9
OP4M SWrucWural Analysis of HisWorical ConsWrucWions – Jerzy Jasieńko (ed) © 2012 DPNH ProcławH PolandH ISSN 0860-2395H ISBN 978-83-7125-216-7 AClrpTfC bMfppflN MlNfTlofNd lc cobpClp abdoAaATflN fN A usff th CbNTrov CeAmbi lc Teb “pACoba MlrNTAfN lc sAoAiil” EfTAivF Alberto Carpinteri N I ptefano fnvernizzi O Idiuseppe iacidogna P I cederico Accornero 4 ABpToACT qhe present paper describes the results of the Acoustic bmission monitoringI performed for five months in order to assess the structural behaviour and the frescos degradation of a usff th Century Chapel belonging to the pacred jountain of sarallo EftalyFK qhe pacred jountain of sarallo i s composed of 4R ChapelsI some of which are isolatedI while others are part of monumental groupsI containing over UMM lifeJsize wooden and multicoloured terracotta statuesI which represent the iifeI the massion and the aeath of ChristK qhe site is considered the most notable example in the group of pacred jountains of miedmontsI a complex that has been included in the rkbpCl torld eeritage iist since OMMPK qhe Chapel number NTI dedicated to the jount qabor episode of Christ qransfigurationI shows some structural concern due to an existing large crack and some degradation of the high valuable frescosI which tend to detach from the masonry supportK fn order to assess the evolution of the phenomenaI an Acoustic bmission monitoring apparatus was usedI with six sensors that enable the recording of the signals and localization of the eventsK fn additionI a detailed survey of the Chapel was providedI together with a structural finite element simulationK qhe results of the monitoring show that the large crack is stableI while the process of detachment of the frescos is evolving cyclicallyK ft seems that the frescos degradation could be mainly related to the diffusion of moisture in the mortar substrateK pome preliminary laboratory tests also confirm that Acoustic bmissions are recorded in mortar samples subjected to moisture diffusionK heywordsW Acoustic emission monitoringI ptructural assessmentI crescos detachment NK fNTolarCTflN qhe mroject “mreservationI pafeguard and salorization of jasonry aecorations in the Architectural eistorical eeritage of miedmont” – named obJcobpClp − was approved by the miedmont oegional dovernment EftalyF in August OMMV xNzK ft involves the main theme of the Conservation of the miedmont Artistic eeritage and particularly the safeguard of the historical site of the pacred jountain of sarallo EcigK NFK qhe research activity of the obJcobpClp project is multidisciplinary and is developed by some aepartments of the molitecnico di qorinoI the qher modynamic aivision of the kational fnstitute of N cull mrofessorI aepartment of ptructuralI deotechnical and Building bngineeringI molitecnico di qorinoI Corso auca degli Abruzzi O4I NMNOV qorino ftalyI albertoKcarpinteri]politoKit O Assistant mrofessorI aepartment of ptructuralI deotechnical and Building bngineeringI molitecnico di qorinoI Corso auca degli Abruzzi O4I NMNOV qorino ftalyI stefanoKinvernizzi]politoKit P Associate mrofessorI aepartment of ptructuralI deotechnical and Building bngineeringI molitecnico di qorinoI Corso auca degli Abruzzi O4I NMNOV qorino ftalyI giuseppeKlacidogna]politoKit 4 mha ptudentI aepartment of ptructuralI deotechnical and Building bngineeringI molitecnico di qorinoI Corso auca degli Abruzzi O4I NMNOV qorino ftalyI federicoKaccornero]politoKit

lrpfbMfppfllflofd lccobplpabdoaflfusff brov ... · OPN= jtrolog=osear=EfkofjF====auth=o==p=k=ose===pcre= junta==salloK=qhi=ra==ss=t=t=mployme=o=J=onitori= methodologie==ge==pre=m=ssessmen==stori=I=decorate=rface=n=

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: lrpfbMfppfllflofd lccobplpabdoaflfusff brov ... · OPN= jtrolog=osear=EfkofjF====auth=o==p=k=ose===pcre= junta==salloK=qhi=ra==ss=t=t=mployme=o=J=onitori= methodologie==ge==pre=m=ssessmen==stori=I=decorate=rface=n=

=

OP4M=

SWrucWural Analysis of HisWorical ConsWrucWions – Jerzy Jasieńko (ed) © 2012 DPNH ProcławH PolandH ISSN 0860-2395H ISBN 978-83-7125-216-7

