Ludlam Hirschoff Statement for May 11 2011 Hearing of HFAC Peace Corps

8/6/2019 Ludlam Hirschoff Statement for May 11 2011 Hearing of HFAC Peace Corps

1/37

7

Zuguflfau bhJcvj` Dvedgl gae _gvdg Cmyzjcbhh7

Yfuvyafe _fgjf Jbypz Xbdvauffyz #Afpgd$ @fa}g$ Zfafkgd-Yfkgyemak _fgjf Jbypz Yfhbyl

Zvilmuufe ub ucf Cbvzf Hbyfmka Ghhgmyz Jbllmuuff

Lg} 77$ 9?77

Mauybevjumba gae Bxfyxmf{

[cfa {f cfgye cb{ @guf _v~f}$ g Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fy$ {gz lvyefyfe i} _fgjf Jbypzzughh ma Ifama$ {f kymfxfe ivu {fyf abu zvypymzfe! [cfa {f cfgye cb{ Nfzz Zlbjcf` {gz uyfgufei} ucf _fgjf Jbypz ghufy zcf {gz ygpfe ma Igakdgefzc$ {f {fyf emzuyfzzfe ivu abu zvypymzfe!Bvy zuguflfau {mdd fspdgma {c} ucfzf zubymfz gyf ybbufe ma _fgjf Jbypz jvduvyf$ pbdmjmfz gaepygjumjfz gae gyf abu mzbdgufe majmefauz!

[f dbxfe zfyxmak gz Xbdvauffyz ma ucf 7=8?z gae gkgma hybl 9??6 ub +?;! Bxfy lbyf ucga 5?

}fgyz {f cgxf iffa pybve bh bvy zfyxmjf gz Xbdvauffyz! Ma mlpbyugau {g}z$ _fgjf Jbypz cgzzcgpfe bvy dmxfz! [f gyf zumdd maxbdxfe {muc hymfaez ma @fa}g$ Afpgd$ gae Zfafkgd$ ucf jbvauymfz{cfyf {f zfyxfe! [f hffd g ibae {muc bucfy Xbdvauffyz! [f ucma` gae gju emhhfyfaud} ma ucf{byde gz g yfzvdu bh bvy _fgjf Jbypz fspfymfajfz! Gae ucf u{b bh vz lfu gu g _fgjf Jbypz

7Jvyymjvdvl Xmugf> Jcvj` Dvedgl gae _gvdg Cmyzjcbhh> Zfdfjufe i} Zfaguby Ebee ub ufzumh}ba ifcgdh bh 3$??? jvyyfau Xbdvauffyz ifhbyf Zfaguf Hbyfmka Yfdgumbaz Jbllmuuff baEbee"@faafe} _fgjf Jbypz Xbdvauffy Flpb{fylfau Gju$ Z! ;:9 #_JXFG-$ Nvd} 9??;! Hdf{ mahybl Zfafkgd$ {cfyf {f {fyf zfyxmak gz Xbdvauffyz$ ub ufzumh}! Ma Nvaf 9??= pvidmzcfejblpyfcfazmxf 9?,pbmau _fgjf Jbypz yfhbyl pdga #_fgjfJbypz[m`m-! Hybl 9??3,pyfzfau$ dfgebppbafauz bh jglpgmka ub ebvidf _fgjf Jbypz Xbdvauffy jbypz gae bh pybpbzgd ub gvucbym~flbavlfau ub _fgjf Jbypz ba Agumbagd Lgdd! Jcvj` Dvedgl> U{mjf zfyxfe gz _fgjf JbypzXbdvauffy$ Afpgd #7=83,;?0 Gk Fsufazmba- gae {muc _gvdg ma Zfafkgd #9??6,?;0 Gkyb,Hbyfzuy}Fsufazmba-! Jb,hbvaefe Hymfaez bh Afpgd! Ma 9??= zfyxfe gz gexmzby ub Biglg"Imefa UygazmumbaUfgl hby _fgjf Jbypz! Ma 9??= gjumxf ma jyghumak pybxmzmba bh @faafe} Zfyxf Glfymjg Gju#9??=- gvucbym~mak Xbdvauffyz hby _ybzpfymu} pybkygl$ ga gdufyagumxf ub ucf _fgjf Jbypz! Bxfy5?,}fgy pfymbe zfyxfe gz zughh gae dfkgd jbvazfd ub xgymbvz Cbvzf gae Zfaguf Jbllmuuffz #7=86$7=8;$ 7=;6,;=$ 7=37,=:$ gae 9??7,?6- gae Jgyufy [cmuf Cbvzf #7=;=,37-0 uymgd guubyaf} guHfefygd Uygef Jbllmzzmba+z Ivyfgv bh Jbazvlfy _ybufjumba #7=;9,;6-0 gae Xmjf _yfzmefau gaepymajmpgd dbii}mzu hby ucf gzzbjmgumba yfpyfzfaumak 7??? hmylz bh imbufjcabdbk} maevzuy} #7==:,9??7-! Zugahbye Vamxfyzmu} #IG 7=8;- gae Vamxfyzmu} bh Lmjcmkga Dg{ Zjcbbd #NE$ 7=;9-!_gvdg Cmyzjcbhh> U{mjf zfyxfe gz Xbdvauffy$ @fa}g #7=83,;?0 Fevjgumba- gae {muc Jcvj` maZfafkgd #9??6,?;0 Zlgdd Faufypymzf Efxfdbplfau-! Zfyxfe ba ibgye bh Hymfaez bh @fa}g! Ebjfaugu Agumbagd Lvzfvl bh Ghymjga Gyu #7=3=,pyfzfau- gae ebjfau jcgmy #9??7?,77-! Jbddfkf Fakdmzcmazuyvjuby0 {ymufy"femuby$ jbakyfzzmbagd gmef$ nbvyagdmzu #7=8;,9??6-! Lgjgdfzufy Jbddfkf #IG7=88-0 Kfbykf [gzcmakuba Vamxfyzmu} #LG ma Gaucybpbdbk}$ 7==8-! Jbaugju mahbylgumba>Jcvj`!DvedglOklgmd!jbl$ _cmyzjcbhhOklgmd!jbl$ 5?9? Yfab Ybge A[$ [gzcmakuba$ E!J!9???3$ 9?9,:85,8?97! Emzjdbzvyf vaefy jdgvzf 9#k-#6- bh Cbvzf Yvdf SM> [f cgxf afxfyyfjfmxfe g Hfefygd kygau #by zvi,kygau- by jbauygju #by zvijbauygju-!


2/37


3/37

:

Mu hbddb{z ucgu bvy dfge yfhbyl pybpbzgd mz ub lgaeguf ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz fzugidmzc dmzufamaklfjcgamzlz ub fajbvygkf Xbdvauffyz ub bhhfy jbazuyvjumxf mapvu yfkgyemak zughh pfyhbylgajf gaepybkygl fhhfjumxfafzzba g jbahmefaumgd igzmz! Ucmz {mdd flpb{fy Xbdvauffyz ub yfhbyl ucf_fgjf Jbypzhybl ucf mazmef! Ma geemumba$ {f pybpbzf ub flpb{fy gppdmjgauz i} pvidmjm~maklfuymjz bhucf gkfaj}z pfyhbylgajf zb ucgu ucf} jga efufylmaf {cmjc _fgjf Jbypz pybkyglz

gyf {fdd lgagkfe! Ucmz {mdd pyfzzvyf ucf gkfaj} ub yfhbylhybl ucf bvuzmef! Hmagdd}$ {f pybpbzfub vumdm~f ucf vdumlguf majfaumxfxmkbybvz gae cfgduc} lgy`fu jblpfumumba ifu{ffa ucf _fgjfJbypz gae ucf af{d} gvucbym~fe Xbdvauffyz hby _ybzpfymu} pybkygl! [muc ucmz jblimagumba bhz}zuflz$ majfaumxfz gae pyfzzvyf$ {f cgxf cbpf ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz {mdd ifkma ub dmxf vp ub muzmjbamj yfpvugumba!

Dmzufamak Lfjcgamzlz Kvgygauffmak Jbahmefaumgdmu} gae _ybufjumba Gkgmazu Yfugdmgumba

Fagjulfau bh lgaegufz hby ucf _fgjf Jbypz ub fzugidmzc dmzufamak lfjcgamzlz mz bvy hmyzu lgnbyyfjbllfaegumba! Mh ucf Xbdvauffyz gyf flpb{fyfe ub zpfg` bvu ba g jbahmefaumgd igzmz {mucbvuhfgy bh yfugdmgumba$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz {mdd hgjf fhhfjumxf maufyagd pyfzzvyf ub yfhbyl!

Ucf vykfau affe hby ucmz yfhbyl {gz maufazmhmfe i} ucf lvyefy bh _fgjf Jbypz Xbdvauffy gae{cmzudf idb{fy @guf _v~f} ma Ifama i} g _fgjf Jbypz zughh lflify {cb zcf cge yfpbyufe {gzygpmak zuvefauz gu cfy zjcbbd! @guf ifkkfe ucgu cfy mefaumu} gz g {cmzudf idb{fy if cfde majbahmefajf! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz zughh idf{ cfy jbxfy gae hgmdfe ub {gya cfy ucgu zcf {gz manfbpgye}! Gz g hbyfzffgidf jbazfwvfajf$ ucf gjjvzfe zughhfy lvyefyfe @guf!

Mu gppfgyz ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz eme abu yfhfy ucf jgzf ub ucf Hfefygd Ivyfgv bh Maxfzumkgumba ubefufylmaf {cfucfy ucf Jbvauy} Emyfjuby zcbvde if maemjufe hby xmbdgumak @gufz jmxmd ymkcuz!9

U{b }fgyz ifhbyf cfy lvyefy ma 9??;$ Zfagubyz Jcymz Ebee gae Ufe @faafe} mauybevjfedfkmzdgumba lgaegumak ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz kvgygauff jbahmefaumgdmu} hby Xbdvauffy {cmzudfidb{fyz gae pybufju ucfl gkgmazu yfugdmgumba! Ma Nvd} 9??; {cmdf zfyxmak gz Xbdvauffyz ma [fzuGhymjg$ {f hdf{ ub [gzcmakuba ub ufzumh} ifhbyf ucf Zfaguf Hbyfmka Yfdgumbaz Jbllmuuff ma hgxbybh ucf Ebee"@faafe} imdd pybufjumbaz! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz bppbzfe ucgu dfkmzdgumba! Mu emzpgygkfeucf mefg ucgu ucfyf {gz ga}ucmak iyb`fa ma ucf _fgjf Jbypz! Ucf Agumbagd _fgjf JbypzGzzbjmgumba gdzb bppbzfe ucf dfkmzdgumba! Ucfa ma Lgyjc 9??= @guf {gz lvyefyfe!

[bvde ucf Ebee"@faafe} imdd pybufjumbaz cgxf zgxfe cfy dmhf2 Mu+z g cgvaumak wvfzumba! [f jgau

gaz{fy g c}pbucfumjgd$ ivu mu gppfgyz ucgu ucf gjumbaz gae pbdmjmfz bh _fgjf Jbypz Cfgewvgyufyz{fyfnvzu gz jvdpgidf gz ucf gjumbaz gae pbdmjmfz ma Ifama! Ucf gkfaj}z yfdvjugajf ub dmzufa ubgae yfzpfju Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz zvjc gz @guf mz effpd} fauyfajcfe ma _fgjf Jbypz jvduvyf!Ucf pybidflz dfgemak ub cfy efguc gyf pgyu bh _fgjf Jbypz jvduvyf gae pbdmjmfz! Ucmz jgaabu ifemzlmzzfe gz ga mzbdgufe by vahbyfzffgidf fxfau!

[f hgmdfe @guf ifjgvzf {f {fyf abu ubvkc gae pfyzvgzmxf fabvkc ub efhfgu ucf bppbafauz bh ucfEbee"@faafe} imdd yfhbylz! [f hffd uybvidfe gae maemyfjud} yfzpbazmidf hby cfy efguc!

9 Zff Umudf 73$ V!Z!J!$ Zfjumba 957 #Jbazpmygj} Gkgmazu Ymkcuz- gae Umudf 73$ V!Z!J!$ Zfjumba959 #Efpymxgumba bh Ymkcuz Vaefy Jbdby bh Dg{-!


4/37

5

Ma Lgyjc 9?7?$ g }fgy ghufy@guf {gz lvyefyfe$ {f uymfe gkgma ub fagju pybufjumbaz hby Xbdvauffy{cmzudf idb{fyz$ ygmzmak ucfl gz glfaelfauz ub ucf 9??= Ebee _fgjf Jbypz Yfgvucbym~gumbadfkmzdgumba! Gkgma$ ucf gkfaj} gae A_JG bppbzfe gae `mddfe ucfl!

Ma Nvaf 9?7? ghufyZfaguby Ebee cge hbylgdd} yfwvfzufe ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz gzzfzzlfjcgamzlz ub zbdmjmu Xbdvauffyz+ xmf{z ba g jbahmefaumgd igzmz$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz hgmdfe ub eb zb!

Ba Ngavgy} 75$ 9?77$ ucf zglf eg} ucgu ucf 9?"9? fspbzf {gz iybgejgzu$ ucf _fgjf Jbypzpyblvdkgufe muz hmyzu yvdfz ub pybufju Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz! Ucf yvdfz gyf agyyb{$ jbahvzmak$gae jvlifyzblf! Ucf} hgdd hgy zcbyu bh ucf dmzufamak lfjcgamzlz gae pybufjumbaz ma ucf 9??;Ebee"@faafe} imdd!Guugjcfe mz bvy gagd}zmz cmkcdmkcumak 9: lgnby pybidflz {muc ucfzf yvdfz!

Ucf ibuubl dmaf mz ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz pvidmzcfe pbbyd} jyghufe yvdfz :: }fgyz ghufyucf yfzubh ucf kbxfyalfau jglf vaefy ucf Hfefygd [cmzudf Idb{fy Gju bh 7=;3! Ucmz mz gavajbazjmbagidf efdg} gae ucf {by` mz zcbee}!

Ucf umlmak bh ucf af{ _fgjf Jbypz yvdfz zvkkfzuz ucgu ucf} gyf efzmkafe ub emzjbvygkf ucfJbakyfzz hybl fagjumak yfhbyl dfkmzdgumba! Ivu {muc ucf mzzvgajf bh ucfzf yvdfz$ ucf _fgjf Jbypzcgz gj`ab{dfekfe ucgu Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz efzfyxf pybufjumba! Ucmz zufp zuyfakucfazgykvlfauz hby lgaegumak ucgu ucfzf pybufjumbaz ifjblf g pfylgafau pgyu bh _fgjf Jbypz jvduvyf!

Ucf _fgjf Jbypz cbzumdmu} ub Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz fspdgmaz {c} ucf jmyjvlzugajfz bh @guf_v~f}z efguc eb abu zvypymzf vz!

Mu mz umlf ab{hmagdd}ub fagju ucf Ebee"@faafe} pybpbzgdz ub fzugidmzc lfjcgamzlz {cfyfi}Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz jga zpfg` bvu ba g jbahmefaumgd igzmz gae if pybufjufe hyblyfugdmgumba!: [f zcbvde mkabyf _fgjf Jbypz zughh binfjumbaz ucgu gyf igzfe ba hfgyz bh {cgu ucfXbdvauffyz {mdd zg} gibvu ucfmy pfyhbylgajf! Ucmz pybpbzgd {bau iymak @guf igj` ivu mu {mdd

pybufju hvuvyf Xbdvauffyz!

Ucf Ebee"@faafe} dmzufamak lfjcgamzlz {bvde fazvyf ucgu Xbdvauffyz gyf cfgye {cfa ucf}yfxmf{ zughh pfyhbylgajf$ _fgjf Jbypz pbdmjmfz$ uygmamak$ zmuf pyfpgygumba$ gae efxfdbplfaupybkyglz! Ucf Xbdvauffyz `ab{ ifzu {cmjc zughh lflifyz gyf jblpfufau gae {cmjc pybkyglzgyf {by`mak! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz lvzu yfxfyzf jbvyzf gae cffe ucfmy jbllfauz! Ivu ucf} {ba+uzpfg` bvu mh ucf gkfaj} ebfzau kvgygauff ucfl jbahmefaumgdmu} gae pybufjumba gkgmazu yfugdmgumba!Mh Xbdvauffyz gyf flpb{fyfe ub zpfg` bvu$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz jga ifkma g pybjfzz hby jbaumavbvzyfaf{gd!

Bykgam~gumbaz ucgu yfzpfju ucfmy flpdb}ffz zfu vp ucfzf dmzufamak lfjcgamzlz! Ucf}yf jgddfe :8?efkyff yfxmf{z! Zvjc bykgam~gumbaz eb abu hfgy {cgu flpdb}ffz {mdd yfpbyu gibvu lgagkflfau!Jbazvlfyz ma lga} gyfgz cgxf ygumak lfjcgamzlz!Fsglpdfz gyf YgufL}Ufgjcfy!jbl$ Gakmfzdmzu$ gae Glg~ba!Ab{ muz umlf hby ucf Xbdvauffyz ub if kmxfa ucf lfgaz ub yguf ucfmy lgagkfyz!

: Ucfzf pybxmzmbaz gppfgy gz ga gppfaems ub ucmz zuguflfau!


5/37

6

Vadfzz Jbakyfzz yfwvmyfz mu ub eb zb$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz {mdd abu fzugidmzc fhhfjumxf lfjcgamzlz ubdmzufa ub Xbdvauffyz gae pybufju {cmzudf idb{fyz!

_ybhfzzmbagd gae Zfazmumxf _bdmjmfz hby Ygpf gae Zfsvgd Gzzgvduz

Mlpdflfaugumba bh g af{ gae pybhfzzmbagd zuygufk} ub pyfxfau gae lgagkf ygpf gae zfsvgdgzzgvduz mz bvy zfjbae lgnby yfjbllfaegumba ub yfxmugdm~f ucf _fgjf Jbypz! Ucf dmzufamaklfjcgamzlz gae pybufjumbaz hby {cmzudf idb{fyz gyf fzzfaumgd ma ucmz gyfg ubb! Ucf} {mdd fazvyfucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz dmzufaz ub Xbdvauffy xmf{z yfkgyemak muz pbdmjmfz gae pygjumjfz ba pyfxfaumakgae yfzpbaemak ub zfsvgd gzzgvduz gae ygpfz!

Ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz hgmdfe ub efxfdbp zfazmumxf$ pybhfzzmbagd pbdmjmfz gae pygjumjfz ub pyfxfauygpfz gae zfsvgd gzzgvduz gae ub hbddb{ lbefya pybjfevyfz ma jgymak hby ucf xmjumlz!Ucmz efdg} mz gdzb vajbazjmbagidf! Ucmz mz jbazmzufau {muc muz bxfyymemak hgmdvyf ub dmzufa ub gaeyfzpfju ucf Xbdvauffyz! Ucmz mz {c} ucf zubymfz bh _fgjf Jbypz ygpf gae gzzgvdu xmjumlz eb abuzvypymzf vz!

