Upload
vuongngoc
View
223
Download
2
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
International Business Environment
Activities of McDonalds and KFC in emerging economies
Introduction
In current business world, China, India, Brazil, Belgium etc. have vital importance as emerging
economies, as the multinational companies are concentrating their business activities in these
market places (Kose, 2011). In view of Singh (2010) it has become essential for the firms to be
successful in the emerging market for a sustainable growth in the market as the developed
markets are becoming saturated. Organizations like Coca-Cola and Pepsi had realized the
importance of emerging markets in sustainable growth during the period of 1980s. So these
companies were able to enter in to the emerging markets without facing high level
competition. However, fast-food restaurants like McDonalds and KFCdelayed in realizing the
strategic significance of emerging markets, observes Atsmon et al. (2012). Therefore in this
article, the activities of McDonalds and KFC in the rising markets are compared and contrasted.
Further, the article will detail the present accomplishment of these organizations and the
possibility of future achievements.
McDonalds and KFC in emerging markets
According to Kose (2011) the emerging economies are the ones that make advanced
development through rapid industrialization and international investment by creating suitable
economic systems. In the present situation India and China are the leading economies in the
emerging markets.The variables that distinguishes these marketplaces from other developing
markets are the big size and the growing population of these countries, that provide large
potential growth prospects, reviews Anand et al. (2014). Therefore this report will focus on the
performance of McDonalds and KFC in these emerging markets.
2
McDonalds and KFC have been following different market entry modes in India and China.
While both opted a Company owned mode for entry in China, in India McDonalds opted 50-50
joint venture whereas KFC opted Company owned mode for entry.
McDonalds utilized joint venture style for entering the Indian marketplace. Through this mode
the firm was able to fulfill the requirements of the Indian customers reports Bhushan (2012).
Whereas KFC entered the Indian marketplace by utilizing company owned businesses. Because
of adopting company owned operations the firm could not last long in the Indian market and
forcefully terminated its operations in India. But in 2004, KFC re-entered the Indian market
through franchising mode of market entry. In the Chinese market both McDonalds and KFC
entered through company owned business, reviews Hu and Xie (2013) and Bhushan (2012). This
is largely due to the insufficient franchising ordinances in Chinese marketplace, reviews
Edwards (2011).Form this it can be understood that the success or failure of the company in
foreign markets largely depends on its market entry mode.
Current achievements of McDonalds in emerging markets
McDonalds in India
McDonald factory outlet in India was started in 1996. Further, the firm had started its
procedure in India 4 years later, after setting an efficient supply system across India. This long-
term preparation was a critical factor for the achievements of McDonalds in the Indian
marketplace. With the support of a strong distribution system, McDonalds was capable
ofexpandingits operations in a more rapid paceacross India. From the report of McDonald’s
(2013), it can be noted that, there is an increase in the number of outlets and now it has 300
outlets in India.
Through two joint venture partnerships, McDonalds had entered the Indian market and the
partnerships was with Connaught Plaza restaurants for north and east India and Hardcastle
Restaurants for west and south India. In 2010 the joint venture relationship with Hardcastle
Restaurants was terminated but continues with the franchise operation, and the other joint
venture has been continuing, reviews Bhushan (2012).
3
According to McDonald’s (2013) the McDonalds has been mainly focusing on the adaptation of
local consumer preferences and is successful in the Indian market. In India, majority of the
population are vegetarians and beef consumption is prohibited in many parts of the countryas a
part of religious sentiments. However McDonalds mainly providing beef and pork based
products had introduced new products in India. Through McAlooTikki burger, a pure vegetarian
item, McDonalds was able to lure more vegetarian customers towards them. At Present,
McAlooTikki is the most marketed product in McDonalds’ Indian factory outlets (Bhushan,
2012). This implies that by localizing its products McDonalds has made an achievement in the
Indian marketplace.
By following a dual pricing strategy, McDonalds provides some products (affordability of brand)
at affordable costs and the core products (core value of the brand) at premium cost. It was
revealed from the report of McDonald’s (2013) that the cost of McAlooTikki and Chicken
McGrill are 20-30 rupees whereas the cost of the core branded products of McVeggie and
McChicken burgers are priced at 50-60 rupees.This strategy has helped McDonalds in
addingmorecustomers with distinct price perception.
