo{s vgkfy kfxfmapdfg{' Mbs{m~- {yvf magj${fyd pyalfo{ gbgof seavmk
if dbkf bxbnmbimf'
_avyof< Fufov{nag Gaimf
8/8/2019 Indian Infrastructure Going Beyond the Sound Bytes
19/44
2>
)Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf < jangj if~agk {ef savgki~{fs) $ Pasn{nag Pbpfy 9020 Fufov{nag Gaimf ( Oadpbg~ M{k bgk [ef On{~ a Magkag' Bmm ynje{s yfsfyxfk'
[bimf 20 < Hayfnjg pby{nonpb{nag ng Ngknbg PPPs ns fy~ sdbmm
Ngfs{ay [~pf[a{bm ngfs{dfg{
%Ys ig.& a {a{bm gvdify
a pyalfo{s& a {a{bm
pyalfo{ oas{
Pay{s > ; 9;&
Yabks > ? 26&
Bnypay{s ; 22 82&
[a{bm 99 2: 200&
_avyof< PPP Ngknb Kb{bibsf
Mboc a pvyf pyalfo{ gbgof'
Ngknb- vgmncf {ef a{efy kfxfmapfk bgk
kfxfmapngj gb{nags- mbocs b magj${fyd
[bimf 22 < _fo{ay$znsf iyfbc$vp a ayfnjg ngfs{ay pby{nonpb{nag ng PPP
_fo{ay Ga' a Pyalfo{s
Ngfs{dfg{
%Ys ig.
& a {a{bm
pyalfo{ oas{
Hayfnjg Ngxfs{ay 2: :& 2&
Ngknbg Pynxb{f
Ngxfs{ay2-?;2 >?& >>&
[a{bm 2-?6> 200& 200&
_avyof< PPP Ngknb Kb{bibsf
kfi{ dbycf{ ay pvyf pyalfo{ gbgof'
Das{ a {ef mabgs {eb{ {ef kfxfmapfys
byf ovyyfg{m~ ybnsngj byf 20$26 ~fby
mabgs ay oagofssnags yvggngj ay
dayf {ebg 90$96 ~fbys'
Dayfaxfy- {efsf magj${fyds mabgs
ebxf yfjvmby yfsf{s zenoe vgkfydngf
{ef fssfgof a magj${fyd ibgc
vgkngj'
Hvy{efy- zenms{ pyalfo{ gbgongj ns
jmaibmm~ ag b gag$yfoavysf ibsns-ng Ngknb pyalfo{ gbgof oadpbgnfs
ka ga{ apfyb{f ng {ens zb~ bs
mfgkfys zbg{ bkkn{nagbm jvbybg{ffs
bgk svppay{ yad {ef spagsays ay
kfxfmapfys'
[ef ynje{ cngk a pyalfo{ gbgof
oaxfyngj das{ a {ef oagofssnag
pfynak oag{ngvfs {a if vgbxbnmbimf-
kfspn{f {ef oagofssnag pfynaks
ifoadngj magjfy'
Hayfnjg kfxfmapfys yad Fvyapf
bgk Bsnbg oavg{ynfs sebyfk sndnmbyoagofygs bs {ef kadfs{no kfxfmapfys
iv{ bmsa bkkfk
?2
>:
:0
?9
?>
9;
?>
29
8/8/2019 Indian Infrastructure Going Beyond the Sound Bytes
28/44
95
)Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf < jangj if~agk {ef savgki~{fs) $ Pasn{nag Pbpfy 9020 Fufov{nag Gaimf ( Oadpbg~ M{k bgk [ef On{~ a Magkag' Bmm ynje{s yfsfyxfk'
_pfono bo{nag pang{s>6' [ef _{b{f
Jaxfygdfg{ ngxn{fk inks bgk {efg
aydfk b pby{gfysenp zn{e dblayn{~
s{bcf ifngj azgfk i~ {ef pynxb{f
sfo{ay pby{nonpbg{- bgk {ef dngayn{~
ifngj zn{e {ef s{b{f Jaxfygdfg{
%{eyavje Jvlbyb{ Dbyn{ndf Iabyk
bgk Jvlbyb{ Ngkvs{ynbm Ngxfs{dfg{
Oaypayb{nag.'
B{ {ef {ndf a {ef ink- Dvgkyb ebk
ga ybnm oaggfo{nxn{~' Mb{fy ag {ef
Bkbgn Jyavp ivnm{ b 89 cd mngf b{ {ef
oabs{ bgk {efg {aac 90& frvn{~ ng b
?26 cd mngf pyaxnkngj bm{fygb{f yav{f
{a Dvgkyb pay{' [efsf ybnmzb~ mngfs
zfyf bdagjs{ {ef ys{ fz pynxb{fm~
ivnm{ ybnmzb~ mngfs ivnm{ ng Ngknb'
Pyfsfg{m~- {ef pay{ ns oaggfo{fk {a
{ef gb{nagbm ybnm gf{zayc {eyavje ybnm
bgk {a {ef s{b{f enjezb~ gf{zayc
{eyavje yabk' [efsf yabk bgk ybnm
mngcs zfyf oyn{nobm ng pyaxnkngj
oaggfo{nxn{~ {a zeb{ zbs vg{nm {efg
agf a {ef das{ yfda{f pbs{ a
Zfs{fyg Ngknb'
Ng aykfy {a kfxfmap {ef pay{- BkbgnJyavp ngxn{fk P(A Pay{s %a VC. {a
apfyb{f agf oag{bngfy ify{e' [akb~
Dvgkyb ebs 29 ify{es- ngomvkngj {za
ay oag{bngfy ebgkmngj' Dvgkyb bmsa
ebs Ngknbs ys{ dvm{n oaddakn{~ _F\
spyfbkngj axfy b 200 sr cd byfb'
Bkbgn Jyavp kfxfmapfk ga{ agm~
boofss ngybs{yvo{vyf iv{ bmsa {ef
saonbm ngybs{yvo{vyf ng {ef eng{fymbgk'
N{s ga{ bs n {ef pay{ kfxfmapdfg{