Majmefauz bh ygpf gae zfsvgd gzzgvdu ma ucf kfafygd pbpvdgumba gyf zvizugaumgdd} vaefyyfpbyufeifjgvzf {blfa hfgy ucgu ucf} {mdd if idglfe by eflfgafe! _fgjf Jbypz xmjumlz gyf fzpfjmgdd}yfdvjugau ub yfpbyu ucfzf jymlfz ifjgvzf ucf} cgxf zffa ucgu ucf zughh idglfz gae eflfgaz xmjumlzgae uymfz ub zfxfy jbaafjumbaz {muc ucfl gz zbba gz pbzzmidf! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz zcbvde ug`ffsufazmxf geemumbagd zufpz ub fazvyf ucgu zfsvgd gzzgvduz gae ygpfz gyf yfpbyufe$ ucgu Xbdvauffyzghfu} mz ucf gkfaj}z cmkcfzu pymbymu} gae ucgu ucf majmefauz gyf lgagkfe ub ucf cmkcfzu zugaegyez

bh pybhfzzmbagd jgyf! Zghf pygjumjfz majdvef ifuufy zfjvymu} hby Xbdvauffy dmxmak wvgyufyz! Ucf_fgjf Jbypz Mazpfjuby Kfafygd cgz hbvae ucgu 5?& bh ucf Xbdvauffyz cbvzfz eme abu lffu ucfP_fgjf Jbypz\pbzuz b{a jymufymg hby zghf cbvzmak5

Flpcgzmz ba Wvgdmu}$ abu Wvgaumu}$ gae Cbafzu Lfuymjz bh Gkfaj} _fyhbylgajf

Faemak ucf _fgjf Jbypz fspgazmba jglpgmka gae lgaegumak ucgu ucf gkfaj} ifjblf lbyfuygazpgyfau {muc BLI$ ucf Jbakyfzz$ gae ucf gppdmjgauz mz bvy ucmye lgnby yfjbllfaegumba ubyfxmugdm~f ucf _fgjf Jbypz! Gkgma$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz lvzu dmzufa ub ucf Xbdvauffyz$ {cb zvppbyuyfhbyl bxfy fspgazmba!

Vahbyuvagufd}$ ucf gkfaj}z cmkc pymbymu} bxfyucf efjgefz cgz iffa ub majyfgzf ucf avlify bhXbdvauffyz ma ucf hmfde! Ucmz fhhbyu cgz iffa dfe yfjfaud} i} ucf Lbyf _fgjf Jbypz jglpgmkazpbazbyfe i} ucf Agumbagd _fgjf Jbypz Gzzbjmgumba gae ucf _vzc hby _fgjf Jbypz jglpgmka!Ucmz mz g jdgzzmj fsglpdf bh hgxbymak wvgaumu} bxfy wvgdmu}! Kmxfa ucf pfyxgzmxf lmzlgagkflfau$geemumbagd Xbdvauffyz mz ucf dgzu ucmak ucmz uybvidfe gkfaj} affez! Ucf gkfaj}z b{a zvyxf} bh

Xbdvauffyz hbvae ucgu ucf} zvppbyufe yfhbyl bxfy fspgazmba i} g 6 ub 9 lgykma! Ivu$ bajf gkgma$ucfmy pbmau bh xmf{ {gz mkabyfe!

Ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz yfjfaud} geefe 7$??? Xbdvauffyz {byde{mef! Ucfzf geemumbagd Xbdvauffyz{fyf kfafygdd} geefe ub ucf {by`dbge bh fsmzumak zughh$ lga} bh {cbl cgxf iffa zuyfujcfe ub ucf

5 _J BMK Zflmgaavgd Yfpbyu ub Jbakyfzz #Gpymd 7$ 9??3 , Zfpuflify :?$ 9??3- gu 9?!


6/37

8

iyfg`mak pbmau! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz Mazpfjuby Kfafygd #MK- cgz hbvae ucgu ucf gkfaj} cgz abefhmamumba bh wvgdmu} zb mu jgaabu fxfa guuflpu ub lfgzvyf ucf mafxmugidf uygefbhhz ifu{ffawvgaumu} gae wvgdmu}! Ucf MK yfpbyufe ucgu _fgjf Jbypz zughh cge fspyfzzfe jbajfyaz gibvu gefjdmaf ma Xbdvauffy wvgdmu} gae zvmugimdmu} hby zfyxmjfgz #zughh- hgjf majyfgzmak pyfzzvyf ub

lffu gkfaj} kyb{uc ugykfuz! Mu hbvae ucgu zughh {fyf ifmak fajbvygkfe ub yfwvfzu db{fy,z`mddfe

uygmaffz

6

Gae ab{$ {muc ucf kbxfyalfauz lbxf ub{gye ivekfu gvzufymu}$ gdd bh ucf yfjfaufspgazmba lvzu if va{bvaeg lgagkflfau amkculgyf! Ucf fspgazmba gppfgyz ub cgxf iffa gemzgzuybvz lmzjgdjvdgumba! Mu cgz$ cb{fxfy$ zvjjffefe ma cfdpmak ub `mdd yfhbyl dfkmzdgumba gaezmdfajf ga} lfaumba bh ucf gkfaj}z pybidflz!

[f ifdmfxf ucgu bad} i} faemak ucf fspgazmba jglpgmka {mdd ucf _fgjf Jbypz if gidf ub hbjvzmaufaud} ba yfhbyl! [f ifdmfxf ucmz ifjgvzf cbafzu} gibvu ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz iffa ma zcbyuzvppd} evymak ucf fspgazmba jglpgmka! Ucmz jglpgmka yfzufe pgyud} ba g lmzdfgemak jdgml ucguucfyf gyf : gppdmjgauz hby fxfy} Xbdvauffy uygmamak zdbu! Gz yfjfaud} gz Hmzjgd 9??3$ =;& bh ucfgppdmjgauz {cb zvyxmxfe ucf lfemjgd zfdfjumba pybjfzz {fyf maxmufe ub uygmamak! Ma Hmzjgd 9??; mu{gz =8&! Zb ma ucbzf }fgyz lfemjgd hmuafzz {gz ucf igzmj jymufymba hby zfyxmjf! Ma bucfy {byez$

afgyd} fxfy}baf {cb mz jbazmefyfe lfemjgdd} hmu kfuz ub faufy uygmamak ub ifjblf g Xbdvauffy!Ucf zjgyjmu} bh nbiz pybigid} jbauymivufe ub g yfjfau zvykf ma gppdmjgauz {cb gyf fjbablmjyfhvkffz$ ivu ucf} gyf abu afjfzzgymd} {fdd lbumxgufe gae wvgdmhmfe ub zfyxf gz Xbdvauffyz!_fgjf Jbypz zughh lg} jblpdgma gibvu ucf Xbdvauffyz+ lbumxgumba gae zfazf bh yfzpbazmimdmu}$ ivuucf gkfaj} muzfdh cgz jcbzfa abu ub if zfdfjumxf gae ub fspgae efzpmuf ucf gizfajf bh g zvypdvz bh{fdd wvgdmhmfe gppdmjgauz!

Ucf fspgazmba jglpgmka cgz iffa pyflmzfe ba g zfjbae lmzdfge mak jdgml ucgu 9? jbvauymfz gyfzcbxfd,yfge} hby af{ by yfaf{fe _fgjf Jbypz pybkyglz! Gppgyfaud} ab zvjc dmzu fsmzuz! Ucf_fgjf Jbypz jbvde abu hmae baf ma yfzpbazf ub bvy HBMG yfwvfzu! Ucf Xbdvauffyz ma gu dfgzu geb~fa jbvauymfz zg} ucfmy pybkyglz zcbvde if zcvu eb{a$ ivu gkgma ucf _fgjf Jbypz ebfzau cffeucfmy pbmau bh xmf{!

Ma geemumba$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz cmefz ucf hgju ucgu :?,:6& bh Xbdvauffyz {byde{mef gyf ugd`mak {mucucfmy hffu gae wvmuumak fgyd}! Ma zblf jbvauymfz gae zblf pybkyglz ucf fgyd} wvmu yguf mz 5?&$8?&$ by vp ub 3;&! Bxfy ucf 9??6,?3 hmzjgd }fgyz$ :6 emhhfyfau jbvauymfz cge ga fgyd},wvmu yguf bh5?& by lbyf!8 Hmhuffa bh ucfzf jbvauymfz cgxf cge fgyd},wvmu ygufz kyfgufy ucga 5?& ma lvdumpdf

6 Hmagd _ybkygl Fxgdvgumba Yfpbyu> Hbddb{,Vp Fxgdvgumba bh ucf Xbdvauffy Efdmxfy} Z}zufl$_fgjf Jbypz Bhhmjf bh Mazpfjuby Kfafygd #Efjflify 9?7?- gu m! Bxfygdd ucf _J MK hbvae ucgu ucfgkfaj} cge abu mamumgufe by hvdd} jgyymfe bvu ucf MKz jblpyfcfazmxf yfjbllfaegumbaz bh

9??: hby mlpybxmak ucf efdmxfy} bh zfyxmjfz ub Xbdvauffyz!8 Ucf :6 jbvauymfz {muc fgyd},wvmu ygufz bh lbyf ucga 5?& majdvef> Gylfamg 59!9& #?6-0 Ifdm~f59!6& #?8-0 Ibuz{gag 5;!6& #?8-0 Ivy`mag Hgzb 56!6& #?6-$ 5?!:& #?8-$ gae 57!5& #?;-0Jglfybba 66!8& #?6-0 Jgpf Xfyef 55& #?6-0 Fgzufya Jgymiifga 55!5& #?8- gae 59!:& #?;-0Fjvgeby 55& #?8-0 Fucmbpmg 5;!5& #?3-0 Hmnm 6:!7& #?8-0 Kfbykmg 53!=& #?6-0 Kv}gag 6?& #?8-gae 59!5& #?;-0 Nglgmjg 56& #?6-$ 55!7& #?;-$ gae 53& #?3-0 Nbyega 6?& #?6-$ 6=!6& #?;-$gae 66!:& #?3-0 @g~g`czuga 69!6& #?6- gae 58!8& #?3-0 @fa}g 57!9& #?6-0 @mymigum 66!9?6-$ 6:!6& #?8-$ gae 38!;& #?;-0 @}yk}~zuga 68!7& #?6-$ 69!6& #?8-$ 67!8& #?;-$ gae 68!;?3-0 Lfsmjb 58!;& #?6-0 Lmjybafzmg 59!:& #?8- gae 55& #?3-0 Lbdebxg 58!9& #?6-$ 59!6&


7/37

;

}fgyz! Evymak ucmz yfpbyumak pfymbe$ ucfyf {fyf bad} zms jbvauymfz ucgu emeau fspfymfajf ga fgyd},wvmu yguf bh :?& by lbyf; gae abu g zmakdf jbvauy} ucgu lgmaugmafe ga fgyd} wvmu yguf bh dfzz ucga9?&! Zmajf 9??6 ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz iffa lgampvdgumak zugumzumjz zb mu jga jbajfgd ucmzfligyygzzmak mahbylgumba hybl BLI$ ucf Jbakyfzz$ ucf lfemg$ gae ucf gppdmjgauz! Bh jbvyzf$ ucfgppdmjgauz cgxf g xmugd maufyfzu ma `ab{mak mh ucf}xf iffa maxmufe ub g jbvauy} {muc g cmkc by db{

fgyd} wvmu yguf! [c} {bvde ga} gppdmjgau gjjfpu ga maxmugumba ub zfyxf ma g jbvauy} {muc ga fgyd}wvmu yguf bh lbyf ucga 9?&2 Cmkc fgyd} wvmu ygufz eflbygdm~f ucbzf {cb zug} ub jblpdfuf ucfmyzfyxmjf! Ucf} efzuyb} jbaumavmu} ifu{ffa Xbdvauffyz! Ucf} jbahvzf gae emzgppbmau ucfjbllvamumfz {cfyf ucf Xbdvauffyz zfyxf! Baf jga lg`f g zuybak jgzf ucgu ucf gkfaj} mzzwvgaefymak g pfyjfaugkf bh muz ivekfu ybvkcd} fwvgd ub ucf fgyd} wvmu yguf! Ucf gkfaj}zlmzyfpyfzfaugumba gibvu ucmz yguf lfgaz ucgu xmugd mahbylgumba mz abu vzfe ub ugykfu mlpybxflfauzma pybkyglz {muc ucf cmkcfzu wvmu yguf gae pbbyfzu lgagkflfau! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz egyfz abu gelmuucf uyvuc gibvu ucf fgyd} wvmu ygufz$ ifjgvzf mu {bvde yfxfgd ucgu ub fspgae$ mu lvzu hmyzu hmdd ucfzfxgjgufe zdbuzg jbzud} gae jbaumavbvz uyfgelmdd!

Ucf gkfaj} gdzb cmefz ucf hgju ucgu muz b{a zvyxf}z bh Xbdvauffyz ebjvlfau pfyxgzmxf lgdgmzf

gae lmzlgagkflfau! [f biugmafe g jbp} bh ucf jbvauy},i},jbvauy} yfzvduz hby ucf 9??3 zvyxf}hybl g zughh {cmzudf idb{fy! [f jyfgufe ga fsjfd zpyfge zcffu ucgu yga`z ucf jbvauymfz hybl ubp ubibuubl ba fgjc zvyxf} wvfzumba! Ucf zglf jbvauymfz dgae gu ucf ubp by ibuubl ba wvfzumba ghufywvfzumba! Ucfzf yfzvduz yfxfgdfe ucgu gibvu 76 jbvauymfz {fyf {fdd lgagkfe! Ucf Xbdvauffyz kmxflgykmagd by db{ ygumakz ub lga} Jbvauy} Emyfjubyz gae bucfy zughh gae ucf pybkyglz ub {cmjcucf} {fyf gzzmkafe! Ucf Jbvauy} Emyfjuby ma Ifama {cfa @guf {gz lvyefyfe yga`fe ma ucfibuubl 7? {byde{mef! Ucf zvyxf} egug ebxfugmdz {muc ucf fgyd} wvmu yguf egug> Ucf zglf jbvauymfzyga` db{ by cmkc! Ucf gkfaj} zfflz ub cgxf ab z}zufl ub vzf ucf zvyxf}z ub bxfycgvd ucf {byzu,lgagkfe pybkyglz!

Ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz yfhvzfe ub yfdfgzf ucf jbvauy},i},jbvauy} yfzvduz hby ucf 9??= gae 9?7? mayfzpbazf ub bvy HBMG yfwvfzuz! Mu efamfe vz gjjfzz ub ucmz mahbylgumba ifjgvzf ucf _fgjf Jbypz mzdbguc ub emxvdkf ucf jbvauy},i},jbvauy} gae pybkygl,i},pybkygl yfzvduz ub gppdmjgauz gz ucf}lmkcu yfhvzf ga maxmugumba ub zfyxf ma g db{,yga`fe jbvauy}! Gdzb$ {fyf ucmz mahbylgumba ubifjblf pvidmj$ mu {bvde if ubsmj ub ucf fspgazmba jglpgmka! Ucfzf gyf abu xgdme yfgzbaz hbyyfhvzmak ub jblpd} {muc HBMG by _yfzmefau Biglgz uygazpgyfaj} mamumgumxf! [f ifdmfxf {f cgxf

iffa zvjjfzzhvd ma yfjyvmumak g ubp dg{ hmyl ub zvf ucf _fgjf Jbypz ub jblpfd mu ub emxvdkf ucfjbvauy},i},jbvauy} yfzvduz vaefy HBMG!

[f yfjbllfae ucgu ucf Jbakyfzz jblpfd ucf _fgjf Jbypz ub yfxfgd ucf jbvauy},i},jbvauy} gaepybkygl,i},pybkygl fgyd},wvmu ygufz gae zvyxf} yfzvduz ub BLI$ ucf Jbakyfzz$ ucf pvidmj gae

#?;-$ gae 59!8& #?3-0 Lbakbdmg 57!;& #?;- gae 5:!=& #?3-0 Lbybjjb 53!6& #?6-0 Amkfy 57!5?8-0 Zglbg 6?& #?6- gae 68!:& #?;-0 Zbvuc Ghymjg 68!6& #?;-0 Zvyaglf ;:!;& #?6-$ 87!6?;-$ gae 5?& #?3-0 Z{g~mdgae 67!6& #?6- gae 5?!;& #?8-0 Ubkb 6:!6& #?;- gae 57!;& #?3-0Ubakg 6:!6& #?8- gae 56!6& #?3-0 Uvy`lfamzuga 5?!6& #?6- gae 53!6& #?8-0 Vkgaeg 55!7?6-0 V~if`mzuga 5:!3& #?6-0 Xgavguv 5:!7& #?6-0 gae ^glimg 5;& #?3-! Hmhuffa bh ucfzfjbvauymfz cgxf cge fgyd},wvmu ygufz kyfgufy ucga 5?& ma lvdumpdf }fgyz!; Ucf zms jbvauymfz ucgu eme abu fspfymfajf ga fgyd} wvmu yguf bh :?& by lbyf {fyf Jcmag$ Kvmafg$Lgjfebamg$ Amjgygkvg$ _fyv$ gae Yblgamg!


8/37

3

ucf gppdmjgauz! Mh ucf gppdmjgauz gyf flpb{fyfe ub if zfdfjumxf ma gjjfpumak ga maxmugumba ub zfyxf$ucf _fgjf Jbypz {mdd hgjf fhhfjumxf fsufyagd pyfzzvyf ub yfhbyl!3 Mh ucf _fgjf Jbypz hmaez muemhhmjvdu ub pfyzvgef gppdmjgauz ub zfyxf ma ucf {byzu lgagkfe pybkyglz ma jbvauymfz {muc ucfcmkcfzu fgyd} wvmu ygufz gae ucf {byzu zvyxf} yfzpbazfz$ mu {bvde hffd pyfzzvyf ub maufyxfaf ubhvaeglfaugdd} bxfycgvd by zcvuufy ucfzf pybkyglz! G pb{fyhvd majfaumxf hby yfhbyl!

Lbyf Flpcgzmz ba Hmyzu Kbgd

Bvy hbvyuc lgnby yfjbllfaegumba mz hby ucf Jbakyfzz ub lgaeguf ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz ug`f ucfHmyzu Kbgd lvjc lbyf zfymbvzd} gz ga fzzfaumgd fdflfau bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz lmzzmba! Gkgma$ ucf`f} pyfzzvyf {mdd jblf hybl dmzufamak ub Xbdvauffyz gibvu ucf pfyhbylgajf bh ucf lgagkfyz gaeucf fhhfjumxfafzz bh ucf pybkyglz ma {cmjc ucf} {by`!

