17

K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

� ����� ����� � ������������������������ �"!��#�%$'& �(�)�+*,*,�-$/.0�1��!32)$)�,465/��87)7)*,���#�9���:�;2/�:<6!��%�=���%$><�2/�+*�?@�%$/�A<�*,�B7C�

DFEHGJIJK1EML=NPORQ;GJETS;UJEML�V�WYXZQ=[\L=N=S3GJL=]_^(Ea`bQ;GJc-]edfc-[gGihkj;Gihl`bQm/[on;GJc,hlKp[oLqh6IJr�s)`\[gGJL�ItNtclGin=QqVm)GJuMQ=ItW=v-Ea[)w6L=EMxJ[ockv-EMhyV

z�GJuaE{r|G }~S=��I�xiGpXZ`oIihlEHGZS���GJL;GJ]=G�S����tz���U��[\K�GJEMu��+�oQ;GJEH�/n=QqVZv\��I�`o[oGJL���];GJuT��`oG

�)[\V���Itc-]=vo���Eac-`oW=uaGihlEMItL�S�vk[\K1E��yn=c-ItNtL=Itv,hlEM`�K1[�hlQ=I�]�SChy�BIi����GgV�L=[ov,hlEML=N=S�hlQ�ck[o[��y]=EMK1[\L=vkEMItL;GJuCK1I�]=[ouTSItL=[�����GgV�L=[ov,hlEML=N=S3XZ`\IJhlEaGJLeXZQ=[ou{r�S�XZuMItn~[/� Gihk[oco�

Page 2: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

� ����� ����� � ������������������������ �"!��#�%$'& �(�)�+*,*,�-$/.0�1��!32)$)�,465/��87)7)*,���#�9���:�;2/�:<6!��%�=���%$><�2/�+*�?@�%$/�A<�*,�B7C�

DFEHGJItKpEaL�NPORQ;GJE��bS3UJEaLqV�WYXZQ=[oL�N���S;GJL=]e^(Ea`bQ;GJc-]edfc-[gGihkj;Gihl`bQ��

�������� ���

� L=[\v-hl[\]Z�yNJckEa] I�`o[oGJL `oEMck`oW�uHGihkEaItL"K1I�]=[ou�Eav�]�[\xt[\uaItn3[o] r Itc1hlQ=[ XZ`\IJhlEaGJL XZQ�[ouMr GJL�]GJ]��kGi`o[oLqh%v-uaItn3[J��� Q�[6L�[ov-hk[o]pK1I�]=[\u=`oItL�vkEav,hlv IJrRG��;L=[��yck[\vkItuMW�hlEMItL EaL�L=[oc KpIZ]�[ou�[\K�j3[o]=]=[\]EaL�vkEa]�[ G)`oIqGJc-vk[��yck[\vkItuMW�hlEMItL ItW�hk[oc%KpIZ]=[\u���� Q=[(EaL=L�[oc KpIZ]=[\u�`\I xJ[oc-v hkQ=[�XZ`oIJhkEHGJL1XZQ�[ouMr~GJL�]vkuMItn3[JS �(EMhkQ"G c-[ovkIJuaW�hkEaItL IJrFGJn=n=c-Ig}�EMK�G hl[�����Ke��� Q�[_IJW�hl[\cpKpI�]=[ou�EMv�hlQ=[@L=IJc-hlQq�B[ov,h� hluaGJLqhlEM`6s)`\[gGJL�K1I�]=[ou;]�[\xt[\uaItn3[o]1jqV�X�Q=[oL=N [\h�GJu�� �"!�#�#���$�Sq�(E{hlQ1G Q=Itc-Ea�\ItLqhbGJu;c-[ovkIJuaW�hkEaItLIJrFGJn=n=c-Ig}�EMK�G hl[�!&%���K_��� Q=[eW�L=E('�W=[�r [oGihlW=c-[@IJr�hkQ=[@L=[ov,hl[\]Z�yNtc-Ea] K1I�]=[\u�Eav E{hlv�W=v-[eIirhlQ�[�vk[\K1E��yn=c-ItNtL=Itv,hlEM`�Kp[\hlQ�IZ]ChkI)[�}Z`bQ;GJL�Nt[(EaL�r Itc-K�G hlEaIJL j3[\hy�B[o[\L1hlQ�[�hy��I)]=E*)R[\ck[\L�h%NJckEa]�vo�� Q=[ L=[ov,hl[\]Z�yNtc-Ea] IZ`\[gGJL�K1I�]=[\uqEav�r Itck`\[o] j�V)hkQ=[ K1ItLqhkQ=uMV)Kp[gGiL�� s � mfX+�T��ItKpn=ck[\Q=[oL=v-EMxJ[s/`o[oGJLZ� � hkK1IJvkn=Q=[\ck[ m)GihlG XZ[\h,$1�(EaL=] v,hlck[\vkveGJL=] vkW�c-r|GJ`\[ Q=[gGih�-;W�}R�.� Q=[ K1I�]=[ou�vk[oGvkW�c-r|GJ`\[/vlGJuMEaL=E{hyV EavBck[\v-hlIJck[o]�hkIChlQ�[/K1IJL�hkQ=uMVpKp[gGJL�`ouaEMK�G hlItuMItNJVt�/� Q=[FL=[ov,hl[o]��yNtc-Ea]�KpIZ]�[ouEavBEaLqhl[\NtclG hl[o]�r IJcBhy�BIPVJ[gGJc-v(GJL=]�hkQ=[)K1I�]=[\u~c-[ovkW�uMhlv�EaL�hlQ�[/vk[\`oItL=]�VJ[gGJc(GJc-[/n=c-[ovk[\Lqhl[o]_EaLhlQ�Eav%n;GJn3[oc\��� Q=[FEML=L=[\cBKpIZ]�[ou;n=c-IZ]=W�`o[ovBL=IJh ItL=u{VPuHGJc-Nt[���vk`oGJua[ `\Eack`\W=uHG hlEaIJL�r [gGihkW=ck[\vB�(Q=EM`bQGJc-[1`\ItL=vkEMv-hk[oLqh��(EMhkQ Itj�vk[oc,xiGihlEMItL=v GJL=] hkQ=Itvk[1n=ckI�]=W=`\[o]jqV hlQ=[pItW�hk[oc K1I�]=[ouTS+j�W�h�GiuavkIKpItck[/Kp[ov-Ii�yv-`gGJuM[/r [gGihkW=ck[\v6hkQ;GJL�hlQ�Itvk[�EaL�hkQ=[ IJW�hl[\c K1I�]=[ouT�

01 ���243�5����6�2 1

� Q=[ XZ`oIJhkEHGJL8XZQ�[ouMr7��X=X8$@GiL=]�Gi]��kGJ`o[\Lqh XZuMItn3[ �Gihk[oc9��X��:$@Gick[ j~IJW=L=]=[\]�jqV hlQ=[;�GJW=c-[oLqhlEaGJL1��Q;GJL=L=[\u;hlI)hlQ=[([oGJv-hoS�hkQ=[6��Itc,hlQ=[oGJv-h���Q;GiL=L=[ou;hkI�hkQ=[ ��[\v-hgSZGJL=]p]=[\[onP��Gihk[oc-vhlIphlQ=[ vkItWZhlQ<�>= EaNtW�ck[P��$��?� Q=[�XZ`oIihlEHGiL XZQ=[\uMr EMvFGij~ItWZh@��#�#A��K�uaItL=N1GJL=]�!�#&#A��K �(EM]=[JS�(EMhkQCGiL Ggxt[ockGJNt[B]=[on�hkQ�IJr�Gin=n=ckIg}ZEaK1Gihk[CB�#�K_��� Q=[Bj~IihkhlIJK�hlItn3ItNtckGJn=QqVfEav#`bQ;GJckGJ`\hk[ockEM�o[\]jqV�]=[\[onPj;GJv-EaL=v�GJL=] K1GJckNtEML;GJu�hlc-ItW=NtQ=v IJr3Ntck[oGihl[\c hlQ;GiL���%�#FK ]=[on�hkQPI xJ[oc�hkQ=[ EaL=L�[oc�v-Q=[ou{rGJL=] uaItL=NY`bQ;GJEaL�vCIJr6vkQ=GJuauMI � j;GJLD��v I�xt[\cChlQ=[�ItW�hl[\c�vkQ�[ouMr��E� Q�[�I�)~vkQ=Itc-[�j;GJL8��v IJL hlQ=[X=X r ItckK'G@L=GihlW=ckGJu j;GJc-ckEM[oc/hlI_[�}Z`bQ;GiL=Nt[�j3[\hy�B[o[\LI�`o[gGiL=Ea`PGJL�]�`\IqGJv-hlGJu ��G hl[oc-vo�P�G hl[ocFHG�IKJ�LNMPOPQ IKRO�SNT/UWVHIXLNR�SYZM[LNJ�\^]Z_�G�LZ`a\�SZb�cPdaI e/R�dafIgM[c>daO�]Z_ih�LZ`adaT*L,ji_lk�S,fmL�n�VgSNOPdoL�_�pqLZR�LZr�L�_isutZh9vwyxZz

{�| Q}LNd~`��D�K\�LNd���J�\^]�cgz S�VHIKLZRlz r�LN`(z VKL

Page 3: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

K1GJvkv�]�Eav-hkckEMj=W�hlEMItL=v+ItL hlQ=[6X=X GJc-[(Gy)~[o`\hk[o]Pn=c-EaK1GJckEMuMVfjqV vk[oGJvkIJL;GJuau{V xiGJc,V�EaL=NfGJEMc,��vk[gG�Q=[gGihGJL=]@r ck[\vkQq��Gihl[\c -;WZ}Z[\voS~hkQ=[C��GJj~Iih/X�hlclGiEMh(ItW�hK-;I���r ckIJK hlQ=[CdfW�uMr+IJr%X�ho� ;�Gg�(ck[\L=`o[iSRGJL�]hlQ�[�vkQ�[ouMrH��j=ck[oG�� `oW=c-ck[\L�h hkQ;GihCEavfhlQ=[�`\ItLqhlEML�W=GihlEMItL IJr hkQ=[�;�GJj�clGJ]=IJc ��W=c-ck[oLqh�r c-ItK hlQ=[��[�� r ItW=L=]�uHGJL=] XZQ=[ou{r��W� Q=[ dfW=u{r3X�hkck[gGiK GJuMvkI/EML8-;W=[\L=`o[\v�hlQ=[�XZ`oIihlEHGiLPXZQ=[\uMr�EaL�]=Eac-[o`\hkuMV)x�EHGXZuMItn~[(� Gihl[\c�GJL�]�hlckGJL=vkEM[oLqh�c-EaL=NJvo���yL�Gi]=]=EMhkEaItLRSthlQ=[/X=X�GJL=]�X�� GJck[6r ck['�W�[oLqhlu{V�Gy)~[o`�hl[\]jqVpv-hlIJckKpvoS�[ov-n~[\`oEHGiuauMV�]=W=ckEML=NfhlQ=[6�(EaLqhl[\cBKpItLqhlQ=v\����hBr IJuauaI��(v�hkQ;Gih hlQ=[�IZ`\[gGJL1`oEac-`oW=uaGihlEMItLGJL=]�hk[oKpn~[\clGihkW=ck[��ivlGJuMEaL=E{hyV ]�Eav-hkckEMj=W�hlEMItL=v�IJL hkQ=[eX=X GiL=] X�� Q;Ggxt[_vkEMNtL=E*�;`gGJLqhPv-n;GihlEaGJuGJL=]�hk[oKpn~ItckGJuRxiGJc-EHGJj=EMuaE{hyVpGih xiGJckEMItW=v�hlEMK1[/GJL=]_ua[oL�NJhlQ@vk`oGJua[\vo�

70°W 60°W 50°W 40°W 30°W

40°N

50°N

60°N

(a) Outer Model

400

400

400

300

300

300

300

200

200

200

200

100

100

5000

40003000

3000

2000

2000

2000

1000

NewfoundlandShelf

66°W 64°W 62°W 60°W 58°W

42°N

44°N

46°N

(b) Inner Model

400350300250 200150

150

150

100

100100

100

100

50

50

40003000

2000

1000

Laurentian Channel

Gulf of St. Lawrence Cabot Strait

Sable Island BankEmerald Basin

Banquerau

LaHaveBank

Northeast Channel

������ ����������������������� �"!$#%�&�����' ��&(*)+�"���'�",.-/��01���'�$2������� ���243'�&5�3�2��.�6�",726#������$,�26 ����8)9�&(��;:���5"�6,8���"!< !=�&�6,?>@�6,'3A-CBD09�����7�E,',��� ���2�3��&5?3�2��.�6�E,F26#����'�HG�!=26���"�6,IG����&5#;�6,J3KG�526L1�NMA������ &O

!

Page 4: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

s/`o[gGiL `oEMck`oW�uHGihkEaItL@KpIZ]=[\uav�GJck[ W=vk[�r W=u�hlI�Ituav(r Itc6W=L=]=[\ckv-hlGJL=]=EML=N�GJL�]Y[\xJ[oLqhlW=GJuau{VYn=c-[��]=EM`\hlEML=N�`\Eack`\W=uHG hlEaIJL�I�xt[\c(hkQ=[)vkQ�[ouMr#v-[gGJv\��X�EaNtL=E*�;`gGiL�h�[)~Itc-h Q=GJv j~[\[oL_K�Gi]=[/I�xt[\c�hlQ=[)uaGJv-hhy�B[oLqhyV VJ[gGJc-v EaL ]�[\xt[\uaItn�EaL=N L�W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW�uHGihkEaItL K1I�]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[�X=XGiL=] X���SclGiL=NtEaL�N�r ckItK hy�BIi��]=EaKp[oL=v-EaItL=GJu�j;GJc-IJhlc-Itn=EM`)K1I�]=[ouMv�hlIpvkItn�Q=Eav,hlEa`oGihl[\]_hkQ=ck[\[���]=EaKp[oL=v-EaItL=GJuKpIZ]=[\uav���d)ck[o[\L�j~[\ckN=S��^B��t����� c-EaNtQqh�[�h6GJu��{S3��B�������zFGJL�L;GJQ�[\h6Giu��{S~��B�B����=z�GJL�[\h6Giu��{S~��B�Bi���� Q=ItKpn=v-ItL GiL=]�XZQ�[oL=N=SB��B&Bi��� XZQ=[\L=NY[�h�Giu��{SW!y#&#���$����eIJv-h IJr�hkQ=[ov-[�KpIZ]=[\uavfQ;Ggxt[1Gec-[��NtEMItL;GJuZvkQ=[\uMr~]=ItK1GJEaL��(E{hlQ1Gfv-n~[\`oE*�;`gGihkEaItLPIJr3hlQ�[(hkclGJL�vkn3Itc-hBGJL=] ��Gihl[\cBK1GJv-v ]=Eav,hlckEMj=W�hkEaItLGih6hlQ=[�KpIZ]=[\u�Itn~[\LYj3ItW=L=]=GJckEM[ovo��XZEML=`o[�hlQ=[�n=QqV�vkEM`gGJu#n=ckI�`o[\vkv-[ovfGy)~[o`�hlEaL�N1`\Eack`\W=uHG hlEaIJLeItLhlQ�[)X=X�GJL�]@X�� Itn3[oclG hl[FI�xJ[oc(G �(EM]=[FckGJL=Nt[�IJr�hl[\K1n3ItclGiu~GiL=]�vkn;G hlEHGiu3v-`gGJuM[ov\S�hlICr W�uauMVPc-[��vkIJuMxt[�GJuMu�hlQ=[\vk[�]=E�)~[oc-[oLqh�v-`gGJuM[ovBW=vkEML=NCG�vkEML=Ntua[��yNtc-Ea] KpIZ]�[ou;Eav Gfr ItckKpEa];Gij=ua[�hlGJvX��� =;Itc GJLqVvkEML=NtuM[��yNJckEa]pL�W=Kp[ockEM`gGJu3KpIZ]=[\u�S�ItL=[FEav�W�vkW;GJuMuMVPr|GJ`\[o]��(EMhkQ@GC`bQ=ItEM`o[/j3[\hy�B[o[\LYG uHGJc-Nt[���vk`gGiua[vkEMK�W=uaGihlEMItL�Gih GPc-[ouaGihlE{xt[ou{V�`\IqGJc-vk[fck[\vkItuMW�hlEMItL�S�IJc G uaEaKpEMhk[o]Z�yGJck[oG�v-EaK�W�uHGihkEaItL��(E{hlQ@G�xt[\c-VQ=EMNtQ�c-[ovkIJuaW�hkEaItLpEaL��(Q�Ea`bQ�GCn�ckEaIJc ��L=I��(uM[o]=Nt[FEav�c-[ '�W=EMck[o]1r ItcBn�Q�V�v-Ea`gGiuRn=c-IZ`\[ovkv-[ov(GihB��IJcX�GJuMItL=NPhlQ=[ K1I�]=[ou�Itn3[oLYj~ItW�L=];GJc-Ea[ov ��d)EaL�Eav([\h/GJu��{S���B&B��i$�� =�W�c-hlQ�[ockKpItc-[JS�EaLeuaEaKpEMhk[o]Z�yGJck[oGvkEMK�W=uaGihlEMItL=voS~hlQ=[puHGJc-Nt[���vk`oGJua[ `\Eack`\W=uHG hlEaIJL r [oGihlW�ck[ov�K�W=v,hCj3[Pvkn3[o`\E��;[\]�S�GJL�] EaLqhk[oclGi`\hlEMItL=vj3[\hy�B[o[oL_hlQ=[fuaGJckNt[fGiL=]@vkK1GJuau�v-`gGJuM[ov6GJc-[)n=ckItQ�Eaj=E{hl[o]R�

� Q=[CK1GJEMLeGi]�xiGJLqhbGJNt[ IJr GpL=[ov,hl[\]Z�yNtc-Ea]eK1I�]=[ou�EMv6hkQ;Gih6EMhFGJuauMI��(v(hkQ=[�uHGJc-Nt[���vk`gGiua[@-;I��I�xt[\cFGpuHGJc-Nt[f]=ItK1GJEaL�hlIpj3[ v-EaK�W=uaGihl[\]@j�VeGP`oIqGickvk[ ck[\vkItuMW�hlEMItL@K1I�]=[ouTS=�(Q=EauM[f`oEac-`oW=uaGihlEMItLI�xt[\c�G vkK1GJuMu6]�ItK�GiEaL EMv�v-EaK�W=uaGihl[\] Gih�G Q=EMNtQ=[oc1ck[\vkItuMW�hlEMItL jqV G vkW=j�K1I�]=[ou6hlQ;G h�Q;GJv[ov-vk[\L�hkEHGJuMuMVPhlQ�[/vlGJKp[Fn�Q�V�v-Ea`ov(GiL=]�L�W=K1[\ckEM`gGJu3v-hkckW=`�hlW=c-[fGJvBhkQ=[/`oItGJckv-[��yc-[ov-ItuaW�hkEaItL�K1I�]=[ouT�� Q=[6hy��Ii����GgV�EaLqhl[\clGJ`�hlEaIJL�j3[\hy�B[o[oL�hy�BI�]=E*)R[\ck[oLqh�K1I�]=[ou3Ntc-Ea]=v `gGJL�j~[FGJ`bQ=Ea[�xt[\]�EaL�K1GJLqV��G�V�v\� � r|GiEacku{V `\ItK1KpItL�L=[ov,hlEaL�Nehl[\`bQ=L=E�'�W�[�EavfhlI [�}Z`bQ;GJL=Nt[�EaL�r Itc-K�G hlEaIJL j~[�hy��[\[oL�hlQ=[hy�BI�NJckEa]�v�EaLPG/L;GickckI��"�oItL�[ � ]�V�L;GJKpEa`�EMLqhl[oc,r|GJ`o[^$+L=[oGJc�hlQ=[ NJckEa] EMLqhl[oc,r|GJ`o[ � [J��N=�{S��fW�ckEaQ=GJclG[\h�GJuT�MS;��B&��Bi$���� Q=[F`\IqGJc-vk[FNJckEa]PKpIZ]�[ou;xiGJckEaGJj=ua[\voSqv-W=`bQ�GJv%xt[\uaI�`oEMhyVJS�hk[oKpn~[\clGihkW=ck[iS�vlGJuMEaL=E{hyVGJL=] GJvkv-IZ`\EHGihk[o] -=WZ}Z[ovoS%Gick[pEaLqhl[\ckn3ItuHGihk[o] Gih hkQ=[�]ZVZL=GJK1EM`1EMLqhl[oc,r|GJ`o[1ItLqhlI_hlQ=[A�;L=[�Ntc-Ea]hlIYn=ckI�x�Ea]=[\vChlQ�[�hlEaKp[���]=[on3[oL�]=[oLqh�j3ItW=L�];GJc-V�`oIJL=]=EMhkEaItL�v r Itc�hlQ=[+�=L=[���NtckEM]K1I�]=[\u���� Q=[�;L=[��yNtc-Ea]�K1I�]=[ou xiGJc-EHGJj=uM[ov�GJc-[�EaLqhk[ockn3ItuaGihl[\] j;GJ`,� ItLqhkIYhlQ=[1`oIqGickvk[�NtckEM]�hlIeW=n3];Gihl[phlQ=[`oIJEaL=`\Ea]=[\L�h�`oIqGJc-vk[��yNtc-Ea]�xiGJuaW�[ov EaL�hkQ=[)L;GJc-ckI����\ItL=[i� � Q�[�K1GJEML�]=Ep`\W=uMhyV�IJr+hkQ=Eav�L=[ov,hlEaL�Nvk`bQ�[oKp[ Eav�G `oItKpn;GihkEaj=EMuaE{hyVn=c-Itj=ua[\K � [J��N=�{S K�GJv-v�`oIJL=vk[\c-xiGihlEMItL $pGih�hkQ=[ Ntc-Ea] EMLqhl[oc,r|GJ`o[��d)EaL�Eav [�hBGJu��{S=��B&B��i$��W=�W�c-hlQ�[ockKpItc-[JSthlQ�[ock[(EMv�W=L=]=[\vkEMclGJj=uM[ L�W=K1[\ckEM`gGJu=L�ItEav-[ ck[ov-W=uMhkEaL=N)r c-ItKhlQ�[e`bQ;GiL=Nt[YIirFhlQ�[eNtc-Ea] ck[\vkItuMW�hlEMItL Gih1hkQ=[_NtckEM]"EML�hk[oc,r|GJ`o[eGJL=] GJ]=]=E{hlEaIJL;GJu�];GiK1n=EML=N Eavck['�W=Eac-[o]:�P=;Ig} GJL�]��eGJvX�i[ouauTS(��B&Bi%&$�� ��hPv-Q=ItW=uM]�j~[�L�IJhl[\] hkQ;Gih hkQ=[�]�V�L;GJKpEa`�EMLqhl[oc,r|GJ`o[IJr+hlQ=EMv6L�[ov-hkEaL=Npvk`bQ�[oKp[C`gGiLej3[ `\ItL=v-Ea]=[\ck[o]YGJv�GJLeEMLqhl[oc-L;GJu�j3ItW=L=];Gic-V@IJr#hlQ=[�`oItGJckv-[��yNJckEa]KpIZ]=[\u�S�GJL�]�hlQ�[p`\IqGJc-vk[���NtckEM]�EMLqhl[oNJclGihkEaItL EavfL=Iih L�[o`o[\vkvkGJc-V�I�xt[ocfhlQ�[1v-W=j=ck[\NtEaIJL�`\I xJ[oc-[o]jqV�hlQ�[ �=L=[���NtckEM]_]�ItK�GiEaL��

� L�GiuMhl[\ckL;G hlEMxJ[�L�[ov-hkEaL=N�hl[\`bQ=L=E('�W=[F]=[\xJ[ouaIJn~[\]�j�V�s/[\V�GJL=]���Q=[oL ����B&Bi!�$%EMv hkIC[oKCj~[\]G �;L=[)NJckEa]E�|EaL�L=[oc�KpI�]=[ou $%EML=vkEM]=[)G�`oItGJckv-[)NtckEM] �|ItWZhl[oc�K1I�]=[ou $BGJL�]�W=vk[/hkQ=[)EaL=L�[oc�KpIZ]�[ouxiGJckEaGJj=uM[ov�hkI c-[on=uaGJ`o[ hkQ=[ ItW�hk[oc@K1I�]=[\u�xiGJckEaGJj=uM[ov�I�xt[\c@hkQ=[ vkW=j�ck[oNJEaItL �(Q=[\ck[ hlQ=[ hy�BINtc-Ea]=vfI�xt[\ckuHGin�� �yL`oIJK1n;GickEav-ItL �(EMhlQ IJhkQ=[oc vk`bQ=[\K1[\voS%s/[\V�GJL�]���Q=[\L� �vCL=[ov,hlEaL�NYvk`bQ�[oKp[Q;GJvfhlQ�[�GJ]ZxJGiL�hlGJNt[PIJr(GiuauaI��(EML=N@G@hy�BIi����GgV EaLqhl[\clGJ`�hlEMItL�L�IJh�ItL=uMV Gih hkQ=[pNtckEM] EMLqhl[oc,r|GJ`o[j=W�h/GJuav-I�]=EMck[\`\hlu{V@EaL=v-Ea]=[fhlQ�[C`oIJK1KpItLYv-W=j=c-[oNtEMItLe�(Q=[\ck[ChkQ=[Chy�BI�Ntc-Ea]=v6I�xt[oc-uHGJnR�H�yLYhkQ=Eav

Page 5: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

v-hkW=]�VJS=��[fr ItuauMI��8s)[�V@GJL=]Y��Q=[\L ����B&Bi!&$BGJL=]_[oK�j3[o]_G �;L=[��yNtc-Ea]@K1I�]=[\u�EaL=v-Ea]=[/GP`\IqGJc-vk[��Ntc-Ea] KpI�]=[ouT��m/E�)~[oc-[oLqh�r c-ItK s/[\V GJL=] ��Q=[\L� �v�L�[ov-hkEaL=Nhk[o`bQ=L�E('�W=[JS(�B[ W=vk[ hkQ=[ v-[oKpE{�n=c-ItNtL=Itv,hlEM`�Kp[\hkQ=IZ] ��X�Q=[oL=NC[\h Giu��{S8!y#&#������ ]=[oL�[�h GJuT�MS�!�#�#J� ��dfc-[gGihkj;Gihl`bQ�[\h�GJu��{S�!�#&#J�l$�hlI[�}Z`bQ;GiL=Nt[ EaLZr ItckK1GihlEMItL�j~[�hy��[\[oL hlQ=[�hy�BI)Ntc-Ea]=v+I xJ[oc�hkQ=[�`oIJK1KpItL�v-W=j=ck[\NtEaIJL��}� � ]=[\hlGJEauM[o]]=EMvk`oW�vkvkEMItL IJr hkQ=[ L=[\� L=[\v-hlEML=N�hl[\`bQ=L=E�'�W�[ `gGJL j3[Cr ItW=L�] EaL XZQ=[\L=N�[\h)GJu��A�P!�#&#J�l$��o$�� Q=[K1GJEaL Itj �-[\`\hkEMxt[eIJr/hkQ=Eavpv-hkW=]�V Eav hlI�]=[oKpItL=v,hlckGihl[_hlQ=[eGJ]�xiGJLqhbGiNt[eIir/hlQ=[_L=[�� L=[ov,hlEaL�Nhl[\`bQ=L=E�'�W�[)EaL�vkEMK�W=uaGihlEML=N�hkQ=[)Kp[gGJL@GJL�]�vk[gGivkItL;Giu�`oEMck`oW�uHGihkEaItL�GJL=]�hl[\K1n3[ockGihlW�ck[6� vlGJuMEaL=E{hyV]=EMv-hlc-Eaj=WZhlEaIJL=v�ItL�hlQ�[CX�`oIJhkEHGJLeXZQ=[\uMr GJL=]eGJ]��kGJ`\[oLqhFXZuaIJn~[/� Gihl[\co�

� Q=[eGJckckGJL=Nt[\K1[\L�hPIirFhlQ�Eav n;GJn3[ocPEMv1GivPr IJuauaI��(v\��� Q=[eL�[�}�hpvk[o`�hlEMItL"j�ckEa[Z-=V�c-[\x�Ea[��(vhlQ�[ I�`o[oGJLe`\Eac-`oW=uaGihlEMItL@K1I�]=[ouT�C� Q�Eav(Eav(r ItuauMI���[\]_jqVeGPn=ck[\vk[oLqhlGihlEMItLYIJr+hlQ=[�L=[���hy��Ii����GgVL=[\v-hlEML=N hl[\`bQ=L=E('�W=[fj;Givk[o]_ItL�hlQ�[)vk[oKpE{��n=ckIJNtL=Itv,hlEa`�K1[�hlQ=I�]�����[)]=Eav-`oW=v-v6hkQ=[)L=[\v-hl[\]YNtc-Ea]KpIZ]=[\u~c-[ov-W=uMhkv GJL=]�`\ItK1n=GJck[FhkQ=[oK �(EMhkQ�ck[\vkW=u{hlv�n=c-IZ]�W=`o[\]_jqV�IJhlQ=[\c�L=[\v-hlEML=NChk[o`bQ=L=E�'�W=[ov\�� Q=[@�;L;Giu�vk[o`�hlEMItLeEMv(G vkW=KpK�Gic-V�GiL=]e`\ItL=`\uaW=v-EaItL��

�A���l 1�� 6��y�i5��� 8�6�2 1 243����� Q=[(IZ`\[gGJLP`\Eack`\W=uHG hlEaIJL�K1I�]=[\u=W=vk[\]1EML hlQ=EMv v-hlW�]�V Eav�hkQ=[ hlQ=c-[o[��y]=EMK1[\L=vkEMItL;GJuZn=ckEMK1E{hlEMxJ[