knk ga{ bof bg~ oebmmfgjfs' Dvgkyb
ebk {a bof pyaimfds kvf {apyamagjfk kfmb~s ng sf{{ngj vp {ef
oyn{nobm ibsno ybnm bgk yabk mngcbjfs'
Bs pfy {ef oadpbg~- {efyf zbs
bg ngn{nbm mboc a s~goeyagnsb{nag
bgk {ndf mbjs ng {ef kfxfmapdfg{
a xbynavs {~pfs a majns{nos
ngybs{yvo{vyf yfrvnyfk'
Ffo{nxf pmbggngj bgk s{yagj
pamn{nobm znmm %zn{e svppay{ yad
{ef enjefs{ foefmags a {ef _{b{f
Jaxfygdfg{. ay {ef kfxfmapdfg{
a {ef pyalfo{ efmpfk {ef pyalfo{ {ayfboe b sobmf n{ ns {akb~'
Ze~ zbs n{ svoofssvm1
Jvlbyb{ zbs {ef ys{ s{b{f ng {ef
oavg{y~ {a fgbo{ bg Ngybs{yvo{vyf
Kfxfmapdfg{ Bo{' [ens zbs
kagf {a iaas{ ngxfs{dfg{ ng
ngybs{yvo{vyf pyalfo{s' [ef Bo{
pyaxnkfk b ybdfzayc {a pynxb{f
sfo{ay pmb~fys cffg {a pby{nonpb{f
ng {ef oags{yvo{nag- gbgof bgk
dbng{fgbgof a {ef ngybs{yvo{vyf
pyalfo{s' [ef Jvlbyb{ Ngybs{yvo{vyf
Kfxfmapdfg{ Iabyk- sf{ vp ng 2>>6
vgkfy {ens Bo{- bonmn{b{fs {ef haz
a vgks yad {ef pynxb{f sfo{ay
ng{a {ef ngybs{yvo{vyf sfo{ay bgk
fgsvyfs oaaykngb{nag bdagj xbynavsbjfgonfs'
Dayfaxfy- Jvlbyb{ zbs {ef ys{ s{b{f
{a bggavgof b sfpbyb{f Pay{ Pamno~-
zenoe ng{fjyb{fs {ef kfxfmapdfg{ a
pay{s zn{e ngkvs{ynbm kfxfmapdfg{-
pazfy jfgfyb{nag bgk ngybs{yvo{vyf
kfxfmapdfg{' N{ zbs bmsa {ef ys{
s{b{f {a pynxb{nsf {ef oags{yvo{nag a
pay{s ng {ef oavg{y~'
Bs pfy avy knsovssnags zn{e xbynavs
ngkvs{y~ pby{nonpbg{s- Dvgkyb Pay{sfxamv{nag pyaxnkfs vsfvm ngsnje{s
ng{a eaz {a ffo{nxfm~ dbgbjf b
mbyjf PPP' B fz yfbsags on{fk ay n{s
svoofss zfyf bs ammazs
Mbgk borvnsn{nag pyaofss ifs{yfbdmngfk3
_{yagjjaxfygdfg{fg{n{nfs
{a pyaxnkf oyfkn{
fgebgofdfg{ ay pyalfo{s3
Hbonmn{b{nagng{fydsah
jf{{ngj bmm omfbybgofs (
bppyaxbms yad jaxfygdfg{
bjfgonfs pynay {a pyalfo{
oaddfgofdfg{3
_oapfahXfg{vyfhvgks{aif
fupbgkfk {a bmmaz
ngxfs{dfg{ ng bmm
ngybs{yvo{vyf sfo{ays3 bgk FOIifdbkfboofssnimf
{a bmm ngybs{yvo{vyf pmb~fys
vgkfy bv{adb{no yav{f'
2?' PPP Pyalfo{ Hngbgongj$
Oebmmfgjfs bgk Ap{nags- Hfiyvby~
900>- Ky _ K Gbgkb- NNHOM
DOBs {a if kfxfmapfk ay bmm
ngybs{yvo{vyf sfo{ays3
Kaovdfg{{efyamf-
yfspagsninmn{nfs- ynscs bgkyfzbyks ay fboe pby{ ng
s{b{v{ay~ bv{eayn{nfs3
[akfxfmapsngjmfzngkazhay
bppyaxbms ng {ndf iavgk
dbggfy ay PPP pyalfo{s3
[akfxfmappnpfmngf!sefmhah
pyalfo{s3 bgk
[akfxfmap{efpamno~hay
borvnsn{nag a mbgk'
2;' By{nomfs a xngb~bc Oeb{{fylff-
Oebnydbg Hffkiboc xfg{vyfs-Ivsngfss _{bgkbyk
Oyfb{nag a ibgcbimf
pyalfo{s3
NgoyfbsfPPPobpbon{nfsng
Ofg{yf bgk s{b{fs3
_{bgkbyknsb{nagahPPPink
kaovdfg{s bgk DOBs3
Fu{fgsnagah_fo{nag50NB
ay bga{efy 26 ~fbys bgk
DB[ if biamnsefk ng {ef
pfynak a bxbnmdfg{3
Hvmmpbss${eyavjeahknxnkfgk
kns{yniv{nag {bu ay
ngybs{yvo{vyf _PXs- bgk{yfb{dfg{ a magj${fyd
obpn{bm jbngs {bu ag sbmf a
frvn{~ eamkngjs ng vgmns{fk
_PXs ng mngf zn{e {efny mns{fk
oavg{fypby{s3
BgFupfy{Oaddn{{ffag
Kfgn{nag a Ngybs{yvo{vyf {a
if sf{ vp3
_f{vpGb{nagbmKfxfmapdfg{
Oavgonm ay Ngybs{yvo{vyf
%GKON. bgk svppay{ngj
bjfgo~ obmmfk {ef Gb{nagbm
Ngybs{yvo{vyf Hbonmn{b{nagbgk Dagn{ayngj Bjfgo~
%GNHDB. ay ndpyaxngj
ndpmfdfg{b{nag bgk bkap{
90 oyass$sfo{aybm pyalfo{s a
gb{nagbm ndpay{bgof3
_f{vpbGb{nagbmMbgkIbgc
Oaypayb{nag %GMIO. zn{e
bg ngn{nbm obpn{bm a Ys 60-000
oyayf- vgkfy bg Bo{ a
Pbymnbdfg{3
_f{{ngjvp{yvm~ngkfpfgkfg{
yfjvmb{ay~ oaddnssnags!
