Upload
mahammad-khadafi
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
1/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
Proposed Performance Management System Framework byUsing IPMS Method at Center for Pulp and Paper Ministry of
Industry
Journal: International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
Manuscript ID: Draft
Manuscript Type: Standard Paper
Keywords:Performance management, Goverment Research Institution, TOWS Matrix,IPMS Method
International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
2/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
ED EACE AAEE E AE B
ED A CEE AD AE
D
K D
B
I B, I.@..; @...
A
I I C .
I . &D
. , &D
. ,
. C,
&D I C
.
D//A I (I) ,
.
(KI)
I .
A H (AH).
.
F .
.
I
.
C I I A.
/ I C .
C I.
: , G I, , I
1.
I
. I
. C (C) (&D)
I. I 14, 1968
C ,
, , , , .
I 2010 2014
ge 1 of 16 International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
3/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
2010 2014 5 2010.
,
. , 3
, .
K I (KI)
114 2013.
F 1.
F 1. I ( , 2013)
&D &D &D
. , &D
/ . I
, &D
,
&D .
1
1. B &D D C
Page 2International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
4/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
2. B E
C
A A
I (BKII). &D
. I C
. C
,
.
. C
&D
. C
:
1. C &D ( B)
2.
3. &D
4. G &D
F ,
.
2011 2013. B 2014,
I .
F 2.
F 2. G 2011 2014
&D
20 27% 2011 2014.
&D 27,70% 2013. D
, &D 2013 2014.
F 3. &D
27,7% 20,95% 2014 (C)
. A &D ,
&D .
. C
&D
. C ,
.
(, 2006).
ge 3 of 16 International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
5/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
F 3. G C &D A
,
, . E
A
,
.
C . F
F 4, 2011 2014.
&D
&D .
F 4. G F &D A
16,67% 2011 0%
2014 &D .
I (I)
. A I
(I) .
&D &D
&D .
&D &D
.
&D .
&D
Page 4International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
6/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
&D . F 5 &D
2012, 2011 2012. B
.
&D C
. B
C, (
C).
F 5. G I
&D B
B , C
.
. C
:
1.
2.
&D
3.
4. C &D
&D
5.
C ,
6.
&D
&D .
7. &D
.
8.
&D .
C , &D . I
&D
. ,
I .
3. B
A
. C
.
ge 5 of 16 International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
7/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
B
. A (&D)
.
C , I F 6 .
Problem Diagnosis
•
Lack of approriate performance management system• Poor performance of company core competence in R&D services
• KPI isn’t inline with ministry of industry strategic plan
• Reform of bureaucracy issues
Business Solution
Designing the new Performance Management System based on
Integrated Performance Management System
Proposed Application PMS
Proposed application of Integrated Performance Management System at
Center for Pulp and Paper, Ministry of Industry, Republic of Indonesia
Collection and Processing Data
Identification external and internal Business Environment
Identify the strategic environment of company based on business
environmental analysis
Primary Data
Questionnaire and Forum Group Discussion
Secondary Data
Appropriate document such as goverment
accountability report, strategic plan report and literature
Stage 0 : Foundation
4 principles and 5 rules
Stage 1 : Basic InformationExternal and internal analysis
IPMS design
framework
Stage 2 : Design
•
Vision, mission and strategy analysis• Performance variable
• Linkage
• Benchmark
Stage 3 : Implementation
Recommendation of
framework implementation
Choose the suitable Performance Management System Framework
The choice of PMS available are IPMS, BSC, Performance Prism and SSBSC.
PMS that selected comes from company strategy analysis
Methodology for weight and scoring parameter
Analytical Hierarchy Process
Page 6International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
8/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
F 6. D C
) 0 :
. I
, I ,
2,
:
2 I
1.
, ,
/
2.
( )
3.
4.
KI
J KI
5. E
6. C
(B)
7.
8.
C
9.
,
.
) 1 : B
B
,
. I ,
(EE )
( F F ).
1) E
. : C
&D (IB
), &D ( II )
&D (A A).
. E : I &D FI , K
C I (A &D )
ge 7 of 16 International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
9/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
&D I . &D
AEA
I AEC 2015.
(IB) ,
.
.
: C
. B C
. . B B : C .
I .
I
.
. B :
, , I
. ,
.
2)
E
3 E
E E 1)
•
/
2)
E
• C
I GD
• I
AEA
2015
•
C
3)
• E
•
4)
• E
.
I 9
& 6
.
.
G
,
.
I
AEC 2015,
.
.
) 2 : D
. A
F C , :
.
B
, , .
4
K I I
Page 8International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
10/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
(B
&D )
&D .
D
&D .
E
, ,
(
, ,
)
D
.
