30
Emory S. De Castro E-TEK division, De Nora N.A., Inc. May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04 through May ’05 DE-FC04-02AL67606 This presentation does not contain any proprietary or confidential information DE NORA NORTH AMERICA, Inc. GRUPPO DE NORA Durantes Vincunt 1 FC2

Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

Emory S. De CastroE-TEK division, De Nora N.A., Inc.

May 2005

DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review“Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs”

Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04 through May ’05

DE-FC04-02AL67606

This presentation does not contain any proprietary or confidential information

DE NORA NORTH AMERICA, Inc.GRUPPO DE NORA

Durantes Vincunt

1FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

FC2

Page 2: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

OverviewTimeline• Project start: 1 Oct ’01

(2 Jan 02)• Project end: 30 June ’06• Hi T membrane extended Oct 05• Percent complete ~75%

DOE Technical BarriersO. Stack Material and Manufacturing Cost P. DurabilityQ. Electrode PerformanceR. Thermal and Water Management

DOE Technical Targets(consistent with FreedomCar)

• PM loading 2005: 0.6g/ rated kW• PM Loading 2010: 0.2g/rated kW• >2000 hrs life (2005)• >5000 hrs life (2010)• Target achieved using method

amenable to Mass manufacture: <$125/kWe 2005; <$45/kWe 2010

• High Temperature Membrane– All of the above and– Contributes significantly to

achieving System efficiency targets

Budget• Total project

funding:$19.5M– DOE : $14.5M– Contractors: $5M

• Funding FY04:$2.73M• Funding for FY05:$4.64M

DOE Review May 2005 2FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Page 3: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 3FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Objectives

1A1: catalyst and structures• New cathode alloys

1A2: Hi T Membrane• Operates sub-ambient to 120 °C

and 25% to 100% RH• Memb. resistance ≤ 0.1 ohm cm2

• Hydrolytic, oxidative, mechanical stability in FC at 120 °C

• No leachable components• H2 fuel permeation ≤ than 5 mA/cm2

• Cost ≤ Nafion®

and ELAT structures that allow an overall cell performance of greater or equal to 0.4A/cm2 at 0.8V or 0.1A/cm2 at 0.85V operating on hydrogen/air with precious metal loadings of 0.3mg/cm2 or less and scales to mass manufacturing technology.

• Support 1A2 with high temp interface and/or GDL structure.

1A3: MEA Fab for Stack Scale• Take advances from 1A1 and/or

1A2 and integrate into pilot manufacturing

• Demonstrate stack scale elements operating with performance consistent with objectives of 1A1 or 1A2

2004/2005 Objectives• 1A1: cited performance at 0.4mg/cm2

using fg-ELAT: transfer to machine fabrication: continue to lower PM, develop high temp interface for A2 materials

• 1A2: single cell testing of HT membrane, evaluate properties at <0oC, begin scale up of advanced membranes

• 1A3: scale-up of 1A1 components; testing at stack scale

Page 4: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 4FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Team Members responsible for objectives of low precious metal MEAs:

NFCDeliverable: testing of short stacksContaining reference and low PM

MEAs as well as operational protocols

E-TEK (De Nora)Deliverable: Low PM MEAs (5 layer) for short stacks

Containing sub-builds, full builds, as well as reference materials

NEU (Prof. Mukergee)Deliverable: durability profile and

failure mechanism of low PM load MEAs (IBAD and ink based)

CWRU (Prof. Zawodzinski)Deliverable: porosity and

hydrophobicity targets to guide fabrication of low PM MEAs through

modeling of fg-ELAT

Spire BiomedicalDeliverable: coating services for ulra-low loaded

MEAs (IBAD) including batch and roll processingCWRU=Case Western Reserve UniversityNEU=Northeastern UniversityIBAD=Ion Beam Assisted Deposition

Page 5: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 5FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Approach: Catalyst and Fine Gradient ELAT®• Catalyst: create structure-function relationships supported by Reitveld analysis of

XRD patterns; develop/optimize new prep methods for catalysts and alloys: now in scale-up and durability phase

• GDL/GDE: Develop a new ELAT gas diffusion layer and/or electrode structure based on fine gradients of hydrophobicity and porosity using developmental coating machine– Current focus on machine implementation, and extending approach w

machine– Methodology for fine gradient approach:

Ink preparation parameters

Web properties

Coating parametersGDL/GDE Structure

FC Performance & characterization

Carbon typeParticle sizeAdditives Rheology

Paper and ClothMachine settings

Flow poreGurley No.ConductivityHydrophobicity meas.