iaknfs3 bgk Ngoyfbsfngpamn{nobmznmmbgk
ivyfbvoyb{no fgfyj~'
26' Oags{yvo{nag Hfkfyb{nag a Ngknb
%OHN. znse mns{- Hfiyvby~ 9020
Dbycf{ ay magj {fyd kfi{$
sadf kfsnjgb{fk ngs{n{v{nags
if bscfk {a pyaxnkf dbycf{$
dbcngj svppay{ ay iagk
nssvbgofs i~ ibgcs ay
agzbyk ngybs{yvo{vyfmfgkngj3
Ibgcsseavmkifbmmazfk{a
ybnsf magj {fgay {bu fufdp{
iagks {a ag$mfgk {a
ngybs{yvo{vyf sfo{ay3
YINdb~ifpfysvbkfk{a
mazfy obpn{bm bkfrvbo~
gayds ay [bcf$av{ gbgongj3
GaydshayNgsvybgof!
Pfgsnag Hvgks seavmk bmmaz
pfgsnag vgks {a ngxfs{
biav{ 20 {a 26 & a {efny
vgks ng Ngybs{yvo{vyf
Iagks3 bgk
[yfb{Nghybs{yvo{vyfEamkngjOadpbgnfs bs b sfpbyb{f
ombss a GIHO bgk fufdp{
{efd yad {ef yfs{yno{nags
ndpasfk ag vsvbm GIHOs'
28' By{nomfs bgk ng{fynfzs a
Dy Bdyn{ Pbgkvybgjn- Mfbkfy
Ngybs{yvo{vyf Pybo{nof- PzO
Iams{fy vyibg dbgbjfdfg{
scnmms3
Oagsns{fgo~bgks{binmn{~ahpamnonfs!ngybs{yvo{vyf
pamnonfs3 bgk
Hnsobmoagofssnagspyaxnkfk
{a ngybs{yvo{vyf sfo{ays if
dayf kfgn{nxf- dayf
oagsns{fg{ bgk ngknob{nxf a b
magj${fyd s{bimf yfjndf'
8/8/2019 Indian Infrastructure Going Beyond the Sound Bytes
37/44
?:
)Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf < jangj if~agk {ef savgki~{fs) $ Pasn{nag Pbpfy 9020 Fufov{nag Gaimf ( Oadpbg~ M{k bgk [ef On{~ a Magkag' Bmm ynje{s yfsfyxfk'
rvfs{naggbnyf ay kffmapfys
ngfs{ngj ng{a Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf
2' Zeb{ byf {ef injjfs{
ais{bomfs {eb{ ayfnjg
ngxfs{ays!fg{n{nfs byf ga{
bimf {a pby{nonpb{f ng {ef
Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyfs
appay{vgn{~1
9' Eaz bzbyf byf {ef ayfnjg
ngxfs{ays a ynscs ng ngxfs{ngj
ng Ngybs{yvo{vyf bssf{sfspfonbmm~ Ngknbg
ngybs{yvo{vyf bssf{s1 Eaz
ka {ef~ sffc {a bkkyfss
{ef ynscs bgk oagofygs zefg
{ef~ oagsnkfy ngxfs{dfg{s ng
~avy yd ay pyalfo{s {eb{
~avy yd ns fufov{ngj1
?' Eaz ebxf yfjvmb{nags
oebgjfk ay ndpyaxngj
ayfnjg ngxfs{dfg{ ng{a ~avy
yd1
;' Ka ayfnjg ngxfs{ays iyngj
bg~ mfbygngj yad {efng{fygb{nagbm ngybs{yvo{vyf
ngxfs{dfg{s1
6' Kafs {ef s{yvo{vyf a b
kfxfmapfy ovd oags{yvo{nag
oag{ybo{ay yfkvof bg~
oebmmfgjfs oagofygs ay b
kfxfmapfy1
8' Kfxfmapfy ns {ef injjfs{
ngxfs{ay a frvn{~' Zeb{
byf booaykngj {a ~av
{ef injjfs{ oebmmfgjfs1
Zeb{ byf {ef oebmmfgjfs ay
ayfnjg ngybs{yvo{vyfkfxfmapfys maacngj b{ Ngknb
fn{efy i~ {efdsfmxfs ay ng b
LX zn{e Ngknbg pmb~fys1
:' [YBN ebs iffg agf a {ef
injjfs{ kynxfys a ng{fyfs{ ng
Ngknbg {fmfoad1 Ka ~av
{engc a{efy sfjdfg{s bmsa
gffk svoe yfjvmb{ays1 Bg~
a{efy yfjvmb{ay zenoe ns
kangj jaak zayc1
Bppfgknu ? < Rvfs{naggbnyfs
rvfs{naggbnyf ay fvn{~ ngfs{ays
ngfs{ngj ng{a Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf
2' Bs bg ngxfs{ay zefg ~av maac
b{ Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf
bssf{s- eaz ka {efsf
oadpbyf zn{e appay{vgn{nfs
ng a{efy Bsnbg!Fdfyjngj
oavg{ynfs! Kfxfmapfk
oavg{ynfs ng {fyds a ynscs
bgk yfzbyks1
9' Zeb{ byf {ef cf~ ynscsbgk oagofygs {eb{ ~av bof
zefg oagsnkfyngj ngxfs{ngj
ng Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf bssf{s
ay oadpbgnfs1 Ebxf {efsf
ynscs bgk oagofygs yfkvofk
axfy b pfynak a {ndf1
?' Byf {efsf oagofygs sndnmby
