1
U(D5E71D)x+,!=!/!#!{ SAHARANPUR, India — In- dia’s most influential guru joined thousands of believers four years ago as the temple’s first stone was set in the ground. It was a glorious day for its builders, the Gupta brothers, the sons of a local shopkeeper who had risen, almost magically, to be- come one of the richest families a world away in South Africa. The three brothers had flown back on their private jet to start work on the temple, a 125-foot monument of pink sandstone and white marble that would tower over the tiny place where their fa- ther used to ride his bicycle to pray every day. But one morning last month, as the sun struggled to break through the smog in Saharanpur, their hometown in India’s north, the giant yellow crane raising the temple stood still — in limbo, like the brothers themselves. The Guptas are now in self-im- posed exile in Dubai, evading ar- rest in South Africa, where they stand at the center of a scandal that has already brought down the nation’s president and exposed staggering amounts of corruption in the once-legendary party of Nelson Mandela. Even here in India, the family’s legacy — so large that it has been elevated to myth — faces collapse. The new temple, dedicated to Lord Shiva in their father’s honor, is now being investigated for the same kind of self-dealing and fraud the family is accused of mas- tering in South Africa. The rise and fall of the Gupta brothers is so improbable that in Saharanpur their story is told like a parable. They began by selling shoes in South Africa and swiftly became central figures in the nation’s post-apartheid history, outsiders who broke into the very pinnacle of political power. Seemingly overnight, they joined the ranks of South Africa’s most influential families, playing a leading role in one of the biggest dramas after the end of apartheid: Who is get- ting rich, and how? Mr. Mandela’s election as presi- In Family’s Rise And Fall, a Tale Rife With Graft Ties to Brothers Haunt South Africa’s A.N.C. By NORIMITSU ONISHI and SELAM GEBREKIDAN Continued on Page 10 Tyler Perry is a household name in the United States, where his movies have made nearly a bil- lion dollars. But in Britain, he is known mainly for playing the law- yer to Ben Affleck’s accused hus- band in “Gone Girl” — if he is known at all. Some of the movies Mr. Perry has written and directed have re- ceived small international open- ings, most often in South Africa and the Arabian Peninsula. Only one or two ever got anything close to a European theatrical push. “I fought for it, I asked for it,” Mr. Perry said. But often he gets the same response: “Stories with black people don’t travel, don’t translate.” For years, minority filmmakers have pushed Hollywood studios and distributors to get over a re- luctance to promote their films worldwide. They are hoping that 2018 was the tipping point they have been waiting for. This year “Black Panther,” “Crazy Rich Asians” and “BlacK- kKlansman” all raked in money overseas, an unusual winning streak that challenged beliefs about the global appeal of actors of color. Charles D. King, the chief exec- utive of Macro, a financial backer of “Fences,” starring Denzel Washington, and the summer in- die hit “Sorry to Bother You,” said he had seen examples of an indus- try shift. He pointed to Metro- Goldwyn-Mayer’s and Warner Bros.’ full-bore promotion of the November boxing sequel “Creed II,” with its star, Michael B. Jor- dan, traveling with the film inter- nationally. Of the longstanding belief that films need white leads to travel, Mr. King said: “We’re seeing pockets of progression, where the Will ‘Black Panther’ Pave Way For Minority Stars Overseas? By CARA BUCKLEY Continued on Page 4 BETHLEHEM, Pa. — Away in a manger on Bethlehem’s public square, a woman approached a statue of the baby Jesus one dark, December night. Then she stole it. The theft, from a Nativity scene outside City Hall, raised alarm in this eastern Pennsylvania city that shares a name with the real Jesus Christ’s birthplace. When the missing baby Jesus was found, it had been damaged, and Bethlehem’s police chief had to glue its leg back on. Then the city took action, positioning a con- cealed security camera exclu- sively on baby Jesus and assign- ing police officers to monitor the footage. In the two years since, the statue has been left at peace, asleep on the hay as the camera, nicknamed the “Jesus cam” by some residents, rolls. “If anybody looks real close, they’ll see a crack in his leg,” said Lynn Cunningham, a leader of the local chamber of commerce. Such manger larceny, in glaring violation of the Eighth Command- ment, is also part of a sad national trend. This year, thieves have raided Nativity scenes in Tennes- see, West Virginia, Minnesota and plenty of other places, and made off with Jesus figurines (and sometimes Mary and a donkey, too). The episodes, which have rat- tled Christian communities, have become so common that the own- ers of holiday displays have bol- stered security. On church lawns and in downtown parks, baby Je- sus is back in his manger, but often with a security camera rolling and a tether securing him to the ground. Some places have gone so far as to equip figurines with GPS devices. In West Bend, Wis., north of Mil- waukee, a baby Jesus figurine was stolen twice last year. After the first theft, the statue’s torso was found nearby, but the rest of it was missing. The faithful were outraged, and someone donated a new Jesus doll for the Nativity set, which had been displayed around town for decades. A few days later, early on Christmas Eve, an alert police offi- cer saw a woman “cradling some- thing” on West Bend’s Main Street. It was the replacement baby Jesus. “I yelled ‘Police, stop,’” the officer wrote in his offi- cial report of the incident. Once confronted, the woman dropped the figurine and took off running. The thefts took a toll in West Bend, a city of about 30,000 