59
Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS, RD, CDE Nutrition Concepts by Franz, Inc – Minneapolis, MN Moderator: James M. Rippe, MD – Leading cardiologist, Founder and Director, Rippe Lifestyle Institute Approved for 1 CPE (Level 2) by the Commission on Dietetic Registration, credentialing agency for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. NUTRI-BITES ® Webinar Series

Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes

November 14, 2013

Presenters:

Marion J. Franz, MS, RD, CDENutrition Concepts by Franz, Inc – Minneapolis, MN

Moderator:James M. Rippe, MD – Leading cardiologist, Founder and Director,

Rippe Lifestyle Institute

Approved for 1 CPE (Level 2) by the Commission on Dietetic Registration, credentialing agency for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics.

NUTRI-BITES®

Webinar Series

Page 2: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Webinar logistics CEUs – a link to obtain your personalized Continuing

Education Credit certificate will be emailed within 2 days.

A recording of today’s webinar, slides, and summary PowerPoint will be available to download as a PDF within 2 days at: www.ConAgraFoodsScienceInstitute.com

The presenter will answer questions at the end of this webinar. Please submit questions by using the ‘Chat’ dialogue box on your computer screen.

Page 3: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

ConAgra Foods Science Institute With a mission of:

Promoting dietary and related choices affecting wellness

by linking evidence-based understanding

with practice

Page 4: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Today’s Faculty

Marion J. Franz, MS, RD, CDENutrition Concepts by Franz, Inc – Minneapolis, MN

Moderator:James M. Rippe, MD – Leading cardiologist,

Founder and Director, Rippe Lifestyle Institute

Page 5: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Learning Objectives

List expected outcomes from diabetes nutrition therapy and when to evaluate outcomes

Discuss the role of weight loss therapy across the continuum of diabetes

List goals and evidence-based nutrition therapy priorities for type 1 and type 2 diabetes

State evidence to support macronutrient intake recommendations for diabetes

Select appropriate nutrition therapy interventions for persons with diabetes

NUTRI-BITES®

Webinar Series

Page 6: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of

Diabetes

Marion J. Franz, MS, RD, [email protected]

Page 7: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Is Diabetes Nutrition Therapy Effective?• Pre-diabetes outcomes

– Nutrition therapy along with physical activity ↓ risk of type 2 diabetes by 58%; maintained up to 14 yrs

• Diabetes outcomes– Nutrition therapy provided by RDs: ave.↓ in

A1C 1% to 2% (ranging from 0.5 to 2.6%) depending on type, duration, and level of control of db

– LDL-C ↓ by 15-25 mg/dl or by 7-22%– SBP and DBP ↓ on average by ~5 mmHg– Outcomes known by 6 weeks to 3 months

Evert AB, et al. Diabetes Care 2013:36(11); Acad Nutr Diet. EAL.www.andevidencelibrary.com

Page 8: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

United Kingdom Prospective Diabetes Study:A1C (pts newly diagnosed)

6

7

8

9

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15YEARS

GLY

CO

HEM

OG

LOB

IN (H

bA1c

, %)

INTENSIVE GROUP

CONVENTIONAL GROUP

UKPDST. Lancet 1998; 352: 837-853

Page 9: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Early ACTID (Early Activity in Diabetes)• Newly diagnosed type 2 db (n=593) in

England, usual care vs intensive nutrition intervention with or without a physical activity program– Baseline A1C: 6.7%, 6.6%, 6.7%– 6 mo maintained to 12 mo: no improvement in

usual care, intervention groups A1C -0.3% (p<0.001), even with use of fewer diabetes drugs

– Addition of physical activity: no added benefitAndrews et al. Lancet 378:129, 2011

Page 10: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Lifestyle Over and Above Drugs in Diabetes (LOADD) Study

• RCT in 93 pts type 2 db hyperglycemic (A1C>7%) despite optimized drug therapy

• Intensive MNT according to international nutrition management guidelines vs control

