50
1 The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & Compact City: Singapore’s Experience Compact City: Singapore’s Experience World Bank, Washington DC 7 October 2010 Presenter: WONG Kai Yeng Urban Redevelopment Authority, Singapore

Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

1The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & Compact City: Singapore’s ExperienceCompact City: Singapore’s Experience

World Bank, Washington DC7 October 2010

Presenter: WONG Kai YengUrban Redevelopment Authority, Singapore

Page 2: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

2The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Singapore TodaySingapore Today

View of the Central Business District

Page 3: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

3The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

1960s: Severe Housing Problems

• Acute housing shortage: 25% of population lived on 1% of land

• Poor living conditions

Housing conditions in the city Overcrowding within each housing unit

Page 4: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

4The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

High Unemployment Rate

1960s: Lack of Jobs & Poor Infrastructure

Poor Infrastructure

Page 5: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

5The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Population and DensityPopulation and DensityPopulation Growth over the YearsPopulation Growth over the YearsPopulation Growth over the YearsPo

pulation

 (‘00

0)

0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010

Year

Singapore’s Population Size

Increase of 1 million people every 10 years since 1990

Popu

lation

 (‘00

0)

Page 6: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

6The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Singapore on the World MapSingapore on the World Map

Singapore

Page 7: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

7The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

9

23 km

43 km

Land Area: 710 km2

Population: 5.08 millionDensity: 7000 pple/km2

Page 8: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

8The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

0

2,000

4,000

6,000

8,000

10,000

12,000

14,000

0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000

Singapore’s Density in Relation to Other CitiesSingapore’s Density in Relation to Other CitiesPo

pulation

(‘000)

Density(no. of people per km2)

Population & Density Comparison

Singapore

ParisTokyo

Hong Kong

New York

Page 9: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

9The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Our LimitationsOur Limitations

• • Small City-State

• Limited land area

• No hinterland

• No natural resources

Page 10: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

10The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Urban Redevelopment Authority:Singapore’s National Land Use Planning Authority

Mission: To make Singapore a Great Place to Live, Work & Play in

Page 11: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

11The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

The Planning Process

PlanningPlanning

ImplementationImplementation

Concept PlanConcept Plan

Master PlanMaster Plan

Land SalesLand Sales Development Development ControlControl

Concept PlanConcept Plan

Page 12: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

12The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Concept Plan• Strategic and Long Term Plan• To ensure that there is sufficient land for the future

Concept Plan 2001Concept Plan 2001

Page 13: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

13The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Integrated Planning: Multi‐Agency Effort

Page 14: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

14The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Concept Plan:Concept Plan:Balancing 

Competing Land Use Needs

Indus

Housing

Industry Water treatment & storage

Culture and Heritage

Nature and GreeneryCommerce

Page 15: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

15The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

SUSTAINABILITY

ECONOMIC

SOCIALENVIRONMENTAL

Concept Plan: Planning for Sustainability

Page 16: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

16The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Concept PlanConcept Plan

Master PlanMaster Plan

The Planning Process

Land SalesLand Sales Development Development ControlControl

Master PlanMaster Plan

Page 17: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

17The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Master Plan

Master Plan 2008Master Plan 2008

Page 18: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

18The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

• Shows permissible land use & density

• Detailed & transparent

• Review every 5 years

Master Plan: Statutory Land Use Plan 

Page 19: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

19The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Master Plan: Economizing on Land Use 

Marine Parade Community ClubMarine Parade Community Club houses different users and tenants which would usually be sited separately

Sports Hall

Gymnasium

Popular Coffee Joint

263-seat Theatrette

Rooftop Basketball Court

Public Library

CoCo‐‐Location and IntegrationLocation and Integration

Community Club

Page 20: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

20The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

PRE-PLANNED CHAMBERFUTURE RECLAMATION

SEAWALL

Master Plan: Economizing on Land Use

Stormwater Collection Pond integrated with a Secondary School

CoCo‐‐Location and IntegrationLocation and Integration

Page 21: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

21The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Deep Tunnel Sewerage System Deep Tunnel Sewerage System (DTSS)(DTSS)

• One main water reclamation plant

• Frees up land previously occupied by smaller plants and pumping stations

Master Plan: Economizing on Land Use

Page 22: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

22The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

• Underground rock caverns for storage or utility purposes

Caverns inside or under mountains

Master Plan: Economizing on Land Use

Use of Underground SpaceUse of Underground Space

Illustration of the Underground Storage Cavern by the Straits Times

Oil and gas storage

Page 23: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

23The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Concept PlanConcept Plan

Master PlanMaster Plan

The Planning Process

Land SalesLand Sales Development Development ControlControlLand SalesLand Sales

Page 24: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

24The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

• Helps realise planning intentions

• Meet market demand for residential, commercial and industrial developments

• Private‐Public Partnership

Government Land Sales

Page 25: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

25The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Concept PlanConcept Plan

Master PlanMaster Plan

The Planning Process

Land SalesLand Sales Development Development ControlControl

Development Development ControlControl

Page 26: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

26The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

• Ensure land and buildings are developed according to planning intentions of the Master Plan