resi- dents, where churches are central to public life and longtime resi- dents recall admiring the old Na- tivity set as children. Cameras, Bolts and an Elusive Goal: To Sleep in Heavenly Peace By MITCH SMITH A statue of the baby Jesus was stolen from a crèche in St. Cloud, Minn. Such thefts have rattled Christian communities nationally. TIM GRUBER FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES Continued on Page 26 In a rare show of unity, tribal nations worked together to shelter homeless Native Americans camped near down- town Minneapolis. PAGE 18 NATIONAL 18-27 Tribes Helping City Brethren Who is the rightful inventor of the blockbuster swimsuit known as the Kiini? Sometimes, there’s a fine line between inspiration and theft. PAGE 1 SUNDAY BUSINESS The Itsy-Bitsy Litigious Bikini Five members of the N.B.A.’s class of 2003, including LeBron James and Dwyane Wade, are still playing. They share an uncommon bond. PAGE 1 SPORTSSUNDAY A Distinguished Draft Class The Year in Pictures SUNDAY REVIEW WASHINGTON As the White House and Democrats re- mained locked in a standoff over funding for President Trump’s border wall, Senator Mitch Mc- Connell, the Republican leader, sent his colleagues home for the Christmas holiday on Saturday, virtually ensuring that the gov- ernment will remain partially shuttered for at least several more days. Mr. McConnell’s adjournment of the Senate until Thursday came after a frenzied day of negotia- tions in Washington and conflict- ing signals from the White House. Around the country, the partial shutdown, which began at 12:01 a.m. Saturday and affects roughly one-quarter of the federal govern- ment, deprived 800,000 workers of their pay and was visible at places like national parks, where sites were unstaffed or, in some cases, closed. Mr. Trump is demanding $5 bil- lion for the “big, beautiful wall” he promised to build at the southern border, and in a conference call with reporters, administration of- ficials insisted that he would ac- cept nothing less. But even as they spoke, Vice President Mike Pence was on his way to the Capitol to present an offer to the top Senate Democrat, Chuck Schumer of New York. Those talks, however, appeared to make little headway. Mr. Pence was tight-lipped as he left Mr. Schumer’s office — “We’re still talking,” he said — while a spokes- man for Mr. Schumer, Justin Goodman, pronounced the two sides “very far apart.” Mr. McCon- nell then announced the Senate’s adjournment and left the Capitol SHUTDOWN IS SET TO LAST FOR DAYS AS TRUMP DIGS IN SENATORS HEAD HOME Spending Talks Remain Stuck on Funding for a Border Wall By SHERYL GAY STOLBERG and KATIE ROGERS Continued on Page 21 WASHINGTON — When President Trump grows frustrated with advisers during meetings, which is not an uncom- mon occurrence, he sits back in his chair, crosses his arms and scowls. Often he erupts. “Freaking idiots!” he calls his aides. Except he uses a more pungent word than “freaking.” For two years, Mr. Trump has waged war against his own government, con- vinced that people around him are fools. Angry that they resist his wishes, uninter- ested in the details of their briefings, he becomes especially agitated when they tell him he does not have the power to do what he wants, which makes him suspi- cious that they are secretly undermining him. Now, the president who once declared that “I alone can fix” the system increas- ingly stands alone in a system that seems as broken as ever. The swirl of recent days — a government shutdown, spiraling scandals, tumbling stock markets, abrupt troop withdrawals and the resignation of his alienated defense secretary — has left the impression of a presidency at risk of spinning out of control. At the midpoint of his term, Mr. Trump has grown more sure of his own judgment and more cut off from anyone else’s than at any point since taking office. He spends ever more time in front of a television, of- ten retreating to his residence out of con- cern that he is being watched too closely. As he sheds advisers at a head-spinning rate, he reaches out to old associates, complaining that few of the people around him were there at the beginning. Mr. Trump is said by advisers to be con- sumed by the multiplying investigations that have taken down his personal lawyer, campaign chairman, national security ad- viser and family foundation. He rails against enemies, who often were once friends, nursing a deep sense of betrayal and grievance as they turn on him. “Can you believe this?” he has said as he scanned the torrent of headlines. “I’m doing great, but it’s a war every day.” “Why is it like this?” he has asked aides, with no acknowledgment that he might have played a role. The aides, many Isolated Leader Sees ‘a War Every Day’ President Clings to His Own Judgment as Turmoil Deepens, Allies Say President Trump has grown increasingly suspicious of many of the people around him, convinced that they are fools. DOUG MILLS/THE NEW YORK TIMES ‘It’s entirely possible it gets worse, not better.’ MICHAEL STEEL, longtime adviser to Republican politicians Continued on Page 25 By PETER BAKER and MAGGIE HABERMAN DISRUPTED The shutdown’s ef- fects were felt at national parks, airport checkpoints and the coun- try’s borders. PAGE 23 Zamanbol is a tech-savvy 14-year-old, but she practices an ancient craft to connect with her elders and their cul- ture. Mongolia Dispatch. PAGE 6 INTERNATIONAL 6-16 She Hunts With an Eagle Late Edition VOL. CLXVIII . . No. 58,185 © 2018 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, SUNDAY, DECEMBER 23, 2018 Record collection Elegance is an attitude Kate Winslet Longines Boutiques Ala Moana, HI · Aventura, FL · New York City, NY Also available in selected fine jewelry retailers. www.longines.com Today, sunny, then increasingly cloudy, high 44. Tonight, rain and snow, little to no accumulation, low 35. Tomorrow, partly sunny, breezy, high 45. Weather map is on Page 22. $6.00

