29
JHEV ;:GDH<< WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=HI?JBH>: KF=mjb_\B= Ihki_eh\ :gghlZpby Ij_^eZ]Z_lky fZl_fZlbq_kdZy fh^_ev ^_yl_evghklb [ZgdZ \ hl kmlkl\b_ bgneypbb b wdhghfbq_kdh]h jhklZ IhdZaZgh qlh \ wlhf kemqZ_ [Zgd fh`_l ihemqZlv ijb[uev aZ kq_l hi_jZpbc ih kljZoh\Z gbx l_dmsbo jbkdh\ deb_glh\ JZkkfZljb\Z_lky jhev [ZgdZ \ bgl_ ]jZpbb ij_^ijbylbc \ nbgZgkh\hijhfure_ggu_ ]jmiiu IhdZaZ gh qlh \ hlebqb_ hl ljZ^bpbhgguo fh^_e_c bgl_]jZpbb \ ^Zgghc fh^_eb [he__ _kl_kl\_gghc y\ey_lky g_ \_jlbdZevgZy bgl_]jZpby Z h[t_^bg_gb_ij_^ijbylbck g_aZ\bkbfufbjugdZfbk[ulZ <hafh`gu_nmgdpbb[Zgdh\\ jhkkbckdhc wdhghfbd_ GZebqb_ wnn_dlb\ghc jZa\_l\e_gghc [Zgdh\kdhc kbkl_fu ± \Z`g_crZy g_hlt_fe_fZy q_jlZ ex[hc kdhevgb[m^v jZa\blhc ju ghqghc wdhghfbdb < Jhkkbb fu fh`_f gZ[ex^Zlv bgl_j_kg_crbc n_ghf_g kihglZggh]h jZa\blby [Zgdh\kdhc kbkl_fu ba gbq_]h GZqZevguc dZiblZe jhkkbckdbo dhff_jq_kdbo [Zgdb h[jZah\Zeky ba Zdlb\h\ ]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo ijhfure_gguo b lhj]h\uo ij_^ijbylbc kj_^kl\ gZdhie_gguo \ l_g_\hc wdhghfbd_ b ba ihemqb\rbo kZfh klhyl_evghklv kljmdlmjguo ih^jZa^_e_gbc =hk[ZgdZ KKKJ AZ kqb lZggu_ f_kypu \_ebdh_ fgh`_kl\h wlbo [Zgdh\ h[t_^bgb\rbkv \ kbkl_fm \ayeh gZ k_[y \k_ h[_ki_q_gb_ \gmlj_gg_]h ^_g_`gh]h h[ jZs_gby b \g_rg_]h h[hjhlZ kljZgu Dh]^Z `_ \ ] [ueh ij_ djZs_gh p_gljZebah\Zggh_ ev]hlgh_ dj_^blh\Zgb_ ijhba\h^kl\Z dhff_jq_kdb_ [Zgdb f]gh\_ggh \ayeb gZ k_[y b \k_ dj_^blgu_ hi_ jZpbb < gZklhys__ \j_fy g_kfhljy gZ hij_^_e_ggu_ ijbagZdb djbabkZ [Zgdh\kdZy kbkl_fZ y\ey_lky gZb[he__ Zdlb\guf k_dlhjhf wdhghfbdb b aZgbfZ_l \ g_c ^hfbgbjmxs__ iheh`_gb_ G_ m^b\b l_evgh qlh khklhygb_ b ^_yl_evghklv [Zgdh\kdhc kbkl_fu \uau\Z_l \k_h[sbcbgl_j_k DZd qZklh [u\Z_l hkljuc h[s_kl\_gguc bgl_j_k d ijh[e_f_ ihjh`^Z_l g_ijbfbjbfu_ b g_dhgkljmdlb\gu_ lhqdb aj_gby < ^Zgghf kemqZ_ bo fh`gh knhjfmebjh\Zlv lZd ± i_j\Zy ©M [Zgdh\ ihegh ^_g_] gh hgb ijhdjmqb\Zxl bo g_\_klv ]^_ gbq_]h g_ \deZ Hgb [u dhg_qgh g_ kfh]eb wlh]h k^_eZlv _keb [u g_ hdZaZehkv qlh jZ[hqbf fh`ghg_ieZlblvaZjieZlm

JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

JHEV ;:GDH<�< WDHGHFBD?IJ?OH>GH=H�I?JBH>:K�F��=mjb_\��B�=� Ihki_eh\:gghlZpby�Ij_^eZ]Z_lky�fZl_fZlbq_kdZy�fh^_ev�^_yl_evghklb�[ZgdZ�\ hl�kmlkl\b_�bgneypbb�b wdhghfbq_kdh]h� jhklZ��IhdZaZgh�� qlh� \ wlhfkemqZ_�[Zgd�fh`_l�ihemqZlv�ijb[uev�aZ�kq_l�hi_jZpbc�ih�kljZoh\Z�gbx l_dmsbo�jbkdh\�deb_glh\��JZkkfZljb\Z_lky�jhev�[ZgdZ�\ bgl_�]jZpbb� ij_^ijbylbc� \ nbgZgkh\h�ijhfure_ggu_� ]jmiiu��IhdZaZ�gh��qlh�\ hlebqb_�hl�ljZ^bpbhgguo�fh^_e_c�bgl_]jZpbb��\ ^Zgghcfh^_eb�[he__�_kl_kl\_gghc�y\ey_lky�g_�\_jlbdZevgZy�bgl_]jZpby��Zh[t_^bg_gb_�ij_^ijbylbc�k g_aZ\bkbfufb�jugdZfb�k[ulZ��� <hafh`gu_�nmgdpbb�[Zgdh\�\ jhkkbckdhcwdhghfbd_GZebqb_� wnn_dlb\ghc�� jZa\_l\e_gghc� [Zgdh\kdhc� kbkl_fu ±\Z`g_crZy��g_hlt_fe_fZy�q_jlZ�ex[hc�kdhev�gb[m^v�jZa\blhc�ju�ghqghc�wdhghfbdb� < Jhkkbb�fu�fh`_f�gZ[ex^Zlv�bgl_j_kg_crbcn_ghf_g� kihglZggh]h� jZa\blby� [Zgdh\kdhc� kbkl_fu �ba� gbq_]h��GZqZevguc�dZiblZe�jhkkbckdbo�dhff_jq_kdbo�[Zgdb�h[jZah\Zeky baZdlb\h\�]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo�ijhfure_gguo�b lhj]h\uo�ij_^ijbylbc�kj_^kl\��gZdhie_gguo�\ l_g_\hc�wdhghfbd_�b ba�ihemqb\rbo�kZfh�klhyl_evghklv�kljmdlmjguo�ih^jZa^_e_gbc�=hk[ZgdZ�KKKJ��AZ�kqb�lZggu_�f_kypu� \_ebdh_�fgh`_kl\h� wlbo� [Zgdh\�� h[t_^bgb\rbkv� \kbkl_fm��\ayeh�gZ�k_[y�\k_�h[_ki_q_gb_�\gmlj_gg_]h�^_g_`gh]h�h[�jZs_gby�b \g_rg_]h�h[hjhlZ�kljZgu��Dh]^Z�`_�\ �����]��[ueh�ij_�djZs_gh� p_gljZebah\Zggh_� ev]hlgh_� dj_^blh\Zgb_� ijhba\h^kl\Z�dhff_jq_kdb_�[Zgdb�f]gh\_ggh�\ayeb�gZ�k_[y�b \k_�dj_^blgu_�hi_�jZpbb��� < gZklhys__� \j_fy�� g_kfhljy� gZ� hij_^_e_ggu_� ijbagZdbdjbabkZ��[Zgdh\kdZy�kbkl_fZ�y\ey_lky�gZb[he__�Zdlb\guf�k_dlhjhfwdhghfbdb�b aZgbfZ_l�\ g_c�^hfbgbjmxs__�iheh`_gb_��G_�m^b\b�l_evgh��qlh�khklhygb_�b ^_yl_evghklv�[Zgdh\kdhc�kbkl_fu�\uau\Z_l\k_h[sbc�bgl_j_k�DZd� qZklh� [u\Z_l�� hkljuc� h[s_kl\_gguc� bgl_j_k� d ijh[e_f_ihjh`^Z_l� g_ijbfbjbfu_� b g_dhgkljmdlb\gu_� lhqdb� aj_gby�� <^Zgghf�kemqZ_�bo�fh`gh�knhjfmebjh\Zlv� lZd� ±�i_j\Zy�� ©M [Zgdh\ihegh�^_g_]��gh�hgb�ijhdjmqb\Zxl�bo�g_\_klv�]^_��gbq_]h�g_�\deZ�� Hgb�[u��dhg_qgh��g_�kfh]eb�wlh]h�k^_eZlv��_keb�[u�g_�hdZaZehkv��qlh�jZ[hqbffh`gh�g_�ieZlblv�aZjieZlm

Page 2: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

^u\Zxl�\ ijhba\h^kl\h��b \ j_amevlZl_�ohayckl\h�aZ^uoZ_lky�hl�g_�o\Zldb�h[hjhlguo� kj_^kl\ª��\lhjZy�� ©<k_�^_gv]b�[Zgdh\�k\yaZgu�\dj_^blZo� g_^h[jhkh\_klguf� deb_glZf�� b [ZgdZf� klhbl� h]jhfguomkbebc�ijhklh�\u`blv��Z gZ�k_jv_agu_�bg\_klbpbb�ijhklh�g_�hklZ_l�ky�j_kmjkh\ª�: dZd�jZkkm^bl� wlhl� kihj� wdhghfbq_kdZy� l_hjby"� �M\u��\ lhfijhkl_cr_f�__ \ZjbZgl_��dhlhjuc�baeZ]Z_lky�\ ihimeyjguo�mq_[gb�dZo�� wdhghfbq_kdZy� l_hjby� ml\_j`^Z_l�� qlh� \ Jhkkbb� [Zgdh\� [ulv\hh[s_�g_�^he`gh��< kZfhf�^_e_��kh\j_f_ggZy�wdhghfbq_kdZy�l_h�jby�hkgh\ghc�nmgdpb_c�[Zgdh\�ijbagZ_l� ljZgknhjfZpbx�k[_j_`_�gbc \ bg\_klbpbb��GZ� i_j\uc� \a]ey^� wlh� \_jgh� b ^ey� jhkkbckdbo[Zgdh\���[hevr_�iheh\bgu�bo�Zdlb\h\�dhlhjuo��khklZ\eyxl�dj_^blu\u^Zggu_�ijhfure_gguf�b lhj]h\uf� ij_^ijbylbyf��H^gZdh�� ^h�oh^� hl� bg\_klbpbc� \hafh`_g� lhevdh� \ mkeh\byo� wdhghfbq_kdh]hjhklZ�beb�ohly�[u�bgneypbb��dhlhjZy�^ey�nbgZgkh\hc�kbkl_fu�\u�]ey^bl�dZd�jhkl >�@��< Jhkkbb�`_�ihke_�j_nhjfu�j_Zevgh]h�wdhgh�fbq_kdh]h�jhklZ�g_�[ueh��Z bgneypby��\hl�m`_�ljb�]h^Z�dZd�ij_djZ�lbeZkv�LZdbf�h[jZahf��gZ^h�[he__�]em[hdh�\gbdgmlv�\ l_hjbx�b magZlvdZdb_� _s_� nmgdpbb� b bklhqgbdb� ^hoh^Z� [Zgdh\kdhc� kbkl_fu� hgZhlf_qZ_l�� LZdbo�nmgdpbc� ^\_� >��� �@�� h[_ki_q_gb_� b h[kem`b\Zgb_h[hjhlZ� b ^b\_jkbnbdZpby �kljZoh\Zgb_�� jbkdh\�� KjZam� aZf_lbf�qlh�\ hlkmlkl\b_�jhklZ�b bgneypbb�[Zgdh\kdZy�kbkl_fZ�\ p_ehf�g_fh`_l�jZkkqblu\Zlv�gZ�kbkl_fZlbq_kdh_�ba\e_q_gb_�keh`gh]h�ijh�p_glZ�ba�k\hbo�\eh`_gbc��<hafh`gh� lhevdh�ihemq_gb_�^heb�[he__beb�f_g__�ihklhygghc� kj_^g_c�ijb[ueb� deb_glh\��?^bgkl\_gguf�gh� \Z`guf� bkdexq_gb_f� y\ey_lky� hj]Zgbah\ZggZy� ]hkm^Zjkl\hf�ibjZfb^Z�� =DH�� ihdZ� ijbghkysZy� ihklhyggmx� \ukhdmx� ^hoh^�ghklv� ijb� jZkrbj_gbb� \eh`_gbc� b bf_ggh� ihwlhfm� hl\e_dZxsZy\k_�bf_xsb_ky�k\h[h^gu_�dZiblZeu�BlZd�h[jZlbfky�d ^\mf�mdZaZgguf�ihl_gpbZevguf�bklhqgbdZf^hoh^Z�[Zgdh\��ieZl_�aZ�jbkd�b aZ�hi_jZpbhggh_�h[kem`b\Zgb_�< fh^_eyo� ljZgaZdpbhggufb� ba^_j`dZfb� �klhbfhklvx� ijhp_�^mj�h[jZs_gby�^_g_]��h[uqgh�ij_g_[j_]Zxl��ihkdhevdm�\ jZa\blhckbkl_f_�jZkq_lh\�hgb�hlghkbl_evgh�g_�\_ebdb��< Jhkkbb��ihke_�lh]hdZd� oZjZdl_jgu_� ^ey� gZqZeZ� j_nhjf� agZqbl_evgu_� aZ^_j`db� h[jZ�s_gby�[ueb�ebd\b^bjh\Zgu��ljZgaZdpbhggu_�ba^_j`db�lh`_�fh]eb[u� kgbablvky�� gh� wlhfm� ij_iylkl\mxl� ^\Z� h[klhyl_evkl\Z�� \h�i_j\uo��k l_hj_lbq_kdhc�lhqdb�aj_gby�d ljZgaZdpbhgguf�ba^_j`dZfhlghkblky�hieZlZ�hdZau\Z_fuo�fgh]bfb�[ZgdZfb�mkem]�ih�hlfu\Z�gbx�g_e_]Zevguo�^hoh^h\�b m\h^m�e_]Zevguo�^hoh^h\�hl�gZeh]hh[�eh`_gby ±� � wlb�Zki_dlu�fu�gb`_�g_�jZkkfZljb\Z_f��\h�\lhjuo��\

