16
Commentaries On the Founding of the Journal of Macromarketing Shelby D. Hunt 1 Abstract This article chronicles the events leading to the founding of the Journal of Macromarketing, including (1) the first Macro-Marketing Seminar, which was organized by Charles C. ‘‘Chuck’’ Slater and held the University of Colorado at Boulder in 1976, (2) the subsequent Macro-Marketing Seminars of 1977 to 1979, (3) the formation of the Macro-Marketing Editorial Advisory Board in 1978, and (4) a meeting of the Advisory Board on August 9, 1979, at the Broker Inn in Boulder, Colorado. The article represents the author’s personal account. Accordingly, it relies on personal recollections of the events and some documents that were retained in an old manila folder. Keywords Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater, Macro-Marketing Seminar Volume 1, Issue 1, of the Journal of Macromarketing (JMM) appeared in the spring of 1981. With its founding, the study of macromarketing became institutionalized as a part of the marketing discipline. As JMM enters its fourth decade, it is appropriate to consider the events leading to its founding. These events include, most prominently, (1) the first Macro-Marketing Seminar, which was organized by Charles C. ‘‘Chuck’’ Slater and held the University of Colorado at Boulder in 1976, (2) the subsequent Macro-Marketing Seminars of 1977 to 1979, (3) the formation of the Macro-Marketing Editorial Advisory Board in 1978, and (4) a meeting of the Advisory Board on August 9, 1979, at the Broker Inn in Boulder, Colorado. This article chronicles these events from the perspective of one who attended the first Macro-Marketing Seminar (and eleven of the first fourteen seminars), has served continuously on the Macro- Marketing, Editorial Advisory Board since its inception, and participated in the discussions that led to JMM’s founding. I emphasize that what follows is my personal account of the events that led to JMM’s founding, as I experienced them. Accordingly, I rely on my recollections of the events, the proceedings of the 1976–1979 Seminars, and some documents I–quite fortuitously–retained in an old manila folder. One par- ticipant’s account, of course, tells only one part of the story, but at least this part of the story is a step toward understanding how the Journal of Macromarketing, now considered a major pub- lishing outlet for marketing scholars, came to be. 1 I begin with my experiences at the first Macro-Marketing Seminar, held in Boulder at the University of Colorado in August of 1976. The First Macro-Marketing Seminar On Sunday, August 8, 1976, I returned home from the Market- ing Educators’ Conference, which that year had been held in Memphis, Tennessee. My wife, Suzanne, told me that a professor Charles C. Slater at the University of Colorado had called and asked me to call him back concerning a conference on macro-marketing that was going to be held in Boulder, August 15–18, only one week later. ‘‘Chuck,’’ she said, had just read my article, ‘‘The Nature and Scope of Marketing’’ (Hunt 1976), which had detailed the distinction between micro- marketing and macro-marketing in a model of marketing, which would later be called the ‘‘three dichotomies model.’’ She indicated that Chuck believed the model was relevant to the conference, and he wanted to invite me to attend. Tired of conferences as I was, I returned Chuck’s call with the belief that I would decline his invitation. However, he stressed his interest in my model and how he thought discus- sions of it would contribute significantly to the conference. He then said he was sure that I would find interesting the papers that would be presented, and he mentioned those of participants such as Rick Bagozzi, Bob Bartels, Pete Bucklin, Ralph Day, Ben Enis, Mike Etgar, George Fisk, Ken Uhl, and John Wish. He made his macro-marketing conference sound so interesting that the next day I made plane reservations for Denver. As all those who knew Chuck Slater will attest, he could be very persuasive. 2 1 Jerry S. Rawls College of Business Administration, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX, USA Corresponding Author: Shelby D. Hunt, Department of Marketing, Jerry S. Rawls College of Business Administration, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX, USA Email: [email protected] Journal of Macromarketing 31(2) 199-214 ª The Author(s) 2011 Reprints and permission: sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav DOI: 10.1177/0276146710383283 http://jmk.sagepub.com 199

Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

Commentaries

On the Founding of the Journalof Macromarketing

Shelby D. Hunt1

AbstractThis article chronicles the events leading to the founding of the Journal of Macromarketing, including (1) the first Macro-MarketingSeminar, which was organized by Charles C. ‘‘Chuck’’ Slater and held the University of Colorado at Boulder in 1976, (2) thesubsequent Macro-Marketing Seminars of 1977 to 1979, (3) the formation of the Macro-Marketing Editorial Advisory Board in1978, and (4) a meeting of the Advisory Board on August 9, 1979, at the Broker Inn in Boulder, Colorado. The article representsthe author’s personal account. Accordingly, it relies on personal recollections of the events and some documents that wereretained in an old manila folder.

