173

Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

��������� � ������� ������������� ����������������� � ����!��#"$� ������� ��� �����%�������&����'��(���#��������'*)+�,"-� "/.��0� ��' "$���1)2��)2����!#���3.

4/576�8:9;8$<>=?%@BADC�EF@BGH@IA�J

KML*NPORQ:ST9UORV3WYXIV[Z\V[V;]�6�L>S_^a`PST576 b$6�cdXI9;QT6�]+6�L>Se8`f^�QgST576 hi6�j�Q:6�6k^R`

hi^BlmSe^�Q/^R`nN�579;V[^�8T^Ro75>=

p ORV[9[`f^�Q:L79UO KML78:ST9[STXISe6k^R`P4P6�lq57L7^�V[^�jR=NnOa8eORr76�L\OIs p ORV[9[`f^�Q:L79UO

tRu�u�vwyx X7<7]�9[STST6�r{zRX7L76 t s tRu�u�v>|

Page 2: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

9[9

l� tRu�u�v�_6�L��(V[6�]�6�L78

� V[V b-9;j�5>Se8-b-6�8:6�Q���6�r

Page 3: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

9[9;9

� ����� ��� ��� ��� ������

4/5\ORL��d8 ST^�]�= ORr �d9;8:^�QT8�� �(9[] �_^�QTrI6�Q�s�N 6�ST6�Q �_^�8:8eOR6�Q:ST8�s��*OaS:S�z�ORl�� 8T^�L s OaL7r b-9;lq5\ORQ:r�{l �k6�V �R6�=��4/5\ORL��d8$ORV[8T^�ST^���r��{l p O! QT6�= ORL7r � 8 =>O�NP6�Q �dX"� 579;L,`f^�QgV[6�j>OaV3ORr �d9[l�6Rs p 57QT9[8# 9 Selq57l�^Bl��,`f^�Q 579;8i9[L78T9[j�5>Se8 9;L>Se^+l#ORX78TORV;9 SM=�s ORL7r�]�=,`f6�V[V;^%$ j�QTORr7X\OaST6�8 SeX7r76�L>Se8(`f^�Q�6 ��6�Q:='&Se5I9;L7j�6�V[8T6!�

Page 4: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

9 �

� � ������� � �

4/579[8$rI9;8T8:6�Q SqOaST9;^�L,9;8/9[L1Se57Q:6�6 o\ORQ Se8 ���� p 5\ORoBSe6�Q�/o7QT6�8T6�L>ST8�Oil�^�L ��6�L79;6�L>S�L7^RSqO Se9;^RL `f^�QPr76�8:l�QT9[<79;LIji]+6mSe57^dr78�^a` ORj�j�Q:6�j>OaST9;L7j

9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L,Se^1`f^�Q:] o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q r79;8 SeQ:9;<7XIST9;^�LI8�s3OaV;V;^%$-9[L7j1O rI6�8Tl�QT9[oISe9[^�L�^R`�< ^RSe5 �gO#=R6�8T9;ORLX7o r\OaST9;L7j ORL7r+] OaL = ^R` ST576 l�^�j�L79 Se9 ��6/6�Q:QT^�Q:8 o 6�^Ro7V;6-l�^R]+]�9[S�9[L�ST576-VUOR< � p 5\ORoIST6�Q t V[^B^ �d8OaS�Se576{]+^RL7^RSe^RL76{^RQTr76�QT9;LIj o7Q:^�<7V[6�] �*9[`�Se576{o7QT9[^�Q�r79;8 SeQT9[<7XIST9;^�L78�ORQ:6{^RQTr76�QT6�rH9;LH8:^�]�6]+ORL7L76�Q�s�$-57OaS X7o r\OaST9;L7j{^�o 6�QeO Se9;^RL78 $-9[V;V�o7Q:6�8:6�Q �R61Se5\O S ^�Q:r76�Q:9;L7j� �gO#=�6�8:9UORL XIo r\O Se9;LIj9;8�O0]+6�] < 6�Q%^R`iO 8:] ORV[Vgl�V;OR8T8�^R` ^�o 6�QeO Se^�Q:8 $-5I9;lq5HoIQT6�8:6�Q���6*ST576{]�^�L7^aSe^�L76 V[9 �a6�V;9[57^d^BrQeO Se9;^�o7QT^�o 6�Q SM=�s <7XIS�9[8�L7^RS�9;L Se5I6/l�VUOa8T8�^R`Y`fX7L7lmSe9[^�L78 $-579[lq5�oIQT6�8:6�Q���6-Z\QT8 S &M^RQTr76�Q�8:Se^dlq5\OR8 Se9[lr7^�]�9;L7ORL7l�6!��4/579;8�lq5\ORoBSe6�QPORV[8T^-l�^�LI8T9;rI6�QT8 ^�Q:r76�Q:9;L7j-r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL783<>=(Se576�9;Q ]�6�r79;ORL78�s $-5I9;lq59;8/XI8T6�`fXIV�`f^RQ-NP^�V[9[Se9[l#ORV x l�9;6�LIl�6 ORL7r,^RSe5I6�Q-r76�l�9;8:9;^�L,]+O � 9;L7j�ORoIo7V;9[l#OaST9;^�L78��

����� p 57ORoISe6�Q v o7QT6�8T6�L>ST8%O{V[9[Se6�QeOaSTX7QT6�Q:6 �d9;6 $ ^R`/6� B9[8:Se9[L7j2]+^dr76�V[8k^R`/9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L0ORj!&j�Q:6�j>OaST9;^�L�`fQT^�] ^�L76�o\ORQ:SM=1ORL7r j�9 ��6�8_Se576 ��6�Q = $ 6#O � l�^�L7rI9[Se9[^�L78 X7L7r76�Q $-579;lq5,^�LI6i^�Q S $ ^<79;OR8T6�r+Oar ��^dl#OaST6�8 $-9;V[VIORV $gO#=d8�QT6 ��6#OaVY`fXIV;VI9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L � p 57ORoISe6�Q��iSe576�L+o7Q:6�8:6�L>Se8_Ok]�^dr76�V^R`PO�SeQ:9UORVFsB9[L $-579;lq5,6 ��6�L>ST8 OaQT6(j�Q:^�X7o 6�r,9;L>Se^�l#ORX78TORV38 Se^�Q:9;6�8�� �Oalq528 Se^�Q =1]+O#= o ^�9;L>SgST^�O8To 6�l�9[Z\l �R6�Q:r79;lmS#s\<7XIS/ST576��:X7r7jR6(5\OR8/V;6�6�$_O#=19;L 8:6�V[6�l�ST9;L7j�O �R6�QTrI9;l�S $-5I6�L2] X7V[ST9;o7V[6 8 Se^�Q:9;6�8ORQ:6+8:57^%$-L Se^{8T9;]�X7V[SeORL76�^RX78TV =�< 6�8TX��+l�9;6�L S Se^{6� Bo7VUOa9;L ORL 6 ��6�L>S �24 $ ^��:X7rIj�6�8 ] O#=0< 6� o 6�Q:`f6�lmS �gO#=�6�8T9;ORL78�� sI8:5\ORQ:6�Se576 8eOR]�6�oIQT9;^RQT8�sBORL7r 8:Se9[V;V ORQ:QT9 �R6�O Sgr79 6�QT6�L>S ��6�Q:r79;lmSe8_`f^RQ Se5I68eOa]+6gSTQT9UOaV ��� L7V[9 �a6_Se576-9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L QT6 ��6�V;OaSe9[^�L%V;9 Se6�QeOaSTX7QT6Se^kr\OaST6Rs�Se5I6�QT6-]+O#=�< 6-ORo7Q:^�o ^R88:ST^�QT9[6�8$ORL7r ` ORlmSe8/Se57OaS-L76�9 Se576�Q-o\ORQ:SM= $-9;V;V $gOaL S$Se^�Q:6 ��6�ORV�9;L,6�c X79[V;9[<7QT9[X7]��

������� p 5\OaoISe6�Q��+o7Q:6�8T6�L>Se8 O 8T9[] X7V SqORL76�^�X78 ]+^dr76�V�^R`�jR^B^dr78�^RQiORlmSe9;^RL78 $-579[lq5�r76�]�^�L &8:STQeOaST6�l�^�LI`f^�Q:]+9 SM= 6� 6�lmSe8 � N�QT6 �B9[^�X78 ]+^dr76�V[8-^R`�8:X7lq5�j�^d^Br78$X7L79 ��6�QT8eOaV;V[=1r76�8:l�QT9[< 6 o 6�^�o7V[6OR8 ORl�ST9;L7j�9;L28T6�c X76�L7l�6�� Oal�Se^RQT8$9;L,Se576 ]+^dr76�V 576�Q:6�ORlmS�8:9;] XIV[SqOaL76�^�XI8TV[=Rs\8T^�Se576m=2] X78:S r76 &l�9[r76 $-5\O S�Se^irI^i<\OR8:6�r�^�L7V = ^RL%o7QT9[^�QP9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L OR< ^�XISPSe576grI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L�^a`\SqOR8 Se6�8�9[L�Se5I6

Page 5: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

8T^dl�9[6�SM= �+4/576�8T57ORo 6�^R` Se579[8 rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L w 6!� j��[s l�6�L ST6�Q:6�r ORQ:^�X7L7r���6�QT^7s 8 �a6�$ 6�r X7o'$_ORQTr s^�Qk` OaS &ySqOR9[V;6�r | o7QT6�r79;lmSe8 Se576+LdXI] < 6�Q�^R`go 6�^�o7V;6 $-57^ $-9[V;VORlmS�9[L 8T^R]+6�8:=d8:ST6�]+OaSe9[l $_O#=B8�s$-579[lq5{K l#OaSeORV;^�j%5I6�QT6!�

� r �d9[8T^�Q:8 � �*OaS:Se576 $�� z�ORl�� 8:^�L w o7Q:9;]+ORQ:= | s �k9[] p �_^�QTrI6�Q�s NP6mSe6�Q�� �_^�8T8TOR6�Q Se8�sb-9;lq5\ORQ:r2h��{l �(6�V �R6�=

Page 6: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

�d9

� � ��� �����

��������� ������������������� �����

�������� �!"�#� �%$

& �' (�)*�� (� $����

+ ,�- �!.�������/� - �0 (!1���' 2�3������ ����4��5��� +��� � �_6�V[9;6m`f8 ��6�QT8TXI8�r\OaSeO � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���� t hi6�Z\LI9[Se9[^�L ^R`nORL,X7o r\OaSe9[L7j�^�o 6�QeO Se^�Q � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � t��� v � `f6�$ 6� IOR]�o7V;6�8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

��� v � � �iQ:r76�Q-6� 6�lmSe8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � v � ��� � � 6�ORQTL79[L7j�]+^dr76�V;8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

��� v � t W\QTOR]+9[L7j 6 6�l�Se8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 6��� � p ^�L7l�V;X78:9;^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 7

8 9 !.��:�0 (�����/����;<�' 2�=!.���>���?;< ���� �@4�>��� - ��� - !A ����>��� Bt � � KML>SeQT^dr7X7lmSe9[^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � Ct � t N�QT6�V[9;]�9;L\OaQ:=�L7^RST6�8�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � u

t � t � � D O#=d8-ST^+^RQTr76�Q-O�` OR]�9;V =�^R`nrI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L78 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �t � v �gO#=�6�8T9UOaL{X7o r\OaST9;L7j�o7Q:6�8:6�Q �R6�8$Se576 � ��b$N � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � t

t � v � � �iQ:r76�Q:9;L7j�o ^�8:ST6�QT9[^�QT8 $-9 Se5 Se5I6 � � b$N � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � tt � v � t E 6�l�6�8T8:9[SM= � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

t � � � 9;L76�ORQgSeQTORL78TV;OaSe9[^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �t � �"� � D 5I6�L2< ^RST52ST576�^RQT6�]�8/57^�V[r � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��C

Page 7: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

�B9[9t � � � `f6�$ 6� IOR]�o7V;6�8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � tRu

t � � � � � Bo 6�l�SeOaSe9[^�L78$OR< ^�XIS$O%]�^ �d9[6�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � tRut � � � t N�X7<IV;9;l(^Ro79;L79[^�L,OR< ^�XIS-o7XI<7V;9[li^�o79[L79;^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � t �

t � 6 � 6�L76�QTORV3X7o r\OaST9;L7j�^�o 6�QTOaSe9[^�L78 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � t �t � 6�� � �io 6�QTOaSe^�Q:8 $-579;lq52o7Q:6�8T6�Q �R6 Se5I6 � � b$N � � � � � � � � � � � � � � t�tt � 6�� t �io 6�QTOaSe^�Q:8 $-579;lq52o7Q:6�8T6�Q �R6�8T9[L7j�V[6 &Ml�QT^�8:8T9[L7j � � � � � � � � � � � � t �t � 6�� v �io 6�QTOaSe^�Q:8 $-579;lq52o7Q:6�8T6�Q �R6 W � x h � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � t �t � 6�� � N�Q:6�8T6�Q �d9;LIj+< ^RSe5,Se5I6 � � b$N ORLIr{W � x h � � � � � � � � � � � � � t �

t � 7 p ^�L7l�V;X78:9;^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � t 6

� � ��;<�' (��!.���>��� - (��$���� �����?��� ����� ����!A� ��� !"��$����5!1��� 8 Bv � � KML>SeQT^dr7X7lmSe9[^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � t C

v � ��� � N�Q:9;^�Qg]�^dr76�V[8-ORL7r,SM=Bo 6�8$^R`nORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � t��v � t � 6�L76�QTORV `fQTOR]+6 $_^RQ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � t��

v � t � u � � W\X7V[V 9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � v �v � v �{9;V[j�QT^R] ORLIr{b-^�< 6�Q Se8�� 8$]+^dr76�V � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � v �

v � v � � #$^%$ QT^R<7X78:S$9[8gSe579[8/6�c X79;V[9;<7Q:9;X7] � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � v>tv � v � ��� � b-^�<7XI8:S-Se^�lq5\ORLIj�6�8$9;L Se5I6 ]�^dr76�V � � � � � � � � � � � � v>tv � v � ��� t E ^RS-QT^R<7X78:S-ST^�lq57ORL7j�6�8 9[L26�c X79;V[9;<7Q:9;X7] l�^�LIl�6�oBSe8 � � � � v�vv � v � ��� v N ^�8T8:9;<7V[6(QT6�8To ^�L78T6�8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � v �

v � � � 8TX7Q���6m={^a`n]�^BrI6�V;8/^a`n9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L+o7QT^ �d9;8:9;^�L Se^�ORXBSe^�]+OaSqO�� � � � � � � v �v � �"� � b-6 �R6�V;OaSe9[^�L,^R`�O�N�h(W � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � v �

v � �"� ��� � � VUORl��'$ 6�V;V � 8/j�ORQT<7V[9;L7j%l�QT9 Se6�Q:9;^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � v �v � �"� ��� t 4 QeOal�6#Oa<79;V[9[SM= � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � v 6v � �"� ��� v �26�r79;ORL,]+^dr76�V � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � v Cv � �"� ��� � �26#ORL2]+^dr76�V � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � v��

v � �"� t � X78:ST9;L & x ]�9[Se5 � 8_S $ ^!& r79;]�6�L78:9;^�L7ORV3]�^Br76�V�� � � � � � � � � � � � � v��v � � p ^�L7l�V;X78:9;^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � t

Page 8: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

�d9;9[9� � ��;<�' (��!.���>��� - (��$���� ������� �=� � � �>!"� ��� !"��$����5!.������� � ��������� �'; ��:�� - �0 ��

�5� - ���>��� �'; �5!A4�� !1������� � �

�"� � KML>SeQT^dr7X7lmSe9[^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � v�"� t �gORl�� j�Q:^�X7L7r � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���

�"� t � � N�Q:9;^�Q $ ^�Q � ^�L,l#ORX78TORV;9 SM= � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ������ t � ��� � x SqOaST9;8:ST9;l�9UORL78 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ������ t � ��� t N�8 =Blq5I^�V;^�jR9;8:ST8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �)6��� t � ��� v ��O $/=�6�QT8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �07

�"� t � t x SM=BV[9 ��6�r ` ORl�ST8$OR< ^RXIS/SeQ:9UORV[8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �07��� t � t � � � o7o 6�V;V;OaSe6�VUO $/=�6�QT8$6� B9;8 S � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �07��� t � t � t 4/5I6 8 Se^�Q =1Se^RV;r,<>=1Se576kV;O%$ Se6 BST8 � � � � � � � � � � � � �)C��� t � t � v hi9[8Tl�^ �R6�Q = � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

�"� v p ^�L7r79 Se9[^�L78_`f^�Qg`fXIV;V39[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L1Q:6 �R6�VUO Se9;^RL � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � u�"� v � � hi6mZ\L79 Se9;^RL78 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � u�"� v � t 4/5I6k`fXIV;V39[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L+^�XISel�^�]�6 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���

�"� � 4/576k]+^dr76�V � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����"� �"� � �i< �:6�l�ST8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���

��� �"� ��� � x Se^�Q:9;6�8-Oa8$V[6�j>OaV3ORQ:j�X7]�6�L>Se8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��"� �"� t 4/5I6 �:XIr7j�6�� 8$< 6�V;9;6m`f8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��"� �"� v � ST9;]�6�V[9;L76 ^R`nST576(SeQT9;ORV ]�^dr76�V � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �#6

�"� � p ORX78TORV $_6�9;j�5>ST8 OaL7r{oIQT^�<\Oa<79;V[9[Se9[6�8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �57�"� � � � 4/5I6 oIQT^�<\Oa<79;V[9[SM=�Se5\OaS$O�8TX��+l�9;6�L7l�=,l�VUOR9[] 9[8gSeQTXI6 � � � � � � � � � �57

��� � � ��� � x =BV[V;^�jR9;8T]�8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �57��� � � ��� t � `fX7V;V 9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L�r76�Z\LI9[Se9[^�L1^R`�ST576io7Q:^�<\OR<79[V;9 SM=�^R`�8TXI` &

Z7l�9;6�L>S l�ORX78TOaSe9[^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �#C��� � � ��� v � l�l�6�oISeORL7l�6 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

�"� � � t D 6�9[j�5>Se8-^�L,8TX��+l�9;6�L S l#OaX78eOaST9;^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 6 u��� � � t � � ��6�QTr79[l�ST8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 6 u��� � � t � t �io79[L79;^RL1`f^�QT]+ORV;V =�r76�Z\LI6�r � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 6 �

�"� � � v ��c X79[V;9;<IQT9;XI] � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 6 t

Page 9: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

9 �"� � � � � L{6 IOR]+oIV;6i`fQT^R] ORr �R6�Q Se9;8:9;L7j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 6 t

��� � � �"� � p ^R]+o\OaQeOaST9 ��6(8 SqOaST9;l�8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 6���"� 6 # ^%$ ]+ORL>=18 Se^�Q:9;6�8-ST^�o7QT6�8T6�L>S � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 6 �

�"� 6�� � � L{6 IOR]+oIV;6 ��ST576 ORV;6�OaSe^RQ:= �:X7r7j�6 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 656�"� 6�� t p ^R]+o\OaQeOaST9 ��6(8 SqOaST9;l�8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 6)7�"� 6�� v � L*OaV[Se6�QTL\O Se6(8To 6�l�9[Z\l�OaSe9[^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 65C

�"� 7 p ^�L7l�V;X78:9;^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 6 �

� � ����$��>$���!"���%� � ���

� � � KML>SeQT^dr7X7lmSe9[^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 7 u� � ��� � p ^R]+o\OaQT9;8:^�L $-9[ST5+oIQT6 �d9[^�X78�8Tlq57^RVUORQ:8T579[o3s�$-9[ST5�`f^dl�XI8^RL ORoIo7V;9[l#OaST9;^�L78 7��

� � ��� ��� � 4/5I6 Q:6�8 SqORX7QTORL>S�oIQT^�<7V[6�] � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 7��� � ��� ��� t E 6�S $ ^�Q � 6 dSe6�Q:L\ORV[9[Se9[6�8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 7 t� � ��� ��� v WP9;L\ORLIl�6 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 7 t� � ��� ��� � � QT^dl�� ORL7r{hiX7QTV;ORXI` � 8_]+^dr76�V � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 7��� � ��� ��� � p ^RL78TX7]�6�Q-j�^d^dr78�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 7 �

� � ��� t x ^�]+6(l�^�L7l�V;X78:9;^�L78 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 7 �� � ��� v #$^%$ Se^�X78:6 ST579;8/lq57ORoISe6�Q � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 757� � ��� � �iXISTV;9[L76 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 757

� � t 4/576k]+^dr76�V � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 757� � t � � 4/9[]+6(V[9;L76 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 7#C� � t � t � 8T8:X7]+oBSe9;^RL78$OR< ^RXIS/Se576kXIST9;V[9[SM=�`fX7L7lmSe9;^RL�� � � � � � � � � � � � � 7 �

� � v ��cdXI9;V;9[<7QT9;O�r76mZ\L76�r � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � C u� � v � � p XBSe^ 06�cdXI9;V;9[<7QT9;O�ORLIr{6 Io 6�lmSe6�r�r76�]+ORL7r,l�X7Q �R6�8�� � � � � � � � � C �� � v � t p XBSe^ 06�cdXI9;V;9[<7QT9;O�ORLIr{]�^�L7^RST^�L79[lir76�]+ORL7r � � � � � � � � � � � � C v

� � � ��cdXI9;V;9[<7QT9;O�j�9 ��6�L,r79 6�QT6�L S-SM=do 6�8$^R`noIX7<7V;9[l(9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L � � � � � � � � � C��� � �"� � x ^�]+6(oIQT6�V[9;]�9;L\OaQ:=�QT6�8TX7V Se8�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � C �� � �"� t W\X7V[V 9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � C56

� � �"� t � � � IOR]�o7V;6 � �7Se576kL7^RQT]+ORV l�OR8T6�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � C)7� � �"� t � t � IOR]�o7V;6 � �7Se576 OR<7LI^�QT]+ORV l�OR8T6 � � � � � � � � � � � � C5C

Page 10: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � �"� t � v 4/5I6 rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L ^R`Pl�XIST^ 8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � C �� � �"� t � � � 9 6�L jR^B^dr78 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � �"� v �$L79;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9 ��6ioIQT9;^RQg9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��v� � �"� v � � �$L79;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9 ��62o7QT9[^�QT8�$-9[ST5 8:=d]�]+6mSeQT9[lRs/8:9;L7j�V[6 & o 6�O �R6�r

oIQT9;^RQT8/9;]�o7V =+l�XISe^! 06�c X79;V[9;<7Q:9UO � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � �"� v � t �$L79;c X76�L76�8:8 ^a`�O�l�XIST^ �6�cdXI9;V;9[<7QT9[X7] � � � � � � � � � � � 6� � �"� v � v p ^R]+o\OaQT9;LIj%o ^�8 Se6�QT9;^RQT8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 7� � �"� v � � � S $ ^!& o 6�QT9;^dr,]+^dr76�V � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � C

� � �"� � 4/5I6 l�OR8T6 ^R`Po7QT9[^�Qg9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � C� � � � o7oIV;9;l�OaSe9[^�L �nORr ��6�Q:ST9;8T9[L7j � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���

� � � � � � r ��6�Q:ST9;8T9[L7j�]+^dr76�V3^�L76 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���

� � � � t � r ��6�Q:ST9;8T9[L7j�]+^dr76�V S $_^ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � uRu� � 6 � BST6�L78:9;^�LI8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � u �

� � 6�� � N ^�V;9 Se9[l�8/ORLIr{8:o\OaSe9;ORV ]�^dr76�V[8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � u �� � 6�� t WP9;L\ORLIl�6 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � u �� � 6�� v p ^R]+o 6�ST9;L7j%j�Q:^�X7o78$ORLIr2` OR8:579;^RL2jR^B^dr78 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � u �

� � 7 KM8-4 � �d9[6�$ 6�QT8:579;o2<79[]+^dr\ORV � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � u�t� � 7 � � h(O SqO � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � uRv� � 7 � t 4/5I6 XIL79;]�^Br7ORV;9 SM= Oa8T8TXI]+oIST9;^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � uRv

� � 7 � t � � D 5>=2OR8:8TX7]�9;LIj%X7L79;]�^dr\ORV;9 SM=�9;L SqOR8 Se6�8-`fXIQ:Se5I6�QT8-Se5I6 8 SeX7rB= � u �� � 7 � v �26�Se5I^Br � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � u �� � 7 � � b-6�8:X7V[ST8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � u 6� � 7 � � 4 6�8 S$l�^�L7l�V;X78:9;^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � u 7

� � C p ^�L7l�V;X78:9;^�L � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � u C

� � -�- �������� ��� �'�������@!"� �5����$��>$��>!"� !"�#� + ���6�� � 4/576�^RQT6�ST9;l�ORV ]+^dr76�V�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � u6�� t h(OaSqO � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � u

6�� t � � p OaV;9;<IQeOaST9;L7j�ST576k]+^dr76�V�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���

Page 11: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

B9� � -�- �������� ��� �� �'; � +�+ �

7 � � � X� B9[V;9UOaQ:=+QT6�8:X7V[ST8 � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � v7 � ��� � W\^�Q p 57ORoISe6�Q t � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � v7 � ��� t W\^�Q p 57ORoISe6�Q���� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 6

7 � t N�QT^d^R`f8g`f^�Q p 5\ORoBSe6�Q t � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � t �7 � v N�QT^d^R`f8g`f^�Q p 5\ORoBSe6�Q���� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � t 77 � � N�QT^d^R`f8g`f^�Q p 5\ORoBSe6�Q���� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � t �7 � � N�QT^d^R`f8g`f^�Q p 5\ORoBSe6�Q���� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � v �

� �>� �����'�' �! - : � + � �

Page 12: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

I9[9

� � �� � � ���

4/579[8$rI9;8T8:6�Q SqOaST9;^�L,l�^RLI`fQT^�L>ST8�O%`f6�$D^a`PST576 oIQT^�<7V[6�]�8/K_5\O �R6�6�LIl�^�X7L>ST6�QT6�r�9;L,]�=1QT6#Oar79;L7jR8^R` Se576k6�l�^�L7^R]+9[l(V;9[ST6�QTOaSeX7Q:6 �4/576 Z\Q:8:S�o7QT^�<IV;6�] 9[8 9[L ]�^�L7^RST^�L76�^�QTrI6�QT9[L7j"� �{XIlq5 ^R`gSe5I6 6� B9[8:Se9[L7j*V[9[ST6�QeO SeX7Q:6�rI9;8 &

l�XI8T8T6�8-O�l�6�Q:SeOR9;L+QT6�8:X7V[SgOR< ^�XIS_ST576�]�^�L7^aSe^�L76$V;9 �R6�V;9;5I^B^dr�QeOaST9;^ o7QT^�o 6�Q SM= w � ��b N | sdST5\OaSg9 `S $ ^$rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L7838TOaSe9[8:` =$Se576�� ��b$N*ORLIr OaQT6nST576�L X7o r\OaSe6�rkX78T9[L7j-^�L76�o79[6�l�6�^a`BLI6�$-8�s Se5I6�LSe5I6 S $ ^iQT6�8TX7V Se9;LIj�o ^�8:ST6�QT9[^�Q r79;8 SeQT9[<7XIST9;^�L78 $-9[V;V ORV[8T^�8TOaSe9[8:` =(ST576 � ��b$N�� 4/576go7Q:^�<7V[6�] $-9[ST5Se5I9;8QT6�8:X7V[S 9;8�Se57OaS ST576 � � b$N 9;8�<\OR8:9;l�ORV;V =%X78T6�V;6�8T8 w 8eO ��6�`f^RQ O l#O ��6�OaS/< 6�V[^ $ |�� ^�XBSe8T9[r76-^R`]+OaSe576�] O Se9;l�ORVd]+^dr76�V[8�sa9[S�9[8�r79 ��l�X7V[S�ST^k< 6�V;9;6 ��6_ST5\OaS�^�LI6/o 6�QT8T^RL � 8�< 6�V[9;6�`f8�OR< ^RXIS�OiV;^aSTSe6�Q:=$ ^�X7V;r,8TOaSe9[8:` =1ST576 � ��b N $-9 Se5,QT6�8To 6�lmS ST^+OaL7^RSe5I6�Q-o 6�QT8:^�L � 8�s\L7^�Q-9[8gSe576�QT6 ORL>= 6#Oa8:= $_O =Se^%ST6�8:S$^�Q-^�<I8T6�Q���6kSe579[8 �

� L7^aSe576�Q$^RQTr76�QT9;LIj7s7Z\QT8 S & ^�QTr76�Q/8:ST^Blq5\Oa8:Se9[lkr7^�]�9;L\ORLIl�6 w W � x h | s����-X78:6�`fX7V �K `P^�L76ko 6�Q &8T^RL � 8/< 6�V[9;6m`f8gOR< ^�XISgO V;^RS:Se6�Q =+W � x h ORLI^RSe576�Q�� 8�sIST576�L1ST576iZ\Q:8:S/o 6�Q:8T^�L j>Oa9;L78g]�^�Q:6�XIST9;V;9 SM=`fQT^R] ST576 V;^RS:Se6�Q:=�snQT6�j�ORQTr7V[6�8:8%^R`-Se5761rI6�SqOa9;V;8 ^R`-Se576 XBSe9;V[9[SM=�`fX7LIl�Se9[^�L �04/576 � ��b$N ^RL7V[=8eO#=d8 ORL>=dST579;LIj*OR< ^�XISko 6�^Ro7V;6%Se^ ST576�6� dSe6�L S Se57OaS 9[Sk9;]�o7V[9;6�8�W � x h � x ^ p 5\ORoIST6�Q t jR^B6�8r79[QT6�lmSeV = Se^1W � x h s OR8 �d9[L7j $-57OaS�^Ro 6�QeOaST^�QT8 o7QT6�8T6�Q���6�ST576 W � x h ^RQTr76�QT9;LIj7s\Se576 $gO#=,Se5\O S�gO#=�6�8T9;ORL1X7o r\OaST9;L7j o7QT6�8T6�Q ��6�8gSe576 � ��b$N�� KML1^�Q:r76�Q�Se^�ORL78 $ 6�QSe579[8 c X76�8:ST9;^�L3sdK�9[L STQT^dr7X7l�6O%L7^RSeOaSe9[^�L1`f^�Q-r76�Z7L79;L7j�j�6�L76�QTORV X7o r\OaST9;L7j�^�o 6�QTOaSe9[^�L78g9[L p 57ORoISe6�Q � �4/576*LI6� dS1o7Q:^�<7V[6�]&9;8�9;L 9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L o7Q:^ �d9[8T9;^RL�<>= ^�L762^�Q�S $_^ <I9UOR8:6�r Oar ��^dl#OaST6�8��

K ` $_6+OR8T8:X7]�6+O 8:9;]�o7V;6 r7OaSqO1j>O Se576�QT9;LIj,`fQTOR]�6�$ ^�Q �*ORL7r ORV;V[^ $ ORlmSe^�Q:8iSe^ Z\L7r0Se5I6�j�OR]+6Se5I6�^�Q:6�Se9[l 6�c X79;V[9;<7Q:9;X7]2s�Se5I6�L ST576�=���� ����� j�6�S Se576o\O#=�^! �`fQ:^�] `fX7V[V>9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L(QT6 ��6�V;OaSe9[^�L ���8To 6�l�9UORV[V[= $-9 Se5�S $_^ ORr ��^dl#O Se6�8�sdST579;8�9[8 O ��6�Q:=�QT^R<7X78:S QT6�8TX7V S � �$LI`f^�Q SeX7L\O Se6�V =�s 9[S�rI^B6�8 L7^aSQT9[L7jiSeQ:X76 � E ^kVUO $/=�6�Q�KP57O �R6 8:o ^ �R6�L�Se^(`f6�6�V;8�ST5\OaS�ST579;8�rI6�8Tl�QT9[< 6�8�ST576-^�XISTl�^�]�6�8�ST576�=%57O �R6^�<78:6�Q���6�r�9[L Se5I6gl�^�XIQ:SeQ:^B^R]{s $-576�Q:6/ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�8�l#OaQT6�`fXIV;V[=k8:6�V[6�l�SnSe576 9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RLkST576�= $-9;8:5

Page 13: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

B9;9[9Se^ QT6 ��6#OaV � D 6iORQ:6 8:9;]�9;V;ORQTV = 57ORQTr & o7QT6�8T8:6�r ST^ Z\L7r o 6�^�o7V;6 $-57^ `f6�6�V\ST5\OaS 5\O �B9[L7j�^Ro7o ^R8T9;LIjV;^R<7<>=B9[8:ST8 9;8 8:X ��l�9[6�L>S%`f^�Q�V[6�j�9[8TV;OaSe^�Q:8 ST^�j>ORQ:L76�Q%OaV;V�Se57619[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L0Se5I6�= LI6�6�r s $-5I9;lq5$ ^�X7V;r{9;]�o7V[=+Se5\O S$ST576 r76�]�^Bl�QeOaST9;lko7Q:^Bl�6�8T8 $_^RX7V;r{< 6 < 6mSTST6�Q$8T6�Q���6�r $-9[Se52< 6�STST6�Q & `fX7L7rI6�rV;^R<7<>=B9[8:ST8_ORLIr `f6�$ 6�Q l�^�LI`f^RX7L7r79[L7j�8:9;j�L\OaV;8�`fQT^�] ST576�o ^�o7XIVUORl�6 � � V[Se5I^�X7j�5�Se576�QT6(OaQT6-Se9;]�6�8$-576�L2V;O#=B]+ORL1^R<78T6�Q �aOaSe9[^�L78/OaQT6�l�^�QTQ:6�lmSe6�r,<>= � OR]�6�4/576�^�Q:=Rs7K�r7^%L7^RS_Se579[L"��ST579;8 9;8 8TX7lq5O%l#OR8:6 ��`fX7V;V 9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L19;8/LI^RS$ORV $_O#=d8$Q:6 �R6#ORV[6�r �4/576�Q:6 ORQ:6+S $ ^�]+^dr79 Z\l#OaST9;^�LI8 $ 61l�ORL ]+O �R6!�{4/5I6 Z\QT8 S 9[8 ST^�OR8T8:X7]�6+Se57OaS�rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L

]+O �R6�QT8-r7^�L7^RS$o7VUO#=1O�j�OR]+6iST^%$gORQ:r�O E Oa8T526�c X79;V[9;<7Q:9;X7]2sd<7XIS$L\O�� � ��6�V = o7Q:^Bl�6�8T8$9;LB`f^�QT]+O &Se9[^�L �+4/579;8 9;8(Se5I6 ORoIo7QT^>Oalq5 ^R` p 5\ORoIST6�Q v s $-579[lq5 Q:6 �d9;6 $-8�8T^R]+6�^R`_ST576�V;9[ST6�QTOaSeX7Q:6 Se5\O SSqO!�R6�8$Se579[8$ORo7o7Q:^>ORlq5�OaL7r*r76�8Tl�QT9;< 6�8�O�`f6 $ ^RSe5I6�Q-]+^dr76�V;8$ORo7Q:^�o ^R8$ST^+]�^BrI6�V;9[L7j%V;^R<7<>=B9[8:ST8X7L7rI6�Q/Se579[8-QT6�jR9;]�6 �4/576k^RSe5I6�Qg]�^BrI9[Z\l�OaSe9[^�L 9[8_Se^%V[6#O ��6�ST576(]+ORlq579;LI6�Q:=+^R` E Oa8T5,6�c X79[V;9;<IQT9UO ORL7r �gO#=R6�8T9;ORL

X7o r\OaST9;L7j$9;L o7VUOal�6Rsa<7XISP] O!�R6_9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L(]�^�Q:6l�^�]�o7V;6 � 4/576�QT6_]�X78:Sn< 6 ORL Oa8:=d]+]�6�STQ:=< 6�S $ 6�6�L�9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L(o7Q:^ �B9[r76�Q:8P`f^�Q�Se5I6 `fX7V[Vd9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L(6�c X79;V[9;<7Q:9;X7] ST^�< 6_<7Q:^��R6�L ��4/5\O S9;8�snSe5I61r76�l�9;8:9;^�L ]+O �a6�Q ] XI8:S%o7Q:^Bl�6�8:8 9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L rI9 6�QT6�L>SeV[= $-576�L 8T57615I6#ORQ:8%9[S `fQT^�]^�L76*o 6�QT8T^RL Se5\ORL $-576�L 8T5I6�576#OaQT819 S `fQT^R] OaL7^RSe5I6�Q � 4/579;8+9;8 Q:6#ORV[9;8 Se9;lasg<7XIS18T6�6�]+8 ^�LSe5I6+8:X7Q:` ORl�6�ST^*< 6�ORL\OaST576�]+OaSe9[l Se^2Se576�9;r76�OR8k^R`gQTOaSe9[^�L\ORVn9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RL�o7QT^dl�6�8T8:9;L7j"� 4/576]�^Br76�V ^a` p 57ORoISe6�Q �%QT6�l�^�LIl�9;V[6�8_ST579;8��nSe5I6ir76�l�9;8:9;^�L ]+O �R6�Q_9[8gl#ORo7OR<7V;6 ^R` l�^�Q:QT6�l�S �gO#=R6�8T9;ORLX7o r\OaST9;L7j7sd<7XIS-9[L1l�6�Q:SeOR9;L18:9[STX\OaSe9[^�L78 8:Se9[V;V 5\OR8gV[6�6 $gO#= ST^ o7Q:^Bl�6�8T8/9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L�r79 6�QT6�L>STV[=��4/576 �R6�={9;8/ST^+SqO!�R6�9[L>Se^+ORl�l�^�X7L>S�ST576�c X76�8:Se9[^�L*^a`�l#ORXI8eORV[9[SM=�s $-579[lq5*9[8 ^�XBSe8T9[r76kSe576 QT6#OaV;]^R`P8:SeOaSe9[8:Se9[l�8��4/576 Z7L\ORV o7QT^�<IV;6�] 9[8 9[L+jRQT^�X7o+< 6�5\O �d9;^�Q�sBL7^aSqOR<7V =%Se576$6�]�X7VUOaST9;^�L�^R`3^RSe576�QT8���4/579;89;8 O

l�^R]+]�^�L�5 X7]+ORL�STQeOR9 S#s <7XISn9;8nLI^RS�$ 6�V[VBSTQT6#O Se6�r�9;L ST576g6�l�^�L7^R]+9[l V[9[Se6�QeOaSTX7QT6!�P4/5I6g8:SeORL7r\ORQ:r]�^Br76�V l�V;OR9;]�8_Se57OaS�o 6�^Ro7V;6k6�]�X7VUOaST6k^RSe576�QT8$< 6�l#ORXI8T6�^a`�V;9[]+9 SqOaST9;^�LI8 9[L29[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L j�OaSe5 &6�Q:9;L7j�� X7L7OR<7V;6 Se^ QT6�8T6�ORQTlq5 O1c X76�8 Se9;^RL�Se576�]+8:6�V �R6�8�s�ST576�=*^�<78:6�Q �R6�l�^�L78:X7]�oISe9[^�L�<>=*ST576�9[Ql�^R57^�Q:S�s ORL7r SeO �R6%ST5\OaS OR8 O2Q:6�l�^�]+]�6�LIr\OaSe9[^�L�`f^�QiSe5I6+o7Q:^BrIX7l�S l�^RL78TX7]�6�r � � ��6�L>SeX\ORV[V[=RsSe5I6�QT6 9;8 O*l�Q:9[Se9[l#ORV�]+OR8T8 ^R`-QT6�l�^�]�]�6�L7r\O Se9;^RL78�snORL7r 6 ��6�Q =�^�LI6,ST576�Q:6#Oa` ST6�Q l�^�L78:X7]�6�8 Se5I68eOa]+6 oIQT^dr7X7l�S � $-9 Se5�o7Q:^�<\OR<I9;V;9 SM=2^�L76 �k4/576%Q:6#OR8:^�L79[L7j19;8�L7^RS(r76�8Tl�QT9;oBSe9 �R6%^R`�57^%$ ] ORL>=l�^RL78TX7]�oIST9;^�L r76�l�9;8T9[^�L78�ORQT6+] ORrI6Rs�ORLIr Se576+o7QT6�r79;lmSe9[^�L 9[8 l�V;6#OaQTV[=�` OaV;8T6+9;L 9;L7L X7]�6�QTOR<7V;6l#Oa8T6�8$9;L $-579[lq5{6�] X7V;OaSe9[^�L1^R`P^RSe5I6�QT8$9;8-OaL29[8T8:X76 �

Page 14: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

B9 �KML p 5\OaoISe6�Q �Bs\Kg^! 6�Q OaL�ORV Se6�Q:L\OaST9 ��6k]�^BrI6�V � � 8 $-9 Se5{ST576 ]+^dr76�V[8-OR< ^ �R6RsYSe576 ORlmSe^�Q:8

`f^�V[V;^%$ Se576kQ:X7V;6�8/^R` x SqOaST9;8:ST9;l�8-ORL7r � Oa]+6i4/5I6�^�Q =,l�V;^R8T6�V =�s7<IXIS/Se576m= 6� Bo7V[9;l�9[SeV = jR6�S-XIST9;V;9 SM=`fQT^R] 6�] X7V;OaSe9[L7jk^RSe5I6�QT8���4/579;89;8]�^�8:STV[=%l�^�L78T9[8:ST6�L>S $-9[ST5�ST576�9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L%l�OR8Tl�ORr76i]�^dr76�Vr76�8Tl�Q:9;< 6�r Oa< ^ ��6asI<7XBSgORV[V;^%$-8�9;L7rI9 �d9;r7X7ORV7o7Q:6�`f6�Q:6�L7l�6�8gST^�5\O ��6 j�QT6�OaSe6�Q Q:6�9[j�L �n9 `38:^�]+6�< ^drI=8:STQT^�LIj�V[= r79[8TV;9 �R6�8�O*oIQT^dr7X7l�S�snSe5I6�= ] O#= L7^RS <7XI= 6 �R6�L 9[`/6 ��6�Q:=d< ^drI= 6�V[8T61r7^d6�8��*K S ORV;8:^l�V;ORQT9 Z\6�8 ST576_9[]+o ^�Q:SeORL7l�6^a`76� Bo 6�lmSqOaST9;^�L78�s�6�8:o 6�l�9;ORV;V =(9;L 8T9 SeX\OaST9;^�LI8 ^a`\o\ORQ Se9UOaV>9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RL �Wn9[L\ORV;V =�s Se576%r79[8:STQT9;<IXISe9[^�L�^R`SqOR8 Se6�8k`f^RQkO,jR^B^dr�o7QT6�r79;lmS $-5\OaSko 6�Q:l�6�L>SeORj�6�^R`o 6�^�o7V;6 $-9[V;Vl�^RL78TX7]�6Rs $-9 Se5�6� dSTQT6�]�6%^�XISTl�^�]�6�8(V[9 �a6 � u�u�� l�^�LI8TX7]�oISe9[^�L�^dl�l�XIQTQT9[L7j ^�L7V =*9[L�6� dSeQ:6�]�68T9 SeX\O Se9;^RL78 �4/576�V;OR8:S$S $ ^ 8T6�l�ST9;^�L78�ORV;8:^+9[L7r79[QT6�lmSeV =,ORr7r7Q:6�8:8iORL7^aSe576�Q r79 ��l�X7V SM=,9;L,Se576 QeOaST9;^�L\OaV39;L &

`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L�ORj�j�Q:6�j>O Se9;^RL V;9 Se6�QTOaSeXIQT6 �PORr �R6�Q Se9;8:9;L7j���D 6-ORV;V �dLI^ $�Se576/oIQT^dr7X7l�S�ST576 p ^dl#O & l�^�V;Op ^�]�o\ORL>={] O �a6�8�s ORL7r0ORV[V�^R`�9[ST8�QT6�V;6 �ROaL Silq5\ORQeOal�Se6�QT9[8:Se9[l�8 QT6�j�ORQTr79[L7j SeOR8:ST6Rs3l�O! 6�9;L76 l�^�L &Se6�L>S#s\6�S$l�6�Se6�QeO � 8T^ $-5>={rI^B6�8 p ^dl#O &Ml�^RVUO <7V;ORL"�R6mS-Se576 $ ^�QTV[r $-9 Se5{ORr �R6�Q:ST9;8:9;L7j�{WYXIQ:Se5I6�Q�s$-5>= 9[8(Se576 ORr ��6�Q:ST9;8T9[L7j*<7OR8T9[l#ORV[V[=�l�^�L>Se6�L STV;6�8T8 K `/l�^�L78:X7]+6�QT8�ORQT6�o7X7Q:6�V[= r\O SqO & ^�QT9[6�L>Se6�rORL7r*^�L7V[=,SeO �R6�`fQ:^�] ORL�ORr{Se576 ` ORl�S Se5\OaS Se576�QT6 6 B9;8:ST8(O+oIQT^dr7X7l�S $-9[Se5{l�6�Q:SqOa9;L*`f6�OaSeX7Q:6�8�sSe5I6�L0ORr �R6�Q Se9;8:9;L7j1`f^RQ p ^dl#O & l�^�V;O ORL7r �d9[Q:SeX7ORV;V =2ORL>=�^RST576�QioIQT^dr7X7l�S $_^�XIV;r�V[^B^�� �R6�Q:=*r79[` &`f6�Q:6�L>Sk`fQT^�] $-5\OaS $ 6�8T6�6!� 4/576%`f^�Q:]+8i^a`gORr ��6�Q Se9[8T9;LIj p ^Bl�O &Ml�^�VUO XI8T6�8 9;L�ST576%QT6�ORV $ ^�QTV[rr76�QT9 �R6 L\O SeX7QTORV;V =�`fQT^�] ST576�SM=Bo 6 ^a`-ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6+r76�8:l�QT9[< 6�r 9;L p 5\ORoBSe6�Q ��ORLIr Se576�SM=do 6+^R`l�^RL78TX7]�6�Q-r76�8Tl�QT9;< 6�r29;L p 5\OaoISe6�Q � �

Page 15: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � ��� � � �

� � � � ��� � ��� ��� � � ��� � � ����� � � � �

4/579[8glq5\ORoIST6�Q $-9[V;VY9;L>SeQ:^BrIX7l�6(O j�6�L76�QeORV L7^RSeOaSe9[^�L+`f^�Q_X7o r7OaSe9[L7j�^�o 6�QTOaSe^RQT8 � x X7lq52ORL ^�o 6�Q &OaST^�Q�SqO �a6�8 S $ ^ 8:6�Se8 ^R`3< 6�V[9;6m`f8^RQ 9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L%Oa8_9;LIo7XISe8�sdORL7r oIQT^dr7X7l�6�8gO o ^�8 Se6�QT9;^RQ8:6�S ^R`< 6�V;9[6�`f8 OR8 ORL1^�XISTo7XIS � ��8To 6�l�9;ORV;V = $-9[ST579;L�Se576 < 6�5\O �d9;^�QTORVYV;9[ST6�QTOaSeX7Q:6Rs>Se5I6�QT6 6� B9;8 S/ORL OR<7X7L &r\ORLIl�6�^a`�]�^Br76�V;8-^R`�V[6#ORQ:L79;LIj+OaL7r*X7o r\OaST9;L7j $-579[lq5�6#ORlq5*5\O ��6 ST576�9[Q�Oar �aORL>SqORj�6�8 �/KML2Se579[8lq5\ORoBSe6�Q�s3K $-9;V[V LI^RS(ORr ��^dl#OaST6�`f^�Q�^RL76�^ ��6�QiSe576�^RSe576�QT8�s3ORL7r $-9[V;V�L7^RS�o7QT^Ro ^�8:6 L76 $ ^RL76�8��K $-9;V[V 8:9;]�o7V[=,rI9;8Tl�X78T8iST576 L76�6�r�`f^�Q�O+`fQeOR]�6�$ ^�Q � $-579[lq5�9;L7l�V;X7rI6�8 �gO#=R6�8T9;ORL�X7o r\OaST9;L7j Oa8O+8:o 6�l�9;ORVPl�OR8T6 ^R`�O ]�^�Q:6 j�6�L76�QTORV�o7QT^dl�6�8T8�s ORL7r $-9[V;V ^ 6�Q O l�^�L78T9[8:ST6�L>SiL7^aSqOaST9;^�L,`f^�Q-Se579[8o7Q:^Bl�6�8T8��KML p 5\ORoBSe6�Q t sdK $-9;V[V\8T57^%$ Se57OaSg8:^�]+6$^�o 6�QTOaSe^�Q:8 oIQT6�8:6�Q���6il�6�Q:SeOR9;L+^�QTrI6�QT9[L7j�8^R` 8:6�Se8 ^R`

< 6�V;9[6�`f8�s�$-579;V[6i^RST576�Q-X7o r\OaST9;L7j�^�o 6�QTOaSe^�Q:8/o7QT6�8T6�Q ��6 ^RSe5I6�Q-^�QTrI6�QT9[L7j�8��

�� �i!#���i��� )��(������� '�� ���

p ^�L78:9;r76 Okl�^�L78:X7]�6�Q�� 8< 6�V;9;6m`f8�OR< ^�XIS�Se576$V;9 �R6�V;9;5I^B^dr�Se57OaS ORL Oar ��6�Q:Se9[8T6�r j�^d^Br�9[8XI8T6�`fXIV ^RQL7^RS�s7^�Q-O o 6�Q:8T^�L � 8-< 6�V;9[6�`f8/OR< ^�XIS/ST576(V;9 �R6�V;9;5I^B^dr ^R` j�^d^dr ^�Q/<\ORr $ 6#OaST576�Q/Se^R]+^�Q:QT^%$ � D 6l#OaL�$-QT9 Se6kSe576�8T6 < 6�V;9;6m`f8-OR8$o7QT^�<7OR<79;V[9[SM= r76�L78:9[SM=,`fX7L7lmSe9[^�L78 w N�h(Wn8 | s��:X78:S�OR8 $_6 l#ORL{X78T6�ON�h(W ST^�8TX7]�] OaQT9 ��6iSe576 r\OaSeO $-5I9;lq5,Se576 $_6�OaSe5I6�QT]+ORL2X78T6�8 ST^+r76mSe6�QT]�9;L76(Se5I6 V[9 �a6�V;9[57^d^Br^R`nQeOR9[L � � XISiOaV[Se5I^�X7j�5 Se5I6�=2l#ORL{< ^aSe52< 6 $-QT9 STST6�L�Oa8�N�h(Wn8�s\r79;8 SeQT9[<7XIST9;^�L78/^a`�< 6�V;9[6�`f8$ORQ:6L7^RS-rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L78/^R`Pr\OaSeO��h(OaSqO 9;L ��^RV ��6�8 6 ��6�L>ST8 $-579;lq5 57O �R6�ORlmSeX\ORV[V[= 57ORo7o 6�L76�r ORL7r � ORo\ORQ S�`fQ:^�] o ^aSe6�L>ST9UORV

r7^�XI<ISe8*OR< ^RXIS2^�X7Q2]+6�OR8TX7Q:6�]�6�L>S{9;L78 SeQTXI]+6�L ST8{^RQ{]�9;8TORo7o7V[9;l#O Se9;^RL78 ^R`�Se576 # 6�9;8T6�L < 6�QTj

Page 16: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

t� LIl�6�Q SqOR9[L>SM= N�QT9;LIl�9;oIV;6 � ORQT62L7^RS,9[L r79;8:o7XIST6 � K ` $ 60ORQT6�X7LI8TX7Q:6 Oa< ^�XBS 57^%$ ST576�r\OaSeO$_OR8%o7QT^dr7X7l�6�r3s $ 6 l#OaL o ^RST6�L>Se9;ORV;V =0<7QT6�O � ^�o 6�L ORL>= <7V;ORl�� < ^ B6�8�ORLIr X7L7r76�QT8 SqORL7r Se5I6]�6�lq5\ORLI9;8T] Se^�OR8-] X7lq52o7QT6�l�9[8T9;^RL{Oa8$^RX7Q/l#ORo7OR<79;V[9[ST9;6�8_ORV;V[^%$ �

�_6�V[9;6m`f8 ^a` Se6�L l�^R]+6 `fQT^R] X7L <7QT6�O � OR<7V[6�<7V;ORl�� < ^ I6�8 � W\^�Q06 7Oa]+o7V[6Rs%9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�Lo7Q:^ �d9[r76�Q:8{]+O#= 5\O ��6 SeQeOar7608T6�l�QT6mSe8�$-5I9;lq5 ST576�= $-9[V;ViLI^RS*Q:6 �R6#ORVFsi^�Q Se576m= ] O#= oIQT6�`f6�QL7^RS-ST^+V[6�S$o 6�^�o7V[6 � L7^%$ 57^%$D]�X7lq5*^R`�O�jRX76�8:8 Se5I6�9;Q-< 6�V[9;6�`f8/Q:6#ORV[V[=1ORQT6!� p ^�L78:X7]+6�QT8$] O#=L7^RS � L7^%$ $-5>=�Se5I6�=�< 6�V[9;6 �R6%Se5\OaSkST576�QT6�r r7^�LIj�V;6%9[8 < 6�S:Se6�QkST5\ORL0Se576�<7V[X76%r7^�LIj�V;6asPOaL7r6 �R6�L 9[`-8:l�9[6�L>Se9[8:Se8%l�^�X7V[r o7XIS ST^�j�6mSe576�Q%O�]+^dr76�V ^R`/ST576 <7QTOR9;L ST5\OaS�l�^�X7V[r 6� Bo7V;OR9;L ST576�8:6^�o79[L79;^RL78�s39 S(9;8(oIQT^�<\Oa<7V[=*9;]�o ^�8:8T9[<7V;6 Se^ � L7^%$ 6�LI^�X7j�5 OR< ^�XIS O o 6�QT8:^�L � 8 6 Bo 6�QT9;6�L7l�6�8 ^RQo\OR8 S-SeQeOa9;L79[L7j Se^�o7XIS-ST576 ]�^dr76�V ST^�X78T6!�_Wn9[L\ORV[V[=�s Se5I6�QT6 ORQ:6kST576k8T9[]+o7V[6io7QTORl�ST9;l#OaV3l�^�LI8T9;r &6�QTOaSe9[^�L78�s ST5\OaS $ 6�OR8 � Se576-< 6�V[9;6�`f8�^R` 9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L o7Q:^ �B9[r76�Q:8 9[L+8:9[STX\OaSe9[^�L78 $-576�QT6$^�X7Q�Se9[]+6^�Q_OR<79;V[9[ST9;6�8�o7Q:6�l�V;X7r76�j>OaSe5I6�QT9[L7j ST576ir\O SqO�^�XIQT8T6�V �R6�8 �K ` $ 6(5\ORr ST576(OR<79[V;9 SM=�ORL7r1Q:6�8T^RX7QTl�6�8Se^kX7LIr76�Q:8:SqOaL7r�ST576/8T^RX7QTl�6�8^R` ORL�6� Bo 6�Q:S�� 8r\OaSeOIs�Se576�L $_6 $ ^�X7V;rIL � S�57O �R6 < ^RST576�Q:6�r�OR8 � 9[L7jSe5I6i6� Bo 6�Q:S � x ^%X7L7V[9 �R6 <7VUOal��+< ^ I6�8 $-579;lq5 oIQT^dr7X7l�6�r\OaSqOBs $-579[lq5 $_6(]+O#= < 6(OR<7V[6 ST^�SqO �a6ORo\OaQ:S-ORLIr2XIL7r76�Q:8:SeORL7r*< 6�S:Se6�Q�sIST576(576#Oar &M8:5\ORo 6�r2< ^ B6�8/Se57OaS-o7QT^dr7X7l�6(< 6�V;9[6�`f8gl�ORL,L7^RS-< 6SqO!�R6�L*ORo\ORQ S#sI`f^RQ/8T^dl�9UOaVysI<I9;^�V[^�j�9;l�ORVys OaL7r{oIQeORlmSe9;l�ORV3Q:6#OR8:^�L78 �4/579;8 V;6�ORr78 ST^%ORL7^aSe576�Q 9[]+o ^�Q:SeORL>Sr79 6�Q:6�L7l�6i< 6mS $_6�6�L,< 6�V;9[6�`f8 ORL7r1r7OaSqO��nK Sg9;8 ORL16�OR8:=

]+OaSTST6�Q�Se^ko7XBS�Se^�j�6mSe576�QOk]�6�ST57^dr%^R`3Oaj�j�QT6�j>OaST9;L7j(r\O SqO�� �gO#=�6�8 � 8 QTX7V[6/9;8�6�OR8T9[V[=�ORo7o7V[9;6�r ST^o7Q:^Br7XIl�6 �_O =R6�8:9UORL1XIo r\O Se9;LIj7s�$-579;lq5 sIj�9 ��6�L�Se576$QT9[j�5>S_8:6�STX7o3sI9[8O ]+OaSe576�] O Se9;l�ORV;V = l�^�Q:QT6�lmS]�6�Se5I^Br `f^�Q�OR8:8T9[]+9[VUOaST9;L7j/L76 $ r\OaSqO � �_XISn8T9[L7l�6 < 6�V;9;6m`f8PrI9 6�QP`fQ:^�]Dr\OaSeO `f^�QnORV;V>Se5I6_QT6�OR8T^RL78OR< ^ ��6Rs\9 S-9;8/r79 ��l�X7V S/Se^ �:X78:ST9[` = X78T9[L7j�ST576k8eOR]�6(]�6�Se5I^Br Se^�ORjRj�QT6�j>OaSe6iST576�] ���

��� � ��� ���������+� ��� � � ��� '�� ���#��� ��� �(��� �n���

4/579[8�8T6�l�Se9[^�L�o7QT6�8T6�L ST8OiL7^RSqO Se9;^RL $-579;lq5�l�ORoISeXIQT6�8�ST576g9;rI6#Oi^R`YSqO!�d9[L7jiS $ ^ N�h(Wn8�OR8�9;LIo7XIS#sORL7r,Se5I6�L2l�^�L7l�V;X7rI9;L7j $-9[ST52O�o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q-N�h(W �� 6�S�� w | < 6+ST576 STQTX76as�X7L7^�<I8T6�Q��aOR<7V;61Nh(W ^R` � x O =0ST5\OaS ^RL76 8:^�X7QTl�61l�V;OR9;]�8(Se5\O S

`f^�Q �� ��s � w � | ��� s�ORL7r ORL7^RST576�Q(8:^�X7Q:l�6%l�V;OR9;]�8�� w � | ��� � 4/576�r76�l�9;8:9;^�L�]+O �R6�Q(] X78 S�����������������! "�!�$#&%�'( *)+�$�!�$�,��'� &-!.�/0-!-1 "�����325476,%�8��!�390�39� "#& "�1 &��-:'(�;-1.$�1 &9� &��<=9>�$#& "�$2?-��3�1�@���3�7�1�A9>�@�!�1�;�B�1�;'

#& "C��=8��1��90��90 "#& *�! "�;-@'(��-!.��! &9� "�0<��D���E'(�3FG��H3�����D-$IJ "�0.$#"/E'( "�0<K-L��FM�= &�,�1���1�;-�! "��<�6� N-L�1�3�!%K���O�!6��A-1/�9(P��.���IQ-L����160�@ "�,�1�!�('(/0.��1�3�!%A.D60�38(�1��� �1�SRT60��2U�$�WV X�Y[Z]\

Page 17: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

vOR]+ORV;j�OR] O Se6 ST576�8:6*S $_^ r\OaSqO0o ^�9;L>Se8�9;L>ST^ ^�L762< 6�V;9[6�` s 8T^ V[6�S���� w1���B� | < 62ST576*XIo r\O Se9;LIj^�o 6�QTOaSe9[^�L3sI]+ORo7oI9;L7j������ � Se^��� �4/576 8TOR]+6 ]+O =,< 6�rI^�L76 `f^RQ�ORL>= �aORV;XI6 ^R` �/V;6�S � w | < 6 ^�L76 8T^�X7Q:l�6�� 8il�VUOR9[]+8-Oa< ^�XBS

Se5I6iSeQTXI6 rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L1^R` sYORLIr2V[6�S � w | < 6iSe5I6 ^aSe576�Q�� 8 ��4/576�L���� w1� w | �B� w |:| r76�Z\LI6�8 ORL9;]�o7V[9;l�9 S `fXIL7l�ST9;^�L,]+ORo7o79[L7j ST^�� � � � `f6�$ ]�^�Q:6(l#O ��6�OaSe8 6�L78:X7QT6kSe5\O S/Se579[8 $-9[V;V V;6#Oar,ST^O �aORV;9[r ^�XISeoIXIS$j�9 �R6�L �aORV;9[r,Nh(WP8 Oa8$9[L7o7XIST8 �

� ��� ��>������� +������������ �"!#�%$'&���(*)+� �,&-)!/.0� ��12�43 &-576-� )�!4��8:9/(<;��=�?>*�4!@&-� ��� wL�A�[� | �B� � 0� �DC� �E 3GF�(*)H( ��� wL���B� |JI u ;K&-)L� 9#9 � I u � �<� � I u%M � �<��! ;ONQPR P

� w |+S � � � �<�N PR P

� w |+S � � E �TF�(*��N PR P ��� wL� w | �[�aw |T|US !/.QVW��!#�7(:X

K $-9;V;V�Q:6�8 SeQT9[l�S OaSTST6�L>Se9[^�L Se^*^�o 6�QeOaST^�QT8 $-579[lq5 ORQT6+l�^�L>Se9[L X7^�X78 9[L < ^RSe5 �ROaQT9UOa<7V;6�8 �2K S$-9;V[VIOaV;8T^�< 6g^dl�l�OR8T9[^�L\ORV[V[=kX78:6�`fX7VBSe^(QT6�8:STQT9;lmS�OaS:Se6�L>ST9;^�L ST^iSe57^�8:6gX7o r\OaST9;L7ji^Ro 6�QeOaST^�QT8 $-5I9;lq5ORQ:6 9;LIl�QT6�OR8T9[L7j29;L < ^RST5 ORQTjRX7]+6�L>Se8 �,4/5\O S 9;8�sn9 `ZY\[^]�sPST576�L_��� w Y �a` | [^��� w ] �a` | OaL7r��� wT`b� Y | [c��� wT`b� ] | `f^�QgORV[V ` ��4/5I9;8_9[8_8:6�L78:9;<7V[6�< 6�l#OaX78T6(9 ` ^�L76 8T^�X7Q:l�6i]�^dr79[Z\6�8_9 Se8QT6�o ^�Q S`fQT^R] � w � | � ] Se^ � w � | � Y s7ST5 X78�o7XBSTSe9[L7j�]+^RQT6 $_6�9;j�5>S$^�L � s O�V[9;8 Se6�LI6�Q-8T57^RX7V;r,SqO �a6Se57OaS�9[L>Se^�ORl�l�^�X7L>S $-5I6�L�ORjRj�QT6�j>OaSe9[L7j%Se576 9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L ORLIr*o7XIS�O+V[9[S:SeV;6�]+^�Q:6 $_6�9;j�5>S ^�L � OR8 $_6�V;V �

� V Se57^�XIj�52ST576 r79;8:l�X78:8T9;^RL2ST^+Se5I9;8-o ^R9;L>S-5\OR8$< 6�6�L{^�QT9[6�L>Se6�r{Se^%$_ORQTr{8:=d]�]+6mSeQT9[lkORo7o7V[9 &l#O Se9;^RL78�snST576+Z7QT8:S%ORL7r 8:6�l�^RL7r 9;L7oIXISe8 9;L>Se^2Se5761XIo r\O Se9;LIj*^�o 6�QTOaSe9[^�L $-9[V;V�5\O ��6 rI9 6�QT6�L>S9;L>ST6�QToIQT6�SeOaSe9[^�L78�`f^�Q�] ORL>= ^R`iST576�Oao7o7V;9[l#OaST9;^�LI8�< 6�V[^%$ � W\X7Q Se576�Q�s/8 =B]�]�6�SeQ:9;l2^�o 6�QeO Se^�Q:8$-9;V[VP< 6 8:57^%$-L ST^15\O ��6�8T^R]+6%Oar7r79[ST9;^�L7ORV�9;]�o7V;9[l#OaST9;^�L78-^ ��6�QiSe576�j�6�L76�QeORVn8To 6�l�9 Z\l#O Se9;^RL�^R`hi6�Z7L79[ST9;^�L ��s $-576�Q:6'��� w1���B� | ]+O = ^�Q/]+O =1L7^RS-6�c X\OaVd��� wL���B� | �4/576�Q:6*9[8�LI^ QT6�OR8T^RL $-5>= N PR P ��� w@e�w | �af w |T|+S 8T57^�XIV;r < 62^�L76asg]+6�ORL79[L7j�Se5\OaS�Se5I6

ORlmSeX\ORV o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q_QT6�c X79[QT6�8 L7^RQT]+ORV;9 �#OaST9;^�L �

� ��� ��>������� 8hgiF�(j��&�.*�7(*)�!@&-)k� !/.*�4)*!48:�%�4!@&-�_$ !#6 (*�l������� �"!#�%$L&���(*)+� �,&-) ��� w,m/�Km | � �<�n!#� �<�=�#.e�w,m | � �<� f wUm | !/.

�A�poKq w"e�wUm | �af w,m | � ��� w,m/�Km | �; | � ��� w"e�w | �af w |:|N PR P ��� w"e�w4r | �+f3wTr |:|+S r �

Page 18: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

�$-579;lq529;8-j�X7ORQeORL>ST6�6�r,Se^�9[L ST6�j�QTOaSe6iST^�^�L76 �KML�Se579[8(L7^RSqO Se9;^RL3s �gO#=R6�8T9;ORL X7o r7OaSe9[L7j 9;8i6�c X79 �aORV[6�L>SiSe^���� w@enw�� m | �af w,m |T| �^e�w �� m | f wUm | s

`f^�Q/OaL =�Z B6�r s7jR9 �d9;L7j O�o ^R8:Se6�QT9[^�Q $-579[lq5 ] OaSTlq576�8gST576ir76mZ\L79 Se9;^RL1j�9 �R6�L,< 6�V;^%$ 9[L ��c X\O &Se9[^�L t � ��� W\^�Q 6 7Oa]+o7V[6RsV;6mS < 62ORL ^�<78T6�Q �aOR<7V[6 �ROaQT9UOa<7V;6 ORL7rlq�< 62O0o7ORQeOR]�6�ST6�Q%^R` 8TXIlq5 OR8kSe576�]+6�ORL � � �_O =R6�8:9UORL QT6�8:6#ORQ:lq576�Q $_^RX7V;r < 6�j�9;L $-9[ST5 o7Q:9;^�Q(< 6�V[9;6m`f8kST5\OaSjq(5\Oa8O N�h(W f w q | s ST5\OaS ST5760r\OaSqO 5\OR8,r79[8:STQT9;<IXISe9[^�L e�w �� q | � 4/5760Q:6�8T6�ORQTlq5I6�Q{ST576�L QTXIL782ORL6� Bo 6�Q:9;]�6�L>S $-579[lq5 o7QT^ �d9;r76�8,O �aORV;XI6�^R` s�� � � S Se579[8 o ^�9;L>S#s/ST576�QT6�8T6�ORQTlq576�Q2ORo7o7V[9;6�8��� w@e�w � � q | �+f3w q |T| � e�w � � q | f w q | Se^ ORQTQ:9 �R6 O SiO�o ^R8:Se6�QT9[^�QQ�A� o:q w q � � | s $-579;lq5{9;8$O�`fXIL7l�ST9;^�L2^R`qg<IXIS$L7^RS �x 5\Oa`f6�Q�� � u�� r76�8:l�Q:9;< 6�8i57^%$DST579;8 9;8$6�c X79 �aORV[6�L>S�ST^1hi6�]+o78 Se6�Q�� 8�QTXIV;6 $-9 Se579[L2ST576 o7Q:^�<\O &

<79[V;9[SM=�`fQeOa]+6 $_^�Q � 576�QT6!�W\^�Q O o ^R8:Se6�QT9[^�Q $-579;lq5HO �R6�QTORj�6�8+Se576{o7QT9[^�QT8�s ��� w@e�w,m | �af wUm |:| � e�wUm |� f wUm | sgOaL7rHSe5I6

o ^�8:ST6�QT9[^�Q/9;8

�A� o:q w"e�wUm | �af wUm | � ��� w,m/�Km | �; | � enw |� f w |N PR P

enw4r |�� f w4r |+S r � e�w |� f w |t �

Wn9[L\ORV;V =�sdL7^RST9;l�6iST5\OaS-9 `� 19;8$ORL>= o ^�8:9[Se9 ��6(l�^�L78:SeORL>S#s

m ��� w@enw | �+f3w |T|NWPR P m ��� w@enw4r | �af w4r |T|US r � ��� w"e�w | �af w |T|

NQPR P ��� w"e�w4r | �af wTr |:|+S r �

KML*^RST576�Q $ ^�QTr78�s3ORL>=,8 SqOaST6�]�6�L>S�< 6�V[^%$ OR< ^�XIS-Se576 o7Q:^�o 6�Q:ST9;6�8$^R` ��� w"e�wUm | �af w,m | �� | ORV;8:^ORo7oIV;9;6�8iSe^������ w@enwUm | �af wUm | �; | � m ��� w"e�wUm | �af w,m | �� | � # O �d9[L7j,] ORrI6�ST579;8(LI^RSe6�576�QT6Rs K $-9[V;V8:SeOaSe6iORV;V QT6�8TX7V Se8g< 6�V[^ $ 9[j�L7^�Q:9;L7j Se576�` Oal�SgST5\OaS_ST576(^�o 6�QTOaSe^�Q:8_l�ORL1SeQ:9 �d9UORV[V[=%< 6i] XIV[Se9[o7V;9[6�r<>=,ORL>=,o ^�8T9 Se9 �R6(l�^�LI8:SqOaL S �

��� � �R��� ���2� ��!�� �

4/579[8n8T6�l�ST9;^�L�SeO �R6�8�6� IOR]�o7V[6�8P`fQ:^�] Se5I6_< 6�5\O �d9;^�QTORVdV;9[ST6�QTOaSeX7Q:6ORL7r 8:57^%$-8 $-5\OaSPSe576m=�9[]+o7V =OR< ^�XIS�Se5I6 `f^�Q:] ^R`7ST576 XIo r\O Se9;LIj ^�o 6�QTOaSe^RQ � K SP9[8PLI^RSPO l�^R]+o7Q:6�576�L78T9 ��6 ^�QPl�^�]�o7V;6mSe6�8TX7Q���6m=^R`Se576�V[9[Se6�QeOaSTX7QT6as3<7XIS $-9[V;VnjR9 ��6 ST576�QT6�ORr76�Q(` OR]�9;V[9UORQ $-9 Se5�Se576 �aORQ:9;^�X78�6� 6�l�ST8 rI9;8Tl�X78T8:6�r

Page 19: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

�9;L,< 6�5\O �d9;^RQeORV36�l�^�LI^�]+9[l�8-ORL,9[r76#O%^R`P57^%$ Se5I^�8T6k6� 6�lmSe8 ORQT6(rI6�8Tl�QT9[< 6�r*<>=1Se5I6k`fQTOR]�6�$ ^�Q �576�QT6 �

��������� ��� ���������������

4/576�QT6�9;8i6 BST6�L78:9 �R6 6� Bo 6�Q:9;]�6�L>SqORVn6 �d9;r76�L7l�6�Se57OaS(Se576%^RQTr76�Q 9[L $-579;lq5 9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L*9[8(QT6 &l�6�9 �R6�r $-9[V;VYO! 6�lmS ST576 $_O#=+9[L $-579[lq5 9 S 9[8 oIQT^dl�6�8:8T6�r �78T6�6RsB6 � j"�[s p OR]�6�Q:6�Q � � t � `f^RQ_O 8TX7Q���6�= �W\^�Q 6� IOR]�o7V;6as�4 ��6�QT8 �>= OaL7r �kOR57L76�] OaL � ��� � `f^�X7L7r � ORL7lq5I^�QT9[L7j � 6� 6�l�ST8 $-576�QT6 8TXI< �:6�lmSe8o7V;ORl�6,]�^�QT6 $ 6�9;jR5 S+^�L 6 �d9;rI6�L7l�6*o7Q:6�8T6�L>Se6�r 6�ORQTV[9;6�Q�Se5\OaLH^�L 6 �d9;rI6�L7l�6*o7Q:6�8T6�L>Se6�r V;OaSe6�Q �x X7lq5 < 6�5\O �B9[^�Ql#ORL+L7^RS< 6$]�^Br76�V;6�r+<>=+O 8 =d]+]�6�STQT9;l-X7o r\OaST9;L7j ^�o 6�QTOaSe^�Q��n9 S ]�X78:S < 6-Se5I6l#Oa8T6�ST5\OaS_ST576i^�Q:r76�Q ^R` Se5I6�9;LIo7XISe8 Se^ ST576�`fX7LIl�Se9[^�L1]+OaSelq5I6�8_ST576�^�Q:r76�Q_9;L $-5I9;lq51Se5I6�r\OaSeO9;8/oIQT6�8:6�L>Se6�r3s ORL7r���� wL���B� |��� ��� w1���B� | �4/579;8 6 Bo 6�QT9;]�6�L>SeORV�6 �B9[r76�LIl�6�Se6�V;V;8+X78 L7^RST579;LIj ]+^�Q:6�OR< ^�XIS Se576�`f^�Q:] ^a` XIo r\O Se9;LIj

^�o 6�QTOaSe^�Q���W\^�Q�6� IOR]�o7V[6Rs>Se576$]�6#ORL79[L7jk^R` � $ 6�9;jR5 ST9;L7j �>r76�o 6�L7rI8_^�L�Se576$lq57^�9[l�6$^R`3^Ro 6�QeOaST^�Q �O�] X7V Se9[o7V;9[l#OaST9 ��6�^�o 6�QTOaSe^RQ�l�^RX7V;r SeO �R61ST576 `f^�Q:] ��� w1���B� | � ���jm � s I ���gORL ORrIr79[ST9 ��6^�o 6�QTOaSe^�Q/l�^�X7V[r,SeO �R6(ST576(`f^�QT] ��� wL�A�[� | � m�� � � s I ���KML O 8:V;9;jR5 STV[= rI9 6�QT6�L>S `fQeOa]+6 $_^�Q �Ysg8TX7lq5 OR8 =d]+]�6�STQT9;l,^�o 6�QTOaSe^RQT8 $-9[V;V-ORV[V;^%$ o7ORQ:ST9UORV

9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L Q:6 �R6�VUO Se9;^RL2^RL{o\Oaj�6 � v �

+ � � � + � + � ��!. 2�������������1���

� p ^�X7QTLI^RS-V;6�ORQTL79[L7j � 9;8 Se576(l�QT6#O Se9;^RL1^R` < 6�V;9[6�`f8g<\Oa8T6�r,^�L1ST576(VUOa8:SgoIVUO#= ^R<78T6�Q ��6�r �KML2^aSe576�Q$ ^�QTr78�s-j�9 �R6�L O LI6�$ QT^�XIL7r ^R`(9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L3sSe576{X7o r\OaSe9[L7j Q:X7V;6{9;8�Se^ ST57QT^%$ ^�XIS o\OR8 SQT^RX7L7r78 ORL7r�8T9[]+o7V =�SeO �R6-Se576$L76 $ QT^�XIL7r1OR8OkL76�$ 8T6�S ^R` < 6�V;9;6m`f8 � � Wn9[l�ST9[Se9[^�X78�oIVUO#= �[s 9;L�Se5I6l�^RL ST6� dS576�Q:6Rsd9;L ��^RV ��6�8OiV;6#OaQTL79[L7j(]+^dr76�V�$-579;lq5�O ��6�QeORjR6�8^�XISel�^�]�6�8�^ ��6�Q_ORV[VIo\Oa8:S�QT^RX7L7r78��4/576�OR8T8:X7]+oBSe9;^RL78-^R`�< ^RSe52^R`�ST576�8:6�V;6�ORQTLI9;L7j�]�^Br76�V;8-l#OaL*< 6 8:X7<78TXI]+6�r�9;L>Se^�^�L76 ]�^Br76�Vys<>=,O $_6�9;j�5>Se6�r*O �R6�QeOaj�9;L7j�^�o 6�QTOaSe^RQ

��� wL���B� | � � � ` ���

$-576�QT6 � 9[8ST576�L76 $ o7QT^R<\OR<79[V;9[SM= ^R`�ORL+6 ��6�L>S#s\ORLIr � 9;8�Se576$^�V;r+< 6�V;9[6�`f8OR< ^�XIS 9[Se8o7Q:^�<\OR<79[V &9[SM= w ST576(^�XISTo7XIS-^R`�ST576(X7o r\OaSe9[L7j%^�o 6�QTOaSe9[^�L `fQT^R] ST576(VUOR8 S/QT^RX7L7r | �K ` ` � u sIST576�L Se5I9;8g9[8

Page 20: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6p ^�X7Q:L7^RS-V[6#ORQ:L79;L7jIs7ORL7r29[` ` 9;8/j�Q:6#OaST6�QgSe57ORL Se^�^�L76as7Se576�L{9 S/9;8/l�V;^�8:6�QgSe^%ST576kV;6#OaQTL79[L7j%OR8 &8T^dl�9;OaSe6�r�$-9 Se5�Z\l�ST9[ST9;^�X78�oIVUO#=�� x 6�6 WYXIr76�L < 6�QTj ORL7r � 6 �d9;L76 � t�t � ^�Q p 576�X7L7j�ORL7r1W\Q:9;6�rI] ORL� � � � �n^�Q 8T6�6 p OR]�6�Q:6�Q ORL7r # ^ � 8 � Bo 6�QT9[6�L7l�6 & D 6�9;j�5>Se6�r � STSTQeORlmSe9[^�L � � � � s $-579;lq5 9;8k<\OR8:6�r^�L Se5I9;8-]+6mSe57^dr,^R`PX7o r7OaSe9[L7j"�4/579;8/`f^�Q:] $-9[V;V3]+O �R6kO�QT6�ORo7o 6#ORQTORL7l�6 9[L x 6�lmSe9;^RL t � 6�� v �

��������� ����������� ��� � ��� �

N�QT9[^�Q(9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L�l#OaL O! 6�lmSkSe576+OR<78:^�QToIST9;^�L0^R`_8TX7<I8T6�c X76�L>S%9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L � N 6�^�oIV;6 $-57^8:STQT^�LIj�V[= < 6�V[9;6 ��62O0ST576�^RQ:= ]+O = 9;j�L7^RQT6 9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L $-579[lq5Hl�^�X7L>Se6�QT8�Se576�9;Q�o 6mS�Se576�^�Q:=RsORL7r X7o r\OaST62^RL7V[= X78T9[L7j09;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RL $-579[lq5HORjRQT6�6�8�$-9 Se5 Se5I6�9;Q%oIQT9;^RQT8 � p Oa]+6�QT6�Q w � � t � s9;L>STQT^dr7X7l�ST9;^�L | j�9 ��6�8�ORL 6� dST6�L78:9 ��6,Q:6 �d9;6 $ ^a`$ST576 �aORQ:9;^�X78 8:STX7r79;6�8 $-579[lq5 57O �R6 ^�<78:6�Q �R6�r8TXIlq5*6� 6�lmSe8��4/576�]+^R8:S(r79[QT6�l�S $_O#=�Se^ ]�^BrI6�VPST579;8�9;8�ST^ 8eO#=*ST5\OaSiST576�Q:6�9[8(O1o 6�QTl�6�oIST9;^�L�`fXIL7l�ST9;^�L3s

e�wL�A�[� | s�$-579[lq5,STQeORLI8:`f^�Q:]+8gLI6�$ 9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RL � <7OR8T6�r2^RL,ST576(o7Q:9;^�Q < 6�V;9;6m`f8 � � � 8:SeORL7r\ORQ:rX7o r\OaST9;L7j%]�6�ST57^Br ]+O#= ST576�L,< 6kORo7o7V[9;6�r1ST^ Se576(STQeORL78 `f^�QT]�6�r 9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L � � L2XILd<I9UOR8:6�r^�<78:6�Q���6�Q $_^RX7V;r X7o r7OaSe6�X78T9[L7jO��� wL�A�[� | s $-5I9;V;6�ORL ^�<78:6�Q �R6�Q $-57^*8:X� 6�QT8 Se576�8T6 6�L7l�^dr79[L7j<79;OR8T6�8 $ ^�X7V[r,X7o r7OaSe6kX78:9;L7j���� w1����e�wL�A�[� |:| �W\^�Qk6� IOR]�o7V;6as 8eO#=�Se5\O S ST576�]+6�ORL0^R`/O �aORQT9;OR<7V[6%9;8kO,57^RSeV =�l�^�L>Se6�8 Se6�r 9;8:8TX76!�1NP6�^�o7V[6

$-57^�< 6�V;9[6 ��6iST5\OaS-Se5I6 ]�6#OaL29[8/o ^R8T9[ST9 �R6(9;j�L7^RQT6iL76 $D9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L $-5I9;lq52l�VUOa9;]�8_Se5\O S-9[S/9[8L76�j>OaSe9 ��6asYORL7r �B9[l�6 �R6�QT8TO��4/576�L

e�wL� w | �B� w |T| �� �� w | ]�6#OaL w1� | m ]�6#ORL w1� |�� u� w | ]+6�ORL wL� | m ]�6#OaL w1� | I u

$-576�QT6 � w | 9[8+OaL�X7LI9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9 �R6 o7QT9[^�Q w rI6�Z\L76�rH`f^�Q:] ORV[V[= 9;L x 6�l�Se9[^�L � � ��� v>| � E ^�QT]+ORV�gO#=�6�8T9;ORL X7o r\OaST9;L7jIsnOR8 OR< ^ ��6as�9;8(Se5I6+X7o r\OaST9;L7j,^�o 6�QTOaSe^RQ ��� wL�A�[� | � ��m � sP8:^ �gO#=R6�8T9;ORLX7o r\OaST9;L7j�j�9 ��6�L `fQTOR]+9[L7j%6� 6�lmSe8-l#OaL{< 6k]+^dr76�V[6�r <>=���� w1����e�wL���B� |T| sI^�Q/< 6kQ:6�$-QT9 STST6�L{OR8-O`fX7L7lmSe9[^�L,^�L7V[= ^R` � ORL7r � �

��� � w1���B� | �� � ]�6#ORL wL� | m ]+6�ORL wL� |�� u� m�� ]�6#ORL w1� | m ]+6�ORL wL� |0I u

Page 21: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

78T9[L7l�6 �gO#=R6�8T9;ORL�X7o r7OaSe9[L7j(<\OR8:6�r ^RL�ST576-X7L79[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9 ��6 o7QT9[^�Q�QT6�8TX7V Se8�9[L+O(o ^�8:ST6�Q:9;^�Q $-5I9;lq56�c X\OaV;8/Se576ko7Q:9;^�Q��

��� � ����" ! ���������

D 6$57O �R6 ^RL7V[=�^�L76/Se^d^�VB`f^RQ�X7o r7OaSe9[L7jk< 6�V;9;6m`f8�OR< ^�XIS�Se5I6$oIQT^�<\Oa<79;V[9[SM= ^R` 6 ��6�L>Se8_XI8T9;LIj r7OaSqO���gO#=�6�8�� 8iQTXIV;6 � �_XIS 9[` $_6 ^�L7V[=15\O ��6�< 6�V[9;6m`f8$oIQT6�8:6�L>Se6�r�Se^+X78 <>=2l�^RL78TX7V SqORL>ST8�s ORr ��6�Q:ST9;8T6�QT8�sL76 $-8To\ORo 6�Q:8�s ^�Q-^RSe576�Q 5 X7]+ORL78�s\Se576�L*9[S$9[8$9[L\ORo7oIQT^�o7Q:9UOaST6iSe^�X78T6 �gO#=�6�8�� 8�QTXIV;6 OR8-9[`nST576�8:6ORQ:6 ^�< �:6�l�Se9 ��6 ^R<78T6�Q �aOaSe9[^�L78(Oa< ^�XBSio ^RSe6�L ST9UORV 8:SeOaSe6�8i^R`�ST576 $ ^�QTV[r �iK S(9[8�^R` ST6�L�o75>=d8T9[l#ORV[V[=9;]�o ^�8T8:9;<7V[6iSe^1j>O Se576�Q 6�L7^�X7j�5�9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L1ST^1QT6�r7X7l�6�Se576�8T6 ^Ro79;L79[^�L78/Se^+^�< �:6�l�Se9 ��6 r7OaSqOIsORL7r{QT6�o7VUORl�9;L7j�Se5I6 ]�9;8:8T9;LIj�9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L $-9 Se5{< 6�V;9;6m`f8-OR< ^�XIS$Se576 QT6�l�6�9 ��6�r�< 6�V;9;6m`f8�s\< 6�V[9;6�`f8OR< ^�XIS Se57^R8T6 < 6�V[9;6m`f8�OR< ^�XIS < 6�V;9[6�`f8�sP6mS l�6mSe6�QeOIs�V[6#ORrI8 ST^�ORL OaL\ORV[= ST9;l�c X\ORj�]�9;Q:6 $-5I9;lq5 9[8< 6�=�^RL7r ST576+l�^�]�o7XISqO Se9;^RL\ORV�Oa<79;V[9[SM={^R`_]�^�8 S 5 X7]+ORL78�snOaL7r ]+O �a6�8k9[Sk9[]+o ^�8T8:9;<7V[6�`f^�Q(Se5I6]�^Br76�V;6�QPSe^�] O �a6g8T6�QT9[^�X78�o7Q:6�r79[l�Se9[^�L78P^�QnSe^(8TO#=%ORL>= Se579[L7j(r76�8Tl�Q:9;oIST9 �R6�V[= 9;L>ST6�QT6�8:ST9;L7j(Oa< ^�XBSo 6�^�o7V[6kORL7r,Se576�9;Q/o7Q:^Bl�6�8:8T9;LIj+^R`P< 6�V;9[6�`f8��4/576�Q:6�ORQ:6*O L X7] < 6�Q�^R`i]�6�ST57^BrI8+^R`(OR8T8:9;]�9;VUO Se9;LIj*9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L�$-579[lq5H5\O ��6*8T57^%$-L

Se5I6�]�8T6�V ��6�8_Se^ < 6$r76�8:l�Q:9;oIST9 ��6�^R` 57^%$ o 6�^�o7V[6 9[L+6 Bo 6�QT9;]�6�L>SeORV V;OR<78 ORL7r+9;L+ST576�Q:6#ORV $ ^�QTV[rOR8:8T9;]�9;V;OaSe6 r\OaSeO��

�_6�l�ORX78:6*^R` < ^aSe5 Se576 ST576�^�Q:6�ST9;l#OaV/o7QT^�<IV;6�] Se5\O S+< 6�V[9;6m`f8�ORQT6 L7^aS+r7OaSqO0ORL7r l#OaL�L7^aS< 6 QT6�rIX7l�6�r�Se^0r\O SqOIsORL7r Se5I6 QT6�8:X7V[ST8%`fQT^�] Se576 V;OR<3s�9[S%9[8 �aORV;X\Oa<7V;6�Se^ ORr7]�9[S%rI9 6�QT6�L>SSM=do 6�8%^R`-X7o r\OaST9;L7j{^�o 6�QeOaST9;^�LI8�9;L>ST^*^�X7Q Se576�^�QT6mSe9;l�ORV]+^dr76�V[8 �{4/579;8 lq5\ORoIST6�Q%9;L>STQT^dr7X7l�6�rO�L7^RSeOaSe9[^�L\ORV�`fQTOR]+6 $_^RQ � `f^RQ�r7^�9[L7j*ST579;8�s�ORL7r j>O ��6 6 IOR]+oIV;6�8�^R`$57^%$ ST579;8 l�^�QTQ:6�8:o ^�LIr78Se^�l�6�Q SqOR9[L 6 6�l�ST8�^R<78T6�Q ��6�rH9[L Se576,< 6�5\O �d9;^RQeORV V;9[ST6�QTOaSeX7Q:6 � 4/576 lq5\ORoBSe6�Q:8 $-579;lq5 `f^�V;V[^%$$-9;V[V X78T6 Se579[8$`fQTOR]+6 $_^RQ �1Se^+r76�ST6�Q:]+9[L76 $-5I9;lq5�X7o r\OaST9;L7j+^�o 6�QeO Se^�Q:8�ORQ:6�Oar7]+9[8T8:9;<7V[6 jR9 ��6�Ll�6�Q:SeOR9;L,o79[6�l�6�8 ^a`n6 �B9[r76�LIl�6 ^�QgSe576�^�QT6mSe9[l#ORV3Q:6�c X79[QT6�]�6�L>ST8 �

Page 22: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

C

� � ��� � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� � � ��� �� � ��� � � � � � ���� �

� � ���1�����,'���"/�����+�

Wn9[QT8:S &M^�Q:r76�Q 8:ST^Blq5\Oa8:Se9[lir7^�]�9;L7ORL7l�6 w W � x h | 9[8gO�XI8T6�`fXIV3o7QT^Ro 6�Q:SM= `f^RQgO�8:6�S-^R`�o7Q:^�<\OR<I9;V;9 SM=r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL78�Se^,5\O �R6 � � V[^RSTST6�Q = $-57^�8:6+rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L�W � x hi83� Se57OaS ^R`gOaL7^RSe5I6�Q(V;^aSTSe6�Q:=l#OaL*< 6 8TOR9;r,Se^�< 6 � < 6mSTST6�Q��Y^�Q � ]+^RQT6k^�oIST9;]�9;8:ST9;l��[sB9;L Se576 8T6�L78T6 Se5\OaS-ST576 6 Bo 6�l�Se6�r�XIST9;V;9 SM=j�9 ��6�L ST576 ST5761r7^�]�9;L7ORL>S V;^aSTSe6�Q:= 9;8 579;jR576�Q Se5\ORL ST5\OaS%^a`/Se5761rI^�]+9[L\OaST6�r V[^RSTST6�Q =���4/579[88:SeOaSe6�]+6�L>S1OR8:8TX7]�6�8�Se57OaS+O 579[j�576�Q�o7O =R^ 9;8�< 6�STST6�Q�sg<7XIS+OR8:8TX7]�6�8+L7^RSe5I9;L7j OR< ^�XIS�QT9[8 �o7Q:6�`f6�Q:6�L7l�6�8�s Q:6�SeXIQTL78/Se^�8Tl�ORV;6as7^�Q$ORL>= Se579[L7j�6�V[8T6 OR< ^�XIS/Se5I6k`f^RQT] ^a`nXIST9;V[9[SM=�`fX7L7l�ST9;^�LI8 �W\^�Qg8T^R]+6(Oao7o7V;9[l#OaST9;^�LI8�sBW � x h l�ORL,< 6�X78T6�r*OR8-O 8TORL79 SM= lq576�l�� �ST576(r79;8 SeQ:9;<7XIST9;^�L+^R`PO

8:ST^Bl�� � 8 6 Bo 6�l�Se6�r�OR8 �1o7Q:9;l�6k8:57^�X7V[r{OaV $_O =d8$W � x h ST576kr79;8 SeQ:9;<7XIST9;^�L ^R`PST576k6� Bo 6�l�ST6�r{<79;r3sORL7r OR8%LI6�$ 9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L l�^�]�6�8%9[L3s�Se576 XIo r\O Se6�r OR8 � r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL 8T57^RX7V;r 8:ST9;V[V_W � x hSe5I6 X7o r\OaSe6�r�<79;r � 8 r79;8 SeQT9[<7XIST9;^�L �$KML�^RST576�Q(Oao7o7V;9[l#OaST9;^�LI8�sY9[S 9;8�O1X78T6m`fX7V�OR8:8TX7]�oIST9;^�L �-^�LI6<79[r7r76�QP] O#=k5\O �R6/O 579[j�576�QP6 Io 6�lmSe6�r �aORV[X76�`f^�QnO$j�^d^Br Se5\ORL�ORL7^RST576�Q�s $-579[lq5 $_6_l#ORL ]�^dr76�V<>=%8eO#=d9;LIjkST5\OaS�ST576gZ\QT8 S<79;r7rI6�Q�� 8�r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL ^R` Se576/j�^d^dr � 8�6 Bo 6�l�Se6�r �aORV[X76/W � x hi8�Se5\O S^R` Se576k8:6�l�^RL7r �

D 5\OaS{8T^�Q S*^a` 9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�LH`fQ:^�] Se576 ORX7lmSe9[^�L76�6�Q $_^�XIV;r ^RQ $ ^�X7V[r L7^aS*O 6�l�S2Se579[8^�Q:r76�Q:9;L7j�

��� 6�� 806��!��-L������� R�� -� ��0F=�[%�9E� �1�;�3' �3-������0�D-��� ���!'��$� -L�1�(.D60��-�! &.���#&#"%S'��3F "�E�B�1�;-� ��"\�� 60� .�#N���! *�%��2 �!6�� ��909��1��HT &���1 &�3��F �3�!� �160�3� F �3C3�;-7/�8�2U�3�����T%��7-L�16��$�1 N. -16��3�1�!.$�3F &��<�- "� F=�[%S60�[H��3\7RT &FM &#N���!#"%�I��160��!���3'��$�:F=�[%��!�3C3��������� ��! -� ����!�SF ���3�"���O-!�B�! &-#�0�;-7�160� F �3���3�1����� #& "C��$#& "60�,�('��D�B�! "�A80�1��8E���L�% V '����0���;'9>�$#&�B4 Z 47 *�!6��!��-18>��. �7�!�$ %�&\

Page 23: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

x 9;]�9;V;ORQTV =�s x 6�l�ST9;^�L � � � � t < 6�V;^%$ OR8 � 8 $-576�L ^�L76 ORr �R6�Q:ST9;8:6�]�6�L>S*l�ORL < 60l�V;OR8T8:6�r Oa8� < 6mSTSe6�Q��IST5\ORL2ORL7^aSe576�Q ��K ` ^�L76(o 6�Q:8T^�L,< 6�j�9[L78 $-9[ST5 8T^�]�6io7Q:9;^�Q/OaL7r $_6�QT6(Se^%XIo r\O Se6 $-9[ST5ORr �R6�Q Se9;8:6�]�6�L>S�� Se^ o ^�8 Se6�QT9;^RQ�� sB^RQ $ 6�Q:6�Se^ X7o r7OaSe6 $-9[ST51ORr �R6�Q Se9;8:6�]�6�L>S�� Se^�o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q� s Se576�L%9[`7o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q�� W � x hi8Po ^�8 Se6�QT9;^RQ�� s $_6_l#ORL 8TO#= ST5\OaS��H9;8PO�< 6�S:Se6�QnORr �R6�Q:ST9;8:6�]�6�L>SSe57ORL�� ��4/579;8-9;8 �29;V;jRQT^�] � 8_ORo7o7V[9;l�OaSe9[^�L19;L,579[8 � j�^d^dr L76�$-8�s <7ORr{LI6�$-8��Yo\Oao 6�Q � v 7 � �K `1Se5I6 oIQT9;^RQ rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L78�8TOaSe9[8:` = ST576�]�^�L7^aSe^�L76 V[9 �a6�V;9[57^d^BrDQTOaSe9[^ o7QT^�o 6�Q SM= w Se5I6

� ��b$NPsdr76�Z\LI6�r < 6�V;^%$ | sdST576�L ST576�o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q�r79[8:STQT9;<IXISe9[^�L78Oa` Se6�Q �gO#=R6�8T9;ORL1X7o r\OaST9;L7j $-9[ST5l�^R]+]�^�L09;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L $-9;V[V�ORV[8T^,8eOaST9;8 ` =�Se576 � ��b$NPs�QT6�j>ORQTrIV;6�8:8k^R` $-5\O S�l�^�]+]�^�L09;LB`f^�Q &]+OaSe9[^�L09;8 X78T6�r Se^*XIo r\O Se6 � x 9[L7l�6 ORL>= o\OR9;Qk^R`gr79;8 SeQT9[<7XIST9;^�L78 $-579[lq5 8eO Se9;8 ` =0Se576 � ��b NORV[8T^�8TOaSe9[8:` = W � x h s"� ��b$N oIQT9;^RQT8j�X\ORQTORL>Se6�6 �gO#=�6�8:9UORL,o ^�8:ST6�Q:9;^�Q:8�$-579[lq5,ORQT6 ^�QTr76�QT6�r < =W � x h �4/579;8_9;8 ST576i8 SqOaST6i^R` Se5I6iV;9 Se6�QTOaSeXIQT6 �P4/579;8_QT6�8:X7V[S/ORo7o 6#ORQ:8_9;L1O�r79;8:l�Q:6�Se6i`f^RQT] 9;L D 5I9[STS

� �#C � sI9;L �29;V;jRQT^�] � v 7 � s7ORL7r,9[L 8T^�]�6i^R`�Se5I6(o\ORo 6�QT8gST5\OaSgST576�= l�9 Se6 � � 9 � 57lq5\ORLIr\ORL79Fs x 6�j�ORVysORL7r x 5\OaQT]+O � C � rI^+O�8T9[]+9[VUORQ�Se5I9;L7j $-9[ST52O�8:9;]�o7V;9 Z\6�r 8:6�STX7o �4/579;8%lq57ORoISe6�Q�6� Bo7V;^RQT6�8 ST579;8%Q:6�8:X7V[S � KkZ\QT8 S�8T57^%$ 9[L x 6�lmSe9[^�L t � v � t ST5\OaS ST576�� ��b N

9;8 < ^RSe5 8:X ��l�9[6�L>S#s�Oa8�r79[8Tl�XI8T8T6�r 9;L Se576+V;9[ST6�QTOaSeX7Q:6RsPORL7r LI6�l�6�8T8TORQ:= `f^�Q o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q:8 $-5I9;lq5ORQ:6%j�X\ORQTORL>Se6�6�r ST^,< 6�^�Q:r76�Q:6�r < =�W � x h � 4/576�L 9;L x 6�l�ST9;^�L t � �7s�K ]�^dr79[` =,Se5I6�ST576�^RQT6�]Se^ rI6�8Tl�QT9[< 6�O 8:9[STX\OaSe9[^�L $-576�QT6%o ^�8:ST6�Q:9;^�Q:8(ORQT6�^�QTr76�QT6�r LI^RS(<>=�W � x h s <IXIS(<>=�8 SqOaST9;8:ST9;l�88TXIlq5DOR8 Se5760]�6�r79;ORL � 4/579[8{Q:6�8TXIV[S2QT6�cdXI9;QT6�82ST5\OaS2o7X7<IV;9;l�9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�LH< 60V;^Rj!&Ml�^�L7l#O �R6w `f^RQ(6� IOR]�o7V;6as�ST576�l�^�]�]�^�L0L7^�QT]+ORV�rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L | s ORL7r o7QT9 �aOaSe6%9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L�< 6%`fQT^�]�OSeQTORL78:VUOaST9;^�L ` OR]+9[V[= ��WY^RQPSe5I^�8T6/Oao7o7V;9[l#OaST9;^�LI8 $-5I9;lq5 `f^dl�X78�^RL�Se576_]+6�r79UORL sR8TXIlq5+Oa8�o ^RV;9[ST9;l�ORVc X76�8 Se9[^�L78$^�Q/8T^�]�6iSM=do 6�8 ^a` �:X7Q = 8T9 SeX\O Se9;^RL78�sIST576�8:6 l�^�L7r79 Se9[^�L78/ORQ:6 ORV;V Se5\OaS$9[8/L76�l�6�8T8TORQ:= �

D 9[ST579;L*ST576 l�^�L>Se6� dSk^R`�ST576 j�6�L76�QTORVnL7^aSqOaST9;^�L*`f^RQ�X7o r\OaST9;L7j1^Ro 6�QeOaST^�QT8i9[L>SeQT^dr7X7l�6�r�9[Lp 5\ORoBSe6�Q ��sSe5762^�< �d9;^�X78�L76 dS c X76�8:Se9[^�LH9[8 �257^%$ ` ORQ�l�ORL�ST576�8:6{Q:6�8TXIV[Se8�< 6{j�6�L76�QTORV;9 ��6�r< 6�=�^RL7r �gO#=R6�8T9;ORL2X7o r7OaSe9[L7j�p ORV �R6�Q S � � u � l�V;OR9;]�8 ST5\OaS � � � � � ST576�Q:6 9;8 LI^RSe579[L7j�]+ORj�9;l�ORVOR< ^�XIS �gO#=R6�8�� 8�QTX7V[6 Se5\O S

8T5I^�X7V;r%l�ORX78:6gX78�Se^�< 6�V;9;6 ��6as�9;L%Oar �aORL7l�6as�Se5\O S�Oir79 6�QT6�L>SnQTX7V[6 $_^RX7V;r c X\OaV;9[SeOaSe9 ��6�V[=klq5\ORLIj�6^�X7Q(l�^�L7l�V;X78:9;^�L78kOa< ^�XBS(Se576�QeO Se9;^RL\ORV X78T6�^R` � � � � � 9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L ��� x 6�l�ST9;^�L t � 6 8T57^%$-8kSe5\O SSe5I6�QT6 ����8:^�]�6�Se5I9;L7j�]+ORj�9[l#ORV�Oa< ^�XBS �gO#=�6�8�� 8�QTX7V[6Rs�ORLIr Se5\OaS�^RSe5I6�Q Q:6#OR8:^�L\OR<7V[6 ]�6�ST57^BrI8^R`PX7o r\OaSe9[L7j%r7^�L7^RS-57O �R6 ST576kl�^�LI8T9;8 Se6�L7l�=,o7Q:^�o 6�Q:SM=1^R` o7QT6�8T6�Q��d9;L7j�Se576 � ��b$N�`f^�Q $-5I9;lq5

Page 24: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� u�gO#=�6�8�� 8-QTX7V[6�9;8`fQT6�cdXI6�L>SeV =1l�9 Se6�r 9;L ST576iV;9 Se6�QeOaSTX7QT6!�nK ` $_6(< 6�V[9;6 ��6 ST5\OaSgST576 � ��b$N 8:57^�X7V[r< 6�o7Q:6�8T6�Q �R6�r3s7ST576�L $ 6i< 6�V;9[6 �R6$ST5\OaS �_O =R6�8:9UORL X7o r\OaST9;L7j 9;8�Se576�l�^�Q:QT6�lmSg]�6�ST57^Br+^R` ORj�jRQT6 &j>OaST9;L7j%9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L �

�_XISkOa8�o7Q:^ �R6�L�9[L x 6�lmSe9[^�L t � v � t s �_O =R6�8:9UORL�X7o r\OaST9;L7j+r7^d6�8iL7^aSij�X\OaQeORL>Se6�6�o ^�8:ST6�Q:9;^�Q:8^�Q:r76�Q:6�r1<>= W � x h j�9 �R6�L ORQ:<79[STQeORQ =�o7QT9[^�QT8^�Q:r76�Q:6�r1<>= W � x h � Se576$o7Q:9;^�Q:8 L76�6�r1ST576�]�^�QT6QT6�8:STQT9;lmSe9 ��60]+^RL7^RSe^RL76�V;9 �R6�V[9;57^d^dr QeOaST9;^ o7Q:^�o 6�Q:SM= � 4/5I6�^�Q:6�] ��6 8T5I^ $-8,Se5I9;82ORj>OR9[L3s$< =r76�8Tl�Q:9;<79[L7j+ST576 `fXIV;V�8T6mS(^R`�X7o r\OaST9;L7j+^�o 6�QeO Se9;^RL78 $-579;lq5 $-9[V;V j�X\OaQeORL>Se6�6 W � x h o ^�8:ST6�Q:9;^�Q:8j�9 ��6�L W � x h o7Q:9;^�Q:8 ��4/579[8 8:6�S ^R` ^�o 6�QTOaSe^RQT8�l�^�LI8T9;8 Se8 ^R` ST57^�8T6 $-579;lq5�SqO �a6�V[9;L76�ORQ $_6�9;j�5>ST6�rO ��6�QeORj�6�8/^R` Se5I6�9;Q_9;L7o7XBSe8�sIORL7r l�^�L78ToI9;l�XI^�X78TV = 6 Bl�V;XIr76�8 �gO#=R6�8T9;ORL,X7o r\OaSe9[L7j `fQ:^�] Se576i8:6�S �

� �� � ���(!��# �#��� ��. ���%��� �

x O#= Se5\OaS Se576�QT6 OaQT6+S $ ^�l�^R]+o 6�ST9;L7j{QT6�8:6#ORQ:lq576�Q:8�s $-57^�< ^RSe5�� L7^%$ Se5I61l�^�LIr79[ST9;^�L\OaVrI9;8 &SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL enw�� q | w $-9 Se5 d� q�� � | sP<IXIS�57O �R6�o7Q:9 �aOaST6 oIQT^�<\Oa<79;V[9[SM=1rI6�L78:9[SM=,`fX7L7lmSe9;^RL78/`f^�Q q sf � w q | ORL7r f�� w q | � � 8T8:X7]+6 Se5\OaS�ORV[V�`fXIL7l�ST9;^�L78 5\O ��6 8 SeQ:9;l�STV[=,o ^�8T9 Se9 ��6 �ROaV;X76�8 `f^�Q ORV;V �D�ORL7r q���� w ST5\OaS-9;8�s7Se576m= 5\O ��6k`fX7V[V38TX7oIo ^�Q S | �

� 9 ��6�L O o7QT^�<7OR<79;V[9[SM= r76�L78T9 SM= `fX7LIl�Se9[^�L w Nh(W | f�� w q | r76�8:l�QT9[<79;LIj Se576 o7ORQeOR]�6�ST6�Q q s�gO#=�6�8�� 8�Q:X7V;6iST6�V;V[8gX78$57^%$ ST^�XI8T6 e�w�� q | Se^�X7o r\OaSe6(ST^�o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q/rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L78�� �

��� o:q � w q � | � e�w�� q | f�� w q |N� e�w �� � | f��Mw � |+S � � w t � � |

4=do79[l#ORV[V[=Rs q 9;8�O o\ORQeOa]+6mSe6�Qn8TX7lq5�OR8�O ]+6�ORL3s>ORLIr 9[8�L76 $�r7OaSqOi8:X7lq5�OR8�6� Bo 6�Q:9;]�6�L>SqORV^�<78:6�Q��RO Se9;^RL � � 6�S� < 6 Se576 ^�<78T6�Q �R6�r �aORV;X76�8n^R` � O ` Se6�Q� 9;8P^�<78T6�Q �R6�r3s 9[SP5\OR8nO Z B6�r �aORV[X76Rs8T^j�A�po:q � w q � | 9;8-O `fX7L7lmSe9;^RL2^a`n^�LIV[= q �4/5\OaS{8eOR9[r3sic X76�8:Se9[^�L782^R` $-5I6�Se5I6�Q{ST576 �ROaQT9;^RX781`fX7L7lmSe9;^RL78 f��Mw q | ORL7rl�A� o:q �Mw q � | ORQ:6

^�Q:r76�Q:6�r2^R`nl�^�X7Q:8T6 QT6�c X79[QT6k8T^R]+6(]�6�ST57^BrI8$^a`n^�Q:r76�Q:9;L7j�r79[8:STQT9;<IXISe9[^�L78 � � � �[%���-1 &�3� /�8+'��B�! "��< � FM�;���0- '( ")+�$�!�$�,� �!6� &��<�- �1� '( ")>���1���,�M8>�$��8�#"��\ ����� ������F 8�#&�3I � �BP/�F='��3��V ���BZ

���E'�� 6� "�L� V X��[Z 80�1�$2U�$� � 2U�3�!F 4760 &.D6 N-M��8�8�#& N.$��90#"�=�!�O� �E�� *�!�S�T/�F 9E��� �32 -�D�B�1�;-W�327�16���4 ���1#N' \�� �$4 &�(2U�3�!F=�B�1 &�3� ��#" &F "�E�B�1�;- -L�!���1��- ��2 �!6��S4 �3�!#&'�2U�!�3F .����0-1 &'(���!���1 &�3� I ���E'��16T/0-M.D60����<���- �!6��S80�1��90��9� &#& *�! "�;-8�#N�3.$��'��3�K�16��W�3�16�����-L�!���1��-�\�� �$�!�3I��7/E-L� ��.������! "�T/���/0- 2U���1F�I+���0'�����4 "��2U�3�!F ���1 &�3�K.$�3F ��- "���!6��W2U���1F��25�M#" &C3��#" &6��T�('A2U/0�0. �! "����47 "�16�2U/�#&# -1/�8�8>�3�1��\

Page 25: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �� ��� ��� � ��� � �������� � � ��� ����������� � � ��� �� �� � �� ��x 9[L7l�6 ST579;8i8:6�lmSe9;^RL�j�9 �R6�8(j�6�L76�QTORV�r76mZ\L79[ST9;^�LI8�s SeO �R62� w q | Se^ < 6�ORL>=�N�h(W_s ] ORoIo79;L7j+`fQT^�]�aORV;XI6�8/^R` q �O� ST^�� � ���` Se6�L s�$_6k5\O �R6 O ` OR]�9;V =�^R` QT6�VUOaST6�r,N�h(Wn8 �W\^�Q 6� IOR]�o7V;6as76#ORlq52QT6�8T6�ORQTlq576�Q-] O#=157O �R6

< 6�V;9[6�`f8 $-579[lq5 rI9 6�Q�8TV[9;j�5>SeV = `fQ:^�] ST576�< 6�V;9;6m`f8 ^R`B^RSe576�Q�QT6�8:6#ORQ:lq576�Q:8 � � 6�S�� � � < 6ORL 9[L7r76 sORL7r r76�L7^aSe61O2]+6�] < 6�Q ^R`gSe5I6�` OR]�9;V =�^R`gr79;8 SeQT9[<7XIST9;^�L78 OR8 6�9 Se576�Q � �Mw q | ^�Q�sP6�c X79 �aORV[6�L>SeV =�s� w q � � | � � ` OR]�9;V[=�^R`YN�h(Wn8 9;8 ^�QTrI6�QT6�r $-576�L ORL>= S $ ^i]�6�] < 6�Q:8 � �Mw q | ORL7r���� w q | ORQ:6 ^RQTr76�QT6�r �� ��� ��� ST576k]+^RL7^RSe^RL76(V;9 �R6�V[9;57^d^dr QeO Se9;^%oIQT^�o 6�Q SM= �9[`��W[��\s

� w q � � |� w q � � |

9;8%OaL 9;L7l�QT6�OR8T9[L7j*`fX7L7lmSe9[^�L ^R`Zq �9[`�� � �09 S 9[8�r76�l�QT6�OR8T9[L7j7sORL7r 9;8 l�^�L78:SeORL>S w ^RL76 | 9 `� � � � E ^RST9;l�6iSe5\OaS/ST576�8:6�OaQT6k8:STQT9;lmS-9;L76�c X\ORV;9 Se9[6�8 �#�O �d9;L7j�S $ ^�`fX7LIl�Se9[^�L78Q� � w | ORL7r � � w | 9[8/6�c X79 �aORV[6�L>S-Se^�5\O �d9;L7j�^�LI6k`fXIL7l�ST9;^�L���� w �� � |

$-576�QT6�� � w �� � | � � � w | ORL7rn� � w�� t�| � � � w | � 4/576�QT6m`f^�QT6as Se^�8TO#= � f � w q | � ��b N�8 f � w q | �]�6#ORL78/ST5\OaS f � w q |�� f � w q | 9;8-ORL,9[L7l�Q:6#OR8:9;L7j%`fX7L7lmSe9[^�L,^R` q �&��! � � Z7QT8:S &M^�Q:r76�Q-8 Se^dlq5\OR8:ST9;lkr7^�]�9;L7ORL7l�6!�i� � w q | W � x hi8 � � w q | 9 �`f^RQ-ORL>= l�^�LI8:SqOaL S �

" P�

� � w q |+S q [" P�

� � w q |US q � w t � tR|

� V Se6�Q:L\OaST9 ��6�V[=Rs O(` Oa]+9[V[=Z� wUm � q | 8TOaSe9[8:Z\6�8 W � x h 9 � wUm � q � | W � x hi8 � wUm � q � | `f^RQ�ORV;V%q � [ q � �

� ������>� � �5 ���� � ���� � � � w q | [ � � w q | `f^�QkOaV;V q V;6�8T8iST5\ORL 8T^�]�6%o ^R9;L>S$# s�ORL7rk� � w q | � � � w q |`f^�Q-ORV[V?q[%#���� �!"�� �>!.���>��� � � STQeORLI8TVUO Se9;^RL ` OR]�9;V[=�^a`nr79[8:STQT9;<IXISe9[^�L78_9[8-O%8T6�S-^a`�N�h(Wn8 � w q � � | 8TX7lq5,Se5\O S� w q'&(� � � | � � w q � u>| �-WY^RQ$6 IOR]+oIV;6Rs\ST576 E ^�QT]+ORV r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL78�s*),+.- w � � � | s OaQT6 O�SeQTORL78 &VUO Se9;^RLH` OR]�9;V[= � K�$-9[V;V�^a` Se6�L Q:6�`f6�Q1ST^n� w q � u>| OR8,8T9[]+oIV[= � w q | s $-579[lq5 9;81Se5I6�X7L7r76�QTV[=d9[L7jr79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL $-579;lq529;8/< 6�9[L7j%SeQeOaL78TV;OaSe6�r2<>=/��X7LI9[Se8/ST^�oIQT^dr7X7l�60� w q � � | �

Page 26: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� t4/576�8:6 ST6�QT]�8-ORV[V;^%$ Se576(`f^�V[V;^%$-9;L7j�r76�Z\LI9[Se9[^�L78��

� ��� ��>������� ���&-��.*!4�%(*)������ . e E f � E � �<� f � E � 9#9&,;�3GF%!@>�F�F�� 6 ( ;��%9#9 .*������&-)*� &-6 (*)��#F�()H(a� 9 .:X giF�(*� � � � ����� �4!#�%$ &���(*)+� �4!@&-� o7Q:6�8T6�Q �R6�8-W � x h ! � f � w q | ��� � . f�� w q | !����<9 !@(�. �TF�� ��A�po:q � w q � | ���� ��. �A�po:q � w q � | ;K&-) � 9#9i9 !���(*9 !/F�&�&:� ;��%�?>*�"!@&-��. e�w�� q | � �<� � ��1ZV��=(a� X

� ��� ��>������� � N�Q:6�8T6�Q �d9;LIj�ST576 � ��b N !/. .*!���!#9 � )�9 1 �%(TVW�?(a��X

� �� � .+� ����� � ��� '�� ���#��� ����� �n�(��)�� � ����� � ��� �

� 8(rI9;8Tl�X78T8:6�r OR< ^ �R6Rs W � x h oIQT^ �d9;r76�8 OaL�9;r76�ORVn]�6�ST57^Br0^R`^�Q:r76�Q:9;L7j rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L78�� �_XBSX7LI`f^RQ:SeXIL\OaSe6�V[=RsP9 Sk9;8k6#OR8 =0Se^2l�^�L78 SeQ:X7l�S�6� IOR]�o7V;6�8 $-5I9;lq5 8:57^%$ Se5\O S �gO#=R6�8T9;ORL XIo r\O Se9;LIjr7^d6�8 �?&-� o7QT6�8T6�Q ��6{W � x h �P4/5I9;8%8T6�l�ST9;^�L 8:57^%$-8�5I^ $ Se5I61o7QT^R<7V;6�] l�ORL < 618:X7QT]�^�X7L>ST6�rX78:9;L7j%Se5I6 � � b$N��hi9UORjRQeOR]�] O Se9;l�ORV;V =�saWn9;jRX7QT6 t � �i8T5I^ $-8 Se576$SeQT9[l���X78T6�r 9;L+ST576�V[9[ST6�QeO SeX7Q:6$ST^�6�LI8TX7Q:6�Se5\O S

o ^�8:ST6�QT9[^�QT8/8TOaSe9[8:` =,W � x h � � ��b$NHo7Q:9;^�Q:8/9;]�o7V[= � ��b N o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q:8�s�$-5I9;lq5*9[L SeX7Q:L{9[]+o7V =W � x h o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q:8 �

N�Q:9;^�Q:8 N ^�8:ST6�Q:9;^�Q:8

� ��b N//

��

� ��b$Noo

��8T9;LIj�V;6 &Ml�Q:^�8T8:9;L7j

��

8T9[L7j�V[6 &Ml�QT^�8:8T9[L7j

��W � x h W � x hWn9[j�X7Q:6 t � � ��b$6�VUOaST9;^�L78 Se^�< 6ko7Q:^ ��6�L{9;L Se5I6 8:6�c X76�V

� ������� ��� ��� � ���� � � � � � �� ����� ����� � ����� "!$#

4/576 �aORV[9;r79 SM=�^R` Se576iORQTQ:^ $-8/9[L Wn9[j�X7QT6 t � �kORQT6�o7QT^ ��6�L,9;L ST576�`f^�V[V;^%$-9;L7j 8:SeOaSe6�]+6�L>Se8�sYOaV;VY^R`$-579[lq5{5\O �R6�ORoIo 6�ORQT6�r{9[L,ST576kV;9 Se6�QTOaSeXIQT6(ORLIr&%a^�Q-ORQ:6k6#OR8:9;V[= o7QT^ �R6�L �

Page 27: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� v� �1����! +��b(*� q �_� E � �<� � � w q | � �<� � � w q | 8*( >�&-���4!#����&-� . � � � .:X"��(TVW�?( # �7&�8*(��#F�(.�(*� &,; q .�.*��>�F �TF�� � � � w q | � � � w q | � � X��T; � � w q |�� ��� �W. � � w q | E �TF�(*� # !/.�� .*!#�%$ 9/(���&-!#���@X��9 .�& E � � w q |�� � � w q | � � ;K&-)j� 9#9 q � # � �<� � � w q | � � � w q | [ � ;K&-) � 9#9 q [%# X��*�O&-�#F�(*) 3 &-)+�-. E� �� �� .*!#�%$ 9/(*5a>*)H&�.�.*!#�%$�X

� 4/579;8 ORL7r�^RSe5I6�Q�o7QT^d^R`f8�L7^RS j�9 ��6�L�9;L�Se5I6$< ^drI=�^R` Se576-Se6 BS_ORQ:6$9[L�ST576 ORo7o 6�L7r79 s p 57ORoISe6�Q7 � �

� �1����! 8��T; � �Mw q | !/. � ; � ��!#9 1 &,; .*!#�%$ 9/(*5a>*)H&�.�.*!#�%$�� !/.*�4)�!48:�=�4!@&-��. �TF�(*� �#F�(d; � ��!#9 1 .:� �4!/.TV (�.��� � X

� �1����! �� !#6 (*� � � � �<� q � � E � �<� ��;��=�?>*�4!@&-��. enwd� q | 3Q!#�#F ;��%9#9Q.*� ����&-)�� &-6 (*)�#F�( )+� �%$%(�. &,; � �<� q X giF�(*�L! ; enwd� q | .:� �"!/.TV (�.��TF�( � ��� � 3Q!#�#F )H(�.7��(�>*�Z�,& q�� �TF�� �Z!/. Ee�w d� t�|�� ��� �W. e�w d� � |�� E �TF�(*� !#� � 9 .�& .:� �4!/.TV (�. �#F�( � ��� � 3Q!#�#F )H(�.7��(�>*�2�7& � �#F�� �2!/. Ee�w t � q |�� ��� �W. enw � � q |�� X

