Major Tillery Retaliation Lawsuit Complaint

7/23/2019 Major Tillery Retaliation Lawsuit Complaint

1/41

COURT OF COMMON PLEASCIVIL ACTIONSKUYKILL COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA

--------------------------------------------------------------------------MAJOR GEORGE TILLERY,

Plaintiff,

Vs.

JON !ET"EL, S#$%#ta%& 'f t(# )#*a%t+#nt 'fC'%%#$ti'ns JON KERESTES, S*#%int#n#nt,SCI Ma(an'& /REN)A TRITT, S*#%int#n#nt,

SCI F%a$01ill# GEORGE MILLER,)#*t&S*#%int#n#nt, SCI F%a$01ill# JENNIFER NE!/ERRY,A$tin2 S*#%int#n#nt3s Assistant )%. PAUL NOEL,)i%#$t'% 'f )OC M#i$al S#%1i$#s JON STEINART,C(i#f #alt( Ca%# A+inist%at'%, SCI Ma(an'& )%. J'(nLisia0 KAREN OLLY, RN VICKIE STANISEFSKI,F'%+#% C(i#f #alt( Ca%# A+inist%at'%, SCI F%a$01ill#)%. ARES PAN)YA Ma4'% MICAEL )AMORELt. CLARK Ms. GRIFFIN Ca*tain S. )O!NS SARONLU5UIS )ORINA VARNER, C(i#f G%i#1an$# Offi$#%,

)OC Offi$# 'f In+at# G%i#1an$#s an A**#als anRAN)ALL SEARS, )#*t& C'ns#l, )#*a%t+#nt 'f C'%%#$ti'ns

)#f#nants.---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

COMPLAINT

MAJOR GEORGE TILLERY,pro se AM 6789

SCI FRACKVILLE :::: Alta+'nt /l1.

F%a$01ill#, Pa :769;

)at#< Jana%& =, ;>:?

JURISDICTION AND VENUE


2/41

:. T(is is an a$ti'n f'% #$la%at'%&, in4n$ti1# an +'n#ta%& %#li#f f'% 1i'lati'ns

'f t(# Fi%st, Ei2(t( an F'%t##nt( A+#n+#nts t' t(# U.S. C'nstitti'n an

S#$ti'ns :, ;, 7 an :: 'f A%ti$l# I 'f t(# C'nstitti'n 'f t(# C'++'n@#alt( 'f

P#nns&l1ania *%sant t' ; USC B:689, ; Pa C'nst. Stat. ??>;#D$D:, an

1i'lati'ns 'f 't(#% P#nns&l1ania stat# la@.

;. T(is C'%t is t(# a**%'*%iat# 1#n# *%sant t' ;9: Pa Rl#s 'f Ci1il

P%'$#%# B:>>? #$as# t(# #1#nts an '+issi'ns 2i1in2 %is# t' t(# $as#s 'f

a$ti'n '$$%%# in S$(&l0ill C'nt&, P#nns&l1ania.

PARTIES

9. Plaintiff, MAJOR GEORGE TILLERY Plaintiff '% Till#%&D is a sit&-fi1#

a% 'l Af%i$an-A+#%i$an +an in$a%$#%at# in t(# $st'& 'f t(# P#nns&l1ania

)#*a%t+#nt 'f C'%%#$ti'ns )OCD, $%%#ntl& ('s# at SCI F%a$01ill#, ::::

Alta+'nt /l1, F%a$01ill#, PA :76;:.

. )#f#nant JON !ET"EL !#t#lD is S#$%#ta%& 'f t(# P#nns&l1ania

)#*a%t+#nt 'f C'%%#$ti'ns an is %#s*'nsil# f'% t(# $'nfin#+#nt, $a%# an

%#(ailitati'n 'f a**%'i+at#l& =:,>>> in+at#s at stat# $'%%#$ti'nal fa$iliti#s

fn# & t(# C'++'n@#alt( 'f P#nns&l1ania. As *a%t 'f (is '1#%all +ana2#+#nt

an '*#%ati'n 'f t(# #nti%# alt $'%%#$ti'ns s&st#+, t(# s#$%#ta%& i%#$tl&

s*#%1is#s t(# Offi$# 'f C(i#f C'ns#l, Offi$# 'f In+at# G%i#1an$# an A**#als,

Offi$# 'f S*#$ial In1#sti2ati'ns an Int#lli2#n$# an t(# Offi$# 'f M#i$al

2


3/41

S#%1i$#s. is a%#ss is< S#$%#ta%& J'(n !#t#l, )#*a%t+#nt 'f C'%%#$ti'ns, :6;>

T#$(n'l'2& Pa%0@a&, M#$(ani$s%2, PA :7>=>.

=. )#f#nant JON KERESTES K#%#st#sD is t(# S*#%int#n#nt at SCI

Ma(an'& an is %#s*'nsil# f'% t(# '1#%all '*#%ati'n 'f SCI Ma(an'& in$lin2

t(# @#ll-#in2 an (#alt( 'f ini1ials in$a%$#%at# t(#%#. )#f#nant K#%#st#s is

s# in (is ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s. is a%#ss is SCI Ma(an'&, 9>:

M'%#a R., F%a$01ill#, PA :769;.

?. )#f#nant /REN)A TRITT T%ittD is t(# S*#%int#n#nt at SCI F%a$01ill#.

)#f#nant T%itt is %#s*'nsil# f'% t(# '1#%all '*#%ati'n 'f SCI F%a$01ill# in$lin2

t(# @#ll-#in2 an (#alt( 'f ini1ials in$a%$#%at# at SCI F%a$01ill#. )#f#nant

T%itt is s# in (#% ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s. #% a%#ss is SCI F%a$01ill#,

:::: Alta+'nt /l1, F%a$01ill#, PA :769:.

7. )#f#nant GEORGE MILLER Mill#%D is )#*t& S*#%int#n#nt 'f

Fa$iliti#s Mana2#+#nt )SFMD at SCI F%a$01ill# an +a0#s #t#%+inati'ns 'n

in+at# 2%i#1an$#s as *a%t 'f t(# P%'2%a+ R#1i#@ C'++itt## PRCD. # is s# in

(is ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s. is a%#ss is SCI F%a$01ill#, ::::

Alta+'nt /l1, F%a$01ill#, PA :769:.

8. )#f#nant JENNIFER NE!/ERRY N#@#%%&D is a$tin2 S*#%int#n#nt3s

Assistant an Fa$ilit& G%i#1an$# C''%inat'% at SCI F%a$01ill#. S(# is s# in (#%

ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s. #% a%#ss is SCI F%a$01ill#, :::: Alta+'nt

/l1, F%a$01ill#, PA :769:.

6. )#f#nant )R. PAUL NOEL N'#lD is t(# )i%#$t'% 'f t(# /%#a 'f #alt(

3


4/41

Ca%# S#%1i$#s 'f t(# )OC. T(# /%#a 'f #alt( Ca%# S#%1i$#s is %#s*'nsil# f'%

t(# #li1#%& 'f all +#i$al an #ntal $a%# s#%1i$#s t(%'2('t t(# )OC.