Yfkgyemak muz Hmyzu Kbgd bh zvzugmagidf kygzzybbuz efxfdbplfau$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz hgmdz ubgj`ab{dfekf ucgu mu cgz hgddfa hgy zcbyu! Hby bxfy 6? }fgyz$ mu cgz cge ab fhhfjumxf z}zufl ubebjvlfau ucf Xbdvauffy pybnfjuz ucgu {by`fe gae ucbzf ucgu eme abu! Mu cgz lmamlgd z}zuflz ub

ebjvlfau Xbdvauffyz+ {by` ba g zmuf,i},zmuf igzmz by ub efxfdbp zuygufkmj pdgaz hby fgjc zmuf![cfa ucf Xbdvauffyz efxfdbp ga fhhfjumxf pybnfju$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz ab z}zufl hby ug`makucbzf pdgaz ub zjgdf! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz lg`fz fzzfaumgdd} ab vzf bh Ifzu _ygjumjf Kvmefz! Mu jbvdecgxf efxfdbpfe ucbvzgaez i} ab{ igzfe ba ucf fspfymfajfz bh 9??$??? yfuvyafe Xbdvauffyz!Ucgu mu hgmdfe ub eb mz ga myyfuymfxgidf {gzuf gae dbzz! Ma geemumba$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz abuvpegufe muz pcmdbzbpc} by zuygufk} hby efxfdbplfau gae ebfz abu pgyumjmpguf ma ucf maufyagumbagdefigufz gibvu ucf lbzu fhhfjumxf {g}z ub zpvy efxfdbplfau!

Ucf _fgjf Jbypz ebfz abu pybxmef zffe jgpmugd hby Xbdvauffy pybnfjuz! ]fu zvjc zffe jgpmugd mzzbyfd} affefe ub dgvajc eflbazuygumbaz! Cbzu jbvauy} agumbagdz gyf abu pfyzvgefe i} mefgz gaeugd`0 ucf} dfgya {cfa ucf} jga zff zblfucmak eflbazuygufe! Ucf dgj` bh zffe jgpmugd mz jymppdmakgae eflbygdm~mak! Gae ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz zfu vp ivyfgvjygumj yvdfz ucgu `ffp Xbdvauffyz hyblhvaeygmzmak ub zvppbyu ucfmy pybnfjuz! Ucf Ebee"@faafe} imdd gddbjgufz zffe jgpmugd ub Xbdvauffyzgae pfylmuz lbyf Xbdvauffy hvaeygmzmak!

Gz g yfzvdu bh ucfzf Hmyzu Kbgd hgmdvyfz$ af{ Xbdvauffyz vzvgdd} zugyu hybl zjygujc {muc dmuudfkvmegajf ba pybnfjuz gae zuygufkmfz ucgu ucf} lmkcu zff` ub mlpdflfau! _yfemjugid}$ lga} }bvakXbdvauffyz kfu hyvzuygufe gae wvmudmufygdd} by hmkvygumxfd}! Bh jbvyzf$ zblf maemxmevgdXbdvauffyz gjcmfxf zvizugaumgd zvjjfzzfz$ ivu ucf} bhufa zg} ucgu ucmz mz ma zpmuf bh$ abu ifjgvzf bhucf _fgjf Jbypz! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz+ hgmdvyfz gz g kygzzybbuz efxfdbplfau gkfaj} abu bad} cvyu ucfXbdvauffyz0 ucf} gdzb efpymxf ucf cbzu jbvauymfz bh ucf `mae bh gzzmzugajf ucf} efzpfygufd} affegae efzfyxf!

Ucf _fgjf Jbypz mz lbyf zvjjfzzhvd gu muz Zfjbae Kbgdjvduvygd fsjcgakf! Xbdvauffyz$ {cbbhufa zpfg` ucf dbjgd dgakvgkf gae dmxf gu ucf kygzzybbuz dfxfd$ gyf {baefyhvd jvduvygdgligzzgebyz hby ucf Vamufe Zugufz! Ivu ucf jbzu bh zblf %6?$??? pfy Xbdvauffy pfy }fgy mzfsjffemakd} fspfazmxf!

3 Ucfzf pybxmzmbaz gppfgy gz ga gppfaems ub ucmz zuguflfau!


9/37

=

Vpkygef Magefwvguf Gelmamzuygumxf Mahygzuyvjuvyf

Bvy zmsuc yfjbllfaegumba mz ucgu ucf Jbakyfzz lgaeguf ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz vpkygef muzmagefwvguf gelmamzuygumxf mahygzuyvjuvyf!

Ma muz ~fgd ub fspgae$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz mz abu ug`mak zufpz ub yfhbyl muz gaumwvgufe gelmamzuygumxfmahygzuyvjuvyf! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz lbyf pbdmumjgd gppbmauffz pfy jgpmug ucga ga} bucfy hfefygdgkfaj}! Hby efjgefz mu cgz iffa g evlpmak kybvae hby pbdmumjgd gppbmauffz! [f yfjbllfaejvuumak ucf avlify bh pbdmumjgd gppbmauffz gu ucf _fgjf Jbypz i} u{b,ucmyez! Ucf Jbvauy}Emyfjubyz lg`f by iyfg` ucf pybkyglz ucf} dfge! ]fu ucf zfdfjumba bh jbvauy} emyfjubyz mz abubykgam~fe ub fdmlmaguf hgxbymumzl igzfe ba pbdmumjgd jbaafjumbaz! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz MazpfjubyKfafygd mz abu gppbmaufe i} ucf _yfzmefau zb cf by zcf mz abu maefpfaefau bh ucf pbdmumjgdgppbmauffz! Gz g yfzvdu$ ucf dfge ma maxfzumkgumak jymlfz gkgmazu Xbdvauffyz {gz ug`fa g{g} hyblucf _fgjf Jbypz MK$ g lbxf efzmkafe ub lmamlm~f ucf ige pvidmjmu} ucgu {gz gymzmak hybl ucfMKz maxfzumkgumbaz bhucfzf jymlfz gae pybzfjvumbaz bh ucf pfypfuygubyz! Ucf hmxf,}fgy dmlmu baucf ufavyf bh _fgjf Jbypz zughh lfgaz ucgu ab baf zug}z xfy} dbak$ zb ucf gkfaj} cgz dmuudf

mazumuvumbagd lflby}! Zcbyu,ufyl jmxmd zfyxmjf zughh jgaabu zugae vp ub ucf pbdmumjgd gppbmauffz!Zughh uvyabxfy mz jbazugau gae jcgbumj! Ifjgvzf bh ucf hmxf,}fgy yvdf$ gkfaj} zughh eb abu cgxfjmxmd zfyxmjf ymkcuz! Ucf} gyf jbazmefyfe uflpbygy} flpdb}ffz {cb dgj` `f} ymkcuz bh bucfy

hfefygd flpdb}ffz! Ucf} jga if hmyfe gyimuygymd} gu ucf {cml bh g pbdmumjgd gppbmauff! Ucf} affeub if kmxfa {cmzudf idb{fy ymkcuz gae pybufjumbaz! Ucmz mz g {g} ub yfzpfju ucf _fgjf Jbypz zughh!

Ucf _fgjf Jbypz pymefz muzfdh ba abu cgxmak yvdfz ivu ucmz lfgaz ucgu {cfa mu pvidmzcfz

kvmegajf ucgu cgz ucf fhhfju bh yvdfz mu ebfz abu jblpd} {muc ucf Gelmamzuygumxf _ybjfevyf Gjugae pvidmzc pybpbzgdz hby pvidmj jbllfau! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz mz abu uygazpgyfau {muc gppdmjgauzgibvu ucf fgyd},wvmu yguf gae zvyxf} yfzpbazfz ma ucf jbvauy} ma {cmjc ucf} gyf maxmufe ub zfyxf![f cgxf pbzufe gexmjf ub gppdmjgauz ba _fgjfJbypz[m`m!byk$ ucf {fizmuf hby ma,efpuc gagd}zmz bh_fgjf Jbypz pbdmjmfz gae pfyhbylgajf$ zvkkfzumak {cgu ucf} zcbvde `ab{ ifhbyf efjmemak{cfucfy ub gjjfpu ga maxmugumba ub zfyxf! Gdzb$ ghufy ablmagumak ga gppdmjgau ub g zpfjmhmjpybkygl gae jbvauy}$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz gjuvgdd} maxmufz ucf gppdmjgau ub zfyxf ma g emhhfyfau

jbvauy} gae pybkygl gibvu 5?& bh ucf umlf0 gppdmjgauz gyf gddb{fe bad} 7? eg}z ub efjmef{cfucfy ub ug`f mu by dfgxf mu! Ucfzf z{mujcfz$ ebaf hby ucf jbaxfamfajf bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz$ gyfvahgmy ub ucf gppdmjgauz! Zvjc gelmamzuygumxf zcbyujblmakz pyfxfau ucf _fgjf Jbypz hybldmzufamak ub gae yfzpfjumak ucf Xbdvauffyz gae jmxmd zfyxmjf zughh!

Lgy`fu Jblpfumumba ub Zpvy _fgjf Jbypz Yfhbyl

Bvy hmagd yfjbllfaegumba mz hby ucf Jbakyfzz ub pvu ucf _fgjf Jbypz maub xmkbybvz gae cfgduc}jblpfumumba {muc ucf Xbdvauffyz hby _ybzpfymu} #Xh_- pybkygl! Fxfa mh Xbdvauffyz gyfflpb{fyfe ub zpfg` bvu gae gppdmjgauz gyf flpb{fyfe ub if zfdfjumxf$ {f ifdmfxf ucgu bad}ucybvkc maufazf lgy`fu jblpfumumba {mdd ucf _fgjf Jbypz ifjblf jbllmuufe ub yfhbyl!

Mu mz umlf ub gz` {cfucfy ucf _fgjf Jbypz lbefdga fspgazmxf$ ymz`,gxfyzf$ gae ymkmeivyfgvjygj}mz {by`gidf gu jvyyfau hvaemak dfxfdz! Ucf zjgaegd fspbzfe i} 9?"9? gae ucfHfefygd Ivekfu jymzmz gju ma z}afyk} ub ygmzfucf ymz` ucgu Jbakyfzz {mdd zmlpd} zdgzc ucf _fgjfJbypz ivekfu$ kfafygumak g afu yfevjumba ma pdgjflfauz! Cb{fxfy$ mh {f gju ibded}$ {f jga


10/37

7?

geeyfzz ucf zjgaegdz gae ucf ivekfu jymzmz ibuc gu bajf gae gjuvgdd} majyfgzf ucf avlify bh ucfzfpdgjflfauz hmxf ub zms,hbde!

Cge _fgjf Jbypz iffa dfzz bh g agumbagd mjba$ mu lmkcu cgxf fxbdxfe maub g efjfauygdm~fe pybkyglucgu pdgjfe Xbdvauffyz {muc AKBz! Ucmz mz cb{ XMZUG fxbdxfe maub GlfymJbypz ma 7==:!

XMZUG zumdd fsmzuz$ ivu mu mz e{gyhfe i} GlfymJbypz$ {cmjc cgz hgy lbyf xbdvauffyz! Jblpgyfe ubXMZUG$ GlfymJbypz cgz lmamlgd ivyfgvjygj} gae jbzu ifjgvzf mu jbaafjuz xbdvauffyz {mucAKBz {cb cgaedf zfdfjumba$ uygmamak$ pdgjflfau$ gae zvppbyu! Gz g yfzvdu$ afgyd} 8??$???GlfymJbypz xbdvauffyz cgxf ebaf eblfzumj zfyxmjf ma bad} 73 }fgyz zmajf ucf pybkygl {gzfzugidmzcfe!

Zmajf ucf _fgjf Jbypz {gz hbvaefe$ AKBz cgxf lvdumpdmfe maub ucf ucbvzgaez$ lga} dfe i} cbzujbvauy} agumbagdz! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz hgmdfe ub gz` cb{ ucmz lmkcu hvaeglfaugdd} gdufy ucf_fgjf Jbypz lbefd bh zfyxmjf!

Ucf Jbakyfzz mz {fdd g{gyf bh ucf GlfymJbypz lbefd gae cgz gdyfge} fagjufe ucf Xh_ pybkygl

hby maufyagumbagd zfyxmjf lbefdfe ba ucf eblfzumj pybkygl! Xh_ {gz gvucbym~fe gz pgyu bh ucf@faafe} Zfyxf Glfymjg Gju ma 9??=$ gducbvkc mu cgz iffa bpfygumak zmajf 9??:! Xh_ jbaafjuzGlfymjga xbdvauffyz {muc maufyagumbagd AKBz gu g hygjumba bh ucf jbzu pfy Xbdvauffy bh ucf _fgjfJbypz! Xh_ gppdmjgauz jga jcbbzf glbak cvaeyfez bh AKBz$ majdvemak ucbzf bpfygumak majbvauymfz ucgu cgxf ab _fgjf Jbypz pybkygl gae ucbzf {muc {by` gzzmkalfauz abu bhhfyfe i} ucf_fgjf Jbypz! Ifjgvzf Xh_ mz efjfauygdm~fe$ mu lmamlm~fz ucf pgyumjmpgauz+ fspbzvyf ub ufyybymzuguugj`!

[f pybpbzf ucgu bxfy g pfymbe bh : ub 5 }fgyz$ cgdhbh ucf _fgjf Jbypz ivekfu if gddbjgufe ubXh_!= Ucmz {bvde lfga ga gddbjgumba bh gibvu %9?? lmddmba ub ucf _fgjf Jbypz gae ucf zglf ubXh_! [muc muz cgdh$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz jbvde hmfde 5$??? Xbdvauffyz! [muc muz cgdh$ Xh_ jbvde hmfdevp ub 5?$??? xbdvauffyz! Ucvz$ i} ifuufy vumdm~mak ucf _fgjf Jbypz jvyyfau ivekfu$ {f jbvde zff ghmxf ub zms hbde majyfgzf ma ucf ubugd avlify bh maufyagumbagd xbdvaugy} pdgjflfauz!

Ucf _fgjf Jbypz lmkcu gykvf ucgu fgjc bh muz Xbdvauffy mz {byuc hmxf ub ufa umlfz lbyf ucga gXh_ xbdvauffy! Kmxfa ucf jvyyfau lmzlgagkflfau$ cb{fxfy$ mu jgaabu jyfemid} zvizugaumguf zvjcg jdgml!

= Ucf _fgjf Jbypz gppybpymgumba hby H] 9?7? {gz %5?? lmddmba! Vaefy ucf jvyyfau JbaumavmakYfzbdvumba hby H] 9?77$ muz gppybpymgumba {bvde if ucf zglf! Ucf Cbvzf H] 9?77 gppybpymgumbaimdd zfu muz gppybpymgumba gu %:5? lmddmba #H] ?3- dfxfd! Gzzvlmak ucgu _fgjf Jbypz mzgppybpymgufe %5?? hby jvyyfau hmzjgd }fgy$ {f yfjbllfae ucgu _fgjf Jbypz gvucbym~gumba if zfu gu%:6? lmddmba hby H] 9?790 %:?? lmddmba hby H] 9?7:0 %96? lmddmba hby H] 9?750 gae %9??lmddmba hby H] 9?76! [f yfjbllfae ucgu gppybpymgumba hby Xbdvauffyz hby _ybzpfymu} pybkyglebxfugmd _fgjf Jbypz gppybpymgumba gae if zfu gu %6? lmddmba hby H] 9?790 %7?? lmddmba hby H]9?7:0 %76? lmddmba hby H] 9?750 gae %9?? lmddmba hby H] 9?76! Mh _fgjf Jbypz gppybpymgumba mzzfu gu %:5? lmddmba hby H] 9?77$ ucfa ucfzf hmkvyfz {bvde affe ub if genvzufe gjjbyemakd}! Ucf_fgjf Jbypz affez g hf{ }fgyz ub eb{azm~f gae Xh_ affez g hf{ }fgyz ub yglp vp!


11/37

77

Bh jbvyzf$ zblf AKBz$ ubb$ gyf pbbyd} lgagkfe$ ivu gppdmjgauz jga hmae bvu {cmjc bafz gyf yva{fdd gae gppd} ub ucfl! Maeffe$ {muc Xh_ {f jbvde zfu vp g lgy`fu jblpfumumba glbak ucfAKBz ub fagidf Xh_ gppdmjgauz ub lg`f mahbylfe jcbmjfz glbak pbufaumgd pbzmumbaz0 ucmz {bvdekmxf ucf AKBz ga majfaumxf ub mlpybxf ucfmy lgagkflfau bh xbdvauffyz! Ab zvjc lgy`fulfjcgamzlz bpfyguf hby ucf _fgjf Jbypz! [muc hf{fy zdbuz ub hmdd$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz {bvde cgxf g

zvypdvz bh gppdmjgauz gae jbvde zfdfju ucbzf {muc g eflbazuygufe jbllmulfau ub kygzzybbuzefxfdbplfau gae jybzz,jvduvygd mllfyzmba gae jbvde pybxmef ucfl {muc zvizugaumgdd} ifuufyuygmamak gae ufjcamjgd zvppbyu! Ucmz zcbvde yfevjf ucf jbzud} fgyd},wvmu yguf!

Fxfa mh ucf _fgjf Jbypz {fyf abu lmzlgagkfe$ ucmz af{ emxx} mz g zlgyu zuygufk} kmxfa ucfHfefygd ivekfu yfgdmumfz! [f lvzu lg`f lbyf jbzu,fhhfjumxf vzf bh bvy yfzbvyjfz gz ucf} kyb{zjgyjf!

Baf `f} mzzvf yfkgyemak Xh_ mz {cfucfy ucf _fgjf Jbypz {bvde lg`f g ime ub lgagkf mu! UcfJbypbygumba hby Agumbagd Zfyxmjf lgagkfz ibuc XMZUG gae GlfymJbypz!

Bvy pybpbzgd mz abu ub ufylmaguf ucf _fgjf Jbypz! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz uygmaz Xbdvauffyz ma dbjgddgakvgkfz$ uygmaz ucfl ub {by` gu ucf kygzzybbuz dfxfd$ gae bhufa zfaez ucfl ub xmddgkfz {cfyfAKBz gyf dfzz gjumxf by abafsmzufau! Cb{fxfy$ ucf pybpbzgd {bvde fae ucf _fgjf Jbypzlbabpbd} ba kbxfyalfau,zpbazbyfe maufyagumbagd xbdvaugy} zfyxmjf! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz {bvdejbaumavf gz baf bh 9 lgnby bpumbaz hby maufyagumbagd xbdvaugy} zfyxmjf ucybvkc ucf V!Z!kbxfyalfau! Gjcmfxmak g igdgajf ifu{ffa ucf _fgjf Jbypz gae Xh_ {bvde pybxmef cfgduc}lgy`fu jblpfumumba hby ucf _fgjf Jbypz gae zpvy mu ub fliygjf yfhbyl!

Mh bxfy umlf ucf _fgjf Jbypz ebfz abu yfhbyl muzfdh$ ucfa Xh_ {bvde efzfyxf kyfgufy gae kyfgufyjdgmlz ba ucf ivekfu hby maufyagumbagd xbdvaugy} pdgjflfauz! Ucf jblpfumumba {bvde ucvzefufylmaf {cfucfy ucf _fgjf Jbypz zvyxmxfz!

