Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Wehran Engineering Corporation666 Ea;: Va.r. 5:ree:PC Bex 2006
January 20, 1992 M da.etown New York -Q94C' , Tei 914-343-0660
Fax 914-343-1946
Ms. Alison BarryUnited States Environmental Protection Agency26 Federal Plaza-Room 759New York, NY 10278
Re: Operable Unit 2 Feasibility StudyKin-Buc Landfill Superfund Site, Edison, New JerseyAdministrative Order No. II-CERCLA-00114 (Order)WE Project No. 09406.HG
Dear Ms. Barry:
Wehran Engineering Corporation (Wehran) has prepared this submittal on behalfof Respondents to Administrative Order Index No. II-CERCLA-00114 in response toAgency correspondence dated December 20, 1991 regarding the U.S. EnvironmentalProtection Agency's (EPA) establishment of a PCB cleanup level of 5 parts per million(ppm) for contaminated wetland sediments at the Kin-Buc Landfill Site, Operable Unit 2.As requested, Wehran has normalized all sediment PCB data from the Edmonds Creekmarsh and Pool C connecting channel areas to the fraction of organic carbon containedin the sediment at that data point. In addition, the normalized data have been mappedfor comparison with contour intervals representing the lower, mean, and upperSediment Quality Criteria (SQCs) for PCBs in freshwater ecosystems using EPA's InterimEquilibrium Partitioning Method (EP) in accordance with your request. The results ofthis effort are attached. A brief description of these results is presented below.
Table 1 summarizes the available total PCB and total organic carbon (TOC) datafor the Edmonds Creek/Connecting Channel wetland sediments derived from theOperable Unit 2 investigations, normalized PCB data (expressed as ug PCB/g organiccarbon) for each sampling station, and calculated freshwater SQC equivalents for eachsampling station. Calculated SQC equivalents include the location-specific mean and95 percent (lower and upper) confidence intervals for comparison to un-normalized PCBdata. SQCs used to derive these location-specific equivalents were obtained from EPA's"Interim Sediment Criteria Values for Non-Polar Hydrophobia Organic Compounds" andare listed on Table 2. «a
In addition, Wehran has calculated location-specific saltwater SQC equivalents for °EPA's consideration (Table 1) because the wetlands in question also support saltwater 0aquatic life (see Operable Unit 2 RI/FS, Section 2.4). Salinity in the Raritan River at othis location during high tide intervals ranged from 3.25 to 17.4 parts perthousand (ppt) during eight weeks of water quality sampling conducted by Wehran in oOctober - November 1991. These data suggest that the site would be classified as a £
10.1/92.09406 HG
Ms. Alison BarryJanuary 20, 1992Page 2
saltwater system in accordance with NJAC 7:9-4.4. Further, the toxicological data baseused to derive the freshwater SQC may not be representative of the resident biologicalcommunity in Edmonds Creek marsh system, although it is recognized that the saltwatertoxicological data base may not be entirely representative either. As such, bothfreshwater and saltwater SQCs are offered for consideration and comparison with thesuggested PCB cleanup criterion of 5 ppm.
Seven figures have been enclosed to contour un-normalized and normalized PCBdata and criteria. These include the approximate distribution of sediments exceeding5 ppm PCBs (Figure 1), normalized PCB data expressed as ug PCB/g organic carbon(Figure 2), normalized PCB data contoured to show areas exceeding the upper, mean,and lower SQCs for freshwater (Figures 3, 4, and 5) and areas exceeding the upper,mean, and lower SQCs for saltwater (Figures 6, 7, and 8). To interpret these figures,contours derived for un-normalized PCBs greater than 5 ppm (Figure 1) should becompared with contours derived for normalized PCBs in excess of freshwater andsaltwater SQCs (Figures 3 through 8) to determine which SQC limits are best satisfiedby 5 ppm total (un-normalized) PCBs. These figures show that the un-normalized5 ppm contours (Figure 1) exihibit adequate compliance with the upper freshwaterSQCs (Figure 3) and the upper saltwater SQCs (Figure 6) .The suggested PCB cleanupcriterion of 5 ppm will allow for consideration of remedial alternatives for the EdmondsCreek marsh system that are largely confined to existing stream channels and theirassociated intertidal shorelines or borders (as outlined in Figure 1) while preserving themajority of the vegetated wetlands within the study area.
