Livelihood Restoration Plan for Persons Affected by ...€¦ · Vol IV Submitted by Submitted to: WUB Consult Architectural & Development Planning Consultant P.O.Box 19974, Addis

Livelihood Restoration Plan for Persons Affected by

Tourism Development Projects in Lalibela

Ethiopian Sustainable Tourism Development Project

Vol IV

Submitted by Submitted to:

WUB Consult

Architectural & Development Planning

Consultant

P.O.Box 19974, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia

Tel.

E-mail: [email protected]

Ethiopian Sustainable Tourism

Development Project-ESTDP

P.O.Box 100953 Addis Ababa

Tel.25115 509540; Fax:

E-mail: [email protected]

April 2011

Addis Ababa

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

wb20439

Typewritten Text

RP775 v4

Livelihood Restoration Plan for Lalibela Page 2 of 111

WUB Consult

Table of Contents

List of Acronyms .................................................................................................................... 4

Preface .................................................................................................................................... 5

Executive summary ................................................................................................................ 6

1.2. Objective ......................................................................................................................... 9

1.3. Methodologies .............................................................................................................. 10

1.4. Structure of the Document ............................................................................................ 11

II. Implementation Strategies ............................................................................................... 11

2.1. Organizational Arrangement ........................................................................................ 11

2.2. Supply of Land for Production and Marketing Premises ............................................. 12

2.3. Construction of Production and Marketing Premises ................................................... 12

2.4. Training ........................................................................................................................ 12

III. Intended Target Beneficiaries ................................................................................... 13

IV. Identified Business Activities ......................................................................................... 16

4.1 Households’ Preference towards Business Types ......................................... 16

4.2. Households’ Preference towards Forms of Business Ownership ................................. 17

4.3. Identified Business Enterprises and Economic Activities ............................................ 18

Table 4.8 Summary of target beneficiaries by category of Business /Industerial Group .... 22

Industrial group ................................................................................................................... 22

No of estabilishement .......................................................................................................... 22

No of persons ....................................................................................................................... 22

Proportion of beneficiaries across the business categories (%) ........................................... 22

V. Safeguarding the Livelihoods of Vulnerable Persons ..................................................... 23

VI. Project Financing ............................................................................................................ 24

6.1. Estimated Financial Requirement for Enterprise Development ................................... 24

6.2 Financial Estimates for Training and Skill Development ............................................. 25

6.3 Financial Estimates to Safeguard the Livelihoods of the Vulnerable ........................... 26

6.4. Total Project Financing ................................................................................................ 26


WUB Consult

Annex I: Cost Estimates for Construction, Procurement and Working Capital ............... 28

Subgroup 1.2: Woodwork Products ..................................................................................... 30

Subgroup 1.3: Leather Craft ................................................................................................. 31

Annex II: Training Needs and Estimated Training Cost ...................................................... 47

Annex III: List of Intended Target Beneficiaries ................................................................. 54

Annex IV: List of persons whose status for Eligibility to livelihood restoration projects should

be verified ............................................................................................................................. 84

Annex V: Business activities that will be affected due to relocation from the Core Zone 102

Annex V/A: Name of business owner, Types of Business, Annual Income and Computed

Disturbance Allowance of Formal businesses ................................................................... 103

Annex V/B: Petty traders Average Monthly Income for People to be relocated ............... 105


WUB Consult

List of Acronyms

ANRS Amhara National Regional State

BoCT Bureau of Culture and Tourism (Regional level)

BoQ Bill of Quantities

LCA Debre Lalibela Churches Administration.

EOTC Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahdo Church

ESTDP Ethiopian Sustainable Tourism Development Project

GOE Government of Ethiopia

ESTDP-

LSMU

Ethiopian Sustainable Tourism Development Project-Lalibela Site

Management Unit

LMA Lalibela Municipal Administration

MoCT Ministry of Culture and Tourism

MSO Municipal Services Office

PASDEP Plan for Accelerated and Sustainable Development to End Poverty

PA Peasant Administrations

PAP Project Affected persons

RAP Resettlement Action Plan

RPF Resettlement Policy Framework

RPFP Resettlement Project Focal person

TNRS Tigray National Regional State

RC Resettlement Committee

WB World Bank


WUB Consult

Preface

Resettlement projects displace persons from places where ones memories are deeply rooted. No

amount of compensation and replacement of one artefact by another can wash away the myriads of

valued relations to places and people. However, change is natural, human beings and their social

relations are after all parts of nature. The resettlement project in Lalibela is a project which, in the

view of those who came to be near the spiritual core of Lalibela, is displacement from their

perpetual abode. Such hard feelings have made the study a soul searching one. It needed the

participation of many people who believed the conservation of the historic and cultural heritage

sites of Lalibela are beneficial not only to them but also to those residents who, deep in their heart,

love the churches, the residents of the Core Zone.

For WUB Consult staff this was a very challenging project; but finally to see would-be relocated

persons contributing positively to the planning of the new resettlement sites is very encouraging.

First and foremost, I would like to thank the staff of ESTDP in Lalibela as well in Addis Ababa

who put unreserved efforts to keep the momentum of the RAP project. I would also like to thank

the Lalibela Town administration officials for their contribution in organising public forums. The

residents of the Core Zone in Adishade, Chifrgoch, Mikael Ghibi and Gebriel Sefer and farmers in

Kurakur area deserve special mention for their trust in our work. I deeply share their concerns,

frustrations and uncertainties surrounding resettlement projects. I sincerely hope the new

settlement, with its improved layout, will compensate the loss in proximity to the churches by

providing decent and honourable spaces in lieu of the crowded and privacy-less environs of the

old Core Zone.

I would also like to thank the professional team1 of WUB Consult for their dedication to the

project ideals and their understanding of the aspiration of the project affected persons while

carrying out their professional duties.

April 2011

Wubshet Berhanu (Dr.Ing)

General Manager

WUB Consult

1 Ato Assefa Hagos; Ato Abraham Workneh, Ato Elias Gashaw, Ato Dagnachew Adugna, Ato Yohannes Tadesse,

Ato Amha Tigabu, and Ato Desalegn Berhanu and Ato Ezra Teshome and Ato Yeneneh Chanyalew participated in

different capacities in the project.


WUB Consult

Executive summary

The Government of Ethiopia has identified tourism as one of the key sectors for economic growth. The

policy stresses the need to develop the historic and cultural sites in the country so as to make them

productive sources of jobs, incomes, and economic growth. To this end, the Ethiopian Sustainable Tourism

Development Programme (ESTDP) is conceived in support of this objective and the various initiatives

already taken by the Government of Ethiopia (GOE).

As part of the development of a strategy for the tourism sector, a series of studies were planned to analyse

the situation, identify key potentials in the sector, and to develop strategic integrated destination

development plans (IDDP). A Resettlement Policy Framework (RPF) was first prepared to guide the

development of resettlement issues that may arise as a result of the development of projects for historic and

cultural sites. Some of the important initiatives and actions carried out by the GOE at national level as part

of the tourism development strategy include:

Upgrading the tourism portfolio from a Commission to a ministry level

Establishment of a public-private forum known as the National Tourism Council, which is to be replicated at regional level.

Commitment to rehabilitate the Tourism Training Institute

Upgrading transport facilities, such as roads and airports, especially in the Northern Historic Route

Adopting a tourism policy

Approaching and showing commitment to work with the World Bank (WB) to develop a strategy and implement an investment program for the tourism sector.

Conducting project studies and entering agreement with WB

This document, Resettlement Action Plan for Lalibela, presents the summary of the socio-economic profile

of persons affected by the ESTDP project, review of legal frameworks for resettlement project, categories

of persons according to entitlement for compensation, audit report on persons relocated immediately before

this RAP was studied, methods of property valuation, modalities for managing allocation of compensation,

and other RAP components. This document is an action plan documenting overall resettlement actions

while reports dealing with specific components provide details in separate volumes. The background

documents which form part of the Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) are:

1. Vol.1: Resettlement Action Plan for Lalibela (this report)

2. Vol. 2: Socio-economic situation assessment of persons affected by tourism development projects in

Lalibela

3. Vol.3 Property valuation of private properties in the Core Zone of Lalibela

4. Vol.4: Livelihood restoration plan for persons affected by tourism development projects in Lalibela

5. Vol.5: Neighbourhood and infrastructure designs for resettlement of persons from the Core Zone of

Lalibela

6. Vol.6: Environmental Impact Assessment of the resettlement project in Lalibela

7. Vol. 7: Appendices of Evidences for the RAP studies of Lalibela

Volume One deals with the resettlement action plan proper (this report) where the major issues of the

resettlement project are assessed (legal, social, administrative, and financial), project activities including

their costs and time frame is provided; implementing institutions are identified and mechanisms for

monitoring and evaluation are suggested. This report deals with review of policies related to forced

resettlement, and categorises of entitlements; it has identified differences between policies of GoE and the

WB and means for bridging the two is provided. The policy which provides better benefits to the PAPs is

used in the allocation of entitlements. This report also deals with an audit report or a remedial plan for

persons relocated in 2009 from Micheal Ghibbi and the Host community whose land was taken over for


WUB Consult

resettlement . It also deals with the households from the Adishade, Chifrgoch and Gebriel Sefer localities of

the Core Zone. The study has identified households from the Core Zone by category of private house

owner-occupier, kebele tenant and tenant in Kebele house. As part of the property valuation process, the

property owners in the Core Zone were required to verify building and plot measurements and trees in their

compounds. The verification was done for measurement only as the value of compensation would vary

depending on the period of payment.

Volume one also deals with livelihood and income restoration mechanisms. Households will be

compensated for loss of income for three months. Business owners will also be allocated plots along main

road to establish their business. A mechanism for grievance redressing is designed too. Possible grievances

are identified and mechanisms to deal with them are provided. A Grievance Hearing Committee will be set

up to deal with cases arising from being relocated. Furthermore, the institutional capacity of the OMS is

reviewed and found to be unable to implement the resettlement project by its own. A mechanism is

proposed to address the issue of capacity. This volume also deals with monitoring and evaluation of the

resettlement project. Internal and external monitoring and evaluations are proposed to ensure compliance

with RAP and other project directives. Sequencing of activities and possible simultaneity is also provided.

The basic characteristics of the new neibourhood plan and infrastructure design is also presented in Volume

one. Finally, assessment of the environmental impacts of the resettlement is summarised. The assessment

shows that there is no major negative impact from the relocation project, hence it is grouped as Category C.

Volume Two assesses the socio-economic situation of households in the Core Zone (Adishade, Chifrgoch,

Gebriel Sefer, and Mikael Ghibi) and the host community in Kurakur area. The residents of the Core Zone

live in very crowded localities. However, they have built social ties over long years of living in the

localities. The socio-economic survey revealed that the majority of households are women-headed. Out of a

total of 2025 residents in the Core Zone, about 44% of the residents in Adishade and Chifrgoch live in

kebele houses. The overwhelming majority of residents are Orthodox Christians; a quarter of the residents

are below 14 years of age and less than 10% are 65 years and above. There are people with disability of

different kinds (1.5%) who need special support during the relocation. The unemployed, the elderly and

women are the vulnerable groups identified by the study. This study is a basis for planning the resettlement

actions and also a baseline for future monitoring of impacts.

Volume Three presents the methods of property valuation, the eligibility criteria, and challenges of the task.

All houses in the Core Zone were measured, their specifications and bill of quantities prepared based on the

unit rate provided by the Zone administration. The measurement was verified to be correct by property

owners and the Resettlement Committee. The estimated cost of compensation for private house owners in

the three Core Zone localities as of January 2011 is about thirty five million Birr (about USD

2,187,850).The compensation for loss of farmland is estimated to be about five million Birr (about USD

312,500). An Excel Sheet is prepared separately for use by the resettlement implementation unit providing

methods of adjusting the compensation based on the unit rate at the time payment.

Volume Four dealt with livelihood restoration plan for projected affected perosns. Based on the socio-

economic situation assessment reported in Vol.2, possible engagement areas of beneficiaries were

identified in consultation with the PAPs, possible businesses sectors were identified based on assessment of

the local economy of Lalibela Town. The tourist attraction potential of the cultural and historic sites in and

around Lalibela were considered in the identification of business sectors for development. A total of about

Birr 16 million (about one million USD) is required to construct MSE operation shades, for training, as

well as for seed capital to start businesses.

Volume Five presents the new neighbourhood plan of the resettlement areas. It dealt with site selection

criteria, standards for plots and social facilities, and approaches for the subdivision of blocks into parcels.

Two sites were selected in consultation with the Office of Municipal Services and the persons affected by

the resettlement project. The resettlement sites are located in Kurakur on both sides of the asphalted road


WUB Consult

leading from Neakutoleab to the town centre of Lalibela. Private house owners will be allocated plots

proportional to their former plot while tenants in Kebele houses will be allocated the minimum size plot

provided by the Structure Plan of Lalibela. A total of 713 plots are provided in the two sites; however not

more than 450 plots will be required by the displaced person. The neighbourhood plan presents

infrastructure design (water and power supply, road network, drainage, solid and liquid waste

management). Engineering cost estimate for infrastructure development is also provided .

Volume Six dealt with the environmental impact assessment of the resettlement project. The impacts of

infrastructure developments and that of persons who will not be relocated from the Core Zone (the church

school and the monastery) is presented in detail. The church school and the monastery are considered part

of the living cultural heritage, hence will not be relocated outside the Core Zone. The assessment indicated

that the main impact on the environment by these group is from solid and liquid waste generated by the

residents. Proper mitigation measures are designed to address the possible impacts. It is also suggested that

the site development project for the Core Zone should include these two functions. The analysis of the new

resettlement site indicated that there are no appreciable fauna and flora nor cultural heritage artefacts which

require conservation. The would-be relocated and the host community are households of nearly similar

culture and the displacement being only about three kilometres, the social impact was found to be minimal.

The assessment concluded that the possible environmental impact of the resettlement project as a whole is

minimal and falls under Category C according to the WB Operations manual.

Volume Seven consists of appendices that are evidences for the RAP study and documents to assist

implementation. Attendance sheets for the different consultative meetings, lists of persons by category of

entitlements, verification of property measurements, and other documents used for the study are presented

in this volume. The Bill of Quantities and specifications is presented in a separate soft copy as it contains

list of property owners with the amount of compensation and mechanisms for adjusting the amount based

on the unit rates at the time of disbursement of compensation.


WUB Consult

1.0 Introduction

1.1. Background

Livelihood restoration plan is one of the major components of Resettlement Action Plan (RAP).

Alongside with compensation for real properties, as mentioned in Resettlement Policy Framework

(RPF), a RAP must ensure that the livelihoods of people affected by the project are restored at

least to levels prevailing before of the project.

Thus, the livelihood restoration plan is prepared to ensure restoration and improvement of income

and livelihood of the project affected groups and individuals, which is in addition to, and separate

from, compensation for property losses, through development of income generating activities.

The main target beneficiaries of the livelihood restoration plan are people, groups and individuals

who are and will be at risk of losing their jobs and income due to loss of market, customers, and

farmland as well as unemployed and vulnerable groups.

Information from different sources was used to prepare the livelihood restoration plan. Potential

economic activities and business opportunities were identified in consultation with relevant

stakeholders (concerened experts, the officials, and the affected communities, and target

beneficiaries), and market survieys and review of studies on local economic potentials were also

used to identify feasibile business activities. The socio-economic data from the survey was, on the

otherhand, used to identify target beneficiaries among project affected people for possible

inclusion in the project.

.

An attempt was also made to catagorize the target beneficiaries to specific economic activities

they would be best fit based on their socioeconomic situation. Financial requirement and cost is

also estimated for construction, procurement, working capital and training corresponding to each

proposed businesses and enterprises. Regarding the vulnerable group a number of safeguarding

options are recommended and financial estimate is made to implement the options. Moreover in

order to excute the proposed plan possible implementation strategies are recommended.

1.2. Objective

The general objective of the livelihood restoration plan is to ensure livelihood of the project

affected people is sustainably restored, and enhanced and improved standard of living is achieved.

The following are the specific objectives:

Restoring and improving income and lives of the project affected groups and individuals

who are at risk of losing their means of living


WUB Consult

Enhancing the community and household economy through creating job opportunities for

unemployed persons in the project affected community

Safeguarding the lives of the vulnerable persons at sustainable manner

Utilizing tourism potential to promote the local economy by creating economic integration

with other sectors of the local economy

1.3. Methodologies

Besides, the census analysis results that explained the socioeconomic situations and characteristics

of the project affected groups and individuals, a number of consultations were carried out with

project affected communities to examine the possible risks at their livelihoods and identify their future

aspiration and desired activities that should be considered in the preparation of livelihood restoration

project and identifying possible business venetures as means of income restoration. It was also held

comprehensive community consultations with the whole project affected people and in particular with

the identified target benefcieries regarding the criteria for the inclusion in the project. Further,

suggestions and comments were gathered on the identified business activities during workshops held

with the intended beneficiaries

Extensive and consultative meetings and thorough discussions were also carried out with heads

and staffs of the Micro and Small Enterprises (MSEs) Development office and the Urban

Agriculture Development office and other city administration officials to gather information on the

possibilities and potentials of small business development and income generating opportunities

and different implementation options.

Market survey has made by interviewing the local businessmen in Lalibela (owners and managers

of tourist standared hotels and restaurants, owners of souvinor shops, wholesalers, construction

enginners and mangers, etc). Along side informal consultation were held with experienced persons

engaged in the local businesses and small scale productive activities to gather round additional

information on demanded goods and services as well as to estimate the cost of materials and

inputs, construction costs and seed capital to start up small scale businesses. Effort has also been

made to consider transportation costs to supply machineries, materials and inputs that might not be

available in Lalibela to start proposed business.

Efforts were also made to examine the local government institutional arrangements and

institutional capacity to support and implement the intended development interventions as well as

to make livelihood restoration plan will be prepared and implemented in compliance with local

Government policies and program.

Likewise, different studies on local economic development potential of Lalibela town, particularly

tourism related opportunities and potentials and the missing links in this regarded was critically

assessed.


WUB Consult

Thus all the information gathered as primary and secondary data sources was utilized as a basis for

preparation of the proposal, and inform a direction for designing implementation strategies.

The consultation and participatory approach is supposed to be continuing all the way through the

detailed action plan preparation and implementation of the income restoration program with the

full involvement of the intended target beneficiaries and the relevant stakeholders.

1.4. Structure of the Document

The livelihood restoration plan document is organized into six main parts including this

introductory part. The second part deals with the implementation strategy which mainly describes

the organizational arrangements and the role and responsibility of the local government and

Lalibela ESTDP Site Managent Unit towards implementing and follow-up of the program.

The third part describe the intended target beneficiaries whose livelihood are and will be at risk

due to resettlement program, is from the analysis of the socioeconomic census result and

consultation with affected communities and other stakeholder. This part also includes the rationale

of identifying the intended target beneficiaries.

The fourth part outlines the identified potential business enterprise and income generating

activities and the corresponding form of business ownership as well as the number of persons and

socioeconomic groups recommended corresponding to each proposed economic activities. Parts V

explain different safeguarding and supporting options for the vulnerable group.

Part VI summarizes the estimated budget required for livelihood restoration plan that consists of

cost estimates and financial plan for business and enterprise establishments, skill and capacity

development training and fiancing safeguarding options of the lives of the vulnerable group.

The last part, Annex 1 and 2, presents details of construction and procurement plan including

financial requirements and proposed working capital for each enterprises and business

establishments as well as details of training need and training cost. Annex 3 presents list of the

intended target beneficiaries including vulnerable group.

II. Implementation Strategies

2.1. Organizational Arrangement

Lalibela City Micro and Small Enterprise Development office should be the main responsible

body to implement the livelihood restoration plan in close collaboration with and follow up of

ESTDP Lalibela Site Management Unit office. The proposed enterprises and businesses should

be established, organized and operate in compliance with the Goverenment micro and small scale

enterprise development program.Thus, intended target beneficiaries should be organized and

registered under cooperative forms of businesses and individual MSE (sole proprietorship ) and

should be provided with legal entities and licences.