AClrpTfC bMfppflN MlNfTlofNd lc cobpClp abdoAaATflN fN A usffth CbNTrov CeAmbi lc Teb “pACoba MlrNTAfN lc sAoAiil” EfTAivF Alberto CarpinteriNI ptefano fnvernizziOIdiuseppe iacidognaPI cederico Accornero4 ABpToACT qhe= present= paper= describes= the= results= of= the= Acoustic= bmission= monitoringI= performed= for= five=months= in= order= to= assess= the= structural= behaviour= and= the= frescos= degradation= of= a= usffth= Century=Chapel=belonging=to=the=pacred=jountain=of=sarallo=EftalyFK=qhe=pacred=jountain=of=sarallo=is=composed=of=4R=ChapelsI=some=of=which=are=isolatedI=while=others=are= part= of= monumental= groupsI= containing= over= UMM= lifeJsize= wooden= and= multicoloured= terracotta=statuesI=which=represent=the=iifeI=the=massion=and=the=aeath=of=ChristK=qhe=site=is=considered=the=most=notable=example=in=the=group=of=pacred=jountains=of=miedmontsI=a=complex=that=has=been=included=in=the=rkbpCl=torld=eeritage=iist=since=OMMPK=qhe=Chapel=number=NTI=dedicated=to=the=jount=qabor=episode=of=Christ=qransfigurationI=shows=some=structural=concern=due=to=an=existing= large=crack=and=some= degradation=of= the=high=valuable= frescosI=which=tend=to=detach=from=the=masonry=supportK=fn=order= to= assess= the= evolution=of= the=phenomenaI= an=Acoustic=bmission=monitoring=apparatus=was=usedI= with= six= sensors= that= enable= the= recording= of= the= signals= and= localization= of= the= eventsK= fn=additionI= a= detailed= survey= of= the= Chapel= was= providedI= together= with= a= structural= finite= element=simulationK=qhe=results=of=the=monitoring=show=that=the=large=crack=is=stableI=while=the=process=of=detachment=of=the=frescos=is=evolving=cyclicallyK=ft=seems=that=the=frescos=degradation=could=be=mainly=related=to=the=diffusion= of= moisture= in= the= mortar= substrateK= pome= preliminary= laboratory= tests= also= confirm= that=Acoustic=bmissions=are=recorded=in=mortar=samples=subjected=to=moisture=diffusionK= heywordsW Acoustic emission monitoringI ptructural assessmentI crescos detachment NK fNTolarCTflN =qhe= mroject= “mreservationI= pafeguard=and= salorization= of= jasonry=aecorations= in= the= Architectural=eistorical=eeritage=of=miedmont”=–=named=obJcobpClp=−=was=approved=by=the=miedmont=oegional=dovernment= EftalyF= in= August= OMMV= xNzK= ft= involves= the= main= theme= of= the= Conservation= of= the=miedmont=Artistic=eeritage=and=particularly=the=safeguard=of=the=historical=site=of=the=pacred=jountain=of=sarallo=EcigK=NFK=qhe= research= activity= of= the= obJcobpClp= project= is= multidisciplinary= and= is= developed= by= some=aepartments= of= the=molitecnico=di=qorinoI= the=qhermodynamic=aivision=of= the=kational= fnstitute=of=

================================================N=cull=mrofessorI=aepartment=of=ptructuralI=deotechnical=and=Building=bngineeringI=molitecnico=di=qorinoI=Corso=

auca=degli=Abruzzi=O4I=NMNOV=qorino=ftalyI=albertoKcarpinteri]politoKit=O=Assistant=mrofessorI=aepartment=of=ptructuralI=deotechnical=and=Building=bngineeringI=molitecnico=di=qorinoI=

Corso=auca=degli=Abruzzi=O4I=NMNOV=qorino=ftalyI=stefanoKinvernizzi]politoKit=P=Associate=mrofessorI=aepartment=of=ptructuralI=deotechnical=and=Building=bngineeringI=molitecnico=di=qorinoI=

Corso=auca=degli=Abruzzi=O4I=NMNOV=qorino=ftalyI=giuseppeKlacidogna]politoKit=4=mha=ptudentI=aepartment=of=ptructuralI=deotechnical=and=Building=bngineeringI=molitecnico=di=qorinoI=Corso=

auca=degli=Abruzzi=O4I=NMNOV=qorino=ftalyI=federicoKaccornero]politoKit=

Page 2: lrpfbMfppfllflofd lccobplpabdoaflfusff brov ... · OPN= jtrolog=osear=EfkofjF====auth=o==p=k=ose===pcre= junta==salloK=qhi=ra==ss=t=t=mployme=o=J=onitori= methodologie==ge==pre=m=ssessmen==stori=I=decorate=rface=n=

=

OP4N=

jetrological=oesearch=EfkofjF=and=the=regional=authority=of=the=ppecial=kature=oeserve=of=the=pacred=jountain= of= saralloK= qhis= cooperation= is= addressed= to= the= employment= of= nonJinvasive= monitoring=methodologies= to= get= a= precise= damage= assessment= of= historical= structuresI= decorated= surfaces= and=terracotta=statues=belonging=to=this=siteI=which=is=in=the=rkbpCl=torld=eeritage=iist=since=OMMPK=qhe= physicalJchemical= decay= and= the= damage= evolution= of= materialsI= constituting= the= decorated=surfaces=and=the=structural=supportsI=can=be=caused=by=infiltrations=of=waterI=thermoJelastic=stressesI=or=seismic= and= environmental= vibrationsK= qhe= physicalJchemical= degradation= has= to= be= dealt= with=jaterials=pcience=and=Chemical=bngineering=techniques=xOzK=ln=the=other=handI=the=instability=and=the=dynamic=behaviour=of= the=decorated=surfacesI= induced=also=by=seismic=and=environmental=vibrationsI=can= be= investigated= by= Acoustic= bmission= technique= EAbF= using= monitoring= systems= to= control=continuously=and=simultaneously=different=structural=supports=xPzK=qhe=data= collected=during=the= in=situ= experimental= tests= can=be= interpreted=with=cracture=jechanics=models=and=methodologies=x4I=RzK=