Page 3: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

mkeh\byo�`_kldhc�fhg_lZjghc�iheblbdb�[Zgdb� hdZau\Zxlky�fhgh�ihevgufb�h[eZ^Zl_eyfb�hkljh^_nbpblgh]h�j_kmjkZ�±�^_g_]�b fh]mlba\e_dZlv�fhghihevgmx j_glm�Qlh�dZkZ_lky�kljZoh\uo�nmgdpbc�[Zgdh\�� lh�gZ�bo� kms_kl\_g�ghklv�mdZau\Zxl�wfibjbq_kdb_�gZ[ex^_gby� aZ�^_yl_evghklvx�ijh�\bgpbZevguo�[Zgdh\��K h^ghc�klhjhgu�hkgh\gZy�qZklv�bo�j_kmjkh\\eh`_gZ� \ dj_^blu� ijhfure_gghklb� b lhj]h\e_� �Z g_� \ =DH�� dZdqZklh� ibrml� \ ij_kk_��� k ^jm]hc� klhjhgu� [Zgdb� ^hklZlhqgh� e_]dhhlghkylky�d ijhkjhqd_�ieZl_`_c�ih� wlbf�dj_^blZf� >��� ��� �@��LZdh_ih\_^_gb_�oZjZdl_jgh�g_�^ey�bg\_klhjZ��m\_j_ggh]h�\ hl^Zq_�b `_�eZxs_]h� dZd�fh`gh� [uklj__� \_jgmlv� dZiblZe�� Z ^ey� kljZoh\Zl_ey�dhlhjuc�ihemqZ_l�ijb[uev�\ kj_^g_f��Z \ dZ`^hf�dhgdj_lghf�kem�qZ_� jbkdm_l�� LZdbf� h[jZahf�� fu� [m^_f� jZkkfZljb\Zlv� dj_^bluij_^ijbylbyf�dZd�k\h_]h�jh^Z�kljZoh\u_�\uieZlu��\u^Zggu_�[Zg�dZfb� ^ey� nbgZgkbjh\Zgby� ^hklZlhqgh� jbkdh\Zgguo� ijh_dlh\� ihj_ZebaZpbb�ijh^mdpbb�gZ�^_ij_kkb\ghf�\gmlj_gg_f�jugd_�Dj_^blmy�jbkdh\Zggu_�ijh_dlu��[Zgdb�klZedb\Zxlky�k ijh[e_�fhc�ebd\b^ghklb��Fu�ij_^iheZ]Z_f��qlh�hgb�j_rZxl�__ k ihfhsvxhi_jZpbc�gZ�^\mo�^hklZlhqgh�ebd\b^guo�jugdZo�=DH�b f_`[Zgdh\�kdh]h�dj_^blZ� �F;D���Hlf_lbf��qlh�klZlbklbdZ� >��@�ihdZau\Z_l�iZ�jZ^hdkZevgmx� kblmZpbx�� hlghkbl_evgh� g_[hevrb_�� gh� kms_kl\_g�gu_�� Zdlb\u� ijh\bgpbZevguo� [Zgdh\� \ \b^_� =DH�f_gvr_�� q_f� bog_llh�aZbfkl\h\Zgby�gZ�jugd_�F;D��ijhp_gl�ih�dhlhjuf�\ur_�^h�oh^ghklb�=DH�HdZau\Z_lky�� qlh� ij_^iheh`_gbc� h kljZoh\Zgbb� ijhba\h^kl�\_gguo�jbkdh\�b h �ehdZevgh��fhghihevghf�iheh`_gbb�[Zgdh\�hdZ�au\Z_lky�^hklZlhqgh��qlh[u�jZpbhgZevgh�hibkZlv�k ihfhsvx�fZl_�fZlbq_kdhc�fh^_eb�^_yl_evghklv�[Zgdh\�\ kh\j_f_gghc�jhkkbckdhcwdhghfbd_��Fh^_ev�h[tykgy_l�b mihfygmluc�\ur_�iZjZ^hdk�h^gh�\j_f_gguo�\eh`_gbc�\ F;D�b =DH�b \u]h^ghklv�bgl_]jZpbb�ij_^�ijbylbc�\hdjm]�[Zgdh\��;he__�lh]h��fh^_ev�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh�h[_ ijb�\_^_ggu_�\ur_�iheyjgu_�hp_gdb�^_yl_evghklb�[Zgdh\�\ hij_^_e_g�ghf� kfuke_� hijZ\^Zg��Fh^_ev�� h^gZdh�� ij_\jZsZ_l� wlb� hp_gdb� badZq_kl\_gguo� \ dhebq_kl\_ggu_�� iha\heyy� \ ijbgpbi_� ih^kqblZlvkdhevdh j_kmjkh\�\uk\h[h^blky��_keb�m\_ebqblky�gZ^_`ghklv�deb_g�lh\��gZkdhevdh g_h[oh^bfh�[ZgdZf�©djmlblvª�^_gv]b�gZ�ki_dmeylb\�guo�nbgZgkh\uo�jugdZo��b l�i��<hafh`ghklv�ijhbgl_jij_lbjh\Zlvk jZaguo�lhq_d�aj_gby�h^gm�b lm�`_�fh^_ev�b��l_f�kZfuf��i_j_\_klbim[ebpbklbq_kdb_� kihju� gZ� dhgkljmdlb\gmx� hkgh\m� ±� wlh� fh`_l[ulv�kZfZy�[hevrZy�ijZdlbq_kdZy�ihevaZ��dhlhjmx�fh]ml�ijbg_klbfZl_fZlbq_kdb_�fh^_eb�wdhghfbdb�

Page 4: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

GZdhg_p�aZf_lbf��qlh�ijbgylu_�]bihl_au�b hkgh\Zggh_�gZ�gbonhjfZebah\Zggh_� hibkZgb_� ^_yl_evghklb� [Zgdh\�� jZkkfZljb\Z_fh_gb`_��hlghkylky�\ hkgh\ghf�d ijh\bgpbZevguf�dhff_jq_kdbf�[Zg�dZf��Fhkdh\kdb_�[Zgdb�b K[_j[Zgd�JN�bkihegyxl�bgu_�nmgdpbb�Hgb�bf_xl�h]jhfgu_�\eh`_gby�\ =DH�b \uklmiZxl�dj_^blhjZfb�gZjugd_�F;D��Bo�]eZ\gufb�dj_^blgufb�j_kmjkZfb�kem`Zl�k[_j_`_�gby�gZk_e_gby� �� Fh^_ev�^_yl_evghklb�[ZgdZ���� Ij_^iheh`_gby�h[ hkgh\guo�hi_jZpbyo�b p_eyo�[ZgdZ=eZ\gZy�^_yl_evghklv�[ZgdZ� khklhbl� \ lhf��qlh� hg�ijb\e_dZ_l^_g_`gu_�kj_^kl\Z�\ \b^_�jZkq_lguo�b ^_ihablguo�kq_lh\�b bkihev�am_l�bo�\f_kl_�k kh[kl\_ggufb�kj_^kl\Zfb�^ey�\u^Zqb�kkm^�deb_g�lZf�b \eh`_gbc�\ ]hkm^Zjkl\_ggu_�p_ggu_�[mfZ]b��Qbkluc�^hoh^�ihemq_gguc�hl�wlbo�hi_jZpbc���[Zgd�jZkoh^m_l�^ey�nbgZgkbjh\Zgbyhi_jZpbc�\lhjbqguo��ijbh[j_l_gby�fZl_jbZevguo�Zdlb\h\��\uieZljZ[hlgbdZf�b Zdpbhg_jZf��mieZlu�gZeh]h\��mqZklby�\ ohayckl\_gghc^_yl_evghklb� b ijbh[j_l_gby� Zdpbc� b l� i�� <lhjbqgu_� hi_jZpbb[ZgdZ�a^_kv�g_�jZkkfZljb\Zxlky��Hq_gv�kms_kl\_gghc�khklZ\eyxs_c�^_yl_evghklb�[ZgdZ�y\ey_l�ky�jZ[hlZ�ih�ihbkdm�b ijb\e_q_gbx�gh\uo�\deZ^qbdh\��Z lZd`_�ihhp_gd_�ieZl_`_kihkh[ghklb�deb_glh\��H^gZdh�dZd�b \k_��k\yaZggh_�kihbkdhf�b h[jZ[hldhc�bgnhjfZpbb�� wlZ� ^_yl_evghklv� ijZdlbq_kdbg_�ih^^Z_lky�fh^_ebjh\Zgbx��Kms_kl\mxsb_�\ wlhc�h[eZklb�fh^_�eb� ihdZ� _s_� \_kvfZ� ijbfblb\gu� �kf��� gZijbf_j�� h[ahj� \ >��@��� ba^_kv�fu� [m^_f� kqblZlv�� qlh� [Zgd� ihemqZ_l� khhl\_lkl\mxsmx� bg�nhjfZpbx�[_kieZlgh�< jZfdZo� k^_eZgguo� ij_^iheh`_gbc� _kl_kl\_ggh� kqblZlv� p_�evx�^_yl_evghklb�[ZgdZ�fZdkbfbaZpbx�qbklh]h�^hoh^Z��gh�lh]^Z�_k�l_kl\_ggh�\hagbdZ_l�\hijhk�h lhf��dZd�khbaf_jyxlky�k_]h^gyrgb_�b[m^msb_� ^hoh^u��Fu� a^_kv� ijbgbfZ_f� h[uqgh_� ij_^iheh`_gb_�qlh�\ fhf_gl�\j_f_gb�W ihlhd�[m^msbo�^hoh^h\�<W hp_gb\Z_lky�_]hijb\_^_gguf�agZq_gb_f >��@

� JZkkfZljb\Z_fuc�a^_kv�qbkluc�^hoh^�hlebqZ_lky�hl�[ZeZgkh\hc�ijb[ueb�l_f�qlh�kqblZ_lky�g_�ih�gZqbke_gguf�ijhp_glZf��Z ih�nZdlbq_kdhfm�baf_g_gbx�eb�d\b^ghklb��FDVK�IORZ���kf��gb`_�� ?keb�^hoh^�hl�hi_jZpbc�k Zdpbyfb�kms_kl\_g_g��lh�wlh�m`_�g_�klhevdh�[Zgd�kdhevdh�nbgZgkh\Zy�dhfiZgby�

Page 5: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

139 � �¦ftW �W�W'�\W W�� ���]^_� '!�� ±� \gmlj_ggbc� dhwnnbpb_gl� ^bkdhglbjh\Zgby� [ZgdZ� �SXUHWLPH�SUHIHUHQFH���Dhwnnbpb_gl� ^bkdhglbjh\Zgby� ' ba^Z\gZ� kbkl_fZlbq_kdb� bmki_rgh� bkihevamxlky� ijb� fZl_fZlbq_kdhf� hibkZgbb� ih\_^_gbywdhghfbq_kdbo� Z]_glh\�� b�� l_f� g_�f_g__�� kgh\Z� b kgh\Z� \uau\Zxlkihju��Kmlv� ljm^ghkl_c� \ ke_^mxs_f�� ki_pbZebklu� ih�fbdjhwdh�ghfbd_� b hp_gd_� bg\_klbpbhgguo� ijh_dlh\� h[uqgh� j_dhf_g^mxlwdhghfbq_kdbf� Z]_glZf� [jZlv� \ dZq_kl\_� dhwnnbpb_glZ� ^bkdhglb�jh\Zgby� keh`b\rmxky� gZ� jugd_� klZ\dm� ijhp_glZ� ih� [_ajbkdh\ufZdlb\Zf� �^_ihablZf� beb� ]hkm^Zjkl\_gguf� p_gguf� [mfZ]Zf��� Z gZ\hijhk��q_f�hij_^_ey_lky�wlZ�klZ\dZ�j_dhf_g^mxl�h[jZlblvky�d ki_�pbZebklZf�ih�fZdjhwdhghfbd_��ki_pbZebklu�`_�ih�fZdjhwdhghfbd_m[_`^_gu��qlh�ijhp_gl�ih�[_ajbkdh\uf�Zdlb\Zf�hij_^_ey_lky�\gml�j_ggbfb�dhwnnbpb_glZfb�^bkdhglbjh\Zgby�wdhghfbq_kdbo�Z]_glh\b l_ogheh]bq_kdb� h[mkeh\e_gguf� ihl_gpbZehf� wdhghfbq_kdh]hjhklZ�Ij_^klZ\ey_lky�� qlh� \hagbdZxsbc� ihjhqguc� djm]� fh`gh� jZ�ahfdgmlv��_keb�ijb\e_qv�khh[jZ`_gby�h[�hl[hj_�ih\_^_gby�Z]_glh\gZ�jugd_�b bo�ih^jZ`Zgby�^jm]�^jm]m��Bf_ggh��fh`gh�ij_^klZ\blvk_[_��qlh�Z]_glu�bf_xl�jZagu_�\gmlj_ggb_�dhwnnbpb_glu�^bkdhg�lbjh\Zgby�b��khhl\_lkl\_ggh��\_^ml�k_[y�g_kdhevdh�ih�jZaghfm��?kebdhwnnbpb_gl�^bkdhglbjh\Zgby� kebrdhf� hldehgy_lky� hl� jughqghcklZ\db�ijhp_glZ��ih\_^_gb_�Z]_glZ�hdZau\Z_lky�g_Z^_d\Zlguf�h[t�_dlb\gh� kdeZ^u\Zxs_cky� gZ� jugd_� kblmZpbb�� b lZdhc� Z]_gl� eb[h[m^_l�bkdexq_g�ba�jugdZ��eb[h�kf_gbl�k\hc�dhwnnbpb_gl�^bkdhg�lbjh\Zgby��< j_amevlZl_�m h^ghlbiguo�Z]_glh\�keh`blky�ihqlb�_^b�guc�dhwnnbpb_gl�^bkdhglbjh\Zgby�b h^gh\j_f_ggh�keh`blky�khhl�\_lkl\mxsZy�_fm�klZ\dZ�ijhp_glZ�ih�[_ajbkdh\uf�Zdlb\Zf���Gb`_fu�dhgdj_lgh�bkihevam_f�lZdh]h�jh^Z�khh[jZ`_gby��qlh[u�hij_^_�eblv�khhlghr_gb_�f_`^m�\gmlj_ggbf�dhwnnbpb_glhf�^bkdhglbjh�\Zgby�[ZgdZ�b jughqgufb�klZ\dZfb�ijhp_glh\�� A^_kv�b ^Ze__�fu�ij_^iheZ]Z_f��qlh�bgneypby�hlkmlkl\m_l��?keb�[u�fu�aZoh�l_eb�__ mq_klv��d \_ebqbg_�' gZ^h�[ueh�[u�ijb[Z\blv�h`b^Z_fuc�l_fi�bgney�pbb�� < k\h_�\j_fy�fu�ihdZaZeb�gZ�mijhs_gghc�fh^_eb�ijbgpbibZevgmx�\hafh`�ghklv� lZdh]h�ijhp_kkZ� kh]eZkh\Zgby� dhwnnbpb_glh\� ^bkdhglbjh\Zgby� ihlj_[�e_gby��kf�>��@�

Page 6: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

GZdhg_p�k^_eZ_f�_s_�h^gh� aZf_qZgb_��Ihkdhevdm�^hoh^u��ih�klmiZxsb_�\ fhf_glu�W !W���' ^Zxl�fZeuc�\deZ^�\ 139������ \_eb�qbgm� ��' fh`gh� jZkkfZljb\Zlv� dZd� ]hjbahgl�ieZgbjh\Zgby� Z]_glZ�<ke_^kl\b_�ijhr_^rbo�\ �����_ ih�\k_fm�fbjm�dhfiZgbc�ijb\Zlb�aZpbb�� hldZaZ� ]hkm^Zjkl\� ih^^_j`b\Zlv� djmigu_� bg\_klbpbhggu_ijh_dlu� b h[s_c� ihl_j_c� q_eh\_q_kl\hf� ]eh[Zevghc� i_jki_dlb\ujZa\blby��]hjbahgl�ieZgbjh\Zgby�bg\_klhjh\�\ ihke_^g__�^_kylbe_�lb_�j_adh�khdjZlbeky��< j_amevlZl_�gZ�fbjh\hf�nbgZgkh\hf�jugd_h[jZah\Zeky�ba[ulhd�djZldhkjhqguo�dZiblZeh\�ijb�g_^hklZld_�^he�]hkjhqguo��Wlh�\ugm`^Z_l�dhfiZgbb��bf_xsb_�Zf[bpbhagu_�ieZ�gu�jhklZ���gZijbf_j�Dhj_ckdb_���nbgZgkbjh\Zlv�^he]hkjhqgu_�ijh�_dlu�k\h_]h�jZa\blby�aZ�kq_l�djZldhkjhqgh]h�dZiblZeZ��LZdZy�kblmZ�pby�g_mklhcqb\Z�b fh`_l�e_]dh�jZajmrblvky�eb[h�kZfZ�ih�k_[_��eb�[h�[eZ]h^Zjy�bkdmkghc�fZgbimeypbb��Ij_^klZ\ey_lky��qlh�bf_ggh�\wlhf� b [ueZ� ]em[bggZy� ijbqbgZ�:abZlkdh]h�nbgZgkh\h]h� djbabkZ����]��?keb� \ �����_ ]h^u� m\e_q_gb_� �hlgx^v� g_� lhevdh� \ KKKJ�]jZg^bhagufb�bg\_klbpbhggufb� ijh_dlZfb� ^_eZeh� wdhghfbdm� g_�]b[dhc� b __ ih\_^_gb_� qZklh� gZihfbgZeh� eh\ex� [Z[hqdb� dh\rhfwdkdZ\ZlhjZ��lh�l_i_jv�fgh]hfbeebZj^gu_�dZiblZeu��km^hjh`gh�f_�qmsb_ky�ih�nbgZgkh\uf�jugdZf��qZklh�g_�[j_a]mxsb_�djbfbgZev�gufb�ijbf_g_gbyfb��gZ\h^yl�gZ�h[jZa�^hfZ�� kljhys_]hky�gZ�nmg�^Zf_gl_�ba�ihjoZxsbo�[Z[hq_d�AZf_lbf��gZdhg_p��qlh�dZd�ihdZaZgh�\ >��@��fZehklv�]hjbahglh\ieZgbjh\Zgby�hdZau\Z_l�g_]Zlb\gh_�\ebygb_�g_�lhevdh�gZ�bg\_klb�pbhggmx�kn_jm��gh�b gZ�ihlj_[bl_evkdbc�jughd����� B_jZjoby�oZjZdl_jguo�\j_f_g�ijhp_kkh\>Z`_�_keb�fu�h]jZgbqb\Z_fky�lhevdh�hkgh\gufb�[Zgdh\kdbfbhi_jZpbyfb�� ihegh_� hibkZgb_� bo� hdZau\Z_lky� kebrdhf� keh`guf^ey�^_lZevgh]h�ZgZebaZ��Ihwlhfm�ijb�ihkljh_gbb�fh^_eb�[ZgdZ�fubkihevam_f�ba\_klgmx�b^_x�jZa^_e_gby�ijhp_kkh\�k jZagufb�oZjZd�l_jgufb�\j_f_gZfb��F_lh^�jZa^_e_gby�ijhp_kkh\�ih�oZjZdl_jguf\j_f_gZf� y\ey_lky� ]eZ\guf� bgkljmf_glhf� ihemq_gby� dhgdj_lguoj_amevlZlh\�\ nbabd_��Z \ wdhghfbd_�bklhjby�_]h�ijbf_g_gby�\hkoh�^bl�d :�FZjrZeem�>��@��dhlhjuc�ij_^eh`be�jZaebqZlv�djZldhkjhq�gh_�� kj_^g_kjhqgh_ b ^he]hkjhqgh_� jZ\gh\_kb_� gZ� jugd_��<h� \k_okemqZyo�kmlv�f_lh^Z�khklhbl�\ lhf��qlh�i_j_f_ggu_�oZjZdl_jbamx�sb_� ijhp_kk� ^_eylky� gZ� ©[uklju_ª� b ©f_^e_ggu_ª��Ijb� ZgZeba_^bgZfbdb� [ukljuo� i_j_f_gguo�� agZq_gby� f_^e_gguo� kqblZxlkynbdkbjh\Zggufb��Z ijb�ZgZeba_�^bgZfbdb�f_^e_gguo�i_j_f_gguo[uklju_�kqblZxlky�^hklb]rbfb�k\hbo�mklZgh\b\rboky�agZq_gbc�

Page 7: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

Ijb�ZgZeba_�^_yl_evghklb�[ZgdZ�f_^e_ggufb�fu�[m^_f�kqblZlv\_ebqbgu�� oZjZdl_jbamxsb_� dj_^blguc� ihjln_ev�� kj_^gbc� jZaf_j^_ihablh\�b kj_^gb_ hklZldb�l_dmsbo�kq_lh\��oZjZdl_jgh_�\j_fy�bobaf_g_gby� ±�g_kdhevdh�f_kyp_\��� Z [ukljufb� ±�ebd\b^gu_�Zdlb\u�dZkkm�b dhjj_kihg^_glkdb_�kq_lZ���Z lZd`_�hklZldb� aZbfkl\h\ZgbcgZ�f_`[Zgdh\kdhf�jugd_�dj_^blh\� �F;D��b \eh`_gbc�\ ]hkm^Zjkl�\_ggu_�p_ggu_�[mfZ]b��=DH��±�hgb�fh]ml�kms_kl\_ggh�baf_gblvkyaZ�\j_fy�ihjy^dZ�g_^_eb�< khhl\_lkl\bb�k gZ[ex^Z_fhc�kljmdlmjhc�Zdlb\h\�ijh\bgpb�Zevguo�[Zgdh\��[he__ ����±�kkm^u�deb_glZf��f_g__�����±�\eh`_gby\ =DH�� hkgh\guf� bklhqgbdhf� ^hoh^Z� [ZgdZ� kem`Zl� ©f_^e_ggu_ªhi_jZpbb��G_h[oh^bfhklv� [ukljuo� �l_dmsbo�� hi_jZpbc� \hagbdZ_lihlhfm��qlh�aZdexq_gb_�kh]eZr_gby�k deb_glhf�g_�hij_^_ey_l�ihe�ghklvx�ihjy^hd�ihklmie_gby�b jZkoh^h\Zgby�^_g_`guo�kj_^kl\�\h\j_f_gb��GZijbf_j��ijbgy\�^_gv]b�gZ�jZkq_lguc�kq_l��[Zgd�h[yam_l�ky�\u^Zlv�bo�ih�i_j\hfm�lj_[h\Zgbx�deb_glZ��<u^ZqZ�dj_^blZ�dZdijZ\beh�ijhbkoh^bl�g_�_^bgh\j_f_ggh��Z \ ihjy^d_�hieZlu�jZkoh�^h\�aZ_fsbdZ� �dj_^blgZy�ebgby���Ih]Zr_gb_�`_�dj_^blZ�b \uieZlZijhp_glh\� ijhbkoh^yl� \ gug_rgbo� jhkkbckdbo� mkeh\byo� ©ih� \ha�fh`ghklbª��Ih�wlbf�ijbqbgZf�[Zgd�^he`_g�ihklhyggh�aZ[hlblvky�hihdjulbb�\hagbdZxsbo�dZkkh\uo�jZaju\h\�Kh]eZkgh�f_lh^m� jZa^_e_gby� oZjZdl_jguo� \j_f_g�fu� kgZqZeZj_rbf� aZ^Zqm� mijZ\e_gby� ebd\b^ghklvx� ijb� aZ^Zgghf� dj_^blghfihjln_e_�� Z aZl_f�bkihevam_f� __ j_r_gb_� ^ey� hp_gdb�nbgZgkh\hcwnn_dlb\ghklb�dj_^blgh]h�ihjln_ey��=h\hjy� yaudhf� lhjbb� mijZ\�e_gby�fu�[m^_f�hp_gb\Zlv�©ijh]jZffmª� �dj_^blguc�ihjln_ev��bk�oh^y�ba�\hafh`ghkl_c�©j_]meylhjZª��l_dmsbo�hi_jZpbc��iZjbjh\Zlv©\hafms_gbyª��dZkkh\u_�jZaju\u���Wlh�dZd�fu�m\b^bf�gb`_�iha\h�ebl� gZf� [_a� ^hihegbl_evguo� ij_^iheh`_gbc� ihemqblv� g_� lhevdhhp_gdm�^hoh^ghklb��gh�b hp_gdm�jbkdZ dj_^blgh]h�ihjln_ey�BlZd�jZkkfhljbf�l_dmsb_�hi_jZpbb��>ey�ijhklhlu�[m^_f�kqb�lZlv��qlh�ebd\b^gu_�Zdlb\u�f_gyxlky�\ ^bkdj_lgu_�fhf_glu�\j_�f_gb��Ihkdhevdm�dj_^blguc�ihjln_ev�fu�kqblZ_f�nbdkbjh\Zgguf�kZev^h� ihklmie_gbc� b ieZl_`_c� W; ih� hi_jZpbyf� k jZkq_lgufbkq_lZfb��^_ihablZfb�b kkm^Zfb�deb_glh\�\ fhf_gl�\j_f_gb� W fh`ghkqblZlv�kemqZcghc�\_ebqbghc��\b^�nmgdpbb�jZkij_^_e_gby�dhlhjhcaZ\bkbl� hl� dj_^blgh]h� ihjln_ey� [ZgdZ�� KemqZcgu_� \_ebqbgu� W;ijb�jZaguo� W ^ey�ijhklhlu�kqblZxlky�g_aZ\bkbfufb�b h^bgZdh\hjZkij_^_e_ggufb�k nmgdpb_c�jZkij_^_e_gby�) b dhg_qguf�fZl_fZ�lbq_kdbf� h`b^Zgb_f�� WlZ� nmgdpby� jZkij_^_e_gby� b hibku\Z_l� \fh^_eb�dj_^blguc�ihjln_ev�b kj_^gbc�jZaf_j�^_ihablh\�b hklZldh\jZkq_lguo�kq_lh\

Page 8: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

;Zgd�hij_^_ey_l�\_ebqbgm�qbklh]h�^hoh^Z < ��bkoh^y�ba�nmgd�pbb jZkij_^_e_gby�kemqZcghc�\_ebqbgu� ; ��Ijb�j_ZebaZpbb�\_eb�qbgu�kZev^h� ; m [ZgdZ�h[jZam_lky�eb[h�g_^hklZlhd��eb[h�ba[ulhd^_g_]�� < i_j\hf� kemqZ_� [Zgd� aZgbfZ_l� g_^hklZxsb_� kj_^kl\Z� gZjugd_�djZldhkjhqguo�F;D��Z \h�\lhjhf�\deZ^u\Z_l�ba[ulhqgu_�j_�kmjku�\ =DH��>himkdZ_lky��qlh�djZcg_f�kemqZ_��[Zgd�fh`_l�l_ji_lvm[uldb� � ��< ���gZijbf_j��ihdju\Zy�bo� aZ� kq_l� j_ZebaZpbb� k\hbofZl_jbZevguo�Zdlb\h\�Ih�l_ogbq_kdbf�ijbqbgZf�ijh\bgpbZevgu_�[Zgdb�g_�fh]ml�\u�klmiZlv� dj_^blhjZfb� ih�F;D�� djhf_� lh]h�� bf� g_^hklmigu� kZfu_djZldhkjhqgu_�F;D��RYHUQLJKW���Ihwlhfm�^ey�ijh\bgpbZevguo�[Zg�dh\�oZjZdl_jgh_�\j_fy�hi_jZpbc�ih�F;D�b =DH�hdZau\Zxlky�ijb�f_jgh�h^bgZdh\ufb��g_^_ey���Z p_gZ�F;D�hdZau\Z_lky�kbkl_fZlbq_�kdb� b kms_kl\_ggh� \ur_� ^hoh^ghklb� =DH��Ihkdhevdm� =DH� a^_kvjZkkfZljb\Zxlky� dZd� bgkljmf_gl� mijZ\e_gby� ebd\b^ghklvx�� Z g_dZd�bklhqgbd�^hoh^h\��fu�kqblZ_f��qlh�[Zgd�g_�`^_l�bo�ih]Zr_gby�Z [ukljh�j_Zebam_l��>ey�ijhklhlu�ij_^iheZ]Z_lky�qlh�kjhd��gZ�dhlh�juc�[_jmlky�F;D�b kjhd� aZ�dhlhjuc�j_Zebamxlky�dmie_ggu_�=DHkh\iZ^Zxl�k rZ]hf�jZkq_lh\�\ fh^_eb�H[hagZqbf�q_j_a� WWW 6.0 �� ebd\b^gu_� Zdlb\u�[ZgdZ� �dZkkm�bhklZldb� dhjj_kihg^_glkdbo� kq_lh\��� _]h� aZbfkl\h\Zgby� gZ� jugd_F;D�b \eh`_gby�\ =DH�\ fhf_gl�\j_f_gb� W ��khhl\_lkl\_ggh��Z q_�j_a� VN 55 � ± ijhp_gl ih�F;D�b ^hoh^ghklv�=DH��khhl\_lkl\_ggh��<wlbo�h[hagZq_gbyo�bf__f�ke_^mxs__�mjZ\g_gb_�baf_g_gby�ebd\b^�guo�Zdlb\h\�� � � � ��WW�W�WWVWNW�W ;6.65�.5�00 ���� <�������� ���A^_kv�b gb`_�fu�iheZ]Z_f�ijhp_glu� VN 55 � ihklhyggufb��ohlyih�klZlbklbd_�hgb�aZf_lgh�baf_gyxlky�\ l_q_gb_�]h^Z��>_eh�a^_kv�\lhf��qlh�[Zgd�bgl_j_kmxl�g_�ba\_klgu_�ijhreu_�agZq_gby�ijhp_g�lh\�� Z ijh]gha�bo�baf_g_gby� \ [m^ms_f�� AZ^Z\Zlvky� dZdhc�lh� dhg�dj_lghc� [m^ms_c� ^bgZfbdhc� ijhp_glh\� ijb� bkke_^h\Zgbb� h[sboijh[e_f�g__kl_kl\_ggh��Z qZklh�ijbgbfZ_fh_�\ nbgZgkh\hf�ZgZeba_ij_^iheh`_gb_� h kemqZcghklb� [m^msbo� agZq_gbc� ijhp_glh\� g_lhevdh�ijbgpbibZevgh�mkeh`gy_l�aZ^Zqm��gh�b khfgbl_evgh�k f_lh�^heh]bq_kdhc�lhqdb�aj_gby��< kZfhf�^_e_��[Zgdh\�fgh]h�b deb_glh\m [ZgdZ�fgh]h��ihwlhfm�fh`gh�]h\hjblv�h g_dhlhjhc�klZlbklbq_kdhcih\lhjy_fhklb� \_ebqbg� lbiZ� W; �� Jughqgu_� `_� ijhp_glu� VN 55 �_^bgu�^ey�\k_]h�[Zgdh\kdh]h�khh[s_kl\Z�b baf_gyxlky�\f_kl_�k _]hkhklhygb_f�b h`b^Zgbyfb��=h\hjblv� a^_kv� h klZlbklbq_kdbo� aZ\b�

Page 9: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

kbfhklyo�b nemdlmZpbyo�\ lhf�kfuke_��dZd�h gbo�]h\hjyl�\ nbabd_�aZ\_^hfh�g_evay�K gZr_c�lhqdb�aj_gby�gZb[he__�jZamfguf�kihkh[hf�ijbf_g_�gby� ijb\h^bfuo� gb`_� j_amevlZlh\� y\ey_lky� ijbgpbi� kdhevays_]hieZgbjh\Zgby�� j_rblv� aZ^Zqm� \ ij_^iheh`_gbb�� qlh� ijhp_glu� kh�ojZgylvky�gZ�gZ[ex^Z_fhf�\ gZklhysbc�fhf_gl�mjh\g_��ijbf_gblvj_dhf_g^m_fu_� __ j_r_gb_f� mijZ\e_gby� gZ� h^ghf� i_jbh^_�� \aylvgh\u_�gZ[ex^Z_fu_�ijhp_glu�� kgh\Z� j_rblv� aZ^Zqm� mijZ\e_gby�bl�^��Bf_y�\ \b^m�wlhl�kihkh[�^_ckl\bc��fu�b jZkkfZljb\Z_f�ijhp_g�lu�dZd�ihklhyggu_�iZjZf_lju����� MijZ\e_gb_�ebd\b^gufb�Zdlb\Zfb��ZgZeba H[�SRVWQlh[u�ihykgblv�hkh[_gghklb�aZ^Zqb��ijh\_^_f�ke_^mxsb_�jZk�km`^_gby��Ij_^iheh`bf�qlh�gZ�bgl_j\Ze_�\j_f_gb� > @7W� j_Zebah\Z�eZkv� ihke_^h\Zl_evghklv� \_ebqbg�� k\yaZgguo� mjZ\g_gb_f� ���� JZk�kfhljbf�qZklbqgmx� kmffm� jy^Z�139� ��� b \ujZabf� \ g_c� ��W< kihfhsvx�mjZ\g_gby� �����Ihke_�hq_\b^guo�ij_h[jZah\Zgbc�gZc^_f�qlh� � ^ `� � � �

� � � �� � � �� �� � � ��7�77W �77W

�7�W WV

�7�W WN

�7�W W7

W WWVWNW7

W �W

60� .�6�5.�5

0�;�65.50�

��� ���� W WW��� W WW�

�� W WW� W WW� W �WW�

�'�� �'���'�'���'��'�

�'�'�'����� <'�

¦¦

¦¦¦

I_j\h_� keZ]Z_fh_� �nb]mjgZy� kdh[dZ��ihdZau\Z_l� \deZ^� \ 139gZqZevguo�ebd\b^guo�Zdlb\h\�[ZgdZ��<lhjh_�keZ]Z_fh_�aZ^Z_l�\deZ^\ 139 hl� hi_jZpbc� k deb_glZfb��Lj_lv_� keZ]Z_fh_� \ujZ`Z_l� mim�s_ggmx�\u]h^m�hl�lh]h��qlh�^_gv]b�[ueb�aZfhjh`_gu�\ \b^_�gZebq�ghklb�Q_l\_jlh_� keZ]Z_fh_� hibku\Z_l� \deZ^� \ 139 hl� hi_jZpbc� gZjugd_�F;D��Hg�fh`_l�[ulv�iheh`bl_evguf�beb�hljbpZl_evguf�\