[f `ab{ ucgu bvy pybpbzfe emxx} ifu{ffa ucf _fgjf Jbypz gae Xh_ {mdd if jbauybxfyzmgd!XMZUG gdvlam xmkbybvzd} bppbzfe ucf fzugidmzclfau bh GlfymJbypz! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz bppbzfeucf gvucbym~gumba hby Xh_! Mu mz mybamj ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz bppbzfe Xh_ gae eme abu lbxf ub ug`fmu bxfy$ kmxfa ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz ab{ bykgam~fe g zmlmdgy pybkygl> _fgjf JbypzYfzpbazf!7? #Mh ucf _fgjf Jbypz ug`fz bxfy lgagkflfau bh Xh_$ muz abu jdfgy cb{ Xh_ gaeYfzpbazf lmkcu if lfzcfe by lfykfe!- Hbyuvagufd}$ ibuc GlfymJbypz gae Xh_ {fyf fagjufe!

7? Lga} bh bvy jymumjmzlz bh ucf uygemumbagd _fgjf Jbypz {bvde if xmumgufe mh mu {fyf lgagkfe ma gpybhfzzmbagd lgaafy gz gppfgyz ub if ucf jgzf {muc ucf Yfzpbazf pybkygl! Yfzpbazf pdgjfz gibvu9?? yfuvyafe Xbdvauffyz pfy }fgy$ gzzmkalfau i} gzzmkalfau$ ma jcgddfakmak kygzzybbuzefxfdbplfau nbiz hby g : ub 79 lbauc pfymbe! Ucf Yfzpbazf pbzmumbaz yfwvmyf ucf pgyumjmpgauz ubcgxf gppybpymguf z`mddzmajdvemak dgakvgkf gae jybzz,jvduvygd gae ub {by` maefpfaefaud}$ {muclmamlgd _fgjf Jbypz zughh zvppbyu by zvpfyxmzmba! Gzzmkalfauz gyf u}pmjgdd} hgzcmbafe i} _fgjfJbypz bxfyzfgz zughh {by`mak {muc pgyuafymak dbjgd bykgam~gumbaz ub lffu g zpfjmhmj affe bh ucfcbzu jbvauy}! Gz {fdd ucfzf pbzmumbaz pybxmef wvgdmu} bppbyuvamumfz hby ucf Yfzpbazf Xbdvauffyub biugma jgyffy,hbjvzfe fspfymfajf {cmdf gjjblpdmzcmak ugakmidf yfzvduz ma g jbaefazfe pfymbebh umlf! _fgjf Jbypz Yfzpbazf zff`z ub lg`f ucf zuybakfzu lgujc pbzzmidf ifu{ffa gabykgam~gumba+z yfwvfzu hby gzzmzugajf gae ucf Xbdvauffy+z dgakvgkf$ ufjcamjgd$ gae jybzz jvduvygd


12/37

79

[f cbpf ucgu _fgjf Jbypz gdvlam {mdd zvppbyu ucmz hmxf ub zms hbde majyfgzf ma ucf avlify bhmaufyagumbagd pdgjflfauz ygucfy ucga lfyfd} efhfaemak ucf _fgjf Jbypz! [f ifdmfxf muz umlf hby

ucf Jbakyfzz ub maxfzu ma Xh_ gz mu cgz maxfzufe ma GlfymJbypz zb ucgu {f jga pyfzfyxf gaemajyfgzf ucf avlify bh maufyagumbagd pdgjflfauz!

Ub zfu vp ucmz jblpfumumba$ ucf Jbllmuuff zcbvde gebpu ucf glfaelfauz ub ucf Xh_ gvucbym~makdfkmzdgumba {cmjc gyf guugjcfe! Gae yfkgyemak _fgjf Jbypz yfhbyl$ {f cgxf guugjcfe eyghu

dfkmzdgumba ub ucf Jbllmuuff fajblpgzzmak gdd bh bvy yfjbllfaegumbaz!

Zvllgy} gae Jbajdvzmba

Ma bvy zuguflfau {f cgxf fspdgmafe {c} {f {fyf abu zvypymzfe i} ucf 9?"9? fspbzf! [f cgxfebjvlfaufe ucf cbzumdmu} bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz ub Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz gae muz mazfazmumxmu} ubxmjumlz bh ygpf gae zfsvgd gzzgvdu! [f cgxf pvu ucfzf hgjuz ma ucf jbaufsu bh ga gkfaj} ucgu mzcmfygyjcmjgd$ ymz` gxfyzf$ ivyfgvjygumj$ gae zfjyfumxf! Mu lmzyfpyfzfauz fgyd},wvmu ygufz$ cmefzyfzvduz bh muz b{a zvyxf}z bh Xbdvauffyz$ flpcgzm~fz wvgaumu} ygucfy ucga wvgdmu}$ lg`fz hgdzf

jdgmlz ub zvppbyu ucf fspgazmba jglpgmka$ hgmdz ub bykgam~f muzfdh hby Hmyzu Kbgd fhhfjumxfafzz$gae jbaumavfz mafhhfjumxf lgagkflfau pygjumjfz! Ucfzf pybidflz pgmau g jbazmzufau gae jbcfyfaupmjuvyf bh ga gkfaj} ucgu cgz dbzu g zfazf bh muz lmzzmba!

[f cgxf abu nvzu jblpdgmafe0 {f cgxf pybpbzfe lgaegumak ga gyyg} bh maufydbj`mak z}zuflz ucgu{mdd gppd} pyfzzvyf hybl ucf mazmef gae bvuzmef gae ucybvkc lgy`fu jblpfumumba ub fazvyf ucgu ucf_fgjf Jbypz fliygjfz yfhbyl! [f uyvzu ucgu ucfzf z}zuflz {mdd ifjblf g pfylgafau hmsuvyf bh_fgjf Jbypz jvduvyf zb ucgu ucf Jbakyfzz {mdd abu gkgma if hbyjfe ub yfxmzmu ucf yfhbylmlpfygumxf! [f cgxf guugjcfe ub ucmz zuguflfau dfkmzdgumxf dgakvgkf ba ucf `f} yfhbyl mzzvfz!

Ucf Jbllmuuff ebfz abu affe ub yfd} ba bvy xmf{pbmau gae yfjbllfaegumbaz ivu jga dmzufaemyfjud} ub ucf Xbdvauffyz ma ucf hmfde! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz ucf flgmd geeyfzz bh fxfy} Xbdvauffy![muc baf `f} zuyb`f ucf Jbllmuuff jbvde zfae ucfl gdd g wvfzumbaagmyf gibvu ucf gkfaj}+zpybhfzzmbagdmzl gae yfhbyl bpumbaz! Eb abu gzzvlf ucgu ucf Cfgewvgyufyz zughh zpfg` hby ucfXbdvauffyz! Ucf Xbdvauffyz gyf ucf lbzu yfdmgidf zbvyjf bh mahbylgumba ba ucf cfgduc bh ucf _fgjf

z`mddz jymumjgd hby pgyuafy bykgam~gumbaz gae ucf jbllvamumfz ma {cmjc ucf} zfyxf! _fgjf JbypzYfzpbazf Xbdvauffyz gyf gidf ub lg`f xgdvgidf jbauymivumbaz ifjgvzf ucf} jblf fwvmppfe {mucucf z`mddz gae gyf ucvz yfge} ub cgxf ga mllfemguf mlpgju! Ucf gppdmjgumba gae pdgjflfau pybjfzzug`fz g hygjumba bh ucf umlf mu ug`fz ub pybjfzz ga gppdmjgumba ub zfyxf gz g Xbdvauffy! Jblpfumumbahby ucf pbzmumbaz jga if maufazf! Ba gxfygkf$ ucf umlf hybl {cfa ga gzzmkalfau bpfaz ub {cfa gxbdvauffy mz pdgjfe ma jbvauy} mz 8,7? {ff`z! Yfzpbazf Xbdvauffyz yfjfmxf g zcbyu _fgjf Jbypzbymfaugumba vpba gyymxgd ma ucf jbvauy}$ kfafygdd} ucyff eg}z! Ucf pgyuafymak bykgam~gumba gdzbpybxmefz ga bymfaugumba! Yfzpbazf u}pmjgdd} pdgjfz Xbdvauffyz ma gibvu :? jbvauymfz pfy }fgy gaebpfygufz ma jbvauymfz ucgu cgxf ab jvyyfau _fgjf Jbypz pybkygl #dm`f Ibzamg$ Xfaf~vfdg$ J~fjcYfpvidmj$ gae Zym Dga`g-! Ucf Yfzpbazf Xbdvauffyz gyf jbazmefyfe ub if _fgjf Jbypz Xbdvauffyz{muc ucf zglf ifafhmuz pgj`gkf$ majdvemak lfemjgd jgyf gae g yfgenvzulfau gddb{gajf! Ucf _fgjfJbypz mz lbxmak ub fspgae Yfzpbazf gae fxfa bpfa mu vp ub maemxmevgdz {cb cgxf abu pyfxmbvzd}zfyxfe gz Xbdvauffyz!


13/37

7:

Jbypz! Ucf} cgxf g lgy`fed} emhhfyfau pbmau bh xmf{ hybl ucgu bh lgagkflfau! [f gyf jbahmefauucgu ucf} {mdd jbahmyl bvy xmf{pbmau gae faebyzf bvy yfjbllfaegumbaz!

Ucga` }bv hby dmzufamak ub gae yfzpfjumak ucf Xbdvauffy pfyzpfjumxf! Ucf Xbdvauffyz gyf ucf bad}yfgzba hby ucf _fgjf Jbypz0 ucf gkfaj} mz abucmak {mucbvu ucfl! Ucf Xbdvauffyz {mdd

faucvzmgzumjgdd} faebyzf }bvy bxfyzmkcu gae dfkmzdgumxf gkfaeg hby ucmz uybvidfe gkfaj}! [f lvzuflpb{fy Xbdvauffyz$ facgajf Jbakyfzzmbagd bxfyzmkcu$ gae fajbvygkf ucf pyfzz ub gz`pfafuygumak wvfzumbaz! Ucf mllvamu} bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz ub jbazuyvjumxf jymumjmzl lvzu fae!

Hmagdd}$ {muc ucf 9?"9? fspbzf ygmzmak fsmzufaumgd wvfzumbaz gae ucmz Jbllmuuff dmzufamak ub gaeyfzpfjumak ucf Xbdvauffyz$ {f {bvde dm`f ub if lbyf jbahmefau ucgu yfhbylz {mdd zbba iflgaegufe! Ivu ghufy hmkcumak hby yfhbyl hby zms }fgyz {mucbvu zvjjfzz$ {f yflgma z`fpumjgd ucguucf lgaegufz {mdd if fagjufe! Hby bxfy 6? }fgyz ucmz cgz iffa ga gkfaj} ucgu ab baf cgz iffa{mddmak by gidf ub cbde gjjbvaugidf! [f cbpf ucgu ucf Jbllmuuff {mdd pybxf ucgu bvy pfzzmlmzlgibvu ucf pybzpfjuz hby fagjumak yfhbyl mz abu {gyygaufe! Ucf zug`fz gyf ubb cmkc ub gigaeba ucmzgkfaj}! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz mz zumdd Glfymjg+z ifzu bvuyfgjc ub ucf {byde! Ma muz hmhumfuc gaamxfyzgy}

}fgy$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz efzfyxfz ucf umlf gae guufaumba affefe ub cbde mu ub ucf cmkc mefgdz {muc{cmjc mu {gz hbvaefe! [f gyf cgpp} ub gaz{fy }bvy wvfzumbaz!

Gppfaems> Lfjcgamzlz hby Dmzufamak ub Xbdvauffy [cmzudf Idb{fyz ba gJbahmefaumgd Igzmz gae _ybufjumak Ucfl Gkgmazu Yfugdmgumba gae MajyfgzmakUygazpgyfaj} bh ucf Gkfaj} #Ug`fa ma pgyu hybl Ucf _fgjf Jbypz XbdvauffyFlpb{fylfau Gju$ Z! =:9$ Ebee"@faafe}> Lgyjc 7$ 9??;-

_GYUMJM_GUMBA BH _FGJF JBY_Z XBDVAUFFYZ MA YFXMF[Z BH ZFAMBYZUGHH GAE _YBKYGLZ#g- Yfxmf{z bh Zfamby Zughh,

#7- MA KFAFYGD, Ucf Emyfjuby bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz zcgdd fzugidmzc g lfjcgamzl hby zbdmjmumakucf xmf{z bh _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffyz zfyxmak ma jbvauy}$ ba g jbahmefaumgd igzmz$ yfkgyemak ucfzvppbyu pybxmefe gae pybhfzzmbagdmzl bh zfamby zughh! Ucf mefaumu} bh ucf xbdvauffy zcgdd if `fpujbahmefaumgd gae ucf xmf{z zcgdd if yfpbyufe ub ucf gppybpymguf Yfkmbagd _fgjf Jbypz Emyfjuby!Ucf Jbvauy} Emyfjuby lg} pvidmzc ucfzf xmf{z ub ucf jbypz bh xbdvauffyz zfyxmak ma jbvauy}!#9- JBAZMEFYGUMBA BH YFXMF[Z MA JBAAFJUMBA [MUC JBAUYGJU EFJMZMBAZ,Ucf mahbylgumba jbddfjufe pvyzvgau ub pgygkygpc #7- zcgdd if kmxfa zvizugaumgd {fmkcu ma ucfefjmzmba lg`mak pybjfzz {muc yfzpfju ub ucf fsufazmba bh jbauygjuz hby Jbvauy} Emyfjubyz$ JcmfhGelmamzuygumxf Bhhmjfyz$ _fgjf Jbypz Lfemjgd Bhhmjfyz$ gae Gzzbjmguf _fgjf Jbypz Emyfjubyz!#i- Yfxmf{z bh _fgjf Jbypz _ybkyglz,#7- MA KFAFYGD, Ucf Emyfjuby bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz zcgdd fzugidmzc g lfjcgamzl hby zbdmjmumak

ucf xmf{z bh _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffyz zfyxmak ma jbvauy}$ ba g jbahmefaumgd igzmz$ yfkgyemak ucfefzmka$ fhhfjumxfafzz$ gae jbaumavfe xgdvf hby ucf pybkyglz ma {cmjc ucf} zfyxf! Ucf mefaumu} bhucf xbdvauffy zcgdd if `fpu jbahmefaumgd gae ucf xmf{z yfpbyufe ub ucf gppybpymguf Yfkmbagd _fgjfJbypz Emyfjuby! Ucf Jbvauy} Emyfjuby lg} pvidmzc ucfzf xmf{z ub ucf jbypz bh xbdvauffyz zfyxmakma jbvauy}!#9- JBAZMEFYGUMBA BH YFXMF[Z MA JBAAFJUMBA [MUC _YBKYGL EFJMZMBAZ,Ucf mahbylgumba jbddfjufe pvyzvgau ub pgygkygpc #7- zcgdd if kmxfa zvizugaumgd {fmkcu ma ucf


14/37

75

efjmzmba lg`mak pybjfzz {muc yfzpfju ub ucf efzmka bh$ gae jbaumavfe affe hby$ _fgjf Jbypzpybkyglz!#:- _VIDMJGUMBA BH YFXMF[Z,Zvjc mahbylgumba zcgdd if pvidmzcfe ma ucf jbvauy} {mucyfkgye ub {cmjc zvjc mahbylgumba cgz iffa zvilmuufe ba ucf _fgjf Jbypz mauygafu gae gxgmdgidfub jvyyfau Xbdvauffyz ma zvjc jbvauy} bh zfyxmjf gae ub ucbzf {cb gyf maxmufe ub zfyxf ma zvjc

jbvauy}!

JBAHFYMAK [CMZUDF IDB[FY YMKCUZ BA _FGJF JBY_Z XBDVAUFFYZ GAEZUGHHUcf Emyfjuby bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz zcgdd fazvyf ucgu _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffyz gae zughh yfpbyumak ucflmzjbaevju bh _fgjf Jbypz zughh by gexbjgumak hby yfhbylz gyf uyfgufe ma gjjbyegajf {muc ucfpybxmzmbaz bh jcgpufy 9: bh umudf 6$ Vamufe Zugufz Jbef$ pybcmimumak jfyugma pfyzbaafd pygjumjfz#jbllbad} yfhfyyfe ub gz {cmzudfidb{fy pybufjumba pybxmzmbaz-!

MA_VU BH XBDVAUFFYZ YFKGYEMAK ZMUF ZFDFJUMBA GAE UYGMAMAKJVYYMJVDVL

Jbvauy} Emyfjubyz gae Gzzbjmguf _fgjf Jbypz Emyfjubyz zcgdd kmxf zvizugaumgd {fmkcu ub ucfyfjbllfaegumbaz bh _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffyz yfkgyemak,,#7- _fgjf Jbypz zmuf zfdfjumba$ majdvemak ucf pdgjflfau bh geemumbagd by zvizfwvfau _fgjf Jbypzxbdvauffyz gu fsmzumak zmufz0 gae#9- ucf uygmamak jvyymjvdvl hby _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffyz!

UYGAZ_GYFAU] YFKGYEMAK FGYD] UFYLMAGUMBA YGUFZ BH _FGJF JBY_ZXBDVAUFFYZMa ga fhhbyu ub ifuufy efufylmaf fgyd} ufylmagumba ygufz bh _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffyz$ ucf _fgjfJbypz zcgdd,,#7- Jgdjvdguf ucf yguf bh fgyd} ufylmagumba glbakzu Xbdvauffyz vumdm~mak ucf jbcbyu by zmlmdgyzugumzumjgd lfucbe0#9- _vidmzc zvjc egug ba g }fgyd} igzmz gae majdvef gz lvjc eflbkygpcmj egug gz mz hfgzmidf maga} fgyd} ufylmagumba yfpbyumak0 gae#:- Uygazlmu zvjc egug ub gppdmjgauz gae maxmuffz!

UYGAZ_GYFAJ] YFKGYEMAK ZVYXF]Z BH _FGJF JBY_Z XBDVAUFFYZUcf _fgjf Jbypz zcgdd pvidmzc ba dmaf ucf yfzvduz bh zvyxf}z bh xbdvauffyz$ majdvemak g jbvauy},i},jbvauy} gae pybkygl,i},pybkygl iyfg` bvu bh ucf yfzvduz! Mu zcgdd uygazlmu zvjc mahbylgumbaub gppdmjgauz gae maxmuffz!

_YBXMEMAK HBY MAJYFGZFE UYGAZ_GYFAJ] BH UCF _FGJF JBY_Z VAEFYHYFFEBL BH MAHBYLGUMBA GJU#g- Mh ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz abu yfzpbaefe ub g Hyffebl bh Mahbylgumba Gju yfwvfzu {mucma ucfzuguvuby} efgedmaf$ ucf gkfaj} zcbvde if pybcmimufe hybl {muccbdemak ga} pbyumba bh ucf yfjbyezvaefy )emzjyfumbagy}) gvucbymu} gae ucf gkfaj} zcgdd if yfwvmyfe ub yfdfgzf mu!#i- Ucf _fgjf Jbypz zcgdd abu jcgykf ga} hffz ub yfwvfzufyz hby ga} HBMG yfwvfzu {cmjc mz abugaz{fyfe {mucma ucf zuguvuby} umlf dmlmuz!#j- Ucf _fgjf Jbypz zcgdd pvidmzc ba dmaf gdd mahbylgumba ucgu mu cgz zvppdmfe ub ucf pvidmj mayfzpbazf ub Hyffebl bh Mahbylgumba Gju yfwvfzuz!