=

=

cigK N=qhe=pacred=jountain=of=saralloW=siew=of=the=pquare=of=qribunals=

OK Teb pACoba MlrNTAfN lc sAoAiil

OKNK Brief eistory qhe=most=ancient=pacred=jountain=of=miedmont=and=iombardy=is=situated=among=the=green=of=the=forests=at= the=top=of=a=rocky=spur=right=above=the=city=of=saralloK= ft=consists= in=4R=ChapelsI=some=of=which=are=isolatedI= while= others= are= part= of= monumental= groupsK= qhey= contain= over= UMM= lifeJsize= wooden= and=multicoloured=terracotta=statuesI=which=represent=the=iifeI=the=massion=and=the=aeath=of=ChristK=qhe=pacred=jountain=of=sarallo=is=the=work=of=two=great=churchmen=and=of=a=number=of=artists=headed=by=daudenzio=cerrari=xSzK=qhe=two=churchmen=areW=the=cranciscan=criarI=Blessed=Bernardino=Caimi=and=ptK= Charles= Borromeo= Archbishop= of= jilanK= At= saralloI= cra= Bernardino=Caimi=put= into=practice= the=idea=that=he=had=been=turning=over=in=his=mind=during=his=stay=in=the=eoly=iandK=eis=aim=was=to=erect=buildings= that= would= recall= the= “eoly= mlaces”= of= malestineK= qhose= places= evoke= the= characteristic=monuments=of=Christ∞s=stay=on=earth=Ethe=ptable=at=BethlehemI=the=eouse=in=kazarethI=the=iast=pupperI=Calvary=and=the=eoly=pepulchreFK=ee=began=his=work=in=N4VN=and=carried=on=with=it=as=long=as=he=lived=Euntil=the=end=of=N4VVFI=assisted=by=daudenzio=cerrari=who=continued=the=idea=and=decorated=a=number=of=chapels=with=frescos=and=statues=in=wood=and=terracottaK=ptK=Charles=Borromeo=appreciated=the=work=already=done=when=he=paid=a=visit=to=the=pacro=jonte=in=NRTU=andI= giving= the=place=the=appropriate=name=of=“kew=gerusalem”I= made= it= more=widely=known=among= his= contemporariesK= oeturning= there=at= the= end= of= lctober= NRU4I= he= decided= to= develop= the=original=idea=by=building=new=chapelsI=which=would=illustrate=the=life=of=gesus=more=completelyK=cor= the= great= Bishop= of= jilan= it= was= an= effective= mean= of= his= timeI= giving= the=population= greater=religious=fervour=and=protecting=them=from=the=heresies=that=threatened=korthern=ftalyK=ee=utilized=the=project =for =the =rearrangement =of =the =pacred =jountain =drawn =up =by =the =architect =daleazzo =Alessi =in =NRVO=andI=adapting=it=to=his=own=plansI=gave=instructions=for=the=resumption=of=workK=qhe=work= continued=until= NTSRK=auring= the= eighteenth= century=a= half= dozen=new=artists= added= their=names= to= daudenzio= cerrari∞sW= jorazzoneI= qanzioI= the= ciammighini= and= the= aanedi= in= panting=frescosX= diovanni= d∞bnrico= and= qabacchetti= for= sculptureI= to= mention= only= the= most= wellJknown= of=themK=ptK=Charles=Borromeo∞s= idea=and=efforts=made=the=pacred=jountain=of=sarallo=the=prototype=of=few=other=pacri=jonti=that=arose=in=the=area=during=the=usff=CenturyK=fn=totalI=nine=sites=were=builtI=the=most=important=being=pacred=jountains=of=lrtaI=sareseI=lropaI=Crea=and=iocarnoK=

qoday=the=pacred=jountain=of=sarallo=continues=to=be=a=school=of=Christian=truth=and=lifeI=while=at=the=same=time=it=is=the=most=precious=treasury=of=art=in=the=salsesia=salleyK=

Page 3: lrpfbMfppfllflofd lccobplpabdoaflfusff brov ... · OPN= jtrolog=osear=EfkofjF====auth=o==p=k=ose===pcre= junta==salloK=qhi=ra==ss=t=t=mployme=o=J=onitori= methodologie==ge==pre=m=ssessmen==stori=I=decorate=rface=n=

=

OP4O=

OKOK The Chapel usffW the Transfiguration of Christ on Mount Tabor As=the=first=object=of=investigation=with=the=Ab=techniqueI=the=Chapel=usff=of=the=pacred=jountain=of=sarallo=is=chosen=EcigK=OFK=qhis=Chapel=houses=the=scene=of=the=qransfiguration=of=ChristI=who=appeared=to=the=Apostles=at=the=foot=of=the=mountainI=in=radiant=light=between=blijah=and=josesX=the=Apostles=then=perform=miraclesK=qhis=Chapel=was=also=foreseen=in=the=“Book=of=jysteries”=by=daleazzo=Alessi=ENRSRJNRSVF=xSITzI=from=which=the=group=of=sculptures=located=high=on=the=mountain=take=inspirationK=qhe=relative=foundations=were=already=begun=in=NRTOI=but=the=chapel=was=not=completed=until=the=NSSMsK=qhe=statues=are=attributed= to=mietro=crancesco=metera=of=sarallo=and=to=diovanni=poldo=of=CamascoI=who=collaborated=with=aionigi=BussolaI= the=last=dating=back=to= the=NSTMsI=whilst= the=frescoes=Eabout=NSSSJNSTRF=are= the=work=of= the=brothers=jontaldoI= known=as= the=“aanedi”I=also=responsible=for= the=decoration=of=the=cupola=of=the=Basilica=of=pacro=jonteK=

