JITP_7(4)_Wilber.pdf

8/10/2019 JITP_7(4)_Wilber.pdf

1/10

!" $%&%"'% (& !")%*+,- ).%(+/

! #$%&'(%$ )' *+,),-./ #$./,%0

012 345617

!81 9:55:;42< =71 >;: 5:2< 12?2:>1@ AB!2>14G=5 +1=54@HIJ BK=2L@CG84@HIMN =2? :21

1OG17L> AB!2>15C Q24@81? 6::RN 1$23 4.+0.3 *+$.),5,)6N ;84G8 4@ S:5PH1

T :9 >81 0:@H:@ )745: D:5PH1 4@ 1$23 7-'/'863 1&,+,)9./,)6E )81@1 2:>1@ ;171 ;74>>12N 42 L=7>N

42 71@L:2@1 >: K=P5 U=7@8=55V@ =7>4G51 B):;=7? =2 !2>184@ 4@@P1MN =2?N ;8451 =LW

L71G4=>42< G17>=42 =@L1G>@ :9 F74>4G=5 +1=54@HN G:H1 :P> @>7:21181=?N K147G1N -14624>ZN 1>GEMX>: ;4>N =>:H@ ?: 2:>

?1L12? PL:2 6142< R2:;2 6C 8PH=2@N 6P> >81C ?: ?1L12? PL:2 6142< R2:;2 6C 1=G8 :>817E )81 BL71812W

@4:2I =@L1G> :9 =>:H@ AL7:>:WR2:;42:W911542:WG:2@G4:P@21@@M 815L@ >: G:W12=G> >81 6142< :7

:2>:5: :9 >81 =>:H@ 9:7 1=G8 :>817X>8147 :;2 1L4@>1H:5::5:8P@ 42@1L=7=651 =2?

G:WG71=>4D1E )81 =>:HV@ L71812@4:2 4@ L=7> :9 4>@ D17C :2>:5::H L71812?@

4>@ L71?1G1@@:7N 4> 4@ 42@>7PH12>=5 42 6742 9:7>8 :7 12=G>42< 4>N [P@> =@ 4>@ :;2 6142< ;455 ?1L12? 42 L=7>

:2 6142< L71812?1?\R2:;2\42G5P?1? 6C 4>@ :;2 @PGG1@@:7E !9N 9:7 >81 H:H12>N ;1 51=D1 ]P=2>PH H1G8=24G@

:P> :9 >81 L4G>P71 A@11 615:;MN 2:21 :9 >84@ ?1L12?@ :2 8PH=2@ 9:7 4>@ 1O4@>12G1 :7 6142 >81 =>:HV@

L71812@4:2W911542742@4G L=7> :9 >84@ 51D15 :9 >81 B71=5EI F:2@G4:P@21@@ 4@ 2:> @:H1>8428=> G=2 61 @PGR1? :P> :9 6142< >: 51=D1 =2 =;=7121@@W9711 B:2>:5:42< >: 61 R2:;2 6C

@:H1 :>817 @12>412> 6142 :9 >81 42>742@4G =;=71W

21@@ =2? 42>742@4G G71=>4D4>C :9 1=G8 :2>:5:181=?V@ BP5>4H=>1 G=>181 G71=>4D1 =?D=2G1 42>: 2:D15>CIX4@ L=7> :9 >81 L71812@4:2 :9 1=G8 =2? 1D17C 6142< 42 1O4@>12G1N =2? >81

G71=>4D1WL=7> G=22:> 61 74LL1? 97:H >81 6142 ;4>8:P> @1D171 D4:512G1E ): L:@>P5=>1 >81 H:@> 9P2?=H12>=5

51D15 :9 71=54>C =@ H1715C :2>:5:8:P> R2:;42< :7 G:2@G4:P@21@@ :7 G71=>4D4>CX4@ 6=@4G=55C =

Q7@>W>417 H:D1 >8=> @8=>>17@ >81 38:5121@@ :9 >84@ =2? 1D17C 71=5 :GG=@4:2E

-4R1;4@1N @L474>P=5 >7=2@G12?12G1 A%7:@M 71=G81@ =55 >81 ;=C ?:;2 =@ ;155E !2 !)V@ 21:W384>181=?4=2

D41;N 1=G8 21; H:H12> G:H1@ >: 61 =@ = @P6[1G> A;4>8 =55 9:P7 ]P=?7=2>@MN =2? 4> L71812?@ A>1>7=WL71812?@M 4>@

L71?1G1@@:7N ;84G8 4@ 2:; =2 :6[1G> A42 =55 9:P7 ]P=?7=2>@M 9:7 >84@ 21; @P6[1G>E )81 21; @P6[1G> B>7=2@G12?@

=2? 42G5P?1@I >81 :5? @P6[1G> A2:; =@ :6[1G>MN =2? >8P@ >81C HP>P=55C G:WG71=>1 1=G8 :>817Y >81 :5? @P6[1G>

>8=> 4@ 2:; :6[1G> =2? 4@ 42G5P?1? 42 >81 21; @P6[1G> 815L@ @8=L1 >81 21; @P6[1G> 4>@159N 6C >81 @4HL51 9=G> :9

6142< 42G5P?1? 42 4>N =G>P=55C 1H67=G1? 6C 4>N =2? >8P@ >: @:H1 ?117H4242< 4>E -4R1;4@1N >81 21; @P6W

[1G>N 42 42G5P?42< >81 :5? @P6[1G>N 4@ 42@>7PH12>=5 42 6742 9:7>8 :7 12=G>42< 4>N G:WG71=>42< 4>@ D17C 6142 =@ 4> ?:1@ @:X=2? >81 21; @P6[1G> >812 =??@ 4>@ :;2 ?14D4>CN G:2@G4:P@21@@N :7

3"&*#+/ "4 5#,'.*+/ 6-'"*1 +#2 7*+!,%!'N T^_TN `AaMN LLE abcdT


2/10

66 3"&*#+/ "4 5#,'.*+/ 6-'"*1 +#2 7*+!,%!'

!" $%&'()

2:D15>CN =2? >8P@ =G>P=55C G:WG71=>1@ = 21; 6142< 42 >81 D17C =G> :9 L71812@4D1 P24QG=>4:2E )84@ B>7=2@G12?

=2? 42G5P?1I 81 ;=C ?:;2 >: >81 @H=551@> H4G7:@P6=>:H4G L=7>4G51@N =2? =55 ;=C >87:P81 =G>P=5

H1@:W?1D15:LH12>=5 51D15@ A;8171N =@ 01@ 4> 9:7 8PH=2 ?1D15:LH12>N B>81 @P6[1G> :9 :21 51D15 61W

G:H1@ >81 :6[1G> :9 >81 @P6[1G> :9 >81 21O>IX;84G8 4@ >81 H1@: D41; :9 384>181=?V@ L71812@4:2X2=H15CN

>8=> B>81 @P6[1G> :9 >84@ H:H12> 61G:H1@ >81 :6[1G> :9 >81 @P6[1G> :9 >81 21O>IX6P> =G>42< 2:; :2 = 5=7: >81 H=G7: L7=G>4G1@ :9 H1?4>=>4:2N ;8171

>7=2@G12?12G1 4@ >81 :D17=55 87:P81 :6[1G>4QG=>4:2 :9 @>=>1W@>=51 >:

G=P@=5 >: )7P1 '159 >: P5>4H=>1 'L474> A;4>8 1=G8 @>=>1W@>=7=2@G12?42< =2? 42G5P?42< 4>@ L71?1G1@@:7X>81

@P6[1G> :9 :21 61G:H42< >81 :6[1G> :9 >81 21O>ME )84@ %7:@ A;84G8 G17>=425C G=2 61 D41;1? =@ @L474>P=5M 4@ =

L74H=7C ?74D17 :9 1D:5P>4:2 4>@159N @>=7>42< =55 >81 ;=C 6=GR ;4>8 >81 e4< e=2< =2? =55 >81 ;=C >87:P: P5>4W

H=>1 %25412H12>E ,@ %74G8 f=2>@G8 LP> 4>N 1D:5P>4:2 4@ B@159W:74:2 >87:P7=2@G12?12G1NI =2?