[ '�W;G hlEaIJLp���yuM[\xt[\u;K1I�]=[\u8��L=I��(L�GJvB� � �Fm ��� �TXZQ=[oL�N [�h GJu��{S;��B&B��&$��W� Q�Eav KpIZ]=[\u=Q;GJv%j3[o[\LvkW�`o`o[\vkv,r W=uau{V W=v-[o]�hlIYv-hlW�]�V�xiGJc-EaItW�vCn=QqV�vkEM`gGJuBn=ckI�`o[\vkvk[\v ItLhlQ�[�vkQ�[ouMr�S EML=`ouMW=]=EML=N_�(EML=]Z�]=c-EMxt[\L�`oEMck`oW�uHGihkEaItL�I xJ[ocPGJL�EM]=[gGiuaEa�\[o]`\IqGJv,hbGJuB`gGJLqVtIJL �TXZQ=[\L=N [\hPGJuT�MS �^B&B��i$�S�L=ItL=uMEaL=[oGJc]�V�L;GJKpEa`\vFIJrBG�]=[\L=vkE{hyVq�y]=c-EMxt[\L `oIqGJv,hbGJu+`oW=c-ck[\L�h �TXZQ=[\L=N=S�!�#&#Z��$�S3hlEa]=GJu+`\Eac-`oW=uaGihlEMItLYEMLYhlQ=[d)W=uMr IJr X�ho��;�Gg�(ck[oL�`o[��>;�WY[\h)Giu��{Su!�#�#���$(GJL=]Y�(EML=]Z�y]�ckEMxJ[oLe`oEac-`oW=uaGihlEMItL_I xJ[oc)G1v-hlckGihlE*�;[o]`oItGJv-hlGJuq[oK�j=G�V�Kp[oLqh �Tm)Ggx�Ea]=v-ItLf[\h+GJuT�MSy!�#&#Z��$�� �eItv,h c-[o`\[oLqhlu{VtSJ� � �Fm ��� Q=GJv�j~[\[oL�Gin=n=uaEM[o]hlIphlQ=[f�B[ov-hk[oc-L ��GickEaj�j~[oGJL X�[gG�jqVYXZQ=[\L=N�GJL=] � GJL�NE�"!y#&#t�i$��}� Q=[CNtI�xJ[ockL�EaL=N1[ '�W;GihkEaItL=vIJr#hlQ=[fKpIZ]�[ou�`oGJL@j~[)�(ckE{hkhk[oL_EaL�vkn�Q=[oc-Ea`gGiu�`oI�Itck]=EML;Gihk[ov6GJv �� ������ ������� � � hbGiL��� �� ! � �"�# � `oItv$� �% '&(�*),+ � � .- ��/ + �� $- �10 �,��$ �� �� � � � � � hbGiL��� � � ! � �"�# � �% � ��)2+ � .- � / + .- � 0 �"!&$

�� `oItv$� � �� $& � � `\Itv$�q$ � � ! � .3 .- 0 �T�i$ �% .- ! � "�4 0 �|�l$ �5 ��1�� 5 ! ),6 5 � $- ��/ 6 �5 .- �70 �"%&$ $8 �� �� 8 ! ),6 8 � $- � / 6 $8 $- � � �i$

�(Q=[\ck[ � 09 GJL=] 3 GJc-[_hkQ=[Y[oGJv-h�� & $�S�L=Itc-hkQ �:�q$ GJL=] xt[oc,hlEM`gGJu � - $ `oIJK1n3ItL=[\L�hkv�IJr�hlQ=[xt[\uaI�`oE{hyVexJ[o`\hkItc1;� S % Eav�n=ck[\vkv-W=ck[ �|v-[o[Pj3[ouaI�� $�S�GJL=] " Eav�hlQ=[ ]=[\L=vkE{hyVt� z�[\ck[ / + GJL=] / 6�

Page 6: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

GJc-[6xJ[oc-hkEa`oGJu~[\]=]�Vpx�Eavk`\ItvkE{hyVpGJL=]�]�E�)~W=vkE{xZE{hyVP`oI�[ p`oEM[oLqhlv\S � Eav%hlQ=[/��ItckEMItuaEMv n;GJclGiK1[�hl[oc\S "�#Eav�G�ck[�r [ock[\L=`o[f]=[\L=vkE{hyVtS���GJL�] 4 Gick[FhkQ=[ �%GJc-hkQ� �v ckGJ]=EMW=v�GJL�]�NtclGgx�EMhlGihlEMItL;GJu3GJ`\`o[ouM[ockGihlEMItL�S� Eav(GJL_GJ]Zxt[o`�hlEMItLeIJn~[\clGihkItc ]=[�=L=[o]YGJv

� � ! �� `oItv$� � � � $ '& � �� `\Itv$� � � `\Itv$�q$ � � � 3 � $ .- �"�&$GJL=] )2+ GJL=] ),6 GJc-[f]=E�)~W=vkEMItL�Itn3[ockGihlItc-v(]=[�;L�[o] Giv

)�� +�� 6�� � ! ��� �`oItv�� � $& � � � +�� 6�� � $& � � � � � `\Itv$� � � +�� 6�� � � ��� � �i$

�(Q=[\ck[ � + GJL�] � 6 GJc-[pQ�ItckEM�oItLqhbGiu�[o]=]ZV x�EMvk`oIJvkEMhyV GJL=] ]=E�)~W=vkE{x�EMhyV `\IZ[ p`oEa[\LqhlvoS+ck[\vkn3[o`��hlE{xt[\uMVt�E� Q�[�K1I�]=[ou W=v-[ov hlQ=[�vkW=j=NJckEa]��yvk`oGJua[�K1E�}�EML=NYn=GJclGJKp[\hk[oc-Ea�gG hlEaIJL�IJrFXZK1GJNtIJckEaL�vX�qV�,�^B��t�i$Br Itc hkQ=[CQ=IJckEa�\ItLqhbGJu�[\]=]�V@x�Eav-`oItv-EMhyV9� � + $6GJL�]Y]=E*)RW=v-EMx�EMhyV � � 6 $�S3GJL=]ehkQ=[�vk`bQ=[\K1[\vn=c-Itn~IJvk[o]_jqV�;�GJckNJ[�[�h6GJu�� ����B&BJ�i$ r Itc�hlQ�[fxJ[oc,hlEa`oGJu�KpE{}ZEaL=NC`oI�[ p`oEM[oLqhlv / + GiL=] / 6 �

� vfKp[oLqhlEMItL=[o] EML hlQ=[PEaLqhkckI�]=W=`\hkEaItLRSRhlQ=[PL=[\v-hk[o]Z��NtckEM] KpI�]=[ouMuaEaL�N1v,VZv,hl[\K Q=GJvfG��;L=[��ck[\vkItuMW�hlEMItL@EaL=L�[oc(K1I�]=[\u�[oK�j3[o]=]�[o] EML=vkEM]=[�G1`oItGJckv-[��yc-[ov-ItuaW�hkEaItL@ItWZhl[oc6KpIZ]=[\u �P= EMNtW=c-[p��$��� Q=[��;L�[��yc-[ov-ItuaW�hkEaItL EaL=L=[\c�KpIZ]=[\u�`\I xJ[oc-vPhkQ=[@XZ`\IJhlEaGJL XZQ=[\uMr�GJL=]�v-uaItn3[�j3[\hy�B[o[\L %i���-�GJL=] �����-� GJL=]@j~[�hy��[\[oLY�&B��l��GiL=]@�l� �l��S��(EMhkQ@G�Q=ItckEM�oItLqhlGJuRc-[ovkIJuaW�hkEaItL�IJr#ItL�[)[oua[�xt[\L�hkQ]=[\Ntck[\[�EaL uaItL�NtEMhkW=]=[ �TGJj3ItW�h�� ��K+$���� Q=[�`\IqGJckv-[���ck[ov-ItuaWZhlEaIJLCItW�hk[oc+K1I�]=[ou�EMv#hkQ=[�L=IJc-hlQq�B[ov,h� hluaGJLqhlEM` s/`o[gGiL8KpIZ]�[ou/]=[�xt[\uaItn3[o] jqV8XZQ=[oL�N"[�hYGiu�� �P!�#&#���$P�(Q=Ea`bQ `oI�xt[\ckv@hlQ=[ GJc-[gGJvj3[\hy�B[o[oL �&#��-� GiL=]E��� �-� GJL=]ej~[�hy��[\[oL �&% �l� GJL=] �����l� S;�(E{hlQeG1Q=Itc-Ea�\ItLqhbGJu�c-[ovkIJuaW�hkEaItLIJr�ItL=[�hkQ=Eac-] ]�[oNtc-[o[@EaL uaIJL=NtEMhkW=]=[ �|GJj3ItW�h !&%���K�$�� � Q=[\ck[eGJck[_����W=L�[\xt[\L=uMV v-n;GJ`\[o] �ua[�xt[\uav)EaL j3IJhlQ hkQ=[PItW�hl[\c�GJL=] EaL=L=[\c)K1I�]=[\uav/�(EMhkQ hlQ=[P`o[\Lqhl[oc-v Iir�[oGJ`bQ uM[\xt[\u uaI�`gGihk[o] Gih%ZS�� ��S}!yB�S��t��S ���tS �&#�S���#i!ZS���!���S���%&�ZS6��B��JS}!&!�BZS}!&�J�ZS��i!i��S����J��S��l%y#�S}%&!��ZS �Z��%ZS}�����ZS�t�t�ZS/B��i�ZS �t��!Z�tS���!yBi�ZS ��%�#�#�S ���J�t�ZS�!�#&#&#�S4!J�&#i�ZS�! �i%�B�S��&#��t��S��i%&! ��S��i#��Z�tS�GJL=] � �i�J��K_Sck[\vkn3[o`�hlEMxJ[ou{Vt�%��IJhkQ�hlQ�[FItW�hk[oc�GJL=]�EML=L=[\c�KpIZ]=[\uav GJc-[FEaL�EMhlEaGJuaEM�o[\]��(EMhlQphlQ=[)UtGJL�W;GJc-VpKp[gGJLhl[\K1n3[ockGihlW�ck[)GJL�]_vkGJuaEML=EMhyV1GJL�]@r IJck`o[\]@j�V1hlQ=[)KpItLqhlQ�uMV1K1[oGJL_� s � mfX �T��ItKpn=ck[\Q=[oL=v-EMxJ[s/`o[oGJLZ� � hkK1IJvkn=Q=[\ck[ m)GihlG XZ[\h,$1�(EaL=] v,hlck[\vkveGJL=] vkW�c-r|GJ`\[ Q=[gGih�-;W�}R�.� Q=[ K1I�]=[ou�vk[oGvkW�c-r|GJ`\[CvlGiuaEaL�EMhyV@Eav6ck[\v-hkItck[\] hlI�hkQ=[CKpItLqhlQ=u{V@K1[oGJL `\uaEaK1GihkItuaItNiV�GihF[\xJ[oc-VehlEMK1[fv-hk[on��H�yLGJ]=]�EMhlEMItL�S Gih�hlQ�[�EaL=L�[oc�KpIZ]�[ou Itn~[\L�j~IJW=L=];GJc-Ea[\voS�hlQ�[�hl[oKpn3[oclG hlW=c-[�GJL=]�vkGJuaEML=EMhyVE�;[\ua]=vGJc-[ �;ckv,hBckGJ]=EaGihl[\]Pr c-ItK hkQ=[(EaL=L�[oc KpIZ]=[\u=W=v-EaL=N GJLP[�}Zn=uMEa`oE{h s/ckuaGJL=vX��E;ckGJ]=EHG hlEaIJL�`oItL�]=EMhkEaItL��s/c-uHGJL=vK��E�S;��Bi� �i$�GJL=]PhlQ=[\L�c-[ov-hkItck[\]1hkI�hkQ=[�IJW�hl[\c KpI�]=[ou�xiGJuMW=[ovBGih%[oGJ`bQ�����ua[�xt[ou=�(E{hlQPhlQ=[hlEMK1[Fvk`gGiua[)IJr�!P]=G�V�v\���� ����� ���Z�6 1���� � ��� 1 6��u5��! �� ��3 2 1 "���$# �&% 6('*) ��2 ��1 2���6>� �i"�/243

� Q=[�v-[oKpE{��n=ckItNJL=Itv-hkEa`PKp[\hlQ�IZ] ��GJv EaLqhlc-IZ]�W=`o[\]ItckEMNtEaL=GJuau{VYjqV XZQ=[\L=N [\hCGJu�� �P!�#&#���$�Sr Itc/hkQ=[Pn=W=ckn3Itv-[1IJr�GJ]��-W�v-hlEML=N@K1I�]=[\u K1ItKp[oLqhkW=K9['�W=GihlEMItL=v)hlI_`oItc-ck[\`\hfr Itc)KpIZ]=[\u v-V�v,�hl[\K�G hlEa`_[oc-ckItc-v �|v-[o[ d)ck[oGihlj;G hl`bQ [\h�GJu��{S !�#&#J��r Itc�GJL I�xJ[oc-x�EM[\� $�� � Q=[ Gi]��-W=v-hkK1[\Lqh�EavGJ`\`oItKpn=uaEMvkQ=[\]@j�V_c-[on=uaGJ`oEML=NphkQ=[�]=[oL=v-EMhyV�xiGJc-EHGJj=uM[ " EaL@hlQ�[CQqV�]=ckItv,hbGihkEa`�[ '�W;GihkEaItL �|�i$(jqVG uaEML=[gGJc�`oItK�j�EaL;GihkEaItL�IJr+hkQ=[fK1I�]=[\u{�y`\ItKpn=W�hl[\]�]=[oL�vkEMhyV " + GJL=]eGJL@EaL=n=WZh(]=[oL=v-EMhyV "�+ �" !-, " + � �,� � , $ "�+/. " + � �,� � , $� "�+ � " + $ �PBi$

%

Page 7: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

�(Q=[\ck[ " + ! " � 5 0 8 0 %�� ��� $�Eav hkQ=[f]=[oL=v-EMhyV_`gGiua`oW�uHGihk[o]�r ckItK0hlQ=[fKpIZ]=[\u�n~Iihl[oLqhkEHGJuRhk[oKpn~[\c,�GihkW=ck[ 5 GJL=]�vkGJuaEML=EMhyV 8 ]=[\vk`oc-Eaj3[o]@EaL �P%&$BGiL=]9� �i$�S=GJL=] %�� ��� EavBhlQ=[/c-[\r [\ck[oL�`o[fn=ck[\vkv-W=ck[�GihhlQ�[1`\[oLqhl[\cCIJr [oGJ`bQ�pua[�xt[ouTS GiL=] , Eav)hlQ�[�uaEML=[gGic)`oItK�j�EaL;GihkEaItL `\IZ[ 1`\Ea[\L�h �(EMhkQ G@xJGiuaW=[j3[\hy�B[o[oL #@GJL=] �t� �yL XZQ=[\L=N_[\h�GJuT�7�"!y#&#���$�SRhlQ=[ EML=n=W�hf]�[oL=v-EMhyV "�+ Eav)`\ItK1n�W�hl[\] r c-ItK'G`ouMEaK1GihlIJuaItNJVPIir QqV�]=ckIJNtclGJn�Q=Ea`)];G hbG�S;j=WZh(EMh(KpEaNtQqh(GJuMvkIPj3[)]=[oL=v-EMhyV�r c-ItK GJL�IJhlQ=[\c(K1I�]=[ouTSGJv�EML�hlQ=[)L�[ov-hkEaL=N hk[o`bQ=L=E�'�W=[)hlI j3[/]=[ov-`oc-Eaj3[o]�� w�v-EaL=N �>Bi$�S�hlQ=[)QqV�]=ckIJv-hbG hlEa`)['�W;GihlEMItL�`gGiLj3[)ck[\�(c-EMh-hl[oLeGJv\� �% .- ! � 4 " + � 4 ��� � , $� "�+ � " + $ 0 ����#i$�(Q=[\ck[/hlQ�[)vk[o`\ItL=]�hl[\ckK0ItL�hlQ=[f^6z/X�Iir ����#i$BEMvBhkQ=[)`oItc-ck[\`\hlEMItL�hl[\ckK0W=vk[\]@hkI `oItc-ck[\`\h r ItcKpIZ]=[\u�v-V�v-hk[oK1GihlEM`C[\ckckIJcFGJL�] W=L=c-[ovkIJuMxt[\] n=c-IZ`\[ovkv-[ov\� � v�v-hlGihl[\] EaL XZQ=[oL�N�[\h/GJu�� �P!�#&#���$�ShlQ�[�Gij~I�xt[�n=ckI�`o[\]=W=c-[�EMv ['�W=EMxiGJuM[oLqh%hlI GJ]=]=EML=NCG)r Itc-`oEaL�Nfhk[oc-K hlIfhlQ=[6Q=Itc-Ea�oIJL�hlGJu;KpItK1[\LZ�hlW�K'[ '�W;GihkEaItL�vo���#IY]=[\K1IJL=v-hkclGihk[PhkQ=Eav\S#�B[�]�[o`oIJK1n3Itvk[PhlQ�[1KpIZ]�[ou�n=c-[ov-vkW=c-[�xiGJckEaGJj=ua[ %EaLqhkI�hy��Iphl[oc-K1v\� % ! %�� ���% ���t��$�(Q=[\ck[ % � Eav�hlQ�[fhkclGJ]�EMhlEMItL;GJu~n=ck[\vkv-W=ck[fxiGJckEaGJj=ua[FvlGihkEav-r V�EML=N �% � $- ! � 4 " + ����!&$