=

=EaF= =EbF==

cigK O=bxternal=view=of=the=Chapel=usff=EaFX=internal=view=of=the=jount=qabor=installation=EbF=

=PK aAMAdb ANAivpfp lc Teb abCloATba procACb pTorCTroAi

prmmloTp Bv Teb Ab TbCeNfnrb

PKNK bnergy aensity Criterion and b-value Analysis of Ab bvents qhe= preservation= of= mural= painting= heritage= is= a= complex= problem= that= requires= the= use= of= nonJdestructive=investigation=methodologies=to=assess=the=integrity=of=decorated=artworks=without=altering=their= state= of= conservationK= A= complete= diagnosis= of= crack= pattern= regarding= not= only= the= external=decorated=surface=but=also=the=internal=support= is=of=great= importance=due=to=the=criticality=of= internal=defects=and=damage=phenomenaI=which=may=suddenly=degenerate=into=irreversible=failures=xUI=VzK=A=great=deal=of=nonJdestructive=techniques=work=by=introducing=some=type=of=energy=into=the=system=to=be=analyzedK=ln=the=contraryI=in=Ab=testsI=the=input=is=the=mechanical=energy=release=generated=by=the=material=itself=during=the=damage=evolutionI=so=that=no=perturbation=is=induced=and=the=integrity=of=the=system=may=be= guaranteedK= By= monitoring= the= support= of= a= decorated= surface=by= means= of= the= Ab=techniqueI=it=becomes=possible=to=detect=the=occurrence=and=evolution=of=surface=vsK=support=separation=and=of=stressJinduced=cracksK=CrackingI=in=factI= is=accompanied=by=the=emission=of=elastic=wavesI=which=propagate=through=the=bulk=of=the=materialK=qhese=waves=can=be=received=and=recorded=by=piezoelectric=EmwqF=transducers=applied=to=the=external=surface=of=the=artwork=supportK=lbjective= of= the= research= is= to= use= the= Ab= technique= to= assess= the= support= of= the= decorated= mural=surfaces=developing= the=application=aspects=of= this= techniqueI= which=has=been=widely=studied=from=a=theoretical= and= experimental= point= of= view= by= the= authors= in= the= safeguard= of= civil= and= historical=buildings =xNMJNOzK =fn =a =first =stageI =it =will =be =essential =to =recognize =the =artwork =to =be =monitoredI =its =conservation=state=and=the=severity=of=its=conditions=at=the=beginning=of=the=monitoring=and=restoration=processesK=qhe=Ab=technique=makes=it=also=possible=to=predict=and=localize=the=presence=of=cracks=and=analyze=the=damage=evolution=in=supports=such=as=decorated=masonry=walls=and=vaults=xNPzK=Acoustic=bmission=data=have=been=interpreted=by=means=of=statistical=and=fractal=analysisI=considering=the=multiscale=aspect= of=cracking=phenomena= x4zK= ConsequentlyI= a= multiscale=criterion= to=predict= the=damage= evolution= has= been= formulatedK= oecent= developments= in= fragmentation= theories= xN4zI= have=

Page 4: lrpfbMfppfllflofd lccobplpabdoaflfusff brov ... · OPN= jtrolog=osear=EfkofjF====auth=o==p=k=ose===pcre= junta==salloK=qhi=ra==ss=t=t=mployme=o=J=onitori= methodologie==ge==pre=m=ssessmen==stori=I=decorate=rface=n=

=

OP4P=

shown=that= the=energy=t=during=microcrack=propagation=is=released=over=a=fractal=domain=comprised=between=a=surface=and=the=specimen=volume=sK=qhe=following=sizeJscaling=law=has=been=assumed=during=the=damage=processW== t ∞=N ∞=s aLP= ENF

=fn= bqKENF= a= is= the= soJcalled= fractal= exponent= comprised= between= O= and= PI= and= N= is= the= cumulative=number=of=Ab=events=that=the=structure=provides=during=the=damage=monitoringK=qhe=authors=have=also=shown=that= energy=dissipationI= as=measured=with= the=Ab= technique=during= the=damaging=processI=follows=the=timeJscaling=law=xNRzW==