>8=> B>7=2@G12? =2? 42G5P?1I 4@ >81 D17C 9:7H :9 >81 H:H12>W>:WH:H12> P29:5?42< :9 71=54>CE

&P7>817N ;8=> F+ ?1@G7461@ =@ B71=5IX:7 B>81 42>7=2@4>4D1 51D15IX4@ =G>P=55C =2? H:@>5C >P7]P:4@1

71=54>CE )84@ 4@ 2:> >81 @=H1 B71=5I >8=> 4@ 9:P2? => >81 71? 51D15N >81 =H617 51D15N >81 :7=281 81 42?4 4> H1=2> 6C B:2>:5:: @:H1:21 => 71?N >81C ;:P5? g=>5C

?4@=8 F+V@ D17@4:2 :9 :2>:5:8147 81=?@EI !2 9=G>N ;8=> H:@> @:L84@>4G=>1? >842R17@>:?=C G=55 B:2>:5:P=55C >81 >P7]P:4@1 51D15 :9 6142 =@ = H171 ?1@G74L>4:2N

6P> = 71=5 :2>4GW1L4@>1H4G @>7PG>P71 :9 >81 P24D17@1E )81@1 51D15@ :9 6142 [P@> 51D15@

:9 = 8PH=2 6142 51D15@ :9 >81 0:@H:@ 4>@159 A=2? >8:@1 ?4991712> 51D15@ +*'?4991712> ;:75?@hME ': ! =H

G17>=425C 2:> @=C42< >8=> >84@ B>P7]P:4@1 71=54>CI :7 :2>:5: 71=5N :25C >8=> 4> 4@ 42@1L=7=651 97:H >81 L71W

812@4D1WR2:;4281 >P7]P:4@1 51D15 :9 6142@159E )8171 4@ 2: ;=C =7:P2?

>84@XL71G4@15C 61G=P@1 :9 L=2L@CG84@H A@PG8 =@ @P6@G7461? >: 6C -14624>ZN 384>181=?N :7 K147G1ME )81 >P7W

]P:4@1 51D15 5::R@ => >81 =>:H4G 51D15N >81 H:51GP5=7 51D15N >81 G155P5=7 64:5:GEN =2? G:2G5P?1@

>81C 8=D1 = 71=54>C 42 =2? :9 >81H@15D1@X=2 :2>:5: 2:> :25C 4@ 4> ?1@G74642< >8:@1 51D15@ =@ ;8=> >81C

5::R 54R1 97:H >P7]P:4@1X1D12 49 ;1 48=> L=7>X>81C =71 :D175::R42< >81 L71812@4D1WG:2@G4:P@21@@W

R2:;42< ?4H12@4:2 :9 >81 =>:H@N H:51GP51@N =2? G155@ >81H@15D1@N =2 1L4@>1H4G ?4H12@4:2 >8=> G:WG71=>1@ >81

:2>4G ?4H12@4:2 ;4>8 >81 6142< =@L1G> :9 >8:@1 8:5:2@ A=2? D4G1 D17@=MX=1H:5::5:;: ?4991712> ?4H12@4:2@ :9 >81 @=H1 38:5121@@ :9 >81 71=5 :GG=@4:2N =2? G=22:> 61 97=1? ;4>8:P>

: >81 0:@H:@E

)8P@N 9:7 1O=HL51N >=R1 H:51GP51@ ?P742< >81 H= B1OW4@>I AH1=242=2?

:P>IM =2C;8171 42 >81 H=8171 ;=@ 2:>842< 42 >81 G:2@G4:P@21@@ :9 42?4D4?P=5@ => H=8=> G:7W

71@L:2?1? ;4>8 BH:51GP51@EI eP> ;1 H:?172@X;1 => >P7]P:4@1X=@@PH1 >8=> >81 H:51GP51@ 1O4@>1? 2:21W

>8151@@X49 >81C ?4?2V> 1OW4@>N >81C ?4? ;8=> ;1 H4 G=55$&8$%$,A! =: F+V@ >7=2@4>4D1

A1OW4@>M =2? 42>7=2@4>4D1 A@P6@4@>M ;4>8 :21 H=[:7 1OG1L>4:2Y =@ 2:>1?N !) 4@ L=2L@CG84GX1L4@>1H:5::5: 61 >:72 =@P2?17E 38=> ;1 G=55 BL71W8PH=2 :2>:5:P=55C

$ &+$;:90.( %$(),$() :'/'( H1715C = ?4@1H6:?41?N g:=>42:5: :9 4>@ 6142:5: >81 H:51GP5=7 51D15N =2? 6:>8 =71 21G1@@=7C >: G:WG71=>1 1=G8 :>817E ! 51=D1@ :2>:5:81 H:51GP51N =2? 1L4@>1H:5:

: 8PH=2@ A:7 84 >: =55 @12>412> 614281C :25C 6142 R2:;42 49 =

8PH=2 G:2@G4:P@21@@WR2:;42< 4@ 2:> 42D:5D1? 42 G:WG71=>42< >81 :2>:5::H@N H:51GP51@N :7 G155@N ,-'%*

"0#G:2@G4:P@21@@WL71812@4:2 4@ 42D:5D1?N =55 >81 ;=C ?:;2 A"5= K147G1 =2? 384>181=?ME

&P7>817N ;812 ;1 =G>P=55C ?:;2 >: 1OL5=4242< ;8=> >84@ @P6@4@>12G1 71=54>C 4@X>81 B71=5IX4> G8=28 1=G8 21; @>7PG>P71 A71?N =H617N :7=2 ;1 :H@I 1OW4@> => :7=28:@1 61G:H1 @P6W@P6=>:H4G L=7>4G51@ => 8:@1 61G:H1 iW9:5?W;=C

]P=7R@ => >1=5J >8:@1 61G:H1 __W?4H12@4:2=5 @>742 >P7]P:4@1E 31 G=2V>$+1;8=> >81 =>:H4G 51D15 4@ 1OG1L>

97:H @:H1 @>7PG>P71 :9 61427PG>P71 ?4@G5:@1@ = 21; :2>:5:


3/10

3"&*#+/ "4 5#,'.*+/ 6-'"*1 +#2 7*+!,%!' 67

!"#$%&'( #*$+&,

:2>:5:8171N 4@ 71=5N 6P> 4@ G:WG71=>1? 6C >81 L71812@4D1 8:5:2@ => >8=> 51D15EM ,84@ 4@ 2:> >: 71?PG1

:2>:5:: 1L4@>1H:5: 7=>817 G5=4H >81C =71 G:HL51H12>=7C =@L1G>@ :9 >81 @=H1 38:51 :GG=@4:2E A!2

@8:7>N ! ?4@=8 6:>8 0=2> =2? e8=@R=7X:7 ! =8 >81H 6:>8N ?1L12?42< :2 8:; C:P 5::R => 4>EM

)84@ 71H42?@ H1 :9 .PH617>: U=>P7=2= =2? &7=2G4@G: S=715=V@ 674554=2> =2=5C@4@ :9 >81 ;:75? A>81 B71W

=54>CIM :9 = 97:: U=>P7=2= =2? S=715=N H:@> 64:5:@ 9:55:;1? @:H1 9:7H :9 1G:@C@>1H@ >81:7C =2?