Respondents reserve judgment as to the appropriateness of the 5 ppm criterion forPCBs as the sole basis for considering remedial action until EPA's EndangermentAssessment is made available for our review and incorporation into the Feasibility Study.For example, Respondents would consider the potential impact (positive or negative)of each remedial alternative on the existing uses of the wetland, and the anticipatedreduction of exposure via critical pathways associated with each alternative, as possiblemodifiers to the final areas selected for remediation. Existing uses and critical exposurepathways should be defined in the Endangerment Assessment and considered in theFeasibility Study.
We would welcome the opportunity to discuss these issues with Agencyrepresentatives at your earliest convenience. In the interim, we will assume that thecleanup level of 5 ppm PCBs will be the final action level for the Operable Unit 2wetlands, pursuant to your letter of December 20, 1991. In order to proceed, we must ^incorporate the 5 ppm action level for PCBs into the ongoing Feasibility Study. We will couse this action level to determine the extent of affected acreage and to finalize remedialalternatives. However, completion of this effort is dependent on receipt of any oadditional information regarding remedial action goals and objectives. We believe that °these goals and objectives should be derived, at least in part, from the EndangermentAssessment. ro
ilk00
10.1/92.09406.HQ
Ms. Alison BarryJanuary 20, 1992PageS
If you should have any questions regarding the enclosed information, please donot hesitate to contact us. We would encourage further dialogue between the Agency'sand Respondents' technical representatives regarding these and any other proposedaction levels prior to their final adoption and throughout the Feasibility Study process.
Very truly yours,
WEHRAN ENGINEERING CORPORATION
Kevin M. Burger, C.E.P.Kin-Buc-Facility Coordinator
KMB/mefcc: R. Sundstrom, P.E.
S. Jaffe, Esq.R. KarrD. Rothberg, Esq.M. TlcachR. Basso, USEPAI. Curtis, NJDEPR. Dewling, Ph.D.R. O'Hara
03o
oo
oto*•VO
10.1/92.09406.HG
Page 1 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUC OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA, NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PCBs(ug/g)Total Organic Carbon (%)'NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOC)* *
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS***
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS***
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
M12C
U8.00%
U
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M13C
3.517.32%
48
0.281.47.3
0.613.116
M12S
0.846.73%
12
0.261.36.7
0.562.814
M12N
2.876.95%
41
0.271.46.9
0.582.915
M13N
1.927.85%
24
0.301.57.8
0.653.317
M13S
0.778.00%
10
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
MIC
U6.96%
U
0.271.47.0
0.582.915
M2C
U8.00%
U
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M3C
U7.18%
U
0.281.47.2
0.603.015
M1S
U8.00%
U
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
OSZO tOO
Notes* - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%' * - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC - Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)*** - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC = Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990,revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area,Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g » mg/kg = parts per million (ppm)
Page 2 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUC OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA, NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PCBs (ug/g)Total Organic Carbon (%)'NORMALIZED PCBs (ugfgOC)* *
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* * *
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* * *
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
M1N
U8.00%
U
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M2S
1.638.00%
20
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M2N
0.690.0122%
5656
0.00050.0020.01
0.0010.010.03
M3N
1.345.02%
27
0.191.05.0
0.422.111
M3S
16.30%
16
0.241.26.3
0.522.613
M4C
0.948.00%
12
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M5C
4.68.00%
58
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M6C
U6.96%
U
0.271.47.0
0.582.915
M4N
U8.00%
U
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M4S
0.898.00%
11
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
T S Z O TOO
Notes* - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%* * - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC - Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)* * * - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC = Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990.revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area,Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g - mg/kg = parts per million (ppm)
