LIFE WITH AN OLD MOTORSAILER

Lawrence Zeitlin

Motorsailers are a vanishing breed. Every year sees the dropping off of one or moremanufacturers from the field who, if not in actual Chapter 11, usually convert theirproduction lines to make tugboat trawler lookalikes. In the words of Rodney Dangerfield,"we moto-sailors don't get no respect."

In my area of the Lower Hudson there are only two true motorsailers in a fleet of severalhundred recreational boats, both made by Willard a full generation ago. The company hasrecently given up producing recreational boats in favor of craft for the military. Judgingby market demand, who can blame them.

It is hard to define a motorsailer. Francis Kinney, who revised "Skene's Elements ofYacht Design", gives a general rule that says a motorsailer is a yacht with enough enginepower to achieve hull speed AND enough sail power to claw off a lee shore. Insurancecompanies conclude that this requires at least a sail area equal to the LWL squared,divided by two. Thus a motorsailer with a 40 ft. LWL should, for insurance purposes,have at least 800 sq. ft. of sail area. Less than that and it is basically a powerboat withsteadying sails. Juan Baader, in "The Sailing Yacht" has a much more pragmatic rule. Hesays that if a yacht is faster under sail than under power it is an auxiliary poweredsailboat. On the other hand, if it is faster under power than under sail, it is a motorsailer.

All current motorsailers feature a pilothouse with full headroom and an internal helm. Infact this feature almost defines the class. Several manufacturers, including PacificSeacraft, build boats with identical hulls and differing deck moldings. Those with a pilothouse are called motorsailers, those without are called auxiliary powered sailboats. Thetype is much more popular in Northern Europe where typical boating conditions are suchthat most American yachtsmen would be heading for the nearest bar in search of a hottoddy.

Most motorsailer owners slip onto the class as a waystation between sailboats andtrawlers. They figure they can use their hard learned sailing skills in the air conditionedcomfort of a full powered trawler. They couldn't be more wrong. I've been there, I know!

A motorsailer has twice the maintenance problems of the average boat. Not only do youhave a full mechanical plant to agonize about but you also have sails and rigging toconsider. These take up space on deck and impose the ever present threat of getting hit bya wildly swinging boom when jibing about. Jibing, as I tell my non-sailing friends, isroughly the equivalent of backing your car into a garage. Easy when you know how butthe learning curve is full of dents and dings.

I have an older Willard Horizon motorsailer, PUFFIN, essentially the Willard 30 trawlerhull with a mast and sail. This 30' hull has been produced by Willard Marine, Inc. of

Anaheim, CA since the Jurassic, or at least since 1973. The hull was in production until2004 as the Willard Passagemaker 30, although like most of us, it had grown slightlyheavier with age. It has been fitted with a variety of topsides moldings ranging from acommercial fishing boat through a luxury liveaboard for people who are content to residein small spaces.

Figure 1. Puffin at anchor.

Puffin's LOA is 30 feet but the boat feels larger. The LWL is 27.5' with a displacement of16,000 lbs of which 4000 lbs is internal ballast. On my boat there is a wide, shortbowsprit and a full width stern boarding/swimming platform. Overall length betweenperpendiculars would be about 35 feet. The beam is nearly 11 feet and the draft a measly3'6" thanks to a full length broad keel. The hull shape is vaguely similar to a Colin Archerturn-of-the-century lifeboat with a high bow and a canoe stern. Like the Colin Archerdesigns, the Willard has very good sea keeping characteristics, a necessity since it cannotoutrun any storm. The rounded bottom gives it a tendency to roll in a beam sea, morethan harder chine trawlers, but not as much as most sailboats under power. It is certainlyseaworthy but not altogether comfortable in bad weather. Boat motion is excessive inbeam seas of 3' or more and it is unwise to have breakable crockery on the table or openbeer bottles on deck when passed by a powerboat.

Power is supplied by a Perkins 4-107 driving an 18" x 14" prop. The boat carries 260 sq.ft. of sail on a low aspect rig, a large foresail and a smaller main. This is only about halfthe sail that a cruising sailboat of similar specifications would carry and PUFFIN can beconsidered to be sailing under perpetually reefed conditions. It can best be considered a30/70 motorsailer.

Maneuverability under power is exceptional with the sailboat sized rudder, a 3.25 squarefoot half inch thick bronze plate mounted immediately behind the prop. The inertia isfairly high given the hull's mass but if you have the dexterity of a six ball juggler,manipulation of the engine controls and rudder will let you turn 360 degrees in the boat'sown length. This is convenient in crowded marinas.

The specifications were established when fiberglass construction techniques were still influx and err on the conservative side. Trawler mavins speak of the Willard as the "pocketbattleship" of trawlerdom and judged by solidity of construction, they are certainlycorrect.

Figure 2. Hull plan. Note large rudder and long shaft.