�(EMhkQ % � ! 4 "�� Gih hlQ�[�v-[gGPvkW=c,r|GJ`o[iS3GJL=] �% EMv(G `oItc-ck[o`�hlEMItL�hl[oc-K vlG hlEav,r V�EaL=N �% .- ! � 4 �,� � , $� "�+ � " + $ �����i$

�(EMhkQ �% ! #�Gih6hlQ=[ vk[oG�vkW=c,r|GJ`o[i�/w�v-EaL=N��,�t��$�S�hlQ=[ Q=ItckEM�oItLqhlGJu�K1ItKp[oLqhkW=K [ '�W;GihkEaItL�vF`gGiLj3[)ck[\�(c-EMh-hl[oLeGJv\� ;� �� ! � �"�# 6 % � � �"�# 6��% ������� ���g�l$

�(Q=[\ck[ ;� EMv�hlQ�[CQ=Itc-Ea�\ItLqhbGJu�xt[\uaI�`oEMhyV@xJ[o`\hkItc)GJL�]� 6 EMv6hkQ=[�Q=Itc-Ea�\ItLqhbGJu�;�GJn=uaGJ`oEaGJLeIJn~[\clG �hlIJco�+� Q�[ock[�r Itck[iS+hkQ=[1v-[oKpE{��n=ckItNJL=Itv-hkEa` Kp[\hkQ=IZ] Eav�[ '�W=E{xiGJua[\L�hfhkIYGJ]�]=EaL=NeG�r Itck`\EaL=N@hl[\ckK� � ���� 6��% $)hkI_hkQ=[�KpIZ]�[ou Q=Itc-Ea�\ItLqhbGJu%KpItK1[\LqhlW=K'['�W;GihlEMItL=v\� ��h EavfEMK1n3Itc-hlGJLqhfhlI_L=IJhl[hlQ=Gih/hlQ�[�vk[\K1E��yn=c-ItNtL=Itv,hlEM` Kp[\hkQ=IZ] EMv)GJ]=EaGJj;GihkEa`iS~uM[gGgx�EaL=N�hkQ=[�hl[\K1n3[ockGihlW�ck[ GJL�] vlGJuMEaL=E{hyV[ '�W;G hlEaIJL=v W=L=`bQ;GiL=Nt[o]RS~ET��[i�%GJv EaL9�"%�$�GJL=] � �i$@�Tdfc-[gGihkj;Gihl`bQ_[\h�GJuT�MSD!�#&#J�i$��

� Q=[%ItckEMNtEaL=GJuiv-[oKpE{��n=ckItNJL=Itv-hkEa`+K1[�hlQ=I�] ��sfX��eQ�[ock[\EaL;G r hl[ocm$REaLqhlc-IZ]�W=`o[\]�jqV�X�Q=[oL=N6[\h+GJuT�Q;GJv6]=ckG��(j=GJ`,��v/IJr�]=GJK1n�EaL=N hlQ�[ Kp[ov-Itvk`oGJua[�[o]=]ZV �=[oua]eGJL=]eck[\]=W=`oEML=N1��Ggxt[ n=ckItn=GJNqGihkEaItLvkn3[o[\]=vo� �%]�[oL�[�h�GJuT�C�"!�#&#i�l$�ck[o`\[oLqhlu{V�EaLqhlc-IZ]=W�`o[o]fhlQ�[�vkKpI�IJhlQ=[\] v-[oKpE{��n=ckItNJL=Itv-hkEa` Kp[\hkQ=IZ]��X�X�� Q=[\ck[oEML;Gir hk[oc,$�jqV_GJn�n=uMV�EaL�N�hlQ=[f`oIJckck[\`\hkEaItL�hl[\ckK IJL=uMV�ItLeuaGJckNJ[/vkn;G hlEHGiu�vk`oGJua[\vo� �% $- ! � 4�" + � 4 �,� � , $�� "�+ � " +�� ����%&$

�(Q=[\ck[�� � ck[\n=ck[\vk[oLqhkv v-n;GihkEHGJu�Ggxt[\clGJNtEML=N=� �%]�[oL�[\h GJu�� �"!�#�#J�l$�]=[oKpItL=v,hlclG hl[o]�hkQ;GihhlQ�[�X�X���K1[�hlQ=I�] [)~[o`\hkEMxJ[ouMV c-[o]=W�`o[ov�hlQ=[P];GiK1n=EML=N@[)~[o`�hCIJrBhlQ=[�sfX���Kp[\hkQ=IZ] ItL hlQ=[Kp[ovkIJvk`gGiua[)[o]�]�V7�;[ouM]��

Page 8: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

�yL�hkQ=Eav�v-hkW=]�VtS+��[1W=vk[1GeL=[��:hy��I ����G�V L=[\v-hkEaL=N_hl[o`bQ�L=E('�W=[�j=GJvk[\]ItL hlQ=[1vkKpIZIJhkQ=[o]vk[\K1E��yn=c-ItNtL=IJv-hlEM`YKp[\hkQ=IZ] � ck[\r [\ckc-[o] hlI GJv�hlQ=[�X=X � L=[ov,hlEML=N�hl[o`bQ�L=E('�W=[ �PXZQ=[\L=N"[�h_GJu��{S!�#&#i�l$�� = EMckv,hgSBhkQ=[YIJW�hl[\c�KpIZ]=[\u xJGickEHGij=ua[\v1Gick[YEMLqhl[oc-n~IJuHGihk[o] ItLqhlI�hkQ=[ �=L=[YNtc-Ea]�� � Q=[EaLqhk[ockn3ItuaGihl[\] �;[ouM]=v GJck[�hkQ=[oLpW=vk[\]1hkI�n�ckI�x�Ea]=[(j3ItW=L=];Gic-V `\ItL=]=E{hlEaIJL=v�r Itc�hlQ�[6EML=L=[\c K1I�]=[ouT�XZ[\`oItL=]RSthlQ=[BItW�hl[\c�KpIZ]=[\u�]=[oL=v-EMhyVCEav W�vk[o]�hkI)GJ]��-W�v-h�hkQ=[�EaL�L=[oc+K1I�]=[ou�EMLChlQ=[�ck[oNJEaItL��(Q=[oc-[hlQ�[�]�ItK�GiEaL=v�Iir+hkQ=[)hy��IpK1I�]=[\uav I�xt[\ckuHGin_j=GJvk[\]YItL �% .- ! � 4 " ����� � � � 4 ��� ��� � $ � �"�#�� � � � " ����� � � � � r Itc�hlQ=[fEML=L=[oc KpI�]=[ou $ ��� �i$

�(Q=[\ck[ % EMv hkQ=[Fn�ck[ov-vkW=c-[/xiGJckEaGJj=ua[(`oGJckc-Ea[o]�j�VPhkQ=[/EaL�L=[oc K1I�]=[\u�S " ����� � � Eav%hlQ=[�EaL=L=[\c�KpIZ]�[ou]=[\L=vkE{hyVtS �"�#�� � � EMv hlQ�[�]=[oL=v-EMhyV `oItKpn=W�hk[o]�r ckItK hlQ�[�ItW�hk[oc KpIZ]=[\u 5 GJL=] 8 �;[\ua]=vPGir hk[ocEaLqhk[ockn3ItuaGihlEMItL1hkIPhkQ=[@�;L=[�NtckEM]�S=GiL=] � � EMv(G uaEaL�[gGJc�`\ItK�j=EML;GihkEaItL�`\IZ[ 1`\Ea[\L�h(�(E{hlQ_G�xJGiuaW=[j3[\hy�B[o[oL #�GiL=] �tSZGJL=] � � EavBhkQ=[/v-K1I�IJhlQ�EaL=N�Itn3[oclG hlItc�� r Itc hlQ=[/c-[ov-W=uMhkv�vkQ=I��(L�Q=[\ck[iS�hlQ=[`oIJckck[\`\hkEaItL�hl[\ckK EMv vkKpIZIihlQ=[\]_I�xJ[oc�� � NtckEM]�n~ItEMLqhlv �=hkQ;Gih(EMvoS��t��! ��K+$��

�yL�hkQ=[1vkGJKp[p��GgVtS hkQ=[1EML=L=[\c KpIZ]�[ou ]=[\L=vkE{hyV�EMvfW=vk[\] hlIYGJ]��-W=v,h hkQ=[1IJW�hl[\c KpIZ]�[ou EaLhlQ�[�I�xJ[ockuaGJn=n=EML=NPvkW=j�ck[oNJEaItL@j;GJv-[o]eItL �% .- ! � 4 "�#�� � � � 4 �,� ��� # $ � �" ����� � � � "�#�� � � � � r Itc�hkQ=[fItW�hk[oc(K1I�]=[\u $ �����&$

�(Q=[\ck[ % EMvFhlQ=[Cn=ck[\vkvkW�ck[ xiGJckEaGJj=ua[�IJr hkQ=[�ItW�hk[oc/KpI�]=[ouTS �" ����� � � Eav6hlQ=[ ]=[\L=vkE{hyVY`oGJua`\W=uHG hl[o]r ckIJK hkQ=[(EaL=L=[\c K1I�]=[\u 5 GiL=] 8 �;[\ua]=v%Gir hk[oc EML�hk[oc-n~ItuaGihlEMItL hkI)hlQ=[(`oItGJckv-[ NtckEM]�S�GJL=] � # Eav%GuaEML=[gGicB`\ItK�j=EML;GihlEMItL�`\IZ[ p`oEa[\Lqh �(EMhlQ�GCxJGiuaW=[�j~[�hy��[\[oL # GJL=] �tS�GJL=] � � EMv GCv-K1I�IJhlQ�EaL=NItn3[ockGihlItc��|W=v-W;GJuMuMV ]=E�)~[oc-[oLqh�r ckIJK hkQ;Gih�W=v-[o] EaL ��� �i$K$�� =;Itc1hkQ=[ n=c-[ovk[\LqhYGin=n=uaEM`gGihkEaItLRShlQ�Eav�vk[\`oItL�]8v-K1I�IJhlQ�EaL=N�Itn3[ockGihlEMItL Eav�L�IJh_GJn=n=uMEa[\]�� � � `\ItK1n�uaEa`oGihlEMItL EML hlQ=[ n=c-[ovk[\LqhGJn=n�uaEa`oGihlEMItLPEav hlQ;GihBhlQ=[FItW�hl[\c�KpIZ]�[ou3EavBGJuav-I�j~[\EaL=N `oItc-ck[\`\hl[\]�W=vkEML=N�`\uaEaK1GihkItuaItNJEa`gGiu�];GihlG��m/[\hlGJEauMv�Iir%Q=I�� hkI@GJn=n=u{VehkQ=[ov-[�hy��I@`oIJckck[\`\hkEaItL=vFvkEaKCW=uMhlGJL=[oIJW=vku{VYGick[�NtE{xt[\L EaL XZQ�[oL=N@[\hGJuT�?�"!�#�#J�l$��~$

� Q=[_GJj3I xJ[�hy��I ����G�V EMLqhl[ockGJ`\hkEaItL�`oGJL j~[@Gin=n=uaEM[o]�G hP[gGJ`bQ ItW�hk[oc KpIZ]=[\uBhkEaKp[�v-hk[on��z�I��B[\xJ[ocoS v-EaL=`\[ehkQ=[en�ck[ov-[oLqh�L�[ov-hk[o]Z��NtckEM] KpIZ]�[ou EavP]=c-EMxJ[oL jqV KpItLqhlQ=u{V r Itc-`oEaL�NtvoSBEMhpEavvkW�1`\Ea[\L�h�r Itc hkQ=[/`\Itckc-[o`\hkEaItL1hl[oc-K:hlI�j3[FW=n3];Gihk[o]�ItL�`o[Fn3[oc�];GgVt� � uMvkI=S�r Itc vkEMK1n=uMEa`\EMhyVtS � �GJL=] � # GJc-[�v-[\h(hlIPj3[ #��o%��

��h�v-Q=ItW=uM]�j3[�L�IJhl[\]�hlQ;G h XZQ�[oL=NCGJL=]��+GJL=N��"!�#&#i�l$�W=vk[\]�hlQ=[6Itc-EaNtEML;GJu=v-[oKpE{�yn�ckItNtL�Itv-hkEa`Kp[\hlQ�IZ]_EaL@hlQ=[ ]=[\xJ[ouMItn=Kp[oLqh/IJr�Gphy�BIi����GgV_L=[ov,hl[o]��yNtc-Ea]YKpI�]=[ou�r Itc hlQ�[ �e[\vkIi� � Kp[ockEM`gGJL��GJc-ckEM[oc�^([o[�rCX�V�v-hl[\K IJr)hkQ=[ ��GJckEMj=j3[gGJL XZ[oG�� � Q=[oEMc�L=[\v-hlEML=Nhl[\`bQ=L=E�'�W�[ �|ck[�r [oc-ck[o] GJvhlI hkQ=[_sfX�� L�[ov-hkEaL=N hk[o`bQ=L=E�'�W=[�$�]=E*)R[\ckv�r ckIJK hkQ=[@GJj3I xJ[eX=X�� hk[o`bQ=L�E('�W=[@ItL=u{VEaLhkQ;GihhlQ�[�`oItc-ck[o`�hlEMItL�hl[oc-K1v W�vk[o] hlI [�}Z`bQ;GJL=Nt[_EaLZr ItckK1GihlEMItL j3[\hy�B[o[\L"hkQ=[�hy��I Ntc-Ea]=vPGJc-[�L=IJhvkn=GihlEaGJuau{VvkKpI�IJhlQ=[\]�� � [evkQ=I�� G�`\ItKpn;GJckEMvkItL j3[\hy�B[o[oL hkQ=[ X=X � GiL=] sfX��:K1[�hlQ=I�]=vj3[ouaI��f� ��[)GJuMvkI `oItKpn;GJc-[�hlQ�[fX=X�� K1[�hlQ=I�]��(E{hlQ��(Q;G h��B[)`gGJuMu� ,`oItLqxt[\LqhlEaIJL;GJu�ItL�[�����GgV��L=[\v-hlEML=N ��� s(�Ar Itc�vkQ=IJc-hN$��9�yLfhlQ=[�� s(� K1[�hlQ=I�]�S�hlQ=[ j3ItW=L=];Gic-V)`\ItL=]=E{hlEaIJL=v�r Itc�hlQ=[ EaL�L=[ocKpIZ]=[\u3GJck[6hbG��i[oL�r ckIJK hlQ=[�ItW�hl[\c�KpIZ]�[ou3[�}�GJ`\hkuMV1GJvBEaL1hkQ=[)X�X�� Kp[\hkQ=I�]���� Q=[/]�E�)~[ock[\L=`o[Eav�hlQ;G h�hlQ=[�EaL=L=[\c�KpIZ]=[\uBIJL=uMV ��L=I��(vpGJj~IJW�hChkQ=[�ItW�hk[oc�KpIZ]�[ou%hlQ=c-ItW=NtQhkQ=[�j3ItW=L=];Gic-V