?1@G7461? >81 71=54>C :9 >81 97:< =@ 1O4@>42< 42 D=74:P@ @C@>1H@ :9 2=>P71E eP> U=>P7=2= =2? S=715= L:42>1? :P>

>8=> >8=> ;=@ =G>P=55C ;8=> >81 97:C 5::R1? 54R1 4*"9 ,-' $!%'#,%$,:$L:42> :9 D41;N 6P> 2:> 97:H >81

97:1? :25C :9 D=74:P@ L=>G81@ :9 G:5:7 =2? H:>4:2N @H155@

=2? @:P2?@J 4> ?4? 2:> 8=D1 >81 G:4D1 G=L=G4>C >: @>=2? :P>@4?1 4>@159 =2? L4G>P71 >81 12>471 @C@>1H :9 ;84G8

4> ;=@ = L=7>X:25C >81 @G412>4@> ?4? >8=> AP@42< Z:21 iME +1=54>CN 9:7 >81 97:81 4HH1?4=>1 D41; 97:H

Z:21 _N =2? >81 61@> >81 @G412>4@> G:P5? ?: ;=@ =>>1HL> >: G=L>P71 >8=> P@42< Z:21 dX= bL O _WL O bLX2=H15CN

>81 :6[1G>4D1 @G412>4@>N ;8451 @>P?C42< =2 :6[1G>4D1 :7>1HL>@ >: >=R1 >81 :7842I :7 B64:5:12 P@1?E S=715= L:42>1? :P> >8=> >84@

BD41; 97:H ;4>842I ;=@ 2:> >81 =G>P=5 Q7@>WL17@:2 D41; :9 >81 97:< 4>@159 >8=> >81 @G412>4@> 4@ ?471G>5C :6@17D428=> ;:P5? 61 >81 97: >81 1O>174:7 D17@4:2 :9 >81 97:81 D41;

97:H >81 42@4?1 :9 >81 jLL17 +4N 2:> >81 42@4?1 :9 >81 jLL17 -19>ME )81 L:42> 4@ >8=> >81 97:< 12=G>@ 4>@ :;271=54>CX4>@ :;2 1L4@>1H:5:1@ 4>@ :;2 :2>:5:81

G5:@1@> >: ;84G8 >81 @G412>4@> G=2 4@ Z:21 dMX=2? >81 @G412>4@> 84H@159 54R1;4@1 12=G>@N :7 G=2 12=G>N 84@

:;2 D41; :9 >81 97:CN ;84G8 H=2C @G412>4@>@ 61541D1 4@ 1H@ D41; AZ:21 iMN 6P> H:71

>7P>89P55C 4@ = Z:21Wd D17@4:2E eP> 42 6:>8 G=@1@N >81 6142< =2? R2:;42< =71 >;: ?4H12@4:2@ :9 >81 @=H1 =G>P=5

:GG=@4:2N ;8=>1D17 4> 4@E eP> H1715C P@42< = @C@>1H@ D41; 4@ = ?11L5C =2>87:L:G12>74G D41; :9 >81 97:: R2:; >81 97:P=5 ;:75? AZ:21 _M 6C P@42< >81 @G412>4@>V@ >::5@ AZ:21 iM ?:1@ : >81 97:P=5 42>174:7E

)8P@N =GG:7?42< >: !)N >81 51D15 :9 >81 B71=5I ?1@G7461? 6C F+ ?:1@2V> 1O4@> =@ F+ ?1@G7461@ 4>E +=>817N

42 !)V@ D41;N 42 =G>P=54>C 4> 4@ 14>817 >81 L7:?PG> :9 6:>8 >81 L71812@4D1W911542 >81 L=7>4GP5=7 51D15 :9 >81 71=5 6142< ?1@G7461? A1E:H@N H:51GP51@N

4G@M =2? >8147 715=>4:2@X=55 :9 ;84G8 =71 >1>7=W12=G>1? =2? >1>7=W1D:5D1?J =2?\:7 4> 4@ >81 71@P5> :9 >81;=C >81 ;:75? 1H171>7=W12=G>1? => =2? 97:H = L=7>4GP5=7 51D15 :9 G:2@G4:P@21@@W6142< A1EP7W

]P:4@1M :9 >81 @G412>4@>E !2 >81 5=>>17 G=@1N >81 71=5 4@ 2:> G71=>1? 6C 4>@ H171 ?1@G74L>4:2 6C >81 L=7>4GP5=7 51D15

:9 G:2@G4:P@21@@W6142 7=>817 =G>P=55C 1H1781 71=5 ;4>8 >81 1H1781 ?11L

@>7PG>P71@ :9 >81 L=7>4GP5=7 51D15 :9 6142 51D15@ :9 8PH=2 6142 51D15@ :9 >81 71=5 0:@H:@EM )81@1 51D15@ :9 6142 ?4991712> 42>17L71>=>4:2@ :9 = :21N @42

=71 >81H@15D1@ =G>P=55C 2%44'*'#, 0"*/2$42 ?11L @>7PG>P71 A=2 4297=71? ;:75?N = 71? ;:75?N =2 =H617 ;:75?N =2

:7=2GEN $.-: '> ?:,-: ,% -'0&'%$@ '> A.)9+$: =G>P=55C G71=>1 8=64>@X>81C =71 54D42< =2? G:2@G4:P@ 6142@hX42@>1=? :9 L71812@4:2W9711 :2>:5:8=> 8=D1 2: 54D42< G8:4G1@N =2? >8P@ HP@>


4/10

68 3"&*#+/ "4 5#,'.*+/ 6-'"*1 +#2 7*+!,%!'

!" $%&'()

6542?5C :61C 5=;@N @:H1>842< 6:>8 K147G1 =2? !N =H:2< :>817@N Q2? P242>1554817N =GG:7?42< >:

K147G1N 4> 4@ >81 9=G> >8=> 1=G8 @1H4:>4G 614281 ;=C ?:;2X8=@ 42 4>@ >74L=7>4>1 H=R1PL =2 ,()$+&+$;