)#f#nant N'#l is s# in (is ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s.is a%#ss is

)#*a%t+#nt 'f C'%%#$ti'ns, :6;> T#$(n'l'2& Pa%0@a&, M#$(ani$s%2, PA :7>=>

:>. )#f#nant JON STEINART St#in(a%tD is t(# C(i#f #alt( Ca%#

A+inist%at'% at SCI Ma(an'&. )#f#nant St#in(a%t is t(# 'ffi$ial @it( t(#

at('%it& t' ins%# t(at *%is'n#%s %#$#i1# +#i$al t%#at+#nt an +#i$al t#sts at

SCI Ma(an'&. )#f#nant St#in(a%t is s# in (is ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s.

is a%#ss is SCI Ma(an'&, 9>: M'%#a R., F%a$01ill#, PA :769;.

::. )#f#nant )%. JON LISIAK Lisia0D is a )'$t'% at SCI Ma(an'&.

)#f#nant Lisia0 is s# in (is ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s. is a%#ss is

SCI Ma(an'&, 9>: M'%#a R., F%a$01ill#, PA :769;.

:;. )#f#nant KAREN OLLY 'll&D is a n%s# at SCI Ma(an'&. )#f#nant

'll& is s# in (#% ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s. #% a%#ss is SCI

Ma(an'&, 9>: M'%#a R., F%a$01ill#, PA :769;.

:9. )#f#nant VICKIE STANISEFSKI Stanis(#fs0iD @as ntil 'n '% a't

N'1#+#% ;>:= @as t(# C(i#f #alt( Ca%# A+inist%at'% at SCI F%a$01ill#.

)#f#nant Stanis(#fs0i @as t(# 'ffi$ial @it( t(# at('%it& t' ins%# t(at *%is'n#%s

%#$#i1# +#i$al t%#at+#nt an +#i$al t#sts at SCI F%a$01ill#. )#f#nant

Stanis(#fs0i is s# in (#% ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s. #% last 0n'@n

a%#ss is SCI F%a$01ill#, :::: Alta+'nt /l1, F%a$01ill#, PA :769:.

:. )#f#nant )%. ARES PAN)YA Pan&aD is a )'$t'% at SCI F%a$01ill#.

4


5/41

)#f#nant Pan&a is s# in (is ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s. is a%#ss is

SCI F%a$01ill#, :::: Alta+'nt /l1, F%a$01ill#, PA :769:.

:=. )#f#nant Ma4. MICAEL )AMORE )a+'%#D is (#a 'f Unit

Mana2#+#nt at SCI Ma(an'&. # is s# in (is ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s.

is a%#ss is SCI Ma(an'&, 9>: M'%#a R., F%a$01ill#, PA :769;.

:?. )#f#nant Lt. CLARK Cla%0D is a s#$%it& 'ffi$#% at SCI Ma(an'&. # is

s# in (is ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s. is a%#ss is SCI Ma(an'&, 9>:

M'%#a R., F%a$01ill#, PA :769;.

:7. )#f#nant GRIFFIN G%iffinD is t(# Unit Mana2#% 'f )/ l'$0, SCI

Ma(an'&. S(# is s# in (#% ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s. #% a%#ss is SCI

Ma(an'&, 9>: M'%#a R., F%a$01ill#, PA :769;.

:8. )#f#nant Ca*tain S )O!NS )'@nsD is (#a 'f S#$%it&HInt#lli2#n$# at

SCI F%a$01ill#. # is s# in (is ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s. is a%#ss is

SCI F%a$01ill#, :::: Alta+'nt /l1, F%a$01ill#, PA :769:.

:6. )#f#nant SARON LU5UIS LisD is a #a%in2 Ea+in#% at SCI

F%a$01ill#. S(# is. #% a%#ss is SCI F%a$01ill#, :::: Alta+'nt /l1, F%a$01ill#,

PA :769:.

;>. )#f#nant )ORINA VARNER Va%n#%D is C(i#f G%i#1an$# Offi$#%, )OC

Offi$# 'f In+at# G%i#1an$#s an A**#als. S(# is s# in (#% ini1ial an 'ffi$ial

$a*a$iti#s. #% a%#ss is)#*a%t+#nt 'f C'%%#$ti'ns, :6;> T#$(n'l'2& Pa%0@a&,

M#$(ani$s%2, PA :7>=>.

;:. )#f#nant RAN)ALL SEARS, ES5. S#a%sD is )OC )#*t& C'ns#l an a

5


6/41

C(i#f #a%in2 Ea+in#%. # is s# in (is ini1ial an 'ffi$ial $a*a$iti#s. is

a%#ss is)#*a%t+#nt 'f C'%%#$ti'ns, :6;> T#$(n'l'2& Pa%0@a&, M#$(ani$s%2,

PA :7>=>.

INTRODUCTION

;;. T(is is a $i1il %i2(ts a$ti'n %'2(t & Ma4'% G#'%2# Till#%&, a ?= a%-'l

Af%i$an-A+#%i$an +an t' st'* an %#+#& %#taliati'n a2ainst (i+ f'% (is ##%$is#

'f (is Fi%st A+#n+#nt Ri2(ts. Till#%& @as s4#$t# t' n+#%'s %#taliat'%& a$ts

& t(# P#nns&l1ania )#*a%t+#nt 'f C'%%#$ti'ns an its #+*l'#s, in$lin2

+#i$al n#2l#$t an +#i$al +ist%#at+#nt, n4stifi# $#ll s#a%$(#s, t%ansf#% t'

an't(#% $#ll l'$0, l'ss 'f (is *%is'n 4' an *%#$i*it's t%ansf#% f%'+ SCI

Ma(an'& t' SCI F%a$01ill# an t(#n #in2 s#t-* @it( a fals# +is$'n$t an

2i1#n '1#% f'% +'nt(s in is$i*lina%& $st'& s'lita%& $'nfin#+#ntD. T(is

%#taliati'n @as int#n# t' *nis( an st'* Till#%& f%'+ filin2 2%i#1an$#s

$(all#n2in2 +#i$al n#2l#$t an +ist%#at+#nt 'f (i+s#lf an 't(#% *%is'n#%s,

in$lin2 t(# @#ll-0n'@n 4'%nalist an f'%+#% #at( %'@ *%is'n#% M+ia A-

Ja+al. T(is %#taliati'n @as *nis(+#nt f'% Till#%& $'ntinin2 t' *li$l& a1'$at#

f'% M+ia A-Ja+al, an t' *li$l& #*'s# t(# )OC3s n#2l#$t an +ist%#at+#nt

'f *%is'n#%3s +#i$al *%'l#+s as @#ll as t(# )OC3s %#taliati'n a2ainst Till#%&

an $'ntinin2 t' fil# 2%i#1an$#s '4#$tin2 t' t(#s# %#taliat'%& a$ti'ns & *%is'n

'ffi$ials.

