Upload
jamie-schau
View
109
Download
5
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Interview Manual designed for refugees served by the International Rescue Committee's Center for Financial Opportunity in San Diego, California.
Citation preview
IRC Center Financial Opportunities San Diego Interviewer’s Manual for a survey of San Diego refugees Jamie Schau March 2011
2
Introduction
The International Rescue Committee (IRC) is an organization that advocates for positive change
and performs refugee resettlement services worldwide. The San Diego office of the IRC is
looking to have its Center for Financial Opportunity (CFO) services evaluated based upon
quality-of-life indicators, going beyond the typical strictly-financial metrics. The four programs
that will be assessed in this survey include:
Early Employment Services: Provides vocational counseling, resume preparation, job
search and placement services, and financial assistance for basic needs with the goal of
helping refugees find their first job in America and achieve early economic self-
sufficiency.
Career Development: Helps clients with professional backgrounds re-enter their
professions in a timely manner.
Microenterprise: Supports refugees in starting and expanding their own businesses by
providing intensive technical assistance and access to capital. The IRC has aided in the
start of over 120 businesses and 85 expansions.
Financial Education: Teaches refugees the basics of the U.S. financial system and
encourages good habits in budgeting, credit, tax preparation, and banking. The IRC also
operates an IRS VITA (Volunteer Income Tax Assistance) Program during tax season.
In order to reach the clients who utilize these services, the series of interviews will be conducted
in various neighborhoods in San Diego County where IRC’s clients reside, particularly in the El
Cajon and City Heights areas. The sample of refugees who will be surveyed will be
representative of their populations, particularly heavily focused on Burmese, Somalian and Iraqi
clients.
Each interviewing team will consist of a volunteer who is able to speak the same language as the
client (and translate it into written English post-survey), and if the volunteer is under 18 years
old, s/he will be accompanied by a staff member or senior surveyor. If any issues or questions
arise, they should be communicated by the staff member or volunteer (if over 18) to an IRC CFO
Supervisor immediately at number below for resolution.
The interviewers are responsible for interviewing respondents and collecting information in
line with this manual and the training that they have received. The following pages offer general
instructions to ensure the interviews are of highest quality and consistent across the board. In
total, it is expected that the IRC will conduct approximately 100 surveys.
It is of utmost importance that the every question in the survey is asked in a consistent, neutral
and similar way.
In an emergency or with urgent questions, please contact:
Thuba Nguyen or Jason Jarvinen at (619) 641-7510
3
1. What to do before fieldwork:
1. Attend a brief training session where you will learn about the motives and procedures for
each question in the survey.
2. Read the survey and this manual carefully to make sure you completely understand each
question and why it is being asked.
3. Talk with your IRC supervisor to go over procedures for handling the survey and field
logistics.
4. Confirm that you have enough spare writing pencils and paper to write down the answer and
record your thoughts on the survey when necessary.
5. Assure that you will have enough privacy in the location where the survey will take place,
that the respondent is comfortable, and that the interview setting will have minimal
interruptions.
2. What to note before, during and after the interview:
Appearance of interviewers in the field is very important because it can make them appear either
close or distant from the interviewee. Make sure that you do not wear smart/stylish-looking/
highly formal clothing that creates distance between interviewers and interviewees. Please be
clean, casual and comfortable.
Check the respondent’s identification to make sure it matches the pre-defined list of respondents
in the region before proceeding to interview. Do NOT interview if the respondent is not on the
list. Report to Thuba Nguyen at (619) 641-7510 if this is the case.
Read out loud the introduction in the questionnaire. Try to make a positive “first impression” in
order to create confidence with the respondent.
VERY IMPORTANT: Please read each question exactly as it appears in the questionnaire. Do not introduce your own interpretations of the questions. Stick to the questions word-by-word.
If the respondent fails to understand a particular question, only then provide an explanation
provided in this manual (see Section 4: “Question by Question Instructions”).
Expressions/statements in ALL CAPS within the punctuation ((...)) are those for interviewers
only. It means that you will perform those requests by yourself, and will not read them aloud to
the interviewee. Bolded Section titles do not need to be read by the interviewer.
Ask the questions slowly to ensure that the respondent understands what s/he is being asked.
After you have asked a question, pause and give her/him time to think. If the respondent feels
hurried or is not allowed to formulate her/his own opinion, s/he may respond with “I don’t
4
know” or give an inaccurate answer. If you feel the respondent is answering without thinking,
just to speed up the interview, say to the respondent:“There is no hurry. Your opinion is very
important, so please consider you answers carefully.”