Page 3 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUC OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA, NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PCBs (ug/g)Total Organic Carbon (%)*NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOC)**
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* * *
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* * *
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
MSN
0.848.00%
11
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M5S
1.168.00%
15
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M6N
2.978.00%
37
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M6S
1.118.00%
14
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M7C
U0.231%
U
0.010
0.23
0.020.100.49
M8C
124.76%
252
0.180.934.8
0.392.010
M9C
1.498.00%
19
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M10C
11.38.00%
141
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M11C
U0.372%
U
0.010.070.37
0.030.160.80
M7N
3.468.00%
43
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
2SZO TOO
Notes• - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%* * - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC - Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)* * * - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC - Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990,revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area,Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g - mg/kg = parts per million (ppm)
Page 4 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUC OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA. NORMAUZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PCBs(ug/g)Total Organic Carbon (%)'NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOC)**
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS***
Lower (ug PCBs/g sedfenent)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sedknent)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS***
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
M7S
247.04%
341
0.271.47.0
0.582.915
MSN
4.86.46%
74
0.251.36.5
0.542.714
M8S
0.588.00%
7.3
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
MSN
0.338.00%
4.1
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M9S
2.18.00%
26
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M10N
U8.00%
U
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M10S
816.60%1227
0.261.36.6
0.552.814
M11N
U0.25%
U
0.010.050.25
0.020.100.54
M11S
U0.282%
U
0.010.050.28
0.020.120.60
M21C
17.31.88%
920
0.070.37
1.9
0.160.794.0
£520 TOO 09)1
Notes• - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%** - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC - Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)* * * - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC - Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990.revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area,Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g = mg/kg - parts per million (ppm)
Page 5 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUC OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCS AND ORGANICCARBON DATA. NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PC Bs(ug/g)Total Organic Cartoon (%)*NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOC)" *
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS***
Lower (ug PCBs/g sedknent)Mean (ug PCBa/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* * *
Lower (ug PCBs/g sedtanent)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
M22C
0.442.98%
15
0.120.583.0
0.251.26.4
M23C
0.318.00%
3.9
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M15C
4.362.54%
172
0.100.502.5
0.211.15.4
M16C
1.713.33%
51
0.130.65
3.3
0.281.47.1
M17C
29.73.44%
863
0.130.673.4
0.291.47.4
M18C
U3.52%
U
0.140.693.5
0.291.57.5
M19C
0.512.80%
18
0.110.552.8
0.231.26.0
M20C
2.544.35%
58
0.170.854.3
0.361.89.3
M21E
2.885.70%
51
0.221.15.7
0.472.412
M21W
3.485.00%
70
0.191.05.0
0.412.111
too
Notes* - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%* * - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC - Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)* * * - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC « Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990,revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area.Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g = mg/kg - parts per million (pom)
Page 6 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUG OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA, NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PCBs (ug/g)Total Organic Carbon (%)*NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOC)**
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS***