15/37

76

Gppfaems> Geemumbagd Yfhbyl Dfkmzdgumxf _ybxmzmbaz

EMKMUGD _FGJF JBY_ZUcf Emyfjuby bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz zcgdd fzugidmzc g z}zufl hby pyblbumak$ i} fdfjuybamj lfgaz$

mlpybxfe jbllvamjgumba glbak _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffyz gae zughh$ majdvemak ucf fzugidmzclfaubh {fizmufz gae f,lgmd dma`z hby vzf ba g pgzz{bye,bad} igzmz i} _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffyz majbvauy} ub emzjvzz efxfdbplfau zuygufkmfz$ hvaemak zbvyjfz$ ifzu pygjumjfz kvmefz$ _fgjf Jbypzlgagkflfau pygjumjfz gae pbdmjmfz$ gae bucfy mzzvfz! Zvjc {fizmufz zcgdd cgxf ga gdvlam zfjumbahby yfuvyafe xbdvauffyz {muc ga maufyfzu gae fspfymfajf ma zvppbyumak xbdvauffy kbgdz gaepybkyglz$ gae ucmz zfjumba zcgdd if maufkygufe maub ucf dgykfy z}zufl gjjfzzmidf ub gdd xbdvauffyz!Gdd jdbzf bh zfyxmjf yfpbyuz zcgdd if gxgmdgidf ba zvjc {fizmufz by f,lgmd dma`z!

MAEF_FAEFAJF BH UCF _FGJF JBY_Z MAZ_FJUBY KFAFYGD!Ucf _fgjf Jbypz Mazpfjuby Kfafygd zcgdd if gppbmaufe i} ucf _yfzmefau zvinfju ub jbahmylgumbai} ucf Zfaguf!

MAXFZUMKGUMBAZ BH JYMLFZ GKGMAZU _FGJF JBY_Z XBDVAUFFYZUcf _fgjf Jbypz zcgdd yfpbyu ub ucf Jbakyfzz ba ucf bykgam~gumba bh maxfzumkgumbaz bh jymlfzgkgmazu Xbdvauffyz$ majdvemak ga fxgdvgumba bh {cfucfy ucf _fgjf Jbypz Mazpfjuby Kfafygd zcbvdeif kmxfa ucf dfge ma ucfzf maxfzumkgumbaz!

DMLMU BA AVLIFY BH _BDMUMJGD G__BMAUFFZUcf _fgjf Jbypz zcgdd if dmlmufe ub 76 _yfzmefaumgd pbdmumjgd gppbmauffz!

JBL_DMGAJF [MUC GELMAMZUYGUMXF _YBJFEVYF GJUUcf _fgjf Jbypz zcgdd jblpd} {muc ucf Gelmamzuygumxf _ybjfevyf Gju! _vidmj Dg{ ;=,5?50 6

VZJ 6?? fu! zfw! ma pyblvdkgumak yvdfz$ lgavgd glfaelfauz$ gae zmlmdgy kvmegajfz! [mucma baf}fgy mu zcgdd pvidmzc fsmzumak yvdfz hby pvidmj jbllfau!

YF_FGD BH HMXF,]FGY DMLMUGUMBA BA _FGJF JBY_Z _FYZBAAFDZfjumbaz 96?8 #g-#9-#G-$ #g-#6- gae #g-#8- bh_fgjf Jbypz Gju! _vidmj Dg{ 3;,9=: #Zfpuflify99$ 7=87- #gz glfaefe- gyf yfpfgdfe!

_FYZBAAFD YMKCUZ BH _FGJF JBY_Z FL_DB]FFZ_fgjf Jbypz zughh zcgdd cgxf ucf zglf pfyzbaafd ymkcuz gz Hbyfmka Zfyxmjf _fyzbaafd vaefy 99VZJ :=?6!

YFMLIVYZFLFAU HBY [BY@ YFDGUFE FS_FAZFZ BH _FGJF JBY_ZXBDVAUFFYZ#g- Hmaemakz, Jbakyfzz lg`fz ucf hbddb{mak hmaemakz>#7- Ucf _fgjf Jbypz mz ga gkfaj} hbjvzfe ba kygzzybbuz$ ibuubl,vp efxfdbplfau!#9- Yfmlivyzflfau hby {by`,yfdgufe fspfazfz hby eflbazuygumba gae zmlmdgy pybnfjuz mz jyvjmgdub ucf zvjjfzz bh _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffyz!#:- Eflbazuygumba gae zmlmdgy pybnfjuz gyf g xfy} fhhfjumxf lfucbe hby _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffyz ubfevjguf pfbpdf ma cbzu jbvauymfz!


16/37

78

#i- Hvaemak, Ucfyf mz gvucbym~fe ub if gppybpymgufe vp ub 7 pfyjfau bh ucf ubugd glbvaugppybpymgufe hby ucf _fgjf Jbypz hby hmzjgd }fgy 9??= gae fgjc hmzjgd }fgy ucfyfghufy hbyyfmlivyzflfau hby {by`,yfdgufe fspfazfz hby _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffyz ub jgyy} bvu eflbazuygumbagae zmlmdgy pybnfjuz ucgu cgxf iffa gppybxfe ma gexgajf i} ucf _fgjf Jbypz Jbvauy} Emyfjuby bycmz by cfy efzmkaff ma ucf jbvauy} {cfyf ucf xbdvauffy mz zfyxmak!

#j- Yfmlivyzflfau hby {by`,yfdgufe Xbdvauffy fspfazfz ,#7- GXGMDGIMDMU] BH HVAEZ, Ucf Emyfjuby bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz zcgdd efufylmaf gu ucfifkmaamak bh fgjc hmzjgd }fgy ucf glbvau bh hvaemak ucgu {mdd if gxgmdgidf gz yfmlivyzflfau hby{by`,yfdgufe Xbdvauffy fspfaez hby eflbazuygumba gae zmlmdgy pybnfjuz hby ucgu hmzjgd }fgy gaemahbyl fgjc Jbvauy} Emyfjuby bh ucf pbyumba bh ucgu glbvau ucgu {mdd if gxgmdgidf ub emzuymivuf ubxbdvauffyz vaefy ucf zvpfyxmzmba bh zvjc Jbvauy} Emyfjuby!#9- G[GYEMAK BH HVAEZ, Ucf Emyfjuby bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz zcgdd pyblvdkguf yvdfz pvyzvgauub {cmjc fgjc Jbvauy} Emyfjuby lg} yfmlivyzf Xbdvauffyz hby {by`,yfdgufe fspfazfz vumdm~makhvaez lgef gxgmdgidf vaefy ucmz zfjumba ub fdmkmidf _fgjf Jbyp xbdvauffyz!#:- FDMKMIMDMU], Ub if fdmkmidf hby yfmlivyzflfau hby {by`,yfdgufe fspfazfz vaefy ucmzzvizfjumba$ g _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffy zcgdd,,

#G- zvilmu ub ucf Jbvauy} Emyfjuby by cmz by cfy efzmkaff bh ucf jbvauy} {cfyf ucf xbdvauffy mzzfyxmak g pdga hby g eflbazuygumba by zmlmdgy pybnfju$ majdvemak ga fspdgagumba bh cb{ ucfeflbazuygumba by zmlmdgy pybnfju {mdd dfge ub zvzugmagidf efxfdbplfau gae g zuguflfau bh ucffhhbyuz ucf Xbdvauffy cgz lgef ub zfjvyf hvaemak hby ucf eflbazuygumba by zmlmdgy pybnfju hyblaba,_fgjf Jbypz zbvyjfz0 gae#I- lg`f g {ymuufa guufzugumba ucgu hvaez g{gyefe vaefy ucmz zvizfjumba gyf vumdm~fe hby ucfpvypbzfz zpfjmhmfe ma ucf pdga!#5- GLBVAU BH YFMLIVYZFLFAU, Yfmlivyzflfau bh {by`,yfdgufe fspfazfz pybxmefe ubg xbdvauffy igzfe ba cmz by cfy gppdmjgumba by gppdmjgumbaz hby yfmlivyzflfau lg} abu fsjffe gubugd %7$???$ evymak ucf cmz by cfy mamumgd ufyl bh zfyxmjf!#6- YF_BYU, Fgjc _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffy {cb yfjfmxfz yfmlivyzflfau vaefy ucmz zvizfjumbazcgdd zvilmu ub ucf Jbvauy} Emyfjuby by cmz by cfy efzmkaff bh ucf jbvauy} {cfyf ucf xbdvauffy mzzfyxmak ifhbyf ucf jdbzf bh zvjc xbdvauffy+z zfyxmjf g yfpbyu ba ucf eflbazuygumba by zmlmdgypybnfju hvaefe i} ucf yfmlivyzflfau!

JCGYMUGIDF HVAEYGMZMAK I] _FGJF JBY_Z XBDVAUFFYZ#g- Zfazf bh Jbakyfzz ba Gzzmzugajf ma Hvaeygmzmak, Mu mz ucf zfazf bh Jbakyfzz ucgu _fgjf Jbypzxbdvauffyz zcbvde gppd} hby kygauz gae dbgaz hybl abakbxfyalfaugd bykgam~gumbaz ub jgyy} bvueflbazuygumba pybnfjuz$ majdvemak i} pgyuafymak {muc kbxfyalfaugd gae abakbxfyalfaugdgkfajmfz gae {by`mak {muc cbzu jbvauy} agumbagdz!#i- Hvaeygmzmak i} Xbdvauffyz,#7- GVUCBYMU],#G- MA KFAFYGD, Zvinfju ub zvipgygkygpc #I-$ _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffyz gyf gvucbym~fe ub zbdmjmujbauymivumbaz hby eflbazuygumba pybnfjuz hybl pfyzbaz pfyzbagdd} `ab{a ub ucfl$ majdvemakhglmd} lflifyz$ hymfaez$ gae lflifyz bh ucfmy cblf jbllvamu} ma ucf Vamufe Zugufz$ gae hyblkbxfyalfau gae abakbxfyalfaugd gkfajmfz$ majdvemak$ ivu abu dmlmufe ub {by`mak ucybvkc ucf_fgjf Jbypz _gyuafyzcmp _ybkygl! Ga} zvjc zbdmjmugumba zcgdd zuguf ucf eflbazuygumba pybnfju bypybnfjuz ub {cmjc jbauymivufe hvaez {mdd if gppdmfe!


17/37

7;

#I- YFWVMYFE G__YBXGD, G _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffy zcgdd zff` gae yfjfmxf gexgajf gppybxgdhybl ucf Jbvauy} Emyfjuby bh ucf jbvauy} {cfyf ucf xbdvauffy mz zfyxmak ifhbyf fsfyjmzmak ucfgvucbymu} vaefy zvipgygkygpc #G-!#9- GJJBVAUGIMDMU], _fgjf Jbypz xbdvauffyz yfjfmxmak jbauymivumbaz pvyzvgau ub ucfgvucbymu} vaefy pgygkygpc #7- zcgdd,,

#G- lgmaugma yfjbyez gae yfjfmpuz ub jbahmyl ucf pybpfy gppdmjgumba bh jbauymivufe hvaez0 gae#I- fazvyf ucgu zvjc hvaez gyf fspfaefe zbdfd} hby ucf eflbazuygumba pybnfju by pybnfjuz hby{cmjc ucf} {fyf maufaefe!

YFGENVZULFAU GDDB[GAJFZ HBY _FGJF JBY_Z XBDVAUFFYZ GAEXBDVAUFFY DFGEFYZ#g- Xbdvauffyz, Zfjumba 6#j- bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz Gju #99 V!Z!J! 96?5#j-- mz glfaefe ma ucf hmyzuzfaufajf i} zuym`mak o%796+ gae mazfyumak o%96?+!#i- Xbdvauffy Dfgefyz, Zfjumba 8#7- bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz Gju #99 V!Z!J! 96?6#7-- mz glfaefe i}zuym`mak o%796+ gae mazfyumak o%96?+!

GVUCBYM^GUMBA BH G__YB_YMGUMBAZZfjumba :#i-#7- bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz Gju #99 V!Z!J! 96?9#i-#7-- mz glfaefe ub yfge gz hbddb{z>o#7- Ucfyf gyf gvucbym~fe ub if gppybpymgufe ub jgyy} bvu ucf pvypbzfz bh ucmz Gju %5??$???$???hby hmzjgd }fgy 9?7?$ %222 hby hmzjgd }fgy 9?77$ %222 hby hmzjgd }fgy 9?79$ gae 222 hby hmzjgd }fgy9?7:+!ABUF> UCF GVUCBYM^GUMBA HBY UCF _FGJF JBY_Z ZCBVDE EBXFUGMD [MUCUCF GVUCBYM^GUMBA HBY XBDVAUFFYZ HBY _YBZ_FYMU]! [F CGXFYFJBLLFAEFE UCGU CGDH BH UCF JVYYFAU _FGJF JBY_Z G__YB_YMGUMBAZ$%9?? LMDDMBA$ IF EMXFYUFE UB HVAE XH_!77

GLFAELFAUZ UB UCF @FAAFE] ZFYXF GLFYMJG GJU #XBDVAUFFYZ HBY_YBZ_FYMU]-Gebpu glfaelfauz ub ucf Xh_ pybkygl zb ucgu mu {mdd pybxmef cfgduc} jblpfumumba hby ucf _fgjfJbypz! Majdvefz glfaelfauz ub majyfgzf gvucbym~gumba hby Xh_ub if ebxfugmdfe {muc efjyfgzfma ucf gvucbym~gumba hby ucf _fgjf Jbypz! Bxfy hmxf }fgyz$ pybxmef fwvgd gvucbym~gumba hby _fgjfJbypz gae Xh_!

@faafe} Zfyxf Glfymjg Gju

77 Ucf _fgjf Jbypz gppybpymgumba hby H] 9?7? {gz %5?? lmddmba! Vaefy ucf jvyyfau JbaumavmakYfzbdvumba hby H] 9?77$ muz gppybpymgumba {bvde if ucf zglf! Ucf Cbvzf H] 9?77 gppybpymgumbaimdd zfuz muz gppybpymgumba gu %:5? lmddmba #H] ?3- dfxfd! Gzzvlmak ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz mzgppybpymgufe %5?? hby ucf jvyyfau hmzjgd }fgy$ {f yfjbllfae ucgu ucf gvucbym~gumba hby ucf _fgjfJbypz if zfu gu %:6? lmddmba hby H] 9?790 %:?? lmddmba hby H] 9?7:0 %96? lmddmba hby H] 9?750gae %9?? lmddmba hby H] 9?76! [f yfjbllfae ucgu ucf gppybpymgumba hby ucf Xbdvauffyz hby_ybzpfymu} pybkygl ebxfugmd ucf _fgjf Jbypz gppybpymgumba gae if zfu gu %6? lmddmba hby H]9?790 %7?? lmddmba hby H] 9?7:0 %76? lmddmba hby H] 9?750 gae %9?? lmddmba hby H] 9?76! Mh ucf_fgjf Jbypz gppybpymgumba mz zfu gu %:5? lmddmba hby H] 9?77$ ucfa ucfzf hmkvyfz {bvde affe ubif genvzufe gjjbyemakd}! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz affez g hf{ }fgyz ub eb{azm~f gae Xh_ affez g hf{}fgyz ub yglp vp!


18/37

73

C!Y!7:33 #_vidmj Dg{ 777,7:-Zfyxf Glfymjg Gju #Faybddfe Imdd PHmagd gz _gzzfe Ibuc Cbvzf gae Zfaguf\ , FAY-

UMUDF X,,XBDVAUFFYZ HBY _YBZ_FYMU] _YBKYGL. . .

ZFJ! 67?9! EFHMAMUMBAZ!Ma ucmz umudf>

#7- XH_ BHHMJF, Ucf ufyl oXh_ Bhhmjf+ lfgaz ucf Bhhmjf bh Xbdvauffyz hby_ybzpfymu} bh ucf Vamufe Zugufz Gkfaj} hby Maufyagumbagd Efxfdbplfau! Mu zcgdd ifgelmamzufyfe i} ucf Emyfjuby$ Xbdvauffyz hby _ybzpfymu}$ {cb zcgdd yfpbyu ubucf Gelmamzuyguby!ABUF> BAF JFAUYGD WVFZUMBA GIBVU Xh_ MZ [CFUCFY MUZCBVDE JBAUMAVF UB IF LGAGKFE I] VZ GME BY LGAGKFE I]UCF _FGJF JBY_Z!#9- XH_ _YBKYGL, Ucf ufyl oXh_ _ybkygl+ lfgaz ucf Xbdvauffyz hby_ybzpfymu} _ybkygl fzugidmzcfe ucybvkc Fsfjvumxf Byefy 7::7;!

#:- XH_ZFYXF, Ucf ufyl oXh_Zfyxf+ lfgaz g pybkygl fzugidmzcfe i} ucf Xh_Bhhmjf$ ma jbbpfygumba {muc ucf VZG Hyffebl Jbypz$ ub pybxmef fdmkmidfgppybpymgufd} z`mddfe .79Glfymjgaz Pefdfuf> pybhfzzmbagdz\ {muc lgujcmakkygauz gae gzzmzugajf! Pefdfuf> hmsfe glbvau zumpfaez ub bhhzfu ucf uygxfddmxmak jbzuz bh xbdvauffymak giybge!\

ZFJ! 67?:! BHHMJF BH XBDVAUFFYZ HBY _YBZ_FYMU]!#g- Hvajumbaz, Ucf Xh_ Bhhmjf zcgdd pvyzvf ucf binfjumxfz bh ucf Xh_ _ybkygl efzjymifema zvizfjumba #i- i},,

#7- mlpdflfaumak ucf Xh_Zfyxf _ybkygl ub pybxmef fdmkmidf gppybpymgufd} z`mddfe. Glfymjgaz Pefdfuf pybhfzzmbagdz\ {muc lgujcmak kygauz gae gzzmzugajf ubfagidf ucfl ub zfyxf gz xbdvauffyz Pefdfuf> hmsfe glbvau zumpfaez ub bhhzfu

ucf uygxfd gae dmxmak fspfazfz bh xbdvauffymak giybge {muc abapybhmubykgam~gumbaz\0ABUF> LGUJCMAK KYGAUZ LFGAZ UCGU UCF G__DMJGAU GAE"BYUCF AKB LVZU ZV__D] LGUJCFZ UB UCF XH_ JBAUYMIVUMBAZ! UCFZF

LGUJCFZ [MDD FAZVYF UCGU UCF G__DMJGAU GAE AKB

EFLBAZUYGUF G JBLLMULFAU UB UCF ZFYXMJF _YBNFJU!