Scale to stack

Page 6: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 6FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Catalyst Activities: Durability and scale up

Impact of alloy structure and H2O2 production (Rotating Ring Disk Electrode to detect H2O2 formation)

Peroxide Yield Comparison Pt Etek 30% vs Pt Cr in Sulfuric Acid

E (V) vs RHE

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

x H

2O2

0.00

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.10

E (V) RHE 900 vs x H2O2 Pt Etek 30% Col 4 vs x H2O2 PtCr HT 001 Col 7 vs x H2O2 PtCr HT 004

≅ 5.6%

≅ 1.8%

Having established good activity in 2004, now focused on stability

Have scaled alloy to 1Kg, final qualification goal is 3Kg

Page 7: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 7FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Tools to help build the fine gradient: Method to measure Hydrophobicity -Contact angle and solid surface energy being developed at CWRU

Cobb Titration at E-TEK division

Sample thetaH2Ogammas gammas

d gammasp

30% PTFE, carbon 1 89 ± 3 21 ± 2 13 ± 1 8 ± 2

70% PTFE,carbon 1 101 ± 3 17 ± 1 13.8 ± 0.8 3.1 ± 0.8

30% PTFE,carbon 2 88 ± 7 22 ± 4 14 ± 2 8 ± 3

70% PTFE,carbon 2 96 ± 7 19 ± 3 14 ± 2 4 ± 2

• CWRU uses Washburn method with hexane (wetting) and water to measure internal contact angle and surface energy

Krüss Processor TensiometerElectronic Balance

Test Liquid

Screw Motor

GDL

Sample Holder

Internal Contact Angle to Water theta H2O, GDL Surface Energy gamma s, and its Dispersive and Polar Components gamma sd and gamma sp

COBB TEST: Simple GDL, no gradient

0

0 . 1

0 . 2

0 . 3

0 . 4

0 . 5

0 . 6

2 0 3 0 4 0 5 0 6 0 7 0 8 0% ETHANOL

WT

GA

IN, g

/100

cm2

70% PTFE, Carbon 2

60% PTFE, Carbon 2

55% PTFE, Carbon 2

Team verified earlier Cobb results with tensiometerHowever, previous Cobb method

unable to discriminate a delta of <10% PTFEModified the solvent: can measure

<5% delta PTFEPlan to extend method to gdl

durability tests

“Cobb Titration”

Page 8: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 8FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Comparison of alloy fg ELAT intermediate build Somerset lab cell vs. Nuvera 225 cm2

1.5BarA (150kPa) air/H2, 70 Deg C

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2

Somerset Lab Cell Test, alloy fg ELATintermediate build, 0.40 mg/cm2 Pt

Cambridge Nuvera 225 cm2 Cell Stack, alloyfg-ELAT intermediate build 0.63 mg/cm2 Pt

Volts

Current, A/cm2

Stack scale fg-ELAT constructed by machine and hand steps: supper-scaling at under 0.6A/cm2

Fine gradient ELAT

fg-ELAT, all machine1) fg-ELAT MEA DOE T and P, 1mg/cm2 PM2) fg-ELAT MEA 70 deg C, 1mg/cm2 PM3) Commercial MEA 70 deg C, 1mg/cm2 PMfg-ELAT MEA at DOE T and P with

0.39mg/cm2 PM (0.28mg Pt cat. alloy, 0.11mg Pt anode) results in 0.86V at 0.1A/cm2 and 0.8V at 0.4A/cm2 – interim goal achieved