� �1����! ��� � 1 (�.*!4� ��� ����� �4!#�%$'!/. �%&-�?(Z��.*!#�%$���� )+� 3 ;�)H& � � �<� �#F�( .*!#�%$ 9/( � !/.*�4)�!48:�=�4!@&-�e�w �� q | X�giF�(*�D��� !/.*�")�!48:�%�"!@&-� ; � ��!#9 1 f�� w q | .:� �"!/.TV (�. �#F�( � ��� ��� 3Q!#�TF%!#� �#F�( .*������&-)�� &,;e�w �� q | E �#F�(W; � ��!#9 1 &,; ��&�.*�,(*)�!@&-) � !/.*�4)�!48:�=�4!@&-��.2.:� �"!/.TV (�.2�TF�( � ��� � 3Q!#�#F�)H(�.7��(�>*� �7& q X

� (� ��; � 4/579;8(9[8io7QT^ �R6�L 9;L0O1]�^�QT6 jR6�L76�QeORV�8:6�S:Se9;LIj < =�N�Q:^�o ^�8T9 Se9;^RL�� u ORLIr � 6�]+]+O � ����

E ^RST6kORV;8:^ Se5\O S/<>= � 6�]�] O v s78:SeOaSe9[8:` =d9;LIj�Se576 � � b$N $-9 Se5 Q:6�8To 6�lmS-Se^�q 9;8g6�cdXI9 �aORV;6�L>SSe^�8TOaSe9[8:` =d9;L7j%ST576 � ��b N $-9 Se5,QT6�8To 6�lmS ST^ �p 5\OR9[L79;L7j%ST576 OR< ^ �R6kST^�j�6mSe576�Q$jR9 ��6�8/Se576(`f^�V[V;^%$-9;L7j�QT6�8:X7V[S �

� :��0�' (��� � � �� � �<)�!@&-)H.��+&-� q�� ���� � ��&�.*�,(*)�!@&-)H. &-� q ;K&-) � ��1WV��=(a� E 3Q!#�TF%!#� �#F�(.*������&-)*� &,; enw�� q | X giF�� � !/. E f � w q |�� �� �W. f � w q | !����<9 !@(�. �A� o:q � w q � | ��� � . �A�po:q � w q � |;K&-) � ��1 X

� (� ��; � � ��b N o7QT9[^�QT8 ^�LOq � ��b N o ^�8 Se6�QT9;^RQT8i^�LOq w < = � 6�]�] O � | � � ��b N o ^�8 Se6 &QT9[^�QT8 8T9[L7j�V[6 &Ml�QT^�8:8T9[L7j%o ^R8:Se6�QT9[^�QT8 w <>= � 6�]+]+O � | �\8:9;L7jRV;6 & l�Q:^�8T8:9;L7j%o ^�8:ST6�Q:9;^�Q:8 W � x ho ^�8:ST6�QT9[^�QT8/^RL�q w <>= � 6�]�] O tR| � �

Page 28: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �� ������� � � ����� � ��� �W\^�QORL>=�8T6�S ^R`3W � x h V;9 �a6�V[9;57^d^Br `fX7L7l�ST9;^�LI8 f�� w q | s Se576�QT6$9;8 .�& � ( o7Q:9;^�Q�r79[8:STQT9;<IXISe9[^�L e�w�� q |8TXIlq5+Se57OaS�X7o r\OaST9;L7j f $-9[Se5 e ORV $gO#=d8�QT6�8TX7V Se8�9;L�W � x h o ^R8:Se6�QT9[^�QT8 � �:X78 S�X78T6/Se5I6 �$L79[`f^RQT]r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL ^ �R6�Q/Se5I6 8:X7o7o ^�Q:S$^R` Se5I6 f 8�s7`f^�Q/6� IOR]�o7V;6!���# ^%$ 6 ��6�Q�s�9 ` ST576 � ��b N 9[8kL7^RS 8eOaST9;8 Z\6�r w `f^�Q O 8T6mS�^a`go ^�9;L>Se8(jRQT6#O Se6�QkSe57ORL ]�6#Oa8TX7Q:6

��6�QT^ | s$ST576�L ST576�Q:6�9;8 ORV $gO#=d8,O `fX7L7lmSe9[^�L e�w�� q | `f^�Q $-5I9;lq5 Se576�o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q:8 $-9;V[V LI^RS < 6^�Q:r76�Q:6�r*<>={W � x h `f^�Q-8:^�]+6 �aORV;XI6 ^a` �g4/579[8 8:6�lmSe9;^RL�$-9;V[V38T5I^ $ 5I^ $ Se^ l�^�L78 SeQTXIl�S 8TX7lq5O `fX7L7lmSe9;^RL3sISe5 X78$r76�]+^�LI8:SeQTOaSe9[L7j%Se576 � ^�L7V =19[` �Io7ORQ:S$^R` Se576(`f^�V[V;^%$-9;LIj"�� (� - ��� �%���>��� � � ��� !#)�&,; �<)*!@&-)H. f � w q | � �<� f�� w q | .*��>�FO�#F�� � f � w q | ���� ��. f�� w q | >a� �L8*(������� �,(a� � .*!#�%$ ORL>= 9 !���(*9 !/F�&�&:� ;��=�?>*�4!@&-� enw�� q | �7& � � ���� �l; � ��!#9 1�&,; ��&�.*�7(*)�!@&-)�.�! � f � w q |� �� �W. f�� w q | X

� (� ��; � 4/576�^RQT6�] � o7Q:^ ��6�r2Se5\O S-9[` f � w q | � ��b N�8 f�� w q | sBSe576�L2ST576�8:6 o7Q:9;^�Q_r79;8 SeQT9[<7XIST9;^�L788eO Se9;8 ` =,W � x h sYORL7r{l#ORL2< 6 X7o r\OaST6�r*<>=2ORL>=,V[9 �R6�V;9[57^B^dr `fX7LIl�Se9[^�L,Se^+ORL�W � x h ` Oa]+9[V[=�^R`o ^�8:ST6�QT9[^�QT8��{4 ^�o7Q:^ ��6 ST576 ^RST576�Q r79;Q:6�lmSe9;^RL3s�OR8:8TX7]�6+ST576 � ��b$ND9;8 L7^RS 8TOaSe9[8:Z\6�r �*4/5I6�LSe5I6�QT6k9[8/8T^�]�6kQeORL7jR6 w1���B� | ^ �R6�Q $-579;lq5 f � w q |�� f � w q | 9;8/r76�l�Q:6#OR8:9;L7j"�hi6mZ\L76

f � � �� f � w q | q � w1���B� |u q �� w1���B� | s ORL7r f �� �� f � w q | q � wL���B� |

u q �� wL���B� | ���

4/576�L f �� w q | � f �� w q | 9;8 w $ 6#O!�dV = | 9;L7l�QT6�OR8T9[L7j�6 ��6�Q = $-576�Q:6kST576�QTOaSe9[^�9[8 r76mZ\L76�r3s78T^�4/576�^�Q:6�] �l#OaL2< 6kORo7oIV;9;6�r Se^%8:57^%$ ST5\OaS/Q:6�j>ORQ:r7V;6�8T8/^R`�ST576(r79;8 SeQ:9;<7XIST9;^�L e�w�� q | ORL7r Se5I6(^�<78T6�Q �R6�r s�A�po:q � � w q � | W � x hi8Q�A�po:q � � w q � | `f^RQ-ORL>=1Z B6�r �� 6�S enw�� q | < 6$ST576 �$L79[`f^�Q:] � ���B� � r79;8 SeQ:9;<7XIST9;^�L%`f^�QORV[V�q ��4/576�L �A� o:q � w q | � �A�poKq � � w q | OaL7r

�A�po:q � w q | � ��� o:q � � w q | s38:9;L7l�6 Se5I6�={] OaSTlq5*Se5IQT^�X7jR57^�XISiST576�8:X7o7o ^�Q:Si^R` e�w�� q | ORLIr�ORQT6 ��6�Q:^6�V[8T6 $-576�Q:6 �H4/5I6�QT6m`f^�QT6 �A�po:q � w q | W � x hi8j��� o:q � w q | � 8:^���� o:q � w q | l�V;6�ORQTV = r7^d6�8�L7^RS�W � x h�A�po:q � w q | � 4/5 X78�s `f^�Q ORL>={` OR]�9;V =1^R`�r79;8 SeQT9[<7XIST9;^�L78 $-579[lq5�r7^d6�8�LI^RS�8TOaSe9[8:` =,Se5I6 � ��b$N `f^RQ8T^R]+6$QeORLIj�6RsdSe576�QT6�9[8_O r79;8 SeQ:9;<7XIST9;^�L $-9[ST51O 8T]+ORV;V\8:X7o7o ^�Q:S�$-579;lq51l�ORL1< 6�X78:6�r ST^ X7o r\OaST6Se^�j�6mS$L7^�L &MW � x h o ^�8:ST6�QT9[^�QT8�� �

������� �16��W-1/�8�8>�3�1�:��2���� ���� I0���:�0 *2U���1F���� ���� '( N-�!�1 &9�/(�! "���� &-7'(� �0���;'�����80��<������\� � 6���-1�@'( N-�!�1 &9�/(�! "���0- ���$�;'A�!� 9E� F /0#*�! "8�#& &��'�9T%S� .$�3�0-L�!�3�,� �!� &�,�1��<3�D�B�1���1� �����3I(9�/��7�16��@.����0-L�!���,� &-

.�#&���3�1#&%= &�1�!�$#&�$HB���,�;\

Page 29: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �4/576 �$L79[`f^�Q:] r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL 9[8Pl�6�Q SqOR9[L7V[=k6 Il�6�oIST9;^�L7ORVys 5\O �d9;L7j V;9;]�9[ST6�r(8:X7o7o ^�Q:S�ORL7r�^RL7V[=

S $ ^ �aORV[X76�8-^R`<� w q | � x ^+OR8$O%`fXIQ:Se5I6�Q-6�] < 6�V[V;9[8T57]�6�L>S#sBl�^�LI8T9;rI6�Q/Se579[8/r79;8 SeQ:9;<7XIST9;^�L �

) +���� ���

��� � R����� ������� ��� R���� r � �� &�� ���Jr��G�

��� � R����� !�"�#�� ��� R���� r [ ��

w t � v�|

4/576ir79[8:STQT9;<IXISe9[^�L�ORo7o7Q:^>ORlq576�8_Se576 � LI9[`f^�Q:] r79;8 SeQT9[<7XIST9;^�L�OR8$�_j�^d6�8�Se^ ��6�Q:^7sI<7XBS_9 S_5\Oa8`fX7V[V_8TXIo7o ^RQ:S#s�L7^�rI9;8Tl�^�L>Se9[LdXI9[Se9[6�8�s�9;8 $ 6#O � V = 8T9[L7j�V[6 &Mo 6#O!�R6�r s OaL7r $_^�XIV;r 8:ST9;V[V 8:6�Q �R6*Oa8%Ol�^RX7L>Se6�Q:6� IOR]�o7V;6%`f^�Q ORL ORo7oIQT^�o7Q:9UOaST6�V =*8:] ORV[V%� � x ^,Se576�QT6�9;8kL7^RST579;LIj2XIL79;c X76�OR< ^�XISkSe5I68TXIo7o ^RQ:S$^�Qg`f^�Q:] ^R`PSe576 � LI9[`f^�Q:] r79[8:STQT9;<IXISe9[^�L �

� �� � �#���i��������� ���n!�� �������

4/579[8n8T6�l�ST9;^�L Z\LIr78�l�^RL7r79[ST9;^�LI8 $-576�QT6/OaL = SeQTORL78:VUOaST9;^�Lk` OR]�9;V[= w $-579[lq5%] O#= ^�Q ] O#= L7^RSn8eOaS &9;8 ` = Se5I6 � ��b$N | V[6#ORr78�Se^ ^�Q:r76�Q:6�r o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q:8 ��K ` f w q � � | 9;8OkSTQeORLI8TVUO Se9;^RL�` Oa]+9[V[=�OR8 o 6�Q�Se5I6r76mZ\L79[ST9;^�L,9[L x 6�l�ST9;^�L t � t � ��s7Se576�L f w q � t�| W � x hi8 f w q � � | � �_XIS OR8$r79;8:l�X78:8T6�r�OR< ^ ��6Rs W � x ho7Q:9;^�Q:8�ORQT6/L7^aS 8:X ��l�9[6�L>S�Se^kj�X\ORQTORL>Se6�6 W � x h o ^R8:Se6�QT9[^�QT8�sd8:^k9;L78 Se6#Oar3sdOkLI6�$ ^�Q:r76�Q:9;L7j $-9[V;V< 6 ^! 6�QT6�r �4/576gSeQ:9;l�� 9;8PST^(8T6mS�X7o�ORL�� ��b$N SeQTORL78:VUOaST9;^�L ` OR]+9[V[=(`f^�Q Se576g`fXIL7l�ST9;^�L XI8T6�r�Se^(XIo r\O Se6Rs

ORL7r,Se5I6�L2r7^�ORL*Oao7o7QT^Ro7QT9;OaSe6(l�^B^�Q:r79;L7OaSe6�STQeORLI8:`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L ��K S-QT6�V;9;6�8/^�L Se576(`f^�V[V;^%$-9;LIj"�

� (� - ��� �%���>��� � ��;��%�?>*�4!@&-�O!/. 9/&a$ 5a>�&-�?>a� 6 (2! � !#�#. �4)a� ��.*9 � �4!@&-��; � ��!#9 1�.:� �"!/.TV (�. � ��� � X

W\^�Q$O�o7Q:^B^a` s\8T6�6 ��6�l�� 57^�XIrISkORL7r � ^�V;9[6�Q � � ��� sY8T6�lmSe9[^�L ��� ���'& K S $-9;V;V < 6kX78:6�`fX7V�Se^�L7^RST6`f^�Q-VUO Se6�Q-Q:6�`f6�Q:6�L7l�6 ST5\OaS$Se579[8$Q:6�8:X7V[S r7^d6�8$L7^RS r76�o 6�L7r*^�L2ST576 ` Oal�S-Se5\O S ST576 9[L>Se6�jRQeORV ^R`�ON�h(W ^ �R6�Q$9[ST8/6�L>Se9[QT6(r7^�]+OR9[L 9;8/^�L76!�p ^�L78:9;r76�QkST579;8iORV[ST6�QTL7OaSe6 8:6�STX7o � e �Mw�� q | 9[8(O1SeQTORL78TV;OaSe9[^�L*` OR]�9;V =�sYSqO � 9[L7j `fX7L7l�ST9;^�LI8i^R`

Se5I6 `f^�QT] e�w �� q | ORL7r ]+OaSelq5I9;L7j2Se576�] Se^*O*8T9[L7j�V[6+`fX7L7lmSe9[^�L f w q | 9;L rI9 6�QT6�L>S o ^�8T9 Se9;^RL78�sOR8 r79;lmSqOaST6�r <>= � � �gORQ:QT9[L7j*O2`f6�$ r76mSqOR9[V;8(Se^{< 6+r79;8:l�X78:8T6�r < 6�V[^%$ksnSe579[8 9[8 6�c X79 �aORV[6�L>S ST^

( � 6��$% �1�$2U�$�M�1�O�16�� ��� ��! �3- �16�� � �������!�3��� ! �!�39E��9� &#" "�%"�:�B�! "� � ��! � � 8��!�38>�$�1�%3I �!��-1�$�!HT "�0<K�160��0�3FM� F �3�0���1����� #" &C3��#" &6��T�('S�D�B�! "� 8��!�38>�$�1�% 2U�3��-L��FM�$�16� &��< �$#N-1�3\

Page 30: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

��65\O �d9;L7j2O1SeQTORL78:VUOaST9;^�L�` OR]�9;V = f��Mw q | s $-5I^�8T6�]+6�] < 6�QT8kOaQT6%]+OaSelq576�r ST^,^�L76�ORL7r ^�L7V =�^�LI6r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL e�w�� q | �4/579;8 �R6�Q:8T9;^RL 9;8_ST576(]+^dr76�V OR< ^ ��6as"$-576�Q:6 f3w q � � | 9;8_8To 6�l�9 Z\liSe^%9[L7r79 �B9[r7X\ORV ��ORLIr e�w�� q |

9;8 O 8T9[L7j�V[6Rs�l�^�]�]�^�L�`fX7L7lmSe9;^RL �+4/5I6+8 =B]�]�6�SeQ =�^R` sbq sPORL7r ��c X\OaSe9[^�L t � ��ORV[V;^%$-8iSe5I9;8 �# ^%$ 6 �R6�Q�s$Se576�l�^�L7r79 Se9[^�L78�^R` � 6�]�] O�� 5\O ��6�8T5I9[` Se6�r � 9;LHST576�ORV Se6�Q:L\OaST6*8T6mSeX7o s 9 S $_OR8L76�l�6�8:8eORQ = Se57OaS�ST5761` OR]�9;V[= e � w �� q | 8TOaSe9[8:` =0Se5I6 � ��b N sn<7XIS 576�Q:6 Se576 f��Mw q | ` OR]�9;V =�L76�6�r^�L7V =*8TOaSe9[8:` ={SeQeOaL78TV;OaSe9[^�L3s 9[L�] OaL =�$gO#=d8 ORL�6#OR8:9;6�Q(l�^�L7rI9[Se9[^�L*ST^28TOaSe9[8:` = ����#$^ $ 6 �R6�Q�sPSe5I6`fX7L7lmSe9[^�L e�w�� q | ]�X78:S�L7^%$ 8TOaSe9[8:` = V[^�j!& l�^�L7l�O �B9 SM= w 8T9[L7l�6,9[ST8%SeQeOaL78TV;OaSe9[^�L ` OR]�9;V = 5\Oar ST^8eO Se9;8 ` =1Se5I6 � � b$N | �4/576g8 SqOaST6�]�6�L>S�Oa< ^�XBSPST576_o ^�8:ST6�Q:9;^�Q ORV[8T^�lq57ORL7j�6�8n9;L Se576 ]+^dr79 Z\6�r l�^d^�QTrI9;L\OaST6�8:=d8:ST6�] �

Se^ l�V;ORQT9 ` =�s K�o7QT6�8T6�L S_Se576$`f^�V;V[^ $-9[L7j(` ORl�S�s $-5I9;lq519[8STQTX76$`f^�Q_OaL =�o\Oa9;Q^R`3`fX7L7lmSe9[^�L78 e ORL7r f �

"��

�e�w | f w � Sd|+S � "�� ���

� ���e�w & Sd| f3w |+S � w t � � |

Wn9;jRX7QT6 t � t 8:57^%$-8�ST579;8nj�QeORoI579;l�ORV;V = �3ST576gV[6�` S & 5\ORL7r%8:9;r76_^R` ��c X\O Se9;^RL t � �(]�X7V[ST9;o7V[9;6�8�Se5I6�aORV;XI6�8^R` f w | 9[L�ST576 Q:6�j�9[^�L�< 6mS $_6�6�L � �OS ORL7r � �OS <>=%Se576 �aORV;X76�8 ^a` e�w | < 6�S $ 6�6�L �ORL7r � �4/5I6(QT9;jR5 S &M5\OaL7r18T9[r76(^R`�Se5I6i6�c X\OaST9;^�L,] XIV[Se9[o7V;9[6�8�Se5I6(8eOR]�6 �aORV;XI6�8g^R` f w | 9;L1Se5I6QT6�j�9;^RL+< 6�S $ 6�6�L � �nS ORLIr � �nS <>=�Se576 �aORV;XI6�8^R` e�w & Sd| 9;L�Se5I6 Q:6�j�9[^�L+< 6�S $ 6�6�L � �nSORL7r � �LS � x 9[L7l�6�ST576 �aORV[X76�8g^a` e�w | 9;L ST576iZ\QT8 S/QT6�j�9;^RL ORL7r enw & Sd| 9[L Se576�8T6�l�^�L7r2ORQ:6Se5I6 8TOR]�6Rs7Se5I6 6�c X\OaSe9[^�L,57^�V[r78 �� 6�SnST576 p h(W{^R`B�A�po:q � w�� q | X7o Se^ � < 6�� � ) �MwL�� q | �'��c X\OaST9;^�L t � �(ORV;V[^%$-8 XI8nSe^ QT6�$-Q:9[ST6

Se5I6�L X7]�6�QeO Se^�Q-^R`��� � ) �MwL��� q | w 8T6�6 ��c X\OaST9;^�L t � � | sYX78T9[L7j � � &�� s � � u s ORL7r S � � ��*O � 9[L7j%Se576k8TXI<78:ST9[SeXBSe9;^RL{OaL7r2ST576�L2L76�OaSe6�L79;L7j�Se5I6 LI^RSqOaST9;^�L �

"��

R Pe�w | f3w � � |US � " �

R Pe�w & � | f3w |+S d�

� � � �3-1 "��� �+-16��3/�#N' ���3� 9>� �!��C��$� �1�T�S#& *�!�$�D��#&#"% 60�$�!��� �160�$�!�M�3�1� 2?��F "#& &��- 476� N.D6O-!�B�1 N-L2U% ��� ��! 9�/(�@���!����3� �!�!�3�0-1#&���1 &�3� 2?�3FM &#& "�;- �?-1/0.D6���-��16���� 6� �]-��,/0���!��' '( &-L�1�! &9�/(�1 &�3�E- ��IJ���0' �1�D���E-L#N�B�! "��� 2?��F &#" &��- 476� N.D6O'�����3� -!�B�! &-L2U%"��� ��! \ �:�B4 �$H��$�;I *� &-M�;�3-1 "���W�1�SP/0-L�1 "2U% F �T'��$#&#" &��<K�4 � 8>�$��8�#&��60�[HT &��<K9>�$#& "�$2?- 476� N.D6 ���!��1�D���E-L#N�B�! "���0-7��2 �;�3.D6 �3�16���� �!60��� �!�A���(8�#N�� &�K476T%��4 �A8>�$��8�#&� 4 �3/�#N' 60�[H��@9E��#" &��2?- 476� N.D6���� ��! ��'��;�3.D6���!6��$�;\

Page 31: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

��7

Wn9[j�X7Q:6 t � t � �i9;8:X\ORV Oa9;r `f^�Q ��c X\OaSe9[^�L t � �

9 � 6 � s" �R P

enw | f w �� &�� |US � " �

R Pe�w�� � | f w |+S �

4/576 V[6�` S &M5\ORLIr 9[L ST6�j�QTORV�9;8kX7o Se^{O2Z B6�r o ^R9;L>Sk9;L0Se576�l�^d^�Q:r79;L\O Se6�8To\Oal�6Rs�ORL7r l�^�X7V[r< 6 $-Q:9[S:Se6�L2OR8/ST576kLdXI]+6�QeOaST^�QgSe^ �� � ) R � w u�| � �_XIS-ST576kQT9;jR5 S &M5\OaL7r 9;L>Se6�j�QeOaV39;8/X7o,Se^�Se5I6]�^ �d9[L7j%9;L7rI6� `f^�QgST576(SeQTORL78TV;OaSe9[^�L1` OR]�9;V = � � � ) � w � | �

D 6 � L7^%$ ST5\OaS�Se576-V[6�` S�8T9[r76-8eOaST9;8 Z\6�8W � x h s ORL7r�8T^ 9;8�9[L7l�Q:6#OR8:9;L7j OR8 ��9;L7l�QT6�OR8T6�8 w Se5\O S9;8�s\OR8$& ��` OaV;V;8 | �B8T^�Se576kQT9[j�5>S & 5\ORL7r 8:9;r76k] X78 S ORV;8:^%< 6k9;LIl�QT6�OR8T9[L7j�OR8 ��9;L7l�QT6#Oa8T6�8��x 9;LIl�6 e � w�� q | $_OR8 O SeQTORL78:VUOaST9;^�L*` Oa]+9[V[= $-579;lq508TOaSe9[8:Z\6�8kST576�� ��b$N `f^�QkORL>={Z B6�r s

N�QT^�o ^�8:9[Se9[^�L 7 8eO#=d8$ST5\OaS e�w �� q | w O!�aO e�w�� q |:| ] X78 S < 6kV;^�j &Ml�^RL7l#O ��6(jR9 ��6�L �

4/576k`f^�V;V[^ $-9[L7j 8 SqOaST6�]�6�L>S$5\OR8-L7^%$ < 6�6�L{o7Q:^ ��6�L{9;L Se5I6 LI6�$Dl�^B^�Q:r79;L7OaSe6i8 =d8:Se6�]��

� :��0�' (��� B �T; f�� w q | !/.2���")+� ��.*9 � �4!@&-� ; � ��!#9 1�&,;W�<)�!@&-)H.j� �<� e�w�� q | !/.j��9/&a$ 5a>�&-�?>a� 6 ( 9 !���(*59 !/F�&�&:� ;��%�?>*�"!@&-��;K&-) � ��1'$ !#6 (*� E �#F�(*� � � ) � w � | !/. � �n!#�?>*)H(a�-.*!#�%$Z;��%�?>*�4!@&-�L&,; � X4/579;8(]�6#OaL78iSe5\O S(`f^�QiV;^%$ �aORV;X76�8i^R`��Ts ]�^�8:Si^R` ST576%r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL�9;8(Oa< ^ ��6 � w Se5\OaSi9;8�s

�g9[8�< 6�V;^%$DST576 ]�6�r79;ORL*^R`�ST576�rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L*jR9 ��6�L � | s $-579[V;6k`f^�Q�579[j�5��aORV[X76�8 ^R` �g]�^�8:S ^R`Se5I6 rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L 9;8/< 6�V[^%$,� w ST5\OaS-9[8�s*��9;8-Oa< ^ ��6kSe5I6 ]�6�rI9UORL j�9 ��6�L � | �� ��� � �5�����5!)$��%� � ��� ���� � � � & �'������ �!"� ; 4���#�������� #$^ $ 8T57ORV;V $_6k9[L ST6�Q:o7QT6mSgSe576(V[^�j!&l�^RL7l#O �d9[SM=2^R` e�w�� q | 9[L2ST6�Q:]+8$^R`Gq p ^�L78:9;r76�Q$ST576 <I9 �aORQT9;OaSe6 `fX7L7l�ST9;^�L e � w d� q | �%�\ � C� � s $-576�QT6 e � wd� q | � e�w�� q | ��4/576(^RL7V[=�l�^RL7l�6�oISeX\OaV3OR8 =B]�]�6�SeQ =�< 6mS $_6�6�L ORL7r q�9;8Se5\O S

Page 32: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

��CN���e � wd� � |+S �,] XI8:S/< 6iZ\L79 Se6Rs $-579;V[6 N

���e � w � � q |+S � ]+O#=+SeO �R6(^RL{OaL = �aORV;X76!� x ^�]�6(^R`�Se5I6

QT6�8TX7V Se8 OR< ^�XIS N�h(Wn8�V;9;8 Se6�r�ST^ ST579;8�o ^�9;L>SORo7oIV[= $-576�L $ 6 57^RV;r Z B6�r1OaS�� <7XISV;6mSWq �aORQ:=OR8 $-576�L $ 6 5I^�V;rkq_Z� I6�r*O S �q_ORL7r2V;6mS �aORQ =��W\^�Q 6 IOR]+oIV;6RsBORL>=�L7^�L7LI6�j>OaST9 �R6RsIl�^�L>Se9[LdXI^�X78�sBV;^�j &Ml�^RL7l#O ��6$`fX7L7lmSe9;^RL l#OaL1L7^RS 5\O ��6�S $ ^

V;^dl#OaV3] O I9[] O ��K ` e � wd� �q | 8eO Se9;8 Z\6�8$V;^Rj!&Ml�^�L7l#O �d9[SM=+`f^�Q-ORL>= Z B6�r �qms7Se576�L e � wd� �q | 9;8/8:9;L7jRV;6 &o 6#O �a6�r � x 9;]�9;V;ORQTV =�s>9 ` e � w �d� q | 8eOaST9;8:Z76�8-V;^�j &Ml�^RL7l#O �d9[SM=+`f^�Q/ORL>=1Z B6�r�� s7Se5I6�L e � w �b� q | ] X78 S< 6 6�9[ST576�Q/8:9;L7j�V[6 & o 6�O �R6�r3s\]+^RL7^RSe^RL79;l�ORV;V =�r76�l�QT6#Oa8T9;LIj7s\^�Q/]�^�L7^RST^�L79;l�ORV;V =�9;L7l�QT6#Oa8T9;LIj"�K ` e � w �d� q | 9;8�V;^Rj!&Ml�^�L7l#O �R62`f^�Q�ORL>= Z B6�r�� s_Se5I6�L e � w �d� q | 8TOaSe9[8:Z\6�8�ST576 � � b$N�$-9[ST5

QT6�8To 6�lmS ST^+OaL = SeQeOaL78TV;OaSe9[^�L ^R`P9[Se8:6�V ` ��W\^�Q/6� IOR]�o7V;6as e � w �b� q | � ��b$N�8 e � w �d� q � 7 | �� o\OR9;Q_^R`P`fXIL7l�ST9;^�L78 $-5I9;lq528eOaST9;8:` = Se576 � ��b$N�l#OaL{L7^aS-l�QT^R8T8$]+^�Q:6�Se57ORL{^RL7l�6!� x 9;L7l�6

e � wd� �q | � � b$N�8 e � w � 7 � �q | s Se5I6�S $_^ `fX7LIl�Se9[^�L78i8TOaSe9[8:` ={8T9[L7j�V;6 &Ml�QT^�8:8T9;LIj ^�QirI^1L7^RS(l�QT^�8:8OaS$ORV[V �dSe576k8eOa]+6(9[8gSeQTXI6 $-5I6�L e � w �d� q | � � b$N�8 e � w � � q � 7 | �x ^1OaV[Se5I^�X7j�5 e � w �d� q | 9;8$L7^RS O N�h(W_sY]+ORL>=,^R`nST576 9[]+oIV;9;l�OaSe9[^�L78g^a`�V;^Rj!&Ml�^�L7l#O �d9[SM=18:Se9[V;V

57^�V[r3s78:^�]+6mSe9[]+6�8 $-9[ST5{]�9;L7^RQ_]�^Br79 Z\l#O Se9;^RL �

� �� ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� � �$� ��� KML>SeX79 Se9 ��6�V =�s OR8�]+^RQT6 9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L ORoIo 6�ORQT8�s_^�L76,]+O#= 6� Bo 6�l�S�Se57OaS�Se576 �aORQT9[^�X78�o7Q:9 �aOaSe6o ^�8:ST6�QT9[^�QT8nl�^�L ��6�QTj�6-Se^%$_ORQTr+Oi8T9[L7j�V[6gr79;8 SeQ:9;<7XIST9;^�L � �iL76/]+O#= 6#Oa8T9;V =�l�^�L78 SeQTXIl�Sl�^�XIL ST6�Q:6� &OR]�o7V;6�8 $-576�Q:6+Se5I9;8k9;8(` ORV[8T6Rs <7XIS 9;L0Se5I6+l�OR8T6�$-576�Q:6+< ^RSe5 ^R`_ST576+OR< ^ �R6+Se5I6�^�Q:6�]�8 57^RV;r3sSe5I6�L ST579;8 9;8 9;L7rI6�6�r Se576+l#OR8:6 �24/579;8 8T6�lmSe9[^�L 8:SeOaSe6�8 ST576��:^�9[L>S�Q:6�8TXIV[S `f^�QT]+ORV;V =�ORLIr Se5I6�Lj�9 ��6�8$O%r76mSqOR9[V;6�r,r76�8Tl�QT9;oBSe9;^RL2^a`n57^%$ Se576kr79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL78gl�^R]+o7Q:6�8:8 9[L ST^�^�L76(r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL �

� �' (������!. � � �#;2�#F�(0�<)*!@&-)H. � )H('� �4)+� ��.*9 � �"!@&-�'; � ��!#9 1�3GF%!@>�F .:� �4!/.T;�1��#F�( � ��� � E � �<� � )H(������� �,(a� ��.*!#�%$ � 9/&a$ 5a>�&-�?>a� 6 ( � !/.*�4)�!48:�=�4!@&-� f w q | E � �<� � � !/.'� ��1 >�&-��.*�@� ��� E �#F�(*� 8*&-�#F

" P�

�A� o:q � w � |US � � �<� " � � �R P

�A�po:q � w � |+S �

� )H( !#�?>*)H(a�-.*!#�%$Z;��%�?>*�"!@&-��.�&,; � ;K&-) � 9#9 X

� �� �'; � 4/5I6oIQT6�]�9;8:6�8 ^R`B< ^RSe5k4/576�^�QT6�]+8 �/ORL7r C/57^�V[r3s ORL7rkSe576�QT6m`f^�QT6�ST576�l�^�L7l�V;X78:9;^�LI8^R`P< ^aSe5 Se576�^�QT6�]+8$ORQ:6k8T9;]�X7V[SeORL76�^RX78TV =+STQTX76!� �

Page 33: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �W\^�Q 8:^�]�6+9[L STX79[ST9;^�L OR8kSe^ $-5\OaS�ST579;8 ]�6#ORL78�s�l�^RL78T9[r76�Q Se576+V;^dl#OaST9;^�L0^R`gST576 ]�6�rI9UORL78

X7L7rI6�QgSe5I6�S $_^�l�^�L7l�V[X78T9[^�L78/Oa< ^ ��6!��4/576(o7QT9[^�QT8 $_6�QT6 O STQeORL78:VUOaST9;^�L+` OR]+9[V[=Rs>]+6�ORL79;LIj�Se5\O S9[` Se5I6 ]�6�r79;ORL2^R` f

�w q | 9;8$OaS u s\ST576�L2Se576 ]+6�r79UOaL2^a` f � w q | 9;8$OaS ��s\Se5I6 ]�6�r79;ORL2^R` f�� w q | 9[8

OaS t s\6mS-l�6mSe6�QTO��� 8/`f^�QgST576ko ^�8 Se6�QT9;^RQT8�s\8TO#=1Se5\O S$ST576k]+6�r79UOaL ^R` ��� o:q

�w q | 9[8 ��6�QT^7s\9 � 6!�[s

" P�

�A� o:q�w � |US � � �

t �

4/576-`f^�V;V[^ $-9[L7jiV[9;L76�8�o7QT^ ��6-<>=�l�^RL STQeORrI9;l�ST9;^�L ST5\OaS�Se5I6$]�6�rI9UORL%^R` Oko ^�8 Se6�QT9;^RQ�r79;8 SeQ:9;<7X &Se9[^�L $-9[ST5,9;L7r76 j�Q:6#OaST6�Q/Se57ORL ��6�Q:^+]�X78:S-< 6(j�QT6�OaSe6�Q/Se5\ORL ��6�QT^ $-576�L p ^�Q:^�V;V;ORQ:= � 57^�V[r78 �p ^�L78:9;r76�QQ�A� o:q � w q | 9;L>Se6�j�QeOaST6�r `fQT^R] & 1Se^�9[LIZ\L79 SM=�s�$-576�QT6 & 9;8-OaL =1L76�j>O Se9 �R6kLdXI] < 6�Q �

" PR �

�A�po:q � w � |+S � [ " P�

�A� o:q � w � |US �

[ " P�

�A� o:q�w � |US � w t � � |

� �t �

KML76�c X\OaV;9[SM= t � � 9[8(ORL ORo7oIV;9;l�OaSe9[^�L*^a` 4/5I6�^�Q:6�] C w $-5I9;lq50QT6�8:SqO Se6�8k4/576�^�QT6�] � | ��4/579[88T6�c X76�L7l�6i^R` 9;L76�cdX7ORV;9 Se9;6�8�r76�]+^�LI8:SeQTOaSe6�8ST5\OaS9[S $ ^�X7V[r+< 6 O l�^�L>SeQeOar79;lmSe9;^RL�`f^RQ�Se576$]+6�r79UOaL^R`A�A�po:q � wUm | Se^ < 6(OaS/ORL>= �aORV;XI6 & V[6�8:8_Se5\OaL ��6�Q:^"���{^�Q:6ij�6�LI6�QeOaV;V[=RsdST576(]�6�r79;ORL1] X78 S/< 6ORL,9;LIl�QT6�OR8T9[L7j%`fX7L7lmSe9;^RL2^a`PST576k9;L7r76 $-576�L76 �R6�QiW � x h 57^�V[r78 �K ` ST576%8T6�l�^�LIr 9[L76�c X\ORV[9[SM={57^�V[r78�s3ST576�L�Se5I6%]+6�r79UORL�^a`b��� o:q � wUm | l#OaL LI^RSk< 6 Se^d^ ] X7lq5

j�Q:6#OaST6�Q/Se5\OaL{Se5I6 ]�6�r79;ORL,^R`?��� o:q�w,m | � � j>Oa9;L3s\Oa8T8TXI]+6kSe5\O S$ST576 ]+6�r79UORL,^R` �A�poKq

�w,m | 9[8 O S

��6�QT^7s\8:^ N �R P �A�poKq�w � |US � � �� �4/5I6�L �

" �

R P�A�po:q � w � |+S � [ " �

R P��� o:q

�w � |+S � w t � 6 |

� �t �

Page 34: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

tRuKML76�c X\OaV;9[SM= t � 6%9;8/`fQ:^�] Se5I6 8:6�l�^�L7r�5\OaV[`P^R`n4/5I6�^�Q:6�] C w $-579;lq52QT6�8:SeOaSe6�8 p ^�Q:^�V;V;ORQ:= �>| �

x ^ Se5I6%]+6�r79UORL�^a` �A�po:q � wUm | l#ORL � Sk< 6%VUORQ:j�6�Q Se5\ORL0^�LI6%9[`�Se576�]�6�r79;ORL�^R`b�A�po:q � wUm | 9;8 ��6�QT^��p ^�] <I9;L79[L7j+< ^RST5*^R`�ST576�8:6 QT6�8:STQT9;lmSe9[^�L78 OaSi^�LIl�6�]�6#OaL78$ST5\OaS�9[`nST576�]�6�rI9UORL{^R`i�A�po:q

�wUm | 9[8

��6�QT^7s Se5I6 ]�6�r79;ORLk^R` ��� o:q � w,m | 9;8 < 6�S $ 6�6�L ��6�Q:^�OaL7r ^RL76 � x 9;]�9;V;ORQTV =�s�ST576�]+6�r79UOaL ^a` �A�po:q R � wUm |9;8/< 6�S $ 6�6�L�L76�j>OaSe9 ��6k^�L76 ORLIr ��6�QT^Is7Se576k]�6�r79;ORL,^R` ��� o:q � wUm | 9;8/< 6�S $ 6�6�L ��6�QT^+ORL7r,S $_^7sY6mSl�6mSe6�QeO�� W\X7Q:ST576�Q�s Se579[8i57^�V[r78iL7^aS(^�L7V =2`f^RQ�Se576%]�6�rI9UORL � Se5\O S�9[8�s $-576�QT6 ST576 p h(W 9;8 �� �<7XIS $-576�QT6+ST576 p h(W 9[8 OaL = �aORV[X76�< 6mS $_6�6�L ��6�Q:^�ORL7r ^�L76asP6!� j"� sPST576%Z\QT8 S�c X\OaQ:Se9[V;6�8 $-9[V;Vl�^R]+o7Q:6�8:8n9;L X7o ^�LkSe576�]+8:6�V �R6�8P9;L O 8T9[]+9[VUORQ ` OR8T5I9;^�L � 4/5 X78�saSe576r79;8 SeQ:9;<7XIST9;^�LI8 < 6�jR9;L 6 ��6�L7V[=8To7ORl�6�r3sY<7XIS Oa` Se6�Q/X7o r\OaSe9[L7j7sIST576�=1l�^�]�o7QT6�8T8$9;L X7o ^�L,Se576�]+8:6�V ��6�8��4/579;8�r79[8Tl�X78T8:9;^�L�ORo7oIV;9;6�8nSe^ ORL>=�^R` ST576 � $_6�9;j�5>Se6�r �gO#=R6�8�� 8QTX7V[6�8��!$-579;lq5 $-9;V[VB< 6-r76�Z\LI6�r

ORL7r2r79[8Tl�XI8T8T6�r*< 6�V[^ $ �

� �� � �R��� ���2� ��!�� �

# 6�QT6�ORQ:6�O `f6�$ <7QT9[6�`8 �a6�Selq5I6�8 ^R`_5I^ $ Se5I6�^�Q:6�]�8(8TX7lq5 OR8 p ^�Q:^�V;V;ORQ:= � l�^RX7V;r�< 6�ORo7o7V[9;6�r9;L{Se576 rI6�8T9[j�L�^R`�]�^dr76�V[8 ��4/5I6�Z\QT8 S(9;8$SqO �a6�L�`fQ:^�] l�^�L78:X7]+6�Q�Se5I6�^�Q =�s3OaL7r�Se576�8T6�l�^�L7r�9[8`fQT^R] NP^RV;9[ST9;l�ORV x l�9;6�L7l�6!�

� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� � ���� �� � � � � � � ��� � �� 6�S Se576+c X\ORV;9 SM=�^R`-O2]+^ �d9;6�< 6�q��c�$s/OaL7r ST576+L X7]�< 6�Q�^R`/o ^�8:9[Se9 ��6�]�^ �d9[6+Q:6 �d9;6 $-8�< 6 � � x O#= Se57OaS l�^�L78TXI]+6�QT8%5\O ��6 oIQT9;^RQ�< 6�V;9[6�`f8 Se5\OaS�Se576�9;Q�XBSe9;V[9[SM=�`f^�Q�O�j�^d^Br $-9;V;V< 6� � �Mw q | � # � � q s $-576�QT6 # � 9[8�O l�^�L78 SqORL>Si8:l#ORV;ORQ $-5I9;lq5�9[8 8:o 6�l�9[Z7l�Se^+9;L7r79 �d9;r7X\OaV��Ts3OaL7ro7Q:9;^�Q:8/^�L�q + - w u � � | ��W\^�Q-6 7Oa]+o7V[6Rs\OaL*ORlmSe9[^�L,]+^ �d9;6k]+O =1ORo7o 6#ORV3ST^ � o7QT9[V ]+^RQT6iSe57ORL�_^�< s>8T^(Se5\O S�# � [%#

�s><7XIS�9 ` ST576/]�^ �d9[6g9;8 $ 6�V[V7] Oar76_Se5I6�L�< ^aSe5�ORQT6/V[9 �a6�V[=kST^ 6�L �:^ = Se5I6

]�^ �d9[6%]+^�Q:6 �%4/576�QeOaL7r7^�] �aORQ:9UOR<IV;6 r76�o 6�L7rI8 ^�Lnq �B9;O1Se576 �:^�9[L SkrI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L e�w �� q | s$-579[lq5 9[8(O �_9 �aORQ:9UOaST6 E ^RQT]+ORVnr79[8:STQT9;<IXISe9[^�L � L7^%$-L ST^,ORV;VPl�^�L78:X7]�6�QT8��%4/576�L < ^aSe5 � o7Q:9;VORL7r �_^R<%l#ORL�^�<78:6�Q���6 ORLIr�ST576�L�X7o r\OaST6gSe576�9;Q�oIQT9;^RQ�� � � w q | X78T9[L7j e�w �� q | �P4/576-o7QT6�]+9[8T6�8^R` p ^�Q:^�V;V;ORQ:= � 57^�V[r3s38T^ $ 6 $-9;V;V Z\L7r�Se57OaS0�A�poKq � w q | W � x hi8 ��� o:q � w q | s <7XIS(Se5I6�rI9;8:SeORL7l�6< 6�S $ 6�6�L,Se5I6�]�6�r79;ORL1^R`��A�po:q � w q | ORLIr1Se576i]�6�rI9UORL+^R`��A�poKq � w q | 9;8 V;6�8T8_ST5\ORL/# � & # � ��KML

Page 35: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

t �^RST576�Q $_^RQTr78�s � o7QT9[V\8:Se9[V;V\o7Q:6�`f6�QT8�Se576$]+^ �d9;6-^ ��6�Q �_^R<3s <7XISSe576m= OaQT6-l�V[^�8T6�QST^�Okl�^�LI8T6�LI8TX78Oa` ST6�Q/l�^RX7L>Se9;LIj+Q:6 �d9;6 $-8-ST5\ORL2< 6m`f^�QT6!�

� ��� ��� # �� �� � � ��� � �� � ��� �$���� �� � � ��� � �� � l�^RL ST9;L X7X7] ^R` o ^�V[9[ST9;l�9;ORL78 ORQT6(6�ORlq5{OaSTST6�]�oISe9[L7j�Se^�o7V;ORl�6 Se576�]+8:6�V �R6�8 OaS $-5\O S/Se576m= 9;L &r79 �B9[r7X\ORV[V[=�o 6�QTl�6�9 �R6�Se^ < 6 ST576�]�6�rI9UORL�^R`3ST576ir79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL�^a`�o7X7<7V[9;l$^�o79;LI9;^�L�QT6�j>ORQTrI9;L7j Oc X76�8 Se9[^�L ��� x O#=�Se5\O S_9[L79[ST9UORV[V[=�s ��^RST6�Q:8��Io ^�8:9[Se9[^�L78ORQ:6 Q:6�o7Q:6�8T6�L>Se6�r,<>=+o ^�9[L>Se8Wq�� w &�� � � |ORV[^�L7j ST576io ^�V;9 Se9[l#ORV78:o 6�l�STQTX7]2s7ORLIr f��Mw q | 9[8 ST576(N�h(W ^R` �R^RSe6�QT8-ORV[^�L7j Se5\OaS_o ^RV;9[ST9;l�ORV78To 6�l &SeQ:X7] OR8io 6�QTl�6�9 ��6�r <>=�o ^�V;9 Se9[l�9UOaL � � WYXIQ:Se5I6�Q�s3OR8T8:X7]+6 Se5\OaS f��Mw q | 9[8�^R`�Se5I6�`f^�QT] - w � � � | s]�6#ORL79[L7j Se5\O S*6�ORlq5 o ^�V;9 Se9;l�9UORLH< 6�V;9;6 ��6�82ST5\OaS{o7X7<7V[9;l0^�o79[L79;^�L 9[82LI^�QT]+ORV;V =HrI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe6�rORQ:^�X7L7r15I9;8_l�X7QTQ:6�L>S/o ^�8T9 Se9[^�L � E 6�$ 9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L�l�^�]�6�8_9;L+ST576�`f^�Q:] ^R` O�V[9 �R6�V;9[57^B^dr%`fX7L7l &Se9[^�L enw�� q | $-579[lq5 9;8 V;^�j!& l�^�LIl#O ��6�9;L q �{4/579[8�9[8 6 7Oal�SeV = ST576 8:6�STX7o 9;L 4/576�^�Q:6�] CIs�OaL7r8T^�9[` L76 $ o7X7<7V[9;l-9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L�ORo7o 6#ORQ:8_QT6�j>ORQ:r79;L7j Se576 r79;8 SeQ:9;<7XIST9;^�L�^R`�^�oI9;L79[^�L Oa]+^�LIj Se5I6o ^�o7X7V;ORl�6as Se5I6�LHST576�Q:6*9;8�^�LIV[= ^�LI6 �aORV;XI6 q � 8TXIlq5 Se5\OaS�9 ` � � q � Se5I6�L o ^�V;9 Se9[l�9UOaL � $-9[V;VL7^RS�lq5\ORL7jR6 579;8$o ^�8T9 Se9;^RL � � V;V�o ^�V;9 Se9[l�9UOaL78 $-9[ST5 � � q � $-9;V;V Z\LIr*Se5\O S�Se5I6�9;Q$]�6�r79;ORL*8:579[` ST8X7o'$_ORQTr�Se^ O o ^�9;L>S�< 6�S $ 6�6�L!� ORL7r q � s�$-579;V[6/Se57^�8:6 $-9[Se5 �W[ q � $-9;V[VBZ\L7r�Se5\O SST576�9[Q�]+6�r79UOaL8T5I9[` Se8-r7^%$-L'$_ORQTr2Se^�O%o ^�9[L>S-< 6mS $_6�6�L q � ORL7r � �K `�l�ORL7r79[r\OaSe6�8-< 6�V;9;6 ��6iST5\OaS-Se576m= 8T5I^�X7V;r2o ^�8T9 Se9;^RL Se576�]+8:6�V ��6�8 OR8-l�V[^�8T6(ST^�ST576k]+6�r79UOaL

OR8�o ^�8T8:9;<7V[6RsRST576�L�Se576m=%]+O = 9;L79 Se9UOaV;V[=io7VUORl�6gSe576�]+8:6�V ��6�8OaS�rI9;8To7ORQeOaST6/o ^R9;L>Se8�ORV[^�L7jiST576-o ^!&V;9 Se9[l#ORVY8To 6�lmSeQ:X7]{sI< 6�l#ORX78:6iSe576m=15\O �R6 rI9 6�QT6�L>S-o 6�QTl�6�oISe9[^�L78g^a` ST576(r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL ^R` o7X7<IV;9;lSqOa8:Se6�8 � �_XBSiOR8$]�^�QT6k9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L ORoIo 6�ORQT8�s $ 6 $-9[V;V 8:6�6 ST576 o ^�8:9[ST9;^�L78/^a`nSe5I6�l#OaL7r79;r7OaSe6�8l�^RL �R6�Q:j�6 ST^%$gORQ:r{^RL76ko ^�9[L>S �

� �� � �(���(����! ��� '�� ���#��� ��� �i��� ���������

x O#=�Se57OaS O2r76�l�9;8:9;^�L ] O!�R6�Q $ ^�X7V;r V;9 �R6%Se^�� L7^%$ Se576�V;9 �R6�V[9;57^d^dr�^R` � � s_ORL7r Se^%$gOaQTrSe57OaSi6�L7r�S $_^ rI9 6�QT6�L>SkORXIST57^�QT9 Se9[6�8$6#ORlq50o7Q:6�8T6�L>Sk576�Q $-9 Se5�O+r79 6�Q:6�L>SkN�h(W `f^�Q s e�w |ORL7r f w | �+4/576 rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L ]+O �a6�Q 576�Q:8T6�V `/l#OaL ^�L7V =�5\O ��6+^�L76�8T6mS ^R`_< 6�V;9;6m`f8�s�8T^{8T576+] X78 S

� � 6�� ��-1-1/�F 8(�1 &�3�M�!60�B� �@.����0'( N'����1�:-16��3/�#N' 8�#N�3.$�76� "F=-1�$#"2+��� �160�7FM�;'( N���= N-58��!�$HB��#&�$�,� &� �16���! ��#" "�1 N.$�3#R(.$ "���0.��@#& *�!�$�D�B�!/��1��IT9�/(� ���3�1� �160�W.$�[H3�;�B�D- �32 RT�;. �! "��� X�\ �0\���\

Page 36: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

t�tOR]+ORV;j�OR] O Se6 e�w | ORL7r f3w | 9[L ST^�^�LI6go ^R8:Se6�QT9[^�QnN�h(W �aW\^�Q 6� IOR]�o7V;6as�9[SP] O#= < 6_QT6�OR8T^RL\OR<7V[6`f^�QgST576kr76�l�9;8T9[^�L,] O!�R6�Q/ST^�8:9;]�o7V[=�SqO!�R6(Se576 O ��6�QeORjR6 ^R` Se5I6kS $ ^�r76�L78:9[ST9;6�8��

�A�poKq w | � e�w | � f w |t �

w t � 7 |

E ^%$ 8eO#=*ST5\OaSiST576%8T6�l�^�L7r ORXIST57^�Q:9[SM={5\OR8�S $ ^,r79;8 SeQT9[<7XIST9;^�L78$Se^ lq57^d^�8:6 `fQT^�]2s f � w q | OaL7rf�� w q | ��4/576-8eOR]�6gc X76�8:Se9[^�L+OR8�OR< ^ �R6-l#ORL�< 6-OR8 �a6�r ��9 ` f � w q | � ��b N�8 f�� w q | s�Se576�L�$-5\O S�8T^�Q S^R` X7o r\OaSe9[L7j ^�o 6�QTOaSe9[^�L78 $-9[V;V o7QT6�8T6�Q���6�Se576�� ��b$N +4/579;8(8:6�lmSe9;^RL 8:57^%$-8 ST5\OaS(ST576%QT6�8TX7V SSe57OaSnST576 �gO#=�6�8T9;ORL�X7o r7OaSe9[L7j�^�o 6�QTOaSe9[^�L o7Q:6�8:6�Q �R6�8�Se5I6 � ��b N0l#OaL%< 6g6 Bo\ORL7r76�r%Se^(Oil�VUOR8:8^R` X7o r\OaST9;L7j(^�o 6�QTOaSe9[^�L78 $-5I9;lq5�KPr7XI< � $ 6�9;jR5 ST6�r �gO#=�6�8T9UOaL�Q:X7V;6�8�� � <7XBS�Se579[8�l�VUOa8T8�r7^d6�8�L7^aS9;LIl�V;XIr76 ]+ORL>=2QT6�OR8T^�L7OR<7V;6 X7o r\OaSe9[L7j ^Ro 6�QeOaST9;^�L78$8TXIlq5 Oa8 Se5I6 O ��6�QeORj�9[L7j1^�o 6�QTOaSe^RQ�OR< ^ ��6!�D 6 OaQT6-j�X\ORQTORL>Se6�6�r+ST5\OaS9[` ORL�X7o r\OaSe9[L7jk^�o 6�QeO Se9;^RL Se5\OaS9[8LI^RS9;L%Se579[8�l�V;OR8T89;8�X78:6�r3s Se5I6�LSe5I6�QT6(9[8g8T^R]+6ioIX7<7V;9[l�9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L $-579;lq5 $-9[V;VYr76�8 SeQ:^ = Se576(^�Q:r76�Q_^R`�Se576io ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q:8�sBX78T9[L7jSe5I6 � ��b$N ^RQTr76�QT9;LIj"� �{6�ORL'$-579;V[6Rs Se576�O �R6�QTORj�9;LIj�^�o 6�QTOaSe^�Q^R` ��c X\OaST9;^�L t � 7 9;8 O�]�6�] < 6�Q^R`/ST576 l�V;OR8T8 ^a`/`fX7L7l�ST9;^�LI8 $-579;lq5 o7Q:6�8:6�Q �R62W � x h s <7XIS $-5I9;lq5 ]+O = r76�8:SeQ:^ = Se5I6 � ��b N^�Q:r76�Q:9;L7j"�

� ������� � ��� ��� �*������� � � � � ����� ��� � � � � ����� "!$#

b-6�l#OaV;V�`fQT^�] hi6mZ\L79[ST9;^�L t ST5\OaS�ST576 XIo r\O Se9;LIj*^�o 6�QTOaSe^�Q ] X78 S%< 6 QT6�8Tl�ORV;6�r Se^�< 61O2SeQTXI6N�h(W � #$^ $ 6 �R6�Q�s ST576(`f^�V;V[^ $-9[L7j�8 SqOaST6�]�6�L>S-Se6�V;V;8/XI8-ST5\OaS $ 6kl#ORL28T9[]+o7V[9[` =�Se5I6 oIQT^�<7V[6�] < =9;jRL7^�QT9[L7j�ST576kQT6�8:l#ORV[9;L7j��

� (� - ��� �%���>��� + � giF�( ��&�.*�7(*)�!@&-) � !/.*�4)�!48:�=�4!@&-� �A� o:q w"e<�af � � ��� �; | � ��� � . �A�po:q w@e<�+f �K� ��� �� |! � �#F�(Q;��=�?>*�4!@&-� ��� w@eA�af � �; | � ��� �W. �#F�(W;��=�?>*�4!@&-� ��� w@eA�af � | �; X

4/5\OaS 8eOR9[r3s'$_6 l#ORL�l�^RL78T9[r76�Q ORQT<I9[SeQTORQ:= o ^�8:9[ST9 ��6/`fX7LIl�Se9[^�L78 $-9[ST57^�XISQ:6�j>ORQ:r�ST^ $-576mSe576�QSe5I6�= 9[L ST6�j�QTOaSe6(ST^�^RL76 ��4/576�L �

� �1����! +�+�� >�&-���4!#���A&-��.�&���(*)+� �,&-) �<)H(�.�(*)�6 (�.j�#F�( � ��� � ! � !#�!/.�&,;j�#F�(W;K&-) �

��� w1���B� | � q wL� | m������

Page 37: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

tRv3Q!#�#F ��[ u E � �<� q wUm | � ��1��4)a� ��.T;K&-) ��� �4!@&-�<X

4/576 ` Oal�S�Se5\O SPST576Z7QT8:SnORQ:j�X7]�6�L>S ] O#=kX7L7rI6�QTjR^iORL>=(SeQTORL78 `f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�Lk9;8�L7^RSP8TXIQTo7Q:9;8T9[L7j"�ORL ^�o 6�QeOaST^�Q�o7QT6�8T6�Q ��6�8nSe5I6 � ��b$N�9[`���� w"e�w | �af � w |:| � ��b$N�8 ��� w@e�w | �af�� w |T| `f^�QPORL>=ko\OR9;Q^R` f 8�$-5I9;lq5 8eO Se9;8 ` =�Se576 � � b$N ORL7r ��� �1r76�LI8T9[SM= e�w | � x ^%L\O SeX7QTORV;V =�s 9[`d��� w,m/�Km | o7Q:6�8:6�Q �R6�8Se5I6 � � b$NHj�9 ��6�L e�w | s79 S$ORV;8:^�o7QT6�8T6�Q���6�8 Se5I6 � � b$NHj�9 ��6�L�q w"e�w |:| ��{^�Q:6 9;L>Se6�QT6�8 Se9[L7j $ ^�X7V;r < 6 ST^�QT6�8:SeQ:9;lmS%^�X7Q:8T6�V ��6�8 Se^�^�o 6�QTOaSe^RQT8 $-579[lq5 o7QT6�8T6�Q ��6,Se5I6

� ��b$N�8:=d]+]�6�STQT9[l#ORV[V[= � ��� w@eA�af � | � � b$N�8 ��� w@eA�af�� | saORL7r�ORV;8:^ ��� w#f � ��e | � ��b N�8 ��� w#f �K��e | �

� :��0�' (��� +�8 � >�&-���4!#����&-� .k&���(*)+� �7&-)2�<)H(�.�(*)�6 (�. �#F�( � ��� �\.*1 � � (*�4)�!@>a� 9#9 1�! �^!#� !/. &,;�#F�(W;K&-) �

��� w1���B� | � � � m���� �

3Q!#�#F � ��� [ u X

� �� �'; � KML Se5I9;8kl#OR8:6Rs $_6+5\O ��6�S $_^{l�^�L7rI9[Se9[^�L78��'��� w1���B� | � q wL� | m � � OaL7rL��� wL�A�[� | �� � m q w1� | � � L =0^Ro 6�QeOaST^�Q $-5I9;lq5 8TOaSe9[8:Z\6�8�< ^RSe5 ^R`_ST576�8:6 l�^�L7r79 Se9;^RL78k] X78:S SqO!�R6+ST576�`f^�QT]��� w1���B� | � � � m�� � � �x ^1Se5I6 � ��b N 9;8 8:=d]�]+6mSeQT9[l#ORV[V[=,o7Q:6�8:6�Q �R6�r 9;L�OaV;V�l#OR8:6�8(^�LIV[= $-576�L0r76�l�9[8T9;^RL�] O!�R6�Q:8

X7o r\OaST6 <\OR8:6�r0^�L0O1]�^�L7^�]�9UORV ^Ro 6�QeOaST^�Q �(4/576 �_O =R6�8:9UORL0X7o r\OaST9;L7j1^Ro 6�QeOaST^�Q�s?��� wL���B� | �� m�� s\9[8gSe576k8To 6�l�9UORV l�OR8T6 $-576�QT6Z� ��� � ���4/576g6 Io ^�L76�L>Se8?��OaL7r � ORV;V[^%$ ST576_r76�l�9[8T9;^RL�]+O �R6�QPSe^ o7VUOal�6]+^�Q:6 ^RQPV[6�8T8 $_6�9;j�5>Sn^�L�Se5I6

r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL78 e�wUm | ORL7r f w,m | � x O#= Se5\OaS f w | 9;8 O�8T9;LIj�V;6 &Mo 6#O �a6�r*rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L �IST576�l�^�L ��6 SeQTORL78 `f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L*^a` 8:c X\ORQT9[L7j $ ^�X7V;r�6 IORl�6�QT<\OaST6%Se576 o 6#O!� s Q:6�r7XIl�9;LIj1Se576 �aORQ:9UORL7l�6 ^R`�Se5I6r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL �PKML�Se5I6$l�^�L>Se6 BS ^R` QT6�l�6�9 �d9;L7jk9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L�`fQ:^�] ORL+ORr �d9[8T^�Q�s�Se579[8�]+6�ORL78�Se5\O S��� w@eA�af<�; | � e � w | f � w | o7V;ORl�6�8 ]�^�Q:6 $_6�9;j�5>S ^�L0Se576�8T6�l�^�LIr ORr �d9[8T^�Q � 8kl�V;OR9;] ORL7r o7XIST8]�^�QT6%^R`Se5I6�o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q(rI6�L78:9[SM=0ORQ:^�X7L7r0Se5I6�l�6�L>Se6�Q ^a` ST5\OaS ORr �d9[8T^�Q � 8kr79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL ��KML O8T9[]+9[VUORQ�]+ORL7LI6�Q�s���� w@e<�+f �� | � e ��� � w | f � w | r79;8:l�^�XIL ST8gSe576$Z\QT8 S-ORr �d9[8T^�Q � 8/Oar �d9;l�6!� � SgSe5I66� dSTQT6�]�6RsA��� w"e<�af<�; | � e � w | f � w | 9;8-O V[^�L7j $_O#=,^R` $-QT9[ST9;L7j ��� w"e<�af<�; | �Jf3w | s79[j�L7^�Q:9;L7jSe5I6 9;LIo7XIS ^R`gST576+`fX7LIl�Se9[^�L e�wUm | 6�L ST9;Q:6�V[= �14/579[8 �:X78 Se9[Z76�8kSe576+X78T6+^R`gSe5I6�ST6�QT] � $_6�9;j�5>ST6�r�gO#=�6�8�� 8kQTX7V[6��YSe^1r76�8Tl�QT9;< 6�ST579;8 l�VUOa8T8i^R`�XIo r\O Se9;LIj1^�o 6�QeO Se^�Q:8�s $-5I6�QT6 ST576 $ 6�9[j�5>Se8(ORQ:6�Se5I66� Bo ^�L76�L ST8 �*ORL7r � �

Page 38: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

t ��_XISgST576�8:6�S/^a` $_6�9;j�5>Se6�r �gO#=�6�8�� 8$Q:X7V;6�8_9[8gO�8:] ORV[VY8TX7<78:6�S $-9 Se579[L+Se5I6�l�V;OR8T8_^R`�o ^R8T8T9[<7V;6

]�6�Se5I^Br78�^R` X7o r\OaST9;L7j7s>6 Bl�V;XIr79;L7jk8:X7lq519;L>STX79[ST9 ��6_]+6mSe57^dr78OR8O ��6�QTORj�9[L7j�OaL7r�l�^�L ��^RV;XIST9;^�L �K `�ST576�Q:6#ORr76�Q�r7^d6�8 L7^RS�< 6�V;9;6 ��6kSe5\O S�o7Q:6�8:6�Q �d9[L7j1Se576 � ��b N 9[8 6�8T8T6�L>Se9UOaVysYSe576�L�576�^RQ 8:5768T5I^�X7V;r�SeO �R6 ST576%]+6mSe57^dr78(r79[8Tl�X78T8:6�r 6#ORQ:V;9;6�Qi9;L�ST579;8�lq5\ORoIST6�Q $-9[ST50O,jRQeOR9[L�^R`8eORV S#s 8:9;L7l�6Se5I6�= r76�8:l�QT9[< 6+^�L7V = lq57ORQeORlmSe6�QT9;8 Se9[l�8�^a` �gO#=�6�8T9UOaL X7o r7OaSe9[L7j�ORLIr 8TV[9;j�5>S �aORQT9;ORL>Se8 ST576�Q:6�^R` ��_XISk9 `�Se576�Q:6#ORr76�Q(< 6�V;9[6 ��6�8iSe5\O S(Se576�� ��b$N ������� ��2< 6%o7Q:6�8:6�Q �R6�r <>=*L76�$ 9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RL3sSe5I6�LHST576�OR< ^ ��6{8T57^%$-8 ST5\OaS�Se576{QT6#Oar76�Q+] X78:S1ORV;8:^ < 6�V[9;6 ��6{ST5\OaS+o 6�^�o7V[6{X78:6 �gO#=R6�8T9;ORLX7o r\OaST9;L7j w o ^�8:8T9;<IV[= $ 6�9[j�5>Se6�r | Se^�OR8T8:9;]�9;V;OaSe6 L76�$D9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L �

� ������� � ��� ��� �*������� � � � � ����� ��� � � � � ����� �� ��� ����� ���# 6�QT6�9;8kO,lq5\ORQTORl�ST6�QT9 �#OaST9;^�L0^R`Se5I6�8:6�S ^R` X7o r7OaSe9[L7j,^�o 6�QeOaST^�QT8 $-579[lq5 V[6#ORr�Se^,o ^�8:ST6�Q:9;^�Q:8^�Q:r76�Q:6�r2< =2W � x h �

� (� - ��� �%���>��� + � !#6 (*� � ��1 ��� !#)Z&,;b�<)�!@&-)H. f � � �<� f � 3GF%!@>�F .:� �"!/.T;�1 .*!#�%$ 9/(*5a>*)H&�.�.*!#�%$ E � �<�� ��1 ;��%�?>*�4!@&-� e E � �<� � � ������� �"!#�%$�&���(*)+� �,&-) ��� w@eA�af | 3GF%!@>�F�!/. � &-�?&-�,&-��!@>a� 9#9 1�!#�?>*)H(a�-.*!#�%$!#� e � �<� f E �#F�(�&���(*)+� �,&-) ��� w,m/�Km | �<)H&-6�!4�%(�. ��&�.*�7(*)�!@&-)�.'&-)a�%(*)H(a�k8:1 ���� � ! � �#F�(W;��=�?>*�4!@&-�!/.�&,;2�#F�(W;K&-) �

��� w"e<�af | � q w"e |� � f<�

3GF�(*)H( q wUm | !/. � �4)+� ��.T;K&-) ��� �"!@&-�';��%�?>*�4!@&-�L&,; � ��1 ;K&-) � E � �<� � !/.'� ��12��&�.*!#�"!#6 ('>�&-��.*� � ���@X

4/579;8_ORV;8:^ rI6�8Tl�QT9[< 6�8 Se5I6 8:6�Sg^a`3X7o r\OaST9;L7j ^�o 6�QeO Se^�Q:8 $-579[lq51o7Q:6�8T6�Q �R6i8T9[L7j�V;6 &Ml�QT^�8:8T9;LIj"�

� �1����! + �\��� ������� �"!#�%$ &���(*)+� �,&-) ��� w@eA�af | 3GF%!@>�F !/. � &-�?&-�7&-��!@>a� 9#9 1D!#�?>*)H(a�-.*!#�%$_!#� e� �<� f �<)H(�.�(*)�6 (�. .*!#�%$ 9/(*5a>*)H&�.�.*!#�%$�! � �#F�(W;��=�?>*�4!@&-�O!/.�&,;2�#F�(W;K&-) �

��� w"e<�af | � q w"e |� � f<�

3GF�(*)H( q wUm | !/. � �4)+� ��.T;K&-) ��� �"!@&-�';��%�?>*�4!@&-�L&,; � ��1 ;K&-) � E � �<� � !/.'� ��12��&�.*!#�"!#6 ('>�&-��.*� � ���@X

E ^RST9;l�6 Se5\OaS 9 ` f � w | � f�� w | s Se576�L q w"e�w |:| � �-f � w | � q w"e�w |:| � �-f�� w | s�]+6�ORL79;LIjSe57OaS�Se576-o ^�9;L>SOaS $-5I9;lq5�Se576-o7Q:9;^�Q:8�l�Q:^�8T89;8�ORV[8T^iST576-o ^�9[L>SOaS $-579;lq5�Se5I6$o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q:8�l�Q:^�8T8��

Page 39: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

t �4/5\OaS$9[8�sI9 `nrI6�l�9[8T9[^�L ] O!�R6�Q:8-X78T6 ORL2X7o r\OaSe9[L7j%^�o 6�QTOaSe^�Q�$-579;lq52o7QT6�8T6�Q ��6�8�8:9;L7j�V[6 & l�QT^R8T8T9[L7j7sL7^�L76 $DL76�$-8$l#OaL{]�^ ��6(Se576ko ^�9;L>S-^R`Pl�Q:^�8T8:9;L7j��

� ������� � ��� ��� �*������� � � � � ����� ��� � � � � �����4/5768T6mS�^R`B^�o 6�QeO Se^�Q:8 $-579[lq5�o7Q:6�8:6�Q �R6gW � x h�]+OaSTlq576�8�Se5768T6mSn^a`7^�o 6�QTOaSe^�Q:8 $-5I9;lq5�oIQT6�8:6�Q���68T9[L7j�V[6 &Ml�QT^�8:8T9[L7j"�

� :��0�' (��� + ��� !#�#F%!#� �#F�(2>*9 �-.�.�&,;�&���(*)+� �7&-)H. ��� w@e<�+f | 3GF%!@>�F�� )H( � &-�?&-�7&-��!@>a� 9#9 12!#�?>*)H(a�-.*5!#�%$O!#� 8*&-�TF_� )"$ � � (*���#. E � �c&���(*)+� �7&-)j�<)H(�.�(*)�6 (�."���� � ! � !#� !/.�&,;��#F�( ;K&-) � ��� w@eA�af | �q w@e |� � f E 3GF�(*)H( q wUm | !/.��D�4)+� ��.T;K&-) ��� �"!@&-� ;��%�?>*�4!@&-� &,;�� ��1�;K&-) � � �<� � !/.�� ��&�.*!#�4!#6 (>�&-��.*�@� ��� X

4/5 X78�s Se576-^�LIV[= XIo r\O Se9;LIj(]+6mSe57^dr $-579;lq5�o7Q:6�8T6�Q �R6�r Z\Q:8:S &M^�Q:r76�Q�8 Se^dlq5\OR8:ST9;l-r7^�]�9;L7ORL7l�69;L ORV;V\l�OR8T6�8/9;8�Se5\O S_^R` SqO � 9;LIj Se5I6 $ 6�9;jR5 ST6�r ]�6#ORL+^R`3ST576 S $ ^%8T6mSe8�sBo 6�QT5\Oao78_SeQTORL78 `f^�QT]�9;L7jSe5I6Z\Q:8:SP< 6m`f^�QT6 � L7^%$-9;LIj Se5I6 8:6�l�^RL7r � � 8P6�8:SqOa<7V;9[8T576�r 9[L 8:6�l�ST9;^�L t � v � t s �gO#=R6�8T9;ORL�XIo r\O Se9;LIj9;8/LI^RS$9;L1Se5I9;8-8T6mS �

� 8 $ 6�rI9;r $-9 Se5{ST576 � � b$NPs 9[S 9;8 $ ^�Q:ST5�l�^�LI8T9;rI6�QT9[L7j+ST576 o7Q:^�<7V[6�] ^R`�8 =d]+]�6�STQT9;l�ORV;V =o7Q:6�8T6�Q �d9;LIj W � x h OR8 $_6�V;V �

� :��0�' (��� + ��� !#�#F%!#� �#F�(2>*9 �-.�.�&,;�&���(*)+� �7&-)H. ��� w@e<�+f | 3GF%!@>�F�� )H( � &-�?&-�7&-��!@>a� 9#9 12!#�?>*)H(a�-.*5!#�%$'!#��8*&-�TF � )"$ � � (*���T. E � � &���(*)+� �7&-)Z.*1 � � (*�")�!@>a� 9#9 10�<)H(�.�(*)*6 (�.���� � ! ��!#� !/.2&,; �TF�(b;K&-) ���� w@eA�af | � � e � � f E 3GF�(*)H( � � �<� � � )H('� ) 8:!#�")+� )�1j��&�.*!#�4!#6 (j3 (*! $-F%�#.:X

� �� �'; � D 6kQT6�c X79[QT6k< ^RSe5���� w@eA�af | � q w@e |� � f ORL7r���� w@eA�af | � � e � q � wTf | ��4/5I6 ^RL7V[=^�o 6�QTOaSe^�Q:8 $-579;lq528eO Se9;8 ` = < ^RSe5,^R` Se576�8T6 l�^�LIr79[ST9;^�L78-OaQT6(Se57^R8T6kV;9[8:Se6�r 9;L Se5I6kST576�^RQT6�] � �b$6�l#ORV[V�`fQT^�] x 6�l�ST9;^�L���� v � ��� ��Se57OaS�Se576�8T6_XIo r\O Se9;LIj ^�o 6�QTOaSe^RQT8�l�^�XIV;r�< 6�X78T6�r�Se^$r76�8Tl�Q:9;< 6

p ^�X7Q:L7^RS$V;6�ORQTLI9;L7j%^�QgZ7l�Se9 Se9[^�X78/o7V;O = ]+^dr76�V;8 �

� ������ # ��� � ��� � � �� � � � ������� !$# ��� � ������_^RST5%Se576 � ��b$N ORLIr+W � x h ORQ:6/o7QT6�8T6�Q���6�r19;L ST576/l#OR8:6-^R` ^�L7V[= ^�L76/XIo r\O Se9;LIj(^�o 6�QeOaST^�Q �Se5I6kSTQT9 �B9;ORV ^Ro 6�QeOaST^�Q $-576�Q:6 LI6�$ 9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L 9;8/9;jRL7^�QT6�r,6�L>Se9[QT6�V =��

Page 40: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

t 6� �1����! + � giF�( &-��9 1�� ����� �4!#�%$�&���(*)a� �7&-)'3GF%!@>�F��<)H(�.�(*)�6 (�.�8*&-�TF��#F�( � ��� �\� �<� ���� �!/.��

��� w@e�w,m | �af wUm | �; | ��f3w | �� �� �'; � 4/579[8-9;8gSe5I6 ^RL7V[= ^�o 6�QeOaST^�Q $-579[lq5{8TOaSe9[8:Z\6�8$< ^RST5 � 6�]�]+OR8 � � ORL7r � � � �4/576�Q:6%9;8$L7^ `fX7LIl�Se9[^�L $-579[lq5�8:=d]�]+6mSeQT9[l#ORV[V[= o7QT6�8T6�Q���6�8 < ^RST5*Se576 � ��b N ORL7r�W � x h �

4/576irI6�Z\L79 Se9[^�L78_jR9 ��6�L1576�QT6(ORQ:6�8 SeQT9[l�S�sI<7XIS_l#ORL < 6 $ 6#O!�R6�LI6�r ��Se576 QeOaST9;^ 9;L+ST576ir76mZ\L79 Se9;^RL^R` � ��b$N ] X78 S,< 6�9[L7l�Q:6#OR8:9;L7j7s $-579[lq5 l�ORL < 6 $ 6#O �a6�L76�r ST^ LI^�L7r76�l�QT6�OR8T9[L7j � ORL7r Se5I6l�^R]+o\OaQT9;8:^�L 9[L+ST576ir76mZ\L79[ST9;^�L+^R` W � x h ]+O =�< 6 $ 6#O �a6�L76�r2`fQ:^�] � V[6�8T8Se5\OaL �dST^ � V;6�8:8_Se57ORL^�Q�6�cdX7ORV\Se^ � ��4/576�L�ST576-l�VUOa8T8�^R` X7o r7OaSe9[L7jk^�o 6�QeOaST^�QT8 $-579[lq5+8 =d]+]�6�STQT9;l�ORV;V = o7QT6�8T6�Q���6 < ^RST5Se5I6 $ 6#O!� � ��b N OaL7r $ 6#O!� W � x h < 6�l�^�]+6�8�O%V;ORQTj�6�^�L76 �

��� w"e�wUm | �af w,m | �� | ����w | �

$-576�QT6 � w | 9;8-ORL>=,ORQ:<79[STQeORQ = N�h(W�$-579;lq52r76�o 6�L7r78$^�L{LI6�9[ST576�Q enw | L7^�Q f w | �

� �� � ����" ! ���������

4/579[8 lq5\ORoBSe6�Q r79;8:l�X78:8T6�r ST576�QT6�8TX7V S ST5\OaS �_O =R6�8:9UORL X7o r\OaST9;L7j o7QT6�8T6�Q ��6�8 Se576�]�^�L7^aSe^�L76V;9 �R6�V;9;5I^B^drHQTOaSe9[^ o7QT^�o 6�Q SM=�� 4/579[8 ]+6�ORL78 Se5\O S,9[` O o\OR9;Q ^a`�o7Q:9;^�Q:818eO Se9;8 ` = Se5I6 � � b$NPsORL7r*< ^RST5�ORQ:6�X7o r\OaST6�r $-9 Se5*ST576�8TOR]�6�V;9 �R6�V;9;5I^B^dr1`fX7L7lmSe9;^RL�ORL7r{Se576 �gO#=�6�8:9UORL�XIo r\O Se9;LIj^�o 6�QTOaSe9[^�L3s�Se576�L Se576 S $ ^ o ^�8:ST6�Q:9;^�Q:8 $-9;V;V_ORV;8:^�8eOaST9;8 ` = Se576 � � b$N���K S�9[8%L76�l�6�8:8eORQ =HOaL7r8TX��+l�9;6�L S�Se57OaS�Se5762o7QT9[^�QT8�8TOaSe9[8:` = ST576 � � b$N `f^�Q%ST576{o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q:8%Se^08eOaST9;8 ` = Z\QT8 S &M^RQTr76�Q8:ST^Blq57OR8:ST9;l�rI^�]+9[L\ORL7l�6 � � 8T9[L7j O 8T9[]+o7V[6-QT6�rI6�Z\L79 Se9[^�L ^R` Se576 O B6�8�s�$_6�ORV;8:^ Z7L7r Se57OaS_9 `3Se5I6o7Q:9;^�Q:8-ORQT6(SeQTORL78:VUOaST9;^�L78/^a`�^�L76 ORLI^RSe576�Q�sYORLIr�ORQ:6 XIo r\O Se6�r2X78:9;L7j+O�rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L $-579[lq5{9[8ORo7oIQT^�o7Q:9UOaST6�V =*V[^�j!&Ml�^�L7l�O �R6Rs3ST576�L0Se576%o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q�]+6�r79UORLI8 w ^�QkOaL =�^RSe576�Q(^�QTrI6�Q(8:SeOaSe9[8:ST9;l |$-9;V[V < 6k^�QTr76�QT6�r �

�_XIS w $ 6�9;jR5 ST6�r | �gO#=�6�8T9;ORL�X7o r\OaST9;L7j�9;8$L76�l�6�8:8eORQ =�ORLIr*8TX��+l�9;6�L S�`f^�Q$ORV;V ^R`nSe576 OR< ^ �R6QT6�8TX7V Se8���K ` O(]�^Br76�V;6�Q�< 6�V;9;6 ��6�8�ST5\OaS�ST576 � � b$N 9[8�ORV $_O#=B8�o7Q:6�8:6�Q �R6�r $-5I6�L o 6�^Ro7V;6-X7o r\OaST6Se5I6�9;Q�o7Q:9;^�Q:8�s>^�Q�ST5\OaS�o ^�8:ST6�QT9[^�Q�]+6�r79UOaL78�8T57^RX7V;r�< 6-^�Q:r76�Q:6�r OR8�r79;8:l�X78:8T6�r1OR< ^ �R6Rs Se576�L+Se5I6]�^Br76�V;6�Q ] XI8:S/r76�8Tl�QT9;< 6io 6�^�oIV;6(OR8 X78T9[L7j �gO#=�6�8T9;ORL X7o r\OaSe9[L7j"��K `PO�]�^dr76�V[6�Q< 6�V;9;6 ��6�8_Se5\O S

Page 41: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

t 7o 6�^�o7V[61r7^0L7^RS�XI8T6 �gO#=�6�8T9UOaL XIo r\O Se9;LIj7s�Se576�L 5I6 ] X78:S�OaV;8T^�< 6�V[9;6 ��61Se57OaS Se5I62^RQTr76�QT9;LIjOR]�^�L7j%o 6�^�oIV;6�� 8-< 6�V;9[6�`f8/l#OaL{< 6(r76�8 SeQ:^ =R6�r�<>=,l�6�Q:SeOR9;L,o79[6�l�6�8-^R`PL76�$D9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L �x 9;]�9;V;ORQTV =�s Se5I61l�V;OR8T8 ^a`$O �R6�QTORj�9;LIj�^�o 6�QeOaST^�QT8�o7QT6�8T6�Q���6�8�Z7QT8:S &M^�Q:r76�Q�8:Se^dlq5\OR8 Se9[l1r7^�]�9 &

L\ORLIl�6 � � QT6�8:6#ORQ:lq576�Q $-57^�r76�8:9;QT6�8$ST5\OaS W � x h < 6ko7QT6�8T6�Q ��6�r�] X78 S�Oa8T8TXI]+6 ORL{O ��6�QTORj�9[L7j^�o 6�QTOaSe^�Q�s3ORLIr�O1QT6�8T6#OaQTlq576�Q $-57^ r7^d6�8iL7^aSkOR8T8:X7]�6%ORL�O ��6�QeORjR9;L7j1^Ro 6�QeOaST^�Q�] XI8:SkORl�l�6�oISSe57OaS/Se576 W � x h ^�QTr76�QT9[L7j $-9;V;V L7^RS ORV $gO#=d8-< 6ko7Q:6�8T6�Q �R6�r �

Page 42: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

t C

� � ��� � � �

� � � � � � � ����� � � ����� � � ��� � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � ���1�����,'���"/�����+�

4/579[8�lq57ORoISe6�Q+rI9;8Tl�X78T8:6�8+]+^dr76�V[8 ^R`�9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RL QT6 ��6�VUOaST9;^�L <>= <79UOa8T6�r�ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�8�s 8TX7lq5OR8%V[^�<7<>=d9;8:ST8 ^�Q%V;O%$/=R6�Q:8 � K S%SeO �R6�8%S $_^ ORo7oIQT^>ORlq5I6�8 � 4/576 Z\QT8 S�9;8�ST^�] O �a61Se5761SM=do79[l#ORVOR8:8TX7]�oISe9[^�L78�^R` � OR]�6_4/576�^�Q:=Rsd9[L $-579;lq5 �:X7r7jR6�8�l#OaL�oIQT6�rI9;l�S�5I^ $HORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�8 $-9;V;VdQT6�ORl�S�ST^Se5I6�9;QPr76�]+ORL7rI8�s>ORLIr%ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�8�SqO �a6g9;L>Se^iORl�l�^�X7L>S $-5\OaSn9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�Lk^�o7o ^�8T9[L7j(ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�8o7Q:^ �d9[r76{9[LHr76�l�9[r79;L7j $-5\OaS+Se576m= Se576�]+8:6�V �R6�8+8T57^�XIV;rHoIQT6�8:6�L>S � 4/579[81ORo7oIQT^>ORlq5�QT6�cdXI9;QT6�8]�9;L7^�QiOR8T8:X7]+oBSe9;^RL78iSe^ Z\L7r0Se57OaS(Se576%^RXISel�^�]+6 $-9[V;VnORV $_O#=B8k< 6%Se5\OaSk^a` `fX7V[Vn9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�LQT6 ��6�VUOaST9;^�L �4/576k8T6�l�^�L7r{9;8_ST^�OR8T8:X7]+6(ST5\OaS/Se5I6��:X7r7j�6k9;8gORL2ORXISe^R] OaST^�L3sIORL7r2V;^d^���OaS $-5\OaS$9;LB`f^�Q &

]+OaSe9[^�L ST576-ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6 $-9[V;Vdo7QT6�8T6�L>S�Se57OaS�o7XIST8�579;8nl#ORX78:6-9;L�ST576/< 6�8:S�V[9;j�5>S ��4/576�QT6$ORQ:6/O�`f6�$SM=do 6�8/^R`�9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L%Se5\O S/ORL,ORr ��^dl#OaST6il�^�XIV;r jR9 ��6 � 6 Io 6�Q:9;]�6�L>SqOaV Q:6�8TXIV[Se8�s78:SeOaSe9[8:ST9;l�8�sB^RQ` ORlmSe8 Oa< ^�XBS O2V;6�jR9;8TV;OaSe^RQ�� 8(l�^�L78 Se9 SeX76�L7l�= � OaL7r 8T^2Se576�QT61OaQT61O �aORQT9[6�SM=0^R`/]�^dr76�V[8 $-5I9;lq5$-9;V[V < 6kl�^�L78:9;r76�QT6�r{576�QT6!�#�O �d9;L7j+OR8:8TX7]�6�r,Se5\O S/Se576�:X7r7jR6 9[8-ORL{ORXISe^R] OaST^�L3sBX7L7V;6�8T8-Se576�QT6k6� B9[8:Se8$O�]+^RL7^RSe^RL79;l

SeQTORL78 `f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L�`fQ:^�] ST576 �:X7r7jR6�� 8XBSe9;V[9[SM=k`fQT^R] ORL�^�XBSel�^R]+6_ST^(Se5\OaS�^R` ST576-ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6 w Se5\O S9;8�s ST576%ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�9;8�9[L�ORj�Q:6�6�]+6�L S $-9[Se5{Se576 �:XIr7j�6 | s39[S 9;8 6#OR8 =*ST^1l�^�LI8:SeQ:X7l�Skl�OR8T6�8 $-576�Q:6^�L7V =1o\OaQ:Se9;ORV 9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L $-9;V;V < 6kQ:6 ��6�ORV;6�r �

Page 43: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

t����������� # � ���� � � ��� � ��� � � ��� � ��� � � � � � �����4/576$V;9 Se6�QTOaSeXIQT6gr76�8Tl�QT9;< 6�8S $_^kSM=do 6�8_^R` ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�8�sdl�V;OR8T8:9[Z\6�r+<>=%Se5I6 l�VUORQ:9[SM= ^R` ST576�9[Q�]+^RST9 &�aOaSe9[^�L78���4/576(Z\QT8 SgSM=do 6(9[L7l�V[X7r76�8/l�^�L78:X7V[ST9;L7j Z\QT]�8g^�Qg8:X7< ^�QTr79[L\OaST6�8g6�L STQTX78 Se6�r $-9 Se5 r\OaSeOj>OaST576�Q:9;L7jIs $-57^�8:6 <79;OR8T6�8�6� B9;8 S�<7XIS ORQT6/XIL"� L7^%$-L+Se^(ST576-r76�l�9;8T9[^�L�] O!�R6�Q�� x XIlq51ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�8ORQ:6�r79[8Tl�XI8T8T6�r 9[L�$ ^�Q � 8(<>= p QTO $/`f^�QTr0ORLIr x ^�< 6�V � ��7 � s < =�hi6�$_OaSeQ:9;o ^�L>SiOaL7r�4/9;Q:^�V;6 � � C � sORL7r29;L1ST576kV;9 Se6�QTOaSeXIQT6(<\OR8:6�r2^�L,Se576�8T6ko\ORo 6�Q:8 ��# ^%$_6 ��6�Q�sYSe576m=,ORQT6kL7^aS-r79;8:l�X78:8T6�r{576�Q:6 �4/579;8�lq5\ORoIST6�Qi`f^dl�X78:6�8k^�L�O18:6�l�^RL7r�SM=Bo 6%^R` ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6as38TXIlq5 OR8�V;^�<7<>=d9;8 Se8i^RQiVUO $/=�6�QT8�s

$-57^�8:6 <I9UOR8/9[8$l�V;6�ORQTV = � L7^%$-L{ST^+OaV;V39[L �R^�V �R6�r3sYOaL7r $-5I^�8T6 j�^>ORV 9[8g`f^Bl�X78T6�r*^�L,9[L��\X76�L7l�9[L7jSe5I6�r76�l�9;8:9;^�L+] O!�R6�Q�Se^ 9;]�o7V;6�]+6�L>S�Se576�9;Qo7QT6m`f6�QTQ:6�r ^�XBSel�^R]+6!� �{9;V[j�QT^R] ORL7r1b$^�< 6�Q Se8 � v 6 � s� XI8:Se9[L & x ]+9 Se5 � v � sBORL7r p OaV ��6�Q:S � � u�� ]+^dr76�V7ST579;8�SM=do 6 ^R`�ORr ��^dl#OaST6 ��4/576�8T6i]�^BrI6�V;8 $-9[V;V\< 6r79[8Tl�XI8T8T6�r*< 6�V[^ $ w ORV Se57^RX7j�5 p ORV ��6�Q S$9;8/V;6m` S/Se^%Se5I6k`f^d^RSTL7^RSe6(^RL2o7ORj�6�� u>| �

� V;O ��6�Q-ORL7r{b$XI< 6�L78:ST6�9;L � tav � 5\O ��6 O�X7L79;c X76k]�^BrI6�V ^R`Pr76�<7OaSe6 OR]�^�L7j S $ ^1ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�8$-9[ST5 Okl�V[6#ORQ�<I9UOR8�� # ^%$ 6 ��6�Q�sdSe576�9;Q�]+^dr76�VYOR8T8:X7]+6�8_OkV;9[]+9 SPST^ ST576 OR]+^RX7L>S�^R`39[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�LSe57OaS/ORL1ORr ��^dl#O Se6i]+O#=+oIQT^ �d9;r76asI]+O � 9;L7j 9[Sg9[L\ORo7oIQT^�o7Q:9UOaST6/`f^�QgORLI8 $ 6�QT9[L7j Se5I6ic X76�8 Se9;^RL1^R`$-576�L{`fX7V[V 9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L $-9[V;V < 6kQT6 ��6#OaV;6�r �Wn9;L7ORV;V =�s7OaV;V3^R` Se5I9;8-V;9 Se6�QTOaSeXIQT6(9;8/rI9 ��6�QTj�6�L>S `fQ:^�] Se5I6 ]�6�lq5\OaL79;8:] r76�8:9;j�L2V;9 Se6�QeOaSTX7QT6(9[L

Se5I6 8 SeQTXIl�SeXIQT6 ^R`n9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L1Se^+< 6 6� dSeQTORl�ST6�r �-KML�]�^�8 S ]�^dr76�V[8-`f^RQ ]�6�lq5\OaL79;8:] r76�8:9;j�L3sSe5I6 ` ORlmSe8i8:^�X7j�5>S(OaQT6�XIL �R6�Q:9[ZYOR<IV;6�9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L s\8TX7lq50OR8 ^�L76�� 8irI6�8T9[QT6 `f^�Q�O+o7X7<7V[9;l j�^B^dr3s8T^0o 6�^�oIV;6 ORQ:6 OR<7V[6 Se^�V[9;6 OR< ^RXIS Se5I6�8T6 ` ORlmSe8�� 4/576,8:6�SeXIo 9[L ORV;V^R`-Se5I6 ]+^dr76�V[8 9;L Se579[8lq5\ORoBSe6�Q-OaL7r1Se57^R8T6(l�9 Se6�r,OR< ^ �R6(9;L7l�V;X7r76�8/ORL 57^RL76�8 SM= QTX7V[6i^R` 8T^R]+6i8:^�Q:S�sI8 Se9;oIX7VUOaST9;L7j Se5\O SORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�8_]+O#=�^�<78Tl�X7QT6$Se576-` ORlmSe8_^RQQ:6�]+OR9;L�8T9[V;6�L S�s <7XISSe576m=+]+O#=�L7^RS V;9[6 �n4/5I6 c X76�8:Se9[^�L9;8 Se576�L ^�L7V[= OR< ^�XIS_57^%$ ] XIlq529[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L%ST576kORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�8 $-9;V;V < 6 $-9;V[V;9;LIj ST^ QT6 ��6#OaVys7L7^aSSe5I6 Oal�l�XIQeORlm=,^R`PST576k9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L �

� �� � �(���(����! �>���� ��� �����

4/579[8_lq5\ORoBSe6�Q $-9;V[V oIQT6�8:6�L>S-O�L X7]�< 6�Q_^R` ]�^dr76�V[8�s <\OR8:6�r ^�L O L X7] < 6�Qg^a` 8To 6�l�9[Z\l�OR8T8:X7]+o &Se9[^�L78PORL7r X7L7r76�QTV[=d9[L7j�8:o\ORl�6�8 ��KML Se579[8P8:6�lmSe9;^RL3sRK $-9[V;V�o7Q:6�8:6�L>S�Se5I6_L7^RSeOaSe9[^�L ORL7r `fQTOR]�6�$ ^�Q �$-9[ST5�$-579[lq5�ORV[V ^a`�Se576�8T6 ]�^dr76�V[8 $-9[V;V < 6�r76�8Tl�Q:9;< 6�r � x 9;LIl�6kSe579[8�9;8 O+jR6�L76�QeORV r76�8:l�Q:9;oIST9;^�L3s

Page 44: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

v�u]�^�8:S(^a`ST576%8To7ORl�6�8 9[L ��^�V ��6�r w�� s���s ORL7r�� | $-9;V;V L7^RSi< 6%8:o 6�l�9[Z76�r0X7L>Se9[VPSe5I6%6� IOR]�o7V;6�8Se57OaS(`f^�V;V[^%$ ��4/576�o ^%$ 6�Qk^R` 4/576�^RQT6�] � C w o\ORjR6 vRv 9[8iSe5\O Sk9[S $ ^�Q � 8 $-9[ST5 �d9[Q:SeX7ORV;V =*OaL =8To 6�l�9[Z\l�OaSe9[^�L,^R` Se576�8T6 8To\ORl�6�8��

�E O SeX7Q:6�� 8lq57^�9;l�6

// � �w,m |

//�ORr ��^dl#O Se6�� 8lq57^R9;l�6

//�

r76�l�9;8T9[^�L,] O!�R6�Q � 8lq57^�9;l�6Rs� w,m |

//� � wUm |

//�

8:SeOaSe68To7ORl�6

ORl�STX\ORV8 SqOaST6

o ^R8T8T9[<7V;68T9;jRL\ORV;8

8T9[j�L\ORV8T6�L S

ORl�ST9;^�L<>=,r � ] � o\O#=R^ �Se^

ORr ��^dl#O Se6

WP9;j�X7Q:6 v � ����W\QT^�] 8:SqO Se6k^R` Se576 $ ^�QTV[r,ST^�ORr ��^dl#O Se6�� 8$o\O#=�^

4/576ko7QT^dl�6�8T8-9;8gO�8:6�Q:9;6�8/^a`P]+ORo7oI9;L7j�8�sB`fQ:^�] 8 SqOaST6�8/^R` Se576 $ ^�Q:V;r1Se^%8:9;j�L7ORV;8_ST^�ORl�ST9;^�LI8Se^ XIST9;V;9 Se9[6�8 ��4/576-`fX7V[V\o7QT^dl�6�8T89;8�r76�oI9;l�ST6�r�9;L+Wn9;jRX7QT6 v � ����WP9;QT8 S#s E OaSeX7Q:6-o79;l�� 8^�L76$8:SqO Se6-^R`Se5I6 $_^�Q:V;r3s � sB`fQ:^�] ORV;V SeQTXI6(8:SqO Se6�8�s � s\ORL7r,QT6 ��6�ORV;8gST5\OaS-8:SeOaSe6iST^ Se576kOar ��^dl#OaST6(<7XIS-L7^aSSe5I6�r76�l�9;8:9;^�L{] O!�R6�Q�� � 9 �R6�L*O 8:SeOaSe6 ^R`�Se5I6 $ ^�QTV[r3s ST576�Q:6�9[8�8T^R]+6 8T6mSi^R`�8:9;j�L\OaV;8� $-5I9;lq5Se5I6 Oar ��^dl#OaST6k] O#= 8:6�L7r �

��� � 4� - ���>��� � � .�.*� � (��#F�� �Z�TF�(*)H(�( �B!/.*�T. � ���*���<!#�%$�� � C � E 3GF%!@>�FO!/.�>�& � � &-�

�-�?&-309/(a��$%(:X giF�( !#��6 (*)H.�( ���*���<!#�%$�R ���� C � !/. � 9 .�&_>�& � � &-� �-�?&-309/(a��$%(:X ��9 .�&

�-.�.*� � (j�TF�� ��R � w � | !/.�>*9/&�.�(a� ;K&-) � 9#9 � ��� X

x ^�w � | 9[8PSe5I6/8T6�S�^a` 8:9;j�L7ORV;8 $-579;lq5%]+O#=�< 6g8T6�L>S jR9 ��6�L Se5\O S � 9;8 Se576gSTQTX76_8:SqO Se6/^R`YSe5I6

$ ^�QTV[r3s OaL7r�j�9 ��6�L*O 8T9[L7j�V[6 8:9;j�L7ORV �/s�R � w � | 9[8 Se5I6�8T6mSi^R`�8:SqO Se6�8 9;L $-579;lq5*ST576 Oar ��^dl#OaST6

l�^RX7V;r,5\O ��6 8T6�L>S$ST576k8T9[j�L\ORV � � E ^RSe9[l�6iSe57OaS�] O#= 6�] < ^drI=1ORL,57^�L76�8:SM=,QTXIV;6RsI<7XIS$K ^RL7V[=

OR8:8TX7]�6(Se5\OaS-9 S-9;8/8:^�]+6(Z B6�r3s\l�^�]�]�^�L �dLI^ $-V[6�r7jR6 ]+ORo7oI9;L7j"�W\QT^�] ST576�8:6 o ^�8:8T9;<IV;6�8T9[j�L\ORV[8�s#ST576 rI6�l�9[8T9[^�Lk] O �a6�Q�]+O =�o7QT6�8T6�L S�ORL>=(^�L76�8:9;j�L\OaV �,Se^-Se5I6

r76�l�9;8:9;^�L ]+O �a6�Q�s $-57^�lq57^B^R8T6�8-8:^�]+6kOal�Se9[^�L � `f^�QgORL>= j�9 �R6�L 8:9;j�L\OaV �gsI`fQT^R] Se5I6(8To\ORl�6(^R`o ^�8T8:9;<7V[6kORl�ST9;^�L78�� �4/576 r76�l�9;8T9[^�L `fX7L7lmSe9;^RL $-579[lq5*]+O �R6�8$ST579;8/]+ORo7oI9;L7j7s � wUm | ��� C � s9;8/8:6�V[6�l�ST6�r{< = Se576�:X7r7jR6RsYORL7r2]+O = 9;L7l�V;X7rI6(8:SeQTOaSe6�j�9;l(l�^�L78:9;r76�QeOaST9;^�L78��4/576kORr �R^Bl�OaSe6(57OR8/8T^�]�6iXIST9;V[9[SM=�OR8:8T^dl�9UO Se6�r $-9 Se5 6�ORlq52ORl�ST9;^�L3s � w � | ��� C �$s $-5I9;lq5

576k57^�o 6�8/ST^+]+O B9;]�9 ��6 �

Page 45: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

v �� � 8 � � � + & 4���� ����;<�' 2�=!.���>���

W\^�Q-Se576 cdXI6�8:ST9;^�L s � $-576�L $-9[V;V `fX7V;V�9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L,< 6�QT6 ��6�ORV;6�r � Se^+< 6�O l�^R576�Q:6�L>S(^�L76as $ 6L76�6�r Se^�6�LI8TX7Q:6,ST5\OaS%8:^�]�6�Se5I9;L7j�V[9 �R6+`fX7V;V 9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RL l�ORL ORV $_O#=B8%< 6 o7Q:6�8T6�L>Se6�r � 4/576`f^�V[V;^%$-9;L7j�r76�Z\LI9[Se9[^�L,ORL7r{OR8:8TX7]�oISe9[^�L2ORV;V[^%$ ST579;8��

� ��� ��>������� � �J.*! $ �<� 9 � !/. `fX7V[V[=i9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9 �R6 ! ��R � w � | !/. � .�(*� 3Q!#�TF &-��9 1 &-�?(Z(*9/( � (*���@X

��� � 4� - ���>��� � � &-) � ��1'$ !#6 (*� � E �TF�(*)H(�( �B!/.*�#. ��.*! $ �<� 9 ��� .*�A>�F��#F�� ��R � w � | ��� ��� �

4/5\OaS9;8�s>9[`YSe5I6/8T9;jRL\ORV7l�^�X7V;r%^RL7V[=�5\O ��6$< 6�6�L�8T6�L S 9;L%^RL76-8:SqO Se6/^R` Se576 $ ^�Q:V;r3s�ST576�L�Se5\O S8T9[j�L\ORVPSe6�V[V;8�ST576�r76�l�9;8:9;^�L0]+O �R6�QkST576�8:SeOaSe6 $-9[ST50l�6�Q SqOR9[L>SM=���W\^�QkORL>=�8 SqOaST6�^a` ST576 $_^�Q:V;r3sSe5I6 Oar ��^dl#OaST6k9;8/l#Oao\OR<7V[6 ^a`n8:6�L7r79[L7j�8TX7lq5*O�rI6�l�9[8T9 ��6k8T9[j�L\ORV �KgOR8:8TX7]�6(Se5\O S$ST576kr76�l�9;8:9;^�L,]+O �R6�Q$l�ORL2r7^+LI^+< 6�S:Se6�Q/`fQ:^�] ST576�Oar ��^dl#OaST6(Se5\ORL2< 6�9;LIj

Se^RV;r Se576k8 SqOaST6 ^a`PST576 $_^�Q:V;r $-9[ST5,l�6�Q SqOR9[L>SM=��

��� � 4� - ���>��� B giF�( �%(�>*!/.*!@&-� ��� ��(*)�� .2�%�"!#9 !#�41 !/. ��� �B!���!�-(a��3GF�(*� �#F�( ��� 6 &�>a� �7(2)H(*6 (a� 9 .��� X

4/579[8$9[8gSe576k^�LIV[= Oa8T8TXI]+oIST9;^�L2OR< ^�XIS/ST576kr76�l�9;8:9;^�L,]+O �R6�Q�� 8$jR^>ORV;8gST5\OaS $ 6 $-9[V;V L76�6�r �W\QT^�] 576�Q:6Rs ORL,6� IOR]�o7V;6(9[8/9;L,^�Q:r76�Q��

� �� � �#!������� � ��' � �� �i����� � � �,'��(!