– Ave duration of db: ~9 yrs

– Intensive MNT—6 sessions with dietitian

– A1C ↓ 0.4% vs control (P=0.007); comparable to adding new drug to conventional agents; cost-effective

Coppell KJ et al. BMJ 2010; 341:c3337

Page 11: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

FIIT (Flexible Intensive Insulin Therapy) Using Insulin-to CHO Ratios

• Dose Adjusted for Normal Eating (DAFNE):– A1C ↓ 1% with no increase in severe hypoglycemia and

quality of life ↑– 44-mo follow-up: continued improvement in A1C and

quality of life– Concerns of excessive or unhealthy eating not observed;

minimal eating changes made and some became more rigid in their eating habits

• Training programs in Germany (3-yr) and Australia (1-yr): improvements in A1C without increasing risk of hypoglycemia

•DAFNE Study Group. BMJ 325:746, 2002; Speight. Diabetes Res Clin Pract 89:22, 2010; Lawton. Diabetes Res Clin Pract 91:87, 2011; Samann. Diabetologia 48:1965, 2005; Lowe. Diabetes Res Clin Pract 80:439, 2008

Page 12: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

What Nutrition Therapy Interventions Are Effective?• A variety of nutrition therapy interventions, such

as reduced energy/fat intake, carbohydrate counting, simplified meal plans, healthy food choices, exchange choices, insulin-to-carbohydrate ratios, physical activity, and behavioral strategies

– Type 2 db: reduced energy intake

– Type 1 db: matching insulin to CHO intake

• A number of initial individual or group sessions and follow-up encounters were implemented

Acad Nutr Diet. www.andevidencelibrary.com/topic.cfm?=3252

Page 13: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

100

200150

300250

350

-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25 300

100

200

50

150

*Postprandial glucose

Fasting glucose

Insulin resistance

Insulin level

Years

At risk fordiabetes β-cell dysfunction

250

Glucose(mg/dL)

%Relative

to Normal

Type 2 Diabetes: A Progressive Disease

* Post Prandial = 1-2 h ppgBergenstal RM et al. Management of Type 2 Diabetes in Endocrinology. 4th Edition; Philadelphia, 2001

BG remains normal until insulin deficiency

Page 14: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Type 2 Diabetes: A Progressive Disease

LifestyleInterventions

Nutrition Therapy Alone

orwith Medications

Nutrition Therapy Medications

Insulin

Lifestyle

Meds

Franz. Am J Lifestyle Med 1:327, 2007

Page 15: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

The Dilemma of Weight Loss in Diabetes• “Diet” doesn’t fail—the beta cells of the pancreas fail

• Insulin resistance

– Modest amounts of weight loss (and physical activity) can prevent or delay type 2 diabetes

– Weight loss may improve risk factors

• Insulin deficiency

– Focus is on nutrition strategies for normalization of blood glucose levels, lipids and blood pressure

– Results on glucose will be known by 6 weeks to 3 months

Page 16: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

What is Known About Weight Management?

• At ~6 months individuals can lose 5% to 10% of their starting weight

• Regardless of the intervention, plateaus and regain of weight loss are expected; compensatory mechanisms protect against weight loss

• If treatment is discontinued, weight gain occurs

• With support, modest weight loss can be maintained

Page 17: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Average Weight Loss Per Subject Completing a Minimum 1-Yr Intervention

80 studies; 26,455 subjects; 18,199 completers (69%)

-20

-18

-16

-14

-12

-10

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

2

1 2 3 4 5 6

Wei

ght L

oss

(kg)

Exercise AloneDiet + ExerciseDiet AloneMeal ReplacementsVLCDOrlistatSibutramineAdvice Alone

6-mo 12-mo 24-mo 36-mo 48-mo•Franz et al. J Am Diet Assoc. 2007;107:1736

Franz et al. J Am Diet Assoc. 2007;107:1736

Page 18: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Why Weight Loss Is Difficult?• Genetics - ~50% of variance genetics and 50%

environment• Weight tightly regulated by neural, hormonal,

and metabolic factors– Hormonal adaptations (↓ leptin, peptide YY,

cholecystokinin, insulin, and ↑ ghrelin, gastric inhibitory polypeptide, pancreatic polypeptide) that encourage weight gain after diet-induced weight loss remain 1-yr after initial weight reduction

