LOSD Seminar Slides: Wisconsin (160224) SAMPLE

7/24/2019 LOSD Seminar Slides: Wisconsin (160224) SAMPLE

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/losd-seminar-slides-wisconsin-160224-sample 1/12





!"#$ & '()* !"#$ #+,-./01 23 4'5'65)*7

89: ;"< => ?>@?"$AB>$ =: 9;: 8>9;# )

LOSD ©2016

Presented by Andrew Branca

West Bend WI

February 24, 2016

2-CDE.C-.!"#$%&'

LOSD ©2016

) )

THE SYLLABUS

Introduction

Laws and Legal Principles

LOSD ©2016

* *

Element 1: Innocence

Element 2: Imminence

Element 3: Proportionality

Element 4: Avoidance

LOSD ©2016

+ +

Element 5: Reasonableness

Defense of Others

Defense of Property

Consciousness of Guilt

LOSD ©2016

, ,

Was it Worth It?

Interacting with the Police

Crafting a Legally SoundSelf Defense Strategy

Self-Defense Immunity

LOSD ©2016

$-./012340-



!"#$ & '()* !"#$ #+,-./01 23 4'5'65)*7

89: ;"< => ?>@?"$AB>$ =: 9;: 8>9;# '

LOSD ©2016

5 5

Attorney Andrew Branca Experienced<F-0G G+D/G+ EH I0/DJD-.K L/M -. NF+ BE,,E.M+/LNF EH

8/CC/DFOC+PCQ C+LH5G+H+.C+ CI+D-/L-R/JE. C-.D+ )SSTU

RespectedVO+CN -.CN0ODNE0 /N NF+ #-K #/O+0 9D/G+,W -. ;XU Y0+ZO+.N IO[L-D

CI+/\+0 E. C+LH5G+H+.C+Q '9 -CCO+C /N L/M CDFEEL CW,IEC-/Q /.G /N

-.GOCN0W +]+.NC 4;?9 9..O/L 8++J.K '()67

Member of the Gun Community9N NF+ HEO.G-.K EH 3$@9Q ̂ )_Q 8/CN+05DL/CC ##@Q B$@U 8E0+ NF/. '(

W+/0C / !-H+ 8+,[+0 ;?9 /.G 3.CN0ODNE0

Advocate for Defensive RightsBE.D+/L+G D/00W /.G '.G 9,+.G,+.N /[CELOJCNU

LOSD ©2016

6 6

Why Are We Here?

• 2+`]+ DE.N+,IL/N+G NF+ IECC-[-L-NW NF/N CE,+G/WQ G+CI-N+ EO0 [+CN +aE0NCQ M+ ,-KFN

b.G EO0C+L]+C DE,I+LL+G NE OC+ HE0D+ /K/-.CN /.ENF+0 I+0CE.U

• <E G+H+.G EO0C+L]+CQ EO0 H/,-L-+CQ /. -..ED+.N NF-0G I+0CE.Q E0 EO0 I0EI+0NWU

• YE0 NF+ L/MW+0CQ M+ DE.N+,IL/N+ NF/N M+`LL [+ D/LL+G OIE. NE 0+I0+C+.N / DL-+.N MFE

F/C OC+G HE0D+ M-NF DL/-,+G L+K/L cOCJbD/JE. E0 +dDOC+U

• 2+ \.EM NF/N OC-.K HE0D+ /K/-.CN /.ENF+0 I+0CE. -C !"#$% '%(#) 2-789:27Q /.G D/.

0+COLN -. ]+0W C+0-EOC D0-,-./L DF/0K+CU

LOSD ©2016

;< ;<

Potential Criminal Charges

)U 8O0G+0 4!-H+7

'U 8/.CL/OKFN+0 4)e56( W+/0C7

_U 9KK0/]/N+G 9CC/OLNf=/P+0W 4g)( W+/0C7

6U 9CC/OLNf=/P+0W 4S( G/WC NE * ,E.NFC7

eU =0/.G-CF-.Kf8+./D-.K 4]/0-+C7

Y-0+/0,C +.F/.D+,+.N1!"#" h)(5'(5!-H+i1 8/W /GG ,/.W W+/0C NE D0-,-./L C+.N+.D+U

LOSD ©2016

;; ;;