,+#,>8=> H1=2@ >81 8:5:2V@ 6142< 4@ ?1>17H421? 42 L=7> 6C 42>17L71>=>4:2N =55 >81 ;=C ?:;2X=2? >84@N 81 @=C@N

4@ B421@G=L=651IME

384G8 6742: =2:>817 L:42>E (741? =@ = ;=C >: 1OL5=42 =2? [P@>49C >81 71W

@P5>@ :9 @G412>4QG 1OL174H12>@ A=@ 0=75 K:LL17 =@R1?N L=7=L87=@42 >8=> @G412G1 =G>P=55C ;:7R@k

!> ;:7R@ 61G=P@1 >8171 4@ = 71=5 :2>:5:8=> G=2 716P99 4>IME eP> 4> 4@ 2:> G51=7 => =55 >8=> >81 >CL1@ :9 71=54W

>41@ ?4@G5:@1? 6C @G412G1 =2? @G412>4QG 1OL174H12>@ =71 >81 @=H1 :21@ >8=> ;:7R ;4>8 H:7=5@N 817H121P>4G@N

=1@>81>4G@N =2? 42>7:@L1G>4:2N >: 2=H1 = 91; :9 >81 HP5>4L51 H1>8:?:5:8=> 1O4@> :P> >8171 =2? =??71@@

?4991712> :6[1G> ?:H=42@ =2? Z:21@E ): G5=4H >8=> :25C @G412>4QG 1OL174H12>@ @ 4@ L1745:P@5C

G5:@1 >: @G412>4@HN =2? @4HL5C =??42< :>817 ?4@G4L5421@ :2 >:L :9 @G412G1 4@ =G>P=55C >: 71?PG1 >8:@1 ?4H12W

@4:2@ >: H1715C @G412>4QG H1>8:?:5:@159E +1?PG42< =55 ?4H12@4:2@ >: @G412G1 G17>=425C @>74R1@ H1 =@ 614214@Q1? ;4>8 >81 A=> 51=@>M 14 9P2?=H12>=5 H1>8:?:5:8=>

?4@G5:@1 ?4991712> :6[1G> ?:H=42@ A=2? ;8:@1 42[P2G>4:2@ :7 L=7=?4 :7 6742< 9:7>8 :7 G:WG71=>1 >8:@1

D=74:P@ ?:H=42@N ;84G8N = [P@> 5C42< =7:P2? :P> >8171 ;=4>42< >: 61 @>PH651? :2 6C = @G412>4QG

H1>8:?:5:8=> 615419 4@ ;8=> '155=7@ G=55@ B>81 HC>8 :9 >81 5CN e8=@R=7 8=@ 42>7:?PG1? @L474>P=5 71=54>41@ =2? G:2@G4:P@21@@ 42>: 84@ @G81H1E eP> ?PHLW

42< G:2@G4:P@21@@ :2 >:L :9 =2 :2>:5:8=> ;=@ ?1D15:L1? ;4>8:P> 4> 4@N ;155N G81=>42: 61 ?:21 :D17N P@42< G:2@G4:P@21@@ =@ =2 42>742@4G L=7> :9 >81 @G81H1 97:H >81 D17C 6142< 4> =9>17 >81 @G81H1 8=@ 6112 ?1D15:L1? ;4>8:P> 4>E )81 G8=2G1@ >8=> >81 @G81H1

;455 8=D1 =2C>842< 71=5 >: ?: ;4>8 =G>P=5 G:2@G4:P@21@@ 4@ @54H 42?11?N =@ G:2@G4:P@21@@ 61G:H1@ = 2'&$ '=

9+!-%#+>: >81 H=42 97=H1E

&42=55CN ! ;:P5? 61 71H4@@ 49 ! ?4?2V> => 51=@> 6741gC H12>4:2 >81 G5=4H@ H=?1 :2 618=59 :9 ]P=2>PH

H1G8=24G@ AlUMN ;84G8 8=@N 49 2:>842< 15@1N 6112 >=R12 =@ >81 H:@> @PGG1@@9P55C L71G4@1 @G412>4QG H:?15 1D17

42D12>1? A:21 1@>4H=>1 LP> 4> => = H4554:2 >4H1@ H:71 L71G4@1 >8=2 "1;>:24=2 L8C@4G@ME )81 G12>7=5 G:2G172

:9 lU G12>17@ =7:P2? ;8=> 4@ G=551? >81 BG:55=L@1 :9 >81 ;=D1 L=GR1>I A;84G8 H1=2@N @4HL54@>4G=55CN >84@Y

=7:P2? _mTdN 6:>8 .14@12617< =2? 'G87:1?428 = @1> :9 H=>81H=>4G=5 1]P=>4:2@ ?1@G7464281 1O4@>12G1 :9 = @P6=>:H4G L=7>4G51E .14@126171? 'H=>74O 1]P=>4:2N =2? 'G87:1?42: 61 42>17G8=2@N =2? >8P@ 'G87:1?424:2N 6142< >81 @4HL517 :9 >81 >;:N @::2 61G=H1 >81 @>=2?=7? 9:7H :9 lUXB>81 G:55=L@1 :9 >81

;=D1 L=GR1>I 71917@ >: >81 G:55=L@1 :9 'G87:1?424:2 D17@4:2ME U=O K5=2GR A;8: 8=? 42>7:W

?PG1? >81 ]P=2>PH 71D:5P>4:2 42 _m^d 6C @P8=> 1217 G:H1 42 = G:2>42PPH 6P> 7=>817

1O4@>@ 42 ?4@G71>1 L=GR1>@ :7 ]P=2>=M 2:>4G1? >8=> 49 C:P >=R1 >81 @]P=71 :9 >81 71@P5>@ :9 >81 'G87:1?424:2N C:P ;:P5? >81 L7:6=6454>C :9 >81 @L1G4QG 5:G=>4:2 A=2?\:7 = @1> :9 :>817 G8=7=G>174@>4G@M :9 >81

L=7>4G51 42 ]P1@>4:2 A6P> C:P :25C >;: G8=7=G>174@>4G@ => = >4H1X=2?X>81 G=>G8X>81 9"*'C:P Q2? :9

:21N >81 /'$$C:P !+#Q2? :9 >81 :>817ME )81 71@P5>@ :9 >84@ 42=6454>C >: ?1>17H421 6:>8 D=74=651@ ;=@ =651 >: 61

LP> 42 = L71G4@1 9:7H =@ ;8=> 61G=H1 9=H:P@5C R2:;2 =@ >81 .14@12617< j2G17>=42>C K742G4L51N ;84G8 6=@4W

G=55C 67:P =2 12? >: @>74G> G=P@=54>C 42 >81 L8C@4G=5 @G412G1@ A=2? L71@PH=65C 71H:D1? BG=P@=54>CI 97:H

>81 +1=54@>@ 51D15 :9 >81 B71=5IME eP> >81 71=5 R4GR17 G=H1 97:H >81 9=G> >8=>N L74:7 >: =G>P=55C H1=@P742< >81

L=7>4G51 >: 4:2 =6:P> 4>N >81 L=7>4G51 1O4@>1? :25C =@ = L7:6=6454>CXC:P /%,'*+//1G:P5?2V>

@=C 4> 1O4@>1? :7 4> ?4?2V> 1O4@>E U:71:D17N >81 >CL1 :9 H1=@P71H12> >8=> C:P L179:7H1? :2 >81 L=7>4G51 ?1>17W

H421? >81 >CL1 :9 6142< >8=> C:P =G>P=55C 1D:R1?X?4991712> H1=@P742< H1>8:?@ 61428 ?4991712> ]P=54>41@E )84@ 51? f:82 3811517 >: @=C >8=> ;1 54D1? 42 = BL=7>4G4L=>:7CW:6@17D=>4:2I P24D17@1E

lU 8=@ 2:; 6112 9:P2? =LL54G=651 42 @G=51@ 97:H >81 D17C @H=551@> >: >81 D17C 5=7N =@ ;155 =@ 42 67=42

42>17=G>4:2@N 64:5:GEN =2? 71H=42@N 9:7 ;8=> 4> ?:1@N B>81 H:@> @PGG1@@9P5 L8C@4G=5 >81:7C :9 =55 >4H1EI

38=> 4@ 71H=7R=651 =6:P> >84@ >81:7C 4@ 8:; Q7H5C 4> P24>1@ 1L4@>1H:5::5:81 >;:N 42

9=G>N G:W1D:R1 1=G8 :>817E , ?4991712> 1L4@>1H:5: :2>:5: :2>:5:


5/10

3"&*#+/ "4 5#,'.*+/ 6-'"*1 +#2 7*+!,%!' 69

!"#$%&'( #*$+&,

;455 G:7715=>1 ;4>8 = @L1G4QG =2? ?4991712> 1L4@>1H:5:81HN =@ 4> ;171N 67428 >81 G:7715=W

>4D1 ?4H12@4:2 A:7 G:WG71=>42< 4>ME

! ?:2V> ;=2> >: :D17W1HL8=@4Z1 >81 7:51 :9 lU 42 !2>1 >: L:42> :P>N 8:;1D17N

>8=>X@>=7>42< ;4>8 0=75 K:LL17X>81 7:51 :9 @G412G1 42 F+ 8=@ 6112 L17D=@4D1N 6P> @G412G1 8=@ 6112 G8=28=> F+ @11H@ 2:> >: 8=D1 R1L> PL ;4>8E !9 1D17 >8171 ;=@ = G=@1 :9 BH1=2@ :9 R2:;4281 H:@> @PGG1@@9P5

L8C@4G=5 >81:7C 42 84@>:7CN :21V@ B:2>:5:8 4>E

! H4 H12>4:2 >8=> 4>V@ 2:> [P@> >81 1O4@>12G1 :9 >81 9:P7 ]P=?7=2>@ >8=> 4@ 4HL:7>=2>XH=2C >81:74@>@

42G5P?1 >81 9:P7 ]P=?7=2>@X6P> 7=>817 >8147 6142< 9:P7 ?4991712> ?4H12@4:2@ :9 >81 @=H1 :GG=@4:2N H:H12>

>: H:H12>N >8=> 4@ ?4@>42G>4D1 ;4>8 !)E )81 9:P7 ]P=?7=2>@N 9P7>817N 81 ;=C ?:;2N =2? >84@ H1=2@ >8=>

G:2@G4:P@21@@ 4>@159 81 ;=C ?:;2N =@ =2 42>742@4G L=7> :9 >81 D17C 9=674G :9 >81 0:@H:@ 4>@159E )84@

4@ ;8=> @1>@ !2>1 97:H @: H=2C :>817 >81:741@E ,@L1G>@ :9 G:2@G4:P@21@@X;84G8 4>@159 4@

L74H=745C =2 :L1242< :7 G51=742< 42 ;84G8 @P6[1G>4D1 =2? :6[1G>4D1 L812:H12= G=2 1H174D4>C A=@ L=7> :9 >81 D17C :L1242< 42 ;84G8 21;21@@ =2? 2:D15>C !+#=LL1=7N =2? >81

H1=2@ 81 0-%!- 4> G=2 =LL1=7Mn =2 =P>:H=>4G 1L4@>1H4GWL71812@4:2 :9 >81 L71G1?42< H:H12> A;84G8 G:WG71=>1@ :7 815L@

6742< 9:7>8 >81 6142< :7 :2>:5:81 L71@12> H:H12>X4>@ 6142< B

6742 9:7>8N =2? 4>@ 6142< L71812?1? 6C =2 ,()$+&+$).()N = 5= K147G1N 4@ ;8=> 81

P2=D:4?=651 42>17L71>4D1 >;4@> >: 4>@ 6142 >81 @=H1 >4H1N >81 B42G5P?1I L=7> A:9 B>7=2@G12? =2? 42G5P?1IM H1=2@ >81 L71D4W

:P@ H:H12>N :2G1 @P6[1G> 6P> 2:; :6[1G> :9 >81 21; @P6[1G>N 4@ 42G5P?1? :7 54>17=55C ,+>'#

%#,">81 6142< :9 >81 21; @P6[1G>N >8P@ =5>1742< >81 21; @P6[1G>V@ D17C 6142< :7 :2>:5:81 @L1G4QG =G> :9 42G5P@4:2X=1H:5:4D1 =2? G:W?1>17H4242< =@ >;: =@L1G>@ :9 >81 38:51 71=5 :GG=@4:2E 'PGR421H4GWG:2@G4:P@21@@W911542< :P> :9 >81 8:5:2N 51=D42< :25C 4>@ ?1=? =2? ?12P?1? 6142:5:4D15C >: R455 >81 6142< 42 ]P1@>4:2N =2? =2>87:L:G12>74G=55C >: >7=2@917=55 >81 1L4@>1H4GWR2:;42812

L7:L:@1 >81:741@ =6:P> >84@ ?12P?1? 51D15 :9 6142< >8=> >81C G=55 B>81 71=5EI )84@ 4@ >7=817N ;8451 >81 B>7=2@G12?I L=7> 4@ %7:@N :7 'L474>W42W=G>4:2 A:7 'L474>W42W@159W:74:2MN =2? 4@ 42[1G>42< 'L474>P=5 G71=>4D4>C 42>: 1D17C H:H12> A>8P@ H=R42< 1D:5P>4:2

B@159W:74:2 >87:P7=2@G12?12G1NI =@ %74G8 f=2>@G8 LP> 4>MX;8451 >8=> 4@

8=LL124281 42G5P?1 L=7> 4@ >=R42< G=71 :9 >8:@1 =@L1G>@ CI =2? 42?PG>4:2E !9 >81 ?14D4>C :7 2:D15>C 42 = 8:5:2W6142< 4@ 1O>71H15C

@H=55 A=@ ;4>8N @=CN = ]P=7RMN >812 >81 L71D4:P@ H:H12>V@ 42G5P?42< G:HL:212> ;455 61 6C

9=7 >81 @>7:2 ?1>17H42=2> :9 >81 21; @P6[1G>N =2? >81 21; @P6[1G> ;455 @11H G:HL51>1W

5C ?1>17H424@>4G A8=D42< 54>>51 G71=>4D4>C >: G:P2>17 >81 G=P@=54>CME eP> 384>181=? L:42>@

:P> >8=> 2: 61424D4>C 4@ =6@:5P>15C Z17:N :25C D=24@8428P@ @>74G>

?1>17H424@H :7 @>74G> G=P@=54>C ?:1@2V> 1O4@> A>81 @=H1 =@ H=42>=421? 6C lUME U:71:D17N

>81 8481 *71=> "1@> >8=> = 8:5:2 =LL1=7@N >81 H:71 2:D15>C =2? G71=>4D4>C 4>

L:@@1@@1@X@: = L8C@4G4@> G=2 L71?4G> ;8171 j7=2P@ ;455 61N H:71 :7 51@@N = _N^^^ C1=7@

97:H 2:;N 6P> 2: 64:5: G=2 >155 C:P ;8171 HC ?:< ;455 61 _ H42P>1 97:H 2:;E eP> 9:7

>8:@1 8:5:2W61428 54>>51 G71=>4D4>CN >81 B>7=2@G12? =2? 42G5P?1I H1G8=24G@ =GG:P2>@

9:7 =2 =2@;17 >: .PH1V@ G74>4]P1 :9 6:>8 G=P@=54>C =2? 42?PG>4:2 A4E1EN =GG:P2>@ 9:7 >8147

1O4@>12G1N 1D12 =@ 6:>8 61G:H1 51@@ =2? 51@@ >81 8481 ?1 =2?

1D:5P>4:2ME


6/10

6: 3"&*#+/ "4 5#,'.*+/ 6-'"*1 +#2 7*+!,%!'