4/579[8(8T6�lmSe9[^�L0r76�8:l�QT9[< 6�8 O1]+^dr76�Vn< 6�8:Sk8TXI9[Se6�r�`f^�Q�Se5I6�oIQT6�8:6�L>SqO Se9;^RL ^a` 6 �d9;r76�L7l�6as 8:X7lq5 Oa8` ORlmSe8�OaS+O0STQT9;ORVg^�Q%8 SqOaST9;8:ST9;l�8+Oa< ^�XBS�O o7Q:^�o ^�8T6�rHo ^�V;9[l�=�� �_ORQTQ:9;L7j O�`f6�$ ]�^dr79[Z\l�OaSe9[^�L78]+ORr76i`f^�Q/6 Io ^�8:9[Se9[^�L\ORV l�VUOaQT9[SM=RsBST576k]+^dr76�V 9;8g`fQT^R] �{9[V;j�Q:^�] OaL7r*b-^�< 6�Q Se8 � v 6 � �4/576�8:SeOaSe6%^R`�ST576 $_^RQTV;r s � � � u � � � s39[8 � L7^%$-L ST^1Se576%V[^�<7<>=d9;8 S(<7XISkL7^aS(Se576 rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L

]+O �R6�Q ��4/576$V;^R<7<>=B9[8:S]+O = 8T6�LIr+Se^kSe5I6 r76�l�9[8T9;^RL+]+O �R6�QO 8:9;j�L\OaV7l�^�LI8T9;8 Se9[L7j ^a` Ok8TX7<78:6�S ^R`� u � � � s � � � ���B� � sYOaL7r{9[8/< ^RX7L7r2< =,5I^�L76�8 SM= Se^�QT6 ��6�ORV�^�L7V[= O�8:X7<78:6�S���8TX7lq52Se5\O S � � � �4/5\OaS�9;8�s

�]+ORo78-`fQT^�] � Se^1OaV;V�l�V[^�8T6�r�8TX7<78:6�ST8(^R`�� u � � � $-579;lq5*l�^�L>SqOa9;L � � 4/576�9;L ��6�QT8T6as

�R � s7ST576�Q:6�`f^�Q:6k] ORoI8g`fQT^�] OaL =1l�V;^R8T6�r29;L>ST6�Q �aORV Se^�9[ST8T6�V ` �

Page 46: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

v>t� � � u � � ��

� � C 8:6�Se8$^R` � u � � � $-579[lq5{9[L7l�V[X7r76 �� � 8T6�ST8 ^a` � u � � � $-579;lq529;L7l�V;X7rI6 �� � �� w � | � �

Wn9[j�X7Q:6 v � t ��� L79[r79;]�6�L78:9;^�L7ORV ]�^dr76�V3<7OR8T6�r*^�L Se57OaS$^R` �29;V;jRQT^�] ORL7r2b-^�< 6�Q:ST8

4/576�r76�l�9;8T9[^�L ] O �a6�Q � 8 ORl�ST9;^�L $-9[V;V�< 6�ST^{8:6�V[6�l�S O �aORV;X76�^R` � s�<\OR8:6�r ^�L 5I6�Q < 6�V;9;6m`f8 �4/5\OaS_9;8�s � � � ��hi6�Z\LI6i576�Q V;^�8:8 `fX7LIl�Se9[^�L+ST^ < 6 & � ��& � � s 8T^ 8:576 $_ORL>Se8gSe^ 8T6�V;6�lmS�� Oa8l�V[^�8T6(ST^ � Oa8$o ^�8:8T9;<IV;6 �4/576�V;^�<I< =d9[8:S � 8iXIST9;V[9[SM=29;8i8:9;]�o7V[= � w � | � � s3]+6�ORL79[L7j Se57OaS(576%57^Ro 6�8i`f^�Q(OR8(V;ORQTj�6�O

r76�l�9;8:9;^�L2OR8-o ^�8T8:9;<7V[6 �4/576i]�^BrI6�Vys�$-9 Se579[L�ST576 `fQTOR]�6�$ ^�Q �%o7Q:6�8:6�L>Se6�r25I6�QT6asI9[8 8:X7]+]+ORQ:9 ��6�r+9[L 4POR<7V[6 v � t � � V;V

^R`�Se5I6(6�V;6�]+6�L>Se8g`fQT^R] Wn9[j�X7QT6 v � �(5\O ��6kL7^%$ < 6�6�L2rI6�Z\L76�r3s\8eO �R6 `f^�Q Se576(8 SeQeO Se6�jR9;lilq57^R9;l�6�8^R` Se576 ORlmSe^�Q:8 ��{9;V[j�QT^R] ORL7r b$^�< 6�Q Se8 8T57^%$ ST5\OaS Se576�QT6 9[8 ORL OaS:SeQTORl�ST9 ��6�6�c X79[V;9[<7QT9[X7]�9[L $-579[lq5 Se5I6

r76�l�9;8:9;^�L ] O �a6�Q X78T6�8gSe576irI6�l�9[8T9[^�L `fX7L7lmSe9[^�L � w � | � ]+9[L w � | sB]�6#OaL79;L7j Se5\O S/8T576iOR8T8:X7]+6�8Se5I6 $ ^�Q:8:S$o ^R8T8T9[<7V;6(8 SqOaST6 OR8-]+6�OR8TX7Q:6�r2<>= Se576 ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�� 8-XIST9;V[9[SM=��

� 9 ��6�L Se5I9;8 ORl�ST9;^�L3s ST576 Oar ��^dl#OaST6 $-9[V;V�8:6�L7r O28T9[j�L\ORV�^R`_Se576�`f^�QT] � � �Hr � s $-576�Q:6 r 9[8ORL>=��aORV[X76 j�Q:6#OaST6�QiST5\ORL � � K ` 576%8T6�L7r78 O18T9[j�L\ORV � d�Hr � $-9 Se5 � � s Se576�L0576 $-9;V[Vnj�6mSkOV;^%$ 6�Q o\O#=�^ Se57ORL 9 `g576+5\ORr Q:6 �R6#ORV[6�r � � �Hr � � # 6+9;8k<\ORQ:QT6�r `fQT^�] jR9 �d9;L7j2O28T9;jRL\ORV�� d�ar �$-9[ST5 [ � s 8:9;L7l�6%9;L*ST579;8 l#OR8:6 � �� � d�Hr � �(4/576�Q:6�`f^�Q:6Rs3Se5I6 r76�l�9;8:9;^�L0ORLIr�o\O#=�^ $-9;V;V < 66�c X79 �aORV;6�L S�ST^ ST576 rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L OaL7r+o7O =R^ ,Se5\O S�$ ^�X7V[r+< 6 Q:6#ORlq5I6�r 9 ` ST576$ORr ��^dl#O Se6$5\ORr jR9 ��6�L`fX7V[V39;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L �

��������� � � � � � ���� � � �� � � ���� � �� �� �� �� ���� � � � + � + � �'��4���� �����2:�!"���'�1�3��� ��:�� ���������

�{9[V;j�Q:^�] ORL7r b-^�< 6�Q:ST8�� 8 6�c X79[V;9[<7QT9[X7] 9;8 6�L>Se9[QT6�V[= 9;L7r76�o 6�L7r76�L S�^a`/Se57619[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L s 8:9;j!&L\ORVFs-ORL7r ORlmSe9[^�LH8:o\ORl�6�8 � 4/576�r76�l�9[8T9;^RL ] O!�R6�Q l#ORL OaV $_O =d8 l�^�]+o ^�Q S 576�QT8:6�V[` OR8 9[`(8:5765\OR8�QT6�l�6�9 ��6�r�ST576{]�^�8 S�o 6�8T8T9[]+9[8:ST9;l1`fX7V[Vg9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L 8T9[j�L\ORV/l�^�L78:9;8:ST6�L>S�$-9[Se5 Se5I62r7OaSqO��W\^�QT]+ORV[V[= �

Page 47: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

v�v� :��0�' (��� + B � .�.*� � ('�TF�� � �#F�(�>�&-�<� !#�"!@&-��. &,; � .�.*� ���<�"!@&-��� E � .�.*� ���<�"!@&-��� E � �<����.*5.*� ���<�"!@&-���kF�&-9 ��XOgiF�(*� �TF�(*)H(�( �B!/.*�T.����2�-.�F (��:�=!#9 !48:)�!#� �h3GF�&�.�( ��� 1 & � �7& �#F�(���� 6 &�>a� �7(!/.�(��:��� 9i�,&��#F�(0��� 1�& � F�(j3 &-�=9 ��$%(*��;�)H& � )H(*6 (a� 9 !#�%$ ;��%9#9i!#�K;K&-) ��� �"!@&-�<X

� 8:8TX7]�oISe9[^�L �*Oa8T8TXI]+6�8�Se5\O S�Se5I6 r76�l�9;8:9;^�L ] O �a6�Q 5\OR8�8:^�]�6 $_O = ^R`-]+ORo7o79[L7j,`fQT^�]8T9[j�L\ORV[81<\ORl���Se^ 8:SeOaSe6�82^a` ST576 $_^RQTV;r s $-579[lq5 9[8 $-5\OaS $ 6 $_^�XIV;r 6� Bo 6�l�S*ORL>= rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L]+O �R6�Q�ST^ < 6$r7^�9;LIj OaL = $_O#=1Oa` ST6�Q�8T5I6 Q:6�l�6�9 �R6�8_5I6�Q8T9;jRL\ORV � � 8:8TX7]�oIST9;^�L 7k8TO#=B8Se5\O SST576�Q:69;8�OaV $_O =d8�`fX7V[V79;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L ST^ < 6/QT6 ��6#OaV;6�r sIORLIr � 8T8:X7]+oBSe9;^RL C(8eO#=d8�Se5\OaS�`fXIV;V79[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L9;8 O+jR^B^dr{ST579;L7j��/4/576�8:6�ORQT6 QT6�VUOaST9 ��6�V[=,X7LIl�^�L>SeQ:^ ��6�Q:8T9;ORVn8 SqOaST6�]�6�L>Se8�s 8T6mSi9[L�O�`fQTOR]�6�$ ^�Q �$-579[lq5 9[8 j�6�L76�QTORVg6�LI^�X7j�5 Se^�rI6�8Tl�QT9[< 6,O��aORQ:9;6�SM= ^R`$]�^Br76�V;8�`fQ:^�] Se576 V[9[Se6�QeOaSTX7QT6as�8T^ $ 6$ ^�X7V;r 6� Bo 6�l�S Se579[8(Se^*< 6�O{QTOaSe576�Q Q:^�<7X78 S�Q:6�8:X7V[S �1K ` $ 6+57^Ro 6�Se^ $-QT9[ST6�O{]�^Br76�V $-576�Q:6`fX7V[V 9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L 9[8 LI^RSiQ:6 ��6�ORV;6�r3s ST576�L�$_6 $-9[V;V L7^aS�j�6mS�ST576�Q:6�<>=*l�QT6�OaSe9 ��6�8:o 6�l�9 Z\l#OaST9;^�LI8^R` Se576k8:9;j�L\OaVysI8 SqOaST6Rs\^�Q-Oal�Se9[^�L,8To\Oal�6�8��

� � � � + � 8 �"� ��'� 4���3���/�(:�!"��'���3��� �� 4�����>�� (��4�� �5�����5� - ���

x O#=�Se5\O S_9[L78:ST6#ORr+^R`3Se5I6�8:SeOaSe6 ^R`3ST576 $ ^�QTV[r < 6�9[L7j�O o ^R9;L>S � � � u � � � s>ST576�8 SqOaST6�9;8 O o ^�9[L S� �n� �k4/576�rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L{]+O �a6�Q$l�^�X7V[r*8 Se9;V[V 9;L78:9;8 S ^RL{Se5I6�OR8:8TX7]�6 &ySe576 & $ ^�QT8 Si8 SeQeO Se6�ja={jR9 ��6�LO�QT6�o ^RQ:S `fQ:^�] ST576,ORr �R^Bl�OaSe61ST5\OaS � � � ���B� � s�`f^�Q%OaL = QT6�ORV � ORL7r � s^RQ 6 �R6�L�O�QT6�o ^�Q S� � � ��� � | � � 8 Oa< ^ ��6asY8T576k]+O =1lq57^B^R8T6(Se576k]�9;L79[] X7]2s � � � �

�_XIS $-57OaS(8T5I^�X7V;r{Se576%r76�l�9[8T9;^RL�] O!�R6�Q r7^ 9[`nSe576%Oar ��^dl#OaST6%j�9 �R6�8�ST576 L7^ &M9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�LQT6�o ^RQ:S � � w & � � � | 4/576 OR8T8:X7]�6 & ST576 & $_^RQT8:S28 SeQeO Se6�ja= r79;lmSqOaST6�81ST5\OaS,Se576�rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L]+O �R6�Qg8T57^RX7V;r lq57^d^�8:6 &�� ��4/579[8g9;8_9;L7r76�6�r,ORL 6�c X79;V[9;<7Q:9;X7] �P9 `3Se5I6kORr ��^dl#O Se6 � L7^%$-8gSe5\O SSe5I6 r76�l�9;8:9;^�L ] O �a6�Q $-9;V;V�lq5I^B^�8:6 & � j�9 �R6�L O*Q:6�o ^�Q:S ^R` w &�� � � | sPST576�L 5I6 $-9;V[V�L76 �R6�Qr\ORQ:6(] O!�R6(Se5\O S-QT6�o ^�Q S � �_XIS-<>= lq5I^B^�8:9;L7j & � sISe5I6 rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L ] O!�R6�Q-9[8gj�9 �d9[L7j%576�Q:8T6�V[`nORL9;LBZ\L79[ST6(V;^�8:8�s�$-5I9;V;6(rI6�l�9[r79;LIj�^RL{OaL =1QT6#OaV LdXI] < 6�Q $_^�XIV;r,j�9 �R6k576�Q$O Z\L79 Se6kV;^�8:8 ��iL O1Se6�lq57L79[l#ORV�V;6 ��6�Vys3Se5I9;8k]+6�ORL78(Se57OaS(Se576�6�cdXI9;V;9[<7QT9[X7] 9;8(8TXI<7j>OR]�6�o 6�Q:`f6�lmS#s�<7XIS 9[8

L7^RS$O�8T6�c X76�L>Se9;ORV E Oa8T5*6�c X79;V[9;<7Q:9;X7] ��iL0O1l�^�V[V;^dcdXI9UORV�V;6 ��6�Vys ST576 j�9[8:S(^R`�ST576�8:6�QT6�Z7L76�]�6�L>Se8(9[8�Se57OaSkORL0ORr ��^dl#OaST6%] O#= � l�ORV;V

Se5I6 r76�l�9;8:9;^�L�]+O �a6�Q�� 8(<7V[X� � ORL7r�o7Q:6�8T6�L>Sko\ORQ:ST9UORV�9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L3sY^�Q ] O#={8T9[]+o7V = `f^�QTjR6�S�ST^5\ORLIr 9;L O{QT6�o ^RQ:S �,K `/ST5761ORr ��^dl#OaST6 l�^R]+]�9[ST8 8:X7lq5 O2` Oa9;V;XIQT6Rs�Se5I6�L ST576 r76�l�9[8T9;^RL ]+O �R6�Q

Page 48: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

v �$ ^�X7V;r+< 6$Se57Q:^%$-9;L7j O $gO#=+X78T6m`fX7V oIQT9;^RQT8 ORL7r1OaL =�9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L ST576�Oar ��^dl#OaST6�r7^d6�8 o7QT^ �d9;rI6<>= l�^RL ST9;L X79[L7j%Se^�`f^�V;V[^ $ 5I6�Q-o7QT^dl�V;OR9;]�6�r 8 SeQTOaSe6�jR=��

� � � � + � � � ��� � �>����� ��1� - ���� ���

W\QT^�] 576�Q:6Rs(Se576�QT6 ORQT60Se5IQT6�6 r79[QT6�lmSe9[^�L78 $_6 ] O#= SeO �R6!��ST576 Z7QT8:S{9;8,Se^ o7Q:6�8TXI]+60Se5\O SSe5I61r76�l�9;8:9;^�L ]+O �a6�Q�l�ORL ]+O �R6+j�^B^dr ^RL 576�Q Se57Q:6#OaS ST^�8T6�V;6�l�S � � & � 9[`/L76�6�r < 6Rs�9[L$-579[lq5 l#OR8:6�^�X7Q1]�^dr76�V[8+]+O#=�9[j�L7^�Q:6{ST576�9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L QT6 ��6�V;OaSe9[^�L o7Q:^Bl�6�8:816�L>Se9[QT6�V[=�� �

<79;OR8T6�r 9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L�o7Q:^ �B9[r76�Qkl�ORL ORV $gO#=d8 < 6�l�^d6�Q:l�6�r Se^2o7QT^ �d9;rI6�`fX7V[V�9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L3s OaL7r8T^ ST576kORr �R^Bl�OaSe6kOaL7r r76�l�9;8:9;^�L ]+O �R6�Qg]+O =+< 6iSeQT6�OaSe6�r,OR8-O X7L79 S ��W\^�Q_8T^�]�6il#Oa8T6�8�s7Se579[8_9[8ORo7oIQT^�o7Q:9UOaST6Rs7<IXIS-`f^�Q/^RSe5I6�QT8/ST579;8/9[8-O�V[9[S:SeV;6$Se^d^�^�oISe9[]+9[8:ST9;l �4/576(8T6�l�^�LIr{^�oBSe9;^RL3sBlq5I^�8T6�L{<>=18:^�]�6i8TX7<I8T6�S$^R`�ST576iV;9 Se6�QeOaSTX7QT6asB9[8_Se^�OR8:8TX7]�6iSe57OaSgSe5I6

r76�l�9;8:9;^�L�]+O �R6�Q 9[8 L7^aS 8 SeQTOaSe6�j�9;l!��8T576$l#OaV;l�XIVUOaST6�8576�Qo ^R8:Se6�QT9[^�Q�< 6�V;9;6m`f8�j�9 �R6�L $-57OaSe6 ��6�Q 9;L &`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�LkSe5I6/ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6/9[8�$-9;V[V;9[L7j$ST^ij�9 ��6Rs�ORL7r SqO!�R6�8�Oao7o7QT^Ro7QT9;OaSe6_ORl�ST9;^�L � 4/579[8�r79;Q:6�lmSe9;^RL$-9;V[V < 6(`f^�V;V[^ $ 6�r,9[L x 6�lmSe9;^RL v � �4/576_ST579;Q:r ^�oBSe9;^RL�9;8�Se^ ] O!�R6�`fX7L7r\OR]�6�L>SeORVBlq57ORL7j�6�8PSe^$Se576 8:SeORL7r\ORQ:r�`fQeOa]+6 $_^�Q � �n4/579[8

ORo7oIQT^>ORlq529;8gSeO �R6�L*9[L p 5\ORoIST6�Q �"�

� �� � ������)+� . ��� �,'��(! � ��� �#�������� � ������� �����k)2� ������� ���

� �*���� � �n�

4/579[8i8T6�l�Se9[^�L�j�9 ��6�8(O 8TXIQ ��6m=�^R`�8:^�]+6 8T6�V;6�lmSe6�r ]�^dr76�V[8 ^R`�9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L2o7Q:^ �d9[8T9;^RL*<>=�^�LI6<79;OR8T6�r ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6!� � V;V ^R`3ST576�] OR8:8TX7]�6�Se57OaS_ST576�9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L�o7Q:^ �d9[r76�Q 9;8gO L7^�L & 8:SeQTOaSe6�j�9;lORXIST^�]+OaSe^�L s $-579;lq5 O �R^�9;rI8kST576%`fX7V;V�9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L{QT6�8TX7V S ^a`g4/576�^�QT6�] ��CIs�6 �R6�L ST57^�X7j�5 9[Sl�^RX7V;r < 6kORo7o7V[9;6�r1Se^�ORV[V ^R`�Se5I6(]+^dr76�V[8g< 6�V;^%$ 9[` ST576(r76�l�9;8:9;^�L,]+O �R6�Q $_6�QT6 ORV;V[^%$_6�r1Se^�ORlmSOR8$O%8:STQeOaST6�j�9[lkORj�6�L>S �4/5I6 `f^dl�X78 $-9[V;V3< 6(^�L2V;^�<I< =d9[L7j�ORo7o7V[9;l�OaSe9[^�L78 �4/576*Q:6�8:X7V[S+9;8%Se57OaS $-9 Se57^RXIS �:X7r7j�6�8 $-57^ ORQT62l#ORo7OR<7V;6,^R`i8:SeQTOaSe6�j�9;l�ORV;V = 9[L ST6�Q:o7QT6mSe9;LIj

9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L3sgo7ORQ:ST9UORV 9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RL�9[81o ^R8T8T9[<7V;6*9;L ORV[]+^�8 S ORV[V�l�OR8T6�8 � 4/57606 Il�6�oIST9;^�L 9[8$-576�L�Se576�QT6 9;8PO ]�^�L7^RST^�L79;l�]+ORo7o79[L7j-`fQT^�] ST576 XBSe9;V[9[SM=i`fQ:^�] O rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L ST^ ST576_9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�Lo7Q:^ �d9[r76�QSe^ ST576�XBSe9;V[9[SM= `fQT^�] ST576�8TOR]+6$r76�l�9;8:9;^�L�Se^ Se576 r76�l�9;8T9[^�L ]+O �a6�Q ��KML�Se579[8 l�OR8T6asISe5I6

Page 49: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

v �ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�< 6�l�^R]+6�8�ORL 6� dST6�L78:9;^�L ^a`_Se5I6�rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L ]+O �a6�Q�sPORL7r 8T^ $-9;V;Vnl�^�]�o7V[=�$-9[ST5 Se5I6r76�l�9;8:9;^�L,]+O �R6�Q�� 8-r76�8:9;QT6(`f^�Qg`fXIV;V39[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L �x 9;LIl�6�o\OaQ:Se9;ORV-9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L�Q:6 �R6�VUO Se9;^RL 9;8+L7^%$ o ^�8:8T9;<IV;6Rs/V[6�S � ����� � � 8:9;j�L79 ` = Se5\O S

8T9[j�L\ORV ^RL76�9[8$]�^�Q:6 9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9 ��6iST5\ORL{8T9;jRL\ORV3S $ ^"�-4/576�6 7Oal�Si]�6#OaL79;L7j�^R`nSe579[8$ST6�QT] $-9[V;V< 6 j�9 ��6�L*^�L*O+l#Oa8T6 & <>= & l#OR8:6 <\OR8:9;8�� � V;8:^7sYV;6mS���� 8T9[j�L79[` = `fX7V;V 9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L,ORLIr ����8:9;j�LI9[` =L7^�9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L �

���� ��� !�� � ��� � ���� ��� � # � �b-^�8T6�L ST5\ORV�� �)C � ORL7r � ^�V;r78 Se6�9;L � t � � QT6�o ^RQ:SkSe5\O S ]+ORL>=�V[^�<7<>=d9;8:ST8kr76�8:l�QT9[< 6�Se5I6�9;Q��:^R<78�Oa8Se57OaS�^R` o7QT^dr7X7l�9;L7j � SeQTORl�6�OR<79;V[9[SM= � � � ^ ��6�Q:L7]�6�L>So ^�V[9;lm=�9[8n` ORQ�Se^d^(l�^R]+o7V[6� �`f^�QnSe5I6 O �R6�QeOaj�69;LIr79 �d9;rIX\ORV�Se^ X7L7rI6�QT8 SqORLIr3snOaL7r09[Si9[8(6#OR8 =*ST^2V[^�8T6 Se576%l�^�L7L76�l�Se9[^�L0< 6mS $_6�6�L Se576%o\Oa8T8eOaj�6^R`�O�V;O%$ ORL7r29[ST8$6 6�l�ST8 �g4/576 QT^�V[6(^R`nST576 V;^�<7<>=d9;8 S$9;8gSe^�]+O �R6 l�V[6#ORQ/Se57OaS$l�^�L7LI6�l�ST9;^�L s 8:^Se57OaS ��^RST6�QT8�� L7^%$ Se5\O S_Oklq5\ORLIj�6 l�ORL < 6/SeQTORl�6�r+Se^ Ok<79;V[V7ORL7r�Se576-<79[V;V7l�ORL < 6/SeQTORl�6�r <\ORl��Se^%ST576�9[Q/QT6�oIQT6�8:6�L>SqO Se9 �R6Rs ORL7r2QT6�o7QT6�8T6�L>SeOaSe9 ��6�8 � L7^%$ Se57OaS ��^RST6�QT8 � L7^%$ �KML OR<78:STQeORlmS(Se6�QT]�8�s O1Q:6�o7Q:6�8T6�L>SqOaST9 ��6�9;8�9;L>Se6�QT6�8 Se6�r 9[L�o7VUOal�9;LIj1576�Q:8T6�V[` OaSiST576%]+6�r79UOaL

^R` w ^�Q�8:^�]+6 ^RSe5I6�Qi8 SqOaST9;8:ST9;l <\OR8T6�r�^�L | ��^RST6�Q(o7Q:6�`f6�Q:6�L7l�6�8kORV[^�L7j+8T^�]�6 8T9[L7j�V[6 r79[]+6�L78T9[^�L �� 6�S Se576 STQTX76+r76�LI8T9[SM= ^R`/oIQT6�`f6�QT6�L7l�6�8�< 6 � w | �d� C � � 4/5I61V;^�<I< =d9[8:S 5\OR8�ST576 ^�oBSe9;^RL^R`�ORo7o7Q:^>ORlq579[L7j�Se5I62Q:6�o7Q:6�8:6�L>SqOaST9 �R6*ORLIr oIQT6�8:6�L>Se9[L7j0Se576 �aORV;XI61^R` � w | `f^�Q%8:^�]�6 QeORL7jR6 � w1���B� | �KML O $ ^�QTV[r $-576�QT6�8T9[j�L\ORV[8(] O#=�< 6�r76�L78:9[SM=�`fX7LIl�Se9[^�L78�s ST576�cdXI6�8:ST9;^�L ^R`_^�QTr76�QT9[L7j,< 6 &

l�^R]+6�8/L7^�L>SeQ:9 �d9UORVFs 8T^�< 6m`f^�QT6(rI9;8Tl�X78T8:9;L7j ST579;8_]+^dr76�VFsIK $-9;V[V Z7QT8:S-rI9;j�Q:6�8T8gST^ Se576(8:X7< �:6�l�S$^R`�_V;ORl��'$_6�V;V � 8/^�Q:r76�Q:9;L7j�^R`P9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L �

� � � � + � + � �>!"�(�� ������� �*�'!A �� ������=�5 (�>���0 (�>���

�_V;ORl��'$_6�V;V � 8 � � � r76�Z7L79[ST9;^�L ^R` � ]�^�Q:6+9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9 ��6�� $gOa8�Se^�8:9;]�o7V[=08TO#= ST5\OaS 9 `-O{rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L]+O �R6�Q�� 8 ( ��� ���7( XISe9[V;9[SM= $_OR8 579[j�576�Q1j�9 �R6�L 6 Io 6�Q:9;]�6�L>S ��ST5\ORL j�9 ��6�L 6 Bo 6�QT9;]�6�L>S � sSe5I6�L,6� Bo 6�QT9[]+6�L>S � $gOa8/]+^�Q:6i9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9 ��6-Se^ ST576(r76�l�9;8:9;^�L ]+O �R6�Q � #$6(r76�Z\LI6�8 � j�ORQT<7V[9;L7jSeQTORL78 `f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L78 �[s ORLIr+8:57^%$-8 Se57OaS_9[L%Se576$l#OR8:6 $-576�QT6-Se576�QT6 9;8O j�ORQT<7V[9;L7jiSTQeORLI8:`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L`fQT^R] ^�L7628T6mS1^R`�8T9;jRL\ORV;8 ST^ ORLI^RSe576�Q�sSe576�LHSe5762o7Q:6 & STQeORLI8:`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L 8:9;j�L7ORV/8T6mS 9[8+]�^�QT6

Page 50: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

v 6� � �

� � � � � � � ORQ:j�]+O ���� � � w � � � � | [ OaQTj�]+O ���� � � w � � � � |w ^�Q � �M��� � �m � � |� w � | � ORQTj�]+O � � � � w � � � |

Wn9[j�X7QT6 v � v � KMLI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L 9;8 SeQT9 �d9UORV[V[=�]�^�QT6 �ROaV;X\OR<IV;6 9 ` �_VUOal�� $ 6�V[V � 8%j>ORQ:<7V;9[L7j*r76mZ\L79 Se9;^RLORo7oIV;9;6�8 �

�aORV;X7OR<7V;6,Se^ ST576�r76�l�9[8T9;^RL ] O!�R6�Q+Se5\ORL�Se576�o ^�8:S & STQeORL78 `f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L 8T6mS QT6�j>ORQTrIV;6�8:81^R`kSe5I6XIST9;V;9 SM=+`fXIL7l�ST9;^�L,9;L �R^�V �R6�r �K `YO j�ORQT<7V[9;L7j/]+OaSTQT9 i6� B9;8 Se8�sRSe576�L O$]+^dr76�V><7OR8T6�r�^�L Se579[8 rI6�Z\L79 Se9[^�L ^a`79;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9 ��6�L76�8:8

$ ^�X7V;r < 6�STQT9 �d9;ORVys 8T9[L7l�6 � ]�^�QT6 9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9 �R6�� l�^RQTQT6�8To ^�L7r78/ST^ � ]�^�QT6 X78T6m`fX7V ST^ Se576irI6�l�9[8T9[^�L]+O �R6�Q�� � 4/576{c X76�8:ST9;^�L ^R` $-576�ST576�Q�Se576,Oar ��^dl#OaST6 $-9[V;V QT6 �R6#ORVg`fXIV;Vg9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L 9;8 Se5I6�L8T9[]+oIV[=%Okc X76�8 Se9[^�L ^R` $-576�ST576�QSe576 ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�� 8 9;L>Se6�QT6�8:Se8_ORV;9[j�L $-9[ST5�ST576$r76�l�9;8T9[^�L�] O �a6�Q � 8��# ^%$ 6 �R6�Q�s�`f^�Q ORL ORQT<79 SeQTORQ:=0o\Oa9;Qk^R`-9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L�8T6mSe8�s�O{j>ORQ:<7V;9[L7j,] O SeQT9 09;8 X7L7V[9 �a6�V[=�ST^6� B9[8:S �4nO!�R6 � Se^ < 6(ORL>=+8T6mS/^R`�8T9[j�L\ORV[8 8:X7lq5 Se5\O S-ORL>= o7OR9;Q^R`�8T9[j�L\ORV[8 � � ORL7r �*�$ORQT6 QT6�V;OaSe6�r

<>= 8T^�]�6�j>ORQT<IV;9;LIj2]+OaSTQT9 � � � w Se57OaS 9;8�s � �M��� � � m �*� | s�ORL7r � � w � | Se^2< 6�ST576+rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L]+O �R6�Q�� 8$XBSe9;V[9[SM=�`fQT^�] r76�l�9;8:9;^�L � ��4/576 8T6mSeX7o{9;8/8:X7]+]+ORQ:9 ��6�r 9;L2Wn9[j�X7QT6 v � v �K `_ST576�ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�� 8 XISe9[V;9 SM=�s � � w � | s 9;8kO ]+^RL7^RSe^RL79;l�ORV;V =,9;L7l�QT6#Oa8T9;LIj1SeQeOaL78:`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RL�^R`

Se5I6 r76�l�9;8:9;^�L ] O �a6�Q � 8 XISe9[V;9[SM=*`fX7L7l�ST9;^�L � � w � | s Se576�L Se576 ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6�$-9;V;V�Q:6 ��6�ORVgOa8�9;LB`f^�Q &]+OaSe9 ��6+O*8T9[j�L\ORV OR8 o ^�8T8:9;<7V[6���9 ` � � w � | 9[8 O*]�^�L7^RST^�L79[l#ORV[V[=�rI6�l�Q:6#OR8:9;L7j�STQeORLI8:`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L^R` � � w � | s�Se576�L ST576,ORr �R^Bl�OaSe6 $-9[V;VQT6 ��6#OaV-OR8%X7L79[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9 ��6 O�8T9[j�L\ORV_OR8 o ^�8T8:9;<7V[6��gOaL7r9[`-ST576�Q:629[8%L7^0]+^RL7^RSe^RL79;l�SeQeOaL78:`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RL3s�Se576�L�9 S%9;8�X7L7l�V[6#ORQ $-57OaS�Se576,ORr ��^dl#OaST6 $-9[V;Vlq57^d^�8T6!�

� � � � + � 8 � �!"�5�0!A�������%� �

b-6�SeXIQTL�Se^kSe576-SeQTORl�6�OR<79;V[9[SM= c X76�8 Se9;^RL+r79[8Tl�X78T8:6�r OaS�ST576-< 6�j�9;L7LI9;L7jk^R` Se579[8�8T6�lmSe9[^�L � � 6�SSe5I6r76�L78T9 SM=+^a` ��^aSe6�Q�SqOa8:Se6�8_^ ��6�Q_8:^�]+6-o ^�V;9[l�=%rI9;]�6�L78:9;^�L�< 6 � w | s � � u � � � �P4/576�V[6�j�9[8TVUO Se^�Q � 8^�L7V = 8T^�X7Q:l�6g^a`Y9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RL Oa< ^�XBS � w | 9;8PO�V[^�<7<>=d9;8:S�$-57^i]+O#= lq5I^B^�8:6_Se^�QT6 �R6#ORVI8T^�]�6_<7XBSL7^RSnORV[Vd^a`7Se576 r76�LI8T9[SM= `fX7L7lmSe9[^�L � 4/576�Q:6/ORQT6 QT9[j�5>S &MV[6#ORLI9;L7j/V[^�<7<>=d9;8:ST8�sR`f^RQ $-57^R] � w � | � ��s

Page 51: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

v 7� � o7QT^R< ��r76�L78:9[ST9;6�8/^ �R6�Q � � u � � �

r76�l�9;8:9;^�L,]+O �R6�Q�� 8 oIQT9;^RQ � � � u � � �� � t�� ��� ���� � � � � � � � � � � [ � � � �� w � | � ]+6�r79UOaL2^RQ/]+6�ORL,^R`no ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q� w � | � �

Wn9[j�X7QT6 v � �"��4 QeOal�6#Oa<79;V[9[SM=+]+^dr76�V

ORL7r2V;6m` S & V;6#OaL79;L7j V;^�<I< =d9[8:Se8�s7`f^�Q $-57^�] � w � | � & � �� OaQT<7V[9;L7j(o7Q:^ �B9[r76�8�^�LIV[=%O �R6�Q:=�o\OaQ:Se9;ORVI^RQTr76�QT9;LIj ^a` ST576-8To\ORl�6 ^a` o ^�8T8:9;<7V[6/8T9[j�L\ORV[8 ��W\^�Q

6� IOR]�o7V[6Rs 8eO#=%Se57OaS O V[6�` S & V;6�ORL79;LIjiV;^�<I< =d9[8:S9;8�^�L7V = $-9[V;V;9[L7j�ST^ Q:6 ��6�ORV � w | `f^�Q � �� s $-5I9;V;6O�QT9;jR5 S &MV[6#ORL79[L7j V[^�<7<>=d9;8:S$9[8$^RL7V[= $-9[V;V[9;L7j�ST^+Q:6 �R6#ORV�� w | `f^�Q [ �� � 4/576�Q:6 9[8-L7^+j�ORQT<7V[9;L7jSe57OaS $_^RX7V;r1STQeORL78 `f^�QT] Se576(V[6�` S &MV;6�ORL79[L7j�9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L+9;L>Se^ ST576(QT9[j�5>S &MV[6#ORLI9;L7j 9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RL3s8T^ � VUORl��'$ 6�V;V � 8_4/576�^�Q:6�] l#ORL L7^aSg576�V;o X78g9[L1^�Q:r76�Q:9;L7j�ST576ir79[8:STQT9;<IXISe9[^�L78 �nKML78:ST6#ORr3sIK^! 6�QORL2ORV Se6�Q:L\OaST6(]+^dr76�V 576�Q:6 �� 6�S � s ST576�8:o\ORl�6%^a`�8:SqO Se6�8�^R`�Se576 $_^�Q:V;r3s < 6 Se576�8T6�Si^R`N�h(Wn8�^ ��6�Q � � u � � � � 4/576

V;^R<7<>=B9[8:S$l#OaL*8T6�L7r�9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L,OR< ^�XIS ORL>=,8:X7<78T6mSi^R`�o ^�9[L>Se8-9;L � u � � � s\^�Q � � t � ��� ��� � �(LI6o ^�8T8:9;<7V[6$^RQTr76�QT9;LIj ^R` � $-5I9;lq51OaV;V;^%$-8ORL>=�S $_^ 6�V[6�]�6�L>Se8�Se^ < 6$l�^�]�o\ORQ:6�r $_^RX7V;r+< 6$<\OR8:6�r^�L Se5I6 ]+ORj�LI9[SeXIr76(^R` Se576k8T6mSe8��� � ��� � � 9 � � � � [ � � ��� �4/576o ^�8 Se6�QT9;^RQ < 6�V;9;6m`f83^R`dSe576�r76�l�9[8T9;^RL ]+O �a6�Q�r76�o 6�LIr�^�Lk576�Q oIQT9;^RQ ORL7rkSe576�9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L

o7Q:^ 6�QT6�r < = Se576 V;^�<7<>=d9;8 S ��4/576 V[6�j�9[8TV;OaSe^�Q $-9[V;VOR8T8:9;]�9;V;OaSe6�Se576 L76�$ 9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L0X78T9[L7j�gO#=�6�8T9;ORL0X7o r7OaSe9[L7j w r76�8To79 Se6 ST576%l#O ��6�OaSe8 ^R` p 5\ORoBSe6�Q � | � W\^�Q 8T9[]+o7V[9;l�9[SM=�s K $-9;V;VPOR8:8TX7]�6Se57OaS�ST576 r76�l�9;8:9;^�L*] O �a6�Q 5\OR8�ST576 X7L79 `f^�QT] o7Q:9;^�QW� w | � ��s�� � � u � � � ��4/576%V[^�<7<>=d9;8 S�9[8< ^�X7L7r Se^%ST6�V;V Se576iSTQTXIST5 $-576�L2576(r7^d6�8-8eO#=,OaL = ST579;L7jIs78T^%Se5I6(r76�l�9;8T9[^�L ]+O �R6�Q�� 8$o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q< 6�V;9[6�`f8+OR< ^�XIS ST57^�8:6�o ^�9[L>Se8 Q:6�o ^�Q:ST6�r ^RL 9;8 6�c X\ORV ST^ Se5I6�QT6�o ^�Q S1j�9 ��6�L �DK `��� 9[8+Se5I6l�^R]+o7V[6�]�6�L>S ^a` �/s�ST576�L `f^RQ%ORL>= ����gsi� w | � � � � �$&_� w � | � ��Se5\OaS 9;8�sPSe5761rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L]+O �R6�Qi9;8iV[6�` S $-9[Se5�O1X7L79[`f^RQT] o ^R8:Se6�QT9[^�Q�< 6�V[9;6�` s $-57^�8:6%V;9 �a6�V[9;57^d^Br26�c X\OaV;8i^�LI6 ]+9[L X78�Se5I6Se^aSqORV o7QT^R<\OR<79[V;9[SM=1QT6�o ^�Q Se6�r�<>=2Se576�V;^�<7<>=d9;8 S � D 9 Se5*ST576�o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q 9;L�]�9;LIr3s ST576�rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L]+O �R6�Q l�ORL*Se5I6�L�ORlmS�<>=2lq57^d^�8T9[L7j+ST576 ]+6�r79UORL2^�Q$]+6�ORL*^a`�Se576 r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL � x 6�6 Wn9[j�X7QT6v � �%`f^�Q-O%8TX7]�] OaQ:=1^a`nSe5I6 ]�^dr76�V �

Page 52: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

v C� � � � + � � � �����>!"� ���������

K S�9;8�6#Oa8:= Se^ l�^�]�6,X7o $-9 Se5 6� IOR]�o7V;6�8 $-576�Q:6{9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L 9[8�LI^RS�`fX7V;V = QT6 ��6�ORV;6�rH<>= OV;^R<7<>=B9[8:S-^R`P6�9 Se576�Q-6� dSeQ:6�]�6 �W\^�Qg6� IOR]�o7V[6Rs\8eO#=1ST5\OaS-Se5I6 rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L1^R` SqOa8:Se6�8 9[8

e�w | �� C � � u � �� �u �� � u � �� � �

4/579;8%9[8 O $ 6�V[V &M< 6�57O �R6�r r79[8:SeQ:9;<7XBSe9;^RL �%9[S�9;8 $ 6#O � V = 8T9[L7j�V[6 &Mo 6#O!�R6�r s�ORL7r Se5I61r79;8:l�^�L &Se9[L X79[SM= ]+O =�6#Oa8T9;V =H< 6�8:]+^d^RSe5I6�r ^�XBS $-9[ST57^�XIS lq57ORL7j�9[L7j Se576*r79;8:l�X78:8T9;^RL < 6�V;^%$ � 4/576SeQ:X76%]�6�r79;ORL�^R`�Se5I9;8ir79[8:STQT9;<IXISe9[^�L�9;8iOaS�� �

�� � v � � x O#=�Se5\O SiSe576%rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L�] O!�R6�QkOa8 � 8kO

V;6m` S & V;6#OaL79;L7j,V[^�<7<>=d9;8:S `f^�Q 9;LI`f^RQT]+OaSe9[^�L � 4/5I6�L 576�$_^RX7V;r ^RL7V[=0Q:6 ��6�ORV�Se5\OaS e�w | � u `f^RQ � � �� � � � ��4/576kr76�l�9;8:9;^�L,]+O �R6�Q $_^�XIV;r,l�^�LIl�V;XIr76 $-9[Se5,Se5I6 o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q

�A�po:q w | �� t � � u � �� �u �� � u � �� �

$-57^�8:6 ]�6�rI9UORL 9[8-OaS ���

� QT9[j�5>S & V;6#OaL79;L7j0V[^�<7<>=d9;8:S $_^RX7V;r Q:6 ��6�ORV ST576�o\OaQ:S1^a`(Se576�rI9;8:STQT9[<7XISe9[^�L 9;L � u � � � t � � � sV;6�ORr79[L7j Se^%Se5I6k`f^RV;V;^%$-9[L7j o ^�8:ST6�QT9[^�Q/< 6�V;9[6�`f8��

�A�po:q w | �� C � � u � � � t � � �� � u�u � �� � u � � � t � � � �

E ^aSe9;l�6 ST5\OaS-OaS Se576�o ^�9[L>S � � t � �Bs e�w | � � � u�u �"��4/5I6(]+6�r79UORL+^R` Se5I9;8_o ^�8 Se6�Q:9;^�Q 9;8_OaS � � u>t �KML < ^RSe5�l#OR8:6�8�sgST576�Oar ��^dl#OaST6�8+lq57^�8T6{Se^ Q:6 �R6#ORV$^�L7V = o\ORQ:ST9UORV/9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9;^�L s OaL7rHSe5I6

r76�l�9;8:9;^�L,]+O �R6�Q-lq57^�8T6�8�O�V;^dl#O Se9;^RL18T^�]�6kr79;8 SqORLIl�6(`fQT^�] Se576(STQTX76k]�6�r79;ORL ��4/576k`f^�V;V[^%$-9;L7jo7Q:^�o ^R8T9[ST9;^�L jR9 ��6�8/Se576kj�6�L76�QTORV QT6�8TX7V S �

� (� - ��� �%���>��� + � �T;��TF�(��4)��A( � !/.*�")�!48:�%�"!@&-�c&,; � � u � � � !/. enw | E �TF�(k�%(�>*!/.*!@&-� ��� ��(*)�� .�<)�!@&-)0!/. � w | E � �<� �#F�( �%(�>*!/.*!@&-� ��� ��(*) 3Q!#9#9 >�F�&�&�.�(0�#F�( � (a� !4� ��&,; F�(*)G��(*)�>�(*!#6 (a� ��&�.*�,(*)�!@&-)� !/.*�4)*!48:�%�4!@&-� E �#F�(*����9/& 8�8:1p!/.*�b3GF�&0�<)H(T;K(*)�.0. ��� 9#9/(*) &-�%�,>�& � (�. �7& 9 � )@$%(*)Z3Q!#9#9��?&-� )�(*6 (a� 9K;��%9#9!#�K;K&-) ��� �"!@&-� ! ; �#F�(*)H(O( �B!/.*�T.�.�& � (k!#���7(*)�6-� 9 w1���B� | ��8*&-6 ( �#F�( � (a� !4� � &,; e�w | .*��>�Fl�TF�� �e�wTr | [ � w4r | ;K&-)�� 9#9 r � w1���B� | E � �<�D�#F�(*)H( � 9 .�&_( �B!/.*�T. .�& � (k!#���7(*)*6-� 9 w��-� SB| 8*(*9/&-3 �#F�(

Page 53: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

v��� (a� !4� �D&,; enw | .*��>�F��#F�� � e�wTr | � � w4r | ;K&-)'� 9#9 r � w � � Sd| X

giF�( .:� � ( 9/& 8�8:1p!/.*�23Q!#9#9)H(*6 (a� 9 .�& � ( �:� � ���4!#�"1_&,; !#�K;K&-) ��� �4!@&-� ! ; �#F�(*)�(�( �B!/.*�T.�.�& � (!#���7(*)*6-� 9 w1���B� | ��8*&-6 ( �TF�( � (a� !4� � &,; � w | .*�A>�F��#F�� � � w4r | [ e�w4r | ;K&-)O� 9#9 r � wL���B� | E� �<�L�#F�(*)�(O� 9 .�& ( �B!/.*�#.k.�& � (�!#���,(*)�6-� 9 w��-� Sd| 8*(*9/&-3 �TF�� ���#F�( � (a� !4� � &,; � w | .*��>�F �TF�� �� wTr | � e�w4r | ;K&-) � 9#9 r � w � � Sd| X

giF�( !#�?(��:��� 9 !#�4!@(�.2� )H(�)H(*6 (*)�.�(a� ;K&-)2��9/& 8�8:1-!/.*� 3GF�&Z�<)�(T;K(*)H.�9 � )"$%(*) &-�%�,>�& � (�.��,& . ��� 9#9/(*)&-�%�,>�& � (�.:X

� � � � + � � � �0!"� ���������

K `nST576kr76�l�9;8:9;^�L,]+O �R6�Q/lq57^B^R8T6�8-Se5I6 ]�6#OaL2^a`PST576ko ^�8 Se6�QT9;^RQ/r79;8 SeQT9[<7XIST9;^�L3sdSe576�L �

� (� - ��� �%���>��� 8 � � )�! $-F%�4579/(a� ��!#�%$�9/& 8�8:1p!/.*� 3Q!#9#9 )H(*6 (a� 9B;��=9#9 !#�K;K&-) ��� �4!@&-�O! � � w | !/. �?&-��5�%(�>*)H(a�-.*!#�%$�X giF�( 9/& 8�8:1-!/.*�W3Q!#9#9 )�(*6 (a� 9?�?& !#�K;K&-) ��� �"!@&-�O! � � w | !/.2�?&-��!#�?>*)�(a�-.*!#�%$�X

giF�( )H(*6 (*)�.�(2!/.j�")���( ;K&-)'��9/(T;��"579/(a� ��!#�%$�9/& 8�8:1-!/.*�@X

x ^19[L�< ^aSe5{ST576 l�OR8T6 ^a`�8T6�V;6�lmSe9[L7j O ]�6#ORL{^�QiO+]+6�r79UORL s `fX7V[V�9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RL29[8 Q:6 �R6#ORV[6�r^�L7V = XIL7r76�Q/8:o 6�l�9 Z\l(l�^�LIr79[ST9;^�L78�s7ORLIr29 Sg9[8go ^R8T8T9[<7V;6 Se5\OaS/O 8T^�V[6iV;^�<I< =d9[8:S $ ^�L � S-QT6 ��6#OaV3`fX7V;V9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L Q:6�j>OaQTr7V[6�8T8-^R` $-576mSe576�Q 576 $_ORL>Se8 O�5I9;j�5 ^�Q-V[^ $ � �

���� ��� � ��� ��� � � ��� � ��� � � � � � � � � �� �� �� � � � ���4 ^ l�^�LIl�V;XIr76�Se5I6i8T6�l�Se9[^�L ^�L1^RL76 &MORr ��^dl#O Se6i]�^BrI6�V;8�s K $-9[V;VYr79[8Tl�XI8T8 � X78:ST9;L & x ]+9 Se5 � 8_]�^dr76�V� v�� s Z7STST9;L7j 9[S�9;L>ST^ ST576{`fQTOR]+6 $_^RQ � r79[8Tl�XI8T8T6�r OR< ^ ��6 � � 8 $-9[ST5 � VUORl��'$ 6�V;V � 8�]�6�Se5I^Br ^R`^�Q:r76�Q:9;L7j 9[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9;^�L3s $ 6 Z\L7r�Se57OaS $-9[ST5�L7^ ]�^�L7^RST^�L76 ]+ORo7o79[L7j+`fQ:^�]�9[LI`f^�Q:] OaS ��6�L76�8:8Se^�ORr ��^dl#OaST6�� 8 XIST9;V[9[SM=�sdSe576�QT6k9;8/LI^�jRX\ORQeOaL ST6�6 ^R` `fX7V;V 9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9;^RL1QT6 ��6�V;OaSe9[^�L �

� X78 Se9[L & x ]�9[ST5 � 8 $_^�Q:V;r 5\OR8(S $ ^*8:SeOaSe6�8�s�� ORL7r � snOaL7r ST576�r76�l�9;8:9;^�L ] O!�R6�Qk5\Oa8kS $ ^^�oIST9;^�LI8�s �DORL7r � ��4/576 �aORV;X76-Se^ ST576�rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L1]+O �R6�Qg^R` SqO!�d9[L7j ST576il�^�QTQ:6�l�S/ORl�ST9;^�L SeO �R6�8S $ ^ ORQ:j�X7]�6�L>Se8�s ST576 8:SeOaSe62ORL7r Se5I62rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L �/D 576�L ST576,r76�l�9;8T9[^�L ] O Selq576�8�ST576,8:SeOaSe6as

� w � � � | � � w � � � | � � � $-576�L ST576�=0r7^,L7^aS#s � w � � � | � � w � � � | � u ��N�QT9[^�Q�ST^{OaL =9;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9[^�L `fQT^R] Se576 V;^�<I< =d9[8:S#s>ST576 rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L ]+O �R6�Q < 6�V[9;6 ��6�8�Se5I6 V[9 �R6�V;9[57^B^dr%^R` 8:SqO Se6 � 9[8� � [ �� �g4/576 r76�l�9;8T9[^�L2] O �a6�Q$] O I9[]+9 ��6�8/579;8$6� Bo 6�l�ST6�r�XBSe9;V[9[SM=Rs\ORL7r2Se576�QT6�`f^RQT6�lq5I^B^�8:6�8 �

Page 54: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� u$-9[ST5 l�6�Q:SeOR9;L>SM= 9[`7ST576go ^�8:ST6�Q:9;^�Q V;9 �R6�V[9;57^d^dr ^a`\8:SeOaSe6���9;8 j�QT6�OaSe6�QPST5\ORL%O�57ORV[` sRORL7r 8:9;]�9;VUOaQTV[=`f^�Q � � �4/576�Q:6,9;8 ^�LI6 V;^�<7<>=d9;8 S#s $-57^ $-9[8T576�8 Se5\OaS 6�9[ST576�Q � 9;8%ORV $gO#=d8%lq57^�8:6�L3s ^�Q�ST5\OaS � 9[8

ORV $gO#=d8�lq57^R8T6�L s�r76�o 6�L7rI9;L7j�^RL 579[8�o 6�QT8:X\OR8:9;^�L � x 9[L7l�6�Se576�QT6+9;8 L7^�]�^�L7^RST^�L79;l%STQeORL78 `f^�Q &]+OaSe9[^�L�`fQ:^�] Se576 V;^�<I< =d9[8:S � 8_jR^>ORV;8�Se^ Se57^�8:6i^R`3ST576ir76�l�9[8T9;^RL ]+O �R6�Q�s � VUORl��'$ 6�V;V � 8 4/576�^RQT6�]w rI9;8Tl�X78T8:6�r{9;L,8T6�l�Se9[^�L v � ��� ��� � | 9[8/L7^RS-X78:6�`fX7V�576�QT6 �4/576 8T9;jRL\ORV;8 Se576kV;^R<7<>=B9[8:S$lq57^d^�8T6�8$`fQ:^�] OaQT6k6� Bo 6�QT9[]+6�L>Se8�s"$-5I9;lq5,SeX7Q:L{X7o26�9 Se576�Q-^�XIS &

l�^R]+6 � ^�Q � �� 4/576{6 Bo 6�QT9;]�6�L>S�9;8�r76�8Tl�QT9;< 6�r <>= S $_^ L X7] < 6�QT8���� � � u � � � j�9 ��6�8

Se5I6 V[9 �R6�V;9[57^B^dr ST5\OaS$Se576 ^�XISTl�^�]�6k9;8� � 9[L28 SqOaST6 � s $-579;V[6 � � � u � � � j�9 ��6�8$ST576 V[9 �a6�V;9[57^d^BrSe57OaS-Se576k^�XISTl�^�]�6k9;8� � 9;L,8:SeOaSe6 � � 4/576 8:9;j�L7ORV38To7ORl�6 9[8-ST5 X78$ST576k8T6mS�^R`n^�QTrI6�QT6�r*o\Oa9;QT8� � w � � � |�� � ��� s ORL7r�l#ORL�< 6-o\OaQ:Se9;ORV;V = ^�QTr76�QT6�r+<>= � � ��� � � 9 � � &'� � [ � � &'� � �n4/576`fX7V[V[=+9;LI`f^�Q:] O Se9 �R6�8:9;j�L\OaV 9;L ST579;8/l�^�L>Se6� dS$9;8���� � w u � � | �nSe5I6 rI6�l�9[8T9[^�L ] O!�R6�Q � L7^%$-8-Se5\O SSe5I6�8 SqOaST6+9[8 � 9[`Se576�6� Bo 6�Q:9;]�6�L>SkSeX7Q:L78 XIo � ORL7r�Se5I6+8 SqOaST6�9[8 � jR9 ��6�L ^RXISel�^�]+6 � �4/576g`fX7V[V[= X7L79[LI`f^�QT]+OaST9 ��68T9[j�L\ORVB576�Q:6/9;8���� � w �� � �� | s>^�Q�ORL>= ^RST576�Q�8:9;j�L\OaV $-576�QT6 � & � � u �

� X78 Se9[L & x ]�9[ST5{8:57^%$-8iSe5\O SiORL*6� Bo 6�QT9[]+6�L S�l#ORL*9;L7r7XIl�6 S $ ^ SM=do 6�8(^R`�< 6�57O �d9[^�Q�9[L{Se5I6r76�l�9;8:9;^�L{] O!�R6�Q��/9[S l#ORL*l�^�L �d9;L7l�6 576�Q Se^+lq57^d^�8T6 � $-9[ST5*l�6�Q:SeOR9;L>SM=�s ^�Q�9 S$l#ORL�9[L7r7X7l�6 576�QSe^ lq57^B^R8T6 � j�9 �R6�L*ST576�8:9;j�L\OaV � ORL7r � j�9 ��6�L�8T9[j�L\ORV � � � 9 ��6�L{Se576 o\ORQeOa]+6mSe6�Q:8�576�QT6asL7^RSeOR<7V = � [ �� s ST576*r76�l�9[8T9;^RL�]+O �R6�Q�$-9[V;V-ORV $gO#=d8 lq5I^B^�8:6�� j�9 �R6�L�^�XISel�^�]�6 � � 4/576r76�l�9;8:9;^�L,]+O �R6�Q $-9;V;V lq57^d^�8T6 � j�9 �R6�L2^�XISel�^�]�6 � 9 � w � � � | [ �� s"$-579[lq5{^dl�l�X7QT8$9

� � � �7w ��& � | � w v � � |

���:/0-L�1 &���RTF *�!6 � - -1���!/�8=9>�����D- �@�!��-1�$F 9�#N���0.$� �1�@�!60�B� �32 � ��#&H3���L� V���Y[Z]I��16���/�<36=���� *�!6��$� 80��8>�$� .� "�1�;-5�160����!6��$�;\ � /(� � ��#&H3�$�1� � - '����0�� "�1 &�3����2 9� &��- N- '( ")>���1�����;\ �: N- '(��.$ &-1 "��� F=��C��$�� &- .����0-1 &'(���1 &��<S�4 ��8��1�3P��.��!-�I476��,-L�=HB��#&/��= N-W &� V Y � �$Z IQ���0' F /0-�M.D6��T��-1� �!6��A9>���1�1�$� ��2 �160�=�4 �E\�� � �3'(HT N-L���@47 "#&# <� "H��=8��1�3P��.���� �� <3�T�(' � �D�B�1 &��< ����#"%O *2 �!6��A/(�! "#& *�%O2U�!�3F�� &-W�BH3�$�W� .$�$�1�!�3 "���160�1�;-L6���#&' \ �]2 �16E�B�W�!6��1�;-L60�3#N'O N-W�0�����@�����3I�160�$���16��@�3'�H, N-1�3� &-7.$�3�0-1 &'��$�!��'=�!� 9>� 9� N�3-1��'���<��3 "�E-���WI�-1 "�0.$�� 6E�3- �1� 9>� �3#"F �,-��E�[47#&��-!- �!�M�!��.$�$ &H3� �� <3�T�(' �B�!���1 &��<0\ � /(� /���#& "C����:/0-L�1 &���RTF *�!6 � - FM�('(��# I,�B2��!�$� �1�;.��� "HT &��<@� � <3�T�(' �B�D�B�1 &��<EIB�16��7'(�;.� N-L &�3�MF=��C��$� &-<3/E���D���,�1����' �160��� �!6�� 8��!��P�;. � N- &�0'(����'A� <3�T�(' �3����\ ��'(HT &-1�3�D-5�!6��$�!��2U���1� �1��8��1�;-L���,� '( *)+�$�!�$�,� "�(2U���1F=���1 &�3�80�3�L�! *�! "���0-$I��3�0'� *�: N- �1���,/0�3/0- �!�A-1�[% �!60�B� �3����'(H3�(.$���1� 476�� �1��#" N��90#"%A�!�$8>�3�1�!- 476����1�@�M8��!��P�;. � � - HB��#&/�� &-#&�T.��B�!��' &� �160� 80�3�L�! *�! "�����,V Y ��� XBZ �;V�� X � ��Z��@ &- � #&��-!-�9� &��-L�;' ���!60������� ��'(H3�(.��B�1�@4760�S�!�$#& &�39�#"%��!�$8>�3�1�!-�476��$�!���8��!��P��.�� � - H[�3#"/0� N- #"�(.��B�1�;' 47 "�160 "���,V Y ��� �,X[Z ��V�� �,X � �$Z��,\ �]�@ &-@�3#&-1��'( ��A.�/�#"�@�1��8��!��'� &.����������! "�#� 476� N.D6���2�160��-1� �4 � 80���1�1 "�1 &�3�E- 47 &#&#(9E�7F �3�!� "�(2U���1F=���1 &H3� �1�@� '(��.$ &-1 "��� F=�3C3�$�;\ �J�16����1�$2U�3�!� -L�1 N.DC@�!�$� /0-L�1 &��� R(FM "�16 � -HB���! &�3�,� �32J�!6� &-:FM�('(��# I0476��$�!� 9� &��-7���0'� &�(2U�3�!F=�B�1 &H3������-!-7���!� ���3-1 &�$� �1�='(� �0����\ ��:/0-L�1 &���RTF *�!6 /0-1��'��16��@�0���!���1 &�3�&%�'W���E'(% � \

Page 55: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �� 8:8TX7]�9;L7j�� � � 6�LI8TX7Q:6�8�ST5\OaS Se576�8T9[j�L\ORV[8 l�ORL LI^RS�< 6�QT6 �R6�Q:8T6�r s�ORL7r ST576�^�XISel�^�]�6

$-576�QT6 � 9;8$lq57^�8T6�L $-9[ST5*l�6�Q:SeOR9;L>SM=2l#ORL*< 6 8T57^%$-L*ST^1< 6 9;]�o ^�8T8:9;<7V[6(j�9 �R6�L�O�o7QT9[^�Q-< 6�V;9;6m`Se57OaSiSe5I6%V;9 �a6�V[9;57^d^Br2^R` � 9[8ij�Q:6#OaST6�Q�ST5\ORL �� �k4/576���� ������� o7Q:^�<\OR<79[V;9 SM=,^R`�^�XISTl�^�]�6 � 9[8^�L76+9[` p ^�L7r79 Se9;^RL v � � rI^B6�8�L7^RS 57^�V[r3s�OaL7r 9;8 6�c X\OaVST^{Se5I6 o7Q:^�<\OR<79[V;9 SM=�^R` � 9[`g9 S r7^B6�857^�V[r �-4/576 o7Q:^�<\OR<I9;V;9 SM=1^R` � s `fQ:^�] Se576 o ^R9;L>S�^a` �d9;6�$ ^a`�Se576 V;^�<I< =d9[8:S $-9 Se5{o7QT9[^�Q-< 6�V;9;6m`Se57OaS-^�XISTl�^�]�6 � $-9;V;V ^Bl�l�X7Q $-9 Se52o7QT^�<7OR<79;V[9[SM= � � 9[8

� w ��� � | m � w � |� � w � � � | m � w � | � � � � � �7w ��& � � | �Wn9[j�X7QT6 v � �28:57^%$-8�Se5\O S `f^�Q � �

� �2ORL7r � �� 6Is Se576+o7QT^�<7OR<79;V[9[SM=�^a` � 9[8�ORL 9;L7l�QT6#Oa8T9;LIj

`fX7L7lmSe9[^�L3s7X7L>ST9;V�� � �� s\OaS $-579[lq5{o ^�9[L S � $-9[V;V < 6klq57^�8:6�L $-9[Se52l�6�Q:SeOR9;L>SM=��4/576 ]+^dr76�V 9;8/8TXI]+]+ORQT9 ��6�r 9;L2Wn9;jRX7QT6 v � 6��

Wn9;jRX7QT6 v � � ��4/576ko7Q:^�<\OR<I9;V;9 SM= ^a` � 9;L7l�QT6�OR8T6�8 $-9 Se5 � s7<7XBS$ST576�L,` ORV[V;8_ST^ ��6�Q:^"�

4/576 ( �O� ���7( XISe9[V;9[SM= ST^,O � &MV[^�<7<>=d9;8 S(9;8 9;L7l�QT6#Oa8T9;LIj,OR8 � w � | 9[L7l�Q:6#OR8:6�8�s <7XISk^�L7V =*8:^V;^RL7j OR8il�^�L7r79 Se9[^�L v � �%9;8�]+6mS �kWn9 I9[L7j � � �Rs `f^�Qi6 IOR]+oIV;6Rs OR8 �09[L7l�Q:6#OR8:6�8i`fQT^R] ��6�QT^1ST^^�L76as Se576�8T9[j�L\ORVnj�^B6�8(`fQT^�] < 6�9;L7j `fX7V[V[=�9[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9 �R6 Se^2< 6�9;LIj1`fX7V;V =�X7L79[LI`f^�Q:] OaST9 �R6 � �_XBSSe5I6�� &MV[^�<7<>=d9;8 S � 8nXIST9;V;9 SM=k9;8P]+^�LI^RSe^�LI9;l#OaV;V[=i9;L7l�QT6#Oa8T9;LIjiX7L>Se9[V-� � w � & � |�� � s>O S $-579;lq5%o ^�9[L SXIST9;V;9 SM=�r7QT^Ro78_Se^ ��6�Q:^"� � 8g8:57^%$-L,9;L Wn9[j�X7Q:6 v � �Bs7O ]�^�L7^aSe^�L79[l lq57ORL7j�6i9[L19;LB`f^�QT]+OaSe9 ��6�L76�8:8w <>=2ORL>= ]�6#Oa8TX7Q:6RsYL7^RS �:X78 S � & � | r7^B6�8-L7^RS$9;]�o7V[= O�]+^�LI^RSe^�LI9;lilq5\OaL7j�6 9;L,XISe9[V;9 SM=���4/579[8ORV[V;^%$-8 ST576_^RoISe9[] ORV 8:^�V;XIST9;^�LkSe^�< 6 L76�9 Se576�QP`fX7V[VdLI^�Qno\OaQ:Se9;ORV QT6 ��6�V;OaSe9[^�L �R`f^RQ ST576�� & V;^�<7<>=d9;8 S#s

Page 56: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� t� � � � � � �� � w � ��� |

� � ��� � � � � � � & � � � [ � � � &O� � � s7^�Q ���� � [ ���

� �� w � | �

�� � � � � [ �7w � & � |� � � � �7w ��& � |�� �� � � � �7w ��& � |�� �

� w � | � ��� � � �� ��������� ������ ������ � � � ��������� ������ ������ �� ��! �#" � 6 �%$ ���&�'�( &&)+* ��-, � � * ��.��/��', �0��� �' * � * ����(132�45� � �76 � � R98��8 � �;: ���< , � � & ��� ����� ���� $ ��� 4=, ��� � � � 2�( . � � � 32� � � � �'2>�'��& � 4 � ( . ��- � ( " � � ? � � �-,@2A� � $ ������ 4=, � � � ( $ ��-,B4 � !��=2A�(�� � ��� � �C6 �� � �� : 2�4=,� �ED � �#�',���F� � 2 � � ���(�4 � ( � G�', � !#�-�� (@2 � � ( � ! � * � 2�!��-�H2A( � �(I � ! * 2A�- � ( ? �', �J.�� 4E��- � ( * 2 � � !H�� ��� K� $ G�',L, � ! � !- � !%�',@2A� � [ �� ? 2A( .� � $ ��� 4=, ��� � � � $ G�',M4 � !��=2A�(�� � �� �� �ONQPSRJT ���VU NQP< ,���F� � 4E�- � ( . ��-4E���-� �/. �', � 2 * � ��(�� � W�(I � ! * 2A�' � (M! �ED�� 2 ���/.B���X� Y2A� �/. 2 .ID � 4Z2>� � �E[ D �\ � � ��.]� �^ � 2 .ID�� 4/2A� � �Q� � 4 � (������� � (�� �G� ! �5D � 2 � ��( � �2�� �E. �(I � ! * 2A�- � ( ? � ! � ( � ����,_�(+ � !&`* 2A�' � (a�',@2>�L2A(b��( � �2�� �E._.�� 4/��- � (b�� ��� ���- �I��� [ < � 2�4=,I �ED�� �-,��� ? G�c��c�-� � 4E � (��Q�',@2>��', �0.I� 4/��- � ( * 2A^ � !d4/2�( .�� ���� (X2 * � ( � � � (I�4Z2 ����� �(�4/! � 2����(�� * 2 ��� �(��ef! � * �(I � ! * 2A�- � (� ! �;D .��/. � � �-, � 2 .ID � 4Z2A� � � �1�I�- � G� � [_gh�I����Q��Q( � �L2 � \ 2 � � ��� �-�� ����� � �i.�� �-�� (j�-�I4=,k2* 2 ��� �(�� � � � ��� 4EY2 ����� G � ( � \ ���, � �F� �L� (��-��! � ! � � �����-( � ��� � ! ���l� !��' � �J�-��4=,m2�� �/n �� � � !�Y2��� �(I�0� �/n � � (9�-Y2 � E 2��-, � 2�( . � � � � * � ����'��2A�' � (�� \ ���I��� 2 . � � f� ��� �(I � ! * 2A�- � (e! �ED��/� 2>�' � (2�� .�� �-�! �/. ? \ ,� ��� �( � �-, � !�� ? �', � 2 .+D � 4Z2A� ��o � � �2�� \ ��� �( � � � (I4 � �', ��p (@2 ����� � �4 �q� �I�-4 � * � [

� � � � �,/� "#& &9��1 &/�F�I �16�� '(�;.� N-L &�3� F=��C3��� .D6��T��-1��-Fr 4760�$� "�0'� *)+�$�!�$�,��\ �160�$�!47 &-1�sr 4 �3/�#N' -1 &<3�0�3#� � � �st ��u't � �sv;I����E'��0�M� �,/� "#& &9��1 &/�F 4 ��/�#&'����( N-�7<� "H��$��.��3�,�! "�T/���/0-7-L &<3�E��#N-$\

Page 57: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� "

� � ��� ��� �

�� ��� �� ����� �� � ��� ����� �� ��� � � �� �!���"�$# �%# ���'& �����$�)( * � � # �,+ �-� ��� �� � & �� ��� �� �-� & �/. �0�,��� �1

2�354 687:9�;=<?>A@AB�9DCE<F7

G�HJILKNMOHQPSRUTWVYXNRJXZVEKZVY[\TZK]P0^F_a`JVEbc_SdeP"TWXfIgPSbihjGlkm_nPS`poS_UMYPqTWVEK:RJXfVYKZVE[\TrPSXZsutp^FVE[vTZKFTZ_�P`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[A^FPSxqVYXYy � kzHJ_ TWHJVE[A`JVYMEIw`JVEK{kzHJIwMOH0PSXfsutJ^|VY[\TWK{PSXZV}ME_uXZXfVYM~T�y8PS[J`�TZHJV�KZV~ouVEXZILT���_SdTWHpVeRptJ[JIwKfHJ^|VY[\T���ILd�PS[\�p�~h�)HQPqT�PqXZsutJ^|VY[\TZK�kzIwbLbDTWHJV Pq`pou_aM�PqTZVYK}^FPSxqVSy=PS[J`�HJ_5k�MYPS[�kmV:V~�UR�VYMET�TZHJVN`pVYMYILKZIL_u[

^FPSxSVEX|TZ_�VEoqPSbLtQPqTZVrTZHJVY^N�'G�_�PS[JK�k�VEXNTWHJVEKZV��vtJVEKfTZIw_u[JKEy���RJXZVEKZVE[vT P�^|_U`JVEb�_Sd�MYPStJKWPqbKfTZ_uXZILVYK�PS[p`"TZHJVYILX�VEoqPSbLtQPqTWIL_u[�heG�HJV�^F_a`JVEb�Iw[JMEbwtJ`pVYK���_STWH"VEoSVY[\TWKe_Sd�TWHJV�tpKZtQPSb�d�_SXZ^������_aMYMYtpXZXZVE`� ¡�~y¢PS[J`?V~ouVY[\TZKc_Sd8TZHJV{d�_uXZ^-���$M�PStJKfVYK¤£F ¥hDG�HJV�`QPqTWP§¦�_SXZIwVE[\TWVY` ^|_a`JVYbLKYyp_qd¨kzHpIwMOHTWHpV{bwI¥TWVYXZPqTWtpXZV©ILK�RJXfIw^FPSXZILbL��ME_u^|Rª_uKfVY`�ypPSXZV{P}KZR�VYMYIwPSb«MYPSKZV�_qd¬TWHJILKl^F_a`JVEb­h!G�HpV�PS`J`JI¥TWIw_S[QPSbVY^��ªVEbwbwILKZHJ^|VY[\TZK:�ªV~�u_u[p`jTZHJV"`QPqTOP®¦�_uXfIwVY[\TZVY`)^F_a`JVEb{PSXfVA[J_ST?[JVEMYVYKfKWPSXfIwb¥�¯�¡ILXZXZPqTWIL_u[QPSbi �_SXRJXf_5�UILVYK�d�_uX�MY_Ssu[JILTZILoSV{bwIL^FI¥TOPqTZIw_u[JKE°vIw[JK�TWV�Pq`�ypTWHpVE�?PS`p`JXZVEKZK¤�atpVYKfTZIw_u[pK¤_qd�TZHJV�RªVEXZMYVERpTWIL_u[?_SdM�PqtJKWPSbLILT��SypkzHJIwMOHrbwILV{_utpTZKZIL`JV�TWHJV�d�XWPq^FV~k�_uXfxN_Sd�KfTWPqTWILKfTZIwMYKEh±Q_uXcME_u^|RQPSXZILKZ_u[«yªP|KfTZXZIwM~TWb¥� `QPqTWP§¦�_uXfIwVE[vTZVY`]^F_a`JVYb¬km_uXZxvK�PqK¤d�_ubLbw_5kzKY²�TWHJV�KfTWPqTWV�_Sd�TWHpV

km_uXZbL`|ILKD`JVYKfMYXfIw��VY`N�\��P�bLIwKfT�_Sdªd�PqMETWKEyaPS[J`FPS`pou_aM�P§TWVYK=KfIw^|RJbL��RJXZ_5oaIw`pV¤IL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u[�KZ_�TWHQP§T³�´¶µ�·i¸§¹�º=»½¼u»Y¾À¿~Á§Â�·ªÃiÄ5Ã�·­¹�Å{ÆE·i¸®¹fÂi¹¨Ç~Âi¹�·�È«¿D·�Ä�ÉS¹fâ¿~ÊvË5¹f¾�Ì¡ÃiÌÍ¿Eµ�Å�ÇÏÎ~¹fÂfÆ~Ȭ¸®¿=¸§ÇWÐE¹8Ë5ÌÒÑu¹�­¹�µY·ª·­Ç~ÃiÎ5Ã�Ó§Ô�Á®Â­¿~ÂÕÃÇϵqË!Ô�Á§Ë5Ö~¹ZÃ�»J×®¿EÂQ·i¸§¹¨É®Á®Â­ÉS¿EÃi¹fÃQ¿~ÊS·­¸®Ì�Ã�¾Õ¸§Ç~É5·i¹fÂfÆ~·i¸®¹fÂi¹¬Ì�âµ®¿�Øq¹fµ®¹ÀÙ®·�·i¿=Å�ÇÏÎ�Ì¡µ®Ö=Ç=Ë5Ì�Ã�·iÌ¡µ§¾�·­ÌÍ¿Eµ�Øq¹�·�Ȫ¹f¹�µl·i¸§¹·�È«¿§Æ~Ãi¿�´UȬ̡ÚÍÚ§Á§Ã�¹«·­¸®¹¬·i¹fÂiÅ�ë۽Ë5¹f¾�Ì¡ÃiÌ¡¿~µ�ÅlÇ~Î~¹fÂfÜO¿EÂ�Û Ô�Á§Ë®Ö~¹~Ü¡Æ~¹fÐ~¹fµ�·­¸®¿~Á®ÖE¸�·­¸®¹¬ÉS¹�ÂÕÃ�¿Eµ�Ì¡µ�Ð~¿EÚÍÐE¹fË=Ì�ÃQÃi¿~Ål¹À·­ÌÍÅl¹fÃÇϵ{Ç~¾À·iÁ§Ç~Ú�Ô�Á§Ë5ÖE¹=Çϵ§Ë©Ì�ìÃ�¿EÅ�¹�·iÌ¡Ål¹fìÇ�Ô�Á®Â­¿~ÂZ»

Page 58: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

���

TWHpVr`pVYMYILKZIL_u[ ^FPSxqVYX�M�PS[�tJR�`QPqTZV]HJVEX�RJXZIL_uX��ªVEbwILVEd�K�PS��_utpT�TWHpV?oSVYXZPSMYI¥T��n_Sd©TZHJV d�PSMETZK�TZ_^|_uXZV�PSMYMEtJXWPqTZV}R�_uKfTZVYXZIL_uX©��VYbLIwV~d�KYh��¤d¶TWVYX¤TOPSxvIL[JsNd�PSM~TWtQPSb�KfTWPqTWVE^FVE[vTZK©d�XZ_S^-TZHJV�PS`poS_UMYPqTWVEKPS[J`�`p_uIw[JsrTWHJV?PqRJRJXZ_SRJXZIwPqTWV|tJR�`QPqTWIL[JsJy�KfHJV `JVEMYIw`pVYK�tJR�_u[�TZHJV:^|_uKfT�bLIwxqVYbL�"K�TOPqTZV:_SdzTWHpVkm_uXZbL` �QPSKfVY` _S[JbL�n_u[ HJVYXF_5kz[ Rª_SKfTWVEXZIL_uX��ªVEbwIwV~d�K|PS�ª_StpTFTZHJV]d�PqMETWKEh)G�HJV�RJXfVY`JILMETZIw_u[�_SdTWHpV�`QPqTOP®¦�_uXfIwVY[\TZVY`�^|_U`pVYb!ILK©KfIw^|RJbwV�PS[J`�TWHpVY_uXfVETWILM�PSbLbL�rXZ_S�JtJKfTY²©_uRpRª_uKfIw[Js:PS`pou_aM�P§TWVYK{kzILbwbPSb¥klP��aKzXZVEoSV�PSb¬d�tJbLb�Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�h�� d�tJbLb�`JIwKfMYtJKfKZIL_u[]ILK�Iw[��UVEMETZIw_u[ � h��phahG�HJV�RpXZVY`pIwMETZIw_u[)_Sd�TWHJV"MYPStJKWPqbe^|_a`JVYb�ILK:TWHQPqTrVYPSMOH PS`poS_UMYPqTWVAkzILbwb{��V�^�tJMOH ^|_uXZV

KZVEbwVEMETWI¥ouV|Iw["`JVEMYIw`pIw[Js?kzHQPqTeIw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�HJV�kzIwbLb!RJXf_5oUIL`JVShF�ÕTeIwK�Rª_SKZKZIL�JbwV}TZHQPqT�TWHpVYXZVFPSXfVPSRJXf_uR�_uK�KfTZ_uXZILVYK�kzHJIwMOHr[JVEILTWHpVYXzRQPSX�T��:kzIwbLbªk�PS[\T¤TZ_|TZVYbLb­h

�©b¥TWHJ_utpsuH RQPqXfTWIwPSb�Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�XZV~ouVEbgPqTZIw_u[ ^NP��nKZVEVY^ Iw[\TZtJILTZILouVEbL��_S�voaIL_utJKN_SXFVYPSKZILbL�V~�URJbwPSIw[pVY`�ypTZHJV�bwI¥TWVEXWPqTZtJXZVcKZt��ªVYXfKzd�Xf_u^�P�RJPStJMYI¥T��N_qd!^|_U`pVYbwKm�QPSKfVY`r_u[?P�KfTWXftJMETZtJXZV{kzHpIwMOHPSbLbw_5kzK:RQPSX�TWIwPSb©IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[�XZV~ouVYbwPqTWIL_u[ Iw[)VE�atpIwbwIL�JXZILtJ^rh ±¢_SX:V~�pPS^|RJbwVqycTZHJVAMY_u[p`JILTZIw_u[JK[JVEVY`JVE`rd�_uXmd�tJbwb�Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[NXfVEouVEbgPqTZIw_u[N`JIwKfMYtJKfKZVY`]Iw[ �aVYMETZIw_u[ � h��ph����VYbw_5k PSbwbL_5k d�_uX�`JVEMYI ¦KZIL_u[?^NPqxSVYXfK�kzHJ_FHJP5oSV�KfHJ_uX�Tc^|VY^|_uXfIwVYK�_uX�tJKZVeXWPq[J`J_u^|I��YPqTWIL_u[:`JV~oUILMYVEKYhG�HJV�RJXZIL^NPqXf�r`JI��ªVYXfVY[JMEV��ªV~T�k�VEVY[0TWHJV}^|_a`JVYb�RJXZVEKZVY[\TZVY`�HpVYXZV�Pq[J`ATWHJV�`QP§TOP§¦Õ_uXZILVY[\TWVE`

^|_U`JVEbwK�ILK�TZHQPqTFILT�ILK|_qd¶TWVY[�TWHJVrM�PqKZV?TWHQPqT�T�km_�`JI��«VEXZVY[\T|V~�URJbwPS[QPqTZIw_u[pK|_qd�PS[ VEouVE[\T PSXfVKZIL^}tJb¥TOPS[JVE_utJKfbL��Kft��|MYILVY[\T}VÏ�pRpbgPS[QP§TWIw_S[JKYh ±Q_uX�VÏ�JPq^FRJbLVSy=���aHJVFK�TOPS�p�ªVE`�HJIw^��ªVEM�PStJKfVNKfHJVHQPS`rHQPqTZVY`rHJIw^�d�_uX�^F_S[vTZHJKY ¥y�PS[J`"�¡KfHJVeKfTOPq�J�ªVE`�HJIL^���VYMYPStJKZV�KZHJV�k�PSKc`pXZtJ[Jx:PS[J`�_StpTz_SdMY_S[vTZXZ_ubi ¬PSXfV�T�km_r`JI��ªVYXfVY[\TeKfTW_SXZIwVEK�kzHJIwMOH0Iw^|RJbL�rT�km_�`JI��«VEXZVY[\TeR�VY[QPSb¥TWILVYKYh��a_?kzHJPqTe`J_UVEKTWHpV��ftp`JsuV?`J_0ILd¤�ª_qTWH�KfTW_SXZIwVEK|PSXZV RJXf_5ouVY[�TW_0�ªV TZXZtJV����=Xf_u�QPS�pIwbwI¥T���kzILbwbm[J_ST|HJVYbLRnHJVYXEy��VYM�PqtJKZV{KfHJV�PSbLXZVYPS`p�|xv[J_5kzK�TWHJV©KfTOP§TWV©_qd¬TWHJV¤k�_uXfbw`"�¶TWHJVc`JVEd�VE[J`QPS[\Tlk�PSKl��_STZH:`JXZtp[JxNPq[J`HQPS`�HQPqTZVY`�HpIw^1d�_uX�^|_u[\TWHJKW�~y!Kf_]TZHJV��J[QPSbDouVEXZ`JILMET}ILK�bwVEd¶T�TZ_]TWHpV��ftJ`psuVS ÒK�_uRpIw[JIL_u[�h|�ÕT�ILKR�_uKZKfIw�JbLV�TZHQPqTeKZHpV|kzILbwb��QPqKZV|HJVYX�_uRJIL[JIw_S[0_S[0kzHJ_rRJXfVYKZVE[\TWVY`�TZHJV|PSXZsStJ^FVE[\T�°!I¥d�KfHJV|`J_UVEKKZ_pyªTWHpVY[�TZHJVYXfV}^NP��?VÏ�pILKfT©KfTW_SXZIwVEKcTZHQPqT©kzILbwb¬��V�`JV~TWXfIw^|VY[\TOPSb¬TZ_NTWHJV�RJXZVEKZVE[vTZVYXEy¬XZVYsuPSXZ`JbLVYKfK_Sd¨kzHJVETZHJVYXzTWHpVeRpbgPSIL[vTZI��]_uX�`JV~d�VY[J`QPq[vTcRJXfVYKZVE[\TWKYh

�c_uXf^NP§TWILoSVYb¥�uyuTWHpVYXZVcIwK�P�KZIwsS[JI��QMYPS[\T�`JI��ªVYXfVY[JMEVc��VET�kmVYVE[:TWHJVEKZVcT�km_�^|_a`JVYbLKY²¨tJ[J`JVEXmTWHpV`QPqTWP§¦�_SXZIwVE[\TWVY` ^|_a`JVYbiyUIL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[|IwK�PqbLk�P5�aK�d�tJbLbL�|XZV~ouV�PqbwVY`«yJKZ_�TWHpV�`JVYMEIwKZIL_u[ ^FPSxSVEX�IwKlIL[TWHpV�Iw`pV�PSb8R�_uKZI¥TWIw_S[rTZ_:^NPqxSV}P|`JVYMEIwKfIw_u[�°��JtpT©Iw[�PNM�PStpKWPSbLbL�?_uXfIwVY[\TZVY`�^|_U`pVYb­yJTZHJV�`pVYMYILKZIL_u[^FPSxSVEX�^NP��]V�PSKfIwbL�]XZVYPSMOH0P `JI��ªVYXfVY[\T�`JVYMEIwKfIw_u[�d�Xf_u^-TZHJV�_u[JV�KfHJV�k�_StJbw`A^FPSxSV�sSILouVE[Ad�tJbwbIw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�h

Page 59: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

������������ ���������� G�HJVz^F_a`JVEbQHJVYXfV¤^FP�����VcPqRJRJbwILVY`�TW_ePS[\��KfILTWtJPqTWIL_u[}kzHJVYXfV¤T�km_�_SRJRª_SKZIw[psPS`poS_UMYPqTWVEK©P§TZTWVE^FRUT�TW_|MY_u[\oaIw[JMEV�P�`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[?^FPSxSVEX�TWHQPqTzTZHJVYILXZKzIwKlTZHJV�ME_uXZXfVYM~T¤oaILVEkzR�_uIw[\T�hG�HJILK©Iw[pMYbwtp`JVYKcPS`poSVYXfTZIwKfIw[JsJy¢kzHJVEXZV�T�km_NouVE[J`J_uXfK{oaIwV�d�_uX©PFRJtJXZMOHJPSKZV�d�Xf_u^/_u[JV�MY_u[pKZtJ^|VYXE°_uX¤bw_u�p�v�aIL[JsJyQkzHJVYXfV}bw_S�J�\�UILKfTZK©PqTcVYI¥TWHJVEXcVÏ�aTWXZVE^FV�PSXZsStJVeTZHQPqT{PFbwVEsuIwKfbgPqTZ_uXlKfHJ_utJbL`�ou_STZV�IL[d�P�ou_uXz_Sd¨TWHpVYIwX�KfIw`JVqh

�©bLKZ_JyDTWHpIwK�^|_U`JVEbl^FP5��suVY[pVYXWPqbwbL�0TWVEbwbltpK|^|_uXfV PS��_utpT�HJ_5k%R�VY_SRJbwV ^FPSxSV `pVYMYILKZIL_u[JKYh�UIL[JMYV�ILT©PSbwbL_®kzK�d�_uXzTWHpV}KZVERQPSXWP§TWIw_S[�_SdD��VYbLIwV~d�K©PS��_utpT¤d�PSM~TWKcd�Xf_u^ _uRJIL[JIw_u[pKcPq�ª_utUT©^|_STWI¥ouVEK_uX�MYPStJKZVEKYy¢ILT�d�PqMYIwbLILTWPqTWVEK�KfTZtJ`p�?_Sd¨TWHpVeRpXZ_uR�VYX�TWIwVEKz_Sd�TZHJ_uKfVe_SRJIw[JIL_u[JKEh

���������������������� ���!�"��# �UVYM~TWIL_u[ � h��suILoSVYK P�XZVEoaILVEk-_Sd�TWHpV�bwI¥TWVYXZPqTWtpXZVr_SdeM�PStJKZPSbwI¥T��uyd�XZ_S^%TWHJV�RªVEXZKZR�VYM~TWI¥ouV}_Sd�KfTOP§TWIwK�TWILMYIgPq[JKYy¢RJK��UMOHp_ubw_usSIwKfTZKYy«PS[J`�bLVYs\Pqb¨RpHJIwbL_uKZ_uRpHJVYXfKYhz��`JIwKfMYtJKfKTWHpV}PS`poaILMYV�sSILouVE[��\�?TWHJV�TZV~�aTWKc_u[�bLVYs\PSb¨PSXfsutJ^|VY[\T�y¢kzHJILMOHAPSXfTZIwMEtJbgPqTZV�TWHJV�Iw^|Rª_uX�TOPS[pMYV�_SdRJXfVYKZVE[\TWIw[ps:RQPSXfKZIw^|_u[JIL_utJK¤PSXfsutJ^|VY[\TWK¤Iw[rTWXZIwPSb­h �©KcIw[]TZHJVe_u[JV~¦�PS`poS_UMYPqTWV�M�PSKfV�_Sd%$�HJPSRpTWVEX�py �UVYM~TWIL_u[ � h��Uh�RJXf_®oSVYK�TWHQP§T�tJ[J`JVEX�TZHJV?KZIL^FRJbLVYK�T�_Sd©PSKZKftJ^FRUTWIw_S[JKYy=d�tJbwbmIw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�ILKPSb¥klP��aK�XfVEouVYPSbwVE`��\�"T�k�_APq`pou_aM�PqTZVYK}IL[�Pr`QPqTWP§¦��QPqKZVY`�d�XWPS^|VEkm_uXZx¢h��UVEMETZIw_u[ � h � suILoSVYK�PS[_5ouVEXfoaIwV~k _qd�PS[}PSb¥TWVEXZ[QPqTZV�K�TW_uX��v¦Õ�QPSKfVY`�^|_U`JVEbaPS[J`}I¥TWK¨VYbwVE^FVE[\TWKYyuPS[J` �UVEMETZIw_u[ � h � `JVYKfMYXZIL�ªVEKTWHpVFMYPStJKWPqb�kmVYILsuH\TWK}Pq[J`�RJXf_u�QPS�pIwbwI¥TWILVYK�PSbLbwtJ`pVY`"TW_�Pq�ª_5ouVqh �UVYM~TWIw_S[ � h'&?TZHJVY[�PSKZxvK�kzHpIwMOHKfTZ_uXZILVYK�TWHpV�Pq`pou_aM�PqTZVYK�kzIwbLb«MOHJ_a_uKfVeTZ_|XfVEoSV�PSbih

2�3)( *,+�B.-�/|;D<|@A7A>

G�HJILKlKZVEMETWIL_u[:kzIwbLb¢`JIwKfMYtJKfKlTWHJV�RJXfIw_uX=km_uXZxF_u[ M�PStpKWPSbLILT��uyUPS[J`:TZHJVY[?RJXfVYKfVY[\T¤P�d�VEkjV~�UMEVYXZRUTWKd�XZ_S^/KZ_u^|V�_Sd!TWHJVebgP�k¯TZV~�aTW��_U_SxaKckzHJIwMOH�TWPStJsuH\T©PSXZsStJ^FVE[\TcTZ_N^FPS[\�]_qd�TWHJV�bgP�k��uVEXZK¤TWHJILKRQPSR�VYXzHJ_SRªVEKzTZ_�`JVYKfMYXZIL�ªVqh

021435176 8:9�;=<%9?>@<%9BAC<EDGF�HJILKMHJNO;QP R

S�TVU�TWBTW X �Y�M����Z���[��!�\�

G�HJV�K�TOPqTZIwKfTZIwMEIgPS[FPS[J`:TZHJV �ftJ`JsSV�PSXZV©Iw[:`JI��«VEXZVE[vTlRª_uKfILTZIw_u[JKEh!G�HJV�K�TOPqTZIwK�TWIwMEIgPS[F^}tJK�T�`JVETZVYXÀ¦^|Iw[JV�kzHJILMOH:VEoSVY[\TWKl^FP����ªVcMY_utp[vTZVY` PqK�M�PqtJKZVEKl_Sd«TZHJV©V~ouVE[vTlIw[N�vtJVEKfTZIw_u[�h!��[:KZ_�`J_uIw[psJyvHJV

Page 60: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� &d�PSMEVYK�Pr[vtJ^}��VYX�_Sd�RQPSXZPS`J_��UVYK�PS[J`0RJXZ_u�pbwVY^|KYy¬kzHJILMOH�HJP5oSVN��VYVE[�MYPqTOPSbL_usuVE`��\�ARJXfVEoaIw_StJKPStpTZHJ_uXfKY°¤G�HQPSbw_SK�� � ���¤suI¥ouVEKNP"su_a_U`�_5ouVYX�oaIwVEk�h���tUT|TZHJV�`pVYMYILKZIL_u[ ^FPSxqVYX|HJVYXfV]HQPqKFTWHpVM�PqtJKWPSb¬K�TW_uXfIwVEK¤HJPS[J`JVE`rTZ_|HpVYXz�\� TWHJVePS`poS_UMYPqTWVEKYy�PS[J`?[JVEVY`]_u[JbL�NVEoqPSbLtQPqTWV{TZHJVY^rh

�©[J_qTWHJVEX�KZIwsS[JI��QMYPS[\T�`JI��«VEXZVY[pMYV IwK�TWHQPqT�TWHJV K�TOPqTZIwKfTZIwMEIgPS[�HQPSK�PS[nPS�ptJ[J`QPS[pMYV _Sd¤`QPqTWPkzILTZHrkzHpIwMOH]TZ_FMYPSbwMEtJbgP§TWV�MY_uXfXZVEbgPqTZIw_u[JKEh���XWPq[JsuVYXE ÍK�� &��8ME_u[JMYVERpT{_qd�M�PqtJKWPSbLILT��Sy¢PSbwKf_Fxv[J_5kz[PSK}�ÍKZMEXZVYVE[JIw[ps]_ �l Ly¬ILK{TWHJV��QPSKfIwK{d�_uXcTWHJV�KfTWPqTWILKfTZIwM�Pqb!M�PqtJKWPSbLILT���bwILTZVYXZPqTWtJXfV ��VShÒsJhLy �¨VYXZb� ��� �g�~h�ÕT ILK:_uXZILVY[\TWVE` TW_5klPqXZ`)KfTWPqTWILKfTWILM�PSb¤RJXfVY`JILMETWIL_u[�²0ILde� XZVY`ptJMYVEKrTZHJV�oqPSXZIwPS[JMEV�_Sde_utJX:��VYK�TRJXfVY`JILMETW_SXl_Sd!£FyUTZHJVY[?kmV�MYbgPqKZKz�,PSKzP}MYPStJKfVe_qd!£�Pq[J` M�PS[?^|V�PSKftJXZV�I¥TWKlV �|M�PSM~�rPSKlKZtpMOH�h��XWPS[JsSVYXYyQkzI¥TWHrHJIwKzKfTWPqTWILKfTZIwMYIwPS[� ÒK�kzILT�yQ��VYsSIw[JK¤HJIwKzVÏ�pR�_uKfILTWIL_u[r_u[�MYPStJKWPqbwILT��NkzILTWH«²� �¬V~T������V:PSbLb�TZHJVNIL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u["Iw[�TWHJVFtJ[JILoSVYXfKZV?PSMEMYtJ^}tpbgPqTZVY`�KfIw[JMEVFTWIL^FV���������� � &��iy�R � ��\�~h�UtJMOH�P��atJPS[\TWILT��:_Sd!V~oaIw`JVE[JMYV�kzIwbLb�[J_STz��V��JXZ_utpsuH\T¤TZ_�TWHJV�MY_StJXfTZXZ_a_u^]h±!Iw[JPSbwb¥�uy«TZHJV������ ���!�#"%$'&)("_SdlMYPStJKZPSbwI¥T���IwK�[p_STeM�PStJKZPSbwI¥T��uh�G�HJVEXZVFPSXZV�RpHJIwbL_uKZ_uRpHJVYXfK�Pq[J`

KfTWPqTWILKfTZIwMYIwPS[JK�kzHJ_FMYbgPqIw^�TZHQPqTcM�PStpKWPSbLILT��?`J_aVYK¤[J_STcV~�UIwK�T�y�_uX�TWHQP§T©I¥TcILKcXfVYK�TWXZILMETZVY`]TZ_:P�d�VEkkmVYbwb ¦�`JV �Q[JVE`�M�PqKZVYKEh*��tpTeTWHpV|km_uXZ`��¡��VYMYPStJKfVS ¨IwK�d�tJ[J`QPq^FVE[vTWPSbDTW_rbgPS[psutQPSsuVqy8�ªVEM�PStJKfVFkmVR�VYXZMEVYI¥ouVeM�PStJKZPSbwI¥T��:IL[ ^��aXZIgPq`rMYPSKZVEK©Pq[J`]�JPSKZV�_utJXlTZHJIw[pxaIL[Js�tJR�_u[ TWHJVEKZVe_u�JKZVEXfoqPqTZIw_u[JKEh±Q_uX�PSbLbm_Sd�TZHJVYKfV?XZV�PqKZ_u[JKEyDTWHJV ^|_U`pVYb�RJXZVEKZVY[\TZVY`�HJVYXfV:d�_UMEtJKZVEK|_S[�TWHJV:R�VYXfMYVERpTWIL_u[�_Sd

M�PqtJKWPSbLILT�� PS[J`)TWHJV0PSKfKZ_aMYIgP§TWVY`jKZtp� �fVYM~TWILoSV�RpXZ_u�QPq�JIwbLILTWILVYKEycPq[J` ILK:TWHvtJKr_uXZILVY[\TWVE` TW_5klPqXZ`��VYHQP�oaIw_uXZPSb�RJXfVY`JILMETZIw_u[?Iw[pKfTWVYPS`?_Sd�KfTOP§TWIwK�TWILM�PSb�RpXZVY`pIwMETZIw_u[«h

S�TVU�TWBTVU + �-,� ����� �/.���Z���

G�HJV{bLILTZVYXWP§TWtJXfVc_u[NKfTW_SXZIwVEKlPSKmRªVEXZMEVYILoSVY` �\���ftJXZ_uXfK�ILK�RJXfIw^FPSXZILbL�}VE^FRpIwXZILM�PSbih#0?�NMEbgPSIL^�TWHQP§TR�VY_uRJbLVzRJXZ_aMYVEKZK�Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[�oaIgP�KfTZ_uXZILVYK=V~�pPSM~TWbL�}^NPqTZMOHJVYK=TWHJPqT=^NPq`JVz�v��TZHJV �aTW_SXf�10]_a`JVEb_Sd ��VE[J[JIL[JsSTW_S[�PS[J`12©PSK�TWILV�� � � �-�iy/� � 3�iy4� � ���¶�Ïh!G�HJVEIwXD^|_U`pVYba_SdªP{KfTW_SXf�}IL[JMYbLtJ`JVEK�Iw[JsSXZVY`pIwVY[\TZKKZtpMOH�PSK©su_\PSbLKYy�IL[JILTZIgPqTZIw[Js�VEoSVY[\TWKEy!PqMETWIL_u[JKEy¬PS[J`"MY_S[JKZVE�atpVY[JMEVYKYh�G�HpV|^|_a`JVYb¨HJVYXfV�IwK{^|_uXZVPS�JK�TWXZPSMET¤PS[p`r`pIwKZMEtJKZKfVYK¤_u[Jb¥�NKfVETWKz_Sd¨MYPStJKZVEKYh �©KlkzI¥TWH?PS[\� Pq�JKfTZXWPSM~TWIw_S[�ypTWHpIwK�PSbLbw_5kzKl^|_uXZVsuVE[JVYXZPSb�PS[QPSb¥�UKfIwKePS[J`�PSRJRJbLIwMYPqTWIL_u[ATW_r^NPS[\�"KfILTWtJPqTWIL_u[JKYy¨PqTeTWHpVFME_uKfT�_Sd���VYIL[Js]tp[QPS�JbLV�TZ_^FPSxSV�KZ_S^FV�_Sd�TWHJVe^F_SXZV�KZR�VYMEI��QMeKfTWPqTWVE^FVE[\TWKzTWHQPqT¤`JVEXZI¥ouV�d�XZ_u^�TZHJV�^F_SXZV�`JVETWPSIwbLVY` �aTZ_uXf�0]_a`JVYbih

Page 61: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

���

S�TVU�TWBT�� � ����,���# �

�¬VYs\Pqb©RJHJILbw_uKf_uRJHJVEXZK PqXZV�d�PS^|IwbLIgPSX}kzI¥TWH TZHJVAIw`pV�P�_SdeKfVYRQPSXZPqTWIL[Js�[JVEMYVEKZKWPqXf�)M�PqtJKZVEK:d�XZ_u^KZt �FMEIwVE[vT�MYPStJKfVYKYy8VqhÍsJh�2c_S[J_uX��V � ��)�­h���tpT�PqK�P:�atJPSbwI¥TOPqTZILouV �QVYbL`�y�bLVYs\PSb¨RJHJILbw_uKf_uRJH\�]KfTW_SRJKkzILTZH:TWHJVEKZVeMYbwPSKZKfI��QMYPqTWIL_u[JKYh!G�HJIwK�RQPqRªVEX�V~�aTWVE[J`JKzTWHJV�IL`JV�P}�\� RJbwPSMYIL[Js}�vtQPS[\TZI��¢PS�pbwV{MYPStJKWPqbkmVYIwsSHvTZK�_u[AIw[p`JILoaIw`ptQPSb¨M�PStJKfVYKEh�G�HJILK�PSbwKf_ PSbwbL_5kzK©tJK{TZ_ KZR�VYMYI¥d¶��VÏ�JPqMETWb¥��kzHJILMOHARQPSX�T�_SdmPXZtpbwIw[psNIwK¤TWHJV�KZtJ� �fVEMETZILouV�V~oqPSbwtQP§TWIw_S[�_Sd=RJXf_u�QPS�pIwbwI¥TWILVYKe��kzHpIwMOHAM�Pq[A�ªV�PStJ`JI¥TWVY`A�\�]_utpTZKZIw`pV_u�JKfVYX�ouVYXfKO��PS[J`:kzHpIwMOH RQPSX�T�IwKmRJtJXfV{_uRJIL[JIw_u[���kzHJILMOH M�PS[ [p_ST���V�PStJ`JI¥TWVE`¢�~°pPS[J`?PSbLbw_5kzK�d�_SXVY^|RJILXZIwMYPSbªTZVYK�TWKYy¢IL[:TWHJV�bgPq�]Pq[J`rd�Xf_u^%PqMETWtJPSb¬M�PSKfVYKEh

021435143 P R2NO;��� ����)H"F P!K H�� <.I2P PM9�;OHJN=K

G�HJILK!KZVEMETZIw_u[�kzILbwbvRJXfVYKZVE[\T=KZ_u^|Vm_qdQTWHJV�d�PSMETZK!k�V�_u�JKZVEXfoSVlIw[}bwP�knPSK!RpXWPSM~TWIwMEVY`}IL[�TWHpV��c[pILTWVE`�aTWPqTWVEKYyJkzHJILMOHrTZHJV�^F_a`JVYbªkzIwbwb«tJKZV�_uX�VÏ�pRpbgPSIL[�h

S�TVU�TVU TW �����"���� �M�Y� �����,�� # � ������Z�

��VeME_u^|^F_u[pbL�:KZP�� TWHQPqT¤P �ftJ`JsSVS ÒKcXf_ubwV�ILKzTZ_�`JVETZVYXZ^|Iw[pV�TZHJV�TWXftpTWH�y¢�JtUT¤TZHJIwKzILKlTWXZtpVe_S[JbL�Iw[�PS[�PqRJRJXZ_��UIw^FPqTZV|KfVY[JKfVShrG�HJV �ftp`JsuVS ÒK�Xf_ubwV|IwK�TZ_]kmVYIwsSH�TWHpVNM�PqKZVYK�RJXZVEKZVY[\TZVY`��\�0�ª_STZHKZIL`JVYK¤PS[p`]KfVYbwVEMETzkzHJILMOH]KfHJV�`pVYVY^|K�TW_���V�TZHJV��ªVEKfT¤_u[JVqhG�HJV|`JIwK�TWIw[pMETWIL_u[AIwK�PqXfTWILMYtJbwPqTWVE`AIw[�TZHJV�ou_ubLtJ^FIL[J_utJK�XftJbwVEK�_SdmVEoaIw`JVE[JMYVqh�$�_S[JKZIL`JVYX�TWHpV

KZI¥TWtQP§TWIw_S[ IL[�kzHJILMOH P�`pVEd�VY[p`QPS[\T:s\P�oSV�P�MEbwVYPSXZb¥��KZIL[JMYVEXZV�ME_u[pd�VEKZKZIL_u[ TZ_�P�MEXZIL^FV?��VEd�_uXfVHQP�oaIw[Js?HJILK�0]IwXZPS[J`QP:XfIwsuH\TZK�V~�URJbgPqIw[JVE`"TZ_?HJIw^rh�G�HJV�d�PSM~T�TWHQP§T�HJV�MY_u[pd�VEKZKfVY`�^FP���VYPSKZILbL�XZVYPSMOH�TZHJV �ftJ`psuVS ÒK©VYPSXZKEyª�JtUTcd�_uXcPF[vtJ^��ªVEXc_Sd�XZV�PqKZ_u[JKEyªI¥T¤IwK¤[J_ST©PS`J^|IwKZKfIw�JbLV�VEoaIw`pVY[JMEVSh ��DbgPqTZ_u[JILM{TWXZtUTWHU¦ÕKZVYVExvIw[Js��ftJ`JsuV�k�_StJbw`]�ªV�tJ[JME_u[JMEVYXZ[pVY`�²�KfHJV�xv[J_5kzK©��VE�S_u[J`AP�XZVYPSKZ_S[QPS�JbLV`J_utp�pT©TZHQPqT¤TWHJVeTWXZtpV�KfTWPqTWV�IwKzTWHQP§TcTZHJV�`JV~d�VY[J`JPS[\T�IwK¤sutJILbLT��uy�PS[p`�MY_StJbw`]Iwsu[J_SXZV�PS[\��Pq`J`JI¥¦TWIL_u[QPSb!Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[�TWHJV|RJXf_uKZVEMYtpTZ_uX�^FP��ARJXfVYKZVE[\T�h ��tpT�Iw["XfV�PSbLILT��uy¬TZHJVFRpXZ_uKfVYMYtUTW_uXe^}tJK�TRJXfVYKZVE[\T�P�MYPSKZV¤tJKfIw[Js�PS`J^|IwKfKZIw�pbwV�VEoaIL`JVY[JMEVSypPS[J`�TWHJV �ftJ`JsuV¤^}tJK�T�`pVYMYIL`JVzkzHJVETZHJVYX�TWHJV¤M�PSKfVRJXf_®oSVYK�sutJILbLTYh��Õd�TZHJVYXfV�IwK{V~oaIw`JVE[JMYV}TZHQPqT{TZHJV �ftJ`JsuV��QPSKZVE`�HpVYX{`JVEMYILKZIw_S[A_u[Axv[J_5kzbwVY`psuV�_SdTWHpVeTZXZtpTZH�XWP§TWHJVEX¤TZHQPS[�_S[rTZHJV�RJXf_uKZVEMYtpTZ_uXY ÒK©MYPSKZVqy�TZHJVY[rTWHJVe`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[]^NP�� ��Ve_®oSVYX�TWtJXf[JVY`�\�?PS[]PSRJR�VYbLbgPqTZV{MY_utpXfT�hG�HJVeVEoqPSbwtJPqTWIL_u[ _Sd�KfTW_SXZIwVEKzV~�URJbgPqIw[JKlkzH\�rbgP�k��uVEXZKz��VEd�_uXfV�TZHJVePSRJR�VYbLbgPqTZV�PS[J` �UtJRJXfVY^|V

Page 62: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �

MY_StJXfTZK�V~�UILKfT�h?G�HJV��ftJ`JsuVEK}PSXfV|d�_SXZ^|VYXebgP�k��uVEXZK}Pq[J`�TZHJVYXfVEd�_uXfVFkmVYbwb ¦ÕoSVYXZKfVY`�IL[�TZHJVF^|Iw[vtU¦TWI��¯_Sd�bwVEs\PSb¨RJXZ_aMYVE`JtJXZVqy8PS[J`�TZHJV}M�PqKZVYKePSXfV�d�tJbLb�IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[?TWHJXf_utJsuHp_utpT�yªKZIL[JMYV��Q[p`JIw[JsSK_Sdcd�PSMET�IL[ PAbw_5kmVYX�MY_StJXfT|^FP5��[J_ST|�ªV?`JILKZRJtUTWVY`«h G�HQPqT|ILKYy=TWHJV TWXfIgPSb�IwK�[J_STFPS��_utpT�tJ[a¦V�PqXfTWHpIw[Js][JVEk VEoaIL`JVY[JMEVSyD�JtUT�PS��_utpT�RJXZ_aMYVEKZKfIw[Js�VÏ�UIwKfTZIw[Js�VEoaIw`JVE[JMYVqh�G¨_AP]TZXZtpTZHU¦�KfVYVYxvIL[Js�ftJ`JsSVSy�TWHpV bgP�k��uVEXZK�PSXfV:XZVE`JtJ[J`QPq[vTY² P�MEbwVYXfx�ME_utJbw`�RJHJ_STZ_UME_uR\��TWHpV PSRJRJXf_uRJXfIgPqTZVNRQPSR�VYXfKd�_uXzTWHJV �ftJ`JsSV}PqT©P|d�XZPSMETZIw_u[r_Sd�TZHJV�ME_uKfTc_SdDHJILXZIL[Js|T�km_:bwP5k��SVYXfK{PS[J`]KfTWPSsuIw[ps:P|TZXZIwPSb­hmG�HJV�lP��uVEKZIwPS[�� �DbgP§TW_u[JILMrPSRJR�VYbwbwPqTWV �ftJ`JsuVrM�PS[ _u[Jb¥��V~�URJbwPSIw[nHJVEXF[JVEVY`�d�_uX�_uRJR�_uKZIL[Js�bwP�k��uVYXfKPS[J`rP}TWXfIgPSb«PSKzP�KZHJ_5k _Sd8d�PSIwXf[JVYKfKYyJTWXZPS`JI¥TWIw_S[�yU_SX�RJtJ�JbLIwM{XfVYMY_SXZ`�h ��tpT�TZHJV�PSRJR�VYbLbgPqTZV �ftJ`JsSVkzHJ_uKfV �f_u��ILKcTW_Fk�VEIwsuH�T�km_ KZIL`JVYK{_qd�PNM�PSKfV�PS[J`�KfVYbLVYMET©TWHJV}^|_uXfV�MY_S^FR�VYbLbwIw[ps|_qdDTWHJV�T�km_TOPqtpTW_ubL_usuILM�PSbLbL��XZVEbwILVYK�tJR�_u[?bgP�k��uVEXZKzTW_�RJXf_®oaIL`JV�TWHJVePSXfsutJ^|VY[\TWKzKZHpV�kzILbwb�k�VEIwsuH�h

S�TVU�TVU TVU � ��� � �Y��#), �Y������� , ����� � ���C�Y��� ���

±Q_uX�P]bw_a_uxAP§T�HJ_5k bwP5k��SVYXfK}PSXfsutJVSy!�©d�_utJ[J`0TWHJV|T�k�_��ª_a_uxvK�_u[0TWXfIgPSbLK�d�Xf_u^����M$ �¨P�k� ÒK±¢PSbwb � � |XfV�PS`JIL[Js:bLIwKfTYyª�\� 0�PStJV~T1� � � �DPq[J` 0]tJXfXWP�� � �)�­h�0�PqtJVET�PqbwKZ_NPSRJR�V�PSXfK{_u[�kzHQP§T_STZHJVYXcXZV�Pq`JIw[Js|bwILKfTZKc�lME_utJbL` �Q[J`���TWHp_uKZV�_Sd�TWHpV�bgP�k KfMOHJ_a_ubwK©PqT���� �$PS[J`]TZHJV �¤[JILoSVYXfKZILT��_Sd.$�HJILM�PSsu_\�~y8PS[J`"ILK{Iw[AI¥TWK{KfI¥�aTWH"VY`pILTWIL_u[�y�IL^FRpbL�aIw[Js|TWHQP§T�ILT�HJPSK�MY_u^|V�XZVEMY_u^|^|VY[J`JVE`"�v�^FPS[\� bgP�k RJXZ_Sd�VEKZKf_uXZKzIw[ TZHJV�RQPSKfTYh

0�PStJV~T�IwKDMYbLV�PSXD_S[FPq`poaIwKZIL[Js{TWHpV¤bwP�k K�TWtJ`JVE[\TmTZ_��ªVEMY_u^|V¤P�K�TW_uX��vTWVYbLbwVEXY² fG�XfIgPSbLK�Iw[\oS_ubLoSV^}tJMOH ^|_uXfVcTWHJPS[:^|VYXZVEbL�|Iw[\TZXZ_a`JtJMYIL[Js�P�KfVET�_qd¬d�PSMETZKY°pTZHJ_uKZVcd�PSMETZKl^}tJK�Tl��V{_uXZsuPS[JI��EVY` Pq[J`RJXfVYKZVE[\TWVY` PSK�RQPSX�T�_SdcPA^FVE^F_SXWPS�JbLVFK�TW_uX��uh � � R � � �c_SX}^}tJK�T�TWHJILK}KfTZ_uXf����V:�JtpXZ`JVE[JVY`�\��TW_a_"^}tJMOH�`JVETWPSIwbi² �%TZHJVY_uX���_Sd¤TWHJV?MYPSKZV?IwK�PAMEbwV�PqXYy�KZIw^|RJbLVNKfTZ_uXf��_Sd��ÒkzHQPqT|XfV�PSbLbL�HQPSRpRªVE[JVY`� ªd�XZ_u^/�u_StJX{R�_uIw[\T{_qdDoUILVEk � hLh¥h ���Õd=�S_utAM�PS[A[p_ST{K�TOPqTZV��u_utpX{TWHJVE_uXf�]_SdDTWHpV}M�PSKfVIw[rP�^|Iw[vtpTWV�_SXlT�k�_Jy¢I¥T�[JVYVE`JK¤^F_uXfV{k�_SXZx¢h � � R � �

0]tJXfXWP�� � R ��¬ME_uXZXf_u��_uXWPqTZVYKlTZHJIwK�TWVEKfTZIw^|_u[\�ª²G�HJV?TWXfIgPSb�bgP�k��uVEXY ÒKFTOPqKZx�MYPS[ ��VrPS[QPSbL_usuI��EVY`�TW_"TWHpVrXf_ubwV?_Sd©XWPSME_u[\TWVEtJX|PqTFPKf_UMEIgPSb�RQPSXfT���_uX�KZIL^FILbgPSX¤Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPSb8s\PqTZHJVYXfIw[JsJh�G�HJV�KfTZ_uXf�vTWVEbwbLVYX{VE[vTZVYX�TOPSIL[JK�HJIwKPStp`JIwVE[JMYV{�\�NXZVYMEXZVYPqTWIL[Js�Iw[:TZHJV{MY_S[JKZMEIw_utJKf[JVYKfKz_Sd8TWHJV�bLIwKfTZVY[JVEXlPS[ IL^NPqsuV©_Sd¨Pq[V~ouVY[\Tc_uXzVYRJILKZ_a`JV{d�XZ_S^/PS[J_STZHJVYXlTZIw^|V�PS[J`rRJbwPSMYVqh

�$xqVE�]PSKfRªVEMETc_Sd�K�TW_uX��aTZVYbLbwIw[ps|ILKzKZVYbLVYM~TWIw[ps|kzHJILMOH]d�PSM~TWKzkzIwbLb��ªVetJKfVY`]TZ_FTZVYbwbªTWHJVeKfTZ_uXf�Sh

Page 63: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

�©K{PS[\��su_a_a`�KfTZ_uXf�vTZVYbwbLVYX���_uX©PS[\�u_u[pV�kzILTZHAPNbw_S[Jsq¦ÕkzIL[J`JVE`]d�XZILVY[J`Q�¤xv[J_5kzKYy«TZHJV}K�TW_uX���MYPS[��VrXftJIw[pVY`�ILd¤TW_a_0^FPS[\��VÏ�UTZXWPS[pVY_utJK|_uX}TWPS[JsuVE[vTZIgPSbld�PqMETWK|PSXfV?Iw[JMEbwtJ`JVE`�h 0�PStJV~T�� R � �Y&��KZVEVY^|K�TW_|HQP�ouV�TWHJILK�Iw[?^FIL[J`:kzHJVE[�HJVePS`poaILKZVYK�TZHJV�bgP�k K�TWtJ`pVY[\T�²

�uh��{_F[J_qT©_5ouVEXZRJXf_5ouV��S_utJX¤M�PSKfVSh�� hLh¥h ����[]suVY[pVYXWPqb­y¢M�PSbLbwIL[Js�PFRJXfIw^FPSXf�FkzILTZ[JVYKfKPS[p`A_u[JV}_uX¤T�k�_?ME_uXZXf_u�ª_SXWPqTZIw_u[rkzILTW[pVYKZKfVYK�_u["Pq[v�]xSV~�AR�_uIw[\T{ILK©VE[J_utJsuH«h��ÕT� ÒKtJKftQPSbLbL�r�ªVEKfT{TZ_:^FPSxSV��S_utJX�MYPSKZV}IL[�MOHJILVEd�KZIL^FRJbLVSy¢d�PSKfTYy�PS[p`�TWHJVE[0�vtJI¥T©kzHJILbwVPSHpV�PS`�h

�UIw^|IwbwPSXZb¥��d�Xf_u^ 0]tJXfXWP���� R ��i² ���ouVE[:TWHJVcKZIw^|RJbLVYKfTmPS[p`NKZHp_uXfTZVYKfT�_Sd¬V~ouVY[\TZK�MY_u[\TOPqIw[JKmP^��aXZIwPS`?_Sd�R�_STZVY[\TWIwPSb�`JV~TOPSILbwKYh � hLh¥h �{G�HJV�TWXfIgPSb�bwP�k��uVYX¤^}tJK�T¤XZIwsS_uXZ_utpKZbL�NKZVEbwVYM~TzTWHJ_uKfV�`pVETOPqIwbwKTWHJPqTzPSXfV{VYKfKZVY[\TZIgPSb�TW_}TWHpV{Iw^FPSsuVzTW_���V{RJXfVYKZVE[\TWVY`]PS[J` ^�tJKfT �J[J` V �|MYILVY[\T�k�P5�aKz�\�FkzHpIwMOHTW_�ME_u[\ouVE�?TZHJVY^rh �G�HJVYKfVcRJPSKZKZPSsuVYKmPSXfV�XZVYRpXZVYKfVY[\TOP§TWILoSVc_qdªkzHQP§T�PSMETZtQPSbJbwP5k KfTZtJ`JVE[vTZK�PqXZVzPS`poaILKZVY`�TW_�`J_�IL[

KZVEbwVEMETWIL[JseP©TWXfIgPSbUKfTWXZPqTWVEsS�uh!�ÕdªkmV�kzIwKZH�TZ_e^|_a`JVYbpP�TZXZIwPSbURpXZ_aMYVYKfK�PqKDILTDILKDPSMETZtQPSbLbL��V~�UVYMEtpTWVE`�yTWHpVY[�k�V?^}tpKfT�TOPqxSV Iw[\TZ_"PSMYME_utJ[\T�TWHJV:d�PqMET�TWHJPqT}TWHpV bgP�k��uVEX|ILK�P�KfTZ_uXf�vTZVYbwbLVYXEy=PS[J`�TWHQP§TXZV~ouVYPSbwIL[Jsed�tpbwbQIw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�IwKmPS[QP§TWHJVE^NPqTZIwMlTZ_�TWHpV©RJXf_UMEVYKZKm_Sd«TZVYbLbwIw[ps�P�MY_S[voaIL[JMYIL[Js�K�TW_uX��uh

S�TVU�TVU T�� � ��� ������#),

G�HJILK�PS`poaIwMEV�MY_u^|VYK�Iw[\TW_�VEKZR�VYMYIwPSbwb¥�|KfTOPqXZxNME_u[\TWXZPSKfT�kzHJVE[ k�V�ME_u[JKZIL`JVYXlTZHJV�`JILKZMY_5oSVYXf�:RJXZ_q¦MYVEKZKEy¢kzHpIwMOHrRJXZVEMYVY`pVYKcTZHJV�TWXfIgPSb�I¥TWKfVYbLdÀh �c_�d�PSMETZKz_uX¤PSXZsutp^FVE[vTZK�^NP�� ��V�RJXfVYKZVE[\TWVY`�Iw[ TWXfIgPSbtJ[JbLVYKfKlTWHJV~�:PSRpRªVYPSXlIw[FTWHJV{�pXZIwV~d�K �QbLVY`:��VEd�_uXfV©TWHpV©TWXfIgPSbih!G�HJV�MEtJKfTZ_u^�ILKmTWHpVYXZV~d�_uXZVcd�_uX�TWHpVPS`poS_UMYPqTWVeTW_FbwIwK�T¤VEouVEXf�]MY_u[pMYVYI¥oqPS�JbwVeILTZVY^/IL[]TWHpV��JXfIwVEd�KEy�TZ_:P�ou_SIw`]TZHJV�R�_uKfKZIw�pIwbwI¥T��NTZHQPqTcHJV[JVEVY`JK�Kf_u^FVFd�PSMET�Iw[�TZXZIgPqb��ptpT�IwK��QPSXfXZVY`�d�Xf_u^ tJKZIL[Js�ILT��ªVEM�PStpKZV HJVNd�PqIwbwVE`�TZ_�Iw[JMEbwtJ`pVNILTIw[�HJIwKc�JXZILVEd�KYh�±Q_uXzTWHpV}s\PS^|V�TZHJVY_uXfIwK�TWKYyªTWHJILK©IwK¤d�_uXfTZtJ[QPqTZV}��VYM�PqtJKZV}TZHJV}tJ[JI¥ouVEXZKZV�_qd=ILTWVE^FKkzHJILMOH:M�PS[N�ªVcRJXZVEKZVY[\TZVY`rIw[FTZXZIwPSbQIwK�PekmVYbwb ¦�`JV �Q[JVE`�ypME_u^F^|_u[|xv[J_5kzbwVY`psuV{KZV~T�²DI¥TWVY^|K�bwIwK�TWVE`Iw[�TZHJV��JXfIwVEd�KEh�±Q_uX©TZHJV�`JIwKfMYtJKfKZIL_u["HJVYXfVSy8ILT�ILK{[J_STZVEkm_uXfTZH\�ATWHQPqT�TZHJIwK©KZVETe_Sd�I¥TWVY^|K{ILK{MYtJKÀ¦TW_S^NPSXfIwb¥��PSKmbgPSXfsuV©PqK�R�_uKZKfIw�JbLVSya_Sd¶TWVE[:Iw[JMEbwtJ`pIw[Jse^}tJb¥TWIwRpbwV�KfTZ_uXZILVYKm_uXmbLVYs\Pqb�MYPqTWVEsu_uXfI���P§TWIw_S[JKYyKZ_ 0�PqtJVETY ÍKePS[J` 0rtJXZXZP5�� ÒK�Pq`poaIwMYV�TWHQPqT�TZHJV�PS`poS_UMYPqTWV�KfHJ_utJbL`"RJIwMOx]_u[JV�KfTZ_uXf��PS[J`"RJXf_®oSVILT�kzI¥TWHrP�KZ^FPSbwbªKZtJ�pKZVETc_Sd�TWHJV�ILTZVY^|KlbwILKfTZVY`?Iw[ TWHpVe�pXZIwV~d�K�IwK�VEKZR�VYMYIwPSbwb¥�:K�TWXZILxvIw[JsJh

Page 64: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �2�3�� � <|7A>ACE9DCE<F7����u<|;��\@��� C�7�u<|;�� +�9DCE<F7 ;� ��� �� +�9�CY<|7

G�HJILK�KfVYMETZIw_u[�RJXZVEKZVE[vTZK�ProSVYX���suVE[JVYXZPSb=MY_uXf_ubwbwPSXf��_SdlTZHJV 0rIw[JIL^NP§��G�HJVY_SXZVY^ TWHJPqTeKZHJ_5kzKTWHJPqTcd�tpbwb¬Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[:kzIwbLb¬�ªVeXZV~ouVYPSbwVE`�Iw[�PSbwb¬_Sd�TWHJV�^F_a`JVEbwKzRJXZVEKZVE[vTZVY`AIL[]TWHpV�bLILTWVEXWPqTZtJXZV_Sd\$�HQPqRpTWVEX �phD�ÕT�RJXf_®oaIL`JVYKl^|_STZILoaIgPqTZIw_u[�d�_uX�TWHJV{^FPSIL[NXZVEKZtJb¥TWKEypkzHJIwMOHrPSRpRªVYPSX�bwPqTWVEX�Iw[FTWHJILKMOHQPSRUTWVYXEh

021�� 176 � �� D ;QPB;=<.DLK

G�HJVeMY_u[p`JILTZIw_u[JKzXfVY�vtJIwXfVY`rd�_uX�d�tJbwb¬IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[:XfVEoSVYbgP§TWIw_S[�PSXfV�d�VEk PS[p`�KZIL^FRpbwVSh�G�HJV �QXZK�TIwKlTZHQPqT¤PS`Uou_aM�PqTZVYKcPSXZV�Iw[ _SRJRª_SKZILTZIw_u[«²

� ��� ��� �Y���������� �"!$#%��#'&(�*)�#+&!$,-#%.�!$/0�1!%24365�37/0�83$9;:6<>=@?BA�CD&(� EF�G?�HI9137�(J�9K� #L!%2!$,-#%.�!$/0��90MN!$E�O-��. HI9 HP!$�Q9 �7R�S � #G#+&(�1,T#UH+VWH+#UJX!%24#'&Q37#�!$,-#Y.�!$/0��#Y![Z\V]37J^� E;_a` � �cbQ� :6< � =ed Rf K�TWXfIwMETZbL��MY_u^|RªV~TWI¥TWILoSV�s\PS^|V HI9�3�#UCG!$gIZ\V]37J^� EG5�37/0�;CD&(� EF� �ih~� : hZ�Gj ��hE� :lk � H 2�37�\Om!$�(VWJH 2 � k � :lk �Gj � k � : h��R

�U_|ILd¨_u[JV�RJbwP5�SVYXzRJXfVEd�VYXfK : hmTW_ :lk yJTWHpVe_qTWHJVEX¤^�tJKfTzRJXfVEd�VEX :lk TW_ : hÏhG�HJIwK�ILK�PNd�_uXZ^FPSbLI���P§TWIw_S[]_Sd=TZHJV�`JVYKfMYXfIwRpTZIw_u[A_SdmKfTZXZILMETWb¥��ME_u^|RªV~TWILTZILoSV�s\PS^|VYK�sSILouVE["Iw[�y

VShÒsJh¥y�8tpMYVAPS[p`>ncPqI��«P � �����ih �©K|TWHJV~� R�_uIL[vTN_utpTYyzPS[\� K�TWXZILMETZbL�nMY_S^FR�VETZILTWI¥ouVrs\PS^|V�MYPS[��V�TWXZPS[JKfd�_SXZ^|VY`�IL[vTZ_:P �EVYXZ_§¦�KZtp^ s\Pq^FVq²�XZVYRpbgPSMEIw[Js � k � : �zkzI¥TWH � ��hY� : ��kzIwbLb¨[p_ST�P �ªVYM~TRJbwP5�SVYX¬T�km_J ÍK�`JVYMEIwKfIw_u[JKEyqKfIw[JMEV=�ª_STZH�tUTWIwbLILT��¤d�tJ[JM~TWIw_S[JK8_uXZ`JVEX8_utpTWME_u^|VYK8Iw[�TWHpV�KZPS^|V�^FPS[J[pVYXYhG�HJV?[JV~�aT|MY_S[J`JILTZIw_u[�XfVpoQVEMETZKNPS[nIL[vTZVYXfVYKfTZIw[Js�d�VYPqTWtpXZV?_Sdzd�tJbwb�Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[�²�_u[JMYV?_u[pV

RJbwP5�SVYX�XfVEouVYPSbwKzI¥T�yUTZHJV�KZILsu[QPSbª_Sd8TWHJV�_STZHJVYX�RpbgP��uVEX�M�PS[?��V�Iwsu[J_SXZVY`?Pq[J`?�atpVYKfTZIw_u[pK�_Sd!suPS^FVTWHpVY_uX�� �ªVEMY_u^|V�IwXfXZVYbLVEoqPS[\T�h

� ��� ��� �Y���� W^q f 9 #rEN37#Y�P57J�HI9 tp[JIwbwPqTWVEXWPSb H stH+#i/m37J0` �6.�&(!K9K� �e`J�37�(J[Z\V]37J�� E[,T�\O-� E437�(J.�!$�\O7H+#UHP!$�Q9�A4#'&(�X!$,T#Y.�!$/0�uHI9v#+&(�B937/0�BE��P5�37ENOQVI��9�9w!%2vCD&-HP.�&@Z\V]37J�� E1Z\V]37JK9u#+&(�v,-�(H+V]37#%� EN37V9 #UEx37#Y�P57JKA[37�\O@#+&(�v!$,T#Y.�!$/0��57H+y7� �z#+&Q37#4!$�"�8Z\V]37J�� EB.�&(!K!K9K��9{#'&(�m,-�(H+V]37#Y� Ex37VD9 #UEN37#%�P57JO-!K��9�"!$#|O-�YZ(� �\Ow!$��CD&Q37#}#'&(�{!$#+&(� E*Z\V]37J�� E�O-!K��9 Rv~ &(�l!$,-#%.�!$/0��57H+y7� ��#+&(�1,T�(H+V]37#Y� EN37V"9 #rEN37#Y�P57JHI94#+&(� tJ[JIwbwPqTWVEXWPSb�RQP��u_ ��R

Page 65: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �±Q_uX¤TZHJV�KZPSxSV�_SdDME_u[JMYXfVETZVY[JVEKZKYy¬��RJXZVEKZVY[\T{TZHJV�d�_Sbwbw_5kzIL[Js�s\PS^|Ve��VET�kmVYVE[AT�k�_:_SRJRª_SKZIw[ps

PS`poS_UMYPqTWVEKYh��¬VET�������� h�� k ��� ��� ���Ub��|��V�TZHJV}KZV~T�_Sd�P�oqPSIwbwPS�JbwV�I¥TWVY^|K©_qd=Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[�hzG�HJVKfTZXWPqTZVYsS�eKfVET¨d�_uX���_STZH}PS`poS_UMYPqTWVEK!ME_u[JKZILKfTZK!_SdJPSbwb\KftJ�JKZV~TWKD_Sd��¤°\bwVET8TZHJV�suXf_utJR�_SdJIL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[ILTZVY^|KzMOHJ_uKZVE[�d�_uX�RJXfVYKfVY[\TOPqTZIw_u[]�\�]RpbgP��uVEXc_u[pVe��V��lh�PS[J`?TWHQPqT¤MOHJ_SKZVY[��v�rRJbwP��uVYXzT�km_N��V� k hDG�HJVYKfV�KZtJ�pKZVETZK�^NP��|��VcTWHpV{VY^|RpT��|KZV~T�_uXlPqbwbQ_Sd��¤h �¬VETlTZHJVYILXmtp[JIw_u[F�ªV������6h���� k hG�HJV�`JVYMEIwKZIL_u[e^NPSxqVYX8HQPSK�P�d�tJ[JMETZIw_u[�kzHJILMOH�^FPSRJK¬d�XZ_S^ KZV~TWK�_SdpIL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u[�� Iw[\TW_ �Q[QPSb

`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[pK : �����~h=±Q_uX�MY_u[JMEXZV~TWVY[pVYKZKEyQTOPSxqV : ����� =d y¬PS[J`?bwV~TlTWHpV �QXZK�T¤PS`poS_UMYPqTWVq ÍKztpTZIwbwI¥T����V�Iw[pMYXZVYPSKZIL[JsNIL[]TZHJV�oqPSbLtJV�_qd : �����~y¢kzHJILbwV�TWHJV�KZVYME_u[J`"PS`Uou_aM�PqTZVS ÒK{tpTWILbwI¥T��:IwK¤`JVEMYXZVYPSKZIL[JsIw[ : �����ÏhD��[rTZHJV�s\PS^|V{HJVEXZVSyQTZHJVePS`pou_aM�P§TWVYK¤RJXfVYKZVE[\T©HJVEX�kzILTWH��lyQKf_FKfHJV�`JVYMEIw`JVEK : ���=�~hG�HJV}s\Pq^FVeIwKcKfTWXfIwM~TWbL�?ME_u^|RªV~TWILTZILoSVekzI¥TWH�XfVYKfRªVEMET�TW_|TWHJV}PS`pou_aM�P§TWVYKE «RQP��S_ �«Kcd�XZ_u^/TWHpV

�Q[QPqb«`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[«h��! "�#� IwK�P}tJ[JILbgPqTZVYXWPqbªK�TWXWP§TWVYsq�ª²��6hmIwKl`pV �Q[JVE` TW_���V�P}KZtJ�JKfVET¤_Sd��¤yQKZ_�I¥d� k ���¤y�TWHJVE[$�lh%�&� k IwK©TZHJV�KWPq^FV?�'���cXZVEs\PSXZ`pbwVYKfK�_Sd=kzHQPqT(�6hcMOHJ_a_uKZVEKYy8PS[J`"KfIw^|IwbgPqXZbL�d�_uX)�6h��+*�hG�HJIwK�ILK�P ^|_U`pVYbD_Sdms\PqTZHJVYXfIw[Js?Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�IL[0I¥TWK�RJtpXZVYK�T�d�_SXZ^r²{TWHJV�`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[0^FPSxSVEX

KZIL^FRpbL��KZVEVYxvKzP�KfVYXZILVYKm_Sd¬d�PSMETZKmkzHJILMOH KZHJV©IwK�tp[QPS�JbLV¤TZ_}s\PqTZHJVYXmHJVYXfKZVYb¥dÀyp`JtpV©TW_�XZVYK�TWXfIwMETZIw_u[pK_u[ TWIL^FVqy¤PS�JIwbLILT��Sy¤_SX:_STWHpVYX XZVEKZ_utpXZMYVEKYh-,{[JMYVATZHJVAIw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[ ILK:HQPS[J`pVY`)TW_nHJVYXEy©KfHJVIwK�VY[\TWILXZVYb¥��tJ[pMY_u[JMEVYXf[JVY`�kzILTWH�TZHJV KZ_utpXZMYV?_Sd¤TWHpV Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[�y�PS[p`�KfHJV?Iw[J`pVYR�VY[J`JVE[\TWbL�PSXfXZILoSVYK¤PqTzHJVEXz`JVYMEIwKZIL_u[�hD�ÕTzd�V�P§TWtJXfVYK¤P�tJ[JIwbwPqTWVEXWPSbªKfTZXWPqTZVYsS�rPS[p`rME_u^|RªV~TWIw[ps�PS`pou_aM�P§TWVYKEh

021�� 143 .�/ � I N7N ;7D �)<%910 H�P!;=<.D <EI2P!F�<�0

G�HJV�_utUTWMY_S^FVl_qd�TZHJVls\Pq^FVl`pVYKZMEXZIL�ªVE`FPq�ª_5ouVlkzILbwbv��V�`JVETZVYXZ^|Iw[pVY`��\��TZHJVld�_ubwbL_5kzIw[Js¤bwVE^F^FPpykzHJILMOH]ILKzP�KfIw^|RJbwV�ME_uXZ_SbwbgPqXf�|_Sd¨TWHJV�0]IL[JIw^FP§�NG�HJVY_uXfVY^rh� ��232 � U�W54 �t3z9 #rE HP. #UVWJ>.�!$/ Z(� #UH+#UH+y7�w5�37/0��C�H+#+& 3 ,T�(H+V]37#Y� EN37V;9 #UEx37#Y�P57JKA1Z\V]37J�� EF9eC�H+V+V37VWCi37JK9[EF��.�� H+y7�[#'&(�4,-�(H+V]37#Y� Ex37VQZQ37J�!%s R

+ #�� ����6 n¤VEs\PSXZ`pbwVYKfK}_Sd�kzHQP§T}RJbwP5�SVYX}_S[JV:`J_aVYKEyDRJbgP��uVEX�T�km_AM�PS[�RpbgP���TZHJV:tJ[pIwbgP§TWVYXZPSbKfTZXWPqTZVYsS�SyJ^|V�PS[JIL[Js�TZHQPqT�HJILKl_uRpTZIw^FPSb�XZVYKfRª_S[JKZV{kzILbwb�suILoSV�P}RQP��u_ �"PqKlbgPSXfsuV©_SXl�ªV~TZTZVYXlTWHJPS[TWHpV:tJ[JILbgPqTZVYXWPqbmRQP��S_ �!h"G�HJV ^|Iw[pIw^}tJ^ Pq^F_u[ps]TWHpVYKZV ^FP§�UIw^FP]ILK�TZHJV tJ[JILbgPqTZVYXWPqb�RJP5�S_ ��h�UIL^FILbgPSXfbL��d�_uX:TZHJV�_qTWHJVEXrRpbgP��uVEXY²nTWHJV"^FP§�UIw^}tJ^ PS^|_u[JsnHJIwK ^|Iw[pIw^}tJ^ RQP��u_ �«KrIwK TWHpVtJ[JILbgPqTZVYXZPSbmRJP5�S_ ��h�G�HJV?^FIL[JIw^FP§�0RQP��u_ � d�_uX}RJbwP5�SVYX�_u[JV ^FPqTZMOHJVYK�TWHpV ^NP§�UIL^FIL[�RQP��u_ �

Page 66: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� d�_uXcRJbgP��uVEX©T�km_Jy8PS[J`�TZHJV}s\PS^|V�ILK©K�TWXZILMETZbL�rMY_u^|R�VETWI¥TWI¥ouVSh©G�HJV10]Iw[pIw^FP§�rG�HJVY_SXZVY^ �iPSK©Iw[�yVShÒsJh¥y��¬tJMYVNPS[J` n¤PSI���P � � ���¶��TWVEbwbwK�tJK�TWHQPqTeTWHpV:tJ[JILbgPqTZVYXWPqbDRQP��u_ � IwK�TWHJVEXZV~d�_uXZV PqbLk�P5�aK�PS[VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^�RJP5�S_ ��h

�©KfKZtJ^|V:TWHJVEXZV:VÏ�UIwKfTZK�PS[J_qTWHJVEX}VY�vtJILbwIw�pXZIwtp^�kzILTZH�P�`JI��«VEXZVY[\T�RJP5�S_ ��h$,�[pVNRJbwP5�SVYX}_SXTWHpV:_STWHpVYX�kzILbwb=�ªVN`J_uIw[ps�k�_SXZKZV:TZHQPS[�TZHJV:tJ[JILbgPqTZVYXZPSb=RQP��u_ ��yDKZIL[JMYVNTZHJV s\PS^|V|IwK}K�TWXZILMETZbL�MY_S^FR�VETZILTWI¥ouVqh G�HQPqT:RJbgP��uVEXNkzIwbLbz`JVEd�VEMET TW_�TWHJV�tp[JIwbwPqTWVEXWPSbzKfTZXWPqTZVYsS�Syz^FVYPS[JIw[ps�TWHJPqT:TWHpVPSKfKZtJ^|RpTWIL_u[?_Sd!PS[]VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^�kzILTZHrP|`JI��«VEXZVE[vTzRJP5�S_ �"klPqKzd�PqbwKZVqh��

�c_STZIwMEV{TWHQPqT�TWHJV�RJXf_U_Sd8k�PSK�Iw[?[J_}k�P�� `JVERªVE[J`JVY[\Tc_u[ TWHJV�VÏ�pPS^FRpbwVS²DI¥TzPSRJRpbwIwVEK�TW_��3(��KfTZXZILMETWb¥�0MY_u^|RªV~TWI¥TWILoSVFsuPS^FV�kzILTZH�P�tJ[pIwbgP§TWVYXZPSb=KfTZXWPqTZVYsS�Sh �©bLKZ_�[p_STWILMYVFTZHQPqT�TWHJVNTZHJVY_SXZVY^KWPqIw`�[J_qTWHJIL[Js PS��_utpT©HJ_5k$TZHJV}`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[�^NPSxqVYX{sS_UVEK�PS��_utpT{^FPSxvIw[ps:P:`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[«y«_uX{IL[�TWHpVMY_S[vTZV~�aTl_qd«TWHpVcVÏ�JPq^FRJbLVSyukmV©`JIL`F[p_ST�[JVYVE`NTW_e^NPqxSV¤PS[\�|PSKZKftJ^|RpTWIL_u[JKmPS�ª_StpT=TWHJV�d�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[: �����ÏhrG�HpVFd�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[�^FP��"_uX�^FP��0[J_ST�Iw[JMEbwtJ`JV|KfTZXWPqTZVYsuILMFME_u[JKfIw`JVEXWPqTZIw_u[JKe^FPS`JV|�v�0TWHpV`JVEMYIwKfIw_u["^FPSxSVEX���VEd�_SXZVYHJPS[J`�y¨PS[J`�^NPqxSVYK�[J_]PSKfKZtJ^|RpTWIL_u[JKePS��_utpTeHJ_5k,[pVEk�IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[MOHQPS[psuVYK�TWHJV �Q[JPSbD`JVYMEIwKfIw_u[�h�G�HpVF_u[pbL�APqKZKZtp^FRpTZIw_u["IL[JHJVYXfVY[\T�TW_?TWHJILK{d�tJ[JM~TWIw_S[QPSb!d�_uXf^�ILKTWHJPqTzKZHJVe�QPSKfVYK¤HJVYXz`JVEMYILKZIw_S[JK�_u[Jb¥�:_u[?TWHJV�IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[FKZVET!�lh±QtJbwbQIL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[�XfVEouVEbgPqTZIw_u[|IwKmP�tp[JIwbwPqTWVEXWPSbJK�TWXZPqTWVEsS�|�v�|^|_uKfT�`JV �Q[JI¥TWIw_S[JK=_Sd�TWHpV¤TZVYXZ^

��IL[JMYbLtJ`JIL[Js �{V �Q[JI¥TWIw_S[ &\�Ïh]�Õd¤Pq`pou_aM�PqTZVYK�PqXZVN_S[JbL�"RQPqXfTWIwPSbwb¥��XfVEouVYPSbwIL[Js�IL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u[«y�Pq[J`_u[JV¤_uX=TWHJV¤_STZHJVYX�MY_utpbw`N`p_���VETZTZVYX��\�FXfVEoSV�PSbLIw[Js�d�tJbwbQIL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u[«ySTWHJVE[NHJV©PSbLk�P��aKmHQPqKmTWHpV_uRpTZIw_u[FTW_�`J_�KZ_pyQPS[J` HJILKl_uRJR�_uKfILTWIL_u[:MYPS[ `J_�[J_STZHJIw[Js�TW_�_u�pd�tpKZM�P§TWV{d�PSM~TWKzPqd¶TZVYX�TZHJVE� HJP5oSV��VYVY[A�pXZ_utJsSHvT©TW_ bwILsuH\T�hcG�HJVYXfVEd�_uXfVSy¬PSK©RªVEX©TWHJV�RJXZ_a_Sd=_Sd �¬VY^|^FP �uyª[JVYI¥TWHJVEX©RJbwP5�SVYX©kzILbwbVEoSVYXcPSMYMEVYRpTcP�RQP��u_ �"bLVYKfKzTZHQPS[ TWHJPqT¤HJV�MY_utJbL`?suVET¤�\� XZV~ouVYPSbwIL[Js�d�tJbwb�IL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u[«h

�c_STZHJIw[pseRpXZVEoSVY[\TWKlPS[J_STZHJVYX=_utpTZMY_u^|Vld�XZ_S^,HQP�oaIw[Js�P�RQP��u_ �?kzHJILMOHFILK=TZHJVzKWPS^|V¤PSKDTWHQP§Td�_uX�d�tJbLb�Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[:XZV~ouVEbgPqTZIw_u[�h ��tUT¤d�tpbwb�IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[:ILK¤P�d�_aM�Pqb¬VY�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^�PS[J`rKZVEVY^|K^|_uXZV�bLIwxSVEbL�|TW_|�ªV�MOHJ_SKZVY[rTWHQPq[�PS[rPSb¥TWVEXZ[QPqTZV|��R�_uKZKfIw�Jb¥�:^|I¥�UVY`Q��KfTWXZPqTWVEsS�:kzHJ_SKZVeRQP��u_ �"ILKTWHpV{KWPS^|VShDG�HpVYXZV~d�_uXZVqy¢PSbLTZHJ_utJsSHNTWHJVEXZV{ILKl[J_}TZHJVY_uXfVETZIwM�Pqb«sutQPqXWPS[\TWVEV©TWHJPqTld�tJbLbªIL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[kzIwbLb�suVE[JVYXZPSbwb¥�A�ªVFP?tJ[JIw�vtJV|VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^]y«ILTeKZVEVY^|K�XfV�PSKf_u[QPS�JbLV|TZ_]RpXZVYKftJ^|VFTWHJPqT�TWHQPqTeILKTWHpVe_StpTWME_u^FV{TZHQPqTzkzIwbLb«RJXfVEoqPSILb�ILd8TWHpVeME_u[J`JI¥TWIL_u[JK�_Sd �¬VY^|^NP ��HJ_Sbw`�h k� ´gÊUÈ«¹�È«¹�­¹�Ã�¿�Ì͵q¾ÀÚ¡Ì͵®¹ZË\Æ5È«¹!¾�¿~Á®Ú�ËzÁ§Ãi¹!·i¸®Ì�Ã�Ç~Ã�Ç�Ë5¹ÀÙ§µ§ÌÒ·­ÌÍ¿Eµc¿~ÊUÌ¡Âi­¹�Ú¡¹�ÐOÇϵq¾À¹~ÓU·i¸§¿EÃi¹¨Ê¥ÇE¾�·­Ã«È¬¸®Ì�¾Õ¸{ÇÏ­¹¨µ®¿~·Â­¹�Ð~¹ZÇÏÚ¡¹fˤÌ͵{¹��YÁ®Ì¡Ú¡ÌÍخ­̡Á®Å Ë5¿lµ®¿~·¨¾Õ¸§Çϵ§Ö~¹�·i¸®¹D¿EÁ5·­¾�¿~Ål¹~Æ®Ç~µ§Ë{ÇÏ­¹¨·­¸®¹�­¹ÀÊ ¿EÂi¹�Ì¡Âi­¹�Ú¡¹�ÐOÇϵY·Z»

Page 67: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� ��ÕT�M�Pq[��ªV�KZHJ_5kz[�TWHJPqT{V~ouVYX���KfIw[JsubLV�VÏ�JPq^FRJbLV�sSILouVE[AIw[ $�HQPSRpTZVYX��Fd�_SX©_u[JV�RJbgP��uVEX �JTZK

TWHpVe`pVYKZMEXZILRpTWIL_u[?HJVYXfVSh

� ���\�\�Z�Y��� � �����B� � �B� �Y��# ���M��� ��� � �¬VE^F^FP ��HQPqK�_u[pbL��T�km_{RJXZVE^FILKZVEKY²¬TWHQP§T�TZHJVmsuPS^FV=ILKKfTZXZILMETWb¥�|MY_u^|RªV~TWI¥TWILoSV{PS[p`:TWHQPqTlP}tJ[JILbgPqTZVYXWPqb�K�TWXZPqTWVEsS�NVÏ�UIwKfTZKYhD��V{[JVYVE`JVY`?[J_�PqKZKZtp^FRpTZIw_u[pKPS��_utpT�TWHJV©KfTWXftJMETZtJXZV©_Sd¬Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�TWHQP§T�^FP��F��V©RpXZVYKfVY[\TWVE`�yJTWHpV©_uXf`JVYXmIw[FkzHpIwMOH:RJbwP��uVYXfK^|_®oSVSyvTWHJVc`JVYMEIwKfIw_u[F^NPSxqVYXE ÍK�^FV~TWHJ_a`N_qd¬RJXZ_aMYVEKZKfIw[Js�Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[�yu_uX=_STZHJVYX�T��URpIwM�Pqb�`pVETOPqIwbwK_Sd¨TWHJV�s\Pq^FV{d�_uXf^]h

�U_{TWHpVlTWHJVE_uXZVE^�HQPSK�d�VEk ^F_5oaIw[Js©RQPSXfTZK�TWHQP§TDMY_utpbw`}�JXfV�PSx¢yvPS[p`|KfHJ_utJbL`�PSRJRJb¥��IL[�P©kzIw`pVXWPq[JsuV�_SdmKZI¥TWtQPqTZIw_u[pKYh ��V~T�y8PSK�kzIwbLb!��V�`JIwKfMYtJKfKZVE`�Iw[ �UVEMETZIw_u[ � h�Uh�Uhay8PS`pou_aM�P§TWVYK�T��aRJILM�PSbLbL�TWVEbwbQ_u[pbL��_u[pVcK�TW_uX���V�PSMOH�yaXZV~ouVYPSbwIL[Js�_S[JbL�}TZHJV¤KZtJ�JKfVET�_Sd�IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[�PSRpXZ_uR�_uKDTW_�TWHJV¤KfTZ_uXf�TWHpVE��TWVEbwb­h¬�)HQP§T�TZHJIwK¨^FVYPS[JK¨IwK8TWHQP§T!IL[eTZHJVYKfV�KZI¥TWtQP§TWIw_S[JK8_SdQRQPSX�TWIwPSb\Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�XZV~ouVYbwPqTWIL_u[�yTWHpV �ftJ`JsuVcTOPSxqVYK�Iw[\TZ_�PSMYME_utJ[\T�^|_uXZV¤TWHQPq[ �ftJKfTlTZHJV{bLIwKfTm_Sd¬d�PSM~TWKEyp�JtpT�TWHJV{ME_u[\TWVÏ�UTz_qd¬TWHJ_uKfVd�PSM~TWKYyQKftJMOH�PqKzkzHp_FRJXfVYKfVY[\TWKzkzHJIwMOHrd�PSMETYh

,{[JVePSRJRJXf_\PSMOH k�V�^FP��NTOPqxSV�IwKlTZ_�RJXZVEKZtJ^|V�TWHQP§T�TWHJV �ftJ`psuV�M�PSbLMYtJbwPqTWVEKlTWHJV�bLIwxqVYbwILHJ_a_U`_Sd�MEVYXfTWPSIw[ VEouVE[\TWK?_uXNK�TW_uXfIwVEK:`JVYR�VY[p`JIw[Js�_u[ kzHJ_�RJXfVYKZVE[\TWK:TWHpVY^rh��DHJXWPSKfIw[Js�TZHJV�^FPSIw[�vtJVYK�TWIL_u[]IL[ TWHJV�TWVEXZ^|Iw[J_Sbw_usS�|_Sd $�HQPSRUTWVYX��uypkzHJPqT¤tJRª`JPqTWIL[Js�_uRªVEXWPqTZ_uXZKlkm_utJbL`�Pq`J^FI¥TlTWHpVXZV~ouVEbgPqTZIw_u[]_SdD_u[Jb¥�?RQPSX�TWIgPqb¨IL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u[Q� nzVYMYPSbwb¬TWHpV�`JV �Q[JILTZIw_u[]_Sd=P|tJ[JIwbwPqTWVEXWPSb¬K�TWXZPqTWVEsS��²TWHJPqTlI¥d¬_u[JVcRJbgP��uVEXlRJbwP5�aK�TWHQPqT�KfTZXWPqTZVYsS�SyUTWHpV©_utpTZMY_u^|V©ILKmTZHJV©KZPS^FVcXZVEs\PSXZ`pbwVYKfKl_Sd�kzHJPqTlTWHpV_STZHJVYX=RJbwP5�SVYX=`J_aVYKEypPS[p`|TZHJIwKDILK=TZXZtJV�d�_uXD��_STZHFRJbwP��uVYXfKYhD��[|_STWHpVYXDk�_SXZ`JKEyUI¥d���ILK�PetJ[pIwbgP§TWVYXZPSbKfTZXWPqTZVYsS�SyJTWHJVE[����¨���1���l������¨�'�!��E��d�_uXzPqbwb��NPS[J`]PSbwb ®h±Q_uX�P RQPSXfTZIgPSb�Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�XZV~ouVEbgPqTZIw_u[A_utUTWMY_S^FV}TZ_]RJXfVEoqPSILb�Iw["P KfTZXZILMETWb¥��ME_u^FR�VETZILTZILouV

s\PS^|VSyqILT¨^}tJK�T���VmTZHQPqT�[p_©tJ[JILbgPqTZVYXZPSbvKfTWXZPqTWVEsS�eV~�UIwK�TWKEh���[}_STZHJVYX¨k�_uXf`JKYy����¨����� ����������8� � ��~�d�_uX?KZ_S^FV�� PS[p`5h �cbwb�K��U^|^|VETWXfIwMAtJR�`QPqTZIw[Jsn_uR�VYXZPqTW_SXZK TWHJVEXZV~d�_uXZV0HQP�ouV�P�tJ[pIwbgP§TWVYXZPSbKfTZXWPqTZVYsS�Sy¢PS[J`rKZ_u^|V�KZtp�JKZV~T©_Sd�TWHJVePSK��a^F^|VETZXZIwM©tJRª`JPqTWIL[Js�_uRªVEXWPqTZ_uXZK�`p_|[p_ST�hG�HJIwK©IwK{PFRJXZ_u�pbwVY^ ��VYMYPStJKZV�Pq[v�]`QPqTWP§¦�_SXZIwVE[\TWVY`�^FV~TWHJ_a`�_Sd=`JV~TWVEXZ^|Iw[JIL[JsFTZHJV}KfTWPqTWV�_Sd

TWHpV]km_uXZbL` kzIwbLb¤��V�K��a^F^|VETZXZIwMq²�TWHpV�d�PSMETNIwK�TWHJV]KWPS^|V�XfVYs\PqXZ`JbLVYKZKN_Sd{TWHpV]TWVEbwbLVYXYy�KZ_�TWHpV`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[�^NPSxqVYX}KfHJ_utJbL`J[�  T}MYPSXZVNkzHp_�TW_ubL`�HJVEX�kzHJIwMOH�d�PqMET�h�G�HJV ^F_a`JVEbmHJVEXZV:XfVYME_u[JMYILbwVEKTWHpIwK��\�0RJXfVYKZVE[\TWIw[ps"P�[QPqTZtJXWPSb=^|_U`pVYb�_SdlTWHpVN`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[p^NPSxvIL[Js]RpXZ_aMYVYKfK�kzHJILMOHnPSbwbL_®kzK�TWHpV�ftJ`JsSV�TW_ `JVEMYIL`JV�TWHpV}KfTWPqTWV}_qd�TZHJV�km_uXZbL`AtJKZIL[Js P:K��U^|^|VETWXfIwM�_uRªVEXWPqTZ_uX©KftJMOH0PSK �lP��SVYKZIwPS[

Page 68: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �tJR�`QPqTZIw[JsJyU�JtpTzTW_�^FPSxSV�PqKf�a^F^|VETZXZILM{`JVYMEIwKfIw_u[JK�kzI¥TWHJIL[ MYVYX�TOPSIL[?KfTOP§TWVYKz_Sd8TZHJV�k�_uXfbw`�yJPqd¶TWVEXKZHpV�HQPqK¤HpVYXzRª_SKfTWVEXZIL_uXZK�IL[rHJPS[J`�h

2�3�2 ��� � <?> 8�

�©K¤`JILKZMYtpKZKZVE`�IL[ �UVEMETZIw_u[ � h��ph�Uy¢P|^|_a`JVYb��JPSKZVE`�RJtJXfVYb¥� _u[rKfTOP§TWIwK�TWILM�PSb�MYPSbwMEtJbgP§TWIw_S[ `JVYXfILouVEKVY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^�Pq`pou_aM�PqTZV��ªVEHQP�oUIL_uX�ouVEXf�"`JI��«VEXZVY[\T�d�XZ_S^�TWHQP§T�_Sd�TZHJV�KfTOPq�JbwV�K�TOPqTZVF_Sd�PSM~TWtQPSbPS`poS_UMYPqTWV?��VYHQP�oaIw_SX|`pVYKZMEXZIL�ªVE` Iw[ �UVEMETZIw_u[ � h�UhahUh�G�HpVYXZV~d�_uXZVqy�TWHpIwK�KZVEMETWIL_u[�RJXZ_uR�_uKfVYK|P^|_U`JVEb©kzHJILMOH PS`p`JK?M�PStJKZPSb�^NPqMOHJIw[JVEXf� TW_�TWHJV"VEKfTWIL^NP§TWIw_S[ _Sd�KftJ� �fVEMETWI¥ouV�RJXZ_u�JPS�JIwbLILTZIwVYKEyXZVEKZtJb¥TWIL[JszIw[{TWHpVY_uXfVETWILM�PSb\VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgPmTZHQPqT8^FPqTWMOH�TWHpVmPqMETWtJPSb\KfTWPS�JbwVDK�TOPqTZV=^}tJMOH�^|_uXfV�MYbL_uKZVEbL�uhG�HJV?d�_UMEtJK�_SdcTZHJIwK�^|_U`pVYb�kzILbwb���V?tJR�_u[ P"MYI¥oaIwbmTZXZIwPSb­h �¤[JbwILxSV?_STZHJVYX�T��aRªVEKF_qdcTZXZIgPqb­y

�ftJ`JsS^FVE[vTZK|PSXZV?tJKftQPSbwb¥��IL[�`p_ubwbwPSXZKEy=kzHpIwMOH�M�PS[ V�PSKfIwbL���ªV?XfVYRJXfVYKZVE[\TWVY` �v��PAME_u[\TWIw[vtJ_StJKoqPSXZIwPS�JbLVSy\PS[p`FTWHpVYXZV¤IwKD[p_�XfVY�vtJIwXfVY^|VY[\T�TWHQPqT �ftJ`psu^FVE[\TWK��ªV��Í�ªV~�u_u[J`:P�XfV�PSKf_u[QPS�pbwV¤`J_utJ�pTY LhG�HJVFPS`J`JI¥TWIL_u[QPSb�ME_u[JKfIw`JVEXWPqTZIw_u[JK�_qd�P?MYXZIL^FIL[QPSbiy¬PSRJR�VYbLbgPqTZVSy¬_uX �UtJRpXZVY^|V $�_utJXfT�TZXZIgPqb�^NP��V�PqKZIwb¥�:��VePS`J`JVE`rTZ_�TZHJV�^F_a`JVEb�HJVYXfVShG�HJIwK¤KZVEMETZIw_u[�kzILbwb �JXZKfT©Iw[\TWXf_U`ptJMYV�TWHJVeIw[p`JILoaIw`ptQPSb¬MY_S^FR�_u[JVE[vTZKc_qd�TWHJVe^|_U`JVEb­²�KfTZ_uXZILVYKYy

KZt �FMEIwVE[vTzMYPStJKfVYKYyJTZHJV �ftJ`psuVS ÒK��ªVEbwILVEd�KlPq�ª_utUTlTWHJVEKZV�ME_u^FR�_u[JVE[\TWKYypM�PStJKZPSbªkmVYILsuH\TWKEyQPS[J` TWHpVouVEXZ`JILMETzd�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[�h

02102176 � ���� �F P!K

�¬VET�� ��V}TWHJV�KfVET�_SdmKfTZ_uXZILVYKYh �aTW_uXfIwVEK�PSXZV��pIw[QPSX��n��VYILTZHJVYX{TZXZtJV�_SX{d�PSbwKfV5�~y�PS[J`"V�PSMOH0KfTZ_uXf�� = �)HJPSK¤P�RpXZ_u�QPq�JIwbLILT��N� � ��_Sd!��VYIL[Js�TWXftJVSh

�¬VETe£�KfIwsu[JI¥d¶�]TZHJV�VEoSVY[\T�kzHJIwMOH"�JXf_utJsuH\T{TZHJV}TWXfIgPSb!PS��_utpT�y�PS[J`�kzHJILMOH"TZHJV�PS`poS_UMYPqTWVEKKZVEVYx:TZ_|VÏ�URJbgPSIL[�h

�¬VET��a� � ��KfIwsu[pILd¶��TZHJV]K�TOPqTZVY^|VY[\Tr� � ILK�KZt��|MYILVY[\TNd�_SXF£1TZ_�_aMYMEtJXY ¥h �UtJMOH MYbgPqIw^|K}_SdKZt �FMEIwVE[JME��PSXZV}_S� �fVYM~TWKYy �ftJKfT�bLIwxqV�TWHpV}KfTZ_uXZILVYKYh �8V~T{TWHpV}KZRQPqMYV}IL[�kzHJIwMOH�TZHJVYKfV�_u� �fVEMETWK©bwIwV��V ���Dh

Page 69: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �S�T S�TWBTW X �Y��# � � � �B���� .��B�E�M#3.�� 2 � � ���

�©b¥TWHJ_StJsuH:^FPS[\�N_qd¨TZHJV�V~�pPS^|RJbLVYKlsuI¥ouVE[ HJVYXfV�PS[J` VYbLKZV~kzHJVYXfVeIL[NTWHpV�M�PStJKZPSb«bLILTZVYXWP§TWtJXfV{PSXfVd�PSM~TWtQPSb�IL[�[QPqTZtJXZVqymTWHpVrK�TW_uX���TW_Sbw`n�\�nP0bwP�k��uVYX�kzILbwb�ME_u[JKfIwKfT|_Sdc��_STWHnd�PSMETZK�PS��_utpT|RQPSK�TVEoSVY[\TWK|PS[p`�bwVEs\PSb�PSXZsStJ^FVE[\TWKYh �%KWPS^|RJbLVFK�TW_uX��ª² 0]KEh ��k�PSK}`JXfILoaIw[Js]M�PSXfVEd�tJbLbL�"�JtUT�HJILTIwMEVS°ª`JXZI¥oUIL[JsNVEXZXf_uXZK©d�Pqbwb¬tJ[J`pVYX�PN[pVYsubLIwsuVE[JMYV�XZtJbLVS°«[pVYsubLIwsuVE[JMYVeXZtJbLVYK{IL[�`JXfILoaIw[psNHQP�ouV��ªVEVY[PSRJRpbwIwVE` Iw[?KZIL^FILbgPSXmRQPSK�TzM�PSKfVYKYhG!PqxaIL[Js�bwVEs\PSb«PSXZsutp^FVE[vT�PSK�PS[?V~�UVEXZMYILKZV�IL[ MYbgPqKZKZI��QM�P§TWIw_S["�iPSK�^NPS[\�NbwVYsuPSbªRpHJIwbL_uKZ_uRpHJVYXfK

`J_JyaVShÒsJh �Utp[JKfTZVYIw[ � � )�¶�=_uRªVE[JK�tpRNTWHJVcRª_SKZKZIL�JIwbLILT��}TZHQPqTm^}tJb¥TWIwRpbwV�KfTZ_uXZILVYKmV~�URJbgPqIw[FTZHJV©KZPS^|VKZIL^FRpbwVlV~ouVY[\TYyJPS[J`FPSXfVcPqbwbJME_uXZXfVYMETmVEoSVY[|TWHJ_utpsuH|TZHJVE��^FP���V�PqMOHFIL^FRJb¥�}P�`JI��«VEXZVY[\T=ouVEXZ`JILMETYh±Q_uXlVÏ�JPq^FRJbLVSypTZHJVYXfV�^NP��N�ªV�_u[pV�KfTOP§TWtpTZV{TWHQPqTzMEbgPSKfKZI��QVYK�`JXfILoaIw[ps}tJ[J`JVEX¤P}[JVYsubLIwsuVE[JMYV©XZtJbLV��Kf_ 0]KYh �,IwKc[J_ST�bLIgPS�JbLV5�ÏyªPq[J`0PS[J_STZHJVYX©kzHpIwMOH"MYbwPSKZKfI��QVEK{_uR�VYXWP§TWIw[ps:HJV�P�ov�A^FPSMOHJIL[JVYX���IL[Iw[pMYbwVE^FVE[\T©ME_u[J`JI¥TWIw_S[JKztJ[J`JVEX©KfTZXZILMETcbwIgPq�JIwbLILT�����KZ_ 0]KYh ��ILKcbLIgPS�pbwV5�Ïh���_qTWH�_qd�TWHJVEKZV}K�TW_uXfIwVEK^FP5�NKZIL^}tJbLTWPS[JVE_utJKZb¥�:��V{TWXftJVePS[J`rKZt��|MYILVY[\T¤TW_�V~�URJbwPSIw[ TWHpVeV~ouVE[vTZK©tJ[p`JVYX�TWHpVebwP�k�h

02102143 .�/ ��I � � � K � �NO;� ��)K

G�HJV �ftJ`JsuV�kzIwbLb�`JVEoSVYbL_uR�KZtp� �fVYM~TWILoSV}��VYbwILVEd�KzPS��_utpT¤TWHpV�RJXf_u�QPS�pIwbwI¥T��NTZHQPqTcPFsuI¥ouVE[�KfTZ_uXf�?_SXM�PqtJKZV�IwKcTWXZtpVSh 2¤VYXZVqy¬�cbwP���TWHpV}d�XWPS^|VEkm_uXZxrd�_uX{`JVEKZMEXZIw�pIw[Js:TZHJV �ftJ`JsuVq ÍK���VYbLIwVEd�KEy¬PS[J`"_5ouVEXTWHpVeME_utJXfKZV�_Sd¨TWHJILK�KZVYM~TWIL_u[�yJkzIwbLb«`JVEKZMEXZIw��V�TWHJV�KfRQPSMEVYKcPS[J`r_u� �fVYM~TWKz_u[ kzHJILMOHrTZHJVYKfV���VYbLIwVEd�KPSM~T�h

� ��� ��� �Y���� W�W S � #�� ² ��� � ��� � � � �-� /m3 Z42 E�!$/ 9K� #+91!%2|9 #Y!$E HP��9837�\O�9 ,�>. HP� �(#i.x37,�9K��9#Y!m#'&(�� ,QOK5-� � 9�9 ,Q`� ��. #rH+y7��` � VWHP�'28#+&Q37#i#'&(�l� VI� /0� �(#+96!%28#+&(��9K�89K� #'9�37EF�[#UE , � R

±Q_uXl[J_qTOPqTZIw_u[QPqbªKfIw^|RJbwILMYILT��Syv��kzILbwb«Kf_u^|VETWIL^FVEKl`JILKZMYtpKZK�TWHJV �ftp`JsuVS ÒK���VYbwILVEd�Kl_5oSVYX�d�VEkmVYX�TWHJPS[T�km_q¦�`JIL^FVE[JKZIL_u[JKEh�±¢_SX©V~�pPS^|RJbLVSy�HJVEX{��VYbwILVEd�PS��_utpTcTWHJV�RpXZ_u�QPq�JIwbLILT��?_Sd�PS[AV~ouVE[vT � IwK©XZVYRa¦XZVEKZVE[vTZVY`n�\� � � � � � �!�Ïhr�{kzILbwb=PS�p�JXZV~oUIwPqTWV|TWHJILK�tJ[p`JtJbL�0MEtJ^}��VYXZKf_u^|VF[J_qTOPqTZIw_u[0TW_ � � � �~ybwVYP�oUIL[Js�ILTlTZ_��ªV�tJ[J`pVYXZK�TW_a_U`?TWHJPqT¤P|KfRQPSMEV�kzHpIwMOH�ILK�[J_STzKfRªVEMYI��JVY`rIwKztJ[JXfVYKfTZXZILMETWVE`�h

�¯XZVYPSKZ_S[QPS�JbLV �ftJ`JsuVckzIwbwb�HQP�ouV���VYbLIwV~d�KmkzHJILMOHrHJP5oSV�KZ_u^|V{K�TWXZtpMETWtpXZV{TW_�TWHJVE^]yU^FVYPS[JIw[psTWHJPqT�TWHJVEXZV kzIwbLbm��V?MYVEXfTOPqIw[�XZVEKfTZXZIwM~TWIL_u[JK�_u[�TWHpV:d�tJ[JMETZIw_u[ � ��� ��� �~h�G�HJV �QXZK�T�IwK}TZHQPqT�TWHpV�ftJ`JsSVeKfHJ_utJbL`?HQP�ouV�TWXZtpVe��VYbLIwV~d�KzPS�ª_StpT�TWHJV�K�TW_uXfIwVYKE²

Page 70: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� &� � � � 2 ����� � � W U � � � ��� F� � � 2 !$E137V+V � = ��R

021021�� � PB; 0 �NO;7D < ��P / P!9�;=HJN 0 < � �N

2cVEXZV�IwKlP��pXZIwV~d!_StpTWbLIw[JVc_Sd�TZHJV{TWXfIgPSbªRJXZ_aMYVEKZKEh �cbwbªTZVYXf^FKlkzILbwb«��V�`JV �Q[JVY`�PS[J`?`JILKZMYtpKZKZVE`�IL[TWHpVeKfVY�vtJVEb­hG�HJVYXfV©VÏ�pILKfTZKlP�tJ[JILoSVYXfKZV©_qd�KfTZ_uXZILVYK©��TZHJVz�JXZILVEd�KO��d�XZ_S^�kzHJIwMOH|TWHJVcPS`poS_UMYPqTWVEK�^FP���KZVEbwVYM~T

TWHpVFK�TW_uXfIwVYK�TWHpVE�AkzIwKfH�TZ_]RJXfVYKfVY[\T}TW_?TWHpV��ftJ`psuVSh:G�HpVNRJbwPSIw[\TWI���PS[p`�`JV~d�VY[J`JPS[\T}KZIL^}tJb¥TOP§¦[JVE_utJKZb¥� �}RJXZVEKZVE[vT�PSK�^FPS[\�"KfTZ_uXZILVYK�PSK�TZHJVE�"kzILKZH�h �cbwbDRQPSX�TWILVYKeHQP�ouV:R�VYX�d�VYMET�RJXfIw_uXfK�_5ouVEXTWHpV �ftJ`psuVS ÒK�KftJ� �fVYM~TWI¥ouV©RpXZ_u�QPq�JIwbLILTWILVYKEh�G�HQP§T�ILKYyaPS[\��Iw^|RQPSX�TWIgPqbp_u�JKfVYX�ouVYX�MY_utJbL`FRpXZVY`pIwMET�TWHpV�ftJ`JsSVS ÒK�KftJ� �fVYM~TWI¥ouVN_SRJIw[JIL_u[JK{XfVYs\PqXZ`JIL[Js TWHJV|RJXZ_S�QPS�JILbwILT��rTWHJPqT ��� ILK��ª_qTWH"TWXZtpVFPq[J`�Kft���¦MYILVY[\T©TZ_:M�PqtJKZV�£|°¬PS[J`]TWHJVeouVYXf`JIwM~T�y��ª� ��� � = d y¨kzHJIwMOH�kzILbwb8�ªV�KZVEbwVYM~TWVE`AILd ��� IwKcTZHJV�_S[JbL�KfTZ_uXf�NkzHJIwMOHrIwKlTZXZtJVePS[J`rKZt �FMEIwVE[vT¤TW_�MYPStJKZV�£Fh

�¯KfTZ_uXf�FIwK � ���-� �#"!���NILd�TZHJV �ftJ`psuV{`JV~TWVYXf^FIL[JVYKmTWHQPqTmTWHJV©KfTW_SXf�:ILKmTZXZtJV�Pq[J` KZt��|MEIwVY[\TlTZ_V~�URJbwPSIw[r£|h�Õd�P �ftJ`JsSV�PSMYMEVYRpTZK�[J_S[JV�_SdmTZHJV|PS`poS_UMYPqTWVEKY ¬KfTZ_uXZILVYK�PSK�TZXZtJV|PS[J`"Kft��|MYIwVE[\T�y8TWHJVE[�KfHJV

km_utJbw`jVYI¥TWHJVEX V~�URJXfVYKZK]HJVYX?`JILKWPSRpRª_uIL[\TW^|VY[\T kzILTZH)TZHJV0PS`poS_UMYPqTWVEK]IL[pd�_uXZ^FPSbLbL�uy�_SX M�PSbLb�P^|IwKfTZXZIwPSb­h8�DkzIwbLb�^|_a`JVYbQTWHpIwK�HpVYXZV©�v�FRJXfVYKZtp^FIL[Js�TZHQPqTlI¥d�TWHpV �ftJ`JsuVcKZVEbwVYM~TWKlTZHJV©K�TOPqTZV{_Sd¬TWHpVkm_uXZbL`"kzHpVYXZV|[J_u[pV|_qd�TZHJV�KfTZ_uXZILVYKePSXZV}TZXZtJVqy8KZHJV|XZVϦ�`JXZP5kzKePS[p_STWHJVEX�KfTWPqTWV�d�XZ_S^ TWHpV|KZPS^|VRJXf_u�QPS�JILbwI¥T��N`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[�h �UHJV�kzILbwb«TZHatpKcV~ouVY[\TZtQPSbwb¥� KZV~TZTZbwV�_u[]P|R�_uKZI¥TWI¥ouV�[vtJ^}��VYXz_Sd�TWXZtpVKfTZ_uXZILVYK�kzILTZH?RJXZ_u�JPS�JIwbLILT��|_u[JVqh

2©P�oaIw[JsNPSMYMEVYRpTZVY`�Kf_u^|VeK�TW_uXfIwVEK©PS[p`�XZV �fVYM~TWVY`�_STWHJVEXZKEy�KfHJV�RpbgPSMEVYKcP�kmVYILsuH\T©_u[]V�PSMOH]_SdTWHpV�KfTW_SXZIwVEK�kzHJILMOHrKfHJV�`JIL` PSMYMEVYRpTYyQ^FVYPS[JIL[Js�TWHJPqTlTWHpV �ftJ`JsuV©d�VEVYbLK�TWHQP§T�KZ_u^|V{K�TW_uXfIwVYKlkmVYXfV^|_uXZVcIw^|Rª_uX�TOPS[\T�Iw[NV~�URJbgPqIw[JIL[Js�£|ypV~ouVY[ TZHJ_utJsuH:PS[\�N_u[pV{_Sd¬TWHpVY^ k�_utpbw`:��V{KZt �FMEIwVE[vTl�v�ILTZKZVEbLdÀh�2cP5oaIL[Js�`JVETZVYXf^FIL[JVY` HJVEXl_uRJIL[JIw_S["��VÏ�pRpXZVYKfKZVE`�Iw[FTWHJV{kmVYILsuH\TWKzPS[J` `pV �Q[JVE`rd�_SXZ^FPSbwb¥�Iw[ �{V �Q[JILTZIw_u[ � � ��VYbL_5kc�~yJKfHJV�tpKZVYKzTWHJPqTz_uRJIL[JIw_u[:TZ_�M�PSbLMYtJbwPqTWV{TZHJV��Q[QPSb«oSVYXf`JIwM~T�hG�HJV�RpbgPSIL[vTZI�� XZVYMEVYI¥ouVYKNP0RJP5�S_ �jVY�vtQPSb�TZ_0TZHJVroSVYXf`JIwM~T�y�PS[p` TWHpV]`JV~d�VY[J`JPS[\TNXfVYMYVEILoSVYK

P]RJP5�S_ ��VY�vtQPSb=TW_rTWHJV|[JVEs\PqTWIL_u[0_SdlTWHpV|oSVYXZ`pIwMETYh?G�HJV �ftJ`psuVF`p_UVEK�[J_qT�XfVYMYVEILoSV:P]RJP5�S_ ��y��´¶µNÇ~µNÇE¾�·­Á§ÇÏÚ«·i­Ì�ÇÏÚwÆQ·i¸®¹�ɧڡÇ~Ì͵Y·iÌÍÑ?Ö~¿�¹ZÃ=Ù§ÂÕÃ�·fÆ¢·­¸®¹�µF·i¸§¹�Ë5¹ÀÊ ¹fµ§Ë®ÇϵY·ZÆ¢·i¸§¹�µNØq¿~·i¸:Ã�Ì�Ë5¹fÃlÇ~Âi¹{ÇÏÚ¡ÚÍ¿OÈ«¹fË|Ç­¹�Ø®Á5·i·­Ç~Ú�Ì¡µ}·i¸®¹¤Ã­ÇÏÅl¹z¿E­ˮ¹�ÂZ»¤´!Ê ¹�¹fÚ¢·i¸qÇO·�¹���ɧÚÍÌ�¾ÀÌÍ·iÚ¡Ä�Ål¿5Ë5¹fÚÍÌ¡µ®Ö�·­¸®¹�·iÁ§Âiµw·­Ç~Î�Ì͵®Ö�È«¿~Á§Ú¡Ë�ÇEË®Ë}ÚÍÌÍ·�·­Ú͹¤ÐWÇ~ÚÍÁ§¹¿OÐ~¹f¬Ã�Ì¡ÅlÉ®ÚÍÄzÙ§µ§Ë5Ì¡µ®Öl·i¸§¹D¹��YÁ®Ì¡ÚÍ̡خ­̡Ç�¿ÏÊp·i¸§¹=Ã�Ì¡Å�Á®ÚÍ·­Ç~µ®¹�¿EÁ§Ã«ÖEÇ~Å�¹�¸®¹fÂi¹E»

Page 71: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

��^|V�PS[JIL[Js�TWHJPqT�KZHpV?kzILbwbm�QPSKZV?HJVEX}ouVEXZ`JILMET|[J_ST�_u[�PS[nVÏ�pR�VYM~TWVE` tpTZIwbwI¥T��0M�PSbLMYtJbwPqTWIL_u[�y��JtUTtJKfIw[JsFP|RpXZ_aMYVYKfKckzHJILMOH]d�_ubLbw_5kzK�sutJIL`JVYbLIw[JVEK�_utpTZbwIw[pVY`?�ªVEbw_5k�h�G�HpV�PS`Uou_aM�PqTZVYK{PqXZVePSKZKftJ^|VY`TW_¤HQP�ouV�tJ[JIL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZILoSV�RJXZIL_uX¬��VYbwILVEd�K8PS��_utpT¬TZHJV �ftJ`JsuVq ÍK8_uRJIL[JIw_S[�°qIL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZILoSV�RJXZIL_uXZK�km_utJbL`TWVE^FR�VYXlTZHJV�XZVEKZtJb¥TWKz�ªVEbw_5k¯�ptpT¤[J_STzMOHQPS[psuV�TWHJVEIwX�KZtp�JKfTWPS[JMYVqh

2�3�� � +}@��\+6��� �C / �:9�� +}7A> �A;D<�� +��AC ��CE9�C 8�

G�HJILKNKZVEMETZIw_u[ kzILbwb�`JILKZMEtJKZKNTZHJV�MYPSbwMEtJbgP§TWIw_S[ _Sd©TWHJV]KZtJ� �fVEMETZILouVARpXZ_u�QPq�JIwbLILT���TZHQPqT��a� � ��ILKTWXftJVSymTWHJV?k�VEIwsuH\T|TWHJV��ftJ`JsSV]RJbwPSMYVEKF_S[ P0M�PStJKZPqTWIL_u[�y�PS[J`nTWHJV �Q[QPSb�oSVYXZ`pIwMETFsuI¥ouVY[�TWHQP§TKZ_S^FV�[vtJ^}��VYXz_Sd�KfTZ_uXZILVYK¤PSXfV�TZXZtJVqhG�HJIwKzKfVYMETZIw_u[?kzIwbLb«ME_u[JMYbLtJ`JV��\�?`JVYKfMYXfIw�JIL[Js�TWHJV�V~�UR�VYM~TWVY`��Q[QPSb�oSVYXf`JIwM~T�h

021�5176 .�/ �L9B< �LH�� ;7NO;4P RCP /LH�P?H KMI � F�; �DLF R F�NOHJ; 0 ;=K PM9�I

��kzIwbLb¨��VYsSIw[��\��`JVYKfMYXZIL�JIw[psNTWHJV�KZtJ� �fVEMETZILouV�RpXZ_u�QPq�JIwbLILT�� � � �v� � �Z��d�_uX©K��abwbw_SsuIwKf^FKEhcG�HJVE[�y¬�kzIwbLbQsuVY[pVYXWPqbwI��EV¤TZ_}XZVYPSb¥¦­k�_SXZbw`|HJILKfTW_SXZIwVEKYh �jbwVEs\PSb�PSXfsutJ^|VY[\TmkzILbwb¢Iw[pMYbwtp`JVcVEbwVE^FVE[vTZK�_Sd��ª_STZHbw_SsuIwMYPSbªMEbgPSKfKZI��QM�PqTZIw_u[pK�_uX�RJXZ_a_Sd�KEy¢PS[J`?_Sd�KfTW_SXf�vTWVEbwbwIL[Js�PS��_utpT�TZHJV�HJIwK�TW_uX�� _Sd!PS[?VEouVE[\T�h

S�T���TWBTW X ,���� �4.�����2 �

$�_u[JKfIw`JVEX¨TZHJV=d�_ubwbL_®kzIL[JslTWHpXZVYVϦ�MYPStJKZVmKfTZ_uXf��TZ_cVÏ�pRpbgPSIL[�TZHJV�VEouVE[\T=£ � �U_aMYXWP§TWVYK¨IwK¨Pz^F_SXfTOPqb­²� h!� �§��h!� �U_aMYXWP§TWVYK�ILK�P ^NPq[�y¬� k � PSbwb�^FVE[0PSXZV}^FPS^|^NPqbwKYyª� � � PSbwb¨^NPq^F^FPSbwKcPSXfV^|_uXfTWPSbwK�vh �©KfKZtJ^|V�d�_uXz[J_5k TWHJPqT � hlILK�TWHJV�_u[Jb¥�:^|VYMOHQPq[JIwKf^%�\�:kzHJIwMOH�£,MY_utpbw`r�ªV{TZXZtJVqh�ÕT}ILK�MEbwVYPSXZb¥�"KZt��|MYILVY[\T}TZ_�V~�URJbwPSIw[�£Fy�IL[�TZHQPqT}I¥d�PSbLb=ILTWKeVYbLVY^|VY[\TWK�PSXZVFsuILoSVY[�TZ_���VFTZXZtJVqyTWHpVY[�£�ILKzTZXZtJV�kzI¥TWHrMYVYX�TOPSIL[\T��uh �¤_5k MY_u[pKZIw`pVYX � k � �§��h�� �U_aMYXWP§TWVYK¤IwKzP�^FPS[�y¢� k �$PSbwb^|VY[]PSXZVe^NPq^F^FPSbwK�vh �aTZ_uXf� � k IwKzKZt �FMEIwVE[vTcTW_|V~�URJbwPSIw[r£ ILd!PS[J`r_u[JbL�:ILd!� � IwK�TZXZtJVqyªPq[J`KZ_|TWHJV�RJXZ_S�QPS�JILbwILT��FTWHQP§T � k IwK¤KZt��|MYILVY[\T©TZ_NVÏ�pRpbgPSIL[�£ VY�vtQPSbLK¤TZHJV�RpXZ_u�QPq�JIwbLILT��NTZHQPqT � h�ILKTWXftJV�suILoSVY[ � k yQI­hÒVSh¥y � � �v� � k �f��� � � � h�� � k �Ïh

�c_5k,KZP���TWHQP§T�Iw["PS`J`pILTWIL_u[�TZ_rK�TW_uX�� � hÏy¨£%ME_utJbw`"PqbwKZ_ ��V}TWXftJV�oaIgP:KfTZ_uXf� � � ² �§��h!��U_aMYXZPqTWVEK©IwK¤P|^NPS[«yª� k �,Pqbwb¬^|VY[�PqXZVe^NPS^|^FPSbwKEyJ���!�,PSbLb¬^NPS^|^FPSbwK�PqXZVebwILoaIL[Js�TWHJIL[JsuKYy���(� PSbwb¨bwI¥oaIw[JsNTZHJIw[psuK�PSXfV}^F_SXfTOPqb��vh �c_5k � k IwK�KZt �FMEIwVE[vT�TZ_ V~�URJbwPSIw["£%I¥d=VYILTZHJVYX � h©_SX

Page 72: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �� � PqXZV�TWXZtpV�suI¥ouVE[ � k y�PS[J`]KZ_FTZHJVeRJXZ_u�JPS�JIwbLILT��FTWHQPqT � k IwK¤KZt��|MYILVY[\T©TZ_FVÏ�URJbgPSIL[�£ IwKz[J_5k� � �v� � k �f� � � � � h � � � � � k �Ïh±!Iw[JPSbwb¥�uySME_u[JKfIw`JVEX � � � �§� k PSbLbp^|VY[|PSXZV�^FPS^|^NPqbwKYyS� � �jPSbwbU^NPq^F^FPSbwK�PSXfV¤^|_uX�TOPSbLK �vh

,{[JV�^NPq[J[JVYXz_Sd�TWHJIL[JxvIw[Js�KZP5�aK¤TWHQPqT¤KfIw[JMEV � � �� � � yJTWHJVeRJXZ_S�QPS�JILbwILT��|TWHJPqT � �©ILK¤Kft��|MYILVY[\TTW_nVÏ�pRpbgPSIL[)£ KZHJ_utpbw` [J_ST?��VA�QPSKfVY`j_u[ � � h �¤d¶TWVYX?Pqbwb­yzI¥dePS[jPS`pou_aM�P§TWV"RJXZVEKZVE[vTZVY` PS[VY[pME�aMYbL_uRªVE`JIgPUy!d�PSMETZK���h�TZHJXZ_utpsuHn���}km_utJbw`�PSbwb��ªVFIw[�TZHJVYXfV:KZ_S^FV~kzHJVYXfVSyD�JtpT�k�VNkm_utJbL`[J_STzKZP�� TWHQPqT�TZHJVePS`poS_UMYPqTWVeHQPSKzRJXf_®oaIL`JVY`]PS[?V~�URJbwPS[QPqTZIw_u[ d�_uXz£|hDG�HJVYXfVEd�_uXfVSy � � �a� � �E�Z� �� � � h�� � k �Ïh

�©b¥TWVYXf[QPqTZILouVEbL�Sy¢kmV�ME_utJbL`�PSbLbw_5k¯_5ouVEXZKft��|MYIwVE[\T�VEoaIw`pVY[JMEVSy«^|V�Pq[JIw[Js�TWHJPqT � � IwKcPSRJXf_uRª_SKVEoSVY[rTWHJ_utpsuH � � �� � � h=�Õd¨k�V�PSbwbL_5kjTZHJIwKEypTWHpVY[ � � �v� � �Ï�Z��� � � � h � � � � � �Ï�~h

S�T���TWBTVU � �4�\�� ����Q��#�2:�M��� � � �������\� ��� ������� �Y���@��#����\� �\���� � , ��� � ��� [� � � � �B���� �M�Y����

,{tpTWKfIw`JV�_Sd�Kf�abwbL_usuILKZ^|KYy�TZHJV�KfTWPqTWVE^FVE[\TA� � IwKNKZt��|MYILVY[\T:d�_uX:£ TW_�_aMYMEtJXY mIwKFIw^|Rª_uKfKZIL�JbwVTW_]�vtQPS[\TWI¥d¶�uh �DoSVY[�I¥d�kmV:HQP�ouV P �QXZ^ suXZPSKZR�_u[�TZHJVNMYPStJKWPqbm^|VYMOHQPq[JIwKf^]y¨TWHJVEXZV:PqXZV|KfTWILbwbMY_S[vTZIw[JsSVY[JMEIwVYK�kzHJVEXZV � _UMEMYtJXfK��ptpT�£ `p_UVEK�[J_qT�y8VShÒsJh¥y!P?^FV~TWVE_uX�^NP���d�Pqbwb!d�Xf_u^�TWHpVFKfxv�PS[J`rMYXftJKZH]PSbLb�Iw[\ou_SbLouVE`�h

�¬VET�����V}PNtJ[pILouVEXZKZPSb!K�TW_uX��uy«bLIwK�TWIw[ps �����8_SdDTWHpV�VEoSVY[\TWK{kzHpIwMOH"PSXfV�[JVEMYVYKfKWPSX���d�_uXctJKcTZ_MY_S^FRJbLVETZVYbL�NsutQPSXZPS[\TWVEVeTZHQPqTcPS[rVEouVE[\T©kzIwbLb«��VeTZXZtJVqh �atJMOH�P�KZV~T©ME_utJbw`r_u[Jb¥�:��V�xv[J_5kz[]�v�PS[�_u^F[pIwKZMEIwVE[vT�_S�JKZVEXfouVEXYh ��tpT�ILdmk�VNPSbwbL_5k$TZHQPqT�KZtJMOH�P?KZV~T}VÏ�pILKfTZKYy�TZHJVY[0TWHJVF`JIwKfMYtJKfKZIL_u[XZVEs\PSXf`JIw[JsAK��abwbw_SsuIwKf^FK�PS�ª_5oSV]PqRJRJbwILVYK}`pIwXZVEMETZbL�uh �¬VET�� ��V:TWHJV?KfVET|_Sd¤tJ[JI¥ouVYXfKWPSb�K�TW_uXfIwVEKkzHJILMOH]VÏ�pRpbgPSIL[]£|h±Q_uXNVÏ�JPq^FRJbLVSy¤P�bgP�k��SVYX:^FP�� TZVYbwbcP�KZHp_uXfT K�TW_uX�� � �:TZ_�V~�URJbwPSIw[ P�`pXZILoSVYX:HpILTZTZIw[Js�P

R�VY`JVEKfTWXfIgPS[«ypKWP��aIw[ps}_u[Jb¥��TWHQPqTmTWHJVc`JXZI¥ouVEXlHJILT�P�RJPqTWMOH _Sd8ILMYVcPS[J`:KfbwIL`NIw[\TZ_�TWHpV{RªVE`JVYK�TWXfIgPS[�h��tpTFTWHJILKFKfIw^|RJbwV?K�TW_uX�� ILKFRJPSXfTF_Sd�PS[ Iw[��Q[pILTWVEbL��bwPSXZsSVYX�KZVE�atpVY[JMEVA_Sd�VEoSVY[\TWKEy ��h~y�kzHpIwMOHIw[pMYbwtp`JVYK{KftJMOH0M�PStJKfVYK�PSKE²cTZHJV�RªVE`JVYK�TWXfIgPS[�k�PSK�_utpT{KZHJ_uRpRJIw[Js ��VYMYPStJKfV�KZHJV�HQPS` �ftpKfT{km_u[TWHpV�bw_STfTWVYX��uy�TZHJV�`JXZI¥ouVEX{klPSK�[J_qT�KZxvIwbLbwVY`]kzILTWH"HQPq[J`JbwIL[Js:ILMYVSy�TZHJV�`JXfILouVEX{klPqKesS_uIw[JsNHJ_u^|VbgP§TWV�TWHQPqT©`QP�����VYMYPStJKfV�TWHJV�MY_uRJILVYXcPqT©km_uXfx]�JXf_uxSVqy¬PS[J`�_Sd=MY_utpXZKZVqy�PN^|VETZVY_uXc`JIw`][J_STcd�PSbwbd�XZ_S^ TZHJV}Kfxv��PS[J`AMEXZtJKfH"PSbwb8Iw[\oS_ubLoSVY`�h�G�HJV�RpXZ_u�QPq�JIwbLILT��:TZHQPqT � ��ILK©Kft��|MYIwVE[\T�TW_:VÏ�pRpbgPSIL[TWHpV}PSMEMYIw`pVY[\T©XfVY�vtJILXZVYK¤TWHQP§T{PSbLb¬_Sd�TZHJV|�ÍHJVEbwR�VYX¤VEouVE[\TWKY ¥y ��h � � �{PqXZV�PSbwb�TZXZtJV�PSK¤kmVYbLb­h�G�HQP§T

Page 73: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� IwKEy � � �v� � �Ï�f�!� � �!��h�� � �O�~h�G�HJVYXfV|PSXZV�PF^}tJbLTZILTZtJ`JV�_qdm_qTWHJVEX{KZV~TWK�_Sd�HJVEbwR�VYX{V~ouVY[\TZK�kzHpIwMOHkm_utJbw`]�ªVeKZt �FMEIwVE[vTcTW_|M�PStpKZV�TZHJV�PSMYMEIw`JVE[vT¤kzILTZH�RJXf_u�QPS�pIwbwI¥T��N_S[JVSyªPS[J`rkzHJIwMOH�PSXZVeV�PSMOH�PKZtpRªVEXZKZV~T©_qd � ��°QbLVET�TWHpVYKZVe��V ��h��� ��� ��h����5h=�ÕdDPS[\� _S[JV�_Sd!TZHJVY^%ILK�TWXZtpVSyJTWHpVY[?TWHJVePSMEMYIw`pVY[\Tkm_utJbw`rHQP�ouV�_aMYMEtJXZXfVY`�y¢KZ_ � � �v� � �Ï�f� � � ��� ��� h������ h���� � � � � �Ï�G�HJV�d�_ubwbL_®kzIL[Js}`JV �Q[JI¥TWIw_S[JK�`JVYXfILoSVe`pIwXZVEMETZbL�Nd�Xf_u^�TZHJV�`JIwKfMYtJKfKZIL_u[�Pq�ª_5ouVqh

� ��� ��� �Y���� W�� f V+VI!$C�H+�-5;2 !$E�!$y7� EF9 , �>. HP� �". J A � � �v� � �f� � � ������ �� ��� � �

� ��� ��� �Y���� W[S �[HI937V+VI!$C�H+�-5B!$y7� EF9 ,�>. HP� �". JKA � � �a� � �Z� � ��� �� �� ��� ���� ������/� � ���S�T���TWBT�� � [ ����� �B�\ �

� �ftJ`JsSV 3-.�.��YZ\#+9 P KfTW_SXf��I¥d�KZHJV|�ª_qTWHA��VYbwILVEoSVYK�TWHQP§T�TWHJV�K�TW_uX��AIwK{TZXZtJVqy�kzHJIwMOH"kzIwbLb!_aMYMYtpXkzILTZHFRpXZ_u�QPq�JIwbLILT�� � � � �Ï°pPS[p`F��VYbLIwVEoSVYK=TWHQP§T�TZHJV¤KfTW_SXf��ILK�Kft��|MYILVY[\T�TZ_�VÏ�pRpbgPSIL[�TZHJV¤VEouVE[\T�£FykzHJILMOH]kzIwbLb�_aMYMYtpX¤kzI¥TWH�RpXZ_u�QPq�JIwbLILT�� � � �v� � �f�~hm�ÕTckzILbwb���V�ME_u[\ouVE[JIwVE[vT©TW_|`JV �Q[pV}P�KZVYRJPSXWPqTZV[J_STWPqTWIL_u[:d�_uXlTZHJIwKzPSM~TWIL_u[�yJKfIw[JMEV�PqMYMYVERpTOPq[JMYVeRJbgP��aKzKZ_|HJV�P�oaIwb¥�:IL[?TZHJV�KZVE�atpVYb­h� ��� ��� �Y���� W � f 9 #%!$E J � HI9 PSMYMEVYRpTZVY` H 24H+#LHI9� , OK5-�xOB#Y!B` ��#UE , �l37�\O0#Y!u` ��3�9 , �a. HP� �(#� �pZ\V]37�\37#UHP!$�L2 !$E £0Rl~ &(� Z\EF!7`�3�`H+VWH+#rJ[!%2G3-.�.��YZ\#�37�".��iHI9 "!�� � � � � � � � �v� � �f��-S � # "!��$# � � �9 H]57�(H 2 J{#'&(�|Z\EF!7`�3�`H+VWH+#UJu!%2�E�� ��. #UHP!$�QA � � � � � � �v� � �Z� ��Õd¬TWHpV �ftJ`JsSV©IwK�_u^|[JIwKfMYILVY[\TmPS[J`:xv[J_5kzK � yaTZHJVY[NIw[FTZHJV©XfVYKfRªVEMETWI¥ouV{MYPSKZVEKl_Sd¨PSbLbw_5kzIw[ps�Pq[J``JILKWPSbLbw_5kzIw[Js�_®oSVYXfKZt��|MYILVY[JM~�uy

%!}� � � � '& � � (��) � �+* _SX�%!}� � � � -,. (�� ��) � � ���� �+/0 �

±Q_uXzV~�pPS^|RJbwVqyQILd¨TWHJV �ftJ`JsSV���VYbLIwVEoSVYKzTWHQP§T¤TZXZtpTZH�Pq[J`�Kft��|MYIwVE[JME�rsuI¥ouVE[]TWXftpTWH]PSXfV�K�TOPqTZIwKfTZI¥¦M�PqbwbL�FIw[p`JVYR�VY[J`pVY[\T�yQTWHpVY[

"!�� � � � � � � ��� � � �v� � �f��1 ´¶µ©·i¸®Ì�Ã8¾À¿EµY·i¹ ��·ZÆ�·i¸®¹=ÃiÄ�Å�ØS¿~ÚJÛ32«Ü§Ã�Ì¡Ö~µ§ÌÒÙ§¹ZÃ�µ®¹�ÖYÇO·­ÌÍ¿EµvÆ5µ®¿Ï·�·­¸®¹=¾À¿EÅ�ɧÚ͹fÅ�¹fµY·fƧÃi¿545672�8 ³:9 Ì¡Ã�·­¸®¹Dɮ­¿~Ø§Ç Ø®Ì¡ÚÍÌÍ·�Äz·­¸§ÇO·;8 ³ Ì�Ã�Ê¥Ç~Ú¡Ãi¹~Æ5µ®¿~·¬·i¸®¹DɧÂi¿EاÇÏخ̡ڡÌÒ·�Äl·­¸§ÇO·=<�8 �?> @:@:@ > 8�ACBDÌ�ë·i­Á®¹~»

Page 74: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

&�021�5143 � �; � /.PMK?<.D KMI � F�; �D.P?F�HJILK�H�PB;=<.D

G�HJV}kmVYILsuH\T�RJbgPqMYVY`A_S["PS[\��suI¥ouVY[AK�TW_uX���`JVERªVE[J`JK�_u[�kzHJILMOHAKfTZ_uXZILVYK{HQP�oSV|��VYVE["PSMYMEVYRpTZVY`PSK�TWXZtpV©PS[p`:KZt��|MEIwVY[\TYh�G�HpVYXZV~d�_uXZVqypbLVET � ��V¤TZHJV©KfVET�_Sd¬KfTZ_uXZILVYK�kzHJIwMOH:HJP5oSV©��VYVE[ PSMYMEVYRpTZVY`PSKe�ª_qTWH"TWXZtpVNPS[p`�KZt �FMEIwVE[vTYyDPS[J`0V~�URJXfVYKfK�TWHJV�kmVYIwsSHvT�RJbwPSMYVE`�_u[ � h{kzHJVE[ �$IwK�TWHJV|KZV~T_Sd�TWXZtpVeK�TW_uXfIwVEK©PSK�� � � h � ���Ïh �UIL[JMYV�TZHJVYKfV}PSXfV�kmVYILsuH\TWKEy�TZHJVE�?KfHJ_utJbL`]��V�Rª_uKfILTZILouVqyQKZtJ^%TZ__u[JVqy¢PS[J`r�ªV��EVYXf_|d�_uXzPqbwb � [J_ST¤Iw[��ch�±Q_uXf^NPqbwbL��²� � � � 2 ����� � � W�� 4 2 £ HI9�37� � y7� �(#+AG37�\O � � � � h�������� � b � AiHI9�#+&(�89K� #;!%2�9 #Y!$E HP��94CD&-HP.�&&Q37y7�1` ��� �e3-.�.��YZ\#Y�xOB3$94#UE , ��37�\Om9 , �>. HP� �(#i#Y!v� �pZ\V]37H+� £ Ai#'&(� �62 !$E��x3-.�& ��� = ���M�H�� � � ��� � �l� � A�� �M�H+H��� b

��� h � � ��� � �l� � �M�H+H+H�� � � ��� � �l� � � A�� ��� �= ��R

�©K�PFKZR�VYMYIwPSb!MYPSKZV�_Sd �©KfKZtJ^|RpTWIL_u[ �Y&FILTcIwK©R�_uKfKZIw�pbwV�TZHQPqT©_u[JbL�r_u[pV}KfTZ_uXf�]IwKcPSMYMEVYRpTZVY`PSK¤PS[?V~�URJbwPS[QPqTZIw_u[ d�_uXz£|hD��[rTZHJIwK�MYPSKZVqy�� � � h � � � h �q� � �uh�)ILTZHjT�km_ K�TW_uXfIwVYKEy{TWHJVEXZV�PSXZVATZHJXZVEV�R�_uKZKfIw�JbLV"KfTOP§TWVYKE² � � h�� � k �Ïy�� � h� # � k �~y�Pq[J`

��# � h�� � k �Ïh]G�HJVNKfTOP§TWVA�$# � h�� # � k ��IwKe[J_ST�XZVYbLVEoqPS[\T�TZ_]TZHJV �ftJ`psuVS ÒK�TOPqKZx¢h �=PSMOH�K�TOPqTZVIw^|RJbLIwVYK�P�`JI��ªVYXfVY[\Tzk�VEIwsuH\T¤RJbgPqMYVY`r_u[ � hlPS[J` � k ²

� � � � h � � � � � h � ����� � � � � � k � �l��� �

� � � � k � � � � � h � ����� � � � � � k � �l��� �� � � � h � � k � � � � � h � �l����� � � k � �l��� � �

G�HJVEXZV�IwK{[p_STWHJIL[Js:IL[�TWHJV�XfV�PSbL^ _Sd�K�TOPqTZIwKfTZIwMEK©kzHJIwMOHAkzILbwb8TWVYbLb!tJK�HJ_5kTWHJV �ftp`JsuV�kzILbwb!`pIwK�¦TWXfIw�JtUTWV�TWHJV�kmVYILsuH\TWK¤Iw[?TWHJV�TWHpIwXZ`rM�PqKZVShGn¤V~TWtJXf[JIw[ps�TZ_NPq[]VÏ�JPq^FRJbLV�d�XZ_u^/Pq�ª_5ouVqy¢KZHJVe^NP��`JVEMYIw`pVeTZHQPqTe�¡KfHJV�k�PSK©`pXZtJ[Jx¢ ¢klPqKcTWHpV�RJXfIw^FPSXf�NM�PStpKZVSyª_uXzKZHJV�^NP��?`JVEMYIL`JVeTZHQPqTe�¡KfHJV�HJPS`HQPqTZVY`rHJIw^ d�_uX�^|_u[\TWHJKE JklPSK�TZHJV�RJXZIL^NPSX��:MYPStJKZVqh

S�T���TVU TW � ��# ��� ���

�¬VET�V�PSMOH�KfTZ_uXf�"HQP�oSVNP oqPSbwtJVqy �ª� � � = d y�XZVERJXZVEKZVE[vTZIw[Js]TWHJV�ouVEXZ`JILMET:��IL[�`J_SbwbgPqXZK{RQPqIw`0�v�TWHpV{RJbgPqIw[\TWI�� TW_�TZHJV{`JV~d�VY[J`QPq[vTO��kzHJILMOH:k�_utpbw` ��V{suILoSVY[:I¥d�TWHpV �ftJ`JsuV©`JVYMEIw`JVE`:TWHQPqT � kmVYXfVTWHpVeKf_ubwV�MYPStJKfV�_Sd!£Fh

Page 75: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

& ���I¥ouVE["TZHQPqT ��� � � h ����� � � � b �NPSXZV�PqMYMYVERpTWVE`�PqK{TWXZtpV�PS[J`AKZt �FMEIwVE[vT�TZ_ M�PStJKfV|£Fy�TWHpV

�Q[QPqb�ouVYXf`JIwM~T©ILKzPSKZKftJ^|VY`]TZ_��ªVeP�bwIw[pV�PSXlME_u^}�JIL[QPqTZIw_u[ _Sd�V�PqMOH�KfTZ_uXf�� ÒK¤oqPSbLtJV{kmVYIwsSHvTZVY`]�v�ILTZK�M�PStpKWPSb�kmVYILsuH\T�²

�N� �����b���� h � � ��� � �l� ��ª� ��� � � � � h �5�

�a_FsuI¥ouVE[rTZHQPqTzTWHJVEXZVePSXfV�P�[vtJ^}��VYXz_Sd�TWXZtpVeK�TW_uXfIwVEKzkzHpIwMOHrMY_u[JMEbwtJ`pVekzI¥TWH TWHJVeVEoSVY[\T�y¢TWHpV�Q[QPqb�ouVYXf`JIwM~TzkzIwbwbª�ªVeP�bwIL[JV�PqXlMY_u^��JIw[QP§TWIw_S[ _Sd�TZHJV�Iw[J`pILoaIw`JtJPSbªoSVYXZ`pIwMETZKYh�ÕdlTWHpVYXZVFIwKe_u[Jb¥�A_u[JV|KfTZ_uXf�"kzHJILMOH�IwK�PSMEMYVYRUTWVY`«y!TWHJVE[ � � � � � � �q� � �uy�PS[J`0TWHJV��Q[QPSb

ouVEXZ`JILMET¤XZVE`JtJMEVYKcTZ_�TWHJV�`JV �Q[JILTZIw_u[ _qd �ª�����~²��:� � � �q� � �ª� � �~hG�HJV�XfVYKZtpbLTWK|kzHJIwMOH d�_Sbwbw_5k�`J_�[J_qT:XZVEbL��HJVYP5oaILbL�n_u[ TZHJV�bLIw[JVYPSX�d�_uXZ^ _Sd©TWHJVrouVYXf`JIwM~T

d�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[�yJ�JtUTz`J_�`JVYR�VY[J`r_u[:TZHJVePSKZKftJ^FRUTWIw_S[:TWHQPqT�TZHJV{ouVEXZ`JILMET¤IwK�KZ_u^|V�KZ_uX�Tz_Sd8k�VEIwsuH\TZVY`PSsusSXZVYsuPqTWIL_u[ _Sd¨TWHJVePSMEMYVYRUTWVY`]KfTZ_uXZILVYKYh

S�T���TVU TVU � �\����� � � �Q��# 2 �B��', ����� ��� �

G�HJVl[p_STOPqTZIw_u[�d�_uX8k�VEIwsuH\TZK�IwK8oqPSbwtQPq�JbwV=��VYM�PqtJKZVlI¥T!ILKZ_ubwPqTWVEK¬TWHJV�PSbwbL_UMYPqTWIL_u[�_SdQM�PqtJKWPSbvkmVYIwsSHvTZKd�XZ_S^�TWHpVeMYPSbwMEtJbgP§TWIw_S[:_Sd�KftJ� �fVEMETWI¥ouVeRJXZ_S�QPS�JILbwILTZIwVEKYh

� ��� ��� �Y���� W�� f �ftJ`JsuVq ÍK¨_uRJIL[JIw_u[ HI9G3�9K� #c!%2L.x37,�937V-CG� H]5$&-#+9 2 !$E}37�(J|57H+y7� ��9K� # !%2 9 #%!$E HP��9 R~ &Q37#LHI9�A\2 !$El37�(Jl57H+y7� � �5� � � h � ����� � � b�� AG#'&(� ,QOK5-� � 9m!�Z\H+�(HP!$�@&Q3$9l3�9 , ` 9K� #;!%2�CG� H]5$&-#+9� � � h � ��� A RKRKR A � � � b�� ���pR

��VFM�PS[�XZVE�atpIwXZV|MY_S[JKZILKfTWVE[JME�0d�XZ_S^1TWHJV��ftJ`JsuVFIw["TWVEXZ^|K�_Sd�HJVYX�VEoqPSbLtQPqTWIL_u["_Sd�RJXf_u�QP§¦�JILbwILTZIwVEKYyQPS[p`�M�Pq[�PSMEMYtJKfV}HJVYX¤_SdD�pIgPSKzILd!HJVYXcVEoqPSbLtQPqTWIL_u[?IwK�TW_a_Fd�PqXzd�Xf_u^ PF^|_uXfVe_S� �fVYM~TWILoSVKfTWPS[J`QPqXZ`�h���tUT�TWHJV�_uRJIL[JIw_S[APSK�`JV �Q[JVY`�HJVYXfV�IwK�Iw[p`JVYVE`�Pq[0_SRJIw[JIL_u[�y¬Pq[J`Ak�V�M�Pq[�VÏ�pR�VYM~TTWHJPqTzILT�kzILbwbªoqPSX��:kzIw`pVYbL�Fd�XZ_u^��ftJ`JsuV�TZ_��ftJ`psuVSyJ_SX¤V~ouVE[�_aMYM�PqKZIw_S[?TZ_�_UMEM�PSKfIw_u[�h�Õd¬P �ftJ`JsSV¤KfVYVE^FK=�JIwPSKZVE`�y\k�Vz[JVEVY`FTZ_�TWVYK�T=TWHQPqT=MEbgPSIL^$tpKZIw[pseMYPSKZVEK�kzHpIwMOH|^FIL[JIw^|I��EVmTWHpV

RJXf_u�QPS�JILbwI¥T��|TZHQPqT�ME_u^|RªV~TWIw[ps}KfTZ_uXZILVYKzPSXfV{KZIL^}tJbLTWPS[JVE_utJKZb¥��TWXZtpVSyQKZ_}TZHQPqT�TZHJV�XZtJbLIw[Js�kzIwbwb���VP��vtJVYK�TWIw_S[]_Sd�VEoqPSbLtQPqTZIw[Js}TZHJV�bwIwxqVYb¥�:KfTWPqTWV�_Sd¨TWHpV�km_uXfbw`?Iw[JK�TWVYPS`]_qd�TZHJV �ftJ`JsuVq ÍKz_uRJIL[JIw_S[�h

Page 76: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

& � ��� �����"� �Y� � ������ � 2 � G�HpV ��� ��(/"!�¤V~�URªVEMETZVY`�_StpTWME_u^FV©IwKlTWHpV{d�_ubwbL_®kzIL[Js�KftJ^%_5ouVEXPSbLbªTWHpVe[p_u[JVY^|RpT��?KfVETWKz_Sd!KfTZ_uXZILVYK �ª²

���� � k��� &�� � �� "!�� � �:* & �� � �� �ª� � � � � � � � � �:*� � � � hS�

G�HJV{RpXZ_a`JtJMETlIwK=TWHJV{RpXZ_u�QPq�JIwbLILT��}TZHQPqT�PqbwbQTWHJV©VYbwVE^FVE[\TWK�_qd � HQP�ouV���VYVE[?PSMYMEVYRpTZVY`?PSKmTWXZtpVPS[J`|PS[�VÏ�URJbgPS[JPqTWIL_u[}_Sdª£F°\TZHJV�KZtJ^$IwK!TZHJVlkmVYIwsSHvTZVY`|KZtJ^$_Sd¢TWHJVloSVYXf`JIwM~TWK�d�XZ_S^ �!�URJXZVEKZKZIL_u[� h �uhG�HJV"`JVEd�VE[J`QPS[\TrklPq[vTZK TW_n^FIL[JIw^|I��EV �!�URJXfVYKZKfIw_u[ � h�UyzkzHJIwbLV�TWHJVARJbwPSIw[\TZI��jklPS[\TZK?TZ_

^FP§�UIw^|I��YVcILTYh

021�51�� �� I ;ON7;��L9�;7I 0�{V �J[JV�PS[?Iw[JMEXZVE^FVE[vTWPSb�MOHQPq[JsuV�TW_���V�TWHJV�PS`p`JILTZIw_u[:_SX�XZVY^|_5oqPSb«_Sd!PS[\�:[vtJ^��ªVEX�_Sd!K�TW_uXfIwVEKd�XZ_S^ TZHJV�KZVETz_qd�K�TW_uXfIwVEK�RJXZVEKZVY[\TZVY`��\�:PS[rPS`pou_aM�P§TWVSh �{V �Q[JV�PS[?VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^�KZV~Tc_qd�K�TW_uXfIwVEKTW_���VeP�KfVETcKZtJMOHrTWHQP§Tz[JVYI¥TWHJVEXcPqsuVY[\T�kzIwKfHJVYKzTW_�^FPSxSVePS[?IL[JMYXfVY^|VY[\TOPSb¬MOHJPS[JsuV�TW_�I¥T�hG�HJIwKmIwK�P�[p_u[U¦�XfVYK�TWXZILMETZILouV¤`JV �Q[JILTZIw_u[|_Sd«VY�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^ryuIL[|TZHQPqTmILd«kmVckmVYXfVcTZ_}PSbLbw_5k ^|_uXZV

`JXZPSKfTZIwM�MOHJPS[JsuVEK!TW_c�ªVm^NPS`pVSySkmV�^FP�� �J[J`�d�VEkmVYXDVE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgPp°5TWHpIwK!ILK�ME_u^|RQPSXWPq�JbwV=TW_ �Q[J`JIL[Jsbw_aM�Pqb¬^NP§�UIL^NP�Iw[JK�TWVYPS`�_SdDPNsubw_S�QPSb¬^FP§�UIw^}tJ^rh �$^F_uXfV�sSVY[JVEXWPSb�PS[QPSb¥�aKZIwK¤IwK¤[J_ST©Rª_SKZKZIL�JbwVsuI¥ouVY[?TWHpVeXfVYbwPqTWI¥ouVYb¥�NKfRQPSXfKZV�PSKZKftJ^FRUTWIw_S[JK�^NPq`JV�HJVYXfVSh

021�510 � D ��2H�0 N� �)9B< 0 H ��� �9MP!;=K!;OD �2©P�oaIw[ps}Iw[\TWXf_U`ptJMYVE`?PSbwb¢_Sd¬TZHJV{MY_S[JMYVERpTWKEyQ�DRJXZVEKZVY[\T¤PS[ VÏ�pPS^FRpbwVcd�Xf_u^�TWHJV©XZV�Pqbw^�_Sd¨PS`UouVYXÀ¦TWILKZIL[JsJh

�©RJRpbwV�kzIwKZHpVYKcTZ_NME_u[\oUIL[JMYVeTWHJVebwILKfTZVY[JVEXc_Sd�TWHJV�VEoSVY[\T�£���� �¡PS[ �©RJRJbLV�ME_u^|RJtpTWVEX¤kzILbwb^FPSxSVz�u_utNHQPSRJR\�� L°akzHJIwbLV �{VEbwbJkzILKZHJVEKmTW_eMY_S[voaIL[JMYV¤TWHJVcbwIwK�TWVE[JVYX=_Sd8£��"�$�¡P �{VEbwbQME_u^FRptpTWVEXkzIwbLb«^FPSxSV��S_ut]HJPSRJR\�� Lh�G!PqxSV�TWHJV�tJ[JI¥ouVEXZKZVe_Sd�Rª_SKZKZIL�JbwV�MEbgPSIL^FK�TW_���V�PqKzd�_Sbwbw_5kzKE²

� �)� �cRJRJbLV�MY_u^|RJtpTZVYXZK¤PSXfV�MYtpTZVSh��� � �©RpRJbwV�MY_S^FRJtUTWVYXfKzHQP�ouV�P�KftJR�VYXZIL_uX��JtJKcPSXfMOHJILTZVYMETZtJXZVqh

Page 77: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

&��� �"� �{VYbwbªMY_u^|RJtpTZVYXfKcPqXZV�Iw[JVÏ�URªVE[JKZI¥ouVSh

�{VYbLb«PS[p` �©RJRJbLV{^FP5�FV�PqMOHrRpXZVYKfVY[\T¤PSKl^FPS[\�FKfTW_SXZIwVEK�PSK�TZHJVE�FkzIwKfH�ypVYPSMOH?MY_u[JKfIwK�TWIw[ps}_SdKZ_S^FV{KftJ�JKfVET¤_Sd8TWHJV{PS�ª_5oSV�M�PStJKfVYKEh �¬VETltJKlTOPSxqV{TWHJV�K�TOPqTZtJK��vtJ_�TW_���V �UI¥TWtQPqTZIw_u[ � h���d�XZ_u^±!ILsutJXZV � h �uh �8V~T©tpKcRJXfVYKftJ^FV�TWHpV�K�TOPqTZtJK©�vtJ_FIwK�TWHQP§T �cRJRJbLVeTZVYbwbLK�KfTZ_uXf� � �ePS[J` �{VYbLb�TWVEbwbwK� �5h

�UIw[pMYV�TWHJVEXZVcPSXZVlT�km_�V~ouVE[vTZKmTZ_e��V¤PSMYME_utJ[\TWVE`Fd�_uXEy\�!KfRªVEMYILd¶��TWHJVzVEoSVY[\T�TZHJVzKfTZ_uXf��ILKDKWPSIL`TW_ ��V}Kft��|MYIwVE[\TeTZ_:V~�URJbwPSIw[«y�VShÒsJh¥y �v� � � �O£ �E�cKfHJ_utJbL`A�ªV�XfV�PS`«y!� � ��IwK{Kft��|MYILVY[\T�TW_ VÏ�pRpbgPSIL[£��q ¥h �UIw^|IwbwPSXZb¥�uy � �Z�i� � ��� � � �q�lkzILbwbª�ªV�V~�aTZVY[J`JVE`]TZ_ � �f�­� � � �O£���� � �!�q�Ïh

�¬VETctJKcTWPSxSV�PSbwb¬_qd!TWHpVYKZV�KfTZ_uXZILVYKzTW_|�ªV�TWXftJVekzI¥TWH]MYVYX�TOPSIL[\T��uy¢I­hÒVSh¥y N� ��� � � �Sy¢d�_SXcPqbwb �ZhG�HJILK¤^|V�Pq[JKlTWHQP§T "!�� ��� ��� � � ��� �O£ � � � � � �~hG�HJVYXfV�PqXZV�T�k�_|RQPSILXZK�_Sd!PSXf�JILTZXWPSX��NVEbwVY^|VY[\TZKzkzHpIwMOH?TWHJV�`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[?^FPSxSVEX�MOHJ_a_uKZVEKYh�G�HJV

�QXfKfT�RQPSIwX�ILK � � �v� � ���O£��Y�Z��PS[J` � � �v� � � �W£ �~�f�~²�TWHJV|RJXZ_S�QPS�JILbwILT��]TWHQP§TeTZHJVNK�TW_uX��"RJXZVEKZVE[vTZVY`�\�]TZHJV�PS`UouVYX�TWILKZVYX©IwK©Kft��|MYILVY[\T�TW_:bLV�PS`rTW_NTZHJV}ME_u^FRptpTWVEX©^FPSxvIw[Js|TWHJV}�ptp�uVEX�HQPSRJR\�uh�±Q_uXPSX�TWIwK�TWKEy � � �v� � ���O£����f��TWVE[J`JKlTW_��ªV{HpIwsuH Pq[J` � � �a� � ���O£ �~�f��TWVE[J`JKlTZ_}�ªV©bw_5k�°UTZHJV{XZV~ouVEXZKZV�ILKT��aRJIwMYPSbwb¥�FTZXZtJV�d�_uXld�XftJs\PSb«�JtJKZIL[JVYKfKZ^|VY[�hG�HJV�KfVYME_u[J` RQPSILX�_Sd�PSXf�JILTZXWPSX���VYbLVY^|VY[\TWKFPSXZV?TWHpV]kmVYIwsSHvTZK � � � ���O£�� � � � ��� � ���q�|Pq[J`

� � � � �O£�� � � � � � � ���q�~h�G�HJPqT�IwKEy«suI¥ouVE[�TWHQPqT{�ª_STZH�KfTZ_uXZILVYK�PqXZV�PSMEMYVERpTWVE`�PqK©TWXftJV�PS[J`AKft���¦MYILVY[\T�yJkzHJPqTzk�VEIwsuH\T¤`J_aVYK�TWHJV�ME_u[JKZtp^FVEX¤RpbgPSMEV�_u[]VYPSMOH¢�G�HJV=ouVYXf`JIwM~T!sSILouVE[eTZHQPqT � ��ILK�PqMYMYVERpTWVE`�ILK�TWHQPqT8TZHJVmME_u[JKftJ^FVEX8�Jtp�aK!Pq[ �cRJRJbwV=ME_u^FRptpTWVEX

PS[J`)[J_qT?P �{VYbwbzkzILTZH)MYVYX�TOPSIL[\T��ª°�TZHJV�ouVEXZ`JILMET?suI¥ouVY[ � �rIwK:KfIw^|IwbwPSXZb¥��`JV �J[JVY`�h �8V~T � �KZILsu[JI¥d¶� � � �v� � ���O£���� � � ��� � ���q�c�iPS[p`:KZIL^FILbgPSXfbL��d�_SX � �E�~h�G�HJVE[rP�bwIL[JV�PSX=ME_u^}�JIL[QPqTWIL_u[|KZtJMOHPSK�� � �ª� � �E� � � � �ª� � �~�¤XfVYKftJbLTZK©Iw[]TWHJV�RJtJXZMOHJPSKZV�_Sd�Pq[ �©RJRpbwV�kzI¥TWH�RpXZ_u�QPq�JIwbLILT�� � ��Pq[J`P �{VEbwb�kzI¥TWHrRJXZ_u�JPS�JIwbLILT�� � �®h�G�HJV�^F_a`JVYb¬HpVYXZV�PSKZKftJ^|VYKcTZHQPqT � � � � �!� �uy¢�JtpTcILd�TWHQP§TPSKfKZtJ^|RpTWIL_u[:ILK�`JXf_uRJR�VY`?PS[J` � � � � � � �uyaTZHJVY[:TZHJV{`JVEMYILKZIw_S[:^NPqxSVYX��Jtp�aK�[J_}ME_u^FRptpTWVEXkzILTZH�RJXf_u�QPS�pIwbwI¥T�� �� � ��� � �q°�ILd�� ��� � �1j �uy�TZHJVY[�KZHJV��Jtp�aK©��_STWH�MY_u^|RJtpTZVYXZKzkzILTZHRJXf_u�QPS�JILbwI¥T�� � � � � � � �uh�ÕT¤IwKz`JI��|MEtJbLT�TZ_FKfRªVEMYILd¶� kzHJPqT � ��_uX � �©kzILbwb���VSyQ�JtUT{P}d�VEk¯XZV�PqKZ_u[QPq�JbwV�sutJVEKZKfVYKckzILbwb

PSbLbw_5kjMY_u^|RQPSXZPqTWI¥ouV�KfTWPqTWILMYKlTZ_F��V�^NPq`JVSh

Page 78: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

& �

�cRJRJbLVS ÒK¤K�TW_uXfIwVEK �{VEbwbi ÍKlK�TW_uXfIwVEK �¤� �©RJRJbLV5�� � � � � � � � h��u�

� ��� ��� � � � � � � h � �� � ��� � � � � � � h � �

±!ILsutJXZV � h �S² �U_u^|V�KfTW_SXZIwVEK¤PS[J`?TWHJV�bwILxSVEbwIwHp_U_a`N_Sd��Jtp�aIL[JsNPq[��cRJRJbLVeIL[J`JtJMEVY`?TWHJVEXZV~d�XZ_u^

S�T���T S�TW � � 2 �\�M# ����� ��� �Z�Y�M�Y��[�

±!ILsutJXZV � h ��KZHJ_5kzK¨KZ_u^|V=KWPS^|RJbLV�_StpTWME_u^FVEK8suILoSVY[�TWHQPqT8TZHJV�Pq`pouVEXfTWILKZVEXZK8TW_ubL`eKf_u^|V�KfVET�_SdUKfTW_§¦XZILVYKEh �UI¥TWtQP§TWIw_S[ � h��zIwK�TZHJV�KfTOP§TWtJK8�vtJ_J² �©RJRpbwV�TWVEbwbLK¬ILTWKD�ÍtJKZVEX�¦­d�XZIwVE[J`Jb¥�ª 5K�TW_uX��uy®kzHJIwbLV �{VYbLbSTWVEbwbwKILTZK}�¡IL[JV~�UR�VY[JKfILoSVFME_u^F^|_a`JILT��� «K�TW_uX��uh �cbLTWVEXZ[QP§TWILoSVYb¥�uy �cRJRJbwV�ME_utJbw`ATZVYbwb!ILTWK�tpKZVYXÀ¦Õd�XfIwVY[p`JbL�KfTZ_uXf��PS[J`�TWHJV�PS`p`JILTZIw_u[QPqbSKfTZ_uXf��PS�ª_StpT¬ILTZK¬�JtJK¨PSXfMOHJILTZVYMETZtJXZVqyuPSK¬IL[ �UILTZtQPqTWIL_u[ � h � h¨G�HJVDTWVEMOHU¦[JILM�PSbaKfTZ_uXf�e^FP5�e��Vl`JV~TWXZIL^FVE[\TOPSb\TW_cTWHJVltpKZVYXÀ¦Õd�XfIwVY[p`JbL��K�TW_uX��uy\MYXfV�PqTZIw[JscMY_u[Ud�tJKZIL_u[�h!G�HpVlKZtJ^_Sd�kmVYILsuH\TWK}RJbwPSMYVE`�_u[���_STWH�KfTW_SXZIwVEK*� � � � � �O£ ��� � � ��� ��� � � � �q��� � � � ���O£���� � � � � ��� � � ���q� �^FP5�"��VNbLVYKfKeTZHQPS[�TZHJVFkmVYILsuH\T�_uXfIwsuIL[QPSbLbL��PSbwbL_UMYPqTWVE`"TZ_]TZHJVNtJKfVYXÀ¦Õd�XZILVY[J`pbL�"KfTZ_uXf�0�\�0ILTZKZVYb¥d� � � � ���O£ � � � � ��� � ���q�!�­yQKf_�TZHJV�RJXZ_S�QPS�JILbwILT��F_Sd�RJtJXfMOHQPSKZIL[JsFPS[ �cRJRJbLV{d�PSbwbLKYh�ÕT�k�_utpbw`��ªV?KfTZIwbLb�^|_uXZV ME_u[pd�tJKfIw[Js"ILd �{VYbLbmkmVYXfVrTZ_�PS`UouVYX�TWILKZV TWHJV?KftJRªVEXZIL_uXZI¥T���_SdcILTZK

MY_S^FR�VETZILTW_SXY ÒKlRJXZ_a`JtJM~T�yJkzHJILMOHrkm_utJbL`]MYPStJKfVeTZHJV�RJXZ_u�JPS�JIwbLILT��|_Sd��Jtp�aIw[psNP �{VYbLb«TW_�d�PSbLb­h��[�KZHJ_SXfT�y!ILT�^NP��0�ªVF`JVETZXZIL^FVE[vTWPSbDd�_uX�VEILTZHJVYX�KZIw`pVFTW_]RJXZVEKZVE[vT ��� yDPS[J`�Kf_A�ª_qTWH�KfIw`JVEK

RJXfVEd�VYX �UI¥TWtQP§TWIw_S[ � h���_5ouVEX¤TZHJVePSbLTZVYXf[QPqTWI¥ouVEKlkzHJIwMOHrXZV~ouV�Pqb�PqbwbªTZHJV�d�PSMETZKYhG�HJVexSVE�?ILKlTWHQP§T¤TZHJV�MY_u[pKZtJ^|VYXzVEoqPSbLtQPqTZVYKzP�KfTW_SXf� �QPqKZVY`]_u[ kzHJ_�TWVYbLbwK�I¥T�h���[]P|^|_a`JVYb

kzHJILMOH `J_aVYK|[J_ST|TOPSxqVrTZHJV?TWVYbLbwVEX|_qd©TWHpV]K�TW_uX��nIw[\TW_�PSMYME_utJ[\T�y�I¥T�IwK|Iw^|Rª_SKZKZIL�JbwVFTWHQPqT|TWHpV_utpTZMY_u^|V©IL[ �UI¥TWtQPqTZIw_u[ � h � IwKm[J_STlVE�vtQPSb«TZ_�TWHJV©_utpTWME_u^|V©Iw[ �UILTZtQPqTWIL_u[ � h � yaKZIL[JMYVcTWHJV{KZPS^|VTWHpXZVYV�K�TW_uXfIwVEK=PSXZVlTZ_ubw`�IL[��ª_STZH�M�PSKfVYKEhD�Õd«��_STWH�KfILTZtQPqTWIL_u[JK�XfVYKftJbLT=IL[�P{RJXZ_u�JPS�JIwbLILT��e_Sd��Jtp�aIL[JsPS[ �©RpRJbwVz_Sd�h � PS[p`FP�RJXf_u�QPS�JILbwI¥T���_qd«�JtU�UIL[JseP �{VEbwbU_Sd!h��pyuTZHJVY[ �{VYbLbpkzIwbLbUTWVEbwb � ��� �v°aI¥d��ª_STZH_utpTZMY_u^|VYK�sSILouV��c� ��� ��h �PS[J`��¤� ��� ��h �uyaTWHJVE[ �cRJRJbwVckzIwbwb�TWVEbwb%� ��� �v°pd�tJbwbªIw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[|kzILbwbPSb¥klP��aKz�ªV�XZV~ouVYPSbwVE`�hG�HJV}d�_ubLbw_5kzIw[Js|KZVEMETZIw_u[JK©`JVYKfMYXZIL�ªV�TWHJV}sSVY[JVEXWPSb�MY_u[J`pILTWIL_u[JK¤tJ[J`JVEX©kzHJILMOHARQPSXfTZIgPSb¨Iw[Ud�_uX�¦

^FPqTWIL_u[ XZV~ouVYbwPqTWIL_u[:kzIwbLb�_aMYMYtpXYh

Page 79: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

& �2�3�� �'< � � +}7�� �¨9�<|;=C 8�%9�< �A;� 8�D {7 9

G�HJV IL[vTZVY[\T�_SdzTZHJIwK�KZVYM~TWIL_u[�IwK�TZ_�V~�URJbwPSIw[�kzHv��bgP�k��uVEXZK�RJXfVYKZVE[\T�_u[JbL��_u[JVNKfTW_SXf�uy�PSK�RªVEX0�PStpVET� ÒKcPS[J` 0]tJXfRJH\�ª ÒK©ME_u^|^FVE[vTZK¤PS�ª_5oSVSh±!IwXfKfTYy¬[J_STWV}TZHQPqT�I¥d�TZHJV �ftJ`JsSVS ÒKe_SRJIw[JIL_u[�ILK�PSRJRJXf_uRJXZIwPqTWVEbL�]XZVEKfTWXfIwM~TWVY`«y�TWHJVE[�I¥T{kzIwbLb!��V

IwXfXZVEbwVEoqPS[\T¤TW_NTZHJV}Pq`pou_aM�PqTZVS ÒK{Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[?XZV~ouVYbwPqTWIL_u[�`pVYMYILKZIL_u[�²zPSbLb�P�oqPSILbgPS�JbLV�KfTZ_uXZILVYKckzILbwb��V�TZ_ubw` IL[rPSbwb�KfILTZtQPqTWIL_u[JKEh

� ��232 � U�U S � #}#'&(�89K� #|!%2�9 #%!$E HP��94CD&-HP.�&u#+&(�63�O7y7!K.x37#%��98/m37Ju.�&(!K!K9K�[#Y![Z\EF��9K� �(#*.�!$�Q9 HI9 #!%2m3�� �T�xOB9K� #[!%2 _ 9 #Y!$E HP��9 � � � � � h � � k ������� � � b��TR 4 26#'&(� ,QOK5-� � 90!�Z\H+�(HP!$� C�H+#'&�E���9YZ(��. ##Y!B#+&(�[9 , ` 9K� #+9�!%2 � HI9�� �T�xOu` �'2 !$EF��#+&(�1#rE HU37V AG#'&(� � #+&(�����\37V y7� ENO7HP. #LC�H+V+V ` �1#'&(�m!$�"�1#'&Q37#CG!$,-V]OB` � 57H+y7� �H 2[#+&(��3�O7y7!K.x37#%��9[3�O7/lH+#r#Y�xOv37V+V !%2 ��R

+ #�� ����6 G�HJV�^|_U`JVEb��JTZK=PSbwba_Sd�TWHJV�XfVY�vtJIwXfVY^|VY[\TWKDd�_uX�TWHJVld�tJbLbpIL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[eRQP��u_ �?sSILouVE[PS��_5ouV©IL[ �UVEMETZIw_u[ � h��UhU²!XZVEoSV�PSbLIw[Js�PSbLb�_qd � ILK�PetJ[JILbgPqTZVYXWPqbQKfTWXZPqTWVEsS�uyUPSKmRªVEX��{V �J[JILTZIw_u[ � �pyPS[J`�TZHJV}s\Pq^FV�PS^F_S[JsNTWHpV}bgP�k��uVEXZK�ILK©KfTZXZILMETWb¥�rMY_u^|RªV~TWI¥TWILoSVSy«PSK{R�VYX �{V �Q[JILTZIw_u[ ph��©RpRJbL��¬VY^|^NP �uh �

��tpT=I¥dQTWHJV �ftJ`psuVzPSXZXfILoSVYK=PqTDHpVYXD_uRJIL[JIw_S[�PqT�TZHJV�VY[J`�_Sd¢TZHJVlTWXfIgPSbiyqI¥TDIwK�R�_uKfKZIw�pbwV�TZHQPqTDKfHJVkzIwbLb¢MOHJ_U_SKZV{TW_��JPSKZV{HpVYXl_uRpIw[JIL_u[N_u[:kzHp_�RJXZVEKZVY[\TZKzTZHJV{K�TW_uX��ª°Ud�tJbwb�Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[FXfVEoSVYbgP§TWIw_S[TWHpVY[r�ªVEMY_u^|VYKzbwVEKZKzbwILxSVEbL�uh!�mkzIwbLb«XfVYKfTZXZILMETcPqTZTZVY[\TWIL_u[ TW_�TWHpVeMYPSKZVe_Sd¨TWHJXfVYV�KfTZ_uXZILVYKEh

� ������# � 2 U � ~ &(� EF� 37EF� #'&-EF��� 9 #%!$E HP��9 CD&-HP.�& #+&(�t3�O7y7!K.x37#%��9�.�!$,TV]O 9 ,Q`/lH+# � � �� � � � � � � < �TR�� H+#+&(!$,T#19 , s�� E H+�-5 37�(J VI!K9�9e!%205-� �"� Ex37VWH+#UJKA{VI� # �ª� � �~��� � A �ª� � ��� � A37�\O �ª� � < � = � � � �®�pR

4 2l#+&(�0O-�'2 � �\O�37�(#L&Q3$9�37VWEF�x3�O7J6Z\E���9K� �(#Y�xO � � 37�\O@#+&(��Z\V]37H+�(#UH s &Q3$9�37VWEF�x3�O7J{Z\EF��9K� �(#Y�xO� A�37�\OzH 2w#'&(� ,QOK5-�/m37Jz`�3$9K�u&(� Ee!�Z\H+�(HP!$� !$�aCD&(!uZ\EF��9K� �(#%�xO � <|Am#'&(� �a#+&(� EF� � � HI9 #.�!$�\O7H+#UHP!$�Q9{37�\OX3 ,QOK5-� � 90!�Z\H+�(HP!$��9 , .�&#'&Q37#*#+&(� Z\V]37H+�(#UH s CG!$,-V]Ow�"!$# Z\EF��9K� �(# � <� ;#'&(� EF�� � HI9 #G.�!$�\O7H+#UHP!$�Q9437�\O03 , OK5-� � 91!�Z\H+�(HP!$�u9 ,(.�&u#+&Q37#�#'&(�[O-�'2 � �\O�37�(#�CG!$,TV]O{�"!$#"Z\E���9K� �(# � <� 37�\OB37V+VD!%28#+&(��9K�l.�!$�\O7H+#UHP!$�Q9[/m37J69 H+/l,TVW#P37�"��!$,^9 VWJ0` �[#UE , � R

G�HJV�Iw^|R�_uXfTWPS[\T�R�_uIw[\T��ªVEHJIw[J`FTWHJILK�TWHJVE_uXZVE^�ILK�TWHJPqT�TZHJVYXfV�PSXZVcMY_u[J`pILTWIL_u[JK�kzHJVYXfV��ª_STZHKZIL`JVYK�ME_utJbL`�XZVYsSXZVET}RJXZVEKZVY[\TZIw[Js � < h��ÕdzTWHpV RJbgPSIL[\TWI��nRpXZVYKfVY[\TWK � < yDTWHJVE[nTZHJV �ftJ`JsSV:^NP��

Page 80: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

& &KZVEbwVEMET � � � � � � � � � < � � �q�¤TW_?��V|Kf^NPqbwb­yªbwVYP5oaIL[Js ^F_a`JVEXWPqTZV�k�VEIwsuH\Te_u[ � �5°8kzHJIwbLV}Iw[ATWHpVM�PqKZV�kzHJVEXZV�TZHJV�`pVEd�VY[p`QPS[\T=RJXZVEKZVE[vTZK � < yuKZHJV�^NP��eKZVEbwVYM~T�� � � � � � � � � � < � � �q�¬TZ_{��V�KZ^FPSbLb­ybwVYP�oUIL[Jsn^F_a`JVEXWPqTZV"kmVYILsuH\T�_S[ � h�G�HJVYXfVEd�_uXfVSy�kmV�^FP�� V�PSKfIwb¥� MY_u[pKfTWXftJMET]M�PqKZVYKrkzHJVYXfV[JVEILTWHpVYX=RQPSX�T���klPS[\TZK�TZ_�XfVEouVYPSb � < yaPS[p`:PSK�P�XZVYKftJbLT=TZHJV �ftJ`JsuVzkzIwbLbJHJV�PqX�_S[JbL�}TZHJVzV~�aTWXfVY^|VPSXfsutJ^|VY[\TWKEh

� ���� � ����# � ���� �DHQP�oSV�[J_ST�`JV �Q[JVE`?TZHJV{bLIwxSVEbwILHJ_U_a`�TWHQP§T�TWHpV �ftJ`JsuVckzIwbwb¢KfVYbwVEMETzPq[?PS`pou_§¦M�P§TWVS ÒK�km_uXZK�Tz_utpTZMY_u^|VSya[J_uXmHQP�ouV��=`JV �J[JVY`:TZHJV�PS`poS_UMYPqTWVEKY JbLVEoSVYbwKm_Sd8XZILKZx|P�ouVEXZKZIL_u[�h=��[:TWHpVM�PqKZVFkzHpVYXZVFTWHJVFMY_u[J`pILTWIL_u[JKePSbLbwtJ`JVE`0TZ_�IL[�G�HJVE_uXZVE^ ��PS[J`�V~�URJbwILMYI¥TWbL��KfTWPqTWVE`�Iw[ �=�vtQP®¦TWIL_u[JK � h � � PS[p` � h � ��PSXfV©[J_qTlKWP§TWIwK �QVY`«yaTZHJVY[ �vtJVEKfTWIL_u[JKl_qd¬XZILKZx|P�ouVYXfKZIL_u[ PSXfV©_u�\oaIgPqTZVY`�²�d�tJbwbIw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[FkzILbwb«PSbLk�P��UKz��V�XZVEoSV�PSbLVY`�h=��[?TWHJV�MYPSKZV�kzHJVEXZV�TWHJVEKZVeMY_u[J`pILTWIL_u[JK�PqXZV�KWP§TWIwK �QVY`«yTWHpVY[nILT�ILK�Rª_SKZKZIL�JbwVFTWHQPqT�k�V kzIwbLb�[J_qT�HQP�ouV d�tJbLb�Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�XfVEoSVYbgP§TWIw_S[�h �cK}TWHJV:km_uXZK�TM�PqKZV�XZVEMYVYI¥ouVEKe^|_uXfV�k�VEIwsuH\TYy¨_SX�PSK{TWHpVFPq`pou_aM�PqTZVYK���VYMY_S^FV}^|_uXfV�XZIwKfx�P�oSVYXZKfVSy8TWHJV�RJXf_u�QP§¦�JILbwILT��}_Sd¬RQPSX�TWIwPSb¢Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[�XZVEoSVYbwPqTWIL_u[NXfIwKZVEKYhD��[NTZHJV©MYPSKZV©_Sd8PS�JKf_ubwtUTWV©XfIwKfx�P5oSVYXfKZIw_S[�ypTWHpVPS`poS_UMYPqTWVEK¤kzILbwbªXZVEoSV�PSb¬d�tJbLb«IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[:I¥d�PS[J`r_u[JbL�NILd8TWHpVeME_u[J`JI¥TWIL_u[JKzPSXfVe[p_STzKWPqTZIwK �QVY`�h

021�� 176 � D ��2H�0 N� �� P�/ HJN� �H�PM<E9!R ��I � �

�¬VET�TZHJVYXfVr��V:TWHpXZVYV?K�TW_uXfIwVYKE² � h��|bwV�Pq`JK�TW_0P�TWVE[U¦Õ�SV�PSX�KfVY[\TWVE[JMYVrd�_uX�TZHJV?`JVEd�VE[J`QPS[\T�y � k �bwVYPS`JKlTZ_NP}T�kmVY[\T��\¦Õ�uVYPSX©KfVY[\TWVE[JMYVqy«Pq[J` ��� �cP�TWHJILXfT��\¦Õ�SV�PSX�KfVY[\TWVE[JMYVqhG�HJV �ftJ`JsuV�HJPSKlTWHJV{d�_Sbwbw_5kzIL[Js�PqbwV�P§TW_uX�� � `pVYMYILKZIL_u[ RJXZ_aMYVE`JtJXfVS²=KZHJV��QXfKfTzHJVYPSXZKzPqbwb«MYPSKZVEK

�\��Pqbwb¨KZIw`pVYKYyªTWHJVE[A`JVYMEIw`JVEK©kzHJIwMOHA_qdDTWHJV}K�TW_uXfIwVEK{RJXZVEKZVE[vTZVY`0PSXfV�PSMYMEVYRpTWPS�JbLV}V~�URJbwPS[QPqTZIw_u[JK_Sd�TWHJVeM�PSKfVShl�Õd!_u[Jb¥� _u[JVeIwK¤PSMEMYVYRUTWVY`«y�TZHJVY[rTWHQPqT¤K�TW_uX��ª ÒKcoSVYXf`JIwM~T©ILKzTZHJV�TWXZIwPSb­ ÒK�oSVYXZ`pIwMETYhl�Õd_u[Jb¥��_u[JVcPS`poS_UMYPqTWVq ÍK�KfTZ_uXZILVYKmPSXZV¤PSMEMYVERpTWVE`�yUTZHJVY[FKZHJV¤XWPS[p`J_u^|bL�}KfVYbLVYMETZKlPS^|_u[Js�TZHJVcK�TW_uXfIwVEKRJXfVYKZVE[\TWVY` �v��TWHQPqT|Pq`pou_aM�PqTZV kzILTWHnVE�atJPSb�RJXZ_S�QPS�JILbwILT��Sh��Õdc�ª_qTWH�PS`poS_UMYPqTWVEK|HJP5oSV]K�TW_uXfIwVEKkzHJILMOH�PSXfV�PSMYMEVYRpTZVY`�yJTZHJVY[rKZHpV �JXZKfT¤XZPS[J`J_u^|bL�|KfVYbwVEMETZKzkzHpIwMOH]PS`pou_aM�P§TWV�TW_�bLIwKfTZVY[:TZ_JypTWHpVY[XWPq[J`J_u^|bL�FKZVEbwVYM~TWKcP�KfTW_SXf�?PS^|_u[Js�TZHJ_uKZV�HJV�RJXfVYKfVY[\TWVE`�h�)H\��ILKzTZHJIwK¤RJbwPStJKZIL�JbwV��0�ÕT¤TOPSxqVYKcIw[\TW_NPSMYME_utJ[\T©TZHQPqT¤TWHJV �ftJ`JsuV�HQPSKcPFXZPqTWIL_u[QPSb¬^|V�PS[pK

_Sdm`JVETZVYXf^FIL[JIw[JsFTWHJV�KfTWPqTWV�_qdmTZHJV�k�_uXfbw`��¶TWHQPqT�ILKYy�kzHJILMOH�K�TW_uXfIwVEK�PS^F_S[Js:TWHJ_SKZV�RJXZVEKZVE[vTZVY`��¸®¹��� �� Ë5¹�Ù§µ®¹fÃ�ÇÏÚ¡¹fÇÏ·i¿~­Ä]ÇEÃ��iË®¹�ÉS¹�µ§Ë5¹fµY·�¿~µ�·­¸®¹�·­¸®Âi¿OÈ ¿ÏÊzÇ?Ë®Ì͹��®Æ�¾�ÌÒ·­Ì͵®Ö]Ç:Ê Â­Ç~Ö~Ål¹�µY·�Ê Â­¿~ź8 �YÁ®¸§Ç~Â�·ZÜ Ã«·­Â­Ç~µ§Ã�Ú�ÇO·­ÌÍ¿Eµ{¿ÏÊ��8ÇÏØS¹�Ú�ÇÏÌ�Ã�Ó��­¼�¿z¾�¿~µY·iÌ¡µ�Á§ÇÏÚ¡ÚÍÄzÊ ¿~Âi·iÁ®µ§ÇÏ·i¹DÌ¡µ{·i¸§ÇÏ·�ÇÏÚ¡¹fÇÏ·i¿EÂiÄ�È�ÇWÄz¿ÏÊ¢Ë5¹Z¾ÀÌ�Ë5Ì¡µ®Ö��aÇWÈ

��¹�اÇÏ·i¹fÃ��®»

Page 81: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

& �PSXfV©TWXftJV5�Ïh �mtpT�_u[JMEV�KZHJV�HJPSK�`JVETZVYXf^FIL[JVY`:TZHJV{KfTWPqTWV�_qd¨TZHJV{km_uXZbL`�yJPS[p` HQPSK�V~�UHQPqtJKfTZVY`]PSbwbIw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[ePS��_utpT!kzHJPqTDHQPSRpRªVE[JVY`|PS[J`}kzHpIwMOH�bwVEs\PSbvXZtpbwVYK�PSXZV�PSRJXZ_SRª_uKEyuKZHpV�^NP��eKfTZIwbwbv[J_qTHQP�ouVcP�ouVYXf`JIwM~TmkzI¥TWH|MYVEXfTOPqIw[\T��uhD±QXf_u^�TWHpVYXZVqyUKfHJV¤^NP��}TZHJVY[|�QPSKfVcHJVEXm`pVYMYILKZIL_u[F_S[|kzHJV~TWHJVEXKZHpV �Q[J`JK:TZHJVARJbgPqIw[\TWI��)_uX:`JV~d�VY[J`QPq[vT TZ_��ªV�^F_uXfV�km_uXfTZHv� _Sd�PSsuXfVYVY^|VY[\TYycXZPqTWHJVEXNTWHJPS[`JVEMYIw`pIw[Js Kf_ubwVEbL�]�QPSKZVE`�_S["TZHJV�PSXfsutJ^|VY[\TWK{TZHJVY^|KZVEbLouVEKYy¨PSbLb!_Sd=kzHJILMOH�KfHJV�^NP��]`JVETZVYXZ^|Iw[pVTW_�HQP�oSV�VE�atJPSb8^FVEXZILTYh

�©KfKZtJ^|VmTZHQPqT!PSbwbuTZHJXZVEV�KfTZ_uXZILVYKEySILdURJXfVYKZVE[\TWVY`«yvkzILbwbu��VlPqMYMYVERpTWVE`�kzILTZH�MEVYXfTWPSIw[\T��Sh"$�bwVYPSXZb¥�uyTWHpV�`JV~d�VY[JKfV�k�_StJbw`�RJXZV~d�VYX�TZ_©RJXfVYKfVY[\T � h��D_5ouVEX�TWHpV�_STZHJVYX8T�k�_�K�TW_uXfIwVEK�_uX¨[J_cKfTW_SXf��PqT!PSbwbi°qTWHpVRJXf_uKZVEMYtpTZIw_u[eRJXZV~d�VYXfK ��� ��_®oSVYX8TWHJV=_STZHJVYX8_uRUTWIw_S[JKYh¨G�HJVY[eTWHJV �ftJ`psuV�kzILbwb$oQIwR�P�MY_uIL[�TZ_cMOHp_U_uKfVkzHJ_u^/TZ_NbwILKfTZVY[?TW_Jy�PS[J`rTWHJV�V~�UR�VYMETZVY`A_utUTWMY_S^FV�TW_|TWHJILKcKfILTZtQPqTWIL_u[?IwKcP ������� � ���� � ��uVYPSXzKZVE[vTZVY[JMEVSh��_StJbw` TZHJV�`JV~d�VY[JKfV"RJXZVEKZVY[\T � k �Ï� �Õd�HJVA`J_aVYK:Kf_Jy�TWHJVE[ TWHJV��ftp`JsuV�kzILbwb �QXZK�TBoQILR P

MY_SIw[]TZ_:MOHJ_a_uKZVekzHJVETZHJVYXcTW_:bLIwKfTZVY[rTW_FTZHJV}RJbwPSIw[\TZI��A_uX¤`JV~d�VY[J`QPq[vTYy¬PS[J`�ILdDKfHJV�MOHJ_a_uKfVYK{TWHpV`JV~d�VY[J`QPq[vTYyDkzIwbwb=TWHpVY[zoQILRnP�MY_uIL[�TW_�`pVYMYIL`JV:kzHJILMOH�_Sd�TWHJV `pVEd�VY[p`QPS[\T� ÒK�KfTZ_uXZILVYK�TZ_AbwIwK�TWVE[TW_ph{G�HJV�V~�UR�VYM~TWVY`AoSVYXZ`pIwMET�ILK�������� � h��k � k �k ���� � �Uh � �uVYPSXZKEy�KZ_:TZHJV}`JV~d�VY[JKfV�IwK{��VETfTWVEX_ ��[J_ST�RpXZVYKfVY[\TWIL[Js � k ��h �UIw^|IwbwPSXZb¥�uypTZHJV�V~�UR�VYM~TWVY`AoSVYXZ`pIwMET�I¥d�TWHpV�RJbgPSIL[\TWI��"RpXZVYKfVY[\TWK � k ��ILK� � �k � k �k ���� � � ���� ��� � h � �uVYPSXZKEy¬KZ_:TZHJV}RJbwPSIw[\TWI��"IwK©PSbwKf_N��VETZTZVYX{_ ��[J_ST©RJXZVEKZVE[vTZIw[Js � k �5hG�HJVe^F_SXZV{^|_U`pVYXWP§TWV�KfTZ_uXf�NkzIwbwb«[J_STz��V�TZ_ubw`«h

� � � � �M�Y� � � ����� ����� � �Y��# � ��[NKf_u^|V¤k�P��UKEypTWHpV©MYbwPSIw^�PS`poS_UMYPqTWVEK�PSs\PSIL[JKfT=TZHJV©Pq`pou_aM�PqTZV^|_U`JVEb­heG�HJV�d�PSMET{TZHQPqT�TZHJV �ftJ`JsuV�_uX �ftpXf�A^FP�����V�Iw[JMEbwIw[pVY`�TZ_rtpKZV�TWHJV�RJXfVYKfVY[\TWVEX�_Sd�TWHpVIw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[eIw[}XfV�PSMOHJIL[Js�PcoSVYXZ`pIwMET=^|V�Pq[JK!TWHJPqT!TZHJVzPS`poS_UMYPqTWVEKD^NP��e�ªV�XZVETZIwMEVY[\TDTW_{RpXZVYKfVY[\TPSbLb¨_qd�TWHJV�Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[ TWHJV~��ME_utJbw`]RJXZVEKZVE[vTYh��c_qTOPS�Jb¥�uy¢TWHJV�^F_SXZV�^|_a`JVYXZPqTWVeV~�URJbwPS[QPqTZIw_u[JKsuV~T{bw_SKfT�h��ÕdDTZHJV�TZXZIwPSb�k�VEXZV}IL[JKfTZV�PS`�MY_u[J`ptJMETZVY`A�\�r_u[JV�IL[J�vtJIwKfILTZ_uX�kzHJ_:IwKcPS`poaILKZVY`��v�rTWHpVRJXf_uKZVEMYtpTZIw_u[�PS[J`�`JV~d�VY[JKfVSyS�ptpT8kzHJ_¤kzILbwbq[J_ST8XZV~ouVYPSbuTWHJV=Kf_utJXZMEVm_qdpPq[v�{RJIwVEMYV=_SdUIw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[�yTWHpVY[�TWHJV�_S[JbL��VY�vtJILbwIw�pXZIgPcPSXZVmTWHJ_uKfVz_utpTWME_u^|VYK!kzI¥TWH}ouVEXZ`JILMETZK�VE�vtQPSbpTZ_�TZHJV�d�tJbLbpIL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[ouVEXZ`JILMETYh

021�� 143 �@<�0 LH"9BH�PB; � K PMH�PB;=F�KG�HJVebwIL^FI¥TWK�suILoSVY[rIw[?G�HJVY_SXZVY^ ��^F_5ouV�PSKlkmVekm_utJbL`?V~�URªVEMET¤TWHJVE^%TW_Jh

Page 82: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

& �� ��# �����M#), U!S ~ &(� EN37�-5-��!%2�y$37VW,(��9�!%2 �ª� � < � CD&-HP.�&0C�H+V+V"H+�\O7,(.��8#+&(�GZ\V]37H+�(#UH s #Y!�37VWCi37JK9EF� y7�x37V � < H+�". E��x3$9K��9[3$9 �ª� � � O-��. E��x3$9K��9�Ai37�\OB3$9 �ª� � �E� 57E�!$CD9 R

4 2XCG� 3$9�9 ,-/0�#+&Q37#m3-.�.��YZ\#P37�".�� !%2 � <|A � AB37�\O � � 37EF��H+�\O-�YZ(� �\O-� �(#{� y7� �(#'9�Am#+&(� �3$9 "!�� � � H+�". EF�x3$9K��9�A*#+&(�{EN37�-5-�0!%26y$37VW, ��9B!%2 �«� � < � CD&-HP.�&C�H+V+V H+�\O7, .��6#'&(� Z\V]37H+�(#rH s #Y!37VWCi37JK9[EF� y7�x37V � < 9�&-E H+���K9 R

� H+/lH+V]37E VWJ;2 !$E8#+&(��O-�'2 � �Q9K� Rf 9�9 ,-/lH+�-5XH+�\O-�YZ(� �\O-� �".���A*#+&(� EF�mHI9{�"!.�&Q37�-5-�6H+� #'&(��Z\V]37H+�(#UH s !$EmO-�'2 � �\O�37�(# � 9{EN37�-5-�

2 !$E[EF� y7� V]37#rHP!$�u57H+y7� ��3u.�&Q37�-5-�[H+� "!�� � < �pR�U_NI¥d�TZHJV�RpbgPSIL[vTZI���HQPSKcP|K�TWXZ_S[JsuVYX¤Iw[pILTWIwPSb�PqXZsutJ^|VY[\TYy�VEILTZHJVYXz��VYM�PqtJKZV�ILT¤IwKz^|_uXZV�bwILxSVEbL�

TW_��ªV|TWXZtpVN_uXe�ªVEM�PStpKZV ILT�Iw[p`JtJMYVEK}P�^|_uXfV|d�P�ou_SXWPS�JbLVFoSVYXZ`pIwMETYy!TWHpVY[�TWHpVYXZV|kzIwbLb���VFd�V~k�VEXMY_S[J`JILTZIw_u[pK�tJ[J`JVEX�kzHJIwMOH�TZHJV�RJbgPqIw[\TWI��FkzILbwbaMYVYX�TOPSIL[JbL�ek�PS[\TDTW_�MY_S[vTZXZIL�JtpTWVzPq[J_STWHpVYXDKfTZ_uXf�Sh��ÕdTWHpV�`JV~d�VY[J`QPq[vT{HQPSK{PFKfTWXf_u[JsuVEX{PSXfsutJ^|VY[\T}��^|V�PSKftJXZVE`��\�]oSVYXZ`pIwMETYy«[J_qT©RJXf_u�QPS�pIwbwI¥T��p�~yJTWHpVY[TWHpVYXZV¤PSXfV�^F_SXZV�MY_S[J`JILTZIw_u[pK�tJ[J`JVEXDkzHJIwMOH�TWHJV�RpbgPSIL[vTZI��|kzIwbLbpMYVEXfTWPSIw[Jb¥��k�PS[\T=TW_ePS`J`|PS[J_qTWHJVEXKfTZ_uXf�ShG�HJV|MY_u^|RQPSXZPqTWI¥ouV�KfTWPqTWILMYK��)VYKfRªVEMYIwPSbwb¥�]TZHJV�MYbgPqIw^ TZHQPqT "!�� � < �©kzILbwb![p_STeMOHQPS[JsuV�TWHpV