KeywordsJournal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater, Macro-Marketing Seminar

Volume 1, Issue 1, of the Journal of Macromarketing (JMM)

appeared in the spring of 1981. With its founding, the study

of macromarketing became institutionalized as a part of the

marketing discipline. As JMM enters its fourth decade, it is

appropriate to consider the events leading to its founding. These

events include, most prominently, (1) the first Macro-Marketing

Seminar, which was organized by Charles C. ‘‘Chuck’’ Slater

and held the University of Colorado at Boulder in 1976, (2) the

subsequent Macro-Marketing Seminars of 1977 to 1979, (3) the

formation of the Macro-Marketing Editorial Advisory Board in

1978, and (4) a meeting of the Advisory Board on August 9,

1979, at the Broker Inn in Boulder, Colorado. This article

chronicles these events from the perspective of one who attended

the first Macro-Marketing Seminar (and eleven of the first

fourteen seminars), has served continuously on the Macro-

Marketing, Editorial Advisory Board since its inception, and

participated in the discussions that led to JMM’s founding.

I emphasize that what follows is my personal account of the

events that led to JMM’s founding, as I experienced them.

Accordingly, I rely on my recollections of the events, the

proceedings of the 1976–1979 Seminars, and some documents

I–quite fortuitously–retained in an old manila folder. One par-

ticipant’s account, of course, tells only one part of the story, but

at least this part of the story is a step toward understanding how

the Journal of Macromarketing, now considered a major pub-

lishing outlet for marketing scholars, came to be.1 I begin with

my experiences at the first Macro-Marketing Seminar, held in

Boulder at the University of Colorado in August of 1976.

The First Macro-Marketing Seminar

On Sunday, August 8, 1976, I returned home from the Market-

ing Educators’ Conference, which that year had been held

in Memphis, Tennessee. My wife, Suzanne, told me that a

professor Charles C. Slater at the University of Colorado had

called and asked me to call him back concerning a conference

on macro-marketing that was going to be held in Boulder,

August 15–18, only one week later. ‘‘Chuck,’’ she said, had just

read my article, ‘‘The Nature and Scope of Marketing’’ (Hunt

1976), which had detailed the distinction between micro-

marketing and macro-marketing in a model of marketing,

which would later be called the ‘‘three dichotomies model.’’

She indicated that Chuck believed the model was relevant to

the conference, and he wanted to invite me to attend.

Tired of conferences as I was, I returned Chuck’s call with

the belief that I would decline his invitation. However, he

stressed his interest in my model and how he thought discus-

sions of it would contribute significantly to the conference.

He then said he was sure that I would find interesting the

papers that would be presented, and he mentioned those of

participants such as Rick Bagozzi, Bob Bartels, Pete Bucklin,

Ralph Day, Ben Enis, Mike Etgar, George Fisk, Ken Uhl, and

John Wish. He made his macro-marketing conference sound

so interesting that the next day I made plane reservations for

Denver. As all those who knew Chuck Slater will attest, he

could be very persuasive.2

1 Jerry S. Rawls College of Business Administration, Texas Tech University,

Lubbock, TX, USA

Corresponding Author:

Shelby D. Hunt, Department of Marketing, Jerry S. Rawls College of Business

Administration, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX, USA

Email: [email protected]

Journal of Macromarketing31(2) 199-214ª The Author(s) 2011Reprints and permission:sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.navDOI: 10.1177/0276146710383283http://jmk.sagepub.com

199

Page 2: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

The first macro-marketing seminar, chaired by Chuck Slater

and held at the University of Colorado at Boulder, included

thirty participants, with one from Mexico (Irma Sanchex

Bretherton) and one from Israel (Jehiel Zif). Sixteen invited

papers were presented. The proceedings, Distributive Pro-

cesses from a Societal Perspective, was edited by Chuck Slater

and published by Colorado’s Business Research Division,

under the guidance of Charles R. ‘‘Chuck’’ Goeldner.