Most people tend to give answers that they think you want to hear. It is therefore very important
that you remain absolutely neutral as you ask the questions. Never, either by the expression
on your face or by the tone of your voice, allow the respondent to think that s/he has given the
“right” or “wrong” answer to the question. Never appear to approve or disapprove of any of the
respondent’s replies.
If a respondent’s answer is not relevant to a question, do not prompt the respondent by saying
something like “I suppose you mean that…Is that right?” In many cases, you will get an
affirmative answer even when that is not what s/he meant.
If the respondent is giving irrelevant or elaborate answers, do not stop her/him abruptly or
rudely, but listen to what s/he has to say. Then try to steer the respondent gently back to the
original question. Please make a great effort to maintain a good atmosphere throughout the
interview. The best atmosphere for an interview is one in which the respondent sees the
interviewer as a friendly, sympathetic, and responsive person who does not intimidate her/him
and to whom s/he can respond freely without feeling shy or embarrassed.
Do not offer the interviewee the options of “I don’t know,” “refuses to respond” or “not
applicable”: Mark answers based on the actual response (or lack thereof) from the interviewees.
Indicate that either s/he doesn’t know the answer, that s/he hesitated/refused to respond, or that
the question was inapplicable to the respondee. Use your expression-reading skills to determine
appropriate use of “don’t know,” “refused to respond,” and “N/A.”
If respondent clearly is unable to answer a question, or hesitates after a period of thought on the
question, code -99 in the box to the left for “don’t know”.
If the respondent is reluctant or unwilling to answer a question, try to overcome his or her
reluctance, explain once again that the same question is being asked of refugees all over San
Diego and that the answers will all be merged together – as well as the fact that all answers are
confidential. If the respondent still refuses, code -98 in the box on the left for “refused to
answer” and proceed as if nothing had happened. If you have successfully completed the
interview, you may try to obtain the missing information at the end, but do not push too
hard for an answer.
If the respondent is clear that the question does not apply to them, or if it is what is implied in the
question clearly does not respond to them based on previous questions, code -97 for “not
applicable.”
If the respondent seems bored or detached, gives an irrelevant answer, or contradicts something
s/he has already said, try to re-capture the respondent’s interest in the conversation. For example,
if you sense that s/he is shy or afraid, try to remove his or her shyness or fear before asking the
5
next question. Spend a few moments talking about things unrelated to the interview (e.g. San
Diego area, the weather, daily activities).
Go-to (Skip) instructions are clearly marked on the questionnaire. If there are no skip
instructions, simply proceed to the next question. If there are skip instructions, they need to be
followed carefully to make sure the right questions are asked to the right respondents.
Most questions require a single answer that should be coded in the box provided on the left side
of the questionnaire. However, certain questions allow for multiple answers. These are clearly
indicated in the questionnaire.
Do not leave any questions uncoded. Remember that if the respondent does not answer one
question, even after you have reiterated the question one more time, you must mark “refused to
answer”.
Before closing the interview, review the questionnaire to assure it has been completed and no
questions are missed by mistake.
After you have left the interview, fill out the Post-Interview section of the questionnaire. Be sure
to record anything strange that may have impacted the integrity of the results. Indicate in
particular any interruptions, settings or unexpected visitors that may have made the respondent
nervous, uncomfortable, or highly distracted.
At the end of your day in the field, discuss any problem you encountered with Thuba and look
for solutions in order to avoid any repetition of them in the coming days or by other surveyors.
3. DOs and DON’Ts:
The following table provides detailed instructions and explanations of things that interviewers
must or should do and must not or should not do before, during and after the course of each
interview.
DOs DON’Ts
Before the interview:
Appearance of
interviewers in
the field
Wear casual clothing to make you
close to ordinary people.
Wear formal-looking clothing that
creates distance between interviewers
and interviewees
Respondent
matching
Make sure the respondent’s
identification matches the pre-defined
list of the respondents of this
community.
Don’t interview if the respondent is not
on the list, but report to your supervisor
if this is the case.
During the course of interviewing:
Introduction Read aloud the introduction as stated
in the questionnaire.
Do not re-word the question in your
own way. Stick to the script.
6
DOs DON’Ts
Read aloud all the transitions in the
questionnaire. These transitions are in
regular text, not CAPS LOCK like the
interviewer instructions.
Never skip transitions, their purpose is
to keep up the interview flow, and have
it sound like a normal conversation.
Interviewees’
confidentiality
Reiterate that the name of the
interviewee will not be reported at any
cost.
Never ask for the respondent’s name.
First impression Be sure to make a positive “first
impression” to create confidence with
the respondent.
