Upload
trismegiste
View
272
Download
5
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 1/23
147
O Sh S
A Acc “Mc-R”M Mc’ C
F J. Korom
D h c h h h Mch Taussig
(1989) c h h c c c b E-
Ac cc ch cc h w, h h bjc q , c b h w
c w b Atkinson (1992) j b c . Hw,
h h bw h I.1 Wh q
cb c, h c bch I w S
* Rch h ch w b h Ac
I S L S 2010 2011. P w bh
Korom 2011. F K P R Ah h D
R B U. H bc c Village o Painters: NarrativeScrolls rom West Bengal (M Nw Mxc P, 2006) Te Anthropology o
Perormance: A Reader (W-Bcw, 2013).
1. S xc , c, x (Centlivres 1971; Sidky 1990), c
C A h c wh Tc , w h
Köprülü (1929), wh h h bw S h h
c h ’ . S Seleznev Dudoignon (2000). Hw-
, Amitai-Preiss (1999) h wh h h S
wh fc h w, c, h h cc c. -
wh, h h h bh S (h , b xc)
b b h cc c j h .
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 2/23
148 | O Shamans and Suis
c c chc wh
h c h h w c. Winkel-
man (1990; 1992) h h- “c-”
h h b c-c h h h- (c , wch c, , c, h)
hh h w.
Ahh h T- “h-
” “h” x whch ch , Siikala (1978)
hc c h h h E Sbcc
, wh Peters Prie-Williams (1980) x
b c- c wh c,
whch Eliade (1964) c. W h c h h c.2 A ch c
h , c wh c
c, h , h h
c- h (Winkelman 1990, 310). Y h c-
h h xc h c, whch
cc ch b fh. W h c ch c
cc, whch Winkelman (1990, 311) c b
ch w, c, b , - (ch, , ), , , , ,
, , c, cc.
I c h, wh h b xc , h -
wh wh I cc h h chq
ch cc wh h G, hb w h w
h .3 A I h c bw, S h,
h h c. N S b h
h bjc h c h ch . Hw, c, c h h x h
2. F b w h h, Duois 2009,
whch h w h h c ch
ww h b c “.”
3. I “b” bc bjc bcc c h .
Wh w c “” h c ,
hc b b c c, cb wh ch
chc bc. S Von Gernet 2000.
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 3/23
frank Korom | 149
hc , h h c c-
.
I wh w, h, I wh ch jc h c
h c c chc S ch wh hx w w h w
h bc c b S L h 1940 h U
S h 1980.4 wh wh I cc h Mh-
Rh Bw Mh (.), chc wh
c h b h x c. Mx Weer
(1948, 267–301, 323–62) h “x” x-
wh , Ch Lindolm (1998, 210) , “
cc c, , bc c.” x hh b c h h w ch
cc, h wh hh w. Ex -
h h “ h ch” (Lindolm 1998, 210). Bw, h
b whch h , b h c
b S h h h c w h b
wh h cq b h -
h. H x h
qutb, h c h w hb w x ch
h b h c h c (Korom,
2012b).
D h , Bw’ ch h
c, whch h h
wh w h w h h h h b
- bc c. D h bc, c w -
h ch b c c, h cc x, I c h h
w S L q c w c c-
c h . I, wh I c w b
c Bw h h h U
S h 1970. I cc c, h h
4. T Guru Bawa and the Making o a ransnational Su Family , -
jc b w b h -h h h w. F -
h ch, Narayan Saney 1999.
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 4/23
150 | O Shamans and Suis
w cc, whch h c
bc bh , h q
h chc . Sch , hw, q c h
th ss ths st s t pc ws hs bty t hd t p th cs, whch h dwpyd t hs but c-
tud t d up ut hs dth. Idd, y hs ws dty sst
tht h ctus t ssst d gud th th (Korom 2012).