WUB Consult

The City MSEs development office should also be responsible supporting, facilitating and

providing all necessary business development services as put into practice for regular MSEs, that

mainly includes provision of working and marketing premises(in collaboration with office of

Municipality services),training arrangements, market integration and technical and operational

supports.

2.2. Supply of Land for Production and Marketing Premises

The office of municipal services should provide plots to construct shades and stores in areas where

reserved for micro and small enterprise development and/ or in industrial zone. Plots for shops

and small buildings for commercial activities should be supplied in developed commercial zone of

the town particularly along the main roads and around the new resettlement area. It is also

recommended that plots that will be allocated for production of goods should be suitable if a

cluster type business formation is implemented to attain economies of scale particularly to

minimize unit cost of infrastructural development.

2.3. Construction of Production and Marketing Premises

Unlike the regular MSEs development package where local Government is responsible to cover

the construction cost of shades, stores, shops and small business buildings, the construction cost

for these premises in this plan is included in the estimated investement and working capital of

each business enterprise and the construction works is assumed to be handled by the intended

target beneficiaries, while the capital comes from ESTDP.

The local Government, on the other hand, should be responsible for infrastructural development,

and will give priorities, in areas (sites) that are not developed and where there is a need of cluster

business development.

2.4. Training

Enhancing technical, operational and business leadership skill and capacity of the intended target

beneficiaries through short term training is one of the key strategy and component of the proposal

to ensure effective implementation and bring sustainable impact of the livelihood restoration plan.

Thus technical and operational as well as business, marketing and cooperative leadership skill

development training should be provided for intended target beneficiaries.

Accordingly, possible training topics for each activity are proposed and potential trainers are

recommended. Instructors from City Technical Vocational Training Center, trained staffs from

City MSEs Development office who are trained in small business development services will be

among the trainers. Professionals and experienced persons from the private sector in the town and

from the neghibouing cities and Regional capital (Dessie, Bahir-Dar) as well as from AddisAbaba

should be hired and involved. Training durations are proposed and financial requirement for

training is also is estimated, as indicated in Annex II.


WUB Consult

III. Intended Target Beneficiaries

Based on the census analysis results, among the total project affected groups and individuals,

those whose livelihood are and will be at risk are identified to be the direct target beneficiaries of

the livelihood restoration plan including the vulnerable group. Identification of target beneficiaries

is, therefore, mainly based on social, economic and gender analysis, including vulnerability.

Consequently four beneficiary groups are identified based on their socioeconomic characteristics.

The rationales of identifying these beneficiaries are explained below.

Affected women have given priority in livelihood and income restoration program because

of their socioeconomic situations. Above all women constitute the majority of the affected

people and the largest numbers of the affected households are female headed. Further

among women who are engaged in productive activities, the majority are involved in petty

trading that is the informal sector and eventually affected by relocation. Moreover, as

quantified below, women constitute the largest numbers of the unemployed and vulnerable

groups.

From occupational perspective, petty trading activities, as indicated above, are largely

dependent on location factors where relocation results in ultimate loss of market and

customers due to change of location. Agricultural activities, on the otherhand, will be

definitely affected due to loss of farmland for resettlement. Thus affected persons engaged

in petty trading and agricultural activities are intended to be one of the main target

beneficiaries of the livelihood restoration plan.

Unemployment and poverty are the prevailing socioeconomic problems in the project

affected communities. Among economically active persons in the project affected

communities, near to 30 % of all affected persons are unemployed. The census further

shows that among the unemployed, near to 70 % are women. Hence, involving the

unemployed in the livelihood restoration program through the provision of short term

technical ,operational and business skill training and financial and technical support to

enable them engaging in some productive activities is indispensable to improve the social

and economic status of the affected communities.

Persons who are identified as vulnerable group, who constitute about 8 % of the total

project affected population, on the other hand, are apparent that they are the most

economically and socially disadvantaged group and will be more destitute when relocated.

Further, 59 % of the vulnerable persons are still women. Thus vulnerable persons are one

of the target beneficiaries to benefit from one or more safeguarding options recomended

(see the recommended options in Section V) that will ensure the inclusiveness of the

livelihood restoration plan to address marginality and vulnerability issues.

Accordingly, based on the above rationales the following project affected individuals and groups

are intended to be direct target beneficiaries.


WUB Consult

165 persons who are /were engaged in petty trading (excluding vulnerable persons who

are/were engaged in petty trading)

45 persons who are/were primarlly engaged in agriculture (excluding vulnerable persons

who are/were engaged in agriculture and the unemployed persons who are in the host

community)

396 unemployed persons (excluding vulnerable persons who are unemployed and

including the unemployed who are in the host community )

262 vulnerable persons (of which 44 persons with disability and 218 elderly persons aged

65 years above, including vulnerable persons from the host community). Totally 868

people (268 male and 600 female) are intended as direct target beneficiaries of the

livelihood restoration program.

As shown above, women constitute the largest number of direct target beneficiaries by

comprising more than 69 % and this male-female proportion is almost similar across the

subgroups, i.e. People relocated in 2009, people to be relocated and the host community.

Table 3.1, 3.2, 3.3 and 3.4 below provide the target beneficiaries by socioeconomic group

and across the affected subgroups and localities as well as by sex proportion. (See the list

of the individual intended beneficiaries on Annex III).

Table 3.1: No of total intended target beneficiaries by socioeconomic group and sex

Category of Intended Beneficiaries by

Socioeconomic Group

M

F

Total

Number Percent

Persons engaged in petty trading 11 154 165 19

Persons engaged in agriculture 29 16 45 5

Unemployed Persons 121 275 396 46

Vulnerable persons 107 155 262 30

Total intended target beneficiaries 268 600 868 100

Table 3.1 shows that unemployed and vulnerable persons constitute the highest proportion of the

intended target beneficiaries and, as explained above, women in total constitute more

than two-thirds of the intended beneficiaries.

On the other hand, the distribution of the intended target beneficiaries across the affected

subgroups and localities indicates that (See Tables 3.2) the majority of the intended beneficiaries

are from people to be relocated which accounts for 64 % of the total intended direct beneficiaries.


WUB Consult

Table 3.2 Intended beneficiaries by subgroup and sex

Subgroup Male Female Total

Number Percent

People relocated in 2009 42 133 175 20

People to be relocated 165 389 554 64

The Host community 61 78 139 16

Total 268 600 868 100

Table 3.3, 3.4 and 3.5 provide further breakdowns of the intended beneficiaries by the socioeconomic

groups across the subgroups and localities.

Table 3.3: Intended target beneficiaries from People relocated in 2009

Socioeconomic

Group Menaheriya Kurakur Total

M F T M F T M F T

Persons who

were engaged in

petty trading

- 12 12 - 15 15 - 27 27

Unemployed 6 8 14 17 56 73 23 64 87

Vulnerable

persons 1 12 13 18 30 48 19 42 61

Total intended

beneficiaries 7 32 39 35 101 136 42 133 175

When looking across the localities, beneficiaries from Addishadde constitutes the largest proportion,

accounting for 40 % of the total intended target beneficiaries.

Intended beneficiaries from the Host Community

The number of households who gave up and will give up their farmland for resettlement program

are much more than the number of beneficiaries identified from the host community. This is

because, despite loss of farmland, some of these called the “host community “reside outside the

proposed resettlement location (Kurakur and Dereq -Wenz). These persons are not mainly

engaged in farming; instead they are involved in other off - farm activities. So beneficiaries

identified from those who lost farmland are those persons who are mainly engaged in farming.

Table 3.4: No of intended target beneficiaries from People to be relocated


WUB Consult

Socioeconomic Group Addishadde Chifrgoch

Gabriel

Total

M F T M F T M F T M F T

Persons who are engaged in

petty trading 5 87 92 6 33 39 - 7 7 11 127 138

Persons who are unemployed 50 99 149 17 35 52 14 24 38 81 158 239

Vulnerable persons 38 72 110 15 22 37 20 10 30 73 104 177

Total intended

beneficiaries 93 258 351 38 88 128 34 41 75 165 389 554

In addition, like wise other subgroups, unemployed and vulnerable persons from the host are

included to be among the intended beneficiaries. Accordingly a total of 139 persons are identified

as target beneficiaries from Kurakur, Dereq Wenz, and persons residing out side these specific

locations but lost or will lose farmland around Kurakur and Derk - Wenz for restelement.

Table 3.5: No of intended target beneficiaries from the host community

IV. Identified Business Activities

4.1 Households’ Preference towards Business Types

Most of project affected households have expressed a willingness to work or otherwise

productively engage in some economic activities if given financial and technical support and skill

development training and retraining as well as plots for working and marketing premises.

Data on the type of economic activities desired by the households was collected and analyzed in

order to examine the possible business activities the project affected households would be engaged

in, if they lose their current occupation and income as a result of the resettlement program. Table

4.1 reveals the economic activities preffered by the project affected households.

Table 4.1: Economic activities preferred by project affected households

Socioeconomic Group M F T

Persons who were engaged in farming 29 16 45

Persons who are unemployed 17 53 70

Vulnerable persons 15 9 24

Total intended target beneficiaries 61 78 139


WUB Consult

N0 Types of Activities No of

Households

Percent

1 Commercial activities 385 62

2 Retain in current occupation 153 25

3 Agriculture 37 6

4 Handicrafts 27 4

5 Others 16 3

Total 618 100

Accordingly the majority of the households (62 %) respond that they prefer to be engaged in

commercial activities, while 27 % of households expressed to retain their current occupation.

4.2. Households’ Preference towards Forms of Business Ownership

Besides to desired economic activities, information was also gathered to examine the preferable

forms of business ownership that the affected households should operate if supported to engage in

some economic activities. Accordinglly, more than 94 % of the respondents explained they prefer

to own and run businesses individually. While only less than 5 % agreed to engage in cooperative

owned or joint venture forms of businesses.

Similar interest with the above census results was also reflected during consultations with the

affected communities that most of the affected persons explained their preference to engage in

commercial activities and own and run businesses individually.

However, it is impossible and easier said than done to set aside the majority of the beneficiaries

only in commercial activities and own and run businesses individually. To mention some of the

reasons:

From point of view of specialization , it is not economically viable and feasible if the

majority are to be engage in commercial activities with less emphasis given to be

engaged in production activities

It is deemed necessary to diversify economic employment and sector engagement to

broaden the economic base of the town and unlock and utilize tourism related economic

potential of the locality as well as creating economic integration among the different

sectors

On the other hand, involving all or the majority of target beneficiaries in individually

owned business will require a large size and number of plots that is unaffordable in

Lalibela situation where land is very scarce, as well as skill and capital are limited. Thus,

attaining economies of scale and running sustainable business through efficient use of

limited resources require pooling of these resources through joint ventures like

cooperative businesses.


WUB Consult

Further, the existing government regulation towards promoting and supporting micro

and small enterprise development show that due emphasis is given to establish as many

as 70 % of MSEs into cooperative societies.

This fact is supplemented by periodic reports that revealed sufficient achievements gained

through aforesaid forms of businesses organizations throughout the urban centers of the

country, including Lalibela.

4.3. Identified Business Enterprises and Economic Activities

A number of business types and economic activities are identified by extensive consultation with

relevant stakeholders (the project affected communities, the target beneficierieis, City Micro and

Small Enterprise Development and Agricultural Development office). Further market survey has

also carried out parallal with informal consultation with experienced persons and enterprises

engaged in the local businesses and small scale productive activities.

Market surveys

Market survey was conducted to get additional information to devise and propose viable business

activities. The data was collected by interviewing businessmen working in the town particularly

owners and managers of tourist standard Hotels, owners of big souvner shops, wholesalers and

construction engineers and construction managers engaged in construction works in the town.

The survey result supposed to support the proposal to ensure the feasibility of proposed business

activities.The result suggests that there is a huge market demand for most of goods and services

which are now in short of supply or supplied from other cities . Addtionally, the survey provides

additional business types for which the businessmen experienced there are high demand.

In addition, exhaustive assessment of studies conducted on the town economy (such as local

economic development study as part of the town master plan revision) was reviwed to support

identification of potential and feasible business opportunities.

As a result Six major industrial/enterprise groups are identified comprising 54 types of economic

activities where a total of 222 business establishments are proposed to absorb as many as 875

target beneficiaries.The proposal also suggests the possible number of persons and socioeconomic

groups who will be best fit to the corresponding activities and enterprises.

The main Industrial/ Enterprise groups are:

Group I: Tourist oriented icons and items production

Group II: Food items production and Urban Agriculture activities

Group III: Textile and Garment production

Group IV: Construction Materials production

Group V: Waste Collection and Compost making activities


WUB Consult

Group VI: Commercial Activities (Wholesale, Retail trade and Service trading)

Tables 4.2 to 4.7 present the detailed business enterprises and economic activities identified

under the above industrial categories and the corresponding forms of business ownership,

number of persons possibly to be involved in and recommended socioeconomic group.

Table: 4.2: Group I: Tourist oriented icons and items production

Subgroup

Fo

rms

of

bu

sin

ess

No

of

esta

bli

shm

ent

No

of

per

son

s

to b

e en

ga

ged

in Recommended

target beneficiaries

Metal Craft (Icons) Cooperative 2 40 Unemployed

Wood Products(Icons) Cooperative 2 30 Unemployed

Leather Craft (Icons) Cooperative 2 40 Unemployed and

disabiled

Stone -Made Icons Cooperative 1 10 Unemployed

Wool-Made products Cooperative 2 20 Unemployed

Fly –Swatter(whisk) made

from animal tail Cooperative 1 10

Unemployed

Pottery products Cooperative 1 10 Unemployed

Subtotal 11 160

Table: 4.3: Group II: Food items production and Urban Agriculture activities

Subgroup

Forms of business

ownership No

of

esta

bli

sh

men

t No of persons

to be engaged

in

Recommended target

beneficiaries

Home economic food items Cooperative 1 15 Petty traders

Baking Injera Cooperative 1 10 Petty traders

Bakery-Bread Cooperative 2 20 Petty traders

Apiculture(Honey

production) Cooperative 2 40 Unemployed and Elderlly

Dairy Farms Cooperative 3 45 Persons engaged in farming

and elderly persons

Sheep fattening Individual owner 20 20 Unemployed and elderly

persons

Subtotal 29 150

Table: 4.4: Group III: Textile and Garment Production and Carpet making

Subgroup

Forms of business

ownership

No of

establishment

No of persons to be

engaged in

Recommended

target


WUB Consult

beneficiaries

Modern Weaving Cooperative 1 20 Unemployed

Modern Embridery

and Sewing

Cooperative 1 15 Unemployed

Carpet production Individual owner 10 10 Petty traders

Subtotal 12 45

Table: 4.5: Group IV: Production of Construction Materials

Subgroup

Forms of

business

ownership

No of

establishment

No of persons

to be engaged

in

Recommended target

beneficiaries

Block production Cooperative 1 20 Unemployed

Red stone production

and Carving Cooperative 2 20 Unemployed

Gravel production Cooperative 1 30 Unemployed

Cobblestones Paving Cooperative 2 30 Unemployed

Subtotal 6 100

Table: 4.6: Group V: Dry Waste Collection and Compost making

Subgroup

Forms of

business

ownership

No of

establishment

No of

persons to be

engaged in

Recommended target

beneficiaries

Waste collection

and compost

making Cooperative 1 15 Unemployed

Subtotal 1 15

Table: 4.7: Group VI: Commercial Activities I: Wholesale and Retail Trading

Subgroup

Forms of business

ownership No

of

est

ab

lish

men

t

No

of

per

son

s to

be

eng

ag

ed

in

Recommended

target

beneficiaries

Building Materials shop Cooperative 2 40 Unemployed

Fish product supplier(from

Bahir Dar) Cooperative 1 20 Unemployed

Soft drink distributer Cooperative 1 15 Unemployed

Kiosks Individual owner 10 10 Petty traders

Cosmotic shop Individual owner 5 5 Petty traders

Super Market Cooperative 3 30 Petty traders

Mini Market Individual owner 5 5 Petty traders


WUB Consult

Car Sparepart shop Cooperative 2 20 Unemployed

Meat selling Individual owner 10 10 Petty traders

Veranda grain trade Individual owner 5 5 Petty traders

Fruits and vegetable shop Individual owner 10 10 Petty traders

Canned honey and butter

trade Individual owner 5 5 Petty traders

Sheep and Goat trade Individual owner 10 10

Persons

engaged in

farming and

elderlly

Cattle trade Individual owner 10 10

Persons

engaged in

farming

Shoe shop Individual owner 5 5 Petty traders

Small boutiques Individual owner 5 5 Petty traders

Cultural clothes shop Individual owner 5 5 Petty traders

Skin and Hides trading Individual owner 5 5 Elderlly persons

Farm tools and equipment

shop Individual owner 5 5 Farmers

Subtotal 104 220

Commercial Activities II: Service Trading

Subgroup

Forms of business

ownership No

of

esta

bli

shm

ent

No of

persons to

be engaged

in

Recommended

target

beneficiaries

Cafeteria Cooperative 2 20 Petty traders

Tea room Individual owner 10 10 Unemployed

Local drink : Tej making Individual owner 5 5 Unemployed

Small restaurant Cooperative 2 20 Petty traders

Beauty Salon (hair

dressing) Individual owner 5 5 Unemployed

Barber Individual owner 5 5 Unemployed

Tire repair(Gomista) Cooperative 1 10 Unemployed

Electronics and Mobile

maintenance Individual owner 10 10 Unemployed

Car washing Cooperative 1 10 Unemployed

Pool (Billiards) house Individual owner

5 5 Unemployed

Video and TV show Individual owner 5 5 Unemployed

Mill service(grain , pulse

and spices) Cooperative 5 50 Unemployed

Bathing Cooperative 1 10 Unemployed


WUB Consult

Laundry Cooperative 2 20 Petty traders

Subtotal 59 185

Total commercial

activities(I+II)

163 405

Table 4.8 Summary of target beneficiaries by category of Business /Industerial Group

Industrial group No

of

esta

bilis

hem

ent

No

of p

erso

ns

Proportion of beneficiaries across the business

categories (%)

Tourist oriented icons and items production 11 160 18 Food items production and Urban Agriculture activities 29 150 17 Textile , Garment and Carpet production 12 45 5 Production of Construction Materials 6 100 12 Waste Collection and Compost making activities 1 15 2 Commercial Activities (Wholesale, Retail and Service trading) 163 405 46

Total

222 875 100


WUB Consult

V. Safeguarding the Livelihoods of Vulnerable Persons

Vulnerability related to affected women is almost entirely addressed by absorbing the majority of

economically active but unemployed affected women in the proposed income generating schemes.

The rest women who live with disability and the elderly are embraced in the vulnerable group. The

vulnerable persons constituting 262 individuals, who are treated separately in the proposal, are

those persons who live with disability (44 persons) and elderly persons aged 65 years above (218

persons), of which women still constitute 59 % of the subgroup.

Some of the vulnerable persons will be willing and capable to be engaged in some productive

activities; for example, leg amputated persons will be trained and involved in hand craft works and

those with sight problem, blind persons and elderly persons could be engaged in some trade

activities as well as in urban farming activities particularly in sheep fattening and raising milk

cows.

Hence the implementing body should scrutinize individual willingness and aspiration of the

vulnerable persons through individual and group discussion to opt for sustainable safeguarding

options among the recommended options discussed below. Accordingly the following options are

recommended towards safeguarding the vulnerable group.

i) The first option is identifying whether or not a vulnerable person is willing and capable

of being involved in some productive works among the identified income generating

schemes and economic activities.

ii) If a vulnerable person is not willing and or not capable, embrace one of the family

member or kin in the proposed economic activities, in favor of the vulnerable person

(who is not already included in the intended target beneficiaries and to be assigned by the

concerned vulnerable person), and to take responsibility to cover the means of subsistence

of the concerned vulnerable person.

iii) The other option is organizing a local social security fund under the City

Administration to run some income generating activities managed by Trust Fund

Administration Board (that will be composed from delegated persons from Governmental

and Non-Governmental Organizations, community representatives, Civil Societies and the

vulnerable persons) and run by hired labors and distribute the returns to the vulnerable

persons at regular basis.

iv) Or, invite Civil and Humanitarian Non Governmental local organization (e.g.