• Evaluate planning submissions and grant planning approvals

• Transparent and clear guidelines

Development Control

Page 27: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

27The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

• Focus Group Sessions

• Public Forums

• Exhibitions

• E‐Consultation

Public Consultation as a part of Planning Process

Page 28: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

28The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Planning Principles and Strategies

• Integrated Land Use & Transport Planning

• A Compact & Transit‐Oriented City

• Planning for a Good Quality Living Environment

• Creating a Vibrant City to Support Growth

• Towards a City‐in‐a‐Garden

• Conserving our Built Heritage

Page 29: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

29The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

• Planning for land use and transport networks done together

• Clustering high‐density developments around public transport nodes

Integrated Land Use and Transport Planning

Tampines Regional Centre in the east

Page 30: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

30The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

High Density Developments Around Major NodesHigh Density Developments Around Major Nodes

A Compact and Transit‐Oriented City

Amenities Close to HousingAmenities Close to Housing

Schools within walking Schools within walking distance to homesdistance to homes

Page 31: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

31The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

NEL

NSL

EWL

East

North

West

North-East

Central Region

Downtown Line

North-South Line Extension

Thomson Line

Eastern Region LineTuas Extension

Circle Line

Existing Lines

In Progress

By 2020

Extending Singapore’s Metro Network

Source: Land Transport Authority

Page 32: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

32The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

High-rise Public Housing Attractive Waterfront Housing

Planning for a Good Quality Living Environment

Private Landed Housing Medium-rise Private Condominiums

• Providing a Variety of Housing Types• > 90% home ownership

Page 33: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

33The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Planning for a Good Quality Living Environment

• > 80% live in public housing

• 23 New Towns

• Building Homes, Shaping Communities 

50-storey public housing

Scenic waterway through a public housing estate

Source: HDB

Page 34: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

34The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Bayfront today Central Business DistrictMarina Centre – Convention/Hotel Hub

Marina Bay: Marina Bay: Seamless Growth of the City CentreSeamless Growth of the City Centre

Creating a Vibrant City Centre to Support Growth

Page 35: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

35The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Events to Activate the Bay

F1 Grand Prix

New Year Countdown Sporting EventsYouth Olympic Games

Page 36: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

36The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

• 1967 Garden City Movement

• Creating spaces of relief and enjoyment in a high density environment

The Greening of Singapore

Page 37: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

37The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Garden City to a City‐in‐a‐Garden

Page 38: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

38The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Park Connectors

• Connectors to link parks and green spaces

Page 39: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

39The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

NEW PARK CONNECTORS

EXISTING PARK CONNECTORS

ROUND ISLAND LOOP

Park Connector Network

Page 40: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

40The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Protecting Our Biodiversity

Page 41: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

41The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Conserving Our Built Heritage

Page 42: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

42The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

• 3 Historic Districts• > 90 Conservation Areas• 7000 Conserved Buildings

Page 43: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

43The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

NEWater Plant

Water Resource Management• Shortage of drinking water supply• 4 National Taps to provide adequate clean water supply

• 100% sewered

Deep Tunnel Sewerage System

Page 44: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

44The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Maintaining a Clean and Green Environment

• Household garbage collected daily

• Incineration of waste

• Encourage recycling

• Power generation

Integrated Waste Management

Page 45: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

45The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

• Strong Political Will and Support

• Long term planning

• Comprehensive Process from Planning through to Implementation

• Close co‐operation between Government Agencies

• Public buy‐in

Factors Facilitating Singapore’s Transformation

Page 46: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

46The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

53

Master Planning ProjectsMaster Planning Projects

• Work with foreign cities to provide advisory services on master planning projects– Suzhou Industrial Park, China

– Tianjin Eco‐city, China

– Durgapur Aerotropolis, West Bengal, India

– Royal Bafokeng Nation, South Africa

Sharing our Experiences

Page 47: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

47The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

54

Training ProgrammesTraining Programmes• Provide training courses for foreign government officials 

• Conducted in Singapore or in their home country

• 4‐day Integrated Land Use Planning

• Courses conducted for:– Lagos State Government, Nigeria– Nanjing Planning Bureau, China– African Nations under the Joint UNCRD, JICA & MFA programme– Abu Dhabi Municipal Councillors

Sharing our Experiences

Page 48: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

48The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

55

International Collaborations

SinoSino‐‐Singapore Singapore TianjinTianjin EcoEco‐‐citycity

• Government‐ Government collaboration project

• URA led the Singapore Master Planning team for the Eco‐city

Perspectives of the Tianjin Eco-city

Page 49: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

49The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

For more information, visit www.leekuanyewworldcity.com.sg

Biennial international award

Recognise individuals and organisations that have made outstanding contributions to the creation of vibrant, liveable and sustainable urban communities around the world 

Recognise individuals and organisationsresponsible for urban initiatives that display foresight, good governance or innovation in tackling urban challenges faced by cities

2010 Laureate: Bilbao City Hall

Page 50: Integrated Planning for a Sustainable City: Singapore’s ...siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTSDNET/Resources/Presentation1.pdf · Integrated Planning for a Sustainable & ... Master

50The slides are property of URA and should not be reproduced and redistributed without permission from URA

Thank YouThank You