B ch c c cb h h-
c c, h bw hh h bc
b, c.5 Hw, I h h c
h “c” h b ccc,
, h ch c c wh cb c ch ch b wh c cc
w c wh h . Hh,
h c, h bc c
whch w ch h b c chc
wh c b h
( Lisitz 1994).6
Wh h xc c (Mauroo 1976)
bch’ h h (Snyder 2003), h cc hb w b Bw, T h h b h
h (b We 1994; 1998; 2006; Korom 2011; 2012,
2012b). M , h, c h-
h c hhc w bh Nh Ac
S L; , w, cc, , ,
w cc bw b wh I
Bw’ “ cc,” h wh c h
h bc h , wh c- b c h b h h.
5. h c Vansina
(1961; 1971). S h Bron Roerts 1980. O c
c Ic hh, , x, Millie 2008.
6. M x h h Ch c-
, b wh Kugle 2007, Renard 2008,
Werner 2003.
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 5/23
frank Korom | 151
Origins
Acc h, bw 1940 1942, h
h j h S L, h -
K. H w - T- S b
h Q , hh h h w q
h . I, h h b
h hc bc h h c h
q G, whch h w h x -
. V h w b h h c
h h j S L h 1940. I c, h bh
h Te ree Tat Fell to the West (Muaiyaddeen 2003)
x c b h cc b h
h c h ch Phh. I b
hc h c , c b h ’
w cc, whch ch h b
h c c bw bjc bjc ,
b.7
Wh w w wh c, hw, h
c hh h h
c c h h h h T-
w J x 1942. I w h
h h wh q h c h h
h . M h c w -
h w-c H, b Ch Bh h cc-
w. C, w M h h h
h . A h h c, h w
c h wh chw b, c, h ,
wh q h c. I w b h c
h h . A
c , Bw’ S w “cb Ic
” (Cittik 1995). Wh h c b c
, h c h h J wh q h
7. I c h Bw w b S L, h cc h
h b c. S Korom 2011.
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 6/23
152 | O Shamans and Suis
c c chc hc w M-
. h h w b h, h h
cw cc (Korom 2012; 2012b).8
I 1952, h h cq Dch wh J, whchh c c h x . A
wh ch ch c Bw -
h h , h h c h
w b.9 L Sh A S h b
h (, x, Eaton 1993, 194–304), Bw cq c
b, whch h c h h h wh
h h . B h , h w w G Bw
h H w, h q wh c , , c, wh h M w h c
“c .” A h h, xc, c , b
M c h, h wh c
b bw , h h cc-
bh h h c c, whch h bh h
Sb S S Cc (sss) 1962.10
Bw’ c wh c b bc h
w bc h h b w. bh cc (Mauroo 1976, 40.), cb b
c, h w bh N, bb J w,
w cc w h c cc
K h h h h h h. Wh h w
h, h w bh Bw h j, wh h
8. M h J M wh wh I w b wh h,
hh h Bw w “ G,” c w hh w .
9. A Bw’ S L H w wh w Ph-
h h h c h . O h ch, h
w q b h c h c w
bw c T b. b’ w c
wh b h. W h c b h c-
, Bw’ w c w h c c h h c
h .
10. sss w c c b h S L 27 Nb
1974 h Bw’ b S.
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 7/23
frank Korom | 153
h bh . cc w b h, wh c-
c. c c w j , b h
h h wh c. h c
cc w h Bw c T, h h c q .11 A wh
h , h h J wh h, b h c,
h h w h . Acc -
, h h w h h wh c, whch
h cc.12
S ch h c bw cc h c w
b h h . A , h
h h, h , - b Bw h h . O
cc w c h:
A w h Bw h c h [h w bh’ h -
’] hh, h c c .
D h c c h hh b h w, h
h b h . A, h w h h w
h w w h
h . Hw, wh h w w h h bh h b ch, h fw h c
(h L K), w h . Wh h w h
, hw, h c wh h K , h
c “” w h w wh h h , , h
h. Th w b h xc,
h h w. (Mauroo 1976, 42)13
11. h w c (hc, c h q) h
fc b Abc c Aw, whch b T. cc w h , hw, c
c, c h T h I (wh Bw w bb b)
q c h h S L. O
Aw, Su’ay 1993.