Isolated Leader Sees a War Every Day - static01.nyt.com · By CARA BUCKLEY Continued on Page 4 BETHLEHEM, Pa. way inA a manger on Bethlehem s public square, a woman approached a statue

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Isolated Leader Sees a War Every Day - static01.nyt.com · By CARA BUCKLEY Continued on Page 4 BETHLEHEM, Pa. way inA a manger on Bethlehem s public square, a woman approached a statue

U(D5E71D)x+,!=!/!#!{

C M Y K Nxxx,2018-12-23,A,001,Bs-4C,E3

SAHARANPUR, India — In-dia’s most influential guru joinedthousands of believers four yearsago as the temple’s first stone wasset in the ground.

It was a glorious day for itsbuilders, the Gupta brothers, thesons of a local shopkeeper whohad risen, almost magically, to be-come one of the richest families aworld away in South Africa.

The three brothers had flownback on their private jet to startwork on the temple, a 125-footmonument of pink sandstone andwhite marble that would towerover the tiny place where their fa-ther used to ride his bicycle topray every day.

But one morning last month, asthe sun struggled to breakthrough the smog in Saharanpur,their hometown in India’s north,the giant yellow crane raising thetemple stood still — in limbo, likethe brothers themselves.

The Guptas are now in self-im-posed exile in Dubai, evading ar-rest in South Africa, where theystand at the center of a scandalthat has already brought down thenation’s president and exposedstaggering amounts of corruptionin the once-legendary party ofNelson Mandela.

Even here in India, the family’slegacy — so large that it has beenelevated to myth — faces collapse.The new temple, dedicated toLord Shiva in their father’s honor,is now being investigated for thesame kind of self-dealing andfraud the family is accused of mas-tering in South Africa.

The rise and fall of the Guptabrothers is so improbable that inSaharanpur their story is told likea parable.

They began by selling shoes inSouth Africa and swiftly becamecentral figures in the nation’spost-apartheid history, outsiderswho broke into the very pinnacleof political power. Seeminglyovernight, they joined the ranks ofSouth Africa’s most influentialfamilies, playing a leading role inone of the biggest dramas afterthe end of apartheid: Who is get-ting rich, and how?

Mr. Mandela’s election as presi-

In Family’s RiseAnd Fall, a TaleRife With Graft

Ties to Brothers HauntSouth Africa’s A.N.C.

By NORIMITSU ONISHIand SELAM GEBREKIDAN

Continued on Page 10

Tyler Perry is a householdname in the United States, wherehis movies have made nearly a bil-lion dollars. But in Britain, he isknown mainly for playing the law-yer to Ben Affleck’s accused hus-band in “Gone Girl” — if he isknown at all.

Some of the movies Mr. Perryhas written and directed have re-ceived small international open-ings, most often in South Africaand the Arabian Peninsula. Onlyone or two ever got anything closeto a European theatrical push.