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.0

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0

Current Density / A/cm2

Pote

ntia

l / V

(2) fg-ELAT 1mg/cm2 70C 150kPa

(1) fg-ELAT 1mg/cm2 80C,250kPa

(3) Commercial Benchmark 1mg/cm2 70C 150kPa

Page 9: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 9FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Summary of “paper” progress to date: started base build

Cathode/Anode: air/H2 150kPa(1.5 Bar A), 70OC; Cell: 70OC, Lynntech CCM

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1.00.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6

Current Density / A/cm2

Pote

ntia

l / V commercial standard

CCM and paper GDL

base build for fg ELAT gdllynntech CCM

Commercial paper GDLlynntech CCM

All “standard” 3rd party electrode (CCM) structuresAll PM loadings are high (~1mg/cm2 total PM)Very encouraging performance for fg sub buildAccomplished through extensive changes in formulation and

coating variables compared to carbon cloth woven web

Page 10: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 10FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

High Temperature Interface with Membrane (V) Du Pont

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2

Current Density (Amp/cm2)

Cel

l Vol

tage

(V) R.H.=40%

R.H.=30%

R.H.=25%Dry

Uncertainty on R.H. ± 3%

Standard Gradient/machine madeFocused effort on formulation and fabrication

variables (hand fab interface, machine GDE)Demonstrated >1500 hrs with membrane V

under accelerated aging protocol (2003/2004)EXCEEDS POWER GOAL AT 30% RH

Experimental conditions:MEA:

A) Total (cathode and anode) PM = 1 mg/cm2

B) Electrode: HT140E-WC) Ionomer Interface: ProprietaryD) Membrane: DuPont Membrane V

Cell:A) R.H. = 25% to 40%B) Gases: Air (Cathode) and H2 (Anode)C) Cell Temperature: 120 oCD) Total Pressure: 2.0 AtmNOTE:

The R.H. was measured at the cathodic and anodic gas inlets usinga digital relative humidity sensor (Tech-Edge, Inc.).

Page 11: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 11FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Dual Ion Beam Assisted Deposition

Breakthrough in approach: can make 3d structures with ion beam. Improvement in mass transport

(~0.14 mg/cm2 total Pt below)

Structural Changes vis IBAD @ DOE STD

0.000

0.200

0.400

0.600

0.800

1.000

1.200

0.000 0.200 0.400 0.600 0.800 1.000 1.200

Current Density (Amp/cm 2)

Cel

l Vol

tage

(V)

StructureA IBAD 750

StructureB IBAD 750

StructureC IBAD 750

StructureD IBAD 750

StructureE IBAD 750

StructureF IBAD 750

0.50099.1LT140-E ELAT Reference

0.14279.6IBAD1500 Structure A

0.07170.9IBAD750 Structure A

0.10234.6IBAD STD 750

0.07823.8IBAD550

0.03426.3IBAD250

Loadings(mg/cm2)

Real Surface Area

(cm2/cm2)Sample

Electrochemical Surface Area Measured with fully flooded GDEs, H2 wave, and cyclic voltammetry

Page 12: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

Pt Skin-effect catalysts with IBAD

• Use IBAD to create multi-layer structures such as depositing Co, Cr, Ni, or Ag first, and then covering with a thin layer of Pt (which then contacts the membrane)

• Can also use new beam-created structures on the multi-layered catalysts• According to XRD, these are not alloys• Preliminary stability acceptable: will continue detailed durability at NEU• Pt:Co “Pattern A” total PM is 110 ug/cm2

• Standard gradient ELAT® employed as substrate

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9

Current Density (A/cm2)

Cel

l Vol

tage

(V)

Pt-CoPt-Co Pattern APt-CrPt-Cr Pattern AIBAD550 Std.

Naf

ion

112

Mem

bran

e

Gue

st M

etal

(Co,

Cr,

Ag

or N

i;)H

ost M

etal

(Pt;)

Hos

t Met

al (P

t;)

LT14

00

LT14

00+ -

DOE standard conditions (80oC, 250kPa) H2/air

DOE Review May 2005 12FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Page 13: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 13FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Comparison of “IBAD”, best fg-ELAT, and start-of-program benchmark: total PM/ power vs. V in“GM” format

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2Current Density/ A/cm2

Cell

Volta

ge,V

Historical Comparison of IBAD results, at DOE Standard Conditions

gPt/kW at 80oC, 250kAa total (2.5BarA), H2/Air

Pt IBAD deposition on anode and cathode Air H2 250kPa total (2.5BarA), 80oC Nafion 112

Significant gains in performance realized through new cathode structures created by ion beam. Showing capability for higher currents as well.