12. h h h w, wh f c ,
b , w , chc h, h , whch
c M h. S Ernst 1997, 58–80.
13. “Sw” Bw b h H J. I h
w c c h “h,” “,” “ ch,”
“.”
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 8/23
154 | O Shamans and Suis
Sch w c h Bw’ .14 I J,
h c h h w. S c
c b cc ch b c
jc ch c c. B c - h b xc wh
ch’ c h Bw b h h c
.15 Acc w wh hc, Bw
w h j h h .
H w h b h h h b bch. H
hb chc , wh
c h b c c b h. Ahh h j c
h c , w c w b bc .
A x c, Bw c h wh
b h bch J w wh h wh h
w wh bh h c h. Sh h ,
c h h , c h c
wh c cch h h . bh
h h w c Bw’ c.
bc hb h, wh h c chc . B 1966, Bw h c
cb, , ch wh h c. H h c
wh h bh h w c, b, cc
c.
B h , Bw h b h w -
h w ch M Cb c h c
w c, c. b w w h c
14. c b w, hc -
b h ch. O h cc h c F-
wh, Korom 2012.
15. h h h Bw’ Ac w wh
cc h S L c b h hc
xc h h. M bc cb h b -
ch c . I b h c h
sss h Bw b c wh h c Cb h
c h, whch Bw h c
cx h h .
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 9/23
frank Korom | 155
wh Bw h c. I, h w -
, w-c M bh h M M c.16
w hc Bh h b .
D h c c, h w c w c h hhc .
U h h H wh c h w ,
h w M w Bw S, M c
h x shaykh. I w h M c
Cb h h Sb S S
Cc, whch , h h cc c,
w b h b c.17 F
, h, Bw bc h J Cb K, h w c 1969 b h c
c w h U S.
he ree that Fell to the West
Hw h w, Ac c S
L M 1969. M w c c Phh h h . H h b b-
c wh h ch bc wh w h w
C. w h h b h ch’ ch-
h c w h cc
h h cc wh h xc w c h c h
w xc.18 w h b x-
16. O h cc h h M, MGilvray 1998. Fh M b h M c S L, Eendi 1982.
17. W h S , whch c
Bw’ ch , h c b h . w , hw-
, ch h h h c , bc
h w .
18. I c, h h c, w c b h,
xc, , h -c h bh. I , h
c wh w wh h w h -
w q, whch w b hc
b h ( Mauroo 1976, 48). M, Bw’ bc h
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 10/23
156 | O Shamans and Suis
c h h 1963 whch h c c. I w
h c Nw O h h Nb h h c
w h h b xc. A h c 2006,
“Eh , I w h hh . I w -, h h b, h.” H hb
hh h w h , b h h w ,
wh . Y , h w h w-
x Bw’ b:
I w , ch . bc
c. Th h b c ,
c. . Eh. N h, , ,
ch, b, h. hh h h, , c . I h wh w wh
b c b . bc , h w, wh
cc , . (Muaiyaddeen 1972, 249)
A c c h h :
A , h b w “” c x wh
w c. A h c , wh bc c. I
h, h w wh x h . Nh w,xc h c h h x. I w qc,
h c [sic] b b.
(Muaiyaddeen 1972, 249)
Rc b b, c wh, h
h c h, , “ c. O…
‘THERE IS ONLY ONE’… x h ‘I’ w, I w w h
w w wh xc j” (Muai-
yaddeen 1972, 249).19
Bc h xc w b, h w q h c
c wh h . “I cc,” h
w. “I b cb h O” (Muaiyaddeen 1972, 250).
h h ch, whch c cc
.
19. h h x. Nc h h c h -
q , whch h h xc c h q h
.