Page 10: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

aZ\bkbfhklb� hl� agZdZ� jZaghklb� N5�' \gmlj_gg_]h� dhwnnbpb_glZ^bkdhglbjh\Zgby� b jughqghc� klZ\db� ijhp_glZ� ih� F;D�� ?keb�5N !�' ��139 \hajZklZ_l�ijb�jhkl_� aZbfkl\h\Zgbc��b [Zgd� kdeh�g_g��ijh_^Zlv��F;D��g_�\abjZy�gZ�m]jham�ih]ZrZlv�bo�aZ�kq_l�[m^m�sbo�m[uldh\��hljbpZl_evguo� ��W< ���LZdhc�[Zgd�[m^_l�ij_^ty\eylvg_h]jZgbq_gguc�kijhk�gZ�jugd_�F;D��qlh�ijb\_^_l��eb[h�d ih\u�r_gbx� N5 ��eb[h�d bkdexq_gbx�^Zggh]h�[ZgdZ�k jugdZ�\ k\yab�k _]hg_ieZl_`_kihkh[ghklvx�Iylh_�keZ]Z_fh_�hibku\Z_l�\deZ^�\ 139 hl�hi_jZpbc�gZ�jugd_=DH��?keb� �5V !'� ��139 g_h]jZgbq_ggh� jZklZ_l� ijb� jhkl_� \eh�`_gbc� \ =DH�� LZdhc� [Zgd� \iheg_� m^h\e_l\hjy_lky� ^hoh^ghklvx=DH�b g_�[m^_l� aZbgl_j_kh\Zg�\ hi_jZpbyo� k deb_glZfb��ijbghky�sbo� h]jZgbq_gguc� \deZ^� \ 139� AZf_lbf�� qlh� _keb� lZdbo� [Zgdh\fgh]h��bo�kijhk�gZ�jugd_�=DH�ihgbabl� V5R_klh_�keZ]Z_fh_�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh�[Zgd�fh`_l�bf_lv�iheh`b�l_evguc�qbkluc�^hoh^�b m\_ebqblv�139��_keb�g_�\ha\jZlbl�ihke_^�gbc F;D��\ayluc�gZ�bgl_j\Ze_�\j_f_gb� > @7W� ��Ijb� fo7 lZdh_�ih�\_^_gb_� ^Z_l� fZl_fZlbq_kdh_� hibkZgb_� nbgZgkh\hc� �ibjZfb^u��SRQV\�JDPH���GZ�j_Zevghf�jugd_�F;D�nbgZgkh\Zy��ibjZfb^Z��bk�dexqZ_lky� ebfblZfb� dj_^blh\Zgby�� ihwlhfm� \ aZ^Zq_� mijZ\e_gbyebd\b^ghklvx�gZ^h�lj_[h\Zlv��qlh[u� �.77 o' � ijb� fo7 �Ihke_^g__�keZ]Z_fh_�\hagbdeh�ba�aZ�lh]h��qlh�fu�jZkkfhlj_ebqZklbqgmx� kmffm� ^ey� \ujZ`_gby� 139�� Hgh� g_kms_kl\_ggh�� _kebjZkkfZljb\Zlv� aZ^Zqm� mijZ\e_gby� ebd\b^ghklvx� gZ� [_kdhg_qghfbgl_j\Ze_�\j_f_gb�Ijh\_^_gguc�ZgZeba�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh��\h�i_j\uo��aZ^Zqm�mijZ\�e_gby� ebd\b^ghklvx�bf__l� kfuke� jZkkfZljb\Zlv� lhevdh� _keb�ijh�p_gl�ih�F;D�[hevr_�ijhp_glZ�ih�=DH��Z \gmlj_ggbc�dhwnnbpb_gl^bkdhglbjh\Zgby�[ZgdZ�aZdexq_g�f_`^m�gbfb��ijbq_f�yk_g�\ ijbg�pbi_�b f_oZgbaf�\hagbdgh\_gby�mdZaZggh]h�kh]eZkh\Zgby�ijhp_glh\b dhwnnbpb_glh\�^bkdhglbjh\Zgby��Ijb�wlbo�mkeh\byo�ihemqZ_lkyhp_gdZ�k\_jom�^ey�\_ebqbgu�139 �� � � � � � �FRQVW65�.5�0� WVWNWW �W �����d<'�¦f W �WW����� MijZ\e_gb_�ebd\b^gufb�Zdlb\Zfb��ZgZeba�H[�DQWH�AZ^ZqZ� mijZ\e_gby� ebd\b^ghklvx� [ZgdZ� hibku\Zxlky� dZd� \u�[hj� mijZ\e_gbc� ���� �W�W�W�W �6�.�0 ���� <ttt k\yaZgguo� h]jZ�

Page 11: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

gbq_gb_f������Ihkdhevdm�ijhp_kk�baf_g_gby�dZkkh\h]h�hklZldZ�hib�kZg�dZd�kemqZcguc��ke_^m_l�kqblZlv��qlh�[Zgd�mijZ\ey_l�l_dmsbfbhi_jZpbyfb� \ aZ\bkbfhklb� hl� keh`b\r_]hky� khklhygby`��^ WWWW 6.0= b j_ZebaZpbb� kemqZcghc� \_ebqbgu� W; �� IhwlhfmkljZl_]bx�[ZgdZ�ke_^m_l�hibku\Zlv�q_l\_jdhc�nmgdpbc�� � � � � � � �^ �̀a��a��a�a =;=6;=.;=0 < : ���ihdZau\Zxsbo� dZd� [Zgd� \u[bjZ_l� �W�W�W�W 6.0 ���� <��� \ khklhy�gbb = ijb�\hafms_gbb�; ��Wlb�nmgdpbb�^he`gu�m^h\e_l\hjylv�mk�eh\byf�� � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � ��a�a�a�a ��a��a��a =;;=6;=.65�.5�;=0 �;=6�;=.�;=0 VN <�������{ ttt

< hij_^_e_gbb�kljZl_]bb���� \Z`gh�lh��qlh�\_ebqbgZ�ieZgbjm_�fh]h�[Zgdhf�qbklh]h�^hoh^Z� � �=<a kqblZ_lky�g_�aZ\bkys_c�hl�l_dm�s_c�\_ebqbgu�kZev^h�ih�hi_jZpbyf�k deb_glZfb� ; ��Kh^_j`Zl_evghwlh�hagZqZ_l��qlh�[Zgd�^he`_g�h[_ki_qblv�hlghkbl_evgh�klZ[bevgucihlhd�qbklh]h�^hoh^Z��g_�j_Z]bjmxsbc�gZ�dZ`^mx�nemdlmZpbx�\_�ebqbgu� W; �KljZl_]by� : b gZqZevgh_� khklhygb_� �= hij_^_eyxl� fZjdh\�kdbc�ijhp_kk�baf_g_gby�khklhygby�[ZgdZ��^ `� � � � � �^ ` � �WWWWWWWW �W�W�W�W ;=*;=6;=.;=0 6.0= ��a��a��a �� :���� ���b ihke_^h\Zl_evghklv�kemqZcguo�\_ebqbg� ��a W�W =< < � ���

< khhl\_lkl\bb�k ijh\_^_gguf�\ ij_^u^ms_f�jZa^_e_�ZgZebahfihlj_[m_f�� qlh[u� kljZl_]by� ]ZjZglbjh\ZeZ� hlkmlkl\b_� ibjZfb^u�l� _��qlh[u�\ jZkkfZljb\Z_fhf�fZjdh\kdhf�ijhp_kk_�k \_jhylghklvx��\uihegyehkv�khhlghr_gb_

�FZl_fZlbq_kdb�kljh]h_�hibkZgb_�fh^_eb�ijb\_^_gh�\ >��@�

Page 12: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

�.WWW ' �foPOL �� � � � ���Z iZjZf_lju�m^h\e_l\hjyeb�g_jZ\_gkl\Zf�NV 55� �'�� ���

< khhl\_lkl\bb� k ijbgyluf� \ur_� djbl_jb_f�139 ����� aZ^ZqmmijZ\e_gby�ebd\b^ghklvx�ihklZ\bf�dZd�\u[hj� kljZl_]bb� : ��dhlh�jZy fZdkbfbabjm_l� h`b^Z_fmx� \_ebqbgm�^bkdhglbjh\Zggh]h�qbk�lh]h�^hoh^Z��139�� � �_�� °¿°¾½°̄°®­ <'� ¦f W WW�: W WW ==�=- ( ���

A^_kv�b gb`_�( ±�agZd�fZl_fZlbq_kdh]h�h`b^Zgby�<ur_�ihdZaZgh��qlh�ijb�mkeh\byo��������� \_ebqbgZ� :- h]jZgb�q_gZ�k\_jom�^ey�\k_o�: b��l_f�kZfuf��aZ^ZqZ�__ fZdkbfbaZpbb�fZ�l_fZlbq_kdb�dhjj_dlgZ�<_ebqbgZ� :- aZ\bkbl�hl�bkoh^gh]h�khklhygby�= b fh`_l�jZk�kfZljb\Zlvky� dZd� hp_gdZ� wlh]h� khklhygby��gZoh^ykv� \ khklhygbb�=[Zgd��ijbf_gyxsbc�kljZl_]bx�: fh`_l�h`b^Zlv�ihemqblv�ijb\_�^_gguc�^hoh^� :- � =���Ba \ujZ`_gby ��� b mjZ\g_gby���� g_ljm^gh\u\_klb�khhlghr_gb_� �mjZ\g_gb_�Dhefh]hjh\Z��g_y\gh�hij_^_eyx�s__� :- dZd�nmgdpbx��hp_gdm��khklhygby�� � `^ �������a�� ;=*-�==- ;� ::�: '��< ( �� � ���Wlh�mjZ\g_gb_�ihdZau\Z_l��qlh� :- kdeZ^u\Z_lky�ba�l_dms_]h�^hoh�^Z� � ��a =< b ^bkdhglbjh\Zggh]h�kj_^g_]h�agZq_gby�hp_gdb�khklhygby��� ;=*: ��\ dhlhjh_�fu�ihiZ^_f�ihke_�i_j\h]h�rZ]Z��kf�������>himklbfmx� kljZl_]bx� :Ö � � � � � � � �^ `=;=6;=.;=0 <Ö��Ö��Ö�Ö [m�^_f� gZau\Zlv� hilbfZevghc�� _keb� \ ex[hf� khklhygbb� hgZ� h[_sZ_lagZq_gb_�139 [hevr__��q_f�ex[Zy�^jm]Zy�kljZl_]by

������Ö Ö =-=-=- :: t ����?keb�hilbfZevgZy�kljZl_]by�kms_kl\m_l��lh� ��Ö =- m^h\e_l\hjy�_l�mjZ\g_gbx�Dhefh]hjh\Z������ijb�: :Ö ijbq_f�\ kbem�hilbfZev�ghklb�kljZl_]bb�:Ö gbdZdh_�baf_g_gb_�nmgdpbc� � �;=0 �Ö �� � �;=. �Ö �

Page 13: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

� �;=6 �Ö �� � �=<Ö g_�fh`_l�m\_ebqblv�ijZ\mx�qZklv� wlh]h�mjZ\g_gby�Bgufb�keh\Zfb� �� � � � � �

»»»»»¼º

«««««¬ª

°°¿°°¾½

°°̄°°®­

ccc'��<

tctctc <��c�c� ����� c< ���Ö��Ö

��� � 6.0-� �6.0-

�6�.�0 ;6. 65�.5�00; VNPD[(PD[ �� ����

Wlh� mjZ\g_gb_� gZau\Z_lky� mjZ\g_gb_f� ;_eefZgZ�� Hgh� hij_^_ey_ldZd� ��Ö =- �� lZd� b hilbfZevgmx� kljZl_]bx� :Ö �� ?keb� fu� ih^[_j_fnmgdpbx� ��Ö =- ��m^h\e_l\hjyxsmx� ������lh�\ ijbgpbi_�kfh`_f�hi�j_^_eblv�b lhqdb�0c��.c��6c��<��\ dhlhjuo�^hklb]Zxlky�fZdkbfmfu�\ijZ\hc�qZklb�������Wlb�lhqdb�[m^ml�aZ\bk_lv�hl�; b ^ ` =6.0 �� ��bwlZ� aZ\bkbfhklv� hij_^_ebl� bkdhfu_� khklZ\eyxsb_� hilbfZevghckljZl_]bb� � �;=0 �Ö �� � �;=. �Ö �� � �;=6 �Ö �� � �=<Ö ��<uiheg_gb_�lj_[h\Z�gby�g_aZ\bkbfhklb�< hl� ; h[_ki_qb\Z_lky�l_f��qlh�fZdkbfbaZpbyih�< \ hlebqb_�hl�fZdkbfbaZpby�ih� 6.0 ccc �� \uihegy_lky�ihke_��Zg_�^h�mkj_^g_gby�ih ; �MjZ\g_gb_�;_eefZgZ�fh`gh� khklZ\blv�^ey�[hevrbgkl\Z�^bgZ�fbq_kdbo�aZ^Zq�hilbfZevgh]h�mijZ\e_gby�b ^_l_jfbgbjh\Zgguo��bklhoZklbq_kdbo�b ^Z`_�b]jh\uo���h^gZdh��j_rblv�wlh�mjZ\g_gb_�ZgZ�eblbq_kdb�m^Z_lky�\ kqblZgghf�qbke_�kemqZ_\��H^gbf�ba�lZdbo�kqZ�kleb\uo�kemqZ_\�y\ey_lky�jZkkfZljb\Z_fZy� aZ^ZqZ�mijZ\e_gby�ebd�\b^ghklvx�[ZgdZ�<\_^_f�h[hagZq_gb_� � � �65�.5�0 VN �����< )b ijb\_^_f�mjZ\g_gb_�;_eefZgZ����� d \b^m� GZijbf_j��_keb�bkoh^blv�ba�ijbgpbiZ�gZbf_gvr_]h�^_ckl\by��fh`gh� khklZ�\blv�mjZ\g_gb_�;_eefZgZ�^ey�f_oZgbq_kdh]h�^\b`_gby��Wlh�[m^_l�mjZ\g_gb_�\qZklguo� ijhba\h^guo� i_j\h]h� ihjy^dZ�� kh^_j`Zs__� hi_jZpbx� fZdkbfbaZpbbg_ba\_klghc�nmgdpbb��< aZ^ZqZo�f_oZgbdb�wlhl�fZdkbfmf�fh`gh�\uqbkeblv��g_agZy�j_r_gby��b ihemqblv�ba�mjZ\g_gby�;_eefZgZ�mjZ\g_gb_�=ZfbevlhgZ�Ydh[b^ey�\_ebqbgu�^_ckl\by��dhlhjh_�y\ey_lky�ZgZeh]hf�nmgdpbb� -Ö ��J_r_gb_�mjZ\�g_gby�;_eefZgZ�f_lh^hf�oZjZdl_jbklbd�nhjfZevgh�^Z_l�khhlghr_gby�ijbgpbiZfZdkbfmfZ�Ihgljy]bgZ�

Page 14: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

� � � � � �� � ���Ö

��Ö��� °¿

°¾½°̄°®­

°¿°¾½°̄°®

­ ccc'��)������

)��c�c c tccc) 6.0-� �65�.5�06.0-

;6.0 �6.0;VN

PD[(PD[ ����

FZdkbfmf�\ ijZ\hc�qZklb����� g_�aZ\bkbl�hl� 6.0 �� ��ke_^h\Zl_evghnmgdpby�;_eefZgZ�ebg_cgZ�� � � � ����� 965�.5�06.0- VN ����� ����Ih^klZ\eyy�wlh�\ujZ`_gb_�\ ������ihemqZ_f��qlh '9

� � � � � �� � °°¿°°¾½

°°̄°°®­

°°¿°°¾½

°°̄°°®­

c��c��)��c�c'��)�t)�� �c�c tcc) 65�.5�;6.� � VN�; 6. �6.;��PD[(PD[

Ihkdhevdm� VN 55 ! �� \ujZ`_gb_� � ��)��c�c ;6. � �.5� N c� �� �65� V c�� \hajZklZ_l��dh]^Z�. c b 6c mf_gvrZxlky�gZ�h^gm�b lm�`_\_ebqbgm��Ba�wlh]h�ke_^m_l��qlh�\gmlj_ggbc�fZdkbfmf�^hklb]Z_lkyijb�agZq_gbyo�0 c � ���) c ;. � � ��)� c ;6 �

]^_�\ujZ`_gb_� �[ h[hagZqZ_l� `^ �[�PD[ ��b \ ����� � � �

� � � � � � � �¿¾½®̄­ )�'��)'�) ¿¾½®̄­ ¿¾½®̄­ )�'��)'��)

³³ f)

)f�)

��);G);5;G);5

;5;59VN

VN;PD[

(PD[ ����]^_�) ±�nmgdpby�jZkij_^_e_gby�kemqZcguo�\_ebqbg� W; �>bnn_j_gpbjh\Zgb_f� ih� ) e_]dh� ihdZaZlv�� qlh� fZdkbfmf� \���� ^hklb]Z_lky�ijb�)��m^h\e_l\hjyxs_f�mjZ\g_gbx