“I fought for it, I asked for it,”Mr. Perry said. But often he getsthe same response: “Stories withblack people don’t travel, don’ttranslate.”

For years, minority filmmakershave pushed Hollywood studiosand distributors to get over a re-luctance to promote their filmsworldwide. They are hoping that2018 was the tipping point they

have been waiting for.This year “Black Panther,”

“Crazy Rich Asians” and “BlacK-kKlansman” all raked in moneyoverseas, an unusual winningstreak that challenged beliefsabout the global appeal of actorsof color.

Charles D. King, the chief exec-utive of Macro, a financial backerof “Fences,” starring DenzelWashington, and the summer in-die hit “Sorry to Bother You,” saidhe had seen examples of an indus-try shift. He pointed to Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer’s and WarnerBros.’ full-bore promotion of theNovember boxing sequel “CreedII,” with its star, Michael B. Jor-dan, traveling with the film inter-nationally.

Of the longstanding belief thatfilms need white leads to travel,Mr. King said: “We’re seeingpockets of progression, where the

Will ‘Black Panther’ Pave WayFor Minority Stars Overseas?

By CARA BUCKLEY

Continued on Page 4

BETHLEHEM, Pa. — Away ina manger on Bethlehem’s publicsquare, a woman approached astatue of the baby Jesus one dark,December night. Then she stole it.

The theft, from a Nativity sceneoutside City Hall, raised alarm inthis eastern Pennsylvania citythat shares a name with the realJesus Christ’s birthplace.

When the missing baby Jesuswas found, it had been damaged,and Bethlehem’s police chief hadto glue its leg back on. Then thecity took action, positioning a con-cealed security camera exclu-sively on baby Jesus and assign-ing police officers to monitor thefootage. In the two years since, thestatue has been left at peace,asleep on the hay as the camera,nicknamed the “Jesus cam” bysome residents, rolls.

“If anybody looks real close,they’ll see a crack in his leg,” saidLynn Cunningham, a leader of thelocal chamber of commerce.

Such manger larceny, in glaringviolation of the Eighth Command-

ment, is also part of a sad nationaltrend. This year, thieves haveraided Nativity scenes in Tennes-see, West Virginia, Minnesota andplenty of other places, and madeoff with Jesus figurines (andsometimes Mary and a donkey,too).

The episodes, which have rat-tled Christian communities, havebecome so common that the own-ers of holiday displays have bol-stered security. On church lawnsand in downtown parks, baby Je-sus is back in his manger, but oftenwith a security camera rolling and

a tether securing him to theground. Some places have gone sofar as to equip figurines with GPSdevices.

In West Bend, Wis., north of Mil-waukee, a baby Jesus figurinewas stolen twice last year. Afterthe first theft, the statue’s torsowas found nearby, but the rest of itwas missing. The faithful wereoutraged, and someone donated anew Jesus doll for the Nativity set,which had been displayed aroundtown for decades.

A few days later, early onChristmas Eve, an alert police offi-cer saw a woman “cradling some-thing” on West Bend’s MainStreet. It was the replacementbaby Jesus. “I yelled ‘Police,stop,’” the officer wrote in his offi-cial report of the incident. Onceconfronted, the woman droppedthe figurine and took off running.

The thefts took a toll in WestBend, a city of about 30,000 resi-dents, where churches are centralto public life and longtime resi-dents recall admiring the old Na-tivity set as children.

Cameras, Bolts and an Elusive Goal: To Sleep in Heavenly PeaceBy MITCH SMITH

A statue of the baby Jesus was stolen from a crèche in St. Cloud,Minn. Such thefts have rattled Christian communities nationally.

TIM GRUBER FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

Continued on Page 26

In a rare show of unity, tribal nationsworked together to shelter homelessNative Americans camped near down-town Minneapolis. PAGE 18

NATIONAL 18-27

Tribes Helping City BrethrenWho is the rightful inventor of theblockbuster swimsuit known as theKiini? Sometimes, there’s a fine linebetween inspiration and theft. PAGE 1

SUNDAY BUSINESS

The Itsy-Bitsy Litigious BikiniFive members of the N.B.A.’s class of2003, including LeBron James andDwyane Wade, are still playing. Theyshare an uncommon bond. PAGE 1

SPORTSSUNDAY

A Distinguished Draft Class The Year in PicturesSUNDAY REVIEW

WASHINGTON — As theWhite House and Democrats re-mained locked in a standoff overfunding for President Trump’sborder wall, Senator Mitch Mc-Connell, the Republican leader,sent his colleagues home for theChristmas holiday on Saturday,virtually ensuring that the gov-ernment will remain partiallyshuttered for at least several moredays.

