KavoshCom Asia R&DApril 9, 2007 1 WiMax RF chip Design Ali Fotowat, PhD. Managing Director KavoshCom Asia R&D [email protected] April 9, 2007

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • Slide 1

KavoshCom Asia R&DApril 9, 2007 1 WiMax RF chip Design Ali Fotowat, PhD. Managing Director KavoshCom Asia R&D [email protected] April 9, 2007 Slide 2 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 What is WiMax Is 3G dead? No way. Basic WiMax RF Specs RF System level analysis Multiband front-end, filter, Tx design Quadrature errors Quadrature calibration Remaining Subcarrier Errors Conclusions Outline Slide 3 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues Slide 4 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues Slide 5 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues Slide 6 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Wireless Technologies (source: Worldwide Interoperability for Microwave Access Forum) Slide 7 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Wireless Standards Mobility vs. User/Link Bit rate Mbps Slide 8 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 WIMAX stands for Worldwide Interoperability for Microwave Access WiMAX refers to broadband wireless networks that are based on the IEEE 802.16 standard, which ensures compatibility and interoperability between broadband wireless access equipment WiMAX, which will have a range of up to 31 miles, is primarily aimed at making broadband network access widely available without the expense of stringing wires (as in cable-access broadband) or the distance limitations of Digital Subscriber Line. What is WiMax? Slide 9 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 802.16a Uses the licensed frequencies from 2 to 11 GHz Supports Mesh network 802.16b Increase spectrum to 5 and 6 GHz Provides QoS( for real time voice and video service) 802.16c Represents a 10 to 66GHz 802.16d Improvement and fixes for 802.16a 802.16e Addresses Mobile needs Enable high-speed signal handoffs necessary for communications with users moving at vehicular speeds IEEE 802.16 Specifications Slide 10 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues Slide 11 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues Slide 12 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Point to Point BACKHAUL INTERNET BACKBONE Telco Core Network or Private (Fiber) Network Non Line of Sight Point to Multi- point FRACTIONAL E1/T1 for SMALL BUSINESS 802.11 E1/T1+ LEVEL SERVICE ENTERPRISE 802.16 Backhaul for Business Slide 13 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 INTERNET BACKBONE Telco Core Network or Private (Fiber) Network Non Line of Sight Point to Multi- point OUTDOOR CPE INDOOR CPE 802.11 Point to Point BACKHAUL 802.11 & 802.16 802.16 Consumer Last Mile Slide 14 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 INTERNETBACKBONE Telco Core Network or Private (Fiber) Network Non Line of Sight Point to Multi-point 802.16e 802.16e SEEKS BEST CONNECTION Laptop Connected Through 802.16e 2 to 3 Kilometers Away Line of Sight BACKHAUL 802.16 PC Card 802.16e Nomadic / Portable Slide 15 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Slide 16 Issues Slide 17 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Slide 18 Slide 19 Adaptive Modulation Slide 20 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Slide 21 Slide 22 Issues Slide 23 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Slide 24 Slide 25 Slide 26 Slide 27 Tolerance to Multipath and Self- Interference Scalable Channel Bandwidth Orthogonal Uplink Multiple Access Support for Spectrally-Efficient TDD Frequency Selective Scheduling Fractional Frequency Reuse Fine Quality of Service (QoS) Advanced Antenna Technology Key Advantages of Mobile WiMax to 3G Slide 28 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 What is WiMax Is 3G dead? No way! Basic WiMax RF Specs RF System level analysis Multiband front-end, filter, Tx design Quadrature errors Quadrature calibration Remaining Subcarrier Errors Conclusions Outline Slide 29 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues Slide 30 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues Slide 31 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues Slide 32 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues Slide 33 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Slide 34 The shared channel concept Slide 35 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Key ideas in HSDPA The HSDPA concept is based on the following features: Shared channel transmission Higher-order modulation Short transmission time interval (TTI) Fast link adaptation Fast scheduling Fast hybrid automatic-repeat-request (ARQ). Slide 36 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Reduced latency Short TTI (Transmission time interval) Channel codes from the shared code resource are dynamically allocated every 2 ms or 500 times