#9- bucfy{mzf pyblbumak zcbyu, gae dbak,ufyl maufyagumbagd xbdvauffy zfyxmjf i}gppybpymgufd} z`mddfe . GlfymjgazPefdfuf pybhfzzmbagdz\$ majdvemak pdgjmakby jbaafjumak zvjc maemxmevgdz Pefdfuf pybhfzzmbagdz\ {muc abapybhmubykgam~gumbaz$ ub gjcmfxf zvjc binfjumxfz ucybvkc lgujcmak kygauz gaegzzmzugajf0

#:- cfdpmak abapybhmu bykgam~gumbaz gae jbypbygumbaz ma ucf Vamufe Zugufz yfjyvmugae fhhfjumxfd} lgagkf geemumbagd gppybpymgufd} z`mddfe . GlfymjgazPefdfuf

.7 Gppybpymgufd} z`mddfe> Baf jfauygd wvfzumba ma glfaemak ucf Xh_ gvucbym~gumba mz {cfucfy muzcbvde yflgma g pybkygl hby pdgjflfau bad} bh cmkcd} z`mddfe pybhfzzmbagdz by zcbvde if

yfugykfufe gu gppybpymgufd} z`mddfe Glfymjgaz! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz mz jblpymzfe dgykfd} bh yfjfau

jbddfkf kygevgufz {muc dmuudf by ab nbi fspfymfajf!


19/37

7=

pybhfzzmbagdz\ hby zcbyu by dbak ufyl xbdvauffy gzzmkalfauz ucybvkcbvu ucfefxfdbpmak {byde0#- hbzufymak pgyuafyzcmpz ifu{ffa ucf pymxguf gae pvidmj zfjubyz ub pyblbuf

gae hgjmdmuguf ucf zfyxmjf bh gppybpymgufd} z`mddfe . Glfymjga xbdvauffyz maucf efxfdbpmak {byde ucybvkc lgujcmak kygauz gae gzzmzugajf0

#5- pybxmemak yfjbkamumba hby gppybpymgufd} z`mddfe . Glfymjga xbdvauffyz gaeucf bykgam~gumbaz efpdb}mak ucfl0#6- cfdpmak abapybhmu bykgam~gumbaz gae jbypbygumbaz ma ucf Vamufe Zugufz ubmefaumh} yfzbvyjfz gae bppbyuvamumfz ma maufyagumbagd xbdvauffy zfyxmjf vumdm~makgppybpymgufd} z`mddfe . Glfymjgaz ucybvkc lgujcmak kygauz gae gzzmzugajf0#8- fajbvygkmak ucf fzugidmzclfau bh maufyagumbagd xbdvauffy pybkyglz hbyflpdb}ffz bh Vamufe Zugufz jbypbygumbaz ucybvkc lgujcmak kygauz gaegzzmzugajf0 gae#;- fajbvygkmak maufyagumbagd xbdvaugy} zfyxmjf i} Pefdfuf cmkcd}\gppybpymgufd} z`mddfe . Glfymjgaz ub pyblbuf cfgduc gae pybzpfymu} ucybvkcbvuucf {byde!

#- pyblbumak gae zvppbyumak mamumgumxfz bh abapybhmu bykgam~gumbaz gaejbypbygumbaz ma ucf efxfdbpmak {byde ub hbzufy fzugidmzclfau bh g aba,pybhmuzfjuby gae g uygemumba bh xbdvaugy} zfyxmjf ucybvkc lgujcmak kygauz gaegzzmzugajf!

#i- Xh_ _ybkygl Binfjumxfz, Ucf binfjumxfz bh ucf Xh_ _ybkygl xbdvauffyz gyf ub pybxmefzfyxmjf ucgu gjcmfxfz zvzugmagidf efxfdbplfau ma

#7- fdmlmagumak fsuyflf pbxfyu}0#9- yfevjmak {byde cvakfy gae lgdavuymumba0#:- majyfgzmak gjjfzz ub zghf pbugidf {gufy0#5- fagjumak vamxfyzgd fevjgumba0#6- yfevjmak jcmde lbyugdmu} gae jcmdecbbe emzfgzfz0#8- jbligumak ucf zpyfge bh pyfxfaugidf emzfgzfz$ majdvemak CMX$ lgdgymg$ gaeuvifyjvdbzmz0#;- pybxmemak fevjgumbagd gae {by` z`mdd zvppbyu hby kmydz gae flpb{fymak {blfaub gjcmfxf maefpfaefajf0#3- jyfgumak zvzugmagidf ivzmafzz gae fauyfpyfafvymgd bppbyuvamumfz0 gae#=- majyfgzmak gjjfzz ub mahbylgumba ufjcabdbk}!#af{- hbzufymak fzugidmzclfau bh g aba,pybhmu zfjuby gae uygemumba bhxbdvauffymak ma ucf efxfdbpmak {byde!ABUF> UCF FL_CGZMZ BA ZVZUGMAGIDF EFXFDB_LFAU

FAZVYFZ UCGU UCF XBDVAUGY] ZFYXMJF IFAFHMUZ UCF CBZUJBVAUY] AGUMBAGDZ$ ABU NVZU UCF XBDVAUFFY!

#j- Xbdvauffyz hby _ybzpfymu} Zfyxmjf Majfaumxf _ybkygl,#7- MA KFAFYGD, Ucf Xh_ Bhhmjf lg} pybxmef lgujcmak kygauz ub bhhzfu ucfuygxfd Pefdfuf> gae\$ dmxmak jbzuz bh xbdvauffymak giybge$ gae mazvygajf jbzuzgae yfgzbagidf hffz$ majdvemak zfyxmjf pybkygl hffz$ hby ucf bykgam~gumba{muc {cbl ucf xbdvauffy zfyxfz hby fspfazfz gzzbjmgufe {muc bymfaugumba gaegelmamzuygumba bh ucf xbdvauffy pybkygl ub ga} fdmkmidf bykgam~gumba ucgu,,

#G- cgz lflifyz {cb pbzzfzz gppybpymguf z`mddz yfdfxgau ub geeyfzzmakga} binfjumxf efzjymife ma zvizfjumba #i-0 gae


20/37


21/37

97

#7- MA KFAFYGD, Ucf Gelmamzuyguby bh ucf Vamufe Zugufz Gkfaj} hbyMaufyagumbagd Efxfdbplfau zcgdd lg`f gxgmdgidf ucf glbvauz gppybpymgufepvyzvgau ub zfjumba 67?5 ub ucf Xh_ Bhhmjf ub pvyzvf ucf binfjumxfz efzjymife mazvizfjumba #i- i} jgyy}mak bvu ucf hvajumbaz efzjymife ma zvizfjumba #g-!#9- VZF BH HVAEZ, Glbvauz lgef gxgmdgidf vaefy pgygkygpc #7- lg} if vzfe

i} ucf Xh_ Bhhmjf ub pybxmef pfyzbaafd gae bucfy yfzbvyjfz ub efxfdbp$ lgagkf$gae fspgae ucf Xh_ _ybkygl$ vaefy ucf zvpfyxmzmba bh ucf Vamufe Zugufz Gkfaj}hby Maufyagumbagd Efxfdbplfau!

#f- Jbbyemagumba, Ucf Xh_ Bhhmjf zcgdd jbbyemaguf muz fhhbyuz {muc bucfy pvidmj gae pymxguffhhbyuz ucgu gml ub zfae gppybpymgufd} z`mddfe . Pefdfuf> pybhfzzmbagdz\Glfymjgaz ubzfyxf ma efxfdbpmak agumbaz!#h- Yfpbyu, Ucf Xh_ Bhhmjf zcgdd zvilmu ga gaavgd yfpbyu ub Jbakyfzz gae ucf pvidmj baucf gjumxmumfz bh ucf Xh_ Bhhmjf {cmjc zcgdd majdvef ga gzzfzzlfau efxfdbpfe majbddgibygumba {muc VZ Gme bh ucf mlpgju bh ucf pybkygl ba zvzugmagidf efxfdbplfau!

ZFJ! 67?5! GVUCBYM^GUMBA BH G__YB_YMGUMBAZ!#g- Ma Kfafygd, Ucfyf gyf gvucbym~fe ub if gppybpymgufe ub jgyy} bvu ucmz umudf %7?$???$???

hby hmzjgd }fgy 9?7?$ gae Pefdfuf> zvjc zvlz gz lg} if afjfzzgy} hby fgjc bh ucf hmzjgd}fgyz 9?77 ucybvkc 9?75\gae zvjc zvlz ucfyfghufy!ABUF> UCF GVUCBYM^GUMBA HBY Xh_ ZCBVDE EBXFUGMD [MUC UCFGVUCBYM^GUMBA HBY UCF _FGJF JBY_Z! [F CGXF YFJBLLFAEFEUCGU CGDH BH UCF JVYYFAU _FGJF JBY_Z G__YB_YMGUMBAZ$ %9??LMDDMBA$ IF EMXFYUFE UB HVAE XH_!#i- Gddbjgumba bh Hvaez, Abu lbyf ucga 7? pfyjfau bh ucf glbvauz gppybpymgufe pvyzvgauub zvizfjumba #g- lg} if fspfaefe hby ucf gelmamzuygumxf jbzuz bh ucf Vamufe ZugufzGkfaj} hby Maufyagumbagd Efxfdbplfau ub lgagkf ucf Xh_ _ybkygl!

Gppfaems> Gagd}zmz bh _fgjf Jbypz 9?77 [cmzudf Idb{fy _bdmj}

Ucf zglf eg} bh ucf gmymak bh ucf GIJ 9?"9? fspbzf bh ucf lvyefy bh g Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyi} _fgjf Jbypz zughh ma Ifama$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz mzzvfe muz hmyzu yvdfz yfkgyemak Xbdvauffy {cmzudfidb{fy!7: G jbp} bh ucfzf af{ yvdfz mz pymaufe ifdb{! Ucmz gagd}zmz zcb{z ucgu ucf yvdfz{cmjcgppfgy gz glfaelfauz ub ucf _fgjf Jbypz Lgavgdgyf agyyb{ gae {fg` gae jbahmylz ucf xmf{ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz yflgmaz cbzumdf ub flpb{fymak Xbdvauffyz gae ucgu bad} {muc ucf fagjulfaubh dfkmzdgumba jga Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz yfjfmxf ucf pybufjumba gae yfzpfju ucgu ucf} efzfyxf!Mu mz jdfgy ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz maufaez ub vzf ucfzf af{ glfaelfauz ub ucf Lgavgd gz gagykvlfau gkgmazu fagjulfau bh dfkmzdgumba lgaegumak ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz pybufju ucfjbahmefaumgdmu} bh Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz gae kmxf ucfl pybufjumbaz gkgmazu yfugdmgumba! Ivu$ mhucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz hmagdd} gj`ab{dfekfe ucgu Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz efzfyxf pybufjumba$ mu

zvyfd} cgz ab gykvlfau dfhu gkgmazu ucf Jbakyfzz fazvymak ucgu ucfzf pybufjumbaz ifjblf gpfylgafau fdflfau bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz Gju gae jvduvyf!

G! Af{ _fgjf Jbypz Yvdfz Yfkgyemak [cmzudf Idb{fyz

7: Ucf _fgjf Jbypz gppgyfaud} jdgmlz ucf umlmak bh ucf af{ yvdf ba ucf eguf bh ucf 9?"9? fspbzfmz g jbmajmefajf!


22/37

99

Ba Ngavgy} 75$ 9?77 ucf _fgjf Jbypz Bhhmjf bh Zghfu} gae Zfjvymu} gae Bhhmjf bh KdbigdBpfygumbaz #BZZ"BKB- pyblvdkgufe ga glfaelfau ub ucf _fgjf Jbypz Lgavgd yfkgyemakcgaedmak bh Xbdvauffy " Uygmaff Gddfkgumbaz! Ucf glfaelfau hbjvzfz ba lmzjbaevju$

lmzlgagkflfau$ by xmbdgumbaz bh dg{ by pbdmj} i} _fgjf Jbypz zughh by jbauygjubyz by majbaafjumba {muc _fgjf Jbypz pybkyglz by bpfygumbaz0 gae ba ucf cgaedmak bh gddfkgumbaz by bucfy

jbajfyaz bh Xbdvauffyz by Uygmaffz gibvu ucf jbaevju bh cbzu jbvauy} agumbagdz {cb gyf abu_fgjf Jbypz zughh yfkgyemak ifcgxmby gae bucfy lguufyz ucgu gyf if}bae ucf dfkgd nvymzemjumba bh_fgjf Jbypz! Ucf glfaelfau kmxfz Xbdvauffyz ucf ymkcu ub yfpbyu xmbdgumbaz ub ucf _fgjf Jbypz

Bhhmjf bh Mazpfjuby Kfafygd! Ucf glfaelfau zugufz ucgu Ga} _fgjf Jbypz zughh lflify {cbyfjfmxfz by cgz `ab{dfekf bh g X"U gddfkgumba by jbajfya lvzu uyfgu ucf mahbylgumba {muc ucfvulbzu emzjyfumba gae jbahmefaumgdmu} gae gppybpymguf lfgzvyfz lvzu if ug`fa ub fazvyf ucf

X"Uz zghfu} Pgae mh\ ucfyf mz ga} vajfyugmau}$ mu mz jymumjgd ucgu lgagkfyz fyy ba ucf zmef bh jgvumbagae ug`f fxfy} lfgzvyf ub fazvyf X"U zghfu}! Ucf glfaelfau gdzb zugufz ucgu Ab _fgjf Jbypz

zughh pfyzba lg} yfugdmguf ma ga} lgaafy gkgmazu g X"U ifjgvzf ucf X"U yfpbyufe ga gddfkgumba byjbajfya vaefy ucmz zvizfjumba!

Ucf af{ Lgavgd glfaelfau zvpfyzfefz g Lgyjc 9;$ 9??= lflb bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz Bhhmjf bhKfafygd Jbvazfd yfkgyemak Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz!75 Ucf BKJ lflb mz abu ga bhhmjmgdgkfaj} yvdf! Ufjcamjgdd}$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz ebfz abu mzzvf yvdfz ma jblpdmgajf {muc ucfGelmamzuygumxf _ybjfevyf Gju #G_G-$ {cmjc yfwvmyfz gkfajmfz ub pvidmzc ucfmy pybpbzfe yvdfz gzeyghuz ifhbyf ucf} ug`f fhhfju$ zbdmjmu pvidmj jbllfau ba ucfl$ kmxf ucf pvidmj gjjfzz ub ucfyvdflg`mak yfjbye zb mu jga gagd}~f ucf eyghu yvdf$ gagd}~f gae yfzpbae ub ucf pvidmj jbllfauzifhbyf hmagdm~mak ucf yvdf$ gae pvidmzc g jblpdfuf yfjbye bh ucf igzmz hby ucf yvdf ucgu lg} ifzvinfju ub nvemjmgd yfxmf{! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz Lgavgd mz ucf _fgjf Jbypz fwvmxgdfau bh {cgu hbyfxfy} bucfy gkfaj} gyf yvdfz! Vaefy ucf G_G$ mu jga ug`f g }fgy by fxfa lga} }fgyz ub

75 Ucf BKJ lflb {gz mzzvfe gibvu u{b {ff`z ghufy @guf _v~f} {gz lvyefyfe gae mu jbxfyzCgaedmak bh Xbdvauffy"Uygmaff Gddfkgumbaz! Ucf pvypbzf bh ucf _J BKJ maufyml pbdmj}zuguflfau {gz ub zfu bvu fspdmjmud} _fgjf Jbypz pbdmjmfz hby cgaedmak gddfkgumbaz i} g Xbdvauffyby Uygmaff bh lmzjbaevju$ lmzlgagkflfau$ by xmbdgumbaz bh dg{ by pbdmj}! Ucf lflb zugufz ucgu

ucf Xbdvauffyz"Uygmaffz lvzu if mahbylfe ucgu ucf} zcbvde yfpbyu ub ucf Bhhmjf bh Mazpfjuby

Kfafygd #BMK- ga} gjumxmu} {cmjc ucf} yfgzbagid} ifdmfxf jbazumuvufz g xmbdgumba bh hfefygd dg{$yvdf$ by yfkvdgumba0 lmzlgagkflfau0 zfymbvz lmzjbaevju0 kybzz {gzuf bh hvaez0 givzf bhgvucbymu}0 by g zvizugaumgd gae zpfjmhmj egakfy ub ucf pvidmj cfgduc gae zghfu} yfdgumak ub ucfpybkyglz gae bpfygumbaz bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz! Mu zugufz ucgu #g- Xbdvauffyz"Uygmaffz lg} gdzbyfpbyu zvjc gddfkgumbaz ub zfamby zughh gu pbzu by ub ucf gppybpymguf Yfkmbagd Emyfjuby0 #i- Ga}

_fgjf Jbypz zughh lflify yfjfmxmak ga gddfkgumba hybl g X"U lvzu uyfgu ucf mahbylgumba {muc ucfvulbzu emzjyfumba gae jbahmefaumgdmu} jbazmzufau {muc gppybpymguf cgaedmak bh ucf gddfkgumba gaegppdmjgidf dg{$ majdvemak {cfyf gppybpymguf$ yfhfyygd ub ucf BMK by bucfy dfkgd gvucbymumfz0 #j-Ab _fgjf Jbypz zughh pfyzba lg} yfugdmguf ma ga} lgaafy gkgmazu g X"U ifjgvzf ucf X"Uyfpbyufe ga gddfkgumba vaefy ucmz zvizfjumba gducbvkc mu jgvumbaz ucgu Abucmak ma ucmz M_Z

zcbvde if jbazuyvfe ub fsflpu g X"U hybl ucf yfwvmyflfau ub ifcgxf ma gjjbyegajf {muc LZ 9?5Xbdvauffy Jbaevju0 Gdd gddfkgumbaz i} X"Uz {mdd if kmxfa zfymbvz jbazmefygumba gae yfxmf{ gae

{mdd if cgaedfe gae yfzbdxfe by emzpbzfe bh$ gz gppybpymguf$ i} lgagkflfau gae"by ucf BMK0

gae #f-Igzfe vpba ucf aguvyf bh ucf gddfkgumbaz gae ucf ubugdmu} bh gxgmdgidf hgjuz$ gppybpymguflfgzvyfz lvzu if ug`fa ub fazvyf ucf X"U+z zghfu}!