Total Pt loadingELAT benchmark: 1mg/cm2

fg-ELAT: 0.39mg/cm2

IBAD/ELAT: 0.17mg/cm2

“improved over initial”Merit Review May 0480ug/cm2

FreedomCarJuly 04100ug/cm2

Q4,’04 Review170ug/cm2

0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

3.00

3.50

4.00

0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9

ELAT, benchmark

fg-ELAT 05

IBAD 2005

2005 Goal

2010 Goal

Volts

g/kW

Page 14: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 14FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Responses to Reviewers • Improvements should be benchmarked against commercially available

components, not necessarily internal or start of program benchmarks– Have shown some examples within this presentation, although obtaining

commercial benchmark data at different operating conditions can be difficult– We have also approached third parties to provide comparative data for these

new components versus commercial benchmarks. The effort is on-going.• IBAD approach may be limited in these assemblies’ capability to achieve

high current – especially beyond the quarter power goal of this program– The recent breakthrough has allowed a substantial improvement in higher

current operation: however, we now need to “reinvent” the GDL to respond to this unique interface for improved water management

• Efforts on the fabrication of electrodes for the high temperature membranes of Du Pont should be increased

– 2003/2004 saw limited quantities of samples: however, improvements by the DuPont team in solving materials issues in making membranes has provided more material for 2004/2005. We expect some of the understanding learned from making an interface/electrode for Membrane V may be applicable to the other new materials being developed by Du Pont. Electrode assembly with new membrane materials is a key focus for 2005/2006, as well as scaling Membrane V assemblies to stack scale.

Page 15: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 15FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Accomplishments/Progress• The team continued to increase power and reduce PM loading

– Met interim goal of 0.8V at 0.4A/cm2 and greater than 0.85V 0.1A/cm2 at DOE test conditions with under 0.4 mg Pt/cm2 total using coating technology suitable for mass manufacturing

• Implementation of fg-ELAT approach on non-woven materials begun: outstanding results with baseline structures may provide a path to achieving final power/PM goals

• Strategy for introducing designed structures for IBAD based fabrications continues to show improvements in power and mass transport at higher currents while approaching 2010 PM loading targets: new approach is subject to a patent application. Realized catalytic activity with layered metal structures

• Have shown first generation high temperature interface capable of approaching DOE power goal with Du Pont’s modified membrane (“Membrane V”)

• Developed much-needed methods to quantitatively measure hydrophobicity for GDL materials. Although initially used to design fine gradient ELAT, these methods will have utility in durability studies

• Began baseline 1,000 hr constant current durability operation

Page 16: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 16FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Next Steps• Reduce PM loading to 0.3mg/cm2 and scale results to stack level

– optimize fg-ELAT approach through structure refinement and machine practices

– develop fg-ELAT on non-woven web– Use next generation CWRU/CAPI modeling to guide structure design

• Catalyst– Scale up prep for improved alloys: 3Kg target– Continue ex-situ lifetime tests; post-mortem MEA/catalyst analysis

• Ultra-low PM loading (IBAD)– Develop new GDL structures tailored to the unique IBAD “Pt-layered”

interface to realize full catalytic potential of these new materials– Lifetime/durability analysis of IBAD structures (at NEU)– Transition to continuous coating

• Durability– Develop durability protocol and methods at stack level (NFC)

• Refine to incorporate at single cell scale at E-TEK– Using new hydrophobicity measurements, analyze fine gradient sub builds

under forced aging regimes for change in hydrophobicity– Durability testing of machine made fine gradient ELAT MEAs

Page 17: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 17FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Program 1A2: High Temperature Membrane General Approach

Evaluate small molecule electrolytes

Start

End

Synthesize monomers e.g. H, M, Y Synthesize monomers AE, Z Class

Synthesize Polymers

Evaluate Conductivity

Evaluate Thermal Stability & Swelling

Fabricate membranes

HT FC Testing e.g. Nafion® and inorganic composites

Program officially ended Oct 2004: however encouraging advances in new classes of polyelectrolytes justified an extension of one year for DuPont’s activities. Programs for the other team members were accordingly.