Page 9: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

`oIJL=]=EMhkEaItL�vo�N�yLen;GJc-hkEa`\W=uHGJc\S=hlQ=[\ck[ Eav6L=I1hkclGJL=v,r [oc6IJr EML�r ItckK1GihkEaItL�EML�hkIphkQ=[CEMLqhl[oc-EaItc Iir�hlQ=[EaL�L=[oc%KpIZ]=[\u=]=ItK1GJEML�S�GJL=]phlQ=[\ck[6Eav GJuav-IfL=I�hkclGJL�v-r [oc IJrREaL�r Itc-K�G hlEaIJL�j;GJ`,� r ckIJK hlQ=[6EaL�L=[ocKpIZ]=[\uRhlI hkQ=[fItW�hl[\c K1I�]=[\u��

243������ � �^5 � ��� Q=[�IZ`\[gGJL_`oEMck`oW�uHGihkEaItL�KpIZ]�[ouav(Gick[fEaLqhl[\NtclG hl[o]@r Itc�hy�BI1VJ[gGJc-vo� � Q�[ KpIZ]�[ou�ck[\vkW=u{hlv(EaL

hlQ�[6v-[o`\ItL=]�VJ[gGJcBGJck[(W=v-[o]phlI�`gGJuM`oW=uaGihl[�hkQ=[FGiL=L�W;GJu;Kp[gGJLPxtItuMW=Kp[(hkclGJL�vkn3Itc-h v-hkck[oGJKpr W�L=`��hlEMItL=v�I xJ[oc/hkQ=[ ItW�hk[oc)GJL�] EaL=L=[\c/KpIZ]=[\u+]�ItK�GiEaL=v\SRck[\vkn3[o`�hlEMxJ[ou{VtS�r Itc6hlQ=[pX=X ��GJL=] � s �Kp[\hlQ�IZ]=v��P= EMNtW=c-[�!&$��%XZEML=`o[6hlQ=[\ck[/EMv�L=I�EML8-;W=[\L=`o[�r ckItK:hlQ�[/EaL=L�[ocBhkIChlQ�[FItW�hk[oc�KpI�]=[ou�EaLhlQ�[�� s(� `gGJv-[JS=hlQ�[��;[ouM]_v-Q=I��(L_r IJc�hlQ=[)IJW�hl[\c K1I�]=[ou~EaL�= EMNtW=c-[ !i]@Eav�hkQ=[)vlGiK1[fGJv�hkQ;GihEaL�XZQ=[oL�Np[�h6GJu��}�"!�#&#Z��$����yL�hkQ=[�X=X�� `gGJv-[JS=hlQ�[)GJL=L�W;GJuRK1[oGJL�v-hkck[gGiKpr W=L�`\hlEMItL=v n=c-IZ]�W=`o[\]jqVPEaL=L�[oc GJL=]pItW�hk[oc%K1I�]=[\uav%GJc-[6xJ[oc-VPv-EaKpEauaGJc I�xt[\c hkQ=[oEMc%`oItKpK1IJLp]�ItK�GiEaL�SqGiL=]�GJuMvkI)xt[\c-VvkEMK1EMuHGJc�hlIYhkQ=[�ItWZhl[oc K1I�]=[\u%�(Q�[oL�ckW�LItLE{hlv�I �(LRS �(EMhkQ=ItW�h�r [o[\]=j;GJ`,� r ckItK hlQ�[�EaL�L=[ocKpIZ]=[\u}� vk[o[ = EMNtW=ck[ !i] $�� � Q=[�GiL=L�W;GJu�Kp[gGJL xJItuaW=Kp[�hlckGJL=v-n~Itc,hfn=ckI�]=W=`\[o] jqV hlQ=[ ItWZhl[ocKpIZ]=[\u�Eav(Gij~ItWZh�%y#1X�xt[oc-]=ckW�n<��X�x8$�r Itc�hlQ�[�v-W=j=n3ItuHGic6`\Eac-`oW=uaGihlEMItL�IJr#hlQ=[���IJc-hlQ � hluaGJLqhlEM`JSB&#CX�x1r IJcBhlQ�[)d)W=uMr#X�hlck[oGJK_S�GJL�] ��#�X�xpr Itc hlQ=[�ck[o`\Eac-`oW=uaGihlEMItL�EML1hlQ�[fXZuaIJn~[(�G hl[ocBck[\NtEaItLj3[\hy�B[o[oL�hlQ=[�XZ`oIihlEHGiL X�Q=[ou{r GJL=] hlQ�[�d)W=uMr�X�hkck[gGiKeS�`oIJK1n;GiclGJj=uM[�hlI_[ov,hlEaK1Gihk[ov)r ItW=L=] EaL]=EaGJNtL=Itv,hlEM` K1I�]=[ouMuaEML=N/v-hkW=]=EM[ovBGJL=]�EML1IJj=vk[\c-xiGihlEMItL=v �|v-[o[ �_[ouauMItc [\h�GJuT�MS;��B��i!��Zdfc-[gGihkj;Gihk`bQ[\h GJu��{S~�^B&B���$��%sFxt[oc�hkQ=[fXZuMItn3[�� Gihl[\c�ck[\NtEaItLRS�I�)~vkQ=IJck[Fr c-ItK:hlQ=[�XZ`\IJhlEaGJL@XZQ�[ouMr�S�hlQ=[�hy��Ii���G�V�L=[ov,hl[o]��yNtc-Ea]PItW�hk[oc%K1I�]=[\u�n=c-IZ]=W�`o[ovBG)vkuMEaNtQqhlu{V�v-hlc-ItL=Nt[\c%ck[o`\Eac-`oW=uaGihlEMItL�EaLP`\ItK1n=GJckEMvkItL�(EMhkQ�XZQ=[oL�N_[�h GJu����P!�#&#���$ �P= EMNtW=c-[ov !ijRS�] $�S�EaL=]=EM`gGihkEaL=N1hlQ=[P[)~[o`�h�IJrBhkQ=[ r [o[\]=j;GJ`,� r c-ItKhlQ�[�EML=L=[\c K1I�]=[ou~hlI hlQ=[fItWZhl[oc(KpIZ]�[ou�EML@hkQ=[)hy��I ����G�V@L�[ov-hk[o]eK1I�]=[ouMuaEML=NCv,VZv,hl[\Ke�

�yL�hlQ=[@� s � Kp[\hkQ=IZ]RS�hlQ=[�EML=L=[\c�K1I�]=[\u�EavC`oItL=v,hlckGJEaL=[\] j�V�hlQ=[�IJW�hl[\c�K1I�]=[\u�ItL=u{VGJuMItL=N hkQ=[/j3ItW=L=]=GJc-V1IJr�EMhkv�]=ItK1GJEML�S�GJL=]�hlQ�[/EaLqhl[\ckEMItcBIir#hkQ=[/EML=L=[ocBK1I�]=[\u~]=IJK�GJEML�EMv�L=IJh`oIJL=v-hkclGJEML=[o]1]=Eac-[o`\hkuMV jqVPhlQ�[�ItWZhl[oc KpIZ]=[\u���� Q=[�c-[ov-W=uMhBEav%hlQ;G h hkQ=[FEML=L=[\c KpI�]=[ou;`oGJL�]=c-EMr hGg��GgV�r c-ItK>hkQ=[eIJW�hl[\cpKpI�]=[ouTS%GJvPEavP[\x�Ea]�[oLqhpQ=[oc-[J� � Q�[_IJL=[�����GgV L=[\v-hl[\] EaL�L=[oc KpIZ]�[ouNt[\L=[ockGihl[\v�GJL W=L�ck[gGiuaEav,hlEM`gGJuMuMV uHGJc-Nt[@GJL=] j=c-IqGJ] [gGJv,hy��Gick]"hkclGJL�vkn3Itc-hpI�xt[\cphkQ=[eX�� GJL�]GJ]��kGi`o[oLqh ]�[o[on���Gihl[\c ck[\NtEaItL�v GJL=]�r|GJEMuav%hlI n=c-IZ]�W=`o[/hkQ=[F�(Ea]�[ouMV1ck[\`oItNJL=Ea�\[o]�ck[\`oEMck`oW�uHGihkEaItLEaL�hkQ=[ X�� c-[oNtEMItL9�P= EMNtW=c-[ !i`�$��

� Q=[fK1I�]=[\uRck[\vkW=u{hlv(EaL�hkQ=[fvk[\`oItL=]@Vt[oGJc6GJck[fGiuavkI W�vk[o]@hlIP`oGJua`\W=uHGihk[FhlQ�[fGJL=L�W;GJu�Kp[gGJLL=[oGJc,��vkW=c,r|GJ`o[1`oW=c-ck[oLqhkv Gih1� �eK ]=[\n�hlQEML�hkQ=[�X=X �+S s�X � GiL=] � s(� `oGJvk[\v��P=+EaNtW=c-[��&$��= EMNtW=ck[1�tG�S#r Itc hkQ=[�IJW�hl[\c�K1I�]=[\u�S#vkQ=I��(vPGYv-ItW�hlQq�B[ov,hy��GJc-]"`\IqGJv,hbGJu -;I�� ��L�I �(L GJv�hlQ=[XZ`\IJhlEaGJL���W�ckck[\Lqh�I�xt[\c+hlQ�[�`oItGJv-hlGJu�ck[oNJEaItL�SiG�L=GJckc-I �`oW=c-ck[oLqh ��L=I��(L Giv#hkQ=[�v-Q=[ou{r;j=ck[oG��C�-[\hI�xt[\c(hkQ=[)ItW�hk[oc6X=X3S�GJL=]_G�L;GJc-ckI�� �-[�h(I xJ[oc hlQ�[�X�� hkQ;Gih �;c-v-h?-;I��(v(L=Itc,hlQ=[oGJv-hy��GJck]_I�xt[\chlQ�[6X�� c-[oNtEMItLPI�)�hlQ�[6v-ItW�hkQ��B[ov,hl[\ckL@X=XPGJL=] hkQ=[oLPhlW=c-L=v%[gGJv,hy��Gick]1hkI)hlQ=[(]=[\[on1��Gihk[oc%I�)hlQ�[/vkItWZhlQ=[oGJv-hk[ockLYX=X~�8=;W=c-hkQ=[oc v-ItW�hlQ�Iir#hkQ=[�X���S�hlQ=[\ck[)Eav�G�v-hlc-ItL=NPGJL�]�j=ckIqGi]�[gGJv,hy��GJc-]-;I���Giv n;GJc-h(Iir+hkQ=[ dfW=u{r#v-hlc-[gGJK_� � Q=[fL=[\v-hl[\]Z�yNJckEa]@EML=L=[oc KpI�]=[ou�W�vkEaL�NPhkQ=[ X=X�� L=[ov,hlEaL�Nhl[\`bQ=L=E�'�W�[pc-[on=c-IZ]�W=`o[\vfhkQ=[ uHGickNt[��yvk`oGJua[�r [gGihkW=ck[\v)IJr%hlQ=[ L�[gGJc��yvkW�c-r|GJ`\[ `oW=c-ck[oLqhkv n=c-IZ]�W=`o[\]jqVehkQ=[�ItWZhl[ocFK1I�]=[ou+EaLYhkQ=[�I�xt[\ckuaGJn=n=EML=N�ck[\NtEaIJL<�P= EMNtW=c-[ov/�JG�S�j�$�SRj�W�h/�(EMhkQ K�W=`bQ j3[\h-hl[occk[\vkItuMW�hlEMItL��

Page 10: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

-5

-10-15-20-25-30-35-40-45 -50-50

-55

6050

40

40

3020

100

Two-Way Nesting (SSP)

(b) Outer-5

-5

-10

-10

4030

20

10

0

0

0

(a) Inner

-5

-10-15-20-25-30-35-40-45 -50-50

-55

6050

40

3020

10

0

Conventional One-Way Nesting

(d) Outer

7060

50

403020100

(c) Inner

�����' ����4� : ,',4�'�65 ���&�6,��62�5"�'���I�� �6,'(�L126 �� (��� ��&�6��#/�','!=���2�,J( !=2���L@�����&3 #C �2�� ����� (��&!=2�,'3�6�&�� 7��2�3��&5; ��&(��'5��( L' �2�3'�'!=�&3IB4� -/��0+�������",',��� N�6,'3 -CBD0+2������� 7��2�3��&5;26#$�����H� )92�� )9� � ,��&(����&36 �"3 ��243'�&5"5"�",� (���(����&� �'(��",' ����� (��.2826�����&3 (��&�.��� L' �26�,�2�(����E!.,��&(����",' ���&! �',J���8�'� �6,'3 B8� -/! 0�����K�E,',��� �6,'3 -/3@0 2��'���� ��2�3��&5+�J(��",� ����� !=2�,�6�&,8���2�,'�65 2�,��� )��&� ,'�&(����",�A���&! �','���4���6O������(��� ��&�6�.#C�',J!=���2�, (��'2 )+, �",I-/3D0 �"($�����N(��6���N�6($���'���9L' �2�3'�'!=�&3 B8�����'� (��E,��5�� 3�2��.�6�E,� +26 ����)9�&(��:���5"�6,8���"! < !=�&�6, ��2�3��&5*26#�G����&,� ��� �65 O.-�������� 0 O���2�,���2��� ( �� ���5"��B1�&5�&3I�", �','���(+26#9G�� -�� ��������N(� � 0 O