UNLESS in Lawful Self-Defense

• #+LH5G+H+.C+ -C /. /[CELON+ G+H+.C+ NE D0-,-./L L-/[-L-NW HE0 NF+ -.N+.JE./L OC+ EH

HE0D+ /K/-.CN /.ENF+0U

• XEM+]+0Q -N -C ]+0W [-./0W1

?OL+C EH

#+LH5$+H+.C+

j+0E D0-,-./L

L-/[-L-NW

"ONC-G+ ?OL+C EH

#+LH $+H+.C+

<"<9! D0-,-./L L-/[-L-NW

LOSD ©2016

;= ;=

UNLESS in Lawful Self-Defense

• =+CN NF+. NE CN/W M+LL M-NF-. NF+ 0OL+CU

• =ON MF/N /0+ NF+ 0OL+Ck

•

<X9< -C MFW M+`0+ F+0+U

LOSD ©2016

;) ;)

Why “Law of Self Defense”?

• '( W+/0C /KEUUU

• h3H WEO CFEEN / KOW EONC-G+ WEO0 FEOC+UUUi

• <F+ /G]-D+ M/C <>??3=!>

• 3N M/C #" [/G -N DEOLG NO0. / KEEG CFEEN -.NE ,/.CL/OKFN+0U

• #E 3`G DE00+DN NF+-0 ,-CO.G+0CN/.G-.K EH NF+ L/MQ /.G NF+W`G /C\ ,+ MF+0+ NF+W

DEOLG b.G / KEEG 0+CEO0D+ E. MF/N C+LH5G+H+.C+ L/M /DNO/LLW M/CU

• <F+0+ C-,ILW M+0+ .EN /.W KEEG CEO0D+CQ -H .EN / L/MW+0Q /.G .EN ,/.W K0+/N

CEO0D+C +]+. -H WEO M+0+ / L/MW+0 4I0-,/0W L+K/L 0+C+/0DF7U



!"#$ & '()* !"#$ #+,-./01 23 4'5'65)*7

89: ;"< => ?>@?"$AB>$ =: 9;: 8>9;# _

LOSD ©2016

;* ;*

Law of Self Defense, 2nd Edition

=EE\1 h<F+ !/M EH #+LH $+H+.C+Q '.G >GUi 4'()_7

9,/RE.UDE, [+CN5C+LL+01

LOSD ©2016

;+ ;+

Law of Self Defense Seminars

LOSD ©2016

>!??&

LOSD ©2016

LOSD Self-Defense Simulator Module

LOSD ©2016

;5 ;5

LOSD State-Specific Online Courses

LOSD ©2016

;6 ;6

LOSD Instructor Program



!"#$ & '()* !"#$ #+,-./01 23 4'5'65)*7

89: ;"< => ?>@?"$AB>$ =: 9;: 8>9;# 6

LOSD ©2016

=< =<

Legal Consults

LOSD ©2016

=; =;

Mostly Bad Sources of Self-defense Law

• 8ECN !/MW+0C

• 8ECN @EL-D+ "lD+0C

• 8ECN Y-0+/0,C 3.CN0ODNE0C

• 8ECN VO. 8/K/R-.+C

• 8ECN 3.N+0.+N VO. YE0O,C

LOSD ©2016

== ==

Self Defense Law Expert

Meet GunForumGuy27

_(m W+/0C /CCO0-.K +]+0WE.+ E.L-.+ NF/N F+ \.EMC MF/N F+`C N/L\-.K /[EONU

Confidence

Creativity

Legal Expertise

2/0.-.K1 ;+]+0 /K/-. M-LL WEO [+ /[L+ NE +.cEW / C+LH5G+H+.C+ L/M NF0+/G E. / KO. HE0O,n

WEO`LL [+ NF+ E.LW I+0CE. -. NF+ NF0+/G MFE \.EMC MF/N NF+W`0+ N/L\-.K /[EONULOSD ©2016

=) =)

Mostly Bad Sources of Self-defense Law

• 8ECN !/MW+0C

• 8ECN @EL-D+ "lD+0C

• 8ECN Y-0+/0,C 3.CN0ODNE0C

• 8ECN VO. 8/K/R-.+C

• 8ECN 3.N+0.+N VO. YE0O,

• 2E0CN EH /LL1 8/-.CN0+/, 8+G-/

LOSD ©2016

=* =*

“Often mistaken, but never uncertain.” 9L,ECN +]+0WNF-.K WEO 0+/G -. NF+ ,/-.CN0+/, ,+G-/ /[EON C+LH5G+H+.C+ L/M /.G C+LH5

G+H+.C+ D/C+C ,OCN [+ /CCO,+G NE [+ M0E.KQ O.JL I0E]+. ENF+0M-C+U

8-DF/+L BF0-DFNE.1 <F+ 8O00/W V+LL58/.. 9,.+C-/ +a+DN

LOSD ©2016

=+ =+

“Often mistaken, but never uncertain.”