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 11/23
frank Korom | 157
A , h c wh h h, h
J. Sh h x h xc h:
A w b, [h xc] bc c b h b
h w . B h , h
c, ‘P c! P c!’ A h h w w
c. I h. I . A I w h I
wh h b xc, b I h I h
G. I c I c G.
(Muaiyaddeen 1972, 250)
I h h c ch h
w h q b h b xc h h
b Nw O.
Wh L, h cb. Sh c
h Phh wh cqc h b
wh w S L W Phh wh, , w
S ch h . S h w h
’ , c h , h ch-
’ . ch w h h G Bw. Sh w h
c q h c 21 Ocb 1969.
H h q 11 Nb 1969. R h “-,” h h h w b h h. Sh h 24
M 1970 b w h Bw “w,” h
w h h b wh h. I h h
h h h w V c w
, whch w c h h x. Sh h h
h x h h w.
I h w, h b c wh Bw, wh cb -
w c b h ch’ c. A h cc w bw 1969 1971. D h
, h c h w b c h b
h S L b wh h, c
cc w c h . Sh h
c h - h h c-
Bw h Phh. Hc,
1971, h h w “wh” -
b h Phh. T c , h c
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 12/23
158 | O Shamans and Suis
h h Bw Mh Fwh
h b h 11 Ocb 1971.
c h Fwh h
h ’ h , whch h w h W Phh. Bw c h , w b
c h h’ ch b h h w.
B h 1972 h h w ch h -
, whch Bw h , h c, h
, wh h x b h xc
c h c h h h h
. Bw’ , cc h c , w b-
c w ch w h c c- h .20
Kw hs gu ptcpt tth dgus, hs ctus
chs, d us tscdt pws cudg th hg tuch
dw d pp ut th hus cud g cc-
dt th t gup. Fwshp gduy gw g d pspus
ugh t puchs Jwsh cuty ct th utsts
th cty 1973 tht ws cvtd by th t cu hus wh
Bw’s “Ac y” cud sd ctby.21
Fwshp wscy gstd s t--pt gzt 1974, wth th g
dscvg th g d hud’s pups th. s
vt s th thd phs th vt’s sttutzt, th st
bg th stbsht hs cu th S L d th sc-
d bg th udg th Sdb Su Study Cc Cb. Wht
ws st cg th scgc ss ws “chuch,” ct pc
wshp, ctpt, d py t whch bs wud hv ccss.
A w , h c , Bw h “ch-
” b b q h Fwh h w c-
20. Hw, b h Fwh wh h c-
b b xc c- c b h cb
bc, whch Weer (1947, 324–91) b w
bh cc b. h h cc Mx-
, whch h, x c, b h h-
.
21. c c b w cq h Sh, h h
j whch h w b b.
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 13/23
frank Korom | 159
c M 1984. I h
c Bw’ Ac c , w hc
c c M.22 F h
h Phh h h 8 Dcb 1986, G Bw xc, bc h bw h
h Sh A h w cc q Phh.
D h h U S, h S L
, w b h Ac “” b
wh h.23 D h c bc, h - h Ac
ch b wh h c G H Mb, h
h c. c h h c c w
h h h h c c ch, h Bw’ c w, cc h h.24
D h h , h c
h b w b wh, w , h
w c h h h h c h w,
b h c h h. P
b h , Bw Phh h
h h h .
D h c hh, cc b c h h b h, h b h b ch
h h Fwh h wh h h
22. Phh h q c M c -
M, b Ac-Ac wh c I h
Bc Pw . O w Bw’ h, hw, Ac-Ac,
whch h wh h h Fwh.
Fwh q w h h c, hh h x
h c . M wh F h c Bw h ch, b c ; h ,
h, whch c . Oh b h ch h
S Abc h ch madrasa b Fwh b. O
Ac-Ac M Phh, MCloud 1996. O c b
Ac-Ac M , Curtis 2007.