23/37

9:

pyblvdkguf g hmagd yvdf! Ivu$ ifjgvzf ucf _fgjf Jbypz ebfz abu jblpd} {muc ucf G_G$ mu jgajcbbzf ub glfae ucf Lgavgd ma g lguufy bh eg}z! Ucf BKJ lflb jdfgyd} cgz g lvjc db{fyzuguvz ucga ga glfaelfau ub ucf _fgjf Jbypz Lgavgd! Ba Lgyjc 7?$ 9?7?$ g }fgy ghufyucf BKJlflb cge iffa mzzvfe$ {f hmdfe g HBMG yfwvfzu {gz hmdfe {muc ucf _fgjf Jbypz yfwvfzumak_ybjfevyfz hby _fgjf Jbypz {cmzudf idb{fyz$ majdvemak pybjfevyfz hby pyfzfyxmak ucfmy ymkcu ub

jbahmefaumgdmu}$ hby pybufjumak ucfl gkgmazu yfugdmgumba gae hby maxfzumkgumak ucfmyyfpbyuz"jblpdgmauz gae Jbllvamjgumbaz ifu{ffa ucf _fgjf Jbypz gae ucf Bhhmjf bh _fyzbaafdLgagkflfau yfkgyemak {cfucfy Xbdvauffyz cgxf by jbvde if kygaufe {cmzudf idb{fy zuguvz vaefyucf Hfefygd {cmzudf idb{fy zuguvuf! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz hbvae ucgu ucfyf {fyf ab ebjvlfauz baucfzf u{b zvinfjuz$ zb fxfa ucf _fgjf Jbypz muzfdh zfflz ub cgxf abu iffa g{gyf bh g 9??= _JBKJ lflb! Gz ucf _fgjf Jbypz zfflz ub gj`ab{dfekf ma hgmdmak ub dbjguf ucf BKJ lflb mayfzpbazf ub bvy HBMG yfwvfzu$ ga BKJ lflb cgz g zvizugaumgdd} dfzzfy zuguvz ucga ucgu bh gLgavgd glfaelfau gae mz abu g pgyu bh ucf bhhmjmgd yvdfz bh ucf gkfaj}! Mh ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgeucbvkcu ucgu ucf zvinfju lguufy bh ucf BKL lflb {gz mlpbyugau$ mu zvyfd} {bvde cgxf lbxfefspfemumbvzd} ub majbypbyguf mu ma ucf _fgjf Jbypz Lgavgd! Ucgu ucmz bad} cgppfafe ba ucf eg} bhucf 9?"9? fspbzf jgzuz ebviu ba ucf mlpbyugajf ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz kmxfz ub pybufjumak {cmzudf

idb{fyz! Mu zfflz ub maemjguf ucgu kmxmak ucf gppfgygajf bh pybufjumak Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyzmz lbyf mlpbyugau ucga ucf yfgdmu} bh gjuvgdd} ebmak zb!

I! Umlmak bh Af{ _fgjf Jbypz Yvdfz Yfkgyemak [cmzudf Idb{fyz

Ma ufylz bh ucf umlmak bh ucf pbdmj} gaabvajflfau$ muz jdfgy ucgu mu {gz mzzvfe abu ifjgvzf bh ucfhgju ucgu @guf _v~f} {gz lvyefyfe ivu ifjgvzf bh ucf hgju ucgu ucf lvyefy {gz gibvu ub ucfzvinfju bh g 9?"9? fspbzf! Ma ucmz zfazf$ ucf pbdmj} gaabvajflfau mz ga bixmbvz pvidmj yfdgumbazpdb}! Ucf Hfefygd [cmzudf Idb{fy _ybufjumba Gju ifjglf dg{ ma 7=;3! Ma 9??; Zfaguby Ebeemauybevjfe dfkmzdgumba ub pybufju Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz ifdmuudfe$ bppbzfegae `mddfe ucfzf pybpbzgdz! Ma 9??= Zfaguby Ebee mauybevjfe dfkmzdgumba yfwvfzumak ucgu ucf _fgjfJbypz gzzfzz lfjcgamzlz hby zbdmjmumak ucf xmf{z bh Xbdvauffyz ba g jbahmefaumgd igzmz! Ucf

_fgjf Jbypz yfhvzfe ub eb zb ma muz Nvaf 9?7? jblpyfcfazmxf gzzfzzlfau!

J! Zvizugajf bh Af{ _fgjf Jbypz Yvdfz Yfkgyemak [cmzudf Idb{fyz

Kmxfa ucf _fgjf Jbypz cmzuby} bh cbzumdmu} ub Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz$ mu mz emhhmjvdu ub ifdmfxf

ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz mz ab{ jbllmuufe ub pybufjumak gae yfzpfjumak ucfzf Xbdvauffyz! Gagagd}zmz bh ucf zvizugajf bh ucf af{ pbdmj} jbahmylz ucmz xmf{!

7! Hby ucmyu},ucyff Hfefygd flpdb}ffz cgxf hmdfe {cmzudf idb{fy jblpdgmauz {muc ucf Bhhmjf bh_fyzbaafd Lgagkflfau #B_L-! Baf jga bad} if zvzpmjmbvz {c} ucf _fgjf Jbypz pybpbzfz ub zfuvp gabucfy gppybgjc {muc _fgjf Jbypz Xbdvauffyz ucgu ebfz abu pfylmu ucfl ub hmdf jblpdgmauz{muc ga gkfaj} maefpfaefau bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz! B_L mz ga fspfyu {muc yfkgye ub [I mzzvfz gaepybufjumak {cmzudf idb{fyz! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz bixmbvzd} mz abu ga fspfyu gae cgz zcb{a efjgefzbh cbzumdmu} ub Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz! [c} zcbvde Xbdvauffyz if hbyjfe ub hmdf ucfmyjblpdgmaz {muc ucfmy b{a gkfaj} ygucfy ucga ga maefpfaefau baf2


24/37

95

9! Mu gppfgyz ucgu _fgjf Jbypz zughh$ {cb gyf jbazmefyfe ub if uflpbygy} flpdb}ffz ifjgvzf bh

ucf hmxf,}fgy yvdf$ gyf abu jbxfyfe i} ucf Hfefygd [cmzudf Idb{fy zuguvuf$ zb ucf} zcbvde if kmxfa{cmzudf idb{fy ymkcuz$ abu nvzu Xbdvauffyz!

:! Ma pfylmuumak Xbdvauffyz ub iymak mzzvfz ub ucf _fgjf Jbypz Mazpfjuby Kfafygd #_J MK-$ ucf

af{ glfaelfau ebfz abucmak af{! Xbdvauffyz cgxf gd{g}z cge ucf ymkcu ub hmdf jblpdgmauz {mucucf _J MK! [f hmdfe lvdumpdf jblpdgmauz {muc ucf _J MK {cmdf {f {fyf zfyxmak gz Xbdvauffyz#9??6,9??;-! Zged}$ ma bvy jgzf$ ucf _J MK ubb` ab gjumbaz {muc yfkgyemak ub ucfzf jblpdgmauz!

5! Ucf af{ glfaelfau mz jbahvzmak ba baf jyvjmgd pbmau> {cb mz ucf dfgefy {mucma ucf _fgjfJbypz cmfygyjc} ma cgaedmak ucfzf gddfkgumbaz$ ucf _J MK by ucf BZZ2 Ucmz jbahvzmba mzvaefyzugaegidf kmxfa ucgu ucf yfzpbazmimdmu} bh ucf _J MK ub maxfzumkguf jymlfz gkgmazuXbdvauffyz {gz uygazhfyyfe ub ucf BZZbxfy ucf xbjmhfybvz binfjumbaz bh ucf _K MK! Mu gppfgyzucgu ucmz uygazhfy bjjvyyfe zb ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz jbvde lmamlm~f ucf ige pvidmjmu} ucgu gymzfzhybl xmkbybvzd} maxfzumkgumak ucfzf jymlfz! Zff guugjclfau hby ma efpuc emzjvzzmba bh ucmz mzzvf!Kmxfa ucmz cmzuby} bh ufazmbaz$ ucf pbdmj} zuguflfau zcbvde kvmegajf ba cb{ ucf _J MK gae BZZ

gyf zvppbzfe ub {by` ubkfucfy by emhhfyfaumguf ucfmy ybdfz gae yfzpbazmimdmumfz!

6! Ucmz jbahvzmba {mdd cgxf ga mlpgju ba Xbdvauffyz gz {fdd! Ucf} zcbvde if ubde fspdmjmud} ucguucfmy pymlgy} bidmkgumba gae bpumba mz ub iymak ucfmy jblpdgmauz ub ucf _J MK bhhmjf$ abu ucf BZZ!

8! Ma geemumba$ ucf af{ glfaelfau ebfz abu jdfgyd} yfgzzvyf Xbdvauffyz ucgu ucf _J MK bhhmjf mzibvae ub cgaedf ucfmy jblpdgmauz ba g jbahmefaumgd igzmz gae pybufju ucfl gkgmazu yfugdmgumba!

;! Ucf af{ glfaelfau ebfz abu kmxf ucf _J MK by ucf BZZ gvucbymu} ub maufyxfaf {muc bucfy_fgjf Jbypz zughh$ majdvemak Jbvauy} Emyfjubyz$ ub zvpfyxmzf ucfmy lgagkflfau bh Xbdvauffy{cmzudf idb{fyz$ ub emyfju ucgu ucf} ug`f gjumba ub pybufju ucf Xbdvauffyz$ ub ug`f pfyzbaafdgjumbaz {muc yfzpfju ub zughh zvinfju bh ucf jblpdgmauz$ by ug`f gjumbaz ub jbyyfju ucflmzlgagkflfau bh pybkyglz!

3! Ub if jdfgy$ gz g lguufy bh bykgam~gumbagd zuyvjuvyf$ mu lg`fz ab zfazf hby Xbdvauffyz ub iymakucf _J MK by BZZ ma ub geeyfzz fxfy} mzzvf bh lmzlgagkflfau!

=! Kmxfa ucf dbjgumba bh ucf _J MK gae BZZ$ mz mu abu dm`fd} ucgu ucf} {mdd if gidf ub gju ma gumlfd} lgaafy igzfe ba g jblpdfuf gae gjjvyguf vaefyzugaemak bh hgzu iyfg`mak efxfdbplfauz baucf kybvae giybge!

7?! Ucf af{ glfaelfau pvuz ucf bavz ba ucf Xbdvauffy ub ug`f gjumba ub hmdf jblpdgmauz!

77! Ucf af{ glfaelfau ebfz abu fzugidmzc g dmzufamak lfjcgamzl {cfyf ucf _fgjf Jbypzybvumafd} zbdmjmuz ucf xmf{z bh Xbdvauffyz ba g jbahmefaumgd igzmz! Ucmz mz ucf jbyf zuygufk} bhZfaguby Ebeez _fgjf Jbypz Xbdvauffy Flpb{fylfau Gju bh 9??;!

79! Ucmz lfgaz ucgu ucf af{ _fgjf Jbypz pbdmj} {mdd ufae ub pbzupbaf mefaumhmjgumba bh pybidflzvaumd ucf} yfgjc ucf jymzmz zugkf!


25/37

96

7:! Ucf af{ glfaelfau mz dm`fd} ub if maufypyfufe i} Xbdvauffyz gz gppd}mak bad} ub jymlmagd bybucfy fsuygbyemagymd} vapybhfzzmbagd jbaevju bh zughh!

75! Ucf Xbdvauffyz gyf abu dm`fd} ub ucma` ucgu ucf af{ glfaelfau gppdmfz ub ybvumaf jblpdgmauzgibvu pybkyglz$ uygmamak$ zmufz$ zvppbyu gae ucf bucfy mzzvfz ucgu ghhfju ucf Xbdvauffyz

pfyhbylgajf!

76! Ucf af{ glfaelfau zpfjmhmfz ab pfagdumfz by jbazfwvfajfz ub if mlpbzfe ba ucf _J MK$BZZ by bucfy zughh {cb xmbdguf ucf pbdmj} yfkgyemak jbahmefaumgdmu} gae yfugdmgumba!

78! Ucf af{ glfaelfau majdvefz ab ymkcuz by yflfemfz hby g Xbdvauffy {cbzf jbahmefaumgdmu} mzxmbdgufe by gkgmazu {cbl yfugdmgumba bjjvyz!

7;! Ucf _J MK bhhmjf cgz abu iffa gppybpymgufd} fspgaefe by uygmafe zb ucgu mu jga cgaedf ucfhmdmak bh ucfzf jblpdgmauz!

73! Ucf _J MK mz abu gppbmaufe i} ucf _yfzmefau gae jbahmylfe i} ucf Zfaguf! Ucf MK mzgppbmaufe i} ucf pbdmumjgd gppbmauffz gu ucf _fgjf Jbypz! Cf by zcf mz abu maefpfaefau bh ucfzfpbdmumjgd gppbmauffz!

7=! Ucf BZZ {gz zfu vp pyfjmzfd} ifjgvzf mu mz lgagkfe ucf gkfaj}z pbdmumjgd gppbmauffz! Ucmz mz

abu yfgzzvymak kmxfa ucf gkfaj}z dbak,ufyl cbzumdmu} ub Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz!

9?! Ucf af{ glfaelfau {gz abu mzzvfe ma jblpdmgajf {muc ucf Gelmamzuygumxf _ybjfevyf Gju${cmjc yfwvmyfz ucgu mu if pvidmzcfe hby jbllfau! Ifjgvzf mu mz abu ga G_G yvdf$ ucfyf mz abnvemjmgd yfxmf{ gxgmdgidf ub jcgddfakf mu!

97! Mu gppfgyz ucgu ucf af{ glfaelfau {gz pyblvdkgufe {mucbvu ga} mapvu hybl ucf Xbdvauffyz!

99! Ucf af{ glfaelfau mz xgdme bad} vaumd ucf _fgjf Jbypz glfaez by yfzjmaez mu! Muz abu

lgaegufe ma ucf _fgjf Jbypz Gju gae abu pfylgafau!

9:! Mu gppfgyz ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz cgz abu ug`fa zufpz ub mahbyl ucf Xbdvauffyz bh ucf af{glfaelfau by ub uygma ucfl ma muz mlpdflfaugumba!

Gdd ma gdd$ muz jdfgy ucgu ucf af{ glfaelfau mz agyyb{$ {fg` gae jvlifyzblf! Ucmz mz abu

zvypymzmak kmxfa ucgu ucf af{ glfaelfau {gz gebpufe vaefy evyfzz gae abu evf ub g jcgakf bhcfgyu gu ucf gkfaj} yfkgyemak Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz! Mu mz jdfgy ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz maufaezub vzf ucmz af{ glfaelfau gz ga gykvlfau gkgmazu fagjulfau bh dfkmzdgumba lgaegumak ucgu ucf_fgjf Jbypz pybufju ucf jbahmefaumgdmu} bh Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz gae kmxf ucfl pybufjumbazgkgmazu yfugdmgumba!

E! Dfkmzdgumxf _ybpbzgdz Yfkgyemak _ybufjumbaz bh _fgjf Jbypz [cmzudf Idb{fyz

Ma 9??; Zfaguby Ebee mauybevjfe dfkmzdgumba ub lgaeguf ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz fzugidmzclfjcgamzlz hby zbdmjmumak ucf xmf{z bh Xbdvauffyz yfkgyemak _fgjf Jbypz zughh gae pybkyglz! Mu


26/37

98

gdzb kgxf Xbdvauffyz {cmzudf idb{fy zuguvz vaefy ucf Hfefygd [cmzudf Idb{fy Gju bh 7=;3! Ucmzgppybgjc mz hgy pyfhfygidf ub ucf af{ _fgjf Jbypz Lgavgd glfaelfau gae ucmz lgaeguf {bvdefazvyf ucgu jbahmefaumgdmu} gae pybufjumbaz ifjblf g pfylgafau hfguvyf bh ucf _fgjf Jbypzjvduvyf! Ucmz pbmau bh xmf{ mz emzjvzzfe ma efpuc ma ucf guugjclfauz!

Guugjcfe>Ngavgy} 75$ 9?77 BZZ"BKB Glfaelfau ub _fgjf Jbypz LgavgdLgyjc 9;$ 9??= _J BKJ LflbFsjfypu hybl Nvd} 95$ 9??= Jblpyfcfazmxf _fgjf Jbypz Yfhbyl _dga> _bmau

Zfxfauffa> Fazvyf _fgjf Jbypz Bhhmjf bh Mazpfjuby Kfafygd Gkgma Dfgez Maxfzumkgumbaz bhXmbdfau Jymlfz Gkgmazu Xbdvauffyz"Zughh

LZ 9;7 CGAEDMAK BH XBDVAUFFY"UYGMAFF GDDFKGUMBAZEguf> Ngavgy} 75$ 9?77Yfzpbazmidf Bhhmjf> Bhhmjf bh Zghfu} gae Zfjvymu} gae Bhhmjf bh Kdbigd BpfygumbazZvpfyzfefz> M_Z 7,?= :"9;"?=

7!? GVUCBYMU]Ucf _fgjf Jbypz Gju$ 99 V!Z!J! 96?: #i-0 Fsfjvumxf Byefy 797:; #7=;=-9!? _VY_BZFUcmz Lgavgd Zfjumba zfuz hbyuc _fgjf Jbypz pbdmjmfz ba ucf cgaedmak bh gddfkgumbaz i} Xbdvauffyzby Uygmaffz bh lmzjbaevju$ lmzlgagkflfau$ by xmbdgumbaz bh dg{ by pbdmj} i} _fgjf Jbypz zughhby jbauygjubyz by ma jbaafjumba {muc _fgjf Jbypz pybkyglz by bpfygumbaz0 gae ba ucf cgaedmak bhgddfkgumbaz by bucfy jbajfyaz bh Xbdvauffyz by Uygmaffz gibvu ucf jbaevju bh cbzu jbvauy}agumbagdz {cb gyf abu _fgjf Jbypz zughh yfkgyemak ifcgxmby gae bucfy lguufyz ucgu gyf if}bae ucfdfkgd nvymzemjumba bh _fgjf Jbypz!:!? _BDMJMFZ#g- Xbdvauffyz"Uygmaffz #X"Uz- lvzu if mahbylfe bh ucfmy ymkcuz gae _fgjf Jbypz fspfjugumbaz{muc yfzpfju ub iymakmak ub ucf guufaumba bh _fgjf Jbypz gddfkgumbaz bh lmzjbaevju$lmzlgagkflfau$ xmbdgumbaz bh dg{ by pbdmj} ucgu yfdguf ub _fgjf Jbypz zughh$ jbauygjubyz$pybkyglz$ gae bpfygumbaz!#i- X"Uz lvzu gdzb if mahbylfe ucgu ucf} lg} emzjvzz {muc _fgjf Jbypz zughh gddfkgumbaz byjbajfyaz ba ubpmjz by mzzvfz ucgu gyf if}bae ucf dfkgd nvymzemjumba bh _fgjf Jbypz$ zvjc gzifcgxmby i} g dbjgd agumbagd {muc {cbl ucf X"U cgz yfkvdgy jbaugju ivu {cb ebfz abu {by` hby_fgjf Jbypz by pgyumjmpguf emyfjud} ma g _fgjf Jbypz pybnfju by pybkygl!#j- X"Uz lvzu if pybxmefe bpfa gjjfzz gae gppybpymguf jcgaafdz ma {cmjc ub ygmzf ucf u}pfz bhgddfkgumbaz gae jbajfyaz yfhfyyfe ub ma zvizfjumbaz #g- gae #i- gibxf$ {muc ga vaefyzugaemak gaejbllmulfau ucgu ucfmy gddfkgumbaz gae jbajfyaz {mdd if kmxfa gppybpymguf guufaumba0 ucgu ab X"U{mdd if yfugdmgufe gkgmazu i} _fgjf Jbypz zughh hby iymakmak hbyuc gddfkgumbaz gae jbajfyaz0 gaeucgu lgagkflfau {mdd ug`f fxfy} zufp afjfzzgy} ub fazvyf ucf zghfu} bh ga} X"U!5!? MAZ_FJUBY KFAFYGD[muc yfzpfju ub ucf ymkcuz gae _fgjf Jbypz fspfjugumbaz yfhfyyfe ub ma Zfjumba : #g- gibxf$ X"Uzlvzu if mahbylfe ucgu ucf} zcbvde yfpbyu ub ucf Bhhmjf bh Mazpfjuby Kfafygd #BMK- ga} gjumxmu}{cmjc ucf} yfgzbagid} ifdmfxf jbazumuvufz #7- g xmbdgumba bh hfefygd dg{$ yvdf$ by yfkvdgumba0 #9-lmzlgagkflfau0 #:- zfymbvz lmzjbaevju0 #5- kybzz {gzuf bh hvaez0 #6- givzf bh gvucbymu}0 by #8- gzvizugaumgd gae zpfjmhmj egakfy ub ucf pvidmj cfgduc gae zghfu} yfdgumak ub ucf pybkyglz gae