!" $%&'()

! ?: ;=2> >: 71L1=> >8=> >8171 4@ HPG8 42 F+ >8=> ! =LL71G4=>1E ! L=7>4GP5=75C =LL71G4=>1 8=D42< =2 =55C

= >81 715=>4D4@H :9 1O>71H1 L:@>H:?1724@H A1D12 49N =5=@N ! @>455 Q2? L7:651H@ 42 8:; F+

?:42< >84@N 6C 74LL42< G:2@G4:P@21@@ :P> :9 >81 0:@H:@ =2? 51=D42< B>81 71=5I >: 61 H1715C = ?12P?1? B:2W

>:5: 4>@ 81=7> 4@ 42 >81 74 L5=G1N :21 H4 @=CN =2? +:C e8=@R=7 84H@159 4@ = >7P5C 1O>7=:7?42=7C

8PH=2 6142842< = L845:@:L817 @8:P5? 61N 42 HC 8PH651 :L424:2 A4> 71H42?@ H1N @:H1;8=>

&:PG=P5> =9>17 >8147 9=H:P@ H11>42842< 4@N @1D17=5 >81:74@>@ 8=D1 L:42>1? :P> 8:; F+

=2? !) G=2 61 67:P 42>: 1 G5:@1M =N ;4>8 = 91; 9P2?=H12>=5 G8=2 :2>:5:81 71=5IJ =2? F+N =GG1L>42< 1L4@>1H4GW:2>4G =@ G:7715=>4D1 ?4H12@4:2@ :9 >81 @=H1 =G>P=5

38:5121@@ :9 @12>412> 8:5:2@ 81 ;=C ?:;2E ,@ ! 71=? F+N ! R11L @1142< 4> @P6>5CXD17C @P6>5CX

71?PG42< 1D17C>842< >: P5>4H=>1 =2G8:7=81 1@@12>4=55C L71812@4:2W9711 +4W.=2? ]P=?7=2>@ A=2? !VH

@P71 F+ @11@ !) =@ @P6>5C 71?PG42< 1D17C>842< >: >81 -19>W.=2? ]P=?7=2>@ME eP> HC L:@4>4:2 4@N =2? 71H=42@N

>8=> =55 9:P7 ]P=?7=2>@ =71 1]P=55C 71=5N 1]P=55C L71@12>N >1>7=W12=G>421>7=W1D:5D42842< 51@@

>8=2 >8=> A=5:2< ;4>8 51D15@N 5421@N @>=>1@N =2? >CL1@N 9P5G7PH@ =2? @;4>G8WL:42>@N !2>18:?:5:1WU1>=L8C@4G@M G=2 @G=7G15C 61 G=551? B42>1455N ;1 42 >81 H:?172 =2? L:@>H:?172 ;:75?X@=CN >P7]P:4@1X=@@PH1 >8=> @:H1>842< 54R1 B=>:H@I 2:21W

>8151@@ ;171 71=5 =2? 1O4@>1? 42 @:H1 @12@1 ?P742< >81 H=8=> @12@1 ;1 G=55 B@P6@4@>12G1EI

,>:H@ ?4? 2:> 1OW4@>N 6P> >81C ?4? @P6@4@>E

eP> >;: 4HL:7>=2> L:42>@ =6:P> >8=>E (21N !2>117H !VH

P2G:H9:7>=651 ;4>8N L71917742< BL=2W42>174:74@>NI H1=242< =55 8:5:2@ 8=D1 6:>8 1O>174:7@ =2? 42>174:7@N =55

>81 ;=C PLN =55 >81 ;=C ?:;2E )81 42>174:7@ =71 >81 BL71812@4:2@I :9 384>181=?N ;84G8N =@ ;1VD1 L:42>1?

:P>N ;1 @>71>G8 >: B>1>7=WL71812@4:2@IME ,2? >84@ H1=2@N 619:71 8PH=2 6142:H@ ;171 42D:5D1? 42 G:G71=>42< 1=G8 :>817E )81 =:H G:2>746P>1? >: >81 :L1242< :7 G51=742< 42 ;84G8 :>817 =>:H@ G:P5? =LL1=7 >: 1=G8 :>817X42 @8:7>N

>81 L7:>:WG:2@G4:P@21@@ :7 L71812@4:2 :9 1=G8 =>:H G:2>746P>1? >: >81 6142< :7 :2>:5::HE )84@

;=@2V> [P@> = 51D15 :9 :2>:5:15C ?4D:7G1? 97:H 1L4@>1H:5: =2 :GG=@4:2 ;8171 R2:;42< =2?

6142;: G:HL51H12>=7C =@L1G>@ :9 >81 @=H1 8=LL1242 61

@1L=7=>1? :7 >:72 =@P2?17 ;4>8:P> : >81 71=54>C :9 >81 =>:H4G 6142817 6142< 2:7 G:2@G4:P@21@@ G=2 61 @1L=7=>1? 97:H >81 :>817N => =2C 51D15N ;4>8:P> @ 81 ;=C PLN =55 >81 ;=C ?:;2E

&P7>817N ;812 4> G:H1@ >: @=C42< 1O=G>5C ;8=> 4> 4@ >8=> @P6@4@>@ => >81 =>:H4G 51D15N 8PH=2 G:2@G4:P@W

21@@N R2:;4217L71>=>4:2 =71 421D4>=65C 67:P 42>: >81 L4G>P71E )81 9P2?=H12>=5 9=G> 71=54@H =2?

L:@4>4D4@H R11L :D175::R42< 4@ >8=> ?4991712> 51D15@ :9 6142 H1>8:?:5:8 ?4991712> ;:75?@E !> 4@ 2:>X=@ >81 BHC>8 :9 =42@X>8=> >8171 4@ :21N @42 4@ 42>17L71>1? ?4991712>5C 6C ?4991712> ;:75?D41;@ A=5>8:P8=> :9 G:P7@1 G=2 8=LL12MN 6P> 7=>817


7/10


8/10

7? 3"&*#+/ "4 5#,'.*+/ 6-'"*1 +#2 7*+!,%!'

!" $%&'()

G5=@@4QG=>4:2@N :7 D41;@N 6C >81 >17H B?1@G74L>4D1 :2>:5:4D1 :2>:5:IME

'1=2 ;4@81@ >: D41; G54H=>1 G8=2:5:4L51 :6[1G>N =2? 2:> H1715C = ?1W

@G74L>4D1 :2>:5: :7 = @42N = D41; ! 9P55C @8=71 A;1 6:>8 71=54Z1 4> G=2 61 D41;1? =@ = @42N 6P> 2:> 1991G>4D15CME B(2>:5:1? >87:P8711 =O1@Y $&,%)$0';

/".%!+/ 2%$,+#!'N 9',-"2"/".%!+/ !2>1 51=@> 71G:84@ >74L51 L5P7=54@H A42G5P?42:5:8:?:5:4G1@ 6742< L812:H12= 42>: 61424=55CI 6742< >81H

42>: 6142 >81 L:42> 4@ G51=7 12:P8=> ! H=42>=42 >8=> A=> 51=@>M =55

>8711 :9 >81@1 G:W1O4@>N =2? C:P G=2V> 8=D1 :21 ;4>8:P> >81 :>817@E ! ;455 :9>12 [P@> @=C B1L4@>1H:5::5:;: G:HL51H12>=7C =@L1G>@ :9 >81 @=H1 :GG=@4:2NI :7 => :>817 >4H1@N B)81 @>7PG>P71 :9 >81 @P6[1G>