– Weight loss results in adaptive thermogenesis (↓ resting metabolic rate) up to 1-yr

Sumithran et al. N Eng J Med 365:1597, 2011; Camps et al. Am J Cl Nutr 2013;97:990

Page 19: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

What Are The Benefits From Modest Weight Loss (~5% of Initial Weight)?

• Prevention or delay of type 2 diabetes

• Decreases in systolic and diastolic blood pressure in dose-dependent fashion

• Decreases in circulating inflammatory markers (C-reactive protein and cytokines)

• Potential improvement in triglyceride levels, total and LDL cholesterol

Klein et al. Circulation 110:2952-2967, 2004

Presenter
Presentation Notes
AHA Scientific Statement Insulin sensitivity, in regard to glucose metabolism, improves rapidly after beginning an energy-deficit diet and before much weight loss occurs. Weight loss decreases both systolic and diastolic blood pressure in a dose-dependent manner. Weight regain results in a steady increase in BP toward baseline. Obesity is associated with an increase in circulating inflammatory markers, including C-reactive protein (CRP) and cytokines (interleukin-6 [IL-6], IL-19, and P-selectin). Adipose tissue is the likely source of these excess cytokines, and IL-6 stimulates the release of CRP by the liver. The greatest relative improvements in serum TG and LDL usually occur within the first 2 months of weight loss. Sustained weight loss of >5% is needed to maintain decrease in triglyceride levels; total and LCL cholesterol revert toward baseline if a >10% weight loss is not maintained Although weight loss modifies many cardiovascular disease risk factor, it is not known whether weight reduction decreased CVD events or CVD mortality in obese persons. Data from the Swedish Obese Subjects study showed that despite a greater reduction in weight and CVD risk factors after surgical than medical therapy for obesity, no difference in cardiovascular disease events or mortality was found at 10 years.
Page 20: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Change in Body Weight and Prevention/Delay of Type 2 Diabetes

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

2

4

0 1 2 3 4

Placebo

Metformin

Intensive Lifestyle

•Cha

nge

from

Bas

elin

e•B

ody

Wei

ght (

kg)

•Years after Randomization

•Base BW (kg)•94.3•94.3•94.1

•The Diabetes Prevention Program Research Group. N Eng J Med. 2002;346:393

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Intensive lifestyle intervention led to the greatest loss in body weight. On average, the weight loss was greatest in the first year. Among subjects taking metformin, there was a modest weight loss over the course of the study. Average weight loss was 5.6 kg (12 lb) in the lifestyle group, 2.1 kg (5 lb) in the metformin group, and 0.1 kg (<1 lb) in the placebo group (P<0.001). It is important to note that the average weight loss in the DPP (and other studies) was small, approximately 10-15 pounds, and regain also occurred, but despite this, efficacy of such moderate weight loss was dramatic. People who started out classified as “obese” would still be classified as “obese.” Therefore, realistic weight goals should be identified with patients and emphasize that thinness is not the goal.
Page 21: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Comparison of Weight-Loss Diets with Different Percentages of Fat, Protein, and Carbohydrates• 811 adults (80% completers) randomized to 15%

vs 25% protein, 20% vs 40% fat, 35% vs 65% CHO diets

– At 6 mo subjects in each diet group lost an ave of 6 kg (7%) and began to regain weight after 12 mo

– At 2-y, all completers lost an ave of 4 kg

– Satiety, hunger, satisfaction with diet, and attendance at group sessions similar for diets

– All diet improved lipid-related risks, fasting insulin levels, and ↓ BP 1-2 mm Hg

Sacks et al. N Engl J Med 2009;360:859

Page 22: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Conclusions from Comparison of Weight Loss Diets

• Calories count—not macronutrients!!