27/37

9;

bpfygumbaz bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz! Zff LZ 387! Zvjc yfpbyuz {mdd if cgaedfe i} ucf BMK gz zfu hbyucma LZ 387!6!? CGAEDMAK GDDFKGUMBAZ GAE JBAJFYAZ#g- X"Uz lg} yfpbyu gddfkgumbaz gae jbajfyaz yfhfyyfe ub ma Zfjumba :!? ub zfamby zughh gu pbzu$ ucfgppybpymguf Yfkmbagd Emyfjuby$ Gzzbjmguf Emyfjuby hby Zghfu} gae Zfjvymu}$ Gzzbjmguf Emyfjuby hby

Kdbigd Bpfygumbaz$ by bucfy gppybpymguf bhhmjfy gu Cfgewvgyufyz!#i- Ga} _fgjf Jbypz zughh lflify {cb yfjfmxfz by cgz `ab{dfekf bh g X"U gddfkgumba byjbajfya lvzu uyfgu ucf mahbylgumba {muc ucf vulbzu emzjyfumba gae jbahmefaumgdmu} jbazmzufau {mucgppybpymguf cgaedmak bh zvjc mahbylgumba gae gppdmjgidf dg{$ majdvemak {cfyf gppybpymguf$yfhfyygd ub ucf BMK by bucfy dfkgd gvucbymumfz!#j- Igzfe vpba ucf aguvyf bh ucf gddfkgumbaz by jbajfyaz gae ucf ubugdmu} bh gxgmdgidf hgjuz$gppybpymguf lfgzvyfz lvzu if ug`fa ub fazvyf ucf X"Uz zghfu}! Mh ucfyf mz ga} vajfyugmau}$ mu mz

jymumjgd ucgu lgagkfyz fyy ba ucf zmef bh jgvumba gae ug`f fxfy} lfgzvyf ub fazvyf X"U zghfu}!#e- Ab _fgjf Jbypz zughh pfyzba lg} yfugdmguf ma ga} lgaafy gkgmazu g X"U ifjgvzf ucf X"Uyfpbyufe ga gddfkgumba by jbajfya vaefy ucmz zvizfjumba!#f- Gdd gddfkgumbaz by jbajfyaz mefaumhmfe i} X"Uz {mdd if kmxfa zfymbvz jbazmefygumba gae yfxmf{

gae {mdd if cgaedfe$ yfzbdxfe by emzpbzfe bh$ gz gppybpymguf$ i} lgagkflfau gae"by ucf BMK!#h- Abucmak ma ucmz Lgavgd Zfjumba zcbvde if jbazuyvfe ub fsflpu g X"U hybl ucf yfwvmyflfauz ubhbddb{ ucf yvdfz gae pbdmjmfz zfu hbyuc ma LZ 9?5 Xbdvauffy Jbaevju$ by ub pyfjdvef ucf _fgjfJbypz hybl ug`mak gppybpymguf gjumba gkgmazu pfyzbaz {cb `ab{makd} lg`f hgdzf zuguflfauz bygjjvzgumbaz8!? FHHFJUMXF EGUFUcf fhhfjumxf eguf mz ucf eguf bh mzzvgajf!

M_Z 7,?= , Cgaedmak bh Xbdvauffy"Uygmaff GddfkgumbazEguf> Lgyjc 9;$ 9??= Yfzpbazmidf Bhhmjf> Bhhmjf bh ucf Kfafygd JbvazfdMzzvgajf Lflb7!? _vypbzfUcf pvypbzf bh ucmz Maufyml _bdmj} Zuguflfau mz ub zfu bvu fspdmjmud} _fgjf Jbypz pbdmjmfz hbycgaedmak gddfkgumbaz i} g Xbdvauffy by Uygmaff bh lmzjbaevju$ lmzlgagkflfau$ by xmbdgumbaz bhdg{ by pbdmj}!9!? _bdmjmfz9!7 Xbdvauffyz"Uygmaffz #X"Uz- lvzu if mahbylfe ucgu ucf} zcbvde yfpbyu ub ucf Bhhmjf bhMazpfjuby Kfafygd #BMK- ga} gjumxmu} {cmjc ucf} yfgzbagid} ifdmfxf jbazumuvufz g xmbdgumba bhhfefygd dg{$ yvdf$ by yfkvdgumba0 lmzlgagkflfau0 zfymbvz lmzjbaevju0 kybzz {gzuf bh hvaez0 givzfbh gvucbymu}0 by g zvizugaumgd gae zpfjmhmj egakfy ub ucf pvidmj cfgduc gae zghfu} yfdgumak ub ucfpybkyglz gae bpfygumbaz bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz! Zff LZ 387 Bhhmjf bh ucf Mazpfjuby Kfafygd ! Zvjcyfpbyuz {mdd if cgaedfe i} ucf BMK gz zfu hbyuc ma LZ 387!9!9 #g- X"Uz lg} gdzb yfpbyu zvjc gddfkgumbaz ub zfamby zughh gu pbzu by ub ucf gppybpymguf YfkmbagdEmyfjuby!#i- Ga} _fgjf Jbypz zughh lflify yfjfmxmak ga gddfkgumba hybl g X"U lvzu uyfgu ucf mahbylgumba{muc ucf vulbzu emzjyfumba gae jbahmefaumgdmu} jbazmzufau {muc gppybpymguf cgaedmak bh ucfgddfkgumba gae gppdmjgidf dg{$ majdvemak {cfyf gppybpymguf$ yfhfyygd ub ucf BMK by bucfy dfkgdgvucbymumfz!


28/37


29/37

9=

jbzu! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz gae Wvmkdf} pyfzzfe bad} hby hvaemak hby fspgazmba! Ma Lgyjc bh 9?7?Dvedgl gae Cmyzjcbhh guuflpufe ub zfjvyf gebpumba bh ga glfaelfau ub Zfaguby Ebeez 9??=_fgjf Jbypz dfkmzdgumba ub pybxmef hby jbahmefaumgdd} gae pybufjumbaz ub Xbdvauffy {cmzudfidb{fyz! Gkgma$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz gae Wvmkdf} bppbzfe ucf lgaegufz gae `mddfe ucfl! Zb$ {cfa mujblfz ub ucfzf ub ucfzf jyvjmgd mzzvfz hby Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz$ ucfyf mz ab emhhfyfajf

ifu{ffa ucf Ivzc gae Biglg _fgjf Jbypz! Gu gdd umlfz$ ibuc ucf _fgjf Jbypz gae Wvmkdf} cgxfiffa bppbzfe ub flpb{fymak Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz nvzu gz Dvedgl gae Cmyzjcbhh cgxfgd{g}z pyfzzfe hby flpb{fymak ucfl gz ucfmy hmyzu yfhbyl pymbymu}!

Wvmkdf}z bppbzmumba ub ucf Ebee imdd mz fspdgmafe ma zfxfygd {g}z! Hmyzu$ ucf abumba bh ucfyf {gzga} affe hby yfhbyl ucf _fgjf Jbypz {gz vuufyd} majbazmzufau {muc ucf A_JG jglpgmka ub ebvidfucf avlify bh Xbdvauffyz! Zb$ abu g {bye gibvu yfhbyl {gz zgme evymak ucf Lbyf _fgjf Jbypzjglpgmkag jbazjmbvz pbdmj} jcbmjf! Abu g {bye gibvu ucf :?,:6& bh ucf Xbdvauffyz {cb gyfwvmuumak fgyd}$ g jbzud} gae fligyygzzmak zjgaegd! Abu g {bye gibvu ucf _fgjf Jbypz d}mak gibvuucf FU yguf! Abu g {bye gibvu ucf emzlgd yfzvduz bh ucf gkfaj}z zvyxf}z bh ucf Xbdvauffyz

yfkgyemak gkfaj} pybkyglz gae lgagkflfau! Abu g {bye gibvu ucf xmf{z bh ucf Xbdvauffyz {cb

zg} ma ucfzf zvyxf}z ucgu ucf} zvppbyu yfhbyl bxfy fspgazmba i} 9!6 ub 7! Abu g {bye ucguXbdvauffyz ma g eb~fa jbvauymfz yfjbllfaefe ucgu ucf pybkygl ma ucfmy jbvauy} if zcvuufyfe! Abug {bye gibvu ucf hgju ucgu fzzfaumgdd} 7??& bh ucf gppdmjgauz {cb zvyxmxf ucf lfemjgd zfdfjumbapybjfzz gyf maxmufe ub uygmamak$ zb ucfyf mz ab zvypdvz bh gppdmjgauz!

Ucf A_JGz Af{ ]by` jbahfyfajf ub `mj` bhh ucf jglpgmka {gz hbjvzfe zb ucgu abu g {bye

{bvde if zgme gibvu ucf pfaemak Ebee _fgjf Jbypz yfhbyl imdd gducbvkc Dvedgl pfyzvgefe ImddNbzfpczba ub hbjvz ba mu ma cmz `f}abuf geeyfzz! Wvmkdf} ufagjmbvzd} pvzcfe ucf ZfyxmjfAgumbajbgdmumba ub faebyzf bad} ga fspgazmba bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz$ ivu Dvedgl pfyzvgefe ucf kybvp ubfaebyzf ibuc fspgazmba gae yfhbyl! Wvmkdf}z Iybb`makz _bdmj} Iymfh bh Zfpuflify 9??3 pvzcfz

bad} hby fspgazmba gae lg`fz ab lfaumba bh yfhbyl![cgu {f zff cfyf mz g lgamgjgd jbazmzufaj} hybl A_JG ma hbjvzmak ba wvgaumu} bxfy wvgdmu}!Jfyugmad} ucfyf {gz ab lfaumba bh ucf affe ub flpb{fy Xbdvauffyz ub yfzpbae ub ucf kybzzlmzlgagkflfau bh ucf gkfaj} gae ab lfaumba bh ucf cmkc cgaefe uyfgulfau bh ucf Xbdvauffyz$fzpfjmgdd} {cmzudf idb{fyz!

Zfjbae$ Wvmkdf}z lbumxgumba ma `mddmak ucf Ebee yfhbyl imdd gppgyfaud} zufllfe hybl cmz efzmyf

ub gxbme ga} hymjumba {muc ucf _fgjf Jbypz$ {cmjc imuufyd} yfzfaufe ga} lfaumba bh yfhbyl! Ucfjbazfwvfajf bh ga} zvjc hymjumba {gz lgef pgmahvdd} jdfgy ub Wvmkdf} ma Efjflify 9??; {cfaucf _fgjf Jbypz ucyfgufafe ub jgajfd muz zvizjympumba ub A_JGz hdgkzcmp pvidmjgumba [bydeXmf{mh A_JG eme abu kmxf ucf _fgjf Jbypz ga bppbyuvamu} ub yfxmf{ ucf gyumjdfz ub lg`fzvyf ucgu ucf} eme abu bhhfae ucf _fgjf Jbypz$ f!k! eme abu majdvef gyumjdfz ucgu jymumjm~felgagkflfau by gexbjgufe yfhbyl! Ucf _fgjf Jbypz cge iffa pvyjcgzmak jbpmfz bh ucfpvidmjgumba ub emzuymivuf ub gdd bh ucf Xbdvauffyz ma ucf hmfde! Mh mu eme abu zvizjymif ub ga mzzvf$ ucfhmagajfz hby [bydeXmf{ {bvde mllfemgufd} jbddgpzf gae A_JG {bvde affe ub zvzpfaepvidmjgumba! Ucf gyumjdf ucgu dfe ub ucf _fgjf Jbypz eflgae gae ucyfgu {gz ga gyumjdf gppybxfe ubif pvidmzcfe i} ucf eb~fa,}fgy [bydeXmf{ femuby$ Egxf Gyabde$ i} Dvedgl gae Cmyzjcbhhjgddmak hby _fgjf Jbypz yfhbyl$ majdvemak pybufjumba hby Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz! Zb$jblpyblmzmak ucf femubymgd maefpfaefajf bh [bydeXmf{ gae ucf maefpfaefajf bh A_JG$Wvmkdf} efhdfjufe ucf _fgjf Jbypz eflgae i} jgajfddmak ucf bhhfaemak gyumjdf! Ucf majmefau


30/37

:?

jbahmylfe ucf A_JG gz ucf dgpebk bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz lgagkflfau gae jbahmylfe ucgu A_JGz

cmkcfzu pymbymu} mz pyfzfyxmak muz hmagajmgd zvppbyu hybl ucf _fgjf Jbypz$ abu pybufjumak Xbdvauffy{cmzudf idb{fyz dm`f @guf _v~f}!

Ucf jbazfwvfajfz bh ucf nbmau bppbzmumba bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz gae Wvmkdf} ub flpb{fymak

Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz mz uygazpgyfaud} jdfgy! Cge ucf 9??; dfkmzdgumba iffa fagjufe bxfy ucfbinfjumbaz bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz gae Wvmkdf}$ @guf _v~f} lmkcu {fdd if gdmxf ubeg}! Ucfmyzvjjfzzhvd bppbzmumba ub ucf 9??; Ebee imdd pybufjumbaz hby {cmzudf idb{fyz pybxfe ub if dfucgd ub@guf!

I} mkabymak @gufz lvyefy gae {cmzudf idb{fy mzzvfz ma ucfmy fsjcgakf bh dfuufyz$ ucf _fgjf

Jbypz gae A_JG mlpd} ucgu ucfyf gyf ab pbdmj} mzzvfz gzzbjmgufe {muc cfy efguc! Ucf} mlpd} ucguucf majmefau mz fspdgmafe zbdfd} gz ucf efygakfe gjumbaz bh g ybkvf _fgjf Jbypz zughhfy ma Ifama!Ivu$ mu {gz ucf pbdmj} pbzmumbaz bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz gae A_JG yfkgyemak {cmzudf idb{fyz ucgu gyfnvzu gz yfzpbazmidf hby cfy efguc!

[muc ucmz igj`kybvae mu ifjblfz bixmbvz {c} ucfzf ucf @guf _v~f} jgzf gae ucf pbdmj} mzzvfzgzzbjmgufe {muc mu {fyf abu geeyfzzfe ma ucf fsjcgakf bh dfuufyz ifu{ffa A_JG gae ucf _fgjfJbypz! Ucfmy nbmau gae zjgaegdbvz cmzuby} bh bppbzmumba ub pybufjumak Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyzlg`fz mu fzzfaumgd hby ucfl ub gxbme ga} emzjvzzmba bh cb{ _fgjf Jbypz zughh jglf ub lvyefy@guf!

Ucmz zmdfajf mz pgyumjvdgyd} bvuygkfbvz kmxfa ucgu flpb{fymak Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fy mz jdfgyd}yfdfxgau ub ucf mzzvf geeyfzzfe ma ucf u{b dfuufyz$ zfsvgd gzzgvduz ba Xbdvauffyz! Ucfyf gyf jgzfzbh _fgjf Jbypz zughh zfsvgdd} cgygzzmak Xbdvauffyz! Ucfyf gyf jgzfz {cfyf _fgjf Jbypz zughhcgxf iffa maemhhfyfau ub ucyfguz ub Xbdvauffyz! Gae _fgjf Jbypz pbdmjmfz ub{gyez gzzgvdu gae ygpfxmjumlz cgxf iffa vuufyd} vapybhfzzmbagd gae cvyuhvd ub ucf xmjumlz! Gdd bh ucfzf pybidflz {bvdeif lbyf fhhfjumxfd} geeyfzzfe mh ucf jbahmefaumgdmu} bh Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz {gz pybufjufegae ucf} {fyf pybufjufe gkgmazu yfugdmgumba! [mucbvu ucfzf pybufjumbaz$ Xbdvauffyz gyf yfdvjugau ubzpfg` bvu gae ucbzf {cb eb gyf ybvumafd} mkabyfe$ cgygzzfe$ by GelmaZfppfe!Yfjfau efxfdbplfauz lg`f mu jdfgy ucgu ucf _fgjf Jbypz bppbzmumba ub flpb{fymak Xbdvauffy{cmzudf idb{fyz jbaumavfz gae mz mlpdgjgidf! Ucf 9??= Ebee imdd #Z! 7:39-gz yfpbyufe hbylucf Zfaguf Hbyfmka Yfdgumbaz Jbllmuuff#cuup>""{{{!kbxuygj`!vz"jbakyfzz"imddufsu!spe2imdd


31/37

:7

Ub if zvyf$ Ebeez 9??= jgdd hby g _fgjf Jbypz gzzfzzlfau bh ucf {cmzudf idb{fy mzzvfz mz guymxmgd kfzuvyf jblpgyfe ub ucf pybxmzmbaz bh Ebeez 9??; imdd ucgu lgaegufe ucgu ucf _fgjf

Jbypz zfu vp ucfzf dmzufamak lfjcgamzlz gae pybufju Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz! Ivu cf emeeflgae ga gzzfzzlfau!

Ma Nvaf bh 9?7?$ yfzpbaemak ub ucf Ebee yfwvfzu$ ucf _fgjf Jbypz mzzvfe muz jblpyfcfazmxfgzzfzzlfau! Abu zvypymzmakd}$ ucf gzzfzzlfau hgmdz ub lfaumba ucf jbajfpu bh {cmzudf idb{fyjbahmefaumgdmu}! Mu hgmdz ub lfaumba ucf {bye {cmzudf idb{fy by emzjvzz pybufjumba bh

Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz!

Ucf geglgau yfhvzgd bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz fxfa ub gzzfzz pybufjumbaz hby Xbdvauffyz dm`f @guf_v~f} zcb{z ucf jbauflpu bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz ub Xbdvauffy {cmzudf idb{fyz! Fxfa {cfa ucfJcgmylga bh ucf _fgjf Jbypz Zvijbllmuuff bh ucf Zfaguf Hbyfmka Yfdgumbaz Jbllmuuff$ ucfbad} Y_JX zfyxmak ma ucf Zfaguf$ yfwvfzuz ucmz gzzfzzlfau$ ucf gkfaj} yfhvzfz ub jblpd}!Affedfzz ub zg}$ A_JG cgz ygmzfe ab bin

Documents

Ludlam Hirschoff Statement for May 11 2011 Hearing of HFAC Peace Corps