ay xbynavs cngks a ngxfs{ays
svoe bsXOs- PFs- Pfgsnag
Hvgks- bgk Mns{fk
Ngybs{yvo{vyf Hvgks1 Eaz
kafs ~avy ayfnjg fg{n{~
s{b{vs yfkvof ay ngoyfbsfoagofygs1
;' Zeb{ ka ~av {engc JaN
seavmk ka nddfknb{fm~ {a
ngoyfbsf ngxfs{ay ng{fyfs{ mncf
~avys ng Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf
bssf{s1 Byf {efyf bg~
spfono sfjdfg{s zenoe
ebxf dayf nssvfs {ebg
a{efys1
6' Byf {efsf ynscs bgk oagofygs
spfono {a Ngknb ay ~av znmm
gk {efd bg~zefyf zenmf
bssfssngj ngxfs{dfg{ ngNgybs{yvo{vyf bssf{s1
8' Jaxfygdfg{ a Ngknb axfy b
pfynak a {ndf ebs dbkf
dbg~ bdfgkdfg{s ng n{s
pamnonfs ng yfjbyks {a
ngybs{yvo{vyf bssf{s svoe
bs yabks- pay{s- bnypay{s ay
pazfy' Ka ~av {engc {ef~
ebxf iffg bimf {a bkkyfss
{ef ynje{ nssvfs ay ngoyfbsngj
{ef pynxb{f pby{nonpb{nag1
:' Eaz dvoe ns ~av frvn{~
pby{nonpb{nag kfpfgkfg{
vpag bkfrvb{f kfi{
bxbnmbinmn{~ bgk zeb{ ka ~av
{engc seavmk if kagf {a
ngoyfbsf kfi{ bxbnmbinmn{~ ay
Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf bssf{s1
5' Ng obsf ~av ebxf dbkf bg~
ngxfs{dfg{s ng bg~
ngybs{yvo{vyf bssf{!sfjdfg{
ng Ngknb- ebxf {efsf
jfgfyb{fk yf{vygs ng mngf zn{e
fupfo{b{nag1 N ga{- ze~1 Byf{efyf bg~ sfo{ay spfono
nssvfs bgk obg ~av kf{bnm
{efd1
>' Zeb{ byf ~avy yf{vyg
fupfo{b{nags yad ngxfs{ngj
ng ngybs{yvo{vyf bssf{s ng
Ngknb1 Ebxf {efsf yf{vyg
fupfo{b{nags oadf kazg
axfy b pfynak a {ndf1
20' Ng obsf ~av byf oagsnkfyngj
dbcngj ngxfs{dfg{s ng Ngknbg
ngybs{yvo{vyf bssf{s!
oadpbgnfs- zenoe sfjdfg{ska ~av pyffy ovyyfg{m~ bgk
ze~1
22' Ka ~av {engc ngybs{yvo{vyf
sfjdfg{s mboc b s{yagj
yfjvmb{ay~ iak~ svoe bs
[YBN zenoe ebs efmpfk
ngxfs{dfg{s ng {fmfoad1
29' Zeb{ byf {ef xbynavs dakfs
{eyavje zenoe ~av obg ngxfs{
ng Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf bssf{s
frvn{~- pyffyfgof sebyfs-
oagxfy{nimf kfi{- svi$kfi{-
iagks12?' Yabks bgk Pazfy afy {za
mbyjfs{ appay{vgn{nfs ay
pby{nonpb{nag i~ pynxb{f
obpn{bm- iv{ ka {efsf bmsa
afy {ef ifs{ yf{vygs ay
yf{vygs oaddfgsvyb{f {a {ef
ynscs {bcfg ay ngxfs{ays1
2;' Ng pbs{ n ~av ebxf sefmxfk
ja{ av{ a bg~ ngxfs{dfg{
fbymnfy {ebg fupfo{fk- ze~
zbs n{1
8/8/2019 Indian Infrastructure Going Beyond the Sound Bytes
38/44
?5
)Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf < jangj if~agk {ef savgki~{fs) $ Pasn{nag Pbpfy 9020 Fufov{nag Gaimf ( Oadpbg~ M{k bgk [ef On{~ a Magkag' Bmm ynje{s yfsfyxfk'
Bppfgknu ; < Inimnajybpe~
2' Hbonmn{b{ngj Pvimno Pynxb{f Pby{gfysenp ay Boofmfyb{fk Ngybs{yvo{vyf Kfxfmapdfg{ ng Ngknb- Kfofdify 9008- BsKfxfmapdfg{ Ibgc
9' Bppyaboe {a Yfjvmb{nag a Ngybs{yvo{vyf- Pmbggngj Oaddnssnag- Jaxfygdfg{ a Ngknb- 26 _fp{fdify 9005
?' Pynxb{f Pby{nonpb{nag ng Ngybs{yvo{vyf- [ef _foyf{bynb{ ay {ef Oaddn{{ff ag Ngybs{yvo{vyf- Lvgf 900>
;' [ef Yfpay{ a [ef Oaddn{{ff ag Ngybs{yvo{vyf Hngbgongj- Db~ 900:
6' Ngknb< Ivnmkngj obpbon{nfs ay Pvimno Pynxb{f Pby{gfysenps- [ef Zaymk Ibgc- Lvgf 9008
8' Ngknb mfbks kfxfmapngj gb{nags ng pynxb{f sfo{ay ngxfs{dfg{- Jynkmngfs- PPNBH- Dbyoe 9005:' Pvimno Pynxb{f Pby{gfysenps$ Oyfb{ngj bg Fgbimngj Fgxnyagdfg{ ay _{b{f Pyalfo{s- ONN- Lvm~ 900:
5' Hngbgongj Pynxb{f Ngybs{yvo{vyf< Mfssags yad Ngknb- Dag{fc _' Bemvzbmnb