Ethiopian Orthodox Church Development and Aid organization) having the role of

involving in some income generating and development activities like urban farming in the

city to generate income and safeguarding the lives of vulnerable groups using the fund that

would be allocated for the vulnerablegroup from the livelihood restoration project.

v) If the above options are not viable and or not preferred by the vulnerable persons the

last resort will be to apply direct cash -transfer program that is handing out the cash to the


WUB Consult

concerned vulnerable person just once and request them to find their own preferred means

of livelihood.

As mentioned above, to implement one of the options or to find out other possibility, it is

recommended that the implementing body will carry out further discussion and consultation with

the identified vulnerable persons at individually and group level to decide what is best for them.

To apply one or the other options, however, the estimated financial requirement is computed based

on individual basis and presented in the cost estimate and financial plan part of the document.(See

part VI).

VI. Project Financing

6.1. Estimated Financial Requirement for Enterprise Development

Totally about Birr 16, 076, 896 million is estimated as total project budget (which includes Birr

2,096,986 as 15 % contingency for unexpected expenses and inflation). The total budget

includes financing the proposed business enterprises and income generating activities, skill

development training and safeguarding activities of the vulnerable. The detail cost estimate for

construction, procurement and working capital corresponding to each economic and business

activities and training cost is presented on Annex I and II. Tables below provide the summary of

financial requirement for proposed business establishments and trainings. As depicted on Table 6.1,

nearlly Birr 9.7 million is estimated as an investment and seed capital to establish income

generating business enterprises.

Table 6.1: Estimated Financial Requirement for proposed Business Ventures

Types of business enterprise Forms of

ownership

No of

persons

Estimated Financial

Requirement (Birr)

Tourist orinted Metal Craft production Cooperative 40 462,000

Tourist oriented Woodwork production Cooperative 30 342,100

Touris oriented Leather Craft

production Cooperative 40 354,200

Touris oriented Stone –Made Icon


Touris oriented Wool-Made products


Touris oriented Fly-Swatter production Cooperative 10 88,000

Touris oriented Pottery production Cooperative 10 88,000

Producing Home Economic food items Cooperative 15 136,400


WUB Consult

Bakery- Injera Cooperative 10 102,300

Bakery -Bread Cooperative 20 191,400

Apiculture Cooperative 40 462,000

Dairy Farms Cooperative 45 412,500

Sheep Fattening Sole proprietorship 20 165,000

Modern Weaving Cooperative 20 237,600

Modern Embroidery and Sewing Cooperative 15 167,200

Carpet production Individual owner 10 110,000

Blocket production Cooperative 20 232,760

Red Stone production Cooperative 20 115,500

Gravel production Cooperative 30 367,950

Cobble Stone paving Cooperative 30 323,400

Dry Waste Collection and Compost

Making Cooperative 15 120,450

Commercial activities(Wholesale, Retail

and Service Trading)

Both coop and

Individual ownerships 405 4,970,000

Total 875 9,734,760

6.2 Financial Estimates for Training and Skill Development

Cost of training basically per-diem allowance for trainees and trainers, refreshment and cost for

training places (Hall and Class Room Rent) are estimated. The detail cost of training based on

training type and duration for each business activity is presented on Annex II. As Table 6.2 below

provides the summary of training cost, near to Birr 1. 6 million is estimated for the training

program.

Table 6.2: Estimated Financial Requirement for Training

Economic activities

No of trainnes

Technical and

operational

skill

development

(Birr)

Business and

leadership

skill

development

(Birr)

Total

Training cost

Metal craft 40 144,000 6,000 150,000

Wood products 30 108,000 4,500 112,500

Leather craft 40 144,000 5,500 149,500

Stone , Wool , Fly swatter and Pottery

products 50 90,000 6500 96,500

Producing Home economic food items 15 10,500 2,500 13,000

Bakery- Injera 10 6,000 1,500 7,500

Bakery -Bread 20 8,000 3,000 11,000

Apiculture 40 32,000 6,000 38,000

Dairy farms 45 30,000 6,000 36,000


WUB Consult

Sheep fattening 20 8,000 2,500 10,500

Modern weaving 20 90,000 3,000 93,000

Modern Embroidery and Sewing 15 81,000 2,500 83,500

Carpet production 10 18,000 1,500 19,500

Blocket production 20 108,000 3,000 111,000

Red stone production 20 45,000 3,000 48,000

Gravel production 30 108,000 4,500 112,500

Cobble stone production 30 54,000 4,500 58,500

Dry Waste Collection 15 18,000 2,500 20,500

Commercial activities

(Wholesale, Retail trading & Service

trading)

405 _ 34,000 34,000

Sub total cost for training 875 1,102,500 102,500 1,205,000

Trainning refreshement cost 369,650

Rent for Hall and Class Room 50,500

Total training cost 1,625,150

6.3 Financial Estimates to Safeguard the Livelihoods of the Vulnerable

To implement one of the recommended options or the combinations of different options towards

safeguarding the lives of the vulnerable, or to find out other options the implementing body should

carry out further consultation at individual and group level to identify their interest and

preferences.

Provided the fact that each option needs financing, it is proposed that Birr 10,000 should be

allocated for each vulnerable person to implement whichever of the options. Hence a total of Birr

2,620,000 is estimated to finance options proposed for safeguarding the lives of 262 vulnerable

persons.

6.4. Total Project Financing

Table 6.3.below shows a summary of total project budget required for livelihood restoration plan

(includes financing enterprises and businesses establishment, training and safeguarding activities

intended for vulnerable and contingency of 15 % for unidentified claims, unexpected expenses

and inflation ). The total budget required to implement the livelihood restoration project is

estimated at Birr 16,076,896 (that is near to 959,815 USD).


WUB Consult

Table 6.3: Summary of Total Project Budget

COST DESCRIPTION ESTIMATED FINANCIAL REQUIREMENT

(BIRR)

Establish and Run Income Generating Activities 9,734,760

Training cost 1,625,150

Activities to safeguard the lives of the Vulnerable 2,620,000

Total Estimated Project Cost 13,979,910

Contingency 15 % , for unidentified claims,

unexpected expenses and inflation 2,096,986

Grand Total 16,076,896


WUB Consult

Annex I: Cost Estimates for Construction, Procurement and

Working Capital


WUB Consult

Enterprise Group I: Producing Tourist oriented Icons and Objects

Subgroup 1.1: Metal Craft

Major Produces: Metal Cross, Jewelries, Horn –made objects, Bronze, Silver products and Religious Icons

Forms of business ownership: Cooperative, Number of establishments: Two Cooperatives, Number of persons to be engaged in: 40 persons (20 per

coop)

Table 1.1: Machineries, materials and input requirement for training, production and financial estimates to produce Metal Craft

No Material and input requirement per cooperative Unit Amount

required

Unit

Price

Estimated total

cost

1 Shade, store and office construction Lump sum 50000

2 Wiring and flatting machine No 1 55000 55000

3 Melting machine (with electricity and cylinder) No 1 10000 10000

4 Hole making punchers , Hammers and Saw Lump Sum 15000 15000

5 Wax Lump Sum 5000

6 Sand paper for smoothing objects Lump Sum 10000

7 Silver, Copper, and Nickel, Lump Sum 50000

8 Washing chemicals Lump Sum 5000

9 Other materials , manual machines and Utilities Lump Sum 10000

Total financing per cooperative 210000

Contingency (10 %) 21000

Grand sum financing per cooperative 231000

Required financing for 2 cooperatives 462000

Share of individual member to total financing 11550


WUB Consult

Subgroup 1.2: Woodwork Products Major Produces: Wooden -Cross, Horn made - objects and Religious Icons and Furniture

Forms of business ownership: Cooperative, Number of Establishments: Two Cooperatives, Number of persons to be engaged in: 30 persons (15 per coop)

Table 1.2: Machineries, materials and input requirement for training, production and financial estimates to produce Woodwork Products

No Material and input

requirement per cooperative Unit

Amount

required

Unit

Price Estimated total cost

1

Shade, store and office

construction Lump sum 50000

2

Wood work machine(plane

machine) No 1 25000 25000

3

Shape making machine

(Jigsaw machine) No 10 2000 20000

4 Drill machine No 5 2500 12500

5

Rotary machine with

accessories No 5 3500 17500

6 Grinder (Boaring) machine No 5 2500 12500

7 Wood fix 1000

8

Hammers , Saw and other

materials Lump sum 2000

9

Tables , wooden board , and

Iron and wooden ruler Lump sum 5000

10

Lumber wood , and other

raw materials Lump sum 10000



Grand sum financing per

cooperative 171050

Required financing for 2

cooperatives 342100

Share of individual member to

total financing 11403


WUB Consult

Subgroup 1.3: Leather Craft

Major Produces: Belts, Wallets, Bags, Key holders, Folders of Camera, Mobile, Piston, etc.

Forms of business ownership: Cooperative, Number of Establishments: Two Cooperatives, Number of persons to be engaged in: 40 persons (20 per

coop)

Table 1.3: Machineries, materials and input requirement for training, production and financial estimates to produce Leather Crafts

No Material and input requirement per cooperative Unit Amount

required

Unit

Price Estimated total cost

1 Shade, store and office construction Lump sum 50000

2 Leather Sewing machine No 1 12000 12000

3

Revolver Puncher , Cutters, Compass, Grinder with brush and Mandrel

(Morsa) Lump sum 5000

4 Iron and plastic hammers, No 30 150 45000

5 Plastic boards and wooden tables Lump sum 5000

6 Stamper , hole making punchers, locker, scissors, Iron and plastic rulers Lump sum 5000

7 Sponge, Wood fix, Glue Lump sum 3000

8 Different decoration materials and sand paper for smoothing objects Lump sum 10000

9 Other materials Lump sum 5000

10 Processed leather Lump sum 20000

11 Utilities Lump sum 1000


Contingency (10%) 16100


Required financing for 2 cooperative 354200

Share of individual member to total financing

8855


WUB Consult

1.4 Other Tourist oriented products

1.4.1: Stone made icons Table 1.4.1: Machineries, materials and input requirement for training, production and financial estimates to

produce stone made icons

Dscription

No of

Estabilishe

ment No of

persons to be

ngaged in

Material and input

requirement per

estabilishement

Unit Amount

required

Estimated

total cost

Cooperative

forms of business 1 10

Shade, and store

construction Lump sum 30,000

Different materials Lump sum 50,000

Total financing per cooperative 80,000

Contingency (10%) 8,000

Grand sum financing per cooperative 88,000


1.4.2: Wool-made products

Table 1.4.2: Machineries, materials and input requirement for training, production and financial estimates to

produce Wool- made ic

Description No. of

establishments

No.

persons

engaged

in

Materials and

equipments

per

establishment

unit Estimated

total cost

Cooperative form of

business

2 20 Shade and

store

construction

Lump

sum 30,000

Total financing per

cooperative Different

materials

Lump

sum 60,000



cooperative 9,000


cooperative 99,000


total financing 198,000


WUB Consult

1.4.3: Fly swatter made of animal tail Table1. 4. 3 Machineries, materials and input requirement for training, production and financial estimates to

produce Fly swatter

Dscription N

o o

f

Est

ab

ilis

hem

en

t

No

of

per

son

s to

be

nga

ged

in

Material and

input requirement

per

estabilishement

Unit Amount

required

Estimated

total cost

Cooperative

forms of

business

1 10

Shade, and store

construction

Lump

sum 30,000

Different materials

Lump

sum 50,000




Share of individual member to total financing 8,800

1.4.4: Pottery products Table 1. 4. 4 Machineries, materials and input requirement for training, production and financial estimates to

produce Pottery products

Dscription

No

o

f

Est

ab

ilis

hem

en

t

No

of

per

son

s to

be

nga

ged

in

Material and input

requirement per

estabilishement

Unit Amount

required

Estimated

total cost

Cooperative

forms of business 1 10

Shade, and store

construction

Lump

sum 30,000

Different materials

Lump

sum 50,000




Share of individual member to total financing 8,800


WUB Consult

Enterprise Group II: Producing Food Items and Urban Agriculture Products

Subgroup 2.1: Home Economic Food Items

Forms of business ownership: cooperative

Number of Establishments: One Cooperative

Number of persons to be engaged in : 15 persons

Table 2.1: Material requirement and financial estimates to produce Home Economic Food Items

No Material and input

requirement per cooperative Unit

Amount

required

Unit

price

Estimated

cost

1 Shade construction and store Lump sum 50000

2

Different stoves use Kerosene

(movable, metallic and bricks) Lump sum 40000

3 Mill(20 HP) No 1 5000 5000

6 Manual grain mill No 2 2000 4000

7 Balance scale(300KG) No 1 7000 7000

9 Utilities and Kerosene Lump sum 3000

10

Other materials including Packing


11

Row materials( Cereals, Pulses,

Ground Red Pepper, Spices, Garlic,

etc)

Lump sum 10000





Sub-Group 2.2: Bakery- Injera

Forms of business ownership: Cooperative:



Table 2.2 List of materials and inputs requirement and financial estimates for

Bakery- Injera

No

Material and input

requirement per

cooperative

Unit Amount

required

Unit

price

Estimated

cost

1

Shade construction and

store Lump sum 50000

2 Electric stoves No 5 1500 7500

3

Bricks made non

electric stoves No 5 300 1500

4

Barrels , Keg and

Buckets, Dough pot, Lump sum 10000

5 Balance scale No 1 3000 7000


WUB Consult


7 Utilities and fuel wood Lump sum 5000

8

Raw materials(Teff,

Millet, other crops) Lump sum 10000

Total financing per

cooperative 93000



cooperative 102300

Share of individual member

to total financing 10230

Subgroup 2.3: Bakery – Bread

Forms of business ownership: Cooperative

Number of Establishment: Two Cooperative


Table 2.3 List of materials and inputs requirement and financial estimates

for Bakery – Bread

No

Material and input

requirement per

cooperative

Unit Amount

required

Unit

price

Estimated

cost


2 Bakery machine (with dual

Battery ) No 1 6000 6000

3 Barrels , Keg and Buckets ,

Kneading trough ,Dough pot Lump sum 4000


5 Steel yard No 1 3000 3000


7 Electricity and Water Lump sum 3000

9 Raw materials(Wheat and

Barely flour) Quintal 20 800 16000

Total per cooperative 87000


Grand sum financing required

per cooperative 95700

Grand sum financing for two

cooperatives 191400




WUB Consult

Subgroup 2.4: Apiculture (Honey production)


Number of Establishments: Two Cooperative


Table 2.4: List of materials and inputs requirement and financial estimates for

Honey production

No

Material and input

requirement per cooperative

Unit Amount

required

Unit price Estimated

cost

1 Office, store and sales shop Lump sum 30000

2 Modern Beehives No 100 1000 100000

3 Bee Colony Hives 100 500 50000

4 Frame spoke Meter 20 300 6000

6 Wax Kg 100 60 6000

7 Dungarees (working cloth) No 20 100 2000

8 Honey refining material No 1 5000 5000

9 Additional feedings(sugar and

powders) 6000

10 Others Lump sum 5000




Grand sum financing for two cooperatives 462000


Subgroup 2.5: Dairy Farm (Raising milk producing cows)


Number of Establishments: - 3 Cooperatives

Number of persons to be engaged in : 45 persons(15 persons per

cooperative)

Table 2.5 List of materials and inputs requirement and financial estimates for Dairy

Farm

No

Material and input

requirement per

cooperative

Unit Amount

required

Unit

price

Estimated

cost

1

Barn , drinking and feeding

trough and feed store

construction

Lump

sum 10000

2 Dairy cows (or Heifers) No 10 10000 100000

3

Feeding ( hay ,straw and

factory byproducts)

Lump

sum 10000


WUB Consult

4 Water line installation

Lump

sum 2000

5 Utilities and Medication

Lump

sum 2000

7 Other materials

Lump

sum 1000




cooperative 137500




Subgroup 2.6: Sheep Fattening

Forms of business ownership: Sole proprietorship

Number of Establishments: 20 Individual farms


Table 2.6: List of materials and inputs requirement and financial estimates for

Sheep Fattening

No

Material and input

requirement per

individual

Unit Amount

required

Unit

price

Estimated

cost

1

Barn construction and

drinking and feeding

trough

Lump

sum 1000

2 Sheep No 15 300 4500

3

Feeding (Hay and

other)

Lump

sum 2000

Total financing per

individual 7500



individual 8250


persons 165000


WUB Consult

Enterprise Group III: Textile and Garment

Subgroup 3.1: Modern Weaving


Number of Establishments: - one cooperative


Table 3.1: List of materials and inputs requirement and financial estimates for Modern

Weaving work

No

Material and input

requirement per

cooperative

Unit Amount

required

Unit

price

Estimated

cost

1

Construction of shade , store

and sales shop Lump sum 50000

2 Modern weaving machine No 20 6000 120000

3

Other machineries and


4 Spinning wheel Kg 20 700 14000

5 Weaving chair No 20 350 7000

6

Raw materials (inputs like

Warp and Weft ) Lump sum 5000





Subgroup 3.2: Modern Embroidery and Sewing


Number of Establishments: One cooperative


Table 3.2: List of materials and inputs requirement and financial estimates for Modern

Embroidery and Sewing

No

Material and input

requirement per

cooperative

Unit Amount

required

Unit

price

Estimated

cost

1

Shade construction, store &

display shop Lump sum 50000

1 Sewing machine No 10 8000 80000

2 Cutting tables and chairs No 10 1000 10000


4 Raw materials and Inputs Lump sum 10000



WUB Consult



cooperative 167200



Subgroup 3.3: Carpet Production

Forms of business ownership: Individual Ownership

Number of Establishments: 10


Table 3.3: List of materials and inputs requirement and financial estimates

for Carpet Production

No

Material and input

requirement per 10

carpet makers

Unit Amount

required Estimated cost

1 Shade construction

lump

sum 1 30000

2 Row materials

lump

sum 20000

3 Machines and materials

lump

sum 50000

Total financing for 10

individual producer 100000


Grand sum 110000

Share of individual

member to total financing 11000


WUB Consult

Enterprise Group IV: Construction Materials Subgroup 4.1: Block production


Number of Establishments: One Cooperative ; Number of persons to be engaged in : 20 persons

Table 4.1: List of materials and inputs requirement and financial estimates for Block (Blocket) production

No Material and input requirement per cooperative

Unit Amount

required

Unit price Estimated cost


2 Block production machinery with 4 moulds No 1 25000 25000

3 Mixer No 1 30000 30000

4 Wooden panels No 1000 20 20000

5 Water tanker No 1 600 600

6 Wheal barrow No 5 800 4000

7 Other materials (Shovels, plastic jar, Trowels, etc) Lump sum 3000

8 Cements Quintals 100 450 45000

9 Sands Truck 10 1500 15000

10 Gravel M3 50 100 5000

11 Red sand M3 60 100 6000


13 Loading unloading Lump sum 5000






WUB Consult

Subgroup 4.2: Red Stone Production and Carving


Number of Establishments: 2 Cooperatives

Number of persons to be engaged in : 20 persons, (10 persons per cooperative)

Table 4.2: List of materials and inputs requirement and financial estimates for Red Stone production


Unit Amount

required

Unit

price

Estimated cost

1 Store and office construction Lump sum 20000

2 Different weight and types of Hammers No 30 150 4500

3 Different types of Chisels No 30 50 1500

4 Pegs No 30 50 1500

5 “Squadera” No 15 100 1500

6 Safety Goggles No 30 100 3000

7 Shovels No 30 50 1500

8 Hoes No 30 50 1500

9 Dungarees (Working cloth) No 30 150 4500

10 Utilities and other materials Lump sum 3000

11 Fees for quarries Lump sum 10000







WUB Consult

Subgroup 4.3: Gravel Production

Forms of business ownership: cooperative



Table 4.3: List of materials and inputs requirement and financial estimates for Gravel production