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sedfenent)Upper (ug PCBs/g sedknent)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS***
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sedment)
M22E
2.56.52%
38
0.251.36.5
0.542.714
M22W
0.246.91%
3.5
0.271.36.9
0.572.915
M23E
1.77.34%
23
0.281.47.3
0.613.116
M23W
1.426.02%
24
0.231.26.0
0.502.513
M15E
4.75.56%
85
0.221.15.6
0.462.312
M15W
1068.00%1325
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M16E
1.364.20%
32
0.160.824.2
0.351.89.0
M16W
9.94.64%
213
0.180.904.6
0.381.910
M17E
4.73.32%
142
0.130.653.3
0.281.47.1
M17W
1.35.67%
23
0.221.15.7
0.472.412
SS20 TOO
Notes* - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%* * - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC - Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)* * * - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC - Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990,revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area,Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g - mg/kg « parts per million (ppm)
Page 7 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUC OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA, NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PCBs (ug/g)Total Organic Carbon (%)*NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOQ* *
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS'"
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* • •
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
M18E
1.556.04%
26
0.231.26.0
0.502.513
M18W
4.25.82%
72
0.231.15.8
0.482.412
M19E
0.435.48%
7.8
0.211.15.5
0.452.312
M19W
5.33.OO%
145
0.140.713.7
0.301.57.8
M20E
0.544.80%
11
0.190.944.8
0.402.010
M20W
0.291.76%
16
0.070.34
1.8
0.150.743.8
SD-6
1.91.86%
102
0.070.36
1.9
0.150.784.0
SD-7
U2.30%
U
0.090.45
2.3
0.190.964.9
SD-8
U2.16%
U
0.080.42
2.2
0.180.904.6
SD-9
U0.895%
U
0.030.170.89
0.070.37
1.9
9SZO TOO
Notes* - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%** - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC » Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)* • * - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC « Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990.revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area,Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g = mg/kg * parts per million (ppm)
Page 8 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUG OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA, NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PCBs (ug/g)Total Organic Carbon (%)*NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOC)* *
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* * •
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* * *
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sedwnent)
SD-10
U0.634%
U
0.020.120.63
0.050.27
1.4
SD-11
U0.386%
U
0.010.080.39
0.030.160.83
RR1
U8.00%
U
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
RR3
1.273.94%
32
0.150.773.9
0.331.68.4
RR4
U2.02%
U
0.080.392.0
0.170.844.3
RR5
U2.22%
U
0.090.432.2
0.180.934.8
RR6
U2.02%
U
0.080.392.0
0.170.844.3
RR7
3.31.95%
169
0.080.38
1.9
0.160.824.2
RR8
0.572.53%
23
0.100.49
2.5
0.211.065.4
M24C
4.10.88%
466
0.030.170.88
0.070.37
1.9
TOO 09)1
Notes" - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%* * - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC - Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)* * * - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC - Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990,revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area,Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g - mg/kg - parts per million (ppm)
Page 9 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUC OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA. NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PCBs(ug/g)Total Organic Carbon (%)'NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOQ* *
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS***
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sedknent)Upper (ug PCBs/g sedknent)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* * *
Lower (ug PCBs/g sedknent)Mean (ug PCBs/g sedknent)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
M24N
288.00%
350
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
M24S
2.44.08%
59
0.160.804.1
0.341.78.7
PC-01
2.27.14%
31
0.281.47.1
0.593.015
PC-02
2908.00%3625
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
PC-03
12.48.00%
155
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
PC-04
5602.80%
20000
0.110.552.8
0.231.26.0
PC-05
3.428.00%
43
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
PC-06
7308.00%9125
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
PC-07
11.18.00%
139
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
PC-08
2.&"8.00%
28
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
8S20 TOO D9)I