>' ONNs Imvfpyng{ ay spffkngj vp Ngybs{yvo{vyf pyalfo{s- Vgn{fk Gfzs a Ngknb- Bvjvs{ 9005
20' Ngs{n{v{nagbm Obpbon{~ bgk Jaxfygbgof ay PPP Pyalfo{s ng Ngknb- Bsezng Dbebmngjbd bgk Xncybd Cbpvy- 900>
22' [ef Ngknbg PPP Fupfynfgof b{ {ef _{b{f Mfxfm- _ebnmfse Pb{ebc bgk Bsezng Dbebmngjbd- Bpynm
29' Bppyaboe {a Yfjvmb{nag a Ngybs{yvo{vyf- Pmbggngj Oaddnssnag- Jaxfygdfg{ a Ngknb- 26 _fp{fdify 9005
2?' Ibocjyavgk Pbpfy$ Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf _vddn{ 900>- Kfman{{f
2;' Ngknb ebs b jaak pnpfmngf a pyalfo{s- Ky' D'_' Cbpbknb- Pyalfo{s dagn{ay- Db~ 9005
26' Pvimno$Pynxb{f Pby{gfysenp ng Ngknb Ngybs{yvo{vyf Kfxfmapdfg{< Nssvfs bgk Ap{nags- M Mbcsedbgbg- YIN AoobsnaPbpfys- _vddfy 9005
28' Axfyxnfz a JaNs ngn{nb{nxfs {a fgoavybjf PPPs- Jaxngk Daebg- Knyfo{ay %Ngybs{yvo{vyf.- Kfpby{dfg{ a FoagaBbnys- Dngns{y~ a Hngbgof- Jaxfygdfg{ a Ngknb
2:' Pyfsfg{b{nag b{ {ef NOYNFY _nmxfy Lvinmff _fdngby- Yblnx I Mbmm- DK ( OFA- NKHO- Gax 9008
25' Yfpay{ bgk Yfoaddfgkb{nags a {ef Oaddn{{ff ag Mbvgoe a Kfknob{fk Ngybs{yvo{vyf Hvgks %KNHs. i~ Dv{vHvgks- _FIN- 9? Lvm~ 900:
2>' [ef v{vyf a pynxb{f ngybs{yvo{vyf- Lasf B Jadf|$Nibgf|- Kadngnrvf Mayybng bgk Dfj Asnvs- Bpynm 900; [bvidOfg{fy ay _{b{f bgk Maobm Jaxfygdfg{- Cfggfk~ _oeaam a Jaxfygdfg{- Ebyxbyk Vgnxfysn{~
90' Ngknb mfbk kfxfmapngj gb{nags ng pynxb{f sfo{ay ngxfs{dfg{- Jynkmngfs- PPNBH- dbyoe 9005
92' YIN yfmbufs yvmfs yfmb{ngj {a FOIs- Bsevys{ MMP- Kfofdify 9005
99' Hngbgongj {ef iaad ng pvimno$pynxb{f pby{gfysenps ng Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf- Jynkmngfs- PPNBH- Kfofdify 9005
9?' Ngknbg Yabks< ag {ef ynje{ {yboc- Bsevys{ Ngsnje{- Kfofdify 90059;' [ef {yavimf zn{e pvimno$pynxb{f pby{gfysenps- [yvs{fk _avyofs- ?0 Lbgvby~ 9005
96' Foagadno Oebmmfgjfs ay {ef Gfz Jaxfygdfg{- _vjjfs{nags ay Pamno~ Haydvmb{nags- Lvgf 900>- AisfyxfyYfsfbyoe Havgkb{nag
98' _oefdf bgk Jvnkfmngfs ay Ngknb Ngybs{yvo{vyf Pyalfo{ Kfxfmapdfg{ Hvgk- Kfpby{dfg{ a Foagadno Bbnys-Dngns{y~ a Hngbgof- Jaxfygdfg{ a Ngknb
9:' Oags{yvo{nag Hfkfyb{nag a Ngknb %OHN. znse mns{- 99 Hfiyvby~ 9020- GID ( OZ
95' Hngbgongj {ybgspay{ ngybs{yvo{vyf bgk sfyxnofs ng Ngknb- 26 Lbgvby~ 900>- _' _ynybdbg bgk _vgbgka Ya~-Kfxfmapdfg{ Yfsfbyoe Jyavp- Kfpby{dfg{ a Foagadno Bgbm~sns bgk Pamno~- YIN- Dvdibn
9>' [ef Jyfb{ Ngknbg Enjezb~ _{ay~- Lbgvby~ 9020- Ngybs{yvo{vyf [akb~
8/8/2019 Indian Infrastructure Going Beyond the Sound Bytes
39/44
?>
)Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf < jangj if~agk {ef savgki~{fs) $ Pasn{nag Pbpfy 9020 Fufov{nag Gaimf ( Oadpbg~ M{k bgk [ef On{~ a Magkag' Bmm ynje{s yfsfyxfk'
?0' Pyalfo{ Pyfpbyb{nag- [ef Ongkfyfmmb a Pynxb{f _fo{ay Pby{nonpb{nag- Ngknb Ngybs{yvo{vyf Yfpay{ 9002
?2' Ngybs{yvo{vyf ng Ngknb$ B xbs{ mbgk a oags{yvo{nag appay{vgn{~- Gaxfdify 9005- Pynofzb{fyeavsfOaapfys
?9' _vs{bng {ef ngybs{yvo{vyf ngxfs{dfg{s$ Ng{fyxnfz zn{e Dy Bdyn{ Pbgkvybgjn- Hfiyvby~ 9005- Ivsngfss Mngf
??' Xngb~bc Oeb{{fylffs %Oebnydbg- Hffkiboc Xfg{vyfs. Ivsngfss s{bgkbyk NGHYB[BMC oamvdg$ e{{p
pppngknbkb{bibsf'oad.