per second. A short TTI reduces roundtrip time and improves the tracking of channel variationsa feature that is exploited by link adaptation and channel- dependent scheduling. Slide 37 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Code sharing for shared channel Shared channel transmission HS-DSCH is based on shared-channel transmission, which means that some channel codes and the transmission power in a cell are seen as a common resource that is dynamically shared between users in the time and code domains. The shared code resource onto which the HS-DSCH is mapped consists of up to 15 codes. The spreading factor (SF) is fixed at 16. Slide 38 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues Slide 39 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Increase average speed by serving channels that can be best served!! Slide 40 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues Slide 41 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues QPSK, 16QAM Slide 42 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues Slide 43 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request Slide 44 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues Slide 45 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 HSDPA Mutli-User Diversity Efficient scheduler High data rate Low data rate Slide 46 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Issues Slide 47 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 What is WiMax Is 3G dead? No way! Basic WiMax RF Specs RF System level analysis Multiband front-end, filter, Tx design Quadrature errors Quadrature calibration Remaining Subcarrier Errors Conclusions Outline Slide 48 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Transmitter test set-up Slide 49 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Transmitter requirements (IEEE 802.16-2004 8.3.10, 8.5.2) 8.3.10.1 Transmit power level control 8.3.10.1.1 Transmit spectral flatness 8.3.10.1.2 Transmit constellation error 8.5.2 Transmit spectral mask ACPR, maximum output power, spurious and harmonics are also important Slide 50 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Transmitter Spectral Flatness Spectral linesSpectral flatness Spectral lines from -50 to -1 and +1 to +50 +/--2 dB from the measured energy averaged over all active tones Spectral lines from -100 to -1 and +1 to +100 +2dB/--4dB from the measured energy averaged over all active tones Adjacent subcarriers+/--0.1dB Slide 51 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Burst typeRelative constellation error (dB) BPSK-1/2-13.0 QPSK-1/2-16.0 QPSK-3/4-18.5 16QAM-1/2-21.5 16QAM-3/4-25.0 64QAM-2/3-28.5 64QAM-3/4-31.0 Transmitter Constellation Error Slide 52 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Receiver test set-up Slide 53 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Receiver requirements are defined in IEEE 802.16-2004 section 8.3.11 8.3.11.1 Receiver sensitivity 8.3.11.2 Receiver adjacent and alternate channel rejection 8.3.11.3 Receiver maximum input signal 8.3.11.4Receiver maximum tolerable signal 8.3.11.5Receiver image rejection Slide 54 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Modulation type and coding rateBandwidth 64QAM16QAMQPSKBPSK 3/42/33/41/23/41/2 -75.7 -72.7 -69.8 -68.1 -65.0 24.4 -77.4 -74.4 -71.3 -69.8 -66.7 22.7 -81.9 -78.9 -78.8 -74.3 -71.2 18.2 -83.7 -80.7 -77.6 -76.1 -73.0 16.4 -88.9 -85.9 -82.8 -81.3 -78.2 11.2 -90.7 -87.7 -84.6 -83.1 -80.3 9.4 -93.7 -90.7 -87.6 -86.1 -83.0 6.4 1.75MHz 3.5MHz 7.0MHz 10.0MHz 20.0MHz Rx SNR (dB) Receiver Sensitivity (dBm) for 10e-6 BER Slide 55 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Slide 56 What is WiMax Is 3G dead? No way! Basic WiMax RF Specs RF System level analysis Multiband front-end, filter, Tx design Quadrature errors Quadrature calibration Remaining Subcarrier Errors Conclusions Outline Slide 57 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Almost all of the implementations use Direct Conversion method Direct Conversion pros and cons: Advantages: 1.High level of integration 2.Low power consumption Disadvantages: 1.DC offset problem 2.Higher flicker noise 3.Poor quadrature matching Examples of Implementation Trials Slide 58 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 For WLAN / WiMAX [B. Farahani-05] Direct Conv Architecture Slide 59 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Frequency Synthesizer Specifications [B. Farahani-05] 1.The phase noise requirement for PLL : 110dBc/Hz @1MHz offset frequency 2.The settling time should be better than: 5s Direct Conv Architecture Slide 60 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Block Requirements for Direct Conversion WiMAX Receiver [B. Farahani-05] Slide 61 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Block Requirements for Direct Conversion WiMAX Receiver [B. Farahani-05] Slide 62 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Different