Notes* - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%* * - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC * Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)* * * - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC « Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990,revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area.Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g - mg/kg - parts per million (ppm)
Page 10 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUC OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA. NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PCBs (ug/g)Total Organic Carbon (%)*NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOQ* *
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS"*
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS***
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
PC-09
1.658.00%
21
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
PC-10
1008.00%1250
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SO- 12
0.225.08%
4.3
0.201.05.1
0.422.111
SD-13
0.91.24%
73
0.050.24
1.2
0.100.522.7
M25C
3003.98%7538
0.150.784.0
0.331.78.5
CD1
U3.26%
U
0.130.643.3
0.271.47.0
CD2
U3.36%
U
0.130.663.4
0.281.47.2
CD3
U3.32%
U
0.130.653.3
0.281.47.1
UD1
U1.24%
U
UD2
U1.84%
U
0.05 0.070.241.2
0.100.522.7
0.361.8
0.150.77
3.9
TOO
Notes" - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%*" - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC « Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)*** - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC - Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990,revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area.Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g - mg/kg = parts per million (ppm)
Page 11 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUC OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA, NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PCBs (ug/g)Total Organic Carbon (%)*NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOC)**
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS***
Lower (ug PCBs/g sedknent)Mean (ug PCBa/g sedwnent)Upper (ug PCBa/g sedknent)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* **
Lower (ug PCBa/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBa/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
SD-1
U2.70%
U
0.100.532.7
0.221.15.8
SD-2
U2.81%
U
0.110.552.8
0.231.26.0
SD-3
U0.251%
U
0.010.050.25
0.020.100.5
SD-4
U0.231%
U
0.010.050.23
0.020.100.49
SD-5
0.0962.66%
3.6
0.100.522.7
0.221.15.7
RR9
U4.55%
U
0.180.894.5
0.381.910
RR10
U5.06%
U
0.201.05.1
0.422.111
SD-1-1
0.138.00%
1.6
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-1 -2
0.278.00%
3.4
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-1 -3
U8.00%
U
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
0920 TOO
Notes* - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%** - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC - Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)* * * - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC « Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990.revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area,Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g « mg/kg * parts per million (pom)
Page 12 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUC OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA, NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL RGBs (ug/g)Total Organic Carton (%)*NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOQ* *
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* **
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sedknent)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS' "
Lower (ug PCBs/g sedknent)Mean (ug PCBs/g sedwnent)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
SD-1-4
0.258.00%
3.1
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SO- 1-5
0.298.00%
3.6
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-1-6
0.24.94%
4.0
0.191.04.9
0.412.111
SD-1-7
U8.00%
U
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-1-8
0.375.995%
6.2
0.231.26.0
0.502.513
SD-1-9
0.438.00%
5.4
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-1-10
0.28.00%
2.5
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-2A-1
0.378.00%
4.6
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-2A-2
0.768.00%
10
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
TOO
Notes* - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%"* - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC * Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)* * * - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC = Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990,revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area,Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g - mg/kg - parts per million (ppm)