6


7/41

;9. T(%'2('t (is '1#% t(i%t& a%s in *%is'n s#%1in2 a s#nt#n$# 'f lif# @it('t

*a%'l#, Till#%& (as $(all#n2# (is $'n1i$ti'n an s#nt#n$#, an n$'nstitti'nal

%#st%i$ti'ns 'n a$$#ss t' $'%ts, *%is'n $'niti'ns in$lin2 s#$%it& $lassifi$ati'n

an *la$#+#nt *%'$#%#s, +#i$al t%#at+#nt, an ('sin2 $'niti'ns 'n #(alf 'f

(i+s#lf an 't(#% *%is'n#%s. # @as (#l in s'lita%& $'nfin#+#nt in s*#%-+a

institti'ns in t(# f##%al an P#nns&l1ania *%is'n s&st#+s f'% '1#% t@#nt& 'f

t('s# a%s.

;. Until t(# s#t-* +is$'n$ts t(at Till#%& @as a$$s# 'f 'n A*%il 9>, ;>:=,

(# (a n#1#% (a a +is$'n$t f'% *'ss#ssi'n '% s# 'f a $'nt%'ll# sstan$# n'%

#1#n t#st# *'siti1# f'% i%t& %in# in (is '1#% t(i%t& a%s 'f i+*%is'n+#nt.

STATEMENT OF FACTS

Background:

;=. Till#%& @as t(# l#a *laintiff in Tillery v. Owens, a $lass a$ti'n la@sit fil#

Jl& ;9, :687, $(all#n2in2 t(# $'nstitti'nalit& 'f t(# $'niti'ns 'f $'nfin#+#nt at

t(# Stat# C'%%#$ti'nal Institti'n at Pitts%2( SCIPD l'$at# in Pitts%2(,

P#nns&l1ania. It sta%t# as apro sel#2al a$ti'n & Tilla%&. It %#slt# in an (ist'%i$

l#2al '%#% %#i%in2 %#+#iati'n 'f n$'nstitti'nal *%is'n $'niti'ns in$lin2

#fi$i#nt s#$%it&, fi%# *%'t#$ti'n, a$$#ss t' t(# $'%ts, '1#%-$%'@# ('sin2,

+#i$al $a%#, +#ntal (#alt( $a%# an #ntal s#%1i$#s. T(# )OC @as %#i%# t'

+a0# *%is'n %#n'1ati'ns $'stin2 +'%# t(an a +illi'n 'lla%s. See Tillery v. Owens,

7:6 F.S**. :;=?!.).Pa.:686D.

7
http://www.leagle.com/cite/719%20F.Supp.%201256http://www.leagle.com/cite/719%20F.Supp.%201256


8/41

;?. T(# PA )#*a%t+#nt 'f C'%%#$ti'ns )OCD a**#al# 'nl& t(# *a%t 'f t(#

)ist%i$t C'%t '%#% t' #n 'l#-$#llin2. T(# T(i% Ci%$it C'%t 'f A**#als

%l# t(at 'l#-$#llin2 in+at#s in an '1#%$%'@#, ila*iat# an nsanita%&

stat# *%is'n 1i'lat#s t(# Ei2(t( A+#n+#nt *%'(iiti'n 'n $%#l an nsal

*nis(+#nt. Tillery v. Owens, 6>7 F.; :8 9%Ci%. :66>D

;7. Till#%& %#+ains %#n'@n '% n't'%i'sD in t(# #s 'f t(# )OC as t(#

*%is'n#% %#s*'nsil# f'% Tillery v Owens. is *%is'n %#$'%s i#ntif& (i+ as a

f'%+#% l#a#% in t(# P(ila#l*(ia /la$0 Mafia an as 'n# @(' (as l#a#%s(i* an

infl#n$# in t(# *%is'n *'*lati'n. E(iit AD

;8. In t(# i++#iat# aft#%+at( 'f %i'ts at Ca+* ill an 't(#% *%is'ns in

O$t'#% :686, Till#%& @as s(i**# 't 'f P#nns&l1ania an t%ansf#%%# int' t(#

f##%al s&st#+, int' +ai++ s#$%it& an s'lita%& $'nfin#+#nt at L#a1#n@'%t(

an t(#n t(# s*#%-+a is'lati'n *%is'n at Ma%i'n, Ill. is *%is'n 4a$0#t fals#l&

stat# t(at Till#%& @as a *a%ti$i*ant in t(# Ca+* ill %i't an t(at (# (a 2an2

in1'l1#+#nt. E(iit /D

;6. T(is @as )OC %#taliati'n f'% Tillery v O@#ns sin$# Till#%& @as n't

in$a%$#%at# at Ca+* ill. Aiti'nall&, Till#%&3s PA In+at# Classifi$ati'n F'%+,

at# N'1#+#% :?, :686t(# a& #f'%# (is t%ansf#%2i1#s (i+ t(# #st

*'ssil# s$'%# ini$atin2 (is %#s*'nsil# #(a1i'%, an t(at (# @as a n'n-

*a%ti$i*ant in t(# *%is'n %i'ts. E(iit CD In Till#%&3s t(%## #$a#s 'f

in$a%$#%ati'n, (# (as n' +is$'n$ts as# 'n 2an2 affiliati'ns '% *%is'n#%

'%2aniin2.

8


9/41

9>. In t(# f'll'@in2 a%s, Plaintiff @as t%ansf#%%# #t@##n n+#%'s PA stat#

*%is'ns, in$lin2 t@' stints in t(# Ca+* ill S*#$ial Mana2#+#nt Unit SMUD

an t(#n t%ansf#%%# t' N#@ J#%s#& @(#%# (# s*#nt fi1# a%s in t(# N#@ J#%s#&

Stat# Mana2#+#nt C'nt%'l Unit MCUD in T%#nt'n. E(iit )D

9:. # @as a l#a *lantiff in Tillery v Hayman, $(all#n2in2 t(# '*#%ati'ns 'f

t(# NJ MCU. T(# in1#sti2ati'n int' (is s#$%it& stats an +is$'n$t %#$'%

#*'s# +lti*l# fals# %#*'%ts in (is PA *%is'n 4a$0#t. E(iit ED Till#%&3s 2''

$'n$t in t(# N.J. MCU #a%n# (i+ a %a%# t%ansf#% 't 'f a (i2(l& %#st%i$ti1#

$'nt%'l nit.

9;. On Ma%$( 6, ;>:> Plaintiff @as n#*#$t#l& t%ansf#%%# a$0 t'

P#nns&l1ania #$as# 'f Tillery v Hayman, @it('t (is l#2al *a*#%s an 't(#%

*%'*#%t&.

99. Inst#a 'f s#nin2 Plaintiff $l's# t' (is fa+il& in #ast#%n P#nns&l1ania, (#

@as i+*%is'n# in @#st#%n P#nns&l1ania at SCI F'%#st, a +ai++-s#$%it&

*%is'n, an i++#iat#l& *la$# 'n t(# R#st%i$t# R#l#as# List RLLD, a f'%+ 'f

in#finit# s'lita%& $'nfin#+#nt. E(iit FD Aft#% a f#@ +'nt(s, Till#%& @as

t%ansf#%%# t' SCI R#t%#at an *t in t(# ('l# t(#%#.