Page 18: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

Team Members responsible for objectives of high temperature MEAs:

NFCDeliverable: testing of short stacks

Containing reference and high temperatureMEAs as well as operation protocol

E-TEK (De Nora)Deliverable: High T MEAs (5 layer) for short stacks Containing high temperature interface as well as

reference materials

DOE Review May 2005 18FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Du PontDeliverable: at least two types of high temperature membranes

Enough of one for stack level testing

CWRU (Prof. Litt)Deliverable: High T membrane Structures

and synthesis for materials fulfilling “ uncollapsible hydrophilic domains”

CWRU (Prof. Zawodzinski)Deliverable: porosity and

hydrophobicity targets to guide fabrication of high temp interface

NEU (Prof. Mukergee)Deliverable: 1. durability profile

of “ultra low” PM load MEAs (IBAD) at Hi T

2. durability profile of High Temp Interface

CWRU=Case Western Reserve UniversityNEU=Northeastern UniversityIBAD=Ion Beam Assisted Deposition

Page 19: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 19FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

1A2 High Temperature Membrane

Past year focused on 3 technology options:

Polymer Type Features

Candidate V Per-fluorinated composite membrane

FC lifetime at 120 C increased vs Nafion®; similar conductivity

Candidate BA Partially fluorinated composite membrane

Increased conductivity vs Nafion®

AE - type

AE: perfluorinatedDesign & synthesis of

partially fluorinated polymers

AE: Best conductivity (73 mS/cm 25%RH), thermal & chem. stability. Challenge to insolubilize & strengthen

Page 20: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 20FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

High Temperature Membrane: Focus areas for 04/05

Conductiveat Low RHAF, AK,

BB, AY, AX

Thermally StablePBI, Teflon®

Polyelectrolyte InsolubleReasonable Swelling Mechanical Strength

Y, AZ

AO

AE

Nafion®,V, BG

BA

Additional dimensions:Chem. & oxid. stabilityLow-T conductivity (new)H2 permeationCostFC durability….

?

04/05 Focus

Page 21: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 21FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Candidate V

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2.0

0 500 1000Time (hr)

Cur

rent

(A/c

m2)

0.750

0.770

0.790

0.810

0.830

0.850

0.870

0.890

0.910

0.930

0.950Life Test Candidate V 40um

OC

V (V

olts

)

Clean clogged filter on humidifier

70% RH

25% RH

F5570

OCV

120 oC H2/air 21 psig 25 cm2 active areaConst. flow = stoic 2/2 anode/cath. @ 1.2 A/cm2

Triple cycle: 1) 10 min OCV 70/70 %RH 2) 5hr 0.5V 70/70 %RH3) 5hr 0.5V 25/25 %RH

• Properties similar to Nafion®:– Conductivity, strength, swelling, H2

permeation• Properties superior to Nafion®:

– Fenton test chemical stability– Lifetime in FC

• Life tests at 120 oC show cycling feeds to lower RH accelerates membrane degradation.– New protocol cycling to 25% RH– More aggressive than pervious

cycling to 40% RH– 1000 hr life test Candidate V

• Membrane scaled-up to size for 250 cm2 short stack; Delivered 17 membranes to De Nora

• Future V work: Increase strength & decrease swelling

Page 22: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 22FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Progress BA Membrane

Isothermal TGA 150 oC air + 0.5% RH

87

89

91

93

95

0 500 1000time (min)

wei

ght (

%)

BA 14X reduced impurity

Nafion(R) N112

BA 200X reduced impurity

-0.0079 %/hr

-0.0070 %/hr

• Thermal stability of BA membrane significantly improved

• Thermal decomposition dominated by weak-link impurity– ‘04 Focus: Identify impurity,

decrease impurity

• BA membrane with weak links decreased to 1/200 of original– Thermal stability similar to