• Multiple encounters are needed (59 group and 13 individual counseling sessions offered)– Attendance at group sessions predicted weight loss at 2-y

– Attendance at 2/3 of the sessions = 9 kg weight loss

• “Any type of weight loss diet taught with enthusiasm and persistence can be effective.”

• “Thus, even these highly motivated, intelligent participants who were coached by expert professionals could not achieve the weight losses needed to reverse the obesity epidemic.”

Katan MB. N Engl J Med 2009;360:923

Page 23: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

What Have We Learned About Weight Loss?• Health care professionals do not prescribe drugs

not proven to be efficacious, yet they write and recommend diet books not proven to be effective

• It’s reduced energy intake and continued support that’s important not macronutrients

• Weight loss diets are not likely to reverse the obesity epidemic, but—

• Modest weight loss/maintenance and increased physical activity have important health benefits!!

Page 24: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Weight Loss Intervention Studies in Type 2 Db• Systematic Review: 1-yr study duration; 70%

completion rate; 2000 to 2013

• 11 studies (5 >1-yr): 8 compared weight loss interventions (WLI) and 3 compared WLI to usual care or control (19 WLI groups)

• Weight, AlC, lipid, and BP effectiveness

• Weight losses 1.9-8.4 kg at 1-yr

– 17 interventions -1.9 to 4.8 kg

– Mediterranean-style -6.2 kg; ILI -8.4 kg

– Low carbohydrate -1.9 kg

Franz. Diabetes Spectrum. 2013;26:145-151

Presenter
Presentation Notes
(
Page 25: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Weight Change Outcomes

-10-8-6-4-20

6 mo 12 mo 18 mo 2 yr 3 yr 4 yr

Kg

Usual Care/Control (3)n=2,709Meal Replacements (2)n=102Individualized Food Plan(2) n=109Group Behavioral Wt Mgmt(2) n=217High-CHO (3) n=310

Low-CHO (2) n=85

Low-Fat (3) n=188

High MUFA (1) n=43

High-Protein (2) n=260

MED (1) n=108; 6 mo datanot availableILI (1) n=2,570; 6 mo datanot available

Average Weight Loss/Maintenance in Persons with Type 2 Diabetes (11 studies; 6,710 participants)

Page 26: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Systematic Review cont. • 8 WLI improved A1C at 1-yr

– Meal replacements, behavioral at 12 mo but not at 18 mo; high CHO, high protein, low-fat, MED, ILI

– 3 with PA: MED ↓ 1.2%; ILI ↓ 0.6%; low-fat ↓ 0.6%

• 11 WLI reported NS changes in A1C at 1-yr– Individualized food plan; soy-meal replacement; high-

MUFA; high-CHO; low-fat; high-protein

• Majority NS changes in lipids (10 ↑ HDL0

• 7 WLI improved BP; 7 NS changes in BP

Page 27: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Systematic Review cont. • 5 studies compared macronutrients (all

reported similar weight changes)– High MUFA vs high CHO (-4.0 vs -3.8 kg)

– Low CHO vs low fat (2) (-3.1 vs -3.1 kg; -1.9 vs -3.9 kg)

– High protein vs high CHO (2) (-3.2 vs 2.4 kg; 2.2 vs 2.2 kg)

• 8 WLI reported NS changes in A1C from baseline at 1-yr; 2 (1 high-protein, 1 high-CHO) reported improvement (-.2%)

•Brehm et al. Db Care. 2009;32:215; Davis et al. Db Care 2009;32:1147; Larsen et al. Diabetologia 2011l54:731; Krebs et al. Diabetologia 2012;55:905; Guldbrand et al. Diabetologia. 55:2118, 2012

Page 28: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Intensive Lifestyle Intervention (ILI) in Look AHEAD Trial: 1-y and 4-y Results

• Objective: Can long-term weight reduction reduce CVD morbidity and mortality in persons with type 2 db? Trial stopped early in September 2012