9. Fift&-nin# a%s 'l an aft#% fi1# $'ntin's a%s in s'lita%& $'nfin#+#nt,

Till#%& (a (i2( l'' *%#ss%#, #*is'#s 'f la'%# %#at(in2 an $(#st *ains,

%#+'1al 'f (is 2all la#%, a failin2 li1#% t(at %#i%# i+*lantati'n 'f an

int%a(#*ati$ st#nt, *''% $i%$lati'n, #2#n#%ati1# a%t(%itis in (is l#2, a$0 *ain an

9


10/41

nt%#at# #* C. F'% +#i$al %#as'ns (# (a ##n *%'1i# @it( an aiti'nal

+att%#ss, '%t('*#i$ s('#s, an a$0 %a$# as @#ll as +#i$ati'ns.

9=. A +#i$al #+#%2#n$& in S#*t#+#% ;>:> t(at %#i%# #+#%2#n$& s%2#%&

t' $l#a% a l'$0a2# in Till#%&3s li1#% st#nt s#nt (i+ t' t(# ('s*ital, an t(#n t' t(#

SCI )allas infi%+a%&. P%is'n 2a%s t'l (is fa+il& (# @as n#a% #at(.

9?. Plaintiff @as aft#%@a% t%ansf#%%# a$0 t' SCI R#t%#at, t(#n t' SCI

Pitts%2(, an t(#n a$0 t' SCI F'%#st.

97. Till#%& @as st%i**# 'f (is *#%s'nal *%'*#%t&, #ni# n#%$l't(#s an

'%t('*#i$ s('#s an (#l n#% $'niti'ns i#nti$al t' )is$i*lina%& Cst'&

stats, alt('2( (# (a n' +is$'n$ts.

98. /#$as# Till#%& @as a 0n'@n a1'$at# f'% *%is'n#%s3 +#ntal (#alt(

t%#at+#nt, (# @as a @itn#ss f'% *#titi'n#%s inDisability Rigts !etwork o" #$ v.

%on &et'el, fil# in Ma%$( ;>:9, a la@sit 'n t(# #ff#$t 'f ('sin2 in+at#s f'%

l'n2 t#%+ an @(at #ff#$ts t(at (as 'n t(# +#ntal stat# 'f l'n2ti+# *%is'n#% in t(#

R#st%i$ti1# 'sin2 Unit RUD.

96. As a %#slt, Plaintiff @as *la$# in t(# SCI F'%#st RLL st#*-'@n *%'2%a+

'n A*%il ;, ;>:9 in *%#*a%ati'n f'% a %#t%n int' 2#n#%al *'*lati'n. T(is in$l#

%#2la% *s&$('l'2i$al t%#at+#nt, t' (#l* @it( t(# #ff#$ts 'f l'n2ti+# *la$#+#nt in

s'lita%& $'nfin#+#nt. E(iit GD

>. Aft#% nin# $'ntin's a%s in s'lita%& $'nfin#+#nt, Till#%& @as %#l#as#

f%'+ a R#st%i$t# R#l#as# List RLLD St#* )'@n *%'2%a+ at SCI F'%#st. T(is

%#i%# a**%'1al 'f S#$%#ta%& 'f C'%%#$ti'ns J'(n !#t#l. Plaintiff (an3t (a a

10


11/41

+is$'n$t in #l#1#n a%s. Till#%& @as t%ansf#%%# t' SCI Ma(an'& 'n A*%il 9>,

;>:.

:. T(# S*#%int#n#nt at SCI Ma(an'&, J'(n K#%#st#s, (a ##n )#*t&

S*#%int#n#nt at SCI F%a$01ill# in Ma%$( ;>>; @(#n Till#%& @as i+*%is'n#

t(#%# an fals#l& a$$s# 'f '%2aniin2 in+at#s t' atta$0 2a%s. Alt('2( t(#%#

@as n' s$( '%2aniin2, Till#%& @as t%ansf#%%# t' t(# Ca+* ill S*#$ial

Mana2#+#nt Unit SMUD f'% nin# +'nt(s. Till#%& (a n' +is$'n$ts in t(#

Ca+* ill SMU.

;. Aft#% t@' @##0s in SCI Ma(an'& A+inist%ati1# Cst'&, 'n Ma& :,

;>:, Till#%& @as %#l#as# int' G#n#%al P'*lati'n an ('s# in $#lll'$0 )/.

9. Plaintiff @as t(#n a sit&-f'% a% 'l +an, a *%is'n#% f'% t(i%t& a%s, '1#%

;> a%s s*#nt in s'lita%& $'nfin#+#nt in n+#%'s *%is'ns in t(# PA an f##%al

s&st#+s. is +#i$al *%'l#+s $'ntin#< (i2( l'' *%#ss%#, la'%# %#at(in2

an $(#st *ains, a failin2 li1#%, *''% $i%$lati'n, #2#n#%ati1# a%t(%itis in (is l#2,

a$0 *ain an nt%#at# #*atitis C. # $'ntin# n##in2 an aiti'nal +att%#ss,

'%t('*#i$ s('#s, an a$0 %a$# as @#ll as +#i$ati'ns.

()ercise o" *irst $mendment Rigts at S+ -aanoy

. As a $'niti'n 'f t(# St#* )'@n P%'2%a+ an #nt%& int' 2#n#%al

*'*lati'n, $'nfin#+#nt, Till#%& @as s**'s# t' %#$#i1# +#ntal (#alt( aft#%$a%#,

t (is %##sts @#%# i2n'%# & Ms. G%iffin, (is nit +ana2#%, @(' in3t @ant

*%is'n#%s f%'+ RLL t' # $'+*lainin2 a't *%is'n $'niti'ns. Till#%& fil#

11


12/41

2%i#1an$# G% =;?8;, A2st ;, ;>: t' 'tain t(at @##0l& *s&$('l'2i$al

s#ssi'n. E(iit D

=. Till#%& sff#%# f%'+ $(%'ni$ $'2( an $(#st *ains. # fil# G%. =;6=7

A2st ;?, ;>: statin2 t(at (is $#ll (a ina#at# 1#ntilati'n nits, @it( n'n-

@'%0in2 #(ast 1#nts n' @in'@s. T(# la$0 'f +aint#nan$#, *%'*#% ai%

$i%$lati'n, a$t#%ia fn2s, +'l in t(# s('@#%s an $i2a%#tt# s+'0# $%#at#s a

(i2( %is0 'f illn#ss f'% t(# *%is'n#%s, #s*#$iall& t(# #l#%l& @(' a%# sff#%in2 f%'+

$(%'ni$ %#s*i%at'%& *%'l#+s. Citin2 Tillery v Owens, 7:6 F. S**. :;=? !.).