23. h M 1972–Fb 1973; Fb 1974–J 1975;
Nb 1976–A 1978; Dcb 1980–Nb 1982.
24. c xc , w h h h c. R
cc h w F, h b h
c’ wc Bw’ ch b.
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 14/23
160 | O Shamans and Suis
h S L.25 H b w b h
Fwh h, whch w b E Fw-
, Ch c c c x
Phh.26 w ch b h Fwh 1973 Bw’ . H h c h ch
h 100-c c M c c
, h w hw c w c h
U S. A h b, h w b h h
h c wh h h w . O h c h
, h c h bc c
c Nh Ac Sh A.27 I h
h Bw’ c , c h h
h c, whch h b
hh c , , c.28
25. H w wh c h b h h
w h bh. Bw w h h , hh h
, cc wh w h w. Hw, h -
b w c b c b b h b h w.Bw cw h h h h h Fwh
b h h U S. I 16 Nb 1970, h c, “h
w w h c. B wh h c h
h h b h w. I c. I h h-
h wh b. Y, h ch h c
h ch h . Wh w bc c, , h, h
c bc h c h w ch h . , bh, wh h-
h. Oh h h, h ch h , h, .”
26. O wh bh Bw’ b b h c h h b
hw c. I c, x h c fw. E , h c h w wh w b h c, c-
b h ch.
27. B 1976 h Fwh b c 7,000
b, h b Fwh c h Bw h
x 10,000 “ch” ww. ’ c, hw, c
1,000 , whch h h b h b ch h
hh.
28. 14 Mch 2011 h w-h h ,
c wh b , c b P-
cw bc h .
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 15/23
frank Korom | 161
Closing Remarks
B h hhc c bw
2006 h h , I wh h hhb b chc S ch S L h c-
c h c h c shaykh
h h “ ” h c h U S
h 1960 1970, h w h b x
w A Ac , whch w h
bh h w .29 Acc w-
, Bw h 1973 w G Mhj
J b h H A h M73 , whch w . Wh Mhj J w b
h c h h h h
c h L h W, c h H
Kh.30 I h bh h M
ch, Bw c h ccc hc
hh, h , b b Ic
w S c, whch w c . B
h , h c ch h -c b fc
h h G, wh H c.
I , Bw Mh h “c”
h c h c h I
cb b. h h S L h, wh h -
h ( w ) c H ch S ,
29. Ellood (1994) b c h c Ac h-. I bq cqc b Roo 1999. I w,
Bw’ shaykh wh h Winkelman
(1990; 1992) h h h c- c
ch c cc ccc.
30. c wh h c h . H A-
c ch, c h h Phh q, c w Bw
h, wh h S L w c h Ac h c h.
R bw h Ac S L c, c h w
bc 1972 wh Bw w ch S L b h
c Phh. S Mauroo (1976, 29).
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 16/23
162 | O Shamans and Suis
chc b (, h, ,
h). c h cc wh h b h
b Cb wh h .
hhc, h hhc h w w w b h 1970 ( Bond 2003), b whch h c h
c, ch b h
bc . h h cc wh h h U S.
H h h c c, h
Nw A b h , whch -
-. E, hw, h c h
c Ic h c .31
w, whch c h w b bh, h w, w h h,
whch h h cc, h h,
whch cc wh G b cc,
, c wh G h
c bc c h c h “
.” Bw h H, Z, Ch,
I, ch whch c h
( We 1994).T ppct Bw’s pp, ust tc hs hstc dvpt
hs hub c ts t hs s tt . Wh dg
s, tcs vt tt d -dt pch
twd stuctud ud dstct gus g tg
y tuus s wth p-stbshd tdt wth Is. My g
pjct s t sh ut ths tst d t udstd hw
Bw cstty djustd hs tchgs t sut th ssbts hs chgg
udcs. s ctxt sstvty y b td Bw’s tchgs,
whch cud vy w hv b fucd by th Buddhst t su
s usd t tch t v cphsb t th dvdu studt.32
31. S h c Nw A cc -
. Heelas 1996 Hanegraa 1996, w x h Nw A, x,
wh . I h b c h w h
h c. S Wilson 1997.