Page 15: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

��� VN V55 5) ��' ) ����dhlhjh_�\ kbem���� \k_]^Z�bf__l�_^bgkl\_ggh_�j_r_gb_�DZd�]h\hjbehkv�\ur_��agZgb_�lhq_d�fZdkbfmfZ�\ ���� iha\hey_lhibkZlv� hilbfZevgmx� kljZl_]bx� :Ö � �^ ;=0 �Ö �� � �;=. �Ö �� � �;=6 �Ö �� �̀=<Ö ��HgZ�dZd�e_]dh�ijh\_jblv�[m^_l�lZdhc��� � �;=0 {�Ö ����� � > @��) ;;=. �Ö � � > @ ��Ö �)� ;;=6 ����� � � � � �65�.5�0= VN ����)� <Ö �� ����]^_�dhgklZglZ�) hij_^_ey_lky�mjZ\g_gb_f�����Kfuke� ihemq_gguo� \ujZ`_gbc� ^ey� hilbfZevghc� kljZl_]bb�hq_gv�ijhkl��<h�i_j\uo��g_�ke_^m_l�^_j`Zlv�\ dZkk_�ebrgbo�^_g_]�<h�\lhjuo��qbkluc�^hoh^�gZ^h�ieZgbjh\Zlv�ih�ijZ\bem����� \ aZ\b�kbfhklb�hl� l_dms_]h�khklhygby�dj_^blgh]h�ihjln_ey� ) ��ijhp_glZih�F;D� N5 ��^hoh^ghklb�=DH� V5 b \b^h\�gZ�[m^ms__��dhlhju_�\u�jZ`Zxlky� ghjfhc� ^bkdhglZ� [m^msbo� ^hoh^h\� ' � <�lj_lvbo�� _kebl_dms_]h� ^hoh^Z� � � � �65�.5�; VN ���� g_� o\ZlZ_l�� qlh[u� ihem�qblv�aZieZgbjh\Zgguc�^hoh^�< ��^_nbpbl�^_g_]�gZ^h�ihdju\Zlv�aZ�bfkl\h\Zgbyfb�gZ�F;D��< ijhlb\ghf�kemqZ_�\k_�hklZ\rb_ky�^_gv]bgZ^h�\deZ^u\Zlv�\ =DH�

���� Fbdjh��beb�fZdjh��fh^_ev"Ihemq_ggZy� \ur_� hilbfZevgZy� kljZl_]by� mijZ\e_gby� ebd\b^�gufb�Zdlb\Zfb�[ZgdZ�lj_[m_l��qlh[u�hklZldZ�ebd\b^guo�Zdlb\h\�g_[ueh� \h\k_ ������ qlh�� hq_\b^gh�� g_� khhl\_lkl\m_l� j_Zevghklb�� Wlhh[tykgy_lky�l_f��qlh�\ jZkkfhlj_gghc�\ur_�aZ^Zq_�fu�g_�mqeb�h]�jZgbq_gbc�ebd\b^ghklb��kf���gZijbf_j��>��@�� >ey�[ZgdZ�wlb�h]jZgb�q_gby�k\yaZgu�k g_h[oh^bfhklvx�gZdZieb\Zlv�ebd\b^ghklv�^ey�ih�djulby� g_dhlhjuo� nbdkbjh\Zgguo� khklZ\eyxsbo� qbklh]h� ^hoh^Z�aZjieZlu� khljm^gbdZf�� gZeh]h\�� ^b\b^_g^h\��� g_\hafh`ghklvx� ?keb�) bf__l�jZaju\u��j_r_gb_f�kqblZ_lky�lhqdZ��ke_\Z�hl�dhlhjhc�) f_gvr_)��Z kijZ\Z�±�[hevr_�� Fu� ihemqbeb� mjZ\g_gb_� ;_eefZgZ� dZd� g_h[oh^bfh_� mkeh\b_� hilbfZevghklbkljZl_]bb��ihwlhfm��kljh]h�]h\hjy��gZ^h�_s_�^hdZaZlv��qlh�hilbfZevgZy�kljZl_�]by�kms_kl\m_l�b qlh�gZc^_ggZy�gZfb�kljZl_]by�:Ö g_�ihjh`^Z_l�ibjZfb^u��kf�������Khhl\_lkl\mxsb_�^hdZaZl_evkl\Z�ijb\_^_gu�\ >��@

Page 16: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

\aylv�f_`[Zgdh\kdbc� dj_^bl� g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh� i_j_^� ieZl_`hf�� b^j�� Mqblu\Zy� wlb� h]jZgbq_gby� k jZaghc� kl_i_gvx� ^_lZevghklb�fh`gh�ihemqblv�p_euc�ki_dlj�aZ^Zq�mijZ\e_gby�ebd\b^ghklvx��ih�^h[guo�jZkkfhlj_gghc�\ur_��gh�[he__�keh`guo��J_r_gb_�h^ghc�bawlbo�aZ^Zq�[ueh�bkihevah\Zgh�gZfb�ijb�hibkZgby�^_yl_evghklb�j_�]bhgZevghc� [Zgdh\kdhc� kbkl_fu� \ jZfdZo� jZ[hlu� ih� fh^_ebjh\Z�gbx�wdhghfbdb�b dj_^blgh�^_g_`ghc�kn_ju�K\_j^eh\kdhc�h[eZklb�\uiheg_gghc�\ ���������]��jZ[hq_c� ]jmiihc�<P�J:G�ih^�jmdh\h�^kl\hf�ZdZ^_fbdZ�J:G�:�:� I_ljh\Z��kf��lZd`_�>��@���< wlhc�mkeh`�g_gghc�fh^_eb�\f_klh����� ihemqZ_lky�\ujZ`_gb_� � D;=0 �Ö � � E= �<Ö � �;=6 �Ö]^_�D��E ±�dhgklZglu��\ujZ`Zxsb_�h]jZgbq_gby�ebd\b^ghklb�� � �=<Ö �� �;=. �Ö �� � �;=6 �Ö ih� ij_`g_fm� hij_^_eyxlky� \ujZ`_gbyfb� �����������Z ijZ\Zy�qZklv�mjZ\g_gby����� klZgh\blky�g_kdhevdh�keh`g__�Djhf_�h]jZgbq_gbc�ebd\b^ghklb�\ fh^_eb�dZd�wdah]_gguc�nZd�lhj�[ueb�mql_gu�g_db_�^h\hevgh�aZ]Z^hqgu_�i_jbh^bq_kdb_�]Zjfh�gbq_kdb_�dhe_[Zgby��ijhgbau\Zxsb_�kbgojhggh�\k_�ihdZaZl_eb�kh��� NZdlbq_kdb�\ gZqZe_�hi_jZpbhggh]h�^gy�[Zgd�^he`_g�bf_lv�gZ�k\h_f�dhjj_k�ihg^_glkdhf�kq_l_�\ P;�kmffm�^hklZlhqgmx�^ey�ihdjulby�\k_o�k\hbo�ieZl_`�guo�ihjmq_gbc�g_aZ\bkbfh�hl�h[t_fZ�h`b^Zxsboky�\ wlhl�^_gv�ihklmie_gbc�

���������������������������yg\��

�Zij��

�bxe��

�hdl��

�yg\��

�Zij��

�bxe��

�hdl��

�yg\��

�Jbk���

Page 17: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

klhygby�wdhghfbdb�j_]bhgZ��Ki_pbZebklu�ih�wdhghfbq_kdhc�klZlb�klbd_�gZau\Zxl�wlb�dhe_[Zgby�k_ahggufb��gh�nZdlbq_kdb�bo�i_jbh^b nZaZ�g_�khhl\_lkl\mxl�gb debfZlbq_kdbf�k_ahgZf��gb nbgZgkh\ufpbdeZf��kjhdZf�ih^Zqb�hlq_lghklb�b gZeh]h\uo�ieZl_`_c���gb dhe_�[Zgbyf�l_fiZ�bgneypbb�b ijhp_glh\�\ fZkrlZ[_�kljZgu�GZ�jbk����ihdZaZgZ�^bgZfbdZ�kj_^gbo�agZq_gbc�kmffZjgh]h�hk�lZldZ� ebd\b^guo� Zdlb\h\� [Zgdh\� j_]bhgZ�� \uqbke_ggZy� ih�fh^_eb�ebgby��b nZdlbq_kdb_� agZq_gby� wlh]h�ihdZaZl_ey�\aylu_�ba� klZlb�klbdb� �lhqdb���Kj_^g__�hldehg_gb_�fh^_eb�hl�klZlbklbdb�ih�wlhfmihdZaZl_ex�f_g__������dhwnnbpb_gl�dhjj_eypbb�fh^_evgh]h�b klZ�lbklbq_kdh]h�jy^Z�[he__�����LZdbfb�j_amevlZlZfb�g_� ]j_o�iho\ZklZlvky��gh�[he__� ]em[hdh_bo�hkfuke_gb_�gZ\_jgh�\uah\_l�m qblZl_ey�g_dhlhjh_�g_^hmf_gb_�Ijbf_g_gb_� hilbfZevghc� kljZl_]bb� ���� ^he`gh� ijb\h^blv� d ih�klhygguf�beb��k mq_lhf�©k_ahgguo�dhe_[Zgbcª��d i_jbh^bq_kdb�dh�e_[exsbfky�kj_^gbf�agZq_gbyf�ihdZaZl_e_c�khklhygby�[ZgdZ��Z gZjbk� ��\b^gu�Zi_jbh^bq_kdb_�dhe_[Zgby"�Fh^_ev�hibku\ZeZ�jZpbh�gZevgh_�ih\_^_gb_�h^gh]h�[ZgdZ��Z ijbf_g_gZ�d hibkZgbx�kh\hdmi�ghklb�[Zgdh\�j_]bhgZ��khklhys_c�ba�ijbf_jgh����g_aZ\bkbfuo�[Zg�dh\��g_�bf_xsbo�_^bgh]h�p_gljZ��dhlhjuc�^bdlh\Ze�[u�bf�h[smxkbgojhggmx�kljZl_]bx�mijZ\e_gby�ebd\b^gufb�Zdlb\Zfb"GZ�i_j\uc�\hijhk�hl\_lblv�ijhklh��J_r_gb_�aZ^Zqb�hilbfZev�gh]h� mijZ\e_gby� ebd\b^gufb� Zdlb\Zfb� \ jZfdZo� fh^_eb� j_]bhgZbkihevah\Zehkv�kh]eZkgh�mihfygmlhfm�\ dhgp_�jZa^_eZ���� ijbgpb�im�kdhevays_]h�ieZgbjh\Zgby��H[t_f�aZbfkl\h\Zgbc�ih�F;D�b \eh�`_gbc�\ =DH�hij_^_eyeky�kh]eZkgh�hilbfZevghc�kljZl_]bb� ���� ihl_dms_fm�khklhygbx�dj_^blgh]h�ihjln_ey�) ��b l_dmsbf�agZq_gbyfijhp_glZ�ih�F;D� N5 ��^hoh^ghklb�=DH� V5 �� Z aZl_f� wlb� \_ebqbgubaf_gyebkv��Dj_^blguc�ihjln_ev�±�\ kbem�hibkZggh]h�\ fh^_eb�ba�f_g_gby�nbgZgkh\h]h�khklhygby�deb_glh\� �kf��gb`_���Z N5 �� V5 ±�\kbem�gZ[ex^Z_fh]h�baf_g_gby�gZ�jhkkbckdbo�nbgZgkh\uo�jugdZo���GZ�\hijhk�h lhf��fh`gh�eb�ijbf_gylv�fh^_ev�h^gh]h�[ZgdZ�dp_ehc�kbkl_f_��g_�bf_xs_c�_^bgh]h�mijZ\eyxs_]h�p_gljZ��hl\_lblv]hjZa^h�keh`g__��A^jZ\uc�kfuke��\hkiblZgguc�gZ�fh^_eyo�nbabq_�kdbo� kbkl_f�� ]h\hjbl�� qlh� ijbf_g_gb_� fh^_eb� d kbkl_f_� [Zgdh\^he`gh�^Zlv�j_amevlZlu�om^rb_��q_f�__ ijbf_g_gb_�d dZ`^hfm�hl�^_evghfm�[Zgdm�kbkl_fu��< kZfhf�^_e_��dZ`^uc�[Zgd�bf__l��\hh[s_�� Ijhp_glu� hij_^_eyxlky� gZ� gZpbhgZevguo�nbgZgkh\uo� jugdZo� b g_� fh]ml[ulv�jZkkqblZgu�k ihfhsvx�fh^_eb�j_]bhgZevghc� wdhghfbdb��Fh^_ev� kh\j_�f_gghc�jhkkbckdhc�wdhghfbdb��dhlhjZy�fh]eZ�[u�wlh�k^_eZlv�\ gZklhys__�\j_fyjZajZ[Zlu\Z_lky�gZr_c�jZ[hq_c�]jmiihc�

Page 18: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

]h\hjy�� k\hc� dhwnnbpb_gl� ^bkdhglbjh\Zgby� ' b k\hc� dj_^blgucihjln_ev�)��GZeh`_gb_�`_�kljZl_]bc�j_rZxsbo�jZagu_�hilbfbaZ�pbhggu_�aZ^Zqb�g_�h[jZam_l��\hh[s_�]h\hjy��hilbfZevghc�kljZl_]bbgb ^ey�dZdhc�hilbfbaZpbhgghc�aZ^Zqb�^ey�\k_c�kbkl_fu�Hiul�fh^_ebjh\Zgby wdhghfbdb��h^gZdh��g_^\mkfuke_ggh�ih�dZau\Z_l��qlh�wlhl� a^jZ\uc�\a]ey^�hrb[hq_g��<j_f_ggu_�jy^u�ba�f_g_gby� hklZldh\� ebd\b^guo� Zdlb\h\� hl^_evguo� [Zgdh\� y\eyxlkybgnhjfZpb_c� \_kvfZ� dhgnb^_gpbZevghc�� H^gZdh�� ihiZ^Z\rbo� \jZagh_�\j_fy�\ jZkihjy`_gb_�Z\lhjh\�^Zgguo�^hklZlhqgh��qlh[u�ml�\_j`^Zlv�kh�\k_c�hij_^_e_gghklvx��qlh�ijb\_^_ggZy�\ur_�fh^_evg_�^Zkl lZdbo�ohjhrbo�j_amevlZlh\��dZdb_�ijb\_^_gu�gZ�jbk� ���gb^ey�h^gh]h�dhgdj_lgh]h�[ZgdZ��>_eh�a^_kv��\b^bfh�\ lhf��qlh�kljZ�l_]bb�[Zgdh\�g_�ijhklh�gZdeZ^u\Zxlky�^jm]�gZ�^jm]Z��;Zgdb�gZoh�^ylky� f_`^m� kh[hc� \ keh`guo� hlghr_gbyo� ki_pbZebaZpbb�� dhgdm�j_gpbb b ih^jZ`Zgby��< kbem�ki_pbZebaZpbb�[Zgdh\�gZ�hl^_evguo\b^Zo�hi_jZpbc��hgb�lhevdh�\k_�\f_kl_�h[jZamxl�ijhklmx�h^ghjh^�gmx� kbkl_fm�� hibku\Z_fmx� khhlghr_gbyfb� ����� ����� \ kbem� dhgdm�j_gpbb��\u]h^Z��mims_ggZy�h^gbf�[Zgdhf��i_j_o\Zlu\Z_lky�^jm]bfb \k_�\f_kl_�hgb�ba\e_dZxl�[hevrbc�^hoh^��q_f�ijb�ijhklhf�gZeh�`_gbb�ih\_^_gby��gZdhg_p��ih^jZ`Zgb_�ijb\h^bl�d \hagbdgh\_gbx_^bghc�hp_gdb�i_jki_dlb\��< j_amevlZl_�wlbo�wnn_dlh\�ba�g_hilb�fZevgh� ^_ckl\mxsbo� we_f_glh\� kdeZ^u\Z_lky� hilbfZevgh� ^_ckl�\mxsZy�kbkl_fZ�Ih^h[gu_� wnn_dlu�� gZau\Z_fu_� qZklh� kbg_j]_lbq_kdbfb�� gZ�[ex^Zxlky� b \ ^jm]bo� ih^kbkl_fZo� wdhghfbdb� �b [bhkn_ju�� GZ�ijbf_j��ohjhrZy�fh^_ev�hljZkeb�ijhfure_gghklb ihemqZ_lky��_kebjZkkfZljb\Zlv�__ dZd�kh\hdmighklv�©nbjfª��hibku\Z_fuo�ijhkl_c�rbfb� ebg_cgufb� hilbfbaZpbhggufb� fh^_eyfb� >��@�� gh� ihiuldZkhihklZ\blv� wlb� ©nbjfuª� k j_Zevgufb�ij_^ijbylbyfb� hljZkeb�g_m^Z_lky��?s_� [he__� m^b\bl_evguf�ijbf_jhf� kem`bl� hibkZgb_� ih�lj_[bl_evkdh]h�ih\_^_gby�gZk_e_gby��LjZ^bpbhggZy�fh^_ev�jZpbh�gZevgh]h�ihlj_[bl_ey��fZdkbfbabjmxs_]h�ihe_aghklv�ihlj_[e_gbyijb�[x^`_lghf�h]jZgbq_gbb� >��@��aZ\_^hfh�g_ijb]h^gZ�^ey�hibkZ�gby�ih\_^_gby�hl^_evghc�k_fvb�b ^Z`_�h^ghjh^ghc�]jmiiu�k_f_c�gh�� dZd� ^hdZaZgh� wfibjbq_kdbfb� bkke_^h\Zgbyfb� >��@� ij_djZkghih^oh^bl�^ey�hibkZgby�ih\_^_gby�\k_c�kh\hdmighklb�ihlj_[bl_e_ckljZgu�beb�j_]bhgZ�< dZ`^hf�ba�wlbo�kemqZ_\�SRVW� IDFWXP�fh`gh�gZclb�dZq_kl\_g�gh_� h[tykg_gb_� gZ[ex^Z_fh]h� kbg_j]_lbq_kdh]h� wnn_dlZ�� h^gZdh�f_lh^h\��iha\heyxsbo�ij_^m]Z^Zlv�_]h�aZjZg__��Z l_f�[he__�hibkZlvnhjfZevgh��ihdZ�g_�kms_kl\m_l��HklZ_lky�lhevdh�ijZdlbq_kdbc�j_�p_il��_keb�gm`gh�ihkljhblv�fZdjhfh^_ev� emqr_�\k_]h Z]j_]bjh\Zlv