= t ∞=N ∞=t=βt= EOF =where=βt=is=the=timeJscaling=exponent=for=the=released=energy=in=the=range=EMI=PF=and=N the=number=of=Ab=eventsK==By= working=out= the= exponent= βt= from=the= data= obtained= during= the=observation=periodI= we=can=make=a=prediction= on= the= structure∞s= stability= conditionsW= if= βt= Y= N= the= structure= evolves= toward= stability=conditionsX=if=βt ≈=N=the=process=is=metastableX=if=βt=[=N=the=process=becomes=unstableK=joreoverI= a= statistical= interpretation=to= the=variation= of= the= bJvalue=during= the=evolution=of=damage=detected=by=Ab= has=been=proposedI= which= is= based= on=a= treatment= originally=proposed=by=Carpinteri=and=coJworkers= xNSI=NTzK=qhe=proposed=model=captures= the= transition=from=the=condition=of=diffused=criticality=to=that=of=imminent=failure=localisationK=By=analogy=with=seismic=phenomenaI=in=the=Ab=technique=the=magnitude=may=be=defined=as=followsW=== m=Z=iogNM Amax=H=fErF= EPF==where=Amax=is=the=amplitude=of=the=signal=expressed=in=voltsI=and=fErF=is=a=correction=taking=into=account=that=the=amplitude=is=a=decreasing=function=of=the=distance=r=between=the=source=and=the=sensorK=fn=seismology=the=empirical=dutenbergJoichter∞s=law=xNUzW== iogNM N (≥=mF=Z=a – bm ===or=====N (≥=mF=Z=NM=a – bm E4F==expresses=the=relationship=between=magnitude=and=total=number=of=earthquakes=in=any=given=region=and=time=periodI=and=it=is=one=of=the=most=widely=used=statistical=relations=to=describe=the=scaling=properties=of=seismicityK= fn=bqK= E4FI= N= is= the=cumulative=number=of=earthquakes=with=magnitude=³=m= in =a =given=area=and=within=a=specific=time=rangeI=whilst=a and=b=are=positive=constants=varying=from=a=region=to=another=and=from=a=time=interval=to=anotherK=bquation=E4F=has=been=used=successfully=in=the=Ab=field=to=study= the= scaling= laws= of= Ab= wave= amplitude= distributionK= qhis= approach= evidences= the= similarity=between= structural=damage=phenomena=and=seismic=activities= in=a=given=region=of= the=barth∞s= crustI=extending=the=applicability=of=the=dutenbergJoichter∞s=law=to=ptructural=bngineeringK=According=to=bqK=E4FI= the= bJvalue= changes= systematically= at= different= times= in= the= course= of= the= damage= process= and=therefore=can=be=used=to=estimate=damage=evolution=modalitiesK=bquation=E4F=can=be=rewritten=in=order=to=draw=a=connection=between=the=magnitude=m=and=the=size=i=of=the=defect=associated=with=a=Ab=eventK=By=analogy=with=seismic=phenomenaI=the=Ab=crack=sizeJscaling=entails=the=validity=of=the=relationshipW=== N (≥=iF=Z=ci=–Ob ERF==where= N= is =the =cumulative =number =of =Ab =events =generated =by =source =defects =with =a =characteristic =linear= dimension=≥=iI=c= is =a =constant =of =proportionalityI =and =Ob Z=a= is= the= fractal=dimension= of= the=damage=domainK==ft= has=been=evidenced=that= this= interpretation=rests=on= the=assumption=of= a=dislocation=model= for= the=seismic= source= and= requires= that= OKM= ≤= a= ≤= PKMI= iKeKI= the= cracks= are= distributed= in= a= fractal= domain=comprised=between=a=surface=and=the=volume=of=the=analysed=region=xNVI=OMzK=qhe= cumulative= distribution= ERF= is= substantially= identical= to= the= cumulative=distribution=proposed=by=Carpinteri=xNSzI=which=gives=the=probability=of=a=defect=with=size=≥=i=being=present=in=a=bodyW=

Page 5: lrpfbMfppfllflofd lccobplpabdoaflfusff brov ... · OPN= jtrolog=osear=EfkofjF====auth=o==p=k=ose===pcre= junta==salloK=qhi=ra==ss=t=t=mployme=o=J=onitori= methodologie==ge==pre=m=ssessmen==stori=I=decorate=rface=n=

=

OP44=

m (≥=iF=∞=i=–γ ESF==qhereforeI=the=number=of=defects=with=size=³=i=isW== NG(≥=iF=Z=ci=–γ ETF==where= g= is= a= statistical= exponent= measuring= the= degree=of= disorderI= iKeK= the= scatter= in= the=defect= size=distributionI= and= c= is= a= constant= of= proportionalityK= By=equating=distributions= ERF=and= ETF= it= is= found=thatW=Ob Z=γK=At=the=collapseI=the=size=of=the=maximum=defect=is=proportional=to=the=characteristic=size=of=the =structureK =As =shown =by =Carpinteri =and =coJworkers =xNTzI =the =related =cumulative =defect =size =distribution=Ereferred=to=as=selfJsimilarity=distributionF=is=characterized=by=the=exponent=γ Z=OKMI=which=corresponds=to=b Z=NKMK=ft=was=also=demonstrated=by=Carpinteri=xNSz=that=γ Z=OKM=is=a=lower=bound=which=corresponds=to=the=minimum=value=b Z=NKMI=observed=experimentally=when=the=load=bearing=capacity=of=a=structural=member=has=been=exhaustedK=qhereforeI= by= determining= the= bJvalue= it= is= possible= to= identify= the= energy= release= modalities= in=a=structural=element=during=the=monitoring=processK=qhe=extreme=cases= envisaged=by=bqK= ENF=are=a Z=PKMI=which=corresponds=to=the=critical=conditions=b Z=NKRI=when=the=energy=release=takes=place=through=small=defects=homogeneously=distributed=throughout= the=volumeI=and=a Z=OKMI=which=corresponds= to=b Z=NKMI=when=energy=release=takes=place=on=a=fracture=surfaceK=fn=the=former=case=diffused=damage=is=observedI= whereas= in= the= latter= twoJdimensional= cracks= are= formed= leading= to= the= separation= of= the=structural=elementK=fn=the=followingI=the=data=obtained=from=the=monitoring=are=mainly=interpreted=by=bquation=EOF=and=E4FK=

