Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
IT for ADR: The Procrustean Challenge. Pablo Noriega IIIA-CSIC. IT in ADR. Pervasive Useful Unavoidable. It may become a Procrustean bed. Adapt to type of ADR. 17. Different degrees and modes of automation. 17. 17. 17. 17. 19. 10. 10. 3. 16. 19. 10. 16. 3. 16. 16. 16. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Citation preview
IT for ADR: The Procrustean Challenge
Pablo NoriegaIIIA-CSIC
IT in ADR
• Pervasive
• Useful
• Unavoidable
2Procrustean Challenge
It may become a Procrustean bed
3Procrustean Challenge
Adapt to type of ADRDifferent degrees and modes of automationdo
cum
enta
ción
com
unic
ació
n
virt
ualiz
ació
n
cont
rol d
el fl
ujo
form
as
estr
uctu
rada
s
mec
anism
os
de d
ecisi
ón
grad
o de
au
tom
atiza
ción
med
iaci
ón
grad
o de
au
tom
atiza
ción
nego
ciac
ión
reco
men
daci
ón
arbi
traj
e
quej
as
33
10
1919
1717 17
1613
1016
1010
16
1717
1016
conc
iliac
ión
20
13
13
3 CyberSettle10 Juripax
13 MediationRoom16 ODRWorld
16
4Procrustean Challenge
Adapt to type of ADR
• Support process
• Support participants
5
Different degrees and modes of automation
Design premises
Fair– Due process
Invisible– Accessible– Unobtrusive
Reliable– Privacy– Permanence
Effective
6Procrustean Challenge
Designing for effectiveness
1 conventions for communication• Specific ADR and domain ontologies• Roles• Standardized documents
2 procedural conventions• Repetitive activities• Sequence of activities• Rules of engagement / disengagement
3 obligation management• Establishment conventions• Satisfaction conventions
4 constitutive and “anchoring” conventions
7Procrustean Challenge
Designing for effectiveness
1 conventions for communication• Specific ADR and domain ontologies• Roles• Standardized documents
2 procedural conventions• Repetitive activities• Sequence of activities• Rules of engagement / disengagement
3 obligation management• Establishment conventions• Satisfaction conventions
4 constitutive and “anchoring” conventions
8Procrustean Challenge
Feasible:ExplicitFormalExecutable
Example of communication and procedural conventions 1:
Mediated Negotiation
Offer (proposer, receiver; deal[v1,v2,..,vn], t)
Invalidoffer(mediator, proposer; improvedeal[xi,xj], t)
9Procrustean Challenge
Example of procedural conventions 2:Generic Agreement Framework
10Procrustean Challenge
Qualities to guarantee
Fairness– Due process
Invisibility– Accessible– Unobtrusive
Reliability– Privacy– Permanence
Effectiveness
11Procrustean Challenge
Fairness– Due process
Invisibility– Accessible– Unobtrusive
Reliability– Privacy– Permanence
Effectiveness
12Procrustean Challenge
