Upload
miles-holland
View
223
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
International Atomic Energy Agency
Medical exposure in radiology:Medical exposure in radiology: Guidance or Reference Levels Guidance or Reference Levels
Module VIII.3 - Part 4: Guidance levels for the patients
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
2 International Atomic Energy Agency
IntroductionIntroduction
• In general, in medical exposure there are no dose limits or constraints
• Dose reference (DRL) or guidance levels are tools to optimize procedures and equipment use
• We will see how to establish them and give some examples of values and discuss their usefulness
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
3 International Atomic Energy Agency
TopicsTopics
1. Medical Exposure
2. Medical exposure framework and reference doses
3. Medical exposure dose constraints for comforters and in research
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
4 International Atomic Energy Agency
OverviewOverview
• Overview of types of radiation exposure
• Dose limits, dose constraints
• Justification and optimization
• Dose guidance/reference level definition
• How to establish them
• How to use them
• Examples of dose reference levels
International Atomic Energy Agency
Topic 1: Medical exposure Topic 1: Medical exposure framework and reference dosesframework and reference doses
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
6 International Atomic Energy Agency
Types of exposureTypes of exposure
• Medical Exposure:• principally the exposure of persons as part of their
diagnosis (or treatment)
• Occupational Exposure: • exposure incurred at work, and practically as a
result of work
• Public Exposure:• all other exposures
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
7 International Atomic Energy Agency
What is a medical exposure?What is a medical exposure?
• Exposure of persons as part of their diagnosis or treatment
• Additionally:• Exposures (other than occupational) incurred
knowingly and willingly by individuals such as family and close friends helping either in hospital or at home in the support and comfort of patients
• Exposures incurred by volunteers as part of a program of biomedical research
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
8 International Atomic Energy Agency
What is occupational exposure?What is occupational exposure?
All exposures of workers incurred in the course of their work.
[excepted the exposures excluded from the Standards (see Basic Safety Standards) and exposures from practices or sources exempted by the Standards]
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
9 International Atomic Energy Agency
What is exposure of the public?What is exposure of the public?
• ALL exposures not falling in the two other categories
• effective dose of 1mSv in a year
• in special circumstances, effective dose of 5mSv in a single year, provided that the average over five consecutive years in less than 1mSv per year
• equivalent dose to lens of the eye 15mSv in a year
• equivalent dose to skin of 50mSv in a year
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
10 International Atomic Energy Agency
Overview Dose limits (ICRP60)Overview Dose limits (ICRP60)
Occupational dose limit
Public dose limit
Effective dose20mSv/y, averaged
over 5 y1 mSv/y
Annual effective dose in:
Lens of eye 150mSv 15mSv
Skin 500mSv 50mSv
Hands and feet 500mSv -
International Atomic Energy Agency
Topic 2: Medical exposure Topic 2: Medical exposure framework and reference doses framework and reference doses
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
12 International Atomic Energy Agency
Question 1Question 1
• Mr. Sharp, I am given to understand that 2 CT examinations performed on me have given me 25 mSv whereas 20 mSv is the safe dose. I want to file legal suit against the doctor.
What do you feel ??
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
13 International Atomic Energy Agency
Question 2Question 2
My resident doctor has got 12 mSv in her last badge report as she was wearing the badge while getting her barium study. She wants off from radiation work.
?????
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
14 International Atomic Energy Agency
Medical exposure frameworkMedical exposure framework
• Justification
• Optimization
• The use of doses limits is NOT APPLICABLE
• As an aid to keep doses as low as reasonably achievable:
•Dose constraints and guidance (or reference) levels ARE RECOMMENDED
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
15 International Atomic Energy Agency
Justification: 3 levelsJustification: 3 levels
• General level:• Use of radiation in medicine is doing more good
than harm
• Generic level:• By national professional bodies
• Specific procedure with a specific objective: chest radiographs for patients showing relevant symptoms
• Individual level:• Application of the procedure to an individual patient
Review benefits and disadvantages !
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
16 International Atomic Energy Agency
Sharing responsibility: Sharing responsibility: the referring physicianthe referring physician
• A useful investigation is one in which the result —positive or negative — will alter management or add confidence to the clinician’s diagnosis.
• The chief causes of the wasteful use of radiology are:• Repeating investigations which have already been done
• Investigation when results are unlikely to affect patient management
• Doing the wrong investigation
• Failing to provide appropriate clinical information and questions that the imaging investigation should answer
• Doing the wrong investigation.
• The responsibility for patient dose is shared by the radiology department AND the referral physician
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
17 International Atomic Energy Agency
OptimizationOptimization
• Optimization is usually applied at two levels:
• The design and construction of equipment and installations
• Day to day radiological practice (procedures)
• The optimization means that doses should be “as low as reasonably achievable, economic and social factors being taken into account” compatible with achieving the required objective
• The optimization of protection in diagnostic radiology does not necessarily mean the reduction of doses to the patient (ex: antiscatter grid)
• Since no dose LIMITS, there is a need for indicator for optimization:
GUIDANCE LEVELS
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
18 International Atomic Energy Agency
What is a guidance or reference level?What is a guidance or reference level?