=PKOK ptructural Condition Assessment of the Chapel usff As=regards=the=structural=integrityI=the=Chapel=usff=shows=a=vertical=crack=of=about=PKMM=m=in=length=and=a= detachment= of= frescos=both=on= the=korth= wallI= which=are= the= object= of= the=present= monitoring=campaign= by= means= of= AbK= pix= Ab= sensors= are= employed= to= monitor= the= damage= evolution= of= the=structural=support=of=the=decorated=surfaces=of=the=Chapel=usffW=four=are=positioned=around=the=vertical=crack=while=O=are=positioned=near=the=frescos=detachment=EcigKPFK=cor=the=sensor=pasting=on=decorated=surfacesI=a=suitable=methodology=is=appliedK=joreoverI=the=Chapel=usff=shows=another=vertical=crack=on=the=pouth=wallI=symmetric=of=the=previous=one=with=respect=to=the=pronao=of=the=buildingK=

=

=

cigK P=Chapel=usffW=siew=of=the=jonitored=aamages=and=mosition=of=the=Ab=pensors==

qhe=monitoring=period=of=the=structural=supports=of=the=chapel=began=on=April=OUI=OMNN=and=ended=on=gune=4I=OMNNK=qhe=results=obtained=by=the=application=of=the=Ab=sensors=are=presented=in=cigsK=4=and=RK=

Page 6: lrpfbMfppfllflofd lccobplpabdoaflfusff brov ... · OPN= jtrolog=osear=EfkofjF====auth=o==p=k=ose===pcre= junta==salloK=qhi=ra==ss=t=t=mployme=o=J=onitori= methodologie==ge==pre=m=ssessmen==stori=I=decorate=rface=n=

=

OP4R=

=

cigK Q=Chapel=usffW=Ab=from=sertical=Crack=jonitoring==

As =can =be =seen =from =cigK =4I =the =vertical =crack =monitored =on =the =korth =wall =of =the =chapel =presents =a=stable=condition=during=the=acquisition=period=EMKR=Y=βt=Y=NKMF=and=a=clear= distribution=of=cracks= in=a=surface=domain=is=proved=by=the=bJvalue=in=the=range=EMKVRI=NKNMFK=qhe=evidence=for=the=presence=of=a =large =crack =is =offered =by =the =low =frequency =signals =registered =EY =OMM =kezFW =as =a =matter =of =factsI =considering=the=velocity=as=a= constant= and=applying=the=iamb= ratio=xONzI= the=wavelength=needs= to=be=larger= than= that= of= the= maximum= inhomogeneity= in= order= for= the= wave= to= pass= through= without=significant=modifications=in=its=waveformK=ft=is=reasonable=to=assume=that=for=a=high=frequency=wave=it=is=possible=only=to=propagate=through=a=small=inhomogeneityX=on=the=contrary=for=a=low=frequency=wave=it=is=possible=also=to=propagate=through=a=large=inhomogeneity=x4IOOzK=

=

=

cigK R=Chapel=usffW=Ab=from=crescos=aetachment=jonitoring==Concerning=the=monitored=frescos=detachment=EcigK=RFI=the=decorated=surface=tends=to=evolve=towards=metastable=conditions= EMKR=Y=βt=Y= NKUF=and= the= signals= acquired= show= high= frequency=characteristics=EY=4MM=kezFW=therefore=a=distribution=of=microcracks=in=fractal=domain=near=to=a=volume=is=assumed=for=the=analysed=regionK=

Page 7: lrpfbMfppfllflofd lccobplpabdoaflfusff brov ... · OPN= jtrolog=osear=EfkofjF====auth=o==p=k=ose===pcre= junta==salloK=qhi=ra==ss=t=t=mployme=o=J=onitori= methodologie==ge==pre=m=ssessmen==stori=I=decorate=rface=n=

=

OP4S=

joreoverI= a= correlation= between= the= specific= analysed= Ab= activity= and= damage= of= the= decorated=surface=could=also=be=found= with=respect= to=different= water= cycle=stages= EeKgK= immersionI= drying=and=coolingFK=As=a=matter=of=factI=a=mortar=specimen=was=monitored=by=means=of=Ab=during=SM=minutes=of=immersion= in= mineral= water= EcigK= SaFK= qhe= relevant= Ab= activity= recorded= is= due= to= the= effect= of= salt=crystallization=and=to=the=specific=pore=distribution=in=the=mortar=bulk=xOPzK=ft=is=worth=noting=that=the=evolution=of= the=cumulated=Ab= resembles= the=kinetics=of= the=capillary=rising= in= the=transient= regime=EcigK=SbFI=underlying=how=the=two=phenomena=are=correlatedK=