No

Material and input requirement per

cooperative

Unit Amount

required

Unit

price

Estimated cost


2 Crusher( 8 Hours service) No 1 150000 150000

2 Engine 495 A 35KW No 1 30000 30000

3 Sieved frame No 1 50000 50000

4 Wheelbarrow No 15 800 12000

5 Safety goggle No 30 100 3000

6 Sledge Hammer No 30 150 4500


8 Raw materials Lump sum 20000

9 Machinery installation and site preparation Lump sum 5000

10 Quarry site preparation Lump sum 5000






WUB Consult

Subgroup 4.4: Cobblestone Paving Forms of business ownership: Cooperative

Number of Establishments: 2 Cooperative

Number of persons to be engaged in : 30 persons ( 15 persons per cooperative)

Table 4.4: List of materials and inputs requirement and financial estimates for Cobblestone paving work


Unit Amount

required

Unit

price

Estimated cost

1 Store and office construction Lump sum 20000

2 Machinery for labeling (Rollo) Lump sum 100000

3 Measuring material No 20 350 7000

4 Sledge Hammer(4 kg) and other types of Hammers No 25 150 2500

5 Special hammers for cobblestone works No 20 200 4000

6 Flat Chisels No 20 50 1000

7 Spiky Chisels No 20 75 1500

8 Straight edges (3m) No 10 50 500

9 Wheelbarrows No 5 800 4000

10 Shovels No 10 50 500

11 Rakes with teeth No 20 100 2000

12 Pickaxes No 20 50 1000

13 Other materials including first aid box Lump sum 3000







WUB Consult

Enterprise Group V: Door to Door Dry Waste Collection and Compost Making Forms of business ownership: Cooperative, Number of Establishments: One Cooperative, Number of persons to be engaged in: 15 persons

Table 5: List of materials and inputs requirement and financial estimates for Cobblestone paving work


Unit Amount

required

Unit

price

Estimated cost

1 Shade for compost production , and Store for materials Lump sum 60000

2 Different size and types of hand driven carts No 5 1000 5000

3 Mesh wire made - cart for non Asphalted road No 2 5000 10000

4 Wheel borrows No 5 800 4000

5 Different types of Dust bins No 10 600 6000

6 Dungarees (Working dress) No 40 150 6000

7 Shovels No 20 50 1000

8 Fork No 20 50 1000

9 Pickaxe No 10 50 500

9 Buckets No 10 100 1000


11 Water tanker No 3 1000 3000

12 Different chemicals for bad smell Lump sum 1000

12 Other materials (Goggles, Buckets, Hat, Shoes etc) Lump sum 5000







WUB Consult

Enterprise Group VI: Commercial Activities: Retail Trading Table 6: Types of Retail trading, no of people to be engaged in and estimates of start up capital and cost for shade, shop and materials

No

No

Types of retail trade

Fo

rms

of

bu

sin

ess

ow

ner

ship

No

of

Est

ab

lish

men

ts

N

o o

f p

eo

ple

to

be

en

ga

ged

in

Sta

rt

up

ca

pit

al

per

ind

ivid

ual

Co

st f

or S

ho

p

co

nst

ru

cti

on

a

nd

ma

teria

ls

per

ind

ivid

ual

Co

st f

or S

ho

p

co

nst

ru

cti

on

an

d

ma

teria

ls

per

coo

pera

tiv

e

To

tal

fin

an

cia

l

req

uir

em

en

t p

er

ind

ivid

ual

Gra

nd

su

m f

or

pro

po

sed

bu

sin

ess

est

ab

lish

men

ts

1 Building Material Shop Cooperative 2 40 7000 _ 100000 12000 480000

2 Fish Product Supplier Cooperative 1 20 5000 _ 140000 12000 240000

3 Soft Drink Distributer Cooperative 1 15 7000 _ 75000 12000 180000

4 Super Market Cooperative 3 30 5000 _ 7000 12000 360000

5 Car Sparepart Shop Cooperative 2 20 6000 _ 60000 12000 240000

6 Mini Market Individual ownership 5 5 5000 7000 _ 12000 60000

7 Cosmotic Shop Individual ownership 5 5 5000 7000 _ 12000 60000

8 Kiosks(Grocery store) Individual ownership 10 10 4000 8000 12000 120000

9 Meat Selling Individual ownership 10 10 5000 7000 12000 120000

10 Veranda Grain Trade Individual ownership 5 5 4000 8000 12000 60000

11 Sale of Fruits and

Vegetables Individual ownership 10 10 3000

9000 12000 120000

12 Canned Honey and Butter Trade Individual ownership 5 5 5000 7000 12000 60000

13 Sheep and Goat Trade Individual ownership 10 10 10000 - 10000 100000

14 Cattle Trade Individual ownership 10 10 10000 - 10000 100000

15 Shoe Shop Individual ownership 5 5 5000 7000 12000 60000

16 Small Boutiques Individual ownership 5 5 5000 7000 12000 60000

17 Cultural Clothes shop Individual ownership 5 5 5000 7000 12000 60000

18 Skin and Hides Trade Individual ownership 5 5 5000 7000 12000 60000

19 Farm Tools and Equipment

Trading Individual ownership 5 5 5000

7000 12000 60000

Total estimated financial requirement for Wholesale and Retail Trade establishments 2,600,000


WUB Consult

Table 7: Types of Service trading, no of people to be engaged in and estimates of start up capital and cost for shade, shop and materials

No Types of retail trade Fo

rms

of

bu

sin

ess

ow

nersh

ip

No

of

est

ab

lish

men

ts

No

of

per

son

s p

er

coo

pera

tiv

e

To

tal

no

of

peo

ple

to b

e e

ngag

ed

in

Sta

rt

up

ca

pit

al

an

d m

ate

ria

ls

per

est

ab

lish

men

t/in

div

idu

al

Co

st f

or

co

nst

ru

cti

on

a

nd

mach

iner

ies

per

est

ab

lish

men

t

To

tal

fin

an

cin

g

per

est

ab

lish

men

t/

ind

ivid

ual

Gra

nd

su

m

to

fin

an

cin

g

the

pro

po

sed

bu

sin

ess

acti

vit

ies

1 Cafeteria Cooperative 2 10 20 20000 100000 120000 240000

2 Tea Room Individual

ownership 10 _ 10 2000 6000 8000 80000

3 Local Drink : Tej Making Individual

ownership 5 _ 5 4000 8000 12000 60000

4 Small Restaurant Cooperative 2 10 20 20000 100000 120000 240000

5 Beauty Salon (Hair Dressing) Individual

ownership 5 _ 5 4000 8000 12000 60000

6 Barber

Individual

ownership 5 _ 5 4000 8000 12000 60000

7 Tire Repair Cooperative 1 10 10 50000 50000 100000 100000

8 Car Washing Cooperative 1 10 10 20000 100000 120000 120000

9 Pool (Billiard) House

Individual

ownership 5 _ 5 5000 7000 12000 60000

10 Video and TV show

Individual

ownership 5 _ 5 7000 5000 12000 60000

11 Mill Service( Grain, Pulse,

Spices) Cooperative 5 10 50 10000 110000 120000 600000

12 Bathing Service Cooperative 3 10 30 10000 100000 110000 330000

13 Laundry Service Cooperative 2 10 20 20000 100000 120000 240000

14 Electronic and Mobile

Maintenance

Individual

ownership 10 _ 10 4000 8000 12000 120000

Total estimated financial requirement for Service Trade establishments 2,370,000


WUB Consult

Annex II: Training Needs and Estimated Training Cost


WUB Consult

I. Technical and Operational Skill and Capacity Development Training

Table 2.1: No of trainees and trainers, training topics and duration and estimated cost

Bu

sin

ess

ente

rp

rise

s

Tra

inin

g

top

ics

Trainees Trainers

To

tal

tech

nic

al

tra

inin

g c

ost

Recommended Trainers

No

of

tra

inees

No

of

day

s

Co

st p

er

da

y/t

rain

ee

Su

b t

ota

l f

or

tra

inees

No

of

tra

iners

No

of

day

s

Co

st

per

da

y

Su

b t

ota

l f

or

tra

iners

Tourism related metal craft

production

Use of machineries,

designing objects ,

cutting, welding,

hammering, etc

40 90 20 72000 4 90 200 72000 144000

Experienced persons engaged

in metallic works(From

Lalibela , Dessie ) and

instructors from city TVET

center

Production of tourism related

Woodwork products

Use of machineries ,

designing objects ,

cutting, , hammering,

etc

30 90 20 54000 3 90 200 54000 108000


in wood works from the

Lalibela City and instructors

from the city TVET center

Production of tourism related

Leather crafts

Use of machineries ,

designing objects ,

cutting, , hammering,

decorating ,

40 90 20 72000 4 90 200 72000 144000


in Leather craft works in the

Lalibela City and instructors

from city TVET center

Production of Stone –made,

Wool - Made, Fly Swatter and

Pottery - tourism related

products

Use of handtools, small

machines, designing

objects , shape

designing, cutting, ,

decorating , etc

50 45 20 45000 5 45 200 45000 90000


in Wood , Wool, Fly Skatter

and Pottery

Food Items

Food reservation

,protecting from

contamination, packing

and preparation

15 15 20 4500 2 15 200 6000 10500

Professionals and experienced

persons from hotels and

restaurants, instructors from

Colleges

Bakery- Injera

Food reservation,

protecting

contamination, packing

10 10 20 2000 2 10 200 4000 6000 Professionals and experienced

persons from private sectors


WUB Consult

Cont… Technical training B

usi

nes

s

ente

rp

rise

s

Tra

inin

g

top

ics

Trainees Trainers

To

tal

tech

nic

al

tra

inin

g c

ost

Recommended Trainers

No

of

tra

inees

No

of

day

s

Co

st p

er

da

y/t

rain

ee

Su

bto

tal

tra

inees

No

of

tra

iners

No

of

day

s

Co

st p

er

day

Su

b t

ota

l f

or

tra

iners

Bakery-Bread

Use of materials , hygiene,

keeping from contamination,

packing, ,and bread

preparation

20 10 20 4000 2 10 200 4000 8000 Professionals and experienced

persons from private sectors

Apiculture(Honey

production)

Bee keeping, honey

harvesting, insect protecting ,

etc

40 20 20 16000 4 20 200 16000 32000 Experts from city urban agricultural

development office

Dairy farms

Cattle raising, feeding, health

protection, milking and

keeping milk from

contamination

45 20 20 18000 3 20 200 12000 30000

Experts from city urban agricultural

development office , experienced

person engaged in dairy farming

Sheep fattening Feeding and health protection 20 10 20 4000 2 10 200 4000 8000

Experts from city urban agricultural

development office and

experienced person engaged in

Modern Weaving work

Use of modern weaving

machine and other materials,

weaving design , weaving

techniques ,etc

20 90 20 36000 3 90 200 54000 90000


individuals , instructors from the

city TVET center

Modern embroidery and

sewing

Use of machine, Design, ,

cutting, measuring, sewing,

etc.

15 90 20 27000 3 90 200 54000 81000


persons from private sectors and

instructors from TVET center


WUB Consult

Cont ...Technical training B

usi

nes

s

ente

rp

rise

s

Tra

inin

g

top

ics

Trainees Trainers

To

tal

tech

nic

al

tra

inin

g c

ost

Recommended

trainers

No

of

tra

inees

No

of

day

s

Co

st

per

da

y

Su

b t

ota

l fo

r

tra

inees

No

of

tra

iners

No

of

day

s

Co

st p

er

day

Su

bto

tal

for

tra

iners

Carpet Production

Differenty Types of carpet

design , use of handtools and

machinies , use of mixing inks

,production of carpets,etc

10 30 20 6000 2 30 200 12000 18000

Block production

Types of blocks, use of

machineries, , mixing raw

materials , keeping product

quality, production of blocks

20 90 20 36000 4 90 200 72000 108000

City TVET instructors,

professionals and

experienced persons from

private sectors

Red stone production

Use of materials and tools,

keeping production quality,

safety measures , environmental

protection awareness,

rehabilitating quarries properly

20 45 20 18000 3 45 200 27000 45000

Experienced persons from

private sectors and staffs

from city environmental

protection office

Gravel production

Managing quarries, Keeping

quality of raw materials and

production, , use of machineries, 30 90 20 54000 3 90 200 54000 108000

City TVET instructors,

professionals and

experienced persons from

private sector

Cobblestones Paving

Use of machineries and tools,

surveying, measuring and on

job paving training,

30 45 20 27000 3 45 200 27000 54000

Civil engineers involved in

cobblestone works,

experienced persons

Dry Waste Collection and

compost making

Solid waste management,

collection and transporting of

solid wastes, preparing for

compost production, compost

making, and environmental

protection awareness

15 20 20 6000 3 20 200 12000 18000

City Urban -Agricultural

development office, City

cleanness and beautification

office , city environmental

protection office

Training cost for technical and operational

skill and capacity development

501500 601000 1102500


WUB Consult

II. Business, Marketing and Leadership Skill and Capacity Development Training

Table2.3.No of trainees, trainers and training topics and duration and estimated training cost

Business

enterprises

Trainings

topics

Trainees Trainers

To

tal

bu

sin

ess

skil

l

tra

inin

g c

ost

Recommended

trainers

No

of

tra

inee

s

No

of

da

ys

Co

st p

er

da

y

Su

b t

ota

l

for

tra

inee

s

No

of

tra

iner

s

No

of

da

ys

Co

st p

er

da

y

Su

b t

ota

l

for

tra

iner

s

Metal craft

production

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill

40 5 20 4000 4 5 100 2000 6000 Experts from MSEs office &

City TVET Instructors

Woodwork products

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill



Leather crafts

production

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill



Production of Stone

–made, Wool -

Made, Fly Swatter

and Pottery -

tourism related

products

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill



Food items

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill



Bakery - Injera

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill



Bakery-Bread

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill

20 5 20 2000 2 5 100 1000 3000

Experts from MSEs office &


Apiculture(Honey

production)

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill

40 5 20 4000 4 5 100 2000 6000



Dairy farms

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill

45 5 20 4500 3 5 100 1500 6000



Sheep fattening Business 20 5 20 2000 1 5 100 500 2500 Experts from MSEs office &


WUB Consult

,marketing and

leadership skill


Weaving

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill



Modern Embroidery

and Sewing

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill



Carpet Production

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill



Block(Blocket)

production

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill



Cont 2.4: Business skill training

Business

enterprises

Trainings

topics

Trainees Trainers

To

tal

bu

sin

ess

skil

l

tra

inin

g c

ost

Recommended

trainers

No

of

tra

inee

s

No

of

da

ys

Co

st p

er

da

y

Su

b t

ota

l

for

tra

inee

s

No

of

tra

iner

s

No

of

da

ys

Co

st p

er

da

y

Su

b t

ota

l

for

tra

iner

s

Red stone

production

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill



Gravel production

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill



Cobblestone paving

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill



Dry waste collection

and Compost

Making

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill 15 5 20 1500 2 5 100 1000 2500



Wholsale and Retail

trading

Business

,marketing and

leadership skill



Service trading Business

,marketing and 185 5 20 18500 11 5 100 5500 24000




WUB Consult

leadership skill

Training cost for Business , Marketing and

Leadership skill development training 87000 34000 121000

Total Cost for Training 588500 63500

0 1223500

III. Trainning Refereshiment Cost

Refereshiment cost for training was also estimated based on the assumption that Birr 10 for a trainee and Birr 20 for a trainner per day

is required for tea, coffee and water (for trainers). Thus, considering number of trainees and trainers as well as training days, a total of

Birr 369,650 is estimated for referesheemnt (of which Birr 318,450 is for trainees and Birr 51,200 is for trainers). The estimated

refereshiment cost is included as part of training cost separetelly.

VI. Rent for Trainning Places (Hall and Class Room Rent)

It is intended that training should be carried out in class rooms in the City TVET centre and Preparatory school, particularly in

TVET Workshops apart from on job training where similar activities are practiced in the city. Training to be undertaken in the

class rooms is intended to be carried out after the daily regular school time and in the weakends and/or during the annual and bi-

annual break of the regular school season .

Use of classrooms should incur costs to be paid up for the school administration. Thus it is assumed that at least Birr 50 is required

perday for renting a classroom. Based on this assumption, and considering number of training days a total of Birr 50,500 is

required for renting cost.