• 5,145 subjects, 16 centers, RCT; ILI vs db education; planned to extend for ~11.5 y– Weight loss at 1-y: 8.6% (ILI) vs 0.7%

– Weight loss at 4-y: 6.1% (ILI) vs 0.9%

– A1C at 1-y: ↓ from 7.3 to 6.6% (ILI) vs 7.3 to 7.2%

– A1C at 4-y: 7.0% (ILI) vs 7.2%

– Seen 3-4/mo yr 1; seen or contacted 2/mo yrs 2-4; meal replacements

The Look AHEAD Research Group. Diabetes Care 2007;30:1374; Arch Intern Med 2010;170:1566

Page 29: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Look AHEAD Trial Summary• Trial stopped in Sept. 2012 by NIH after 9.6 yrs:

– “ILI did no harm but was not on a trajectory that would result in greater decreases in CV events relative to control”

– Wt loss at study end: 6.0% vs. 3.5%– Greater ↓ in A1C (7.3% vs. 7.4%) and greater

improvements in fitness and CV risk factors (except LDL)

• “An ILI focusing on weight loss did not reduce the rate of CV events in overweight or obese adults with T2DM.”

•The Look AHEAD Research Group. N Engl J Med. 2013;369:145

Page 30: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Summary of WLI in Diabetes• The ILI and MED (both included PA and pts in

MED were newly diagnosed) WLI reported improvements in A1C, lipids, and BP

• All other WLI interventions reported minimal, if any, beneficial effects on A1C, lipids, and BP

• A weight loss of >6 kg (7-8.5%), regular physical activity, and frequent contact with RDs appears necessary for consistent beneficial effects

• How to achieve this weight loss in clinical practice remains unknown

Page 31: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Why doesn’t weight loss always lead to improved glycemia?

• Usual weight loss therapies do not lead to adequate weight loss

OR

• Persons are primarily insulin deficient—need medications to be combined with nutrition therapy

• OR

• Energy restriction leads to improved glycemia, not weight loss per se

Page 32: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Carbohydrate

• There is no most effective mix of carbohydrate, protein, and fat that applies broadly; macronutrient proportions should be individualized and adjusted to meet metabolic goals and individual preferences of the person with diabetes.

• Monitoring carbohydrate, whether by carbohydrate counting, choices, or experience-based estimation, remains a key strategy in achieving glycemic control.

•Evert AB. Diabetes Care 2013;36:3821-3842

Page 33: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Macronutrients and InsulinEffect Carbohydrates Protein Fat

Transport Activates the transportsystem of glucose into muscle and adipose cells

Lowers blood amino acids in parallel with blood glucose levels

Activates lipoprotein lipase, facilitating transport of triglycerides into adipose tissue

Anabolic (promotesstorage)

Facilitates conversionof glucose to glycogen for storage in liver and muscle

Stimulates protein synthesis

Facilitates conversion of pyruvate to free fatty acids, stimulating lipogenesis

Anticatabolic(prevents breakdown)

Decreases breakdown and release of glucose from glycogen in the liver

Inhibits protein degradation, diminishes gluconeogenesis

Inhibits lipolysis, prevents excessive production of ketones and ketoacidosis

Page 34: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

0

10

20

30

40

50

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24

Normal Insulin Secretion •S

erum

insu

lin (m

U/L

)

•Hours

Meal Meal Meal

Basal Insulin Needs

Bolus insulin needs

•Kendall DM. N Engl J Med 322:898, 1990

Page 35: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Insulin by Injection or Pump

• Bolus or mealtime insulin dose covers need of carbohydrate for insulin (~1/2 of total insulin dose)

• Basal or background insulin dose covers need for protein and fat for insulin and other insulin needs (~1/2 of total insulin dose)

Page 36: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

• High- (55%) and low- (40%) carbohydrate diets were compared in intensively treated persons (protein and fat similar)

• Amount of carbohydrate in the meal does not effect acute glycemic control, if premeal insulin is adjusted appropriately