Page 19: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

ko_fZlbq_kdb_� hilbfbaZpbhggu_�fh^_eb� we_f_glh\� kbkl_fu�� _kebgm`gh� ihkljhblv�fbdjhfh^_ev� emqr_� hklZ\blv�f_lh^u� hilbfbaZ�pbb b bkihevah\Zlv� f_lh^u� hibkZgby� ih\_^_gby�� \ujZ[hlZggu_� \bkdmkkl\_gghf� bgl_ee_dl_� �wdki_jlgu_� kbkl_fu�� kblmZpbhggh_mijZ\e_gb_�b l� i����� Fh^_ev�\aZbfh^_ckl\by�[ZgdZ�k deb_glZ�fb���� Djbl_jbc�hp_gdb�dj_^blgh]h�ihjln_ey<_jg_fky�kgh\Z�d fh^_eb�����������������jZkkfZljb\Zy�__ dZd�hib�kZgb_�hl^_evgh]h�[ZgdZ��FZdkbfZevgh�\hafh`gh_�h`b^Z_fh_�agZq_�gb_� 139 ���� kdeZ^u\Z_lky� ba� \_ebqbgu� � � ��� .5�0 N� � �65� V�� dhlhjZy�^Z_l�hp_gdm�\ _^bgbpZo�h`b^Z_fh]h�139 l_dm�s_]h�khklhygby� ^ `6.0= �� ��b \_ebqbgu� > @)99 ��dhlhjmx�ke_^m�_l�bgl_jij_lbjh\Zlv�dZd�hp_gdm�\ _^bgbpZo�h`b^Z_fh]h�139 jZk�ij_^_e_gby�\_jhylghkl_c�) ihlhdZ�^hoh^h\�b jZkoh^h\��ihjh`^_g�gh]h bf_xsbfky� m [ZgdZ� dj_^blguf�ihjln_e_f��Ih^q_jdg_f�� qlhnmgdpbhgZe� > @)9 ���� aZ\bkbl� hl� jZkij_^_e_gby�� Z g_� hl� kj_^g_]h^hoh^Z�b��ke_^h\Zl_evgh��hp_gb\Z_l�h^gh\j_f_ggh�b ^hoh^ghklv bjbkd�ihjln_ey��GZihfgbf��qlh�wlh�khbaf_j_gb_�^hoh^ghklb�b jbkdZ�ihemq_gh�g_�ba�Zijbhjguo�khh[jZ`_gbc��Z \ kbem�dhgdj_lguo�\ha�fh`ghkl_c� [ZgdZ� iZjbjh\Zlv� \hagbdZxsb_� dZkkh\u_� jZaju\u� bjZaf_sZlv� \hagbdZxsbc� gZ� dhjhldbc� kjhd� ba[ulhd� ebd\b^guokj_^kl\�H[uqgh� \ lhjbb� \u[hjZ� hilbfZevgh]h� ihjln_ey� >��� ��@� jZk�kfZljb\Z_lky�ij_^eh`_gguc�>`��Nhg�G_cfZghf�nmgdpbhgZe�h`b�^Z_fhc�ihe_aghklb �H[SHFWHG�XWLOLW\�> @ � � � �;G);X)1 ³ff� ����

]^_� � �;X ±�g_dhlhjZy�\h]gmlZy�fhghlhggZy�nmgdpby��aZ^ZxsZy�kl_�i_gv�hl\jZs_gby�d jbkdm Z]_glZ��\u[bjZxs_]h�ihjln_ev��_keb�\u�qbkeblv� ���� ^ey�^\mo�jZkij_^_e_gbc�k h^bgZdh\uf�kj_^gbf�b jZa�ebqghc� ^bki_jkb_c�� lh� 1 hdZ`_lky� [hevr_� ^ey� jZkij_^_e_gby� kf_gvr_c�^bki_jkb_c�b jZagbpZ�\ hp_gd_�jZkij_^_e_gbc�[m^_l� l_f[hevr_��q_f�[hevr_�djb\bagZ�]jZnbdZ�nmgdpbb� � �;X �G_kfhljy�gZ�k\hx�rbjhdmx�ihimeyjghklv�nmgdpbhgZe����� dZdkihkh[�hp_gdb�jZkij_^_e_gbc�h[eZ^Z_l�ba\_klgufb�kms_kl\_ggufb

Page 20: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

g_^hklZldZfb��\h�i_j\uo��_]h�ijbf_g_gb_� lj_[m_l� aZ^Zgby�ijZdlb�q_kdb��k ihlhedZ��p_ehc�nmgdpbb� � �;X ��\h�\lhjuo��hg�\hh[s_�]h\h�jy�g_�bg\ZjbZgl_g�d baf_g_gbx�fZkrlZ[Z�hi_jZpbc� ±�ijb�baf_g_�gbb \k_o�^hoh^h\�b jZkoh^h\�\ h^gh�b lh�`_�qbkeh�jZa�hg�[m^_l�j_�dhf_g^h\Zlv�baf_gblv�ijhihjpbb�ihjln_ey����gZdhg_p��\�lj_lvbo��\g_dhlhjuo� kemqZyo� \u[hj�� ^bdlm_fuc� nmgdpbhgZehf� ���� j_adhijhlb\hj_qbl�bglmbpbb�[hevrbgkl\Z�ex^_c��iZjZ^hdk�:ee_��Ihemq_gguc�gZfb�nmgdpbhgZe ���� dZd�fh`gh�ihdZaZlv�>��@ g_\ujZ`Z_lky�\ \b^_�������Hg�h^ghjh^_g��ijb�ebg_cghf�ij_h[jZah\Z�gbb kemqZcghc�\_ebqbgu ED;; �o hg�ij_h[jZam_lky�ih�lhfm�`_aZdhgm� ED99 �o ���\ kblmZpbb�\u[hjZ��ij_^eh`_gghc�:ee_��hg�^Z�_l� j_amevlZl� kh]eZkmxsbcky� k bglmbpb_c� b�� \ lh�`_� \j_fy��nmgd�pbhgZe ���� hibku\Z_l�hl\jZs_gb_�d jbkdm��Ijb�h^bgZdh\uo�kj_^�gbo�b jZaguo�^bki_jkbyo�agZq_gb_�9 ^ey�jZkij_^_e_gby�k f_gvr_c^bki_jkb_c�[m^_l�l_f�[hevr_��q_f�[hevr_�jZagbpZ�f_`^m� N5 b V5 �NmgdpbhgZe ���� [ue�ij_^eh`_g�>��@�\ l_hjbb�\u[hjZ�ihjln_�ey� g_kdhevdh� e_l� gZaZ^� ba� h[sbo� khh[jZ`_gbc� dZd� Zevl_jgZlb\ZnmgdpbhgZem�h`b^Z_fhc�ihe_aghklb�b ihemqbe�gZa\Zgb_��nmgdpbh�gZeZ�^\hckl\_gghc�l_hjbb�\u[hjZ� �IXQFWLRQDO� RI� GXDO� FKRLFH� WKHRU\beb� gZ� [_kobljhklghf� `Zj]hg_� nbgZgkh\h]h� ZgZebaZ� QRQ�H[SHFWHGXWLOLW\���AZf_qZl_evgh�h^gZdh��qlh�a^_kv�fu�ihemqbeb�wlhl�nmgdpbh�gZe�g_�ba�Zijbhjguo�khh[jZ`_gbc��Z dZd�j_r_gb_�\iheg_�_kl_kl\_g�ghc�ebg_cghc�aZ^Zqb�mijZ\e_gby�ebd\b^gufb�Zdlb\Zfb�[ZgdZ����� Nhjfbjh\Zgb_�kijhkZ�gZ�dj_^bl>h� kbo�ihj�fu�hibku\Zeb�dj_^blguc�ihjln_ev� h[h[s_ggh�� kihfhsvx� nmgdpbb� jZkij_^_e_gby� )�� Qlh[u� ihklZ\blv� aZ^ZqmmijZ\e_gby� dj_^blguf� ihjln_e_f� wlh]h� g_^hklZlhqgh��GZ^h� y\ghhibkZlv�dZd�k\yaZgh�wlh�jZkij_^_e_gb_�k dhgljZdlZfb��aZdexq_ggu�fb� [Zgdhf� kh� k\hbfb� deb_glZfb��Imklv� m [ZgdZ� _klv� Q deb_glh\�aZ_fsbdh\�±�ijhfure_gguo�b lhj]h\uo�nbjf��Lh]^Z�kZev^h�ihklm�ie_gbc�b ieZl_`_c� W; \ ��� ij_^klZ\ey_lky�\ \b^_

W; ¦ � Q�L LW�W ;; ����

�� Wlh�fh`_l�[ulv�_kl_kl\_ggh�^ey�bg^b\b^mZevgh]h�bg\_klhjZ�jZkiheZ]Zxs_]haZ^Zgguf�bkoh^guf�dZiblZehf��gh�kljZggh�^ey�[ZgdZ�hjb_glbjh\Zggh]h�gZ�kbk�l_fZlbq_kdbc�jhkl�h[hjhlZ�

Page 21: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

]^_� LW; ±� kZev^h� hi_jZpbc� k L�f deb_glhf� ih� \u^Zq_� b \ha\jZlm� kijhp_glhf�dj_^blh\��Z �W; ±�kZev^h�hi_jZpbc�k ^_ihablZfb�b jZk�q_lgufb�kq_lZfb�deb_glh\�b [x^`_lZ�b ijhqbf�hi_jZpbyf��g_�k\y�aZgguf�k dj_^blh\Zgb_f��\eh`_gbyfb�\ =DH�b aZbfkl\h\Zgb_f�ihF;D��MijZ\e_gb_� wlbfb� hi_jZpbyfb� fu� a^_kv� g_� jZkkfZljb\Z_f�ihwlhfm�kemqZcgmx�\_ebqbgm� �W; [m^_f�kqblZlv�aZ^Zgghc�b deb_g�lZfb�\ ^Zevg_cr_f�gZau\Z_f�lhevdh�aZ_fsbdh\�ih�kkm^guf�kq_lZf�JZkkfhljbf�l_i_jv�ko_fZlbqgh_�hibkZgb_�^_yl_evghklb�deb_g�lZ� �[he__� dhgdj_lgZy�fh^_ev�gm`gh]h� lbiZ� jZkkfhlj_gZ� \ >��@���Klhqdb�aj_gby�nbgZgkh\�deb_gl� L oZjZdl_jbam_lky�kihkh[ghklvx�ba�\e_dZlv�ijb[uev� L3 ba�k\h_c�^_yl_evghklb����WlZ�ijb[uev�qZklbqghhij_^_ey_lky� \u[hjhf� j_`bfZ� ^_yl_evghklb� deb_glhf� �ghf_gdeZ�lmju�b h[t_fh\�ijhba\h^kl\Z��dZgZeh\�j_ZebaZpbb�b l�i���±�\kx�wlmkh\hdmighklv�nZdlhjh\�fu�mkeh\gh�h[hagZqbf�q_j_a� L\ � Z qZklbqgh±�g_dhgljhebjm_fufb�nZdlhjZfb� �dhe_[Zgbyfb�kijhkZ��p_g��©gZ_a�^Zfbª�ij_klmigbdh\�b dhjjmfibjh\Zgguo�qbgh\gbdh\��b l�i����dhlh�ju_�[m^_f�kqblZlv�kemqZcgufb��Qlh[u�ba[_`Zlv� lhgdbo�\_jhylgh�klguo� jZkkm`^_gbc�� ij_^iheh`bf�� qlh� \k_� \hafh`gu_� khq_lZgbyagZq_gbc�g_dhgljhebjm_fuo�nZdlhjh\� ^ey� deb_glZ� ^_eylky�gZ� ^\ZdeZkkZ� ±� ©ohjhrb_ª�b ©iehob_ª��dhlhju_�j_Zebamxlky� k \_jhylgh�klyfb� LW b L� W� ��khhl\_lkl\_ggh��� �� LW �����Ijb�j_ZebaZpbb�©ohjh�r_]hª�khq_lZgby�nZdlhjh\��\ ohjhr_f�khklhygbb��deb_gl�\ j_`bf_L\ ihemqZ_l� ijb[uev� � �LL \3� �� Z \ iehohf� khklhygbb� ±� � �LL \3� �� �LL \3� ��Deb_gl� \u[bjZ_l� j_`bf�nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby� L\ ��g_� agZy� \dZdhf�khklhygbb�hg�gZoh^blky�b ihemqZ_l�kemqZcgmx�\_ebqbgm ijb�[uebL3 � �� �°̄°®­ ��� LLLL LL 2�2\3 \3 vx\_jhylghklk vx\_jhylghklk

GZijbf_j��\ mihfygmlhc�\ur_�fh^_eb�j_]bhgZevghc�wdhghfbdb�b \>��@ \ dZq_kl\_�deb_glZ�[ZgdZ�\uklmiZ_l�ij_^ijbylb_�� dhlhjh_�g_�^hieZqb\Z_l�ihklZ\sbdZf�aZ�kujv_�b \ k\yab�k wlbf�\ugm`^_gh�l_j�i_lv�g_ieZl_`b�ljZ^bpbhgguo�ihlj_[bl_e_c�k\_c�ijh^mdpbb��kf��ih�� DZd�\k_]^Z�\ wdhghfbq_kdhc�l_hjbb��ih^�ijb[uevx�a^_kv�ih^jZamf_\Z_lky�g_hlq_lgZy� [mo]Zel_jkdZy� \_ebqbgZ�� Z j_Zevguc� ^hoh^� nZdlbq_kdh]h� \eZ^_evpZij_^ijbylby�k mq_lhf�©l_g_\uoª�^hoh^h\�b ©l_g_\uoª�jZkoh^h\��gZijbf_j��\ay�lhd�qbgh\gbdZf�b hlklmiguo�jwd_lbjZf���kf��lZd`_��>��@