Small talk (on topics like the weather,
the scenary of the San Diego) with
interviewees (1-2 minute talk) is
encouraged to familiarize yourself
with the interviewees and help them
feel comfortable.
Do not talk about personal issues.
Atmosphere of
the interview
Maintain a good atmosphere during
the course of the interview.
The best atmosphere for an interview
is one in which the respondent sees the
interviewer as a friendly, sympathetic,
and responsive person who does not
intimidate her/him and to whom
s/he can say anything without feeling
shy or embarrassed.
Never cause tensions or trigger debates
or arguments with the respondent, for
any reason.
Neutrality Remain absolutely neutral as you ask
the questions.
Never, either by the expression on your
face or by the tone of your voice, allow
the respondent to think that s/he has
given the “right” or “wrong” answer to
the question.
Never appear to approve or disapprove
of any of the respondent’s replies.
Treating survey
questions
Read each question exactly as it
appears in the questionnaire. Stick to
the questions word by word.
Pay special attention to
expressions/statements in ALL CAPS
in the ((...)) punctuation as these are
Do not introduce your own
interpretations of the questions.
Do not leave any questions blank.
7
DOs DON’Ts
for the interviewers to follow.
Interviewees’
comprehension
Ask the questions slowly to ensure that
the respondent understands what s/he
is being asked.
Provide the explanation provided in
this manual (see Section “Question by
Question Instructions”) only when the
respondent fails to understand a
particular question.
Again, please do not introduce your
own interpretations of the questions.
Short intervals
to allow
interviewees
time for thought
Pause and give your respondent time
to think after each question.
If the respondent feels hurried or is not
allowed to formulate her/his own
opinion, s/he may respond with “I
don’t know” or give an inaccurate
answer. If you feel the respondent is
answering without thinking, just to
speed up the interview, say to the
respondent: “There is no hurry. Your
opinion is very important, so consider
you answers carefully.”
Never ask the respondent to respond
immediately.
Prompting Strictly follow instructions for
prompting .
Do not prompt respondent by saying
something like “It sounds like you mean
________. Is that right?” if the
respondent’s answer is not relevant to a
question.
In many cases, s/he will agree
with your interpretation of her/his
answer, even when that is not what s/he
meant.
Reiterating Steer the respondent gently back to the
original question if the respondent is
giving irrelevant or elaborate answers.
Reiterate the question again (once) if
the respondent fails to understand it.
Do not stop her/him abruptly or
rudely, but listen to what s/he has to
say.
How to treat
“Don’t know”
Code -99 for “don’t know” in the box
on the left if the respondent says
he/she doesn’t know the answer, or
seems not to know the answer, even
after careful thinking.
Do not read aloud option for “don’t
know”
8
DOs DON’Ts
How to treat
“Refuses to
answer”
Code -98 for “refused to answer” in
the box on the left and proceed as if
nothing had happened in case the
respondent refuses to answer.
Mark “refused to answer” when
respondent does not answer one
question even after you have reiterated
the question one more time.
If the respondent is reluctant or
unwilling to answer a question, try to
overcome her/his reluctance,
explaining once again that the same
question is being asked of refugees all
over San Diego and that the answers
will all be confidential, and merged
together.
Do not read aloud option “refuses to
answer.”
Do not push too hard for an answer.
Remember, the respondent cannot be
forced to give an answer.
Regaining
interviewees’
interests
Do your best to re-interest the
respondent in the conversation if the
respondent seems bored or detached,
gives an irrelevant answer, or
contradicts something s/he has already
said.
For example, if you sense that s/he is
shy or afraid, try to remove her/his
shyness or fear before asking the next
question. Spend a few moments talking
about things unrelated to the interview
(e.g. San Diego, the weather, her/his
daily activities).
Do not leave room for boredom during
the course of the interview.
How to treat
skipping paterns
Follow orange-arrowed skipping
patterns carefully to make sure the
right questions are asked to the right
respondents.
Proceed to the subsequent question if
no skipping instructions are provided.
Do not miss any question at any cost!
How to treat
multiple
choice/answer
questions
Strictly follow instructions for “more
than one answer permitted” questions.
Note down all responses provided by
the respondent, and code
appropriately.
Certain questions allow for multiple
9
DOs DON’Ts
answers. These are clearly indicated
in the questionnaire.
Closing
interviews
Say “thank you” to the respondent.
Double-check the questionnaire to
ensure that no questions are missed by
mistake.
Fill in final question and interviewer
comments in the Post Interview
section.
Sign the questionnaire before handing
it in to Thuba.
Don’t miss any question by mistake!