On arriving at the conference, I noted that all participants

were attending all the sessions. Furthermore, all the sessions

contained free-wheeling discussions of a broad range of topics,

from macro-marketing theory (Bagozzi 1977) and Alderson’s

works (Blair and Uhl 1977), to consumerism (Day 1977), eco-

nomic development (Bartels 1977), and education (Wish

1977). In addition, throughout the entire conference, there

was a spirited discussion going on as to how to define

macro-marketing, and much of the discussion focused on the

deficiencies of the approach taken in Hunt (1976, 20), which

defined macro-marketing as being ‘‘based on the level of

aggregation . . . usually marketing systems or groups of con-

sumers.’’ For example, as a contrast to Hunt (1976), Slater

(1977, 2) proposed that macro-marketing is distinguished

from micro-marketing on the basis that the former is ‘‘from

societal perspectives,’’ while the latter is ‘‘from the perspec-

tive of the firm.’’

I found the papers delivered at the conference to be inter-

esting, the discussions of the papers to be thoughtful and con-

structive, and the entire conference to be much more

intellectually stimulating than most marketing conferences.

After the conference, Chuck Slater asked me to write a short

paper on how macro-marketing should be defined, based on

the group’s discussions of the three dichotomies model.

I titled the paper ‘‘The Three Dichotomies Model of Marketing:

An Elaboration of Issues,’’ and Chuck included it in the

proceedings (Hunt 1977). The paper’s conclusion was that

‘‘Macro-marketing refers to the study of (1) marketing systems,

(2) the impact and consequences of marketing systems on society,

and (3) the impact and consequences of society on marketing

systems’’ (Hunt 1977, 56).

At the first macro-marketing conference, I recall no discus-

sions on developing a new journal to focus on macro-marketing

issues. However, many participants urged Chuck to organize a

follow-up conference the next year, which he did.

The Second Macro-Marketing Seminar

The second Macro-Marketing Seminar was held at the Univer-

sity of Colorado at Boulder, August 14–17, 1977. As was the

first, the dates for the conference, just one week after the Amer-

ican Marketing Association (AMA) Educators’ Conference,

were set for the purpose of encouraging non-American market-

ing academics who attended the AMA Conference to also

attend the Seminar. Chuck hoped that non-Americans would

consider it a ‘‘package deal.’’ The conference was chaired by

Phillip D. White and Chuck Slater, and it included thirty-

seven participants, with one from Mexico (Irma Sanchex

Bretherton), one from Norway (Johan Arndt), and two from

Israel (Michael Etgar and Arieh Goldman).

Twenty three papers were presented, and, borrowing the

subtitle that I used in my contribution to the first conference,

the proceedings carried the title Distributive Processes from a

Societal Perspective: An Elaboration of Issues. In the ‘‘Intro-

duction,’’ Phil White and Chuck Slater (1978, 1) discussed

the 1976 Macro-Marketing Seminar and pointed out that the

‘‘purpose of [the] first Seminar was to clarify and identify the

boundaries of macro-marketing.’’ Furthermore, they indicated

that the first Seminar ‘‘produced lively debate and a consen-

sus that expanding the understanding of marketing problems

from a societal perspective is a worthwhile goal.’’ Of the

twenty-three papers, five explored macro-marketing defini-

tional and conceptual issues, four focused on ‘‘tools,’’ four

related to economic development, and ten addressed a variety

of other topics and issues.

Because of personal reasons, I was unable to attend the 1977

Seminar. However, I was briefed on it by several attendees. It is

my understanding that preliminary discussions took place con-

cerning the possibility of starting a new journal that would

focus on macro-marketing issues. In addition, shortly after the

1977 Seminar, George Fisk contacted me, told me how great

the conference had been, and strongly encourage me to attend

the third seminar. After I agreed, he then proceeded to recruit

me as a track chair.