32. h cc h h b x b ch .
Wh h c H Bh h c I H h
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 17/23
frank Korom | 163
Bc h chc h , h
h jc h fw h -
h -
hw h wh ’ ch h cc S c h
’ , b h , c, cc
wh h S L. M, I h h -
h h cc h
h . A I , w w h h
, whch wh Wb w c h
ch cc. I c Bw’ h h h ch
c bh, wh Bw’ c c w bc h b h ’ ch
hh h c b c c b bh-
, h c, x bh
b h ’ ch hh ,
ch bc h ch c
.33
q h b w , hw
w c bc bb w c bh h b h-
h cc cc
( h Fwh’ c h h h b chc)? M,
wh Bw h “h” h
h S L h U S, w h
h ccc c
S shaykh wh h Ic hx
ch c--ch c h ? Iw ch q, w h chc
Bw’ c, whch wh w c wh h
b x, h x x h fc h Bh
h h I, c , b Elverskog 2010 Sott 1995. O upāya (-
), Pye 2003.
33. I h c bbh h h ch, -
b bh b h Bw Mh Fwh P ccb
h ’ wb. S h://www.b.c/Sc/..
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 18/23
164 | O Shamans and Suis
h u, s I dscussd t th utst. T bg wth, Bw spt y
ys st, whch cspds t th sh’s “sty qust” ut-
d by Winkelman (1990). It ws dug ths sty qust tht Bw
bg t pctc th shc tchqus td bv, such s ud-ty dvg (chtg & sgg), stg (bstg d tgth),
d ustty (vg cvs d jugs wthut ps bggs).
I h Bw cc . w h w
x w h wh h w w h cc c-
, h w c , b c, whch
fh w cc. A Bw cb , h w h
c “G’ w.” Bw’ hc
h b q c. Bw b h c ,whch h w , , whch h wh
w h w, b h h h h.
B bb h , h bc hc w. D h
S L, h x h c cc c
ch c. H c h h w h wh w h -
c c h, whch h -
h w h. Oc h w c, h w b
cc x h w.Bawa, however, was a reluctant prophet, in the sense that he hesitated at
each major step in his career. It took him a ew years to make the commit-
ment to begin his ormal ministry in Jana, then it took him many more
to spread out to Colombo. It is said that when Bawa was invited to the
capital to ound the Serendib Su Study Circle, he balked, stating that he
eared he was a tree upon which too many people would perch. Interest-
ingly, his correspondence rom Colombo to Philadelphia indicates that he
was eager to leave the island or oreign terrain. It is not clear why, but
perhaps he was aware o the impending bloodshed that would occur once
ethnic confict and violence led to civil war.34 One thing is certain, though.
It took a certain amount o recruitment and cajoling by interested parties
to convince Bawa to make the moves that he did. Teir motivations, no
doubt, were based on sel-interest arising out o their observations o this
unique individual.
34. H w c h Bw c h w b b, h h
c h J w jw h c, c h h c.
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 19/23
frank Korom | 165
Wh h w T bh J w Bw w
bjc cc c
whch h w jc. Th c h,
cc W h, c - wh hw , , , c. Ahh
ch c ch c w q -h
, c h , c , h
cc. S h h S, h
h bw h, ch h h cq
hh h h ch-
hc. A , c h
c hh h w, b h h h h b h cc Nw A ch.35
qc h I h cc h -
b h b hw c S c
h, b hw h c. J W
h h h h c c-
ch, Bw h
c h c . B
b h c c x- , I h h h ch w cb q
c c h cc hw -
“c” “c,” h “chch”
c , w hw h w h bc
h c c
w.
Reerences
Amitai-Preiss, R., “S R h I h M h
Ih.” Journal o the Economic and Social History o the Orient 42
(1999): 27–46.