XWPq[JsuV�_Sd�XZVEoSVYbwPqTWIL_u[��)^FP��NVYPSKZILbL�N�ªV{TZVYKfTZVY`]Iw[ TWHJV�bwPS��h

021�� 1�� ��DCHJN4P �9�DLH�P K �F�;Y� F�H�PB;=<.D

,{[JV©XfV�PS`pVYX�ME_u^|^FVE[vTZVY`|TWHQPqTlPSKZKftJ^|Iw[Js�P�^|IwKfTZXZIwPSbJIw[|TWHJVcM�PSKfVckzHJVEXZV{[p_�KfTZ_uXZILVYK�PSXZV¤TWXZtpV^FP5��[J_ST��ªVFPSRJRJXf_uRJXfIgPqTZVS°�d�_SXeVÏ�pPS^FRpbwVSy¬TZHJV��ftp`JsuV|^NP��"XZtpbwV�d�_uX�TWHJV|`JV~d�VY[JKfVNIw[0KZtpMOH�PM�PqKZVSh=��[?TWHJILKzM�PSKfVSyQG�HJVE_uXZVE^ ��XZVY`ptJMYVEK¤TZ_|TZHJV�d�_ubwbL_®kzIL[JsJ²

� ��# �����M#), U � f 9�9 ,T/0��#+&(��937/0�*9 H+#U, 37#UHP!$�@3$9 ~ &(��!$EF� /�� A�`,T# #+&(� , OK5-� E ,TVI��9c2 !$E #+&(�O-�'2 � �Q9K�mH+� #'&(�w.x3$9K�mCD&(� � �"!u9 #%!$E JHI9B3-.�.��YZ\#Y�xO�3$90#UE , � R ~ &(� � #+&(� EF�vO-!K��9��"!$#[� � HI9 #839 H+#U, 37#UHP!$��CD&(� EF�137�(JBO-�'2 � �\O�37�(#�C�H+V+V EF� y7�x37V � < R f �(J8Z\E�!K9K��. ,-#Y!$E8C�H+V+V�E�� y7�x37V � < H s

�ª� � < �Gj � � � � � � < �q�� � � � � � � ��� � < �q�Z� �

Page 83: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

&2�3�� � <|7AB��Y@���CY<|7

G�HJV{IL`JV�PeTWHQPqT�_u[JV¤TWHJIL[Js�MYPStJKZVEKzPS[J_STZHJVYXmM�PS[ [p_STl��V{PSMEMYtJXZPqTWVEbL�|`JVEKZMYXfIw��VY` �\�FKfTOP§TWIwK�TWILMYKYh��V�PSXZV�Pqbwb¢d�PS^FILbwIwPSX�kzILTZH:TWHJV�RJXf_u�JbLVY^|KY²J$�HJXfIwK�TW^FPSKlM�PqXZ` KWPqbwVYK�`p_�[J_ST�MYPStJKZV $�HpXZIwK�TW^FPSKY°^��}k�PqTZMOHNXZVYPS`JIL[Js � U² � �¤`p_UVEK�[p_ST�M�PStJKfV¤�S_utJX=klP§TWMOHFTZ_�XfV�PS` � U² � �uh �©b¥TWHJ_utpsuH|kmVcPSK=Hata¦^FPS[N��VYIL[JsuK�tp[J`JVYXfKfTWPS[J`:TWHpVcTWXftJV©MYPStJKZPSb«XfVYbgP§TWIw_S[JKZHJILRJK�PS^|_u[Js�TZHJV©V~ouVE[vTZKYyQI¥TmILK��QPqKZIwMYPSbwb¥�Iw^|R�_uKZKfIw�JbLVcTW_|XZ_S�JtJKfTZbL�FkzXZILTZV�`J_5kz[]TZHJV�XZVYbwPqTWIL_u[JKfHJIwRJK�tJKZIL[Js�_u[JbL� �f_uIw[\TzRJXf_u�QPS�pIwbwI¥TWILVYKYh

� `JVYMEIwKZIL_u[�^NPSxqVYX�^FP5���ªVrP"RªVEXfd�VYM~T ��P5�SVYKfIgPS[�kzILTWHnXfVYKZR�VYM~TNTZ_�HJVEX�VEoqPSbwtJPqTWIL_u[�_Sd�vtJVYK�TWIL_u[JKr_Sd�RpXZ_u�QPq�JIwbLILTWILVYKEy��JtpT?TWHJILK k�_utpbw`)KWP��)[J_STZHJIw[ps Pq�ª_utUT?HJ_5k1KZHpV�su_aVYK?Pq�ª_utUTRJbwPSMYIL[Js�kmVYIwsSHvTZK _u[ `JI��«VEXZVY[\T?MYPStJKZVEKYh �©K KZtpMOH�ycT�km_ �¡R�VYX�d�VYMETZbL� XWPqTZIw_u[QPqb­  �ftJ`JsuVEK ^NP��PSXfXZILoSV©P§Tm`pI��ªVYXZVE[\Tl`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[pKmsuI¥ouVE[FTWHpVcKZPS^FV¤M�PqKZV � _uX�_u[JV �ftJ`JsuVc^NP���PSXfXZI¥ouVcPqT�`pI��ªVYXZVE[\T`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[pK¤sSILouVE[ T�k�_FM�PSKfVYK�kzHJIwMOHrTWHJV�K�TOPqTZIwKfTZIwMEIgPS[Nkm_utJbL`]`pVYKZMEXZIL�ªVePSKzVY�vtJI¥oqPSbwVE[vTYh±Q_uX�TZHJVl�vtJVYK�TWIL_u[�_Sd¢Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�XZVEoSVYbwPqTWIL_u[�ySTZHJIwK�^NP���MYXZVYPqTWV�RJXZ_u�pbwVY^|KYh��ÕT�ILK�Rª_SKZKZIL�JbwV

TWHJPqTcP��ftJ`JsSV�km_utJbL`�RJbwPSMYV�`JI��«VEXZVE[vT¤kmVYIwsSHvTc_u[]PFK�TW_uX��?`JVYR�VY[J`pIw[JsF_u[rkzHp_NRJXfVYKZVE[\TWVY`AI¥T�yPS[J`�TWHJILK�^NPSxqVYKFILT|Rª_SKZKZIL�JbwV TZHQPqT|[JVYI¥TWHJVEXFKfIw`JV?kzIwbLblklPq[vT|TW_�RJXZVEKZVE[vTNMYVEXfTOPqIw[ RpIwVYMEVYK|_SdIw^|R�_uXfTWPS[\T�Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�h

Page 84: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �

� � ��� ��� �

� �� �� � � �!�%+D�¬� �

� 354 687:9�;=<?>A@AB�9DCE<F7

��VE_uRJbLV��Q[p`���VY[JV �JT�IL[���VYHJP5oaIL[Js]bLIwxqV|_qTWHJVEXZKYhNG�HJVYXfV:PSXfVFP oqPSXZILVET��"_Sd�V~�URJbwPS[QPqTZIw_u[JK{d�_SXTWHpIwK�d�PqMET�yS`JVYR�VY[J`pIw[Js�_u[�TWHJV�KfILTWtJPqTWIL_u[�²¬_STZHJVYXfKY uPqMETWIL_u[JK�M�PS[�KfIwsu[QPqbakzHJILMOH�MOHJ_uILMYVlILK!��VETZTZVYXE°TWHpVeoqPSbLtJV�_Sd �f_uIL[JIw[ps�P|[JV~T�k�_SXZx?IwKzsuXfV�PqTZVYXzkzHJVY[]ILT¤HQPSK¤^F_SXZV�^|VY^}��VYXfKY°¢RªVE_uRJbLV�kzILbwb�RJP5�^|_uXZV|d�_uX}P�su_a_a`�ILdlTZHJVE��xv[J_5k�TZHJVE��M�PS[�XfVYKZVEbwbmILT�TZ_A_STWHpVYXZK�kzHJ_"PSbwKf_�k�PS[\T�TWHJV:I¥TWVE^]°_uX¤RªVE_uRJbLV�^FP��?KZIw^|RJb¥� VY[ �f_5�rTWHJVed�VYVEbwIw[psF_Sd�MY_u^|^F_S[QPSbwI¥T��:RJXf_U`ptJMYVE`��\�]IL^FI¥TOPqTZIw[Js�_qTWHJVEX^|VY^}��VYXfK}_SdcPAsuXZ_utpR�h���[�TZHJIwK}MOHJPSRpTWVEXYy���`pVEouVEbw_uR�P�^|_U`pVYbmTZ_A`JVYKfMYXfIw��V?PS[\��KZI¥TWtQPqTZIw_u[kzHJVEXZV{TWHpVcoqPSbwtpVcd�XZ_S^�PqMETWIL[Js�_SX�MY_S[JKZtJ^|Iw[ps}IwK�PS[:Iw[pMYXZVYPSKZIL[Js�d�tp[JMETZIw_u[:_qd¬TWHJVcRJXZ_uR�_uX�TWIw_S[_Sd8_STZHJVYX�RªVE_uRJbwV¤kzHJ_�PSXfV{PSbLKZ_�PSM~TWIL[Js}_uXmMY_u[JKftJ^|Iw[JsJh ��VY_SRJbwV{IL[NTWHpIwK�^|_a`JVYb¢kzIwbLb�tpKZV©TZHJVYILXRJXfIw_uXDIL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[�Pq[J`NPq[v�|P�oqPSILbgPS�JbLV�RJtp�JbwILM�Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[�TW_e`JVEoSVYbL_uRNVÏ�pR�VYM~TOPqTZIw_u[pKmPq�ª_utUTTWHpV �J[QPSb¬[vtJ^}��VYXz_Sd�MY_u[pKZtJ^|VYXfKYy�PS[J`?��VYHQP�ouV�PSMEMY_uXf`JIw[JsSbL�uh

0]_a`JVYbLKl_SdD�ÍHJVYXf`JIw[Jsp p��VYHQP�oaIw_uXmV~�UIwK�T�Iw[FTWHJV{bLILTZVYXWP§TWtJXfVSya�JtpTzPSbLb�PSXZV{KfVY�vtJVE[vTZIgPSb«^F_a`JVYbLKYhG�HJILK�IwK�TWHpV �QXfKfT}^|_a`JVYb=`JVEKZMYXfIw�JIL[Js�R�VY_SRJbwV�kzHJ_�^FPSxSVNP]KfIw^}tJb¥TOPS[pVY_utJKe`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[«h �aIw[JMEVPSM~TW_uXfKF^|_5ouV�KfIw^}tpbLTOPq[JVY_utpKZbL�Sy�TZHJVE��MYPS[ [J_qTNKfIw^|RJbL��_S�JKZVEXfouV]_STWHpVYXZK|kzHJ_�PqMETWVE` ��VEd�_uXfVTWHpVY^ry�PSK©TZHJV}VÏ�UTWPS[\T�^|_U`JVEbwKc`JVYKfMYXZIL�ªV�RªVE_uRJbwV�PSK{`J_SIw[JsJhc��[JKfTZV�PS`«y�TWHJV~��^}tpKfT��QPqKZV�TZHJVYILXPSM~TWIw_S[JK�_u[?TWHJVEIwX�RJXfIw_uXl��VYbLIwV~d�KzPS�ª_StpT�kzHQPqT¤R�VY_uRJbLV{kzIwbLb«`J_JhG�HJIwK�MOHQPSRpTZVYXlTWHpVY[ d�_UMEtJKZVEKl_u[:TZHJV{�vtJVYK�TWIL_u[�²=HJ_5kj`J_ � �B37�(#Y� RJXZIL_uXZKm_u[:TWHpV{`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtU¦

TWIL_u[?_Sd¨TOPSK�TWVYKzRJXfVY`JILMETzkzHJ_�kzIwbLb�PSM~T � �1Z(!K9 # �

Page 85: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� ��5176%176 �@<�0 LH"9�;OK�<.D >?;QP / L9 ��2;O<EILK K�F /L<EN=H"9BK / ; �� > ;4P / � < F�ILK <ED

H N7;=F�H�P!;O<EDLK

G�HJV:��_a`p�0_Sd�TWHJILK�MOHQPqRpTWVEX�TOPSxqVYK�ME_u[pd�_uXf^FI¥T��"V �ªVYMETZK�PSK�sSILouVE[�yDPS[p`�d�XZ_u^�TWHJPqT}K�TOPSX�TWIw[psR�_uIw[\T�y¨`JVEXZILoSVYK}IL^FRpbwIwMYPqTWIL_u[JK�Pq�ª_utUT�R�_uKZKfIw�JbLVF_StpTWME_u^FVEKYh �©K�KZtJMOH«yD�{kzIwbwbD[p_ST�`pVYbLoSV:Iw[\TZ_TWHpVe�vtJVEKfTZIw_u[r_Sd������]I¥TzIwKlTZHQPqT�TWHpVYKZVeMY_S[pd�_uXZ^|ILT��FV �ªVYM~TWK¤V~�UIwK�T¤Iw[?MYVEXfTOPqIw[?KZI¥TWtQPqTZIw_u[pKYhG�HJV�RptJXZR�_uKZV]_Sd{TZHJIwK�Iw[\TZXZ_a`JtJMETZIw_u[�IwK�TWHpVYXZV~d�_uXZV?TW_�`JIwKfMYtJKfKNKf_u^FVr_Sd{TZHJVrKZILTZtQPqTZIw_u[JK

kzHJVEXZV�_u[JV{km_utJbL` V~�UR�VYMET¤ME_u[pd�_uXf^FI¥T��FV �«VEMETZKlTW_���V�Iw^|Rª_uX�TOPS[\TYh!�=`J_�[J_STlIw[\TWVE[J` TW_�RJXf_®oSVTWHJPqT�KftJMOHFV �«VEMETZKD^}tJKfT!V~�UIwK�TD�QPSKfVY`�_u[�_STZHJVYX�tJ[J`JVEXZb¥�UIL[Js{d�V�P§TWtJXfVYKYySKZIw[pMYVlTWHpVYKZV�tJ[J`JVEXZbL�aIL[Jsd�V�P§TWtJXfVYKckm_utJbL`]��VeIwXZXfVYbLVEoqPS[\TzTW_�TWHJV�XZVY`ptJMYVE`U¦Õd�_uXf^/^F_a`JVEb�kzHJIwMOH�d�_Sbwbw_5kzKEhm��kzILbwb¬VÏ�pRpbgPSIL[d�_uX�V�PqMOH _SdcTWHJVrKZI¥TWtQPqTZIw_u[pK|��VYbL_5k�kzH\��ILT|IwK�RJbwPStJKZIL�JbwV:TZHQPqTFPSM~TW_uXfK|km_utJbL` HQP�oSV�tpTZIwbwI¥T��kzHJILMOH|ILK�Iw[pMYXZVYPSKZIL[Js�Iw[}TZHJV�[vtJ^}��VYXD_Sd�_STZHJVYXDR�VY_SRJbwVlkzHJ_ePSM~TDbwILxSV�TZHJVY^ryvPS[J`�TZHJVY[�y\HJP5oaIL[Js`JILKZMYtpKZKZVE`�kzH\�"ILT�ILK�RJbgPqtJKZIL�JbwV�TZHQPqT�TWHpV|R�VYXfMYVE[vTWPSsuV|_Sd�PSMETZ_uXZK�IwK�IL[JMYbLtJ`JVE`0IL[ATWHJV�tpTZIwbwI¥T��d�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[�yJ��kzIwbwbªKZIL^FRJb¥�FTWPSxSV�TWHpIwKzPSKzsuI¥ouVY[ kzHJVE[]TZHJV�^F_a`JVYb«ILTWKfVYb¥d�ILK�`JVYKfMYXfIw��VY`�h

� TW�TWBTW � ��� #�� �Z�Y�!��#��B� � ��# ���\�� 2

G�HJVz^|_uKfTDME_u^|^F_u[�^|_a`JVYbLK�_Sd¢TWHJV�VE^}tJbwPqTWIL_u[}_Sdª_STWHpVYXZK=PqXZVlTWHpV��ÍHJVEXZ`JIL[JsJ S_SXl�¡IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[M�PqKZM�Pq`JVS ¢^|_U`JVEbwKEypVShÒsJh �lPS[pVYX �fVEV � � �8_SX ��IwxvHJMOHQPq[J`QPS[JIiy42cILXZKZHpbwVYI¥d�VYXEyJPS[J`?��VYbwMOH � � �ihG�HJV�^FPSIw[|d�V�PqTZtJXZV{_qd¬TWHJV{^|_a`JVYb�IwK�TWHQPqT�TWHJVEXZV{ILKlP}KZVE�vtJVY[JMEV�_Sd8^F_5oSVYKYyUkzHJIwMOH bLV�PS`NTZ_

P�RQPqTZHU¦�`JVERªVE[J`JVE[vTc_utpTZMY_u^|VSh hG�HJV�^|_U`JVEbªHpVYXZV�`p_UVEK�P�klP��NkzI¥TWH:TZHJV�PSKfKZtJ^|RpTWIL_u[:_Sd8KfVY�vtJVE[vTZIgPSb«Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[�h��ÕT�PSbwKf_

tJKfVYK�Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�PS��_utpT�TZHJV�`JILKfTWXfIw�JtUTWIw_S[�_Sd�TOPSK�TWVYK�kzI¥TWHJIL[AKZ_aMYIwV~T��uy8PSbLbw_5kzIw[ps:`JIwKfMYtJKfKZIL_u[_SdªHJ_5k RJXfIw_uX!Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[�RJXfVY`JILMETWKDkzHJ_�kzILbwbJPqMET�h!G�HJVYXfV¤ILKD[J_ePS[QPSbL_us{TW_�KftJMOHFRpXZVY`pIwMETZIw_u[pKIw[ TZHJV�HJVYXf`JIw[Js�^|_U`pVYb­hG�HJV©HpVYXZ`pIw[Jse^F_a`JVEbQXZVY^FPSIL[JKDtJ[\TWVEKfTWVE` Iw[�TWHJV¤bwI¥TWVEXWPqTZtJXZVqh�G¨VYK�TWK�KfV�PSXfMOHJIw[ps�d�_uX=HJVEXZ`JIL[Js

V �ªVYM~TWKcIw[ oqPSXZIL_utJKzKZI¥TWtQPqTZIw_u[pKcPq�ª_utp[J`���VShÒsJh¥y¢��VYIL[v�ªVEXZs|_u[�VE^FRJbL_5�U^|VY[\T � � &3�iy �DoqPS[pKcV~T{PSb_u[AXZPSMYIwPSb!P§TZTWI¥TWtJ`pVYK � ���iy�$lPS^|RJ��VYbLb�_u[AHpIwsuH�KfMOHJ_a_ub!`JXf_uR�_utpT�PS[p`ARJXZVEsu[QPS[JM~��XZPqTWVEK�� � ���­y��VY[J[pVY`p�]_u[�RJXfIw^|V~¦­TWIw^|V©TZVYbwV~oaIwKZIL_u[ � � �­y �©[J`JVEXZKf_u["PS[J`�2c_ub¥T©IL[]TWHpV�bgPq� � 3�iyªV~T{MYV~TWVEXWP\�Ïy³��ÂiÚ��¹ZÇϵ � ���pÇ~ÚÍÅl¿EÃ�·¨Ç~˧Ë5Âi¹ZÃiÃi¹fë·­¸®Ì�Ã�ÆqØYÄ©Ç~ÃiÎ�Ì͵®Ö�¸§¿OÈ]ÉS¹�¿EÉ®Ú͹DȬ̡ڡÚU¾Õ¸§Ç~µ®Ö~¹=ÇÏÊ ·i¹�¨¹�Ð~¹fÂiÄE¿~µ®¹!¸§ÇEèÇÏڡ­¹fÇ~Ë®ÄÇ~¾À·i¹ZË\ÆuÖ~Ì¡Ð~¹�µe¿~µ®Ú¡Ä{·i¸®¹lÇÏÖEÖ~­¹�ÖYÇO·i¹Dµ�Á®ÅmØq¹fÂ�¿~Ê�ÉS¹�¿~ɧÚ͹lÇ~¾À·iÌ¡µ®ÖcÇÏ·�·­¸®¹�·­ÌÍÅl¹E»D´¶µ�·i¸§Ì¡Ã!­¹fÃiÉq¹Z¾�·fÆu¸®Ì�Ã!Ål¿�Ë®¹�ÚJÌ¡ÃÅl¿~­¹DÇÏÎ�Ì͵c·i¿�·­¸§ÇO·8¿~Ê��«Â­¿�¾ÕÎzÇ~µ§Ë �¨Á§ÂiÚ�ÇÏÁ5Ê�Ʈˮ̡í¾ÀÁ§Ã­Ãi¹fË©Øq¹fÚÍ¿OÈD»

Page 86: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

�JtpTl[J_u[JV{_qd�TWHJVEKZV{TZVYKfTZKzPSXZVcIw[pd�_SXZ^|VY`N�\�|TWHJV©^F_a`JVYbLK�d�Xf_u^ TWHJVcHJVYXf`JIw[Js�bwILTZVYXZPqTWtJXfV¤kzHpIwMOHTWHpVE� MYILTZVSh G�HJV�RJXf_u�JbwVE^�IwKF[J_STNkzI¥TWH�TWHJV�VE^FRpIwXZILM�PSblTZVYK�TWKYyzI¥T:IwK�kzILTZH TWHpV]TWHpVY_uXfVETWILM�PSb^|_U`JVEb­yakzHJIwMOHr`J_aVYK�[J_STz^FPSxqV�TZVYK�TOPS�JbLV�RJXZVE`JIwM~TWIL_u[JK���VE�u_S[J`]TZHJV��QPSKfIwM�MYbwPSIw^ TWHJPqTzRªVE_uRJbLVHJVEXZ`�h�G�HJVe^F_a`JVYb¬_qd�TZHJIwKzMOHQPSRUTWVYX¤^FPSxSVEKcKfRªVEMYI��JMSyQTWVEKfTOPq�JbwV�MYbwPSIw^|K�PS��_utpTzHpVYXZ`pIw[Js|�QPSKfVY`_u[?RJtJ�pbwIwMEbL�:P5oqPSILbgPS�pbwV©IL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u[NPS[J`rRJXZIL_uXl��VYbLIwVEd�KEh

� TW�TWBTVU � �[� � ��# � ��� �Y��# ���!��� ��� ���

G�HJILKcILKzPFRJXf_uRªVEXfT��?_Sd!su_a_U`JKlkzHpVYXZV�MY_u[pKZtJ^|RpTWIL_u[r�v�?_qTWHJVEXZK¤Iw[JMEXZV�PqKZVYKzTWHpV�tpTZIwbLILT��:_qd!TWHpVsu_a_U`«y�KZtJMOH�PSK�MY_S^FRJtUTWVYX�VE�atpIwRJ^|VY[\T�h�G�HJV|T��aRJILM�PSb�PS[QPSb¥�UKfIwK���VShÒsJh¥y8TZHQPqT�_Sd5$�HJ_uI� � � �¶�©ILKKZIL^FILbgPSXzTW_ TZHQPqT�_Sd�TWHJV�XfVYKfTWPStJXZPS[\T�RpXZ_u�JbLVY^ry¬V~�UMYVERpT�V~�URªVEMETZVY`�tUTWIwbLILT��]IwK�s\PqIw[JVE`0`pIwXZVEMETZbL�Iw[pKfTWVYPS`r_Sd�TZHJXZ_StJsuH?Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�°vTWHJV�`JILKZMYtpKZKZIL_u[]PS�ª_5oSV�PqRJRJbwILVYKEh

� TW�TWBT�� � ����B�� �

0�PS[\� �Q[JPS[JMYIwPSb�IL[JKfTZXZtJ^|VY[\TWK �JT�TZHJIwKz^|_U`pVYb­yad�_uXzP�[vtJ^}��VYXz_Sd�XZV�PqKZ_u[JKE²

� �DXZILMYIL[Js�ILKlRQPSX�TWbL�|�QPqKZVY` _S[:TWHJV©oqPSbLtJV©_qd¬TWHJV{tp[J`JVYXfbL�aIw[ps�PSKZKfVETzPS[p` RQPSXfTZbL�|_u[:kzHQP§T_STZHJVYXfK¤PSXZV{kzILbwbwIL[Js�TZ_�RQP��:d�_uXlTWHpV�PqKZKZV~T�h �lTzTWHJV�VÏ�UTZXZVE^FVqyQRªVE_uRJbwV{kzILbwbª�Jtp�?P�KfTZ_UMOxkzHJILMOHNRQP��aK �EVYXZ_�`JILoaIL`JVY[J`pKm_u[pbL��ILdªTWHJV~�FPSXZV¤MY_u[ �Q`JVY[\TmTWHQPqT�TWHpVYXZV©PSXZV¤_STZHJVYX�RªVE_uRJbLVkzHJ_�kzILbwbªPSbwKf_��Jtp�:TZHJV�KfTZ_UMOx¢°¢PSK�^|_uXZV©RªVE_uRJbwV{PSXZV{kzILbwbwIL[Js�TW_��Jtp�SyJTWHJV{oqPSbLtJV{_Sd¨TWHpVK�TW_aMOxNTW_FPS[\� Iw[p`JILoaIw`ptQPSb«XfIwKfVYKYh

� �ÕT¤HQPSKzbL_u[Js��ªVEVY[�P�bwPS^|VY[\Tz_Sd!TZHJV�d�tJ[J`r^NPq[QPSsuVEXlTWHQPqT¤I¥d�TZHJV�HJVYXf`�`J_aVYKz�QPS`pbL� �JtUTHJV�`J_aVYK�kmVYbLb­yJHJV�KfVYVYKcbwI¥TZTWbLV©��VY[JV �JT�°Q�ptpT¤ILd¨TWHJV�HJVEXZ`r`J_UVEK�k�VEbwb8PS[J`rHJV�`J_aVYKz�QPS`pbL�uyTZHJVY[:HpV{suVETZK �QXfVY`�h=G�HJVEXZV~d�_uXZVqyª�Í�ªVEHQP�ouV�bwILxSV¤_STWHpVYXZKE p^FP���ouVYX��:VÏ�pRpbwIwMEILTZbL��PSRpRªVYPSX�IL[P}d�tJ[J`r^FPS[QPSsuVEXY ÒK�tpTWILbwI¥T��Fd�tJ[pMETWIL_u[�h

� �UIL[JMYV�Pq[0tp[J`JVYXfM�PSRpILTOPqbwI��EVY`AME_u^FRJPS[\��IwK�bLIwxqVYbL�rTW_:d�PqIwb­y�TWHJV�KftJMYMEVYKZK�_SdmP RJtJ�JbLIwM}_Sdg¦d�VEXZIw[ps�^NP�� `JVERªVE[J`r_u[]Hp_®k k�VEbwb ¦�KZtp�JKZMEXZIw��VY`?I¥TzIwKYypRJXZ_5oaIw`JIL[Js|PS[J_STZHJVYX �ftpKfTWI��QM�P§TWIw_S[d�_uX�RptpTZTZIw[Js�TWHpVe��VYHJP5oaIL_uX�_Sd�_STWHJVEXZKzIw[ TZHJV�d�tJ[J`r^NPS[JPSsuVYXE ÍK�tUTWIwbLILT��|d�tJ[JM~TWIw_S[�h

� �ÕdcP�bgPqXZsuVF[atp^}�ªVEX}_Sd¤�QPS[pxaK}TWPSxSVNKZIw^�tJbLTWPS[JVY_StJK}bgPqXZsuV|bw_uKfKZVEKYyDTWHJVE[�TWHJV~��^FP5����V�QPqIwbwVE`A_utpTY°!KZIL[JMYV|P?�QPSILb¥¦�_StpT�IwK�tp[JbwILxSVYb¥��I¥d�_u[pbL�A_u[pV|�JPS[Jx�TWPSxSVEK}P bw_uKfKYy8TWHJILK�^NP��

Page 87: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �

PSbLKZ_�KZVEXfoSV�PSK¤PS[?IL[JMYVE[vTZILoSV�d�_SX �Q[QPS[JMEIwVEXZK�TW_�TOPSxqV�XZIwKfxvKzTZ_usuV~TWHJVEXYh

� �UIL^FRpbL��d�_ubwbL_5kzIw[JseTWHJV�HJVEXZ`�²� � hYhEh �¤VYbLVY^|VY[\TWK�KftJMOH]PSKld�PSKZHpIw_u[?PS[p` KZVY[pKZVe_Sd¨HJ_u[J_utpXP �ªVYM~TWVE`0TZHJV��QPS[JxvKE ¬`JVYMEIwKZIL_u[ATW_:TWPSxSV�RQPSX�T�Iw["P Kf�a[J`pIwM�P§TWVY`0bw_uPS[�h��lPS[JxvKePSXZV�MEVYXÀ¦TWPSIw[Jb¥��[J_ST�Iw[JKfVY[JKfILTWI¥ouV¤TW_�RpXZVEoqPSILbwIL[JseTZXZVE[J`JKYyJPS[J`:I¥d¬ILTmIwK¤�ÍTZHJV{Iw[|TWHJIL[JsJ \TW_�TOPSxqV{RQPSX�TIL[rK��a[J`JIwMYPqTWVE`]bL_\PS[JK � hEhYh �­yQR�VY_uRpbwV�KZ_u^|VETZIw^|VYKlME_u[JKfVY[\TcTZ_U_�XfV�PS`JILbL�Sh � � � � ���iyJR ��� � �

�©Ke[J_STZVY`�PS�ª_5oSVSy8TWHJV�^|_U`JVEb�HJVEXZV|IwK�P XZVE`JtJMYVE`�d�_uXf^�^|_U`JVEb!kzHJILMOH�KZIL^FRpbL��PSKZKftJ^FVEKTWHJPqT}P �Q[QPS[pMYIwVEXY ÒK�VÏ�pR�VYM~TWVE`�tpTWILbwILT��]d�XZ_u^ Pq[�PSM~TWIw_S[�IwK�IL[JMYXfV�PSKfIw[Js]Iw["TWHJVFRªVEXZMYVE[\TOPSsuVF_Sd_STZHJVYX�R�VY_uRpbwV�PSM~TWIw[psJh��¤^NPqxSV�[J_?V �ª_uX�T�TW_?V~�URJbwPSIw[�kzH\��TZHJV|PS�ª_5oSV|V �«VEMETZKeMYPS["HQPSRJR�VY[«y�JtpT¤R�_uKZI¥T�TWHQP§TzsuILoSVY[?TWHJVEKZV�V �ªVYM~TWKYyQTZHJV�^F_a`JVYb«�ªVEbw_5k¯ILKzPSRJRJbLIwM�Pq�JbwVqh

�D^FRJILXZILM�PSbLbL�uy®TWHpVYXZVzILK�VEoaIw`pVY[JMEV¤TZHQPqT�PS[QPqbL�aKfTZKD`J_�Iw[J`JVEVY`�HJVEXZ`�h=±Q_uX�VÏ�pPS^FRpbwVSy ��XZPSHQPS^� � � �Q[p`JKFV~oaIw`JVE[JMYV?_SdcHJVYXf`JIw[ps�PS^|_u[JsAIL[\ouVYK�TW^|VY[\T|[JVEkzKfbwV~TZTWVEXFXfVYME_u^F^|VY[p`QPqTWIL_u[JKEymPq[J`�Q[J`pK�TWHJPqT�TZHJV��*&)� ��XfVYRJtpTWPS�JbLVm_u[pVYK�PqXZV�^F_uXfVmbLIwxqVYbL�©TW_©HpVYXZ`«h 0]V�Pq[vkzHpIwbwVqy 2¤_u[Js � �� �Q[p`JKVEoaIL`JVY[JMEVz_Sd¢HJVYXf`JIw[ps�PS^F_S[Js�Iw[\ouVEKfTZ^FVE[vT�Pq[QPSbL�aK�TWKYyvPq[J`��Q[J`JKDTZHQPqTDIL[JV~�UR�VYXZILVY[JMEVY`|PS[QPqbL�aKfTZKPSXfV f^|_uXZVFbwIwxqVYb¥�ATW_A��VNTWVEXZ^|Iw[QPqTZVY`�d�_SX���_ubw`�d�_SXZVYMYPSKfTZK�TWHJPqT�`JV~oUIwPqTWVFd�XZ_u^ MY_u[pKZVY[pKZtJK �JyPS[J`:TZHJVYXfVEd�_uXfV � ������XZVERJtpTWPS�JbwV{PS[QPSb¥�UK�TWKzPSXfV{^|_uXZV{bLIwxqVYbL��TZ_�HJVYXf`�h���VEbwMOH � �� � �J[J` TWHQPqT�PS[PS[QPqbL�aKfT�XfVYME_u^F^|VY[p`QPqTWIL_u[AHQPSK�P:K�TWXf_u[Js?Iw^|RQPSM~T{_u[ATWHpV�[JV~�aT�T�km_]XfVYMY_S^F^|VY[J`JPqTWIL_u[JKcd�_SXTWHpVcKZPS^FV¤KZVEMYtJXfILT��|�\�|_STWHJVEXlPS[JPSbL�aKfTZKYyUPS[J`|TWHQPqT�TWHpIwK=V �ªVYM~TlIwK�tJ[JME_uXZXfVYbwPqTWVE`FkzILTZHFkzHJV~TWHJVEXTWHpV�XZVEMY_u^|^|VY[J`QP§TWIw_S[JK�RJXZ_5ouVrTW_��ªVrMY_uXfXZVEMET:_SXF[J_qT�h �©b¥TWHJ_StJsuH TZHJVYKfV�RQPqRªVEXZKN`pIwKWPqsuXZVEVIw[0TWHJV|`JV~TOPSILbwKYy8TWHpVE��PSbwb �Q[p`�VY^|RJIwXfIwMYPSb�VEoaIL`JVY[JMEVNTWHJPqT}Pq[QPSbL�aK�TWK�PSXZVFIw[JMEbwIw[pVY`ATW_]�ªVEHQP�ouVbwILxSVe_STWHpVYXcPS[QPSb¥�UK�TWK}�iPS[J`rTWHJVEXZV~d�_uXZVeTWHJV�RªVE_uRJbwV�kzHJ_:bLIwK�TWVY[?TW_NPS[QPSb¥�aKfTWK¤kzIwbLb8PSbwKf_|TZVY[J`�TZ_��VYHQP�ouV�PSbLIwxSV��~yJKf_|TZHJV�^F_a`JVEb��ªVEbw_5k IwKzPSRJXf_uR�_uKYh�)ILTZHJIw[}TZHJV�TWHJVE_uXZV~TWIwMYPSb��Q[JPS[JMYVzbLILTWVEXWPqTZtJXZVqyuRQPSR�VYXfK=PS��_utJ[J`|XZVEs\PSXZ`pIw[Js�HJVEXZ`JIL[Js���VYHQP�o\¦

Iw_SX?� ��XZ_uKfKZ^FPS[�� � y �)�­y}n¤PS`J[JVEX � � &3�­yE$�HJ_uI�� � � �iy 0]Iw[pVYHQPSX�T|PS[J` �UME_STWMOHJ^|VYX � � �3�g�~y=�uV~TPSbLblMY_u[pMYVYXf[�TZHJVY^|KZVEbLoSVYK�kzILTWHnVE�atpIwbwIL�JXZILtJ^ Pqd¶TWVEX�P0KfVY�vtJVY[pMYV�_qd©V~ouVY[\TZKYylkzHJVE[ Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FP§¦TWIL_u[nPS��_utpT�kzHJ_"MOHJ_SKZV kzHQPqT|HQPSK���VYVE[ `pIwKZKfVY^|Iw[QP§TWVY`j��tJKZtJPSbwb¥��Iw[�TZHJV:d�_uXf^'_SdcRJXZILMYVEKO�~hG�HJV�^|_a`JVYb¤HJVYXfV�IwKF^F_SXZV]PSRJRJbLIwM�Pq�JbwV?TW_�TZHJV�MYPSKZVA_qd�PS[ Iw[pILTWIwPSblRJtp�JbwILM]_ �ªVYXfIw[Js ��� � ,��_SdzP?KZVEMYtJXfILT��Sy!kzHJVYXfVFTZHJVYXfVNIwKe[J_STe�uV~T}IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u["PS��_utpTe_STZHJVYXfKY ¨MOHJ_uILMYVYK�P�oSPqIwbgPq�JbwV�d�_SX`JILKZKZVE^FIL[QPqTZIw_u[�h

Page 88: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �

�ÕT�IwK}ME_u^|^F_u[pbL�0xv[J_5kz[nTZHQPqT�bL_us�VY�vtJI¥T���XfVETWtpXZ[JK�HQP�oSV]PAxvtJX�TW_uKfIwK}bwPSXZsuVEX�TWHJPS[�TWHQP§T_SdlP��¤_uXZ^FPSb�`pIwKfTZXZIL�JtpTWIL_u[�h�G�HJVE_uXZVE^ � � KfHJ_5kzKeTZHQPqTeILd�kmVNPSKfKZtJ^|V�TWHQPqTeRJXfILoqPqTZV�VY�vtJILT��oqPSbwtpVYK¤PSXZV �c_SXZ^FPSbwb¥�N`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWVE`�y¢�JtpT¤RªVE_uRJbLVeoqPSbLtJV�VY�vtJI¥TWIwVEKc�JPSKZVE`�_u[�P|^|I¥�?_qd�RJXfILoqPqTWVoqPSbwtpV�PS[p`�RJtJ�pbwIwM=oqPSbwtpVSy®TWHJVE[}VY�vtJI¥T���`pVY^FPS[J`}^}tpKfT��ªVmbwVYRUTW_uxvtJX�TW_STZIwMSh �c[p`JVYX!PSRJRJXf_uRJXZIwPqTWVMY_S[J`JILTZIw_u[pKYypTZHJIwKlkzILbwb«IL^FRpbL�FbwVYRUTW_uxvtJX�TW_STZIwM{XfVETWtpXZ[JKcPSK�k�VEbwbih

� TW�TWBT S � #��� � �B� � � ��# � �B����� ��2:� ��� �

��Xf_UMOx Pq[J` �{tpXZbgPqtpd � ���KZR�VYMYI¥d¶�?P�^F_a`JVEb«kzHJIwMOHrIwK�KfIw^|IwbwPSXmTZ_�TZHJV�_u[JV�RJXfVYKZVE[\TWVY`]HJVYXfVSh���[TWHpV �QXZK�TDXZ_StJ[J`�y\PcRJXZIL_uX�R�VYXfMYVE[vTWPSsuVl_qd�PSMETZ_uXZK�ILK!suI¥ouVE[�y\PS[J`�RªVE_uRJbwV�PSMET!I��|TWHQP§T�R�VYXZMEVY[\TOPqsuVkm_utJbw`���VrbwPSXZsSV VY[J_utpsuH�TZ_"suILoSV?TZHJVY^ PAR�_uKZI¥TWI¥ouV?tpTWILbwI¥T���d�Xf_u^ PSM~TWIL[JsJhn��[ KftJ�JKfVY�vtJVY[\TXZ_StJ[J`JKEyQIw[J`JI¥oaIw`JtQPqbwKltJKfV�TWHJV�R�VYXZMEVY[\TOPqsuV�_qd!R�VY_uRpbwV{kzHJ_|MOHJ_uKfVeTZ_FPqMET¤Iw[:TZHJV�RJXZIL_uX�XZ_utp[J`TW_�`JVEMYIL`JV�kzHJVETZHJVYXzTW_|PSM~Tc_SX�[J_ST�h

��XZ_aMOx"PS[J` �{tJXZbwPStpd�^FPSxSVFPr[vtJ^��ªVEXe_qdlKfTZXZ_u[ps�PSKfKZtJ^|RpTZIw_u[JKEy�IL[JMYbLtJ`JIL[Js?�atJPSKZILbwIw[pV�PSXtpTZIwbwI¥T��uyzP�bL_usuIwK�TWILMr`pIwKfTZXZIL�JtpTWIL_u[ _qd�RpXZVEd�VEXZVE[JMYVEKYy�PS[p`)P�MYtpTZ_ ��¦­T��aRªVAVE�atpIwbwIL�JXZILtJ^ry�kzHJVYXfVVEoSVYX��u_u[JV�kzILTZH0PNTOPSK�TWV�RQPSXZPS^FV~TWVEX{_5ouVYXeP:MEVYXfTWPSIw["R�_uIw[\T�ME_u[JKftJ^FVEKePS[J`"VEoSVYXf�S_u[JV|�ªVEbw_5kTWHJPqT{R�_uIw[\Tc`J_aVYK{[J_qT�h k G�HpVYIwXc^F_a`JVEb�ILKcME_u^FRJPSXWPS�pbwV�TW_NTZHJV}KZV~TWtJRA_qd=V~�pPS^|RJbwVEK ��PS[p` �_Sd �UVYM~TWIL_u[ � h � hUyJPS[J`rPSXZXfILoSVYK¤PqT¤P}MY_S^FRQPqXWPS�JbLV{VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^�IL[:TWHJ_SKZV�KZR�VYMEI��QM�KZI¥TWtQP§TWIw_S[JKYh��tpT¤KfIw[JMEV�TZHJVE�rPqKZKZtp^FVeKZtJMOH�P|KfRªVEMYI��QMed�_SXZ^�_qd�`JILKfTWXfIw�JtUTWIw_S[?PS[J`rtpTWILbwILT��|d�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[�ypTZHJVYILXRQPSR�VYXFsuILoSVYKNP�bwIL^FI¥TWVY`�PS[pKfkmVYXNTZ_�TWHpV��vtJVYK�TWIw_S[ _Sd�HJ_5k-RJXfIw_uX�Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�P �ªVYMETZKNTWHpV[vtJ^}��VYXz_Sd�RªVE_uRJbLV{kzHJ_|kzILbwbªMOHJ_U_SKZV�TW_|PSMETYh

� ��2@���. �B� � ����Q��# 2 �M�Y���� G�HpV©TWIL^FIL[Js�_Sd���XZ_aMOx|PS[J` �{tpXZbgPqtpdY ÒK�^F_a`JVYb�IwKmPSbLKZ_�km_uX�TWHMY_S[JKZIL`JVYXfIw[JsJ² TZHJVE��HJP5oSV�P " � "��&)( (/� �*� (/"�RJXZ_aMYVEKZKFTZ_5klPSXf` P �©PqKZH�VY�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^ry�kzHJILbwV �M�PqbwMYtpbgPqTZVmP �©PqKZH�VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^ `JIwXfVYMETZbL�Sh�G�HJILK�ILK8�QPSKZILM�PSbLbL�©VY�vtJILoqPSbLVY[\T�y§V~�UMEVYRpT�TWHQPqT�Iw^|RJbLIwMYI¥TTW_ ��Xf_UMOx�Pq[J` �{tpXZbgPqtpdY ÒK�KZV~TWtJR IwK�TWHpV]PqKZKZtp^FRpTZIw_u[�TZHQPqT|RªVE_uRJbLVrHJP5oSVrd�tpbwblIL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[PS��_utpT�TZHJV�`pIwKfTZXZIL�JtpTWIL_u[ _Sd¨TOPSK�TWVEKcIL[?TZHJVeKZ_aMYIwV~T��uh�G�HJIwKzRQPqRªVEXcPqbwKZ_�`JILKZMEtJKZKfVYKcTZHJV�M�PSKfVYK¤_SdtJ[JIL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZILoSV{_uX�_u[Jb¥�:RQPqXfTWIwPSbwb¥�|Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWILoSV{RJXfIw_uXlIL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u[«h��¸®¹�¿EÂi¹fÅ�����Ãi¸®¿OÈ8ë·­¸§ÇO·¨Ø�Ä©Ç~íÃ�Á®ÅlÌ¡µ®ÖlØq¿~·i¸�ÇlÚ¡¿~Ö~Ì�Ã�·iÌ�¾DË5Ì¡Ã�·i­̡خÁ5·iÌ¡¿~µ�Ç~µ§Ë{Ç�¾ÀÁ5·­¿ÏÑe¹ �EÁ§ÌÍÚ¡ÌÍاÂiÌ¡Á®Å{Æ®·­¸®¹�ÄÅ�Ç~Ë5¹!¿~µ§¹!ÇEÃiÃiÁ®ÅlÉ5·iÌ¡¿~µcÅl¿~­¹¨·­¸§Çϵ¤·i¸®¹fÄzµ®¹�¹ZË5¹fË Ç�¾ÀÁ5·­¿ÏÑ�¹ �EÁ§ÌÍÚ¡ÌÍاÂiÌ¡Á®Å�¾fÇϵ¤ØS¹�Ë5¹�­ÌÍÐE¹fËzÊ Âi¿EÅ�·i¸®¹fÌͬ¿~·i¸®¹fÂÇ~íÃiÁ®ÅlÉ5·iÌ¡¿~µ§Ãf»

Page 89: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �� TW�TWBT�� � ���\� � 2 ��# .�� � �\�

±¢PSKZHpIw_u[�su_a_U`�^|_U`pVYbwKDKftJMOH PSK�±QXZI ��TWVEXZK� ���iy �¨VYKfVY[J`J_SXfd�VYX � �[� �iyU_uX �mVYXZ[pHJVYIL^ � &���PqXZVz�QPSKfVY`_u[:sS_U_a`JKlPqK�P�KZILsu[QPSb�_Sd8K�TOPqTZtJKYhDG�HJV~�:MEbgPSIL^,TWHQPqT�RªVE_uRJbLVck�PS[\TlTW_}KfVY[J`?KfIwsu[QPqbwK=TW_}_STZHJVYXfKIw[p`JIwMYPqTWIL[Js�TWHJVEIwXz�vtQPSbwI¥T�� �)Iw[ ��VEKZVE[J`J_uX�d�VYXY ÒK�bgPq[JsutQPSsSVSyJTWHpVE�r�Jtp�]P �`JVYKfIwsu[]MY_u^|^F_a`JI¥T�� �d�_uX�TWHpVeKZPSxSV�_SdDP§TZTWXZPSMETZIw[Js|P�HJIwsSHU¦��vtQPSbLILT�� f`QPqTZV��Jh�G�HJVeKfTZXZVY[psSTWH]_Sd!TZHQPqT¤KZILsu[QPSb¬`JVEMYbLIw[JVEKPSKz^|_uXZV�R�VY_uRpbwV�KZVE[J`�I¥T�h

�©[ IL^FR�_uXfTWPS[\TFd�VYPqTWtpXZV�_Sd�KftJMOHjILTWVE^FK|IwKFTWHQPqTFTWHJV~� PSXfV�_Sd¶TZVY[ ��I��ªVY[ sS_U_a`JKYyzKfIw[JMEVPS["V~�UR�VY[JKfILoSVNILTZVY^ ^NP��A��V�Iw["`JVE^NPS[p`�KfIw^|RJbL�]�ªVEM�PStpKZV|ILT�ILK�V~�URªVE[JKZI¥ouVqh �©K�KftJMOH�y8TWHJILKMOHQPSRUTWVYX}kzILbwbmHQP�ouV KZ_S^FV~TWHJIL[Js�TW_AKZP5��PS�ª_StpT�KfTWPqTWtpK�¦�_SXZIwVE[\TWVY`n^|_U`pVYbwKEy�Iw[�TZHQPqT�I¥T�RJbwPSMYVEKXZVEKfTZXZIwM~TWIL_u[JK¤_u[]TZHJV�Kf_uXfTc_Sd=PqKZKZtp^FRpTZIw_u[pK¤TZHQPqTzTWHJV~�r^NP��?��Ved�_utp[J`JVY`�_u[�h0]_uK�T{[J_qTOPS�Jb¥�uyG�HJVE_uXZVE^ � � KfHJ_5kzKzTZHQPqT�KftJMOHrsu_U_a`JKlMYPS[ [J_STlV~�UIwK�T¤PqT�VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^�ILd¬TZHJV�`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZIw_u[F_SdTOPqKfTWVEKzIwKzKZt��|MEIwVY[\TZbL� `JI��«tpKZVePS[J` TWHpVYXZVeIwKld�tpbwb«IL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u[:PS�ª_StpT�TOPSK�TWVEKcPq[J`]RpXZIwMEVYKEh

�5176%143 < 0 F�<.DLF�NOILK!;=<EDLK

±Q_ubwbL_5kzIw[Js"PSXfV]TZHJV�^FPSIw[nME_u[JMYbLtJKZIL_u[JKF_Sd{TWHpV�PS[QPqbL�aKZILK|_qd{TWHJV]^F_a`JVEb¤RpXZVYKfVY[\TWVE`)Iw[nTWHJILKMOHQPSRUTWVYXE²

� � ������ �\# � � � tJ[JIL�atpV|VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^ V~�UIwK�TWKeIw["^NPq[v��KZR�VYMYI��QM�P§TWIw_S[JKYh $�_u[J`JI¥TWIL_u[JK�kzHJVYXfVTWHpVYXZV�^FP�����V�^}tJbLTZIwRJbLV�VE�atpIwbwIL�JXZIwPNPSXfV�KZR�VYMEI��QVE`�PS[p`0`pIwKZMEtJKZKfVY`�h �c[�VE�atpIwbwIL�JXZILtJ^/kzHJVYXfVTWHpVYXZV�ILK�P�MYtpTZ_ �!ypKZtJMOH?TWHQP§TzVEouVEXf�a��_U`p�NkzHJ_uKZV�TOPqKfTWV�RJPSXWPS^|VETZVYXlILKzPS��_®oSV{TWHJV�MEtpTW_ �"PSMETZKPS[J`�V~ouVYX��a�ª_a`p�}kzHJ_SKZV�TOPSK�TWV�ILK��ªVEbw_5knTWHJV�MEtpTW_ �:`J_aVYKD[J_qT�PSMETYySkzIwbLbpPSb¥klP��aK=V~�UIwK�T�h���[|Kf_u^|VM�PqKZVYKcPSbLb«VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZIwP�kzIwbLb��ªV�MEtpTW_ �"VY�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgPphG�HQPqT�KZPSIw`«y�kmV}��VYsuIL[�kzILTZH�PN`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[]_qdDTOPSK�TWVYKEy¬PS[J`�VY[J`�kzI¥TWH�PF`JIwK�TWXZIL�JtpTZIw_u[r_Sd

MYtUTW_ �ªKYh �©KZKftJ^|V|d�_uX{TZHJV|KWPSxqVF_SdmTWHJILK�KZtJ^|^NPqXf��TZHQPqT�TOPqKfTWVEK�PqXZV|[J_uXZ^FPSbLbL�r`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZVY`�y^|V�PS[JIL[JsNTZHQPqT�TWHpVE�APqXZV�Kf�a^|^FV~TWXfIwM�kzI¥TWH"P KZIL[JsubLV�R�V�PSx�PqT��YVEXZ_Jh ��KZIL[JsubwV�RªVYPSx�P§T �YVYXf_^|V�PS[JK�TZHQPqTzIw[p`JI��ªVYXfVY[JMEVeILKlTWHJV�^|_uKfTzbLIwxqVYbL�F_uRJIL[JIw_S[�h

� �:����Q��# 2 �M�Y���� ��[?TWHpV�M�PSKfVeHpVYXZVqyQILd8TWHpVYXZVePSXfV�[J_�RJtJ�JbLIwM{KfIwsu[JPSbwKEyUTWHpVY[?TWHJVEXZV�IwKl_S[JbL�_u[JVrMYtUTW_ ��y�KftJMOH TWHJPqTNV~ouVEXf�u_S[JVAPSM~TWKFPSKFI¥dcTZHJVE��s\PqIw[JVE` [J_0tpTZIwbwI¥T���d�Xf_u^'TWHpV]��VYHQP�oaIw_SX

Page 90: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� &_Sd�_qTWHJVEXZKYh �U_]Iw[0^NPq[v�"KfILTZtQPqTWIL_u[JK�kzHJVEXZVFTZHJVYXfV � � &�� � �A��VN[JV~T�k�_uXfx�VÏ�aTWVYXf[QPSbLILTWILVYKEy¨R�VYVEXRJXfVYKZKftJXZVqyªV~TzMYV~TWVYXZPpyQTWHJVEKZV�d�_uXZMEVYKzHQP�ouVe[J_�V �ªVYM~T�h

� �\�� �����Q��# 2 �M��� ��� ��ILouVE[�d�tJbwb=IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[�y8TWHpV:`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZIw_u[�_Sd�TOPqKfTWVEK�kzIwbLbm��V:^|_uXZVbwVERpTW_SxatpXfTW_qTWIwM|��KZRJXfV�PS`]_utpTzTW_5k�PSXZ`rTWHJVeV~�aTZXZVY^|VYKW�zXfVYbwPqTWI¥ouV{TW_�TWHpV�`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[ _Sd!TWPSKfTZVYKEh±Q_uX!VÏ�pPS^FRpbwVSyS^F_5oaIwVm�atJPSbwI¥T���^FP�����Vl`JXZP�kz[�d�Xf_u^P{�ªVEbwbaMYtJX�ouVzMYVE[\TWVYXfVY`FPSXZ_StJ[J`�P©^|_U`pVYX�¦PqTZV¤�vtQPqbwILT��Syv�JtpT�^F_5oaIwVzXfVETWtpXZ[JK=TWVE[J`FTZ_���VzVYILTZHJVYX=IL[|TZHJVe� oQ_uR« \_uX��¡�JbL_UMOxv�JtpKfTWVEXY aM�PqTZVYsu_SXf�uhG�HJVEXZV�IwKmXZVYPSKZ_u[ TZ_}�ªVEbwILVEouVcTWHQPqTlVY�vtJILT��|oqPSbwtJPqTWIL_u[JK�KfHJ_utJbL`:��V{[J_uXf^NPSbLbL��`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWVE`�yp�JtUTVY�vtJI¥T��|XZVETZtJXZ[pK�TWVE[J`NTW_��ªVcbwVERpTW_uxvtJX�TW_STZIwMq°aTZHJV©MEbgPSIL^,HJVYXfV©ILK�TZHQPqT�TZHJVYKfV{V �ªVYM~TWK�PSXZVc`JtJVcTZ_TWHpVeME_u[pd�_uXf^FI¥T��NV �«VEMETcIw[JHpVYXZVE[\TcIL[?^F_5oaIwV�_uX�VE�vtJILT�� `pVY^FPS[J`�hG�HJV©`pIwKfTZXZIL�JtpTWIL_u[�_Sd«MYtpTZ_ �«Km^NP�����V¤KZ_eV~�aTWXfVY^|V¤TZHQPqT�oUILXfTZtQPSbwb¥��V~ouVEXf�u_S[JV�PSM~TWK�_uX=`J_UVEK

[J_ST!PSM~T �)HpVYXZ`pIw[JsJh �UtJMOH�VY�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgP�PSXfVmsStQPSXWPq[vTZVYVE`}_u[Jb¥��tJ[J`JVEX�MEVYXfTWPSIw[�MY_u[p`JILTZIw_u[JKEh!±�IwXZK�T�yR�VY_uRJbLV�HQP�ouV�TW_�k�VEIwsuH\T¤TWHJVePSM~TWIw_S[JKz_Sd�_STZHJVYXfK�ouVYX��rHJV�P�oaIwb¥�uyQ_uX�TWHpV�Kf_UMEIwVET��� ÒK¤TWPSKfTZVYK¤^}tJK�T��V¤xv[J_5kz[�TW_e�ªVloSVYX���HJ_u^|_usuVY[p_utJKYh �UVYME_u[J`�y\TWHpVYXZV¤^}tJK�T=�ªVzRJXfIw_uX!Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[�PS��_utpTDTWHpV^|_U`JV�_qd�TZHJV�`JIwK�TWXZIL�JtpTZIw_u[ _Sd¨TOPqKfTWVEKYh

�U_�PqK|TZHJV]kmVYILsuH\TN_Sd{_STWHJVEXY ÒKNPqMETWIL_u[JK|XZILKZV���_uX�TWHpV]oqPSXZIwPS[JMEVr_qd{TWHJVrKZ_aMYILVET��� ÒKFTOPqKfTWVEK��VYMY_S^FV�^|_uXZV�MY_u[JMEVY[\TWXZPqTWVE`¢�~y\TZHJVz`JIwK�TWXZIL�JtpTZIw_u[}_qdªMEtpTW_ �«KD��VYME_u^FV�^|_uXfV�PS[J`�^|_uXZVlKfRJXZVYPS`_utpTYyQtJ[\TWILb�^F_a`JVEXWPqTZV�_utpTWME_u^|VYKzPSXfVeIL^FR�_uKfKZIw�pbwVSh

�����J� � .�� � ��� G�HJVcHQPSbwbL^NPqXZxe_Sd�TWHpVcK�TOPqTZtJK�¦Õ`JXZI¥ouVY[Fd�PSKZHJIL_u[|su_U_a`|IwK�PS[NtpRvk�PSXf`:KZbL_uRJIw[ps`JVE^NPS[p`|MEtJXfoSVShDG�HJILKDIwKDKfHJ_5kz[|TZ_e��V�Iw^|R�_uKZKfIw�JbLV�tJ[J`pVYXDMYVEXfTWPSIw[�MY_S[J`JILTZIw_u[pKYyuKftJMOH:PSK�kzHpVY[R�VY_uRJbLV{HQP�ouV{d�tpbwb�Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[NPS��_utpTlRJXZILMYVYKlPS[J`:TWHpV�`JIwK�TWXZIL�JtpTZIw_u[F_Sd8TOPSK�TWVYK�ILK�Kft��|MYIwVE[\TWbL�`JI��«tJKfVSh

� � � ��#Y���� ���. � �mVETZTZVYXE ¬PS`poSVYXfTZIwKfIw[Js:kzILbwb¨�ªV}`pV �Q[JVE`�h��¤_ST�_u[pbL�rkzIwbwb¨��VETZTZVYX�Pq`pouVEXfTWILKZIL[JsIw[p`JtJMYV�^F_uXfV]ME_u[JKftJ^FRUTWIw_S[�yz�JtpT:��VETfTWVEX � � �#���)" � "%$'&)( � Pq�ª_utUT PS`poSVYX�TWIwKfIw[Js�M�PS[ IL[JMYXfV�PSKfVMY_S[JKZtJ^|RpTZIw_u[�h

� � ��2:��� # �� �B� � ��� � G�HpV:^F_a`JVEb�ILK�PqRJRJbwILVY`"TW_�G���KZR�VYMEIgPSbLKYy�kzHpIwMOH�suI¥ouV|VEoaIw`pVY[JMEV:_Sd^}tJb¥TWIL^F_a`QPSbLILT���IL[r`pVY^FPS[J`�h

Page 91: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

��

�5176%1�� � <\> P!<,ILK P / ;OK F /LH 2P �9

G�HJILKeRJPSRªVEX�IwK�P?M�PqTWPSbw_Ss _Sd�XfVYKftJbLTZKYy8^F_SKfT�_Sd�kzHJIwMOH"TOPqxSV�KZ_u^|V�Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[QPSb¨KfTZXZtJM~TWtJXfVPSK�suI¥ouVE[ PS[p`�ME_u[JMEbwtJ`JV Kf_u^|VETWHpIw[Js0PS��_utpT�VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgPp²�TWHQP§T�TWHJV~�nPSXZV MEtpTW_ ��¦­d�_uXZ^ry�TWHQP§TTWHpVE�"PSXfV�tJ[JIw�vtJVqy¬TWHQPqT�TZHJVE�"PqXZV�`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZVY`"bwVERpTW_SxatpXfTW_qTWIwMYPSbwb¥�uy�TWHQPqT�TZHJVE�"^�tJKfTeIw[\oS_ubLoSVHJVYP5ov�rMY_S[voaI¥oUIwPSbwI¥T��NV �«VEMETZKYy�VET¤MYV~TWVYXZPph�G�HpVYKZV�`JVYKfMYXfIwRpTZIw_u[JKz_Sd�VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^�^FP��:V�PqKZIwb¥� ��VTWXZPS[JKfbgPqTZVY`nIw[\TW_"K�TOPqTZVY^|VY[\TWK|PS��_utpT�`JVE^NPq[J`�y=kzHJIwMOHnkzIwbLb���Vr^�tJMOH ^|_uXfV `JVETWPSIwbLVY`�TWHJPS[TWHp_uKZV�R�_uKZKfIw�JbLV�tJKZIL[Js�TWHJV��QPSKfIwM�HJVEXZ`JIL[Js�^F_a`JVYb«`JIwKfMYtJKfKZVY`�PS��_®oSVSh

��tpT�`JVE^NPS[p`|ILKDPqT=^|_uKfT=HJPSbLd�_Sd«PS[\�}^|IwMEXZ_aVYMY_S[J_u^|IwM�^|_a`JVYbiyuXZVE�atpIwXZIL[Js�P�KZtJRpRJbL��MYtJX�ouV_uX{ME_u^|RªV~TWIw[ps:su_a_U`JK¤d�_uX{ME_u[\TWV~�aTYh��U_:TZHJIwK©RQPSR�VYX{ILK{[J_ST�PFMY_u^|RJbwV~TWV}^|_a`JVYb¨_SdmPS[\�vTWHJIL[Js�\��ILTWKfVYb¥dÀym�JtUT:PS[ Iw[JRptpT|Iw[\TW_"TWHJV]RJXZ_a`JtJM~TWIL_u[ _qd{^|IwMYXf_UVEMY_u[p_u^FILM:^|_U`JVEbwK�_Sd©KZILTZtQPqTZIw_u[JKkzHJVEXZV�RªVE_uRJbLV�s\PSIw[ tUTWIwbLILT���d�XZ_S^�VY^�tJbgPqTZIw[Js�_qTWHJVEXZKYh=G�HJVePSKfKZtJ^|RpTZIw_u[JKzPqXZV{TWHvtJKzIL[vTZVY[J`pVY`TW_ ME_5ouVYX�VE[J_utJsuH"suXf_utJ[J`�TZHQPqT�TZHJV�^F_a`JVEb!`JVEKZIwsS[JVYX{^FP���KfVYbwVEMET�TZHJ_uKZV�PqKZKZtp^FRpTZIw_u[pK©TWHQP§T��VYKfT�`pVYKZMEXZIL�ªVNTZHJV KZI¥TWtQP§TWIw_S[�HJV ILK}^F_a`JVEbwIw[psJy!Pq[J`n^NP��0TWHJVE[�MY_utJMOH�TZHJV MY_uXfXZVEKZR�_u[J`JIL[JsXZVEKZtJb¥TWK¤PS��_utpTz`JVE^NPq[J`rkzI¥TWHJIL[?P�MY_u^|RJbwV~TWV�^|IwMEXZ_aVYMY_S[J_u^|IwM©^|_a`JVYbih

�5176%10 � I2PBNO;7D

�UVEMETWIL_u[ � h{`JV �Q[JVEK�TZHJVc^|_a`JVYbih �UVEMETZIw_u[ � h��e`pV �Q[JVEK�P��lP��uVEKZIwPS[ �cPSKZHFVY�vtJILbwIw�pXZIwtp^IL[�TWHJILKMY_S[vTZV~�aT�h �UVEMETWIL_u[ � h � h�N`JIwKfMYtJKfKZVEKeVE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgP�suILoSVY[AMY_S^FRJbLVETZV�Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�y �UVEMETWIL_u[ � h � h��`JILKZMYtpKZKZVEK�kzHQPqT�TWHpVcVE�atpIwbwIL�JXZIwP©kzIwbLbJbw_a_ux}bLIwxSVzIL[|TZHJVcMYPSKZVc_Sd�tp[JIw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWI¥ouV�RJXfIw_uX=Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FP§¦TWIL_u[�yªPS[J` �UVEMETZIw_u[ � h � h � suI¥ouVEK�P:MY_u^|RQPSXZPqTWI¥ouVeKfTWPqTWILMYK{XfVYKZtpbLT©d�_SXcTWHpV}M�PSKfV�_Sd=Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWI¥ouV�JtpTmIw[pMY_u^|RJbwV~TWV�IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[�h �UVEMETZIw_u[ � h � KZHp_®kzK�T�k�_eklP��aKlIL[�kzHpIwMOHNTZHJVc^|_a`JVYbQME_utJbw`|��VV~�aTZVY[J`JVE`�TZ_rIL[JMYbLtJ`JV�Pq`pouVEXfTWILKZIL[JsJy �UVEMETWIL_u[ � h'& _ �«VEXZK�Kf_u^FV�VÏ�aTWVY[pKZIw_S[JKYy�PS[J` �UVEMETWIL_u[ � h �KZHp_®kzK=Kf_u^FV�VY^|RJIwXfIwM�PqbaV~oaIw`JVE[JMYVlTZHQPqT�TZHJVloaIwVEkmVYXfKZHJILR�_Sd�G��)KZR�VYMEIgPSbLK!KZHp_®kzK=KfIw^}tJb¥TOPS[pVY_utJKMY_S[voaI¥oUIwPSbwI¥T��NV �«VEMETZKc_Sd¨TWHpV�T��aR�V�`JIwKfMYtJKfKZVY`�Iw[ TWHJILK�MOHQPSRpTZVYX�h

� 3)( ��� � <?> 8�

�©M~TW_uXfK�PSXZV:d�PqMYVY`nkzILTZHnPA�JIw[QPqXf��PqMETWIL_u[�h�±Q_uX}V~�pPS^|RJbLVS²:K�TOPS[J`nIL[�bLIw[JVNPqT�TWHpV Rª_uRptJbgPSXXZVEKfTWPStJXWPq[vT�_uX8su_¤KfTZXWPSILsuH\T�IL[�TW_zTWHJV�tJ[JR�_uRJtJbwPSX¬_u[JVqySIL[JKfTWPSbwbuVEILTZHJVYX¨P �(, �\¦��QPSKfVY`e_uR�VYXWP§TWIw[ps

Page 92: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �

Kf�aK�TWVY^ _uX{P � �c���¤¦��QPqKZVY`"K��UK�TWVE^]y�XfVEoS_ubLT©_uX©`J_S[� ÒT©XZV~ou_ub¥T�y«�ptp��PFsu_U_a`�_SX©`J_u[« ÒT��ptp��I¥T�h±Q_uX�TZHJV:KZPSxSV _Sd¤ME_u[JKZILKfTZVY[\T}TWVEXZ^|Iw[J_Sbw_usS�Sy!��kzIwbLb=`JVYKfMYXZIL�ªV:TZHJV:MOHJ_SIwMYV:PSK}��VYIw[ps��ªV~T�k�VEVY[�¡PSMETZIw[JsJ JPS[J`"�¡[J_qT¤PSMETZIw[JsJ ¥h

� ME_utJ[\TOPS�pbL�eIw[��J[JILTZVm[vtJ^}��VYX�_Sd¢Iw[p`JILoaIw`ptQPSbwK�kzILbwbvKZIL^}tJb¥TOPS[JVE_utJKfbL��MOHJ_a_uKZV�TW_�PqMET�_SX�[J_qTPSM~T�h�G�HJV¤`JVEMYIwKfIw_u[|IwKD�JPSKZVE`N_u[|T�k�_�d�PSMETZ_uXZKEh�G�HJV �QXZK�Tmd�PqMETW_SX�ILK�TWHJV¤R�VYXZMEVY[\TOPqsuV � _qd«_STZHJVYXfKPSM~TWIw[psJy�� = � � �����­y�kzHpIwMOH"kzIwbwb��ªV�VE[J`J_usSVY[J_utpKZbL��`JVETZVYXZ^|Iw[pVY`�h}G�HpVFKfVYMY_S[J`0d�PqMETW_SX�IwK{TWHpV[JV~T�Iw[p`JILoaIw`ptQPSbvtpTWILbwI¥T��{TW_{ME_u[JKftJ^FVEX �fyu`JVY[p_STWVE`��v��PcXfV�PSbU[vtJ^}��VYX � � h!G�HJV�`JIwK�TWXZIL�JtpTZIw_u[e_Sd �kzILTZHJIw[�TWHJV�Kf_UMEIwVET���`JVYR�VY[p`JK=_u[|P{RQPSXWPq^FV~TWVYX ) yukzHJIwMOH�IwK!`JIwKfMYtJKfKZVY`F�ªVEbw_5k�h���ILoSVY[ ) y\TWHpV`JILKfTWXfIw�JtUTWIw_S[r_qd�TOPSK�TWVEK©IwK¤`JVEKZMYXfIw��VY`��\�]P � ��±����'� � ) ��kzHJILMOH�HQPSK¤KZtpRJRª_SXfT�� ��� ��� �ld�_SXPS[\� suI¥ouVE[ ) h�G�HJV�d�PS^FILbL�|_Sd�`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZIw_u[pK���'� � ) �lIwK�MY_S^F^|_u[?xv[J_5kzbwVY`psuVSy¢VEoSVY[rTWHJ_utpsuH) ^FP��:[J_qTc��VSh

�51435176 .@; 0 NO;7D

G�HJVeKZVE�atpVY[JMEV�_Sd�VEoSVY[\TWKcIwKzPSK�d�_ubLbw_5kzKY²

�uh ��ouVEXf�S_u[JV�KZHQPqXZVYKlP}MY_u^|^F_S[NRJXfIw_uX��ªVEbwILVEd8PS��_utpTmTWHJV©`JIwK�TWXZIL�JtpTZIw_u[F_Sd¬TWHJVcRQPSXZPS^FV~TWVEX) yaIw[�TWHJV¤d�_uXZ^�_qd¬P�RpXZ_u�QPq�JIwbLILT��}`pVY[JKfILT���d�tJ[JM~TWIw_S[ ��� ) �ÏyUkzI¥TWH�d�tJbwb¢KZtpRJRª_SXfTm_®oSVYX�PSbwb) = � �� ��� �~y§`JVEXZILoSVY`ed�XZ_u^¯VEILTZHJVYX8RJXfVEoaIw_utpK�VÏ�pR�VYXfIwVE[JMYVm_uXm��MYXfVY`JIL�JbwV���PS`poSVYXfTZIwKfIw[JsJhG�HJILK!RJXfIw_uX¨^FP5��XZPS[JsuV�PS[\�vkzHJVYXfVld�XZ_u^¯d�tJbLbL��IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZILouVDTZ_©VY[\TZIwXZVEbL��tJ[pIw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWILoSVSh�cKmP�MY_S^F^|_u[�KZR�VYMEIgPSbQMYPSKZVqyaTZHJV¤RQPSXWPq^FV~TWVYX ) kzIwbLbJ_Sd¶TWVE[F��V�TOPSxqVY[|TW_��ªV�TZHJVc^|_a`JVSh

Uh �cPqTWtJXfV�`JXWP�kzK¤P �U�pVE`roqPSbLtJV �"d�_uX ) yQ�JtpTz^FP�� _uX�^FP5�N[J_ST¤XZV~ouVYPSb��"TZ_|PSMETZ_uXZKEh�phz��[J`pILoaIw`JtJPSbwKl`pXWP�k P�RJXZI¥oqPqTWV�tpTZIwbLILT���� � h� hz��[J`pILoaIw`JtJPSbwKmtJKZV � � TZ_�tJRª`JPqTWV{TZHJVYILXlRJXZIL_uX���VYbLIwV~d�K ��� ) �mTZ_�P}[JVEk RJXZI¥oqPqTWV{bLIwxqVYbwILHJ_a_U``JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[ _5ouVYX�TZHJV�`JIwK�TWXZIL�JtpTZIw_u[ _Sd¨TOPqKfTWVEKYh

��¸®Ì�Ã=Ì�Ã=Çϵ�ÇÏɧɮÂi¿ �5Ì¡Å�ÇO·iÌ¡¿~µaÆvÃ�Ì¡µ§¾À¹�ÌÍ·�Ì�ÃDÌ¡Å�ÉS¿EíÃiÌÍخڡ¹l·i¿�Ë®¹ÀÙ§µ®¹zÇ{ÉS¹�ÂÕ¾À¹fµY·­ÇÏÖE¹l¿ÏʬÇ�¾À¿~Á§µE·ÕÇÏخڡÄ�Ì¡µ5Ù§µ®ÌÍ·i¹µ�Á®Å�ØS¹�ÂJ¿~Ê®Éq¹f¿~ɮڡ¹~»���¿~­¹�ɧÂi¹Z¾ÀÌ�Ã�¹fÚÍÄEÆZÈ«¹«È¬ÌÍÚ¡ÚYÙ§µ§ËD·­¸§ÇO·p·i¸§¹�­¹ª¹���Ì�Ã�·­ÃpǨ¾À¿Eµ§ÃiÌ¡Ã�·i¹fµE·J¹fÃ�·iÌ¡Å�ÇO·­¹ª¿~Ê5·i¸®¹«ÚÍÌ¡Î~¹fÚÍÌ¡¸®¿�¿5Ë·i¸qÇO·DÇzÂÕÇϵ§Ë5¿EÅlÚÍÄ�Ë5ÂÕÇWȬµ�Ì͵qË5ÌÍÐ�Ì�Ë5Á§Ç~ÚpȬ̡ڡÚJÇE¾�·ZÆ���� � >�� �w»!´8Ȭ̡ÚÍÚQÃ�·iÌ�¾ÕΩ·i¿c·i¸®¹lË5¹fí¾À­̡É5·iÌ¡¿~µ�Û ÉS¹�ÂÕ¾À¹�µY·ÕÇÏÖ~¹�¿ÏÊÇ~¾À·i¿E­ÃfÜÍÆ\¸§¿OȪ¹fÐ~¹�ÂZÆ\ØS¹f¾�Ç~Á§Ãi¹�ÌÍ·=Å�ÇÏÎE¹fÃ�Ål¿~­¹lÌ͵Y·iÁ§ÌÒ·­ÌÍÐE¹lÃi¹�µqÃ�¹EÆUÇϵqËeÌ�Ã�Ê ¿~­Å�ÇÏÚ¡ÚÍÄ�¾�¿~­Âi¹Z¾�·DÌ¡µe·­¸®¹�Âi¹ZÇÏÚQÈ«¿~­ڡËvÆȬ¸®¹fÂi¹!·i¸§¹�­¹�Ç~Âi¹DÇ�Ú�ÇÏ­Ö~¹!Ø®Á5·8Ù§µ§ÌÒ·­¹DµYÁ§Å�ØS¹�¬¿ÏÊQÇ~¾À·i¿E­Ãf»

Page 93: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� h �¨VYXZKf_u[ �}[J_5k-HQPSKFVY[J_StJsuH Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�TW_�MYPSbwMEtJbgP§TWV?TWHJV�VÏ�URªVEMETWVE`)tpTWILbwILT���d�XZ_u^PSM~TWIL[Js|PS[J` d�XZ_u^�[J_ST¤PSM~TWIw[psJyQPS[J`?^FPSxSVEK©P�`JVEMYILKZIw_S[]PqMYMY_SXZ`JIL[JsubL�Sh

&ph �cbwb�IL[J`JILoaIL`JtQPSbLKlPSM~TcKfIw^}tpbLTOPq[JVY_utpKZbL�Sh� h �¨VYXZKf_u[ ��XZVEMYVYI¥ouVEK{PFRJP5�S_ �0�QPSKfVY`�_u[ � � PS[J`]TZHJV�PSMETZtQPSb8RJXZ_SRª_uX�TWIL_u[?_Sd�R�VY_uRpbwV�kzHJ_PSM~TWVE`�h

�ph �UVEMETZIw_u[ � h � h��Uh � MY_S[JKZIL`JVYXfK�TZHJVcMYPSKZVzkzHJVEXZV©IL[J`JI¥oUIL`JtQPSbLK�HQP�ouVcP�KZVYME_u[J`FMOHQPS[JMEVcTW_�PSM~TPS[p`]XfVYMYVEILoSV�P�KZVEMY_u[p`]Xf_utJ[J`r_Sd�RQP��u_ �ªKYh

�51435143 � K�K!I 0 2PB;=<EDLK H�� <EI2P P / I2PB;ONO;4P R � I DLF P!;O<ED

G�HJV�TW_qTOPSb!oqPSbLtJV�d�Xf_u^1PSM~TWIL[Js IwK�PNd�tJ[pMETWIL_u[ � �'� � ���J�e² d � � ��� ��� � d y�kzHJVEXZV � � = d ILKP�bLVEouVEb�_Sd�TWPSKfTZVYK}`pXWP�kz[�d�XZ_u^�TZHJVN`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[�`JILKZMEtJKZKfVY`�PS��_®oSVSy=PS[p` � = � � � �-��ILK�TWHpVR�VYXZMEVY[\TOPqsuV�_Sd¨_STWHpVYX�PSM~TW_uXfKYy � �8Z(!K9 # ypPqd¶TWVEXlVEoSVYX��u_u[JVeHQPSK�`JVYMEIw`JVE`?kzHpVETWHpVYXlTW_�PqMET�_uX�[J_ST�h

� � � � 2 ����� � � W�� ~ &(� 2 ,T�". #UHP!$� � �'� ���p� HI9;#+&(�;937/0� 2 !$E 37V+V\3-. #Y!$EF9�A HI98.�!$�(#rH+�(,(!$,^9 37#D37V+V`,-#�3����(H+#Y���(,T/m` � E8!%2�O7HI9K.�!$�(#rH+�(,-H+#rHP��9�A 37�\O6HI9;9 #rE HP. #UVWJ6/0!$�"!$#%!$�(HP.x37V+VWJ4H+�". EF�x3$9 H+�-56H+�@` !$#+&� 37�\O � R

~ &(�4,T#UH+VWH+#UJ�2 EF!$/ �"!$#G3-. #rH+�-5�HI9�O-� ���"�xOm#%!0` � � � � � � � �J�pR

�c_STZIwMEV�TZHQPqT�kzHJVE[�[J_qT¤PSMETZIw[JsJypRªVE_uRJbwV�MYPSXZVePS��_utpTzTZHJV�RªVEXZMYVE[\TOPSsuV�_Sd!_STWHpVYXZK�kzHJ_FPSXfV[J_STlPSMETZIw[Jspy �ftJK�T�PSK�TZHJVE�NM�PSXfV�PS��_utpTmTWHJV{R�VYXfMYVE[vTWPSsuV{_qd8_STWHJVEXZKlkzHJ_�PqMET�kzHpVY[ TOPSxvIL[Js�TWHpVPSM~TWIw_S[?TZHJVY^|KZVEbLoSVYKYh��VFMY_utpbw`�HJP5oSVN`JVEKZMEXZIw��VY`�TWHJVFKZILTZtQPqTZIw_u["kzILTZH�TWHpXZVYV|oqPSXZIwPS�JbwVEKY² ����VYIw[ps]TWHpVNRJXfILoqPqTWV

tpTZIwbwI¥T��:d�XZ_S^ PqMETWIL[JsJy �]��VYIw[psFTWHpV}RªVEXZMEVY[\T�_Sd�PSM~TW_uXfKYy«PS[J` ��TWHpV}RJXZI¥oqPqTWVetpTWILbwI¥T��:d�XZ_u^ [J_qTPSM~TWIw[psJh ��tpT �ekm_utJbL`?�ªV�XZVE`JtJ[J`JPS[\T�²

� ��232 � U ��� !$E[37�(J|2 ,-�". #rHP!$� �}� � � ��� CD&-HP.�&BHI9[/0!$�"!$#%!$�(HP.x37V+VWJlH+�". EF�x3$9 H+�-5{H+�e` !$#'&w37EP57,-g/0� �(#+9�A #+&(� EF�B� � HI9 #+90312 ,T�". #UHP!$� �:� � � ��� CD&-HP.�&eHI9m37V 9K!u/0!$�"!$#%!$�(HP.x37V+VWJuH+�". EF�x3$9 H+�-5XH+� ` !$#+&37Er57,T/0� �(#+9�A 9 ,(.�&w#'&Q37#iH 2 �}�'� ���p�|j���� � � � � �J� Ai#+&(� � �:� � � � ���p�|j �:� ��� � � �J�R

Page 94: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

��

�c_uXf^NPqbwI��EIw[Js|TWHJV�RJXfILoqPqTZV}tpTWILbwI¥T��rd�Xf_u^�[p_STePSMETZIw[Js:TZ_ �YVYXf_]ILK{TWHJVEXZV~d�_uXZV�P MY_S[voSVY[JILVY[\TPS[J`rtJ[JXfVYK�TWXZILMETZILouVePSKfKZtJ^|RpTZIw_u[�h±!Iw[JPSbwb¥�ª²

� � � � 2 ����� � � W � ~ &(� E��HI9@9K!$/0�w9 ,�>. HP� �(#UVWJ VI!$C y$37VW,(� ������� 9 ,(.�&>#+&Q37# �F�'��������� �®� �

�:� � � �\�pRG�HJILK�^FVYPS[JK}TWHJPqT�ILdzI¥d!��`pXWP�kzK � � � �������FTWHJVE[ � � kzILbwb�[p_ST�PSM~T�y�XZVYsuPSXZ`JbLVYKfK�_Sd¤V~�URªVEMETWP§¦TWIL_u[JK�PS��_utpT���h|��[0_STZHJVYX�km_uXZ`JKEy¨TWPSKfTZVYKe`J_?^NP§TZTWVEX�KZ_u^|VEkzHJPqT�y8KZ_?TWHJPqTeVEouVE[�I¥d��zxv[J_5kzKTWHJPqT�VEoSVYXf�S_u[JV�kzIwbLb�PSM~T�kzILTWH"MEVYXfTWPSIw[\T���� � � �®�~y«HJV�KfTWILbwb¨k�_u[« ÒTePSM~T�ILd�HJV �Q[J`pKe`p_uIw[Js Kf_KZt �FMEIwVE[vTZbL� `pIwKfTWPSKfTZVEd�tJbihDG�HJIwK¤PSKfKZtJ^|VYK¤P�k�P5�?Kf_u^|VeR�VYX�ouVEXZKZVeVY�vtJILbwIL�JXZIwPph

2©P�oaIw[Js�`pVYKZMEXZIL�ªVE`)TZHJV�oqPSbwtpV�d�XZ_u^ PSM~TWIw[ps�PS[J` [J_qTrPSMETZIw[JsJylTZHJVAs\PS^|V�ILKNKZIL^FRpbL� P�vtJVYK�TWIL_u[�_Sd!MY_u^|RQPSXfIw[Js�TWHpV�VÏ�pR�VYM~TWVE`�oqPSbwtJVEKc_qd �F²�PSbwb�ME_u[JKftJ^FVEXZKc_u�JKZVEXfoSV�TWHpVYIwX¤RJXfILoqPqTWVtpTZIwbwI¥T���� � y!PS[p`�KZIL^}tJb¥TOPS[JVE_utJKfbL�A`JVEMYIL`JV|kzHpVETWHpVYX�TZ_]ME_u[JKftJ^FVF_uX�[J_STYy��QPqKZVY`�_u[�kzHJV~TWHJVEX£ � � � � ���J�Gj £ �)� ��� � � �J��_uXloaIwMEV�ouVYXfKWPph

� 3�� ��� @AC �YC �A;=C + > 07 �>

G�HJILK�KZVEMETZIw_u[ `JV �Q[JVEK�RJtJXZV©KfTWXZPqTWVEsS�FKf�a^F^|VETZXZILM �lP��SVYKZIwPS[ �©PqKZH VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZIwP�IL[NTWHpV{MY_u[\TZV~�aT_Sd¨TWHJV�^|_U`pVYb­ypPSbw_S[Js}kzILTZH?TZHJV�MYbL_uKZVEbL� XfVYbgP§TWVY`?VÏ�pR�VYM~TWVE`�`JVE^NPS[p`rd�tJ[pMETWIL_u[�hG�HJV�^FPS[J[JVEXNIL[ kzHJILMOH �lP��uVEKZIgPq[ �©PSKfH VY�vtJILbwIw�pXZIgP�kzILbwbz�ªV]`JV �J[JVY` IL[ TWHpIwKNMOHJPSRpTWVEX

XZVE�vtJIwXfVYKzT�k�_|[JVEk¯KZVETZKc_qd![J_qTOPqTZIw_u[�²!_u[JV�TW_|`JVYKfMYXfIw��VeKfVETZKc_Sd!PSM~TW_uXfKcPq[J`][p_u[U¦ÀPqMETW_SXZKYy¢Pq[J`_u[JV�TZ_|`pVYKZMEXZIL�ªV�TWHpVeKftJ� �fVEMETWI¥ouV�`JIwK�TWXZIL�JtpTZIw_u[:_qd � suILoSVY[ �Ïh��[ TWHpV�VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZIwP��ªVEbw_5k�yzP�R�VYXfKZ_u[ kzILbwb���V�Pq�JbwV?TW_�`JVYMEIw`JVrkzHJVETZHJVYXNTZ_�PSM~TN_SXF[J_qT

�QPSKfVY`rVY[\TWILXZVEbL�:tpRª_u[?HJILKl_uX�HJVEXz`JXWP�k _Sd � � h �¬VETzTWHJ_SKZV ��kzHJIwMOHrRJXZ_S^FRpT�TWHJV�MY_S[JKZtJ^|VYXlTZ_PSM~T{��V��� �y«PS[J`�TZHJ_uKfV�TWHJPqT{MYPStJKZV�TWHJV}ME_u[JKftJ^FVEXcTZ_:[J_ST{PSMET{PSK����zh©�lkzIwbLb¨PSKZKftJ^FVeTWHQP§TMY_S[JKZtJ^|VYXfKmkzHJ_}PSXZV¤Iw[J`pI��ªVYXZVE[\TmkzILbwbQ[J_ST�PSM~T�°abwVET�TWHpV �ÀKmkzHpIwMOHNIL[J`JtJMEV©IL[J`JI��ªVYXfVY[JMEVc��V����Yy^|V�PS[JIL[Js}TWHJPqT���������¤h

� � ������ �\# � � ����� ��� � G�HpVFPqMETW_SXZK�Iw[�TZHJV�^F_a`JVEb�PSXfV�MY_u^|RJbwV~TWVEbL�]`JVYKfMYXZIL�ªVE`"�v��TWHJV�RQP§¦XWPq^FV~TWVYX#�ÏyUPS[J`�TWHpV¤KfVETm_SdªRJtJXZVϦ�K�TWXWP§TWVYsq�|PSMETZIw_u[JK=P�oqPSILbgPS�JbLV�TW_�TZHJVY^ PSXfV�TW_�PSMET=_uX=[J_qT�PqMET�h

Page 95: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �

G�HJVEXZVEd�_SXZVSy�PNRJtJXfV�KfTZXWPqTZVYsS�]Kf�a^|^FV~TWXfIwM��lP��uVYKfIgPS[ �cPSKZH�VY�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^���HJVEXZVYIL[�XZV~d�VYXfXZVY`�TZ_PSK��¡PS["VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^] ¡�lIwK{ME_u^|RJbwV~TWVYb¥�r`JVYKfMYXZIL�ªVE`"�v��P:KZV~T � he±Q_uX{bwIL[JsutJILKfTZIwM�KZIL^FRJbLIwMEILT��uy��kzIwbLbQ_Sd¶TWVE[FKZP��r� �� ?IwK�PS[NVE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^r qTZ_�^|V�PS[r�¡IL[FVE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^ryu_u[Jb¥��^|VY^}��VYXfKm_SdªTWHJV¤KZV~T�� APSM~T� ¥h

��KZV~T �� �IwK�PS[AVE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^ I���PS[\�AIL[J`JILoaIL`JtQPSb8kzHJ_?`JXWP�kzK � � = �� �MOHp_U_uKfVYK�TW_?PqMET�ysuI¥ouVY[�TWHJVFRJXZIL_uX�IL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u["HJVEbw`��\�0TWHJVFIw[J`pILoaIw`JtJPSb=PS[J`�sSILouVE[�TWHJPqT�PSbLb=_STWHJVEX�RJbwP��uVYXfKPSXfV�RJbwP��UIL[Js�TWHJVeKfTZXWPqTZVYsS�A�¡PSMETcI��"��`JXWP�k¯TWPSKfTZVYK � � = �  ¥°«PS[p`�[J_|Iw[J`pILoaIw`JtJPSb�kzHJ_N`pXWP�kzK� � �= �� APSM~TWKYy¢suI¥ouVE[?TZHJV�KWPS^|V�Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�h

� ��� ��� ����!��� � , G�HJIwK�[p_STOPqTZIw_u[0PSbLbw_5kzK©TZHJV�d�_ubwbL_®kzIL[Js:`JV �Q[JI¥TWIw_S[JKY²�PSM~TWI¥ouV�MY_u[\oaILoaIwPSbwI¥T���ILKkzHJVE[ Kf_u^FVE_u[JV�kzHJ_SKZV"`JXWP�k _Sd � � IwK bLVYKZK:TZHQPS[ �YVEXZ_nMOHJ_a_uKZVEK TW_nPSM~T�h�G�HJPqT?IwKEy�� �� �� � �\� �� � � �vhA��[QPqMETWI¥ouV:ME_u[\oaILoaIgPSbLILT��"ILK�kzHJVE[�Kf_u^|VY_u[JVFkzHJ_uKZV `pXWP�k _Sd � � IwK�suXZVYPqTWVEXTWHJPS[ �EVYXf_FMOHJ_a_uKfVYKz[J_STzTW_|PSM~T�h=G�HQPqT¤ILKYy ��� ��� � ��� � �� � � �vhG�HJV©sSIwKfTm_Sd�TZHJVYKfV©`JV �Q[JI¥TWIw_S[JKmILKDTWHQPqTmILd«tpTWILbwI¥T���kmVYXZV©RJtJXZVEbL�|P�d�tJ[JMETZIw_u[F_Sd«TWPSKfTZVYKEyUTWHpVY[

VEoSVYX��u_u[JV{kzI¥TWH1� � � �ekm_utJbL`J[�  T�PSM~TmkzHJILbwV¤VEoSVYXf�S_u[JV©kzHp_}`JXWP�kzK � � j �ekm_utJbw`«h �UILTZtQPqTZIw_u[JK_Sd8PqMETWI¥ouVc_uXmIL[QPSM~TWILoSVcME_u[\oaILoaIgPSbLILT��}PSXZV¤TWHJ_uKfVckzHJVEXZVcKZ_u^|VY_u[pV©HQPSKmMOHQPS[JsSVY`NTZHJVYILXm��VYHQP�oaIw_SX�QPSKfVY`]_u[ TWHJV���VYHQP�oaIw_uX�_qd!_STZHJVYXfKYh

�51�� 176 � I2PM<�� 2I ;ONO; �L9�;=H HJD � �� �F P �� � %0 HJD � F�IL9 � �K�)ILTZHJ_utpT!KWP��aIw[Js�Pq[v�vTZHJIw[Js{PS�ª_StpT!TZHJVlRJXfIw_uXfKYySTZHJV�d�_ubLbw_5kzIw[Js¤IwK¨TWXftJV�d�_uX!PS[\���lP��SVYKZIwPS[ �©PqKZHVY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^]²

� ��232 � U � ��� ���"� ��� � � ) � #Y!w` �l3w#UEx37�Q9 V]37#UHP!$��2p37/lH+VWJ � `�3$9K�xO!$�z3���� � C�H+#'&�3 ���(H+#Y��(,-/m` � El!%21O7HI9K.�!$�(#UH+�(,-H+#rHP��9 R�~ &(� ��H+� ���,-H+VWHU`E H+,T/�A �� HI9�3M Z(!K9�9 HU`VWJu� / Z\#UJ �l9K� #*!%26!�Z(� �H+�(#Y� E y$37V 9 R

� `JVYKfIwXWPq�JbwV�XfV �Q[JVE^FVE[\Tckm_utJbL`r��V�TW_�HQP�ouV�P�MYtpTZ_ �"VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^]²

� ��� ��� �Y���� U(q f . ,-#Y!%s ���,-H+VWHU`E H+,T/ HI9XCD&(� EF� �� HI9e!%2X#+&(�42 !$E / � ��� ��� � 2 !$Ev9K!$/0�Z(!$H+�(# �� R1 aÂÕÇϵqÃ�Ú�ÇO·­ÌÍ¿Eµ¤Ê¥Ç~Å�Ì¡Ú¡Ì͹ZÃ�Ȫ¹fÂi¹DË5¹�Ù§µ®¹fË©Ì¡µ�¼�¹f¾À·iÌ¡¿~µ �5» �5» � »

Page 96: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

��[�TWHJV¤PS[QPqbL�aKZILK�_Sd¢TWHJV�TZHJXZVEV�M�PSKfVYKDkzHJIwMOH�d�_ubLbw_5k�yuPSbLbpVE�atpIwbwIL�JXZIwPcIL[}TWHJVld�tJbLbpIL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[M�PqKZV�kzIwbLb���V�MYtpTZ_ �ªKYy8XZVYPSKZ_u[JPS�JbwV}PSKZKftJ^FRUTWIw_S[JK{kzIwbLb!Iw[p`JtJMYV�MEtpTW_ ��VY�vtJILbwIw�pXZIgP|Iw[�TZHJV�M�PSKfV_Sd{PS[ntJ[JIw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWI¥ouV RJXfIw_uXEy�PS[J` PAMEtpTW_ � kzILbwblKfIw^|RJbL���ªVrPSKfKZtJ^|VY`�d�_uX}TWHpV]MYPSKZV?_Sd{PS[Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWI¥ouV{RptJ�JbwILM{RJXfIw_uXEh

� � ,���� ��B� ��� ���M�����. G�HJV `JVYMEIwKfIw_u[JK�^NPq`JV:�\��TZHJV PSM~TW_uXfK�PSXfV:^NPq`JVNtJKfIw[JsAR�_uK�TWVYXfIw_uXRJXf_u�QPS�JILbwI¥T���`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZIw_u[pKYyvPSXfXZILoSVY` P§TlPqd¶TZVYXmPS�JKf_uXZ�JIL[Js}Pqbwb�P�oSPqIwbgPq�JbwV�IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[�h¬�)I¥TWHJIL[TWHpV MY_u[\TWVÏ�aTF_qd¤TZHJIwK�MOHQPSRpTZVYXYy �lP��uVEKZIwPS[ntJRª`JPqTWIL[Jsn� �D�vtQPqTZIw_u[ ah �®��TOPSxqVYK�TWHJV bLIwxqVYbwILHJ_a_U`d�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[ ��� � � ) ��Pq[J`�TWHJVFRJXZIL_uX�`pVY[JKfILT�� �ª� ) ��PS[J`�RJXZ_a`JtJMEVYK�P�R�_uKfTZVYXfIw_uXe`JVY[pKZILT���_Sd )suI¥ouVY[ �m`JV �Q[pVY`]TZ_F��V

� � ���E� ) � �f� � ���'� � ) � ��� ) ����� � ���'� ���J� �����J���� �� � 2 �B� � �B� ���4�\�� ��� ���:���"�Y�B�Z�Y� � G�HJIwK=KfVYMETZIw_u[�`JV �Q[JVEKmTWHpV¤VÏ�URªVEMETWVE`N`JVE^NPq[J`�MYtJX�ouVPSKfKZ_aMYIgP§TWVY`FkzILTWHFV�PSMOH VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^ �� ¨h �{IwKfMYtJKfKZIL_u[:_Sd�TZHJV©IL^FRpbwIwMYPqTWIL_u[JKD_Sd�MYtpTZ_ ��VE�vtJIwbLIw�U¦XZIwP�ILK���VYKfTl`J_u[JV{IL[FTZHJV{MY_S[vTZV~�aTz_Sd¬TZHJV©VÏ�pR�VYM~TWVE`]`JVE^NPq[J`Nd�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[JKmTZHJVE�NIw^|RJbL��² �UVYM~TWIL_u[� h � h�Uh � kzIwbLbDKZHJ_5k TWHJPqTeMYtpTZ_ � VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgP PSXfVFXfVYbgP§TWVY`0TW_]^F_u[p_STW_u[pIwM�PqbwbL�]tJR\k�PSXZ`U¦ÕKZbL_uRJIw[psV~�UR�VYM~TWVY`n`JVE^NPq[J`�y!kzHJILbwV|[J_u[U¦ÕMYtpTZ_ � VY�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgP:kzIwbLb=HQP�ouV:[J_S[J^F_S[J_STW_S[JIwM|V~�UR�VYMETZVY`n`JVϦ^FPS[J`�hG!PqxaIL[Js�PSKlsSILouVE[:TWHJV©KZVET�� PS[J`:TWHpV©oqPSbwtJV©_Sd ) ypTWHpV©TW_STWPSb�[atp^}�ªVEX�_Sd8R�VY_uRJbLV�PSM~TWIw[ps

IwK��� � � ) � ���� ����� � ) ����� �

� ��VYbLIwV~d8PS��_utpT�«� � ��� �D^NP��|�ªVcTWHJ_utpsuH\Tl_Sd¨PSK�TWHJV©V~�URªVEMETZVY`?`JVY^FPS[J` sSILouVE[:VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^�� �yp^NPSRpRJIw[Js ) TW_�TWHpVeR�VYXfMYVE[vTWPSsuVe_Sd!PSMETZ_uXZKEh

�©M~TW_uX �f ÍK�oSPqbwtJV�d�XZ_u^PSM~TWIw[ps{suILoSVY[�TZHJV�PS��_5ouVlIL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u[�km_utJbw`��ªV ���%� � ����� �� � ) ���vh2c_5kmVEoSVYXYypILd ) IwK=[J_qT�xv[J_5kz[�y ��^�tJKfT�XZVEbL��_S[FTWHpV¤R�_uK�TWVYXfIw_uX=bLIwxSVEbwILHJ_U_a`}_Sd�PesSILouVE[FoqPSbLtJV�_Sd) ² � � ���E� ) � � � �Ïh�G�PSxvIw[Js�TWHJILKzIw[\TW_|PSMEMY_utJ[\TYy�TZHJV�VÏ�URªVEMETWVE`�tpTZIwbwI¥T��Nd�Xf_u^/PSM~TWIw[ps|ILK�TWHJVeKZtJ^_Sd �¥��TZHJV¤RQP��u_ �]suILoSVY[ ) � �j��TZHJV©bLIwxSVEbwILHJ_U_a`�_Sd ) � �ª_®oSVYX�PSbwbQR�_uKZKfIw�JbLV¤oqPSbLtJVYK�_Sd ) yaTZHQPqTmIwKY²

�� � ��� � � ����� � � ) ��� � � ���E� ) � � � ��� ) � � � h �5�

Page 97: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

���

�Õd �«� �� %� ) �|k�VEXZV0PS[ IL[voSVYX�TWIw�pbwV�d�tJ[pMETWIL_u[ _Sd ) ��KZVEV"�ªVEbw_5kc�~y¤KZ_�TZHQPqT TWHpVYXZVAVÏ�UIwKfTZK?Pd�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[ ) � � ���p�~y\TWHJVE[|kmV©ME_utJbL`�kzXfILTZV �f ÍK�R�VYXZMEVYI¥ouVY`NRJXZ_u�JPS�JIwbLILT��eTWHQP§T ��R�VYXZMEVY[\Tl_qd«TWHpVR�VY_uRJbLV{kzIwbLb«MY_S[JKZtJ^|VSy¢suI¥ouVE[ �� ¨y¢PSKY²

� � � �J��� � � ���E� ) � � ���J� � � � � �

PS[J` �D�vtQPqTWIL_u[ � h �uypTWHpVeVÏ�URªVEMETWVE`�tpTZIwbwI¥T��|_Sd�PqMETWIL[JsJyJME_utJbL`r��V�kzXZI¥TZTWVE[�PqK

h� � �'� � ���¢� � � ��������� ��51�� 143 � I2PM<�� 2I ;ONO; �L9�;=H HJD � 0 <EDL<JPM<ED ;OF � 0 HJD �

��V�`J_u[« ÒT¤�uV~T�xv[J_5kkzHJPqT�� _uX�� � bL_U_uxNbwIwxqV�IL[�VE�atpIwbwIL�JXZILtJ^r°pk�V�`J_u[�  Tc�SVET�xv[J_5k HJ_5kTWHpV¤VÏ�URªVEMETWVE`FoqPSbLtJV�_Sd ��ILKD`JVYXfILouVE`|d�Xf_u^ � � °a�ptpT=k�VzM�Pq[FK�TWIwbLbpK�TOPqTZVzTZHJV�d�_ubwbL_5kzIw[Js{XfVYbwPqTWIL_u[�²

� ������# � 2 U � f 9�9 ,-/0�1#'&Q37# ����� � ) � 37�\O � � ���E��� � ) � 937#UHI9'2 J ��� � � R � ~ &(� � � ��� �� � ) � HI9/0!$�"!$#Y!$�(HP.x37V+VWJmH+�". EF�x3$9 H+�-5{H+�v)�� �� HI9�3u. ,-#Y!%s ���,TH+VWHU`E H+,-/ R

,{[JVlk�_StJbw`�VÏ�pR�VYM~TDTWHQP§TDtJ[J`JVEXD[J_uXf^NPSbaMY_S[J`JILTZIw_u[pKYyuPqK�TWHJVl^|VY`pIgPS[}_qd¢MY_u[JKftJ^|VYX�TOPqKfTWVEKIw[pMYXZVYPSKZVEKYy�TWHJVrRªVEXZMEVY[\TOPSsSV]_SdcR�VY_uRJbLVrPSMETZIw[Js�km_utJbL` PSbLKZ_"Iw[pMYXZVYPSKZVqh G�HpIwK�TWHJVE_uXZVE^ KWP��aKTWHJPqT�KZtJMOHr�¡[J_SXZ^FPSbJMY_S[J`JILTZIw_u[pKY SIL^FRpbL��PeMEtpTW_ �?VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^rh%,�XEy\Iw[JHpVYXZVE[\T�TZ_�P�[J_S[U¦�MEtpTW_ �VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^�ILK�TZHJV©MEbgPSIL^$TWHJPqTmTZHJVYXfV©ILKmKf_u^FV¤XZVEsuIw_S[FIL[FkzHJILMOHNMY_S[JKZtJ^|VYXfKlbwILxvIw[Js{TZHJV©su_a_a`^|_uXZV{km_utJbL`rIL^FRpbL�|d�VEkmVYX¤MY_u[JKftJ^|Iw[JsJh±Q_uX{TWHJV�XfVY^FPSIw[J`pVYX{_Sd�TWHpV|MOHJPSRpTWVEXYy8�ckzILbwb�MY_u[JKfIw`JVEX�_u[Jb¥��MYtUTW_ ��VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgPphe��[�Kf_u^|V

_Sd8TWHpV�M�PSKfVYKz�ªVEbw_5k�ypTZHJIwK�kzILbwb��ªV�RpXZ_5ouVE[rTZ_��ªV{TZHJV�_u[Jb¥�NR�_uKZKfIw�JILbwI¥T��uyv^FVYPS[JIL[Js�TWHJPqTzsu_a_U`JKkzILTZH�tJR\k�PSXZ`U¦ÕKZbL_uRJIw[ps�V~�UR�VYM~TWVY`n`JVE^NPq[J`�MYtpXfouVEK�M�PS[�[p_ST}VÏ�pILKfTYh���[�_STZHJVYX�M�PSKfVYKYyDI¥T�kzILbwb��V�PSKfKZtJ^|VY`�°cTWHJV�ME_u^|^FVE[vTWPSXf��Pq�ª_5ouV�KZHJ_5kzK:TWHJPqTNTZHJIwKFIwKFP�RJbgPqtJKZIL�JbwV?�JtpT:[J_STNTZXZI¥oUIwPSbPSKfKZtJ^|RpTWIL_u[�h�f× ��¼ �"È«ÇEìË5¹ÀÙ§µ§¹fË©Ì͵�¼�¹Z¾�·­ÌÍ¿Eµ �®» �®» � »

Page 98: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �� 3�2 ��� @AC �YC �A;=C + /|Cp�m �7 >AC�� �;� �7:9 9 � � 8� <{� �A@ ����C�B C�7�u<|;��

� +e9DCY<|7

�FkzILbwbc`JVYKfMYXZIL�ªV0VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZIwP�Iw[ TWHpXZVYV0KZI¥TWtQP§TWIw_S[JKY²�TZHJV �QXZK�T]ILK:TWHJV0M�PqKZVAkzHJVYXfV0TZHJV"TWXZtpVRQPSXZPS^|VETWVEX ) IwK�xv[J_5kz[rkzI¥TWH MEVYXfTWPSIw[\T��Sh�G�HpVeKfVYME_u[J`rIwK�TZHJV�M�PSKfV{kzHJVYXfV�TZHJVYXfV�IwKl[J_�RJXfIw_uXIw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[0PS��_utpT ) h]G�HJVFTWHJILXZ`�ILKeTZHJVNMYPSKZVFkzHJVYXfVFTWHpVYXZVNIwKeMY_u^|^F_S[JbL�Axv[J_5kz[�RJXfIw_uXIw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[A���JtpT¤KfTZIwbLb«KZ_S^FV�tJ[JMEVYX�TOPSIL[vT��p��PS��_utpT ) hG�HJVe^NPSIL[ MY_u[pMYbwtpKZIw_S[JK�_Sd¨TWHJILK¤KfVYM~TWIw_S[]PqXZVePSK�d�_ubwbL_5kzKY²

� ��ILoSVY[}d�tJbLbUIL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[�y§PSbLbUVE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgP¤PSXZVlMEtpTW_ �:VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZIwPph8G�HJVYXfV�M�PS[���Vl^}tJb¥TWILRJbwVVE�atpIwbwIL�JXZIwPpy¬�JtpT�_u[Jb¥�"ILd�TZHJVN`pIwKfTZXZIL�JtpTWIL_u[0_SdlTOPqKfTWVEK�ILK�Kft��|MYIwVE[\TWbL�0ME_u[JMYVE[\TWXWP§TWVY`nP§TMEVYXfTWPSIw[?R�_uIw[\TZK�_uX�ILd¨TWHJV�tpTZIwbLILT��|d�XZ_u^�MY_u[pd�_SXZ^|ILT��FIwK�HJILsuH?VY[J_utpsuH�h � G�HpVY_uXfVY^ � � �

� �$RJXZIL_uX©`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[�_Sd=^|VY`pIgPS[JKEy ��� ) �~y�IL[J`JtJMEVYK�P:`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[]_qd=MYtpTZ_ �«KE°¬tJ[J`JVEXPSRpRJXZ_uRpXZIgP§TWVrPSKZKftJ^|RpTWIL_u[JK���[J_STWPS�Jb¥��d�tJbwbzIw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[nPS[J`�TWHQP§T ��� � � ) ��ILK|KfIw[JsSbwV~¦R�V�PSxqVY`¢�ÏyQTWHJV�`JILKfTWXfIw�JtUTWIw_S[ _Sd!MEtpTW_ �«KzIwKzbLVYKZKzME_u[JMYVE[\TWXWP§TWVY`�PSXZ_StJ[J`?TWHJV�MYVE[\TWVYXzTWHJPS[TZHJV©`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[F_qd¬^FVE`JIgPq[JKYh ��ILoSVY[:Kf_u^|VcRQPqXWPS^|VETZVYXZKEyJPSbLbQVY�vtJILbwIw�pXZIgP�PSXfV©VÏ�UTZXZVE^FVqh�½G�HJVY_SXZVY^ � � �

� �Õd ) ILKcTOPqxSVY[�TZ_NXfVYRJXfVYKZVE[\T�RJXZILMYVYK���KZVEV �UVEMETWIL_u[ � h � h�Uh � d�_uXc`JVETWPSIwbLKO�~yQTZHJVY[A`JVE^NPq[J`MEtJXfoSVYK�MYPS[ Kfbw_uR�V"tJR\klPqXZ`¯_u[pbL� I¥d}R�VY_uRJbLV0PSXZV0KZt��|MEIwVY[\TZbL�)MY_S[JMYVEXZ[JVE` kzILTZH HJ_5k_STZHJVYXfK©��VYHQP�oSVSy�_uX¤ILd�TOPSK�TWVEK�PSXZVeKZt �FMEIwVE[vTZbL�]HJ_u^|_usuVE[J_utJKEyªPqK©`JV �Q[JVY`A�\�]G�HJVY_SXZVY^� � h �UIw[JMEV�d�PSKZHJIL_u[ su_a_U`pKzPSXZV�_Sd¶TZVY[?tJKZVE`�PSKzVÏ�JPq^FRJbLVYK�_Sd#��I��ªVY[?su_a_U`JKEypTWHpIwK�RJbwPSMYVEKXfVYKfTZXZILMETWIL_u[JK�_u[?HJ_5k _S[JV�MY_utJbL`?^F_a`JVYbªTWHJVE^]h� �DXZ_uR�_uKZI¥TWIL_u[ � &��

� ��ILoSVY[Nd�tJbLbªIL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u[|PS��_utpT ) yJP}K��U^|^|VETWXfIwM¤`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZIw_u[NPSKZKftJXZVEK�tJK�TZHQPqT�TZHJVYXfVILK�PS[�VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^1kzILTZH�[p_AMY_u[\oaILoaIgPqbwILT��0V �«VEMETWKE°�PS[�tJR\k�PSXZ`a¦�bwVYPS[JIL[JsA`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZIw_u[PSKfKZtJXfVYK�tpK!TWHQP§T�TZHJVYXfVlV~�UIwK�TWK!PS[}VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^ kzILTZH}PSM~TWI¥ouV�ME_u[\oaILoaIgPSbLILT���°uPc`J_5kz[vk�PSXf`U¦bLV�PS[JIL[Js `JILKfTWXfIw�JtUTWIw_S["PSKZKftJXZVEK�tJK�TZHQPqT�TWHpVYXZV|IwK�Pq[0VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^ kzILTZH0IL[QPSM~TWILoSV�MY_u[a¦oaILoaIwPSbwI¥T��uh �½G�HJVE_uXZVE^ � ���

� ��ILoSVY[|PS[�tJ[JIL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZILouV�RJXZIL_uXYySTZHJVYXfVzM�PS[���V¤_S[JbL��_u[JVzMYtUTW_ � VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^rh � �DXZ_SRª_q¦KfILTWIL_u[ ���

Page 99: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �

� ��ILoSVY["PS["tJ[JIL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZILoSV�RJXfIw_uX{PS[J`"P:Kf�a^|^FV~TWXfIwM}`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[�y¢TWHJVEXZV�PSXfV�[J_ MY_u[a¦oaILoaIwPSbwI¥T��©V �«VEMETWKE°vsuILoSVY[�Pc`JILKfTWXfIw�JtUTWIw_S[ebLV�PS[pIw[Js�TW_5k�PSXZ`eTWHJV�R�_uKZI¥TWILoSVSy®TWHJVEXZV�PSXZVmPSMETZILoSVME_u[\oUI¥oaIgPSbLILT��|V �ªVYM~TWKY°�PS[p`rsSILouVE[rP�`pIwKfTZXZIL�JtpTWIL_u[:bLV�PS[JIL[Js}TW_5k�PSXZ` TZHJV�[JVYs\P§TWILoSVSypTZHJVYXfVPSXfV�Iw[QPqMETWI¥ouV�MY_S[voaI¥oUIwPSbwI¥T��NV �«VEMETZKYh � G�HpVY_uXfVY^ � ���

� ��ILoSVY[A_u[JV�`JIwK�TWXZIL�JtpTZIw_u[]_Sd�RJXZIL_uX©IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[ �QhE�����¤kzHJIwMOHAKZPqTWILK �QVEK{TWHJV�^|_u[J_qTW_u[JVbLIwxSVEbwILHJ_U_a`nXWPqTZIw_0RJXZ_SRªVEXfT��¯� 0�� n �m��kzILTZH XZVEKZR�VYMETNTW_�PS[p_STWHJVEXYy � k �����~hjG�HJVY[)Pq[v�VE�atpIwbwIL�JXZIwP©Iw[p`JtJMYVE`F�\� �QhY� � �!^}tJK�T=Iw[\ou_SbLouVzK�TWXZILMETZbL��d�V~k�VEX�PSMETZ_uXZKDTWHJPS[NPq[v�}VY�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgPIL[J`JtJMEVY`n�\� � k �����~yD^|V�PS[JIL[Js�TZHQPqT�^|_uXZVFRªVE_uRJbLVNkzIwbLb�PSM~T�h0��[�_STWHpVYX}km_uXZ`JKEym��VETfTWVEXPS`UouVYX�TWILKZIw[ps�^NPSxqVYKz^|_uXZV�R�VY_uRpbwV©k�PS[\TzTW_��Jtp�SyJkzHJVYXfV��Í��VETZTZVYXE QIwKl`JV �Q[JVE`�tJKfIw[Js�TWHpV0�� n ��h��½G�HJVY_SXZVY^ � 3�

�5102176 < 0 L9 �N7; 0,;ODLH"9!RC9 �KMI N4PMK

G�HJV"d�_ubwbL_5kzIw[Js�bLVY^|^NPSKFkzIwbwb©tJKZVE` Iw[ PSbLb©TWHJXfVYV0Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[QPSb¤M�PSKfVYKr�ªVEbw_5k�h � MEtpTW_ �VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^kzILbwbJ��V¤VYILTZHJVYX=RJXf_5ouVY[N_uX�PSKZKftJ^FVE`Fd�_uXDVYPSMOH:MYPSKZVqh �©K=KZtJMOH«yJP�KZIw[psubwV�R�_uIw[\T ���`JV �Q[JVYK{PS[APSXfV�P � ��� � � ��� �ÏyªKf_ PSbwb�kmV}[JVEVY`�TZ_ �Q[J`"P|RJtJXfV�KfTZXWPqTZVYsS���lP��uVEKZIwPS[ �©PqKZHVY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^�_qd�P�MYtUTW_ �Ad�_uXf^�ILKlTWHJV�KZIL[JsubLV�Rª_uIL[\T � � hG�HJV"MY_u[pKZtJ^|VYX:ILK:Iw[p`JI��ªVYXfVY[\T ILd�TZHJVAV~�UR�VYM~TWVY`jtpTZIwbwI¥T���d�XZ_u^ PSM~TWIw[ps�IwKNTZHJVAKWPq^FVAPqK

TWHpV:V~�UR�VYMETZVY`�tpTWILbwI¥T��Ad�XZ_u^ [J_ST�PqMETWIL[JsJhA±Q_uX�V�PSMOH � � yD`pV �Q[JV � ���'� � �N² d � d TW_���V:TWHpVR�_uIw[\TcKZtJMOH�TZHQPqT{I¥d�TWHpV�MYtUTW_ � ���ck�VEXZV�TZ_NVE�atJPSb � �®� � � �~y¢TWHpVY[A_u[JVekzHJ_:`JXfVEk � � km_utJbL`���VIw[p`JI��ªVYXfVY[\T�hD�ÕT¤KZ_SbLouVEKY²

�� � �)� � � ����� � � � �'� � ���� � ���¢��� � � ���E��� � � � ����� � �

� � �)� � � � � ��� � � � � � � ���� ����Q�f� � � ���E��� � � � ����� �� � hS�

+ # ���"��� � ��� � � U � 4 2G#'&(�cZ(!K9 #%� E HP!$EF9 � � ���E��� � ) � 937#UHI9'2 J � � � � A�37�\O8#+&(�|VWH ��� VWHI&(!K!OD2 ,T�". #UHP!$���� � � HI9l.�!$�(#rH+�(,(!$,^9�A�#'&(� � � �®� � � � HI943w.�!$�(#rH+�(,(!$,^9�AiH+�". EF�x3$9 H+�-5|2 ,T�". #UHP!$� !%2 � � R

G�HJIwKzILKlTWHJV�TW_a_ub«kmVe[JVYVE`rTZ_ �J[J`]TZHJV�VY�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgPp²

Page 100: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� &� ��# �����M#), �(q�� H+y7� � #'&Q37#8#+&(�6Z(!K9 #Y� E HP!$EF9 � � ���E� � � ) � 937#UHI9'2 J � � � � 37�\Oe#'&(�BVWH ��� VWHI&(!K!O2 ,-�". #rHP!$� �!��� � HI96.�!$�(#UH+�(, !$,�9� �#+&(� �#+&(�6. ,T#Y!%s*gY#UJ Z(�|Z\,-EF��9 #rEN37#Y�P57J��;37J^��9 HU37���[3$9�&����,-H+VWHU`gE H+,T/ ��� HI9u37#�#+&(�0y$37VW, � Mr9 �e!%2 � � 2 !$E�CD&-HP.�& � �®�'� � � � � � R ~ &(� EF�0HI9B37VWCi37JK9u37# VI�x3$9 #1!$�"�. ,-#%!%s ���,-H+VWHU`E H+,T/�AL� H+#+&(� E137#�9K!$/0� ���(H+#%�4y$37VW,(�6!$E137# ����� �tR

��VFM�PS[�PSbwKf_rTZXWPS[JK�d�_uXZ^1TZHJIwKeXZVEKZtJb¥T�TZ_]TWHpVFKfRQPSMYVN_Sd �ªh?G�HJVE_uXZVE^ ��]KfTWPqTWVE`�TWHJPqT�I¥dTWHpVYXZV�IwK¤PFMEtpTW_ ��VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^rypTWHpVY[ ��� �� � �f�zILK©P�^F_S[J_STW_S[JIwMYPSbwb¥�N`JVEMYXfV�PSKfIw[JsNd�tp[JMETZIw_u[r_Sd�Ïy8KZ_ TWHpIwK�IwK�PNTZXZI¥oUIwPSb�TZXWPS[pKfd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u[«h �{V �Q[JV � �5� � � �e² d � � � � ���DPSK{TWHJV�R�VYXfMYVY[\TWPSsuV�_SdR�VY_uRJbLV|kzHp_�k�_StJbw`�[pVYVY`�TW_�PqMET�TZ_�^FPSxSVF_u[JV|kzHJ_�`JXfVEk � � IL[J`JI��«VEXZVY[\T��ªV~T�k�VEVY[�PSM~TWIw_S[PS[J` Iw[QPSM~TWIL_u[�h �Õd � � HJPSKN`JVE[JKZI¥T�� �!�'�f�~ylTZHJVY[ bwVET��F�'�f�|��V]TZHJV�MEtJ^}tJbwPqTWI¥ouVr`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZIw_u[d�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[0� $���±D��_Sd �Ïh �cbwKf_Jyp[J_qTWV{TWHJPqT�ILd � � kmVYXfV�TZHJV�MYtUTW_ �AIL[?P}MYtpTZ_ �AVE�atpIwbwIL�JXZILtJ^ryUPq[J`ILd �D��VYbLIwV~ouVYKmTWHQPqT�TWHJV � � KlPSXZV�`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWVE`��� � � � � ) �~yUTZHJVY[ � �� � �'� � � ) �mR�VYXfMYVY[\TzkzIwbLb«PqMET�hnzVYKfTWPqTWIL[Js $�_uXZ_SbwbgPqXf� ���Iw[ TWHJV�KfRQPSMYV�_Sd �ª²