After the interview:
Debriefing at the
end of each
interview day
Discuss any problem you encounter
during the day with Thuba or your
supervisor and look for solutions in
order to avoid any repetition of them
in the coming days.
4. Question-by-Question Instructions:
This part of the interview manual provides detailed instructions and explanations to various
questions in the questionnaire to help interviewers to better understand them correctly and be
clear on how to conduct the interview. Remember that in case of doubt, you must discuss ANY
issues with your supervisor.
Section I: Background and Demographics
Remember, statements in bold do not need to be read by interviewer
1.1 What ethnicity are you?
Don’t read the options. Let the interviewee tell you what ethnicity s/he is. If their
answer is not on the list, check the “Other” box and fill in his or her response
under 1a.
1.2 How old were you on your last birthday?
10
It is not necessary to read off all of the options, elect the appropriate bracket
based on the interviewee’s response.
1.4 How many individuals are there in your household?
The respondent may be confused about who to consider a household member.
Clarify, if necessary, that children and babies count, as well as anyone else who
sleeps in the household more than half of the time.
1.4a
How many of these individuals are formally employed?
If the interviewee is not sure who to consider “formally employed,” explain that
part- and full-time formal employees – basically anyone paying taxes – are
considered “employed” for our purposes.
1.4b How many children (under the age of 18) are there living in the household?
If there is confusion on this point, clarify that 18-year-olds do count as adults.
“Living in the household” is considered those who sleep in the household more
than half of the time.
1.5 What is the highest level of formal education you have completed?
If clarification is needed, explain that:
“Completed” means that all full academic years were finished
Primary education is elementary and/or middle school (1-9 years [total],
generally)
Secondary education is high school (10-13 years [total], generally)
College includes community colleges, vocational and/or technical
degrees, and accredited online degrees (14-18 years [total], generally)
University education is a four-year institution (14-18 years [total],
generally)
Professional or post-graduate education includes that received beyond a
4-year university degree, such as a law degree or an MBA (19-24 years
[total], generally)
1.6a-e Which of IRCWhich of the following programs are you – or have you been – involved with?
Make it clear to the respondent that s/he can select multiple programs, and to
please advise you of ALL of the ones s/he is involved with.
1.7 How long have you been receiving IRC career / financial assistance?
If clarification is needed, explain that this figure will include ANY time that the
respondent was receiving ANY Center for Financial Opportunity services.
11
1.8 Do you know your credit (FICO) score?
If the respondent asks you to explain what this is, mark down “No” and skip to
question 1.9
1.9 What is your household income:
If the respondent seems confused, explain that “household income” is the total
income of everyone in the home that earns a wage.
1.10 How has your income changed in the last 12 months?
Please be sure to only allow one answer.
Section II: Employment Conditions, Opinions and
Prospects: Remember, statements in bold do not need to be read by interviewer
2.1 Are you formally employed?
If the interviewee is confused about what is considered “formally employed,” we
mean to say part or full-time formal employment i.e. if s/he pays taxes, s/he is
employed.
Please hand card # 1A or 1B (attached at bottom of Interview Manual) to
respondent, each of which have all the same options but in opposite orders. Be
sure to alternate the cards at each interview. The cards do not include the N/A or
“don’t know” options, please do not verbally offer them these either, but do code
them in the box on the left if it is clear that the respondent does not know or is
unwilling to answer.
The respondent can either point at or utter his/her answer. Once you get the
answer, please mark the corresponding questions appropriately on the
questionnaire. Please read questions in sequence – first read 1a., list options,
obtain an answer, then move on to 1b., etc.
2.1 d. Please explain that this question is referring to whether the respondent is in
a work environment in which s/he feels comfortable learning and developing his
or her language skills, and has those opportunities.
2.1f. If the client needs clarification, explain that “employer flexibility” refers to
whether they allow changes in the schedule, time off when necessary, consider
12
employees’ scheduling needs, etc.
You may mark answers in corresponding boxes, and go back and code later if
this makes you more comfortable with the alotted time. After respondent has
finished, collect the card from him or her.
2.2 Who do you turn to for help when you have a question about a standard work
procedure, for example: how to fill out a time card, what is appropriate attire,
etc.?
If the client is not clear on “another social service,” provide the examples:
CalWorks, 2-1-1, Salvation Army, etc. Please emphasize that there is more than
one option permitted, and code all answers selected. For example, if respondent
chooses the first three options, code -012
2.4 How many hours per week do you work?
Emphasize that this is total hours in a whole week, Sunday to Sunday. If the
respondent requests further explanation, use this as an example:
If you work an eight hour work day, and work six days per week, then you have
a [8*6=] 48 hour work week.