G:WG71=>1@ >81 2=>P71 :9 >81 L812:H12= L17G14D1?IX6P> =@ ! H=R1 G51=7N ! >842R =55 >8711 L7:G1@@1@ A38: O

.:; O 38=>N =5:2< ;4>8 = 91; :>817@M =71 =2 42@1L=7=651 L=7> :9 !2>18:?:5:81:7C

=2? %# *'+/%,1ME ,55 >8711 :9 >81@1 =71 :9>12 ?4991712>X:9>12 ]P4>1 ?4991712>X6P> =55 >8711 :9 >81H =71 =5;=C@

=571=?C L71@12> 42 =2C :GG=@4:2 A42G5P?42< L71W8PH=2 8:5:2@N ;84G8 L71812? 1=G8 :>817 >87:P8:?@ G:L7:?PG42< D=74:P@ ?:H=42@ME ,2? >84@ H1=2@N ;4>8:P> ?:P6>N >8=> G8=281 38: :7 G8=281 .:; ;455 G8=281 38=>X812G1N 42>1:5:8=> >81

38=> @P6@4@>@ A4> L:@@1@@1@ ;8=> 345974? '155=7@N L4:2117 G74>4G :9 B>81 HC>8 :9 >81 742@4G

91=>P71@IMN ;1 G=2V> @=C ;8=> >8:@1 =G>P=55C =71 A:7 ;8=> >8:@1 42>742@4G 91=>P71@ =71M ;4>8:P> @L1G49C42< >81

38: =2? >81 .:; A1OL54G4>5C :7 4HL54G4>5CME

":;N '1=2 @=C@ >8=> 42 84@ .:;N 81 4@ 42G5P?42817 4>1H@N !2>14G=5 +1=54@HN

,G>:7W"1>;:7R )81:7CN 'G412G1 =2? )1G82:5: >81 G:H642=>4:2 :9 >8:@1 H1>8:?@ =71E 31 G=2V> @4HL5C

@=C >81C =71 =55 4HL:7>=2> A42 H=2C ;=C@N >81C =71 42?11? =55 4HL:7>=2>N =@ =71 ?:Z12@N L178=L@ 8P2?71?@N :9

:>817 H1>8:?:5:rE 3155N C:P >81 !2>1P71E )81 9=G> >8=> !2>1 2=H1 1D17C

@4281:74@> >8=> ;12> 42>: 4> ?:1@2V> H1=2 >81C ;1712V> >=R12 @174:P@5CE !25#,'.*+/ 7$1!-"/".1N ! =5 >81:741@N =55 :9 ;84G8 8=D1 6112 >=R12 42>: =GG:P2> 42 G71=>42< >81 B=5>4>P?1I G:HL:212> :9

>81 !2>14:21? 1OL54G4>5C ;812 1OL5=4242< >8=> ?4H12@4:2N

6P> =2C :7 =55 :9 ;84G8 G=2 61 G=551? :2N =@ 21G1@@=7CN >: g1@8 :P> >81 97=H1;:7RN ;84G8 ;=@ G71=>1? L71G4@15C

>: 61 =651 >: 42G5P?1 :>817 >81:741@ =@ 211?1?EM

eP> >8=> ?:1@2V> H1=2 >8=> ;1 G=2 @4HL5C 42G5P?1 = 5:2< 54@> :9 2=H1@ =2? G5=4H >81C =71 L=7> :9 = 21;

=2? 1OL=2?1? !2>18:@1 2=H1@ 7=>817 ?7=H=>4G=55C ?49917 ;4>8 >81 G:71

>121>@ :9 !2>11H12> )81:7C 4>@159E 31 HP@> 61 G=719P5N 9:7 1O=HL51N ;4>8 F74>4G=5

+1=54@HV@ >71=>H12> :9 B:2>:5: >12?@ >: L74D451:: H=2C G=@1@N ;8=> F74>4G=5 +1=54@H G=55@

B:2>:5: B71=5 :2>:5: B?1@G74L>4D1 :2>:5: @4HL5C ?:1@ 2:> 81 ?1L>8@ :9 ;8=>

12=G>H12> 4@ =G>P=55C ?:42< A1D12 ;812 4> P@1@ >8=> >17HME ,@ '1=2 =LL7:D424G1@ :7 H1>8:?@ P@1? >: P2?17@>=2? FF ?: 2:> [P@> ?1@G7461 4>N 42@>1=?N >81C =G>P=55C 815L >:

L7:?PG1 :7 12=G> 4>EI ,2? f:82 -=;N B)81 =7 4@ 2: 5:28=> H1>8:?@ ?4@G:D17 =2? ?1L4G> 71=54>41@E

!2@>1=?N 4> 4@ >8=> >81C L=7>4G4L=>1 42 >81 12=G>H12> :9 >8:@1 71=54>41@EI ): ;84G8 '1=2 G:2G5P?1@N B3812 ;1

=55:; 9:7 >81 12=G>4D1 :7 L179:7H=>4D1 2=>P71 :9 H1>8:?@N ;1 61: P2?17@>=2? 8:; >81 P@1 :9 HP5>4L51

H1>8:?@ >: P2?17@>=2? =2 =5514L51X6P> 21>;:7R1?X:6[1G>@EI

,2? >8=> H1=2@ 2:> [P@> ?1@G74L>4D1 :6[1G>@ 6P> 71=5 :6[1G>@E

/1> 42 1D17C 1O=HL51 >8=> '1=2 L7:?PG1@ :9 F74>4G=5 +1=54@HN G5=4H42< 4> @PLL:7>@ 84@ !2>181 =P>8:7 =74L51 ?1@G74L>4D1 :6[1G>@N 2:> HP5>4L51 71=5 :6[1G>@E )4H &:7@C>8V@ B>CL:5:


9/10

3"&*#+/ "4 5#,'.*+/ 6-'"*1 +#2 7*+!,%!' 7@

!"#$%&'( #*$+&,

12D47:2H12>=5 L7:651H@NI 9:7 1O=HL51N ?4D4?1@ >8:@1 L7:651H@ 42>: 9:P7 H=[:7 :D175=LL42< G=>11 9=G>@I :7 B42@>4>P>4:2=5 9=G>@EI )81 67P>1 9=G>@ =71 [P@> @>7=49:7;=7?

1HL474G=5 B9=G>@EI 38=> =71 1O=HL51@ :9 B42@>4>P>4:2=5 9=G>@Ik .1 54@>@ B@849>42< GP5>4D=>4:2N 12D47:2H12>=5

DP5217=6454>CN =>4:2N =2>87:L:1 G8=28 @>=>1@ >8=> B12D47:2H12>=5 t67P>1

9=G>@V A:7 64:L8C@4G=5 L7:L17>41@M =71 ?4D4?1? 5:G=55C :7 8147 ?4991712G1@ =71 H=>>17@ :9 5:G=>4:2N

2:> :2>:5:CpE )81 t42@>4>P>4:2=5 9=G>@V A:7 ?1Q24>4:2@ :9 ?14:2M =71 G:2>7:551? 6C ?4@GP7@4D1

L7=G>4G1@ o4E1EN =@ 81 @=C@N t?1Q24>4:2@VpEI $4991712> ?4@GP7@4D1 L7=G>4G1@ : ?4991712> >:L4G@ =2? ?1Q24W

>4:2@ :9 ?4@GP@@4:2N 2:> >: >81 ?11L 71=54>41@ :9 >8:@1 >:L4G@ >81H@15D1@E .4@ H=[:7 G:HL5=42> =6:P> 8:; FF

4@ >71=>1? 4@ >8=> >81@1 9:P7 G155@ G:29P@1?X=2? 2:> >8=> >8171 =712V> 12:P8:?:5: = ;4?17 P2?17@>=2?42< :9 >81 *'+/HP5>4L51 :6[1G>

R2:;2 =@ FFE !2 :>817 ;:7?@N 84@ =7 4@ 5:=?1? ;4>8 @849>42< ?1@G74L>4D1 :2>:5: 2: 71=5 :2>:5:W

12?@ >: 1]P=>1 ;4>8 71=5 64:L8C@4G=5 :2>:5: ?4@=8 84@ L:42>@J !