Pa. :686D. E(iit ID

?. )#f#nant Ma4'% Mi$(a#l )a+'%#, s*#%1isin2 all t(# nit +ana2#%s at SCI

Ma(an'&, a1is# Till#%& t' st'* filin2 2%i#1an$#s, t#llin2 (i+ t(at (# $'l #

2i1#n a *%is'n 4' as *##% s*#$ialist. )a+'%# sai t(at Till#%& $'l 2#t +'%#

'n# t(at @a& t(an & filin2 2%i#1an$#s.

7. Plaintiff @as s#l#$t# & )a+'%# t' # t%ain# in a s*#$ial )OC C#nt%al

Offi$# $lass t' #$'+# a P##% S*#$ialist, a t'* $#%tifi# *%is'n 4', @it( a t'*

*%is'n *a& s$al#. Till#%& $'l n't (a1# ##n $('s#n f'% t(is 4' nl#ss (is $'n$t

%in2 t(# St#* )'@n *%'2%a+ an @(il# in A+inist%ati1# Cst'& @as

#$#ll#nt. T(# *ai t%ainin2 *%'2%a+ t''0 *la$# '1#% t#n a&s, #i2(t-('%s a a&.

8. On N'1#+#% 7, ;>: (# %#$#i1# a C#%tifi$at# 'f A$(i#1#+#nt at SCI

Ma(an'& f'% t(is an #2an (is 4' as *##% s*#$ialist. E(iit JD Till#%& @as

*ai 7> +'nt( f'% t(is 4'.

12


13/41

6. Plaintiff3s @'%0 as *##% s*#$ialist %#i%# #in2 'n $all t@#nt&-f'%

('%s a a& t' assist a CO in (#l*in2 @it( a *%'l#+ @it( a *%is'n#% '% 't(#%@is#

assistin2 't(#% *%is'n#%s, *a%ti$la%l& t(# #l#%l& an +#ntall& ill. P##% s*#$ialists

+#t @it( )a+'%# an nit +ana2#%s 'n$# a +'nt( t' is$ss *%is'n#% *%'l#+s.

=>. In t(# latt#% *a%t 'f )#$#+#% ;>:, Till#%& #1#l'*# a s0in %as( $'1#%in2

(is l'@#% #t%#+iti#s an *%$(as# a (&%'$'%tis'n# $%#a+ f%'+ t(# *%is'n

$'++issa%& t' t%#at it.

=:. T(# %as( #$a+# @'%s# an Plaintiff @#nt t' si$0 $all an %#*'%t# t(at (#

an 't(#% *%is'n#%s (a #1#l'*# t(is %as( an (# #li#1# it @as $as# & a

a$t#%ia, *'ssil& in t(# @at#%. T(# *%is'n 2a%s %in0 'ttl# @at#%. Till#%& @as

2i1#n an't(#% $%#a+ f'% t%#at+#nt, t%ia+$in'l'n#, @(i$( is a st#%'i, als' $all#

a%ist'$'%t.

=;. On Jana%& 9:, ;>:=, Plaintiff fil# G%i#1an$# =67: #$as# t(# s0in

%as( $'1#%in2 (is l'@#% #t%#+iti#s @as %nin2 an *ainfl an int#%f#%# @it(

(is sl##*. Till#%& '4#$t# t' t(# la$0 'f ia2n'sis an i+*%'*#% t%#at+#nt. Till#%&

f%t(#% $'+*lain# t(at t(is %as( is an #*i#+i$ 'n ) l'$0 (alf 'f t(# in+at#s

a%# (a1in2 *%'l#+s @it( t(is %as(. E(iit KD

=9. An't(#% *%is'n#%, M+ia A-Ja+al AM 899=D, @as sff#%in2 f%'+ a

n'ti$#al& s*%#ain2 s#1#%# s0in %as(, %a*i @#i2(t l'ss an $(an2# in (is +ann#%

'f @al0in2 an $'n1#%sati'nal %#s*'ns#s. Till#%& %2# M+ia A-Ja+al t' s##0

+#i$al assistan$#.

13


14/41

=. On '% a't F#%a%& :8, ;>:= Plaintiff i%#$tl& a**%'a$(# SCI Ma(an'&

S*#%int#n#nt J'(n K#%#st#s an t'l (i+ t(at M+ia A-Ja+al l''0# as if (#

@as 2'in2 t' i# an n### t' # ta0#n t' t(# ('s*ital. S*#%int#n#nt K#%#st#s

t'l Till#%& t(at (# s('l +in (is '@n sin#ss an 4st ta0# $a%# 'f (i+s#lf.

Till#%& ans@#%# t(at ta0in2 $a%# 'f M+ia @as li0# ta0in2 $a%# 'f (i+s#lf an

M+ia A-Ja+al n### t' 2' t' t(# ('s*ital.

==. Plaintiff als' $'+*lain# t' K#%#st#s t(at 'l#% *%is'n#%s (a ##n 2i1#n

+is$'n$ts f'% +issin2 $'nt #$as# t(#& sl#*t t(%'2( $'nt. Till#%& als'

%#*'%t# t(# s*%#ain2 s0in $'niti'n in (is $#lll'$0 t(at @#nt nia2n's# an

nt%#at#. T(is a1'$a$& @as *a%t 'f Plaintiff3s 4' as a *##% s*#$ialist.

=?. Lat#% t(at a&, F#%a%& :8, ;>:= Lt. Cla%0 $'n$t# an in1#sti2ati1#

$#ll s#a%$( 'f Till#%&3s $#ll. T(is @#nt 'n f'% t@' ('%s, $asin2 (i+ t' +iss

inn#%. T(i%t& *a2#s 'f (is l#2al *a*#%s @#%# %#+'1# an (is $#ll @as l#ft in

s(a+l#s. Till#%& fil# G%i#1an$# ==>66 'n F#%a%& ;>, ;>:= $itin2

2'1#%n+#nt int#%f#%#n$#, & $'nfis$atin2 l#2al '$+#nts. A f#@ a&s lat#%

+'st 'f t('s# l#2al *a*#%s @#%# %#t%n#. E(iit LD

=7. T@' a&s lat#% )a+'%# #%at# MT f'% (a1in2 tal0# @it( K#%#st#s t#llin2

Till#%& t(at (# s('l (a1# 4st $'+# t' +#.

=8. On F#%a%& ;, ;>:=, Ka%#n 'll& RN #ni# G%i#1an$# =67:, fil#

'n Jana%& 9:, ;>:=, is*tin2 Plaintiff3s +#i$al %##sts an 's#%1ati'ns 'f a

%as( #*i#+i$ 'n ) l'$0, statin2 t(at s0in *%'l#+s @#%# n't t%#at# @it(

antii'ti$s an t(at (# s('l n't # i+*l&in2 t(at $'niti'ns at t(# institti'n

14


15/41

$as# (is s0in $'niti'n, asking im "or is proo". #+*(asis a#D On

inf'%+ati'n an #li#f antii'ti$s (a ##n is*#ns# f%'+ t(# infi%+a%& f'%

t%#at+#nt 'f 't(#% in+at#s f'% s0in %as(. Till#%& 2%i#1# K#ll&3s ('stil# %#s*'ns#

t s(# @as *(#l & St#in(a%t an K#%#st#s. E(iit MD

=6. On F#%a%& ;=, ;>:= Cla%0 s#a%$(# Till#%&3s $#ll a2ain an l#ft it a +#ss.