2.5 How long is your work commute each day, round trip?
Be sure to emphasize that this is a daily – not weekly – figure. Explain, if
necessary, that a commute includes time spent walking, on a bicycle, public
transportation, or in a vehicle (personal or shared) – heading to or home from
work. Round trip will be the sum of both legs of the journey.
2.6 Were you or will you be required to obtain a license or certification for a job
that you were already licensed for or practiced in your home country?
If clarification is needed – explain that this applies to people who either have
already obtained a license/certification, or those who will have to in the future. In
BOTH cases, if the answer is yes, please do not skip to 2.7, but continue below
on 2.6a.
2.6a. If yes, do you feel that when you need this certification (or if you needed another,
or to re-certify), that you could obtain it independently?
If there is confusion, remember that this question is meant to apply to those who
have not AND those who have obtained these licenses or certifications. So if they
have already, this is a direct question. If they have not yet, this is a hypothetical.
2.7 Are you in the process of starting your own business,or are you currently running
your own business?
13
Be sure if the answer is yes to either of those, that you code -1 and move to
question 7a. Only if the answer is no to both questions will you skip to 2.8.
Please note this does question is meant to include those who ARE AND ARE
NOT receiving IRC services. Advise the respondent of this if the question is
asked.
2.7a. If yes, do you feel that the establishment of this business has helped or hindered
you in any of the following?
There may be more than one option selected. Read all of the options through
once, then go back, repeat them each individually and wait for an answer before
moving to the next option. This way the respondent will know all of the options
before answering, and that they do not necessarily have to have experienced any
of these feelings. Code all of the options that the respondent selects. For instance,
if s/he picks the first and fourth, code -03. If s/he picks none, code -5.
2.8 If income from formal employment is not sufficient to cover your expenses or you
do not have formal employment, in what way or ways do you support yourself?
Respondent may choose multiple answers. Please clarify, if respondent is
confused, that this applies to those who ARE and who ARE NOT employed. Do
not provide the “Other” option, but if the client advises you of another means,
tick the “Other” box and fill in the blank. If there are questions as to the meaning
of “another organization or agency” – please name some various examples such
as CalWorks, 2-1-1, Salvation Army.
Section III: Personal Independence and Confidence:
Remember, statements in bold do not need to be read by interviewer
3.1 How confident do you feel in your ability to navigate the following procedures by
yourself, without any outside assistance?
Please be sure to read slowly and clearly, and repeat the options when necessary.
If necessary, explain that “outside assistance” includes anyone: friends, family,
IRC, language tutors, etc. Read the questions in sequence, starting with 1a.,
reading all options, waiting for an answer, then moving on to 1b., etc. You may
mark answers in corresponding boxes, and go back and code later if this makes
you more comfortable with the alotted time.
3.1c. Preparing and Executing a Budget:
If the client seems confused or needs clarification, please explain that this entails
saving enough money to meet expenses and paying bills on time every month.
14
Section IV: Economic Welfare and Opinions: Remember, statements in bold do not need to be read by interviewer
4.4 What do you think the financial situation of your family will be two years from
now?
Clarify, if necessary, that this is a hypothetical question. Respondent should give
you his or her best guess.
4.5 Which of the following do you and / or your family own?
For each item that the respondent answers “no” to, leave the box blank and
move to the sub-question below it. Only codeon number in the box: -0 if the
respondent does own the item, and -1 or -2 if they do not. If the respondent
answers yes, check the box (and code -0), then move on to the next sub-question.
Closing
Take your time to review the survey prior to leaving, and ask the respondent any
questions that might have been missed. Thank the respondent and make your
exit.
**Do not fill in interviewer comments in the residence. Please leave and fill out
the “comments” section outside, immediately after interview.
Section V: Post-Interview: Remember, statements in bold do not need to be read by interviewer
5.1 What is the sex of the respondent?
This is to be answered by the interviewer, not the respondent.
Comments Interviewer Comments:
Be sure to record anything strange that may have impacted the integrity of the
results. Indicate in particular any interruptions, settings or unexpected visitors
that may have made the respondent nervous, uncomfortable, or highly distracted.
Print your name and sign the bottom of the questionnaire.
Cards #1A and 1B are attached below, to be brought to every interview.
15
CARD 1A
PLEASE DO NOT WRITE ON THIS CARD
TELL YOUR ANSWERS TO YOUR SURVEYOR VERBALLY
16
CARD 1B
PLEASE DO NOT WRITE ON THIS CARD
TELL YOUR ANSWERS TO YOUR SURVEYOR VERBALLY