� ��# �����M#), ��W ~ &(�6. ,-#Y!%sL9�2 !$E�. ,T#Y!%s*gY#rJ�Z(�|Z\,-E��89 #UEN37#%�P57J���37J���9 HU37���83$9�&����,TH+VWHU`E HU3B37EF�37#�#+&(�8y$37VW,(� Mr9 ��!%2 � � 2 !$E CD&-HP.�& � � � � � ��� � ��� � �'� � �pR 4 2 � � � � � �Lj � � � � � � � � 2 !$E[37V+V � � A�#+&(� �� ��� � HI9�37� ���,-H+VWHU`E H+,T/ M�CD&(� EF�[�"!0!$�"��3-. #'9 � R

��[ _STZHJVYX?km_uXZ`JKEy�k�V�[JVYVE`¯_u[Jb¥� �Q[J` P R�VYXZKf_u[ kzHp_ km_utJbw` �ªV0Iw[p`JI��ªVYXfVY[\TrILd�TZHJVE�HQPSRpRªVE[JVY`|TW_e�ªV�TWHpVcMEtpTW_ ��h �UtpMOH:P�RªVEXZKZ_S[N^FP5�}MY_u[JKfIwK�TWVY[\TZbL����V©P�MEtpTW_ �rIL[|VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^ryPS[J`�PFR�VYXfKZ_u[�^FP��?_u[Jb¥� �ªV�PFMEtpTW_ �0IL[]VE�atpIwbwIL�JXZILtJ^%I¥d�HJVeIwK¤Iw[J`pI��ªVYXZVE[\T©suI¥ouVE[]TWHJPqT©HpV�ILKTWHpVeMEtpTW_ �!h

�5102143 � I NON ;OD �)<E910 H�PB;=<ED

G�HJILK�KZVYM~TWIL_u[�`pIwKZMEtJKZKfVYK�TWHJV�d�tJbLb!IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[]M�PSKfVSy¨`JV �Q[pVY`"TW_?^FVYPS[ATWHQP§T�ILT�IwK©MY_u^|^F_S[xv[J_5kzbwVE`JsuV�TWHQP§T¤TZHJV�RQPSXZPS^FV~TWVEX ) VY�vtQPqbwKzKZ_u^|V��p�UVY`roqPSbwtJV �AkzI¥TWH?MYVEXfTOPqIw[\T��uhG�HJV©MYP�ouV�P§TWKlPq�ª_utUT�kzHpVY[NkmV©PqXZVcPSKZKftJXZVE` PeMEtpTW_ �?VY�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^%�iPS[p`|TZHJVYXfVEd�_uXfVc^|_u[J_q¦

TW_S[JIwM�VÏ�pR�VYM~TWVE`�`JVE^NPS[p`¢�l�ªVEMY_u^|V�^F_a_ST�IL[ TWHJV�d�tJbLb�Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[NMYPSKZVq²

� ��232 � ��U�� H+y7� �42 ,TV+V"H+� 2 !$E /m37#UHP!$�QAi37V+V^Z(� E+2 ��. #�9 #UEN37#%�P57J���37J���9 HU37���83$9�&@���,-H+VWHU`E HU3037EF�. ,-#%!%s ���,-H+VWHU`E HU3 R

Page 101: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �

G�HJIwK�XfVYKZtpbLT�`JIL`"[J_ST�^FPSxSV�PS[\�"PqKZKZtp^FRpTZIw_u[pK�PS�ª_StpT{TWHpV�d�_SXZ^-_SdmTZHJV�`JILKfTWXfIw�JtUTWIw_S[�_SdTOPqKfTWVEK ��� � �ÏyªPq[J`�XfVY�vtJIwXfVYKc_u[JbL� TZHJV�^|_u[J_qTW_u[JILMYI¥T��Nd�XZ_S^ �©KZKftJ^|RpTWIL_u[ � ��kzILTZH�XZVEs\PSXf`JK¤TZ_TWHpV�d�tp[JMETZIw_u[ �:� � � ���~h±QXZ_u^�HJVYXfVSy¢MY_u^|RJbLIwM�P§TWIw_S[JK�VE[JKZtJVq°¢KZ_u^|V�V~�pPS^|RJbwVEKz^NP��:��V�HJVYbLRpd�tJbih

±!ILsutJXZV � h �u²�TZHJV��¡[p_uXZ^FPSb­ UM�PSKfV

� T S�TVU TW � ��� 2 ��� � � 6\����� ����# 2 �!�. �B� �

G�PSxSV ��� � � ) � ���,� ) � �®�Ïy©Pq[J` TOPSxqV�TWHJV�oqPSbLtJV�d�tJ[JM~TWIw_S[ TW_n�ªVAbLIw[JVYPSX:Pq[J`)KZVYRJPSXWPS�pbwVS²� �'� ���J��� � � _ � ��Õd _ � �SyvTZHJVY[�kmVcHQP�oSVzTZHJVzM�PSKfVcIL[|±!IwsutpXZV � h �u² � �5�'� � �!IwK�TWHpV¤K�TWXZPSIwsuH\T=bLIw[JVq° ��� �N� � � � �\�

IwKcTWHJV�MYtpXfouVqh�G�HJV�VY�vtQPqTZIw_u[ � ���'� � �!� � � �F�'� � � ) �©IwK�KZPqTWILK �QVE`0PqT�TWHJV�MEXZ_uKfKZIL[Js?_SdmTZHJVYKfVT�km_NMYtpXfouVEKYy�^FVYPS[JIL[Js�TWHQPqTzTZHJIwKzIwK�TZHJV�bw_aM�PqTZIw_u[ _Sd�PS[\�?VY�vtJILbwIw�pXZIgPUhJ$�bwVYPSXZb¥�uyJTWHpVYXZVeIwK�_S[JbL�_u[JV�MEXZ_uKfKZIw[ps|R�_uIL[vTYyQPS[J`?TWHpVYXZV~d�_uXZVeP�tJ[JIL�vtJV�VY�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^rh$�_u^|RQPSXWP§TWILoSV?KfTOP§TWIwMEKNPqXZV?KZIL^FRJbLV Iw[nTWHJILK�M�PSKfVS²�I¥d ) XZIwKfVYK�d�XZ_u^ �YVYXf_�TZ_�P0Rª_uKfILTZILouV

oqPSbwtpVSy\TWHJV¤MYtpXfouVcTWXWPq[JKZbwPqTWVEK=TZ_�TZHJVcXfIwsuH\TYyUPq[J`FTZHJVYXfVEd�_uXfV¤TZHJVcMEtpTW_ �rd�PqbwbwKEh �UIL[JMYVzTWHpVcMEtpTW_ �d�PSbLbwKYyp^F_uXfV�RªVE_uRJbwVePSM~T�hm��[�_STZHJVYX�km_uXZ`JKEyªI¥d!I¥T¤IwKzXZV~ouV�PqbwVY`rTWHQP§Tc^|_uXfVeR�VY_SRJbwV�bwILxSVeP�su_U_a`�yTWHpVY[r^F_uXfV�RªVE_uRJbLV{kzIwbwb«MY_u[JKftJ^|VSh

Page 102: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �

±!ILsutJXfV � ha²D�Õd!R�VY_uRpbwV�M�PSXfV�VY[J_StJsuH�Pq�ª_utUT �ªyJR�VYXfoSVYXfKZV�VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgP}PSRpRªVYPSXYh

� T S�TVU TVU � ��� 2 ��� � � 6\����� � �\����# 2 �B�. �B� �

G�HJV�MYPSKZV _ � Uy�Kf_ � �'� ���J� � � � � �ªIwK{^�tJMOH"^F_uXfV�IL[vTZVYXfVYKfTZIw[Jsph �¤_5k�ME_u[JKZtp^FVEXZK�PSXfVT�kzIwMEVePSKzIw[\TWVEXZVYK�TWVE`�Iw[ TZHJV�R�VYXfMYVE[vTWPSsuVe_Sd!PSMETZ_uXZK�TWHJPS[]IL[ TWHJV�su_a_U`?I¥TWKZVEbLdÀyQPq[J`rTZHJV�XZVEKZtJb¥TIwK¤PSKzIL[�±!ILsutJXfV � hah�G�HJVEXZV�PSXZV�TWHJXfVYVeRª_SKZKZIL�JbwV�MEtpTW_ �«KEyªPq[J`]TZHJV�Kf_UMEIwV~T��?PSsuXfVYVYIL[Js|_u[�Pq[v�_u[JV�_Sd=TWHJVE^ ILK�P �©PqKZH"VY�vtJILbwIw�pXZIwtp^]h ,{[JV�k�P5�]TW_ XfVYKZ_SbLouV�TWHJILK{IwK¤TW_ ^FPSxSV�P:R�VYKfKZIL^FILKZ^PSKfKZtJ^|RpTWIL_u[�y�TWHQPqT{suILoSVY[0PNd�VEkVY�vtJILbwIL�JXZIwPpyªV~ouVEXf�u_S[JV|PSsuXZVEVYK�_u[�TZHJV�_u[JV�kzILTWH�TZHJV}bL_®kmVYK�T[vtJ^}��VYXz_Sd�RªVE_uRJbLV�PSMETZIw[Js]�iPq[J`rTZHJVYXfVEd�_uXfV�TWHJV�HJILsuHJVYK�T�oqPSbwtJV�_qd �f�ÏhG�HJV{ME_u^FRJPSXWPqTZILoSV¤K�TOPqTZIwMEKmd�_uX=TWHJVcRªVEKZKfIw^|IwKfT©��_uX�TZHJV©_SRpTWIL^FILKfTÏ�!MYPSKZVcIwK=ouVEXf�FKZIw^|RJbLVS²�PqK

TWHpV�^|V�PS[]_Sd�TWHpV�`JILKfTWXfIw�JtUTWIw_S[rXfIwKfVYKYy � � d�PSbLbwK¤PS[J`�^|_uXfVeR�VY_SRJbwV�PSMETYh¤G�HpVYXZV�IwKcP��ftJ^|R�IL[TWHpV�oqPSbLtJV�_Sd¨TWHJV�MEtpTW_ �0P§T¤P�MEVYX�TOPSIL[?oqPSbLtJV|�iPqKzTZHJV����� QMYXZ_SKZKZVEK¤TZHJV�bwIL[JV5�Ïh

0]tJMOH ^F_uXfVAIw[\TWVEXZVEKfTWIL[JsnIwK:TZHJV��¡^|_a`JVYXZPqTWIL_u[� �MYPSKZVq²nILdeMY_u[pKZtJ^|VYXfK�PSsSXZVYVAtpRª_u[)TWHpV^|Iw`J`JbLV�_Sd�TWHpV�TWHpXZVYV�VY�vtJILbwIw�pXZIgPUypTWHJVE["PSK � IL[JMYXfV�PSKfVYKEy ���©PSbLKZ_FIw[JMEXZV�PqKZVYKEy«^|V�PS[pIw[Js�TWHQP§T� � ��� ��RªVE_uRJbwV|MY_S[JKZtJ^|VSh ��VE_uRJbwVN^NP��"MY_a_uXf`JIw[QP§TWV|_u[�TWHpIwK�^|Iw`p`JbwV�VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^]y¬�ptpT}TWHpVVY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^�ILKztJ[JKfTWPS�JbLVS²�ILd�RªVE_uRJbwV�TZHJIw[JxFTWHJVeMYtpTZ_ �"IwKzR�VYX�TWtJXf�ªVE`]TW_�TWHpVebLVEd¶T¤_Sd � � yJTWHJILKkm_utJbw`�_u[pbL��bwV�Pq`�TZ_eP{suXZVYPqTWVEXDKZHJI¥d¶TDTW_�TWHJV�bLVEd¶TYyuVEoSVY[\TWtQPqbwbL�}XZV�PqMOHJIw[Js�TZHJV�bwV~d¶TW^|_uKfTDMEXZ_uKfKZIL[JsR�_uIw[\T�ypPS[J` KfIw^|IwbgPqXZbL��kzILTWH?P}KfHJILd¶T�TW_}TWHpV�XZIwsSHvTYh�G�HJVEXZVEd�_SXZV{TWHpV�VY�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^ R�_uIw[\T�M�PS[?��V

Page 103: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

TWHp_utJsuH\Te_Sd�PqK�TZHJV|`JILoaIw`pIw[Js bLIw[JV���VET�kmVYVE[�Rª_SIw[\TWK{kzHJILMOH�bLV�PS`"�\� #�37#��!$�(�"� /0� �(# TW_]P bw_5k� � Pq[J`?Rª_uIL[\TWKlkzHJILMOH]bLV�PS` TW_|P�HJILsuH � � °JKZIL[JMYV�TWHpIwK�IwK�IL[JMYXfV�PSKfIw[JspypTWHJV�[vtJ^}��VYX�_qd!R�_uIw[\TZKkzHJILMOH�bLV�PS`"TW_?HJILsuH"MY_u[JKftJ^|RpTWIL_u[�XZPqTWVEK�Iw[JMEXZV�PqKZVYK�PSK�TWHpV|^|V�Pq["TWPSKfTZV|d�_SX{TWHJV|PSM~TWIw_S[0_SXsu_a_U` IL[JMYXfV�PSKfVYKEy�ME_u[JKfIwKfTZVY[\T¤kzILTWH?IL[vTZtJILTZIw_u[«h

� � ����# �!�L# � � ��� ��� G�HJVYKfVFVÏ�JPq^FRJbLVYK�KfHJ_5k,TWHQP§T�ILd=TWHJV�`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[�_Sd�TOPSK�TWVEKeILK�`JI��ªtJKfVVY[p_utJsuHj_uX0��VE�vtJILoqPSbLVY[\TWb¥�J�FTZHJVA`JVEKZIwXfVAd�_uX MY_u[Ud�_uXZ^|ILT�� IwK bL_®k VY[p_utJsuH�ycTWHJVE[jTZHJVYXfV"kzILbwb��VF_u[pbL�"_u[JVFVY�vtJILbwIw�pXZIwtp^]h|G�HJVFd�_Sbwbw_5kzIL[Js?XZVYKftJbLTZK�VÏ�URJbgPSIL[�Kft��|MYILVY[\T�MY_S[J`JILTZIw_u[pK�d�_SX�_u[pVVY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^]h

+ # ���"��� � ��� � � � � ~ &(� ��� � �!��� � ) � /m37Jz#P3 ���e37�(J�2 !$E /�Am37�\O #+&(��ZQ37EN37/0� #Y� E�) C�H+V+V` � �$�"!$C��>#%! &Q37y7�w#+&(�@y$37VW,(� � C�H+#'&a.�� E #P37H+�(#rJ R 4 282 !$E@37�(J ���,-H+VWHU`E H+,T/�Z(!$H+�(# � � � A��� � � �8� � �������

�� � �f� 2 !$El37V+V �[j � A;#+&(� � #+&(� EF�lC�H+V+V ` �0!$�(VWJ@!$�"�0���,-H+VWHU`E H+,T/�2 !$E6#+&(�157H+y7� �

��R

� ������# � 2 �!S ~ &(� �i� � ����� � ) � /m37J #P3 ����37�(J02 !$E /�A�37�\Oz#'&(�mZQ37EN37/0� #%� E�) C�H+V+V�` ��$�"!$C�� #Y!B&Q37y7�6#'&(�{y$37VW,(� � C�H+#'& .�� E #P37H+�(#UJ R 4 2 �!�'�f� � � ��� �

�� �'���¥� 2 !$E{37V+V � � ��� A;#'&(� � #'&(� EF�

C�H+V+V ` �l!$�(VWJv!$�"�6���,-H+VWHU`E H+,-/ 2 !$E137�(J ��R

G�HJV¤bwVEd¶T�¦�HQPq[J`�KZIL`JV�_Sd�TWHJVzIw[pVY�vtQPSbLILT���Iw[�TWHJILKDKfTWPqTWVE^FVE[vT=ILK�TWHJVz`JVEXZI¥oSP§TWILoSV�_Sd�TWHJV $���±�ykzHJILbwV{TWHpVeXfIwsuH\T�¦�HQPS[p`rKfIw`JV�ILKzTZHJV�`JVYXfILoqPqTZILouV�_Sd � �®� �f�~yQKZ_�TWHpIwK�KfTWPqTWVE^FVE[\T©HJ_Sbw`JKlkzHJVE[�TWHpV$���±AIwKDVÏ�pRJPS[J`JIL[Js�^|_uXfVlKZbL_®kzb¥�}TWHJPS[ � � �'�f�!ILKDMY_u[\TWXZPSMETZIw[Js � �c_STZIwMEVlTWHQPqT � � �� �!IwK=PSb¥klP��aK[JVEs\PqTWI¥ouV �­h��[ k�_uXf`JKYy¤TWHJILK:^|V�PS[JK:TZHQPqT:TZHJV�oqPSbwtpV�d�XZ_u^ MY_S[pd�_uXZ^|Iw[ps�V~�URQPq[J`JKr�atpIwMOxvbL�XZVEbgPqTZILoSVlTW_�TWHJVz^|_uKfT=ME_u[JMEVY[\TWXZPqTWVE`NRQPSX�TWK=_Sd�TWHJVz`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[�h¨�ÕdªTZHJV � ��±AHQPqK�bL_5k R�V�PSxvKEy_uX¤ILd � � �'�f��d�PSbwbLKlouVEXf�]�atpIwMOxvbL�Sy�TZHJVY[rTWHJVEXZV�kzILbwb¬��V�_u[pbL� _u[pV�VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^]h�G�HJILKcME_u[J`JI¥TWIw_S[IwK�Kft��|MYILVY[\Tcd�_SXzP�tp[JIw�vtJV�VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^]ya�JtpT¤[J_qTz[JVYMEVYKZKZPSXf�Sh

� T S�TVU T�� � ��� ����Z�Y# ���\�������� ��� [���Y� �%�

��ouVE[FTWHp_utJsuH ) k�PSK=TOPSxqVY[FPSK �p�UVY`FPS��_®oSVSyaILTD^FP��}HQP�oSVc��VYVE[F`JXZP�kz[Fd�XZ_S^,P�`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZIw_u[��� ) �c��VEd�_SXZV}��VYIL[Js �p�UVE`�Pq[J`A^NPq`JV�ME_u^F^|_u[]xa[p_®kzbLVY`JsSVSh�±Q_uX©VÏ�pPS^FRpbwVSy�TWHJV�^FVE`JIgPS[]_Sd^|_®oaILV�VY[ �f_5�\Pq�JIwbLILT���^FP�����V�_u�JKZVEXfoSVY`�TZ_]HQP�oSVF`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[ ��� ) �Ïh|�)HJVE[�P [JV~k�^F_5oaIwV

Page 104: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

MY_S^FVEK¬_utpT�y®TWHpVD^FVE`JIgPS[�_qdpI¥TWK¬�vtQPSbLILT��{ILK�`JXZP5kz[�d�XZ_S^ ��� ) �ÏySPS[p`eXfVEoaIwV~k�VEXZK¨XZV~ouV�PqbvTZHJVDoqPSbwtJV_Sd ) TW_�TWHpVeoaIwV~kzIw[Js�RJtp�JbwILMSh�G�HJV�^|_a`JVYb¬ILKlTWHJVE[�PSKcPS��_®oSVS² ) IwKzP �p�UVY`«yªxv[J_5kz[�KfM�PSbwPSXYyPS[J`�G�HJVE_uXZVE^ � � KfHJ_5k�VE` TWHQP§TFI¥d©MEVYX�TOPSIL[�ME_u[J`JI¥TWIL_u[JK�HJ_ubL`�ymTZHJVY[ ���®� ) �}IwK|P�d�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[RJXf_U`JtpMYIw[ps|_S[JbL�N_u[JV�VY�vtJILbwIw�pXZIwtp^ d�_SX�V�PSMOH��p�UVY`]oqPSbLtJV�_Sd ) h

�¬VET ���� �8�{��V�TZHJV�d�tJ[JMETZIw_u["^FPSRJRJIL[Js oqPSbwtJVEK�_Sd �nTW_?TWHJV�VE�atpIwbwIL�JXZILtJ^ ����TWHQP§TeTZHJVE�Iw[p`JtJMYVqh

��I¥ouVE[�TWHJV}_SXZIwsSIw[QPSb � �@37�(#%� `pIwKfTZXZIL�JtpTWIL_u[�_qd �ª� ) �~y«TZHJVY[«y«kzHQPqT�ILKcTZHJV � �X37�(#%� `JILKfTWXfI¥¦�JtpTZIw_u[0_Sd ���O�G�HJVFd�_ubLbw_5kzIw[ps?TZHJVY_SXZVY^�TZHJVY[�KWP��aK�TWHQP§T�tJ[p`JVYX�PSRJRJXf_uRJXZIwPqTWV�ME_u[J`JI¥TWIw_S[JKYyTWHpVe`pIwKfTZXZIL�JtpTWIL_u[ _Sd � � ILK¤P�d�P§Tf¦ÕTWPSIwbLVY`:_S[JV�XZVYbwPqTWI¥ouV©TZ_ ��� ) �~h

� ������# � 2 � � ~ &(�1� ��37�(#Y�4O7HI9 #UE HU`,-#UHP!$� !%2�#'&(��/0�xO7HU37�m) HI9 ��� ) � A�CD&-HP.�&w.x37�X#P3 ���437�(J2 !$E / R f 2 #%� E4O7EN37C�H+�-5 � 2 EF!$/ ��� ) � A � HI9 �$�"!$C��XC�H+#'&@.�� E #P37H+�(#UJ R f 9�9 ,T/0�8#'&(� ��� � �����ª�HI9;9 H+�-57VI� gIZ(�x3 ���xO$AcC�H+#'&v3{/m3 � H+/l,-/ y$37VW, �4!%2 ��� �ª��� hb Ai37�\O6#+&(��y$37VW,(� 2 ,T�". #UHP!$�XHI9 VWH+�"�x37E ��:� � ���J� � _ � � �pR;S � # ��� ���O� ` �[#+&(�l� �u37�(#%��O7HI9 #UE HU`,T#UHP!$� !%2 ��� M%` �'2 !$EF� � HI9 �$�"!$C�� � R� H+y7� �@#+&(��9K�[3$9�9 ,-/ Z\#UHP!$�Q9�A #+&(�8EN37#UHP! ��� ) ��� ��� � � � ) �Z� HI9�9 H+�-57VI� gIZ(�x3 ���xO6C�H+#+&u3�Z(�x3 �{37#

#+&(�iZ(!$H+�(# CD&(� EF� � � ���5� �8�Rl~ &Q37#DHI9�A ��� ���O� HI9�VI��9�9[.�!$�".�� �(#rEN37#Y�xO6#%!$Ci37ENO6#'&(�[.�� �(#Y� E�#+&Q37���� ) �pR

��I¥ouVE[rTZHJV�PqKZKZtp^FRpTZIw_u[pKcPq�ª_utUT��!��� �lPq[J` �N�'� ���J��TZHJV�MY_u[J`pILTWIL_u[JKz_Sd�G�HJVY_SXZVY^ � � [J_5kPSRJRpbL�uyUKZ_�TWHpVYXZV{kzILbwbª�ªV�_u[pbL�F_u[JV{MEtpTW_ ��d�_uX�PS[\�:sSILouVE[ oSPqbwtJV{_qd ) yJPS[J` ���5� ) ��ILK�TWXftJbL�NPd�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[�h

n¤V~TWtJXf[JIw[ps�TW_�TZHJV:VÏ�JPq^FRJbLVSy�I¥dz^F_5oaIwVF�vtQPSbwI¥T��"IwK�[J_uXZ^FPSbLbL�A`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWVE`�y�TWHJVE[�^F_5oaIwVXZV~TWtJXf[JK{kzIwbLb���V}d�PqT�¦ÕTOPqIwbwVE`�h �{V ��Pq[JVE��PS[J`A��PqbwbwK}� � � � �iy¬R � � � u�cKfTZtJ`JILVY`A^|_®oaILV}XZV~TWtJXf[JKPS[J` d�_StJ[J`)V~�pPSM~TWbL��TWHpIwKY² fG�HJVAVE[J`U¦Õ_Sdg¦�XftJ[ _uXNTZ_STOPSbcXZV~ouVY[vtJV"`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[ d�_uXN^F_STZIw_u[RJILMETWtpXZVYK�hYhEhZ[JV~ouVYX��vtJI¥TWVeXZVYPSMOHJVYK©bw_us|[J_uXf^NPSbLILT���°QILT¤HQPqKcd�PqTfTWVYXzTOPqIwbwK�TZHQPS[]TZHJV�bL_us|[J_uXZ^FPSbPS[J`r^FPSKZK�R�_uIw[\TZKzPqTzTWHJV�d�PSX�XfIwsuH\T�yUkzHJVYXfV�TZHJV�KZtJR�VYXfKfTWPSXZKcPSXZV�bL_UMYPqTWVE`�h �$�_u[\TWIL[atpIw[Js|TWHJV}VÏ�pPS^FRpbwVeIw[]TZHJV�ME_u[\TWVÏ�UT{_Sd�TWHpV�TWHpVY_uXfVY^ry ��� ) ��� ��� � � � ) �Z�¤ILKcKfIw[JsSbwV~¦

R�V�PSxqVY`�y�KZ_rILTWK�IL[voSVYXfKZV�� ��� � � � ) �Z������� ) � ��MYPS[���V�`JVYKfMYXfIw��VY`�PqK��ÍKZIL[JsubLV~¦ÕTZXZ_utpsuHJVY`« Lh �©bLKZ_JyG�HJVE_uXZVE^ � ���ªVEbw_5k kzILbwbªKZHJ_5k TZHQPqT����5� �\��� �pyJKf_|TZHJIwK�ILKlkzHJVYXfV�TWHJV�[QPS`pIwX�_Sd8TWHpV�TZXZ_utpsuHkzIwbLb��ªVrbw_aM�P§TWVY`«h G�HJVEKZV�d�PSM~TWK|Iw^|RJbL��TWHQP§T|TZHJV�`pIwKfTZXZIL�JtpTWIL_u[ ��� ���W��^}tJK�TNHQP�oSV�P�bL_5k�VEXMYVE[\TWVYX�PS[J`0d�PqTZTZVYX�TOPSILbwK{TZHQPS[�TZHJV �c_uXf^NPSb!`JIwK�TWXZIL�JtpTZIw_u[�h|G�HQPqT�IwKEy!PqMETWtJPSb=^F_5oaIwV��vtQPSbLILT��

Page 105: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

kzHJILMOH�ILK¨`pIwKfTZXZIL�JtpTWVE`�bw_usq¦Õ[J_uXf^NPSbLbL�zbLV�PS`JK�TZ_cbL_us�^|_®oaILVDXZVETZtJXZ[pK¨kzHJILMOH�HJP5oSV�PzbwVERpTW_SxatpXfTW_qTWIwM`JILKfTWXfIw�JtUTWIw_S[�yJPSK�d�_utp[J`?�v� �{V ��Pq[JVE�?Pq[J`r��PSbLbwKYh

� � ������2:��� � ±Q_uX¬d�tJX�TWHJVEX¨IL[\TWtJI¥TWIw_S[e_S[eTZHJVm^|V�Pq[JIw[Jsz_SdUTWHJILK¬TWHJVE_uXZVE^]y§MY_u[pKZIw`pVYX8TWHJV�M�PSKfVkzHJVEXZV�TWHJV�`pIwKfTZXZIL�JtpTWIL_u[ ��� ) �©ILK©TWHpV �c[JI¥d�_uXZ^�� ��� � �-�!`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[�y�Pq[J`AkzHJVYXfV �!��� � ) �¤ILKP �¤_uXZ^FPSb�� ) � �®�©`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[�h $�_u[\TWIL[atpVFTW_�PSKZKftJ^FV|TWHQP§T�TWHpVFoqPSbwtpVFd�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[�ILK�bLIw[JVYPSXY²�:� � ���J� � _ ��� �ÏhDG�HJVY[:TZHJV{RJXf_U_Sd8KfHJ_5kzKlTWHQP§T�TWHpV©`JILKfTWXfIw�JtUTWIw_S[N_Sd ��� ���O�=IwKmRJXZ_uR�_uX�TWIw_S[QPSbTW_�TZHJV�XWPqTZIw_ hk bhk b � ��� � � � ) ��� ) � �G�HJV¤RJXZVE^FILKZVEKD_Sd�G�HJVE_uXZVE^ � � PSKZKftJXZV¤tJKDTWHJPqT=TWHJVz`JVE[J_u^|Iw[QPqTZ_uX�ILK=PSbLk�P��UK=R�_uKZI¥TWI¥ouVSyukzHpIwMOHkm_utJbw`?^FPSxSV{TZHJIwKzP�ME_u[\TWIw[vtJ_StJK�d�tJ[JMETZIw_u[?_Sd _ d�_uXlTZHJV�XWPS[psuV{kzHJVYXfVeTZHJVYKfV�RJXZVE^FILKZVYKzHJ_Sbw`�h�)HJVE[ TWHpV0`pIwKfTZXZIL�JtpTWIL_u[ ��� � � ) �:IwK �,� ��� �®�~yzTWHpV0R�V�Pqx _SdeTWHJV"`JILKfTWXfIw�JtUTWIw_S[ IwK?PqT �EVYXZ_pykzHJVEXZV ��� � � �\��� � � h0�Õd hk b j[j � � � IihÍVqhLy _ � � � �� � �iy�TWHJILK�XWPqTZIw_APqK�P�d�tJ[JMETZIw_u[�_qd ) ILKPSRJRpXZ_��UIw^FPqTWVEbL��ME_u[JKfTWPS[\T�hD�Õd hk b IwK�_u[Jb¥�|P�bwI¥TZTZbwVlbwPSXZsuVEX�TZHQPS[ � � yvTWHpV©XWP§TWIw_�kzIwbLbQ�ªV¤bgPqXZsuVEXmP§T) ��� ��PS[p`�`JILR]TW_NPN^|Iw[JIL^}tJ^%P§T ) � �ph �©K _ suVETZK©bwPSXZsuVEXYyQTWHpV�TWXf_utJsuH]suVETZK©`JVEVYR�VYXEytJ[\TWILb hk b � � � y¢PqT�kzHJILMOH]R�_uIL[vT�TWHJV�d�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[?�ªVEMY_u^|VYKz`JILKZMY_S[vTZIw[vtJ_utpKYyQ^}tJb¥TWILRJbwVcVY�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgPPSXfVeR�_uKfKZIw�pbwVSyJPS[J`?_u[Jb¥�:V~�aTZXZVY^|V�oSPqbwtJVEK�_Sd ����kzIwbLb«��VeK�TOPS�pbwV�VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZIwPph

� T S�TVU T S �����J� � .�� � ���

±¢PSKZHpIw_u[�su_a_a`JKDPSXfV�_Sd¶TWVE[|tpKZVY`FPSK=PS[�VÏ�JPq^FRJbLV�_Sd ��I��«VE[�su_a_U`JKEy\KZ_�ILT�IwK!km_uXfTZHFME_u[JKfIw`JVEXZIw[pskzHJVE[ ��I��«VE[]su_a_a`JK¤km_utJbL`�PSXfIwKfV�IL[]TWHpV�^|_U`JVEb8HJVYXfVSh¤�ÕT©ILKcVYPSKf�rTW_F^F_a`JILd¶�NTWHJVe^F_a`JVEb8TZ_Iw[pMYbwtp`JV�RJXZILMYVEKY²�TWPSxSV�TZHJVzRQPSXWPq^FV~TWVYX ) TW_���V�TWHJVz[JVEs\PqTWIL_u[�_Sd�TWHJVz^FPSXZxqVET=RJXfIwMEVSy\KZ_�PSKDTWHpVRJXfIwMYV�XfIwKfVYKYyuTZHJVY[�TZHJVz^FVE`JIgPS[�_Sd¢TWHJVzMY_S[JKZtJ^|VYXfKY uoqPSbLtJV�d�_uX�RptJXZMOHQPqKZIw[ps�TZHJV�su_a_U`}d�PqbwbwKEh!±Q_uXV~�pPS^|RJbLVSy�ILdDTWHpV�su_a_U`rk�VEXZV}d�XfVYVSy�TWHJVE[�TWHJV�TOPSK�TWV�d�_SXcTWHpV�PSMETZIw_u[]_Sd=RJtJXfMOHQPSKfIw[JsNTZHJV}su_a_a`^FP5���ªV|`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZVY` � �,� � � �5�~y¬�JtpT�ILd�TWHpVFsu_a_a`0ME_uKfTeT�km_�`J_ubLbgPSXfKYy�TZHJVY[0TOPSK�TWVYK�d�_uX�TWHpVPSM~TWIw_S[�_Sd�RptJXZMOHQPqKZIw[ps�TWHJVFsu_a_U`0k�_utpbw`���VN`pIwKfTZXZIL�JtpTWVE` � ��� �� � �®�~y¨kzILTZH�^|_uKfT�RªVE_uRJbLV[J_STmklPq[vTZIw[Js}TZ_}MY_S[JKZtJ^|V©TZHJV{su_a_U`«yakzHJILbwVzTWHJ_SKZV©kzHJ_�K�TWXf_u[Jsub¥�FRpXZVEd�VEXZXfVY` TWHJVcsu_a_U`NkzHpVY[ILT�k�PSK�d�XZVEV�KfTWILbwbªs\PSIw[pIw[Js�R�_uKZI¥TWI¥ouV�tpTZIwbwI¥T���d�XZ_u^%�ptp�aIw[Js�TWHpVesS_U_a` d�_uX���UhG�HJV �vtJVYK�TWIL_u[�_Sdz`JXZP�kzIw[Js�TZHJV:`JVE^NPq[J`�MYtJX�ouVNTZHJVY^ �ªVEMY_u^|VYKE²|PSK�TWHpV �Q[QPqb�RJXfIwMYV �

Page 106: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

Iw[pMYXZVYPSKZVEKYy¢`J_aVYK�TWHpVeMEtpTW_ � ���¤XfIwKZV�_SXzd�Pqbwb¶�G�HJVzKZV~TWtJRFPS��_®oSV�s\P�ouVzMY_S[J`JILTZIw_u[pK�kzHJVEXZV�� � � ) �!ILKDP�_u[JV~¦­TW_q¦Õ_u[JV�d�tp[JMETZIw_u[�hDn¤V~TWtJXf[JIw[ps

TW_�TZHJV�_uXZILsuIw[QPqbªIL[vTZVYXfRJXZV~TOPqTZIw_u[ kzHJVEXZV ���'� � ) ��IwK�Iw[pMYXZVYPSKZIL[Js�Iw[ ) y

+ # ���"��� � ��� � � � � � H+y7� � #+&(�1Z\EF� /lHI9K��9u!%2 ~ &(��!$EF� / ��QA � � � �8� HI9u3@9 #UE HP. #UVWJ O-��. EF�x3$9 H+�-52 ,-�". #rHP!$� R

G�HJIwK!XZVEoSVYXfKZVYKDI¥d ) XZVERJXZVEKZVE[vTZK=RJXZILMYVYKEyuKZ_ ���'� � ) �¨IwK¨`JVEMYXZVYPSKZIL[Js�Iw[ ) ²!PqK�TWHpV �p�UVY`�RJXfIwMEV�0XZIwKfVYKEyJTWHJVeMYtpTZ_ � ���¤XfIwKfVYKYy¢^|V�PS[pIw[Js}TZHQPqTzTWHJV�R�VYXfMYVY[\TWPSsuV�_qd!ME_u[JKZtp^FVEXZKzd�PSbwbLKYhD��[�_qTWHJVEXkm_uXZ`JKEy¢suILoSVY[ TWHJV�RJXfVY^|IwKfVYKz_Sd�G�HJVY_uXfVY^ � � ypTWHJV�`JVE^NPq[J`]MEtJXfoSV�PqbLk�P5�aKzKZbL_uR�VYKz`J_5kz[�hG�HJVrRJXZVE^FILKZVYK�_qd©G�HJVE_uXZVE^ � � PSXfV [J_ST�TWXfILoaIgPqb­y=PS[J`�PSbLb�_Sd¤TWHpVY^ ^FP�����V RJbgPStpKZIw�pbL�

`JXf_uRJR�VY`}TW_©`JVYKfMYXZIL�ªVzPcKZ_aMYIwV~T���kzHpVYXZV��I��ªVY[�su_a_U`JK�MY_utpbw`�V~�UILKfT�h!±!IwXfKfTYySILT!IwK!PSKZKftJ^FVE`}TWHQP§TVYI¥TWHJVEXDMY_u[pKZtJ^|VYXfK�PSXfVz[J_STDTW_a_�MY_u[pMYVYXf[JVY`|kzILTZH�TZHJVz�ªVEHQP�oaIw_uXD_Sd«_STWHpVYXZKEyv_uX�TWHQP§TDTOPSK�TWVYKmPSXfV[J_ST�TW_a_©ME_u[JMYVE[\TWXWP§TWVY`«h=±�PqKZHJIL_u[�su_a_a`JK!PqXZV�tp[JILoSVYXZKZPSbwb¥��TWHJ_uKfVmkzHJVEXZV�R�VY_uRpbwVmPSXZVmMY_u[JMEVYXf[JVY`kzILTZHAVY^}tpbgPqTZIw[Js|TWHJV���VYHQP�oaIw_SX{_Sd�_STWHpVYXZKEh �cbwKf_Jy�ILdDTZHJVYXfV�PSXZV�^}tJbLTZIwRJbLV�VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgPpyQTWHpVY[0PKZHpILd¶TzIw[ RpXZIwMEVYK�MYPS[]��_STZH M�PStJKfV�P}MOHJPS[JsuV�Iw[ TZHJV�bw_aM�PqTZIw_u[N_Sd8TWHJV�VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZIwP�PS[J`rP�MOHQPS[psuVIw[ kzHJILMOH]VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^�TWHpVeME_u[JKftJ^FVEXZK¤MY_a_uXZ`pIw[QPqTZV�tJR�_u[�h

�UVYME_u[J`�y¬I¥T©ILK{PSKfKZtJ^|VY`ATZHQPqT©TZHJV�oqPSbLtJV�_Sd�PqMETWIL[Js:ILK©^|_u[J_STZ_u[JIwMYPSbwb¥�:IL[JMYXfV�PSKfIw[Js:IL[�TWHpVR�VYXZMEVY[\TOPqsuVN_Sd�_STWHpVYX�PSMETZ_uXZKEh ��tpT�MY_u[JKfIw`JVEXed�PqKZHJIL_u[�sS_U_a`"^F_a`JVYbLK�KZtJMOH�PqK�±QXZI ��TWVEXZK �� ���­y��VEKZVE[J`J_uX�d�VYX�� ��� �iyp_uX ��VYXf[JHJVEIw^ � &��iyp�JPSKZVE` _u[:su_a_U`pK�PSKlP�KZILsu[QPSb�_Sd8K�TOPqTZtJKYh �=PSMOH _Sd¬TZHJVYKfV^|_U`JVEbwK{d�VYPqTWtJXfVNP?tpTZIwbwI¥T���d�tJ[pMETWIL_u["kzHJIwMOH�IwK�Iw[JMEXZVYPSKZIL[Js?Iw["TWHJV|RªVEXZMEVY[\TOPSsSVF_Sd�HJIwsSHU¦ÕT��aR�VMY_S[JKZtJ^|VYXfK _Sd�P�su_a_U`�yzPq[J` IwK:`pVYMYXfV�PSKfIw[JsnIL[ TWHJVAR�VYXfMYVE[vTWPSsuVA_SdebL_®kl¦­T��aRªV�ME_u[JKftJ^FVEXZKEhG�HJVEXZVEd�_SXZV�TWHJV�oqPSbLtJV�_Sd�MY_u[JKftJ^|Iw[Js�^FP�� Iw[JMEXZVYPSKZV�_uX�`pVYMYXfV�PSKfV�PqKcP}d�tJ[pMETWIL_u[?_Sd¨TWHJV{TZ_STOPSb[vtJ^}��VYX{_qd=MY_u[JKftJ^|VYXZKEh�G�HJV�^|_uXWPSb8ILK©[J_STcTWHQP§T©d�PSKfHJIw_u[�su_U_a`JKcM�PS[�  T���V���I��ªVY[�sS_U_a`JK �TWHpVYXZV¤IwK=V~oUIL`JVY[pMYVcTZHQPqTmKZtJMOHNsu_U_a`JK=`J_eV~�UIwK�T � �JtpT�TWHQPqTmPS[\��^|_U`pVYbQ_Sd�d�PqKZHJIL_u[�su_U_a`JKDkzILTZH��I��ªVY[�`pVY^FPS[J`}MEtJXfoSVYK=M�PS[�[J_ST���V��JPSKZVE`|_S[�PcHJ_S^F_usSVY[J_utpK!KZ_aMYILVET��ekzILTZH�d�tJbwbvIL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZIw_u[PS[J`rRJtJXfVYb¥�:KZVEbLdg¦ÕIw[\TWVEXZVYK�TWVE`�PSM~TW_uXfKYh

Page 107: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

��

�51021�� � D ;OD �)<E910 H�PB; � L9�;=<E9 ;OD �)<E910 H�PB;=<ED

G�HJVFtJ[JIw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWI¥ouV�RJXfIw_uX��©kzILbwbDtJKfVNIL[0TZHJIwK�MOHQPSRUTWVYX�IwKeMY_u[pKfTWXftJMETZVY`�PqKed�_ubLbw_5kzKY² �{V �J[JVTWHpV�d�tp[JMETZIw_u[

� �S� ) ��� � �� � ) = � � ��� � �� ) �= � � ��� � � �

G�HJILKFILKNP �c[JI¥d�_uXZ^ `pIwKfTZXZIL�JtpTWIL_u[n_5ouVYX|TWHJV]XWPS[psuV � � �1� � �ih G�HJV]tJ[JIw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWI¥ouV RJXfIw_uX�ILKTWHpVY[�`JV �Q[pVY` PSK�TWHJV:d�tJ[pMETWIL_u[nbwIL^ ��� � � �q� ) �~h�G�HJIwK}T��aR�Vr_qd©`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWIL_u[�IwK�`pIwKZMEtJKZKfVY`V~�aTZVY[JKfILouVEbL�?IL[?TZV~�aTWK¤_u[ �lP��uVEKZIwPS[]IL[pd�VYXfVY[JMEVSy¢VShÒsJh��«VEbwbw[pVYX�� � 3�iyQRJR � ���¨h

�{V �Q[pIw[Js ��� ) �lTW_N��V�PS[]tp[JIw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWI¥ouV�RJXfIw_uX¤PSK¤`JV �J[JVY`�HpVYXZV�suXZVYPqTWb¥� KZIL^FRpbwI��JVYKlTWHpVVY�vtQP§TWIw_S[?d�_SX �lP��uVYKfIgPS[]tJR�`QPqTWIL[JsJ²

� � ���E� ) � �f� � ���'� � ) � ��� ) ����� � ���'� � �8� ��� �8������ bLIw^��� � � �� � � <� ������� �� � �� � � � �� ���� � � ) = � � ��� � �

� ) �= � � ��� � � � � h��u�

� bLIw^��� � � �� � � <�� �� � �� � � � � � ) = � � ��� � �� ) �= � � ��� � � � � h � �

� ���'� � ) � � � h � �� ���'� � ) �� � � h &u�

�D�vtQPqTWIL_u[ � h����JXfV�PSxvKlTZHJV©K�TOPqTZVY^|VY[\T�`J_5kz[?Iw[\TW_eTWHJV©M�PSKfV©kzHJVYXfV � �S� ) � � � k� �iyJPq[J`:kzHJVYXfV� �q� ) � �)PS[J`�TZHatpK�TZHJV}kzHJ_ubLV}V~�URJXfVYKfKZIw_S[��)ILK��YVYXf_Jh �D�vtQPqTZIw_u[ � h � d�_ubLbw_5kzKcd�Xf_u^-TZHJV}d�PSM~TTWHJPqT � k� �\ILK¬MY_u[JK�TOPS[\T8kzILTZH�XZVYKfRªVEMET¨TW_��y®KZ_¤ILT�MY_u^|VYK8_utpT8_qdUTZHJV=Iw[\TWVEsuXWPSbSIw[�TWHJVD`pVY[J_u^|Iw[JPqTW_uXPS[J`"MYPS[JMYVEbwK�_utUT�h �D�vtQPqTZIw_u[ � h � tJKZVEK�TWHJV}d�PSM~T�TWHQP§T � �� � ��� � � �8����� � �uy8PS[J`ATZHQPqT�TWHpVM�PqKZV�kzHpVYXZV ) �= � � ��� � �¨IwK¤_u�\oaIgPqTZVY`]kzHpVY[ � � � h �D�atJPqTWIL_u[ � h'&FtpKZVYKcTWHJV�PSKZKftJ^FRUTWIw_S[TWHJPqT�TWHpVld�PS^FILbL����� � � ) ��ILKDP©TWXZPS[JKfbgPqTZIw_u[ed�PS^FILbL�Sh¨G�HpIwKDPSKfKZtJ^|RpTZIw_u[�RJXf_5oUIL`JVYK�TZHJV�KfTZXZtJM~TWtJXfV[JVEVY`JVE`]TW_|PSXfXZI¥ouVePqT�TWHpVeXfVYKftJbLTZK¤��VYbL_5k�h

�c_STZIwMEV�TWHQPqTrPqK ) XZILKZVYKEycTZHJV"Rª_uIL[\T?PqT kzHJILMOH ��� � �NILK:VEoqPSbLtQPqTWVE`)`JVYMEbwIw[pVYKYy©KZ_�TWHQP§T� � ���E��� � �f��IwKlTZHJV�^FILXZXZ_SXlIw^FPSsuVc_Sd �!��� � �f�lPSXZ_StJ[J` �Ïh

Page 108: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

2cVEXZV�PSXZV�P}d�VEk¯tJKZV~d�tJb¬`JV �J[JILTZIw_u[JKld�_SXzPS[\�?suVY[JVEXZILM � ��± �¨� � �ϲ� ��� ��� �Y���� U�W f O7HI9 #rE HU`,-#rHP!$��HI9 K��a^F^|VETZXZIwM H s �¨� �a� � �¨� � �a� � �\Rf O7HI9 #rE HU`,-#rHP!$��HI9 tJR\k�PSXZ`a¦�bwVYPS[JIL[Js H s �8���a�Lj �¨� � �a� � ��j �(Rf O7HI9 #rE HU`,-#rHP!$��HI9 `J_5kz[\k�PSXZ`U¦ÕbwVYPS[JIw[ps H s �¨� �U� � �¨� � �a� � ��j �(R

�U_¤ILdUP�Kf�a^F^|VETZXZILM�RJXZIL_uX���� � � �f��IwK¬tJR�`QPqTZVY`etJKZIL[Js¤PS[�tJ[JIw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWI¥ouV�RpXZIw_SXYy�TWHpV�R�_uK�TWVYXfIw_uXkzIwbLb\�ªVmKf�a^|^FV~TWXZILMS°qILdQPq[}tJR\klPqXZ`U¦ÕbwV�Pq[JIw[JscRJXZIL_uX8IwK¨tJR�`QPqTWVE`}tJKfIw[Js©PS[�tJ[pIw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWILoSV=RJXZIL_uXYyTWHpVY[�TZHJV�R�_uKfTZVYXfIw_uXzkzIwbLb¬�ªV�`J_5kz[vk�PSXf`U¦�bLV�PS[JIL[JsJ°ªPS[J`roUILMYVeouVYXfKWPNd�_uXcPF`p_®kz[\k�PSXZ`a¦�bwVYPS[JIL[JsRJXfIw_uXEh

� T S�T�� TW � �\����Q��#�2:�M��� � � �\# � ��# � � � ���@�-, 232 �[�Y# �� � � ��� .��� � �"��� ��� � ��# ���# � ��2 �\�',[���Y� � � � ������ �\# � �

�)`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZIw_u[ �!� � � �u�DILKDKZIL[JsubwVϦ�R�V�PSxqVY`|I���²¨d�_SX=PSbwb � � �py �����ª�DILK=PS[|Iw[JMEXZV�PqKZIw[ps�d�tp[JMETZIw_u[�°d�_uXzPSbLb �j �py �����ª��IwKzP�`JVYMEXZVYPSKZIL[JsFd�tJ[pMETWIL_u[�°QPq[J` ��� �ª��PqTfTOPSIL[JK�ILTZK�^NP§�UIL^}tJ^�PqT � � �UhG�HJIwK¤MY_S[J`JILTZIw_u[pKzPS[J`]P�d�V~k ^F_SXZV�PSXfV�Kft��|MYIwVE[\TcTZ_FsutJPSXWPS[\TZVYV�TWHQP§TcVE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgP�kzIwbLb���V

_Sd!P�MYtpTZ_ �Ad�_uXZ^r²+ # ���"��� � ��� � � � � f 9�9 ,-/0�>,-�(H+� 2 !$E /m37#rH+y7�eZ\E HP!$E H+� 2 !$E /m37#UHP!$� >#+&Q37# ��� � � �\� HI9 9 H+�-57VI� gZ(�x3 ���xO�37�\O � H+#+&(� E9 J /l/0� #UE HP. !$E ,KZ\Ci37ENO7gYVI�x37�(H+�-5 e37�\O #'&Q37# ���'� � ) � HI9 3 #UEx37�Q9 V]37#UHP!$�2p37/lH+VWJ Rm~ &(� �#+&(�l!$�(VWJ[Z\,-EF�89 #rEN37#Y�P57J���37J���9 HU37� �83$9�&����,TH+VWHU`E HU3B37EF�l!%243w. ,-#Y!%s 2 !$E / R

X � 2:� ������2:��� � � 2¤VYXZV¤PSXfVzP{d�VEk VÏ�pPS^FRpbwVYK�TZ_�suILoSV�KZ_u^|V�Iw[\TWtpILTWIL_u[�PSKDTZ_�kzH\��tpRvk�PSXf`U¦bwVYPS[JIL[Jsc_SX�K��U^|^|VETWXfIwM�RJXZIL_uXZK¨Iw^|RJb¥��P©MEtpTW_ �|VE�atpIwbwIL�JXZILtJ^ry®kzHpIwbwV=`J_5kz[\k�PSXZ`U¦ÕbwVYPS[JIw[ps{RJXZIL_uXZKPSbLbw_5kjXZVYbwPqTWI¥ouVEbL�FRªVEXfouVEXZKfV�VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZIwPph$�_u[JKfIw`JVEXzTZHJV�d�_ubwbL_5kzIw[Js}MYPSKZVq²

�:�'� ���J� � PSXZM~TOPS[¬�'�f�� ��

���

� � ���E� � � �f� �� ���� � = � � � h

�� � � hk �

� � �= � � � h�� � � hk �

� � � � � � ���� � � �

Page 109: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

�G�HJV�d�tJ[pMETWIL_u[)PSXfMETOPq[8�'�f���J� � � u�|ILK:^F_S[J_STW_S[JIwMYPSbwb¥��Iw[pMYXZVYPSKZIL[Js�Iw[ �Ïyc�JtUT?PSKf�a^|RpTW_qTWIwMYPSbwb¥�PSRJRpXZ_\PSMOHpVYK�_u[JVq°�TWHJILK{^FVYPS[JK©TZHQPqT�[p_r_S[JV�km_utJbw`A��V}kzIwbLbwIL[Js|TZ_?PSMET{ILd=[J_ _u[pV�VYbwKfV}`J_aVYKEhG�HJVeRª_SKfTWVEXZIL_uXlIwK�tpRvk�PSXf`U¦�bLV�PS[JIL[JsJyJKf_|TZHJV�RJXZIL_uXZK�^�tJKfT¤HQP�ouVe��VYVY[r`J_5kz[\klPqXZ`U¦ÕbwV�Pq[JIw[JsphG�HJV�R�VYXZKf_u[AkzHJ_?`JXZV~k �)� ���� � ��VYbLIwV~ouVYK{TZHQPqT�P|TW_STWPSb!`JVE[JKZI¥T���_Sd � � �

� IwK©kzI¥TWHJIL[�� 0PS[J`�kzILbwb¨PSMETYy«Pq[J`APSXfMETOPq[8� � � � ���p� � ��S� � � hk yªKf_ �:� � ���J� � �:� ��� � � �J� � h� h¤G�HJVR�VYXZKf_u[�kzHJ_A`JXfVEk � � hk ��VYbLIwV~ouVYK � � h� y=PS[J`nPSXfMETOPq[8� �� � ���J� � ��u� � hk yDKZ_ �N� � ���J� ��:� � � � � �J� � �

� h�G�HvtJKYy¨��_STWH"VY[p`JKePSXZV}oqPSbLIw`AMYtUTW_ �ªKYy¨PS[J`ATZHJV�XZV�Pq`JVYX�^FP5�]ouVEXZILd¶�]TWHQP§TPSbLb!Iw[p`JILoaIw`ptQPSbwKzkzILTZHA`JXWP�kzK�Iw[ �� 0kzIwbwb¨RJXfVEd�VYX�TZ_?PSMET�Pq[J`0PSbwb¨TWHJ_uKfV}kzILTZHA`JXWP�kzK�_utpTZKZIw`pV_Sd � kzIwbLb�[J_ST¤PSM~T�h

�lTzTWHJV�KWPq^FV�TWIL^FVqy �� �,� ���� � ��� �mIwK¤PSbLKZ_�PS[rVY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^]h�c_5k�y¢MY_u[pKZIw`pVYXlTWHpVeKZPS^|VeKfVETZtJR�PSKzPq�ª_5ouVe�JtpTcP�`J_5kz[\klPqXZ`U¦ÕbwV�Pq[JIw[Js�R�_uKfTZVYXfIw_uXE²

� � ���E� � � �f� � � ��� � = � � � hk � ��� h��

� � �= � � � hk � ��� h���

$�_u[JKfIw`JVEXePS[\�AT�k�_]Rª_uIL[\TWK � � PS[J` � k h ��ILoSVY["TWHJV�R�_uKfTZVYXfIw_uX�HJVEXZVqy ��� �� � �FhZ��� ��� �� � � k �~hG�HJILKA^FVYPS[JK�TWHJPqT �N� �Fh����� � � �FhZ�f� � �N�'� k ����� � � � k �Z�Ïy�kzHJILbwV �F� � � � � ��� � � �FhZ�f� j�:� � � � � ��� �� � � k �f�~ylKf_�ILTFMY_utpbw` [pVEouVEX:��V]TWHpV�M�PqKZV]TZHQPqTF�ª_qTWH �Fh|Pq[J` � k PSXfV]MEtpTW_ �«KEyKZ_�kmVeME_utJbL`][J_qTzKZVYV�PS[?VY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^�_qd�TZHJV�d�_uXZ^ � �$�'�Fh� � k �~h

�©[rIw^|^FVE`JIgP§TWV©IL^FRpbwIwMYPqTWIL_u[N_qd �DXZ_SRª_uKfILTZIw_u[ � � ²

� ��# �����M#), � ��� !$E13 � �T�xOm9K� # �� LH 2 ��� � � ) � HI96309 H+�-57VI� gIZ(�x3 ���xOB37�\OX� H+#'&(� E89 J$/l/0� #rE HP.!$E4, Z\Ci37ENO7gYVI�x37�(H+�-5�2 ,-�". #rHP!$� 37�\O1Z(��!�Z\VI�8&Q37y7��37�e,T�(H+� 2 !$E /m37#UH+y7�|Z\E HP!$E� G#+&(� � �«� �� � �f� HI9/0!$�"!$#Y!$�(HP.x37V+VWJmH+�". EF�x3$9 H+�-5{H+� �pR

+ #�� ����6 G�HJILKzIwK�KZIL^FRpbL�FV~�aTWVE[J`JIw[ps|TZHJV�XZVYKftJbLT¤_Sd �DXZ_uR�_uKfILTWIL_u[ � � oaIgP�G�HJVE_uXZVE^ �ph�

G�HJV{�vtJVEKfTWIL_u[ _Sd¬kzHJV~TWHJVEXlILTmIwKmRJbgPqtJKZIL�JbwV�TW_}PSKZKftJ^FVcTWHQPqTmTWHJVcV~�UR�VYMETZVY`?`JVE^NPS[p`:IwK�PS[Iw[pMYXZVYPSKZIL[Js�d�tJ[pMETWIL_u[ _Sd ��IwKmTWHJVEXZVEd�_SXZV{_u�\oaIgP§TWVY` IL[NTWHpV�M�PSKfV�_Sd¨PS[ tJ[JIL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZILoSVcRJXfIw_uXE²�ILTIwKzP�`JILXZVEMET¤XZVEKZtJb¥Tz_Sd�TZHJV�^F_a`JVEb­ ÒK�KZVETZtJR�Pq[J`rPSKZKftJ^FRUTWIw_S[JKYh

Page 110: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

&� T S�T�� TVU � �\� � ��� ��� � � ���2� [���Y� � � � ���������# ��� 2

nzVYs\PSXf`JbwVEKZK�_Sd¤kzHJV~TWHJVEX �DXf_uRª_SKZILTZIw_u[ � � PSRJRJbLIwVYKEy�TWHJV d�_ubLbw_5kzIw[ps�M�Pq[���V?KWPSIL`nPS��_utpT�TWHpVMYbwPSKZKz_Sd�MYtUTW_ �AVE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgPp²

+ # ���"��� � ��� � � � � �6� ���"� ���'� � ) � #Y!v` �63B#UEx37�Q9 V]37#UHP!$�l2p37/lH+VWJ R 4 24H+�\O7H+yKHUO7, 37V 98&Q37y7�4,-�(H+�(g2 !$E /m37#rH+y7�*Z\E HP!$E[H+� 2 !$E /m37#rHP!$� 3�` !$,-#G#+&(��#UE , �m.�� �(#Y� E{!%24#+&(�lO7HI9 #UE HU`,T#UHP!$�QAG#'&(� �e#+&(� E��1HI963,-�(H �, �l. ,-#%!%s ���,-H+VWHU`E H+,T/ R

�Õd �DXZ_SRª_uKfILTZIw_u[ � � HJ_ubL`JKYyJTZHJVY[?TWHpIwKzIw^|RJbwILVYK�P|tJ[pIw�vtJVeVY�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIwtJ^rya�JtpT¤ILd�ILTz`J_aVYKz[J_qTHJ_ubL`�y8TWHJVEXZVN^FP��"�ªVF[J_u[U¦ÕMYtpTZ_ ��VY�vtJILbwIw�pXZIgP:IL[�PS`p`JILTZIw_u[ATW_rTWHJVFtJ[JIL�atpVFVE�atpIwbwIL�JXZILtJ^�_qdzPMYtUTW_ �Ad�_uXf^]h±QtJXfTZHJVYXEylTWHJV]KZHQPSR�V�_qd{TWHJVr`JILKfTWXfIw�JtUTWIw_S[ KZP5�aK:Kf_u^|VETWHpIw[Js�PS��_utpT|kzHJVYXfV�TWHJVrtJ[JIL�vtJV

MYtUTW_ �"VE�atpIwbwIL�JXZILtJ^ IwK�bL_UMYPqTWVE`�²

� ������# � 2 S\q f 9�9 ,-/0� ��� � � ) � HI9130#UEx37�Q9 V]37#UHP!$�12p37/lH+VWJB!%243 �i� � #+&Q37#}HI96.�!$�(#UH+�(,(!$,^9137#37V+V `,-#|3 ���(H+#Y�[�(,-/m` � El!%2}Z(!$H+�(#'9�A}37�\O0#+&Q37#i#'&(�|Z\E HP!$E8HI94,-�(H+� 2 !$E /m37#UH+y7� R

M�H � �"!0.�!$�(yKH+yKHU37VWH+#UJ � 4 �#+&(��9 J$/l/0� #rE HP.6.x3$9K��� �����a� � ��� � �a��� A�#'&(�8,T�(H �,(�l���,TH+VWHU`E H+,-/937#UHI9 �L��9 ���)� � AG/0�x37�(H+�-50#'&Q37#G#'&(� EF��HI9��"� H+#+&(� E�3-. #rH+y7�1�"!$E4H+�\3-. #rH+y7�{.�!$�(yKH+yKHU37VWH+#UJ Rw~ &Q37#HI9�A1H 2v#+&(�XO7HI9 #rE HU`,-#rHP!$� HI9B9 J /l/0� #UE HP.�A|Z(��!�Z\VI�X` ��&Q37y7�w3$9BH 2v#+&(� J !$�(VWJz.x37EF�xOz3�` !$,-#[#'&(� H+EZ\E H+y$37#%�89 H]57�\37V 9 R

M�H+H � 3-. #UH+y7�1.�!$�(yKH+yKHU37VWH+#UJ � 4 2 #+&(�[O7HI9 #UE HU`,T#UHP!$�wHI9�,KZ\Ci37ENO7gYVI�x37�(H+�-5$AD/0�x37�(H+�-56#+&Q37# �����a� �� ��� � �a��� !� 2 !$E137V+V �Bj � 37�\Om9K!$/0� ! � � A}#+&(� ��#'&(�1,-�(H �, �l. ,-#%!%s ���,-H+VWHU`E H+,T/ 937#UHI9 �L��9��� � � A /0�x37�(H+�-51#+&Q37#�� y7� E J�!$�"�*C�H+#'&03;Z\E H+y$37#Y�L9 H]57�\37V #Y!�3-. # C�H+V+V(O-!89K!KAD`,T# 9K!$/0� Z(��!�Z\VI�C�H+#+&w�"�P5�37#rH+y7�LZ\E H+y$37#Y��9 H]57�\37V 9[C�H+V+V H]57�"!$EF�4#+&(� / 37�\OB3-. #G37�(J Ci37J R

M�H+H+H � H+�\3-. #UH+y7� .�!$�(yKH+yKHU37VWH+#UJ � 4 2 #+&(� O7HI9 #rE HU`,-#rHP!$��HI9 O-!$C��(Ci37ENO7gYVI�x37�(H+�-5$AB9K! ��� �a� �� ��� � �a��� !� 2 !$Ew37V+V �aj � 37�\Oe9K!$/0� ! j � A�#+&(� ��#'&(�v,T�(H �,(��. ,T#Y!%s ���,-H+VWHU`E H+,T/ 937#UgHI9 �L��9 ��*j � A /0�x37�(H+�-5{#+&Q37#G� y7� E J^!$�"��C�H+#'&u38Z\E H+y$37#Y��9 H]57�\37V �"!$#�#%!{3-. #�C�H+V+V"�"!$#i3-. #+Ai`,-#9K!$/0�LZ(��!�Z\VI�[C�H+#+&lZ(!K9 H+#UH+y7�LZ\E H+y$37#%��9 H]57�\37V 98C�H+V+V�H]57�"!$E��8#'&(� / 37�\O0�"!$#}3-. #G3$94CG� V+V R

G�HJIwKeTWHJVE_uXZVE^ tp[J`JVYXfKZME_uXZVEK}TWHJV:IL^FR�_uX�TOPS[JMEV�_SdlTWHpV:`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZIw_u[0_SdlTWPSKfTZVYK��)IwsS[J_uXZVE`Iw[ HJVYXf`JIw[ps�^F_a`JVEbwK � Iw[n`JV~TWVYXf^FIL[JIw[ps�TWHpV�_utpTZMY_u^|V�_qd{TWHJV]s\PS^|VShj�Õd��}TWHJIL[Jx�TWHQP§TNTWHpV

Page 111: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

`JILKfTWXfIw�JtUTWIw_S[�_Sd�_utpTZMY_u^|VYK�ILK{KZxqVEkmVY`�tpRvk�PSXf`�y¨TZHJVY["�cPS^-^F_uXfV}bwILxSVEbL�rTW_ IwsS[J_uXZV}P:KZ^FPSbwb[JVEs\PqTWI¥ouV�KZILsu[QPSb«PS[J`?d�_ubwbL_5k TWHJV�MYXf_5kz`�h=�Õd��=TWHJIL[JxFTZHJV�`JIwK�TWXZIL�JtpTZIw_u[:ILK�Kf�a^|^FV~TWXZILMSypTZHJVY[r�HQP�ouV�[p_:Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[ TW_:su_N_u[�VYI¥TWHJVEXck�P��uy¬PS[p`�KZ_ ��MYPS[A`J_:[J_N�ªV~TZTWVEX©TWHJPS[��ftJK�T{d�_ubwbL_5k^�� _5kz[rKZILsu[QPSbih

� T S�T�� T�� � � 2 �\�M# �� .:�"���Z�Y��# � ��# �

�nTWHJVE_uXZVE^KfIw^|IwbwPSXªTZ_©G�HJVE_uXZVE^ � �zkm_utJbL`���VmtJKfVEd�tJbiySME_u^FRJPSXZIL[Jsz_utpTWME_u^|VYK¨suILoSVY[�`pI��ªVYXZVE[\TKZHJPSRªVEK�_Sd¨`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZIw_u[pKYh���[:TZHJIwKlMYPSKZV{TZHJVYXfV�IwK�TWHJV�PS`p`JILTZIw_u[QPqb�IL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u[ ) � ��h�G�HvtJKTWHpV¤`pV �Q[JI¥TWIL_u[�_Sd¨�¡bLV�PS[JIL[JsJ qtJKZVE`N��VYbw_5k IwKDbLVYKZK=K�TWXZIL[JsuVE[vTYy\�JtpT�`JVERªVE[J`JK�tJRª_S[ ��h � ��� � � �®�IwKzK��U^|^|VETWXfIwM��\� TWHJILKc`pV �Q[JI¥TWIL_u[�yJd�_uXzV~�pPS^|RJbLVSyQ�JtpT¤TWHpV �,� � ���®��`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZIw_u[?ILK¤tpRvk�PSXf`U¦bwVYPS[JIL[JsJypKfIw[JMEV �¨���Õ�|j��¨� � ���ld�_uXzPSbLb ��j �ph

� ��� ��� �Y���� U�U f O7HI9 #rE HU`,-#rHP!$� �!��� � �8� HI9 Kf�a^|^FV~TWXZILM H s �!��� � �8� � ��� � � � �8� � �\Rf O7HI9 #UE HU`,T#UHP!$� ��� � � �¬� HI9 tJR\k�PSXZ`a¦�bwVYPS[JIL[Js H s �!��� � �8�Gj ��� � � � �8� 2 !$E137V+V �0j �(Rf O7HI9 #UE HU`,T#UHP!$� ��� � � �¬� HI9 `J_5kz[\k�PSXZ`U¦ÕbwVYPS[JIw[ps H s ��� � � �8� � �!� � � � �8� 2 !$E437V+V ��j �(R

� ������# � 2 S�W � H+y7� ��#'&Q37#c) � � HI9 �$�"!$C�� RM�H � �"! .�!$�(yKH+yKHU37VWH+#UJ � 4 �>#+&(�w9 J$/l/0� #UE HP.�.x3$9K��A6#'&(� EF�XHI937� ���,TH+VWHU`E H+,-/ 37# � � � � A

/0�x37�(H+�-5�#+&Q37#}#+&(� EF�4HI9[�"� H+#+&(� E�3-. #UH+y7�[�"!$E[H+�\3-. #UH+y7�6.�!$�(yKH+yKHU37VWH+#rJ RM�H+H � 3-. #UH+y7�8.�!$�(yKH+yKHU37VWH+#UJ � 4 2|#'&(� O7HI9 #UE HU`,T#UHP!$�uHI9;, Z\Ci37ENO7gYVI�x37�(H+�-5$A #+&(� �v#+&(� E��;HI9 37�@���,-H+g

VWHU`E H+,T/�37#i9K!$/0�LZ(!$H+�(# ��� � �(RM�H+H+H � H+�\3-. #UH+y7�8.�!$�(yKH+yKHU37VWH+#UJ � 4 2*#'&(� O7HI9 #UE HU`,T#UHP!$�vHI9 O-!$C��(Ci37ENO7gYVI�x37�(H+�-5$A #+&(� �v#'&(� EF�;HI9 37�

���,-H+VWHU`E H+,-/ 37#�9K!$/0�LZ(!$H+�(# ��*j � R

�c_u[pV�_Sd�TWHJVEKZV�M�PSKfVYK�RpXZVYMEbwtJ`pV�_STZHJVYXrVY�vtJILbwIL�JXZIwP�V~�UIwK�TWIw[ps�VEbwKfVEkzHJVEXZVSyePSKrKZHp_®kz[ �v�V~�pPS^|RJbLV �$PS�ª_5oSVSy!kzHJILMOH�k�PSK�K��U^|^|VETWXfIwM|�JtpT�HQPS`�VE�vtJIwbLIw�JXfIgP suXZVYPqTWVEXeTZHQPS[�y�bwVEKZK�TZHQPS[�yPS[J`nVE�atJPSblTW_ �YVEXZ_Jh 2c_5k�V~ouVEXYylIL[nTZHJV M�PqKZV kzHJVYXfV TWHJVEXZV?IwK�_u[pbL��_u[JV?VY�vtJILbwIw�pXZIwtp^]y¨TWHJILK`JVE^F_u[pKfTWXZPqTWVEK©TWHpV}Rª_SIw[\TWK©PSbwKf_N��V}^NPq`JV��\�]G�HJVY_uXfVY^|K � �A��PS��_®oSV5�©Pq[J` � ����ªVEbw_5kc�~²�TWHpVKZHJPSRªV�_qdªTZHJV�`JIwK�TWXfIw�JtpTZIw_u[�^NPqTfTWVEXZK�IL[�`JVETZVYXZ^|Iw[pIw[Js©TZHJV �Q[QPSbpbwVEoSVYbJ_qdªME_u[JKftJ^FRUTWIw_S[�yukzHJVYXfVtJR\k�PSXZ`U¦ÕbwVYPS[JIw[ps�`JIwK�TWXZIL�JtpTZIw_u[JK!bwV�Pq`�TZ_�^F_uXfVlMY_S[JKZtJ^|RpTZIw_u[�°aPS[p`�TZHJVz[JVEkzK=_SdªKZ_S^FV ) K�PSXfV�Í�ªV~TZTWVEXY QIL[?TZHJV�KZVE[JKZVe_Sd�M�PStJKfIw[Js|^|_uXZV�R�VY_uRpbwV{TW_|PSM~T�h

Page 112: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� T S�T�� T S � � � � � �"��# �� � 2 � ��� �

$�_u[JKfIw`JVEX¤TZHJVeM�PSKfV�kzHJVEXZV�TZHJVe^F_a`JVYb8HQPqKc��VYVE[�V~�UVEMYtpTZVY`���kzI¥TWH�PS[�IL[pd�_uXZ^FPqTZILouV©_uXctp[JIw[U¦d�_uXf^NPqTZILoSV�RJXfIw_uXW�~y¬PS[p`�PqMETW_SXZK�PSXfV�suILoSVY[0P:KZVEMY_u[p`�_uRpRª_uX�TWtJ[pILT��rTW_ `JVEMYIw`pVSh�G¨_STWPSb�tpTZIwbwI¥T��kzIwbLbª[p_®kj��V�P�^|_u[J_STZ_u[JIwMYPSbwb¥��Iw[pMYXZVYPSKZIL[Js�d�tJ[pMETWIL_u[ _Sd¬TZHJV�RQP��u_ �ªK�Iw[N�ª_STZH RªVEXZIL_U`JKEh��)ILTZHP"MY_utJ[\TWPS�JbL�nIL[��Q[JI¥TWV [vtJ^}��VYX|_Sd{PSMETZ_uXZKEy�V�PqMOH PSMETZ_uX�HQPSK|^FVYPSKZtpXZV �YVEXZ_Jy�Pq[J`�TZHJVYXfVEd�_uXfVM�Pq[:[J_ST��ªVEHQP�ouV{K�TWXWP§TWVYsSIwM�PqbwbL�}Iw[FTZHJV �QXfKfT�RªVEXZIw_a`FTZ_}MOHQPS[psuVcTZHJV{Iw[Ud�_uXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�P�oqPSIwbwPS�JbwVzIL[TWHpV�KZVEMY_u[p`ARªVEXZIw_a`�hzG�HJVEXZVEd�_SXZV�PSbLb¨PSMETZ_uXZK¤kzIwbwb�TZXf�?TW_N^NP§�UIL^FI��YV{TWHpVYIwX¤tpTZIwbwI¥T�� Iw[rTWHJV �QXZK�TXZ_StJ[J`�y\Pq[J`�TWHpVl^F_a`JVEbUPq�ª_5ouVlPSRJRJbLIwVYK¨Iw[�TWHQPqT!XZ_utp[J`�h!�Õd¢I¥T!ILK!ME_u^F^|_u[�xa[p_®kzbLVY`JsSV�TWHQP§T!TWHpVVY�vtJILbwIL�JXZILtJ^ �� Nk�PSK�MOHJ_uKfVY[�yaTWHJVE[F��_STWH|Iw[pRJtpTWK=IL[vTZ_�TWHJV�d�tJ[JM~TWIL_u[ ) � �� %���p��PSK=`JV �Q[pVY`:IL[�UVEMETWIL_u[ � h��ph �l^NP��e��Vl_u�JKfVYXfoSVY`�yaPS[p`}TWHJVEXZVEd�_SXZV ) IwK�xv[J_5kz[�kzI¥TWH�MEVYXfTWPSIw[\T��Sh�±Q_uX!VÏ�pPS^FRpbwVSyILd=I¥T{ILK{MY_u^|^|_u[�xv[J_5kzbwVE`JsuV}TWHJPqT�P:MYtUTW_ ��KfTWXZPqTWVEsS��k�PSK�MOHJ_SKZVY[«°8TZHQPqT{TZHJV�MYtUTW_ ��klPSK�P§T�YVEXZ_Jy«KZ_ � �%� � ��� �Ï°�TZHQPqT{TWPSKfTZVYK�PSXfV�`JILKfTZXZIw�ptpTWVE` ��� ) � �®�Ï°�PS[J`]TWHQPqT ��� ���/_SdDTWHpVPSM~TW_uXfK�PSM~TWVE`�°UTZHJVY[ Pq[v�S_u[JV{MYPS[NMOHpVYMOx�TWHJVc�QPSMOx�_Sd8PS[\�|KfTWPqTWILKfTZIwMYKDTZV~�aTW��_U_Sx�TZ_�oSVYXZI¥d¶��TWHQP§TTWHpVeMEVY[\TWVEXc_qd�TZHJV�`JIwK�TWXZIL�JtpTZIw_u[ ^}tpKfTz��V�P§T ) � � �� �phG�HJVYXfVEd�_uXfVSy�Iw[?TWHJV�KfVYMY_S[J`�XZ_StJ[J`�y¢suI¥ouVY[�PSbwb«_Sd!TZHJV�IL[pd�_uXf^NPqTZIw_u[:PSKZKftJ^FVE`]TZ_F��VeP5oqPSILb¥¦

PS�JbLVSy8PSM~TW_uXfK�kzIwbwb�HQP�ouV�d�tJbwb!Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[�y�PS[p`0TZHJV�XZVYKftJbLTZK�_Sd �aVYMETZIw_u[ � h � h� PSRJRJb¥�AIw[ATWHpVKZVEMY_u[p`�XZ_StJ[J`�h

�510210 .�/ F�H"K < � L9�;=<%9 ;7D �)<%910 H�P!;O<ED

$�HQPS[psuVYKFIw[nRJXZIL_uX�Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[�KZHpILd¶T�TWHJVrVY�vtJILbwIL�JXZIwP�Iw[nTWHJVrKWPS^|V?^NPq[J[JVYX|PSKFP"KZIw^|IwbwPSXMOHQPS[psuV�Iw[ ) IL[?TZHJV�d�tJbwb«Iw[pd�_uXf^NP§TWIw_S[NM�PqKZVSh�±Q_uXf^NPSbLbL�Sy

� ������# � 2 S U f 9�9 ,-/0�DZ\E HP!$E*O7HI9 #UE HU`,T#UHP!$� � hY� ) � 937#rHI9 �L��9L#'&(�L/0!$�"!$#%!$�"�}VWH ��� VWHI&(!K!O8Ex37#UHP!Z\EF!�Z(� E #rJuC�H+#+&�EF��9YZ(��. #*#%! � k � ) � A 37�\OX3$9�9 ,T/0��. ,T#Y!%s ���,-H+VWHU`E HU3 R f 9�9 ,-/0�{�"!$#'&-H+�-5X3�` !$,T##+&(�0O7HI9 #rE HU`,-#rHP!$� �!�'�f�R ~ &(� � 9K!$/0��!$�"�lCD&(!vHI9{H+�\O7H s�� EF� �(# ` � #UCG��� � 3-. #UHP!$� 37�\OXH+�\3-. #UHP!$�57H+y7� ��Z\E HP!$E � k � ) � C�H+V+V"9 #rE HP. #UVWJ[Z\EF�'2 � E13-. #rH+�-5�57H+y7� � �QhY� ) �R

G�HJIwKe^|V�PS[JK�TWHJPqTeILdmRJtJ�JbLIwM�Iw[pd�_SXZ^FPqTWIL_u[ �QhY� ) ��0�� n �DK � k � ) �~y8TWHpVY[ �Qh{IwK��¡��VETfTWVEXY ¥²ILTcIw[p`JtJMYVEK{PNMEtpTW_ ��d�tJX�TWHJVEXcTZ_FTWHpV�bwV~d¶T�yªPS[J`rTWHvtJK{MYPStJKZVEK�^F_SXZVeRªVE_uRJbwV�TW_NPSMETYhcG�HpIwKckzILbwbHQP�ouV�PS[?Iw^|^|VY`JIwPqTWV©PSRJRJbLIwM�P§TWIw_S[:Iw[ TWHpVe^|_a`JVYb�_qd �UVEMETZIw_u[ � h � hah

Page 113: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

G�HJV�XfV�PS`pVYX©^FP�� k�_S[J`JVYX¤kzH\�]TZHJV�0 �cn � klPqK©[JVEVY`JVE`�d�_uXzTWHJILK¤TZHJVY_uXfVY^rh�G�HJV�KfHJ_uX�TPS[JK�k�VEXmILK�TWHQP§TDTWHJILK�ILK�kzHQPqT=ILKD[JVYMEVYKZKZPSXf��TZ_�VE[JKZtJXfVcR�_uK�TWVYXfIw_uXfK�kzHJIwMOH|KWP§TWIwK�d¶��± , � �)tJKZIL[JsG�HJVE_uXZVE^ � yJ�JtpT $�HQPqRpTWVEX �suI¥ouVYK¤P�MY_S^FRJbLVETZV�`JIwKfMYtJKfKZIw_S[]_Sd¨TWHpIwK��vtJVYK�TWIL_u[�h

� 3�� � � ����C�B +���C��������@�m � ������������

�������� ���������! #"%$&"('*),+.-/���10�-�'*�

2*3&4�5638794;:=<&:�4;7?>@7956AB3CAEDF>BG!HB4�:(7956I�563&JK56I�7=L#>E7M5N7OG&5N:=4;P;79QSRT:9>E56I=4;IM7=L&4U4WVX<Y4�P;7=4�G[Z!7=56QN5N7\RKD]:=A_^P�AB3&I=Z&^�563!J`>a<&:�AXG!Z&P;7�b#cdRe:�4;HB4�>BQN563&JfDg>BPW79Ih>BcYA_Z!7F7=L&4O<&:=AiG&Z&PW7jAB:F5N79IFkdZ#>EQ65N7\RBl

m 4;7On.oqpsr!t�u�vwcY4�7=L&4a<x4;:=P;4�387?>BJB4aABDy<x4;A_<&Q64�z/L&A{I=4;4U>B3|>BG|>B3&GTQN4;7 � o~}���cY4f79L!4>BG&G!4�G[HE>BQ6Z&4`D]:=A_^�I=4;4�563!J|7=L&4e>BG�l��#A_:�7=L&4{I9>B�E4eABDhI=56^�<&QN56P�5S7\R_bw>BI=I�Z&^`4�7=L#>E7 �x� Ia4;�x4�PW756I*>BG&G&5S795NHB4f>B3!G�79L&4aI=>B^`4�D]A_:�>BQNQ�bYI=Ae>ED�7=4�:�Hi564Wz/563&J�>B3C>BG�79L&4�7?>BI(794fD]A_:h79L&4a<&:�AXG!Z&P;7�AB:>BPW7956AB3K:�56I�4�IFD]:=A_^���7=AU� � � l

�X4�4;563&J~>B3&G�>EG�56^�<#>B:(79IUcxAE79L�n�>B3&G � bFI=563!P�4 � 56I�G&56:�4�PW79QNR�ABc&I=4;:�HE>Bc&QN4Bb/>B3&G�n�5NIA_c&I�4�:(HB>Ec&Q64C563�79L&4C^�4�G&5NZ&^ P?L&A_I�4�3 � P�A_^�^�4�:=P;5�>BQNIeA_3�<&:�56^�4T7956^�4T� � 56^�<&QNR�>�z/56G!4Hi564Wz�4;:=I=L!56<�b@z/L&56QN4�>/^`>BI�I1^`>B5NQ6563!J�56^�<&QN564�IY79L#>@7�4WH_4;:�R_AB3&4�7=L&:=4Wz[A_Z!7�7=L&4�>EGMcY4;D]AB:=4�Q6AiA_�d563&J>E7a5S7�l��FL&A_I=4{z/L&A|G&AB3 � 7UI�4�4{79L!4e>BG�3&4�4;G�7=ATL#>�H_4e<&:=5NA_:f4�V!<Y4�PW7?>E7=56A_3!I�byn���>B3&G � ��b�5N3A_:�G&4�:F79AUD]A_:�^,4WVX<Y4�P;79>E795NA_3&Ij>BcYA_Z!7hL&A�z�AB7=L&4�:�Ihz/5NQ6Q�cY4�L#>�HB4Bl� \3e79L&4MI=4;kdZ&4�Q¡b¢z�4O7?>B�E4�79L!4>BG!HB4�:(7956I�4�: � IjI�79:=>E794;J_56PMP?L&A_5NP�4;IhD]A_:hn£>B3&G � >BIhJ_5NHB4�3�b¢Q64�>�HX5N3&JU79L&4;I=4�P;A_3&I�56G&4;:9>E7=56A_3&I�¤¡>E3&G79L!4MkdZ&4;I�7=56A_3KABD1z/L#>E7h56IFP;:=4�G!56c&QN4�¥�79A�>B3!AB79L&4;:/<#>B<Y4�:�l

�FL&4/D]Z&3&P;7=56A_3!I�Z&I=4;G`79AO4WHB>EQ6Z#>E7=4F4WVX<Y4�P;7=4�G�ZX7956QN5N7\RBb_>B3&GU79L!4h5N3!D]A_:�^¦>E7=56A_3�Z&I=4;G`7=AM^`>B�E479L!4M4WHE>BQ6Z#>@7956AB3�b&>B:�4*79L&4;:=4WD]A_:=4E§

P;A_3&I=Z!^`4 G&A_3 � 7hP�A_3!I=Z&^�4I=4;4�>EG ¨f©`¤]�\ª!« � t �1¬ n�t � t9nj��t � ��t=�\ª]¥ ¨f©�¤gr!t�uF­ �1¬ n�t � t9n���t � ��t=�\ª�¥G&A_3 � 7/I=4;4�>EG ¨f©¦¤]�\ª®t �1¬ nj��t � ��t=�\ª]¥ ¨f©�¤gr!t�uF­ �1¬ n���t � ��t=�\ª�¥�FL&4�:�4{>B:�4¦3&A�z.7\z�A¯P�Z!7=AB�°I;b�I=5N3&P�4�79L&A_I�4`z/L&ATI�4�4{>EG&I�L#>�HB4�^`AB:=4�563!D]A_:�^¦>@7956AB3�>E3&G

>�G&5N�x4�:�4�387±HE>BQNZ&4TD]Z&3&PW7956AB3�D]:�A_^ z/L&A�G!A_3 � 7�l m >BcY4�Q ��� >BI{79L&4CP�Z!7=AB�£>ED�794;:KHi5N4;z/563!J>BG!HB4�:(7956I�563&J�>B3!G ���� >BIF79L&4OP;Z!79AB�Tz/5S79L&ABZ!7h>BG!HB4�:�7=56I�563&J&l

Page 114: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u�r_r����������� �� �������������������! !"$#&%!#'��(*)!+�",�,- ���� #&%.���/)! /�0�%!#'��(1#'� nj� ���2� � �43 �����5)!+6"7�,-

8 #'"'�1�������! !"$#&%!#'��(9 � � 9:#&%����/)! /�0�%!#'��(;#'� n 9 � 9 nj� 9<���2� � �=3�FL&56I�^�4�>E3&Iw79L&>E7�^�A_:=4�<x4;A_<&Q64�P�A_3!I=Z&^�4/>BIw7=L&4Fn�I�>E3&G � I�:=5NI=4El��FL&4FA_c&I�4�:(HB>@7956AB3�79L#>@7

>B3e4;�x4�PW795SH_4�>BGeP�>B^�<#>B5NJ_3C¤]7=L#>E7/56I;b#>aL&56JBLeHE>BQNZ&4�ABD�n >B3&G � ¥�P�>E3±4�V!<&>B3&G¯P;A_3&I�Z&^`<X7956AB356Ia3!AB7�>E7�>BQNQ�I=Z!:=<&:�56I=5N3&J&l?>�L#>E7�^¦>E�B4�If7=L&56IaI(7?>E7=4�^�4�387�G&56I(795N3&P;7fD]:�A_^ 7=L&4e:=4;I=Z&QS79IUABDj>^�AXG&4;Q°c#>EI=4�GKA_3{<&Z!:=4�QSR�<&:�5NHE>E7=4*Z!795NQ65S7\R`5NI�79L&>E7A@0B�CD@FE4GIHJGLKNM4OQP/>BcYA_Z!7F>BG!H_4;:�7=56I=5N3&J±¤gnj�j>E3&G� �W¥�>@�°4;P;7/79L&4M>BPW795NA_3&IFABD�cxAE79L{79L&ABI=4Oz/L&A`G!A`>E3&G±G!A_3 � 7jI�4�4M>BG!HB4�:(7956I�563&J!lR � R �7S T��AU����! #"%$&"('*),+.-/���10a �V~-

�FL&4fI�4�P;A_3&GT^`>B3&3&4;:�ABD�^�AiG&4�QNQ6563!J`>EG!H_4;:�795NI=5N3&J`D]AiP�Z&I�4�I*AB3¯79L&4�>BG!HB4�:�7=56I�4�: � I*J_A_>BQ�AED�P�A_3�WHi563&P;563&J�79L&4�P;A_3&I=Z!^`4;:�79L#>E7�^`4;^fcx4;:=I�AEDw>E3{56^`>BJ_563!4�G¦P;A_^�^fZ&3&5S7\R � >EQ6Q¢z/56I=L�7=AaP�A_3!I=Z&^�479L!4a<&:=AiG&Z&PW7�lYXjI�I=Z&P?L�b�7=L&4�>BG!H_4;:�7=56I=4;:�<&:=4;I=4;3d7=I�>{G&5NI�7=:=56c!Z!795NA_3[ZY¤$\K¥�b�z/L&56P?L|I=L!A z/IO79L!4Q65N�B4;Q656L!AXAiG�79L#>@7h7=L&4M^`AiG&4OABD�7=L&4�G!56I�7=:=5Nc&Z!795NA_3e56Ih>E7j>`JB5NH_4;3¯<YA_56387]\Tl_^h>B:=4;QNR{G!A`z�4�I=4;4L&5NI�79ABJ_:9>B^�I�ABDy7?>BI(794;I�5N3 >BGXH_4�:(795NI=563!J&b�c&Z!7�>KP;A_3&I�Z&^`4;:Mz/L!A±5NIODg>E^`5NQ65�>E:hz/5S79L|L&56IOP;A_L&A_:(7z/56QNQ��d3&A�z£L&A�z ^¦>B38R±ABDyL&56IhD]4�QNQ6A�z/I�z/56QNQ�cx4;3&4a`&7�D]:�A_^�>B3|>BG!HB4�:�7=56I�4�GTD]4�>E7=Z&:=4Eb�>B3&G�7=LdZ&I56^�<&Z!7=4/>MG!56I�7=:=5Nc&Z!795NA_3UABD�^�4�G!5�>B3&IbZY¤N\K¥Wl��FL&4hP�A_3!I=Z&^�4�:�79L&4;3�>BPW79I�A_3�79L#>E7yG&5NI�7=:=56c!Z!795NA_3�b:9>@79L&4;:/7=L#>B3eA_3e79L&4OG&4;I=5N:9>Bc&QN4�P?L#>B:=>BP;7=4�:=5NI�7=56P�5N7=I=4;QND%l

�#:=A_^ L!4�:=4Eb17=L&4�:=4�I�Z&QN7=IM>BcxA�HB4¦>B<!<&QNRTG!56:=4;P;7=QNR_l;chAB7?>Bc!QNR_b��FL&4;A_:=4;^ed�f{G&4a`#3!4�I�z/L!4�3A_3&4`>BG!HB4�:(7956I�4�^�4�387�56Ihg cY4;7�794;: � 79L#>B3�>B3&AE79L&4;:�§�z/L!4�3�7=L&4�G&56I(79:=5Nc&Z!7=56A_3|ABD�7?>BI(794�I�56^�<&Q65N4�Gc8R{A_3&4ji m ^]k�Ih7=L&4OAB79L&4;:�l

�FL&4�AB:=4�^ld�m{P�>B3C>BQNI=A{cY4U>B<&<&QN564�G¯563�79L!56I�I=4W79Z&<°b�z/L!4�:=4�>BGXH_4�:(795NI=563!J{AB�°4;:=IO>B3|4;3d7=56:�4G&5NI�79:�56c&ZX7956AB3T563&I(794�>EG ABD�>KI�P�>BQ6>B:�¤gI�A±z�4`G&4!`#3&4�79L&4�A_:=G!4�:=5N3&JnZJo�¤$\K¥YpqZ�r ¤$\K¥�5N�sZJo�¤N\K¥i m ^]k�ItZ�r ¤$\K¥�¥Wbi>B3&GU79L!4h�E4;R�P�AB3&P�QNZ&I=5NA_3az/56Q6Q!cx4F79L!4hI=>B^�4B§wcYAB7=L�cY4;7�794;:�>EG!H_4;:�795NI=5N3&J�>E3&GcY4;7=7=4�:/4WVX<Y4�PW7?>E7=56A_3&Ih>BcYA_Z!7h>EG!H_4;:�795NI=5N3&Jaz/56Q6Q°563&G&Z!P�4O^`AB:=4*<Y4�A_<!Q64�79AUP�AB3&I=Z&^�4OA_:/>BPW7�lu�v'w_xzy!{}|4~0�����aw�w��4|4{��L{}~�� {��<�L�~��I{��I��~��!�Dxj���F�a�����;��~�|4~0�={��7�]��|��=~����$�a|��2��=��w������Lx!y!~��x!�<�!|���

� xa�L�L{�|yt�I~���x/�I{��a|]�I�_�4{}���

Page 115: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u�r!u����� ���e����T�������T�

R ��F��� �¯-�0�"® &"� �$���'*� $����w #"���0¦+.-/���10($

 ®D�H_AE794�:�79Z&:�3&A_Z!7�56I�>�P�A_38Hi5NHi56>BQY>BP;7=5NHi5N7\R¯¤gI�4�4���L&>B<!794;:�b��8¥Wbd79L&4;3�79L&5NI�G!56:=4;P;7=QNR�P�A_387=:9>BG&5NP;7=I^�4�G&56>B36W®HBAB794;:17\Ri<Y4�:�4�I=Z!QN79I;bEz/L&5NP?La>BI�I=Z&^�4�7=L#>E7w>jP�>E3&G&56G&>E794yz/56Q6Q8G!A�L&5NI�cY4�I(7w79Aj^¦> V!5N^`5���479L!4�3dZ&^fcY4�:hABDw<x4;A_<&Q64�z/L&A`I�Ri^�<#>E79L!5���4Oz/5N7=L±L!56Ih<xA_I�5N7=56A_3�l�X P�>B3!G&56G#>@794Oz/L&A¦P;Q�>B5N^`I�7=AL#>�H_4j>�I=^`>BQ6QiD]A_Q6QNA�z/563&J&bB>BQ6Q!ABDxz/L!A_^ z/56QNQX7=Z&:=3�A_Z!7�79A�HBAB794Ebi^`>�RaG&AOcY4;7=7=4�:�79L&>B3`AB3&4Fz/L&AL#>BIh>aQ�>E:=J_4;:�b&^�A_:=4*7=4�<&5NG�b!D]A_QNQ6A�z/563!J&l

�O5SH_4;3�79L!56I�P�Q�>E56^Kb�7=L&4KkiZ!4�I�7=56A_3�ABD�z/L&4;:=4±P�>B3&G!56G#>E7=4�I`I=L&A_Z!Q6G�<&Q�>BP;4K7=L&4�^�I=4;QNHB4�I`7=A^`>@VX56^�5���4�79L&4;56:�I=L&>B:=4�ABDyH_AB7=4�IMP�>BI(7�cY4�P;A_^`4;IM>K3&AB3d7=:=5SHX56>BQ�A_3!4Bl¦�XZ&P?L~>{^�AXG!4�Q�ABD�P�>B3�WG&5NG#>E794¯<&Q�>BP;4�^�4�387{^`>�R�L#>�HB4C4;kdZ&56QN56c&:�5�>Tz/L&4�:�4CI�A_^�4�P�>B3!G&56G#>@794�I{<!Q�>BP;4¯79L&4;^`I�4�QSH_4�Ie>@74WVi7=:=4�^�4�Ij>B3&GeI�A_^`4O<&Q6>BP�4*7=L&4�^�I=4;QNHB4�Ih563{79L&4OP;4�38794;:�l

R ��F�7S �e"�'���'� ��

X�38Rdz/L&4;:=4M563&P;:=4�>EI=4�G{G!4�^`>B3&Ge563&P;:=4�>BI=4;I�79L&4�4�V!<Y4�PW794;G±<#>�RBAB��D]A_:�>B3e>BI=I�4;7�b&79L&5NI�^`AiG&4;Qx5NI>B<&<!Q656P�>Bc&QN4Bl���5NHB4�3K>B38R{ABD179L!4�I=5N7=Z#>E7=56A_3&I�4�3dZ&^�4�:9>@794�GKA_3e<#>BJB4�� fXbX7=L&4O:=4;I=Z&QS79IFL&4;:=4O^¦>�RcY4MZ!I=4�GK79AU<&:�AXG&Z!P�4O^`AB:=4O>BP;P�Z&:=>E794�D]A_:�4�P�>EI�79I/ABDw4WVX<Y4�P;7=4�G±<#>�R_AB�xI�l

�FL&4�:�4�>BG&4;:�z/5NQ6Q�3&AB7=4`79L&>E7�7=L&4¦^�AXG!4�Q�<&:=4;I=4;3d7=4�G�I=A±Dg>B:�Dg>BQNQ6I! �Z&I(7fI=L!A_:�7�ABDF<&:�A Hi5N3&J79L&>E7�QN4�<!7=A_�dZ&:�7=AB795NPO:=4;7=Z&:=3!I*>B:�4�P�>BZ&I=4;GTc8R±P;A_38Hi5NHi5�>BQN5N7\R¦4;�x4�P;7=I�§F5S7jI�L&A�z�4;G�79L#>@7�G&4;^¦>E3&Gz�A_Z&Q6G{cY4�Q64;<!79AB�iZ!:�79AE7956PEbXc!Z!7F79L&5NI�5NI�A_3&QSR¦L#>�HB4�ABD�79L&4�I�Z&<&<&QSR�>B3!GKG!4�^`>B3&G{^�AXG&4;QYz/L!56P?Lz�A_Z&Q6GUL#>�HB4h7=AMcY4�z/:=5S7=7=4�3UA_Z!7�7=AMP;A_^�<&Q64W794�QSR�4�VX<&Q�>B5N3U<&:=5NP�4�I;l��#Z&Q6QSRMI=<Y4�P�5SD�Ri563&J�79L!4h^�AiG&4�Q56IF3!AB7j>UG!5�"�P�Z&QS7F4WVi7=4�3&I�56A_3�b¢c&ZX7j5NIFcx4WR_A_3!G±79L!4MI�P�A_<Y4OABD179L&5NIFP?L#>B<!7=4�:�l

R ��F��# $~-�+%���� #"('*) )y�#-!&'�*$(��'*�*)+��$-,�"%-�' )y-/-h��$

2*3&4M<xA_I�I=5Nc&Q64M4WVi794;3&I=5NA_3¯7=A�7=L&4�^�AXG!4�Q�56I/79A�7?>B�E4�5N3d7=A¦>EP�P�ABZ&387�79L!4�I�5���4�ABDw7=L&4�AB<&<xABI=563!JJ_:�A_Z&<�l��iP?LiZ!4�I=I�Q64;:Op d/.@vY<xAB563879I�A_Z!7�7=L#>E7y5ND10Br32£ABDx79L&4h<YA_<&Z&Q6>E795NA_3a56I�563`>OJ_:=A_Z!<�7=L&4�>EP;79AB:z/56I�L&4�I�79A4 �AB563�b879L!4�3� �A_5N3&563!J�^`>B�B4;I�>�I(7?>E7=4�^�4�387F>EcxA_ZX7�7=L&4*>BPW79A_:�>B3&G`L&56I�cx4;Q6564WD]I�l5�Z!7�5SD./.32�ABD�79L!4�<YA_<&Z&Q6>E795NA_3{56I/5N3K7=L#>E7jJ_:=A_Z!<�b#79L&4;36 �A_5N3&563&JU5NIj>U^�4�>B3&5N3&J_QN4�I=I/G&4WDg>BZ&QS7�>EP;795NA_3�l�FL&5NI�56^�<&Q65N4�I�79L#>@7�A_3&4jz�A_Z!Q6G{4�37 �A R� �A_563!563&J�>�J_:=ABZ&<{^`AB:=4�5SD�79L&4�A_<&<YA_I=5S7956AB3¦56I�Q�>B:�J_4�c&ZX7

Page 116: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u�r�f3&AB7�79AiA�Q�>B:�J_4Bl��X563&P;4�7=L&4a<x4;:=P;4�387?>BJB4aABD�<x4;A_<&QN4�563±79L&4aA_<!<xA_I�5N7=56A_3±56I�uj­��Ybx79L!56I*^�4�>B3!I79L&>E7F79L&4�HE>BQNZ&4*D]Z&3&PW7956AB3¯©¦¤]��t��&¥�z�A_Z&QNG±cY4O3&A_3&^�A_3&AE79A_3&5NP*563��xl

�FL&4O<&:=AiABD]I�5N3�79L&5NI�P?L#>B<X794�:F:�4�QN564�G¦L&4�>�Hi56QSR�A_3{^�A_3&AB7=A_3&5NP�5N7\RBb!>E3&G�D]A_:�J_AiAiG{:=4�>EI=A_3�§�5SDz�4�>EQ6Q6A�z ©¦¤���t��&¥x7=AhcY4�3&A_3!^`A_3!AB79A_3!56P�5N3��xb�79L&4;3MHi56:(79Z#>EQ6QNRj>B38R�cY4�L&>�Hi5NA_:�P�>B3OcY4�4WVX<&Q6>B563&4;Gc8ReI=A_^�4M>BG&^�56I�I=56c!Q64�HE>BQNZ&4�D]Z&3&P;7=56A_3°b#Q64�>�Hi563!J�Z!Ihz/5S79L±>UHE>BP;Z&A_Z&I/79L&4;A_:�RBl��FL&4;:=4WD]A_:=4EbxA_3!4^fZ&I(7hcx4�P�>BZ!795NA_Z&I/563eG&4;I=5NJ_3&563!JU>U7=L&4�A_:(R�79L&>E7F7?>B�E4�I/79L&5NIF563879A�>BP;P�A_Z!3d7�l

�FL&4�I=>B^�4�^�56I�I=563!J�Dg>BP;4;7h79L#>@7��XP?LdZ&4;I=I�Q64�:�G&56I�P�Z&I�I=4�I*>BQ6I�A`^`>B�B4;Ij7=L&56Ih^`AiG&4;Q�563#>B<!<&:=A�W<&:�5�>E7=4UD]AB:MI(79Z&GXRX5N3&J±Dg>EI=L&5NA_3�JBAXAiG&I�� �! Y%��� l`�FL&4�I�79AB:�R|79A_QNG|cdRC^`>B38R|ABD�7=L&4�^`AiG&4�QNI�ABDDg>BI�L&56A_3TJBAXAiG&IU¤g>B3&G|^¦>E3dRKDg>BI�L&56A_3T^`>BJ8> ��563!4�I?¥h56I�7=L#>E7�79L!4�:=4U>E:=4.gsDg>BI=L&5NA_3TQ64�>BG&4;:=I � z/L&A79:(R{79A�G&56I(795N3&J_Z&5NI=L{79L&4;^`I�4�QSH_4�IhD]:=A_^ AB79L&4;:=I;bx>E3&G±7=L&4�L!A_5�<xABQ6Q6AB5xz/L&A�79:�R{7=A`4;^fZ&Q6>E794�79L!4Dg>BI�L&56A_3�Q64�>BG&4�:�I�bFc&ZX7�3&AB7`4�>EP?L AB79L&4;:�l > 4Kz�ABZ&Q6G�>BJ8>B5N3�3&4;4�G > ^�AiG&4�QF79L&>E7¦5N3&P�QNZ&G&4;I^fZ&QS795N<&Q64jJ_:=A_Z!<&IF79AUG&4�I�P�:�56cY4O7=L&4OI=5S79Z#>E7=56A_3°l

��� ��� ��� �K� ��� �� ����T��� �T��� �e������

�FL&5NI�I=4;P;795NA_3e>B3#>EQNR ��4;I�I=A_^�4*G#>@7?>�D]A_:�HX5N4;z�4�:�I=L&5N<{ABD1� ��I=<Y4�P;5�>BQNI�l� ®7�`&3&G&IF4;Hi5NG&4�3&P;4*79L#>@779L!4¯G&5NI�79:�56c&ZX7956AB3�AED*79L&4±3dZ&^fcY4�:¦AED*Hi564;z�4�:�I{>BP;:=A_I�I¦<&:�A_J_:9>E^`IU56I�3&AB7`Z&3&5N^`AiG#>BQ¡l��FL&5NII=Z!<&<xAB:�79IF7=L&4OLdRi<YAB79L!4�I=5NIh7=L#>E7/� � Hi564;z/5N3&JU56I/>aP�AB3dHi5SHX56>BQ�J_AiAiG�l

�FL&4 g L!4�:=G!563&J � Q65N7=4�:=>E79Z&:�4Bb�>BIaG!56I=P;Z&I=I�4�G�A_3�<#>BJ_4 �XuBbyP�>B3�3&AB7U4�V!<!Q�>B5N3~79L&5NI�§�5S7fI9>�RiI79L&>E7�I�A_^`4hHi564;z�4�:�IF�d3&A�z�7=L#>E7�7=L&4�I�L&A�zqz/5NQ6Q¢cY4�J_AiAXGT¤gA_:�3&AB7�¥�b!>E3&G�79L&4WR¦5N3!D]A_:�^ AB79L&4;:=I;bz/L&AK79L&4;3~L&4�:�G[>BQNA_3&Jez/5N79L|79L!4¦563XD]A_:=^`>E795NA_3T<&:�A Hi5NG&4�:;l 5�Z!7�� �,I=<Y4�P;5�>BQNIM>B:=4�A_3&4zW®795N^`4c&:�A8>BG&P�>BI�7=I�bi^`4�>B3&563!JO7=L#>E7y3&AMA_3&4hL#>BIy^`AB:=4F563XD]A_:=^`>E795NA_3U>BcYA_Z!7�7=L&4jI�L&A�z � I�kdZ#>BQ65S7\Rf79L&>B3>B38R_AB3&4T4�QNI=4Bl"!�HB4�:�RBA_3&4|I=4;4�I�7=L&4�I9>E^`4¯>BG!H_4;:�7=56I=4;^`4;3879I{cY4;D]A_:�4�L#>B3!G�bh>B3&G �d3&A�z/I�79L#>@74;HB4�:(R_A_3&4±4�QNI=4{L#>BI�>BIU^fZ!P?L�5N3!D]A_:�^¦>E7=56A_3~>BIf79L&4WR[G&A&l[�FL!4�:=4K56I�3&A�5N3!D]A_:�^¦>E7=56A_3C79A|cY4P�>EI=P�>EG&4�G�l

�FL&4�:�4;D]A_:�4Bb�79L&4�Hi5N4;z�4�:=I�L&56<�ABDh� � I�<x4;P�56>BQ6I;b�5NDh5N7�56I�7=ATcx4�^�AiG&4�QNQ64�G >BIa563!P�Q6Z!G&563&J¯>P�AB3dHi5SHX56>BQ65S7\R�P�A_^�<xAB3&4�387�b/:�4�kdZ&56:�4�Ie>~I�56^fZ&QS7?>B3!4�A_Z&I`^`AiG&4;Q�I=Z!P?Lq>EI�79L&4�AB3&4T<&:=4;I=4;3d7=4�GL&4;:=4Bl

Page 117: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u�r mR ������� � �w ��

 �Z&I�4�>UI=4W7�AED�:9>@79563!J_IFG#>E79>UD]Z&:�3&56I�L&4�GK79A�^`4Oc8R i±5NP?L#>B4�Q ��L8z�4Bbxz/L!A¦A_c!79>B563!4�Ge79L&4OG#>E79>G&5N:=4�PW79QSRCD]:�A_^ X �qch564;Q6I=4;3�lT�FL&4WR~P�A�HB4�:fHi5Nz�4�:�I=L&5N<~D]A_:a2*P;7=A_cY4�:�u .����!b��#4�c!:=Z#>B:(R�u .��/.!b>B3&G��BZ&QSR�u .�� .!l

�FL&4TG#>E79> I=<Y4�P;5 `#4;G�z/L&56P?L <!:=A_J_:=>B^�I`z�4�:=4TAB3&4!W�7956^�4KI=<Y4�P�56>BQ6I;l >�5S79L&5N3�I=<Y4�P;5�>BQNI�bF 4WVXP;Q6Z&G&4;G�7=L&:=4;4eQ�>B:�J_4�P�Q6>BI=I�4�IUABDh<&:�A_J_:9>E^±b�c#>BI�4�G�A_3~79L!4eDg>EP;7a79L&>E7U563!D]AB:=^`>E795NA_3 >EcxA_ZX779L!4*kdZ#>BQ65S7\R�ABD�I=Z&P?LK<&:�A_J_:9>E^`Iy^¦>�R`4WVX56I(7/>B3&G{cY4*Z&3!4;H_4;3&QNR¦G&56I(79:�56c&Z!7=4�G{>E^`A_3!Jf<xAE794�387=5�>BQHi564Wz�4;:=I�bB>BQ6QNA�z/563&J�D]A_:�5N3!D]A_:�^¦>E7=56A_3�P�>BI�P�>BG&4;I�l��FL!4�I=4yP�Q6>BI=I�4�I�>B:=4�� ��c&:�A8>BG&P�>BI�7=I�ABDX^�A Hi5N4�I�bI=5N3&P�4�7=L&A_I=4�z/L&AhI9>�z 7=L&4y^`A�Hi564�5N3O7=L&4�>@79:=4;I�P�A_Z&QNG�5N3&5N7=5�>E7=4�>B3M563XD]A_:=^`>E795NA_3�P�>BI=P�>BG&4�_I=<YA_:�7=I4;HB4�3879I;b�5NDwA_3&QSR{cx4;P�>BZ!I=4�7=L&4;RK563!P�Q6Z!G&4O^¦>B38Re:�4�<Y4�>E7=563&J`4;H_4;3879I*I�Z&P?L|>BI/79L&4 > AB:=Q6G��X4�:�564;IA_:�2�QSRi^`<&5NP�I�!>B3!G�I=<&5N36W\AE�°IyABD�4WVX5NI�795N3&J�7=4�QN4;Hi56I�56A_3`<&:=A_JB:9>B^�I�biI=Z&P?Le>EI�I=<Y4�P;5�>BQY4�<&5NI=AiG&4�I�ABD>aI=5S79P�AB^,c&:=A_>BG&P�>EI�7j>E7h>aI=<Y4�P;5�>BQ�L&ABZ&:FA_:/:=4W79:=ABI=<Y4�P;7=5NHB4�IhABDwQNA_3&J�W®:=Z&3!3&563&J�<&:=A_JB:9>B^�I�l

�FL&56Ij<#>B:�563&J�W®G&A�z/3±QN4;D�7��/�`I�<x4;P�56>BQ6I;b¢z/5S79L±G#>E7?>�563±>BQ6Q�AED�79L&4�G&4�^�A_J_:=>B<&L&5NPOP�>E7=4�J_A_:�564;IQ65NI�7=4�Gecx4;Q6A�zOl

R �����7S � ,*� &�'�"(+�-/�'��0("\ � ��$X$-&�+%�j #"%-�'

�FL&4K�B4WR�>EI=I=Z!^`<!7=56A_3�ABDj79L&4e^�AXG!4�QFL&4;:=4K56Ia79L#>@7a79L&4;:=4K56I�>CZ!3&56^�AXG&>BQ�G&5NI�7=:=56c!Z!795NA_3[ABDHi564Wz�4;:=I � 7?>BI(794;I¦D]A_:`>B38R�J_5SH_4;3�<&:=ABJ_:9>B^Kl��*4;Hi5�>@7956AB3&I�D]:�A_^ 79L!56I¦P;A_Z&QNG�cY4¯G&Z&4±79A�7\z�A<YA_I=I�56c&QN4*P�>BZ!I=4�I;§y7=L&4�G&5NI�79:�56c&ZX7956AB3�ABD1<&:=ABJ_:9>B^ kdZ#>BQ65S7\R¦5NI�D]Z&3&G&>B^`4;387?>BQNQNR`^fZ&QN7=56^�AXG&>BQ�b_AB:79L!4O79>BI�7=4�D]A_:/>B38R{J_5SH_4�3K<&:�A_J_:9>E^ 56IF^�Z&QN7=56^�AXG#>EQ�l

X <&:=A_JB:9>B^ � IakdZ#>EQ65N7\R~56IU>B3�>B^`>BQ6J8>E^¦>E7=56A_3�ABDh79L&4{z�A_:=�[ABD�G&A/�;4�3&I�A_:aLdZ&3&G&:�4�G&I`ABD563!G&5NHi56G!Z#>BQ6I;§°z/:=5S794;:=I�b@<&:�AXG&Z!P�4�:�I�b@794�P?L!3&56P;5�>B3&I;bEI�4;7�G&4�I�56J_3!4�:=I;b_>B3!G�A_3�W\I=P;:=4;4�3�79>BQ64;3d7�l 5�4�5N3&JI=Z!P?L±>E3{>B^`>BQ6J8>E^¦>E7=56A_3°bB5N7�I=4;4�^�I�79L&4'��4�3879:=>BQ m 56^�5N7y�FL&4;A_:=4;^ ¤ � m �h¥�z�A_Z&QNG{cx4j56G&4�>BQ�§w>I=4;:=5N4�IwAED#:=4�>BI=A_3&>Bc&QNRO5N3&G&4;<x4;3&G&4�387wG&:9>�z/I�>B:�4�^`>BG&4�D]:=AB^�G&A/��4;3&IwAED#G&5N�x4�:�4�387�G&56I(79:=5Nc&Z!7=56A_3&I¤]7=L&4�<YAXABQyAEDFz/:=5N7=563&JK7?>BQN4�387�bwI=4;7UG!4�I=5NJ_3 79>BQ64;3d7�b�4;7fP�4;7=4�:=>8¥Wb�>B3!G 79L&4¦<&:=A_JB:9>B^ � I�A�H_4�:=>BQ6QkdZ#>BQN5N7\R�5NIM>ez�4�5NJ_L8794�GC^�4�>B3CABD�7=L&4�I�4`5N3&G&5SHX5NG&Z#>BQ�G&:9>�z/I;l¦�FL&4 � m � 7=L&4�3CI9>�RiI�7=L#>E7O79L!4G&5NI�79:�56c&ZX7956AB3{ABDw<!:=A_J_:=>B^ kdZ#>EQ65N7\R¦I=L&ABZ&Q6GecY4jchA_:=^`>BQ�¤g>B3&G{79L!4�:=4WD]A_:=4OZ&3!56^�AXG#>EQ�¥Wl

Page 118: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u�r�d������������ ���� ������ �����������$ ���� ���� �!�����"�# ��$���%�'&(���#�4� ���)�*�4� �+�$�,�����

2*3&4¦^`>�RC4WVX<&Q�>E563�7=L&4�:�4�I=Z!QN7�7=L#>E7�HX5N4;z�4�:�I=L&5N<~56I�^fZ&QN7=56^�AXG&>BQ�c8R P;Q�>B5N^`5N3&J�79L&>E7�Hi564Wz�4;:7?>EI�794;I�>E:=4O^fZ&QS7956^�AiG#>BQ�bdc&ZX7h7=L&56IFI�56^�<&QNR¦:=4;I�7?>@794�I/79L!4MkdZ&4;I�7=56A_3±A_3¯>aG&5S�°4;:=4;3d7�>@VX56I;§�z/LdR>B:�4O79>BI�7=4�I/^fZ&QS795N^`AiG#>BQ�-

>�5N7=L&A_Z!7h:=4WD]4�:�4�3&P;4�79A�I=AB^`4OG&4;I=56:�4M7=A`4;^fZ&Q6>E794OAB7=L&4�:�Ij5N3±A_3!4 � IjP;A_L&A_:(7�b¢4WVX<&Q6>B3#>E7=56A_3&ID]A_:F^fZ!QN795N^`AiG#>BQ#79>BI�7=4�Ij>B:=4�5N^`<YA_I=I�56c&QN4�79AU^`>B�B4OP;Q64�>E:�l

�#A_:*4WV!>B^�<&QN4Bb�A_3!4fP�A_^�^�A_3T>B:�J_Z&^�4�387�56Ij79L#>E7*P�4�:(7?>B5N3T:9>BP;5�>BQ�A_:*G&4;^`ABJ_:9>B<!56P�JB:=A_Z&<!IL#>�H_4¦>K<!:=4;D]4;:=4;3&P�4�D]A_:�P�4;:�7?>E563|7\RX<Y4�I�ABD�G&:=4;I=I�AB:M^�Z&I=5NPBb�z/L&56P?L�56^�^`4;G&5�>@794�QSRK4�3&J_4;3&G&4;:=I79L!4fkdZ&4�I(7956AB3�§hz/L8R¯G&A{I=A_^�4�JB:=A_Z&<!I*<&:=4WD]4�:*AB3&4�D]A_:�^�A�H_4;:*79L&4�AB79L&4;:.-��FL&56I*kdZ&4;I�7=56A_3T5NI4�I�<x4;P�56>BQ6QSRUG&5�"�P�Z!QN7�J_5NHB4�3¦7=L#>E7�^`>B38R�I=4;4�^�563&J_QSR�G&56I�<#>B:9>@794/D]A_:=^�I�biI=Z&P?LK>BI�I=4;<&L#>B:�G&56P*ABZ&G^fZ&I�56PF>E3&GUI=Z&:(D]4�:�:=AiP?�¢bdcx4�>B:�>�P�QNA_I=4�:�4�I�4�^fc&Q6>B3&P;4h5N3fI=<!5N794FAED°>*HB4�:�RfG&56I�<#>B:9>@794�D]A_QNQ6A�z/563!J&l0/

�XA_^�4�>B:�J_Z&4y79L#>E7w^`4;^fcY4�:=I1ABD¢P;4�:�79>B563�J_:=A_Z!<&I�>BQNQdI=L#>B:�4�>�P;A_^�^`A_3�Z&<&c&:�563&JB563&J&b@^�4�>B36W563!J�79L#>@7/>BQ6QYP�AB3&I=Z&^�4�:�IFABD�79L!56I�J_4;3&4�:=>E795NA_3{>BQNQxL&>BG{<#>B:�4�3879I/>B3!G�794�>EP?L&4�:�I/z/L!AaP�A_3&I�Z&^�4�G79L!4¯I9>E^`4K^fZ&I�56PK>B3&G�z�A_:�4±P;Q6AB7=L&563&JC563�79L!4¯I9>E^`4K^¦>E3&3&4�:;l�2�D�P�A_Z!:=I=4Eb�79L&5NI`G!AX4;I`3&AE7>B3&I(z�4;:f79L&4¦kiZ!4�I�7=56A_3~D]:�A_^ 79L&4¦<&:=4WHX5NA_Z&I�<#>B:9>EJ_:9>B<!L�b�c&Z!7f:=4�<!L&:9>BI�4�Ia5S7f563C794;:=^�IfABDF79L!4<&:�4;Hi56A_Z!IhJB4�3&4;:9>E7=56A_3�l

X�:=4;Q�>E7=4�Ge>B:�J_Z&^�4�387F56I�79L#>E7�I=4�>E:=P?LK56I�G&5 "�P�Z&QS7�bX>B3&GeI=AU^�4�^fcY4�:�I�ABD�>fP�A_L!A_:�7FQNAXAB�U7=A4�>EP?LTAB79L&4;:�79A¦G&4;7=4�:=^�563!4�z/L#>E7*^`4;G&5�>`>B:=4�ABD�L&56JBL�kdZ#>BQ65S7\R_lj�FL&56I*5NI�G&5 "�P�Z&QS7j7=A{I=Z&<&<YA_:(7cY4�P�>EZ&I=4aI�4�>B:�P?LC5N3¯79L!4aP�A_38794�Vi7OL&4�:�4Bb�c&:�A8>BG&P�>BI�7�794�QN4;Hi56I�56A_3¯563¯7=L&4*1*��X ABD�79L&4¦u .��_rBI;b°5NI>BI�P?L&4�>B<C>BI*<&Z!I=L&5N3&JK>�c&Z!7=7=A_3TA_3C>�:=4;^`AE794�P;A_3879:�A_Q�lO \3T79L&4aP;A_38794�VX7OAED�ABZ&GTHXI;l�I�Z&:�D]4;:^fZ&I�56PEbd7=L&4hI=4�>E:=P?L�P;Q�>B5N^ 56I�7=L#>E7y<x4;A_<&QN4h:�4�kdZ&5N:=4hL&4�QN<�D]:�A_^ 79L!4�56:�P;A_L&A_:(7y7=A�G!4;794;:=^�563&4/79L!4kdZ#>BQN5N7\Re3&AB7�ABD�5N3&G&5NHi5NG&Z#>BQ�<Y4�:(D]A_:=^�4�:�I�bYc&Z!7*AED<@/O2GLK�2!@43J@/O52z@/P�°79L&5NIj<!Q�>BP;4�I*>E3�Z&3&G&Z!4�Q64WH_4;QABD�I�7=Z&<&56G!5N7\R{Z&<YA_3{79L!4MP;A_3&I�Z&^`4;:�l