Page 22: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

wlhfm� ih\h^m� >��@���Hgh�� h^gZdh��fh`_l� bkihevah\Zlv� qZklv� kujvy^ey� ijhba\h^kl\Z� ihlj_[bl_evkdh]h� ijh^mdlZ� dhlhjuc�fh`gh� j_Z�ebah\Zlv�aZ�©`b\u_ª�^_gv]b��Ohjhr__�khklhygb_�^ey�wlh]h�ij_^ijb�ylby��dh]^Z�_]h�ihlj_[bl_evkdbc�ijh^mdl�gZoh^bl�kijhk��±�ij_^ijb�ylb_� lh]^Z�ihemqZ_l� [hevrmx� ijb[uev� \ke_^kl\b_� ^_r_\bagu� ku�jvy��iehoh_�khklhygb_��dh]^Z�ihlj_[bl_evkdbc�ijh^mdl�j_Zebah\Zlvg_�m^Z_lky��±�ij_^ijbylb_�lh]^Z�l_jibl�m[uldb��ihkdhevdm�jZ[hlZ_laZ�g_ieZl_`b�Fu�ij_^iheZ]Z_f��qlh�deb_gl� ±� wlh�^ebl_evgh� kms_kl\mxs__ij_^ijbylb_�� dhlhjh_� aZbgl_j_kh\Zgh� \ kj_^g_c� ijb[ueb� �LL \3( LW � �LL \3� � � �L� W� � �LL \3� ��Imklv� L\ j_`bf�nmgdpbhgbjh�\Zgby��dhlhjuc�h[_ki_qb\Z_l�fZdkbfZevgh_�agZq_gb_�wlhc�\_ebqbgu� � LL \3( � � � � � �^ `L\ LLLLLL \3�\3 �� W��WPD[?keb� � � � LL \3 ! �� b � � � LL \3 ! ��� lh� deb_gl� g_� gm`^Z_lky� \ dj_^bl_��GZihfgbf��qlh�fu�jZkkfZljb\Z_f�g_jZklmsmx�wdhghfbdm��\ dhlh�jhc�ijhba\h^bl_eb�b lhj]h\pu�g_�gm`^Zxlky�\ dj_^bl_�^ey�kbkl_�fZlbq_kdh]h� jZkrbj_gby� ijhba\h^kl\Z� b h[hjhlZ��� ?keb� `_� � LL \3( � ��� deb_gl� g_�fh`_l� h[_ki_qblv� iheh`bl_evghc� kj_^g_cijb[ueb b��ke_^h\Zl_evgh�g_�kfh`_l�^he]h�ieZlblv�^Z`_�ijhp_gluih�dj_^blm��;Zgd�g_�^he`_g�\klmiZlv�k lZdbf�deb_glhf�\ ^ebl_ev�gu_�hlghr_gby���LZdbf� h[jZahf�� gZk� bgl_j_km_l� kemqZc�� dh]^Z� � � � LL \3 ! ��� � � LL \3 � �� gh� � � LL \3( ! �� ?keb� deb_gl� g_� bf__l� \hafh`ghklb\aylv�dj_^bl��hg�g_�kfh`_l�\ wlhf�kemqZ_�j_Zebah\Zlv�hilbfZevgucj_`bf� L\ �� ihkdhevdm� iehoh_� khklhygb_� fh`_l� ^eblvky� g_hij_^_�e_ggh� ^he]h� b m[uldb� � � � LL \3 � � k^_eZxl� deb_glZ� g_ieZl_`_kih�kh[guf�� < hlkmlkl\b_� dj_^blZ� deb_gl� \ugm`^_g� \u[bjZlv� j_`bf�L\ ��dhlhjuc�g_�ijbghkbl�m[uldh\�\ iehohf�khklhygbb��� NZdlbq_kdb�m \k_o�[Zgdh\�_klv�deb_glu��dhlhju_�aZ\_^hfh�g_�kfh]ml�\uieZ�lblv�^Z`_�ijhp_glu�ih�\ayluf�dj_^blZf��?keb�wlb�[_agZ^_`gu_�^he]b�g_�y\ey�xlky�kdjulhc�nhjfhc�[x^`_lgh]h�nbgZgkbjh\Zgby�deb_glZ��hgb�^he`gu�[ulvijbagZgu�j_amevlZlhf�hrb[hqgh]h�ih\_^_gby�[ZgdZ��GZdhie_gb_�lZdbo�hrb[hdijb\_^_l�[Zgd�d aZdjulbx��A^_kv�fu�jZkkfZljb\Z_f�b^_Zebabjh\Zggmx�klZpbh�gZjgmx�kblmZpbx��dh]^Z�[Zgd�b deb_gl�kms_kl\mxl�b \aZbfh^_ckl\mxl�g_hij_�^_e_ggh�^he]h�

Page 23: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

� ��LL \3( � � � � � � � �^ `LLLLLL�\3\ \3�\3LLL��t W��W��PD[ ����

JZamf__lky� � ��LL \3( �� � � LL \3( ��b deb_glm�fh`_l�[ulv�\u]h^gh_ aZ�ieZlblv�ijhp_gl�aZ�dj_^bl�ihdju\Zxsbc�m[uldb��q_f�iulZlvky�\h�\k_�ba[_`Zlv�wlbo�m[uldh\�Ij_^iheh`bf� lh]^Z�� qlh� deb_gl� b [Zgd� aZdexqZxl� dhgljZdlke_^mxs_]h�\b^Z��\ iehohf�khklhygbb�deb_glZ�[Zgd�ihdju\Z_l�\k__]h�m[uldb��Z \ ohjhr_f�±�aZ[bjZ_l�^hex�_]h�ijb[ueb� � �LL \U �V k lZ�dbf�jZkq_lhf��qlh[u�\ kj_^g_f�\_jgmlv�\u^Zgguc�dj_^bl�k h]h\h�j_gguf��ijhkluf����ijhp_glhf� LU� �LL \U �V LW � �LL \3� � �LU�� � �L� W� � �> @�� LL \3 �����A^_kv�b ^Ze__� > @ ^ �̀� [�[ � � PD[ Ih�hij_^_e_gbx�wlZ�\_ebqbgZ�ih�eh`bl_evgZ���DhgkmevlZpbb�k [ZgdbjZfb��jZ[hlZxsbfb�\ K\_j^eh\�kdhc�h[eZklb�ihdZaZeb��qlh�dhgljZdlu��qZs_�\k_]h�g_]eZkgu_��mdZ�aZggh]h�\b^Z�±�wlh�lbibqgZy�ijZdlbdZ�AZdexqb\� lZdhc� dhgljZdl�� deb_gl� [m^_l� ihemqZlv� \ ohjhr_fkhklhygbb�^hoh^� � �� �LL \U� �V� � �LL \3� ��Z \ iehohf� ±� � �> @�� LL \3 b \u�[_j_l�j_`bf� � �LL U\Ö ��lZdhc�qlh

� �� �LLL U\3 Ö( � �� � � � � � � �> @^ ̀W��WV� ��� LLLLLLLL\ \3�\3\U�L �PD[� � � � � � � � � �> @^ `L\ LLLLLLLLLL \3U�\3�\3 ���� W��W��W PD[

E_]dh� ihdZaZlv�� qlh� dhgljZdl� deb_glm� [m^_l� \u]h^_g� � ��LL \3( � � �� �LLL U\3 Ö( � � � LL \3( ��b hg�[m^_l�[jZlv�dj_^bl��_keb�ijh�p_gl� LU g_� ij_\hkoh^bl� \_ebqbgu� LL� W�O �� ]^_� LO ±� fgh`bl_ev�EZ�]jZg`Z�ijb�h]jZgbq_gbb� � �LL \3� ! � \ aZ^Zq_�mkeh\ghc�hilbfbaZpbb������� DZd�fu�m`_�]h\hjbeb�\gZqZe_�jZ[hlu�\ g_jZklms_c�wdhghfbdb�[Zgd�j_Zevghfh`_l�jZkkqblu\Zlv�lhevdh�gZ�ihemq_gb_�ijhklh]h�ijhp_glZ�hl�dj_^blguo�hi_�jZpbc�

Page 24: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

���� Bgl_]jZpby� ij_^ijbylbc� ih^� w]b^hc� [Zgdh\�� nbgZgkh\h�ijhfure_ggu_�]jmiiu�K lhqdb�aj_gby�[ZgdZ�\uiheg_gb_�dhgljZdlZ�k L�f deb_glhf�\u�jZablky�\ lhf��qlh�kZev^h�_]h�dj_^blguo�hi_jZpbc�k wlbf�deb_glhf�kf������� [m^_l�kemqZcghc�\_ebqbghcL; � � � �� �� �� �> @°̄°®­ ��V �� �

LLLLL LLLLL 2�2U\3 U\3U vx\_jhylghklk vx\_jhylghklkÖ ÖÖ �� ����]^_�\ kbem�����

� �LL UVÖ � �� � � �� �> @� �� �LLLL LLLLL U\3 U\3�U� Ö Ö� ��W W��WlZ� kemqZcgZy� \_ebqbgZ� bf__l� klmi_gqZlmx�nmgdpbx� jZkij_^_e_�gby

��� LL U;) � �� �> @� �� �> @ � � � �� �� � � �� �°°̄

°°®­

f��dV V�d�� ���f�� ��� ��

;U\3U� U\3U;U\32� U\3;�LLLLL LLLLLLLLL LLL

ÖÖ ÖÖÖ Ö �� ����dhlhjZy�aZ\bkbl�hl�ijhp_glZ� LU dZd�hl�iZjZf_ljZ�Nmgdpby�jZkij_^_e_gby�kmffu� ���� kemqZcguo�\_ebqbg� ���� by\ey_lky�lhc�nmgdpb_c�)� dhlhjmx�hp_gb\Z_l�nmgdpbhgZe�������DZdohjhrh�ba\_klgh��\b^�nmgdpbb�jZkij_^_e_gby�kmffu�kemqZcguo�\_�ebqbg�hij_^_ey_lky�g_� lhevdh�jZkij_^_e_gbyfb�hl^_evguo� keZ]Z_�fuo� ������gh�b klZlbklbq_kdhc� aZ\bkbfhklvx� �dhjj_eypb_c��f_`^mkeZ]Z_fufb�� GZijbf_j�� _keb� deb_glu� ±� wlh� ij_^ijbylby� `_kldhk\yaZggu_�\ l_ogheh]bq_kdmx�p_ihqdm��\ iehoh_�khklhygb_�hgb�[m�^ml� ihiZ^Zlv� kdhj__� \k_]h� h^gh\j_f_ggh� b jZkij_^_e_gb_� kmffu���� [m^_l�bf_lv�]hjZa^h�[hevrmx�^bki_jkbx��q_f�\ kemqZ_�g_k\y�aZgguo�f_`^m�kh[hc�l_ogheh]bq_kdb�ij_^ijbylbc�H[km`^_gb_�wlh]h�\hijhkZ�kgh\Z�\ha\jZsZ_l�gZk�d m`_�h[km`�^Z\r_cky� \ >��@� ijh[e_f_� kihglZggh]h� h[t_^bg_gby� jhkkbckdboij_^ijbylbc�\ ehdZevgu_�nbgZgkh\h�ijhfure_ggu_�]jmiiu��NI=�ih^�w]b^hc�[Zgdh\�

Page 25: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

;Zgdb�b bo�deb_glu�ij_^ijbylby�hdZau\Zxlky�k\yaZgu�hkh[u�fb� hlghr_gbyf�� Mki_rgu_� hi_jZpbb� k jbkdh\Zggufb� ijh_dlZfblj_[mxl�� ^h\_jby�f_`^m� dj_^blhjhf� b aZ_fsbdhf� b ohjhr_c� bg�nhjfZpbb�h khklhygbb�^_e�m aZ_fsbdZ��< j_amevlZl_�wlbo�hlghr_�gbc nhjfbjmxlky��hkh[_ggh�\ ijh\bgpbb��mklhcqb\u_� ]jmiiu�� kh�klhysb_�ba�[ZgdZ��g_kdhevdbo�ijhfure_gguo�ij_^ijbylbc�b lhj]h�\uo�nbjf��aZgbfZxsboky�kgZ[`_gb_f�b k[ulhf�^ey�wlbo�ij_^ijb�ylbc�� :^fbgbkljZpbb� wlbo� mqj_`^_gbc� qZklh� l_kgh� i_j_ie_l_guf_`^m�kh[hc�>�@��Mkeh\by�dj_^blh\Zgby�\ lZdbo�]jmiiZo�bg^b\b^m�Zevgu�b k\h[h^gh]h�jugdZ�dj_^blh\�^ey�ij_^ijbylbc�g_l�Wlb� g_nhjfZevgu_� kihglZggu_� h[t_^bg_gby�� ]^_� h[uqgh� ^h�fbgbjm_l�[Zgd��Z g_�hj]Zgbam_fu_�k\_jom�djmigu_�dhjihjZpbb��fugZa\Zeb�\ >��@ nbgZgkh\h�ijhfure_ggufb�]jmiiZfb��Fu�iheZ]Z�_f�� qlh� gZebqb_� wlbo� ]jmii� hdZau\Z_l� kms_kl\_ggh_� \ebygb_� gZnmgdpbhgbjh\Zgb_� wdhghfbq_kdbo� f_oZgbafh\� \ Jhkkbb�� Ohly]jmiiu�wlb�\hagbdZxl�\ hkgh\ghf��ih�\b^bfhfm�gZ�hkgh\_�ebqguok\ya_c�� \ jughqghc� wdhghfbd_� k\yab�� g_� ijbghkysb_� nbgZgkh\hc\u]h^u�[ukljh�jZajmrZxlky��Ihwlhfm�\Z`gh�\uykgblv�wdhghfbq_�kdb_�hkgh\Zgby�mklhcqb\hklb�wlbo�]jmii��< >��@ fu�mdZaZeb�h^gm�baijbqbg� \u]h^ghklb� bgl_]jZpbb� ±� \hafh`ghklv� ijh^Z\Zlv� b ihdm�iZlv�g_ieZl_`b��ihi_j_d��l_ogheh]bq_kdbo�p_ihq_d��A^_kv�\u�h[gZ�jm`b\Z_f� ^jm]mx� ±� \hafh`ghklv� \aZbfghc� dhfi_gkZpbb� jZfdZo]jmiiu�dj_^blguo�jbkdh\�b \u]h^ghklv�bgl_]jZpbb�^Z`_�\ hlkmlkl�\bb�dZiblZevguo�\eh`_gbc�< >��@�k ihfhsvx�ZgZebaZ�k\hckl\�nmgdpbhgZeZ� > @9 ) �� ���� dZ�q_kl\_ggh�kjZ\gb\Z_lky�k lhqdb�aj_gby�dhfi_gkZpbb�jbkdh\�\u]h^�ghklv� jZaebqguo� \b^h\� bgl_]jZpbb� >�@�� \_jlbdZevghc ±� ij_^ijb�ylbc�k\yaZgguo�l_ogheh]bq_kdhc�p_ihqdhc��eZl_jZevghc ±�koh^guof_`^m�kh[hc�ij_^ijbylbc�b ]_h]jZnbq_kdhc ±� kh\f_klgh�jZkiheh�`_gguo�jZaghjh^guo�ij_^ijbylbc��Ihkdhevdm�ijb�]_h]jZnbq_kdhcbgl_]jZpbb�\_ebqbgu� L; ���� hdZau\Zxlky�f_g__�dhjj_ebjh\Zggu�fb�� q_f� ijb� eZl_jZevghc� b hkh[_ggh� \_jlbdZevghc� bgl_]jZpbb�� klhqdb� aj_gby�dhfi_gkZpbb�jbkdh\� ]_h]jZnbq_kdZy�bgl_]jZpby�hdZ�au\Z_lky�gZb[he__�\u]h^ghc��?kl_kl\_gghc�hdZau\Z_lky�hgZ�^ey�f_�oZgbafZ�i_j_mq_lZ�g_ieZl_`_c��hibkZggh]h�\ >��@��Ij_^klZ\ey_lky�qlh�wlb�l_hj_lbq_kdb_�\u\h^u�khhl\_lkl\mxl�^_ckl\bl_evguf�ijh�p_kkZf��Fgh]b_� nbgZgkh\h�ijhfure_gguc� ]jmiiu�� knhjfbjh\Z\�rb_ky� i_j\hgZqZevgh� gZ� hljZke_\hc� hkgh\_�� Zdlb\gh� ihihegyebkv\ihke_^kl\bb�f_klgufb�ij_^ijbylbyfb� kh\_jr_ggh�bgh]h�ijhnb�ey��KdZaZggh_�� \ijhq_f�� g_� hljbpZ_l� ki_pbnbq_kdbo� \u]h^� \_jlb�dZevghc�bgl_]jZpbb��^hklb]Zxsboky�k ihfhsvx�bguo��g_�jZkkfZl�jb\Z_fuo�a^_kv�f_oZgbafh\ >�������������@�

Page 26: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

AZf_gbf�gZdhg_p��qlh�_keb� L; ���� g_aZ\bkbfu�ijb�jZaguo�L��bdeb_glh\�m [ZgdZ�^hklZlhqgh�fgh]h� �g_kdhevdh�^_kyldh\��b \k_�hgbijbf_jgh�h^gh]h�jZaf_jZ��lh�\ dZq_kl\_�nmgdpbb�jZkij_^_e_gby�)fh`gh� bkihevah\Zlv�nmgdpbx� ghjfZevgh]h jZkij_^_e_gby� k iZjZ�f_ljZfb� ¦ L L;P ( �� ¦ V L L� ;' �� ]^_� kj_^gb_� agZq_gby� L;( b^bki_jkbb� L;' \uqbkeyxlky�ih�jZkij_^_e_gbyf������

���� EhdZevgh�fhghihevguc�jughd�dj_^blh\DZd�[u�gb nhjfbjh\Zehkv� jZkij_^_e_gb_�) ba� jZkij_^_e_gbc������hgh�[m^_l�aZ\bk_lv�dZd�hl�iZjZf_ljh\�hl�agZq_gbc�ijhp_glh\�QL� UUU ���������� ��gZagZq_gguo�[Zgdm�deb_glZfb��H[uqgh�\ l_hjbb�ij_^�iheZ]Z_lky��qlh�ijhp_gl�ih�dj_^blZf�^Zggh]h�lbiZ��p_gZ�gZ�Zdlb\h\hij_^_e_gghc�ebd\b^ghklb��_^bgZ��lZd�`_�dZd�_^bgu�p_gu�gZ�ijh�^mdlu��< jZkkfZljb\Z_fhc�kblmZpbb��h^gZdh��lZdh_�ij_^iheh`_gb_g_� _kl_kl\_ggh�� ihkdhevdm� kijhk� deb_glZ� gZ� dj_^bl� \dexqZ_l� g_lhevdh�h[t_f� � �� �> @�� U\3 LL Ö ��gh�b jbkd� LW ��Djhf_�lh]h��dZd�fu�]h\hjb�eb� \ur_� _^bgh]h� jugdZ� dj_^blh\� g_l� ±� hg� ehdZebah\Zg� \ jZfdZoNI=��Ihwlhfm�ih^oh^ysbf�hibkZgb_f�kms_kl\mxs_]h�dj_^blgh]hjugdZ� ij_^klZ\ey_lky� fh^_ev� fhghihebb� ±� fh^_ev� jZ\gh\_kby� ihRlZd_ev[_j]m�Ij_^iheZ]Z_lky�� qlh� [Zgd�� klhysbc� \h� ]eZ\_� NI=� h[eZ^Z_liheghc�bgnhjfZpb_c�h k\hbo�deb_glZo�b��ke_^h\Zl_evgh��kihkh[_gij_^kdZaZlv�bo�j_Zdpbx� � �LL U\Ö gZ�ijhp_gl� UL ��\uqbkeblv�jZkij_^_e_�gby� ���� b hp_gblv� jZkij_^_e_gb_� � �Q� UU;) ������ kZev^h �f_^e_g�guo��hi_jZpbc�������dhlhjh_�aZ\bkbl�hl�ijhp_glh\� Q� UU ����� dZd�hl�iZ�jZf_ljh\��?keb�ih^klZ\blv wlh�jZkij_^_e_gb_�\ ������lh�ihemqblkynmgdpby� � �Q� UU9 �����Ö �� dhlhjZy� hp_gb\Z_l� wnn_dlb\ghklv� kh\hdmigh�klb�dhgljZdlh\�k deb_glZfb�k mq_lhf��dZd�^hoh^ghklb��lZd�b jbkdZ�ijb� mkeh\bb�� qlh� deb_glZf� gZagZq_gu� ijhp_glu Q� UU ����� �� ;m^mqbfhghihevguf� \eZ^_evp_f� ^_nbpblguo� dj_^blguo� j_kmjkh\�� [Zgdfh`_l�gZagZqblv�ijhp_glu� lZd��qlh[u�h[_ki_qblv�fZdkbfmf�\_eb�qbgu� � �Q� UU9 �����Ö ��LZdh_�j_r_gb_�gZau\Z_lky�jughqguf�jZ\gh\_kb_fih�RlZd_ev[_j]m��Ih^q_jdg_f��qlh�[Zgd�g_�aZ[bjZ_l�\ wlhf�jZ\gh�\_kbb� \kx�ijb[uev� deb_glZ� ±� e_]dh� \b^_lv�� qlh� deb_gl�ihemqbl� \wlhf�jZ\gh\_kbb�^hoh^�[hevrbc��q_f�\ hlkmlkl\bb�dj_^blZ�������lZdqlh�NI=�g_�jZkiZ^_lky�

Page 27: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

Bf_ggh�\ jZfdZo�fh^_eb�jZ\gh\_kby�ih�RlZd_ev[_j]m�fh`gh^Zlv� g_ijhlb\hj_qb\mx� bgl_jij_lZpbx� ^\mf� ijhlb\hiheh`gufkm`^_gbyf�h jheb�[Zgdh\�ijb\_^_gguf�\ gZqZe_�jZ[hlu��K h^ghcklhjhgu� gZ� ehdZevgh�fhghihevghf� jugd_� [Zgd� ihemqZ_l� ijb[uev[hevrmx��q_f�ijhklh�ieZlZ�aZ�jbkd��dhlhjmx�hg�ihemqZe�[u�gZ�k\h�[h^ghf� �dhgdmj_glghf��jugd_�dj_^blh\� >�@��< wlhf� kfuke_�\_jgh�qlh� [Zgdb�� khkj_^hlhqb\� \k_� k\h[h^gu_� ^_gv]b� g_� ^Zxl� ijhfur�e_gghklb� h[hjhlguo�nhg^h\��K ^jm]hc� klhjhgu�� kZfZ� ehdZevghklvjugdZ�h[mkeh\e_gZ�g_gZ^_`ghklvx��keZ[hklvx�ijhba\h^kl\Z��dh]^Z^Z\Zlv�dj_^blu��qm`bf��kebrdhf�jbkdh\Zggh��b ^Z`_�dj_^blh\Zgb_�k\hbo�� lj_[m_l� \ bgl_gkb\ghc� �ijhdjmldb�� ^_g_]� q_j_a� =DH bF;D��qlh[u�iZjbjh\Zlv�\hagbdZxsb_�dZkkh\u_�jZaju\u���DZd� ihdZaZgh� \ >��@�� \ gZr_c� fh^_eb� ^ey� lh]h�� qlh[u� [Zgdbkgb`Zeb�ijhp_glgu_�klZ\db�ih�dj_^blZf�ij_^ijbylbyf��g_h[oh^b�fh�km`Zlv�dhjb^hj�f_`^m� N5 �� V5 ��Wlhl�j_amevlZl� klZ\bl�ih^� kh�fg_gb_�jZkoh`__�fg_gb_�h lhf��qlh�\ukhdZy�klZ\dZ�^hoh^ghklb�ih=DH�ij_iylkl\m_l�kgb`_gbx�ijhp_glZ�ih�dj_^blZf�ij_^ijbylbyf�< gZr_c�fh^_eb�ihdmidZ�=DH�b dj_^blh\Zgb_�ij_^ijbylbc�g_�dhg�dmjbjmxl�^jm]�k ^jm]hf��Z kdhj__�^hihegyxl�^jm]�^jm]Z��Dj_^blmyij_^ijbylby��[Zgd�[_j_l�gZ�k_[y�jbkdb��k dhlhjufb�l_�klZedb\Zxl�ky��Ijb� wlhf� [Zgd� ieZlbl� aZ� jbkd� l_f� [hevr_�� q_f� \ur_� jZagbpZklZ\hd�F;D� N5 b ^hoh^ghklb�=DH� V5 ��?kl_kl\_ggh��qlh�q_f�[hevr_ieZlZ�aZ�jbkd��l_f�g_hohlg__�[Zgd�_]h�dj_^blm_l�b l_f�^hjh`_�h[oh�^blky� dj_^bl� ij_^ijbylbx�� J_adh_� kgb`_gb_� ^hoh^ghklb� ih� =DH[_a�khhl\_lkl\mxs_]h�kgb`_gby�klZ\db�j_nbgZgkbjh\Zgby� �b�� ke_�^h\Zl_evgh�� klZ\hd�F;D��fh`_l� \ua\Zlv�djbabk�[Zgdh\kdhc� kbkl_�fu��ebrb\�ij_^ijbylby�^_r_\uo��k mq_lh\�\hafh`ghklb�ijhkjhqdbb g_\ha\jZlZ��dj_^blh\� �� <u\h^ux < mkeh\byo�kh\j_f_gghc�Jhkkbb�[Zgdb�nZdlbq_kdb�aZgbfZxlky�g_klhevdh�bg\_klbpbhgghc�kdhevdh�kljZoh\hc�^_yl_evghklvx��[_jygZ�k_[y�jbkdb�k\hbo�deb_glh\�b ihemqZy�ijb[uev�aZ�kq_l�^b\_j�kbnbdZpbb�jbkdh\�x G_gZ^_`ghklv� deb_glh\� ^_eZ_l� _kl_kl\_gguf� ehdZebaZpbx� dj_�^blguo�jugdh\�\ jZfdZo�kihglZggh�\hagbdZxsbo�g_[hevrbo�nb�gZgkh\h�ijhfure_gguo� ]jmii�� Ijhp_glu� ^Z`_� \ wlbo� ]jmiiZobg^b\b^mZevgu�b dhgdmj_glguc�jughd�dj_^blh\�hlkmlkl\m_l��� < ihke_^gbc� ]h^�fu�gZ[ex^Zeb��ih� djZcg_c�f_j_� \ K\_j^eh\kdhc�h[eZklb�aZf_lgh_�\ul_kg_gb_�k jugdZ�dj_^blh\�qZklguo�[Zgdh\�K[_j[Zgdhf��Wlhl�ijh�p_kk��\ijhq_f��^he`_g�khklZ\blv�l_fm�hkh[h]h�h[km`^_gby�b bkke_^h\Zgby�

Page 28: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

x K lhqdb�aj_gby�^b\_jkbnbdZpbb�jbkdh\�ba�lj_o�ba\_klguo�\b^h\bgl_]jZpbb�ij_^ijbylbc�[he__�\u]h^ghc�ij_^klZ\ey_lky� ]_h]jZ�nbq_kdZy�bgl_]jZpby���dh]^Z�\ ]jmiim�h[t_^bgyxlky�jZaghjh^gu_ij_^ijbylby�h^gh]h�j_]bhgZ�x EhdZebaZpby� jugdZ� ^Z_l� \hafh`ghklv� [ZgdZf� ba\e_dZlv� fhgh�ihevgmx�j_glm��l_f�g_�f_g__�\ k\yab�k \ukhdbfb�jbkdZfb�b hlkml�kl\b_f�wdhghfbq_kdh]h�jhklZ�nbgZgkh\h_�iheh`_gb_�[Zgdh\�hdZ�au\Z_lky�^h\hevgh�keh`guf��>Z`_�_keb�hkgh\gu_�bgl_j_ku�[ZgdZk\yaZgu�k dj_^blh\Zgb_f�ijhba\h^kl\Z�b lhj]h\eb��hg�\ugm`^_gagZqbl_evgmx�qZklv�kj_^kl\�gZijZ\eylv�gZ�djZldhkjhqgu_�ki_dm�eypbb�� ?kl_kl\_gguf� hdZau\Z_lky� b iZjZ^hdkZevgh_� gZ� i_j\uc\a]ey^�iheh`_gb_��dh]^Z�^hjh]b_�aZbfkl\h\Zgby�ih�F;D�khkms_�kl\mxl�k f_g__�^hoh^gufb�\eh`_gbyfb�\ =DH�x GZ� \_ebqbgm� dj_^blguo� ijhp_glh\� \eby_l� g_� lhevdh�� b fh`_l[ulv� ^Z`_� g_� klhevdh� Z[khexlguc� jZaf_j� ^hoh^ghklb� =DH�kdhevdh�jZagbpZ�f_`^m�wlhc�^hoh^ghklvx�b klZ\dhc�j_nbgZgkb�jh\Zgby�:\lhju�\ujZ`Zxl�[eZ]h^Zjghklv�dhee_]Zf�ba�<P�J:G��PWFBJ:G��=M�P;�ih�K\_j^eh\kdhc� h[eZklb�� Z lZd`_� mqZklgbdZf� ijhn�<�<��FZdZjh\Z�aZ�\gbfZgb_�d jZ[hl_�b dhgkljmdlb\gmx�djblbdm��� Ebl_jZlmjZ�� %KDWWDFKDU\D 6��� $QMDQ 9� 7� &RQWHPSRUDU\�%DQNLQJ�7KHRU\�� ��� -RXU�QDO�RI�)LQDQFLDO�,QWHUPHGLDWLRQ��������� *HUWOHU��0DUN� )LQDQFLDO�6WUXFWXUH�DQG�$JJUHJDWH�(FRQRPLF�$FWLYLW\����-RXUQDO�RI�0RQH\��&UHGLW�DQG�%DQNLQJ������������� =mjb_\�K�F���Ihki_eh\�B�=�Fh^_ev�h[s_]h�jZ\gh\_kby�wdhghfbdbi_j_oh^gh]h� i_jbh^Z�� ��� FZl_fZlbq_kdh_� fh^_ebjh\Zgb_�� �����1����klj�������� 6FKDIIHU 0�(�� %DQN�(QWHUSULVH� 5HODWLRQV� DQG� &UHGLW� $OORFDWLRQ� LQ5XVVLD��������� >fbljb_\ F�W���FZlh\gbdh\ F�X���FboZceh\ E�<��� Kuq_\Z E�B��Lbfhn__\ ?�<� Jhkkbckdb_�[Zgdb�\ gZqZe_�nbgZgkh\hc�klZ[bebaZ�pbb��>hdeZ^� gZ� dhgn_j_gpbb� �Jhev� ijZ\bl_evkl\� \ i_j_oh^guci_jbh^���JWR��Fhkd\Z�������� 5XVVLDV�EDQNLQJ�FULVLV� �� %UXQVZLFN�%URNHUDJH��$XJ�������0RVFRZ��� De_cg_j =� Kh\j_f_ggZy� jhkkbckdZy� wdhghfbdZ� dZd� wdhghfbdZnbabq_kdbo�ebp�����<hijhku�wdhghfbdb��������1����klj�������� :LOOLDPVRQ 2� 0DUNHWV�DQG�+LHUDUFKLHV��$QDO\VLV�DQG�$QWLWUXVW�,PSOL�FDWLRQV��1HZ�<RUN��)UHH�3UHVV�������

Page 29: JHEV ;:GDH< < WDHGHFBD? IJ?OH>GH=H I?JBH>isir.ras.ru › ph › 0004 › D5UXTSI2.pdfkdh]hdj_^blZ F;D Hlf_lbf qlhklZlbklbdZ> @ihdZau\Z_liZ jZ^hdkZevgmx kblmZpbx˛ hlghkbl_evgh

�� >_f_glv_\ <�?� Bg\_klbpbhggu_�b bggh\Zpbhggu_�ij_bfms_kl\ZnbgZgkh\h�ijhfure_gguo�]jmii�����WdhghfbdZ�b fZl_fZlbq_kdb_f_lh^u��������L������<ui����klj����������+DUW 2�� 0RRUH -� ,QFRPSOHWH� &RQWUDFWV� DQG� 5HQHJRWLDWLRQ� ��(FRQRPHWULFD��������9RO�����SS�����������*URVVPDQ 6�� +DUW 2� 7KH�&RVWV�DQG�%HQHILWV�RI�2ZQHUVKLS��$�7KH�RU\� RI� 9HUWLFDO� DQG� /DWHUDO� ,QWHJUDWLRQ�� ��� -RXUQDO� RI� 3ROLWLFDO� (FRQ�RP\��������9RO������SS�������������7KRPDV -���:RUUDOO 7� )RUHLJQ�'LUHFW�,QYHVWPHQW�DQG�5LVN�RI�([SUR�SULDWLRQ�����5HYLHZ�RI�(FRQRPLF�6WXGLHV��������9RO�����SS�����������L_dmsb_�l_g^_gpbb�\ ^_g_`gh�dj_^blghc�kn_j_�����P_gljZevguc[Zgd�JN��11�����Fhkd\Z���������+LUVKOHLIHU -��� 5LOH\ -�*� 7KH�$QDO\WLFV� RI�8QFHUWDLQW\� DQG� ,QIRUPD�WLRQ��&DPEULGJH�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV������� "���FZjrZee :� Ijbgpbiu�wdhghfbq_kdhc�gZmdb��l��,�,,,��I_j��k Zg]e���Ih^�j_^��H��=��JZ^ugh\Z��F�� ��Ijh]j_kk�Mgb\_jk�� ������ ���k�� ����k�������k����Ij_^u^�k[hjgbd���RZoh\Z���Eb\rbp�<�?����=mjb_\ K�F�� Ihki_eh\ B�=� Fh^_ev� ^_yl_evghklb� [ZgdZ� ijb� hl�kmlkl\bb�bgneypbb�b wdhghfbq_kdh]h�jhklZ�� ���WdhghfbdZ�b fZ�l_fZlbq_kdb_�f_lh^u��������lhf�����\ui�����k�����������I_ljh\�:�:�� Ihki_eh\ B�=�RZgZgbg�:�:� Hiul�fZl_fZlbq_kdh]hfh^_ebjh\Zgby�wdhghfbdb��F���Wg_j]hZlhfba^Zl�����������k����Ihki_eh\ B�=��� Ihki_eh\Z E�Y� BG>?DK� �� kbkl_fZ� bkqbke_gbyZ]j_]bjh\Zgguo�ihdZaZl_e_c�ihlj_[bl_evkdh]h�kijhkZ�� ��Khh[s_�gby�ih�ijbdeZ^ghc�fZl_fZlbd_��F���<P�J:G����������k����<DDUL�0� 7KH�'XDO�7KHRU\�RI�&KRLFH�XQGHU�5LVN��(FRQRPHWULFD������������klj������������=mjb_\ K�F�� I_ljh\ :�:�� Ihki_eh\ B�=� RZgZgbg :�: G_ieZl_�`b�dZd�klbfme�d bgl_]jZpbb�ij_^ijbylbc ���WdhghfbdZ�b fZl_fZ�lbq_kdb_�f_lh^u �\ i_qZlb�����:glhgh\ F�<��� IhfZgkdbc :�;� JZpbhgbjh\Zgb_� b Ze]hjblf� wn�n_dlb\gh]h� jZkij_^_e_gby� aZ_fguo� kj_^kl\�� �� WdhghfbdZ� b fZ�l_fZlbq_kdb_�f_lh^u��������l�����\ui���