#O[c+DN 2-NF-. :EO0 >dI+0JC+1

h8/.Q NF-C cEO0./L-CN -C /. -G-ENoi

#O[c+DN "ONC-G+ :EO0 >dI+0JC+1

h8/.Q NF-C cEO0./L-CN -C / K+.-OCoi



!"#$ & '()* !"#$ #+,-./01 23 4'5'65)*7

89: ;"< => ?>@?"$AB>$ =: 9;: 8>9;# e

LOSD ©2016

=, =,

Ferguson “Rubber Bullets” Y+0KOCE. 8" 0-ENCU

h?W/. pU ?+-LLW -C / $UBU5[/C+G 0+IE0N+0 MFE DE]+0C NF+ pOCJD+ $+I/0N,+.N /.G NF+

#OI0+,+ BEO0NU X+ F/C DE]+0+G H+G+0/L L/M +.HE0D+,+.N /.G L+K/L .+MC C-.D+ '((SUi

80U ?+-LLW M/C /CC-K.+G NE DE]+0 NF+ Y+0KOCE. 0-ENCU

LOSD ©2016

=@ =@

Ferguson “Rubber Bullets”

h3 [+L-+]+ NF+C+ /0+ 0O[[+0 [OLL+NCQ D/. /.WE.+ DE.b0,ki

LOSD ©2016

=5 =5

Ferguson “Rubber Bullets”

LOSD ©2016

=6 =6

So Andrew Branca is the best source? ;Eo 3 /, .EN / CEO0D+ EH NF+ L/MU

3 /, /. +GOD/JE./L DF/..+L NE DE..+DN WEO M-NF NF+ CEO0D+U

8W KE/L -C NE /GG ]/LO+ -. NF+ I0ED+CC [W N0/.CL/J.K hL+K/L+C+i -.NE IL/-. >.KL-CFQ /.G

NE ,/\+ NF+ -.HE0,/JE. /DJE./L H0E, / N/DJD/L I+0CI+DJ]+U

YE0 NF+ L/MW+0CQ ,W KE/L -C NE I0E]-G+ / DE.D+INO/L H0/,+ME0\ NE H/D-L-N/N+ +lD-+.N

/.G DE00+DN L+K/L /./LWC-C EH C+LH5G+H+.C+ D/C+CU

VE/L1 NE +./[L+ [+P+0 -.HE0,+GQ ,E0+ DE.bG+.N C+LH5G+H+.C+ L/M G+D-C-E.C1 N/DJD/LLW

HE0 NF+ G+H+.G+0Q CN0/N+K-D/LLW HE0 NF+ /PE0.+WU

8-CC-E.1 NE M-. [ENF NF+ IFWC-D/L bKFN /.G NF+ L+K/L bKFNU

LOSD ©2016

)< )<

So What IS the source of the Law?

)U #N/NON+C

'U BEO0N $+D-C-E.C

_U

pO0W 3.CN0ODJE.C

@>?3"$ 4M+LLQ /LCE DE.CNOJE./L L/MQ E. 0/0+ EDD/C-E.C7

LOSD ©2016

); );

Self Defense Law Compilation



!"#$ & '()* !"#$ #+,-./01 23 4'5'65)*7

89: ;"< => ?>@?"$AB>$ =: 9;: 8>9;# *

LOSD ©2016

)= )=

Sources of Self-Defense Law

#N/NON+C1

2-CDE.C-. #N/NON+C 42U#U7U BX9@<>? S_SU B?38># n V>;>?9! @?"q3#3";#

#A=BX9@<>? 333U $>Y>;#># <" B?383;9! !39=3!3<:

S_SU6r #+LH5G+H+.C+ /.G G+H+.C+ EH ENF+0CU

B/C+ !/M1

$%&%! (" )!*+,-&Q 'er ;U2U'G '*( 423 #OI0+,+ BEO0N )STT7

pO0W 3.CN0ODJE.C1

2-CDE.C-. pO0W 3.CN0ODJE.C 5 B0-,-./L 4'()e7

r((U @0-]-L+K+1 #+LH5G+H+.C+1 YE0D+ L+CC NF/. NF/N L-\+LW NE D/OC+ G+/NF E0 K0+/N

[EG-LW F/0,

LOSD ©2016

)) ))