In view of Sameer and Kaur (2012) McDonalds mainly focuses on attracting kids as they have a
greater influence on the purchasing decision of pizzas and burgers by parents. Based on this
trend McDonalds has implemented a happy meal campaign, through which toys were offered
to children during their visit to McDonalds outlets. Moreover McDonalds has been providing
playing area for children at the restaurants thereby make the visit more joyful.By this strategy
McDonalds identifies itself as a place for fun rather than being yet another restaurant.
McDonalds in China
McDonalds joined Chinese market through business owned outlets and at present about 95% of
outlets in China are business owned. This reveals that just 5% of its own factory stores are
franchises, reviews Hu and Xie (2013) McDonalds usually utilizes franchising with businesses
making 80% of total factory outlets. The primary advantage of franchising is that the firm will be
able to make out large revenue because of the low operation cost (Edwards, 2011). From the
report of China Retail News (2014) McDonalds at present have 2000 factory outlets in China.
4
Most of the outlets have been in tier-1 and tier-2 towns, Moreover McDonalds placed itself in
China as a top quality restaurant.
This positioned McDonalds among Chinese youth, as a fashionable restaurant. Because of this
reason the price of McDonalds’ products are higher compared to other restaurants (Hu and Xie,
2013). In order to cater with the requirements of the Chinese customers, McDonalds altered its
product line and launched new items such as green pea pies, rice burgers and Shogun
burger.The advantage of 24*7 hours of service was yet another factor that assisted the
business in accelerating its growth in China, claims Paz (2011). Yet another primary strategy
embraced by McDonalds in China is creating drive-thru factory outlets in collaboration with
Sinopec - the biggest petroleum retailer in China. McDonalds has been assisted by this strategy
in creating many drive-thru factory outlets. Drive-thru factory outlets generate sales that are
greater than conventional outlets because of the reduced cost of operations. As most of the
customers utilizes home delivery channel, McDonalds has an added advantage through the
implementation of its home delivery system.
The McDonalds’ marketing strategy mainly focuses on attracting children. The single child
policy at China enhances the purchasing power as majority of the Chinese family consists of one
child and has a great influence on the purchasing decisions of parents.Thus McDonalds makes
the whole family visit the outlet, by attracting kids. To ensure this McDonalds offers a
distinctive dining experience and high quality customer service. In view of Maidment (2015)
McDonalds’ adopted strategy in United States was different where McDonalds was a choice of
convenienceto its customers.
Current achievements of KFC in emerging markets
KFC in India
Initially KFC could not lure more customers in the Indian market as the firm failed to offer
culturally based items in the Indian market. Due to this reason KFC is now at third-place in
Indian fast food industry. By localizing its goods and strategies nevertheless, KFC saw a rapid
growth in Indian marketplace. In view of Friend (2013) KFC still has a chance to attain the
5
market leadership in India, as the fast food is gradually nurturing in India and there is no first
mover advantage here.
KFC reached year-over sales boost of 41% in the year 2012 and year worth growth of 45%. This
is the greatest among fast-food restaurants in India. This assisted KFC in positioning itself as the
third biggestfast-food chain in India, reviews Friend (2013). Despite its gradual entry to the
marketplace, KFC was able to be successful in the Indian market by offering culturally oriented
items which fulfill the requirements of the local customers. This was accomplished through
products and menu localization, pricing strategies, and successful consumer education (Balaji,
2013). KFC has launched more spicy items along with Chicken curry to attract local customers.
Vegetarian food was also released by the KFCin India such as burger patties with potatoand
fried vegetable strips. As over 70% of Indians favortraditional flavor over western flavors, hence
it was essential for KFC to satisfy local customers by providing localized items, reviews Friend
(2013).
For the gradual growth of KFC in the Indian market, the pricing strategy plays a significant
role.KFC had previously placed itself as a special event restaurant and thus the costs were
higher. At present, KFC places itself as a regular restaurant, thus lowered costs to draw more
customers, reports Balaji (2013).The firm has adopted franchise system in India, it was in
connection with the KFC’s international strategy by which the company ownedonly 11% of the
outlet stores (Edwards, 2011).
KFC was able to establish a successful workforce in India by the support of skilled and
hardworking employees.KFC achieved the most trustworthy quick-service restaurant brand
prize, reported by Ferguson (2015). This reveals that KFC has been able to offer quality as well
as qualified customer service in India.