• A value of dose, dose rate or activity selected by professional bodies in consultation with the Regulatory Authority to indicate a level above which there should be a review by medical practitioners in order to determine whether or not the value is excessive, taking into account the particular circumstances and applying sound clinical judgment (BSS)
ORdose levels in medical radiodiagnostic practices for typical examinations for groups of standard-sized patients or standard phantoms for broadly defined types of equipment; these levels are expected not to be exceeded for standard procedures when good and normal practice regarding diagnostic and technical performance is applied (Med. Direct. EUR97/43)
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
19 International Atomic Energy Agency
Guidance levelsGuidance levels
The guidance levels are intended:
(a) to be a reasonable indication of doses for average sized patients
(b) to be established by relevant professional bodies in consultation with the local Regulatory Authority
(c) to provide guidance on what is achievable with current good practice rather than on what should be considered optimum performance
(d) to be applied with flexibility to allow higher exposures if these are indicated by sound clinical judgement
(e) to be revised as technology and techniques improve
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
20 International Atomic Energy Agency
Use of the dose reference levels (DRL)Use of the dose reference levels (DRL)
• Act as investigation levels, triggering a local investigation if typical dose for specific type of diagnostic procedure is found consistently to exceed the relevant DRL
• Simple test for identifying situations where patient doses are becoming unusually high and action is required
• Corrective action is compulsory: on the procedure, on the equipment,…
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
21 International Atomic Energy Agency
Other practical aspectsOther practical aspects
• Quantities used as guidance (or reference) levels should be understood by radiologists and radiographers (safety culture)
• DRL are not applicable to individual patients. Comparison with DRL shall be only made using mean values of a sample of patients
• DRL should be "flexible" (tolerances should be established: different patient sizes, different pathologies, etc). DRL are not a border line between good and bad medicine
• The main objective of DRL is their use in a dynamic and continuous process of optimization
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
22 International Atomic Energy Agency
How to set the DRL value?How to set the DRL value?
• Pragmatic: use the 3rd quartile value of wide scale surveys
• If 75% of X Ray depths can operate satisfactory BELOW
• The remaining 25% should be made aware of their less than optimum performance
• ICRP73 recommended that:“...initialDRL values be chosen as a percentile point on the observed distribution of dose to patients.”
• The “Nordic Guidance Levels for Patient Dose in Diagnostic Radiology” (1996) uses values closer to the mean value
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
23 International Atomic Energy Agency
When no surveys are available?When no surveys are available?
• Do not reinvent the wheel
• Regulating Authority/Professional body can adopt DRL’s from country with similar medical infrastructure
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
24 International Atomic Energy Agency
Why no LOWER level?Why no LOWER level?
• Examinations with very low exposure usually give not enough diagnostic information, why no lower limit?
• DRL checks forms part of QA program
• Such program will include more than dose criteria
• Including image quality and diagnostic efficacy
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
25 International Atomic Energy Agency
Dose quantities for monitoring ESD Dose quantities for monitoring ESD
• Conventional radiology
• ESD Entrance surface dose• TLD attached to skin where centre of X Ray beam
enters patient
• Or calculated from output measurements made in free air with ionization chamber during QA procedures corrected for backscatter (in radiology between 1.2-1.4)
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
26 International Atomic Energy Agency
Dose quantities for monitoring: DAPDose quantities for monitoring: DAP
• Conventional and fluoroscopy• DAP Dose area product meter
• Attached to diaphragm housing
• Total DAP value (radiography + fluoroscopy) can be read out per examination or as time sequence
• For fluoroscopy DRL are sometimes given in “Dose RATE Guidance Levels”
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
27 International Atomic Energy Agency
Dose quantities for monitoring: CTDose quantities for monitoring: CT
• Computed tomography• Weighted CTDI per CT
slice (analog to ESD)
• Dose-Length product per exam (analog to DAP)
• Multiple San Dose Average (MSAD)
• Can only be determined on phantoms, not on patients
Do
se
Nominal slice width
CTDI
Dose profile
MSAD
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
28 International Atomic Energy Agency
Examples of guidance levelsExamples of guidance levels
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
29 International Atomic Energy Agency
Guidance or reference levels for diagnostic Guidance or reference levels for diagnostic radiography (typical adult patient)radiography (typical adult patient)
1.5Chest LAT
0.4Chest PA
10Hip joint AP
10Pelvis AP
Entrance surface dose per radiograph (mGy)
Examination
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
30 International Atomic Energy Agency
Guidance or reference levels for diagnostic Guidance or reference levels for diagnostic radiography (typical adult patient)radiography (typical adult patient)
5Dental AP
7Dental peri-apical
20Thoracic spine LAT
7Thoracic spine AP
Entrance surface dose per radiograph (mGy)
Examination
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
31 International Atomic Energy Agency
Guidance or reference levels for diagnostic Guidance or reference levels for diagnostic radiography (typical adult patient)radiography (typical adult patient)
Dose values are in air with backscatter. They are for conventional film-screen combination (200 speed
class). For higher speed film-screen combinations (400-600), the values should be reduced by a factor of 2 to 3.