Why Bother? h3C.`N / KEEG CFEEN / KEEG CFEENki #O0+U

8/.DF+CN+0 ;XQ p/.U )(Q ))1_(I,Q *eWE 6` ))i )(eL[CQ 0+NO0.-.K FE,+ H0E, .-KFN

CF-tQ /DDECN+G [W e`))i '((L[C /CC/-L/.NQ MFE [LED\+G F+0 H0E, F+0 H0E.N GEE0Q

G+,/.G+G F+0 IO0C+Q /.G 0+/DF+G HE0 F+0 M-NF F-C L+t F/.GU #F+ G0+M / U_' u+L5<+D

H0E, F+0 IED\+N /.G CFEN F-, -. NF+ DF+CNU

X+ C/-G h"MUi

<F-C ME,/. .+]+0 F/G /.W N/DJD/L N0/-.-.KQ .+]+0 NEE\ / !/M EH #+LH $+H+.C+ #+,-./0U

#F+ ME. NF+ IFWC-D/L bKFNQ /.G ME.`N H/D+ /.W L+K/L I+0-LU 9 hKEEG CFEENUi

LOSD ©2016

)* )*

Why Bother?

<F+ N0EO[L+ -C NF/N / [/G CFEEN -C / /LCE / [/G CFEENU

9.G C+LH5G+H+.C+ -C ]+0W [-./0W1 WEO0 DE.GODN +-NF+0 ZO/L-b+CQ E0 -N GE+C.`NU

2F+. L/MW+0C K+N / D/LL H0E, / DL-+.NQ M+`0+ CNOD\ M-NF NF+ H/DNC NF+ DL-+.N K-]+C OCU

=/G H/DNCQ [/G D/C+U <F+0+`C / L-,-N NE MF/N M+ D/. /DDE,IL-CFU

=+CN [+ +GOD/N+G [+HE0+F/.G CE WEO K-]+ OC KEEG H/DNC /.G M+ ,/\+ / K0+/N D/C+

H0E, NF+,U

LOSD ©2016

)+ )+

Consequences of Losing Legal Battle

YE0 NF+ NWI-D/L L/M5/[-G-.K D-JR+.Q LEC-.K NF+ C+DE.G [/PL+ v NF+ L+K/L [/PL+ v D/. [+

.+/0LW /C G+]/CN/J.K /C LEC-.K NF+ IFWC-D/L [/PL+U

<F+0+ /0+ I+EIL+ -. EO0 CED-+NW MFE GE cOCN b.+ -. I0-CE.U

<F+0+ /0+ I+EIL+ -. EO0 CED-+NW MFE NF0-]+ -. I0-CE.U

!/M5/[-G-.K I+EIL+ L-\+ OC /0+ .EN /,E.K NF+,U

$E.`N .++G NE CI+.G ,ODF J,+ -. I0-CE. [+HE0+ L-H+ /C WEO \.EM -N -C G+CN0EW+G E]+0U

LOSD ©2016

), ),

Ignorance is Fraught with Peril

3. ,/.W D/C+C / G+H+.G/.N`C hC+LH5G+H+.C+i M/C .EN -. H/DN L/MHOLU

<F+W K+.O-.+LW NFEOKFN NF+W M+0+ /DJ.K -. L/MHOL C+LH G+H+.C+U

=ON NF+W [0E\+ / 0OL+Q NF+W ,/G+ / ,-CN/\+Q NF+W KEEH+GU

;EN EON EH ,/L-D+Q [ON EON EH -K.E0/.D+U

9.G -. GE-.K CE NF+W LECN NF+ cOCJbD/JE. EH C+LH G+H+.C+U

3N M/C NF+-0 /DJE.C NF/N ,/G+ NF+, ]OL.+0/[L+ NE /00+CNQ -.G-DN,+.NQ I0EC+DOJE. /.G

+]+. DE.]-DJE.U

LOSD ©2016

)@ )@

“Can’t believe I’M arrested for self-defense!”