=

= ==

= EaF= EbF=

cigK S=Cumulated=kumber=of=Ab=bvents=during=jortar=fmmersion=in=jineral=tater=EaFX=dimensionless=diagram=of= the= capillary= risingK= bach= curve= refers= to= the= dimensionless= quantity= α= which= is= function= of= the= sample= === thicknessI=sorptivity=and=potential=evaporation=of=the=microenvironoment=xO4z=EbF=

=

== === EaF= EbF=

cigK T=cinite=blement=mesh=EaFX=mrincipal=tensile=stress=contour=on=the=deformed=mesh=EbF==QK cfNfTb bibMbNT MlabiifNd =qhe= chapel= was= discretized= exploiting= symmetry= with= threeJdimensional= linear= pyramid= elementsI=accounting=for= the=accurate=geometry=of=the=stone=masonry=structureK=ln=the=contraryI= the=wooden=roof=structure=was= considered=only=as=an=external= loadK=qhe=mesh=of= the=structure=is=shown= in=cigK= TaK=qhe=elastic=properties=assumed=for=the=masonryI=and=the=densityI=where=respectively=equal=toW=b Z=Ob=H=V=maX=n Z=MKPX=r Z=OMMM=kgLmPK=qhe=elastic=analysis=allows=for=a=preliminary=assessment=of=the=structureK=cigK=Tb=shows= the=contour= of= the=principal= tensile=stressI=reported=on=the=deformed=shape=of= the=structureK=qhe=deformation=clearly=shows=the=opening=mechanism=due=to=the=effect=of=the=pronaoI=as=well=as=to=the=thrust=of= the= internal= vault= that= support= the= mount= qabor= installationK= qhe= tensile= stresses= calculated= on= the=internal=wall=of=the=chapelI=justify=the=presence=of=the=two=symmetric=dominant=cracksK=A=more=detailed=mechanical=characterization=of= the=masonry=is= currently=under= development= to=perform=the=subsequent=nonlinear=analysisK=

Page 8: lrpfbMfppfllflofd lccobplpabdoaflfusff brov ... · OPN= jtrolog=osear=EfkofjF====auth=o==p=k=ose===pcre= junta==salloK=qhi=ra==ss=t=t=mployme=o=J=onitori= methodologie==ge==pre=m=ssessmen==stori=I=decorate=rface=n=

=

OP4T=

RK ClNCirpflNp =qhe=Chapel=number=NTI=dedicated=to=the=jount=qabor=episode=of=Christ=qransfigurationI=of=the=pacred=jountain=of=sarallo=shows=some=structural=concern=due=to=cracking=and=some=degradation=of=the=high=valuable=frescosI=which=tend=to=detach=from=the=masonry=supportK=fn=order= to=assess= the= evolution=of= the=phenomenaI= the=results= of= the=Acoustic=bmission=monitoring=program=of=the=Chapel=have=been=providedI=together=with=a=structural=finite=element=simulationK=qhe=cinite=blement= analysis= provided= the=basic= mechanism=that= is= taking=place= in= the=chapelI= which=caused=two=main=cracks=in=the=internal=wallsK=qhe=results=of=the=monitoring=show=that=the=large=cracks=are=stableI=while=the=process=of=detachment=of=the=frescos=is=evolving=cyclicallyK=ft=seems=that=the=frescos=degradation=could=be=mainly=related=to=the=diffusion= of= moisture= in= the= mortar= substrateK= pome= preliminary= laboratory= tests= also= confirm= that=Acoustic=bmissions=are=recorded=in=mortar=samples=subjected=to=moisture=diffusionK==AChNltibadbMbNTp =qhe=financial=support=provided=by=the=miedmont=oegion=EftalyF=to=the=mroject=‘‘mreservationI=pafeguard=and= salorisation= of= jasonry= aecorations= in= the= Architectural= eistorical= eeritage= of= miedmont”= =EobJcobpClpF=is=gratefully=acknowledgedK== obcbobNCbp xNz oegione=miemonteK=aeterminazione=airigenziale=kKNRNI=T=agosto=OMMVK xOz ae =cilippis =bKI =qulliani =gKjKI =pandrone =oKI =pcarzella =mKI =malmero =mKI =iombardi =pertorio =CKI =

werbinatti=jK=EOMMRF=Analisi=degli=intonaci=della=Cappella=del=Calvario=al=pacro=jonte=di=saralloK=Aohlp=NOWPUJ4RK=

xPz drosse=CKrKI=lhtsu=jK=EOMMUF=Acoustic bmission TestingK=ppringerI=eeidelbergK=x4z Carpinteri= AKI= iacidogna= dKI= mugno= kK= EOMMTF= ptructural= damage= and= lifeJtime= assessment= by=