?4@=8=> >81C @PLL:7> !2>1 =55 A2:> 42 >81 9P2?=H12>=5 @12@1 >8=>N =@

'1=2 @=C@N B(2>:5:=>P@ 4@ 12=G>1? 42 L=7> 6C >81 H1=2@ :9 42>17=G>42< ;4>8 4>IX;8171 B12=G>1?I H1=2@

BG:WG71=>1?IME

,2? ! G:2@>=2>5C Q2? >8=> ;4>8 F74>4G=5 +1=54@H 42 81 L5P7=54>41@ 4> =GR2:;51?8=> =7112=G>1? A:7 ;8:@1 :2>:5:P=55C ?1L12? 42 L=7> :2 >8147 1L4@>1H:5:12? >: 61 5=74D1

:2>:5: 71=5 :2>:5:12? >: 61 ?1Q21? 6C @G412G1 =2? @G412G1 =5:21N 81 ;=C

6=GR >: 0=75 K:LL17ME ":7 ?:1@ F74>4G=5 +1=54@H 61541D=65C 42>11 >81 D=74:P@ R2:;51? =GW

R2:;51?1@ F=7:5=2N ;8: 42 84@ 1O=HL51@ :9 HP5>4L51 :6[1G>@ @=C@N B!2 :>817 ;:7?@N >81 :6[1G>

G8=287:P7=2@5=>4:2N 6P> >81 A@P6M@>7PG>P71 ?:1@ 2:>EI '1=2 L:42>@ :P> >8=> F=7:5=2 =774D1@ => >84@

G:2G5P@4:2 6C =2=5CZ42< >;: =O1@ AO v G:HL51O4>C =2? C v 1L4@>1H:5:=2G1ME '1=2 =8 F=7:W5=2V@ G:2G5P@4:2@N >812 @=C@N B! 8=D1 =??1? = >847? o=O4@p >8=> 71L71@12>@ H1>8:?:5:CI ALE _uTME !9

F=7:5=2 8=? ?:21 >81 @=H1N 81 H4 71=54Z1 >8=> @:H1 9:7H@ :9 >7=2@5=>4:2 =G>P=55C G8=281 A@P6M@>7PG>P71

:9 >81 :6[1G> =@ ;155X=2? ,-+,%& $ *'+/G8=2@ 4>M 6C >81 .:;N =2? 2:> H1715C = ?1@G74L>4D15C ?4991712> :6[1G>E F=7:5=2N 42 :>817 ;:7?@N 4@ 2:> @PLL:7>42817 = ?1@G74L>4D1 L5P7=54@HME (7=27PG>P71@ 5::R => =>:H4G 71=54>41@

42 42G71?465C ?4991712> ;=C@ >8=2 >P7]P:4@1 @>7PG>P71@ 5::R => >81HX2:> [P@> ?4991712> ?1@G74L>4D1 :2>:5: A@P6M@>7PG>P71@ =@ ;155X71=5 :2>:5:842< >8=> F=7:5=2 4@ @=C4242< :P> 4> ?:1@ 2:> @PLL:7> = >7P5C !2>1H12>E

'1=2 6742 7=4@1? 6C e74=2 %??CN 2=H15CN >8=> 42 =??4>4:2 >: 38: O .:; O 38=> ;1 G=2

=?? B38171I =2? B3812NI =2? >84@ 4@ 1@L1G4=55C 4HL:7>=2> 42 G:2>1O>P=54Z42< >81 R2:;51?: L:42> :P> >8=> 42 !2>1 8:P> @=C42< >8=> >81 @P6[1G> A>81 38:M >8=> 4@

?:42< >81 AHP5>4L51M H1>8:?:5:81 AHP5>4L51M :6[1G> 4@ =5;=C@ =571=?C 9P55C G:2>1O>P=54Z1? D4@WwWD4@ >81

-:;17W-19> ]P=?7=2> A;84G8 4HL54G4>5C :7 1OL54G4>5C 42G5P?1@ = B38171I =2? = B3812IME eP> 4> 4@ G17>=425C

:R=C >: H=R1 >8=> 1OL54G4> 6C =??42< 4> >: >81 0:@H4G =??71@@E

&42=55CN '1=2 ]P:>1@ = L17@:2=5 G:HHP24G=>4:2 97:H U=7R %?;=7?@N ;8:@1 ;:7R ! =?H471N @>=>428=> !2>1: @L12? H:71 >4H1 @>=>42< 8:; 4> =774D1? => 4>@ :;2 0:@H4G =??71@@N 6P> %?;=7?@

R2:;@ !2>1 ?: 4>E B": :21 @C@>1H 4@ PL >: >84@ >=@RE .12G1 >81 P5>4H=>15C 42=?1]P=>1 2=>P71

:9 =55 H=4542< @C@>1H@EI eP> !2>1=>1? >84@ =@ >81 B!(j >121>IXB1D17C @C@>1H 4@

14>817 42G:HL51>1 :7 P2G17>=42NI =2? >8=> ?1Q24>15C 42G5P?1@ !2>1 !2>1817


10/10

7A 3"&*#+/ "4 5#,'.*+/ 6-'"*1 +#2 7*+!,%!'

!" $%&'()

G5=4H@ >8=> B%HL>421@@ 71?11H@ =55 !(j@EI )8=> 4@N >81 715=>4D1 ;:75? 4@ 9:71D17 42G:HL51>1 :7 P2G17>=42J :25C

P5>4H=>1 R2:;51?4G =;=7121@@XG=2

?4@G5:@1 P5>4H=>1 71=54>C A'L474> :7 %HL>421@@ME )8=> 71=54>C 4@ 71=5J 4> 4@ P5>4H=>1J 4> 4@ P2]P=54Q=651 A42G5P?428=> G5=4HMJ 6P> 4> G=2 61 BR2:;2I 42 = G17>=42 @12@1 D4= %25412H12> :7 ,;=R1242< A4E1EN @=>:74N @=8=[=N

H1>=2:4=N 1@ => >81 G12>17 :9 4>@ 97=H1;:7RE )81 :25C D=5P1

:9 = @>=>1H12> @PG8 =@ %?;=7?@VX49 4>V@ 2:> >: 61 H1715C = :21WPLH=2@84L H:D1X4@ >: 71H42? P@ >: @>=>1

=@ 9P55C =@ L:@@4651 =55 :9 >81 L5P7=54>41@ >8=> : =2C @C@>1H :7 ?1G4@4:2 >8=> ;1 H=R1 AR2:;42< 4> ;455 61

P5>4H=>15C 42=?1]P=>1N 6P> ;455 H=R1 4> H:71 ;8:51 >8=2 >81 :L>4:2@MX=2? >8=> 4@ >81 :21 9:P2?42< =2? H:@>

9P2?=H12>=5 >121> :9 !2>1

Documents

JITP_7(4)_Wilber.pdf