The Third Macro-Marketing Seminar

The third Macro-Marketing Seminar was held at the W. Alton

Jones Conference Center of the University of Rhode Island,

August 13–16, 1978. George Fisk and Robert Nason served

as both chairs and proceedings’ editors. Hiram Barksdale, Ed

Bursk, Bob Nason, and I served as track chairs. Conference

participants numbered thirty-two, with five non-American

academics, including one from Norway (Johan Arndt), one

from Israel (Dov Izraeli), and three from Canada (J. Allison

Barnhill, Rajeswararao Chaganti, and Stan Shapiro). The con-

ference was becoming more international. The proceedings

carried the title Macro-Marketing: New Steps on the Learning

Curve, and it contained twenty-five papers. As before, it was

published by Colorado.

Throughout the conference, there were numerous discus-

sions among many participants concerning the need for a jour-

nal outlet for macro-marketing research and the possibility of

developing such a journal. On the morning of August 16, there

was a plenary session held on the topic of starting a new jour-

nal. No one, as I recall, specifically opposed the development

of a new journal, but there were several, well-informed faculty

who warned the group of the great difficulties of starting a new

journal. They pointed out that the academic marketplace is lit-

tered with failed journals. I joined with others who were

strongly urging the group to initiate a new journal devoted to

macro-marketing. Ultimately, this view prevailed.

At the plenary session, there was a consensus on the follow-

ing six actions. First, the group agreed to support a new journal,

200 Journal of Macromarketing 31(2)

200

Page 3: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

the Journal of Macro-Marketing. (In 1978, everyone still

retained the dash between macro and marketing. Only later did

the dash disappear.) Second, Chuck Slater was unanimously

invited to be the first editor of the journal, a position that he

accepted. Third, the Business Research Division of the Univer-

sity of Colorado at Boulder was asked to publish the Journal.

Chuck Goeldner, on behalf of the University of Colorado, con-

ditionally accepted the invitation (pending further details).

Fourth, a Macro-Marketing Editorial Advisory Board was

formed to develop the Journal’s policy. The Advisory Board

was comprised of Johan Arndt, Hiram C. Barksdale, Edward

C. Bursk, James M. Carman, George Fisk, Robert W. Nason,

Stanley J. Shapiro, Donald L. Shawver, Phillip D. White, and

me. Fifth, all members of the Advisory Board were asked to

approach their universities to determine whether they would

participate as sponsors of the Journal. Sixth, the Macro-

Marketing Seminar would return to the University of Colorado

at Boulder in 1979.

After the Third Macro-Marketing Seminar

It is fair to say that all participants of the 1978 Seminar left it in

good spirits. I know that I did. I believed strongly in the new

Journal, and I had great confidence in Chuck Slater as the first

editor, the University of Colorado as the publisher, and the

other members of the Editorial Advisory Board. As I had

agreed, I contacted Wisconsin’s Dean Robert H. Bock on

August 24, 1978, to advise him that we were attempting to

develop the Journal of Macro-Marketing. I asked him

if Wisconsin would agree to subsidize the expenses of the

Journal in its first few years. See Appendix A for a copy—

complete with white-out—of the letter I wrote. Readers should

note that I use ‘‘unanimously’’ on line 3, but ‘‘concensus’’ (sic)

on line 7. Although my spelling was inaccurate, I attempted to

portray accurately the results of the discussions. Sometime in

early October, I met with Dean Bock to discuss my August

24 letter. I then wrote a letter on October 11 to Chuck Slater.

In it, I reported that Dean Bock was positive to the idea of

participating in the Journal, but he had questions concerning the

amount of the subsidy that would be required, among other

things. See Appendix B for a copy of the letter I wrote to Chuck.

Chuck Slater never had the opportunity to respond to my

October letter. At only fifty-four years of age, he passed away

on November 7, 1978. With his passing, many of us believed

that our hopes for the Journal of Macro-Marketing had also

passed. We were wrong.