signal levels in Zero-IF receiver for WiMAX system [B. Farahani-05] Slide 63 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 What is WiMax Is 3G dead? No way! Basic WiMax RF Specs RF System level analysis Multiband front-end, filter, Tx design Quadrature errors Quadrature calibration Remaining Subcarrier Errors Conclusions Outline Slide 64 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Good idea to support both WiMax and WLAN WiMAX needs are more stringent than WLAN: 1.Tx EVM requirement is smaller for WiMAX 2.Because of Higher number of subcarriers in WiMAX OFDM, Phase noise of the VCO should be smaller for WiMAX which is on the order of 1 at arbitrary channel centers 3.I/Q sideband rejection requirement is more stringent than WLAN which is of the order of 35dB. 4.To cover different BW in WiMAX, programmable analog channel selection filters are required Slide 65 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Multi-band RF front-end for 4G WiMAX and WLAN applications [C.Garuda-06] 1.Direct Conversion Receiver 2.Multi band including: 2.3-2.9 GHz, 3.3-3.7 GHz, 4.9-5.9 GHz 3.Two stage & programmable LNA instead of wideband LNA 4.The gain of 30-32 dB approximately constant for all bands 5.Utilizes Gilbert cell as a mixer 6.No report about synthesizer and filters 7.In 1.8v IBM 0.18m CMOS process. Slide 66 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Two stage wide-band programmable LNA Slide 67 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Performance summary Slide 68 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Dual-band 4.9-5.95 GHz, 2.3-2.5 GHz, 0.18m CMOS Transceiver for 802.11a/b/g and 802.16d/e(WiBro) [I.Vassiliou, et.al, Broadcom-06] 1.Direct Conversion double band transceiver is fabricated in a 0.18m 1P6M CMOS 2.Fractional-N synthesizer achieves 0.6(0.7) integrated phase error at 5GHz (2.4GHz) 3.Digital calibration eliminates I/Q mismatch and carrier leakage 4.Programmable BW filters are used 5.Achieves EVM of -35dB in both transmit and receive paths 6.Achieves sideband suppression better than 45 dB & LO leakage lower than -30dBc Slide 69 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 System Architecture uses TDD Slide 70 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 GM-C filter and its OTA enable continuous tuning either 2-15 MHz or 10-25MHz Slide 71 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Programmable RF amplifier Slide 72 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Rx EVM vs. input power for different bands Slide 73 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Measured performance summary Slide 74 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 5 GHz Dual-Mode WiMAX/WLAN Direct Conversion Receiver [Y. Zhou, Instit. for Infocom Res-06] 1.Direct Conversion architecture 2.The dual-mode receiver is fabricated in a 0.25m IBM BiCMOS6HP SiGe process 3.The frequency synthesizer uses VCO running at half the RF frequency to help reduce dc offset due to LO feedthrough 4.DC offset calibration is performed on chip 5.The receiver employs GM-C base-band filter with tunable cut-off frequency of either 5 or 10 MHz 6.The chip adopts a 3 wire serial bus interface to control all the functions 7.The chip consumes 360mW from 3V power supply 8.Two mode double gain LNA is used Slide 75 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 VCO with Auto Calibration Circuit 1.Frequency fine tuning is achieved by hyper-abrupt varactor 2.An auto calibration circuit is implemented to select the appropriate band based on process variations Slide 76 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Performance Summary Slide 77 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Old article but explains the integration problems A 2.4GHz Direct Conversion Transmitter for Wimax Applications, C. Masse, Analog Devices Slide 78 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 The I & Q analog baseband Signal Generation Dual 14-bit DAC IQ modulator.direct up-conversion at the RF frequency remove the alias at multiples of the sampling frequency Low-pass Filters external fractional-N synthesizer LO (a continuous signal with minimal Phase error) VGA with about 50dB of gain control range. amplify or attenuate the composite RF signal out of the modulator Precise output power control is achieved. RMS power detector Slide 79 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 A direct up-conversion architecture is attractive because: 1.Wimax OFDM has no active sub-carrier at the origin, direct up- conversion produces less mixing product spurs 2.Requires fewer filters which is important when dealing with such wideband signals 3.The lower number of parts helps minimize the current consumption. Slide 80 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Performance Summary WiMax OFDM modulation used here is a10MHz, 64QAM, 256-OFDM signal Slide 81 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Slide 