?:' Ngknb Ngybs{yvo{vyf Yfpay{s- 9006$900> %e{{p
?>' [ef Pynxb{f Pby{nonpb{nag ng Ngybs{yvo{vyf %PPN. Pyalfo{ Kb{bibsf
;0' Hayfnjg Frvn{~ dngnsovmf ng pvimno$pynxb{f pyalfo{s- 96 Kfofdify 900>- Ivsngfss mngf
;2' Pynxb{f Frvn{~ ng Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf- Bssaoebd bgk Fygs{ ( avgj
;9' Ngknbg Pay{s< Obpbon{~ oags{ybng{s bgk yfrvnyfdfg{ ay {ef v{vyf$ Bg ngxfs{ays pfyspfo{nxf- Bpynm 9005-_e~bd _vgkby- NKHO PF
;?' Hnxf ovmpyn{s $ Ngybs{yvo{vyf Kfxfmapdfg{ ng Ngknb $ 6 Hvgkbdfg{bm Nssvfs- 900>- Efdbg{ Ieb{{ieb{{- Kfman{{f
;;' Jax{ bkdn{s kfmb~s ng 2;0 pyalfo{s- 20 Dbyoe 9020- |ffgfzs'oad
;6' Jax{ db~ mf{ HNs jvbybg{ff ngybs{yvo{vyf iagks- 22 Dbyoe 9020- Foagadno [ndfs
;8' [ef 900> Pyfrng Ngybs{yvo{vyf Yfxnfz
;:' Dbngs{yfbdngj PPPs b{ {ef _{b{f Mfxfm- Yfxnfz ( Pmbgs- Lvgf 9005- Jax{ a Jvlbyb{
;5' Hngbgongj Ngybs{yvo{vyf< Bkkyfssngj oags{ybng{s bgk oebmmfgjfs- Lvgf 9008- [ef Zaymk Ibgc
;>' PPP Pyalfo{ Hngbgongj$ Oebmmfgjfs bgk Ap{nags- Hfiyvby~ 900>- Ky _ K Gbgkb- NNHOM
60' Ngybs{yvo{vyf oebmmfgjfs ng _av{e Bsnb< [ef Yamf a Pvimno$Pynxb{f Pby{gfysenps- _fp{fdify 900:- Jff{ebglbmnGb{bybl
62' _{bgkbyknsb{nag a PPP Oag{ybo{ pyaxnsnags ng Ngknb- Oagsvm{b{nag Kaovdfg{ ay oagsvm{b{nag zn{e Pvimno_fo{ay Iaknfs- Kfofdify 900>- Pby{gfysenps VC PMO
8/8/2019 Indian Infrastructure Going Beyond the Sound Bytes
40/44
;0
Biav{ Fufov{nag Gaimf
Fufov{nag Gaimf ns b mfbkngj
ngxfs{dfg{ ibgcngj bgk sfovyn{nfs
yd aovsngj ag mbyjf bgk dnk obp
pbg$Fvyapfbg sfoagkby~ frvn{nfs
bgk yfsfbyoe- zn{e bg fs{bimnsefk
kns{yniv{nag pmb{ayd boyass Magkag-
Gfz ^ayc- bgk Eagj Cagj'
Zf pyaxnkf avy omnfg{s zn{e
fufov{nag3 frvn{~ sbmfs bgk {ybkngj3
yfsfbyoe3 D(B3 oaypayb{f gbgof3oaypayb{f iyacngj3 frvn{~ obpn{bm
dbycf{s3 bgk oaypayb{f boofss'
Ng {ef mb{{fy ebm a 900>- avy jyavp
fupbgkfk ng{a ufk ngoadf bgk {ef
borvnsn{nag a Gaimf iyavje{ zn{e n{
b pyndby~ kfbm aynjngb{nag obpbinmn{~
fgebgongj avy binmn{~ {a oadpf{f
ay snjgnobg{ frvn{~ obpn{bm dbycf{s
dbgkb{fs'
[ef borvnsn{nag ebs bmsa snjgnobg{m~
s{yfgj{efgfk avy dnk obp yfsfbyoe
pyakvo{- zn{e b enjem~ yb{fk Ngknbg
yfsfbyoe pyakvo{ ifngj bkkfk'
Zf byf bmyfbk~ b yfoajgnsfk mfbkfy
ng sfmm$snkf bmpeb jfgfyb{nag-
bgbm~s{ yfsfbyoe- bjfgo~ iyacngj-
bgk jyaz{e bgk dnk obp oaypayb{f
iyacngj bgk gbgonbm bkxnsay~
sfyxnofs' Zf bmsa apfyb{f bjfgo~oyfkn{ bgk kfynxb{nxfs ivsngfssfs'
Ng bkkn{nag {a avy ngxfs{dfg{
ibgcngj bgk sfovyn{nfs obpbinmn{nfs-
zf ebxf b vgnrvf ngsvybgof pyakvo{s
kns{yniv{nag pmb{ayd $ oadpynsngj
a b Mma~k*s booyfkn{fk yfngsvybgof
iyacfy %FUG 22;?. bgk afyngj
samv{nags ay {ybkn{nagbm yfngsvybgof-
frvn{~ obpn{bm dbycf{s- oaypayb{f
boofss- frvn{~ yfsfbyoe bgk fxfg{
mngcfk v{vyfs'
Efbkrvby{fyfk ng Magkag- zn{e
byavgk 960 pyafssnagbms bgk aofs
ng _oa{mbgk- {ef Vgn{fk _{b{fs- Eagj
Cagj- Ngknb- Hybgof bgk Jfydbg~-
Fufov{nag Gaimf ebs iffg sfyxnongj
dbg~ a {ef zaymks dblay ngxfs{ngj
ngs{n{v{nags- ngomvkngj dv{vbm vgks-
pfgsnag vgks- ngsvybgof oadpbgnfsbgk efkjf vgks sngof 9002- bs
zfmm bs axfy 900 mns{fk bgk vgmns{fk
jyaz{e bgk dnk$obp oadpbgnfs'
Fdpazfyfk i~ {foegamaj~ bgk
knfyfg{nb{fk i~ avy pfapmf- zf
pyaxnkf boofss {a {ef dbycf{*s oayf
mnrvnkn{~ pyaxnkfys {eyavje fu{fgsnxf
pfysagbm yfmb{nagsenps bgk fupfy{nsf'
Biav{ {ef bv{eays
_BVYBIE DVCEFYLFB- OHB
_bvybie Dvcefylfb ovyyfg{m~ efbks
Fufov{nag Gaimfs Ngknbg frvn{nfs
apfyb{nags zenoe ef sf{ vp ng _fp$
05'
_bvybie ns b oa$avgkfy bgk aydfy
Iabyk Knyfo{ay a Omfby Obpn{bm
zefyf ef ybg n{s VC Hngbgonbms {fbd-
mfbkngj n{ {a b {ap ? Fu{fm ybgcngj'
Ef pyfxnavsm~ zaycfk bs b s{yb{fj~
oagsvm{bg{ b{ Boofg{vyf bgk
Magkag Foagadnos- spfonbmnsngj ng
Hngbgonbm _fyxnofs' Ef jybkvb{fk ng
Foagadnos yad {ef M_F
GN[NG IEB_NG
Gn{ng Iebsng ovyyfg{m~ mfbks {ef
ngybs{yvo{vyf sfo{ay ng Fufov{nag
Gaimfs Ngknbg apfyb{nags bgk ebs
iffg zn{e Fufov{nag Gaimf sngof {efifjnggngj a Ngknbg apfyb{nags'
Gn{ng pyfxnavsm~ zaycfk b{ Ca{bc- bg
Ngknbg iyacfybjf eavsf bs b dnk$
obp bgbm~s{ zefyfng ef oaxfyfk
ngybs{yvo{vyf oadpbgnfs bs zfmm'
Pynay {a {eb{- ef zaycfk bs bg bgbm~s{
ng a{efy iyacfybjf eavsfs svoe bs
Fdcb~ _ebyfs bgk _{aoc Iyacfys'
Gn{ng ns b Oeby{fyfk Booavg{bg{'
Gn{ng Iebsng obg if oag{bo{fk ag {ef
ammazngj fdbnm$20'
Zn{e FV bs {ef dblay {ybkngjpby{gfy ay Ngknb- {ajf{efy zn{e{ef s{yagj {za zb~ Ngxfs{dfg{hazs- {ef oag{avys a Ngka FV in$mb{fybm yfmb{nagsenp ns oebgjngj- [efOavgonm booaykngjm~ yf$aynfg{s bgkyfkfknob{fs n{sfm {a sfyxf {ef obvsf
a n{s dfdifys if{{fy' [ef Oavgonmebs iffg {bcngj vp {ef bo{nag pang{sbynsngj av{ a {ef Ngka FV _vddn{sbs n{s aovs byfb ! zayc pmbg {afgsvyf oammbiayb{nxf bppyaboeif{zffg ngkvs{y~ bgk Jaxfygdfg{yad ia{e snkfs'
8/8/2019 Indian Infrastructure Going Beyond the Sound Bytes
43/44
;?