The Fourth Macro-Marketing Seminar

As we had planned in Rhode Island, the fourth Macro-

Marketing Seminar was held at the University of Colorado at

Boulder, August 9–12, 1979. It was chaired by George Fisk,

Robert W. Nason, and Phillip D. White. Hy Barksdale, Bob

Nason, Stan Shapiro, and I served as track chairs. The confer-

ence included forty-six participants, who presented twenty-five

papers. Attendance of non-American scholars was the highest

yet, with two from Australia, six from Canada, one from

Israel, and two from Norway. The Macro-Marketing Seminar,

as we had hoped, was becoming truly international. The chairs

edited the proceedings, entitled Macromarketing: Evolution

of Thought.

Two months prior to the conference, members of the

Advisory Board received a letter, dated June 5, from George

Fisk and Phil White, on Syracuse University letterhead. Appen-

dix C contains the letter. (Note that, though Phillip White is

coauthor, his name is misspelled.) The letter raised several

issues for the Board to consider at the 1979 Seminar, including,

most prominently, whether ‘‘a Macromarketing Journal should

be launched in view of foreseeable personal commitments,

revenues and costs?’’ When I received my copy of the letter,

I recalled that George had been a strong advocate of launching

the Journal, and, I wondered, would he consider (or could he

be convinced to consider) being its first editor? In addition,

I wondered, would the University of Colorado still consider

publishing the Journal in the absence of a Colorado editor? The

second question was soon answered.

A few days before the 1979 Seminar, Phil White contacted

members of the Advisory Board and alerted us that the Univer-

sity of Colorado at Boulder would have a proposal to be pre-

sented to the Board at the Seminar. As he indicated, the

proposal would detail the conditions under which Colorado’s

Business Research Division would publish the Journal. Phil

advised us that he had made reservations for a dinner meeting

at the Broker Inn for August 9, after the reception. The dinner

would be, as he put it, ‘‘Dutch treat.’’ Prior to the 1979 Semi-

nar, Ed Bursk had resigned from the Board. As I recall, all other

members of the 1978 Advisory Board attended the meeting,

including two new members, Charles R. Goeldner and Edward

W. Cundiff.

At the dinner meeting, Phil White and Chuck Goeldner pre-

sented Colorado’s proposal, which is attached as Appendix D.

The proposal discussed many issues, including Colorado’s view

of the desirability of a Journal of Macro-Marketing and how

Colorado could contribute. Specifically, the proposal indicated

that Colorado would, for a period of three years, compose, print,

mail, handle subscriptions, and promote the Journal. However,

‘‘the issue of editorship is crucial to the success of this venture

. . . [and] the issue of editorship must be solved outside the Uni-

versity of Colorado.’’3 The proposal suggested that the Journal

initially be published twice a year, but ‘‘the move to four issues

should be made in 1982 if possible but no later than 1983.’’4 The

Board reviewed Colorado’s proposal, agreed that their proposal

was very reasonable, and unanimously accepted it. We then

turned to the issue of finding an editor.

We began discussing who we could get to be editor, and it

became clear that it would be best if one of the Advisory Board

members could be induced to accept the position. Quite

frankly, I could have supported any of them. However,

I favored George Fisk because of his experience and his strong

commitment to advancing scholarship on macro-marketing.

Discussion revealed that several Board members would not

accept the position, for a variety of reasons. Others seemed

Hunt 201

201

Page 4: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

unsure. We took a break. At the break, I told George that

I thought he would make an outstanding first editor, and

I encouraged him to consider it. He told me that he favored

me for the position. I responded that there were personal reasons

that absolutely prevented me from considering it. When the

meeting resumed, earnest discussion continued. At the end of the

meeting, we unanimously invited George to be the first editor of

the Journal of Macromarketing. He accepted on two conditions,

(1) the Board would provide significant editorial support and

(2) he was successful in getting Syracuse University to provide

the resources essential to carry out his responsibilities.

Readers should note that there was no established, macro-

marketing organization, association, academy, or society to

offer George Fisk the editorship position. Even the Board had

no structure not even an official chair. George pointed out the

obvious to us. He could not easily go to his dean and ask for

resources just because we had verbally asked him to be editor.

He needed something more formal. Someone suggested that

I write a letter to George on University of Wisconsin letterhead

‘‘on behalf’’ of the Macromarketing Editorial Advisory Board

to make the invitation seem, somehow, more official. Others

thought it seemed like a good idea.