• Premeal insulin algorithms are valid; variations in carbohydrate do not modify basal insulin– 1.5 U/10 g CHO at breakfast

– 1 U/10 g CHO at lunch and dinner

• Variations in meal glycemic index, fiber, or caloric intake do not influence premeal insulin

Rabasa-Lhoret et al. Diabetes Care. 1999;22:667

Adjusting Premeal insulin Based on Carbohydrate Amounts

Page 37: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Dietary Fat: Glucose Response and Insulin Requirements in Type 1 Diabetes

• 50 g fat added to dinner (HF) with 10 g fat and identical CHO and protein amounts using a closed-loop system (CGM and a physiologic insulin delivery algorithm– HF meal needed more insulin (12.6 vs 9.0 units)– Despite added insulin glucose AUC higher and higher

insulin levels 5 to 10 hr after the meal– No effect on breakfast glucose and insulin

•Wolpert et al. Diabetes•Care 36:810, 2013

Page 38: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

• Diet books define GI as measure of how rapidly a food raises blood glucose after eating

• Claims made by diet books:– “Foods that are broken down and

absorbed into the blood stream quickly require a lot of insulin…

– High levels of insulin cause blood glucose to drop so low that it triggers new cravings for food.”

• No evidence given for these claims

• This is NOT the correct definition of the GI

Agatston A. The South Beach Diet, 2005

How Important is the Glycemic Index of Food?

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Reference: Agatston A: The South Beach Diet Good Fats Good Carbs Guide. Emmaus, PA, Rodale Inc., 2005.
Page 39: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

80

90

100

110

120

130

140

150

160

170

0 15 30 45 60 75 90 120

Bread Med GI GlucoseBread Low GI Bread High GI

Time (min)

Glu

cose

mg/

dL)

Glycemic Index: The GI Does Not Measure How Rapidly BG Increases!

The GI is the relative area under the postprandial glucose curve (AUC) comparing 50 g of digestible carbohydrate from a test food to 50 g of glucose

Brand-Miller et al. Am J Clin Nutr 2009;89:97

80

90

100

110

120

130

140

150

160

170

0 15 30 45 60 75 90 105 120

Glucose Fruit Juice Fruit

“No statistical difference in the glucose response curve from different foods…Low GI foods do not produce a slower rise in BG nor do they produce an extended, sustained glucose response.”

Page 40: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

ADA Macronutrient Review: GI and Carbohydrate Summary

• In general, there is little difference in glycemic control and CVD risk factors between low GI and high GI or other diets. Slight improvement in glycemia from lower GI diets confounded by higher fiber intake.

• Majority of individuals with diabetes have a moderate intake of carbohydrate (~45% of kcal); difficult to eat a high (or low) CHO diet

• Negotiate with patients; advise healthful CHO choices in appropriate amounts and portion sizes

•Wheeler et al. Diabetes Care 2012;35:434

Page 41: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Is Fiber Beneficial?• Diets containing 44 to 50 g fiber daily have been

shown to have beneficial effects on glycemia; more usual amounts (up to 24 g/d) have not

• It is not known if such high levels of fiber intake can be maintained long term

• Diets high in total and soluble fiber can reduce total cholesterol by 2-3% and LDL-C up to 7%

• Recommendations for fiber for people with diabetes are the same as for the general public

Lafrance L et al. Diabetes Med 1998;15:972; Giacco R et al. Diabetes Care 2000;23:1461; Hollenbeck CB et al. Am J Clin Nutr 1986;43:16; Chandalia M et al. N Engl J Med2000;342:1392; Brown L et al. Am J Clin Nutr 69:30, 19990; American Diabetes Association. Diabetes Care. 2009;32(Suppl 1):S23; American Dietetic Association. www.adaevidencelibrary.com/topic.cfm?format_tables=0&cat=3252

Page 42: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Focus on Carbohydrate • Carbohydrate Counting useful for all

persons with diabetes• Emphasizes total amount of

carbohydrate not the source• Based on 3 food groups:

– Carbohydrate– Protein (meat and meat substitutes)– Fat

Page 43: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Carbohydrate Counting• Sources of carbohydrate

are starches, fruits, milk, and desserts

• One carbohydrate serving = 15 grams of carbohydrate

• Most fresh vegetables are “free foods”

Page 44: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Carbohydrate Counting Recommendations

• Start with 3 to 4 servings per meal for women, 4 to 5 for men; 1 to 2 for a snack

• Emphasize day-to-day consistency• Test post-meal; goal blood glucose <160-

180 mg/dL

Page 45: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Carbohydrate: What’s Important?• Foods containing carbohydrate from fruits,

vegetables, whole grains, legumes, and low-fat milk are important sources of vitamins and minerals and provide glucose for the brain

• No ideal percentage of macronutrients, total energy more important than CHO amount

• Monitoring total intake of carbohydrate is key strategy for achieving glycemic control

• Negotiate with patients; advise healthful CHO choices in appropriate amounts and portion sizes

Evert AB. Diabetes Care 2013;36:3821; Wheeler et al. Diabetes Care 35:434-445, 2012;•AmDietAssoc. www.adaevidencelibrary.com/topic.cfm?=3252

Page 46: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Protein and Diabetes • In persons with type 2 diabetes, ingested protein

does not increase plasma glucose levels but does increase insulin response

– Therefore, protein should not be used to treat hypoglycemia or to prevent hypoglycemia

• In persons with normal renal function, usual protein intake (15-20%) does not need to be changed

• In persons with DKD (either micro- or macroalbuminuria), reducing the amount of protein is not recommended as this does not alter the course of the GFR decline

Evert AB. Diabetes Care 2013;36:3821; Wheeler et al. Diabetes Care 35:434, 2012; Acad Nut Diet. J Am Diet Assoc 110;1852, 2010

Page 47: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Glucose and Insulin Response to 50 g Glucose, 50 g Protein, or Combination in Type 2 Diabetes

• Glucose response stable with protein alone• Glucose peak response the same when protein given

with glucose• Insulin response double when protein combined with

glucose

Nuttall et al. Diabetes Care 7:465, 1984

50 g protein

50 g glucose

combined

Page 48: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Glucose Appearance and Insulin Response to 50 g Protein or Water in Type 2 Diabetes

• 50 g protein (very lean beef) or water at 8 am and followed for 8 hrs

• Protein deaminated, ~20-23 g (changed into glucose in the liver)

• Amount of glucose appearing in circulation, >2 g• Protein ingestion increased insulin levels

Gannon et al. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 86:1040, 2001

water

protein

Page 49: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

• In animal and observational studies, higher intakes of total dietary fat, regardless of the fat type, produce greater insulin resistance

• In clinical trials saturated and trans fats shown to cause insulin resistance, whereas mono- and polyunsaturated and omega-3 fatty acids do not have an adverse effect

• High fat meals interfere with indexes of insulin signaling which results in a transient increase in insulin resistance

Louheranta, 2000; Riccardi, 2000; Denkins, 2002; Lovejoy, 2002; Trichopoulou, 2005

Dietary Fats and Diabetes

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Majority of studies in animals and observational studies in humans have reported a relationship between total dietary fat, regardless of the type of fat, and greater insulin resistance. High intakes of dietary fat, particularly saturated fat, are associated with a decline in insulin sensitivity. In animal studies (relatively short-term studies), an increase in fat, even without an increase in calories, leads to insulin resistance. Studies in humans are equivocal. Clinical trials in subjects without diabetes (n=6) comparing high- and low-fat diets from 3 days to 4 weeks (weight kept constant), demonstrate that low-fat diets cause significant improvements in insulin sensitivity. Other studies (n=3) did not observe any difference between high- and low-fat diets on insulin sensitivity. (Lovejoy JC. Current Diabetes Reports. 2:435, 2002) Type of fat effect may come about via changes in membrane lipid profile. Trichopoulou In a multicenter, prospective cohort study of elderly subjects (74,607 men and women, aged 60 or more) in 9 European countries in which a Mediterranean type diet that substituted polyunsaturated for monounsautrated fats reported adherence to the Mediterranean diet resulted in a 7% reduction in mortality. Polyunsaturated fats were as beneficial as monounsatured fats. (Trichopoulou et al. BMJ 330:991, 2005)
Page 50: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Prioritizing Nutrition Messages