WUB Consult

Annex III: List of Intended Target Beneficiaries


WUB Consult

List of intended target beneficiaries

Intended Target beneficiaries from people to be relocated

No Name Sex Socioeconomic group Locality

1 Fntaye Lakew Kassa Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

2 Asnaqw Anawt Tarkegh Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

3 Dasash Melaku Feten Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

4 Angwch Fekade Asefa Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

5 Demeku Amare Bogale Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

6 Gudaye Yemataw Getu Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

7 Enanaw Sifera Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

8 Desta Sfew Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

9 Yemata Zenebe Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

10 Lakech Getamesay Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

11 Fentanesh Kefyalew Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

12 Misaye Yismaw Desta Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

13 Segedu Tesfaye Sisaye Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

14 Zeritu Molla Reta Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

15 Atala Getenet Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

16 Mulugeta Mersha Maru Male Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

17 Zewde Abreham Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

18 Abeba Asefaw Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

19 Tesfa Wedaj Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

20 Misge Melku Male Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

21 Emameye Wasihun Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

22 Belaynesh Chekole Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

23 Kibret Mezemer Male Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

24 Habitam Birra Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

25 Tirngo Asnake Welde Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

26 Meselu Kefle Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

27 Etewena Setota Tawneh Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde


WUB Consult

28 Mulu Asmare Tesema Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

29 Fentaye Mulaw Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

30 Zenebe Abera Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

31 Tiruwork Abebe Ayalew Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

32 Abeba Gremeu Tegegh Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

33 Belaynesh Aweke Geremu Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

34 Beletu Bezabeh Ereda Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

35 Erteban Gelaw Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

36 Worknesh Beyne Sefe Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

37 Demeku Abera Tedla Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

38 Ennaw Akenaw Workneh Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

39 Tesfu Tere G/Mariam Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

40 Wubit Alula W/Semyat Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

41 Fasika Deblek Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

42 Wubaly Wodajo Beyn Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

43 Yeshi Terfe Yetbark Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

44 Belaynesh Asfaw Adisu Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

45 Birhane Mebratu Besher Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

46 Yemata Setarge Shebeshi Male Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

47 Mantegbosh Salele Siksegh Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

48 Eqaye Tesma Yemer Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

49 Enanu Abebaw Yirsa Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

50 Genete Demese Male Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

51 Alemitu Ketema Yewhla Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

52 Bernesh Alemu Mekonne Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

53 Demeku G/Hiwot Hailu Male Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

54 Zenbech Abera Zewdu Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

55 Enanu Tasew Admeke Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

56 Asnake Berihun Asmare Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

57 Emaghe Mekonne Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

58 Angwach Amare Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

59 Tshaye Dubale Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde


WUB Consult

60 Yezabnesh Mola Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

61 Adena Newte Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

62 Genet Fentaw Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

63 Tsega Kebadu Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

64 Ergoye Birhane Asenake Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

65 Etenesh Zerfu Shibeshi Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

66 Berye Ashenf Arega Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

67 Melka Aweke Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

68 Shiferaw Mamye Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

69 Ennaw Mengaw Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

70 Birke Negash Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

71 Tehune Alemayh Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

72 Wagaye Alemnew Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

73 Yeshi Setotaw Alemu Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

74 Belaynesh Fentaw Gebru Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

75 Zemde Tadese Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

76 Mushera Tequre Male Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

77 Askale Misganw Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

78 Lule Desta Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

79 Enanu Kebede Belew Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

80 Salye Fentaw Male Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

81 Yemata Kebede Belew Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

82 Desta Amare Getahun Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

83 Gudada Mengesha Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

84 Tirngua Kibret Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

85 Tegarda Birra Reta Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

86 Yeshiharge Wagaye Asmmaw Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

87 Muleye Gete Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

88 Belane Hsen Dawud Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

89 Bernesh Bistegh Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

90 Tasech Reda Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde

91 Rita Adisu Female Engaged in Petty trading Addishadde


WUB Consult

92 Mamitu Melaku Female Unemployed Addishadde

93 Kalekidan Fentaw Female Unemployed Addishadde

94 Yezabe Mngaw Salelw Female Unemployed Addishadde

95 Aberash Tedla Wedajew Female Unemployed Addishadde

96 Genete Tedla Wedajew Male Unemployed Addishadde

97 Emawaye Mengesha Dese Female Unemployed Addishadde

98 Desta Asenakew Atalye Female Unemployed Addishadde

99 Amsal Yetbarke Kasaw Female Unemployed Addishadde

100 Hailu Kebede Male Unemployed Addishadde

101 Abera Ambelu Male Unemployed Addishadde

102 Mushrit Adera Female Unemployed Addishadde

103 Workenesh Abebaw Female Unemployed Addishadde

104 Adlaw Kasaye Female Unemployed Addishadde

105 Ehetye Abegaz Embiale Female Unemployed Addishadde

106 Meseret Asefa Female Unemployed Addishadde

107 Ephrem Asefa Male Unemployed Addishadde

108 Eyayaw Tesfay Male Unemployed Addishadde

109 Ayehu Alemu Male Unemployed Addishadde

110 Bekele Demse Male Unemployed Addishadde

111 Adne Agez Female Unemployed Addishadde

112 Abreham Zewde Male Unemployed Addishadde

113 Belaynesh Desalgh Male Unemployed Addishadde

114 Yonas Abreha Female Unemployed Addishadde

115 Geditu Wagaw Male Unemployed Addishadde

116 Kasaye Alemu Female Unemployed Addishadde

117 Abaynesh Alemayhu Female Unemployed Addishadde

118 Sisaye Amare Male Unemployed Addishadde

119 Tilahun Tadesse G/Michale Male Unemployed Addishadde

120 Atsed Getachw Female Unemployed Addishadde

121 Anguch Shiferaw Female Unemployed Addishadde

122 Desta Asmare Sefew Female Unemployed Addishadde

123 Genet Asmire Abje Female Unemployed Addishadde


WUB Consult

124 Enanaw Akanaw Female Unemployed Addishadde

125 Mulugeta Asefa Male Unemployed Addishadde

126 Beyene Abate Yigzaw Male Unemployed Addishadde

127 Enna Teggh Gubena Female Unemployed Addishadde

128 Tiruye Guch Female Unemployed Addishadde

129 Tadesse Tafach Male Unemployed Addishadde

130 Ayale Sew Bewnetu Male Unemployed Addishadde

131 Amakele Mekonne Female Unemployed Addishadde

132 G/Silase Weday Biste Male Unemployed Addishadde

133 Desta Zeru Female Unemployed Addishadde

134 Belaynesh Alemye Female Unemployed Addishadde

135 Aster Tadese Mengiste Female Unemployed Addishadde

136 Fertuna Worku Aderajew Female Unemployed Addishadde

137 Selam Sisay Female Unemployed Addishadde

138 Melkame Getnete Female Unemployed Addishadde

139 Weynitu Afrasha Getu Female Unemployed Addishadde

140 Bizuye Chere Zegeye Female Unemployed Addishadde

141 Yeshiarg Habtamu Akalnew Female Unemployed Addishadde

142 Etetu Adane Yilma Female Unemployed Addishadde

143 Beletu W/Michale Desta Female Unemployed Addishadde

144 Haftu Destaw Temsgen Male Unemployed Addishadde

145 Eteye Destaw Temsgen Female Unemployed Addishadde

146 Dirbe Worke Tegegh Female Unemployed Addishadde

147 Fentay Asfaw Nigatu Female Unemployed Addishadde

148 Yeshi Alem Gelanew Female Unemployed Addishadde

149 Mulu Andarge Mola Female Unemployed Addishadde

150 Terfe Yesmaw Destaw Male Unemployed Addishadde

151 Sinke Adege Niguse Female Unemployed Addishadde

152 Abeje Getahun Atalay Male Unemployed Addishadde

153 Yatebiya Anagre Teka Female Unemployed Addishadde

154 Ennah Checkol Nigatu Female Unemployed Addishadde

155 Muluwork Nega Setargew Female Unemployed Addishadde


WUB Consult

156 Eskedar Zemen Yilma Female Unemployed Addishadde

157 Habitamu Adane Female Unemployed Addishadde

158 Desta Gelaw Female Unemployed Addishadde

159 Tigist Abebe Female Unemployed Addishadde

160 Yohanes Abebe Male Unemployed Addishadde

161 Sisaynew Atalele Male Unemployed Addishadde

162 Manalebesh Wanawe Female Unemployed Addishadde

163 Ayalesew Bewntu Female Unemployed Addishadde

164 Zufan Female Unemployed Addishadde

165 Fitfet Tesfa Female Unemployed Addishadde

166 Zenebe Beyene Kasaw Female Unemployed Addishadde

167 Worke Tadesse Wube Female Unemployed Addishadde

168 Kasaye Getahun Female Unemployed Addishadde

169 Atsed Mengistu W/Kiros Female Unemployed Addishadde

170 Abaynesh Baye Alemu Female Unemployed Addishadde

171 Eden Baye Alemu Female Unemployed Addishadde

172 Lastawork Baye Alemu Female Unemployed Addishadde

173 Endayhu Biste Tefera Female Unemployed Addishadde

174 Ledetu Gedam Wale Male Unemployed Addishadde

175 Eyobe Wale Gedam Male Unemployed Addishadde

176 Melkam Tesfaw Guche Female Unemployed Addishadde

177 Yirga Mekonne Male Unemployed Addishadde

178 Atref Tesfaye Asmmaw Female Unemployed Addishadde

179 Beye Shiferaw Mebre Male Unemployed Addishadde

180 Aynalem Gelaw Wagaye Female Unemployed Addishadde

181 Asnake Berihun Asmare Male Unemployed Addishadde

182 Tshaynesh Asefa Female Unemployed Addishadde

183 Aregash Mola Female Unemployed Addishadde

184 Lastawork Baye Female Unemployed Addishadde

185 Etenesh Ambaw Female Unemployed Addishadde

186 Habtamu Getachew Male Unemployed Addishadde

187 Alemnesh Ejegu Female Unemployed Addishadde


WUB Consult

188 Abaynesh Mekonne Female Unemployed Addishadde

189 Mandefiro Tadese Male Unemployed Addishadde

190 Kasay Kebede Male Unemployed Addishadde

191 Sefiu Reda Male Unemployed Addishadde

192 Adeno Alemu Male Unemployed Addishadde

193 Ambaw Kibret Male Unemployed Addishadde

194 Washun Tesgaye Male Unemployed Addishadde

195 Eshetu Abate Male Unemployed Addishadde

196 Dawit Yeshitila Male Unemployed Addishadde

197 Tshaye Tegegh Female Unemployed Addishadde

198 Mulu Benalfw Female Unemployed Addishadde

199 Anguach Gebru Female Unemployed Addishadde

200 Worknesh Moges Female Unemployed Addishadde

201 Yalemwork Belete Zewdu Female Unemployed Addishadde

202 Shekfe Kibret Kasaw Female Unemployed Addishadde

203 Emahoy Astatke Mola Female Unemployed Addishadde

204 Bezuayhu Wedajenew Kiflu Female Unemployed Addishadde

205 Zeyen Wagaw Admasu Female Unemployed Addishadde

206 Fenta Melku Female Unemployed Addishadde

207 Terfe Negash Female Unemployed Addishadde

208 Teshaynesh Zewde Female Unemployed Addishadde

209 Desta Menbere Anawt Female Unemployed Addishadde

210 Birchko Amberber Desta Female Unemployed Addishadde

211 Genet Asefa Female Unemployed Addishadde

212 Lastawork G/Selase Female Unemployed Addishadde

213 Gelaytu Wube Female Unemployed Addishadde

214 Serke Tilaye Ageze Female Unemployed Addishadde

215 Zekarias Sisaye Male Unemployed Addishadde

216 Yonas Tadese Male Unemployed Addishadde

217 Kifle Abebe Male Unemployed Addishadde

218 Binyame Hodenew Male Unemployed Addishadde

219 Zelalem Misganw Biyarge Male Unemployed Addishadde


WUB Consult

Intended Target beneficiaries from people to be relocated


247 Emahoy Gudaye Berihun Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

248 Tayeseged Abera Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

220 Tefera Misganw Biyarge Male Unemployed Addishadde

221 Sete Misganw Biyarge Female Unemployed Addishadde

222 Yeshiye Fentaw Female Unemployed Addishadde

223 Setewezero Fentaw Female Unemployed Addishadde

224 Eleni Getaneh Female Unemployed Addishadde

225 Zerihune Getaneh Male Unemployed Addishadde

226 Habte Hailu Male Unemployed Addishadde

227 Mekonne Hailu Male Unemployed Addishadde

228 Yengus Hailu Female Unemployed Addishadde

229 Askale Achenfe Gedelu Female Unemployed Addishadde

230 Alemu Meniye Male Unemployed Addishadde

231 Tsega Kasa Female Unemployed Addishadde

232 Adis Birhanu Sewneh Female Unemployed Addishadde

233 Endayehu Melse Male Unemployed Addishadde

234 Sisaye Asefa Wase Male Unemployed Addishadde

235 Mulu Tesfaw Female Unemployed Addishadde

236 Saba Tewld Female Unemployed Addishadde

237 Mekdes Amare Female Unemployed Addishadde

238 Welde Arage Female Unemployed Addishadde

239 Ameha Aligaz Male Unemployed Addishadde

240 Mulu Getinet Abebe Male Unemployed Addishadde

241 Tazezew Getinet Abebe Female Unemployed Addishadde

242 Daghchew Desal Male Unemployed Addishadde

243 Estegenet Ereta Meshesha Female Vulnerable (Elderly)

Addishadde

244 Sisaynesh Gezahegh Gefe Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

245 Sisaye Akele W/Tekele Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

246 Chekolech Eshete Aragw Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde


WUB Consult

249 Gelaytu Adege Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

250 Kelemu Engidawork Meshesha Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

251 Emawye Getu Adera Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

252 E/Wede Feleke Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

253 Yeset Belay Adenw Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

254 Bayush Abebe G/Medhen Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

255 Getu Yemer Felek Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

256 Alemu Areke Taw Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

257 Melkam Abeje Tekaw Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

258 Lezbe Tesema Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

259 Etagegh Zelelw Aleme Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

260 Mekonen W/Michale Desta Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

261 Jemanesh Ali Negw Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

262 Felek Asmamaw Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

263 Worke Tegegh Mengisha Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

264 Lekitu Hailu W/Rufael Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

265 Kasaye Solomon Niguse Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

266 Chane Mengistu Kelkay Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

267 Taytu Muhamed Ali Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

268 Enanu Gesse Ayele Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

269 Mekonne Fetene Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

270 Birhanu Asmare Arega Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

271 Gudaye Fentaye W/Kiros Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

272 Tiruharge Tegaw Aleme Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

273 Mengiste Tesema W/Selase Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

274 Alemye Yalew Ageze Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

275 Aleka Baye Alemu G/Medhine Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

276 Endaftu Teshome Ereta Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

277 Mairgu Setarge Ayalew Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

278 Getachw Tedla Selshi Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

279 Haylmichale Getachw Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

280 Yitbarke Getachw Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde


WUB Consult

281 Alemtshay Getachw Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

282 Fasika Getachw Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

283 Yebekale Ayalew Hailu Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

284 Desta Asnake Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

285 Alganesh Tesema Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

286 Belaynesh Chekol Aboye Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

287 Etenate Chekol Aboye Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

288 Misaye Dese Abebe Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

289 Misganw Bitw Damna Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

290 Tewba Derb Asrese Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

291 Kasech Yemataw Yimam Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

292 Emahoy Yezena Eyasu Mihretu Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

293 Kasech Birra Wubeshet Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

294 Asefa Dinklej Sefiw Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

295 Abebech Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

296 E/y Abere Taye Wendmagegh Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

297 E/y Derese Adughw Fekade Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

298 Alemu Birele Atalel Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

299 Adise Bistegh Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

300 Yayesh Qlocho Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

301 Jemanesh Tesema Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

302 Kasa Sisaye Tegegh Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

303 Beyench Asmrew Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

304 Bekele Awke Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

305 Birhanu Abate Reda Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

306 Demkech Asfaw Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

307 Menbru Negash Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

308 Guday Beyne Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

309 Atal Abebaw Tiruneh Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

310 Guzguze Leza Fenta Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

311 Etenate Kebede Miretu Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

312 Yeshitu Alemu Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde


WUB Consult

313 Godada Biders Aragaw Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

314 Mame Mola Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

315 Feleke Asmamaw Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

316 Kesela Tadese Tsegaw Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

317 Dereb Desale Kasaw Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

318 Hailu Kebede Belw Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

319 Zewde Guch Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

320 Yamrot Bogale Gebru Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

321 Yebiyanesh Kebede Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

322 Aberu Kasa Desta Female Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

323 Emahoy Tenaye Birsaw Male Vulnerable (Elderly) Addishadde

324 Tsega Sefiu Gersile Male Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

325 Gebrehana Fikadu Male Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

326 Girma Tesfaye Sisaye Male Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

327 Teggh Abate Yigzaw Male Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

328 Tilahun Yedersal Male Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

329 Mamitu Wedajo Female Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

330 Emahoy Bire Nigate Kasa Female Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

331 Emahoy Etye Birhanu Aleme Female Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

332 Hftamu Berihun Kasw Male Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

333 Zemedu Gelaw Female Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

334 Birhanu Ebabu Kibret Male Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

335 Melse Gelanw Anbaye Male Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

336 Anguch Abey Damte Female Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

337 Bernesh Elfaser Kebede Female Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

338 Abebe Temsegn Tigabe Male Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

339 Mairgu Almu Mersha Male Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

340 Mogos Tesema W/Selase Male Vulnerable ( with disability) Addishadde

Total number of beneficiaries from Addishadde = 340


WUB Consult


341 Tiruye Demse Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

342 Mulu Mamo Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

343 Negase Chekol Male Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

344 Kasanesh Yimer Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

345 Worke Mengesha Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

346 Zenbe Maru Mekonne Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

347 Kasa Mengesha Yilma Male Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

348 Emamye Sisaye Amaghu Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

349 Semghesh Mekonne Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

350 Zemde Biru Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

351 Ashagre Mengistu Male Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

352 Ehtenat Tktay Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

353 Tirngo Alemu Zegeye Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

354 Teye Ereda Wende Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

355 Sefi Mekonne Gebyaw Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

356 Tiruye Worku Zegeye Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

357 Adena Ayalew Asnake Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

358 Megabi Gebre Male Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

359 Ageghu Melkamu Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

360 Beyench Walelgh Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

361 Adugh Melese Male Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

362 Kasaye Yemame Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

363 Belge Gelaw W/Mariam Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

364 Mesa Sisay Amaghu Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

365 Belaynesh Nigatu Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

366 Wubit Gelaw Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

367 Enanu Tadge Melkam Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

368 Zebene Tadese Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

369 Ehte Melse Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

370 Zewde Derse Nakutolab Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch


WUB Consult

371 Ageghu Alemu Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

372 Abeba Melkamu Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

373 Bernesh Yemtaw Gungul Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

374 Yalga Zegeye Gobeze Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

375 Muluye Abera Male Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

376 Zinet Muhmed Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

377 Tesfa Tadese Yalew Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

378 Hiwot Alemayhu Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

379 Mesaye Besher Female Engaged in Petty Trading Chiferigoch

380 Ehit Fentaw Kase Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

381 Belete Azezew Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

382 Hargeweyn Derso Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

383 Weyneshet Fentaw Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

384 Ambash Aligaz Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

385 Alebachw Fenta Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

386 Bamlak Legase Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

387 Eshetu Misaw Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

388 Asnika Gedamu Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

389 Mola Tegegh Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

390 Samuel Tegegh Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

391 Sisaynesh Emwedw Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

392 Atale Damte Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

393 Alem Admasu Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

394 Abush Mola Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

395 Bekele Mola Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

396 Gelaytu Kasa Mekonne Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

397 Wesene Kebede Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

398 Andafta Sisaye Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

399 Eyaya Getu Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

400 Desal Getu Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

401 Mulu Getu Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

402 Abebe Tadese Wubu Male Unemployed Chiferigoch


WUB Consult

403 Kidist Dbebe Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

404 Tiruset Ambaw Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

405 Getachew Besfat Delu Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

406 Muluken Aseme Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

407 Mseret Aseme Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

408 Meaza Aseme Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

409 Mesay Aseme Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

410 Tekile Berihun Lema Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

411 Alemtshay Endalamw Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

412 Ayale Alelgh Melku Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

413 Mulu Mamo Gode Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

414 Fikrtemariam Belete Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

415 Mulu Moges Mekonne Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

416 Adane Tsegaw Wubu Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

417 Etalem Kasa W/Aregay Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

418 Debre Zewdu Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

419 Ayalenesh Mebre Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

420 Habtamu G/Tsadik Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

421 Bewkete Fentaye Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

422 Getinet Birhane Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

423 Asefu Seyoum Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

424 Yeshalem Leulsegd Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

425 Debesa Dinku Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

426 Abay Tadese Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

427 Tsehynew Tadese Male Unemployed Chiferigoch

428 Abiyot Ders Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

429 Bernesh Weday Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

430 Zewde Asefaw Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

431 Asrebb Wudu Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

432 Birke Ejegu Female Unemployed Chiferigoch

433 Birchko Demeke Gobena Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

434 Adanech Michale Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch


WUB Consult

435 Misaw Fetene Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

436 Mihrete Yilma Birhan Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

437 Yezabnsh Telake Kelkay Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

438 Adisalem Kibret Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

439 Sisaye Worku Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

440 Tadese Guangule G/Hiwot Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

441 Berihun Lema Beyen Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

442 Asefa W/Giorgis T/Mi Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

443 Yerke Kasaw Felek Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

444 Mola Sisa Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

445 Worke Abay Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

446 H/Mariam Worku Zelel Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

447 Etenat Kasaw Kachula Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

448 Etetu Negash Teferi Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

449 Enanu Abera Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

450 kes Asnake Kashun Es Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

451 Muluye Tamrate Abebe Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

452 Fentaye Teka Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

453 Melese Geremu Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

454 Anchiwedya Akele Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

455 Yelfgh Aydagh Gobaw Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

456 Beltu Abeteu Ayele Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

457 Etagegh Mebre Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

458 Anguach Mekonne Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

459 Mihrete Mete Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

460 Yelfgh Erku Kokeb Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

461 Lebse Mekonne Reta Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

462 Tewuba Abetw Yegzaw Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

463 Teje Gelaw Reta Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

464 Yennesh Kashun Qwchra Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

465 Genet Yemam Female Vulnerable(with Diability) Chiferigoch

466 Abebe Ayalew Male Vulnerable(with Diability) Chiferigoch


WUB Consult

467 Nigest Akalu Female Vulnerable(with Diability) Chiferigoch

468 Yirga Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Chiferigoch

Total number of beneficiaries from Chiferigoch = 128 469 Seteye Derbe Female Engaged in Petty Trading Gebreal