)Ngknbg Ngybs{yvo{vyf < jangj if~agk {ef savgki~{fs) $ Pasn{nag Pbpfy 9020 Fufov{nag Gaimf ( Oadpbg~ M{k bgk [ef On{~ a Magkag' Bmm ynje{s yfsfyxfk'
Ngknbg ngybs{yvo{vyf jangj if~agk {ef
savgki~{f
9020 Fufov{nag Gaimf ( Oadpbg~ M{k bgk
[ef On{~ a Magkag'
Bmm ynje{s yfsfyxfk'
Pyng{fk Dbyoe 9020
Gn{ng Iebsng
Bgbm~s{[ #>2 99 ;922 0>90F gn{ng'iebsng@fufov{nag$gaimf'oad
:02- Pazbn Pmb|bEnybgkbgn Jbykfgs- PazbnDvdibn $ ;00 0:8Dbebybse{ybNgknb[ #>2 99 96:0 2269H #>2 99 96:0 226;
zzz'fufov{nag$gaimfjp'oad
Bgn{b Gbgkn
Oenf Yfpyfsfg{b{nxf[ #>2 99 8;69 :9;;F bgn{b'gbgkn@on{~ahagkag'jax'vc
On{~ a Magkag $ Ngknb AofJyavgk Hmaay- KI_ EavsfPyfsoa{{ Yabk- Hay{Dvdibn- ;00002Ngknb[ #>2 99 8; 69:9;;H #>2 99 88 ?8;:2:zzz'on{~aagkag'ja'vc
NDPAY[BG[ NGHAYDB[NAG
[ens Ngxfs{dfg{ Yfsfbyoe ns ngkfpfgkfg{ bgk kafs ga{ oags{n{v{f b pfysagbm yfoaddfgkb{nag bs kfgfk ng {ef Jmassby~ a {ef H_B Ebgkiaac'[ens db{fynbm oags{n{v{fs )ngxfs{dfg{ yfsfbyoe) ay {ef pvypasfs a {ef Dbycf{s ng Hngbgonbm Ngs{yvdfg{s Knyfo{nxf bgk bs svoe oag{bngs bg ailfo{nxf ayngkfpfgkfg{ fupmbgb{nag a {ef db{{fys oag{bngfk ng {ef db{fynbm' Bg~ yfoaddfgkb{nags oag{bngfk ng {ens kaovdfg{ dvs{ ga{ if yfmnfk vpag bs
ngxfs{dfg{ bkxnof ibsfk ag {ef yfonpnfg{*s pfysagbm onyovds{bgofs' Ng {ef fxfg{ {eb{ vy{efy ombynob{nag ns yfrvnyfk ag {ef zayks ay peybsfs vsfk ng{ens db{fynbm- {ef yfonpnfg{ ns s{yagjm~ yfoaddfgkfk {a sffc ngkfpfgkfg{ mfjbm ay gbgonbm bkxnof'
[ens yfsfbyoe yfpay{ ebs iffg pyfpbyfk i~ Fufov{nag Gaimf Mndn{fk bgk ns ay ngaydb{nag pvypasfs agm~' [ens yfsfbyoe yfpay{ kafs ga{ oags{n{v{f bgafy- ngxn{b{nag ay ngkvofdfg{ {a ngxfs{ ng sfovyn{nfs ay a{efy ngxfs{dfg{s' Gfn{efy {ef ngaydb{nag oag{bngfk ng {ens yfsfbyoe yfpay{ gay bg~ vy{efyngaydb{nag dbkf bxbnmbimf zn{e {ef svilfo{ db{{fy oag{bngfk efyfng znmm ayd {ef ibsns a bg~ oag{ybo{'
[ens yfsfbyoe yfpay{ kafs ga{ pvypay{ {a if oadpyfefgsnxf ay {a oag{bng bmm {ef ngaydb{nag ag zenoe b pyaspfo{nxf ngxfs{ay db~ gffk ng aykfy {adbcf bg ngxfs{dfg{ kfonsnag' [ef ngaydb{nag oag{bngfk efyfng ns ibsfk ag pvimnom~ bxbnmbimf ngaydb{nag bgk savyofs- zenoe zf ifmnfxf {a if yfmnbimf-iv{ zf ka ga{ yfpyfsfg{ n{ bs boovyb{f ay oadpmf{f' [ef yfonpnfg{ a {ens yfsfbyoe yfpay{ dvs{ dbcf n{s azg ngxfs{njb{nag bgk bssfssdfg{ a {efngaydb{nag pyfsfg{fk efyfng' Ga yfpyfsfg{b{nag- zbyybg{~ ay vgkfy{bcngj- fupyfss ay ndpmnfk- ns ay znmm if dbkf ay jnxfg bgk ga yfspagsninmn{~ aymnbinmn{~ ns ay znmm if boofp{fk i~ Fufov{nag Gaimf Mndn{fk ay i~ bg~ a n{s knyfo{ays- aofys- fdpma~ffs- bjfg{s ay bkxnsfys- ng yfmb{nag {a {ef boovybo~ay oadpmf{fgfss a {ens pyfsfg{b{nag ay bg~ a{efy zyn{{fg ay aybm ngaydb{nag dbkf bxbnmbimf ng oaggfo{nag zn{e {ef ngaydb{nag pyfsfg{fk efyfng' Bg~yfspagsninmn{~ ay mnbinmn{~ ay bg~ svoe ngaydb{nag ns fupyfssm~ knsombndfk'