82 A CMOS transmitter front-end with digital power control for WiMAX 802.16e applications Y.H. Liu, H.C. Chen Slide 83 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 VGA First Stage of VGA: The gain control is realized with a current steering structure Second Stage of VGA: The primary coil of the on-chip transformer serves as the load inductor for a differential-to-single-ended conversion Totally: 16 gain steps are achieved Slide 84 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 What is WiMax Is 3G dead? No way! Basic WiMax RF Specs RF System level analysis Multiband front-end, filter, Tx design Quadrature errors Quadrature calibration Remaining Subcarrier Errors Conclusions Outline Slide 85 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Complexities in Quadrature signal generation for OFDM Transmitters and Receivers What is Quadrature Modulation? First-Order Error Sources Individual Effects of error sources Proposed New Calibration Procedure Slides 85-107 in this section based on Dr. Earl McCunes presentation Slide 86 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Quadrature Modulator Converting the quadrature modulation equation as a block diagram gives the familiar form Slide 87 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Realistic QM Model There are nine different first-order error terms Slide 88 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Realistic QM Math Gain mismatch & Quadrature error Carrier leakages Data leakages DC offsets Slide 89 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Ideal Error Values Slide 90 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Individual Error Analyses Modulation offsets Carrier Offsets Modulation gain errors Carrier magnitude errors LO quadrature error Modulator output compression Slide 91 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Standard - Use SSB Case A simple, constant- envelope signal (LSB is shown) Slide 92 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Modulation (I,Q) Offsets Cause carrier leakage AM also results Slide 93 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Carrier Offsets No effect on RF spectrum data leakage present amplitude variations on output signal Slide 94 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Modulation Gain Errors Causes image sideband AM at double the data frequency Slide 95 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Carrier Magnitude Errors Carrier magnitude mismatch - looks identical to IQ gain mismatch Slide 96 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 LO Quadrature Error Causes image sideband AM is phase shifted from gain-mismatch cases Slide 97 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Output Compression P1dB effect on QM output adds intermodulation sidebands gain mismatch casedata leakage case Slide 98 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Proposed CAL Procedure Minimize interactivity among adjustments Based on simple SSB signal Five steps (in order!): null data leakage null carrier leakage zero quadrature error match path gains set signal level (for signals with AM) Slide 99 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Error-Combination Case data leakageRF signal Slide 100 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 1. Ideal Modulator Drive Begin with ideal modulator SSB drive signals Slide 101 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 2. Null Data Leakage Zero the carrier offset terms O C and O S data leakageRF signal Slide 102 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 3. Null Carrier Leakage Adjust data offsets tradeoff until carrier is nulled RF signal Slide 103 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 4. Minimize Image Sideband Adjust quadrature error image sideband minimizes at e = 0 may need 0.1 dB resolution RF signal Slide 104 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 5. Match Path Gains Adjust one data-gain term (choose A I, for example) null the image sideband compression distortion also disappears RF signal Slide 105 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 6. Set Overall Gain Apply I(t) and Q(t) for an envelope-varying signal Turn down gains A I and A Q together to drop sidebands effects a backoff from the P1dB of the summer Slide 106 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Limited-Access Bounds Ex. : quad error limitation (no access to quadrature error) If full access to all error terms is not available, then the achievable performance will be limited. 