Aft#%@a%s, it @as sai t(at t(is @as & a$$i#nt.

?>. Unit Mana2#% G%iffin t(%#at#n# Till#%& @it( #si2nati'n as a Msli+

$'+atant if (# 0#*t filin2 2%i#1an$#s.

?:. )a+'%# +'1# Till#%& f%'+ $#lll'$0 )/ t' $#lll'$0 C/ at t(# 't(#% #n

'f t(# *%is'n, t#llin2 (i+ t(at (# @as +'1# t' 2i1# (i+ a n#@ sta%t.

?;. )a+'%# als' %#+'1# Plaintiff f%'+ (is 4' as a P##% S*#$ialist 4'

@it('t a (#a%in2. T(is @as *#naliati'n f'% ##%$is# 'f (is Fi%st A+#n+#nt

%i2(ts f'% a1'$atin2 f'% (i+s#lf an 't(#% *%is'n#%s. R#+'1in2 Till#%& f%'+ (is

4' als' %#slt# in a si2nifi$ant l'ss 'f *a&. Plaintiff fil# G%i#1an$# ===7=;.

E(iit ND

?9. On Ma%$( :>, ;>:= Cla%0 $'n$t# an't(#% $#ll s#a%$( all#2#l& %an'+D

t(at l#ft Till#%&3s $#ll in s(a+l#s. P#%s'nal *%'*#%t& @as ta0#n. Plaintiff fil#

G%i#1an$# ==?:;=, 9H:;H:=. E(iit OD

?. Till#%& fil# a $%i+inal $'+*laint a2ainst Cla%0 f'% t(#ft 'f (is *#%s'nal

*%'*#%t& an s+itt# it t' )a+'%#.

?=. Cla%0 t(%#at#n# Till#%& @it( $#ll s#a%$(#s @(#n#1#% (# @as 'n t& aft#%

9PM #$as# Till#%& (a fil# t(# stat# $(a%2#s a2ainst (i+.

15


16/41

??. Plaintiff $l#a%l& stat# in (is 2%i#1an$#s t(at t(# )OC (as t(# %i2(t t'

$'n$t $#ll s#a%$(#s t' s#a%$( f'% $'nt%aan t $'+*lain# t t(at t(#s#

s#a%$(#s @#%# $'n$t# t' #*%i1# (i+ 'f l#2al +at#%ials an t' (a%ass (i+.

?7. On inf'%+ati'n an #li#f, as# 'n $'++ni$ati'n #t@##n att'%n#&

Ra$(#l !'l0#nst#in @(' @as a$tin2 'n #(alf 'f Till#%&, an *%is'n 'ffi$ials an

)OC $'ns#l3s 'ffi$#, t(# 4stifi$ati'n f'% t(# $#ll s#a%$(#s @as t(at Till#%& is

#si2nat# an #s$a*# %is0 *%sant t' )C A)M 8>;.:.A.#.

?8. On Ma%$( ::, ;>:= Till#%& fil# an't(#% 2%i#1an$# $'+*lainin2 'f t(#

#li#%at# iniff#%#n$# t' (is $'ntinin2 *ainfl s0in %as( & )%. Lisia0 an

'll&. G%i#1an$# ==?::: @as #ni# 'n t(# 2%'ns t(at it @as f%i1'l's.

E(iit PD

?6. On Ma%$( 9>, ;>:= M+ia A-Ja+al, t(# *%is'n#% @(' Plaintiff (a

s*'0#n a't t' K#%#st#s, @as %s(# t' t(# ('s*ital in ia#ti$ s('$0. A-Ja+al

@as %#l#as# a$0 t' SCI Ma(an'& 'n A*%il ;.

7>. On A*%il 9, ;>:= att'%n#& Ra$(#l !'l0#nst#in (a a l#2al 1isit @it( Till#%&.

)%in2 t(at 1isit, Plaintiff inf'%+# att'%n#& !'l0#nst#in t(at t(# $#ll s#a%$(#s,

$(an2# 'f $#ll assi2n+#nt an l'ss 'f (is 4' as *##% s*#$ialist '$$%%# aft#% (#

s*'0# * t' K#%#st#s a't M+ia A-Ja+al3s illn#ss an t(at (# n### t' #

ta0#n t' t(# ('s*ital.

7:. At t(# $'n$lsi'n 'f (#% 1isit @it( Till#%&, att'%n#& !'l0#nst#in an 't(#%s

1isit# @it( M+ia A-Ja+al, @(' @as in a @(##l $(ai%, 1#%& t(in an (a a 1#%&

16


17/41

1isil# s0in ail+#nt. T(# s0in 'n (is a%+s an l#2s @as a%0#n#, t(i$0 an s$al&,

(is fa$ial s0in @as fla0#&.

7;. On inf'%+ati'n an #li#f, M+ia A-Ja+al t'l !'l0#nstin# an 't(#%s

t(at Till#%& (a i%#$tl& a**%'a$(# K#%#st#s a't (is illn#ss.

79. It #$a+# *li$l& 0n'@n t(at Till#%& (a a1'$at# f'% M+ia A-Ja+al

an @a%n# K#%#st#s t(at A-Ja+al n### t' 2' t(# ('s*tial.

Retaliatory Trans"er "rom S+ -aanoy to S+ *rackville

7. At a**%'i+at#l& 7a+ 'n A*%il 8, ;>: Till#%& @as t%ansf#%%# f%'+ SCI

Ma(an'& t' SCI F%a$01ill#. T(is t%ansf#% @as @it('t an& n'ti$# an Plaintiff @as

n't all'@# t' *a$0 (is '@n *#%s'nal #ff#$ts an l#2al *a*#%s, as is sall& 'n#.

7=. Till#%& (a n' +is$'n$ts %in2 (is ti+# at SCI Ma(an'&.

7?. On inf'%+ati'n an #li#f t(is @as an a+inist%ati1# s@a* initiat# &

SCI Ma(an'& initiall& '**'s# & Ca*tain S. )'@ns, int#lli2#n$# 'ffi$# at

F%a$01ill# #$as# Till#%&3s *%i'% ti+# at F%a$01ill# in3t @'%0.

77. On inf'%+ati'n an #li#f t(# *%is'n#% @(' @as s@a**# f'% Till#%& @as

t'tall& s%*%is# & (is t%ansf#% an @as t'l t(is @as an #+#%2#n$& t%ansf#%

f%'+ Ma(an'&.

78. On A*%il 7, ;>:= att'%n#& Ra$(#l !'l0#nst#in %##st# a 2at# *ass f'% a

l#2al 1isit @it( Till#%& at SCI Ma(an'& 'n T(%sa&, A*%il 6, ;>:=, 1ia #+ail t'

Ms. Jan# in+an, assistant t' SCI Ma(an'& S*#%int#n#nt J'(n K#%#st#s.