Ng vygnsengj {ens yfsfbyoe yfpay{- Fufov{nag Gaimf Mndn{fk vgkfy{bcfs ga aimnjb{nag {a pyaxnkf {ef yfonpnfg{ zn{e boofss {a bg~ bkkn{nagbm ngaydb{nag-ay {a vpkb{f- ay {a oayyfo{ bg~ ngboovybonfs- zenoe db~ ifoadf bppbyfg{ ng {ens pyfsfg{b{nag ay bg~ a{efy ngaydb{nag dbkf bxbnmbimf ng oaggfo{nagzn{e {ef ngaydb{nag pyfsfg{fk efyfng'
Bmm pynofs pyaxnkfk zn{eng {ens yfsfbyoe yfpay{ byf {bcfg yad {ef omasf a ivsngfss ag {ef kb~ pynay {a {ef nssvf kb{f vgmfss fupmnon{m~ a{efyznsf s{b{fk'Fufov{nag Gaimf Mndn{fk kafs ga{ pyakvof dbng{fgbgof yfsfbyoe bgk bs b yfsvm{ {efyf ns ga pmbggfk yfrvfgo~ a yfsfbyoe yfpay{s ay oadpbgnfsvgkfy oaxfybjf'
Yfsfbyoe yfpay{s byf pyakvofk ag bg bk eao ibsns'Pmfbsf ga{f {eb{ Fufov{nag Gaimf Mndn{fk ns pby{ a {ef Fufov{nag Gaimf Eamkngjs Mndn{fk jyavp a oadpbgnfs' Mma~ks Ibgcngj Jyavp ebs bsebyfeamkngj a 5'80& ng Fufov{nag Gaimf Eamkngjs Mndn{fk'
Bg~ apngnag yfhfo{s {ef bgbm~s{s lvkjdfg{ b{ {ef kb{f a pvimnob{nag bgk gfn{efy Fufov{nag Gaimf Mndn{fk- gay bg~ a n{s bmnb{fk ay bssaonb{fkoadpbgnfs- gay bg~ a {efny knyfo{ays- aofys ay fdpma~ffs boofp{s bg~ yfspagsninmn{~ ng yfspfo{ a {ef ngaydb{nag ay yfoaddfgkb{nags oag{bngfkefyfng zenoe- dayfaxfy- byf svilfo{ {a oebgjf zn{eav{ pynay ga{nof'
[ens yfsfbyoe yfpay{ ns pynxb{f bgk oagkfg{nbm bgk ns ifngj dbkf bxbnmbimf {a {ef yfonpnfg{ ag {ef vgkfys{bgkngj {eb{ n{ znmm if cfp{ oagkfg{nbm bgk{eb{ {ef yfonpnfg{ sebmm ga{ oap~- yfpyakvof- kns{yniv{f ay pbss {a {enyk pby{nfs {ens yfsfbyoe yfpay{ ng zeamf ay ng pby{ b{ bg~ {ndf' N{ ns ng{fgkfk ay {efngaydb{nag a omnfg{s agm~ bgk ns ga{ ay pvimnob{nag ng {ef pyfss gay ns n{ ifngj nssvfk ay kns{yniv{fk {a pfysags zea byf yf{bnm omnfg{s'[ef db{fynbm ng {ens yfsfbyoe yfpay{ ns jfgfybm ngaydb{nag ng{fgkfk ay yfonpnfg{s zea vgkfys{bgk {ef ynscs bssaonb{fk zn{e ngxfs{dfg{' N{ kafs ga{ {bcfbooavg{ a zef{efy bg ngxfs{dfg{- oavysf a bo{nag- ay bssaonb{fk ynscs byf svn{bimf ay {ef yfonpnfg{'
[ens kaovdfg{ ns ng{fgkfk {a if vsfk i~ dbycf{ pyafssnagbms %fmnjnimf oavg{fypby{nfs bgk pyafssnagbm omnfg{s iv{ ga{ yf{bnm omnfg{s.' Yf{bnm omnfg{s dvs{ga{ yfm~ ag {ens kaovdfg{ bgk seavmk ga{f {eb{ {ef sfyxnofs a Fufov{nag Gaimf Mndn{fk byf ga{ bxbnmbimf {a {efd'[ens yfsfbyoe yfpay{ ebs iffg pyfpbyfk i~ Fufov{nag Gaimf Mndn{fk- zea byf b oayyfspagkfg{ a Fufov{nag Gaimf MMO- 209 Jyffgznoe Bxfgvf-Jyffgznoe- O[085?0'
Fufov{nag Gaimf MMO byf kns{yniv{ngj {ens yfsfbyoe yfpay{ ng {ef V_ bgk boofp{ yfspagsninmn{~ ay n{s oag{fg{s svilfo{ {a {ef {fyds sf{ av{ efyfng' Bg~V_ pfysags yfofnxngj {ens yfsfbyoe yfpay{ bgk znsengj {a ffo{ b {ybgsbo{nag ng bg~ sfovyn{~ knsovssfk efyfng- seavmk ka sa agm~ zn{e Fufov{nag GaimfMMO ay bg ngknxnkvbm yfjns{fyfk {efyfzn{e'
Fufov{nag Gaimf Mndn{fk ns yfjns{fyfk ng Fgjmbgk bgk Zbmfs ga' ;065>:2- ns b Mma~ks Iyacfy- b dfdify a [ef Magkag _{aoc Fuoebgjf- Uf{yb- Xny{$ubgk FvyaGfu{ bgk ns bv{eaynsfk bgk yfjvmb{fk i~ {ef Hngbgonbm _fyxnofs Bv{eayn{~'
8/8/2019 Indian Infrastructure Going Beyond the Sound Bytes
44/44
;;