On returning to Madison, I wrote an ‘‘official’’ invitation to

George to assume the position of ‘‘editor in chief,’’ which to me

sounded more prestigious than just ‘‘editor.’’ As shown in

Appendix E, I also assured him that ‘‘all members of the Board

are prepared to provide you with editorial and other assistance

to ensure the success of this venture.’’ On October 1, 1979,

I received a return letter from George, stating that ‘‘Syracuse

University has agreed to provide me the resources needed for

me to accept the position as editor of the Journal of Macromar-

keting.’’ (See Appendix F.)

The 1981 Founding of the Journal ofMacromarketing

I had promised George and the Board members that I would try

to get financial support for the Journal. In November of 1979,

I interviewed for a position at Texas Tech University, in Lub-

bock, Texas. My wife and I were impressed with Lubbock as a

family-oriented city and with the faculty in the Area of Marketing

and the College of Business Administration. In December, they

offered me a position, beginning fall semester, 1980. Suzanne and

I agreed that I should accept.

Shortly after I accepted, I approached Jim Wilcox, the Mar-

keting Area Coordinator, about Texas Tech providing support

for this new journal, the Journal of Macromarketing. (By then,

the dash had disappeared.) He agreed to discuss it with Dean

Carl Stem and Associate Dean Robert Wilkes. The three of

them agreed that it was a worthy project. In March of 1980,

Texas Tech offered to subsidize all the Journal’s copyediting

(through Texas Tech Press), in exchange for being listed as a

cosponsor on the masthead. George Fisk and Chuck Goeldner

accepted the offer.

All editors of new journals face enormous problems in

getting authors to submit manuscripts, finding competent and

prompt reviewers, and somehow finding enough acceptable

papers to fill each issue of the journal. For a lot of editors, it

often comes down to accepting those articles that their

reviewers dislike the least. George faced all these problems,

plus the fact that there were strong differences among authors

and reviewers as to what does or does not constitute macromar-

keting. These differences prompted the question: Is an article

appropriate or inappropriate for the Journal? Decisions had

to be made, and George, after getting significant feedback from

Advisory Board members, made them. Indeed, I believe he did

a masterful job of navigating the definitional/conceptual waters

that swirled about him.

In the spring of 1981, Volume 1, Issue 1, of the Journal of

Macromarketing appeared. The masthead listed George Fisk

as Editor and Charles R. Goeldner as Business and Circulation

Editor, with Robert W. Nason as Associate editor, James B.

Wilcox as Copy Supervisor, and John R. Wish as Literature

and Book Review editor. The Editorial Policy Board was

identified as Johan Arndt, Hiram C. Barksdale, Edward W.

Cundiff, Ben Enis, Shelby D. Hunt, Stanley J. Shapiro,

Donald A. Shawver, and Phillip D. White. Sponsors of the

Journal were listed as the School of Management, Syracuse

University, College of Business Administration, University

of Rhode Island, College of Business Administration, Univer-

sity of Colorado, and College of Business Administration,

Texas Tech University.

The first issue began with ‘‘An Invitation to Participate in

Affairs of the Journal of Macromarketing’’ (Fisk 1981). In it,

George discussed the ‘‘Goal and Objectives’’ of the Journal,

and he gave specific directions to potential authors as to how

they might tell if their research fit the Journal’s mission.

George’s invitation was followed by ‘‘What is Macromarket-

ing: A Colloquium (Part 1),’’ with short articles on definitions

of macromarketing proposed by Hunt (1981), Shawver and

Nickels (1981), and White (1981). My contribution to the col-

loquium was an adaptation of the paper that appeared in the

proceedings of the 1976 Seminar (Hunt 1977).

Following the ‘‘Colloquium,’’ the first issue contained arti-

cles on macromarketing philosophy (Monieson 1981), legal

problems in franchising (Nevin, Hunt, and Levas 1981), trade

flows (Layton 1981), ethics (Laczniak, Lusch, and Strang

1981), and retailing (Markin and Duncan 1981). The issue con-

cluded with the Book Review Editor inviting readers to suggest

books for review (Wish 1981), four book reviews, and abstracts

of the papers presented at the 1980 Macromarketing Seminar

held at the University of Rhode Island.