35. O h wh Sh Ac h h
h c Ac ch h h h -
bw h w. S Bron 1997.
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 20/23
166 | O Shamans and Suis
Atkinson, J. M., “Sh T.” Annual Review o Anthropology 21 (1992):
307–30.
Bond, G. D., “ C L M M L G
S L.” Religion 33 (2003): 23–55.Bron, K. M. Roerts, . Using Oral Sources: Vansina and Beyond . S-
c I Social Analysis (1980) 4: 3–130.
Bron, M. Te Channeling Zone: American Spirituality in an Anxious Age. C-
b, MA: H U P, 1997.
Centlivres, M. P. Centlivres, M. Sloin, “A M Sh Ah
T.” Ethnology 10 (1971): 160–73.
Cittik, W., “S.” I J. L. E, ., Encyclopedia o the Modern Islamic
World IV, 107–8. Nw Y: Ox U P, 1995.
Curtis IV, E. E., “I I Ac Ac M Cc: Bc M- h E h Ab C W.” American Quarterly 59 (2007):
683–709.
Duois, T. A. An Introduction to Shamanism. Nw Y: Cb U
P, 2009.
Eaton, R. M. Te Rise o Islam on the Bengal Frontier, 1204–1760. B: U-
Chc P, 1993.
Eendi, M. Personages o the Past: Moors, Malays, and Other Muslims o the Past.
Cb: M Ic C H, 1982.
Eliade, M. Shamanism: Archaic echniques o Ecstasy . Nw Y: PhB, 1964.
Ellood, R. S. he 60s Spiritual Awakening: American Religion Moving rom
Modern to Postmodern. Nw Bwc, NJ: R U P,
1994.
Elverskog, J. Buddhism and Islam on the Silk Road . Phh: U
P P, 2010.
Ernst, C. W. Te Shambhala Guide to Susm. B: Shbh Pbc,
Ic., 1997.
Hanegraa, W. J. New Age Religion and Western Culture: Esotericism in the Mir-ror o Secular Tought . L: E. J. B, 1996.
Heelas, P. Te New Age Movement: Te Celebration o the Sel and the Sacraliza-
tion o Modernity , Ox: Bcw Pbh, 1996.
Köprülü, M. F. Infuence du chamanisme turco-mongol sur les orderes mystiques
musulmans. Ib: Mé ’I Tc ’U-
é Sb, 1929.
Korom, F. J., “Ch C: A B H h Bw Mh-
Fwh.” Te Sri Lanka Journal o the Humanities 37 (2011):
19–33.
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 21/23
frank Korom | 167
________, “ Pc Abc: U S C Sh A
S M.” Austrian Academy o Sciences Working Papers in Social
Anthropology 23 (2012): 1–19.
________, “S wh S: D Wh Wh Ab Wh?” I C.C, ., Interreligious Dialogue and the Cultural Shaping o Reli-
gions, E, O: Cc B, 2012b.
Kugle, S. Sus and Saints’ Bodies: Mysticism, Corporeality, and Sacred Power in
Islam. Dh, NC: Nh C U P, 2007.
Lisitz, F., “B P G: ‘Hhc’ Tx Hc
N.” Viator 25 (1994): 95–113.
Lindolm, C., “Ph P: Chc I h M E
Sh A.” I P. Wb H. B, , Embodying Charisma:
Modernity, Locality and the Perormance o Emotion in Su Cults, 209–33. Nw Y: R, 1988.
Mauroo, M. Th C Exc L L
K, PhD. D, U P, 1976.
MCloud, A., “‘Th I M H:’ S Dc h Ac-
Ac Rw H.” I B. D. Mc, ., Making Muslim Space in
North America and Europe, 65–73. B: U C
P, 1996.
MGilvray, D. B., “Ab, M, M: S L M Ehc
R Pc.” Contributions to Indian Sociology 32 (1998):
433–83.