470 Alemitu Metaw Reta Female Engaged in Petty Trading Gebreal

471 Abeba Fentaw Female Engaged in Petty Trading Gebreal

472 Fentay Fekadu Female Engaged in Petty Trading Gebreal

473 Fentay Temsgen Female Engaged in Petty Trading Gebreal

474 Kasch Shiferaw Female Engaged in Petty Trading Gebreal

475 Birke Terfe Mekuriya Female Engaged in Petty Trading Gebreal

476 Beltech Kasa Female Unemployed Gebreal

477 Sintayhu Ambel Male Unemployed Gebreal

478 Dejen Salew Female Unemployed Gebreal

479 Asnake Haile Male Unemployed Gebreal

480 Melkamu Afrash Female Unemployed Gebreal

481 Almaze Alene Male Unemployed Gebreal

482 Merge Baye Male Unemployed Gebreal

483 Habtam Baye Male Unemployed Gebreal

484 Zenabe Bisete Female Unemployed Gebreal

485 Tirngo Tesfaye Female Unemployed Gebreal

486 Desta Admasu Female Unemployed Gebreal

487 Muluye Admasu Female Unemployed Gebreal

488 Amare Demeke Male Unemployed Gebreal

489 Bizuye Abebe Female Unemployed Gebreal

490 Beze Gedlew Female Unemployed Gebreal

491 Ephrem Asefa Male Unemployed Gebreal

492 Mesfin Teferi Male Unemployed Gebreal

493 Tiruye Gebre Female Unemployed Gebreal

494 Weneshte Fesha Female Unemployed Gebreal

495 Tsehay Fesha Female Unemployed Gebreal

496 Mulu Fente Female Unemployed Gebreal

497 Almaz Welde Female Unemployed Gebreal


WUB Consult

498 Birke Besfat Male Unemployed Gebreal

499 Manale Abebe Mera Female Unemployed Gebreal

500 T/Mariam Leulseged Male Unemployed Gebreal

501 Gebeych Mebre Tegegh Male Unemployed Gebreal

502 Ennaw Tesfanew Gebeyaw Female Unemployed Gebreal

503 Adena Adbaru W/Kidan Female Unemployed Gebreal

504 Amare Sisay Mekonne Male Unemployed Gebreal

505 Hagritu Tegaw Female Unemployed Gebreal

506 Beletch Kasa Female Unemployed Gebreal

507 Sentayhu Ambelu Female Unemployed Gebreal

508 Eneyew Wuletaw Male Unemployed Gebreal

509 Anguach Alemu Tegegh Female Unemployed Gebreal

510 Demkech Tawhe Female Unemployed Gebreal

511 Wro Birhane Mengistu Female Unemployed Gebreal

512 Betru Mamo Male Unemployed Gebreal

513 Wro Zewde Mamo Gelaw Female Unemployed Gebreal

514 Wro Alemitu Mamo Female Unemployed Gebreal

515 Desale Mamo Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

516 Asemu Gethanu Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

517 Afrash Wagaye Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

518 Enanu Birra Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

519 Baye Adera Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

520 Aba W/Tensaye Getu Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

521 Emahoy Atalay Berihun Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

522 Kalkidan Admasu Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

523 Melsh Ayele Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

524 E/y Askal Goshu Felek Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

525 Alebachw Reta Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal


WUB Consult

526 Adugh Kibret Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

527 Tangut Lede Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

528 Abebe Adan Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

529 Etenat Fente Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

530 Fesha Flate Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

531 Genanaw Wende Ereta Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

532 E/y Tegwad Ayalew Kasu Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

533 Gelaw Akele Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

534 Tshaynesh Kasa Laybelay Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

534 Sisaye Mekonne Beru Male Vulnerable(Elderly Gebreal

535 Sefew Birele Kekebe Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

536 Asfaw Feten Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

537 Merigeta Mamo Gelaw Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

538 Getu Alebachew Male Vulnerable(with disability) Gebreal

539 Tazbw Amlaku Melese Male Vulnerable(with disability) Gebreal

540 Birra Gelaw Male Vulnerable(with disability) Gebreal

541 G/Meskele Baye Male Vulnerable (with disability) Gebreal

542 Tariqua Kefe Female Vulnerable (with disability) Gebreal

543 Hiywote Genanaw Wende Male Vulnerable (with disability) Gebreal

544 Sisaye Mekonne Beru Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Gebreal

Total beneficiaries from Gebreal = 76 545 Ethiopia Zewdu Kebede Female Engaged in Petty Trading Menaheriya

546 Sefi Baye Hailu Female Engaged in Petty Trading Menaheriya

547 Hageritu Biyadeg Terch Female Engaged in Petty Trading Menaheriya

548 Sefi Kebatu Dems Female Engaged in Petty Trading Menaheriya

549 Sende Ayalew Aweke Female Engaged in Petty Trading Menaheriya

550 Etalem Wesen Female Engaged in Petty Trading Menaheriya

551 Worke Alebe Female Engaged in Petty Trading Menaheriya

552 Alem Fekade Female Engaged in Petty Trading Menaheriya

553 Tesfa Mamo Female Engaged in Petty Trading Menaheriya

554 Belaynesh Gebeyw Female Engaged in Petty Trading Menaheriya

555 Adena Shite Female Engaged in Petty Trading Menaheriya


WUB Consult

556 Guzguz Tesfaw Female Engaged in Petty Trading Menaheriya

557 H/Mariam Tesfaye Male Unemployed Menaheriya

558 Nakachew Wubet Ayana Male Unemployed Menaheriya

559 Serkalem Alemu Female Unemployed Menaheriya

560 Yezena Getaneh Female Unemployed Menaheriya

561 Eyayaw Kasa Male Unemployed Menaheriya

562 Abebe Fetene Male Unemployed Menaheriya

563 Belay Melkamu Male Unemployed Menaheriya

564 Yennesh Genne Female Unemployed Menaheriya

565 Anguach Fentaw Female Unemployed Menaheriya

566 Tesfa Demse Female Unemployed Menaheriya

567 Atal Mengistu Female Unemployed Menaheriya

568 Befeta Melkamu Female Unemployed Menaheriya

Intended Target beneficiaries from people relocated in 2009

569 Wendu Tesfaye Male Unemployed Menaheriya

570 Birtukan Misganw Female Unemployed Menaheriya

571 Magha Alemu Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Menaheriya

572 Adugh Reta Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Menaheriya

573 Asrese Fekadu Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Menaheriya

574 Ejegu Abebe Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Menaheriya

575 Gelanesh Ayalew Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Menaheriya

576 Gudaye Kebed Ayle Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Menaheriya

577 Kasech Wende Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Menaheriya

578 Etalem Ayzenga Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Menaheriya

579 Lewze Melese Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Menaheriya

580 Etagegh Aleme Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Menaheriya

581 Yezab Tebeje Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Menaheriya

582 Habte Andarge Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Menaheriya

583 Guday Bihonegh Female Vulnerable (with disability ) Menaheriya

Total Beneficieries from Menaheriya = 39


WUB Consult

584 Etye Ayana Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

585 Birhane Asefa Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

586 Aterf Asefa Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

587 Mulusew Asefa Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

588 Desta Seyoum Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

589 Emahoy Bose Feten Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

590 Melshewu Ayalew Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

591 Ytemgh Wende Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

592 Abaynesh Admasu Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

593 Asrebeb Abate Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

594 Aterf Demse Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

Intended Target beneficiaries from people relocated in 2009

595 Sefinesh Mola Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

596 Habtam Mola Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

597 Asted Tsegaw Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

598 Alem Admasu Female Engaged in Petty Trading Kurakur

599 Tigist Arage Asefa Female Unemployed Kurakur

600 Negash Lule Asefa Male Unemployed Kurakur

601 Hailu Tefera Birku Male Unemployed Kurakur

602 Workneh Arage Asefa Male Unemployed Kurakur

603 Zerihun Wubetu Female Unemployed Kurakur

604 Guzguz Tesfaw Female Unemployed Kurakur

605 Yehenow Tadese Male Unemployed Kurakur

606 Wubit Asnak Female Unemployed Kurakur

607 Enquyh Seyoum Female Unemployed Kurakur

608 Bernesh Seyoum Female Unemployed Kurakur

609 Etenat Yesmaw Female Unemployed Kurakur

610 Eskedar Beyen Female Unemployed Kurakur


WUB Consult

Cont…. List of intended target beneficiaries

611 Meselu Aweke Female Unemployed Kurakur

612 Sisaye Abebe Male Unemployed Kurakur

613 Muluwork Abebe Female Unemployed Kurakur

614 Enanu Beyen Female Unemployed Kurakur

615 Lastawork Kibat Female Unemployed Kurakur

616 Hymanot Alelgh Male Unemployed Kurakur

617 Begosaw Melku Female Unemployed Kurakur

618 Yeshi Kibret Female Unemployed Kurakur

619 Gebya Derbw Female Unemployed Kurakur

620 Tiruwork Ayalew Female Unemployed Kurakur

621 Etagegh Maergu Female Unemployed Kurakur

622 Atsed Niguse Female Unemployed Kurakur

623 Zenash Melse Female Unemployed Kurakur

624 Temsgen Askale Male Unemployed Kurakur

625 Muluembet Gebre Female Unemployed Kurakur

626 Gashaw Askale Male Unemployed Kurakur

627 G/Meskele Askale Male Unemployed Kurakur

628 Belete Derbe Male Unemployed Kurakur

629 Emamye Bistegh Female Unemployed Kurakur

630 Emahoy Kasaye Ketema Female Unemployed Kurakur

631 Fenta Akele Female Unemployed Kurakur

632 Serkalem Alemu Female Unemployed Kurakur

633 Habte Adem Male Unemployed Kurakur

634 Biruke Adem Male Unemployed Kurakur

635 Meaza Sisaye Female Unemployed Kurakur

636 Eteye Ayana Female Unemployed Kurakur

637 Bosena Walelgh Female Unemployed Kurakur

638 Telefe Aweke Female Unemployed Kurakur

639 Worke Asmare Female Unemployed Kurakur

640 Maye Endashaw Female Unemployed Kurakur


WUB Consult

641 Meseret Mersha Female Unemployed Kurakur

642 Dasash Ageze Female Unemployed Kurakur

643 Mulu Ayalew Female Unemployed Kurakur

644 Muluwork Arage Female Unemployed Kurakur

645 Mulualem Arage Female Unemployed Kurakur

646 Etalem Gebre Female Unemployed Kurakur

647 Sisaynesh Gebre Female Unemployed Kurakur

648 Beletu Mairegu Female Unemployed Kurakur

649 Menber Asekal Female Unemployed Kurakur

650 Mekedes Asekal Female Unemployed Kurakur

651 Gizachw Asekal Male Unemployed Kurakur

652 Serkadis Asekal Female Unemployed Kurakur

653 Tegegh Ayalew Male Unemployed Kurakur

654 Etalem Daghew Female Unemployed Kurakur

655 Emebet Feleke Female Unemployed Kurakur

656 Asenak Feleke Female Unemployed Kurakur

657 Sisaynesh Emewedw Female Unemployed Kurakur

658 Habtam Alemye Female Unemployed Kurakur

659 Enanu Teshome Female Unemployed Kurakur

660 Fenta Akele Female Unemployed Kurakur

661 Workeye Sete Female Unemployed Kurakur

662 Tigist Kasa Female Unemployed Kurakur

663 Bezuhne Tefera Male Unemployed Kurakur

664 Yekaba Tesfaye Female Unemployed Kurakur

665 Enanu Abesha Female Unemployed Kurakur

666 Getahun Birara Male Unemployed Kurakur

667 Kasaye Wale Female Unemployed Kurakur

668 Wagaye Hailu Female Unemployed Kurakur

669 Birra Asefa Male Unemployed Kurakur

670 W/ro Endalech Mengaw Female Unemployed Kurakur

671 Wro Fiker Agez Female Unemployed Kurakur

672 Etenat Dikaw W/Mariam Female Vulnerable Kurakur


WUB Consult

673 Worku Kasy Sinkneh Male Vulnerable Kurakur

674 Babush Baye Male Vulnerable Kurakur

675 Tadese Gobaw Male Vulnerable Kurakur

676 Segenet Ayalew Female Vulnerable Kurakur

677 Bezualem Zewdu Female Vulnerable Kurakur

678 Enanu Belete W/Medhine Female Vulnerable Kurakur

679 Akele Minale Male Vulnerable Kurakur

680 Mantegebo Birsa Female Vulnerable Kurakur

681 Derb Mekonne Male Vulnerable Kurakur

682 Fentaye Adera Female Vulnerable Kurakur

683 Enu Welde Female Vulnerable Kurakur

684 Bizuye Adege Female Vulnerable Kurakur

685 Emagh Belay Female Vulnerable Kurakur

686 Debre Gebru Gelagay Female Vulnerable Kurakur

687 Getitu Ageghu Tarkegh Female Vulnerable Kurakur

688 Amgh Alemu Female Vulnerable Kurakur

689 Magh Alemu Kasa Female Vulnerable Kurakur

690 Adem Alemu Male Vulnerable Kurakur

691 Sahelu Afrash Male Vulnerable Kurakur

692 Angwach Himanote Female Vulnerable Kurakur

693 Baylegh Tesema Male Vulnerable Kurakur

694 Melakebirhan Margu Male Vulnerable Kurakur

695 Ayalew Dese Anawtew Male Vulnerable Kurakur

696 Deytenu Mihretu Female Vulnerable Kurakur

697 Mulutshaye Aregaw Female Vulnerable Kurakur

698 Fentaye Mekonen Female Vulnerable Kurakur

699 Alem Teshome Female Vulnerable Kurakur

700 Alebachw Reta Male Vulnerable Kurakur

701 Adeguh Kibrete Female Vulnerable Kurakur


WUB Consult

702 Gebeyaw Mebre Male Vulnerable Kurakur

703 Aba Kelemwork Hailu Male Vulnerable Kurakur

704 Worash Abetw Male Vulnerable Kurakur

705 Asayech Reda Female Vulnerable Kurakur

706 Zewede Asefa Alemu Female Vulnerable Kurakur

707 Emahoy Mantegebo Bersow Female Vulnerable Kurakur

708 Yamrot Kasa Reta Female Vulnerable Kurakur

709 Emhoy Getitu Guangul Female Vulnerable Kurakur

710 Melshiw Mekonen Female Vulnerable(with disability) Kurakur

711 Gebramu Mersha Male Vulnerable Kurakur

712 Tsegaye Tezera Female Vulnerable(with disability) Kurakur

713 Atsed G/Tsion Female Vulnerable(with disability) Kurakur

714 Ayenw Mekonne Male Vulnerable Kurakur

715 Belay Tadese Male Vulnerable(with disability) Kurakur

716 Emamye Zewdu Female Vulnerable(with disability) Kurakur

Total beneficiaries from Kurakur (2009) = 133

717 Enanu Sisay Female Farmers Farmers reside outside Kurakur but farmland

718 Kes Besifat Ayalew Male Farmers Farmers reside outside Kurakur but farmland

719 Kes Eshetu Tadesse Male Farmers Farmers reside outside Kurakur but farmland

720 Mengesha Alemu Male Farmers Farmers reside outside Kurakur but farmland

721 Ayalenesh Belay Female Farmers Farmers reside outside Kurakur but farmland

722 Desal Sisaye Male Farmers Farmers reside outside Kurakur but farmland

723 Etagegh Admasu Female Farmers Farmers reside outside Kurakur but farmland

724 Goshe Tesema Male Farmers Farmers reside outside Kurakur but farmland

725 Wro Genet Alemu Female Farmers Farmers reside outside Kurakur but farmland

726 Etena Asefa Female Farmers Kurakur farmers

727 Aba G/Egziabher Damen Male Farmers Kurakur farmers

728 Endayen Adise Male Farmers Kurakur farmers

729 Besfat Ayalew Male Farmers Kurakur farmers

730 Zemed Tegari Female Farmers Kurakur farmers


WUB Consult

731 Muluwork Bezabh Female Farmers Kurakur farmers

732 Wedu Fetene Male Farmers Kurakur farmers

733 Ehteye Goshu Female Farmers Kurakur farmers

734 Terengo Aydagh Welde Female Farmers Kurakur farmers

735 Lemlem Sisaye W/Mariam Male Farmers Kurakur farmers

736 Meke Legas Fisha Female Farmers Kurakur farmers

737 Zemed Kasaw Male Farmers Kurakur farmers

738 Ebabu Worke Waka Female Farmers Kurakur farmers

739 Tirengo Agez Debebe Male Farmers Kurakur farmers

740 Eshete Gedamu Fisha Male Farmers Kurakur farmers

741 Aweke Mekonne Asefa Male Farmers Kurakur farmers

742 Kes Kase Admasu Male Farmers Kurakur farmers

743 Aweke Sisaye Male Farmers Kurakur farmers

744 Getinet Aweke Female Farmers Kurakur farmers

745 Debre Kasa Female Farmers Kurakur farmers

746 Enaney Misgane Female Farmers Kurakur farmers

747 Wedaju Beza Male Farmers Kurakur farmers

748 Desal Ayalew W/Mariam Male Farmers Kurakur farmers

749 Digese Daghw Male Farmers Dereq Wenz

750 Sefi Getahne Female Farmers Dereq Wenz

751 Mulu Digese Male Farmers Dereq Wenz

752 Yawkale Digese Male Farmers Dereq Wenz

753 Tesfaw Desale Male Farmers Dereq Wenz

754 Worke Mairgu Female Farmers Dereq Wenz

755 Habtamu Gethun Male Farmers Dereq Wenz

756 Alemnew Gethun Male Farmers Dereq Wenz

757 Tesfaye Kassa Male Farmers Dereq Wenz

758 Jegene Fente Male Farmers Dereq Wenz

759 Ato Zemen Akele Male Farmers Kurakur farmers yet to loss farmland

760 Achenf Gedelu Male Farmers Kurakur farmers yet to loss farmland


WUB Consult

761 Desal Achenfe Male Farmers Kurakur farmers yet to loss farmland

762 Guday Tegegh Female Farmers Kurakur farmers yet to loss farmland

763 Sisaynesh Emwedew Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

764 Kasaye Wale Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

765 Bogale Abay Male Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

766 Tesgaye Abay Male Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

767 Mulu Abay Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

768 Hirut Abeje Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

769 Wro Zemed Tegared Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

770 Fentaw Alemu Male Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

771 Desale Alemu Male Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

772 Mesa Seyfu Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

773 Yemata Daghew Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

774 Fikremenber Bekele Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

775 Direbe Delel Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

776 Almaze Kasa Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

777 Belay Desal Male Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

778 Etewa Bekele Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

779 Menase Tegaw Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

780 Setenet Goshe Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

781 Genet Goshe Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

782 Worknesh Goshe Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

783 Zemed Afworke Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

784 Girma Alebachew Male Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

785 Desta Admasu Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

786 Akele Wedajo Male Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

787 Tesfawork Wedajo Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

788 Birhane Gedamu Male Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

789 Wendeye Tsegaye Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

790 Birtukan Goshu Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

791 Sisaynesh Asenif Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur


WUB Consult

792 Wagaye Gibralem Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

793 Tirngo Gibralem Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

794 Getent Gibralem Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

795 Alem Sefiw Female Unemployed Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur

796 Anguach Beyayw Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

797 Etagegh Dereb Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

798 Emamey Dereb Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

799 Birtukan Tensay Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

800 Birra Ayalew Male Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

801 Setechgh Yehalw Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

802 Belaynesh Abebe Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

803 Zemed Alemu Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

Intended Target beneficiaries from the Host Community

804 Abebe Tashu Male Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

805 Mesay Hailu Male Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

806 Tsege Meke Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

807 Mulu Tesfaw Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

808 Kasa Dejen Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

809 Mulu Mengiste Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

810 Worke Mulaw Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

811 Mengist Adane Male Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

812 Alem Melkamu Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

813 Derib Tesfaw Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers

814 Belge Tsegaye Female Unemployed Family members of Kurakur farmers


WUB Consult

815 Fenta Tesfaw Female Unemployed Family members of Dereq Wenz farmers

816 Zemde Tesfaw Male Unemployed Family members of Dereq Wenz farmers

817 Alem Sefiw Male Unemployed Family members of Dereq Wenz farmers

818 Birke Wedajo Female Unemployed Family members of Dereq Wenz farmers

819 Mesob Asmamaw Male Unemployed Family members of Dereq Wenz farmers

820 Habtmariam Zelalem Female Unemployed Family members of Dereq Wenz farmers

821 Godada Alamrew Female Unemployed Family members of Dereq Wenz farmers

822 Demekech Tesfaye Female Unemployed Family members of Dereq Wenz farmers

823 Abay Habte Male Unemployed Family members of Dereq Wenz farmers

824 Demekch Tizazu Female Unemployed Family members of farmers yet to lose farmland

825 Wro Belaynesh Wubetu Female Unemployed Family members of farmers yet to lose farmland

826 Fiker Zemen Female Unemployed Family members of farmers yet to lose farmland

827 Derebe Tsegaw Female Unemployed Family members of farmers yet to lose farmland

828 Fiker Achenf Male Unemployed Family members of farmers yet to lose farmland

829 Yeshiye Achenf Female Unemployed Family members of farmers yet to lose farmland

830 Emebet Achenf Male Unemployed Family members of farmers yet to lose farmland

831 Amsale Admasu Female Unemployed Family members of farmers yet to lose farmland

832 Ayalew W/Mariam Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur but farmland

833 Zewde Asefa Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur but farmland

834 Ato Alemu Tesema Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur but farmland

835 Lezaw Atena Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur but farmland

836 Aba W/Tensay Getu Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur but farmland

837 Emahoy Atalye Berihun Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur but farmland

838 Wro Muluye W/mariam Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur but farmland

839 Tirworke Abegz Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur but farmland

840 AfeMemher Alebachew Reta Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur but farmland

841 Adugh Kibret Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur but farmland

842 Getu Wagaw Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur but farmland

843 Abebu Birele Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur but farmland


WUB Consult

44 Wedaye Mekonne Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur but farmland

845 Dese Birra Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of farmers reside outside kurakur but farmland

846 Dereb Abera Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of kurakur farmers

847 Beyene Adamu Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of kurakur farmers

848 Mekonne Asefa Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of kurakur farmers

849 Teshome Mekuriy Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of kurakur farmers

850 Terraw Demeke Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of kurakur farmers

851 Belaynesh Nebebe Female Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of DerkWenz farmers

852 Getahun Damtew Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of DerkWenz farmers

853 Wedaje Kebede Male Vulnerable(Elderly) Family members of DerkWenz farmers

854 Goshu Abera Male Vulnerable(with

disability)

Family members of farmers yet to loss farmland

855 Tsehay Mebre Male Vulnerable(with

disability)

Family members of farmers yet to loss farmland

Total beneficiaries from the Host community = 139


WUB Consult

Annex IV: List of persons whose status for Eligibility to livelihood restoration projects should be verified

The following list provides names of persons who claimed change of status since the collection of socio-economic data in August,

October and December 2010. It was not possible to establish if they are residents of the stated localities; whether or not they are

unemployed or were students before and they are unemployed in April 2011. Their list is included here to enable the implementin

agency to check their status before inclusion in the livelihood restoration projects.