Mr. McConnell’s adjournmentof the Senate until Thursday cameafter a frenzied day of negotia-tions in Washington and conflict-ing signals from the White House.Around the country, the partialshutdown, which began at 12:01a.m. Saturday and affects roughlyone-quarter of the federal govern-ment, deprived 800,000 workersof their pay and was visible atplaces like national parks, wheresites were unstaffed or, in somecases, closed.

Mr. Trump is demanding $5 bil-lion for the “big, beautiful wall” hepromised to build at the southernborder, and in a conference callwith reporters, administration of-ficials insisted that he would ac-cept nothing less. But even as theyspoke, Vice President Mike Pencewas on his way to the Capitol topresent an offer to the top SenateDemocrat, Chuck Schumer ofNew York.

Those talks, however, appearedto make little headway. Mr. Pencewas tight-lipped as he left Mr.Schumer’s office — “We’re stilltalking,” he said — while a spokes-man for Mr. Schumer, JustinGoodman, pronounced the twosides “very far apart.” Mr. McCon-nell then announced the Senate’sadjournment and left the Capitol

SHUTDOWN IS SETTO LAST FOR DAYSAS TRUMP DIGS IN

SENATORS HEAD HOME

Spending Talks RemainStuck on Funding for

a Border Wall

By SHERYL GAY STOLBERGand KATIE ROGERS

Continued on Page 21

WASHINGTON — When PresidentTrump grows frustrated with advisersduring meetings, which is not an uncom-mon occurrence, he sits back in his chair,crosses his arms and scowls. Often heerupts. “Freaking idiots!” he calls hisaides. Except he uses a more pungentword than “freaking.”

For two years, Mr. Trump has wagedwar against his own government, con-vinced that people around him are fools.Angry that they resist his wishes, uninter-ested in the details of their briefings, hebecomes especially agitated when theytell him he does not have the power to dowhat he wants, which makes him suspi-

cious that they are secretly undermininghim.

Now, the president who once declaredthat “I alone can fix” the system increas-ingly stands alone in a system that seemsas broken as ever. The swirl of recent days— a government shutdown, spiralingscandals, tumbling stock markets, abrupttroop withdrawals and the resignation ofhis alienated defense secretary — has leftthe impression of a presidency at risk ofspinning out of control.

At the midpoint of his term, Mr. Trumphas grown more sure of his own judgmentand more cut off from anyone else’s thanat any point since taking office. He spendsever more time in front of a television, of-ten retreating to his residence out of con-cern that he is being watched too closely.

As he sheds advisers at a head-spinningrate, he reaches out to old associates,complaining that few of the people aroundhim were there at the beginning.

Mr. Trump is said by advisers to be con-sumed by the multiplying investigationsthat have taken down his personal lawyer,campaign chairman, national security ad-viser and family foundation. He railsagainst enemies, who often were oncefriends, nursing a deep sense of betrayaland grievance as they turn on him.

“Can you believe this?” he has said ashe scanned the torrent of headlines. “I’mdoing great, but it’s a war every day.”

“Why is it like this?” he has askedaides, with no acknowledgment that hemight have played a role. The aides, many

Isolated Leader Sees ‘a War Every Day’President Clings to His Own Judgment as Turmoil Deepens, Allies Say

President Trump has grown increasingly suspicious of many of the people around him, convinced that they are fools.DOUG MILLS/THE NEW YORK TIMES

‘It’s entirely possible it gets worse, not better.’MICHAEL STEEL, longtime adviser to Republican politicians

Continued on Page 25

By PETER BAKERand MAGGIE HABERMAN

DISRUPTED The shutdown’s ef-fects were felt at national parks,airport checkpoints and the coun-try’s borders. PAGE 23

Zamanbol is a tech-savvy 14-year-old,but she practices an ancient craft toconnect with her elders and their cul-ture. Mongolia Dispatch. PAGE 6

INTERNATIONAL 6-16

She Hunts With an Eagle

Late Edition

VOL. CLXVIII . . No. 58,185 © 2018 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, SUNDAY, DECEMBER 23, 2018

Record collection

Elegance is an attitude

Kate Winslet

Longines BoutiquesAla Moana, HI · Aventura, FL · New York City, NY

Also available in selected fine jewelry retailers.

ww

w.lo

ngin

es.

com

Today, sunny, then increasinglycloudy, high 44. Tonight, rain andsnow, little to no accumulation, low35. Tomorrow, partly sunny, breezy,high 45. Weather map is on Page 22.

$6.00