 \3qI�L&A_:(7�b/79L&4C>B:�J_Z&^�4�3879Ie>BI�7=A[z/LdR�7?>BI(794�IK>B:�4T^fZ&QS7956^�AiG#>BQ�b�A_:�79L&>E7{P�4;:�79>B563�G&4zW^�A_J_:9>E<&L&56POJ_:�A_Z&<&Ih794;3&G¯79A�z�>B:=G¯P�4�:(7?>B5N3¯<&:�A_J_:=>B^`I;bxP�>B3¯3!AB7*cY4�I=>E795NI�Dg>BPW79A_:�56QNR¦G&4�I�P�:�56cY4�Gz/5N7=L&A_Z!7�I=A_^�4�:�4;D]4;:=4�3!P�4f79A�>¦I=5N^`<&QN4�G!4�I=5N:=4�7=A�4�^�Z&Q�>E7=4�AB7=L&4�:�I76�z/L&56P?LT5NIj79L!4a>BQN7=4�:�3#>E794L8Ri<xAB7=L&4�I�56I�794;I�794;G�L&4;:=4Bly�iA�c8R�>BI�I=Z&^�563&J�>OZ&3&56^�AiG#>BQ!G!56I�7=:=5Nc&Z!795NA_3UABD°79>BI�7=4�I;biz�4jJB5NH_4/79L!43dZ&Q6Q°LdRi<YAB79L!4�I=5NIf¤]3&A�G&4�I�56:=4*7=A`4;^fZ&Q6>E794*AE79L&4;:=I?¥/>aP?L#>B3&P;4M7=AUcx4�79:�Z&4Bl

8:9 {����;9 xz�}~!�=< ��a�L~twt��${����=~7>�|4~�� �L�4~_�L�4�L� ~��Dy!~�|4�L~a��{}�@?�~��x!|4~��L~!�BA�{��Dw���L{}�<�,�a|�L{}�$�I� �z� � ��x �F{}|4y�xC {��4�=�}~ED2xa�N�I~��I|]w�~��}�=�=�]�a|�x!|�~���~0�7�I�L{�� y!�4{��Ix!���=�L�!w�~,�I{�w�~�� �=�!�4���{}|4y<�L�4~:�I���F�L�4wA�

Page 119: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u�r30����� �� � ���#� � �� � � ����� ��� �$���2�#� 2*3&4h`#3#>BQ�I�Z&J_J_4;I�7=56A_3Tz/5N7=LTz/L&56P?L|79L&4�>BZX79L&A_:OL#>EIABD�7=4�3Ccx4;4�3CP�A_3!D]:�A_38794;G�5NI�>EI*D]A_Q6QNA z/I;§O>BI=I�Z&^�4U7=L#>E7O4WH_4�:(RC<xAB7=4�387956>BQwHi564Wz�4;:OL#>BIM4WV!>BP;7=QNR79L!4MI=>B^�4O79>BI�7=4�I;bx>E3&G±4�V!>BP;7=QNR�7=L&4�I=>B^�4*HB>EQ6Z&4OABD179L&4;56:�7=56^�4Bl��FL&4;3¯4;HB4�:(R_A_3&4�z/56Q6QxJ8>BZ&JB479L!4�kdZ#>BQN5N7\ReABD�>�<&:=ABJ_:9>B^ 4;kdZ#>BQ6QSRY§�5ND�79L&4�<&:=A_JB:9>B^ 5NIj3&AE7jz�A_:�7=L�A_3&4 � Ij7956^�4Bb#5S7jz/5NQ6Q�3&AE7cY4`z�A_:�7=L[>B38RicxAiG!R � I�7956^�4���>B3&G I�56^�56Q6>B:=QSR¯5SD�79L&4`<&:=ABJ_:9>B^ 5NIMz�A_:(79L8R_l±�FLiZ!I�b�>1chA_:=^`>BQG&5NI�79:�56c&ZX7956AB3�ABD�<&:�A_J_:9>E^ kdZ#>BQN5N7\R�P�>B3ekdZ&5NP?�iQSR�QN4�>BG�7=AU>fI=L#>B:�<&QNR`c&5N^`AiG#>BQYG&56I(79:�56c&Z!7=56A_3`ABD79Z!:=3&A_ZX79I�l��jA�z�4WH_4;:�bd79L&5NIw^�AXG&4;Q!5NIwc#>BI�4�GUA_3f7=L&4�P�QN4�>B:�QNRODg>BQNI=4F>BI�I=Z&^�<!7=56A_3&I�79L#>E7w4;HB4�:�RBA_3&456Iy56G!4�38795NP�>BQ¡bd>B3&G`Dg>E56Q6I�7=A�cY4j:�A_c&Z&I(7�7=AMz�4�>B�E4�3&5N3&JaABDx79L#>E7�>BI�I=Z&^�<!795NA_3�l� ®D�<x4;A_<&Q64 � I�7?>EI�794;IA_:yHB>EQ6Z&4;I�D]A_:�7=56^�4�>E:=4�chA_:=^`>BQ6QSRaG&5NI�79:�56c&ZX794�G°bXz�4*L#>�H_4*7=L&4*^�AXG&4;QxAED��X4�PW7956AB3 0Xl�d!l�fXbdz/5N7=L���qr!lbX�I/I�Z&P?L�bY>aZ&3&56^�AiG#>BQ°G!56I�7=:=5Nc&Z!795NA_3{ABD179Z&:�3&A_Z!7Fz/5NQ6Q�:�4�I�Z&QN7�l

R ������# � �� -,*-h�

 fZ&I�4T�X5NQNHB4�:=^`>B3 � Ia794;I�7�AED*c&5N^`AiG#>BQN5N7\R�p 0Xu;v�l  ®7`56IUc#>BI�4�G�AB3�79L!56IUD]Z&3&P;7=56A_3°§��w¤���t�C¥�� ������������������� ���� "!#�

$&% ! t�z/L!4�:=4� o�t�;r�t('(')'* $ >B:=4U79L!4`G#>@7?>eA_c&I=4;:�HB4�G�b,+¤.-!¥�56IM>ncjA_:�^¦>EQ\¤¡rXt�u ¥G&4;3&I=5S7\R�D]Z&3!P;795NA_3�4WHE>BQ6Z#>@794�Gf>E7/-Yb_>E3&G10f56I�>jI�^`AiAB79L!563&Jh<#>B:=>B^`4W794;:�l���56J_Z&:�4 0il}mhI=L&A�z/I�79L!44;�x4�PW7/ABD1:9>B5NI=5N3&J20eA_3�79L&4�I=L#>B<Y4�ABD�79L!4A`&7=7=4�G{P�Z!:�H_4Eb#Z&I=5N3&JfHi564Wz�4;:=I=L!56<eG#>E79>�D]A_:F>BQNQx^�4�3�l>�L&4;330�5NIUHB4�:(R�I�^¦>EQ6Q�b�7=L&4 cjA_:�^¦>BQ�G&56I(79:=5Nc&Z!7=56A_3&IU>E:=A_Z&3!G�4�>BP?L�G#>@7?>|<xA_5N387¦>E<&<&:=A_>BP?LI=<!56�B4;I�b�I=A|79L&4;:=4e56Ia>T^�AXG!4e>E7U4;HB4�:�R�G&>E7?>T<YA_56387�l X�I�0�:�56I=4;I�b�79L&4eI�<&56�E4±>E:=A_Z&3!G�4�>BP?L<YA_56387OI=<!:=4�>EG&I�ABZ!7�>B3&G|^`4;:=J_4;I�z/5N79LCAB7=L&4�:OI=<!56�B4;I�b1Z&38795NQ�4;H_4;3879Z#>BQSRT79L&4U4;3d7=56:�4�G&>E7?>{I=4W756IhI=Z!c&I=Z&^�4�G¯Z&3&G&4;:�A_3&4MI=5N3&J_QN4!W\<Y4�>E�B4�G±P�Z&:(H_4Elh�FLdZ&I;bx7=L&4�:�4�56Ij>U^`A_3!AB79A_3!56PO:=4;Q�>E7=56A_3&I�L&56<cY4;7\z�4�4�340±>B3&Ge79L!4M3dZ&^�cx4;:hAEDw^�AXG!4�IF563{7=L&4OG&4�3&I�5N7\R{D]Z&3!P;795NA_3e563&G!Z&P�4;G±c8R50�l

�X56QSH_4;:=^`>B3eAB�°4;:=Ih>acxAiAB7=I�79:=>B<e^`4W79L&AiGeABDw7=4�I(79563!J`>a3dZ&QNQ�LdRi<YAB79L!4�I=5NIjAED�7=L&4�D]A_:=^ g 7=L&4G&5NI�79:�56c&ZX7956AB3[L#>BI ��AB:fD]4;z�4�:�^`AiG&4�I � l��FL&4e<&:�AXP;4�G&Z!:=4Kcx4;J_563&Iac8R `#3!G&563&JT7=L&4eI=^`>BQ6QN4�I�7HE>BQ6Z!4`ABD60~I�Z&P?L~79L#>@7 ��¤���t�C¥�L#>BI ��^�AiG&4�I��79L&4`3iZ!Q6QyLdRi<YAB79L!4�I=5NIf56IM79L#>@7�7=L&56IMHB>EQ6Z&4�ABD0�¤gL&4;:=4;56370&��¥�5NI�P;A_3&I=5NI�7=4�387az/5N7=L 79L&4`G#>E79>!l��FL&4;3�b�z�4{G!:9>�z >¯cxAiAB7=I�79:=>B< I=>B^�<&Q64Eb/ � bD]:=AB^�7=L&4OG#>E7?>XbXz/:=5S794*G!A z/3 ��¤���t� � ¥yc#>BI=4;G±AB350#��b&>B3&GeP�A_Z!3d7/5S79I�^�AiG&4�I;l��FL#>B3&�dIF79Aa79L!4^�A_3&AB7=A_3&56PO:�4�Q�>@7956AB3&I=L&5N<ecx4W7\z�4;4�380�>B3&G±79L&4M3dZ&^fcY4�:�AED�^�AXG&4;I�b¢79L&4M<Y4�:=P;4�387?>EJ_4fABDwI=Z&P?LcYAXAB7=I�7=:9>B<[G&5NI�7=:=56c!Z!795NA_3&I�z/5S79L � A_:�D]4;z�4�:U^`AiG&4;If^¦>@79P?L&4;If79L&4{QN56�B4;Q65NL&AXAiG|79L#>E7 ��¤]��t�|¥J_5SH_4�370&�a5NI�P�AB3&I=5NI�794;387fz/5N7=L 79L&4¦G#>E7?>Xl[X D]Z&QNQy<!:=AiABD/56I�563��X5NQNHB4�:=^`>B3�p 0Xu�v�l¯ ®Dhz�4�:�4� �4�PW7

Page 120: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u�r/�

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

-2000 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000

line 1

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

-2000 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000

line 1

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

-2000 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000

line 1

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

-2000 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000

line 1

��56J_Z&:�4�0Xl�m!§:X�I60±:�56I=4;I�b&7=L&4O�B4�:�3&4�Q�G&4;3&I=5S7\ReI=^�AXAE79L&IFA_ZX7h>B3&GKL#>BIFD]4;z�4�:h^`AiG&4;I�l

79L!56IyLdRi<YAB79L!4�I=5NI�bi79L&4;3¦z�4hz�ABZ&Q6G`3&4�4;G{>�QNA z�4�:yHE>BQ6Z&4/ABD 0�bX>B3&G�79L&4;:=4WD]A_:=4j^`A_:�4j^�AiG&4�I;bd7=A4WVX<&Q6>B563{7=L&4OG#>E7?>Xl

R ������� � ��$-&�0® &$

�w5NJ_Z&:=4'0Xl �il�dUQ65NI�7=IF<6W®HE>BQNZ&4�I�D]A_:�794�I(79IhABD��{^�AiG&4�I;b&:=Z&3KA�H_4;:�>a3dZ&^fcY4�:FABD�G&5S�°4;:=4�387hG&4;^`A�WJ_:=>B<&L&5NP�I=Z&cYP�>E7=4�J_AB:=564;I�l��FL&4�794;I�7=Ihz�4�:�4�:�Z&3±A�HB4�:�fBr_racYAXAB7=I�7=:9>B<e56387=4�:�HE>BQNI�l

 \3�>BQNQ�c&Z!7hA_3!4MI�Z&cYP�>E7=4�J_A_:(R_b¢z�4M:=4 �4�PW7j7=L&4OLdRi<YAB79L!4�I=5NIh7=L#>E7/79L!4�:=4M56I/A_3!QNR�AB3&4�^�AiG&4Bb>B3&GC563C>BQNQ�c&Z!7�A_3&4UI�Z&cxP�>E794;J_A_:(R_b�z�4�Dg>B56Q179AK:=4� �4;P;7�>KL8Ri<YAB79L&4;I=5NIM7=L#>E7O79L&4;:=4�>B:�4�7\z�A±AB:^�A_:=4�^`AiG&4;I�l{ \3�7=L&4¦AB3&4`P�>BI=4`z/L&4�:�4`z�4`Dg>B5NQ64�G|79A±:=4 �4�P;7�79L&4�<YA_I=I�56c&5NQ65N7\R¯ABDFA_3!4¦^�AXG&4

Page 121: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u�r3�^`>@V�� AEDw^�AXG!4�I XjQ6Qxz�A_^�4�3 >�A_^�4�3Cu �W7m�d >�A_^�4�3|u �W�d3. > A_^�4�31f/04W�0�d

u l�m��30 l �/. l .!u�� l �3�f l �3�/0 l .��30���� l � m30 l ./.30����m l ./.30���� l 0�d l .��30���� l ���d l �!u l �_r30 u_l r_r���� l . m��0 l �/. l �/. l ./� ��� l .30 ���

X�QNQ�^�4�3 i±4�3�u �W7m�d i±4�3Cu �W�d3. i±4;3 f/04W�0�du l �Br30 l�d3�30 l �/� l ��mf l �30 l ./.30 ��� l .�d � l 0��m l�d � l .30 ��� l �30 l �!ud l�m/�30 l �_r l �!u l �/�0 l � f/0 l�m/�30 l � . l .�f��

X�Q6Q°L&A_Z&I�4�L&A_QNG&I !�>BI�7 ��A8>EI�7 >�4�I(7���A_>BI�7 �iA_Z!79Lu l�m30 lSu � l}f�� l ��df l ��d l�m m l �/� l ./�����m l �/�30 l�d � l .�d� l ��fd l ._r�� l �30 l .�f�� l�m�d0 l ��d 0 l .�d�� l ��� l 0�m

�w56JBZ&:=4�0il�d&§��FL!4�JW�HE>BQ6Z&4;I�D]A_:F^�AXG#>EQ65N7\RU7=4�I�7=I�l��i7?>E:=I/563&G!56P�>@794*I�56J_3&5 `#P�>E3&P�4El

¤]z�A_^�4�3�u �W7d3._¥Wb879L&4j794�I(7F<&:�A HB4�G{4;I=<Y4�P�56>BQ6QSRUZ&3&<YA�z�4;:�D]Z&Q¡b&>B3&G`Dg>B56QN4�GU79Af:�4� �4�PW7�D]A_Z&:�A_Z!7�ABDI=5 VeABD179L&4O<&:�A_<YA_I=4;G±L8Ri<xAE79L&4;I=4�I;l

�FL&4¯7=4�I�7`79LdZ&I`J_5NHB4�I¦4WHi56G&4;3&P�4¯7=L#>E7�79L&4±G&56I(79:�56c&Z!7=56A_3�ABD*Hi5N4;z�4�:=I�L&56<�56I�^fZ&QN7=56^�AXG&>BQ>B^�A_3&J�^¦>B38R�P�ABL&A_:�7=I�l �O5SH_4�3�79L#>E7`79L&4;:=4¯>B:=4K7\z�A[A_:`^`AB:=4K^`AiG&4�I;b/>B3&G�^`>B�d563!J�79L!4>BI�I=Z&^�<!795NA_3&IOG&5NI=P�Z!I=I=4;G[>BcYA�H_4Bb�79L!4`^�AXG!4�Q�ABDF�X4�PW795NA_3 0Xl�d!l�f�794;Q6Q6I�Z!IM7=L#>E7 � 6�79L&4�G&4�I�56:�479AU4;^fZ&Q�>@794�AB7=L&4�:�I76�5NIFQ�>B:�J_4Bb&>B3&GKP�Q64�>B:=QSR¦3!A_3-��4;:=A&l

R ����� R �`��$i �-�'� �0 &*$!"(-�'

�FL&4f7=4�I�7�Dg>B56QNIh7=A�:=4 �4�P;7�7=L&4fL8Ri<xAE79L&4;I=56I*7=L#>E7j79L&4fI(79:�Z&P;7=Z&:=4aABD�G!4�^`>B3&G�D]A_:j� � I=<Y4�P;5�>BQNIG&4;^`A_3!I�79:=>E794;I�>�G&4;I=56:�4�79A�4;^fZ&Q6>E794�AB79L&4;:=I;l �jA�z�4;H_4;:�bX>B38R�I�Z&P?L�4�^fZ&Q6>E795NA_3MP�A_Z&QNGa3&AB7�L&>�HB4cY4�4�3�G&4;:=5NHB4�G�D]:=A_^ >B3�563!D]AB:=^`>E795NA_3 P�>BI=P�>BG&4Bb�I=5N3&P�4e3&ATHi564Wz�4;:=IUL#>BG�^`AB:=4�5N3!D]A_:=^`>E7=56A_3>BcYA_Z!7f7=L&4�<&:�A_J_:=>B^`I�<&:=5NA_:�7=A�79L&4;56:�AB3&4!W�7956^�4¦c!:=A8>BG!P�>BI(7�lC�FL&4e>B3#>BQSRiI=56I�>BI=I�Z&^�4�G[79L#>@7Z&3&G!4�:=QSRi563&J{7?>EI�794;IMz�4�:�4`Z!3&56^�AXG&>BQ�b�c!Z!7M5N7�5NIMG!5�"�P�Z&QS7�79Ae4WVX<&Q6>B563Tz/L8RT79L&>E7�>BI=I�Z&^`<X7956AB3z�A_Z&Q6G�3&AB7`cY4e7=:=Z&4K5NDj<Y4�A_<&QN4eL#>�H_4¯3!A 56387=4�:=4;I�7`563�4�^�Z&Q�>E7=563&J|AB7=L&4�:U^�4�^fcY4�:�I`AEDj7=L&4�5N:

Page 122: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u�r��J_:�A_Z&<�l

����� � ����� ���T�������

k�4;A_<&QN4CJ_>B563�Z!7=56Q65S7\R�D]:�A_^ cY4�L&>�Hi5N3&J�QN56�E4TAB79L&4;:=IK563�>[^fZ&QS795N7=Z&G&4TABD�I=5S79Z#>@7956AB3&I�l  ®Df>BQ6Q563!G&5NHi56G!Z#>BQ6I�>BPW7aI=5N^fZ&QN79>B3&4;A_Z&I=QSR_b�L&A�z�4;HB4�:�b�79L!4{<&:=A_c!Q64�^�ABDh<&:�4�G&5NP;795N3&J�L&A�z AB79L!4�:=Ifz/5NQ6QcY4�L#>�H_4O7\Ri<&56P�>BQ6QSR¦:�4�kdZ&5N:=4�Ih^�A_:=4�5N3!D]A_:=^`>E7=56A_3�79L#>B3±>B38R{A_3!4M<Y4�:�I=A_3KL#>BI;l

�FL&4�:�4K>B:=4¦7\z�A|P�Q6>BI=I�4�IaABDh4�kdZ&5NQ65Nc&:=56>!§aA_3&4{5NIfG&4�I�P�:�56cY4�G�c8R[>�P�ZX79AB��Q64;HB4�Q�AEDh79>BI�7=4�I;b>BcYA�H_4�z/L&5NP?L�<Y4�A_<&QN4*>BPW7 �!>B3&G¦7=L&4�AB7=L&4�:�56I�P?L#>B:9>EP;794;:=5���4�G{c8R`G&56I �A_56387yI=4W79IFABD�>BP;7=A_:=I;l��FL&4`#:�I�7aP�>E794;J_A_:�R�563!P�Q6Z!G&4�I�3&A_:=^`>BQ�G&5NI�79:�56c&ZX7956AB3&I�5N3 79L!4¦Z&3&5N3!D]A_:�^¦>E7=5NHB4`<&:�56A_:MP�>EI=4e>B3&G H�G&5NI�79:�56c&ZX7956AB3&IO563|79L&4�D]Z&Q6Q�563XD]A_:=^`>E795NA_3TP�>EI=4Bb�z/L&56QN4U7=L&4¦I�4�P;A_3&G[P�Q6>BI=IM563!P�Q6Z!G&4�I�4�kdZ&56QN56c&:�5�>z/L&4;:=4¯7=L&4�4WVX<Y4�PW794�G G!4�^`>B3&G�5NI¦I=AB^`4Wz/L&4�:�4T> G&4;P�:=4�>BI=5N3&J D]Z&3!P;795NA_3�ABD�79L&4�^�4�G!5�>B3�ABD7?>EI�794;I�l� \3¦7=L&4*P�>EI=4*z/L&4;:=4�79>BI�7=4�I/>B:�4�G&5NI�79:�56c&ZX794�G¦3&A_:=^`>BQNQNR_bd>EG&G&563!J�79L&4jDg>BP;7�79L#>E7�<x4;A_<&QN4Q65N�B4h79AfcY4�L#>�HB4�Q656�E4jAE79L&4;:=I�G&Ai4�I�3 � 7FP?L#>B3&JB4*cx4;L#>�Hi56A_:�D]:�A_^ 79L&4j4�38795N:=4;QNR�<&:=5SHE>E794hHB>EQ6Z#>E7=56A_3P�>EI=4Bb�z/L&4;:=4�563!D]AB:=^`>E795NA_3¯5NI�Q656^�5N7=4�G�l >�5N7=L&A_Z!7�>BG&G&5S7956AB3#>BQ1563!D]A_:�^¦>@7956AB3�b°5N3&G&5NHi5NG&Z#>BQNI*>B:�4D]A_:�P�4�G�7=A[>BI�I=Z&^�4¯79L&>E7¦7=L&4T>�H_4;:9>BJ_4¯56I¦QN56�E4K7=L&4�^Kbh>B3&G�7=L&4�3&A�W®P?L#>B3&JB4�:=4;I=Z&QS7¦D]A_QNQ6A�z/I�l�jA�z�4;HB4�:�b�7=L&4;R�^¦>�R|I(z/5N79P?L~7=A�>¯3!4;z.4�kdZ&5NQ65Nc&:=5NZ&^ >ED�7=4�:�7=L&4;RC�d3&A�z�L&A�z�^¦>B38R|AB7=L&4�:�I>BPW79Z#>BQNQNR±>B:�4�P�AB3&I=Z&^�563!J&l��FL&4a3&4Wz 4;kiZ!56Q65Nc&:=5NZ&^,z/56QNQ�cx4f^�A_:�4fQ65N�B4�QSR{79A{cY4f4WVi7=:=4�^�4f79L!4^�A_:=4KP�A_3!I=Z&^�4�:�I{P�>B:�4�>BcYA_Z!7¦L&A�z AB79L&4;:=I{>EP;7|¤]A_:¦4;kdZ&5NHE>BQN4�3879QSR_bF5ND�79L&4±G&56I(79:=5Nc&Z!7=56A_3�ABD7?>EI�794;IfL#>BI�>±7?>EQ6Q�<x4�>B�X¥ ��5ND�P�A_3!I=Z&^�4�:�IfP�>B:�4�4�3!A_Z&J_L�b�79L&4;3 �� ��� 4�Vi79:=4;^`4¦4�kdZ&56QN56c&:�5�>e>B:�4<YA_I=I�56c&QN4Bl

X�G!HB4�:(7956I�563&J�>B3&G�<&:�56A_:a4�VX<x4;P;7?>@7956AB3&I�>B:=4{I�4�QND W�D]Z&Q `&Q6Q65N3&J&§UJ_5SH_4�3�>TP�A_3!I�7?>E3d7�<Y4�:�I=A_3#>EQZ!7=56Q65S7\R_b1Q6A�z.4WVX<Y4�PW7?>E7=56A_3&I�ABDF79L&4¦3iZ!^fcx4;:fABD/P;A_3&I=Z!^`4;:=Ia^`>�RCI(7956QNQ�<&:=4WH_4�387�>¯P;A_3&I�Z&^`4;:D]:=AB^�>BP;7=563&J!b@cY4�P�>BZ&I�4�L&4�4WVX<Y4�PW79I�7=L#>E713&A_cYAiG!R�4�QNI=4�z/56QNQ8>BPW7�lw�FL!56I�56I�>F794;I�7?>Ec&Q64�P�AB3&P�QNZ&I=5NA_34�387=56:=4;QNROG&5NI�7=563&PW7�D]:�A_^ >j:9>E3&G&A_^ Z!7=56Q65S7\R�^`>@VX56^�5���>@7956AB3�^`AiG&4�Q8z/5S79L�3!A*I=AiP�56>BQdP�A_^�<xAB3&4�387 �563�I=Z&P?L~>±^�AXG&4;Q�b�>ED�794;:�>KP�A_3!I=Z&^�4�:�G&:9>�z/I��\ª®bwL&4`G&AX4;I=3 � 7fP�>B:=4`>BcYA_Z!7M79L&4`G&56I(79:�56c&Z!7=56A_3D]:=AB^ z/L&5NP?L±5S7Fz�>BI/G&:=>�z/3�l

5�4;7�794;:�>EG!H_4;:�795NI=5N3&J{P�>B3CP�>EZ&I=4U^�A_:=4f<Y4�AB<&Q64f7=A{P�A_3&I�Z&^�4Bb1>BI�A_3&4fz�A_Z&QNG|4WVX<x4;P;7�b�c&ZX7I=A�P�>E3±cY4;7�794�:A@�B CD@FE=G�HJG$K$M4OJPj>EcxA_ZX7h>BG!H_4;:�7=56I=5N3&J&l

Page 123: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u�r/.

� � ��� ����

� � � � � � ��� � � ������� � ��� ������� ��� ���! ���"�

�X5NG&563&J�z/5N79L ^/56�E4�:�#�2*:�G&4�I�L&AXAB�ap d �@v¡b@ ¢z/56QNQBG&4;I=P;:=56cY4�79L&4�G!4�I=5N:=4�7=A/HBAB794y>BI�I(794;^`^�563&J�D]:=A_^g P�5NHi5NP�G&Z!7\RBl � �FL&4fkdZ&4�I(795NA_3�56Ih79L&4;3�§Fz/L&4�:�4fG&Ai4�I*P;5NHi56PMG&Z!7\R±P�AB^`4MD]:=A_^ -�2�3!4f<&Q�>EZ&I=5Nc&Q64>B3&I(z�4;:�5NI�§y4�^fZ&Q6>E795NA_3eA_:h>BJ_:�4�4�^�4�387hz/5N7=L±79L!4�cY4�L#>�Hi56AB:hAED�A_3&4 � IjP�A_L!A_:�7=I�l/�iRi^fcYA_QN56P�>EQ6QNRBbQ64W7*�jcx4U>�:�4�>BQ�3dZ&^�cx4;:�:=4�<!:=4�I�4�38795N3&JK>{<x4;:=I=AB3 � I�<!:=5NHE>E7=4�7?>EI�794fD]AB:�H_AB7=563&Je>E3&G �TcY4f79L!4<Y4�:=P;4�387?>EJ_4�ABDwA_3&4 � IhP�A_L!A_:�7hz/L&AUH_AB7=4�I�lF�FL!4�3¯7=L&4�3dZ&QNQ�L8RX<YAB7=L&4�I�56I�AED ��L#>B<X794�: 0a56IF79L#>@7z�4`P�>B3�z/:�5N794a7=L&4UZ!795NQ65N7\RKD]:=AB^�H_AB7=563&J±>BI%$�¤]��¥�b1z/L&5NQ64f7=L&4¦>EQN794;:=3#>@794a56I�7=L#>E7Oz�4�3&4;4�G�7=Az/:=5S794h5N7�>BI&$�¤���t��&¥Wb8z/L&4;:=4*ZX7956QN5N7\Ra5NI�^�A_3&AE79A_3&5NP�>BQNQNR�563&P;:=4�>BI=5N3&J�5N3¦cYAB79L�794�:�^`I;ly�XP?LdZ&4�I�I=QN4�:p d3.Ev�G&4;I=P;:=56cY4�I;b¢c&Z!7hG&Ai4�I/3&AB7/G&4W7?>B5NQ�A_:F794;I�7�b¢>UI�56^�56Q6>B:�^�AiG&4�Q¡l

�FL&4{z�>�R�79A�794;I�7a7=L&56IfI(7?>E7=4�^�4�387U56I�cdR P?L&4�P?�d5N3&JC7=L&4�HE>B:=56>B3&P;4{>B3&G[�dZ&:(79A_I�56IaABD/79L!4G&5NI�79:�56c&ZX7956AB3*ABDi79Z&:�3&A_Z!7=I�>B^`AB3&JFG&5N�x4�:�4�387�G&5NI�79:�56PW79I�l� ®D �*56I�:=4;Q64WHB>E3d7�b�79L&4;3O7=L&4�G&56I(79:�56c&Z!7=56A_3ABD�7=Z&:=3&ABZ!7�z/5NQ6Q�cx4�z/56G&4;:�bxz/5S79L¯Dg>@7=794;:j79>B56QNI�b#79L#>E3�5ND�5S7*5NI�3&AB7�l��FL&5NI*56Ij>¦:�4�I�79>E794;^`4;387�ABD�FL&4;A_:=4;^ m30Xl

�FL&56I�>B<&<Y4�3&G!5SV�794;I�79I�79L&4j4�^�<&56:�56P�>EQ&P�Q6>B56^ 7=L#>E7�>BP;7=Z#>BQ#79Z&:�3&A_Z!7�L#>BI�>�L&5NJ_L&4�:�HE>B:=56>B3&P;4>B3&GC>{Q64;<!79AB�iZ!:�79AE7956P�:=4;7=Z&:=3|:�4�Q�>@795NHB4�79AK>�^�AXG!4�Q�ABDyI�4�QND W®5638794;:=4;I�794;GT79Z&:�3&A_Z!7�lf hz/5NQ6Q�`#:=I(7G&4;I=P�:�56cY4�79L&4{I�4�QSD W\56387=4�:=4;I�7=4�G�^`AiG&4;Q�b�c#>BI�4�G�A_3[P�5SHi56P�G&ZX7\R[cx4;563&JT3!A_:=^`>BQ6QSR|G&56I(79:�56c&Z!7=4�G�b79L!4�3�G!56I=P;Z&I=I179L&4yG#>E79>hZ!I=4�G�79A/794�I(7�7=L&56I�^�AXG!4�Q�b@>B3!G `#3&>BQ6QSRO>BI=�*z/L!4;79L!4�:�7=L&4yI=4�QSD W\5N3d7=4�:�4�I=4;G^�AXG&4;Q�P�ABZ&Q6Ge<&Q6>BZ&I=5Nc&QNR`L#>�H_4MQ64;G{79Aa79L&4OHE>B:=56>B3&P;4O>B3&Ge�dZ&:�7=A_I=5NI/z�4MI=4�4O5N3e7=L&4OG#>E79>!l

�FL&4{P�AB3&P�QNZ&I=5NA_3~56IM79L#>@7U>¯3&A_3�W\P�AB3dHi5SHX56>BQy^`AiG&4�Q�P�>B3[5N3&G&4;4�G[4WVX<&Q6>B563C79L&4{G&>E7?>!l1X�Q W79L!A_Z&J_LC5N7O^`>�RTA_:�^`>�R�3&AB7MG&4�I�P�:�56cY4�L!A z<x4;A_<&Q64U>EP;79Z&>BQ6QSR¯79L!563&�¢b1>K^�AiG&4�Qwz/L!56P?LCG&AX4;I3&AB7�4WVX<&QN56P;5N79QSR�79>B�B4h563879A�>BP�P;A_Z&387y79L&4j4�^fZ&Q6>E795NA_3aABD�AE79L&4;:=Iy563`>BP;7=56A_3&IyA_:�A_<&5N3&56AB3&I�^¦>�RUcY4>BG&4;kdZ#>E794OD]A_:/>B3!I�z�4�:=5N3&J�4�^�<&56:�56P�>EQxkdZ&4;I�795NA_3&I;l

Page 124: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u_u�r� ��� � � ���������������� � �� � �

X�IM>{c#>BI�4�QN563&4Eb�P�A_3&I�56G&4;:�79L&4U^�AXG&4;Qwz/L&4;:=4UZ!795NQ65S7\R¯5NI�4�38795N:=4�QSR�<&:�5NHE>E7=4Bl m 4;7�7=L&4UI=4;3&I=4�ABDP�5SHi56P�G!Z!7\R_b�AB:�79L&4�7?>BI(794�D]A_:h79L&4f>BP;7�ABD�H_AB7=563&J!b°cY4f:=4;<&:=4;I=4�387=4�GCcdR±�*o }hlU�FL&5NI�^`>�R±cY43&4;J8>E795SH_4Eb�D]AB:M4�V!>B^`<!Q64Bb�5SD�7=L&4UP�A_I(7MABD�J_AB563&J�7=Ae7=L&4�<xA_QNQ6I*5NI�L&56JBL�l m 4;7O79L&4UZ!7=56QN5N7\RKD]:=A_^H_AE79563!J{cx4 $�¤���¥ �£��« ��� �Yb°z/L&4�:�4��[:=4;<&:=4;I=4�387=IO7=L&4a56387=4�3&I�5N7\R±ABD�79L&4fG!4�I=5N:=4f7=A{4�^fZ&Q6>E794AB7=L&4�:�I�l >�5S79L&5N3�G&5NI�7=:=56PW7��¢bFQN4;7�79L&4¯^`4�>B3�ABD��Ucx4[\���b/>E3&G�Q64W7¦79>BI�7=4�I¦cY4¯G!56I�7=:=5Nc&Z!794;G��� +¤$\���t�u ¥Wl

m 4;7���� w¤�� ¬ \��;¥fcY4e7=L&4e<x4;:=P;4�387?>BJB4±ABD�<x4;A_<&QN4{cx4;Q6A�z,I�A_^`4eQN4;H_4;Q�� J_5SH_4�3 \���l��FL&4<Y4�:=P;4�387?>EJ_4jAED°79L!4h<YA_<&Z!Q�>E7=56A_3fz/L&5NP?L�HBAB794;Iyz/5NQ6Q&cY4��� w¤$\�� ¬ r_¥Wl��FL&5NI�56I�cY4�P�>EZ&I=4h4;HB4�:�RBA_3&4z/5N7=L¯����r`H_AE794�I;b�^�4�>B3&5N3&J`7=L#>E7�u�­���� �¤gr ¬ \��?¥j<x4;A_<&QN4f>B:�4�H_AE79563!J&b�>B3!G¯79L&4�I�Ri^`^�4;7=:�RABD�79L!4*3&A_:�^¦>BQxG&56I(79:�56c&Z!7=56A_3¦>BQ6QNA�z/I�Z&I�7=A�z/:=5S794�7=L&56IF>EI ��� �¤N\�� ¬ r8¥�l��FL&5NI�D]Z&3&P;7=56A_3¦P�>B3ecY45638HB4�:�7=4�G�§O5SD !��<Y4�:�P�4�387MH_AB7=4�G�b�7=L&4�3C5N7�^�Z&I�7McY4f79L#>E7�7=L&4UG&56I(79:�56P;7 � I�^`4�>B3|56I�Q6AiP�>@794�G|>@7\�� �"��� � o ¤ #�W¥�l

5�Z!7/79L!4*7?>BI(794�D]A_:�H_AE79563!J�P?L&>B3&J_4;I/D]:�A_^,>E:=4�>f7=A`>E:=4�>Xl���AU7?>B�E4�79L&5NI�563879A�>BP;P�A_Z!3d7hI=>�R79L&>E7�\�� � +¤%$wt�u ¥Wbdz/L&4;:=4&$�5NI�>�<#>E:9>B^�4;7=4�:�7=Afcx4�I=<Y4�P�5 `#4�G{cY4�QNA�zOb&>B3&G�7=L&4�HE>B:�5�>B3&P;4�5NI`!VX4�GC>E7�A_3&4MD]A_:�I�P�>BQN563&J&l�cjAB79>E795N3&J`7=L&4f<&:�A_c#>Bc!56Q65S7\ReG&4�3!I=5N7\R±ABD�^�4�>B3!I�\���>BI�')(+* ,!¤$\��;¥Wb79L!4M<!:=A_c#>Ec&56QN5N7\R`ABDwABZ!79P;A_^`4 !��56I ')(+* o�¤%��� � o ¤ #�W¥�¥Wl

�XAT79L&4{5N3&<&Z!7f563879A�7=L&4{^`AiG&4;Q�56I�79L&4{<#>E:9>B^�4;7=4�:�$ G&4;I=P�:�56c&5N3&J�79L!4{^`4�>B3&IaABD/7?>EI�794;I>B^�A_3&J`G&56I(79:=5NP;7=I�l/�FL&4fA_ZX79<&Z!7�56Ij>¦G&4;3&I=5S7\RKD]Z!3&P;7=56A_3�AED�79Z&:�3&A_Z!7�bYz/5S79L�I�Z&<&<YA_:�7�cx4W7\z�4;4�3��4;:=A¦>B3&G¯AB3&4Blh�i79>E795NI�7=56P�Ih>BcYA_Z!7/7=L&56I/G&4;3&I=5S7\RKD]Z!3&P;7=56A_3�b¢I�Z&P?LT>BIh5N7=Ih^�4�>E3�b#HB>E:=5�>E3&P�4Ebx>E3&G�dZ&:�7=A_I=5NI�b�^`>�R�cY4¦D]A_Z!3&G[c8R G&5N:=4;P;7aP�>BQ6P;Z&Q�>E7=56A_3°l± ®D/79L!4�I=4¦I�7?>@7956I(795NP�I�G!4�I=P;:=5Ncx4e>[chA_:=^`>BQG&5NI�79:�56c&ZX7956AB3�b°79L!4�3|z�4�^¦>�RTP;A_3&P;Q6Z&G&4a7=L#>E7)�7�.r ��5SD�79L&4UI�79>E795NI�7=56P�IOG&4;I=P;:=56cY4UI=A_^�4;7=L&563!Jz/56G!4�:F79L#>E3±>�chA_:=^`>BQ�bi79L&4;3±�FL!4�A_:�4�^ m30�794;Q6QNIFZ&IF79L#>E7 �.-��rXl

� �0/ 12�3�4�

 wZ!I=4�G�79L&4]cj>E795NA_3#>BQ !�QN4�P;7=56A_3`�i7=Z&G!R � I�P;Z&^fZ&Q6>E795SH_4FG#>E79> `&Q64�D]:=AB^,u .�d �4W�fBr_rBr!l1�¢AB:�P�4�:(7?>B5N3R_4�>B:=I;b�79L&4a:�4�I=4�>B:=P?L!4�:=IOz�4�387O79A{:=4;J_56I(79:=>B:=I � A "�P�4;IM>B3&GTP?L&4;P?�B4�G�D]A_:�79L!4a3#>B^�4fABDyI=Z&:(H_4WR:=4;I=<YA_3&G&4;3879I�AB3K7=L&4O:=A_QNQ6I�bXP�A_36`#:=^�563&Jaz/L&4W79L&4;:jAB:F3&AB7hL&4OA_:FI=L!4�L#>EGKHBAB794;G�l��FL!56I/56IF79L!4

Page 125: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u_u_u^�4�>BI�Z&:=4� �Z!I=4�GU>EI�^�RMG#>E79>!bEz/L&5NP?LaJ8>�H_4�^�4 �Xb � m �jP�AB3J`#:=^�4�GfHBAB794;I��E3!A_38H_AB7=4�I�l o  �G!5NHi56G&4;G79L!4�I=4�c8RM7=L&4�5N:�G&56I(79:=5NP;7�>B3&GMR_4�>B:�lDXhD�794;:17=L&:=A�z/563!JjA_ZX7wG&5NI�7=:=56PW7��@RB4�>B:�I1z/L!56P?L�P;Q�>B5N^`4;GUu�r_r3279Z!:=3&A_ZX7jAB:FL#>BGCu�raA_:�D]4;z�4�:h:=4;I=<YA_3&G&4;3d7=I�bY �L#>EG m�d3�aA_c&I=4;:�HE>E7=56A_3&I/ABD�G&5NI�79:�56PW7��@RB4�>B:�Ij>E3&G79L!4�56:�P�A_:�:=4;I=<YA_3&G&5N3&JT<x4;:=P;4�387U79Z&:�3&A_Z!7�l?X L&56I(79A_J_:=>B^ ABDF79L!4�79Z&:�3&A_Z!7=If56IfI�L&A�z/3�563~79L!4Q64WD�7�W®L#>B3&GeL&5NI�79ABJ_:9>B^�ABDw�w56JBZ&:=4��!lSu_l

turnout among district/years

percent turnout

nomb

er o

f dist

rict/y

ears

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

010

2030

4050

0.80.60.40.2

0.35

0.3

0.25

0.2

0.15

0.1

0.05

0

x

y

x

y

iwant(x)

��56J_Z&:�4��!lSu_§bc�!y��79Z&:�3&A_Z!7hc8R{G&5NI�79:�56PW7��@RB4�>B:

��56J_Z&:�4��!l}fX§:X�<&:=5SHE>E794zW\Z!7=56Q65S7\R�^`AiG&4�Q°ABD�7=Z&:=3!A_Z!7hc8R{P�A_L!A_:�7

F�7S���� $ ��0("��*� �w #"('*) -,*�£+.-/���10

^/4�P�>EQ6Qw7=L#>E7*7=L&4U^`4�>B3|ABDyG&56I(79:=5NP;7O^�4�>B3!I�b $�b�3&4;4�G&IMP�>EQ656c!:9>E7=56A_3KD]:=A_^ 79L&4U^�AXG&4;Q�>BcYA�H_4El>�4�3&4;4�GTA_3&QSRKA_3&4�HE>BQNZ&4MABD�$ z/L&5NP?L�Q64�>BG&Ij7=A�>¦:�4�>BI�A_3#>Bc!Q64�<YA_I(794�:�56A_:hG&4;3&I=5S7\R±7=A¦Dg>B56Q�7=A:=4 �4�PW7F79L&4�L8Ri<xAE79L&4;I=56I�& yI=4�QN4�PW794�G�$ � f '�d&bX:=4�I�Z&QN7=563&J�563�79L!4�<xA_I(794;:=56AB:�G&4;3&I=5S7\R�ABD�79Z!:=3&A_ZX7G&:=>�z/3¯563e79L&4M:=5NJ_L87�W\L&>B3&GKJ_:9>B<!L¯ABD��w56J_Z!:=4��!l}fXbY>B3&G±7=L&4M^`AiG&4�Q�<&>B:9>B^�4;7=4�:�Ij5N3K7=L&4�79>Bc&Q64cY4�Q6A�zO§

� ��|4�!�L�4~��Dw<~0x!�L�4�I~!� < �4{����j�={}�L~0�7�I��� xa�$�a~�� � ~�� � ��~<{��2�L�~���!�!�L~0���!�D|4�!��� <�x!� �4� � ~��}~��I�$�}���x <�~�� x!|��I~��!~0xz�}~�� �������?�L�4�I|4�a�=��{�|�x<��xz�Iy!~ � ����Ix!��{��N���z���={��N�I�L{��7�����

Page 126: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u_u4f

^`AiG&4;Q G#>E79> G#>E79>�I(79G�l�G&4WH^�4�>E3 l �/0/� l �/0�m l r_r/.�fHB>E:=5�>E3&P�4 l r�fiu7� l r�f�d � l r_r�f�dI=�B4Wz W%r!l r_r�d&u . W\r!l r_r m/. m l r_rBr3� ��dZ&:�7=A_I=5NI l r_r�fiu4f l r_r�f f f l r_rBr�d3�

�FL&4OI�79>B3&G#>B:�GeG&4;Hi5�>@7956AB3&I�z�4�:=4O<&:�AXG!Z&P�4;GKc8R`79L&4�cYAXAE79I�7=:9>B<{^�4;7=L&AiG �!79L!4�AB79L&4;:�G#>E79>56I�D]:�A_^ G&56:�4�PW7�P�>BQ6P;Z#>E795NA_3UABD�7=L&4�>E<&<&:=AB<&:=56>E794/^�A_^`4;3879I�lDcjAB7=56P�4/79L&>E7�79L&4;I=4�^�A_^�4�3879I�>B:�479L!4*>�H_4;:9>BJ_4jABD�P;4�:�79>B563�<&5N4�P�4;I�ABD�G#>E7?>¦¤gI�Z&P?Le>BI�¤��O­ $�¥�� bi563�79L&4hP�>BI�4�ABD��iZ!:�79ABI=56I9¥WbX>B3&G�I�A79L!4���4;3d7=:9>BQ m 56^�5N7w�FL&4�AB:=4�^ G!56P;79>E794;Iy7=L#>E7�79L!4�I=4hI�79>E795NI�7=56P�I�z/5NQ6Q&cY4h3&A_:=^`>BQNQNRMG&56I(79:�56c&Z!7=4�G�l�FL&4/Z&I�Z#>BQ#56387=4�:=<!:=4;79>E795NA_3&I�AEDx7=L&4FI�79>B3&G#>B:�G`G!4;Hi5�>E7=56A_3U>E3&GUP�A_3J`&G&4�3&P;4j5N38794�:(HE>BQ6Iw7=L&4�:�4;D]A_:�4>B<&<!QNR_l

�FL&4�7=L&4�A_:�4;7=56P�>EQY^�4�>E3�bdI=�B4Wz >E3&G¦�dZ&:(79A_I�56I�>E:=4j>BQ6Q&z/5S79L&5N3�>�I(7?>B3!G#>B:=G¦G&4;Hi5�>@79A_3`ABD�79L!4G#>E79> � I/>BP;7=Z#>BQ�HE>BQ6Z!4�I�b&>B3&G{79L&4�HE>B:�5�>B3&P;4�56I�z/5S79L&5N3{7\z�AUI�79>B3&G#>E:=GKG&4;Hi5�>@7956AB3&I�ly�X5N3&P�4*7=L&4�:�4z�>BIjAB3&QNReA_3!4M<&>B:9>B^�4;7=4�:F79A�79L&4M^�AXG&4;Q�b!7=L&4ODg>BP;7/79L&>E7jD]ABZ&:/I�7?>@7956I(795NP�I/^¦>@79P?Le79L&4MG#>E79>�5NI>¯3&AB3d7=:=5SHX56>BQ�:=4;I=Z&QS7�l±�FL&4�:�4;D]A_:�4Bb� *Dg>B5NQ�7=A¯:�4� �4�PW7f79L!4¦3dZ&Q6QyL8Ri<xAB7=L&4�I�56I;§�7=L&4¦G#>@7?>¯P�>B3~cY44WVX<&Q6>B563!4�G|c8RC>K^�AXG!4�Qwz/5S79L|3&AKP�A_38Hi5NHi5�>EQ65N7\R±4;�x4�PW79I�>B3&GC3&A_:�^¦>BQNQNRKG&5NI�79:�56c&ZX794�GC:9>E3&G&A_^7?>EI�794;IFD]A_:FH_AB7=563&J&l

 \3�P�AB3&P�QNZ&I=5NA_3�bY>BQN7=L&A_Z&JBL±5S7jI�4�4;^`Ih:=4�>BI=A_3&>Bc&Q64O79L&>E7j7=L&4�:�4f>B:�4�P;A_L&A_:(79IhABD�<Y4�A_<!Q64Oz/L&A794;3&G�7=A/563��#Z!4�3&P;4�4�>BP?L�AB7=L&4�:�5N3OHBAB795N3&JhA_:�3&AB7�H_AE79563!Jh7=A_J_4;7=L&4�:;b@7=L&4�G#>E79>hP�>B3�cY4�4WVX<&Q6>B563&4;GZ&I�563&J±>{I=56^�<&QN4f^`AiG&4;Q�z/L&56P?LCG&Ai4�IO3&AB7M4WVX<&QN56P;5N79QSR¯5N3&P�QNZ&G&4f7=L&56IO4;�x4�PW7�l r  ®D�7=L&4UG&4�I�56:�4U7=A4�^�Z&Q�>E7=4aAB79L!4�:=IOz�4�:=4`>{I=Z�"�P;564�387=QNR|I�7=:=A_3!J±5N3&G&4�<Y4�3!G&4�387MDg>BP;7=A_:�b�79L!4�3|79L&4aHE>B:=56>B3&P;4`>E3&G�dZ&:�7=A_I=5NI�ABD°79L&4hG&56I(79:�56c&Z!7=56A_3Uz�A_Z&Q6G`cx4jQ�>B:�J_4�:�7=L#>B3`7=L&4j7=L&4�AB:=4;7=56P�>BQ¢G&56I(79:=5Nc&Z!7=56A_3Uz/5N7=L`79L!4I9>E^`4�^�4�>B3°b#c&Z!7F79L!56I/56IF3&AE7F79L&4OP�>EI=4Bl

��� {��I�n�,�a�4�!�L�I�]�${}y!|4{ >���xz|F�L�}���Lw_xz�}��~��_�L�x!|5�={��N�I�L{��7������<�~ w_x �;��~ xz�4�}~��I�*>|�.w��!�I~�~���{��=~�|��,~�� �a��,�a|��F{ ��{}x!��{��N�_~�� ~��,�I���4�4�=� �I�4~b�4xz�Ix<{}��|4�z��x �/xz{}�}x!�4�}~!�

Page 127: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u_u=m

� � ��� ���� �

� � � � � � ��� � � � � ��� �

 t`&:=I�7h<&:�4�I�4�387�I�A_^�4�>EZXVX56Q656>B:�R�:�4�I=Z!QN79IFz/L&5NP?L± yD]4�4;Q�L#>�H_4MQ65N7�79QN4jHE>BQ6Z!4�cdR{7=L&4�^�I=4;QNHB4�I�b¢c&ZX7z/L&5NP?L[>B:=4`3&4�P;4�I�I9>B:(R D]A_:M<&:=A�Hi563!J¯I=AB^`4`ABD�79L!4¦:=4;I=Z&QS79I�Z&I=4;G[563�7=L&4¦cYAiG!R|ABDF79L!56IOz�A_:�� �>B3&Ge79L!4�3K<&:=A�H_4O79L!A_I=4O:=4;I=Z&QS79I/3&AB7/<!:=A�H_4;3¯563{7=L&4OcxAiG!R{ABD179L!4MG!56I=I�4�:(7?>E7=56A_3�l

��� � � ������� � ��� � ��� � � ��

�����y��� �*-y� $ ,�� �j !��� S

����:� ��� �,�N��� ���� ��!"�� 1¤ Yt��!¥�� ��� ����"7���#I)0� � ����#'��)! �0�%!#'��(Y#'� � 9 �&�!" �¤ �x¥�� � ��� �������D9���2� �&�!" ��o;¤ �x¥ ���2� ��r ¤��x¥�� �?��� � � ��#' ��� �!��� % 8 ��#I)/� %F��"L#&%"� � %!#'��( �&�!�0)! �=%/%!#'��( 3 �����!� �$# �;¤ � �t Yt%��o�t �x¥ �'&)(*�A% �$# �;¤ � �t ¢t���r;t �x¥ ��� j��� �h%!+�)/���z+6��)!"$#I��J% # -

+-,� ,� �¤ Yt%��o�t �x¥ � � � +-,

� ,� 1¤ ¢t���r�t �x¥ � � '

���� &�. �w56:�I�7�b! �z/56QNQ�I=L!A z�79L#>E7F7=L&56I/4;kiZ&>BQ65S7\R�P�AB3&G&5N7=56A_3e5NIFI=Z�"�P�5N4�387hD]A_:�79L&4O<YA_I�7=4�:�56A_:�I79A{I=>E795NI�D�R���2O� �fl��X563!P�4 � 1¤ ¢t��!¥j56I�^`A_3!AB79A_3!56P�>EQ6QNR�563&P;:=4�>EI=563!J{563/�Yb�5N7�<&:=4;I=4;:�H_4;I�I�563&JBQ64!WP�:�A_I=I�563&J!b#^`4�>B3&563!Jf79L#>E7 � 1¤ Yt���o�¥�I=5N3&J_Q64zW\P;:=A_I�I=4�I � 1¤ ¢t���r?¥Wl

�X563!P�410 ,� , � 1¤ �¤��x¥�t���oW¤��x¥=¥ � �8�20 ,� , � 1¤ �¤ �x¥Wt���r ¤ �x¥=¥ � ��b°7=L&56I�^`4�>B3&I*79L&>E7*79L!4a<xA_I(794zW:=5NA_:=I � 1¤ ¢t���o(¥

0 ,� , � 1¤ �¤ �x¥Wt���o;¤ �x¥=¥ � �>B3&G � 1¤ ¢t���r?¥

0 ,� , � 1¤ w¤��x¥Wt%��r ¤ �x¥=¥ � �>BQNI=AUI9>E7=56I(D�R�I=5N3&J_QN4!W\P;:=A_I�I=5N3&J&b&>E3&GK7=L&4�:�4;D]A_:�4M��2O� � 56IFI=>E795NI�`#4;G~¤]c8R m 4;^`^`>�f_¥�l

Page 128: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

u_u�d�!>�R|79L#>E7�b�P�A_3879:=>B:�R|7=AK7=L&4¦>EcxA�H_4�<&:�4�^�56I=4Eb17=L&4�:�4`4�VX56I�7M79L!:=4�4UD]Z&3&PW795NA_3&I���o�¤ � ¥�b���r ¤ � ¥Wb

>B3&G �¤ � ¥�I�Z&P?L±7=L#>E7

+ ,� ,� 1¤ �¤��x¥�t���oW¤��x¥�¥ � � � + ,

� ,� 1¤ w¤��x¥Wt%��r�¤��x¥=¥ � � ' ¤ �XlNu�¥

�12M� � 5NIFI9>E7=56I�`&4�Gez/L&4�3

0 ,� � 1¤ w¤��x¥Wt%��o;¤ �x¥=¥ � �0 ,� , � 1¤ �¤��x¥�t���o;¤��x¥�¥ � �� 0 ,� � 1¤ �¤��x¥�t���r�¤��x¥�¥ � �0 ,� , � 1¤ �¤ �x¥Wt���r ¤ �x¥=¥ � �

t

z/L&5NP?LKz�4�P�>B3K:=4;z/:�5N7=4O>BI

0 ,� � 1¤ �¤��x¥�t���o;¤��x¥�¥ � �0 ,� � 1¤ �¤��x¥�t���r ¤��x¥�¥ � � �0 ,� , � �¤ �¤ �x¥Wt���o;¤��x¥�¥ � �0 ,� , � �¤ �¤ �x¥Wt���r ¤��x¥�¥ � ��� u�«�� ' ¤ �Xl�fB¥

 ®D�7=L&4T<&:=4;^`5NI=4�AED�7=L&4�79L&4;A_:=4;^ L&4;Q6G�bh79L&4;3���z�ABZ&Q6G�>BQSz�>�RiI{4�kdZ#>BQ'�;4�:�A&l XjI=I=Z!^`5N3&J \3&4;kiZ&>BQ65S7\R �ilNu{^�4�>B3!I�79L&>E7�� � r!bwc&Z!7a5NI�P�AB3&I�79>B387fz/5N7=L~:=4;I=<Y4�P;7a7=A �xb�I�A�5NDF7=L&4¦:=>E795NAABD)0 ,� � 1¤ �¤��x¥�t���o;¤��x¥�¥h79A 0 ,� � �¤ �¤ �x¥Wt���r ¤��x¥�¥�>B<&<!:=A8>BP?L!4�IOA_3&4�D]AB:�I=AB^`4fI�4�kdZ&4;3&P�4�ABD �XI;b79L!4�3±��2O� ��z/56QNQ°3&AE7jcY4O3&AB7/I=>E795NI�`#4;G�l

 ®D�5N7�56I�3&AE7�7=L&4�P�>BI=4h79L#>E7y79L!56Iy:9>E7=56A�>B<&<&:�A8>BP?L&4;I�A_3&4Ebi7=L&4�3`z�4j^¦>�RU4�>EI=56QSRUP�A_3!I�79:�Z&P;7�>I=4W7yABD�G&5NI�7=:=56c!Z!795NA_3&Iwz/L&4;:=4h5N7�G&Ai4�I;l:^/4�P�>EQ6Q!7=L#>E7yA_3&4/ABDY79L&4hP�AB3&G&5N7=56A_3!I�A_3 � 1¤ �¤��x¥�t���o;¤��x¥�¥z�>BI�79L&>E7�5S79I�5638794;J_:9>BQ�A�H_4;:a>BQNQ4�qo } cx4;`#3&5S794Bl±�#A_:O79L&5NIM7=A¯cY4`79:�Z&4Bbw5N7�^fZ&I�7�cx4�79L#>@70 ,� � 1¤ �¤��x¥�t���o�¤��x¥�¥�>B<&<&:�A8>BP?L&4;I6��4�:�A|>BI��`>B<&<&:�A8>BP?L&4;I�lT�FL��� ������� ��Bb��9L��� ����NI�I��B^����I=Z!P?L��9L���� 0 ,� � �¤ �¤ �x¥Wt���o;¤��x¥�¥ � �0 ,� , � 1¤ w¤��x¥Wt%��r�¤��x¥=¥ � ���

�f '

c ��z"!#�a`%$��� �o ¤ �x¥ � & ��o;¤��x¥ � � ���$(' -*)�+�,.-/�0-%�1� � 1¤ �¤��x¥32 -!¥��54�6�«87

��9 � 1¤ �¤��x¥32���r ¤��x¥�¥ �;:�� '�<-%���=�>)�? � �o ¤��x¥@�>)A�0-�� )0�CB�D��) ��o�¤��x¥@���C =�CEFE#�G+�HI�0�J�1?#�C$�!I��-���$��.�CK���)L��$*�C$M'N��CEF+��O)�+�,.-�0-���� PQ�R�� ��S�C)�)�+� ���!T�0-%�1� � VU WU��x¥X2%� �o U��x¥=¥<�>)O)�EF�>Y�-M��EF'*E>�C �YC�� <�0-%��$ � VU ZU �\[X2���r]U �\[�[L���� O�CE>E

Page 129: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6�670�;: �

�� �>$#Y�E>�zW ,� ���)�)��>$�YJ�>)<)����>EFE )0�1�0�>)�`%��! ? �C$�!/�C$M'����\��$�!#�>$�Y !��F)�,��C$(���>$(+�� � '*B�� '��\� ���C)��FEF'

)�B� �C�0-���!G��+#��

c �C���>,�� �0-%���0 ,� , � VU ZU �\[X2���o�U �\[�[ � �0 ,� , � VU ZU �\[X2���r]U �\[�[ � � � 0 �� , � VU WU��\[X2%��o�U �\[�[ � �0 �� , � VU WU��\[X2%��r]U �\[�[ � �

� 6�� �d 2 U �

�m�[

)��F$�,��!� �o U��\[ �>)V���V�F��) )�B��CE>EF��)�� � ��� � P=�� ��!���� �� ��� � N��L�]?��C$�!R�WP=�C) !��a`%$#��!R)�� �0-���� $����(+%�CEF�F� '��m��>)L�0 �+��

�> � $�� P -�� NC� 0 ,� � U ZU �\[X2�� �o U��\[�[ � �0 ,� � U ZU �\[X2���r]U��\[�[ � � � 6 �

�d 2

P -��FE>� 0 ,� , � VU WU��\[X2%� �o U �\[�[ � �0 ,� , � VU WU��\[X2%��r]U �\[�[ � � � 6�� �f '

$���� +��CE>� � ' ��f��>) $���� )����0�F)�`%��!����� � �o U��\[3? ��r]U �\[X?\�C$�! � �"�]? B� ��$��>$�Y���-%�������� �8�>) $����)0�1�0�>)�`%��!G���� L��-���)�� ��+�$#,��0�F��$�)

� ���0-��S ��XN��� �)��R���� $����(+%��E>�F� ' �

�6J�F)O�� �+���? ��-���$��0-��� ����C �� � PQ�IP=� ' ) PQ�J,��C$;,���$�)��� �+�,X�

)��F$�Y�EF�!W ,� ���)�)��F$�YJ��+�$�,X�0�F��$�)=P -��F,.-�!���$��C�LE>� ��!*�0������ � H\�C)��0�� ��F�� �)�� $�� �>)=���R ���H\�����<�0-#�

��� � N�� H� �� ,���!�+# ��C?#�>$�) �0� ��!*B�� !�� � ' �F$�Y �0-��DE>��� ��W -%��$�!��0�C�>E �C� ��r]U �\[�X $#� ������ =P=� 'I�F)Q�0�JE>���

��DU��\[ � ZU���\[3? ���o U��\[ � ��r U�� �\[X? ��$�! ���r U��\[ � ��oXU�� �\[ � 5Q'G�.�CK(�>$#Y��0-#�JB�> � ��� �>B��CY���>$���-��>)LP=� '�?%P=� ) �0�>EFE -%� N�� ���o U��\[L)��F$�Y�EF�!W ,� ���)�)��F$�Y ���r U �\[X? �C$#!+ ,� ,� VU � U �\[X2�� �o U��\[�[ � � � + ,

� ,� U ZU �\[X2���r U �\[�[ � �

�C$�!+ ,� ,� VU � U �\[X2�� �r U��\[�[ � � � + ,

� ,� U ZU �\[X2���oXU �\[�[ � � '

B� �C$��F$�YR�0-����O���F��-��� � $#���(+%�CEF�F� ' ��6 �>)L�� �+�� �� <� � � � �>)L� �CEF)���?#�0-���$

+ ,� ,� VU � U �\[X2�� �o U��\[�[ � � � + ,

� ,� VU � U �\[X2�� �r U��\[�[ � � '

Page 130: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6�6 �� -��Q,���$�!#�F�0�F��$�)V+�HS��� $����(+%�CE>� � ' �

�6=�C ��A$�� P�)0�1�0�>)�`%��! ?��C$�!SP=�QBI� ' �CH�H#EF' �0-#�=H� �� ,���!�+� ��

P -��F,.-/����EFE>� PQ��!��0-%�1� �F$����(+%��E>�F� '��0� )�-#�]P �0-%��� ��-��� �� ��� �>)�� ��+�$#,��0�F��$�)6��DU��\[3?*��� o � U��\[X? ��$�!��r]U��\[=P -��F,.-�!��$��C� )����0�F)�� ' ���� �

� $�,���$�,�E>+�)��>��$ ?#�F�V�0-��� �� ��� �>) � �0-� ���� !��>) �0 �� ��+#���>��$#)L)�+�,.-/�0-%�1�

+ ,� ,� VU ZU��\[32���oXU��\[�[ � � -� + ,

� ,� VU WU��\[X2%��r U��\[�[ � � 2

�0-#��$/���F��-��� ���� � �>)<$#�C� )0�����>)�`%��!G���� =��-�� !��>) �0 �� ��+#���>��$�)L�C)<Y��FNC��$ ?#�� <$���P k � �W)<, �C$ � �,��C$�)��� �+�,X�0��!/���� LP -��F,.- ���� � !�� ��) $��C�O-���EF!

���

�����y�7S ����� $ ,�� ��� � R

������� �� � ��������� ZU���� \/[! #" � �%$ '& $(��) �*$ ,+-" � �.$ � + ��� � $/)��10 " �2$43 " � ,+ �65 " 57) �����98:<; � & � \ + ) ; � '& $(��) �*$ ,+-" � � $ & $ �=� � &.> �?������� ; �@0 + A � & ����3B� � � : �B��� ; �?5 '+ � +� ��� &C" �$D3 '+ �DEF$(�G0=� "/ $D3 '+ �DEIH�E +�J ����$�LK��10NMOQP=$/)SR

T U��#U 2 M O [ � + ,� , V 4 �#U 2�� U M O 21W%[ 9 � # ��U�W<� �#U�[ �XW �+ ,� ,

V 4ZY 2 6�� � U M O 21W [ 9 � # ��U�W[� �#U [ �XW 'T U��#U 2 M\O []+ )�$!3 " � '+ �65 " 57)��5D��3 ,+-" � " � �#U � "/& $(� �\�LK��10NMO >]^/_�_ &�.a` � $�����!/�0� )�-�� P"��-%���<���� ��E>Ecb�?��0-��� �� �>)<)��CB�� �R)�+�,.-���-%���edb � T U��32 M O [ � T U�� ��� 2 M O [� +-,

� ,V 4 �#U 2�� U M O 21W%[ 9 � # ��U�W[� �#U [ � V 4ZY 2 6�� � U M O 21W [ 9 � # ��U�W[� �#U [ �

f V 4 �#U ��� 2�� U M O 21W%[ 9 �$# ��U�W<� �#U � �C[ � V 4 Y 2 6�� � U M O 2gW [ 9 �$# ��U�W<� �#U�� �C[#h �XW '@P �>E>E )�-#�]P �0-��F)��M'*!�� N �F!��>$#YJ�0-�� )�H%�C,�� �F$M�0�R�0-#� �F$M�0�� ��>�� �?cikjQ2Bl9m ���C$�!��0-�� �0�C�>EF)�? U��D 2BlA[�C$�!�U#jQ23 [ �VP -��� ��=l �C$�!nj �C �� ��+�$�,X�0�>�C$�) �C�<�

�� -���$ ? P �>E>E `%$�! ��$ �CH#H� ���H# �� �1�0�� ?)�+#,.-��0-���� �\�C��-��0-��O�>$M�0�� ��F�� ��C$�! �0-#� �0�C�>EF)��C �� � ��+�$#!���! ? ��NC��$�Y��FNC��$ �0-��<PQ�� �) ��W ,��C)��ON��CE>+��

��+�$�,X�0�F��$�

Page 131: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6�67���� � � � ��� � ^ ` �F�0-#�>$ �C$M' Y�� N���$ ��C$�Y��?W�� i l<2.j\m ? � �C�0- V U��32�� U M\O 21W%[�[ �C$�! V U Y 2 6 �� U M O 21W%[�[L�C ���� ��+�$#!���!��C$�!/,���$M���>$(+���+�)�? �C) �>) �$# ��U$\ � ��[X?%)��

+���

V 4 �#U 2�� U M O 21W%[ 9 �$# ��U�W<� �#U [ �XW ? +���

V 4 Y 2 6 � � U M O 2gW [ 9 �$# ��U�W<� �#U [ �XW#2�C$�!;��-����F !#� �\�� ���$�,��R�C ��S,���$M�0�F$(+���+�) �F$I�#U

�� -��� ������� ��C? Y�� N���$ l<?LjS? �C$�! b�? PQ�R, �C$ `%$�!� �R)�+�,.-/�0-%�1�

b� f � +���

V 4 �#U 2�� U M O 2gW [ 9 �$# ��U�W<� �#U [ � V 4 Y 2 6 � � U M O 2gW [ 9 �$# ��U�W<� �#U [ �f V 4 �#U � �]2 � U M O 21W [ 9 �$# ��U�W<� �#U ���C[ � V 4#Y 2�6�� � U M O 21W [ 9 �$# ��U�W[� �#U ����[ h �XW '

��� ���_G^ �$� � �� � � ���� /U��320�C[ � T U��32 M O [ � T U�� ��� 2 M O [ � �%�� R�;Y��FNC��$�,���$#!#�0�F��$%�CEk � � � # ��UN\ � ��[<�C$�! `�� ��!T� ?� /U��32.�C[QPQ��+�EF! � � ��� �F��)<E �C �Y���) �<���� � � U M\O 2�� [=)�+�,.-���-%���

& � U M O 21W [ �86�2 � U M O 21W ����[ � Y � W�� � # ��U�W[� �#U [ � � # ��U�W<� �#U ����[� U M O 21W%[ � Y 2]U M O 21W ����[ �86 � W�� � # ��U�W[� �#U [ � � # ��U�W<� �#U ����[

� ����� U��#U 2.�C[ � � �0-�� B��/� �>BR+#B �C�� V U��#U 2 6][ � V U Y 2 Y [ �2i V U��#U � �]2 Y [ � V U Y 2�6][#m ��� � V U��#U 2 Y [ � V U Y 2�6][ � i V U �#U���� 2 6][ � V U Y 2 Y [#mg� '

� �F$�,���� U��#U 2.��[ o �>)<$����D�R��+�$#,��0�F��$G�C�LW ?%�F� ,���B��) ��+#� �C�V�0-#� �F$M�0��YC 0�CE,d �U��32.��[���� U��#U 2.��[ + ,

� ,� �$# ��U�W[� �#U�[ � � # ��U�W[� �#U�� ��[ � �7W ' U �

�dM[

��� � �# ����� � �F$�,�� �$# ��U�W%[G�F)�� k � � P � �0- ��$�E ' � `%$��F��� $ +#B �\�� ����R!��F)�,��C$(���>$(+�� �0�>��)�? �$# ��U�W [�� Y ��) W�� �� W�� � ? B����C$��>$#Y��0-���� ���� ��$(' b �C$�! �C$M';� ? ��-��� ���BR+�) �

��� �4~ �L~0x!�=~���w_x ����~ �4|���!w<� �!�L�Ix!�4�}~�< {��L�]�L�4~ � x!�,���I�x/��x!��<�~ �L~�x!�I����� �a��x!|�x �� �L� � �I{}xz�L~ �/xz�}�4~ �z� ���!�"$#&%(' �*)����x!|4y!~0���J���4���I�4~ �L~0x!�=~��2w_x �<�L�4~�| � {�����xz|]x!�L�{��I�Ix!�L� �/xz�}�4~!�=�Ix ���L~��a~�|���xz|���{���xa�L�L�4�I~��������L�~w��!|4�!�L�a|4{}��{��N���z�,+ "$#-'/. )��L�xz� !�"$#&%(' �*)1032 !�"4#&%5' �6) '/!�"$#&%5'/7 )98=� �!��x!���:�<; 7 � � �4~ {}|F�L~�y!��xz��{�| D>=a��x/�L{}�!| 7 � ?{����I�4~��I~,� �a�L~����!�|�=~���xz�����!~ ���_x��L{�w�{}�}x!�2~A@ � �L~0�L�L{��a| < {��I� !�"$#&%(' �*)��L~ � ��x!�,~0�����<w_x*@B2 !�"$#&%5' �C) 'D!�"4#&%&'-7 )E8

Page 132: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6�6 �� � )���B� �>$M�0�� �N��CE�i lOU ��[X2.jRU ��[ZmV)�+�,.-���-%��� ��+#��)��F!�� �C�W��-%��� �F$(���� NC��E ? � �C��-

0 � � 7 �� , � # ��U�W<� �#U�[ �XW � 0 ,� � 7 � �$# ��U�W<� �#U [ �XW � �r � ��� � * 7 � 2�C$�!

0 � � 7 �� , �$# ��U�W[� �#U����C[ �XW � 0 ,� � 7 � �$# ��U�W<� �#U � �C[ �7W � �r � ��� � � 7 * 7 � '

� �>$#,��@�0-��A)�+�B �F$ $#���(+%�CEF�F� '���0<�>) �\�C+�$�!���!R��� � N��@���� �\�C��-� � # ��U�W[� �#U [ �C$#! �$# ��U�W<� �#U ���[X?Q��-����F !�� �\�� ���$�,�� U �C) �>$��0-��/�>$M�0��Y� 0��EL�C� $#���(+%�CEF�F� ' �

�d([J�>)�CEF)�� �\�C+�$�!���!���� � N�� �('

B��/� U �r � ��� � * 7 � ? �r � � � � � 7 * 7 � [ � � -��F)=B� �C$�)A�0-%�1�=�0-#�DH%�C �L�C� /U��32.�C[@H\�� ��0�C�>$��F$�Y �0�GU�� 2BlA[��U#jQ23 [O�>) � ��+�$�!���! �M'�b ������ �\� N���? )�-�� P=��! �0-%�1� P=�, ��$ ��E>)����$�! ��$ ��H�H� ��CH� ��>���0���)�+#,.- �0-%��� �0-#��H%�� ��R���� /U��32.��[ H �� �.�C�F$��>$#YG���ni l<2.j\m=�F)J�CEF)�� �\�C+�$�!���! �M' b��

�� ����-��� ��

��� �F)��0)Q� � )�+�,.-�0-%�1�A��-�� )�+�B ���\��-��<� P=�SH%�C ���)@�>)�� ��+�$�!���!��M'@b�?MP -��F,.-P=�C)@�0���\�O)�-#�]P $�

�������� �� ��� ��� o)-� � r 8 ; ��� M �]U � o�[&-� M �]U � r.[S>]^/_�_ &�. � )�)�+#B�� � o� � r ?\�C$�!/�0-%�1� M � U � o�[ � M � U � rX[

�� �>$�,�� M � U � o�[O��$�! M � U � rX[�C �����)�)�+#B���! �0� �\����-���)��CB�C?VE>��� M � )��>YC$��F� ' � �C��-

�� $�� P -���!� ��XP �#U � M � PQ��+�EF! � ��>$#!�� �\�� ���$M� �\�X� P=����$ ��,��0�F��$G�C$�!/�>$��C,����>��$�Y�� N���$����F�0-#�� � o=�� � r ?%B����C$��F$�YR�0-%�1�

V U M � 2 6 ���IU M � � � o�[�[ � V U Y 2��IU M � � � o�[�[ U ��0C[

�C$�!V U M � 2 6 ���IU M � � � r3[�[ � V U Y 2��IU M � � � rX[�[ U �

���[

5=+#� � o � � r �C$�!G�0-�� B��$��C����$��>,��F� '�C� V U��32 ��[=�>BB���!�� �1�0��E '�>BH�E>�F��)Q��-%���V U M � 2 6 ����U M � � � o�[�[ � V U M � 2�6 ���IU M � � � rX[�[

�C$�!V U Y 2��IU M � � � rX[�[ � V U Y 2��IU M � � � o�[�[

B� �C$��F$�YR�0-����O��$�EF'I��$�� �C��!�� +����0�F��$�) ��0 �C �

���,��C$ � � �0 �+��

���

Page 133: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6�6 .������� �� � ( $ � : " � + ���B)B8 0D�������10 � � - ��� � � ��� $(�G0 - ��� � ����� 8 + � � & )��B3 $ ; ��6"/+ � =U���oX2 -�o [S>�� ; ��� $ " ���N5D� +� ; "/&�+/" � $ � ) ; + � �+ � ; ��� & ) � + ���B8 Z" -1��� U � � 6][ ������ �1$70/) #" $ ; "/&�+/" � $ �[) ; + � + � ; � �6"/+ � " � + � � & )��B3 '+-" � " � �

� � � 8 ) " ; � � � 3 "�"/& 0 + �G$ � " � ; �]��� : �6"/+ � " � + � � & )��B3 '+-" � + ) ��� � �

� � � >

]^/_�_ &�. �%�� L�0-�� ��$M���� ��0�C�>$#B���$(� �C� �0-�� ����C!��� �? QP �>E>E H� ���)���$M� � P=�*H# �� �C��)�? �C$T�CE>YC���� ��C�>,, ��E>,�+#E �����>��$���$�!T��Y�����B���0 ��>, !���B��C$�)��� 0�����>��$

� EFY����� ��C�>,��CE>E '�?%PQ��, �C$ )��CEFN��S�0-��R�F$��F��� �CE ) ' ) �0��B �C�@���(+%�1�0�>�C$�)D�0���$�! �0-%��� �0-���H ���F$(��C� �>$M�0�� �)���,����>��$G���� - ��� � � ��� ��$�! -1��� � � ���@�F) ��� �0-�� H ���>$M�

��� � ���� ��������

2P -��FE>� �0-#� �F$M�0�� �)���,��0�F��$����� L�0-#� EF�>$���) -1��� U � � 6][ � ���D�C$�!5-1��� � � ���A�F) ���<�0-#� H ���F$(�

��� � ��� � �������� ���

� ��� � ������

2 U ���C[

P -��F,.-/P=�C) �0� �\� )�-�� P $�

� ����B���0 ��>,��CE>E '�? �0-#�Q)��F�0+����0�F��$S�F) �>E>EF+�)��� 0������! �>$ �W�FY�+� �� ��6Xd �0-#�QEF�>$����C��)�E>�CH\�����>) )�-#�F� �0��!

E �1�0�� ��CE>E ' �M' ��$���+�$�� � ?V)�����-�� �\�C���0��B EF�>$����F)SYC�FN���$ ����-%� NC�*E>��$�YC�0- ��$���� -��I)�E>��H � �C��0-#�R-M' H �C����$(+�)��������0-�� � �C���0��B5�� �� ��$�Y�E>� �>)�� ? )����0-��R ����0�F�������0-��JNC�� �0�>,��CEVE>��$#YC�0-T���I�0-#�

-��� �������$M�.�CE EF��$�Y��0-��>)���� �F$�,�� �0-#� -��� �������$M�0�CE E>��$�YC��-/�F)<��$���?#�0-�� NC�� ����>,��CE E>��$�YC�0-�BJ+�)�� � �

���%�� =�0-#� $���� �<�0 �� �C$#Y�E>� +�H ?#PQ� $�� P K($�� P �0-%���=�0-�� NC�� ����>,��CE E>��$�YC��-��>)�� ?%�C$#!G��-�� ����0�F�

�C�ON��� ��0�F, �CEQ�0� -��� ������C$(�0�CEL�F)�� ?A)�� ��-��G-��� �������$M�0�CELE>��Y BR+�) ��-�� NC�GE>��$#YC�0-�� ���� ` �G,��C$,��C$(���>$(+���Y��C�>$�Y*�� ���B EF� P=�� ��>YC-(�D�0��+�H�H �� EF��� � ? , �CEF,�+�E>���0�F$�Y���-���E>��$�YC�0- �C�A��$#��E>��YG�1� �

�0�FB���?#Y�� N �>$�YR��-�� E>��$#YC�0-�)O�C) )�-�� P $��F$G��-�� !�� ��Y� 0�CB�

� �/Y��FNC��$ �0-%��� ��-�� E>�F$��R-%�C) )�-��F� ����! �(';��$�� +�$�� � ? �0-#��F$M�0�� �,���H#���\�X� P=����$ ��-�� E>�>$#�R�C�)�EF��H ���*�C$�!G�0-�� EF�>$���)L�C� )�E>�CH\���D-��C) )�-�� � �0��!/E �1�0�� ��CE>E ' �('Gd

Page 134: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 � Y

�W�FY�+� �� ��6(d � -�� � �0�F$�Y���-���E>�F$��R�C�A)�EF��H � ����$#�R+�$�� � �0���0-#��E>��� �D)�-�� � �0) ��-���H\�C�>$M� �C�A�>$M���� �)���,����>��$ �M'�B��C �� �0-��C$��C$�� +�$��F�

6�� � ���� �

� ���� � � � �

����� � '('(' �,�U�� � �

��� U� 66 � ��� �

� � �2

�C)O��� � N��� �

Page 135: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 � 6���� � ��� ��� ��� ��� � � ��� ��&��

������� � L� � ��� 8�$(�G0 ��U���[ $(�G0 �1U���[ � �=3 " � '+ �65 " 5 ) �����9) > �?�������� #" � � ; �)�� �" � � ) )�563 ; ; $ ��U���[ � �]U���[ � 6 > �"� ��U���[�� �� ��) �]U���[ 8 ; ���� + ) $ ) + �DE � � �6"/+ � ->� �k) " 8 ��U���[ � �]U���[ � 6 � "/& $ � � � � $(�G0 �XU���[ � �]U���[��"6 � "/& $ � � � � > ��� "/ ; � & : "/& 0/)B8� �� ��� ) + �DE � � � 3 &C" )B) + �DE > ^ _c_ & . � � �����(? ��-���$��F�*BR+�)�� � �;�0-%�1�G���F��-��� �XU���[ � �]U���[I���� ��CEFE �I�C

��U���[ � �]U���[L���C �CE>EG��� -#� �� �)�� , ��)�� �>BH�E>�F��)A�0-%���

+ ,� ,

��U���[ �X��� + ,� ,

� U���[ �X�32��+#�)��>$�,�� � �C��-��F$M�0��YC 0�CEF)�BR+�)����� +��CE<��$���?Q�0-#�>)��>) � ,���$M�0 0��!��>,X�0�>�C$

�� �>B�>E>�C �E ';���� ��0-#�

)���,���$#! U � [@,��C)�� � � -��� ������� �� -��������i�� �C���O��-%���A�0-��F)Q�F)A�� �+��O���� =��E>E%,��C$(���>$(+���+#)! � �W)�?

P �F��-���+#� ���YM�� �!G�0���0-��#" ��$ �m

�W��-��� ��J�C �� � PQ�IH ���F$(��) � �X21� ��� ? B� �C$#�>$�Y ��U�� ��[ � �]U�� ��[ � ��U�� �X[ � �]U�� �3[3?%�0-���$��0-#�" ��$ �>)LN �>�CE ������!

�% '��0-#�&" ��$ ?M� � � � ?M�0-#��$ ��U���[ � �1U���[ � ��U [ � �1U [ �()��F$�,�� ��U [ � � U [ � 6�?

�0-#�>) B� �C$�) ��-%��� ��U���[ � � U���[ � 6�� �>B�>E>�C �E '*���� ��3� � � -(+�)�? ��U���[ �C$�! �]U���[ )����0�F)�� ')��F$�Y�EF� � ,� ���)�)��F$�Y � �

������� � �"� QU U���[+ )�$)�.$ � + ��� " � ) + �DE � � � 3 &C" )B) + �DE?0 + ) '&�+ � 5 '+-" ��) ; ��� ; ���.$ � + ���])S$ '+ )�� �B)�'&)(*� > ^ _c_ & . � �CK�� !#� �%$���!��C)A�>$ � ��BBI��6�? �C$�!,��C$�)��F!��� @� P=�SB���B � �� �)A�C�\�0-��<� �CB�>E '�?

��U���[<�C$�! �]U���[�� -���$G���� �C$M'GH ���>$M�('�� ? ��U���[�� �1U���[Q���� �CE>E ����' ?%)��

+-,� �XU���[ �X� � + ,� �]U���[ �X��C$�! ���� � �F)<!���B��$�) �0 0�1�0��!

��O� P",��C$�)��F!��� ��>$�Y)' � ?

+ �� ,

�XU���[ �X� � + �� , �1U���[ �7� U+*���[

Page 136: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 ���� �>$#,�� ��-���)�� �C ��& � �W)�? ��-���'��>$M����Y� ����0�<�0�S��$���?��C$�!�)�� $����(+%�CEF�F� ' *

�� �F)Q���(+��FN��CEF��$M�Q���

6 � +-,� �XU���[ �X� � 6 � +-,� �]U���[ �X�� + �#�� 0�C,X�0�F$�Y ��$�� �C$�!/$���Y����0�F$�Y �\�C��-G)��>!#��) !���B��$�) �0 ����0��)����� � �CYM�C�F$

� �������� ��� +�J ��� ��� � $(�G0 � � � 8=$(�G0�$ ��5���3 '+-" ��) WU�� 21��[ : +� ; ��5 � � )�5���� "/&� "/J � & ; � & $(�DED�B) " � � $(�G0 �.> � ; ��� + � WU�� 21��[ )S$ ,+ )�� �B) ; � � �� � : +� ; & �B)��6�B3 Z"?��- ; $ + )B8ZU � 2 ��[)� �� ��) ZU � 2 6][� 8 ; ��� +� $ �k) " )S$ '+ )�� �B) ; � � �� � : +� ; & �B)��6�B3 #" ���- ; $ + )B8ZU � 21��[&� �� ��) WU 6�21��[�.> ^ _c_� . � ��� � � � � � �C$�!������ ���

� ` � �C)�)�+�B� ��-%����WU����X21� ��[�WU���� 21� ��[ � �ZU����X21� �.[

�ZU���� 21� �.[��

�= ��C)�)OBR+�EF���>H�E ' �>$�YSY��FNC��)�WU����X21� ��[�WU����X21� �3[ � �ZU���� 21� � [

�ZU���� 21� �.[ 2H� ��]N �F$�Y ��+� ���)�+�E �

� �]^/_ � _���������_������ � ; ��� " ) � &�+-"/& 0 + ) '&�+ � 5 '+-" � � # ��U�� 2�� �32 � 2 �\[ � �� ��) �$# ��U � 2%��� 2 � 2 �\[+ A ; ���5���3 '+-" � � VU � 2�� �.2 �\[ � �� ��) ; �!��5���3 '+-" � � VU � 2����.[X2 �[> ^ _c_� . " ��$ B� ��$�)<�0-%���<��-�� 0�����>�

� VU �WU��\[X2%� �3U��\[�[� VU �WU��\[X2%��� U��\[�[

�>) �>$�,� �� ��)��>$#Y��F$����D��,���+� �)��C?\BR+�E �0�>H#EF' �>$�Y���-��J ����0�F� �M'T��,��C$�)��0�C$M�U �F$��0�� �B) �����\[

PQ��$"! � ,.-��C$�Y�� �0-��F)�?�)��� VU��ZU��\[32�� �XU��\[�[� VU��ZU��\[32���� U��\[�[ � 0 ,# , � U �ZU%$�[32�����U&$#[�[ ��$0 ,

# , � U �ZU%$�[32�� �.U&$#[�[ ��$�>)J�CE>)����F$�,� �� �C)��>$�Y��>$ �

�% +#�S�0-��F)S�F) ��-��I ����0�F�T�C�L��-��IH ��) �0�� ��>�� �)�? )��T��-��IH ��)����� ��>�� �))0�1�0�>) � '*�0-#��" ��$

Page 137: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 ���� -�� )��0��H�)O ���NC�� �)��S��� )�-�� P ��-���� �C$�EF'�� � ! H%�C � �C�W��-�� )��.�1�0��B��$M�

� ���������� ��� � 3 " � '+ �65 " 57) " �6� & $ Z"/& � & �B)�� &�J �B) ; � � �� � + A +� + ) " � ; �!� "/& �

��� U �%2 �X[� ��U � [�� ��M2: +� ; � � Y 8 $(�G0 ��U � [ $(� � '& $(��)"� "/& �@$ '+-" � > ^ _c_� . �W�F �) � ?1,���$�)��>!��� ����+# WH ��)�� �0�FNC�Q �� �CE($(+�B � �� �)�? �%?�� ?M�]?���$�!��%?��C$#!�� ,���$M�0�>$(+��C+�)

��+�$�,X�0�F��$ �Id � � � )�+�,.-���-%������ �� �

� U � [� U �X[ � � U ��[

�WU%� [ U+*��� [

���C �CE>E\H\��)��F���FN����%?�� ? �]?%�C$�!��� ` -%���O, �C$ � � )��C�>!/��� ��+#�<��-�� ��+�$�,X�0�>�C$�� U � [��

� �����0�F$�Y � � U � � �C��[ � b�? � � � � � ? )���� U � [�� U � [&��� U ��[�� U �X[�� )��������>$�Y � � U � � ����[�� b�?� � � � � ?M)���� U � [�� U � [ � �WU ��[��WU ��[��M)�� �M'R,���$M�0�F$ +#�F� '�?M� �ZBR+#)���� �L�0-��=, �C)��L�0-%����WU � [��WU � [���WU ��[��WU ��[\P -#��$��XN��� � ��� � �

�� -��>) B� ��$�) �0-%����� U � [�� U � [ �>) �<��+�$�,X�0�>�C$ �C$�EF'D�C� ��-��AH� �� !�+�,X�

� �%? �C$�!G, �C$ � � ��� H� ���)�)���! �C)O��$���P"��$�� � �C �YC+�B���$M�<��+�$�,����>��$��AU � � [ � � U � [�� U � [�

� ��K �F$�Y��0-�� !��� �� NC�1�0�FNC� �C� ��-��>)<�F!���$M���F� '*YC�FN���)<� P=��$���P ���(+%�����>��$�).d� � U � [�� U � [ � � � U � � [ � �

�C$�!�WU � [�� � U � [ � � � U � � [ � �

$ � �C � 0�C$�YC�>$�YQd� � U � [�WU � [ � ��� � � U%� [

�WU%� [ � � �$ ��P �� �0��� � U � [ ���WU � [J�C)��AE>$ U �WU � [�[ � � �%?@�C$�! $#�C�0�F,��I��-%���R��-��>)S���(+%�����>��$ -��CE>!�)J���C ��C$M' ��C$�!��

�� ������ <)��CB�� ,��C$�)��0�C$M� � �C$�!����� ��$('���� �O?

�QEF$ U!� U��\[�[� � � ��� �

Page 138: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 ��� $M�0��Y� 0�����>$�Y � � � �C$�!G���#H ��$���$M�0� �1�0�>$#YYC�FN���)Sd

�WU �\[���)� 2P -��� �� E>$�� �F)L�0-�� ,��C$�)��0�C$M�D�C� �>$M����Y� ����0�F��$

�� ����� ��� ��$�! �.�CK�� � ��� ��U�Z[3? �������1U�Z[3?@� � � ��U� [X? � ��� �]U� [3?Q��$�! �WU��\[ �

��� U � 2�� 2 �\[�� -���$�B��CK(�>$#YR�0-���)�� )�+ ��) �0� �0+#���>��$�) �F$(��� B�H�EF�>,����0�F��$ *

� � Y��FNC��).d� ��U��W[� �]U��W[ � � ��U� [� �]U� [ � ��� U�� 2�� �32��W[

��� U�� 2�� � 2��W[ � ��� U � 2�� �.2 � [��� U � 2�����2 � [ � U *�6 Y [

� -%���D�>)SdQ�F��� ��U � [(" ��$ �)�� �]U � [X?%��-���$ ��� U��ZU � [X2�� �XU � [X2 � [ " ��$ �) ��� U��ZU � [X2�� � U � [32�� [�� -��H� �� �C� )�-�� P )R�0-%�1�J�0-#�>)R,��C$ ��$�E ' �\�I��-��*,��C)��*P -���$ ��� U � 2%��[ �>)S�C�<�0-������� �B�� � � � -��,��C$�)��0�C$M��� B�� ' � � ����+#$�,����>��$G�C� � �#+#�O$��C� �C� �

�� -��>) H� �� N���) �0-���� �C$M'*��+�$�,X�0�>�C$GP -#�>,.-/H� ���)��� N���)D�0-��#" ��$ BR+�) � �\� ��B��$���B� �CE

�� � )�-�� P ��-%��� �C$M' B��$���B� �CE +�H\!����0�F$�Y ��H �� ����0�� 8H� ���)��� �N���) �0-�� " ��$ ? E>���

� ��U��\[ � ��� U��\[ �\� �C$G�F$�,� �� �C)��>$�Y���+�$�,X�0�F��$G�C� ��� -���$

��� � U��\[��� � U��\[ � � � �XU��\[

��� U��\[ �

BR+�) � �CE>)����\� �>$#,� ����C)��F$�Y�?�)���EF��$�Y �C) � � Y� �

]^/_ � _���������_���� � � +�J ���F$(��� ��$ +�& " � � &�+-"/& ) � � $(�G0 ��� :<; + 3 ; )S$ ,+ )"���) + �DE�� � � 3 &C" )B) + �DE/8 $(�G0$(������5D��3 '+-" � � 8 $(�G0 $(��5 ��07$ ,+ �DE " �6� & $ Z"/& ��� U � 2��#[ :<; + 3 ; + ) � " � "/ Z" � + 31$������ + ��3 & �1$/) + �DE+ � � $(�G0 � 8 ; � " �6� & $ Z"/& ��� U �>2�� [ � &C"/J�+ 0D�B) � " ) � &�+-"/& ) "/& 0D� & �10 � � � &)(*� + A ; �!��5���3 '+-" �+ ) " � ; �!� "/& �

��� U�� 2��#[ � ��U�� [ ��� � 2:<; � & � ��U � []+ ) $ '& $(��)"� "/& �@$ ,+-" � ��5D��3 '+-" � " �]$(��� � "/& ��8 $(�G0 � + )�$(��� � " ) +� ,+�J ��3 " ��) $(� ->

Page 139: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 ��� ^ _c_� . ` � $�����!T�C$�EF'IH� �� N�� �0-����

+ ,# ,��� U � 2�� �32 �\[ � ��� + ,

# ,��� U�� 2�� � 2 �\[ � � U *

�6�6][

�F�Z�C$�!;�C$�EF'G� � ��� U � 2�� 2 �\[ ,��C$ � �SP ��F������$��>$���-��S���C �B ��U � [ � � � � � ���H\�C)��F���>��$ � �;U H%�CYC�6�6 ��[=H� �� N���)O��-�� ���)��

�� � )�-#�]P �0-%�1�A��-�� �>$M�0��Y� 0��E#�C�G��U �ZU �\[�[ � � � U��\[W�F)�,���$#)��.��$(�A�F$,.-��C$�Y���)A�F$ � U � [3?CP=�O$�����!��$�E ' �� �� �CKI!�� P $��0-#� �F$M�0��YC 0�CE,d

+ ,# ,

��U��ZU��\[�[� � � U �\[ � � � + ,# ,

��U��ZU��\[�[ � ��� + ,# ,

� � U��\[ � �� + ,

# ,��U��ZU��\[�[ � ��� �

� -��F)O�F)<,���$#)��.��$(� P � �0-G ���)�H ��,��O�0� � U � [�

� �GH� �� N��R�0-#���C�0-��� !��> ���,X�0�>�C$ ? O+�)��R��-��R����EFE>� P �>$�Y�0-� �����)��CB�H#E>�S��+#$�,����>��$�) ����)�-�� P�0-����O�F�V�0-�� +�H !%���0�F$�Y��H\�� 0������ <�>) $����D�C� �0-�� ���� �B5Y�� N���$�-��� ��C? �0-���$����(+%�����>��$ *�6�6 !�� ��)

$��C� -#��E>! U ��$�!�)���H ��) �0�� ��>�� �)LP �>EFE $��C� )����0�F)�� ' ������R? �M' � ��CH\��)��F���>��$ � �M[�

�ZU �\[ �& �����ni Y 2Cbgm

Y � -�ni Y 2Cbgm� �XU��\[ �

& �����ni Y 2Cbgm

Y � -�ni Y 2Cbgm��� U��\[ �

& �����ni 6�2�6 � bgm

Y � -�ni 6�2�6 � bgm

�%�� A)��>BH�EF�>,�� � '�? � ��U��\[@�C$�! ���]U �\[Q�C �� PQ� �CK(E 'I)��>$�Y�EF� � ,� ��C)�)��F$�Y�? ��+ �=�0-#��'�BI� ' � �D)�B� �C�0-���!��+#�<�����+#$�,����>��$�)LP -#�>,.-��C �� )��� ��F,��0E '*)��>$�Y�EF� � ,� ��C)�)��F$�Y �� �� ��S�C �� )���B�� +�)�����+�E �F$M�0��YC 0�CEF)�?#P -��F,.-�-#��E>!����� �CEFE � 2 � � Y d

+ ,# ,

�ZU �\[ � ��� + ,# ,� ��U��\[ � ��� + ,

# ,� �]U��\[ � � � 6

+ ,# ,

���%U �\[�� �� U��\[ � � � � 6b�� �� � #

� �

Page 140: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 ���+ ,# ,

� � U �\[�� �� U��\[ � � � Y

� � P",���$�)��>!��� ��$('���+�$�,X�0�>�C$ ��� U � 2 ��[�` ���> �)��0 ��C)�) ! )OH ��EF' $���B� ��E\��H�H� ��e� �>B������>��$I��-���� � ���B �0��EFE>)O+�) ��-%���D�C$M'T,���$M�0�F$ +#��+�) ��+#$�,����>��$�, �C$ � �R��H�H� ��e� �>B�������!;�� ��� �0 0�� ��>E 'IPQ��EFE �M'��

H ��EF' $���B� ��E\�C�V�0-#� ���C �B��� U �%2 �X[�� �

U�� * � * � *������� �� * � * � *������

'(U � � U � �

` -���$ P �FE>E 0 ,# , ��� U �WU��\[X2%� �3U��\[�[ � � ��0 ,

# , ��� U��ZU��\[32���� U��\[�[ � � � �<�0-#�I��� H%��$�)��F��$ �>$ �,�EF+�!���)D�0�� �B)D�C����-��S���� �B 'XU � � U U �\[X? P -��� �� � ��U �\[O�� ��� U��\[ !��I$��C� ��H�H\���C �? �0-#��)��RP �FE>E � ����(+%��E �\�X� P=����$ �\�C��-��>$M�0��Y� 0��E>)

� � �0�� �B8�C� �0-��L���� �B ' � � � U��\[ P �>E>E �>$M����Y� ����0�=��� ��$��L�F$��\�C��-, ��)���)�% +#�R��$(' �C��-��� �0�� �B P �>EFE�!�� �\�� �� ��CB ��$���>$M�0��Y� 0�CE������0-#���C��-���

�� �X�����>$�Y%bJY��X��C ���F�� 0�C ��>EF'�E �� �Y��RP �FE>E�B��CKC� �0-��F) !�� �\�� ���$�,��I�C) E �� �Y���C) P �>)�-���! ? ��+#��)��0 ��>H�H#�>$�Y��0-#���� � ��C

�0�� �B �>$/�0-��SH\��E ' $���B� �CE �CH#H� ��e� �>B����0�F��$�� �*� � ��� U �%2 �X[ �F) $#�C� �C����-��S���C �B Y��FNC��$;�F$T�0-#�

�0-#���� ���B/? ��-��� ������ �>)�� ��+�$#,��0�F��$�)�ZU �\[X?�� ��U �\[X? �C$�!���� U��\[ )�+�,.- �0-%��� � ��U��\[ �C$#! � �1U��\[ �C ��)��F$�Y�EF� � ,� ���)�)��F$�Y�? ��+#� ���(+%�����>��$ * � 6�6 !�� ��)=$��C�<-��CE>! ?#�C$�!�)�����-�� H ��)����� ��F�� �)=!���$��C�<)����0�F)�� '������

� ���������� � � � � 5 ��07$ ,+ �DE " �6� & $ Z"/& ��� U � 2��#[ :<; + 3 ; + )/� " � "/ #" � + 31$������ + ��3 & �1$/) + �DE + � �

$(�G0 � � & �B)�� &�J �B)�) + �DE�� � � 3 &C" )B) + �DE + A ; �!��5���3 '+-" � + ) " � ; �!� "/& �

��� U�� 2��#[ � ��U�� [ ��� � 2:<; � & � ��U � []+ ) $ '& $(��)"� "/& �@$ ,+-" � ��5D��3 '+-" � " �]$(��� � "/& ��8 $(�G0 � + )�$(��� � " ) +� ,+�J ��3 " ��) $(� ->

^ _c_� . � $M'IH%�C�> Q�C� )��F$�Y�EF� � ,� ���)�)��F$�YJH� ��>�� �)=)����0�F) �%��) � ����� U � ��BBI� ��[�� -��� ��X���� ���?�F� ��� U �%2 � ��[Q�C$#! ��� U �%2 � �3[@�0�CKC�D�C$M'IH��C�> @�C� ��+�$#,��0�F��$�)@P -��>,.-�)����0�F) �%��) ������"�C$#!* ��X�0+� �$��H%�C�F ���Z��+�$�,X�0�>�C$�)OP -#�>,.-;)����0�F)�� ' ���� �R? ��-���$��0-��F) +�H !%�����>$�Y���H �� 0�1�0�� �.�CK���) ��$('/H%���> �C�

��+�$�,X�0�F��$�)=P -��F,.-�)0�����>) �%��)<)��>$�Y�EF� � ,� ��C)�)��F$�Y�? �C$�!� ����0+# �$�) �JH��C�> Q�C� ��+�$�,����>��$#)=P -��>,.-�)����0�F)�� '������

�% ') @ ���H ��)�� �0�>�C$�6 � ? � �QBJ+�)�� �\�O�0-�� , �C)�� �0-����=��-��>)A��H �� 0�1�0�� A�>)A�C� ��-��DEF�>$����C ����� �BY�� N���$/�>$���-%��� H� ���H\�C)��F���>��$

Page 141: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 � * � � ��U��\[�� � �]U �\[X?��0-#��$/)��>$#,��

+ ,# ,

��U��ZU��\[�[ � � ��U��\[ � � � +-,# ,

��U �ZU �\[�[ � � �]U �\[ � � 2��U �WU��\[�[ � � �XU��\[

0 ,# , ��U��ZU��\[�[ � � ��U��\[ � � � ��U �WU��\[�[ � ��� U��\[

0 ,# , ��U��ZU��\[�[ � � �1U��\[ � � �

� � �F�)� ��U �\[��2���]U �\[ ���� S�CE>E�� � ? P -��� �� �>)S��-��*,� ���)�)��>$#Y;H\�C�>$M�R�C�<��-��IH# ��>�C �)�?�0-#��$ ���$# � �XU��\[�� ���$# � �]U��\[A���C <�CE>E � � ��,��C$(NC�� �)���E '*���� <��E>E#� : ?#B� ��$��>$�YS�0-%���L�F� �0-#�H� ��>�� �)<)0�����>)�� '*)��>$#Y�E>� � ,� ���)�)��>$�Y#?#)�� !�� �0-#� H ��) �0�� ��>�� �) � ���� � _ ^/�D� ����� +� ; + � ; � 3 �*$/)B) " � " �6� & $ #"/& )���� U � 2%��[ :<; + 3 ; $ & � � " � "/ #" � + 31$������ + ��3 & �1$/) �+ �DE + � ��"/ ; $ & E(5 �=��� )B8]$(� " �6� & $ #"/& � & �B)�� &�J �B) � &)(*� + A +� + ) " � ; ��� "/& ����� U � 2��#[ ���U � [���� � 8 :<; � & � ��U � [ + )%$ '& $(��)"� "/& �@$ ,+-" � ��5D��3 '+-" � " �!$(��� � "/& � $(�G0 � + )%$ � " ) +� '+�J �3 " ��) $(� >]^/_�_� . �O��,���)�)��F� 'Gd�� �>$#Y�E>� � ,� ���)�)��>$�YH� ��>�� �) �C ��J�I)�+ ��)���� �C��� �����8H� ��F�� �)�?\)��*�F� BR+�) � � ��0-#��,��C)���0-%��� �0-#�>) ��H\�� 0������ �>) �>$ �0-���,�E>�C)�) �C�L�CH\�� 0������ �) !���)�,� �� � ��! �M' � ���H ��)�� �0�F��$�6 �U �C <���(+��FN��CEF��$M�0E '�? � ���H\�C)��F���>��$ ���([

�� +��,��F��$�,X'G�>)L���C)��FEF'�,.-���,.K���!cd=�F� � ��U��\[ ������ )'��� U��\[X? �0-���$ $����(+%�CE>� � ' *

�6 �J-��CE>!�)=���C

�C$M'�' �(��-��< ���)�������EFE>� P ) �� ���B8�CE>Y����� 0� U �C$�!R��-��L� �C,�����-%���Z��-��<�>$M����Y� ��CE#�F$R�0-��L!#��$���B�>$����0�� �C� $����(+%��E>�F� ' *

�6 � �F)L�0-�� )��CB�� ���C ��\�C��- � �=�C$�! ���.[

+ ,� � ��U �\[ � � � + ,

� � �]U��\[ � � U *�6 ��[

+-,� ��U �ZU �\[�[ � �

+ ,� � ��U �\[ � � � + ,

� ��U �WU��\[�[ � ��� �+-,� ���1U �\[ � �

+ ,� ��U��ZU��\[�[ ��� � ��U �\[ � � � + ,� ��U �WU��\[�[ � � � �]U �\[ � �0 ,� ��U��ZU��\[�[ ��� � ��U �\[ � �0 ,# , U �ZU �\[�[ � � � ��U��\[ � � � 0 ,� ��U��ZU��\[�[ ��� ���]U �\[ � �

0 ,# , ��U �ZU �\[�[ ��� � �]U��\[ � � U *

�6 �M[

� ��� � ���� ������� �� ��� ��&���

Page 142: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 ������ � _ ^/�D� ��� � )B)�5 �=� ; $ ; �@3 " �G0 +� ,+-" ��) " � � )B)�5 � � ,+-" ���/8 � )B)�5 � � ,+-" ���.8 $(�G0 � ) �)�5 � � ,+-" ��� ; " �*0 > � ; ��� ; � & � �gK + ) ) $ $/) ; ���S5 + � + �S&�+ 5 � :<; " )�� ��$�� "ZA #"F ; �@$70 J(" 31$ �+ ) ���S5�$�� Z"@ ; � ��$�� "ZA ; � : " 5 �*0 ED� � &C" � & � J �1$�� + �DE ��5 ��� + � � "/& �@$ ,+-" � > ^ _c_� . � -��S!#��,��F)��F��$GBI�CK��� B�� 'I)��X�

T U� @[�� �� �Y�B�>$���� ,���� �� � j�U T U� � [�[ � U *�6 �([

�#� 'T�0-���� �0-#� �C!#N�� , �1�0� ��XN�� ��E>)� � ? P -��� ��� ��� ��� �>$�,��R�0-���!���,��F)��>�C$�BI��KC�� D�>) $�� P

!����F$�Y���-��RB�>$��FB���� �����>��$I�>$����(+%�����>��$ *�6 �*� N��� �IE �C �Y��� O)��X� ? )�-��JP �FE>EV�C � ��FNC�R��� ��N��CE>+��

)�+#,.- �0-%�1� jRU T U� � [�[ � jRU T U� � [�[�� �G�0-��!���,��>)��>��$ B��CKC�� PQ��+�EF! ����0-#�� !�������,�� �� ���B

��XN����CE>�F$�Y� � �0�R��-�� )��� 0������YC'I�C�V ��XN�� ��E>�>$#Y� � ?#)�� � �>)Q$��C� �C$����(+��>EF� �� ��>+�B�� �R�0-�� �C$�EF'

���(+��FE>� �� ��F+�B H ��)�)�� �#E>�R���� �0-#����!#N�� , ������-��C) �/H%� 'C�������(+%�CE��0�! �� � )�)�+#B�H#���>��$"���0��E>E>)+�) �0-%�1� �F�O�0-����C!#NC� ,����0�G ��XN����CE>)# � ?A�0-���$ ��-��G!���,��>)��F��$�B��CKC�� , �C$�!�� $�� � �����0�� �?L��$�!

�0-#�� ��X���� �� P �FE>E $#�C�O!�������,�� �� ���B �0-��F)<���(+��>EF� �� ��>+�B� �

]^/_ � _���������_�����$ �"� ; � '& 5 � 0 + ) ,&�+ � 5 ,+-" � " � � � i Y 2 6Sm + ) �WU��\[ 8 ; � 0D�B3 + ) +-" � �@$&%7� &(' )� &�+-"/& + ) � U �\[ 8<$(�G0 ; �0D�B3 + ) +-" � �@$&%7� & : + ��� 3 ; "�" )�� ; � �=�10 + $(� " � ; � & �6� & 3B� +�J �10 � " ) � &�+-"/&0 + ) '&�+ � 5 '+-" ��8 ; ���%$ � " � � � + ) :<; " � & �"�e� & ) ) �@$���� � &�" 5 3 " �=�B) #" �*$ & ED� & : + ���6� "/ [& � J �1$�� ��5 ���+ � � "/& �@$ ,+-" � + � ; � & � �gK + ) ) ) " �=� + � � &�J $�� U �%2 �X[ $ ��"/J � ; � �=�10 + $(� " � �ZU��\[ )�563 ; ; $ �ZU%$�[�� � U&$#[ � "/& $���� $ � U �%2 �X[ 8 $(�G0 ; � & �I$��k) " �gK + ) )=) " �=� + � � &�J $�� U �12 � [ � � � " : ; ��=�10 + $(� " � �WU��\[ )�563 ; ; $ �ZU%$�[ � � U&$#[ � "/& $���� $ ��U �]2 � [S>

� ; �=)S$ �=� � " � � � + ) : + ��� & � J �1$���) " �=�)�S5Q$(� '+� � " � + � � "/& �@$ '+-" � + � ; � & �%�gK + ) ) ) " �=�+ � � &�J $�� U �%2 �X[ $ ��"/J � ; � �=�10 + $(� " � � U �\[ )�5 3 ; ; $ � U&$#[ � �ZU&$#[ � "/& $���� $ � U �%2 �X[ 8$(�G0 ; � & � $��k) " �gK + ) ) ) " �=� + � � &�J $�� U �12 � [ � � � " : ; $(� ; � �=�10 + $(� " � � U��\[ )�563 ; ; $ � U%$�[ � �ZU&$#[ � "/& $���� $ ��U �]2 � [S>

� ; � + �����S5�$�� +� '+ �B) $ & � & � J � & )��10'� "/& $ � " � � � + ) :<; " � & �"�e� & )��*$ & ED� &]" 5 3 " �=�B) Z" ) �@$���� � &" 5 3 " �=�B) > ^ _c_� . �Q�0-��!���,��>)��>��$ B��CKC�� -��C) ��+#E>E��>$ ���� �B����0�F��$ ? ��-���$ -��� H ��)����� ��F�� B����0,.-���)

�0-#� �0 �+��D!#�>)��� �� ��+#�0�F��$ �ZU��\[3?��C$�!��0-�� B���!�� �C$�C� ��-��DH ��)����� ��>�� A�>)@�0-��� ��X���� ��D��-��DB��!#� �C$�C��ZU �\[

�� � P )0� '/�0-��J�C!#N�� , �1�0�S� ���>E>)<���I ��XN����CE ��-��SN��CEF+��J�C� �ZU��\[LP �F��-��>$ U �%2 �X[ �C$#!�U �]2 � [

Page 143: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 � �� -���$ ��-���H\�C)��0�� ��F�� Y��FNC��$ �0-#�>) EF��)�)��� �>$ ���� �B����0�F��$TB�����,.-���) �ZU �\[D��+#��)��>!#�R�0-���)�� ���Y��>��$#)��+#�R-%�C)RB�� ��P=���>Y�-M���F$ U �]2 � [S��$�! E>��)�)R�F$ U �%2 �X[X?�)��;�0-��IH\��) �0�� ��>�C SB��!��>�C$ � � N��C �)R�0-#��C!#NC� ,����0� B�� ���?%�C$�!G�0-#�S��!#N�� , ����� P �>E>E �0-��� ��X���� �� $��C�O ���N����CE ��+�E>E\�>$#���C �B����0�F��$

� �<�0-��!���,��>)��>��$ BI��KC�� S-%�C)S$��T�F$#���� �B������>��$ ? ��-���$ -��� SH\��) �0�� ��>�C B�����,.-���)S-��� SH� ��F�� �?

� U �\[X? �C$�!;��-���B��!��>�C$ �C�@�0-���H ��) �0�� ��>�� �>)D��-��� ������� ��R�0-���B��!#� �C$ �C� � U �\[�� � P8)0� ';�0-#�

�C!#NC� ,����0�J ���NC� �CEF)D�0-#�JN��CE>+��S�C� �ZU �\[OP �F��-��>$ U �%2 �X[D�C$#!�U �]2 � [�� -���$ �0-#�JH ��)����� ��F�� DYC�FN���$�0-#�>) Y� �� ������ �>$ ���� �B����0�F��$TB�����,.-���) � U �\[ �C+#�0)��>!��R��-���)�� ���Y��F��$�) ��+ �S-��C) B��� ��JPQ���>YC-(� �F$U �]2 � [ �C$�! EF��)�)S�>$�U �%2 �X[X?Z)��T�0-#�*H\�C)��0�� ��F�� B���!�� �C$ � � N��� �)J�0-��I�C!#NC� ,����0�*B�� ��C?Z��$�! �0-#�

�C!#NC� ,����0�RP �FE>E �0-#�� ��X���� ���H# ������� D�0�� ���NC� �CEW��-��R�F$#���� �B������>��$���� ��+#� �WU��\[ �F$�)��F!��GU �%2 �X[D��$�!U �]2 � [

� �]^/_ � _���������_���� � � &�+ E ; � � �1$(� + �DE � " � � � + ) : + ��� & � J �1$�� ��5 ��� + � � "/& �@$ '+-" � + A � U �\[ + )]� " � �0D�B3 & �1$/) + �DE >�� ; � � " � � � + ) : + ��� & � J �1$���� " + � � "/& �@$ ,+-" � + A � U��\[]+ ) � " � + ��3 & �1$/) + �DE >

� ; � & � J � & )�� + ) ,& 56��� "/& $�� �"� � � �1$(� + �DE � " � � � + ) -> ^ _c_� . � ��-��� ��O�F)@)���B�< ���Y��>��$%i �%2 �Cm P -#�� �� �0-#�O!#��$�)��F� 'R��+�$#,��0�F��$�>)�!���,� ����C)��F$�Y�?M�0-#��$�0-#�AB� ��$S�C� � U �\[ ���C ��� i � 2 �Bm(�F) E>��)�) �0-%��$ ��-��QB� ��$ ��� ��-��Q+#$��F���� �B !��F)��� �� �#+#�0�F��$ � N��� �0-#�

)0��B�� �C �� ��� -��� ��X���� �� �0-�� EF� � �M' �>)�� �F)��\�X������ ��� $��C� ���H �� ����>$�Y���-��>)< ���Y��F��$

��=��$MN��� �)���EF'C?

���� ��$(';�C ����*� N��� P -#�>,.- � U��\[D�F)D�F$�,� �� �C)��>$�Y�?\�0-���B� �C$ �F)DE>�C �Y��� �F����-��REF� � �M' �>)�� ���NC� �CEF)� U �\[L��-%�C$G�F� -�� !�� ��)�$"! �

� �

� ��� � ���� ������� �� ��� ��&���

��� � _ ^/�D� � � � ; � & � $ & � ; & �B� ) Z"/&�+ �B) :<; + 3 ; ; � $70 J(" 31$ �B) 3 " 5 �*0 )�5 � � +� R�� ��� � 2 2 � ��> � +� ; " 5 )�5 A � &�+ �DE4$(��� � " )B) " �=ED����� & $�� +� ��8 � � ��\U� �X[ � Y 8 �\U� [ � 6 8$(�G0 �\U� � [ ��U Y 2 6][.>

�"� ; �=0D�"�e���G07$(� ; $/) $�� & �1$70�� � & �B)���� �10 � $(�G0 ; � � �*$ + � '+ A ; $/) $�� & �1$70�� � & �B)���� �10 8 $(�G0 + � ; ��5�0�ED�/�@$�� � $/)�� ; � &�" � + � +-" � " � :<; " � & �B)���� �10 � 8 ; ��� ; � & � �gK + ) 3 " �G0 +� '+-" ��) $(�G0%$��5�0�ED� ' ) " � + � +-" � )�5 3 ; ; $ ; � � �*$ + � '+ A : " 5 �*0!� "/ � & �B)���� � � ; � & ��gK + ) 3 " �G0 +� '+-" ��)]$(�G0=$ �5Q0�ED� ' ) " � + � +-" � )�563 ; ; $ � ; �N0D�"�e���G07$(� : " 5 �*0 � "/ � & �B)���� � �

Page 144: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 � Y$(�G0F$���� " � ; �B)�� 3 " �G0 +� '+-" ��) �@$��?) + � 5 � $(��� " 5 ) ��� � � '& 5 � > ^ _c_� . ` �F�0-G��$#EF' �D�C$�! ?#�0-#� ��� H\��,��0��!TN��� �!��F,��O�>).d

V U �� �12 ��[�� �6 ������U ��� �]2�� ��[ 2 U *�6 ��[

P -#�� ��� �����RU ��� � 2 ��[ ����RU �� � 2 ��[� U # U� 2 �� � 2 ��[�[ �

� -��F)I�>) �0-#�;H%� '���� Y�� N���$ �0-��/�0-� ����;H ��)�)�� ��EF��) �.������)*�F$ P -��F,.-���$����C� �0-#�T)����� ��F��)�0��EF!�M' �C$��T�C� ��-��;��!#N�� , ������)*�F)��� �+��

�� �F$�,�� � U �X[ � Y ?L�0-��/�0�� �B�)����RU �� � 2�� ��[�� Y �

����U �� � 2 ��[� U # U � 2 �� � 2 ��[�[�� Y -%� N�� � ����$ ��B�� ������!8�� ���B ��

� �>$�,�� ��-�����NC��$M���� �]2�� � PQ��+�EF!��F$MN���E N�� � ����� ��>�CE ?<PQ� )�, �CEF�;�0-�� N��� �!��F,�� �M' 6 �����RU ��� � 2�� ��[ �i � �!���E N�� �>$M��������� � B��C �� !��X�.�C�FE ? ��-�� N��� �!��F,�� P �>EFE � �

� ����RU ��� �]2�� ��[Si � ������U ��� � 2�� ��[.i � ����RU ��� � 2�� ��[Si ����� m*m m� � ����RU ��� � 2�� ��[ � � i�����U ��� � 2�� ��[Zm � � � ��� �� � ��U 6�������U ��� � 2�� ��[�[X2

�C) �>$ ���(+%�����>��$ *�6 ��m

� � �F) H� ���)���$(����! ? �0-#��$ ��-��� ���C ������>Y�-M� H ��)�)�� ��EF��)��.�1�0��) � � �G)��FB�H#E>�F� 'G��-�� BI����- ? P �>EFEV�C)�)�+�B��S�0-%���D�0-��JPQ���FY�-M�0)� U 2 �� 2 � ��[ �� U 2 �� 2 � 2�� � ��[X? �C$�! )��>B�>E �� �EF'���� ��� 2 � �(?��C$�!)�� 2�� � � � ` � �CK���$��F$�Y �0-��F)Z�C)�)�+�BH#���>��$ P �>E>E(B��CKC�A�0-�� �\��+#$�!�)W����+#$�!� ��E>� P B�� ��S) �0 ��F$�Y���$(�

��� �FNC��$/�0-��F)D�C)�)�+�BH#���>��$ ?%��-��SNC�� �!#�>,�� Y��FNC��$;��E>E �0-� ����S)��0�C ��>��)OP �FE>E� �(d

V U �� � 2 � 2 ��[�� � � ���6 �����RU ��� � 2�� 2�� � ��[ 2 U *�6 �M[

P -#�� ��� � ������U ��� � 2 2�� � ��[ ������U �� � 2 2�� � ��[� U # U� 2 �� � 2 ��[�[32O�C$�!