!"#$ & '()* !"#$ #+,-./01 23 4'5'65)*7

89: ;"< => ?>@?"$AB>$ =: 9;: 8>9;# T

LOSD ©2016

)5 )5

Uncertainty of Prosecutorial Discretion

3. ,/.W -.CN/.D+C NF+ D0-,-./L cOCJD+ CWCN+, LEE\C NF-.KC E]+0 /.G DFEEC+C NE OC+ -NC

G-CD0+JE. NE .EN /00+CNQ -.G-DNQ I0EC+DON+Q /.G DE.]-DN WEOU

<F-C ]/0-+C N0+,+.GEOC [W K+EK0/IF-D 0+K-E.Q N+,I+0/,+.N EH NF+ I0EC+DONE0CQ /.G

NF+ I+EIL+ -.]EL]+GU

LOSD ©2016

)6 )6

Preparing for What the System Can Do

2+ GE.`N F/]+ NF+ LOdO0W EH I0+I/0-.K ,+0+LW HE0 MF/N NF+ D0-,-./L cOCJD+ CWCN+,

,-KFN GEQ -H -N`C \-.GLW G-CIEC+GU

2+ .++G NE [+ I0+I/0+G HE0 FEM NE G+H+.G /K/-.CN MF/N NF+ CWCN+, D/. GEn/.G

DE.GODN EO0C+L]+C /DDE0G-.KLWU

9.G MF/N -N D/. GEQ K-]+. NF+ 0-KFN +]-G+.D+Q -C ION WEO -. I0-CE. HE0 NF+ 0+CN EH WEO0

L-H+Q /.G CN0-I WEO EH +]+0W /CC+N WEO`]+ +]+0 /DDO,OL/N+G E]+0 / L-H+J,+ EH F/0G

ME0\U

LOSD ©2016

*< *<

Preparing for the Legal Battle

2-NF NF+ IFWC-D/L [/PL+Q [+D/OC+ EH NF+ DE.C+ZO+.D+C EH LEC-.K NF+ [/PL+Q NF+

I0OG+.N I+0CE. I0+I/0+C NF+,C+L]+C M-NF NEELCQ N0/-.-.K /.G I0/DJD+U

>d/DNLW NF+ C/,+ ,OCN [+ GE.+ NE I0+I/0+ HE0 NF+ L+K/L [/PL+1 NEELCQ N0/-.-.K /.G

I0/DJD+U

<F/N`C MF/N NF-C C+,-./0 -C /LL /[EONU

LOSD ©2016

*; *;

Minimizing Your Legal Vulnerability

=W NF+ +.G EH NF-C DEO0C+ WEO M-LL IECC+C / 0E[OCN \.EML+GK+ EH1

)U :EO0 CN/N+`C /DNO/L L/MC E. C+LH5G+H+.C+

'U XEM NFEC+ L/MC /0+ /IIL-+G -. NF+ 0+/L ME0LG

_U XEM NE [+CN G+H+.G WEO0C+LH /.G WEO0 H/,-LW -. /DDE0G/.D+ M-NF NF/N L/MQ /.G

/]E-G /DD-G+.N/LLW ]-EL/J.K -N NF0EOKF ,-C-.HE0,/JE. E0 -K.E0/.D+

LOSD ©2016

*= *=

Disclaimers: For the Non-lawyers

=W NF+ +.G EH NF-C C+,-./0 WEO M-LL \.EM ,E0+ /[EON NF+ L/M EH C+LH G+H+.C+ NF/. cOCN

/[EON /.W L/MW+0 WEO ,-KFN 0O. -.NEU

=A<UUU NF-C C+,-./0 GE+C ;"< ,/\+ WEO / D0-,-./L G+H+.C+ /PE0.+WU

<F+0+ /0+ +.E0,EOC /.G ]-N/LLW -,IE0N/.N /0+/C EH NF+ L/M M+ GE .EN +]+. NEODFOIE. v CODF /C 0OL+C EH +]-G+.D+ /.G D0-,-./L I0ED+GO0+ v NF/N D/. M-. E0 LEC+ / D/C+U

LOSD ©2016

*) *)

No Gaming the System!