KFC in China
KFC at present has around 4,200 shops in China and utilizes around 250,000 workers and about
40% of the market share, reviews Brady (2013). By the adoption of five effective strategies, KFC
was able to accomplish the business achievement in China. The absorbed strategies are:
6
Brand’s adaptation to the cultural background:
KFC has succeeded in transforming itself in to a brand among Chinese local customers by
providing items with more varieties and traditional meals. The large floor space in the
restaurant helps to accommodate families as well as large crowd in the restaurant. KFC
provides over 50 products in China compared to 29 in the United States. The products contain
rice meals, spicy chicken, egg tarts, soy milk drinks, fried dough sticks , fish and shrimp burgers
and traditional items especially congee(Zhou and Zhang, 2012).
Speedy expansion:
Unlike its rivals who restricted their businesses to tier-1 and tier-2 cities in China, KFC has
embraced a strategy to follow accelerated growth throughout the country, and also it has
commenced activities in tier-4 and tier-3 cities in China. Through the speedy expansion,
company expects to accomplish the economies of scale. (Brady, 2013)
Establishment of logistical network:
Logistics and transportation has a significant role in providing quality food to the Chinese
customers where food safety is of a major concern.As a result of insufficient accessibility of
present supply system in China, KFC has formulated its own logistical system. This network
further helps ineasy accessibilityof smaller towns (Tse, 2010).
Employee enrichment:
The work force lacked vital abilities when KFC began its operations in China. As quality
customer service was of great concern, it was an important issue for the organization. To
handle this problem, KFC has created a stringent and effectual training course that churns away
around 100 supervisors and 30,000 staffs per year (Tse, 2010)
Guarding against criticism:
A serious criticism is being faced by KFC in United States in connection with high carbohydrate
and high-fat contents in its products. In order to overcome this issue, the firm has embraced a
7
strategy of marketing nutritional products as well as standard products in the Chinese market
(Brady, 2013). All these variables reveal that, by the adoption of localization of all aspects of
KFC’s operation, it has accomplished a successful business in the Chinese marketplace.
Company owned operations:
Over 90% of KFC outlets in China are owned directly by the company. That is in marked
comparison with the US business of KFC where the company possesses just 12% of factory
outlets. This strategy permits the firm to get close control on the business activity in the
marketplaces (Zhou and Zhang, 2012).
Comparing and contrasting the operations of McDonalds and KFC in emerging markets
The aforementioned details reveals that the localization of products, market entry mode,
distribution network, strategic positioning, pricing strategy, marketing strategy, etc. have a
great influence on the operations of McDonalds and KFC in the emerging markets specifically,
India and China.
One of the main factors that can be disclosed from the discussions is that McDonalds and KFC
were not able to make use of their most favoured ways of market entry in China and India.
Zhou and Zhang (2012) record the tremendous achievement of KFC and McDonalds could be
connected directly to the success of franchising.
Initially both KFC and McDonalds were compelled to embrace other modes of market entry as
both countries restricted franchising operations. This resulted in KFC and McDonalds in utilizing
business owned functions to enter in the Chinese market, reviews Edwards (2011). However,
McDonalds employed joint ventures while KFC employed business owned strategy to enter the
Indian marketplace. As these firms own majority of the factory outlets, the manner of business
of McDonalds and KFC hasn't transformed.Moreover both McDonalds and KFC were focusing
franchising system in China market place to enhance the market share. KFC has more
franchisees with a lead of 15% as compared with the 5% of franchisees to McDonalds. In
contrary, KFC is getting disassociated with its normal mode of operation to pursue franchisee
8
operations in India, whereas McDonalds has taken one of the joint venture to franchisee mode
(Edwards, 2011).
The discussion also shows, theachievements in the emerging market by McDonalds and KFC
may be associated with the effective distribution system set up by these companies. KFC is
rolling out the second-largest distribution system in China and thus has the opportunity to grow
to inaccessible locations in the country (Brad, 2013). However, McDonalds put in place a
distribution chain and a supply system in India within a time period of four years before starting
its very first factory outlet. This exceptionally efficient supply system was the key factor for the
achievement of McDonalds in Indian market, reviews McDonald’s (2013). However McDonalds
was unable to establish an effective distribution system in China as their operations were
restricted to tier-3 and tier-4 cities in China (Quanfucius, 2015).