Mikael Gibi Name Registered in the Census

Status registered in the Census

Age Registered in the census

Not registered in the Census

Claimed status

Household's name in the Census

Yalega Ayenemesa Farmer 51

Unemployed Himself Maseresha Alemeye Laborer 25

Unemployed Herself

Abebe Siyum Trader 37

Unemployed Menbere Girma Tsedal Nigatu Farmer 63

Elderlly Herself

Yebicha Mekonene Laborer 45

Petty trader Herself Mesfin Abate Student 18

Unemployed Buzualem Zewed

Desta Zewede Student 20

Unemployed Emahoy Mantegebosh Atsede Walelegn Civil servant 25

Unemployed Gebretsadik Fiqade

Habtamu Walelegn Handcraft 22

Unemployed Emagn Alemu EnanayeWedaye Unstated 48

Unemployed Emagn Alemu

Bezabesh Ayele Trader 36

Unemployed Herself Asenake Bayu Handcraft 38

Unemployed Atsed Niguse

Ateref Maregu Student 22

Unemployed Aserbebe Abate

Qese Asemamawe Melese Unstated 37

Unemployed Emahoy Getitu Ayele Qese Tadese Kasa Laborer 56

Unemployed Etenat Yismaw


WUB Consult

Sisayenesh Geberetsiyon Laborer 60

Unemployed Atsed Geberetsiyon Mesaye Wende Laborer 38

Unemployed Hayile Mola

Selam Hayele Student 18

Unemployed Hayile Mola

መናሀሪያ Menahariya/kebele tenants

Age registered in the census Not registered in the Census Claimed status


Not registered Unemployed Alemayehu Birru

40

Unemployed Herself

51

Unemployed Herself

65

Unemployed Herself

46

Unemployed Herself

37

Unemployed Herself

51

Unemployed Herself

Not registered Unemployed

50

Unemployed Herself

45

Petty trader Herself

70

Unemployed


45

Unemployed

Not registered Petty trader


WUB Consult

Host Community at Kurakur

Name registered in the Census



Not registered in the Census

Claimed status


Locality

Emahoye Mesaye Tesfaye Farmer unstated Farmer Herself Kurakur

Derebe Eshete Student 23 unemployed Eshte Gedamy Kurakur

Semahegn Eshete unstated 27 unemployed Eshte Gedamy Kurakur

mesgan Eshete Student 16 unemployed Eshte Gedamy Kurakur

Emange Kasaw unstated Farmer Urban resident

Bosena Asayu unstated 45 unemployed Tsegaye Getahun Urban resident

Birtukan Tsegaye Student With disability Tsegaye Getahun Urban resident

Habitam Alebel Student 20 unemployed Aserese Bogale Urban resident

Fenta Beyene Not registered Farmer Lewez mender

Habitamu Seregu Not registered Farmer Lewez mender

Sisaye Wedaje Not registered Farmer Urban resident


WUB Consult

Adena Mengeste Not registered Farmer Urban resident

Feqadu Eyayu Not registered With disability Urban resident

Liqekahenat Wedaje Kebede Civil servant 67 Farmer Derk Wenz

Guzeguaz Wedaje unstated With disability Likekahhinat Wedaje kebede Derk Wenz

Teruye Wedaje Student 18 unemployed Likekahhinat Wedaje kebede Derk Wenz

Degetinat Mirete unstated unemployed Likekahhinat Wedaje kebede Derk Wenz

Yekaba Wedage Not registered unemployed Likekahhinat Wedaje kebede Derk Wenz

Belayenesh Wedage Not registered unemployed Likekahhinat Wedaje kebede Derk Wenz

Ferehiwot Getu Not registered unemployed Likekahhinat Wedaje kebede Derk Wenz

Ayana Mekonene Student 17 unemployed Meke Legese Kurakur

Anguach Mekonene Student 22 unemployed Meke Legese Kurakur

Diyakon Melese Mekonene unstated 22 unemployed Meke Legese Kurakur

Tesfaye Tezazu Civil servant 30 unemployed GudaY Tegegn Kurakur

Alemeye Arega Student 15 unemployed GudaY Tegegn Kurakur

Marege Achenef Trader 32 unemployed Achenefe Gedelu Kurakur

Habitamu Tesfaw Civil servant 27 Farmer EmahoY Lemlem SisaY Kurakur


WUB Consult

Lemlem Goshe Farmer 60 unemployed EmahoY Lemlem SisaY Kurakur

Beqele Habte Abera Civil servant 48 unemployed Himself Derk Wenz

Birtukan Wedaje unstated 39 unemployed Beqele Habte abera Derk Wenz

Menen Habte Student 18 unemployed Beqele Habte abera Derk Wenz

Alem Sefiw unstated 40 unemployed Himself Urban resident

Abeba Yigzaw unstated Farmer Kurakur

Emahoy Sisayenesh Achenef unstated 29 unemployed

Emahoy Sisayenesh Achenefe

Urban resident

Getachew Sefiw Student unemployed Urban resident

Goshe Abera unstated Not registered Farmer Kurakur

Enkuayehu Wabe Not registered unemployed Goshe Abera Kurakur

Akilog Goshu Not registered unemployed Goshe Abera Kurakur

Dasash Goshu Not registered unemployed Goshe Abera Kurakur

Werekinesh Mintesinot Not registered unemployed Habte Tesgaw Unstated

Tsega Jegene Student 20 unemployed Jegene Fentae Kurakur

Beqele Mekuriya Laborer 50 unemployed yemata Dagne Urban resident

Zemenu Akalu Not registered Farmer Kurakur

Biderese Zemenu Not registered unemployed Kurakur

GudaY Zemenu Not registered unemployed Kurakur


WUB Consult

Baye Tesfaw Not registered unemployed Tesfaw Desalegn Derk Wenz

Gebrel sefer

Name registered in the Census


Age registered in the census

Not registered in the census

Claimed status


Birhanu Sefiw

Not registered Unemployed Sefiw Birele

Tsega Tekelhayimanot Student 24

Petty trader Sefiw Birele

Emahoye Yalega Shibeshi Not stated Not stated

Elderly Herself

Habtam Maregu


Debreroha Alelegn Laborer 35

Unemployed Herself

Dasash Dagne Student 19

Unemployed Anguach Alemu

Serash Belay

Not registered Unemployed Tareqegn Belay

Kibinesh Belay


Tesfaye Belay


Fiker Belay


Fikru Ebabu Laborer 25

Unemployed Fantaye Temesgen

Eyayaw Wenedyenaw Student 19

With disability Salew Shibishi

Etalem Salew Student 22

Unemployed Salew Shibishi

Mulushet Salew Student 16

Unemployed Salew Shibishi

Fentaw Alemu Student 25

Unemployed Abaweldetensay Getu


WUB Consult

Yemserach Zenaw Student Not stated

Unemployed Abaweldetensay Getu

Mesgan Mebre

Not registered Unemployed Mebre Tegegn

Beqele Afrash

Not registered Unemployed Afrash wageye

Tamire Mekonene


Meaza SisaY


Hayilu Alelegn Not stated 46

Unemployed Agafari Alelegn Bogale

Hayimanot Alelegn Handicraft 26


Saleamelak Alelegn Trader 32


Azawenet Tamene

Not registered Unemployed Emahoy Adene Adebaru

Tesfa Belete

Not registered Unemployed Biset Kasa Farmer 50

Unemployed Baye Adera

Misaye Baye Not stated 46


Belayenesh Baye Student 23


Ayechese Demeke

Not registered Unemployed Demeke Weledekidan

Helen Fisha Student 14

Unemployed Etenat Fenta

Chifrgoch

Name Registered in the Census




Claimed status



WUB Consult

Asenake Getahun Student 28

Unemployed Getahun Yemataw

Reta Fesaha Trader 32

Unemployed Getahun Yemataw

zemede Asefaw Trader 50

Petty trader Himself

Beletu Aneley Student 19

Unemployed Zemede Asfaw

Dega Abera

Not registered Unemployed Enanu Abera

Yeshiwereqe Mesgan

Not registered Unemployed Habitamu Alemu Laborer 27

Unemployed Yezabinesh Teka

Alemu Ademasse Unemployed 22

Unemployed Yezabinesh Teka

Kasaye Sisaye

Not registered Petty trader Daniel Abirham


Waga Moges

Not registered Unemployed Belege Gelaw

Engedawereq Shiferaw Laborer 40

Unemployed Herself

Sefi Tegegn Laborer 35

Unemployed Engedawereq Shiferaw

Getu Kiberet Laborer 53

Unemployed Adisalem Kiberet

Melesew Alemu Student 22

Unemployed Alemu Bezabihe

Abebe Alemu

Not registered Unemployed Birtukan Gebretsadik Student 19

Unemployed Enanu Tadegd

Astede Tsegaye Student 17

Unemployed Tesfa Tadesse

Telake Tsegaw Laborer 45

Unemployed Takele Tsegaw

Gudaye Desse Trade 52


Wendemu Adane Student 23

Unemployed Gudaye Desse

Getaye Yemataw Laborer 28

Unemployed Yemataw Mekonen

Anguach Taweye Farmer 60


Kasa Berihun

Not registered

Anguach Taweye

Kiberet mekonen Farmer 60

Petty trader Aserebebe wedu

Yewagenesh Kiberet Student 22

Student Tayitu Tefera

Belay Gobeze

Not registered Elderly


WUB Consult

Desash Belay

Not registered Unemployed Demeke Belay


Fasika Negash

Not registered Petty trader Abebe Fentaw Student 20

Unemployed Fentaw Kasse

Adishade

Name Registered in the Census Status registered

in the Census

Age Registered

in the census


Claimed status

Household's name in the Census Remark

Asrat Berihun Student 21 Unemployed Berihun Asemare

kasech Berihun Student 30 Unemployed Berihun Asemare

Melesa Tarekegn Trader 60 Elderly Herself

Mulu Tegegn Farmer 60 Elderly Mulu Tegegn

Enan Belaya Student 35 Unemployed Beletu Bezabihe

Mulat Tarqe Handicraft 35 person with disability

Belayenesh Fentaw

Semon Damena _ Not registered Unemployed

Alemenesh Fetete _ Not registered Petty trader

Emahoye Yigaredu Manale _ Not registered Elderly


WUB Consult

tangut wendenew _ Not registered Unemployed

Ferehiwot Getaye Student 17 Unemployed Bilagi Hasen

Segedech Kasaye Not registered Elderly Berenesh Bistegn

Muluye Mebere Laborer 65 Elderly Genet Demessie

Enanu Negatu Laborer 55 Elderly Herself

Gudaye Yewalaw Farmer 64 Elderly Herself

Sereke Abate Farmer 60 Petty trader Herself

Webet Belay Farmer 60 Petty trader

Yegaredu Manale Not registered Elderly

Biru yesmaw Laborer 65 Elderly Himself

Mesaye Adane Trader 50 Petty trader Emahoy Esey Aferash

Mesret Demese Unstated 23 Unemployed Tamene Mengaw

Biweta Demese Not registered

person with disability

Eskedar Zemene 60 Unemployed Yezabinesh Birhanu

Tsega Sisay 56 Unemployed Wendemenew Assefa


WUB Consult

Guday Godana Persons with disability 72

Elderly and person with disability Tefera Hailu

Wereqenesh Ali Student 30 Unemployed Mesaye Dessie

Kasaye Damana Not registered Petty trader

Burtu Manaye Live outside the town Elderly

Elias Assefa Student 27 Unemployed Eteye Abegaz

Amesalu Geberhana Student 20 Unemployed Geberhana Fiqadu

Dege Abate Not registered Elderly

Negat Terefe Laborer 40 Elderly Teref Yesmaw

Sereke Werku Student 16 Unemployed Werequ Weldemicael

Anguach Abay Not registered Unemployed

Tekuse Tasew Persons with disability 80 Elderly Himself

Fenta Asefaw 30 Unemployed Denekayehu Ayanaw

Webit Belay Laborer 60 Unemployed Serqe Abate

Roza Beqele Student 26 Unemployed Beqele Aweqe

Enanau Gubae Not registered


Abun Dege Setegn Farmer 60 Himself

Sisaynesh Wedaje Unstated 27 Unemployed Wubit Aluala


WUB Consult

Meaza Tegen Not registered

Mulugeta Alemu Student 32 Unemployed Yezab Mengaw

Goshe Amare Not registered Elderly

Buzeye Melaku Student 20 Unemployed Melaku Getu

Alab Besefat Not registered Unemployed

Berenas Fentaw Not registered Unemployed

fentaw Kasa Student 19 Unemployed Kasa Sisay

enanu weday Laborer 57 Unemployed Kasa Sisay

Adene Adese Unstated 36 person with disability Herself

Belayenesh Amare Unstated 37 Unemployed Herself

Yenguse wedayenew Petty traders 36 Unemployed Adugna Biweta

Zewede Tesfaw Laborer 26 Petty trader Herself

Ebmet Asmare Handicraft 35 Unemployed Getahun Asmare

mekonene mayet Not registered Unemployed


WUB Consult

lula desta Petty traders 28 Unemployed Wayenesh Tesema

deneb Embeshaw Laborer 32 Unemployed Tamen Andarge

Adena mesgan Student 21 Unemployed Kasech Bira

Tadese mesgana Not registered Unemployed

Belay zeru Farmer 48 Elderly Herself

Ehet Alemayehu Student 23 Unemployed Belay Zeru

Feker gebyaew Student 21 Unemployed Belay Zeru

abebe asenake Student 18 Unemployed Belay Zeru

selom ayalew Student 22 Unemployed Ayale Tensea

ferehiwot ayalew Student 25 Unemployed Ayale Tensea

weyeneshet ayalew Student 20 Unemployed Ayale Tensea

erteban heyele Student 19 Unemployed Enanu Tegafaw

yeshi tadesse Student 18 Unemployed Gebremariyam Dagnaw

habetam aberaham Not registered Unemployed

marege alemu 30 person with disability Teruhare Tesgaw

huluanchi zewede Not registered


asefaw aferash Not registered



WUB Consult

erteban tadese Unstated 31 Unemployed Asfaw Afrash

bogale melese Unstated 21 Unemployed Melesa Tareqegn

habetamu yebazaw Laborer 23 Petty trader Tazebew Walelegn

Tesfa Belay Laborer 24 Petty trader Himself

alemu tazebew Laborer 55 Unemployed Tazebew Walelegn

wereqe welede Not registered Unemployed

Amesal Yetebarek Unemployed 60 Elderly Herself

Gedely Berihun Laborer 55 Unemployed Sefe Cerkos

berenesh tafete Laborer 51 Petty trader Bernesh Tafete

genzebenat siad Student 22 Unemployed Jemanesh Ali

birara Alemu Student 20 Unemployed Alemu Areqe

Tesegay Alemu Unstated 22 Unemployed Alemu Areqe

Zebenay Alemu Unstated 19 Unemployed Alemu Areqe

Yemata Hayilu Laborer 39 Unemployed Herself

Guday Yehualaw Farmer 64 Elderly Herself

Beletu Weledmicael 55 Unemployed Herself

Yamerot Bogale Unstated 70 Elderly Herself

Teshayenesh Belay Unstated 61 Unemployed Herself

Ayalenesh Belay Not registered

Atalay Abebaw Unstated 66 Unemployed


WUB Consult

Asereebebe Abeb Farmer 62 Unemployed Tesfay Arega

Lemlem Aln Farmer 40 Unemployed Herself

Mamush Beqele Laborer 20 Unemployed Lemlem Alene

Kasech Yematw Unstated Un stated Elderly Mesganaw Bitew

Emawayesh Dese Un stated Elderly Mesganaw Bitew

Bayush Desale Farmer 60 Elderly Tesfay Arega

Zeru Eebabu Laborer 57 Petty trader Lekity Hayilu

Tigist Adanu Unstated 21 Unemployed Lekity Hayilu

Wenedumu Ayele Not registered Unemployed

Melekam Fentaw Not registered Unemployed

Habete Gebeyehu Laborer 43 Unemployed Menegeste Tesema

Etagegn Yeredaw Unstated 21 Unemployed Menegeste Tesema

kasech Asemamawe Not registered Unemployed

Bayush Mesefen Not registered Unemployed

Ababa Adane Not registered Elderly


WUB Consult

Aserese Sefiw Not registered Petty trader

Enanu Telake Unstated 65 Elderly Birhanu Asemare

Merigeta Baheru Not registered Elderly

Eskalew Debash Not registered Unemployed

Teruye kefalew Laborer 21 Petty trader Sefe Cerkos

Emamayehu Wasyehun 59 Petty trader Herself

Eshetu Alemu Student 18 Unemployed Alemu Birele

Tefera Aqanaw Unstated 43 Unemployed Himself

Tiruhareg Tsgaw Unemployed 89 Elderly Herself

Sinekenesh Aweke Not registered Unemployed

Beset Alemu Laborer 23 Unemployed Eyase Nigatu

Baye Mengestu Farmer 40 Unemployed Himself

Guzguz Telake Student 17 Unemployed Baye Mengistu

Tesefa Tedla Unstated 23 Unemployed Himself

Webalem Tedela Not registered Unemployed

Bayemesh Elefaser Not registered Unemployed


WUB Consult

Eyayawe Babel Not registered Unemployed

Wereke Tadesse Unstated Un stated Unemployed Yohanes Mitiku

Fasika Ademasu Farmer Un stated Unemployed Lezeb Tesema

Enanaw Binega Not registered Unemployed

Zemed Qenaw Not registered Petty trader

Tiringo Sewenet Laborer 51 Unemployed

Adena Beyene Not registered Unemployed

Yatebiya Anagere Unstated Un stated Unemployed Chane Mengestu

Maregu Chane Unstated 35 Unemployed Chane Mengestu

Fenta Mesegana Not registered Unemployed

Sefinesh Tesefay Not registered Unemployed

Getay Sete Laborer 28 Unemployed Himself

Genet Sete Unstated 23 Unemployed Geteye sete

Fiker Setegn Student 15 Unemployed Geteye sete

Getaye Aweke Student 22 Unemployed Emahoye Astatek Mola

Megabi Wende Not registered Unemployed


WUB Consult

Kasech Yerdaw Not registered Unemployed

Zewede Tesfaw Laborer 26 Unemployed Himself

Enan Alemayehu Unstated Un stated Unemployed Enanu Habitamu

Melese Chekol Laborer 25 Unemployed Himself

Engoca Dereso Laborer 22 Unemployed Meles chekol

Bogale Achenafi Handicraft 28 Unemployed Himself

Tesdale Abebaw Student 16 Unemployed Abebaw Getaw

Gudaye Belaw Laborer 45 Unemployed Teruhareg Tsgaw

Tesganes Desalegn Not registered Petty trader

Teju Gelaw Not registered Elderly

Gedamensh Kashun Not registered Unemployed

Etenesh TesfaY Unstated Un stated Elderly

Baye Minale Not registered Unemployed

Zenebe Mola Not registered Unemployed

Derbe Endaweq Trader 39 Petty trader Derbe Enadaweq


WUB Consult

Annex V: Business activities that will be affected due to relocation from the Core Zone

Business owners will temporarily lose business opportunities associated with the relocation.