Nafion®

Page 23: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 23FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Low-RH Conductivity

Condutivity @ 120 oC 25%RH

05

101520253035404550

0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0IEC (meq/g)

Con

duct

ivity

(mS/

cm)

Nafion N117BA

• Conductivities– BA membranes with high IEC– Up to 45 mS/cm @ 120 0C, 25%

RH– Can still be boiled in water

• Mechanical properties– Poor for IEC above 1.7 meq/g in

current BA membranes• IEC in the range of 1.3 to 1.6

meq/g– 2X to 2.5X conductivity of Nafion®– Maintains mechanical properties– Swelling 62% water uptake

• @1.6 IEC• 100 0C water → 22 0C vacuum

Page 24: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 24FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Low-Temperature Conductivity

-2.6-2.4-2.2-2.0-1.8-1.6-1.4-1.2-1.0-0.8-0.6-0.4

-45 -35 -25 -15 -5 5 15 25Temperature (deg. C)

log(

Con

duct

ivity

S/c

m)

Nafion® NRE212 temp downNafion® NRE212 temp upBA 1.7 IEC temp downBA 1.7 IEC temp up

• New measurement method gives low hysterisis between 0 oC and -40 oC– 4-point probe of initially-wet

membrane cooled/heated in cryo GC

• BA membrane maintains significant advantage over Nafion® only to -20 oC

• At -40 oC, both membranes have similar conductivity

• Due to BA having many of the membrane properties, and good relative conductivity over a wide range of temperatures, the High Temperature Membrane Program was extended

Page 25: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 25FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

FC Performance BA vs N112

0.40

0.45

0.50

0.55

0.60

0.65

0.70

0.75

0.80

0.85

0.90

0.95

0.00 0.25 0.50 0.75 1.00 1.25

Current Density (A/cm2)

Cel

l Vol

tage

(V)

N112 70%RHN112 25%RHBA 70%RHBA 25%RH

F5491F5658

120 oC H2/air 250 kPa25 cm2 GDE• BA membrane

– 53 µm thick– Similar to Nafion® N112

thickness• Superior performance to N112

at low RH.– Even though electrodes are still

PFSA• Future work on BA

– Deliver samples to De Nora– Reduce wrinkles & swelling– Increase FC durability– Will ultimately need also

electrodes based on BA or other adv. electrolyte to deliver MEA performance

Page 26: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

AE Type• Immobilization strategy identified for AE-type polymer• New monomers and partially fluorinated copolymer

synthesized - Candidate BL– Succeed in obtaining high MW and tough membrane

• Mw 124,000, IV 3.5– Membrane is insoluble in room-temp water, soluble in hot water

• Partially success on immobilization (make insoluble)• Melting of polymer, Tm 126 oC (76 J/g), needs to be raised

– Monomer chemistry compromised stability & conductivity• Thermal stability, Tonset 228 oC (too low to be practical)• Conductivity 360 mS/cm @95%RH 80C, only 0.2 mS/cm @25%RH

• Future AE work: Strategies identified to increase thermal stability, melting point, and conductivity– Monomer syntheses begun

DOE Review May 2005 26FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Page 27: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 27FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

AcknowledgementsNortheastern University• Prof. Sanjeev Mukerjee• Robert J. Allen (E-TEK) Distinguished

Visiting Scientist• Andrea F. Gullá (E-TEK), Ph.D.• Basker Veeraraghavan, Ph.D.

(Postdoctoral Fellow) • Madhusudan Saha, Ph.D.