76. On inf'%+ati'n an #li#f 'n A*%il 8, ;>:= att'%n#& !'l0#nst#in %#$#i1#

1#%al a**%'1al f'% t(at 1isit f%'+ Ms. in+an.

17


18/41

8>. On A*%il 8, ;>:= att'%n#& !'l0#nst#in #+ail# a l#tt#% an '$+#nts t'

)OC $'ns#l an SCI Ma(an'& S*#%int#n#nt K#%#st#s *%'1iin2 #1i#n$# t(at

t(# all#2# 4stifi$ati'n f'% *#%i'i$ s#a%$(#s 'f Till#%&3s $#ll @as a @%'n2

$lassifi$ati'n 'f MT as an #s$a*# %is0 )C A)M 8>;.:.A.#D @(#n (is

$lassifi$ati'n (a ##n *%#1i'sl& $'%%#$t# t' )C A)M 8>;, S#$. :.A.:.C. S##

SCI F'%%#st S*#%int#n#nt )ani#l /%ns O$t'#% ;, ;>:; an Unit Mana2#%

/%#na a*t l#tt#%s.D S#$. :.A.:.C. '#s n't *%'1i# t(# l#2al asis f'% *#%i'i$

$#ll s#a%$(#s. E(iit 5D

8:. On T(%sa&, A*%il 6, @(#n att'%n#& !'l0#nst#in a%%i1# at SCI Ma(an'&

t' 1isit Till#%&, s(# @as inf'%+# t(at (# @as n't at Ma(an'& t at SCI

F%a$01ill#.

8;. On A*%il :9, ;>:= att'%n#& !'l0#nst#in f'%@a%# t(# A*%il 8 l#tt#% t' t(#

)OC t' S*#%int#n#nt T%itt an in a s#*a%at# l#tt#% !'l0#nst#in @%'t# t' )OC

$'ns#l, S*#%int#n#nt K#%#st#s an SCI F%a$01ill# S*#%int#n#nt T%itt:=, Till#%& fil# a %##st t' T%itt t' %#1i#@ an $'%%#$t t(#

inf'%+ati'n in (is fil# an a4st (is s#$%it& $lassifi$ati'n, %#f#%%in2 t' att'%n#&

!'l0#nst#in3s A*%il :9, ;>:= l#tt#% an atta$(+#nts. T%itt %#fs# t' $'n$t t(is

%#1i#@, sa&in2 t(at F%a$01ill# @as a n#@ slat# an t(at Till#%& @'l (a1# t'

@ait ntil Ma%$( ;>:?. E(iit SD

8=. Plaintiff fil# G%i#1an$# =?;;8 'n A*%il ;6, ;>:=, '4#$tin2 t' t(is

%#fsal t' $'n$t t(# %#1i#@ t N#@#%%&, a$tin2 Fa$ilit& G%i#1an$#

C''%inat'% #ni# t(is 'n t(# fals# 2%'ns t(at Till#%& (a n't *%'1i# t(#

%#i%# '$+#ntati'n. E(iit TD All t(# '$+#ntati'n (a ##n s#nt &

att'%n#& !'l0#nst#in t' T%itt 'n A*%il :9, ;>:=.

*alse and Retaliatory -isconduct +arges

8?. On A*%il 9>, ;>:= Plaintiff @as $(a%2# @it( %#$#i1in2 a l#tt#% @it(

*'siti1# t#st %#slt f'% s''n#. Mis$'n$t C(a%2# /7;997;, si2n# &

)'@ns, $(a%2# MT @it( t@' Class : +is$'n$ts< ;; P'ss#ssi'n '% s# 'f a

an2#%'s '% $'nt%'ll# sstan$# an > Unat('%i# Us# 'f Mail '%

t#l#*('n#. E(iit UD

87. T(# +is$'n$t %#*'%t @as as# 'n +ail a%#ss# t' Till#%&, t(at an

'ffi$#% in t(# *%is'n +ail%''+ a +ail%''+ s(a%# & SCI Ma(an'& an SCI

F%a$01ill#D t('2(t (a a ss*i$i's '%an2# sstan$# affi# t' #n1#l'*# an

n#%n#at( t(# *'sta2# sta+* an s#nt t(# l#tt#% t' t(# SCI F%a$01ill# s#$%it&

'ffi$#. )'@ns3 %#*'%t stat#s. In (is 9; a%s in *%is'n Till#%& (a n' +is$'n$t f'% %2s '% i%t& %in#.

6:. Aiti'nall&, it is @#ll 0n'@n t(at t(# sta+*s 'n l#tt#%s t' *%is'n#%s at SCI

Ma(an'& an SCI F%a$01ill# a%# %#+'1# f%'+ t(# #n1#l'*#s in t(# +ail%''+

#f'%# #li1#%in2 +ail t' *%is'n#%s, s' it @'l # an a$t 'f 2%'ss st*iit& t' #1#n

t%& s$( a t(in2.

6;. A +is$'n$t (#a%in2 @as (#l 'n Ma& 7, ;>:=. N' #1i#n$# @as

*%#s#nt# t(at Plaintiff (a an& 0n'@l#2# 'f t(# att#+*t t' s#n s''n# int'

t(# *%is'n. N' inf'%+ati'n @as *%#s#nt# as t' @(' fi%st #a+in# t(# l#tt#% '% t(#

#tails 'f t(# t#stin2. T(# t#stin2 @as n't 'n# & an in#*#n#nt la'%at'%&.

69. Till#%& @as f'n 2ilt& & Lis @(' sai %in2 t(# (#a%in2 t(at s(#

in3t n## an& *%''f an 2i1#n san$ti'ns 'f 6> a&s in t(# RU 'n #a$(

is$i*lina%& $(a%2#, t'talin2 :8> a&s, ntil O$t'#% ;?, ;>:=. E(iit VD

20


21/41

6. N'n-$'nta$t 1isitin2 %#st%i$ti'ns @#%# i+*'s# a2ainst Till#%&. E(iit !D

6=. Plaintiff fil# a Mis$'n$t #a%in2 A**#al t' t(# P%'2%a+ R#1i#@

C'++itt## PRCD t(# sa+# a&, Ma& 7, ;>:=, 'n t(# 2%'ns t(at t(# *nis(+#nt

is is*%'*'%ti'nat# t' t(# 'ff#ns# an t(# #1i#n$# insffi$i#nt t' s**'%t t(#

#$isi'n. Till#%& #ni# an& 0n'@l#2# '% in1'l1#+#nt in t(is. E(iit QD

6?. Till#%& @%'t# in (is a**#alH:= @it('t an& in1#sti2ati'n.9. T(#%#3s n' #1i#n$# t(at I t'l, '%#%# '% as0# an&'n# t' +ail +#an&t(in2 t' ' @it( %2s. I 'n3t s# %2s an I31# ##n t#st# f'% 9;

a%s T(is is n't t(# fi%st ti+# t(# +ail (as ##n s# t' s#t s'+#'n# *.An &'3ll 0n'@ t(at. A$$'%in2 t' t(# )OC %#$'%s &'3ll sa& I3+ 'n# 'ft(# s'-$all# int#lli2#nt +ani*lat'%s in *%is'ns an 2#t 't(#% t' ' t(in2sf'% +#. N'@ &' sa& I3+ + #n'2( t' (a1# a l#tt#% s#nt @it( +& na+#'n it n' l#ss @it( %2s #(in a s+all sta+*. '@ +$( $'l t(at t(at #@'%t( #$#*t f'% t' l'$0 +# *.