The discussions also disclose that both McDonalds and KFC have been employing products and
promotions in the emerging markets through adopting the localization strategy (Hu and Xie,
2013). The key examples of localization of items are: in India, McDonalds launched McAloo
Tikka and KFC offered Curry Chicken. On the other hand McDonalds and KFC also launched
localized products in the Chinese market.Friend (2013) records that failure of KFC to
accommodate its offers in Indian marketplace proved to be a primary cause of the first
drawback confronted by KFC in India. So that it could be surmised that localization of goods is
crucial factor in the emerging markets.
Brand positioning has been recognized as a vital variable that aids the growth of fast-food chain
in the emerging markets. In India and China, both McDonalds and KFC have been adopting
different positioning strategies to attract more customers and further to enhance the market
share (Zhou and Zhang, 2012). For instance, McDonalds places itself as a top quality restaurant
where kids are provided toys, scholarship for studying etc. There are specific areas for kids to
play in the restaurant. Because of this reason the items belongs to higher price category,
reviews Sameer and Kaur (2012).
A similar strategy has been utilized by McDonalds in the Indian market. In order to fulfill the
requirements of the rich and the middle class customers McDonalds in India adopted two price
9
strategy (Sameer, and Kaur, 2012.). However, KFC places itself in Indian marketplace as a
regular restaurant which supplies quality service at reduced costs, reviews Friend (2013). These
variables reveal that the choice of price strategy and positioning also affects the expansion of
fast-food restaurant chains in the emerging market.
On the basis of the aforementioned details, it may be surmised that emerging markets is
distinctive from each other hence companies cannot flourish in these markets by embracing a
tailor-made strategy. In view of Hu and Xie, (2013) it was essential for the organizations to
localize and adapt suitable strategies which enable the firms to be successful in the emerging
market.Additionally, it may be inferred that building powerful distribution system is also the
most crucial element for fast-food restaurantsin the emerging markets.
Potential for future sustainable success for McDonalds and KFC in China and India
While Indian marketplace has been triumphed by McDonalds, KFC has made bigger
achievements in the Chinese marketplace. McDonalds and KFC has a great concern in these
emerging markets, as its operations are largely company owned, reviews Hu and Xie (2013) and
Bhushan (2012). For example, McDonalds is operating 5% of its outlets in China through
franchisees and KFC by 15%. However in India all the KFC outlets are franchisees whereas 153
outlets of McDonalds are operating through the joint venture system. Both McDonalds and KFC
should decrease the amount of company-owned outlets and have to widen the business
through franchisees in order to sustain in the emerging market place. From critiquing the
current situation, it may be comprehended that KFC has a more powerful position than
McDonalds in this regard.
Raising the number of factory outlets is just another crucial factor for attaining lasting success
in emerging markets (Kose, 2011). KFC has about 300 outlets in India and 5000 outlets in China.
However, McDonalds has just 2000 factory outlets in China and about 300 outlets in India,
reviews Maidment (2015). This reveals that, in china KFC has efficiently utilized its distribution
system to widen its operations in tier-3 and tier-4 cities. On the other hand, even-though
McDonalds having an effective distribution network in India, it could not expand the number of
10
outlets. Because of the legal battle between McDonalds and Connaught Plaza, one of its joint
venture partners, for sole ownership of operations, the growth of McDonalds in India is slow
paced.It has adversely affected the growth rate of McDonalds in Indian market place, reviews
McDonald’s (2013). KFC has taken advantage of this scenario by raising revenue and its market
share in the Indian market. McDonalds has additionally confronted significant health issues in
Chinabecause one of the vendors usedthe expired meat in various items. This also developed a
negative impact on the performance of McDonalds in China (Chibber, 2014.). This reveals that
KFC has a stronger stand compared to McDonalds in the Indian and Chinese market place for
attaining sustainable growth in the future.
Conclusion
The activities of McDonalds and KFC in emerging markets such as China and India were
analyzed in this report.The evaluation of KFC and McDonalds in China and India shows that
variables like product localization, distribution network,market entry mode;pricing and
positioning strategies etc. affects the growth of the organizations in the emerging markets. It
had been likewise understood that McDonalds achievement in India and KFC's achievement in
China could be connected right back to the powerful distribution system created by these
corporations in India and China respectively. The investigation additionally mentions thatKFC is
in a stronger stand as compared to McDonalds to attain future growth in thesemarketplaces.
References
Anand, R., Cheng, K.C., Rehman, S. and Zhang, L., 2014. Potential growth in emerging
Asia. IMF Working Paper, [online] January. Available at:
<http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2014/wp1402.pdf> [Accessed 21 July 2015].