�+I�GJv-vk[\vkv hlQ=[ n3[oc,r ItckK1GJL=`\[ IJr�hlQ=[ L�[ov-hk[o]Z��NtckEM]PK1I�]=[ouTSi�B[(`oItKpn;GJc-[�hlQ=[ KpI�]=[ouZ`gGJuM`oWZ�uHG hl[o]eGJL=L�W;Giu#Kp[gGiLYL=[oGJc,��vkW=c,r|GJ`o[�`oW=c-ck[\L�hkvF�(EMhkQehkQ=[�hkEaKp[fK1[oGJLe`\W=ckc-[oLqhlvFEaL�r [\ckck[\]er c-ItKhlQ�[�Itj=v-[oc,xt[o]�hkclG��-[\`\hlIJckEa[\v�IJr(L=[oGJc,��vkW=c,r|GJ`o[1]=ckE{r hl[\ckvCjqV =;clGihlGJLqhlItL=E �"!y#&#���$)I�xt[oc hlQ=[@X�XGJL=] X�� c-[oNtEMItL�� sFxt[\clGJuMu�S~hkQ=[ KpIZ]=[\u+`oGJua`\W=uHG hl[o] `\W=ckc-[oLqhlv)EML hlQ=[ X=X��8`oGJvk[PGiNtck[\[��(EMhlQhlQ�[FItj=v-[oc,xt[o]@`\W=ckc-[oLqhlv �>= EaNtW�ck[ov��tG�S�j $��W�+ICr W�c-hlQ�[oc '�W;GJLqhkEMr VPhlQ=[FK1EMvK�=hBj~[�hy��[\[oL�hlQ�[/ItjZ�vk[\c-xJ[o]�GJL�]1KpIZ]�[ou{��`gGJuM`oW=uaGihl[\] L=[gGic,�yv-W=c-r|Gi`o[6`oW=c-ck[oLqhkvoSZ�B[(r ItuauMI � XZQ=[\L=N�GiL=] �+GJL=N��"!�#�#t�i$

B

Page 11: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

�+GJj=ua[��t��� Q�[�� � ��xiGJuaW�[ov%hlQ;Gih�K1[oGJvkW�ck[�hkQ=[/KpEavg�=h�j3[\hy�B[o[\L�hlQ=[�Itj=vk[\c-xJ[o]_GJL=]�hkQ=[FKpIZ]�[ouvkEMK�W=uaGihl[\]�L=[gGJc��yv-W=c-r|GJ`\[f`oW=c-ck[oLqhkvFGihf��%PK0EaL�hl[\ckKpv6Iir ]=E*)R[\ck[\L�h6L=[\v-hkEaL=N hl[\`bQ=L=E�'�W�[ovo�

�+[\`bQ=L=E�'�W�[ � �s/W�hl[\c �TX=X�� $ #��~�J�X=X�� #�� �i!sfX�� #�� �i%� s(� �t�a#��

GJL=]@]=[Z�;L=[�� � GJv� � ! ������� � � � # �*� �� $ � � � � # � �� $ ������� � � � � # $ � � � � # $ � ��� �i$

�(Q=[\ck[ � � � # 0 � # $%GJck[6hlQ=[/Q�ItckEM�oItLqhbGiu3`\ItKpn~ItL�[oLqhlvBIJr�hlQ�[/Itj=v-[oc-xJ[o]�L=[oGJc,��vkW=c,r|GJ`o[F`oW=c-ck[oLqhkvGih�hkQ=[���hlQ uaI�`gG hlEaIJL [ov-hkEaK1Gihl[\] jqV =�ckGihbGiL�hkItL=E �P!�#&#���$�S � � �� 09 �� $�GJck[ hkQ=[ Q=Itc-Ea�oIJL�hlGJu`oIJK1n3ItL=[\L�hkvfIJrBhkQ=[PvkEMK�W=uHG hl[o] L�[gGJc��yvkW�c-r|GJ`\[p`\W=ckc-[oLqhlv GihfhlQ�[pvkGJKp[ uaI�`gGihkEaItL GivfhkQ=[PItjZ�vk[\c-xiGihkEaItL=v\S(GJL=]�� EMv1hkQ=[YhlIihbGJu6L�W=K�j3[oc�IJrfuMIZ`oGihlEMItL=v �(Q=[\ck[ Itj=v-[oc,xt[o] [\v-hlEMK�G hl[ov�GJck[GgxiGJEauaGJj=ua[i����ua[gGickuMVJS3hkQ=[�v-K�GJuMua[\c�� � S3hlQ=[�j3[\h-hl[\cFhlQ=[ K1I�]=[\u+c-[ovkW�uMhlv �=h/hlQ�[CItj=v-[oc,xJG hlEaIJL=vo�=;Itc�hkQ=[)hy��Ii����GgV@L=[\v-hk[o]Z��NtckEM]_KpI�]=[ouMuaEaL�NCv-V�v,hl[oK W=v-EaL=N hkQ=[ X=X�� L=[\v-hkEaL=N hl[\`bQ=L=E�'�W�[JS;hlQ=[xiGJuaW�[�IJr�� � EMv�GJj3ItW�h #��~�J��r Itc hlQ=[FItW�hl[\c�KpIZ]�[ou3GJL=]�#�� �i!)r ItcBhkQ=[FEML=L=[ocBK1I�]=[\u���� GJj�ua[C��$�SEaL�]=Ea`oGihlEML=N�hkQ;Gih hlQ�[6EML=L=[\c K1I�]=[ouZn~[\c-r Itc-K1v j3[\h-hl[\c%hkQ;GJL hlQ�[6IJW�hl[\c K1I�]=[ouZEaLPck[\n=ckI�]=W=`\EaL=N=;clGihlGJLqhlItL�E �v�Itj=v-[oc-xJ[o] `\W=ckc-[oLqhlv\�

� Q=[ I�xt[\clGJuMu+]=EMv-hkckEaj�W�hlEMItL=vFIir hlQ=[ GiL=L�W;GJu Kp[gGiL L=[gGic,�yv-W=c-r|Gi`o[ `oW�ckck[\Lqhlv)n=c-IZ]=W�`o[o] jqVhlQ�[�EaL�L=[oc�K1I�]=[\u W�vkEaL�NehlQ�[�sfX���hl[\`bQ=L=E('�W=[�GJNtck[\[1�(E{hlQ�hkQ=Itv-[�n=c-IZ]=W�`o[o] j�V hlQ�[�EaL�L=[ocKpIZ]=[\u W=vkEML=N hkQ=[ X=X �:hk[o`bQ=L�E('�W=[JS �(E{hlQ v-ItKp[e]=E*)R[\ck[\L=`o[\v�EaL hlQ=[evkK1GJuau��yvk`oGJua[�r [oGihlW�ck[ov�P=+EaNtW=c-[��J`^$�� � Q=[ EML=L=[ocFK1I�]=[ou#W=v-EaL=N�hkQ=[PsfX�� hk[o`bQ=L�E('�W=[ Nt[\L=[ockGihl[\v�c-[ouaGihlE{xt[ou{V@��[oG��J[\cvkIJW�hlQq�B[ov-hy��GJc-] `oW=c-ck[oLqhkv+I�xt[\c�hlQ=[%��[\v-hk[ockL�XZ`oIihlEHGiLCX�Q=[ou{r=GJL�] c-[ouHG hlEMxJ[ou{VF�B[gG��i[oc#[gGJv,hy��GJc-]`oW�ckck[\Lqhlv�EML�hlQ�[�]=[\[on��Gihl[\cCI�) hlQ=[�X�� ck[\NtEaIJL�S+EML `\ItK1n=GJckEMvkItL �(EMhlQ hlQ=IJvk[�W=v-EaL=N_hlQ=[X=X���hl[\`bQ=L=E('�W=[9�>= EaNtW�ck[ov��Jj�S�`�$�� � Q=[@EaL=L=[\c�KpIZ]=[\u�W=v-EaL=N hkQ=[_sfX�� L=[\v-hkEaL=N hl[\`bQ=L=E�'�W�[GJuMvkIPck[\n=ckI�]=W=`\[ov@=;clG hbGJLqhlIJL=E �v�hlEMK1[��yKp[gGJL@Itj=v-[oc,xt[o] `\W=ckc-[oLqhlv�EaL@hlQ=[CX=X_GJL=] X�� ck[\NtEaItLck[oGJvkIJL;GJj=u{VY�B[ouauTS��(EMhlQ hkQ=[�� � xiGJuaW�[ IJr GJj3ItW�h #Z� �i% ��� GJj�ua[���$�S��(Q�Ea`bQ EavfvkuMEaNtQqhlu{VYuaGJckNJ[ochlQ=GJL�hlQ=[)xiGJuaW�[/r Itc�hlQ=[ X=X � hl[o`bQ�L=E('�W=[i�

� Q=[eGJL=L�W;GJu Kp[gGJL L=[oGJc,��vkW=c,r|GJ`o[@`\W=ckc-[oLqhlv�Gih@� � K n=c-IZ]=W�`o[o]"jqV�hlQ=[@EaL�L=[oc KpIZ]�[ouW=v-EaL=N_hlQ=[@� s � L=[ov,hlEaL�NYhl[\`bQ=L=E('�W=[�]=E�)~[oc vkEaNJL=E��;`oGJLqhlu{V r ckItK'hkQ=[�EaL�L=[oc K1I�]=[ou%c-[ovkW�uMhlvW=v-EaL=N)hlQ�[Fs � XPGJL=]1X=X�� L�[ov-hkEaL=Nfhl[\`bQ=L=E�'�W�[ov �P= EMNtW=ck[(�i] $�� �yL�GJ]�]=EMhkEaItL�SihlQ=[(EaL�L=[oc KpIZ]�[ouck[\vkW=u{hlv�W�vkEaL�N/hlQ=[6� s � hk[o`bQ=L=E�'�W=[6GJNtck[\[�n3IZItc-uMVf�(EMhkQ =;clGihlGJLqhlItL=E �v#hlEMK1[��yKp[gGJL Itj=vk[\c-xJ[o]L=[oGJc,��vkW=c,r|GJ`o[ `oW=c-ck[\L�hkvoSt�(E{hlQ hkQ=[�� � xJGiuaW=[%IJr�Gij~ItWZhB�J�~#��JSi�(Q=EM`bQCEav+GJj3ItW�h �&#��8uaGJckNJ[oc�hlQ;GiLhlQ=Gih(IJr#hlQ=[fEaL�L=[oc KpIZ]�[ou�c-[ovkW�uMhlv(W=v-EaL=NPhlQ�[CX�X�� Itc6sfX�� L�[ov-hkEaL=NPhl[\`bQ=L=E�'�W�[ovo�

��#

Page 12: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

100 cm/s

(a) OUTER

100 cm/s

(b) SSP

(c) OSP (d) COW

���"��� ����4� �92���LJ�� �"(�2�, 26#;��2�3��&5�&3 -/(�2�5"�E3 �� � 2 )+( 0 �6,'3F26B@(��� �6�&3A-C26L1�&,F�� � �2 ) ( 0 ,��&�� � (��� #C�6!=�!��� � �&,���( 2 �6�� ����� G'G �6,J3 G4M ����2�,?O ���'�.26BJ(��� �6�&3 !��� ��&,���(H�� �� ����� 6 �"3'3��&3 ���E���� ���&�6,,��&�� � ( �� �#/�6!=� !��� � �&,���(93'�� �E,� ����� �������6(��E,�#%�� ��&3.#C �2�� �� ��� �&!=��26 �"�&( 26# ��� � � 3' �26����&3 (������&5"5"������� �6!�6�&3A3� �#C���� ( B4�K�� �����6,8��2�,'� -�������� 0N2�, � � � 6 �E3?O ����� ��2�3��&5�&3 !��� � �&,���( �� �� �������6,',4�'�65���&�6, !��' � ��&,8��(.��� �� � !=2���L@�����&3 #C �2�� ����� (��&!=2�,J3 �6�&�� ��2�3��&5� ��&( �'5��( 6�&,��� �����&3 B8� -/��0������2������� ��243'�&5 �6,'3 -CBD0 �",','�� N�.243��&5�26#9������� ) 2�� )��&� ,'�&(����&3 � 6 �"3 �.243��&5E5"�",� (��4(����&� �'(��",'����� ( ��2826���'�&3I(��&� � � L' �26�,�2�(����"!.- G'G���0�,��&(����",'.���&! �',J���8�'�� �-/! 0������7� )92�� )��&� ,��&(����&3 � 6 �E3 �",',��� ��2�3��&5��J(��",�����'�$26 ���E,'�65�(��&� � � L' �26�,�2�(����"!+- < G���0?,��&(����",�+���&! �','���4���� ��6,'3F-/3@0?�����9!=2�, �6�&,8���2�,'�652�,��� )��&� -�� < M 0�,��&(����&3 � 6 �"3 �",',��� ��.243��&5 O

� [�L=[�}�h `\ItKpn;GJck[6hlQ=[�EaL=v,hbGJLqhlGJL=[oIJW=v�v-W=jZ�yv-W=c-r|Gi`o[)`oW�ckck[\Lqhlv GJL�]�hl[\K1n3[ockGihlW=c-[ov�Gih?%�#K Gih ];GgV �&B�# �|[\L=]1IirR�6I�xt[oKCj~[\c IJr�hlQ=[ v-[o`oIJL=]1KpI�]=[ou�Vt[gGic,$ n=c-IZ]=W�`o[o]PjqV�hkQ=[ ItW�hk[oc GJL�]EaL�L=[oc�KpIZ]�[ouavRW=vkEML=N hlQ=[BX=X��#S sfX��YGJL�]�� s � L=[\v-hlEML=N hl[\`bQ=L=E('�W=[\v �>= EaNJW=ck[ �l$�� �yL�hkQ=[BX=X��GJL=]esfX�� `gGJv-[ovoS=hkQ=[fuHGJc-Nt[���vk`oGJua[6r [gGihkW=ck[\v6Iir#hkQ=[fvkW=j��yvkW�c-r|GJ`\[�`\W=ckc-[oLqhlv�GJL=]�hk[oKpn~[\clGihkW=ck[n=c-IZ]=W�`o[o]�j�VphlQ�[FEaL�L=[ocBK1I�]=[ou�`\ItK1n=GJck[6��[\uau��(EMhlQ1hlQ=Itv-[Fn=c-IZ]�W=`o[\]�j�VphlQ�[FItW�hk[ocBK1I�]=[ouTS

�t�

Page 13: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

[�}Z`\[on�h�hlQ;G h�hkQ=[pEaL=L=[\cfK1I�]=[ou n=ckI�]=W=`\[ov�K1Itc-[PK1[\vkIi��vk`gGiua[ [o]�]=Ea[\v I�xt[\c�hkQ=[�X�� c-[oNtEMItL�S[ov-n~[\`oEaGJuau{V1EML�hlQ=[�X�X��"`oGJvk[A�>= EaNtW�ck[ov��qG�S�j $��%��IihlQ�hlQ�[)`oEac-`oW=uaGihlEMItL�GiL=]�hlQ=[/hk[oKpn~[\clGihkW=ck[�;[\ua] EML�hkQ=[�� s � `gGJv-[�GJck[ '�W=EMhk[1W=L�ck[gGiuaEav,hlEM`J� �yLn;Gic-hlEM`oW=uaGJcoS�hlQ�[�� s(� L=[\v-hk[o]�EaL�L=[ocKpIZ]=[\u=r|GJEauMv hlICNJ[oL=[\clGihk[�hlQ�[��B[ouau�� ��L=I��(L�X�`oIJhkEHGJL���W=ckc-[oLqh L=[oGJc hkQ=[F`\IqGJv,h GJL=]phlQ=[�vkQ=[\uMrH�j=c-[gG�� �-[�hCI�xt[\c hkQ=[1IJW�hl[\c�X=X3�$�yL�v-hl[oGJ]�S#hlQ=[pK1I�]=[\u Nt[oL=[\clGihk[ov W=L=ck[oGJuaEMv-hkEa`gGiuauMVeuHGickNt[PGJL�]j=c-IqGJ] L=Itc,hlQ=[oGJv-hy��GJck] -;I�� I�xt[ocPhlQ�[YX�� ck[\NtEaItLR��� Q=[eEML=L=[\cpKpI�]=[ou W=v-EaL=N hkQ=[ � s �L=[\v-hlEML=NYhk[o`bQ=L=E�'�W=[@GJuav-IYI�xt[\ck[\v-hlEMK�G hl[ov hlQ=[�v-W=jZ��vkW=c,r|GJ`o[_X�� hk[oKpn~[\clGihkW=ck[�vkEaNJL=E��;`oGJLqhlu{V�P=+EaNtW=c-[/�t] $��

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35100 cm/s

(z=50 m)

(a) OUTER

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

(z=50 m)

(b) SSP

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

(z=50 m)

(c) OSP

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

(z=50 m)

(d) COW

�����' ������ G��E� �'5E�����&3 (���B � (��� �#/�6!=�.���&��L1�� ������ � -C6 � � �"�.��6� 0 �6,'3 !��� � ��&,8��(F-/�� � �2 ) ( 07��� ���� 2 �6�� �����FG'GA�6,'3 G�M �����2�, ��� 3'� � ����KL' 243'�J!=�&3AB4� -/��07����� 2������� H�.243��&5 �6,'3 -CB10N������",','�� ���2�3��&5426#J���'��,'�&(����&3�(���(����&� �'(��",' �����+G'G � ,��&(����",� ���&! �J,'���4���� @-/! 0;������,��&(����&3 � 6 �"3 �",',��� ��2�3��&5?�'(��E,� ����� < G�� ,��&(����",�����&! �','���4��� -/3@0 ���'� !=2�,�6�&,8���2�,'�65 2�,��� )��&� ,��&(����&3I�",',��� ���2�3��&5 O� �&52�!��� � �6�&!=��26 ( �� ��NLJ526�����&3 �������6�� �� #C2��� ���2�3��&5D6 �"3 L12��",���(9#C26 ������7�",','�� ��.243��&51�6,'3F���6�� �� )92 ��2�3��&5?6 �"3FL12��",���(�#C26 ������ 2������� +��2�3��&5 O

��!