Page 13 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUC OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA. NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PC Bs(ug/g)Total Organic Carbon (%)*NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOC)"
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* *'
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g seolment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS***
Lower (ug PCBs/g seolment)Mean (ug PCBs/g seolment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
SD-2A-3
0.328.00%
4.0
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-2A-4
0.418.00%
5.1
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-2A-5
0.728.00%
9.0
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-2A-6
0.248.00%
3.0
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-2A-7
0.286.915%
4.0
0.271.36.9
0.572.915
SO-2A-8
0.357.656%
4.6
0.301.57.6
0.633.216
SO-2A-9
0.578.00%
7.1
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
A-9DUP
2.198.00%
27
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-2B-1
0.0448.00%
0.6
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
2920 TOO D3H
Notes* - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%* * - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC * Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)* * * - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC - Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990,revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area,Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g * mg/kg • parts per million (ppm)
Page 14 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUG OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA, NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PCBs (ug/g)Total Organic Carbon (%)*NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOC)* *
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* * "
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS***
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
SO-2B-2
1.588.00%
20
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SO-2B-3
0.346.65%
5.1
0.261.36.6
0.552.814
SD-2B-4
2.78.00%
34
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-2B-5
0.088.00%
1.0
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-2B-6
0.484.91%
10
0.191.04.9
0.412.111
SD-2B-7
0.0978.00%
1.2
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-2B-8
0.258.00%
3.1
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-2B-9
0.1338.00%
1.7
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-2B-10
0868.00%
11
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
£920 TOO
Notes* - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%* * - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC - Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)** * - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC * Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990,revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area,Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g = mg/kg - parts per million (pom)
Page 15 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUC OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA, NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PCBs (ug/g)Total Organic Carbon (*)*NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOC)**
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* * *
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS* * *
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sedfenent)
SD-2B-11
0.168.00%
2.0
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SO-3-1
0.598.00%
7.4
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SO-3-2
U0.963%
U
0.040.191.0
0.080.402.1
SD-3-3
U0.235%
U
0.010.050.23
0.020.100.50
SD-3-4
0.167.065%
2.3
0.271.47.1
0.593.015
3-4-DUP
U8.00%
U
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-3-5
0.325.26%
6.1
0.201.05.3
0.442.211
SD-3-6
0.314.66%
6.7
0.180.914.7
0.391.910
SD-4-1
0.636.335%
10
0.251.26.3
0.532.614
roo
Notes* - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%* * - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC » Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)* * * - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC - Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990,revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area,Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g » mg/kg - parts per million (ppm)
Page 16 of 16
Table 1KIN-BUG OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF SEDIMENT PCB AND ORGANICCARBON DATA, NORMALIZED DATA AND CRITERIA
LOCATION
TOTAL PCBs (ug/g)Total Organic Carbon (%)*NORMALIZED PCBs (ug/gOC)* *
LOCATION-SPECIFIC FRESHWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS***
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
LOCATION-SPECIFIC SALTWATERCRITERIA EQUIVALENTS***