Atsmon, Y., Child, P., Dobbs, R. and Narasimhan, L., 2012. Winning the $30 trillion
decathlon: Going for gold in emerging markets. McKinsey Quarterly, 4, pp.20-35.
11
Balaji, R., 2013. Retail management in India-A global perspective of the challenges and
opportunities. Middle-East Journal of Scientific Research, 15(12), pp.1931-1934.
Bhushan, R., 2012. With just 12 restaurants, American restaurant chain TGI Friday's far
behind KFC and McDonald's in India. The Economic Times,[online] 15 June. Available at:
<http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-06-15/news/32254606_1_bistro-
hospitality-rohan-jetley-kfc> [Accessed 27 July 2015].
Brady, D., 2013. Should KFC rethink its China strategy?.Bloomberg Business, [online] 14
May. Available at: <http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2013-05-14/should-kfc-
rethink-its-china-strategy> [Accessed 20 July 2015].
Chibber, K., 2014. McDonald’s is losing a lot of customers in China over the expired meat
scandal. Quartz, [online] 9 August. Available at: <http://qz.com/247303/mcdonalds-is-
losing-a-lot-of-customers-in-china-over-the-expired-meat-scandal/> [Accessed 20 July
2015].
China Retail News, 2014. Fast growth equals more fast food for McDonald's in China.
China Retail News, [online] 21 April. Available
at:<http://www.chinaretailnews.com/2014/04/21/7055-fast-growth-equals-more-fast-
food-for-mcdonalds-in-china/> [Accessed 27 July 2015].
Edwards, W., 2011. The pros and cons of franchising in China. China Business Review,
[online] 1 July. Available at: <http://www.chinabusinessreview.com/the-pros-and-cons-
of-franchising-in-china/> [Accessed 20 July 2015].
Ferguson, V., 2015. KFC named most trusted quick-service restaurant brand in India by
the brand trust report. Business Wire, [online] 3 March. Available at:
12
<http://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20150303006370/en/KFC-Named-Trusted-
Quick-Service-Restaurant-Brand-India#.VbYJhrOqqko> [Accessed 20 July 2015].
Friend, E., 2013. Third-ranked KFC is winning the fast food battle in India – for now.
Euromonitor International, [online] 24 December. Available at:
<http://blog.euromonitor.com/2013/12/third-ranked-kfc-is-winning-the-fast-food-
battle-in-india-for-now.html> [Accessed 27 July 2015].
Hu, W. and Xie, Y., 2013. Comparative study of McDonald's and Kentucky Fried Chicken
(KFC):development in China. Bachelor’s Thesis. Savonia University of Applied Sciences.
Kose, M.A., 2011. Emerging markets: resilience and growth amid global turmoil.
Washington: Brookings Institution.
Maidment, N., 2015. McDonald's new CEO has a modern strategy to fix the brand.
Business Insider, [online] 5 February. Available at: <http://www.businessinsider.com/r-
the-burger-loving-brit-mcdonalds-new-ceo-takes-on-sales-slump-2015-
2?IR=T>[Accessed 27 July 2015].
McDonald’s, 2013. McDonald’s India (North & East Region). [online] Available at:
<http://www.mcdonaldsindia.net/PressRelease/McDonalds%20india%20(North%20%20
East)%20-%20Media%20Fact%20Book_February_2013.pdf> [Accessed 27 July 2015].
Paz, 2011. McDonald’s delivery – 24×7 in China. International Carvings, [online] 25
November. Available at: <http://internationalcravings.com/mcdonalds-delivery-24x7-in-
china/> [Accessed 27 July 2015].
13
Quanfucius, 2015. Tiers of joy – living in China. The Chinerd, [online] 16 March. Available
at: <https://chinerd.wordpress.com/2015/03/16/tiers-of-joy-living-in-china/> [Accessed
20 July 2015].
Sameer, and Kaur, S. 2012. Strategy and repositioning the brand McDonald’s in India.
International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, 2(9), pp.1-5.
Singh, S. ed., 2010. Handbook of business practices and growth in emerging markets.
Singapore: World Scientific.
Tse, E., 2010. The China strategy: harnessing the power of the world's fastest-growing
economy. New York: Basic Books.
Zhou, L. and Zhang, Q., 2012. Cultural adaptation pattern analysis of McDonald’s and
KFC in the Chinese market. Master Thesis. Uppsala University.