Page 145: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 �#6� � ���RU �� � 2 2 � ��[��Gi U # U � 2 �� � 2 2 � ��[�[��\U� � [ � U # U 2 �� � 2 2 � ��[�[Zm

� ���RU �� � 2�� 2 � ��[�� U # U� � 2 �� � 2 � ��[�[��\U� � [� ���RU ��� � 2 2 � ��[��Gi U # U � 2 �� 2 � ��[�[ �\U� � [ � U # U 2 �� 2 � ��[�[#m

� ����U ��� � 2�� 2 � ��[�� �\U� � [ � � � �>)�H� ���)���$(����! ��+#�� �� � ��,��0��! ? ��-���$ � � �>)��0-��;��� H\��,��0��!�NC�� �!��>,X� � �F� � �>)�H� �� �)���$M�0��!"�C$�! �C,�,���H#����! ? �0-#��$ ��-�� ��� H\��,�����! NC�� �!#�>,����>) �

�� �C *�0-�� H�E ���>$M�0� � �0��!���,��F!��

P -��X�0-��� �-��;)�-#��+�E>! H# ���)���$M�! � ?O-#�;$�����! ��$�EF'�,��CE>,�+�E ��������-��;��� H ��,X�0��! H%� 'C��� � ������ �� � �>) H� ���)���$M�0��!8U�� V U �� � 2 ��[�[3?L�C)��>$ ��� +����0�F��$�*

�6 � ?=�C$�! ��-��/��� H\��,�����! H%� '�� �"��� ��0�� � � �>) H# ���)���$M�0��! U�� V U �� �]2 � 2 ��[�[X? �C) �F$ � �(+%�1�0�>�C$ *

�6 �� ��� V U �� � 2 � 2 ��[��

� V U �� � 2 ��[3? ��-���$*��-�� H�E>�C�>$M�0� �GP=��+#E>! � ��$�� ���<�� ��CB H# ���)���$M�0�F$�Y� � ?��C$�!�� � �0-��D ���NC�� �)���>)L�� �+���?��0-���$�-#� PQ��+�EF!�$#�C��

��P=��)�-�� P �0-%��� P -���$ ���(+%�����>��$ *�6 ��>)D��� �BI� �#�FBR+�B �C$#! ��� +����0�F��$�*

�6 �I�F)D��� �

B�>$��FBR+�B/?��0-��AH�E>�C�>$M�0� �R) �0�>EFECP=�C$M�0) ��� H# ���)���$M� � ?]�0-���$SPQ�=-%� N��AH� ��]NC��$J��-%���V�0-��@H�E>�C�>$M��� �P �>EFE �CE PL� ' ) H# ���)���$M� � ���Y��C �!�EF��)�)O���W�0-#� � +�!#Y�� ! ) �CH��>$��F��$�� -�� ��� H ��,X�0��!TH%� '���� � ������ ��

H� ���)���$M�0�>$#Y � �>)A���Q� BI� �#�FBR+�B P -���$ U # U� 2 �� � 2 ��[�[��86�M�0-%���A�F)�?�P -���$I�0-�� � +�!�YC�H�E>�C,���)ZBI� �#�FBI��E(PQ���FY�-M����$ �>$R�CE>E , �C)���)ZP -��� ��<)�-��<-%�C)ZEF���XPL� 'J��� !�� )�� � $R�0-#�>)Z,��C)���? � ���!�+�,���)D��� � � ���������U [X?\�C$�! � �� �� ����U �� 2�� � ��[ � �O�C�0�F,�� �0-%��� )��F$�,�� �\U� [ � 6�?�0-#��)��S�C �� �C,���+%�CE>E '*���#H ��,X�0��!�N��� �!��F,���)�? �

�Y�? � � �� ������U [��\U� [ �

� � ���� H# ���)���$M�0�F$�Y � ? ��-�� ���#H ��,X�0��! NC�� �!��>,X� �>) ��� � B�>$��FBR+�B P -#��$ U # U� � 2 �� � 2 � 2 ��[�[ � U # U � 2 �� � 2 � ��[�[�� 6�?<�C$#! U # U� � 2 �� � 2 ��[�[�� 6 6�0-����<�>)�? P -���$��0-�� � +�!#Y�� H�E>�C,���)<�C)<BR+�,.-*PQ���FY�-M�O�C)LH ��)�)�� ��EF�D��$ �]?#�C$�! ?#P -#��$! � �>)L$�����C$G��H#���>��$ ?���$ � � $��0-#�>) , �C)��C?�� ���!#+�,���) �0� � � U � ������U ��� 2 � ��[��\U� � [ �

� -�� H�E �C�F$M�0� �/P �>EFE\��-��� ������� ��S��EFP=� ' )OH� ���)���$(� � P -���$cdV � U � U �� � 2 � 2 ��[ � V � �� U �� � 2 ��[

O �� ����� ������ � O ��������� ���� ��� ��� �� � # O ����&� � � �&� � � ��� � � ��� � O �� � �� � # O ����&� � � �&� � � ��� O ����&� � � � � � ��� � � �

� � # O ����&���� �&���� ������ ��� � O � � �� � # O ���������� ��� � � ��� � O �� � � � ��� � � �

� � # O ���������� ��� ��� �&���!� ���

� U � [ � O � � � O ��������� � � � �� � # O ������ � � �&� � � �&� � � ���

� � # O ���������� ��� � � ��� � O �� � � � �&� � � � O ����&���� � � � � � U *

�6 *�[

Page 146: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 � �` -���$ $#���(+%�CEF�F� '�*

�6 * !�� ��)L$#�C�L-��CE>! ?(�0-���$*�0-��� �� ��� �>)��=,��F �,�+#B�) �.�C$�,���)L)�+�,.-��0-%�1�=�0-#�

H�E>�C�>$M�0� � H# ������� �) �0-%�1� � $��C���\� ���N����CE>��! � � �C���>,��R��-%��� �0-#�>) ,��C$�)��� 0�C�F$(� B�� ' � �C)��>E ' � �Y� �� ������ D��-%�C$;��$#�C? �F$�P -��F,.- , �C)��R�0-��� ��R�F)D$�� �\U� � [<���� P -��F,.-;�0-��JH�E �C�F$M�0� � P �FE>EV�CE PL� ' ) ��XN����CE � �� � P ,���$#)��>!#�� S��-��*!��X����$�)��(d�F�L��-��INC�� �!#�>,��SP �F��-���+#� � �F)R���R�TB�>$��FBR+�B/? �C$�! �0-#�

N��� �!��F,��<P � �0- � �F)<���O�RB��/� �>BR+#B�? �C$�!���-�� !�������$�)�� ) �0�>EFE\P=�C$M�0)L���H# ���)���$M� � ?#�0-���$G-��P �>EFE\P=�C$M� ��� H� ���)���$M� � ���YM�C �!�E>��)�) �C�V�0-�� � +�!�YC� ! ) ��H#�>$��F��$�

% �����C �� H# ���)���$M�0�F$�Y � ? ��-�� ���#H ��,X�0��! N��� �!��>,X� �F) ��� � B�>$��FBR+�B P -#��$ U # U� � 2 �� � 2 ��[�[� 6

�� -���$ � � ���RU ��� � 2 ��[ � � � �0�� VH� ���)���$M�0�>$#Y� � ?1�0-��Q��� H ��,�����!N��� �!��F,��I�>)������ BI�/� �FBR+�B P -���$� U # U� 2 �� � 2 � 2 ��[�[�� U # U� 2 �� � 2 ��[�[�� 6�?

�C$�! U� � 2 �� � 2 � ��[ � 6�

$ �0-��F) , �C)��C? � � � ���RU ��� �]2 2�� � ��[ �C$�! � �����U �� 2 � ��[ ������U ��� 2 � ��[ � U � [ � ` � P=�C$M�O�0� �%$�!GP -���$�d

V � �� U �� � 2 � 2 ��[ � V � U � U �� � 2 ��[32�� O ����&� � � � � � �&� � � � O �� � � � � � � � O ����&� � � � � � ��� � � ���

� � # O ����&���� ��� � � ��� � � ��� � O ������ � � � � � �� � # O ����&���� �&� � � ��� �� )��� � N���?=P=�/B�� ' $�� P B�]NC���0-��GE>�X� �0B��)������� �B�)��C� �0-��GEF��� � )��F!����0� �0-#�� ��>Y�-M� )��F!��C?Y�� N �F$�YQd

O ����&���� ���� ��� ��� �� � # O ����&� � � �&� � � �&� � � ��� � O ����&���� ����� �� � # O ������ � � �&� � � ��� �

O ����&���� � ��� ���� � � O �� � � � ���� �� � # O ����&� � � �&� � � �&� � � ���

� U � [ � O ������ � � � � � �� � # O ����&���� �&� � � ��� �� � # O ����&� � � �&� � � ��� � � ���

O ����&� � � � � � �� O ������ � � � � � ��� � � � O �� � � � � � � �

O ����&� � � � � � � �U *�6 �M[

� $�!#�� L �� �C)���$%����EF�D��)�)�+#B�H#���>��$#)�? $���� �0-��� �=��$�) �0 ��C�>$M�0)!*�6 * $��C !*

�6 � P �>E>E%-#��E>! ? B� �C$ ��>$#YD�0-%�1�Z�0-��=H� ���)���,�+#�0�F��$�, �C$���$MN �F)��F��$ � � +�!�Y�� ! )W��H��>$#�>��$JP -#�>,.-RP �>EFE B��CK��LH� ���)���$(���>$�Y� �+�$�!#��)��F 0���#E>�C? �C$#!/��-��S!#������$#)��J,��C$T!#���-��S)��CB�

��%�� ������B�H�EF�C?%)�� '���-%��� �IU � [X? ��U� �X[X?�C$�!��IU [S�C ��I) �.�����>)����>,��CE>E ' �>$�!#��H ��$�!���$M� ?@�C$�!��IU � [ � �IU �X[�� �IU [ � �

� � � -#��$�=��$�) �0 ��C�>$M� *

�6 * ���!#+�,���) ��� �\U� � [ ��� � ? ��$�! �=��$�) �0 0���>$M� *

�6 �I ���!�+#,���) ��� �\U� � [ � � �� �� ���F��-��� Q�C� �0-���)�� P �FE>E �\�O�0 �+�� Y�� N���$ �\U � [ � U Y 2 6 [X? )���$����F�0-#�� =H��C �� '��>)QY�+%�C ��C$M�0����!*�0-%�1�

Page 147: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 ���H� ���)���$M�0�>$#Y � �F)��\��$�� ��,�� ��E ���Y��C �!�EF��)�)O��� ��-�� � +�!�Y�� ! )O��H��F$��>��$

� �� _ ^/_���� ��^�� � � � ; � & $(�DED� " � J $�� 56�B) " � �\U� � [ :<; + 3 ;=: + ��� + �G0(563B� ; � � �*$ + � '+ A #" $�� : $���)& � J �1$�� � + ��3 & �1$/)��B)N$/) �\U� [ 0D�B3 & �1$/)��B)B8�$(�G0F$/) �\U� ��[ E &B" : ) >

�"� : � $/)B)�5��=� ; $ $D3B3B��� $(��3B� " � � 8 8F$(�G0 � $ & � + �G0D���6���G0D��� � J ��� )B8 ; ���$/) ����U [ + ��3 & �1$/)��B)B8 ; � & $(�DED� " � J $�� 5 �B) " � � U � [ :<; + 3 ; : + ��� + �G0(5 3B� ; � � �*$ + � ,+ A #"$�� : $���) & � J �1$�� � ) ; &�+ � %�) >( + � + �*$ & ��� � "/& ; ��0D�"�e����)�� >� )B)�5�� + �DE + �G0D���6���G0D����3B�B8 ; � & � + ) � " 3 ; $(�DED� + � ; � � �*$ + � '+ A "/& 0D�"�e���G07$(� ' ) & $(�DED�

� "/&N& � J � �*$ ,+-" � E +�J ��� $ 3 ; $(�DED� + � ����U� � [.>� ^ _c_� . � )�)�+�B�>$�Y��>$#!���H ��$�!#��$�,�� )��FB�H#E>� ����)*�0-#� ,���$�)��� 0�C�F$M���F$ $#���(+%�CEF�F� ' *

�6 * ?

P -��F,.-/PQ�S,��C$/$�� P P �� �0� �C).dl � ���RU� �X[U ���RU� [ ������U �X[ �����RU� �X[ ���RU� [�[�U ����U �3[ ��6][��

U *�6 � [

% '��F$�)�H ��,X�0�>�C$ ?#�0-#� EF�>B�F�Q!�� ��) $��C�O!���H\��$�!T��$ ����U � [ �� ��K �F$�Y��0-�� !��� ��FN������FNC� �C�S��-�� H�E ���>$M�0� � ! )IE>�>B�F���>$ ���(+%�����>��$ *

�6 � P �F�0- ���)�H ��,X�����

����U� [�d l ����U [ � ���RU� �X[U ����U [ ������U �X[ �����RU� �X[�����U [�[ � 2P -��F,.-��F) �CEFP=� ' )�H\��)��F���FN��

�� -��F)��>)J��-���E>� PQ�� �� ��+�$�!��C� ��-��G 0�C$�YC�*�C�ONC��E>+���)R�C� � U � [P -��F,.-��F$�!�+�,�� ��-�� H�E ���>$M�0� ����� ���NC� �CE � ?�)����C) �F�< ��>)���)�?���-%���O 0��$�Y�� )�-# ��>$#K ) �

� �I)�-�� P �0-%�1� ��-��J� � ��,�� �C���� ��F)��S�>$ � U [X? P=�S$�����! ��$�E 'G ���)�, �CEF�S��-��J$��XP N��� �!��>,X�0)�?�M'G!��FN �F!��>$�YS�0-���B �(' � U [X?%��$�!� �� �CH#H�EF' � -#���� ���B ���

�� -#�>)<P �>EFE Y�� N�� +�)O��E>�>B�F�=�>$��0-#�$��XP5)�,��CE>��?�l � ?�P -��F,.-��>)R�0-#��H�E �C�F$M�0� � ! )SE>�>B�F� �F$ �0-���,��C)���P -��� �� � � U� [ � 6

�� � �%$�!�0-#��H�E>�C�>$M��� � ! ) E>�FB�� � �>$ ��-����C ��>YC�>$%�CEW)�, ��E>�C? PQ��$�����! �C$�EF' BJ+�EF���>H�E ' l � �M' �\U� [3?VP -#�>,.-P=�C) �C)�)�+�B���! ��� �\��YC �� �1�0�� ��-%�C$ ��$���? )��!l � l � � �(�.�����>)����>,��CEW�F$�!���H ��$#!���$�,���PL�C) $���� ����(+��> ���!G���� L�0-��F) �C �YC+�B���$M�

�� �>B�>E>�C �E '����� L�0-#� !#������$#)��

� �� _ ^/_���� ��^�� � � � )B)�5�=� ; �)S$��=� ) +� 5Q$ '+-" �I$/) � ; � "/& ���� �� 8��S5 9 ; � �5Q0�ED� & 5 � �B)�� "/& ; �

Page 148: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 ���0D� �e����)�� + � ; �!31$/)�� :<; ���4� " ) Z"/& � + )F$D3B3B��� �10 $/) '& 5 � >�� ; ��� ; � & � 0 " �B) � "/ �gK + ) $) +� 5Q$ '+-" � :<; � & � $(���F0D� �e���G07$(� : + ��� & � J �1$�� � > � ��� � &B" )��B3�5 #"/& : + ��� & � J �1$�� � + A

�\U � [ � ���RU �� 2 � ��[����U ��� � 2 � ��[ ��]^/_�_� . $G�0-#�>)<, ��)��C?���-�� H%� '���� Y�� N���$/�C$�EF'�� P=��)��0�C ��>��)<�>).d

� � � i�����U ��� � 2 ��[ ������U �� � 2 ��[ � U� 2 �� � 2 ��[Zm 2�C$�!G�0-#� H�� 'C��� Y�� N���$G�0-# ���� ) �0�� ��>��)<�F)Sd �

����U � � [ � � ����RU� � [ �Di�����U �� � 2 2 � ��[�� i U�� U � 2 �� � 2 � 2 ��[�[ �\U� � [ � U��(U 2 �� � 2 � 2 ��[�[Zm

� ���RU �� � 2�� 2 � ��[�� U��(U� � 2 �� � 2 � ��[�[��\U� � [� ���RU ��� � 2 2 � ��[�� i U�� U � 2 �� � 2 � ��[��\U� � [ � U�� U 2 �� � 2 � ��[�[Zm

� ����U ��� � 2�� 2 � ��[�� �\U� � [Zm � � ��-��ON��C �� ���#E>��)@�� �� )�+�,.-��0-%���@��-���� ��) �A, �C)�� � ������ ��O ���NC� �CEF�>$�Y � -%�C)Q� -��>Y�-#�� �H%� '�� ��0-��C$��-�� P=�� �)��A, ��)�� ��� �0�� A ���NC� �CEF�>$�Y �F��?��0-���$���-���)��ON��C �� ����EF��)�Y�+��C 0�C$M����� �0-%���Q�C$M'�!#������$#)��

PQ��+�E>!��CE PL� ' ) ���NC� �CE � � � -%��� �F)SdV � U � U � 2 [ � V � �� U� � 2 � 2 [

����U ��� � 2 ��[ � ����U ��� �]2 2�� � ��[ ����RU �� 2 � ��[������U ��� 2 � ��[ �\U� � [

����U ��� � 2 2 � ��[ � ����U �� 2 � ��[ ������U ��� 2 � ��[ � U � [ �

� �F$�,�� ���RU ��� � 2 2 � ��[ � ����U �� 2 � ��[3?���-��>)V�>$����(+%�CE>� � ' P �>EFE $#��N��� � �Q�0 �+��C?CB����C$��>$#Y�0-����A� !�������$�)�� �������� �$#��'�,��C$I��EFP=� ' )@�>B��CY��F$��L� � +�!#Y��<P -�� P �>E>E#BI�CK��< ��XN�� ��E>�>$#Y � �����C!����� ����������������������������������� ����!�#"$�%�3�&��������')(�*+-,/.�����0'1�2����.3�54 "7698 ':6<;6'�698 ) �%� �������=��.����>���������

���?�#@A��������2.#��B �������������C@A��������5��.��=��DFE/G�.#�%�<+��H"-�?�I.#J%J��3�K������L���2�:��.#��G���+�����/�M����=�$��.���������J��NG��C�:�$�?��:�=��+���O����1��P�=0J��Q.#RS��0T�>����UBT��"V����B�.#�W�2BT�!���>��#�Q�:��.��G�� .#��BX���� J%��'1���>"V��>����1����������0T����YRS������'1���>'1�����=������G����W� "[ZQ\<"]698 ) "=^�_`ZQ\<"Aa3bL6<;6'�bL6-cNd )()�e ZQ\ "Aa3bL6<; '�6-c5d )() D

Page 149: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 � �B�]NC�

��%�� W�0-#�LH� ��C)���,�+#�0�C �?M-��LP �FE>E �CEFP=� ' )�H� ���)���$M� � �F�%�0-#�=����E>EF� P �>$�YOP=�� �)�� � , ��)��<�>$#���(+%�CEF�F� '�>)L�� �+�� d

V � �� U� �]2 [ � V � U � U� � 2 � 2 [���RU� [ � ����U �� 2�� � ��[ ����RU ��� � 2 � ��[��\U � [

���RU �� 2 � ��[ � ����U ��� �]2 � ��[ � U � [���RU �� 2 � ��[����U ��� � 2 � ��[ � �\U� � [ �

� ��� �������������� �����������

��������� � �� "/& $(��� ��5D��3 ,+-" � jRU �>2 � [ :<; + 3 ; + ) � " � "/ Z" � + 31$������ + ��3 & �1$/) + �DE + � � "/ ; $ & E(5 ��=��� )B8 ; � & �F�gK + ) )=$ ��5���3 '+-" � V U �>2 � [ :<; + 3 ; + )@$��k) " � " � "/ Z" � + 31$������ + ��3 & �1$/) + �DE + � � "/ ;$ & E(5�=��� )B89)�563 ; ; $ �+ � jRU��32�'#[�� j�U���2 6 � '�[ 8 ; ��� V U�� � ��2�'#[�� V U Y 2 6�� '�[S>

� ^ _c_� �� ����� '��� U��32#�][ � ��� - � N��CE>+ ����� ')�+�,.- � -�� � jRU��32�'��� U��32#�][�[�� jRU��M2�6 � '��� U��32#�][�[ ������ �WU��32#�][ � 6 � � '��� U��32#�][X?�� ��!TE �"� V U�W#2�'�[ � W � '

�� + ��) �$#%� + ��# �#Y � U��32#�][ �&�(' W ?%P � ) ���

� -)� � ��! � , # ) #*� ��B+�CK ��' +#) # �#Y V,# ) # ��! # � �-'.� � � P - � � 6�� � '/�� U��32#�][ � ' � 6�� ' ? � ' P - � �' � '��� U��32#�][ � � -�� �0# )�?��1! � , # ) #*� �/B+�CK �-' +�) # ��Y V � �)! � - �2�$' � �#) �&�(' B � ! � �C) �$� H�� ' �CB �"����'

W � �WU��32#�][ # ) # �)! # � ��'$� � � P - � �I- � P � +#E*! -�� N � � ��� � # ��! # � �-'.� � � +�) # ��Y � - ��� '$# Y # ���CE + �$# E #3� '� +)��, ��#%� �

�� - �4'$� � ! �-' B+� ' N �-'$#3� ' � -�� �1� - � ! � , # ) #%� � B+�CK ��' P � +#E*!5�CE>) � H '$�"�&�-' �C, ��# ��Y �(' � ���

�C, ��# �#Y # � � - � )$�CB � B+� �)� ��' +�) # ��Y � ��� - � +)��, �$#*� �#)�

� # �)�CE>E '�?0� � �$# , �6� -�� � �ZU��323�1[ # )�B � � � ��� � # ,-�CE>E ' # ��, '.� �C) # ��Y # � �7� �)!�B � � � ��� � # ,-�CE>E '! � , '$� �C) # ��Y # � ��?�� �)! V U�W#2�'�[�� W � ' # )<B � � � ��� � # ,-�CE>E ' # ��, '$� ��) # �#Y # � W

� ���������� �98;: ������� �ZU���� � [? #" ��� $ '& $(��) �*$ '+-" � �.$�� + ��� � �B$/)��10 " � $7< : : +� ; $N��� +� ��65�� ��� & " � 0 + )�3 " � '+ �65 +� ,+ �B) > � ; ��� + �����S5 + � + � &�+ 5��8 M O + )�$ H � " )B) + � ��� ��� � ��P )�� " � " �6���

= � :.#�9�=J�.3�������O"[.�' �%J%���P�&�M����QBT�?>����B��%�2@!���C���%��� (TD (TD ^ D

Page 150: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

6 � �+ � � &�J $��k) >

� ^ _c_� �� � - � H '$� B # ) � ) ��� ��� BB � � �*U H)�CY � 6C6 �M[ � '$� B ��� ?����)!�) � T U���� M O [ U&! � ��� � !� - �-'$��# � [ # )0� , � � ��# � + � +�) � +)��, ��#*� � ��� � �&�(' � �M'�Y # N � � M\O

�M\O , � B�H '.# ) � ) � - � ) � �#U ) )�+�,.- � -�� ��T U��#U 2 M\O [ � Y

�� # ��, � T U��32 M\O [ # ) , � � �$# �(+ � +�)�? #%�BR+�) � � � � -�� � #%� T U��#U 2 M\O [ � Y ? � - ��'$� # )=) � B � � ��# Y�-�� �(' - �/� !�P - ��'$� T U��#U � b�2 M\O [ # ) �CE>) �Y '.� � �$�-'�� -���� � �-'.� ?%) � �CE>E\H � # � � ) # � � - � � �-# Y�-�� � ' - � � ! � � �#U � '$� ��E>) � # � M\O

� �� � �$# , � � -�� � #%� T U���[ P �-'.� ���C) � ! � � � ) ��� MO P - # ,.- # �#,�E>+�! � !S) # �#Y�E �"��� �SH �(# � � ) �(' ��� - ��',�E � ) � ! # � ����' N��CEF)�? MO ) # B�H#EF'�P � +�E*!6� � � � � , � ��) # ) ��� � � P #%� - #%� ) � E � 6 ) � B � � ��# Y�-�� �(' - � � !

� '.� +)�)! � - � ) � ) # ��Y�E ����� ��)VP � +�E%!R) �$# EFE(P � � � �$� �C, �� �+ � � � � � - �-' P � 'C? #%��#3� P �-'.� � �)� � +)��, � !

���2� - � ) � , #*��� ' � -�� � ) � B � � ' � #%��' � ' 'R) ��� M P �C)=Y � # ��Y ��� �C, � ? � - # )@P � +�E%! # ��)�H #%'$����� �C, ��#*� �� ��E ' � - � ) � P - � ! '.� P � �&'$� B ) � B ��� H � �/) ����� � # � �$�-' N��CEF)

��� � _ ^/�D� � � � )B)�5��=� ; $ �ZU �'� � [ $(�G0 ��� �S��U �,� � [ )S$ '+ ) ���� ���� : > � � ; ���GR ' U M O 2 � [ + )� " � "/ #" � + 31$������ + ��3 & �1$/) + �DE + � �� M O + )�$ 3�5 #"ZA ���S5 + � + � &�+ 5�� >

� ^ _c_� �� � ��� ' � -�� � H �-' ) � �� ! �/� )7�C, � ?0� �)! , � ��) # ! ��' � � ��� - ��' H �-' ) � � �%?LP #%� -� � � �#U

� � # ��, � V U��32�'�[ # )<B � � ����� � # , �CEFEF' # �#, '$� �C) # ��Y # � �3? V U�� � 2�'�[ � V U��#U 2�'#[ �&�(' �CE>E '\?%) �� �� V�� � ������� � � � ��� � � � �� V�� �#U ����� � � � ��� � �

��� # ��� �����! �#"$"&%�')( ��#%� � � �+*��-'$�1# "2�,' � � � ��� � # � �$' � �-" �&�(' ' � �$#*� � ' � M\O � � � �&'$� ' � �$�'/.)� �)! ��� �S� � �,� �#U � "�� ��# " � � "1032 � � � � �+*)�2' ����4 ��� �35 . #%� �#67" � "$� ��# " � � "1082 � � � � �+*��' � ��4 �7��� '�.:9 *��-'$�4#3� " �$' � ��" �&�(' '+� �$#*� � # " � ��� � �$� !5�#" � U � � ��; � # ��� � V���5 U � ' � # " � �

# ��� '.� �#" # ��4 � %)��� ��#%� � � � '�.�082 � � ! # � � � ��� " �$* � �� �� V���5 U ����� � � � ��� � � � �� V��<5 U ����� � U � ��� � �

= �-> @@? �?.���BT� >�����B����2@!�P� ������� (D (D ^ D

Page 151: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � *� �-' " � � 9 # 676 � � �0#��

� �����<5�� ����� � � � ��� � � � �

������ � � ��� � � � ��� � �

��� # ��� ������� � � ' � # " ' � � � ��� � # � � 676 ! � � '.� �#" # ��4 # � '/. 032 � � 4 #� � "��� ������� � � ��� � � � ��� � � � �

������ � � ��� � � � ��� � �

� * � # � # ��4��#6 6 �&� % '�� � �$*)� " � # � ��� %�� 6 #%�$#*� " ��� 4 ���+*��-' 4 #� � "��� �����<5 � ����� � � � ��� � � � �

������ � � ��� � � � ��� � �

" �2�+* � � ( ��' " � � � 9 # 676��#6 " � �#� � ; � # ��� � �#6 6 �+* � � 9 �#" �#"$"&%�' � ! 9 �#" �+* � � 5 � � 5�� . �+*�# ":( '$�� � "�+* � �1#%� 5�� �����3. �+*�� ��� 5�� ������� ��� ; � # ' # 6 � ' 6 . #%� 5

��� 5�� . � �)! ! � � "1� � � �#� � . �+*�� �� ��#%�+*��-' 9 # 6 6! . " � 5�� � ��" # ' (-6 #*� " � � � 5���# � ��" ;%$ *)# " 6 � � � " � " # �-4 6 � ( �(# � ���&�(' � � ;

& ' � � � # "0� ' � �-4 ��� � �+*)���&�(' ' ��5 � �(��� . �$*)� � ' � � � � 5 � # " " # ')(�6 �*)+�,

� �.-0/ 5 � - �

032 � � "$� " �$* � ���+*�# " # � �$� 4 ' �#6 # " # ��� '$� � " # �-4 # � 5 �&� ' �21 � ! 5 � . 9 *)# � * 9 � " �$� � � " *�� 90� ;3

�54769806��������.6���� $ � �;:.<>= �>?�@A:B=AC�DE?7CF@ � � � 5 � � / G � @�HI:�DJ@ ��� ��� :LK HIMONP:Q<>= �RD %S= �RDJ<>?�?�N ��TUM!VA:�DE?7M� � � � DJ@WV(?7M>:�DQM>T>?7TX@ K :.<>=AM 5 � �<5�� � DJ@5HYV(?7M>:�DQM>T>?7TX@ K DQM!VACF=ZH7@ADQM\[ ��TUM!VA:�DE?7M]? � 5��_^

��4`6a6� �� ' � ' %�" � � � " *)� 90� �+* � � #%��5�� � 5 � . �+*�� � 5 � ��5�� � � 5 � ��5 � � ; � #b (� � �$* � � � � � 5 � � / 5�� �032 � � " ��� � 5 � � / 5 � � #3� 5�� � 5 � . $ *��-�('.� 'dc��,"�� " �+* � � ' �&��5 � ��5�� � �������Ze�� # " ' � � � ��� � # �-�#676 # �-� '$� �#" # ��4 # � e ; � � �+* � � � � � 9 *)� ! ' � 9 " 5�� # " # �)! #b�9��'$� � � � � �$*)� � % �$�I� 5 � ��5�� � . " ��+* � � � � %�� �$#*� � � ; c *)� 6*!�" . � �)! � � 9 � � �-" # ! �-' 5 � � 5�� ; � # ��� �f���<5�� � ' �$�<5 � ��5�� � �������Ze��&� # "

Page 152: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � �' � � � �$� � # �-�#676 # ��� '$� �#" # ��4 # � e .�032 � � "�� " �$* � � �� )

# )��� 5�� � ' �&��5 � �<5�� � �(��� �Ze �$� � � � 5 � e / 5 � � e�� � )

# )����5�� � ' �$��5 � ��5�� ������� � e��$� ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � e

� * ; c � �� # ' # 6 � ' 6 . ����� � � ' �&��5 � �<5�� � �������Ze��&� # "�! � � '.� �#" # ��4 # � e . " � 082 � � 4 #b (� "���*)

# )����� � � ' �$��5 � ��5�� ������� �Ze �&� ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � e�� �*)

# )����� � � ' �$��5 � �<5�� ������� �Ze �&� ��� � 5 � e / 5 � � e

� * ; c � �� !�! # ��4 # � ' � � ����� � # � #3� 4� � ����5 � ' � 9 #%�$*�'$� "$( � � � ��� 5 ./" �Y� ��5 � � ' � � � ��5�� � ' � �&�(' �#676 '/.� �)!�� * � # � # �-4 ��� 4 �"�+*)��' � � %�� ��#*� ��" * ; c � . � ; c .�� ��! * ; c � . 9 � � � ��� 6 %)! ���+* � �� )

# )����5 �@� ' �&��5 � ��5�� � �������Ze�� � � � � 5 � e / 5 � � e � � )

# )����� � �� ' �$�<5 � ��5�� ������� � e�� � ��� � 5 � e / 5 � � e �

$ *)��'$���&� '$� . 9 *)��'$� 9 �#" # ��! #�� �-'.� � � � � �+*)� � % ���I� 5 � ��5�� � . � " ��'.# � � 6 ( '.���&�-' " �#� �$# ��4 ; � �5 � ��5 � � ' %�" �1� � 4 '.� � �$�-'��+* � � 5 � ��5�� ��;� � �$# � �+�+* � � #3� ��� � 5 � � / 5 � * � " � ��6 ����� #3��� � %�' � ��' � � ! # "$� � � ��# � % #3��#%� " ���)! � � ( �(# � �

'+�#"$" � " . �$*)� � � � �$* � � �$*)�# � ��� 4 ' �#6 " # � � � %�� �$#*� � � ; c � '$� � � � �$# � % � %�" .0� �)! 5 � ��5�� � # "+�

� � � �$# � % � %-" � %���� �$#*� � � �35�� ; 3

� 69476���� �24�� � � � D��I=AM :.<2HI:P:Q<>= �>?�@A:�=ACADE?7CF@ ��� � 5 � � / G � @�HI:�DJ@ ��� ��� : HIMON :.<>= �RD %S= �RDJ<>?�?�N��T\M!VA:�DE?7M � � � � DJ@ V(?7M>:�DQM>T9?7TS@ � :Q<>=AM :Q<>= VATU:�?���:� �>= �OT\CF= @A:�C HI:�=E[�����H��X=(@AD�HIM H7@(< =���T\D��RD�� C�DQT� � � DJ@ HI: :Q<>=��7H��RT9=���@�� ? � 5�� � ?7C�� <\DEV(< 5 � ��5�� � � 5��_^�� <>=ACF= DJ@ H���� H���@ HI:��J=ZH7@A:�?7M!=VAT\:B?�� =���T\D��RD���C�DQT� K =ADQ:Q<>=AC�HI:%@�? � =��%M>DQ:B=��7H��RT>= ?7C�HI: � � � � ^

��4`6a6� �� $ *�# " " # ')(�6 " � � ��� " � � � � � "$"$� '& � � ��! #%�$#*� � �&�(' � % � � " # � � � �#" * ��� % # 6 #7�)'.# %�' ;' � # " "&%��)� #*� � ��� � �-�#%�" ���� �-' (� � � 9 *)� ! ' � 9 " 5�� � � � 9 # 6 6-9 � � � �$� � � � � �)! �� �-' (� � � 9 *)�! ' �@9 " 5�� � � � 9 � � ! � . � 032 � ��� �)!�' � � � ��� � # � #%� ;

$ *)�-'.� 9 # 676/�#6 9 � " � � " � ' � �#6 % � � � � � � � � ��� # 9 *)# � *+# " � � ��� % # 6 # �)'$# %�' ; '$� ( ���" #3��#%� � c � " *)� 9 � ! �+* � � 5 � �<5�� � # " � ! � � '.� �#" # ��4 � %���� �$#*� � � � 5 ;L$ *)# "�� � �(' !-" � ��6 � 9 � ( � " �" # �)# 6 #%�$#*� "�� 5 � ��5�� � � 5�� � � " � ' � � %�' � �-' � � ( �(# � � " . # � 9 *)# � * � �#" � �+*)� " � � '.� �#6763( ����� � �$# �#6��� % # 6 # �)'$# � � �(' 5 � �<5�� � � 5����&�(' � 676 �#6 % � " � ��5�� . # � 9 *�# � * � �#" � � � � � # " � � � ��" # " ��� � � � % ���I�� " # ��� �1#%� 9 # 676 # ��"&( #*'.� � �4� � � ��� �#� � � ;5$ *)� ( � "$" # �)# 6 #%� 4�+* � � 5 � ��5�� � � 5�� �&�(' �#676 � 67% � " � �

Page 153: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � �5�� . # � 9 *)# � * � �#" � �� �-'& � � � �#� � "�� �)!f� ��9 � %�6*! ��� %��#6 � . # "�( '.� � 6 %)! � ! �! � "$"&%�')( ��#%� �� � ; 3

� 69476���� �24�� � � � <>= VAT\:�?�� @ � ?7C VATU:�?���:�� �>= �OT\C(=P@A:�C HI:B=E[�����H��S=(@AD�HIM PH7@(< =���TUD��RD���C�D�H HICF=HI:0:Q<>= �7H��RT>=���@���? � 5�� � ?7C � <\DEV(< '�� �<5�� � � � � � ��5�� � ^�� � '�� �<5�� � � �% � � �<5�� � � ?7C H���� 5���K :Q<>=AM � � � DJ@ HIM]=���T\D��RD���C�DQT� � � <>=ACF= M!? ?7M!= H\VA:.@�� ^

��4`6a6� �� ' � # "8� 6 � � ' 6 � � � � "&"�� ' 1�+* � � �+*)� ( �-' " � ��� � �+*)� � % ��� � � � # �)! #�� �-'$� � � � �"� 9 ��� ��#� ��# �-4�� �)! � � � � � ��# ��4�. � ! � ��� #%�$#*� � . " � � � �$*)� � % ���I� . 5 � ��5�� � � 5�� ; $ *)# " # " "&%��)� #%� � �� � � � %�" � �A (��'& (� � � 9 *)� ! ' � 9 "�� 5�� "$%-� *7�+* � � '�� �<5�� � � � 9 # 676�9 � � � ��� �#� � � �)! �� �-'& � � �9 *)� ! ' � 9 " 5�� "$%�� * �+* � � ' � ��5�� � � � 9 � �"! � . �! 032 � � ���)! ' � � ����� � # � #3� ;

$ *)�-'.� 9 # 676)� 6 9 � " � � " � ' � �#6 % ��� � � � � � ��� # 9 *�# � *�# " � � ��� % # 6 #7�)'.# %�' ; $ *)�-'.�� '.� � ��6 +� 9 � ( � "$" # �)# 6 #%�$#*� "��'/� ��5�� � � �; � �<5�� � � � " � ' � � %�' � �-'���� ( �(# � � " . # � 9 *�# � * � �#" ��+*�� " � � '$� �#6 6 ( ����� � �$# �#6 ��� % # 6 # �)'$# � � �(' '�� �<5�� � � �P � ��5�� � �&� ' � 676 �#67% � " � ��5�� . # � 9 *�# � *� � " � " ���.��# ��4 � � � # "2��� � ��" # " �$� � � � % ��� � � " # ��� � #3� 9 # 676 # ��"&( #*'.� � � � � ���$� �#� � � ; $ *)�( � "$" #7�)# 6 #%� 1�$* � � ' � ��5�� � � � � �<5�� � �&� ' �#6 6 �#6 % � " ��� 5�� . # � 9 *)# � * �-�#" ���A (�-' (� � � � � � "0���)! � � � . # " ( '$� � 67%�! � ! � � "$"&%�')( ��#%� � � � ; 3

�������� � � � D��I=AM ��T ���!DQM � ?7C�� HI:�DE?7M K H������>=AC � =(VA:0@A:�C HI:B=E[�� ��H��S=(@AD�HIM PH7@(< =���T\D��RD���C�D�H HICF=VAT\:B?�� =���T\D��RD���C�D�H ^

��4`6a6� �� ' � �+*)� � %�6 6 # � �&�(' ' � ��#*� � � �#" � . #3� # "� � � 90� 9 #%�$* � �-'.� � # � � 2�+* � � �+*)� (�� ' �#' �"����'

G � �� � " � � �+*)�W �#6 % �� . � ��! " � �$*)� ( �-' � � � � � 4 � � � � � ��� ' " 4 #b (� � �," �"� � � # � ����' �#67"�� �� � � � � � � � "$"�� '$# 6 � � % �$�I� � # "� � � 9 �$� � � ' � � � � ��; � � 9�"�� ��+* � � � ( �-' " � � 9 #3�+* � ! ' � 9� �35�� # " # �)! #�� �-'$� � � � �"� 9 ��� �6�#� ��#%� � � �)! # ��� � ��#%� � . # ; � ; �

� �<5�� � ' � � � � �&� � � ��� � � ' � � � � �$� �$ *)� � �! 7�+*�� ' � � ����� � # � #3� � � � � � � � � . #3� ' %�" � � ���+* � ���&�(' �#676/( ��� (�6 � 9 *)� ! ' � 9 5�� � 5�� .

� �<5�� � ' � � � � �$� � � ��5�� � ' � � � � �$� � � ��� � � ' � � � � �&� �

Page 154: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � �" � �+*�� 7�$*)�-'.���&�('.� ( '$���&��' � � � �#� �$# ��4 �� (��' �#� �$# ��4 ; 0 �(' � 676 ( �-� (�6 � 9 *)� ! ' �@9 5 � � 5�� �

� �<5 � � ' � � � � �$� � � ��5�� � ' � � � � �&� � � ��� � � ' � � � � �&� �" � �+*�� ( '.���&��'0�$� � � � ;0$ *��-'$�"�&�('$� 5�� # "0� � % �$�I� .�� �)! � � ' %�" �1� � ��5�� �(��� ;

' ���+*)� � % �$�I�# " 5 � �<5�� � � � . �+*�# " # " ! � ��� � ! ��� ' � ��� �+* � � �&�(' �#676 5�� . � �<5�� � ' � � � � �$� �� ��� � � ' � � � � �$� � 3

�54769806��������.6�� ��� � <>= < : � � � / G � � H�� :EH&%S= HIM�� � ?7C�� K HIMON�:Q<>= �2HIC H�� =A:�=AC G �0D�����A= %7M!? �0M :B? <2H �I=Y:Q<>= �7H��RT>= �0DQ:.< V(=AC�:EHIDQM>:�� ^ � � � ?7C HIM�� =���T\D��RD���C�DQT� �>?7DQM>: 5 � e K� �<5�/ � � ����,� + �<5 � � ?7CWH���� 5 � e K :Q<>=AM]:Q<>=ACF= �0D���� �A= ?7M���� ?7M!= =���T\D��RD���C�DQT� � ?7C :Q<>=�[ID��I=AM %^

��4`6a6� �� 0 �(' �+*�� "��� � ��� � � � ��' � ! # � ��#%� � . "$� �+* � � �+*)��'$�4# "1��� � �+*��-' ( �(# � � e � � e9 *)# � * � � %-6*! � � ��� ��� % # 6 #7��'$# %-' � % ���I� . ' � � � # ��4 �+* � � � � � e � / � ��'�� � e � � ;�� '$#%�$# ��4�+*�# " ��� %�� �$#*� � �#" �+*)� # � �$� 4 ' �#67" � � ! �-'.#� � �$#� (� " � � �)! �)'$� �� # ��4 �+*)�2# � �$� 4 ' �#67" # � �$� ()� '.� " � �e�� .

� � ���

# )� �<5�/ � 5 ������ � ��5�/ � 5� � ���

# )�� ' �� 5��5 � 5 ������ � ' �� 5

��5 � 5 � * ; c c �� � e . � � � e / � � '�� � e�� . � '

� � �# )

� �<5�/ � 5 � � �# )�� '��� 5

��5 � 5' � � � # ��4 �+* � � � � %�� ��#*� � * ; c c *)� 6*!�" #b�

� � �� � ��5�/ � 5 � � � �� � '/�� 5��5 � 5

% % � #3� � ��5�/ � � ��� ,� + �<5 � �&�(' �#676 5 � e . �+*)� � �$*)� 6 ��� � � * ���)! " # ! ����� �$*)# " ��� %)� ��#%� � # " �#6 9 � "6 � "$" �+* � � �$*)�2'$# 4 *�� � * � �)!," # ! � ;%$ *)��'$�"�&�('$� e � � � � � �1� � �)� % ��� � ; 3��� �X694 � � ��� � <>=4< : � � � / G � � H��]:EH&%S= HIM�� � ?7C � K HIMON :.<>= �2HIC H�� =A:B=AC G �0D���� �A=%7M!? �0M]:�? <2H �I= :.<>=��7H��RT>= �0DQ:.< V(=ACA:EHIDQM>:� ^ � � � ��5 � � ��� ,� + ��5 � � � ?7C H���� 5 � 5 � K :.<>=AM]:.<>=ACF=

Page 155: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � ��0D���� �A=W?7M����f?7M!= =���T\D��RD���CADQT�� � ?7C�HIM�� %^

��4`6a6� �� � #� (� � �$*)� � � �)! #%�$#*� � *��-'$� . �$*)� � � ��! #%�$#*� ��" � � '.� ( � " #%�$#*� � ���,9 # 676 *)� 6*! �&� '

� � ! ' � 9 � � ; 3

��� �X694 � � � � � <>=�=���HIM>:�=5NIDJ@A:�CAD���T\:�DE?7M ? ��:.<>= � =ZNID�HIM G DJ@�� ��G � K � <\DEV(<YVZHIM :EH&%S=5HIM��� ?7C � ^ � ��:B=AC5NIC H �0DQM\[ ��CF? ��� ��G � K DJ@ %7M!? �0M �0DQ:.< V(=ACA:EHIDQM>:� ^ � @(@AT� =P:.<>= < : � �Q- �DJ@�@ADQM\[��J= �>=ZH&%S=ZN K �0DQ:.<fH � H�� D �WT�� �7H��RT9=5? � � �.- � � �

�K HIMON :Q<>= �7H��RT>= ��TUM!VA:�DE?7M DJ@��RDQM!=ZHIC��

� �<5 � ' � �� ' 5�^� =A: � � � � �A= :Q<>=W=�� HIM>:B= NIDJ@A:�C�D���TU:�DE?7M ? � � � � �A= � ?7CF= DJ@ %7M!? �0M � ^� D��I=AM :Q<>=(@�= H7@(@AT�� �O:�DE?7M2@ K :Q<>=PC HI:�DE?� ��G ��� � � � �.G �$� DJ@�@ADQM\[��J= �>=ZH&%S=ZN �0DQ:Q< H �>=ZH&% HI:

:Q<>= �>?7DQM>: � <>=ACF= ��� � � � ^ � <2HI: DJ@ K � � � � DJ@ �J=(@(@ V(?7M!V(=AM>:�C HI:�=ZN :B? � HIC N :.<>= V(=AM>:�=AC�:Q<2HIM� ��G � ^

��4`6a6� �� $ *)� ��' ����" �&�(' ' � ��#*� � �&'$� ' �+*�� � 0 � ��G � �$���+*)� � 0 � � � # "1� " # ')(�6 �� � �(' ! # ��� ��� ��' � ��" �&�(' '+� ��#%� �a�

� � � � � � � � # � � � �$� � � #�

G � � �� '

� � � � # � � � �&� � � � � � �

G �.G � � * ; c�� �� � * � �-4 � # � G # " � � " �4� � # " #%� � � ! %�" # ��4 0 # 4 % '.� � ; c � (�� 4 � � � � � � � � � � %)� #3� � * � �-4 �# � G ��' � ��"$6*� ��� " �+*)� � % ' (� � � � %)� #%� �$� �$*)� 6 �"� � � � � ,��� # " �$*)� � *)� 9 � � ' ���6�+*)� 6 ��� �1�+*��# � �$�-' � � ( � � �"� 9 ��� � �+*�� 6 # � � � �)! �$*)� � % ' � ' �� (� " ; $ *)� "$6 � ( �+� �0� � � ' # � %�" �+*)� � � 0# " � � � � ��G � / G � . � �)! �+*)� "$6 � ( � � � �+*)� � %)��� ��#*� ��' � �.G � # " �

� � ; 67%-4 4 # �-4 �+*�� " � "$6 � ( � "# � �$� � � %�� �$#*� � * ; * �&'$� '�� � ' '+� � * � ()�#4 � � � � � .-9 � 4 ��� �

� � G ��G � �

�� ��

� � � � � � ��G � / G � � � * ; c�� �$ *)� ( '.� ' # " �� � $ *)���('$� ' ��� 4 %�� ' � � ���-� " �+* � � �+*�� ! � � � ' # ��� �$�('+# "7�#6 9 � " ( � " #3��#b (� .' � � � # ��4 �+* � � � ( � " #%��#b (� " *)#%� �0# � G �#6 9 � " 6 � � !-" ��� ���)� #%�$� .�( � " #3��#b (� " *�#%� �0# �f� � ;

� � %)� ��#%� � * ; c�� "$� " �$* � � � � %�� �$#*� � * ; c � 4 #� � "�%-" �+*)� ' � �$#*� � � �� � , � � � 9 *�# � *7�+*�� $ *)�-� �'$� ' ! � "$� '.#7� � " ; � # ��� � � � � � # "0�#"$"&%�' � ! �$�)� � �)" # ��4#6 � � ( � �� � !4! # " ��'$# � % �$#*� � . � � � � �.G � / G �

Page 156: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� �Xc# " 6*� ' 4 � " � 9 *)��'$� � � ��G � � G ./� �)! # " ' � � ����� � # � �#6 6 ! � � '$� �#" # ��4 �#" G ! #� �-' 4 � " �&'$� ' �+* � � �#67% ��# � �-#%�$*)�-' ! #*'$� � �$#*� � � �$*)� 6 �"� � � * � �)! " # ! �2� � � � %�� �$#*� � * ; c��)6 � �)! �+*)��'$�"�&�('$�2�+*)� 6 ��� � �* � ��! " # ! �1��� � � %�� �$#*� � * ; c��,6 # " �#67" � 6 � ' 4 � " � 9 *)�-'.� � � ��G � � G � �)! # " ' � � � ��� � # �-�#676 ! � � '$� �#" # ��4+�#" G ! #b (�-' 4 � " �&'.� ' �$* � � ( � # � � ; 3

�54769806��������.6�� ��� � D��I=AM :Q<>=�OCF=��WDJ@�=(@ ? � � <>=(?7CF=�� ����� � � � � DJ@ H @A:�CADEVA:��� N\=(VACF=ZH7@ADQM\[��T\M!VA:�DE?7M ^

��4`6a6� �� � ��� � �4�+*��Y �#6 % � � � G 9 *)# � * # �)!�%-� � "+� � ��� % # 6 #7��'$# %-' � � e . � �)! 6 ���e � � e ;5$ *)� ( '.�/� � ��� $ *��-�('.� ' ��� " *)� 9 � ! �$* � � � � %�� �$#*� � * ; c c)" *)� %-6*! �#� � %��#6 6 �� � � �

# � ��� %��#6 #%� �� � � �

# )� ��5�/ � 5 � � � �

# )�� '�� ��5 �� 5 5 � � * ; c�� �

9 *)�-'.� # " �$*)� ' � ! # ��� 9 *)# � * 6 � � !�" �$� � � ��� % # 6 # �)'$# %�' � � � � ; � � �$# � � �+* � � �+*)�1'.# 4 *�� �* � ��! " # ! �2# "0� � � � � %)��� ��#*� � � � . 9 *)# 6 � �+*)� 6 �"� � � * � �)! " # ! � # "�� � # ��� '$� � " # �-4 � %)�-� ��#%� � � �

; $ *��-'$�"�&�('$� . #3�9�+*�� � 9 � " # ! � " � � ' � ��� %)�#6 #3� * ; c��2� '.� ��� %�� 6 . �+*)� 9 # 676 � ���&� ' " � ' �� �#67% � � � . ' � � � # ��4 �+* � � �+*�� ��� % # 6 # �)'$# %�' �#67% � e � � e �-� � � ��6 � � � % ' 4 #� � � ��' � ! # ���

� � ; ' � � �$*)�-' 9 �(' !�" . �$*)� '+�#(�( # ��4 �&'$� ' G ��� � � # "�� � # ��� '.� �#" # ��4 � %���� �$#*� � � �#6 � �-49 #%�$*�+*�� � �#� � �&'$� ' � � ')' ��� � � (��#4 � � � � � �+* � � � � ��G � # " � � � � �$��� � � � . �+*)# " ' � � ��" �+* � �#%� " # � (��' " � � � �.G � # " #%� " � 6 � � � # ��� '.� �#" # ��4 � %)�-� ��#%� � ; 3

�54769806��������.6�� � 8 � @(@AT�� = T\M>DQM � ?7C � HI:�D��I= �OC�DE?7C DQM � ?7C � HI:�DE?7M � :Q<2HI: � �<5�/ � � DJ@ @ADQM\[��J= �>=ZH&%S=ZN*HIMON�=ADQ:Q<>=AC @ � � � =A:�C�DEV ?7C T � � HIC N �J=ZHIM>DQM\[ � HIMON :.<2HI: � ��5�/ G � DJ@]H :�CZHIM2@ �bHI:�DE?7M��H��WD���� ^ � <>=AM :Q<>=W?7M���� �OT\CF=P@A:�C HI:�=E[�����H��S=(@AD�HIM!PH7@(< =���TUD��RD���C�D�H HICF=W? �5HYVAT\:�?�� � ?7C�� ^

��4`6a6� �� $ *)� ( '.�/� � # " � �#" � ! � � �$*)� � �#� � �$* � � ��� # � �$�-' �#6 � � � �6�+* � � # " � � %)�)! � !� � �� (� � ��! � � 6 � 9 ' %�" � � � � � %��)! � ! �! � 9 �4� 6 � ' � � � " � � � � . 5�� � �)! 5 � ; % �$*)� ' � � ������ � # � #%� 6� ���� � � � � . #3� 5 � � 5�� . � % � " � ' �-� � � 9 *)� ! '$� 9 �-#%�$*)�-' 9 � %�6%! � �+# �)! #�� �-'.� � � . #%�' %�" � � �+�$* � � � � � 9 *)� ! ' � 9 " 5��2� 1 ( � � � " ' �('.� ( �-� (-6 � ��� �#� � �$* � � � � � 9 *)� ! '$� 9 5 � ;$ *)# " # " � � � �+*)� � �#" � �&�('2�+*)� 6 � 9 � " � # � ����' �#6 # � ��� ; � � "$"$%-' ( �$#*� � � � �#"&"$% '.� " %�" �+* � �"$%-� * � 6 � 9 � " � # � �$�-'_ � 6 � 1 # " � " ; # $ *)� ( '$� � � 9 # 6 61' � " � 6 � � ��� � � ��' � ���6� � �$*)�� %)��� ��#%� �' � � � � � � � �+*)� '$� ��! �-' # " '$���&��'$'.� ! ��� 0 # 4#% '$� * ; c �&�(' ! � ( # � �$#*� �-" � � �$*)�� � '.#*� %-" ! # "$" � � �$#*� �-"� �)! ��' � ��"&6 � �$#*� ��" ;

Page 157: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � �

0 # 4 % '$� * ; cU� �$� (a� " ')' ����'.# � .�" # ��4 6 � � ( � �� � !4! # " ��'.#7� % ��#*� ��"�� � � ���-'.� !6� � � �-'.� ���)! � � �� � �$�$� ' � ' � � � � 5 � � �$*)� ' #%'$'.�(' # '+�#4 � � � � � � ' � � � � 5 � �&�('�5 � � � ' # !�!�6 � ! � �$�$� !�6 # � � �� � �+* � � �6# ��� 6 %)! � " � � � ��� � � � � �)! � � � � � � �� " ( '$�� (� � # � � � ')' � c * . � � � � ��" # " � " � � � " ��� ���0� ( � � # � �$�-' �#6 " ; � �"� � � � � �+*��

6 � 9 � " � � � �+*)� " � .9� ��! 5�� ���)� � #%� " # � � ' %-' � �)! 5 � #3� " "$%�( '$� ' %�' ; $ *)� � '$� � 6 � ' � � � " � �� � . � % ��#3� "$%��)� � " �$� � � 9 �$* � �0�+*)� � '.� � � ��# �f� � � �)! �#676 ( �(# � � " � �"� 9 ��� � �$*)� ' � '$� ;' � 9 # 676 � � ( '.�` � � �$* � � 5 � � � � %)�#676 " *)� %�6*! � � # � � � .�4 #b /# ��47�)� � � �$' � ! # � �$#*� ��9 *)# � * �-� �� ��6 � �2'$� " � 6 � ! #%� � � # " � � �+*��2�&� ' ' �<5�� ����� ;

� ��� �+*)� � � � �$�-' ��� � � . ��5�� �5 � � � c . � � � ; � �"� �$*)� � '$� "&" # ��4 � ( �(# � � � � ��� � 5 � � / 5�� � ���)!

��� � 5 � � / 5 � � � ��� ; ' � � � � / � � # "1" ')' �"��'$# �#. �+*)� � � � � � #%� � � � / � � # "1%�(!9 � ' ! � 6 � � � # ��4�. �+*��( � " �$�-'$#%�(' "0� '$� ! � 90�!9 � ' ! � 6 � � � # ��4 � � "1( �-'��$*)� ! # "&� %�"&" #*� � � � (�� 4 � � � � .-" ��� � � ;� # �-� � ��� � 5 � � / 5�� � � �)! ��� � 5 � � / 5 � � � '.�2�$' � �-"$6 � ��#*� ��" � � �+*�� "$�#' � " # �-4 6 � � ( � �� � !4! # " ��'.#7� % �

��#%� � .�� # " �+*��-#*' %�� #J� % � � '.� "$" # ��4)( �(# � � ;� H\VA:���� � 0 � ' 5� �). ' � � � � 5 � # "2� � # ��� '$� �#" # ��4 � %)��� ��#*� � ��� 5 ; � < � � � *�#%� ��# ��4 �+*��

" # ��4 6 � � ( � � � !�( � " �$�-'$#%�(' ! # " ��'.#7� % ��#*� � �$���$*)�2'$# 4 *�� ' � ����" �+* � �0�$*)� 6 # � 6 # *)� � ! (-6 �#� � ! � �

Page 158: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � ��� �-' �$*)# �-4 �$� �$*)�2'$# 4 *���� � �+*)� ! # " ��'.#7� % ��#*� �"! "�' � ! � # ��� '.� �#" � " .�9 *�# � * # ��� 67%)! � "0�#676 � � � ��&�(' - � 5�� . � ��! �#6 6 � � � � � � ���&�('P- � 5�� � �)! - � � ; � ')' �"��'& �� ! � 90�!9 � ' ! � 6 � � � # ��4�#6 � ��4 9 #%�$* " # �-4 6 � � ( � �� � !)� � "$" # ')(�6 ��+* � � ' � � � � 5 � # " # ��� '.� �#" # ��4 �&�('�5 � � 5�� � � # ;��� H\VA: � � ' � � � � � � � ' � � � � � � �&�(' �#6 6 � � ; � < � � % �+*��

" ')' �"��' �� ! � 90� 9 � ' ! � 6 � � � # ��4 � � ��! #%�$#*� � . �&�(' �$*)��# � �$� 4 ' �#67" ��� �$*)� ( � " �$�-'$#%�(' "�9 #3�+*)# � � � �� +��+ �

��� � 5 �.-0/ � � - � � +��+ �

� � � 5 �.-0/ � � - �9 #%�$*4��� %��#6 #%� 7# � �+*)� " ')' �"��'.# � � � " � ; 0 �(' �$*)� " � ( �(# � � " � � �� (� 5 � .

���� � � ��� � 5 �.-0/ � � - � �

���� � � ��� � 5 �Q-0/ � � - �" # ��� � ��� � 5 � e / 5 � � � ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � �&�(' �#6 6 e � � ; �% ' � � ����� � # � #3� . �+*)� " �1� �#� � "�� � � % � �+*)� � %)��� �$#*� � ' � � � �Ze�� � 67" � *)� 6*! �&�(' 5�� ! " �#67% �

� � �#� �$#*� � . ��� 5�� � ' � � � �Ze ���!;0 '$� ' *)�-'.� . �)'$� �� ! � 90� �+*)� � %���� �$#*� � � � 5�� � ' � � � � � � � # � �$� ��"&%�' � � � 9 � "&% ��� %)�-� ��#%� ��"��

G �<5 � � � � � 5�� � ' � � � � 5 � � 5 � �

��� 5�� � ' � � � � c�� 5 ��� 5 � �

�<5 � � � � 5 � �

��� 5�� � ' � � � � 5 ��� ��� 5�� � ' � � � � c�� 5 ��� 5 � �

$ *)� � %���� �$#*� � G �<5 � # " " ')' �"��'$# � � � � % � �).�9 *)# 6 � ��5 � # " �$*)� �#" ')' ����'.# � (�� '.� ; ' � �+*��6 � 9 �-' 4 ' �#( * ��� 0 # 4 % '.� * ; c . � � � � � ' � # " �$*)� %�(�( �-' " � 6 # ! 6 # � � . G ��5 � # " �$*)� ' # !)!�6 � ! ���$��� !

6 # � � ���)!f �<5 � # " �$*)� ! # " � � ��� � � ��� 9 �-� � �$*)� ' # !)!-6 � ! � �$�$� ! 6 # � � � �)! �+*)� %�(�( �-' " � 6 # ! 6 # � � ;% � �#� ��� � . G ��5 � # " ' � � ����� � # � �#6 6 # ��� '$� �#" # ��4 %�( ��� � � ��! �+*��-'$�"�&�('$� ' � � � ��� � # �-�#676 ! � � '$� �#" # ��4+� � �� � � .�� �)! �! 7� �#� ��� c .2 ��5 � # "0�#6 9 � " ( � " #3��#b (� ;� H\VA: � � � $ *)� � 1 ( � � � � ��#*� � � � G � � � 4 #b (� � ��� � 5 � � / 5 � � ��� %��#6 " �+*)� � 1 ( � � � � ��#%� � 4 #� (� �

��� � 5 � � / 5�� � ; � < � � $ *)� " #%� %�� �$#*� � # " " ' ' ���$'$# ��� '$� %)�)! � ;��� H\VA: � � � $ *)� � 1 ( � � � � �$#*� � ��� � � � 4 #� (� � ��� � 5 � � / 5 � � # "�4 '.� � �$�-' �+* � � �(' ��� %��#6 �$� �+*��

Page 159: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � �� 1 ( � � � � �$#*� ��4 #� � � ��� � 5 � � / 5�� � ; � < � � �<5 � � � � .�9 *)# 6 � �<5�� � � � ;��

0��#� � " � �1���)! � " *)� 9 �+* � � �+*)� "&%�' G �<5 � � ��5 � � # "�4 '$� � ����' �+* ��� �+*)� "&%�' G �<5�� � �<5�� � .�' � ��� # ��4

� � 5�� � ' � � � � 5 � � � � � � 5�� � ' � � � � 5�� � � � � * ; c�� ��! 7�$*)� ' � � � ��� � # � #%� +� �0� � � � � � .

��� 5 � � ' � � � � 5 � ��� � ��� 5�� � ' � � � � 5 � ��� �� * ; c * �

� * � # � # ��4 ��� 4 ���$*)�-' ' � ��� %)�#6 #3��#*� " * ; c�� � �)! * ; c * .��� 5 � � ' � � � � 5 � ��� � ��� 5�� � ' � � � � 5�� ���:�

� �)! 9 � '+� " # ' # 6 � ' 6 ( '.�� (���+* � ����B� � � ' � � � � 5�� ��� � ����� � � ' � � � � 5�� ���:�

" � #%� � � � ! � � �2�+*)� � �#" � �$* � � ( ��� (�6 � � � � ���+* 5�� � �)! 5 � � '$� # �)! #b�9��'$� � � ; ' � 5�� � � � . �+*�� �5 � ' %�" � � ��# �f� � � " # ��� � �$*)# "�9 � %�6%! � � ��' % ���&�(' � � 6 � 9 ��' %�(�( �-' � � %)�)! � � � � .2� � �-� �* � (� � � %�(�( �-' � � %)�)! ; 3

�54769806��������.6�� � $ : = �%M!= � ��5�/ G � :�? �A= H :�CZHIM2@ �bHI:�DE?7M ��H��WD���� ^ � �5DQMONID���D�NIT H�� @P<2H �I=5T\M>DQM � ?7C � HI:�D��I= �OC�DE?7C DQM � ?7C � HI:�DE?7M H �A?7T\:;:Q<>= :�C�T9= V(=AM>:�=AC ? �5:Q<>=WNIDJ@A:�C�D���TU:�DE?7M��;:.<>=AM :Q<>=AC(=�DJ@ HT\M>D ��T9=WVAT\:B?�� =���T\D��RD���C�DQT� ^

��4`6a6� �� � # ��� � 9 � � '.� � � �-" # ! �-'$# ��4 �+*�� � 6*�#"$" ��� � % ��� �7��� % # 6 # �)'$# �-. ' � ��� � 5 � # " �#"$"&%�' � !

����� � � ' � � � ��� � # �-�#676 # ��� '.� �#" # ��4�. # � �-'?��#7� 6 �1� %)��� ��#*� � � � 5 . ' � � � # ��4 �+* � � �$*)�-'.�+# " � �

# � �-' " � 5 � � � � ' � 9 *�# � * 4 #� � " �+*)� %)� #�� % �P � 67% ��� � ' "$%�� *�$* � �0#3� ',( ��' � � � � � � � . #3� ' %�" �� � �+* � � G � 5 ;�$ *)� ! # " ��'.#7� % ��#*� � � � ( � "&" #7� 6 � � 67% � " � � ' �&� ' ( �-' " � � &. 4 #b (� � �+* � � 5�� # "�+*�� � % ��� � . �-� � �$*)�-'.���&�('.� � � ! � "$� '.#7� � ! �#"��

� � � ' � � ��� � 5 �<5 � � � � ' � / 5�� �� ��� � 5 �<5 �$��5�� ����� � ' � / 5�� � � * ; c�� �

Page 160: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � �� � ��5�� / 5 �$�<5�� ������� ' �&� � * ; c � �� � ��� / 5 �$��� ����� � ' �$� � * ; � � �

� � %�� ��#%� � * ; c�� � 1 (�� �)!�" � � ��� ��5�� ����� %)�)! ��' �$*)� �#"$"&%�')( ��#%� � �+* � � 5�� # " �$*)� � % �$�I� ;� � %�� ��#%� � * ; c � '$� " � � �$� " � � %�� ��#%� � � ; � . �+* � �0�+*)� ( � " �$�-'.#*�(' 4 #b (� � ����%�� # � �&� ' '+� ��#b (� ( '.#*�('# " �$*)� ' #%'$'$� '�� � �$*)� 6 # � 6 #7*)� � ! � %)��� �$#*� � ; � � %�� �$#*� � * ; � �4�&� 676 � 9 " �&'.� ' �+*����$' � ��"&6 � �$#*� �( '.� ( ��'.� ��� �$*)� 9 *)� 6 �2� ( �-' � ��#%� � ;

' ��� � ��� 67%�" #*� � . � � � ' � ! �/� " � � � ! � ( � �)! � �� �(' 5�� . " �5#3� �-� � � � 9 '.#%�$�$� ��9 #3�+*)� % �� "&% � "$� '$# ( � �#" � � � � � ' ' � � � %���� �$#*� � � � ' ��; $ *)��'$���&� '$� . # � �+*)� � � ')(�� '$# " � � � �"� 9 ��� �� 1 ( � � ��� ! % ��# 6 #3� +�&'.� ' �#� ��# ��4�� �)! � � � �#� ��# �-4�.

� �

����<5�� ����� � � ��� � " � �

������ � � ��� � � ��� � � � * ; � � �

�$*)� 6 ��� � � * � ��! " # ! ��# ":' � � � ��� � # �-�#676 # ��� '.� �#" # ��4 # � 5�� . " # �-� �0�+*)� � 1 ( '$� "$" #*� � ���<5�� ����� � � ���# " ' � � � ��� � # �-�#676 1# ��� '$� �#" # ��4 # � 5����&�(' � 4 #b (� � � . " � �$*)��# � ��� 4 ' � 6 � � �$*)� " ��� 1 ( '$� "$" #*� ��" �&� '�#6 6 � ' %�" � �#6 " � � � # ��� '.� �#" # ��4-.�9 *)# 6 � �+*)� '$# 4 * � � * ���)! " # ! � � � 9 '+�� � " � � ' � � �$#*� � ��� 5��� �)! # " �+* %�" � � � ��" � � � � ; � ' � � � �$� � # �-�#676 # ��� '.� �#" # ��4 � %)��� ��#%� � # " ��� %��#6 ��� ��� � ��" � � � �� � � � ' � " � � � � ( �(# � � .�" �+�+*)��'$� # " � � ' � " � � � � ��� % # 6 #7�)'.# %�' � % �$�I� ( �(# � � ; � " ! # "$� %�"$" � !� � �� (� . #3���+*)� 6 ��� � � * � ��! " # ! � � � � � ')(�� '$# " � � * ; � � # " �#6 9 � " 6 � "$" �$* � � �+*�� '$# 4 *�� � * � �)! " # ! � .�+*�� � � � � � � 9 � %�6%! � � 9 # 6 6 # �-4 ��� �#� � #3� �$*)� 9 �-'.� ( #b (� � �#6 .(� �)!)" �2�+*)����� % # 6 #7��'$# %-' � % ���I�# " � � � � ; 3��� �X694 � � � � � @(@AT�� = � �<5�/ G � DJ@�H :�CZHIM2@ �bHI:�DE?7M ��H��WD���� ? �5H1< : :Q<2HI: DJ@ V(?7M>:�DQM>T>?7TX@�HI:H���� ��T\:H �%M>DQ:�= M>T�� �A=ACW? � �>?7DQM>:.@ � HIMON :Q<2HI: :.<>= �OC�DE?7CPDJ@5T\M>DQM � ?7C�� HI:�D��I= ^

� D �LM!? V(?7M ��D���D�H��RDQ:� � � M :Q<>= @ � � � =A:�C�DEV VZH7@�= ��� � � � � � � �%:.<>=PTUM>D ��T>=W=���TUD��RD���C�DQT��@�HI:�DJ@ � =(@ � � � � � � =ZHIM>DQM\[ :.<2HI:;:.<>=ACF= DJ@ M!=ADQ:Q<>=AC H\VA:�D��I=�M!?7C5DQMOH\VA:�D��I= V(?7M ��D���D�H��RDQ:� ^�� <2HI:DJ@ ��D �f:Q<>= NIDJ@A:�C�D���T\:�DE?7M DJ@ @ � � � =A:�C�DEV � �>=(? � �J= �A=(<2H �I=YH7@ D �f:Q<>= � ?7M���� VZHICF=ZN H �A?7T\: :.<>=ADQC�OC�D��7HI:B=P@ADb[IMOH�� @ ^

� DQD �LH\VA:�D��I=�V(?7M ��D���D�H��RDQ:� � � �L:Q<>= NIDJ@A:�C�D���TU:�DE?7MYDJ@ T � � HIC N �J=ZHIM>DQM\[ � � =ZHIM>DQM\[ :Q<2HI: � � � �� � � � � � # � ?7C�H���� � � HIMON @�? � = � � � � :Q<>=AM :.<>=�T\M>D ��T9=WVAT\:B?�� =���T\D��RD���C�DQT� @�HI:�DJ@ � =(@� � � � � � =ZHIM>DQM\[�:Q<2HI:%= �I=AC��S?7M!=�0DQ:.< H �OC�D��7HI:�= @ADb[IMOH�� :�? H\VA: �0D����>N\?P@�? � ��TU: @�? � = �>=(? � �J=

Page 161: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � *�0DQ:Q<YM!=E[SHI:�D��I= �OC�D��7HI:�= @ADb[IMOH�� @ �0D����aDb[IM!?7CF=5:Q<>=�� HIMON H\VA:;HIM���� H�� ^

� DQDQD � DQMOH\VA:�D��I= V(?7M ��D���D�H��RDQ:� � � �]:Q<>= NIDJ@A:�C�D���T\:�DE?7M DJ@�N\? �0M � HIC N �J=ZHIM>DQM\[ � @�? � � � �� � � � � � # � ?7CYH���� � � HIMON @�? � = � � � � :Q<>=AM*:.<>=fTUM>D ��T>= VATU:�?�� =���T\D��RD���C�DQT� @�HI: DJ@ � =(@ � � � � � � =ZHIM>DQM\[ :Q<2HI:;= �I=AC��X?7M!= �0DQ:.< H �OC�D��7HI:�=�@ADb[IMOH�� M!?7:0:B? H\VA: �0D����!M!?7: H\VA: � ��T\:@�? � = �>=(? � �J= �0DQ:Q< �>?�@ADQ:�D��I= �OC�D��7HI:B= @ADb[IMOH�� @ �0D���� Db[IM!?7C(=P:.<>=�� HIMON M!?7: H\VA:;H7@��;= ��� ^

��4`6a6� �� � # � 2 � � 9 *)� ! '.� 9 5�� # " # �)! #b�9��'$� � �0#b�� )

# )� ��5�� � ' �$��5�� ����� � e��$� ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � e � � )

# )� ��� � � ' �&��5�� ����� �Ze �$� ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � e � * ; �Sc �

$ *�# " 9 � %�6*! � � ��� % #� �#6 � � � #%� 9 � ' � � �$*)�0 � '$# � � 6 � ���)# � �$� 4 ' � ��#%� � � �#� !9 � ' ! . " � 6 �"��� � e �

� )

# )� ��� � � ' �&��5�� ����� �Ze �$� ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � e � � # )

)� ��� � � ' �&��5�� ����� � � �$� ��� � 5 ���O/ 5�� � �

% % �)�! " ')' �"��'& . �� ' �&��5�� ����� � � � �' �$�<5�� �������Ze�� . � ��! " # ��� � �$*)� ( � " ���-'.#*�('1# "��#67" �" ')' �"��'.# �#. ��� � 5 ���O/ 5�� � � ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � ; "�� # �-4 �+*)� " � "$% � " ��#3� % �$#*� �-" � �)! �#4�� # � "&% � " �$#%� % ��# ��4e � � .

� # ))

� ��� � � ' �$�<5�� ������� � �&� ��� � 5 ���O/ 5�� � � � � )# )

� ��� � ' �$�<5�� �������Ze��&� ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � e �� * ; ��� �� � * � � �$* %-"�" � 6 (� ! �&�(' 5�� # � �+*)� 6 ��� � � * ���)! " # ! ��� � � � %�� ��#*� � * ; �ScU� �+*)��'$# 4 *�� � * � �)!)" # ! �� � � � %)� ��#%� ��" * ; ��� "�� " �$* � �0#%�0# " � ��'$� ;

� #%# � $ *)� ( '$� � � � � �+*)� " � 9 � ! � �#" �7# " �! � � ')(�� '$# " � � 9 #%�$* � � � '.�$# � � # �#6 " ' ' ���$'$# �! # " ��'.#7� % ��#*� � ; � � 9 # 6763' � " � 6 � � # � ���-'.� " ��� ! # � �+*�� � �#" � 9 *)�-'.� 5�� � � ./" � 9 6 � 47�#"&"$%�' �

�+*�# " # " �$*)� � � " � ; $ *)� �6! � �)� � �+*)� " ' ' ���$'$# � � %)��� ��#%� ��� � � � �$� � � ��� � 5 �Q- � 9 *)� � - � �� �)! �+*�� ' #*'.'$�(' # '+�#4 � � �.- � � ��� � 5 � - � 9 *�� � - � � ;0$ *�� � � � � 5 � � � # "�� � 9 ! � ��� � ! �! �

� � � 5 �.- � � � � �Q- � - � �� �� - � �

Page 162: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � �� ����# � � �+* � � � � � � # "0� � �0'.� �#6 6 �) � 0�6 #%� ! �/� "$�"! ��# � ��� 4 ' � �$����� � � � �

� � � )

# )� �Q- � -

� � �

# )� �Q- �� - � )

�� �.- � -

� � � �� � �

# )� �Q- � -

� � � �� �c

� )

# )� �.- � -

� � 9 � � ��� !� "&� �#6 # ��4 � � � ��� ' � � �

�c � � �c��

" � �+* � ��� � �.- � - 9 # 676 # �)! ��� ! # � �$� 4 ' � �����$� � � � ; $ *)� � �+*)� � 1 ( � � �$� ! �#6 % �0� � �#� ��# ��4 �&� '

" � ' ��� � � 9 #3�+* 5�� � � . #%� �$*)� 9 ��'$���+*)� � % �$�I� � ��! � �#" ��� " * � ! ! # " ��'.#7� % �$#*� � �� � � � . 9 � %�6%!� � � � )

# )���O� � � )

� � �.-0/ e � -�� �� � e�� e

� ����# � � �+* � � .��#"�! # "&� %�"&" � ! � � �� � . ��� � 5 � e � � � � e � ; � � � � 9 �&'$� ' � # � � � �� (�4�+* � �%)�)! �-'��+*)# " "$� � ��� '.#*� . �$*)� ( ��' " � �� �15 � �1# " # �)! #b�9��'$� � � � ��� 9 �-� �6�#� �$#*� � � ��! # ���#� ��#*� � ;� � 9 '$�"� % ' � # ��4 ��� �$*)� � " ' ' ���$'$# � �-�#" ����� ��� � 5 � � � .�9 � �-� ��%�" ��+*�� ! � �)� #%�$#*� � � �

��� � 5 � � � # � ���-' ' " ��� � � � � �$� 9 '.#%��� �$*)�2� 1 ( � � �$� ! � 67% ��� � �#� �$# ��4 � "��� �

# )� � � � � )

�� �.- e�� - � � � e � e ��� ; ��� �

�*)�

��9� � � �� � �Q- e �� - �*)� � �.- e�� -�� � � e �

� e �

� *! ��#" ( �-' �$*)� ! � ��� #%��#%� � � � � �$' � �-"$6 � ��#*� � � �#' # 6 # � � � � �$#*� � c ; c ; � .:9 � �-� � 9 '.#%�$�� �Q-0/ e�� �#" � �.- e / � � . 9 *)# � * . �! ��$*)� � � � � ��#*� ���#6 " � � ��!�� ' ! �$* � � � � � �� � � � / � � . # " 9 * � ��#(�( � � ' " # � �+*�� # � ��� 4 ' � 67" � � �� � ; ' � �+*)� � ' " ��# � ��� 4 ' � 6 . e � � . " � �+*�� ( � " ����'$#%�(' 6 # � 6 # *)� � !��� � 5 � e�� � � � e�� � � � e � . � ��! " # ��� � - # " � 6 9 � " 4 '$� � ���-' �+* ��� � ��'$� . - e � � . " �� �Q- e�� � � �.- e���; ' � �$*)� " � � � �)! (�� '?� . e � � .�" � � � e � � � � e � � � . � % � - e # "6 � "$" �+* � ��� �-'.� #3� - � e � ��! 4 '.� � �$�-' �$* � �"� �-'.� 9 *�� � - � e � �$* %�" �$*)� # � ��� 4 ' � 6 �� (�-' -

Page 163: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � �* �#" �$�)� � �)'$� � � ! � 90� # � ���1�+*)��� 9 � ()� '.� "1" *)� 90��� � �� (� ;� � � � 9 9 # " * ��� � � ' ()� '$� �$*)��� 1 ( � � ��� ! �#67% � # � �$*)� " ')' �"��'.# ��� ��! �+*)� �#" ' ' ���$'$# �� � " � ; 0 �('�� 1)� ' (�6 � . �$*)� � ' " �1* �#6 � � � � 1-( '$� "&" #%� � � ; ��� # " � � %)��! � ! � � 6 � 9 �! �� �

# )��9� � � )

�� �.- e�� -�� � � e�� e � � �

# )���O� � � )

�� �.- e�� -�� � � e�� e

� � � � %�" � � � 9 *)� � � � � � " # � �+*�� %�(!9 � ' ! � 6 � � � # �-4 �-�#" � 9 � � '$� � � ��" # ! ��'$# ��4�. ���)!����� � � � # " ' � � � �$� � # � �#6 6 6# ��� '.� �#" # ��4 ; ' � �$*)� ! � 90�!9 � ' ! � 6 � ��� # ��4 �-�#" � . � � � . �+*��7# � ���� %�� 6 #%� # " '.�� (��' " � ! ;

� " �&�(' �$*)� " � � � �)! * �#6 � . �)'$� ��7! � 90� �$*)� � ' 4#%�' � � ����������� � � � �#" �&� 6 6 � 9 "��� )�

� �Q- e � - � ����

� �.- e��� - � � �� � �.- e�� - � )

� � � �.- e�� -� � � �

� ��� � �� � �Q- e � -�� � )� � � �Q- e � - ��� ; � � �

� c � ����

� �Q- e � - � �*)� � � �.- e�� - ��� ; � � �

� � �*)�

� �.- e�� -��� � %�� ��#%� � � ; � � # "0!�% � ��� �+*�� " ')' �"��' 4� � � � � ��; ' � ��� %�� 6 #%� � ; � � %�" � " �$*)� � � � ���+* � ���+*��� � � �)� #*� � � � � �

� � # " ��� %�� 6 ��� c �.9� �)! �+*)� � �#� � �$* � � � � ;5$ *��1# � ��� %)�#6 #3� '.�� �-' " � "9 *)� � � � ;

� (�-' " ��� ( # � �+*)���&� 6 6 � 9 # ��4 � * � # � � � # � ��� %��#6 #%��#%� " * �#"0� � 9 � �-� � " *)� 90�a�� � � �#� �I/ " � 9 � � � )

# )���O� � � )

�� �.- e�� -�� ��� � 5 � e � e

� � �

# )� � � � � )

�� �.- e�� - � � � e � e

� )�

���9� � � �� � � �Q- e � - � )� � �.- e�� -�� � � e��� e

� � �

# )���O� � � )

�� �Q- e � -�� � � e�� e

� )�

� � � � �*)�

� �Q- e � - � � � e��� e

Page 164: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � �

� � � �� � � �

# )��9� � � )

�� �.- e�� -�� � � e�� e

� � )# )

���>� � � )�

� �.- e�� -�� � � e � e� � � � �#� �I/ " ' ' ���$'& �

� # ' # 6*� ' 6 . � � ��� � � �� � # " "&' �#6 6 ��'�# � �+*)� �#" ')' ����'.# � � � " � . � ��! " � 9 *)��'$� � ( �-' " � �9 *)� ! '.� 9 � �-'.� 9 �#" # �)! #�� �-'$� � �0# � �+*�� " ' ' ���$'$# � � �#" � . *)� " �$'$# � � 6 ( '$���&��' " ��� �#� �0# � �+*���#" ')' ����'.# � �-�#" � ; � ��#3� ' %�" � � � �+* � � � � � � ;

� #%#*# ��� �A (��' " � �+*)�2# � ��� %��#6 #%�$#*� " � � �$� ! # � �+*)� ( '.�/��� � ��� #%# ��; 3

��� �X694 � � � ��� D��I=AM :.<2HI: G � DJ@ %7M!? �0M ^� D ��M!? V(?7M ��D���D�H��RDQ:� � � M :Q<>=Y@ � � � =A:�CADEV VZH7@�= � :.<>=ACF= DJ@ HIM =���TUD��RD���C�DQT�� HI: � � � � �

� =ZHIM>DQM\[�:Q<2HI: :Q<>=ACF=5DJ@ M!=ADQ:Q<>=AC H\VA:�D��I= M!?7C DQMOH\VA:�D��I= V(?7M ��D���D�H��RDQ:�� ^� DQD ��H\VA:�D��I=PV(?7M ��D���D�H��RDQ:� � � �:.<>=LNIDJ@A:�C�D���TU:�DE?7M DJ@�T�� � HIC N �J=ZHIM>DQM\[ � :Q<>=AMf:Q<>=AC(=�DJ@LHIM =���T\D�

�RD���C�DQT� HI: @�? � =��>?7DQM>: � � � �>^� DQDQD � DQMOH\VA:�D��I=PV(?7M ��D���D�H��RDQ:� � � � :.<>=LNIDJ@A:�C�D���TU:�DE?7MfDJ@LN\? �0M � HIC N �J=ZHIM>DQM\[ � :Q<>=AMf:.<>=ACF=�DJ@LHIM

=���T\D��RD���CADQT�� HI:0@�? � =��>?7DQM>: � � � � ^

��4`6a6� �� � � � �#6 6 �+* � � 5 � ��� � # " �+*�� ( �(# � � � � 9 *)# � * � � � 9 *�� ! '.� 9 5�� � � 9 � %�6*! � �# ��! #�� �-'.� � �0#%� 5 � ��5 � � 9 �-'.� �$*)� � % �$�I� ; ' �0# " �+*)� ( �(# � � 9 *)��'$�

� ��� � � )+ , � �

� �.-0/ G � - � � � ��� � � � )+ , � �

� �.-0/ G � - ��('� )

+�, � �� �Q-0/ G � - � � + , � �

# )� �.-0/ G � -

' � �$*)� " ' ' ���$'$# �)�-�#" � . 9 *)��'$� � �.-0/ G � ��� � -0/ G � . �+*)# " # " � 6 � � ' 6 ���' % � � � 5 � ��� � � � .� �)! �+*��-'$�"�&�('$� � � � � ! �/� " # �)! ��� !4! � "$� '.#7� � � � � " # � � � �#" * ��� % # 6 # �)'$# %�' ;

' � �+*)� � �#" � 9 *)�-'.� � �.-0/ G � � � � -0/ G � . �+*�� � �+*�� ( � # � � 9 *�# � * " � 6 (� " �+*�� � � �` ���� %�� ��#*� � ' %-" � "�� �$# " �< 5 � ��� � � � ; � "&"$%�')( �$#*� � � � . �+*��-'$��# ":" � ' � �#67% ����� 5 . 5 ) . "$%�� *�+* � � �$*)� �#"$" � � # � �$� ! � % ��� � # " 5 � ��5 ) � � � ; � # ��� �)5 � ��5�� � # " � � � � ��# � % � %�" . ' � � � ��� � # �� %)��� ��#%� � � �:5�� . 9 � � � 9 �+* � � 5 ) � � . � ��! �+* � ���$*)�-'.�1# " " � ' � ( �(# � � 5�� � �<5 ) � � � "$%�� *�+* � � 5�� � 5 � �<5�� ��;

Page 165: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � �' � �+*)� �-�#" � 9 *)��'$� � �Q-0/ G � � � � -0/ G � . �$*)� � 5 � ��� � � � ; � � � ��# � % #3� . �$*)�-'.��# " " � ' �

' ����4 � "$%�� * �+* � �15 � �<5�� � � 5�� �&�(' �#6 6 5�� � ��� � 5�� � ; ' � �+*)# " ' � ��4 � * �#" � ��%�(�( �-'1� � %)�)! . �+*�� �� �0�+* � �1� � %��)! . 5�� � 5 � ��5�� � � #3� #3� * �#"�� � %�(�( �-' � � %)�)! . �+*�� � � � � � # "�� � ��� % # 6 #7�)'.# %�' ;3

��� �X694 � � � ��� @(@AT�� = �OC�DE?7C NIDJ@A:�C�D���TU:�DE?7M � � �.G � @�HI:�DJ@ � =(@ :.<>= � ?7M!?7:B?7M!= �RD %S= �RDJ<>?�?�NPCZHI:�DE?�OCF? �>=AC�:����0DQ:Q< CF=(@ �>=(VA: :B? � � �.G � �LHIMON H7@(@AT� =�VATU:�?�� =���T\D��RD���CAD�H ^�� @(@AT�� = M!?7:.<\DQM\[ H �A?7TU::Q<>= NIDJ@A:�C�D���T\:�DE?7M � ��5 � ^ � <>=AM @�? � =(?7M!= � <>?fDJ@ DQMONID � =ACF=AM>: �A=A: �;=(=AM�H\VA:�DE?7M�HIMON DQMOH\VA:�DE?7M[ID��I=AM �OC�DE?7C� � ��G � �0D����!@A:�C�DEVA:��� �OCF= � =AC�H\VA:�DQM\[ [ID��I=AM � � ��G � ^

��4`6a6� �� $ *)�-�('.� ' � . �+*)� �#"$"&%�' ( ��#*� ��" � � � % � �$*)� ( '.#*�(' " # ' (�6 2�+* � � �&�(' � � �21 � !5�� . �$*)� ( � " ����'$#%�(' ��� � 5 � � / 5�� � � � � 032 � � " �+*)� ( � " �$�-'.#*�(' � � � 5 � � / 5�� � � � � ;0$ *)�2� 1 ( '.� "&" #*� �

���5�� � �*)+��

� � �Q-0/ e � -��# "0��� # ��� '.� �#" # ��4 � %)�-� ��#%� � � � e . �! 032 � � ; $ *)�-'.���&�('.� .

�*)

# )����5�� � � )

+��� � �Q-0/ e � -�� ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � � � � e � ��� ; � � �� )

# )� � 5�� � � )

+��� � �.-0/ e�� - � ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � � � � e��

�! 032 � � ; 032 � � .� )

# )� � 5�� � � )

+��� � �.-0/ e�� - � � � � 5 � e / 5�� � � � � e � ��� ; � � �� )

# )� � 5�� � �*)

+��� � �Q-0/ e � - � ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � � � � e

' � � � � 9 *)� ! '$� 9 5�� � �)! * �#" ( '.#*�(' � � � � � # " # �)! #�� �-'.� � � . �+*)� ��*)

# )� � 5�� � � )

+��� � �.-0/ e�� - � ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � � � � e � ��� ; � � �

�*)

# )���9� � � �*)

+��� � �Q-0/ e � -�� ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � � � � e �

Page 166: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� � c

� # ' # 6 � ' 6 .� � � � � �*)

+��� �.-0/ e�� - �

# " ' � � ����� � # � �#6 6 ! � � '.� �#" # ��4 # � e . " � �! 032 � � �� )# )

���9� � � � )+��

� � �Q-0/ e � -�� ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � � � � e � ��� ; � � �� )

# )� � � � � � )

+��� � �.-0/ e�� - � ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � � � � e

� �)! . � 082 � � �� )

# )� � � � � � )

+��� � �Q-0/ e � - � ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � � � � e � ��� ; � � �

� )# )

� � � � � � )+��

� � �.-0/ e�� - � ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � � � � e� * � # � # �-4 ��� 4 �"�+*)��' � 1 ( '.� "&" #*� ��" � ; � � . � ; � �-. � ; � � . � ; � � .�� �)! � ; � � " *)� 9 " �+* � �

� )

# )� � 5�� � � )

+��� � �.-0/ e�� - � ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � � � � e �

�*)

# )���9� � � �*)

+��� � �Q-0/ e � -�� ��� � 5 � e / 5�� � � � � e �

� �7#3� � � � 9 *)� ! '$� 9 5�� # " # �)! #�� �-'$� � � 4 #b (� � � � � � � . *)� " ��'.# � � 6 ( '.���&��' " �$� �#� � 4 #� � � � � � � � ;3

��� �X694 � � ��� � <>=�M!? _HSN �I=ACA:�DJ@ADQM\[ VAT\:B?�� � �� DJ@ N\=(VAC(=ZH7@ADQM\[ DQM � � HIMON�� � ^ � <>= VATU:�?���0DQ:Q< HSN �I=ACA:�DJ@ADQM\[ � � �� �0DJ@ N\=(VAC(=ZH7@ADQM\[ DQM � ����� � � �;HIMON�� � ^

��4`6a6� �� ' � � � 6 #%�� (� " �+* � � �$*)�0�('$# 4 # �)�#6/! # " �$'$# � % ��#%� � � � � �#" ��� " 9 �#" � � � � � . � �)! � � 6 #*�A (� "�+* � � � � ( �-' � � � � � � � � ��"&%�' �-' " * � (�+� 1 (�� ��! � ! % ��# 6 #%� �! � � . �+*)� � � � 6 #%�� (� " �+* � � �+*��( � " � � � ! �-'?��# " # ��4 ! # " �$'$#7� % ��#%� � � � � �#" ��� " ��*)�-'.�-# � � �� ��5 �$� # "

� �� �<5 � � � � � � ��5 � � � � � � � � � � ��5 � �' � � �$*)�-' 9 �(' !�" . � � ( �-' � � � � � � �$*)� ! # " �$'$#7� % ��#%� � 9 �#" " *)#3� ��� ! �� (�-' � � � 9 *)# 6 � �P � �( �-' � � � � ! # !)�"! � � * � ��4 � ; � � �$* � � �$*)� � % �$�I� 9 #3�+*)� % � ��! (��'.��# " # ��4 9 �#" 5 � �<5�� � .�� �)!�" �

Page 167: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� ���� � � 9 *�� ! '.� 9 5�� # " # ��! #�� �-'.� � � � �"� 9 ��� ��#� �$#*� � � �)! # ���#� �$#*� � 4 #� � � � � � ! (��'.�$# " # ��4 ; �% �� " # ��� � � � �<5 � � � ��5 � � � � �1#%� � � � � �

� � �� ��5 � �<5�� �$� � � � � � � � ��5 � � � � � � � � � � ��5 � #� � � � � � � ��5 � � � � � � � � ��5 � � � � � � ��5 � � � �<5 � � � #b#3��� ; �Xc �� � � � ��5 � �

' � � 1 ( '$� "$" #%� � � ; �Xc . �$*)� � ' " � � 9 � �$�-' ')" # � �+*����)' � � ��� " "$%�' ��� � � �<5 � .�� ��! �+*)� '$� '+� # � # ��4(�� '?� 9 #%�+*�# � �)' � � ��� " '.� ( '.� " � � � " �$*)� " *)�('?�$� �#6 6 �! 9 *)# � * �P � �� ��5 � �<5�� �&� ! �/� " � ��� '.� �#� �� � � �<5 � ; � � � � 9 � � 6 #%�� � " �+* � �0�$*)�-'.� � '.� ' �('.� ( �-� (�6 � �#� ��# �-4 4 #b (� � �$*)� "$�#' � � % ���I�5 � ��5�� � . � �)! �+*��-'$�"�&�('$� 9 *)��'$� 9 � " # �)! #b�9��'$� � � . �� � 9 " ��'.# � � 6 ( '$�"�&�-' "+� � ��# ��4�. � �)! �+*��� % ���I� ' %�" � � �#676 ; � # �-� � � � � � � ��5 � � � �<5 � � � # # " # ��� '.� �#" # ��4 # � � � �+* � � ���)! # � � � . �+*��� % ���I� 5 � ��� � ' %�" ��� �#676 � % '.�+*��-' �&�(' 6*� ' 4 ��' �#67% � " � � � � � �)! � � ;

� # ' # 6*� ' 6 . �+*�� ! # " �$'$# � % ��#%� � � � � �#" ��� "14 #� (� � � ���)! � .� � �� �<5 � � � � � ��5 � � � � � � � � �<5 � �

9 # 6 6 �#67" � * � � � *)# 4 *)��' ( �-' � � � � � 4 � � � ( �-� (�6 ���� (�-' � � 4 #� (� � � % ���I� �#"�� � �)! � '$# " � ;� 6 " � . #%� 89 �#" # �)! #b�9��'$� � ��� �"� 9 ��� � �#� �$#*� � � �)! # ���#� �$#*� � 4 #� � � �$*)� � % ���I� " 5 �� ���)! 5 �� .)���)!� � �(' � � � � 676 . �$*)� � 5 �� � �#6 67" .!' � ��� # ��4 ' �('$� ( �-� (-6 � 9 # 676-� � ��"&%�' � . ' � � � # �-4 �$* � � 8" ��'$# � � 6 ( '.���&�-' " � � ��# ��4 4 #b (� � �+*�� � % ��� � 5 �� .�' � ��� # ��4 �$* � � � % ���I� ' %-" ��� �#6 6 ; 3

Page 168: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� ���

� ��� ������� ��� ���

� � # � ���(' 4 � � � �-' 6 � � � �)! � �#� *)� 6���� ' ��� �$� � ; � � � � � ' # � "1� ��! # ! � � �$#%� ; $ � � * � # � � 6'$� ( �('?� . ������� ;

� c # � # "�� � � �)! �-' " � � � �)!�� * � ' 6 � " ��� � 6 � ; ' � �&�(' ' � ��#*� � � �#"&� � ! � " # � �$*)� 6 � � �(' � ���(' ;� <>= � � =AC�DEVZHIM�� V(?7M!? �WDEV! = ��DE= � .#" �-�%$ � �&"(' � �)"�*Sc .,+ � � � ' � ��' ����� � ;

�.- # +�� /# ! � %-" ��# � � � ' #3�+* ; � 676 � � � ��# �-4 �#� � � "$" �&�(' # � �&�(' ' � �$#*� ��� ��!,� � � ��'.#7� % ��#*� ��" ;0/ ?7TUC MOH(1 ? � � H � ��� V(?7M!? �WDEV(@32 � C�[SHIM>D54�HI:�DE?7M . � ' � c � � � '6- � � � ' $ � . ����� " ;

�7' # � ��*�# � #%�08 � � ��' � �-� ; � " # ' (�6 � ' � ! � 6 � � *)��' ! � � * � #*� ' ; � <>=:9 T2HIC�:B=AC;1=< / ?7T\CAMOH(1 ? �� V(?7M!? �WDEV(@ . � � �-� - � � � � � �)" � � . � %�4 �>��� c ;

� $7# �-' � 6 � � ')( � " # %-' � � ? � �+*)� ' � ��# �-�#6 � � � ��# " ��# � " � �)!�@ '$� � � �)# 6 #%� ;�A ? � �2HIC�DJ@�?7M? �!� � �>=AC�D � =AM>:.@ . ��� $ � ;

�.* # B+ � %�4 6*�#" ��' � *��-# ' ; � �$*)�-�(' � � � � � �&�(' ' #%� ;C/ ?7T\CAMOH(1 ? �+< ?D1RDQ:�DEVZH(1E� V(?7M!? �:< .� � c �F$ � �G"(' � �)" � � . �>��� ' ;

� �7# � %�" *)# 6 # * � * � �)!�� � # .H+�� # ! � #*' " * 6 �-#%�&��' . � �)! ' � � � 67� * ; � �$*)�-� '& � � � � !�" . � �#" * �#*� � .-� %-" ��� ' .����)! � %�6 � % ' � 6 � * � ��4 � � " # � �&�(' ' � ��#*� ���#6�� �#"&� � ! � " ;I/ ?7TUC�MOH(1 ? � <�?D1RDQ:�DEVZH(1� V(?7M!? �:< . � � � �%$ � � � ��� c � � � c(*-. �>�(� c ;

�." # � %�" *)# 6 # * � * � �)!�� � # . �KJ-# � � 4(�#6 ./� �)! � %)� # 6 � * � ' '+� ; � ��� � * �#" ��# � ! � ' # ������� � %)�)! ��' � (� " # ��� 6 � � ' � # ��4 ;L/ ?7TUC�MOH(1 ? �M� V(?7M!? �WDEV � <>=(?7C;< . $ *2�G- $ c �N- � � . �>��� c ;

� � # � # 6 6 # � ' � '.� � ���)! � ���� � � � + % ' 6 �#% � ; + # "$� '.���$� � *��(# � � 9 #3�+* " � � # � 6 # � ����' �#� ��#%� ��" ; = ��DE= ��? �!� V(?7M!? �WDEV �9:�T NIDE=(@ .#*("2� cO- $ �2c(* � .>c �I� � ;

Page 169: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� $�$� � � # � ���)!��#6 6 � � �#6 (��'.� ;0$ *��5 �#6 % ��� �8�)# �#" � ! # � �&� ' '+� ��#%� �a� � ' � ��#%� ���#6/� *)�(# � � ' � ! � 6 � �

( � 6 #%�$# �-�#6 � ! # � � ; � <>= / ?7TUC�MOH(1 ? � < ?D1RDQ:�DEV(@ .#' ��� c � � $ - � � $�$�$ .��#%)� � �>� " $ ;� � � # � � 6 # � � �#' �-'$��' ���)! $ � � � � %�� � � ; � 1-( �-'.#*� ��� � � 9 �-# 4 * �$� ! � �$��' �#� �$#*� � 6 � � ' � # ��4 # �

� �(' ' �#6 �&�(' ' 4��#' � " ; ��V(?7M!? � =A:�C�DEVZH .#* ��� ' � �G"Sc � �)" � '�.��#%�6 �>����� ;� � c # � � 6 # � � �#' �-'$��' . � �-�(' 4 � � �/� 9 � ��" �$�-# � .2� �)! ?� �$� � � �)# � . � ! #%��� ' " ; � N �7HIM!V(=(@ DQM

� =(<2H ��DE?7C H(1 � V(?7M!? �WDEV(@ ; @ '$# ��� �"��� � � � #� (��' " #%� @ '$� "$" ./0 �('?�+* � � ' # ��4 ;� � - # ' %-� � � � �#')( � � 6 6 ; � �+*��-�('.����# � �#6 �#(-( '$� � � * ��� ( ���-' # ����% � ��� � # � � ! � 6 � "$� � � � " � �

� # �#6 # J � �$#*� � ; � � =AC�DEVZHIM / ?7T\CAMOH(1 ? � < ?D1RDQ:�DEVZH(1 �aVADE=AM!V(= .>cD' � c � �&- cO' �)-('('�.#?� ��� " � ;� � ' #���# � � � � ��4 � *)� %)��4 � �)! +�� � #%� 6 0 '$#%� !�'+� � ; ' �)! #� # !�%��#6 6 � � ' � # ��4 # �5� �(' ' � 6 �&�(' '

4��#' � "�� � � ' � 6 � � �(' � ��� '& �'.� "$%-6 � " ; � H�� =(@HIMON!��V(?7M!? �WDEV � =(<2H ��DE?7C . �>� � '6* � � *-. ����� � ;� � $7# �(� @ # 6 � *)�(# ; � ��' ! � � * � #%�(' . �+*)��� ( � ��4 % # � ��� � � � .���� ��! �$*)� "&%�(�( '.� "$" #*� � � � # � �&�(' �

' � ��#*� ���#6 ! #�� %�" #%� �a� ��� � ��� 6 " # " ��� # � �&�(' '+� ��#%� � � 1 �$�-' �)�#6 #3��#*� " � �)! ()� �I� # � ����' ! � �( � �)! � ��� ; � : / ?7T\C�MOH(1 ? �!� V(?7M!? �WDEV(@ .9c(" � - � � ' � � � 'Xc $ . � % � %�'�� ����� � ;

� � * # ? # � * � � 6 � % ��� � %)��4 � * 9 � ; HI:�DE?7MOH(1 DQ:�T2H(1 � A T)1R:�T\C(= � A ?�?7C NIDQMOHI:�DE?7M�� HIMON A ? � � ?7M� M!? ��1J=ZN�[\= ; @ '$# ��� �"��� � � � #� (��' " #%� @ '$� "$" .ac �I� � ;

� � �7# 8 # ��� � � � @ � ' � 9 �&�(' !4� ��!�� �/� 6 � � � � 6 ; � �$' � �$� 4 # � # � �&�(' '+� �$#*� � ��' � ��"$' # "&" #%� � ; � V(?7M!? � =A:�C�DEVZH . $ � � * � � � '6- � � � ' $ � . � �� (� ' � �-' �>� "Sc ;

� � " # ?� �$*)# �#"�+ � 9 � ��'.# ( � � � � ��! � � � � $ #*'.� 6 � ; � ! (� � � �$� " ; / ?7T\C�MOH(1 ? � < ?D1RDQ:�DEVZH(1)� V(?7M!? �:< .� � ��� � � � � �)- � . ������� ;

� �>� # � � % # " � � � *)� %)! � � �)! � *)'$# " �$# � � � � 676 #*��' ; + � '+� �)! �&�('�'$# " �#"&" �"� " � �)! �+*)� ' � � ������ � � ( '.� � � ��# 6 #3� 1' � ��#*� �(' ! �-' ;0/ ?7T\C�MOH(1 ? �I DJ@�� HIMON�� M!V(=AC�: HIDQM>: < . � � � � � - � � c c . ����� $ ;

� c � # � # 6 6 # � ' � � � ��" . � �#676*�#� � � 22� ��� " . ���)! � � � �-'?� ? � � * 9 � � ; ? � �#"&% '$# ��41( ���-' 4 '$� %�(��� � � � "�� � " � %)! 4��� �$�-� ���#4 � � � * � #*�(' ; / ?7TUC�MOH(1 ? � < ?D1RDQ:�DEVZH(1 � V(?7M!? �:< . � � � �F$ � � � *�* ����2� .�2 � ���#� ��' ����� c ;

Page 170: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� $ *� c � # @ �#%-6 0 '$#��?�$�-' " ; � ' � ! � 6 � � � �#" *)#*� �-"�� �)!," � � � %�" ; � V(?7M!? �WDEV�� ?�N\= 1 1RDQM\[ . � $ � $I� ��� $ � � .

�>��� " ;� c c # + '$� 9 0 %)! � � � �-' 4 � ��! +�� # ! � �A # � � ; � � � ' � # �-4 # � 4(�#' � " ; �;T\CF? �>=ZHIMC� V(?7M!? �WDEV

= ��DE= � .,'XcU�G*�- ��� *�- � . ?� �>��� " ;� c(- # �(�#� �#��� 6 � J��-' � �)! � '$#%� 6 � % � � ��" �$�-# � ; + � � � �$� " � �)! ! � � # " #%� ��"�� 2 � � ' � ��#%� ���#6 �1� �

� ' 4#%�' � � � � �$#*� � ' %�6 � " ; � H�� =(@�HIMON � V(?7M!? �WDEV �L=(<2H ��DE?7C . -�*2� � $ " �O� � --.2c � � � ;� cO' # � � �)� �"�+* ? ��� 6*!-" ����# � ; � M>:B=ACF=(@A: � CF?7T �>@ � � ?�� � <7DQM\[ � HIMON < HICA:�DEVAD �2HI:�DE?7MfDQM � � =AC�DEVZH ;

� �#' �)'.# !�4 � � #b (��' " #3� @ '$� "&" . �>���(� ;� c $7# � � * � � ��' � * �#' ; � �-' ! # �-4+� ' � �-4 # � (� " � ' � � � � � 9 "&6 �"�$����' "�� $ *)���('& ���)! �A # ! � ��� � ;

/ ?7TUC�MOH(1 ? � %DQMOHIM!V(= . $ ' � � � � c(- � � c(*�"-. 0 � �)' %�� '& �>����� ;� c(* # � � � ��' ����4 �-' ; ' � (� " ��# 4�� �$# ��4 � �#%�"$�#6 '$� 6*� ��#%� ��" �! �� � � � � ' ���$'$# �1' � ! � 67" � ��! � '.� "$" �

"$( � � ��' � 6 � ���#6 " # " ; ��V(?7M!? � =A:�C�DEVZH . - �-� - � �G'XcD' � '6-�" . �#%)� � �>� * � ;� c �7# � � � �&� ' ! � ��'$� "$"$'+� � ; 2 � �$*)� ��� � #*� ��� � � � � ' ( ���$#%�$#� (� " �$� � '+� ' ��� "89 *)��'$� �$' � ! � "

� " # � #-* � � ! #� �-' " � # � �&�(' '+� �$#*� � ; � <>= / ?7TUC�MOH(1O? � %DQMOHIM!V(= .O- � � c � � $ � - � $ " $ .(?� ��� � * ;� c(" # � � � �&� ' ! � ��'$� "$"$'+� � ; � � # � �$'$� !�%�� �$#*� � ��� �+*)� �+*)���('& 5� ��' � ��#%� ���#6 � 1 ( � � � � ��#*� ��"

%)�)! ��' �#" ')' �"��'$# � # � �&�(' '+� ��#%� � ; �= ��DE= ��? �!� V(?7M!? �WDEV �9:�T2NIDE=(@ . '6"U� $ ' ��� $�$ � . �>� " � ;� c � # � � '.'$# " � � � � ��4�. � �A�9'.� + � % �)# �. � �)! � ' #%� � � 6 � ' � � ; � � � % '$#3� � ���#6 " � " ��� � �

'$���-' � � ��� ��' ��" � �)! *)��' ! # ��4 � � � � ' � # ��4#" �&�('$� � �#" � " ; � : / ?7T\C�MOH(1 ? � � V(?7M!? �WDEV(@ .- � � � � � � c ���9� '�'�. � ( '.# ��4�c � �I� ;

�.- � # $ � � � � � � '��� ; =(@ �>?7M2@AD���D 1RDQ: < HIMON1 HITN1R: ; � � '.� @ % � 6 # " *)# �-4�. �>�(��� ;�.- � # � � � � (�'+�-. � �(�#4 ��' . � �)! � �2�#')( * % # " ; � M>:�CF?�NIT>VA:�DE?7Mf:�? � M>:�=AC�MOHI:�DE?7MOH(1)� V(?7M!? �WDEV(@ ;

� !)! # " � � � � � "$6 � . �>��� * ;�.-Sc # � �#� ��'.� � � � ��� � ! ; � �$' � �$� 4 � � !�" � �)! � � ' ( ���$#%�$#� (� � � � �-' 4 � ��� � � � � � ')( #%'$# �-�#6

��� " � �&�(' *)��' ! � � * � /#%�(' # � ( '.# ' � � ��# ' �+�$� 6 �� # " #*� � ( '.� 4 ' �#' ' # �-4 ; � <>= / ?7T\C�MOH(1�? �� MONITS@A:�C�D�H(1 � V(?7M!? �WDEV(@ . $I� � � � � $ � � "('-.#?� ' � * c � � c ;

Page 171: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� $ ��.-�- # � + %)���-� � � %-� � � �)! � � 9 � ' ! � � #�� � ; � H�� =(@ HIMON : =(VADJ@ADE?7M2@ � � M>:�C(?�NIT>VA:�DE?7M HIMON

A C�DQ:�DEVZH(1 �9T\C �I= < ; � �#* � � # 6 � �� � � ��" . �>� $ � ;�.-(' # + # ( � � ��# ?� � %�'+!)� ' ; �%@(@�H(<`@LDQM �a?�VAD�H(1 A <>?7DEV(= � <>=(?7C < ; @ * + �+*)� " # " . ' �)! # � � � � � �$# " �

��# � �#6 ' ��" �$#%� % ��� .�2 � ��� � �-' c � � c ;�.- $7# $ *)� '+�#" � ?�#% �"� ; � C�D�H(1 � =(V(<\M>D���T>=(@ ; � "&( � � @ % � 6 # " *��-' " . * �+*4� ! #%�$#*� � . c � � c ;�.-�* # @ �#%-6N? # 6 4 '$� ' � �)! � � * � � � � �-'.� " ; � � 6 # ��4 � � �+*�� # � �&�(' ' � �$#*� � � �/# � ����'$� " ��� ! (�� '?��#%� " ;

� �: / ?7TUC�MOH(1 ? �!� V(?7M!? �WDEV(@ . � ��� � � � � " � -Sc . � ( '.# ��4 �>� "�* ;�.- �7# @ �#%-6 � ? # 674 '.� ' ; ���/� !6� � 9 " ���)! � � ! � � 9 "�� � � ( '$� " � � � � ��#%� � �$*)�-� '$� ')"2� �)! �#( �

(�6 # � � �$#*� �-" ; � <>= � = 1 1 / ?7TUC�MOH(1 ? �M� V(?7M!? �WDEV(@ . � c � c � �&-(" � � - �U� . � % � %-'+� �>� " � ;�.-�" # + � � �(' � * ? # � � * � '?� � �)! � % J � ��� � � � ��� � * ' �-' ; � 1 ( � " � '$� 4 '$�"� � �)! �$*)� ! � � � � �$' �#6 # J-� !

" * � '$# �-4 � � # � �&�(' '+� �$#*� � ; � H�� =(@�HIMON � V(?7M!? �WDEV �L=(<2H ��DE?7C .>c � � � � ' �O� - � . �>����� ;�.- � # @ �"���-' ? % '$' � ; ��H7@ADEV � C�D�H(1 � N �I?�VZH\V < ; � "$( � � @:% � 6 # " *)��' " . ����� $ ;�7' � # � �)! '��� 2 ' 6 �� ��� ; � " � � � # � �$�-' �#� �$#*� ��" � �)! � � 6 6 � � ��#b (� ! ���#' # � " � ��� ( # � #%� �a� � �-' ! � � �

* � #*�(' � ��! ' # ' ���$# ��� � � � �#4 #%� � ; / ?7TUC�MOH(1a? � � V(?7M!? �WDEV � =(<2H ��DE?7C�HIMON � C�[SHIM>D54�HI:�DE?7M .c("2� c $ � � c � '�. �>��� $ ;

�7' � # � � �-� @ � �)� # ��4 ��� � � �)! � ��# ! � �#" ��#*� ; � # ! � ��� �+�� �#67%)� ��#%� � # � � � ')(�6 � 1 ! � � # " #*� � �' � # ��4 ; / ?7T\C�MOH(1 ? � < =AC(@�?7MOH(1RDQ: <�HIMON �a?�VAD�H(1 <%@ <XV(<>?D1J?Z[(< . $ � � c � � cO'Sc � c $ " . �>� "�* ;

�7'Xc # � � �-� @ � �)� # ��4 ��� � � ��! � �-# ! � �#" �$#*� ; � 1 (�6 � �)� ��#%� � � � �#" � !5! � � # " #%� � '+�� # �-4 � � � ��&� � � " � � ' � ' �('& " �$' %�� � % '.� � � � %)!�4 � ' � � � ;�/ ?7T\C�MOH(1;? �3� � �>=AC�D � =AM>:EH(1 <%@ <XV(<>?D1J?Z[(< �� =ZHICAM>DQM\[ � � =�� ?7C;< �;HIMON A ?Z[IM>DQ:�DE?7M . � ' � - � � $ c ��� $ -�--. �>� "�" ;

�7'6- # � � �-� @ � ��� # ��4 ��� � � �)! � �-# ! � � " ��#%� ; � 1-(-6 � # � # ��4 �+*)� �A # ! � ��� � � $ � " � " � ���$*)� " �$�('& ' � ! � 6 �&�(' � % '$�(' ! � � # " #*� ��' � # ��4 ;!/ ?7T\C�MOH(1%? ��< =ACF@�?7MOH(1RDQ:F< HIMON �a?�VAD�H(19<%@ <SV(<>?D1J?Z[(< .*Sc � c � � � " � � c � *-. �>��� c ;

�7'�' # �#%)! � � @ �-' 6 ; A HITX@�H(1RDQ: < ; � �#' �)'.# !�4 � � #� �-' " #%� @ '.� "$" . ?� ' � * c � �I� ;

Page 172: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� $ "�7' $7# � � 6 � 4�� �-4�@ � " � �)! �('?�&�-' ; + � " # 4 � # �)� �` � �$#*� � � �)! � � " *)#%� ��� � 6 � " ; � <>= � � =AC�DEVZHIM

� V(?7M!? �WDEV! = ��DE= � .#" $�� ' � � � � ��� � � c . � � ( ��� ' � ��' ����� $ ;�7'6* # � �@ � � !�� �-' ; � � ��#*� ���#6 � 1 ( � � � � ��#*� ��" ��� % # 6 #7�)'.# %�'Y� �2� � �-'.# � � 1 # " �$� ��� � � ��! �$*)�1# � �

�&�(' '+� �$#*� � '.�� � �#6 � ! � ( '$# � � " ; ��V(?7M!? � =A:�C�DEVZH . ' ��� - � �G* $�$ � * � "-.,?� �>� � � ;�7' �7# � # 6 6 # � ' � � # �-' ���)! @ �"���-' � 2 ' ! � " *)�/� ; � �+*)���('& � ���+*�� � �#6 � %�6 %�" ��� (� �$# ��4 ;

� � =AC�DEVZHIM < ?D1RDQ:�DEVZH(1 �aVADE=AM!V(=K = ��DE= � .#*Sc � � � � c $ � 'Sc .#?� ' � * �>� *�" ;�7'6" # � 6*� � � � " � � �+* � 6 ; � <>= � <\DQC N���?7TS@�= � � ?�� � <7DJ@A:Q@fHIMON � ?�� � <7DQM\[ DQM�:.<>=)�9:EHI:B=(@ ; ���

@ '$� "&" .�" � � � ��! � ! #%��#%� � . c � � � ;�7' � # � 6 � 1�� �)! ��' � � � * % � "$"&6 �-' ; � � ?Z[IDEV ? � � � �OCF=(@(@AD��I= A <>?7DEV(= ; @ '.# ��� ���$� � � #� �-' " #%�

@ '$� "&" . c � �I� ;� $I� # � 6 � �)� � * � �&�-' ; � � HI:.<>=�� HI:�DEVZH(1 � <>=(?7C;< ? �M� ��D�N\=AM!V(= ; @ '.# ��� ����� � � #� �-' " #%� @ '.� "$" .

�>� � * ;� $ � # �-' ��� ' ! � � # 6 �-' '+� � ; " # ��4 ��' � � 6 ! � ��" #%� � " �$# '+� ��� " ����# � � " �$# 4�� ��� ' %�6 ��# ' � !��#6 �

#%� ; / ?7T\CAMOH(1!? � :Q<>=I ?D< H(1��9:EHI:�DJ@A:�DEVZH(1 �a?�VADE=A:F< �3�a=AC�DE=(@ � � � =A:Q<>?�N\?D1J?Z[IDEVZH(1 � .�'6-U� � � �)��� .�>� " � ;

� $ c # � �#"$" � � %)�-" ����# � ; � =E[SH(1� �=ZH7@�?7M>DQM\[�HIMON < ?D1RDQ:�DEVZH(1 A ?7M�� DEVA: ; 2�1 �&�(' ! � #� �-' " #%� @ '$� "&" . �>��� * ;

� $ - # ?� '.# �#' $ * �#6 � " ;0$ *)� '$� !�%�� ��#*� � ��� � � %�"��#6 ( '$� � � "&" � " ; � < M>:Q<>=(@�= . � -#6�� �(� �O� c(" . c �I� c ;� $ ' # � ' � " $ (��' " � �)! +�� � #*� 6 �2� * � � '+� � ; �#%�!�4 � ' � � � %)�)! ��' %)��� �-'?� � # � � � � � % '.# " �$# � "

� �)! �)# �#" � " ; �aVADE=AM!V(= . � " $�� ' � $ � � � � � cD' �O� � - � . � � ( �$� ' � �-' �>� � ' ;� $�$7# � '?�+* % ' + � 8 � � � � �)! � +�� # ! � �#676 " ; � " � � � # ��" ����# � ! ���#' # � " � �)! � !��#( �$#� �

� � � �$' �#� ��# �-4 # � �+*)� ' � �$#*� � ( # � � % '.� # �)!�%�" ��'& ; � <>= ��V(?7M!?��WDEV(@ / ?7T\C�MOH(1 . ' � � � ' � - �� $ � '-. � �� � ' � �-' �>��� * ;

� $ * # ' %-� � � � ��# � � �-' 4-.)@ � ��'.# � # � � � �#4�� � . ���)! � ��� '$� � � � � � 9 ; + � � �-# 4 * � �('&*)� � !�"� � � � � *)� % ' " 9 �(' � !a� � # ! � ��� ���&'.� ' 6 � �-4 #%� %)! # �)�#6�!�� � � ;�� �(' # ��4 ()�#( ��' .12 *)#%�� � � ��� � #� (��' " #%� � �)!�0 % ' ' � � � #� �-' " #%� . � �� (� ' � ��' c � � � ;

Page 173: Information aggregation, with application to - Ben Klemens

� $ �� $ �7# ' (� � � 67� * ; � �-' ! # ��44�#' � ��4 " � � % '$#3� � ��� 6 " � " ; / ?7T\C�MOH(1 ? � %DQMOHIM!VAD�H(1 � V(?7M!?��WDEV(@ .

$ "2�G-�* � � - � *-.2c � � � ;� $ " # � � ' ! � *)#%�.� ; � � � �$��� � �$*)��# � � % � �-� ��� � �$*)� "��#')(�6 � � � �+*)� ( � " �$�-'.#*�(' ! # " �$'$#7� % ��#%� � ;

/ ?7TUC�MOH(1 ? � :Q<>= � � =AC�DEVZHIM �9: HI:�DJ@A:�DEVZH(1 � @(@�?�VAD�HI:�DE?7M . � ' � -�*�* � � 'XcO' � 'Sc(*-.��#%)� � �>� � � ;� $ � # � ' � � 6*!�� � 6 6*� ��' ; � M � M>:�C(?�NIT>VA:�DE?7M :�? ��H(<S=(@AD�HIM � M � =ACF=AM!V(=�DQM � V(?7M!?�� =A:�CADEV(@ ; � � � �-'?�

� � '$#%� 4 ��' @ % � 6 # " *)# ��4 � � ')(�� � . ��� � � ;