D
. A
B C , :
, ,
,
5
K I I
(
, ,
)
C
D
( )
E
(
,
)
G
.
I
.
.
EFA IFA A
IFA EFA
. IFA
EFA 6 7.
A H (AH) .
ge 9 of 16 International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
11/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
6 IFA A C
(1 5)
()
1 &D
0,10 4 0,40
2
I 17025
I 9001
2009.
0,02 3 0,06
3 &D 80%
(AB). 0,01 3 0,03
4
I
(AKI) I
(AI) 2006
0,02 2 0,04
5 53%
23%
.
0,05 3 0,15
()
1 0,17 3 0,51
2
1986 20040,03 2 0,06
3 &D
12 : 1
0,29 4 1,16
4 70%
0,23 4 0,92
5
0,08 3 0,24
A 1 3,57
7 EFA A C
E
(1 5)
()
1 &D
KA
, I
0,12 3 0,36
2 8
.20
2010
0,11 4 0,44
3
.3
2014
0,05 2 0,10
4 B .100 2012,
0,17 4 0,68
Page 10International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
12/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
5 I .9 .6
I
0,03 2 0,06
()
1 B
() 57%
()
0,17 4 0,68
2
0,03 1 0,03
3 D
0,11 4 0,44
4 AEA E C
2015 0,17 3 0,51
5 .190 2012
C
0,04 3 0,12
A 1 3,42
B EFA IFA ,
F 7. A , C
3,42 AH . F,
,
3,57 .
F 7 D C
F , C
. G C
. I , . B
&D , C .
.
C
.
( ), C (
), C ( )
1
2
3
4
5
1 2 4 5
EFAS
I
F A S
GrowthStability
Retrenchment Diversification
CPP
3,57
3,42
ge 11 of 16 International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
13/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
C ( ). F
8, 11 .
8 C
E ()
1.
&D .
2. C
I 17025 I 9001
.
3.
80%
.
4.
.
5.
53%
23%
EAEE ()
1.
2. G
3. &D
4.
5.
E ()
1. I &D
KA
2.
8
3.
4.
C
.
5.
I .9 .6
.
()
• C &D
(5 1,4)
•
(3 1)
• &D
(1 3,5)
()
•
(1 3)
• B
(4 1)
• D
&D
(2,3 4)
EA ()
1.
2.
3. D
4. AEA
E C 2015
5. F
()
• D
(1 4, 5)
• B
(4
3,4)
()
•
(B)
(1 3)
•
(2, 4 3)
•
(5 2,5)
) 3 :
. C
, C
:
EFAS
IFAS
Page 12International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
14/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
. H
C,
: , ,
&D .
.
C . .
.
.
A
I
.
.
I
. F,
.
.
F ,
C , .
.
F C,
. E &D
,
, , , ,
, .
.
.
C
. B
,
, ,
. C
&D .
I
(I) .
.
.
. I
&D
.
.
. B
F ,
C , .
.
F
F
(B).
.
ge 13 of 16 International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
15/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
.
.
F
A &D , &D C
.
. AH (A H
) . . H AH 3 , 11
24 . ,
.
9.
9 AH
11
.
C F 8.
1 0,181
2 0,171
3 0.152
4 0,060
5 (AB) 0.0496 (BI) 0.049
7 (B) 0.049
8 0,047
9 0,039
10 0,037
11 0,030
12 I 0,022
13 0,016
14 C 0,015
15 0,015
16 0,014
17 0,010
18 0,010
19 0,00820 () 0,008
21 I (I) 0,008
22 0,005
23 0,003
24 0,003
Page 14International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
16/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
F 8 D
C
.
. G
FI (F I )
C. FI E. D &D
C FI 10.
10 &D C FI 2013
()
C
(C)
()
() . 730 . 100,8
/
1 : 4 3 : 10
() 11 189
&D
(E)
8 28
() 20 159• 10 47
• 10 112
()
17 71
() 1 6
()
1 3
()
/A 15
4.
,
, , , . A
, C 5 . D
.
C
.
.
9.
ge 15 of 16 International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
8/21/2019 Jurnal Submit Final
17/17
F o r P
e e r R
e v i e w
F 9 I
C , (2011), C 2010 2014,
I, I.
F I (FI) A , (2013), E, .
G A C , (2011), I,
I.
G A C , (2012), I,
I.
G A C , (2013), I,
I.
I 2010 2014 , (2010), I,
I.
, (2014), I &D I : I I
&D . J , 36, 148
160.
, ., H J. D., (2012), B :
G , E, E : A.
, D., (2012), H C C C : B
D, G : J, I.
, D, (2006), K : K, D D
, E : J, I.
Page 16International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management