Y/-0 M/0.-.K1 ;ENF-.K WEO L+/0. NEG/W M-LL +./[L+ WEO NE ,/.-IOL/N+ NF+ L/M EH C+LH5

G+H+.C+ -. E0G+0 NE DE,,-N [/G /DNC /K/-.CN -..ED+.N I+EIL+ /.G +CD/I+ IO.-CF,+.NU

<F-C DEO0C+ N+/DF+C NF+ L/MC KE]+0.-.K C+LH5G+H+.C+Q .EN FEM NE K+N /0EO.G NFEC+

L/MCU

3H hK/,-.K NF+ CWCN+,i -C WEO0 KE/LQ WEO`LL [+ G-C/IIE-.N+G 4/.G L-\+LW NE CI+.G / LEN EH

J,+ -. I0-CE.7U

@0EC+DONE0C LE]+ C+LH5G+H+.C+ D/C+C MF+0+ NF+ hG+H+.G+0i N0-+G NE K/,+ NF+ CWCN+,U

<F+W`0+ -.]/0-/[LW +/CW DE.]-DJE.CU



!"#$ & '()* !"#$ #+,-./01 23 4'5'65)*7

89: ;"< => ?>@?"$AB>$ =: 9;: 8>9;# r

LOSD ©2016

** **

Disclaimers: For EVERYONE

<F-C C+,-./0 GE+C .EN DE.CJNON+ L+K/L /G]-D+U

3 /, .EN L-D+.C+G NE I0/DJD+ L/M /.WMF+0+ +dD+IN 8/CC/DFOC+PCQ /.G 3 /, .EN

I0E]-G-.K L+K/L /G]-D+ F+0+U

!+K/L /G]-D+ D/. E.LW [+ Ea+0+G [+NM++. /. /PE0.+W /.G DL-+.N -. / HE0,/L

0+L/JE.CF-I -.]EL]-.K / CI+D-bD C-NO/JE.Q /.G [W / L/MW+0 L-D+.C+G NE I0/DJD+ -. NF/N

CN/N+U

<F-C -CQ /C G+CD0-[+GQ / C+,-./0Q -. NF+ /D/G+,-D C+.C+ EH NF+ ME0GU

3H WEO /0+ -. .++G EH L+K/L /G]-D+Q 0+N/-. DE,I+N+.N L+K/L DEO.C+L L-D+.C+G NE I0/DJD+

-. NF+ 0+L+]/.N cO0-CG-DJE.U

LOSD ©2016

*+ *+

Disclaimers

<F-C C+,-./0 GE+C .EN +CN/[L-CF /. /PE0.+W5DL-+.N 0+L/JE.CF-IUUUU

"""./0 /1 2345467879

LOSD ©2016

*, *,

“...and that’s why I’m glad...

""" %:&% 4 ,;* & <&=>:,!"?LOSD ©2016

A89B 8-1 ACD87 E/F-3FG7CB

LOSD ©2016

*5 *5

“Yes, I shot that person, but ...”

YO.G/,+.N/LLWQ C+LH5G+H+.C+ DL/-,C 0+ZO-0+ WEO NE DE.D+G+ NF/N WEO F/0,+G /.ENF+0

I+0CE. E. IO0IEC+U :EO0 G+H+.C+ -C that you were legally justified in doing so.

You would need to say, through your defense attorney:

“Yes, I shot that person, and they died as a result, but I did so

with the legal justification of self-defense.”

3H WEO0 L+K/L DL/-, EH C+LH5G+H+.C+ H/-LCQ MF/N`C L+t EH NF/N CN/N+,+.Nk

LOSD ©2016

*6 *6

Dynamics of Criminal Justice

"H DEO0C+Q L/MC /0+ .EN /IIL-+G -. / ]/DOO,U

XO,/. [+-.KC OC+ / [0E/G FO,/. DE.CN0ODNQ NF+ D0-,-./L cOCJD+ CWCN+,Q NE /IILW

NF+,U

<F-C CWCN+, F/C DE,IL+d /.G Et+. C++,-.KLW [-R/00+ 0OL+C /.G -.D+.J]+C NF/N /0+O.0+L/N+G E0 +]+. DE.N0/G-DNE0W NE NF+ L/.KO/K+ M-NF-. NF+-0 CN/NON+CU