Nutrition Therapy &

PhysicalActivity

Emphasize blood glucose, lipid, and BP control

Reduced energy intake/ carbohydrate foods, number of servings per meal

Encourage physical activity

Use food records with blood glucose monitoring data

Page 51: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

What’s the best nutrition therapy intervention for diabetes?

Page 52: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

In An “Ideal” World• People with type 2 diabetes:

– Lose 5% to 10% of baseline weight– Eat a nutrient dense eating pattern in

appropriate portion sizes– Participate in 150 min/wk of regular physical

activity• People with type 1 diabetes:

– Count carbohydrates– Adjust insulin based on insulin-to-CHO ratios– Use correction factors

Page 53: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

In the “Real” World

• Facilitate behavior changes that individuals are willing and able to make based on proven lifestyle interventions

• A variety of nutrition therapy interventions can be implemented

• But lifestyle interventions for diabetes are effective!

Page 54: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Key References1. Evert AB, Boucher JL, Cypress M, et al. Nutrition therapy for the

management of adults with diabetes. Diabetes Care 2013;36:3821-3842.2. Pastors JG, Franz MJ. Effectiveness of medical nutrition therapy for

diabetes. In: Franz MJ, Evert AB, eds. American Diabetes Association Guide to Nutrition Therapy for Diabetes. Alexandria, VA: American Diabetes Association; 2012:1-18.

3. Franz MJ, VanVormer JJ, Crain AI, et al. Weight loss outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analyis of weight-loss clinical trials with a minimum of 1-year duration. J Am Diet Assoc 2007;107:1755-1767.

4. Franz MJ. The obesity paradox and diabetes. Diabetes Spectrum 2013;26:145-151

5. Wheeler ML, Dunbar SA, Jaacks LM et al. Macronutrients, food groups and eating patterns in the management of diabetes: a systematic review of the literature. 2010. Diabetes Care 2012;35:434-334

6. Franz MJ, Powers MA, Leontos C, et al. The evidence for medical nutrition therapy for type 1 and type 2 diabetes in adults. J Am Diet Assoc 2010;110:1852-1889.

Page 55: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Questions?

Page 56: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Based on this webinar, learners should be able to: List expected outcomes from diabetes nutrition therapy and

when to evaluate outcomes Discuss the role of weight loss therapy across the continuum

of diabetes List goals and evidence-based nutrition therapy priorities for

type 1 and type 2 diabetes State evidence to support macronutrient intake

recommendations for diabetes Select appropriate nutrition therapy interventions for persons

with diabetes

NUTRI-BITES®

Webinar SeriesLifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes

Page 57: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Nutri-Bites® Webinar details

A linkto obtain your Continuing Education Credit certificate

will be emailed within 2 days.

Today’s webinar will be available to download within 2 days at: www.ConAgraFoodsScienceInstitute.com

For CPE information: [email protected]

Page 58: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

Nutrition and Oral Health: What Dietitians Should Know

Wahida Karmally, DrPH, RD, CDE, CLS, FNLA Associate Research Scientist

Lecturer in Dentistry Director of Nutrition Irving Institute for Clinical and Translational Research

Columbia University

Date: January 16, 20142-3 pm EST/1-2 pm CST

www.ConAgraFoodsScienceInstitute.com

Next Nutri-Bites®Webinar

Page 59: Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of ... · Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes November 14, 2013 . Presenters: Marion J. Franz, MS,

How are we doing?

Stay on the line for a brief survey about this Nutri-Bites® webinar:

Lifestyle Approaches to the Prevention and Treatment of Diabetes

Thank you!