My boat is laid out like a cross between a cruising sailboat and a contemporary trawler. Ithas a conventional standing headroom forepeak with two sleeping berths. Immediately aftand up a couple of steps is the pilothouse with full engine controls and navigationalequipment. There is a complete electrical panel with circuit breakers for all onboardequipment and a 110v. distribution system for the infrequent times we use shore power.The engine lies below the pilothouse floor at about the midpoint of the hull. It is easy toreach by raising a hatch but all maintenance has to be undertaken with head hangingdownward. Not good for someone prone to headaches. Fuel is stored in two 60 gal. blackiron tanks on either side of the engine. The engine's central location requires a 13 footlong propeller shaft with two support bearings, each of which must be greased

periodically. There is little sound treatment and noise levels are fairly high under power.

Aft of the pilothouse is the main saloon with galley and sink to port and a table anddining area to starboard. The couch to the side of the table can be converted into a doublebed for friendly guests. There are plenty of storage areas and cabinets. Aft of the diningarea is the head and shower, small but adequate. Fresh water capacity is 100 gallons. Exitthe saloon by climbing a couple of steps and you are on the stern deck. There is sufficientspace for a small party, say 6 people. It's just about rignt for a summer barbeque but toosmall to host a school reunion unless you went to a very small school.. The water tanksand our LectraSan waste treatment system are in the lazarette below the stern deck. Thereis an additional large storage area there as well.

Figure 3. Interior layout.

Above the pilothouse is the upper steering and sailing rig control station. This is not thesame as a flying bridge on a conventional trawler. A seating area and foot well for thehelmsman are molded into the starboard side of the deck. A destroyer wheel is placedbefore the helmsman with a set of engine controls but no instruments. The mast isimmediately to the left on the center line of the boat. All sailing lines are led to thehelmsman and the boat can be sailed by only one person. Visibility is unexcelled butbecause the boom swings directly overhead, a bimini with adequate headroom isimpossible to fit while sailing. The helmsman gets wet when it rains. Sailingconveniences, as delivered, were minimal. We had to add cleats, winches, topping liftsetc. The boat could be sailed without this extra gear but it would not be fun.

The interior decor is more reminiscent of a very well appointed workboat, say the privateboat of the owner of a fishing fleet, rather than a floating boudoir. This is not a boat thatwas intended to appeal to the ladies. There is a lot of varnished teak inside and out andrelatively small ports. The Willard 30 hull permits only about 200 sq. feet of living space,about that of a Sing Sing jail cell. This means that the boat is too small to live oncomfortably for extended periods, particularly for those desiring a high degree of privacy.It is not an ideal marina bound family "summer home".

We have found that, compared to sailboats, the increased cabin space and relativelystable hull form make for comfortable cruising but the practice of sailing takes somerelearning. First, the drag of the prop is so great that sails alone move the boat at only 4 to5 knots in 15 knots of reaching winds. Pointing is similarly poor. Sailing closer than 60degrees to the wind is a chore. Under sail alone Puffin's performance is roughly on a parwith Columbus' caravels. We moto-sailers learn to sacrifice a lot for creature comforts.

Running the engine at a tick over speed of about 900 rpm (about 350 rpm at the prop)when sailing makes all the difference. This compensates for the drag of the largepropeller and provides enough prop wash to assist in turning the boat. Otherwise you willspend half an hour backwinding the jib and getting caught in irons (another best forgottennautical term) every time you try to come about. The slight motor assist also permits youto sail closer to the wind than you can in a conventional sailboat - and you can movefaster too. You can overtake sailboat racers in a light wind with a boat which looks likeTubby the Tugboat with a mast. Just remember to turn off the engine as you pass so theycan't see the tell tale exhaust, then make a quick turn downwind as if you've grown tiredof a contest too easily won. The embarrassed and confused sailors will spend the nexthalf hour fidgeting with their sails to see what has gone wrong.

Apart from such purile amusements, what is gained and lost with a motorsailer ascompared to a conventional motorboat or trawler. Well, as I said, the maintenance offersmore opportunities for worry and you have the nagging problem of the mast for winterstorage. Do you leave it up or down? The mast also inhibits your ability to pass under lowlying bridges and you find yourself consigned to the purdah of circling sailboats waitingfor hourly openings while boats with less elevation scoot through. On the other hand, yougain the confidence of an alternate means of propulsion. If your motor ever packs up, youcould eventually maneuver back to shore. This mitigates some of the obsession thatmotorboat owners have with fuel filtering, electrical malfunctions, and other power plantkilling gremlins. That, of course, and the confidence that sails provide unlimited range.Although it must be said that the wind, as an alternative source of power, leaves much tobe desired. It either blows in the wrong direction, doesn't blow at all, or provides an overabundence of propulsive effect in the form of gales, storms, and hurricanes.