3N`C D0-JD/L WEO O.G+0CN/.G [ENF NF+ L-N+0/L 0OL+C 4CN/NON+C7Q /C M+LL /C FEM NF+W /0+

/DNO/LLW /IIL-+G -. NF+ 0+/L ME0LGU

3H NF+ D0-,-./L cOCJD+ CWCN+, M+0+ / HEEN[/LL K/,+Q MF/N GE+C NF+ IL/W-.K b+LG LEE\

L-\+k XEM /0+ KE/LC CDE0+Gk =LED\+Gk



!"#$ & '()* !"#$ #+,-./01 23 4'5'65)*7

89: ;"< => ?>@?"$AB>$ =: 9;: 8>9;# S

LOSD ©2016

+< +<

Prosecutors Love to Win

@+EIL+ MFE L/D\ / G0-]+ NE M-. GE .EN [+DE,+ I0EC+DONE0CU

".D+ G0-]+. I0EC+DONE0C F/]+ G+D-G+G WEO /0+ / ]OL.+0/[L+ N/0K+N EH I0EC+DOJE.Q

NF+W M-LL OC+ /LL EH NF+-0 N0/-.-.KQ I0EH+CC-E./L C\-LLQ /.G 0F+NE0-D/L N/L+.N NE DE.]-DN

WEOU

<F/N`C NF+-0 cE[Q NF+-0 I0EH+CC-E./L GONWU

"O0 cE[Q EO0 GONWQ MF+. /DJ.K -. L/MHOL C+LH5G+H+.C+Q -C NE ,/\+ EO0C+L]+C / F/0G

N/0K+N NE NF+ I0EC+DONE0U

LOSD ©2016

+; +;

Prosecutors Hate to Lose

@0EC+DONE0C GE.`N L-\+ NE [0-.K D/C+C NE N0-/L NF/N M-NFEON / CN0E.K I0ECI+DN HE0

CODD+CCU

9C ,ODF /C NF+W LE]+ NE M-.Q NF+W F/N+ NE LEC+U

Y0E, NF+ ,E,+.N NF+W b0CN C++ WEO0 D/C+Q NF+W /0+ ,/\-.K / CF0+MG /CC+CC,+.N EH

WEO0 ]OL.+0/[-L-NW NE I0EC+DOJE.U

3HQ NF0EOKF WEO0 EM. -K.E0/.D+ E0 +00E0Q WEO0 /DJE.C H/LL EONC-G+ NF+ [EO.GC EH L/MHOL

C+LH5G+H+.C+Q NF/N`C /. +/CW DE.]-DJE.U

9.G NF/N`C L-\+ [LEEG -. NF+ M/N+0 NE / CF/0\U

LOSD ©2016

+= +=

Prosecutors Hate to Lose

9 I0EC+DONE0`C F/N+ NE LEC+ -C EO0 EIIE0NO.-NWU

B/C+C NF/N LEE\ NEOKF NE M-. K+.+0/LLW 0+D+-]+ / LEM+0 I0-E0-NW NF/. C-,-L/0 D/C+C NF/N

LEE\ +/C-+0 NE M-.Q /.G ,/W [+ h\-D\+G EONi EH NF+ D0-,-./L cOCJD+ I-I+L-.+ +.J0+LWU

:EO M/.N NE LEE\ L-\+ NF+ NEOKF+CN D/C+ IECC-[L+U

:EO M/.N NE [+ I+0D+-]+G /C NF+ LEM+CN I0-E0-NW D/C+ E. NF/N G+C\U

8-CC-E.1 u.EM NF+ 0OL+CQ CN/W M+LL -.C-G+ NF+,Q ,-.-,-R+ WEO0 L+K/L ]OL.+0/[-L-NWU

LOSD ©2016

+) +)