3Skull LAT
5Skull AP
Entrance surface dose per radiograph (mGy)
Examination
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
32 International Atomic Energy Agency
Dose guidance levels in CT Dose guidance levels in CT (typical adult patient)(typical adult patient)
(a) Derived from measurements on the axis of rotation in water equivalent phantoms, 15 cm in length and 16 cm (head) and 30 cm (lumbar spine and abdomen) in diameter.
25Abdomen
35Lumbar spine
50Head
Multiple scan average dose (mGy) (a)
Examination
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
33 International Atomic Energy Agency
Determined in a 4.5 cm compressed breast consisting of 50% glandular and 50% adipose tissue, for film-screen systems and dedicated Mo-target/Mo-filter
mammography units
1 mGy (without grid)
3 mGy (with grid)
Average glandular dose per craniocaudal projection
Dose guidance levels for Dose guidance levels for mammographymammography
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
34 International Atomic Energy Agency
Dose rate guidance levels for fluoroscopy Dose rate guidance levels for fluoroscopy (typical adult patient)(typical adult patient)
(a) In air with backscatter
(b) For fluoroscopes that have an optional 'high level' operational mode, such as those frequently used in interventional radiology
100High Level (b)
25Normal
Entrance surface dose rate (mGy/min) (a)
Operation Mode
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
35 International Atomic Energy Agency
DRL’s in Pediatrics, for standard five-year-old DRL’s in Pediatrics, for standard five-year-old patients, for single viewspatients, for single views
(from EUR-16261)(from EUR-16261)
Radiograph
5-year old patient.Reference Dose
Entrance Surface Doseper SINGLE VIEW. [µGy]
Chest Posterior Anterior (PA) 100
Chest Anterior Posterior (AP, for non-co-operative patients)
100
Chest Lateral (LAT) 200
Chest Anterior Posterior (AP NEWBORN) 80
Skull Posterior Anterior/ AnteriorPosterior (PA/AP)
1500
International Atomic Energy Agency
Special casesSpecial cases
Medical exposure dose constraints for comforters and in research
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
37 International Atomic Energy Agency
Medical exposure dose constraintsMedical exposure dose constraints
• For medical exposure normally no dose constraints are used, only guidance levels
• Only for the protection of persons exposed for medical research purposes, or of persons, other than workers, who assist in the care, support or comfort of exposed patients dose constraints are applicable
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
38 International Atomic Energy Agency
Helping personsHelping persons
• Severely ill patients require assisting persons
• Partially cooperating pediatric patients, especially after trauma or with severe pain, need holding persons to stabilize the patient’s position for exact exposure
• Ideally, no holding persons should be involved in radiography and fluoroscopy of patients
• If at all possible, the helping person should be a technician or a nurse
• Parents present can and often will hold their child
• If female persons assist the radiographer or the radiologist, they should be asked about a possible pregnancy.
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
39 International Atomic Energy Agency
Medical researchMedical research
•The exposure of humans for medical research is deemed to be not justified unless it is:
•(a) in accordance with the provisions of the Helsinki Declaration16 and follows the guidelines for its application prepared by CIOMS and WHO;
•(b) subject to the advice of an Ethical Review Committee (or any other institutional body assigned similar functions by national authorities) and to applicable national and local regulations.
( CIOMS: Council for International Organizations of Medical Sciences)
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
40 International Atomic Energy Agency
What we learnedWhat we learned
• Medical exposure is not subjected to dose limits
• Basic principle is to comply with ALARA, justification and optimization
• Dose reference levels are tools to optimize procedures and equipment use
• A regular check has to be made of actual given doses with DRL’s
• Examples are given of accepted DRL’s for standard patients and common procedures
• Dose constraints are applicable for comforters and persons exposed in research
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
41 International Atomic Energy Agency
Where to get more informationWhere to get more information
• International Basic Safety Standards for Protection Against Ionizing Radiation and for the Safety of Radiation Sources. 115, Safety Standards. IAEA, February 1996.
• Radioprotection 102. Implementation of the medical Directive 97/43. pp 78-84 Available at website: http://europa.eu.int/comm/environment/pubs/nuclear.htm#radiationprotection)
• Referral Criteria for Imaging. Radiation Protection 118. Adapted by experts representing European Radiology and Nuclear Medicine. In conjunction with the UK Royal College of Radiologists. Coordinated by the European Commission. Directorate General for the Environment. Luxembourg, 2000. Available at:website http://europa.eu.int/comm/environment/radprot
Guidance levelsModule VIII.3 Part 4: Guidance levels for patients
42 International Atomic Energy Agency
Where to get more informationWhere to get more information
• ICRP 73. Radiological Protection and Safety in Medicine. Annals of the ICRP, 26(2), 1996.
• WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION, Use of Ionizing Radiation and Radionuclides on Human Beings for Medical Research, Training and Non-Medical Purposes, Technical Report Series No. 611, WHO, Geneva (1977).