Page 14: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

� v6K1[\LqhlEaIJL=[o]_GJj3I�xt[JS3ItL=[fIJr+hlQ=[fKpItv-h6EMK1n3Itc-hlGJLqh `oEMck`\W=uHGihkEaItL�r [oGihlW�ck[ov6I�xt[\c�hlQ�[CX�XGJL=]�X�� c-[oNtEMItL EMv#hkQ=[ vkn=c-[gGJ]=EML=NFIir=hlQ=[C;�GJj=ckGJ]=Itc+��W=c-ck[oLqh�r c-ItK�hkQ=[ d)clGJL�]C��GiLD��v+hlI6hlQ=[ItW�hk[ocfX�`oIJhkEHGJL XZQ�[ouMr�� � Q=[ EML=L=[oc)KpI�]=[ou#W=vkEML=N�hlQ=[pX�X��8L=[\v-hkEaL=N�hk[o`bQ=L=E�'�W=[PvkW=`\`o[ov-v-r W=uMuMVck[\n=ckI�]=W=`\[ovChkQ=[�`\Itua] hlItL=NJW=[�GJv-vkI�`oEHG hl[o]��(EMhlQ�hlQ=[+;#Gij=clGJ]�Itc ��W=c-ck[\L�hpGiuaItL=N@hlQ�[�vkQ=[\uMrH�j=c-[gG����P= EMNtW=ck[��tj $�SqEML=]=EM`gGihkEaL=NFhkQ;Gih%Gi]�xt[\`\hlEMItLpEav�EMK1n3Itc-hlGJLqh r Itc�hkQ=[ n=c-[ovk[\L=`o[6IJr3hlQ=[ `\Itua]EaLqhk[ockKp[o]�EHGihk[/uHGgVt[\c(ItL�hlQ=[fvkQ�[ouMr}�Tz�GJ`bQ=[\VJS���Bt���i$��

#u5 % %9 D��� 1 3 �&2 1 ���P5��^6�2 1� [eQ;Ggxt[ ]�[ovk`\ckEMj~[\] G L=[\� hy�BIi����GgV EMLqhl[ockGJ`\hkEMxJ[eL=[\v-hkEaL=N hk[o`bQ=L�E('�W=[ j;GJv-[o] IJL hlQ=[

vkKpI�IJhlQ=[\] vk[\K1E��yn=c-ItNtL=IJv-hlEM`��TX=X�� $FKp[\hlQ�IZ] v-W=NtNt[\v-hk[o] jqV(� ]=[oL [�hfGJu��A�P!�#&#J�i$ � vk[o[PGiuavkId)ck[gG hlj;Gihk`bQ"[�h1GJu��{SC!�#&#J�l$�� �yL hkQ=EavPn;GJn3[oc �B[e]�[oKpItL=v-hkclGihk[o] hlQ;G h1j3IJhkQ hkQ=[YX=X�� GJL�]sfX�� Kp[\hkQ=IZ]�v6`oGJL_j~[�W=vk[\]ehkI1[�}�`bQ=GJL=Nt[�EaL�r IJckK1GihlEMItL�j3[\hy�B[o[oLehlQ=[�vkW=j��y`oIJK1n3ItL=[\L�hkv�IirGeL�[ov-hk[o]Z��NtckEM] KpIZ]�[ouauMEaL=N�v,V�v-hl[\K>jqV�GJ]=]�EaL=NYG_hy�BIi����GgV�EMLqhl[ockGJ`\hkEaItL hl[\ckK'hlI_hlQ=[1Q=Itc-E{��oIJL�hlGJu�K1IJK1[\L�hkW=K ['�W=GihlEMItL=v6IJr [gGi`bQ vkW=j��yKpIZ]=[\u��C� Q=[CK1GJEaL@]=E*)R[\ck[\L=`o[�j~[�hy��[\[oL hkQ=[ov-[hy�BI�L=[\v-hlEML=N1hk[o`bQ=L�E('�W=[ovFEav(hlQ;Gih(hkQ=[ X=X � L=[ov,hlEaL�N1hl[\`bQ=L=E�'�W�[�W=vk[\v/Gpvkn;GihkEHGJuMuMV�vkKpIZIJhkQ=[o]�|uaGJckNJ[��yv-`gGJuM[�$ EaLqhl[\clGJ`�hlEMItL1hk[ockK_SZ�(Q�Eaua[(hlQ�[fsfX�� L�[ov-hkEaL=N�hk[o`bQ=L�E('�W=[)W=v-[ov(GJL�W�L=vkKpIZIihlQ=[\]EaLqhk[oclGi`\hlEMItLYhk[ockK_� � Q=[oc-[\r Itc-[JS�hkQ=[pX=X�� L=[ov,hlEML=N�hl[o`bQ�L=E('�W=[ c-[o]=W=`\[ov)hlQ�[ ];GJKpn=EaL=N�[)~[o`\hIJr#hlQ=[ sfX�� L�[ov-hkEaL=N hk[o`bQ=L=E�'�W=[ IJL_hkQ=[fK1[\vkItv-`gGJuM[)[o]=]�V7�=[oua]R�

� Q=[/hy�BIi����GgV�L=[ov,hlEML=N�hl[\`bQ=L=E('�W=[fj;Givk[o]@ItL�hkQ=[fX=X�� K1[�hlQ=I�]���GJv W=vk[\]eEML�hlQ�[)]=[\xJ[ou{�Itn=Kp[oLqhFIJr%G1hy�BIi����GgV L=[\v-hk[o]Z��NtckEM] IZ`\[gGJLY`oEac-`oW=uaGihlEMItL_K1I�]=[ou�r Itc6hlQ=[�XZ`oIihlEHGiL XZQ=[\uMr%GJL�]XZuMItn~[B�Gihk[oc\St�(EMhlQpG/Q=EMNtQZ��ck[ov-ItuaWZhlEaIJL�EaL=L�[oc�KpIZ]�[ou=[\K�j~[\]=]=[\]1EML=vkEM]=[ G/`oItGJckv-[��yc-[ov-ItuaW�hkEaItLItW�hk[oc�KpI�]=[ouT�W� Q=[)EML=L=[ocBK1I�]=[\u~`\I xJ[oc-v(hkQ=[�XZ`\IJhlEaGJL@XZQ=[\uMrC�TX=XD$�GJL�]_XZuaItn3[�� Gihk[oc �TX��:$�S�(EMhkQ G�ck[\vkItuMW�hlEMItLYIir GJn=n=c-I�}ZEMK�Gihk[ �+��K_�@� Q=[�ItW�hk[oc/KpI�]=[ou#EavFhkQ=[�L=IJc-hlQq�B[ov,h � hluHGiL�hkEa`s/`o[oGJL KpIZ]=[\u+]�[\xt[\uaItn3[o] [oGJckuMEa[\c6jqV XZQ=[\L=N�[\h/GJu�� �"!�#�#���$�S��(EMhkQ G�Q�ItckEM�oItLqhbGiu+c-[ovkIJuaW�hkEaItLIJrFGJn=n=c-Ig}�EMK�G hl[�!&%���K_��� Q=[eL�[ov-hk[o]Z��NtckEM] EaL=L=[\c K1I�]=[\u�W=vkEML=N hlQ=[eX=X � L=[ov,hlEML=N hk[o`bQZ�L=E�'�W�[ ck[on�ckI�]=W=`o[\v K1GJLqVY�B[ouMu{�[��L�I �(L uaGJckNt[��yv-`gGJuM[C`oEMck`\W=uHGihkEaItLer [gGihkW=ck[\v�I�xJ[oc)hlQ=[1X=X GJL�]X�� ck[\NtEaIJL GJL=] EMvFr W=uau{V@`oItKpn;GihkEaj=uM[��(E{hlQ hkQ=[�ItW�hk[oc/KpI�]=[ouT� �yL GJ]=]=E{hlEaIJL�S3hkQ=[ �;L�[��yNJckEa]EaL�L=[oc/KpI�]=[ou+W=vkEML=N�hlQ=[pX=X �8hl[\`bQ=L=E('�W=[Pn=c-IZ]�W=`o[\v�KpItc-[�vkK1GJuau��yv-`gGJuM[�r [oGihlW=c-[ov �|[i��N��MS�Kp[��GJL=]�[ockEML=Ntv\SZ��GJckK ckEML=Ntv�[�hl`J�~$ChlQ;GiL�hlQ=Itv-[)n=ckI�]=W=`\[o]@jqV1hkQ=[)`oItGJckv-[��yNJckEa]�ItW�hl[\c�KpIZ]=[\u�� �yL`oIJK1n;GickEav-ItLC�(E{hlQ hlQ=[ hkEaKp[�Kp[gGJLPL=[oGJc,��vkW=c,r|GJ`o[(`oW�ckck[\Lqhlv%EaL�r [\ckc-[o] r ckItK hlQ=[ IJj=vk[\c-xt[\]1hkclG ��-[o`�hlItc-Ea[\v+IJr=L=[gGJc��yv-W=c-r|GJ`\[�]=c-EMr hk[ockv+GihB� ��K�jqV =;clGihlGJLqhlItL=E �P!�#&#���$�Sij3IJhkQ hlQ�[ X=X�� GJL�] sfX��L=[\v-hlEML=NChk[o`bQ=L=E�'�W=[ov n3[oc,r ItckK K�W=`bQ�j3[\h-hl[\c�hlQ;GiL�hlQ=[F`oItLqxt[\LqhlEaIJL;GJu�ItL�[�����GgV�L�[ov-hk[o]@EaL�L=[ocKpIZ]=[\u�I�xt[\c1hlQ�[YX�X"GJL=] X�� c-[oNtEMItL�� ��ItKpn;GJckEMvkItL IJr�hlQ=[@EML=v-hlGJLqhbGJL=[\ItW=vpvkW=j��yvkW�c-r|GJ`\[`oEMck`\W=uHGihkEaItLYGJL=] hl[\K1n3[ockGihlW=c-[ �;[ouM] n=ckI�]=W=`\[o] j�VYhlQ=[ EML=L=[oc)KpI�]=[ouMv/]=[oKpItL=v,hlckGihl[\vfhkQ;GihhlQ�[�X=X�� L=[\v-hkEaL=N hl[\`bQ=L=E�'�W�[�n3[oc,r ItckKpv�j3[\h-hl[oc hkQ;GJL�hlQ=[�s � X�GJL=]@K�W=`bQ_j3[\hkhk[oc�hkQ;GJL�hlQ=[� s(� L=[ov,hlEML=Nphk[o`bQ=L�E('�W=[ov\�

�7��� 1 2&��� � 3 � % � 1 ��� [@�(Eav-Q hkI hkQ;GJLD����GJckv,hl[oL �%]�[oL�S};�E�'�W�L �+GJL=N=S�UJEaK ��Q�W;GiL=NGJL�] UJW=L ORQ;GJI r Itc

hlQ�[oEac�W=v-[\r W=u�v-W=NtNt[\v-hkEaItL=v�GJL=]`\ItK1Kp[oLqhkvo�Y��[1hkQ;GJLD��m)GgxZEM]�=;clGihlGJLqhlItL�E r Itc�n=c-I x�EM]=EaL=NhlQ�[�L=[gGic,�yv-W=c-r|Gi`o[�`\W=ckc-[oLqhlv ]=[�hl[\ckKpEaL=[\]Cr ckItK�hkQ=[/��#FK �y]�ckItNtW�[o]�vkGihl[\uauaE{hl[���hlckGJ`,�J[\]�]=c-EMr hl[\ckv

���

Page 15: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

EaL hkQ=[ ��Itc,hlQ � hluaGJLqhlEa`i� � Q=Eav��BItcX� Q=GJv@j~[\[oL vkW=n=n3Itc,hl[o]8jqV r W=L=]=EML=N�r ckItK � =+� � XGJL=] �/X �%^ �F� ^f� U�� d ��GiL=] U�� X~��GJc-[ GJuMvkI�vkW=n=n3Itc,hl[o] jqV �/X �%^ �FS � � ^W� � � �TGz�GJuaE��r|G }_j;Givk[o]Y`oItKpn;GJLqV8$�S3GJL=]ehlQ=[ �e[\hk[oItc-ItuaIJNtEa`oGJu#XZ[oc,x�Ea`o[�IJr ��GiL;GJ];G � � X=�}$ hlQ=c-ItW=NtQ_hlQ=[�/X�� ^�� ��� � ^�� �B� ��� X=� �yL=]=W=v,hlc-EHGJu ^([ovk[oGJck`bQ���Q;GJEac)EML -^6[\NtEaItL=GJu%s/`o[oGJL �eI�]=[\uauaEML=NGJL=] � ck[\]=Ea`�hlEMItL �=�

� ��� �l� � 1 ��� �m)Ggx�Ea]�vkItL�S =B�MS ^f� U�� d)ck[gG hlj;Gihk`bQ�S%GJL=]�F� ]=[�� ItW=L=N�S � v-V�KpK1[�hlc,V�EML hlQ�[�ck[\vkn3ItL=vk[�IirG�v,hlclG hlE��=[o] `oItGJv-hlGJu [\K�j;GgV�K1[\L�hfhkI��(EaL=] r Itc-`oEML=N=S������ � ������������ ����������� S/��#�#��\��y#�� ��S !y#&#��t�� ]=[\L�S��F�{S�^f��U��Rdfc-[gGihkj;Gihk`bQ�S�GJL�] �F�~���~� �ItL=EML=N=S � ]=EaGJj;GihkEa`oGJuau{V�`oIJckck[\`\hkEaL=N�GiL [o]=]ZV��n3[oc-K1E{hkhkEaL=NfKpIZ]=[\u;W=vkEML=N�uHGJc-Nt[���vk`gGiua[ QqV�]=ckItNJclGJn=Q�Ea`6];GihbGZ� � n�n=uaEM`gGihkEaItL�hkI hlQ�[/d)W=uMrX�hlck[oGJK GJL�]_hkQ=[���Itc,hlQ � hluHGiL�hkEa`f��W�ckck[\LqhgS!���#"$�������&%�' )(+*,�)-+./�aS�EML_n�ck[ov-voS !�#&#i�=�

=;Ig}~S � �#m��{S�GJL�] X~�+U�� �eGJvX�i[ouauTSW���BIi����GgVEML�hk[ockGJ`\hkEMxt[pL=[\v-hlEML=N IJr�n=ckEMK1E{hlEMxJ[ [ '�W;GihkEaItLI�`o[oGJL_K1I�]=[ouMv��(EMhkQ@hkItn3ItNtclGin=QqVtS,���#"0���1���&%�' )(+*,�)-+./���32�4JS�!�Bi�&� �H!�B&B��ZS~��B�Bi%Z�

=;ckGihbGJLqhkItL=E�SBm�� =��{S��6Itc-hkQ � hluaGJLqhlEM`�vkW=c,r|GJ`o[_`oEMck`oW�uHGihkEaItL ]=W=c-EaL=N hkQ=[��^B&B&#� �vPItj=vk[\c-xJ[o]�(E{hlQ_vlGihk[ouMuaEMhk[���hlclGi`,�J[o]�]�ckEMr hk[oc-voS5���6�� � �����1���7�8 �����9����� S�!&!�#��i���g!&!�#�Bt��S8!�#&#��t�

d)EaL�EavoS �b�{S � ��^(Ea`bQ;GJc-]=vkIJL�S GiL=] ; ��^(IJhlQ�v-hl[\EaL�S#m/[\vkEaNJL Iir G@K�W=uMhkEan=u{V_L=[ov,hl[o] n=ckEMK1E{hlEMxJ[['�W;GihlEMItL_IZ`\[gGJL@KpIZ]=[\u�S;:<�=*>�@?A)(��8��CB=���D�+2�� S���#i% �i�b��#&��B�SR�^B&B����

d)ck[oGihlj=Gihl`bQ�S�^f��U��{S � �4=�� =3GiL=L=EaL�N=S � ��m���d)ItW=uM]=EaL�N=SRGiL=]�X~�u;�[\x�E{hlW=v\S � ]=EHGiNtL=Itv-EavFIirEMLqhl[oc-n~[\LqhbGJ];Giu�`oEac-`oW=uaGihlEMItL�`bQ;GiL=Nt[ov(EML@hkQ=[f��IJc-hlQ � hkuHGJLqhlEM`JS,���9�� � ���������8�� �����DE�� S!�!�#&#&B �H!&!�#i!i��S~�^B&B��t�

d)ck[oGihlj=Gihl`bQ�S ^��+U��{S U��+XZQ=[\L=N=S%�F��� ]=[\L�S ; �/� GJL�N=S+DC� ORQ=GJE�S#GJL=]�U�� ORQ=GJI=S�� Q=[�v-[oKpE{�n�ckItNtL�Itv-hkEa`fK1[�hlQ=I�]�SGFD�=*�HJIK*,C*�HL(+M,NO��CM P�� ���aS=EaL@n=c-[ov-voS !�#&#J���

d)ck[\[oL�j3[ockN�S�m�� � �{S �eI�]=[\uauaEML=N hlQ=[ K1[oGJL j;GickIJhkckItn=EM`f`oEac-`oW=uaGihlEMItL_EaL@hlQ=[C��GgVYIJr =�W�L=]�VGiL=]_hkQ=[ dfW�uMr#IJr �YGJEaL�[JS5���#"0���1���&%�' )(+*,�)-+./���$�RQtS ����� � B&#J�=S~��B��t���

z�GJ`bQ=[�VtS~z ���F�{S � Q=[ IJckEaNJEaL�IJr+hlQ=[f`\Itua]@��G hl[oc6uHGgVJ[ockv(IJr XZ`oIihlEHGiLYX�Q=[ou{r�S6SO.T(+*����8�U��N5��'��F0(+*>��N5C./���VQtSD!�B �y�i!ZS���Bt�����

z�GJL�S=dP�{S=�F��zFGJL�L;GJQ�S=U������8;�I�]=[\coSZGJL=] �+���F�;X�K1E{hlQ�SZXZ[oGJvkItL=GJu~xiGJc-EHGihkEaItLpIJr�hkQ=[FhlQ�ck[o[]�EaKp[oL=v-EaItL;Giu Kp[gGiL `oEMck`\W=uHGihkEaItL I�xt[\cChlQ=[�XZ`oIihlEHGiL�XZQ=[\uMr�S$�O�W�� � ���������X�� �����Y���=2qS�^#��t�\�l��#i!&%ZS~��B&Bi���

z�GJL=L;GiQ�S=�F��d �{S�U��t��� ;�I�]=[oc\SZGiL=]�m��qdP�t��ckEMNtQqhgS�XZ[oGJvkItL=GJu;xJGickEHG hlEaIJL IJr~hkQ=[6j;GJckI�`ouMEaL=EM``\Eac-`oW=uaGihlEMItL/EaL)hkQ=[ XZ`oIihlEHG � �YGJEML=[�c-[oNtEMItL�S6�yL[Z�\]�=�+(+*,'C� _^U 'CH_�7�=*`' ��(=�CHL(+M�a+�b*>(+c[IL' � �FD��(=�CHL(+M,d0�CHV\�(+.�IK*,WN]HV\�a����94RQtS���B�B����

�g�

Page 16: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

�)W=c-EaQ;GiclG�S5� �{S+dP�#U��4�#ckEMn~IJuaE�S�GJL=] ��� � ����[\L=]=[\coS�m/[\vkEMNtL IJr G�KpI xiGJj�ua[ L=[\v-hl[\]Z�yKp[ov-Qn�ckEaKpEMhkEMxJ[/[ '�W;GihkEaItL@KpIZ]�[ou�S]: �=*>� ?A)(��8��CB=���D��� � S !J��B �g!i�&B�SR��B&��B��

;�GJc-Nt[JS�����d �MS(U����F� �e`\� EMuauaEaGJKpvoS GJL=] X3���F�Bm/ItL=[�VtS6s/`o[oGJL=Ea`@xt[\c-hkEa`gGiu�KpE{}ZEaL�N=� �c-[\x�Ea[��8GJL=]�GCKpI�]=[ou;�(EMhkQ�GCL=IJL=uaI�`gGJu�j3ItW=L=]=GJc-VpuHGgVJ[oc�n=GJclGJKp[\hk[oc-Ea�gG hlEaIJL�S���CB�IL�� �� P��� � �������CIL' � �$QR2qS;���t� �y�&#t��SR�^B&BJ�=�

;�W�S1� �{SJ� � ^f��� Q=ItKpn=vkItLRStGJL=] m�� d �g� c-EaNtQqhgS�� Ea]=GJuq`oW=c-ck[\L�hkv�GJL�]CKpE{}ZEaL=N EML�hkQ=[�dfW=u{r�IirX�hg� ;�Gg�(ck[\L=`o[i� GJLpGJn=n=uMEa`oGihlEMItL�IJr�hlQ�[ EaL=`\ck[oKp[oLqhlGJu;GJn=n�ckIqGJ`bQ hkI�]=GihbG)GJv-vkEMK1EMuHGihkEaItL�SF0(+*>�������GI � �������\�(+HL�UN5'CIJ���$4�tS �&!J� �H�J�i%ZSD!�#&#��J�

�_[ouauMItcoS6d �C;%�{S��F��^f� �e[\`bQ=Itv-I=SFGiL=] � ���)[\hkI=S � ]=EHGiNtL=Itv,hlEa`_KpIZ]=[\u�Iir)hlQ=[ NJ[oL=[\clGJu`\Eac-`oW=uaGihlEMItL1Iir�hlQ=[ � hluaGJLqhlEa`�s/`o[oGJL�S �& � N5)(&�� �����#"7(+.�H���G2�EJS��t���Z�\�b�J��Bi!ZS;��B��i!Z�

s/[�VtS�; ��� �{S=GJL=] �+�;��Q�[oL�S � L=[ov,hl[\]Z�yNtc-Ea]�I�`o[oGJL�KpIZ]=[\u����(EMhkQ�GJn=n=uMEa`oGihlEMItLphkIChlQ�[/vkEMK�WZ�uaGihlEMItL@IJr�Kp[gGiL=]=[oc-vFGiL=]Y[\]=]=Ea[\v�EML_hkQ=[ ��Itc,��[\NtEHGJLY��IqGJv,hbGJu+��W=c-ck[\L�hoS#���7�� � ����������� �����9E � S !y#&#��t� �H!�#&#�����S~�^B&Bi!Z�

s/c-uHGJL=vK��E�SD�b�{S � v-EaKpn=ua[�j~ItW�L=];GJc,V�`\ItL=]=E{hlEaIJL�r Itc�W=L�j3ItW=L=]�[o]_Q�V�n3[oc-j~ItuMEa` -=I �fS5���$FD�=c���>\�HL�"0���������02��JS�!&%Z���g!��&BZS~��B&�����

X�Q=[oL=N�S=U��{S�mFVZL=GJK1EM`ov IJrRG)j=W=I�VqGiL=`\Vq�y]�ckEMxJ[oL�`\IqGJv,hbGJuy�-[�hg�W� Q�[/dfGJvkn��[F��W�ckck[\LqhgS]�O�;"0�������%�' )(+*,�)-+./���$Q��JS=���g� � �y��� �t�ZSD!�#�#��t�

X�Q=[oL=N�S�U��MSJm��td � ��ckEMNtQqhgSi^��JU��qd)ck[oGihlj=Gihl`bQ�SJGJL=] m��im/Ea[�hlc-Ea`bQ�SJ� � ��m ���(�JGFL=[�� xJ[oc-vkEaIJLIir=hlQ=[Bm/Ea[g� � X�� IZ`\[gGJL `oEac-`oW=uaGihlEMItL �eI�]=[ouTS������HVc��8(+*>a[%�' )(+*�IL'YS; ' �����!��4JSZ�g���g�i��o�q�i!ZS��^B&B����

X�Q=[oL=N�S=U��{S�^���U��qdfc-[gGihkj;Gihl`bQRS��F� � ]=[\L�S�D���ORQ;GiE;GJL=] ; �i� GJL�N=S � L=[\�"hy��Ii����GgVPEML�hk[ockGJ`��hkEMxJ[�L�[ov-hkEaL=N hk[o`bQ=L=E�'�W=[ j=GJvk[\]eItL@hlQ�[�v-[oKpE{��n=ckItNJL=Itv-hkEa`�K1[�hlQ=I�]�S�hkIpj3[fvkW=j�K1E{hkhl[\]�S!y#&#J�

X�Q=[oL=N�S)U��{S�^f� U�� dfc-[gGihkj;Gihl`bQRS�GiL=] m���d �B��ckEMNtQqhgS7�yK1n�ckI�x�EaL=N hkQ=[ W�hkEauaE{hyV IJrfI�`o[gGiL`\Eac-`oW=uaGihlEMItLPK1I�]=[ouMv�hlQ=c-ItW=NtQ�GJ]��-W=v,hlKp[oLqhBIJrRhkQ=[�KpItKp[oLqhlW�K j;GJuaGJL=`o[iS>���G�� � ����������� �����9����� S�� �i�Z�t�\�l� �i�&! ��SD!y#&#��t�

X�Q=[oL=N�S3U��MS;GiL=] ;%�8� GJL�N=S � L�W=Kp[oc-Ea`gGiu�v-hkW=]�V�Iir `\Eack`\W=uHG hlEaIJL�EaL�hkQ=[/�B[ov-hk[oc-L ��GJc-Eaj=j3[gGJLX�[gG�S5���#"0���1���&%�' )(+*,�)-+./���$Q�QtS�!�#J�iB �H!�#��&BZSD!�#�#t���

X�Q=[oL=N�SFU��{S6GJL=] ; � � GiL=N=S � hy�BIi����GgV L=[\v-hk[o]Z��NtckEM] IZ`\[gGJL `oEac-`oW=uaGihlEMItL K1I�]=[ou r ItcphlQ=[�_[ovkI � � Kp[oc-Ea`oGJLY��GJckc-Ea[oc�^6[\[\r%X�VZv,hl[\KeS0%�' )(+*�� �b*>(+c[IL' ��S=EML@n=ck[\vkvoS !�#�#J�=�

X�K�GJNJItckEML=vX�qVtS#U��{S#d)[oL=[\clGJu `\Eack`\W=uHG hlEaIJLY[�}Zn3[oc-EaKp[oLqhlv)�(EMhkQ hlQ=[ n=c-EaKpEMhkEMxt[ [ '�W;GihkEaItL�vo�F�b�� Q�[ j;GivkEa`)[�}Zn~[\ckEaKp[oLqhoS,: �=*>� ?A)(��8��CB=���02��JS�B&B �l� �i%ZS~��B��t�Z�

��%

Page 17: K1GJvkv ] Eav-hkckEMj=W hlEMItL=v+ItLxam12yru/papers/Zhai_et_al04a.pdfL W=Kp[oc-Ea`oGJuBv-Q=[ou{r(`oEMck`oW uHGihkEaItL K1I ]=[\uavfr Itc hkQ=[ X=X GiL=] X S clGiL=NtEaL N r ckItK

� Q�ItK1n�vkItL�SJ� � ^��{SJGiL=]�U��iXZQ�[oL=N=StXZW=j�hkEa];Giut`oEMck`oW�uHGihkEaItL)ItLfhlQ�[�XZ`\IJhlEaGJLCXZQ=[ou{r�� � v-vk[ov-vkEML=NhkQ=[�Q=EaL=]�`gGJv,h�vK��Eauau�Iir�GPuaEML=[gGJc\S=j;GJc-IJhlc-Itn=EM`)K1I�]=[ouTS,���6�� � �����1������ �����9���=2qS�!i�iB��i� �!�%�#&#t��SR��B&Bi�Z�

��ckEMNtQqhgS�m���dP�{S�m�� � ��d)ck[\[oL�j3[ockN�S#U��~���4;�I�]=[oc\S�GJL=] �+���F��XZKpEMhkQ�Sq� Q=[ v,hl[oGJ]�Vq�yv,hbGihk[c-[ov-n~ItL�vk[PIJr%hlQ=[pd)W=u{r%IJr �YGJEaL�[ GJL=] GJ]��kGi`o[oLqhfc-[oNtEMItL=vFhkI�vkW=c,r|GJ`o[��(EML=] v-hkck[ov-voSG���"0�������&%�' )(+*,�)-+./���D��� S�BJ�l���HB����ZSR��B������

� �