Lower (ug PCBs/g sediment)Mean (ug PCBs/g sediment)Upper (ug PCBs/g sediment)
4-1 DUP
0.438.00%
5.4
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-4-2
0.344.19%
8.1
0.160.824.2
0.351.89.0
SD-4-3
U0.2705%
U
0.010.050.27
0.020.110.58
SD-4-4
U8.00%
U
0.311.68.0
0.663.317
SD-4-5
0.122.99%
4.0
0.120.583.0
0.251.26.4
SD-4-6
0.374.39%
8.4
0.170.864.4
0.361.89.4
S920 TOO D9H
Notes* - Total Organic Carbon (OC) values reported as >8%
are considered to be 8%* * - Total PCBs (ug/g) x Fraction OC - Normalized PCB concentration
(compare with established freshwater or saltwater criteria shown in Table 2)* * * - Criterion (ug PCBs/gOC) x Fraction OC - Total PCB equivalent
(compare with total PCBs at each location)
Source: All data from Draft Final Remedial InvestigationReport for Kin-Buc Landfill Operable Unit 2 (October 1990.revised May 1991) and Draft Supplemental SedimentSampling Program for the Edmonds Creek/Marsh Area.Kin-Buc Landfill Site Operable Unit 2 (April 1991)
Units: ug/g = mg/kg « parts per million (pom)
Table 2KIN-BUG OPERABLE UNIT 2 RI/FS
SUMMARY OF USEPA PCB SEDIMENT CRITERIA
FRESHWATERLowerMeanUpper
SALTWATERLowerMeanUpper
3.87 ug PCBs/g OCl9.5ugPCBs/gOC99.9 ug PCBs/gOC
8.29 ug PCBs/g OC41 .8 ug PCBs/g OC2l4ugPCBs/gOC
Notes
OC » Organic carbon
Source: USEPA, 1988. Interim Sediment CriteriaValues for Nonpolar Hydrophobia OrganicContaminants. Office of Water Regulations andStandards, Criteria and Standards Division.Washington, D.C.
DOO
Oo
ONJ<T\
EPA REGION IISCANNING TRACKING SHEET
DOC ID #56264
DOC TITLE/SUBJECT:FIGURE 8KIN-BUC LANDFILL, OPERABLE UNIT 2NORMALIZED PCB CONCENTRATION WITHAPPROXIMATE DISTRIBUTION OF AREAEXCEEDING THE LOWER 95 PERCENTCONFIDENCE INTERVAL FOR SALTWATERSQC OF PCBs (ug PCB / g CARBON)
THIS DOCUMENT IS OVERSIZED AND CAN BELOCATED IN THE ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD FILEAT THE
SUPERFUND RECORDS CENTER290 BROADWAY, 18™ FLOORNEW YORK, NY 10007
EPA REGION IISCANNING TRACKING SHEET
DOC ID # 56264
DOC TITLE/SUBJECT:FIGURE 7KIN-BUC LANDFILL, OPERABLE UNIT 2NORMALIZED PCB CONCENTRATIONS WITHAPPROXIMATE DISTRIBUTION OF AREAEXCEEDING THE MEAN SALTWATER SQC OFPCBs (ug PCB / g CARBON)
THIS DOCUMENT IS OVERSIZED AND CAN BELOCATED IN THE ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD FILEAT THE
SUPERFUND RECORDS CENTER290 BROADWAY, 18™ FLOORNEW YORK, NY 10007
EPA REGION IISCANNING TRACKING SHEET
DOC ID # 56264
DOC TITLE/SUBJECT:FIGURE 6KIN-BUC LANDFILL, OPERABLE UNIT 2NORMALIZED PCB CONCENTRATION WITHAPPROXIMATE DISTRIBUTION OF AREAEXCEEDING THE UPPER 95 PERCENTCONFIDENCE INTERVAL FOR SALTWATERSQC OF PCBs (ug PCB / g CARBON)
THIS DOCUMENT IS OVERSIZED AND CAN BELOCATED IN THE ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD FILEAT THE
SUPERFUND RECORDS CENTER290 BROADWAY, 18™ FLOORNEW YORK, NY 10007
EPA REGION IISCANNING TRACKING SHEET
DOC ID #56264
DOC TITLE/SUBJECT:FIGURE 5KIN-BUC LANDFILL, OPERABLE UNIT 2NORMALIZED PCB CONCENTRATIONS WITHAPPROXIMATE DISTRIBUTION OF AREAEXCEEDING THE LOWER 95 PERCENTCONFIDENCE INTERVAL FOR FRESHWATERSQC OF PCBs (ug PCB / g CARBON)
THIS DOCUMENT IS OVERSIZED AND CAN BELOCATED IN THE ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD FILEAT THE
SUPERFUND RECORDS CENTER290 BROADWAY, 18™ FLOORNEW YORK, NY 10007
EPA REGION IISCANNING TRACKING SHEET
DOC ID # 56264
DOC TITLE/SUBJECT:FIGURE 4KIN-BUC LANDFILL, OPERABLE UNIT 2NORMALIZED PCB CONCENTRATIONS WITHAPPROXIMATE DISTRIBUTION OF AREAEXCEEDING THE MEAN FRESHWATER SQCFOR PCBs (ug PCB / g CARBON)
THIS DOCUMENT IS OVERSIZED AND CAN BELOCATED IN THE ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD FILEAT THE
SUPERFUND RECORDS CENTER290 BROADWAY, 18™ FLOORNEW YORK, NY 10007
^ EPA REGION IISCANNING TRACKING SHEET
DOC ID #56264
DOC TITLE/SUBJECT:FIGURE 3KIN-BUC LANDFILL, OPERABLE UNIT 2NORMALIZED PCB CONCENTRATIONS WITHAPPROXIMATE DISTRIBUTION OF AREASEXCEEDING THE UPPER 95 PERCENTCONFIDENCE INTERVAL OF FRESHWATERSQC FOR PCBs (ug PCB / g CARBON)
THIS DOCUMENT IS OVERSIZED AND CAN BELOCATED IN THE ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD FILEAT THE
SUPERFUND RECORDS CENTER290 BROADWAY, 18™ FLOORNEW YORK, NY 10007
EPA REGION IISCANNING TRACKING SHEET
DOC ID # 56264
DOC TITLE/SUBJECT-FIGURE 2KIN-BUC LANDFILL, OPERABLE UNIT 2NORMALIZED PCB CONCENTRATIONS(ug PCB / g CARBON)
THIS DOCUMENT IS OVERSIZED AND CAN BELOCATED IN THE ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD FILEAT THE
SUPERFUND RECORDS CENTER290 BROADWAY, 18™ FLOORNEW YORK, NY 10007
EPA REGION IISCANNING TRACKING SHEET
DOC ID # 56264
DOC TITLE/SUBJECT:FIGURE 1KIN-BUC LANDFILL, OPERABLE UNIT 2TOTAL PCB CONCENTRATIONS WITHAPPROXIMATE DISTRIBUTION OF AREASEXCEEDING 5 PPM PCBs IN SEDIMENTS
THIS DOCUMENT IS OVERSIZED AND CAN BELOCATED IN THE ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD FILEAT THE
SUPERFUND RECORDS CENTER290 BROADWAY, 18™ FLOORNEW YORK, NY 10007