The Impossibility of Absolute Truth

<F+ I+EIL+ MFE M-LL [+ cOGK-.K WEO0 /DJE.C M+0+ .EN NF+0+U

<F+W GE .EN \.EM MF/N 0+/LLW F/II+.+GU

>W+ M-N.+CC+C GE .EN \.EM MF/N 0+/LLW F/II+.+GU

>]+. :"A GE .EN \.EM MF/N 0+/LLW F/II+.+GU

2+ D/. E.LW \.EM MF/N NF+ +]-G+.D+ COKK+CNC 0+/LLW F/II+.+GU

<F+ D0-,-./L cOCJD+ CWCN+, -C / [O0+/OD0/JD ,/DF-.+ G+C-K.+G NE /G,-.-CN+0 cOCJD+Q

.EN b.G /[CELON+ N0ONFU

LOSD ©2016

+* +*

Competing Narratives of Guilt/Innocence

:EO0 L-[+0NW F/.KC OIE. NME DE,I+J.K ./00/J]+C [+-.K I0+C+.N+G NE NF+ cO0WU

<F+ I0EC+DONE0 -C N+LL-.K NF+ cO0W / ./00/J]+ EH KO-LNU

:EO0 L/MW+0 -C N+LL-.K NF+ cO0W / ./00/J]+ EH -..ED+.D+U

<F+ pO0W M-LL [/C+ NF+-0 ]+0G-DN CEL+LW E. NF+ -.HE0,/JE. M-NF-. NF+C+ NME ./00/J]+CU

LOSD ©2016

++ ++

Narrative Building Blocks

=ENF ./00/J]+C /0+ DE.CN0ODN+G EON EH NF+ h[O-LG-.K [LED\Ci EH +]-G+.D+ I0+C+.N+G /N

N0-/LU

#E,+ [O-LG-.K [LED\C H/]E0 NF+ @0EC+DONE0Q CE,+ NF+ $+H+.C+U

<F+ ,E0+ EH NFEC+ [O-LG-.K [LED\C H0E, MF-DF NF+ @0EC+DONE0 -.H+0 KO-LNQ NF+ ,E0+

L+K/LLW ]OL.+0/[L+ WEO /II+/0U



!"#$ & '()* !"#$ #+,-./01 23 4'5'65)*7

89: ;"< => ?>@?"$AB>$ =: 9;: 8>9;# )(

LOSD ©2016

+, +,

8/./K-.K NF+ ;/00/J]+

@0EC+DONE0`C #NE0W EH

VO-LN

<WI+C EH +]-G+.J/0W

[O-LG-.K [LED\C NF+

I0EC+DONE0C LEE\ HE0

<WI+C EH +]-G+.J/0W

[O-LG-.K [LED\C WEO0

L/MW+0 LEE\C HE0XEM NE G+C-K. /

C+LH5G+H+.C+

CN0/N+KW NF/N

,-.-,-R+C KO-LNW

[O-LG-.K [LED\C

XEM NE G+C-K. /

C+LH5G+H+.C+

CN0/N+KW NF/N

,/d-,-R+C -..ED+.N

[O-LG-.K [LED\C

:EO0 #NE0W EH

3..ED+.D+LOSD ©2016

+@ +@

Prosecutorial Avenues of Attack

#E MF/N /0+ NF+ [O-LG-.K [LED\C EH / ./00/J]+ EH KO-LNk 2F/N -C -N NF/N F+LIC WEO0

L/MW+0k

#+LH G+H+.C+ -C / DL/-, EH L+K/L cOCJbD/JE. NF/N`C [++. G+b.+G [W L/MU

<F+0+ /0+ 4OI NE7 b]+ 0+ZO-0+G +L+,+.NC -. NF/N DL/-,Q /LL EH MF-DF ,OCN [+ I0+C+.N

HE0 WEO0 L/MW+0 NE CODD++G -. WEO0 G+H+.C+U

<E G+CN0EW WEO0 G+H+.C+Q NF+ I0EC+DONE0 .++G E.LW G+CN0EW ";> EH NF+,U

3H F+ CODD++GCQ C+LH5G+H+.C+ KE+C /M/WU

LOSD ©2016

+5 +5

Five Elements of Self-Defense Law 3..ED+.D+

3,,-.+.D+@0EIE0JE./L-NW

9]E-G/.D+ ?+/CE./[L+.+CC

!>V9!

;"< !>V9!

LOSD ©2016

+6 +6

Five Elements of Self-Defense Law 3..ED+.D+

3,,-.+.D+@0EIE0JE./L-NW

9]E-G/.D+ ?+/CE./[L+.+CC

A"H&A

;"< !>V9!

2X9< 3Y :"A`?>

X>?>k

LOSD ©2016

,< ,<

;EN VO-LNWVO-LNW

The Legal Playing Field

#N/.G/0GC EH >]-G+.D+1 2F+0+ GE+C NF+ L-.+ KEk

=O0G+.C EH @0EEH1 2F/N +]-G+.J/0W h[O-LG-.K [LED\Ci ,/W M+ OC+k

2FE ,OCN DE.]-.D+ NF+ cO0W MF-DF C-G+ NE ION WEO E. NF+ b+LGk

!3u>!3X""$ "Y VA3!<;<<I <I

LOSD ©2016

,; ,;

Standards of Evidence

XEM 8ABX +]-G+.D+ -C 0+ZO-0+G HE0 /. -CCO+ NE [+ DE.C-G+0+G I0E]+.k

BY A PREPONDERANCE OF THE EVIDENCE

BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT

Documents

LOSD Seminar Slides: Wisconsin (160224) SAMPLE