Acoustic=bmission=monitoringK=bngineering cracture Mechanics T4W=OTPJOUVK=xRz Carpinteri=AKI=iacidogna=dKI=muzzi=pK= EOMMVF=crom=criticality=to=final=collapseW=bvolution=of=the=

bJvalue=from=NKR=to=NKMK=ChaosI politons and cractals=4NW=U4PJURPK=xSz ae=cilippis=bK=EOMMVF=pacro Monte of saralloK=BorgosesiaK xTz Alessi=dK=ENVT4F=iibro dei MisteriK Anastatic=CopyK=BolognaK xUz Anzani=AKI=Binda=iKI=Carpinteri=AKI=iacidogna=dKI=januello=AK=EOMMUF=bvaluation=of=the=repair=on=

multiple=leaf=stone=masonry=by=acoustic=emissionK=Materials and ptructures=4NW=NNSVJNNUVK=xVz Carpinteri= AKI= fnvernizzi=pKI= iacidogna= dK= EOMMVF=eistorical=brickJmasonry= subjected=to=double=

flatJjack= testW= Acoustic= emissions= and= scale= effects= on= cracking= densityK= Construction and Building Materials=OPW=OUNPJOUOMK=

xNMz Anzani=AKI=Binda=iKI=Carpinteri=AKI=fnvernizzi=pKI=iacidogna=dK=EOMNMF=A=multilevel=approach=for=the=damage=assessment=of=historic=masonry=towersK=gournal of Cultural eeritage=NNW4RVJ4TMK=

xNNz Carpinteri=AKI=fnvernizzi=pKI=iacidogna=dKI=januello=AKI=Binda=iK=EOMMUF=ptability=of=the=vertical=bearing=structures=of= the=pyracuse=CathedralW= experimental=and=numerical=evaluationK= Materials and ptructures=4OETFW=UTTJUUUK=

xNOz fnvernizzi= pKI= iacidogna= dKI= januello= AKI= Carpinteri= AK= EOMNNF= Ab= monitoring= and= numerical=simulation=of=a=OJspan=model=masonry=arch=bridge=subjected=to=pier=scourK=ptrain=4TEOFW=NRUJNSVK=

xNPz Carpinteri= AKI= fnvernizzi= pKI= iacidogna= dK= EOMMTF= ptructural= assessment= of= a= usff= Century=masonry= vault= with= Ab= and= numerical= techniquesK= fnternational gournal of Architectural eeritage=NEOFW=ON4JOOSK=

xN4z Carpinteri= AKI= mugno= kK= EOMMOF= cractal= fragmentation= theory= for= shape= effects= of= quasiJbrittle=materials=in=compressionK=Magazine of Concrete oesearch=R4W=4TPJ4UMK=

xNRz Carpinteri= AKI= iacidogna= dKI= mugno=kK= EOMMTF= qimeJscale= effects= on= acoustic= emission= due= to=elastic=waves=propagation=in=monitored=cracking=structuresK=mhysical Mesomechanics UW=TTJUMK=

xNSz Carpinteri= AK= ENVV4F= pcaling= laws= and= renormalization= groups= for= strength= and= toughness= of=disordered=materialsK=fnternational gournal of polids and ptructures=PNW=OVNJPMOK=

xNTz Carpinteri= AKI= iacidogna= dKI= kiccolini= dKI= muzzi=pK= EOMMUF= Critical= defect= size= distributions= in=concrete=structures=detected=by=the=acoustic=emission=techniqueK=Meccanica=4PW=P4VJPSPK=

Page 9: lrpfbMfppfllflofd lccobplpabdoaflfusff brov ... · OPN= jtrolog=osear=EfkofjF====auth=o==p=k=ose===pcre= junta==salloK=qhi=ra==ss=t=t=mployme=o=J=onitori= methodologie==ge==pre=m=ssessmen==stori=I=decorate=rface=n=

=

OP4U=

xNUz oichter=CKcK=ENVRUF=blementary peismologyK=tKeK=creemanI=pan=crancisco=and=iondon=xNVz oundle= gKBKI= qurcotte= aKiKI= phcherbakov= oKI= hlein= tKI= pammis= CK= EOMMPF= ptatistical= physics=

approach= to= understanding= the= multiscale= dynamics= of= earthquake= fault= systemsK= oeviews of deophysics=4NW=NJPMK=

xOMz qurcotte= aKiK= ENVVTF= cractals and Chaos in deology and deophysicsK= Cambridge= rniversity=mressI=kew=vorkK=

xONz iamb=eK=ENVNTF=ln=waves=in=an=elastic=plateK=mrocK oK pocK AK=VPW=NN4JNOUK=xOOz iandis= bKkKI= phah= pKmK= ENVVRF= crequencyJdependent= stress= wave= attenuation= in= cementJbased=

materialsK=gournal of bngineering Mechanics=NONW=TPTJT4PK=

xOPz drossi= CKjKI= bsbert= oKjKI= puarez= del= oio= iKjKI= jontoto= jKI= iaurenziJqabasso= jK= ENVVTF=Acoustic= bmission= monitoring= to= study= sodium= sulphate= crystallization= in= monumental= porous=carbonate=stonesK=ptudies in Conservation 4OW=NNRJNORK=

xO4z eall=CKI=eoff=tKaK= EOMMTF=oising=dampW=Capillary=rise=dynamics= in=wallsK= mrocK oK pocK A=4SPW=NUTNJNUU4K=