1 degree2 degrees Slide 107 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Conclusions Quadrature modulation is a rectangular (Cartesian) method of implementing signals Real Quadrature-Modulators are not as simple as the textbooks (or databooks!) claim Quadrature modulators can be tamed if all ports are available to the design engineer Output Noise Figure is a major problem Linear modulations tend to require large output (and input) backoffs All error terms are, in general, functions of temperature! Slide 108 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 What is WiMax Is 3G dead? No way! Basic WiMax RF Specs RF System level analysis Multiband front-end, filter, Tx design Quadrature errors Quadrature calibration Remaining Subcarrier Errors Conclusions Outline Slide 109 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 How much spur rejection is needed? For 45 dB rejection, the gain matching should be better than 0.1 dB and the phase matching better than 0.5 degree. Some manufacturers require better than 55 dB for individual blocks! Slide 110 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Strong and weak duo A St cos(w St t) + A We cos (w We t) A two tone signal in time domain. Slide 111 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 A quadrature transmitter overall block diagram Slide 112 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Transmitter features 1. Allow offset adjustment blocks at the inputs 2.A programmable low pass filter corner frequency for all WiMax needs 3.Baseband gain with G adjustment (1 dB range in 0.1 dB resolution) 4.Control on the local oscillator phase (3 degree range with 0.1 degree control) 5.A very linear transmit mixer 6.A very linear combiner 7.A programmable attenuator (20 dB range in 1 dB steps) 8.An integrated power level detector Slide 113 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Strong and weak duo is not a duo! f Strong 3 rd Harmonic Weak 3 rd Harmonic Undesired sideband Desired sideband LO feed- through A typical shape of spectrum out of a quadrature transmitter Slide 114 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 LO feed through minimization process Use a 4 MHz baseband tone. Reduce the input level so that the upper side band is more than 60 dB down or into the noise level. The detector gives a 4 MHz LO feed-through, and a 8 MHz upper side band. Use a low frequency bandpass filter to detect the LO feed-through Adjust offset controls till lo feed-through is minimized (2 dimensional search) f 4 MHz LO Feed- through Slide 115 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 The Side-band minimization process f 4 MHz Minimized LO feed- through Undesired sideband Desired sideband Change the input frequency to 2 MHz In crease the input level. The LSB and USB will both increase. The detector detects a 4MHz USB, a 8 MHz USB 3 rd harmonic. The 4 MHz LSB 3 rd harmonic falls on the undesired signal! Adjust G and to minimize the USB. The rejection is limited by the 3 rd harmonic levels which is set by the transmit mixer Slide 116 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 What is WiMax Is 3G dead? No way! Basic WiMax RF Specs RF System level analysis Multiband front-end, filter, Tx design Quadrature errors Quadrature calibration Remaining Subcarrier Errors Conclusions Outline Slide 117 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Will this calibration work across the band? In single carrier systems single frequency interference and even non-flat noise spectrum can be tolerated. In OFDM systems S/N has to be fixed across the band Optimum G and do not stay the same vs. frequency! What are the sources of the error vs. frequency? Slide 118 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Edge of the band matching in filters In a 1 st order filter 0.5% mismatch in components results in 1.14 degree phase error at the edge of the band. In a 5 th order filter assuming random component values the expected phase error will be 3.6 degrees at the edge of the band. R I C C+ C R+ R Q I out Q out Slide 119 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Filter gain response Filter phase response System gain mismatch System phase mismatch OFDM base-band spectrum Slide 120 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 Broadband gain mismatch compensated by G but residual gain error still at the band edge! Broadband phase mismatch compensated by control with LLL, but residual phase error still at the band edge! Slide 121 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 The solution is using base-band filter loop back techniques and saving frequency dependent calibration values in the DSP Slide 122 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 What is WiMax Is 3G dead? No way! Basic WiMax RF Specs RF System level analysis Multiband front-end, filter, Tx design Quadrature errors Quadrature calibration Remaining Subcarrier Errors Conclusions Outline Slide 123 KavoshCom Asia R&D April 9, 2007 123 WiMax is the best the telecom technology offers, but 3G is in hot pursuit! The testing methodology to separate the RF and DSP designers is very critical. Direct Conv. with new VCO/synthesizer techniques is the way to go. The Quadrature calibrations issues are the key to success. What did we learn?