The founding of the Journal of Macromarketing in 1981

marks the beginning of the institutionalization of macromarket-

ing as a part of the marketing discipline. Thanks go to those

who saw and articulated the need for JMM, persisted with great

dedication in developing it in the face of adversity, and suc-

ceeded in bringing it forth. Well done.

202 Journal of Macromarketing 31(2)

202

Page 5: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

Appendix A

Hunt 203

203

Page 6: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

Appendix B

204 Journal of Macromarketing 31(2)

204

Page 7: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

Appendix C

Hunt 205

205

Page 8: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

206 Journal of Macromarketing 31(2)

206

Page 9: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

Appendix D

Hunt 207

207

Page 10: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

208 Journal of Macromarketing 31(2)

208

Page 11: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

Hunt 209

209

Page 12: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

210 Journal of Macromarketing 31(2)

210

Page 13: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

Appendix E

Hunt 211

211

Page 14: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

Appendix F

212 Journal of Macromarketing 31(2)

212

Page 15: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

Declaration of Conflicting Interests

The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to

the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

Funding

The author(s) received no financial support for the research, author-

ship, and/or publication of this article.

Notes

1. Why the Journal of Macromarketing has not only survived, but

prospered, is an interesting question. In a personal communication

to me, George Fisk, JMM’s first editor, attributes much of the suc-

cess of JMM to ‘‘the passion of the editorial board and staff.’’ He

believes this passion for macromarketing was stimulated by the

ideas embedded in the works of Wroe Alderson, Kenneth Bould-

ing, Reavis Cox, Ewald T. Grether, and Roland S. Vaile. For a dis-

cussion of the origins, development, current status, and possible

future directions of macromarketing, see Shapiro (2006).

2. Although Chuck Slater and I were both at Michigan State

University in the mid-1960s (he as a full professor and I as a doc-

toral student), I did not have a class from him. As I recall, we only

met on one occasion. Indeed, when I called him on August 8,

1976, he—quite understandably—was unaware that I was an

MSU graduate. See Nason (2010) and Nason and White (1981)

for more on Chuck Slater, the person, his scholarship, and his

legacy for macromarketing.

3. Phillip White, though a strong advocate of the Journal, was an

assistant professor in 1978. Thus, he was not a candidate. Chuck

Goeldner was willing to serve as publisher (through Colorado’s

Business Research Division) but not as editor.

4. As Stan Shapiro has remarked, instead of converting JMM to a

quarterly in two years (i.e., in 1983), it took us twenty-six years

to do so (i.e., in 2007).

References

Bagozzi, Richard P. 1977. Marketing at the societal level: Theoretical

issues and problems. In Distributive processes from a societal per-

spective: The proceedings of the macro-marketing seminar, ed.

Charles C. Slater, 6-51. Boulder, CO: Business Research Division,

Graduate School of Business Administration, University of Color-

ado at Boulder.

Bartels, Robert. 1977. Marketing and economic development. In

Distributive processes from a societal perspective: The proceedings

of the macro-marketing Seminar, ed. Charles C. Slater, 211-17.

Boulder, CO: Business Research Division, Graduate School of Busi-

ness Administration, University of Colorado at Boulder.

Blair, Ed, and Kenneth P. Uhl. 1977. Wroe Alderson and modern

marketing theory. In Distributive processes from a societal per-

spective: The proceedings of the macro-marketing seminar, ed.

Charles C. Slater, 66-84. Boulder, CO: Business Research Divi-

sion, Graduate School of Business Administration, University of

Colorado at Boulder.

Day, Ralph L. 1977. The macro-message of consumerism: Listen

better! In Distributive processes from a societal perspective: The

proceedings of the macro-marketing seminar, ed. Charles C.

Slater, 186-209. Boulder, CO: Business Research Division,

Graduate School of Business Administration, University of

Colorado at Boulder.

Fisk, George. 1981. An invitation to participate in affairs of the

Journal of Macromarketing. Journal of Macromarketing 1:3-6.