But there are pluses. Motorsailers are, by and large, very attractive boats. Mostlandlubbers, and many yachtsmen too, equate boating with sails. Do tramp steamersattract as much admiration as Tall Ships? The necessity of mounting sail hardware sparesmost motorsailers from the futuristic design excesses of sedan cruisers. After all, whoneed tail fins at 8 knots? In almost every marina I've stopped at I've had people come upto me and compliment the looks of my 30 year old motorsailer. "It looks like a real boat,"they say. OK, so it can't go faster than a six year old on a tricycle - it's better to look goodthan perform good.

In addition to the inherent "get home" ability, there are several real functional advantagesof the motorsailer over a trawler of similar size. First, when compared to trawlers, thesails provide very good roll damping in beam winds and seas. I can ignore all the yacht

club bar discussions about active vs. passive damping, paravanes, flopper stoppers, etc.Who needs them? When the sails are up in a beam wind, my boat is rock steady, althoughit helps if your upwind leg is a few inches shorter than your downwind leg. And whenthose sails are up and the motor is going, fuel consumption drops to amazingly lowlevels. I am grateful that with fuel prices climbing to the stratosphere, I can squeeze anentire season's cruising of about 1000 miles out of one fill of diesel fuel. If I were toattempt a circumnavigation (fat chance) I would choose a motorsailer for that fact alone.

Most motorsailers have less draft than sailboats of comparable size, opening up manymiles of previously risky shoreline. This includes much of the eastern Chesapeake, theFlorida Keys and the coastal Carolinas. I don't know about the West coast but I'm surethere are plenty of shallow, but desirable, areas. The easily lowered sailing rig makescanal cruising relatively simple. I can drop the mast single handed in about five minutes.This converts my motorsailer into a somewhat awkward trawler. I have the New Yorkcircumnavigation Little Loop (Hudson, Erie Canal, St. Lawrence, Lake Champlain, backto the Hudson) and the eastern US Big Loop (ICW, Hudson, Erie Canal, Great Lakes,Mississippi, Tenn/Tom, Gulf coast, Florida, and back to the ICW) at my disposal.Sailboats, with their masts and lower powered engines, can make these trips but with fargreater difficulty.

A motorsailer presents somewhat less challenge to basic seamanship skills. Ample powerturns contrary winds into a mere inconvenience. You can even plan trips and meet aschedule, something virtually impossible to do when sailing. My dedicated sailing friendsaccuse me of copping out but I remind them that I have already paid my dues.

The Willard's forte is extended cruises to remote anchorages for a reasonably adventurouscouple. Here the seaworthiness and self contained nature of the boat pay off. It's size andpower requirements make for economical operation and a long range. The dimensions ofthe boat and conservative nature of the mechanical plant permit most maintenance to becarried out by the owner.

The Willard's quality of construction is generally good. The very solid hull molding, theinner liner, and the deck molding are well bonded together for a very rigid structure. Likemany factory made boats, the mechanical components are inserted during constructionand access for repair or replacement is minimal. Most owners who have repowered theirboats report that considerable surgery has to be performed to get at all the bits and pieces.Fortunately the mechanical parts are conservatively rated and last a long time.

The older Willard hulls are susceptable to osmotic blistering. This seems to becharacteristic of many boats made during the 70s. The gel coat on my boat shows anoverall superficial craze of fine cracks. I was told by a factory engineer that the earlyseries hulls were constructed of the same plastic used for military specification boats.Willard supplied many of the craft used to pacify the Mekong Delta during the Vietnamwar and halogen salts were incorporated into the resin as fire retardants. Unfortunatelythe salts also absorbed water. Obviously Navy combat and surf boats were never intendedto last 30 years. We have repaired over 300 blisters below the waterline, some up to 4" in

diameter. There are numerous small gel coat blisters above the waterline but since theypose little structural threat they have been largely ignored. The final fix, total belowwaterline repair with 6 layers of Interprotect epoxy barrier coat, seems to be holding andonly a few new blisters emerge each year.

Barring the annoying blistering and crazing problem, the Willard 30 motorsailer is justfine for a retired couple who want to experience the cruising life style without selling theold homestead and moving aboard. It is small enough to keep the costs reasonable,especially for a handyman, yet large enough to take any coastal voyage imaginable. It ismore comfortable than our previously owned sailboats and provides almost enough roomto swing a very small cat. My wife and I have lived aboard a month at a time and stillspeak to each other.

The basic problem of the motorsailer is that it requires a psychological straddle on thepart of the owner. Sailboat owners find pleasure in the process of sailing. Trawler ownersare much more goal oriented. They find pleasure in the destination. A motorsailerrequires that the skipper possess the attitudes and skills of the power community some ofthe time and those of the sailng community some of the time and mix the two the rest ofthe time. Most owners lean one way or the other. Comparatively few owners seek themiddle ground.

Besides, sailing a motorsailer gives me sails to fiddle with on those long boring passages.Who knows what trouble I might get into if I didn't have that diversion?

Too bad motorsailers are a vanishing breed.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------Lawrence Zeitlin12 Brook LaneCortlandt Manor, NY 10567

914-737-4905

lrzeitlin@aol.com