(Postdoctoral fellow)• Vivek Srinivasamurthi (Ph.D.

candidate)• Kartikeyan Ramamoorthi (Ph.D.

candidate)

De Nora N.A. E-TEK div

• Yu-Min Tsou, Ph.D.• Lixin Cao, Ph.D.• Hua Deng, MS, ChE• Chien Hou• Michael Schneider• Maria Cayetano• Jeffrey Morse• Laura Bellamy

DuPont• Mark Roelofs, Ph.D

(Project Leader)• R. Dan Lousenberg, Ph.D.• Mark Teasley, Ph.D.• Zhen-yu Yang, Ph.D.• Rosa Ruiz-Alsop, Ph.D.• John J. Borowski• Robin Blackburn• David Lilly• Charles Wheeler

Case Western Reserve U.• Prof. Morton Litt• Casey Check (Graduate

Student)

Spire BiomedicalNadar Kalkhoran, Ph.D.Jason Burns

DE NORA NORTH AMERICA, Inc.GRUPPO DE NORA

Durantes Vincunt

CWRU/CAPITom Zawodzinski, Ph.D.Vladimir Gurau, Ph.D.

NFCOlga PolevayaStack Testing Team

Page 28: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 28FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Publications and PresentationsBy CWRU• M. Bluemle, V. Gurau, J. A. Mann, T. A. Zawodzinski Jr., E. S. De Castro, Y. M. Tsou: “Characterization of

Transport Properties In Gas Diffusion Layers for PEMFCs”, 206th Meeting of Electrochem. Soc., Honolulu, Ha, October 2-8, 2004

• M. Bluemle, V. Gurau, J. A. Mann, T. A. Zawodzinski Jr., E. S. De Castro, Y. M. Tsou: “Permeability and Wettability Measurements for Gas Diffusion Layers for PEM Fuel Cells”, 2004 Fuel Cell Seminar. San Antonio, TX, November 1-5, 2004

By E-TEK• Hua Deng, Qingzhi Guo; Maria Cayetano; Yu-Min Tsou; Emory Sayre De Castro, "An Investigation of Ionic

Conductivity of the PEMFC by AC Impedance Spectroscopy", Meeting of Electrochem. Soc., Honolulu, Ha, October 2-8, 2004

• Yu-Min Tsou, Lixin Cao, Emory De Castro “High Performance Oxygen Reduction Catalyst For PEM and DMFC Fuel Cells”Meeting of Electrochem. Soc., San Antonio, Tx May, 2004

• Emory S. De Castro, Yu-Min Tsou, Lixin Cao and Chien Hou “Approaches for low cost components and MEAs for PEFCs: current and future directions”, Fuel Cell Seminar, San Antonio, Nov, 2004

• Emory S. De Castro, “New Nano-Catalysts and Reduction of Component Costs for Portable Fuel Cells”, Small Fuel Cells, Arlington, Va., April 2004

By NEU• 'High Performance Electrode with very Low Pt Loading Prepared by Dual Ion Beam Assisted

Deposition in PEM Fuel Cells' M. S. Saha, S. Mukerjee, A. F. Gulla and R. J. Allen' Extended Abstracts for the Meeting of the Electrochemical Society to be held in Quebec, Canada, May 2005.

• 'Dual Ion Beam Assisted Deposition as a Method to Obtain Low Loading-High Performance Electrodes for Proton Exchange Membrane Fuel Cells', A. F. Gulla, M. S. Saha, R. J. Allen and S. Mukerjee, Electrochemical and Solid State Letters, (Submitted)

• 'Oxygen Reduction and Transport Characteristics at a Platinum and Alternative Proton Conducting Membrane Interface' L. Zhang, C. Ma and S. Mukerjee, J. Electroanalytical Chemistry 58, 273 (2004).

Page 29: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

DOE Review May 2005 29FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera

Hydrogen Safety

The most significant hydrogen hazard associated with this project is: Testing single cells or short stacks at higher temperature with novel membrane materials

pinholes/cross over at the higher temperatures may lead to more catastrophic consequences

Page 30: Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs · May 2005 DOE Hydrogen and FC Program Review “Integrated Manufacturing for Advanced MEAs” Topics 1.A.1, 1.A.2 and 1.A.3 June ’04

Hydrogen Safety• Our approach to deal with this hazard is:

– Stations in ventilated enclosures with 3 levels of hydrogen detection & interlocks.

H2 Detector“Open Space”

around test station

plumbing

All fuel cell hardware contained within ventilated enclosure

DOE Review May 2005 30FC2 De Nora - Du Pont - Nuvera