Millie, J. “Khq U-Ah Ac h R K: W-
S Hh I.” History o Religions 48 (2008):
43–65.
Moaddedi, J. “G D wh Ab Y S Sb wh J:
C P T S,” Bulletin o the School o Ori-
ental and Arican Studies 66 (2003): 1–13.
Muaiyaddeen, M. R. B. Te Divine Luminous Wisdom Tat Dispels the Dark-ness, Phh: Fwh P, 1972.
________. Te ree Tat Fell to the West: Autobiography o a Su. Phh:
Fwh P, 2003.
Narayan, B. K., R. Saney, . Dialogues o the Su Mystic Bawa Muhai-
yaddeen. Nw Dh: V Pbh H, 1999.
Peters, L., D. Prie-Williams, “Tw Ex A Sh-
.” American Ethnologist 7 (1980): 397–418.
Pye, M. Skilul Means: A Concept in Mahayana Buddhism. L: R,
2003.
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 22/23
168 | O Shamans and Suis
Renard, J. Friends o God: Islamic Images o Piety, Commitment, and Servanthood.
B: U C P, 2008.
Roo, W. C. Spiritual Marketplace: Baby Boomers and the Remaking o American
Religion. Pc, NJ: Pc U P, 1999.Sott, D., “Bh I: P P Ec Ih L-
.” Numen 42 (1995): 141–55.
Seleznev, A. G., S. A. Dudoignon, “L cé ch
Sbé cc.” Cahiers du Monde russe 41 (2000): 341–55.
Su’ay, T. Arabic, Arwi and Persian in Sarandib and amil Nadu. M:
I A T, 1993.
Sidky, M. H., “M, S, Mc: A Ehhc Hc S
Sh Ah.” Asian Folklore Studies 49 (1990): 275–
301.Siikala, A. Te Rite echnique o the Siberian Shaman. H: S
T Ac, 1978.
Snyder, B. H. Hc: Bw Mh Fwh h C
U, B. A. , B Mw C, 2003.
Taussig, M., “ N S: Hc D.” Stanord Humani-
ties Review 1 (1989): 44–81.
Vansina, J. De la tradition orale: Essai de methode historique. T: Mé
R ’Aq C, 1961.
________, “Oc U T: O T H Ac.” Daedalus 100 (1971): 442–68.
Von Gernet, A., “Nh Ac I Nc: U Tbcc Sh-
: E Dc Rc, 1520–1660.” I J. C. W,
., obacco Use by Native Americans: Sacred Smoke and Silent Killer ,
59–80. N: U Oh P, 2000.
We, G., “T I C Ac Ic S-
: Bw Mh Fwh.” I Y. Y. H J.
I. Sh, ., Muslim Communities in North America, 75–108. Ab,
NY: SUNY P, 1994.________, “Tch wh Pc: P Bw Mh.” I
J. R, ., Windows on the House o Islam, 290–296. B: U-
C P, 1998.
________, “-w S Ac h Bw Mh Fw-
h.” I J. M J. H, ., Susm in the West , 86–102. Nw
Y: R, 2006.
Weer, M. Te Teory o Social and Economic Organization. Nw Y: F
P, 1947.
________. From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology, Nw Y: R, 1948.
7/27/2019 Korom - Of Shamans and Sufis
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/korom-of-shamans-and-sufis 23/23
frank Korom | 169
Werner, P., Pilgrims o Love: Te Anthropology o a Global Su Cult . B-
: I U P, 2003.
Wilson, P., “ S F S h Nw A.” I P. B. C, ., New
rends and Developments in the World o Islam, 179–209. L: LcO, 1997.
Winkelman, M. J., “Sh Oh ‘Mc-R’ H: A C-
C S h O, N, Sc T.”
Ethos 18 (1990): 308–52.
________. Shamans, Priests and Witches: A Cross-Cultural Study o Magico-Reli-
gious Practitioners. A S U Ahc Rch
P. T: A S U, 1992.