Hunt, Shelby D. 1976. The nature and scope of marketing. Journal of

Marketing 40:17-26.

______. 1977. The three dichotomies model of marketing: An evalua-

tion of issues. In Distributive processes from a societal perspec-

tive: The proceedings of the macro-marketing seminar, ed.

Charles C. Slater, 52-56. Boulder, CO: Business Research Divi-

sion, Graduate School of Business Administration, University of

Colorado at Boulder.

______. 1981. Macromarketing as a multidimensional concept. Jour-

nal of Macromarketing 1:7-8.

Layton, Roger A. 1981. Trade flows in macromarketing systems:

Part I, A macromodel of trade flows. Journal of Macromarketing

1:35-48.

Laczniak, Gene R., Robert F. Lusch, and William A. Strang. 1981.

Ethical marketing: Perceptions of economic goods and social pro-

grams. Journal of Macromarketing 1:49-57.

Markin, Rom J., and Calvin P. Duncan. 1981. The transformation of

retailing institutions: Beyond the wheel of retailing and life cycle

theories. Journal of Macromarketing 1:58-66.

Monieson, David D. 1981. What constitutes usable knowledge in

macromarketing? Journal of Macromarketing 1:14-22.

Nevin, John R., Shelby D. Hunt, and Michael G. Levas. 1981. Legal

remedies for deceptive and unfair practices in franchising. Journal

of Macromarketing 1:23-34.

Nason, Robert W. 2010. The legacy of Charles C. Slater. Journal of

Macromarketing 30:287-292.

Nason, Robert W., and Phillip D. White. 1981. The visions of Charles

C. Slater: Social consequences of marketing. Journal of Macro-

marketing 1:4-18.

Shapiro, Stanley J. 2006. Macromarketing: origins, development, cur-

rent status and possible future direction. European Business

Review 18:307-21.

Shawver, D. L., and W. G. Nickels. 1981. A rationalization for macro-

marketing concepts and definitions. Journal of Macromarketing

1:8-10.

Slater, Charles C. 1977. Introduction. In Distributive processes from a

societal perspective: The proceedings of the macro-marketing

seminar, ed. Charles C. Slater, 1-5. Boulder, CO: Business

Research Division, Graduate School of Business Administration,

University of Colorado at Boulder.

Slater, Charles C., and Phillip D. White. 1978. Introduction. In Distri-

butive processes from a societal perspective: The proceedings of

the macro-marketing seminar, ed. Phillip D. White and Charles

C. Slater, 1-2. Boulder, CO: Business Research Division, Graduate

School of Business Administration, University of Colorado at

Boulder.

Wish, John R. 1981. Editor’s introduction. Journal of Macromarket-

ing 1:67.

______. 1977. The great marketing game: Theory and practice applied

to post secondary education. Distributive processes from a societal

perspective: The proceedings of the macro-marketing seminar, ed.

Charles C. Slater, 285-315. Boulder, CO: Business Research

Hunt 213

213

Page 16: Journal of Macromarketing On the Founding of the Journal ...sdh.ba.ttu.edu/JMacro On the Founding of final.pdf · Journal of Macromarketing, marketing history, Charles C. Slater,

Division, Graduate School of Business Administration, University

of Colorado at Boulder.

White, Phillip D. 1981. The systems dimension in the definition of

macromarketing. Journal of Macromarketing 1:11-13.

Bio

Shelby D. Hunt is the Jerry S. Rawls and P. W. Horn Professor of

Marketing at Texas Tech University, Lubbock, Texas. A past editor

of the Journal of Marketing (1985–1987), he is the author of numerous

books, including Marketing Theory: Foundations, Controversy, Strat-

egy, Resource-Advantage Theory (M. E. Sharpe 2010) and A General

Theory of Competition: Resources, Competences, Productivity,

Economic Growth (SAGE Publications 2000). One of the 250 most

frequently cited researchers in economics and business (Thompson-

ISI), he has written numerous articles on competitive theory, strategy,

macromarketing, ethics, relationship marketing, channels of distribu-

tion, philosophy of science, and marketing theory.

214 Journal of Macromarketing 31(2)

214