Lost business income opportunities are assessed and different compensation and mitigation

mechanisms are proposed on the basis of the losses caused by the project.

Different options of relocation assistance packages for Business owner

Business owner households whose business and income sources are affected in the project

area will be entitled to different property compensation, relocation assistance or disturbance

allowance and livelihood restoration packages. Specifically the following mitigation,

restoration and disturbance allowances are proposed.

1. As any of loss of structures, business owners who are owner occupier are entitled to

get property compensation. Thus their properties are already included in the property

valuation for property compensation

2. All business owners in the Core Zone whose business is legally registered are entitled

to plot allocation commensurate to the size of their holding in areas allocated for

commercial purposes.

3. Family members of business owner households are entitled to be embraced in the

livelihood restoration plan as any person in the PAP as far as they fulfill the

identification criteria to be beneficiary from livelihood restoration plan.

4. Disturbance allowances for business-owners is computed based on their annual

income. It is suggested to compensate their loss of three months.

The data on type and owners of formal business activities to be entitled for disturbance

allowance and their annual income is obtained from City Government Domestic Revenue

Office.


WUB Consult

Annex V/A: Name of business owner, Types of Business, Annual Income and Computed Disturbance Allowance of Formal businesses

Location: Adishadde

Number Name of owners Business Types

Annual

Income

Ownership Status of

Business buildings

1 Orthodox Church

Seven Olives

Hotel 964,711 Belongs to the Church

2 Hirut Sisay Restaurant 29,200

Owner

3 Abebe Demesash Restaurant 27,010

Owner

4 Alem Agegnehu Restaurant 18,250

Owner

5 Tigest Kefalew Bar 54,750 Rent from private owner

6 Ayale Tenese Pension 2,109

Owner

7 Mekonen Alemu Kiosk 9,000

Owner

8 Ateref Degu Kiosk 1,500 Tenant of Kebele House

9 Aselef Aleme Kiosk 3,000 Tenant of Kebele House

10 Aster Sisay Kiosk 8,400 Tenant of Kebele House

11 Yayeshe Kolech Tej House 5,475

Owner

12 Eresete Abebe Tej House 7,300

Owner

13 Dereb Desal Tej House 7, 026

Owner

14 Kiberet Mezemer Charcoal trade 3,000 Tenant of Kebele House

15 Estalu Kelemu

Billardo

(Korombula

House) 7,300 Tenant of Kebele House

16 Aynalem Luleseged Kiosk 7,500 Tenant of Kebele House

17 Tesfa Wedaje Shop 3,600 Owner -occupier

18

Kebebush

Mekonnen Bakery 18,000 Kebele tenant

19 Mulu Ayalew Shop 2250 Owner occupier

20 Wubit Kibret Tasew Restaurant 6,750 Tenant in private house

21

Lidetu Gedamu

Walle

Boutque/second

hand garment 21500 Private tenant

Total yearly income 1,188,281

Compensation for three months income 297,070

Income of persons from 17-21 was not verified by the Revenue office


WUB Consult

Location: Chiferigoch

Number Name of owners Business Types

Annual

taxable

Income

Ownership Status of

Business buildings

1 Tiruwerek Gugesa Hotel 29,200

Owner

2 Zemed Asfaw Restaurant 14,600 Tenant of Kebele House

3 Meneber Abebe Tej House 12,775 Tenant of Kebele House

4 Melese Geremew Kiosk 31,350

Owner

5 Belete Assefa Kiosk 18,000

Owner

6 Alemu Bezabhe Kiosk 9,000

Owner

7 Almaz Gebresilase

House and Office

Furniture 28,500

Owner

8 Gashaw Gesese

Ready made cloth

trade 24,000

Rent from private

owner

9 Said Mehamed

Ready made cloth

trade 19,500

Rent from private

owner

10 Aweke Mekonen Plastic Shoe Shop 12,000

Owner

11 Melekam Ayalew Beauty Salon 20,400

Owner

12

Tirngo Alemu

zegeye diversified 1,800 Owner

13 Fenta Mengistu Hides and skins 1,800 owner

14 Mulu Fente Tej house 1,800 Kebele tenant

15 Lastawork wossen Honey trader 4,500 Kebele tenant

16 Melkamfire coop Bar 27,000

17 Muluye Abera Tearoom 1,800

18 Member Abebe Tejbet 2,700

19 Nigus Reda Tailor 3600

Total yearly income 264,325


Income of persons from 12-19 was not verified by the Revenue office

Gebriel

1 Genanaw Wende Sovuner shop 7,500

Owner

2 Derebe Tadesse Sovuner shop 6,000 Rent from private owner

3 Misaye Baye Adera

Ready made cloth

shop 6,000

Owner

Total yearly income 19500



WUB Consult

Annex V/B: Petty traders Average Monthly Income for People to be relocated

Locality : Adishade No. Name Business

type

(Bar,Teji,

Tella, shops,

boutiques

Do they have

Business license? If

they have, mention

the date &year

received (in EC)

Type of

housing tenure

where the

business is

carried out

Average

Monthly

income

(in Birr)

Amount of

Disturbance

Allowance

(3 Months)

1 Fentaye Lakew Kassa Tella bet No Kebele tenant 240 720 2 Demeku Amare

Bogale Tella Bet No Kebele tenant 200 600

3 Gudaye Yemataw

Getu Tella Bet No Kebele tenant 400 1,200

4 Enanaw Shiferaw

Gelaw Tella Bet No Kebele tenant 250 750

5 Desta Sefiew Tella Bet No Kebele tenant 200 600

6 Lakech Getamesay Tella Bet No owner

occupier

500 1,500

7 Fentanesh Kefyalew Tella Bet No private tenant 280 840

8 Misaye Yismaw

Desta Tella Bet No owner

occupier

500 1,500

9 Segedu Tesfaye

Sisaye Tella Bet No owner

occupier

400 1,200

10 Zeritu Molla Reta Tella Bet No kebele tenant 300 900

11 Atala Getenet Tella Bet No owner

occupier

160 480

12 Abeba Asefaw Tella Bet No owner

occupier

500 1,500

13 Tiruye Guche

Tella Bet No Kebele tenant 320 960

14 Emameye Wasihun Tella Bet No Kebele tenant 320 960 15 Belaynesh Chekole Tella Bet No Kebele tenant 250 750 16 Habitam Birara Tella Bet No Kebele tenant 400 1,200 17 Tirngo Asnake

Welde Tella bet No Kebele tenant 150 450

18 Meselu Kefle Awoke Tella bet No Kebele tenant 350 1,050 19 Etewena Setota

Tawneh Tella bet No Private tenant 240 720

20 Mulu Asmare

Tesema Tella bet No Private tenant 100 300

21 Fentaye Mulaw Tella bet No Kebele tenant 300 900 22 Zenebech Abera Tella bet No Kebele tenant 160 480 23 Abeba Gremew

Tegegh Tella bet No Owner

occupier

120 360

24 Erteban Gelaw Tella bet No private tenant 200 600


WUB Consult

No. Name Business

type

(Bar,Teji,

Tella, shops,

boutiques

Do they have


they have, mention

the date &year

received (in EC)

Type of

housing tenure

where the

business is

carried out

Average

Monthly

income

(in Birr)

Amount of

Disturbance

Allowance

(3 Months)

25 Worknesh Beyne

Sefe Areki and

Tea

No private tenant 450 1,350

26 Enanaw Akenaw

Workneh Tella bet No Kebele tenant 250 750

27 Tesfu Tedle

G/Mariam Tella bet No private tenant 160 480

28 Fasika Deblek Tella bet No Kebele tenant 300 900 29 Wubaly Wodajo

Beyn Tella bet No private tenant 200 600

30 Yeshi Terfe Yetbark Tella bet No owner

occupier

400 1,200

31 Birhane Mebratu

Besher Tella bet No Kebele tenant 500 1,500

32 Enanu Abebaw Yirsa Tella bet No Kebele tenant 300 900 33 Genete Demese Tella bet No owner

occupier

300 900

34 Alemitu Ketema

Yewhla Tella bet No Owner

occupier

280 840

35 Bernesh Alemu

Mekonne Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600

36 Demeku G/Hiwot

Hailu Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600

37 Zenbech Abera

Zewdu Tella bet No private tenant 200 600

38 Enanu Tasew

Adameke Tella bet No owner

occupier

160 480

39 Kasech Berihun

Asmare Tella bet No Owner

occupier

280 840

40 Emagne Mekonne

Zewdie Tella bet No private tenant 400 1,200

41 Angwach Amare

Wubye Tella bet No private tenant 200 600

42 Tshaye Dubale Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600 43 Yezabnesh Mola Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600 44 Adena Newte Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600 45 Genet Fentaw Tella bet No Kebele tenant 640 1,920 46 Tsega Kebadu Ambasha

and Beso

No privte tenant 700 2,100

47 Ergoye Birhane

Asenake Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600

48 Etenesh Zerfu

Shibeshi Tella bet No Kebele tenant 400 1,200

49 Berye Ashenf Arega Tella bet No private tenant 160 480 50 Melsa Aweke Tella bet No private tenant 200 600 51 Shiferaw Mamuye Tailor No private tenant 450 1,350


WUB Consult

No. Name Business

type

(Bar,Teji,

Tella, shops,

boutiques

Do they have


they have, mention

the date &year

received (in EC)

Type of

housing tenure

where the

business is

carried out

Average

Monthly

income

(in Birr)

Amount of

Disturbance

Allowance

(3 Months)

52 Enanaw Mengaw

Biru Tella bet No private tenant 250 750

53 Birke Negash Birle Tella bet No private tenant 250 750 54 Tehune Alemayehu Tella bet No owner

occupier

340 1,020

55 Wagaye Alemnew Tella bet No owner

occupier

400 1,200

56 Yeshi Setotaw Alemu Tella bet No Kebele tenant 400 1,200 57 Belaynesh Fentaw

Gebru Tella bet No Kebele tenant 300 900

58 Zemed Tadese

Bizuneh Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600

59 Mushera Tequre Tella bet No Kebele tenant 300 900 60 Askale Misganw Tella bet No Kebele tenant 300 900 61 Enanu Kebede Belew Tella bet No owner

occupier

300 900

62 Desta Amare

Getahun Tella bet No Kebele tenant 280 840

63 Gudada Mengesha Tella bet No private tenant 300 900 64 Tirngo Kibret Tella bet No Kebele tenant 520 1,560 65 Tegarda Birara Reta Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600 66 Yeshiharge Wagaye

Asmmaw Tella bet No Kebele tenant 120 360

67 Belagi Hasen Dawud Tella bet No Kebele tenant 400 1,200 68 Bernesh Bistegh Tella bet No owner

occupier

400 1,200

69 Tasech Reda Tella bet No Private tenant 400 1,200 70 Alemwork Kass Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600 71 Yesetbelay Adinew Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600 72 Kassech Yirdaw Tella bet No private tenant 160 480 73 Yenguse Wodajenew Tella and

areki bet

No Private

tenant

320 960

74 Alemnesh Ejigu Tella bet No Kebele tenant 300 900 75 Mulu Binalifew Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600 76 Tirngo Sewinet Tella bet No private tenant 200 600 77 Amakelech Mekonin Tella bet No Kebele tenant 240 720 78 Asrese Sefiew Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600 79 Asrese Mengiste Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600 80 Ayechesh Wase Tella bet No Kebele tenant 280 840 81 Engidawork Abera Tella bet No Owner

occupier

280 840

82 Tiezaze Ebabu Tella bet No private tenant 240 720 83 Berinesh Elifaser Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600


WUB Consult

No. Name Business

type

(Bar,Teji,

Tella, shops,

boutiques

Do they have


they have, mention

the date &year

received (in EC)

Type of

housing tenure

where the

business is

carried out

Average

Monthly

income

(in Birr)

Amount of

Disturbance

Allowance

(3 Months)

84 Geditu Melake

Demise Tella bet No private tenant 200 600

85 Eritiban Tadesse Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600 86 Zemed Gelaw Tella bet No private tenant 200 600 87 Temalida Desse Tella bet No owner

occupier

200 600

88 Habtam Wondiferaw Tella bet No private tenant 200 600 89 Sefinesh Aweke

Biadgilign Tella bet No private tenant 200 600

90 Fitfit Tesfa Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600 91 Berinesh Tafete Tella bet No Kebele tenant 240 720 92 Tesfa Sisay Tella bet No private tenant 280 840 93 Kassaye Demena Tella bet No Kebele tenant 280 840 94 Aregash Molla

Wubet Tella bet No owner

occupiers

400 1,200

95 Enanu Alemayehu Tella bet No private tenant 240 720 96 Etetu Adane Tella bet No owner

occupier

400 1,200

97 Fenta Melake Tella bet No private tenant 200 600 98 Mulu Tesfaw Tella bet No private

tenant

240 720

99 Mushiret Adege Areki bet No owner

occupier

550 1,650

100 Meseret Demile Tella bet No owner

occupier

400 1,200

101 Setechign Ejigu Tella bet No owner

occupier

560 1,680

102 Serge Abate Tella bet No Kebele tenant 200 600 103 W/ro Alemayehu

Sefiew Tella bet No private tenant 320 960

104 Mestawit Tafere Tella bet No private

tenant

320 960

105 Alemnesh Fetete

Tikuye Tella bet No Kebele tenant 320 960

106 Erigib Yesetochena

Yelijageredoch

Mahiber

Cafeteria No Kebele tenant 700 2,100

107 Engocha Amare Tella and

Areki bet

No private tenant 300 900

108 Biset Achenif Beru Video

enter-

tainment


109 Habitam Ayalew Tella bet No private tenant 240 720


WUB Consult

No. Name Business

type

(Bar,Teji,

Tella, shops,

boutiques

Do they have


they have, mention

the date &year

received (in EC)

Type of

housing tenure

where the

business is

carried out

Average

Monthly

income

(in Birr)

Amount of

Disturbance

Allowance

(3 Months)

110 Emebet Asemare Vegetable

& cereals

sales

(Guilit)

No Kebele tenant 300 900

111 Tigist Melike Tella bet No private

tenant

320 960

Total 32,510 97,530

Petty traders Average Monthly Income for People to be relocated

Locality: Chifrgoch No. Name Business type

(Bar,Teji, Tella,

shops,

boutiques

Do they have


they have, mention

the date &year

received (in EC)

Type of housing

tenure where the

business is

carried out

Average

Monthly

income

(in Birr)

Amount of

Disturbance

Allowance

(3 Months)

1 Mulu Mamo Cafeteria (tea &

bread)

No Owner

occupier

150 450

2 Legase Chekol Boutique(Garme

nts)

Yes

Meskerem 2003 private tenant 300 900

3 Kasanesh Yimam Tella bet No private tenant 130 390

4 Worke Mengesha Tella bet No private tenant 200 600 5 Zenebe Maru

Mekonne

Tella bet

(Korefe bet)


6 Kasa Mengesha

Yilma

Farm implement

& table salt

Yes Owner

occupier

400 1,200

7 Emamye Sisaye

Amagnu

Tella bet No Owner

occupier

150 450

8 Semgnesh

Mekonen

Tell bet No private tenant 400 1,200

9 Teye Ereda Wende Tella bet No owner occupier 240 720 10 Sefi Mekonne

Gebyaw

Tella bet No owner occupier 240 720

11 Tiruye Worku

Zegeye

Tella bet No private tenant 320 960

12 Adena Ayalew

Asnake

Tella bet No private tenant 320 960

13 Adugna Melese Tella bet No Private tenant 320 960 14 Belge Gelaw

W/Mariam

Tella & areke

bet

No owner occupier 400 1,200

15 Mesaye Sisay

Amagnu

Tella & derek

enjera

No Owner

occupier

200 600


WUB Consult

No. Name Business type

(Bar,Teji, Tella,

shops,

boutiques

Do they have


they have, mention

the date &year

received (in EC)

Type of housing

tenure where the

business is

carried out

Average

Monthly

income

(in Birr)

Amount of

Disturbance

Allowance

(3 Months)

16 Enanu Tadege

Melkam

Tella bet &

selling milk

No owner occupier 500 1,500

17 Zebene Tadese Tella bet No cohabitant in an

owner occupier 450 1,350

18 Ehete Melse Tella bet No owner occupier 400 1,200 19 Zewde Derse

Nakutolab

Tella bet No owner occupier 540 1,620

20 Agegnehu Alemu Tella bet No owner occupier 350 1,050 21 Bernesh Yemtaw

Guangul

Tella bet No Owner

occupier

450 1,350

22 Tesfa Tadese

Yalew

Retailing

household

items(Sheketa

sheket)

No kebele tenant 250 750

23 Emamey Wuletaw Tella bet No Private tenant 400 1,200 24 Asres Mengesha Tell and Balitina No Kebele tenant 400 1,200 25 Meselu Fanataye Tella, tea &

bread

No Owner

occupier

280 840

26 Munaye Abebaw Tella bet No private tenant 240 720 27 Aserebib Atinafu Tella bet

(Korefe)

No kebele tenant 400 1,200

28 Yezabinesh Telake Tella bet No owner

occupied

550 1,650

29 Sefi Mekonen Tell bet No private renter 200 600 30 Berihun Lemma

Beyene

Selling local

metallic products

No owner occupier 300 900

31 Endehabtua Sisay Tella bet No owner occupier 460 1,380 32 Mulu Mamo Gode Tella bet No owner occupier 280 840 33 Kassaye Sisaye

Birle

Tea & bread No owner

occupied

440 1,320

Total 11,310

33,930


WUB Consult

Petty traders Average Monthly Income for People to be relocated from

Gebriel Ghibbi Locality No. Name Business type

(Bar,Teji, Tella,

shops,

boutiques

Do they have


they have, mention

the date &year

received (in EC)

Type of

housing tenure

where the

business is

carried out

Average

Monthly

income

(in Birr)

Amount of

Disturbance

Allowance

(3 Months)

1 Bizuye Abebe Tella bet No private tenant 400 1200

2 Belge Ayalew Tella bet No private tenant 160 480 3 Alemitu Wodajo Tell bet No private tenant 320 960 4 Tiruye Gebre Tella bet No private tenant 240 720 5 Demekech

Taweye Tella bet No owner

occupier

120 360

6 Tsega T/haimanot Sovenir No owner

occupier

300 900

7 Enanaw Bimerew Tella bet No owner

occupier

600 1800

8 Yeshi Alene Home

processed

food items

(Balitina)

No private tenant 210 630

9 Zewde Mamo Tella bet No owner

occupier

320 960

10 Alemitu Mamo Tella bet No Owner

occupier

240 720

11 Zemed Kebede Tell bet No private renter 160 480 Total 3,070 9,210

Documents

Livelihood Restoration Plan for Persons Affected by ...€¦ · Vol IV Submitted by Submitted to: WUB Consult Architectural & Development Planning Consultant P.O.Box 19974, Addis