P%is'n#% Till#%& (as n't (a a $lass 'n# +is$'n$t in :; a%s t t(#(#a%in2 #a+in#% 2a1# +# t(# +a #$as# s(# stat#s +& %#*tati'n*%#$##s +#. I n#1#% 0n#@ t(at @as a $(a%2#. I @as 2i1#n si +'nt(s )Cti+# an +& 1isits @#%# ta0#n *#% )C A)M 8:;. A2ain n' #1i#n$# I (a*'ss#ssi'n '% s# an& an2#%'s %2s. In fa$t t(# %in# t#st s('@s n'%2s. I3ll ta0# a l'' t#st. In fa$t I3ll @ai1# +& l#2al %i2(ts an si2n# anaffia1it t(at I a+ @illin2 t' ta0# a li# #t#$t'% t#st t(at I (a1# n'0n'@l#2# 'f @(' '% an&'n# s#nin2 +# %2s. I +a& n't # t(# %i2(t#stl in t(# '. /t I @as n#1#% t(at +.

21


22/41

67. On Ma& :9, ;>:= Plaintiff fil# a )C :9=A In+at#3s R##st t' Staff

M#+#% t' T%itt $(all#n2in2 t(# la$0 'f #1i#n$# an la$0 'f l#2iti+at# t#stin2 'f

t(# all#2# $'nt%'ll# sstan$#. # %##st# T' # a%%#st# f'% sai $%i+# &

t(# stat# *'li$#. I @ill @ai1# all %i2(ts t' ta0# a li# #t#$t'% t#st t(at t(at I (a n'

0n'@l#2# '% %##st# an&'n# t' s#n an&t(in2 ill#2al t' t(is *%is'n '% an& 't(#%

*%is'n. # als' $'+*lain# @(#n I @#nt t' +& (#a%in2 I @as 2i1#n t(# +a an

it3s n#% a**#al. T(# (#a%in2 #a+in#% #*lain# t' +# t(at (#% an (#%

$'@'%0#%s COD 'n3t n## #1i#n$#. T(#& 4st (a1# t' #li#1# its s'+#t(in2

t(#%#. S*t. T%itt ans@#%#< t(# t#stin2 @as it# $l#a% an 1ali. E(iit YD

68. On Ma& :, ;:>=, t(# PRC *(#l t(# #a%in2 Ea+in#%3s V#%i$t, @(i$(

stat#9. Till#%& @as n't 2i1#n a $(an2# in n#%@#a% ntil Ma& ;>, ;>:=aft#%

;> a&s in t(# RU. is fa+il& (a t' insist t(at (is +#i$ati'n f'% (is li1#%

*%'l#+ # 2i1#n t' (i+. # in3t %#$#i1# (is l#2al *a*#%s ntil Ma& ;>, ;>:=.

:>. Un#0n'@nst t' Plaintiff, att'%n#& !'l0#nst#in in1#sti2at# t(# a%#ss

s('@n 'n t(# #n1#l'*# as ini$at# 'n t(# $'nfis$ati'n %#$#i*t. S(# s*'0# @it( t(#

+an @(' li1#s at t(at a%#ss an (# *%'1i# a #$la%ati'n ##$t# Ma& ;>,

;:>= n#% *#nalt& 'f *#%4%&.

:>=. Al . Ja+al #$la%# t(at (# %#si#s at ;9; S. 7;nSt%##t,

P(ila#l*(ia, PA, @(i$( is all#2#l& t(# %#t%n a%#ss 'n t(# #n1#l'*# t(at t#st#

*'siti1# f'% s''n#. M%. Ja+al n#i1'$all& stat#s< mailed a letter to -aor

Tillery at te end o" $pril /012 but did not put any drug, narcotic or controlled

substance on te envelope or under te stamp.3 E(iit //D

23


24/41

:>?. M%. Ja+al f%t(#% #*lain# t(at f'% (i+ t' (a1# 'n# t(is @as s' a2ainst

(is '@n int#%#sts as t' # si+*l& n#li#1al#. In A*%il ;>:= M%. Ja+al neLa%%&

F%an$isD @as 'n *a%'l# an a't t' (a1# %2 $(a%2#s is+iss# a2ainst (i+. M%.

Ja+al stat# (# @as a@a%# 'f t(# *'t#ntial $'ns##n$#s if (# @#%# t' # $(a%2#

@it( a $%i+inal 'ff#ns# %#lat# t' t(# all#2ati'n 'f a $'nt%'ll# sstan$# 'n t(#

#n1#l'*# an n#% t(# sta+*.

:>7. N' in1#sti2ati'n @as $'n$t# & t(# P(ila#l*(ia *'li$# '% an& 't(#%

stat# #nf'%$#+#nt a2#n$&.

:>8. Al . Ja+al stat# (# @as @illin2 t' t#stif& n#% 'at( in an&

*%'$##in2 t' in1#sti2at# anH'% a4i$at# t(#s# fals# $(a%2#s a2ainst Ma4'%

Till#%&. # still is.

:>6. T(# #$la%ati'n 'f Al . Ja+al @as s#nt t' )OC S#$%#ta%& J'(n

!#t#l, )OC L#2al C'ns#l T(#%'n P#%#, SCI Ma(an'& S*#%int#n#nt J'(n

K#%#st#s an SCI F%a$01ill# S*#%int#n#nt /%#na T%itt 'n Ma& ;7, ;>:= &

att'%n#& !'l0#nst#in. #% l#tt#% %##st# a fll in1#sti2ati'n & t(# )OC 'f

%#taliat'%& $'n$t a2ainst Till#%&, in$lin2 t(# +is$'n$t $(a%2#s f'%

*'ss#ssi'n 'f a $'nt%'ll# sstan$#. E(iit CCD

::>. On Ma& ;6, ;>:=, Plaintiff s+itt# a $'*& 'f t(# #$la%ati'n 'f Al

. Ja+al t' S*#%int#n#nt T%itt as *a%t 'f a )C :9=A s+issi'n f'%

$'nsi#%ati'n in %#1i#@in2 (is a**#al, statin2 a2ain t(at t(#%# @as n' in1#sti2ati'n

'f t(# all#2# +is$'n$t & (i+ an as0in2 t' # a%%#st# 'n t(# %2 $(a%2#.

24


25/41

:::. In (#% Jn# 9, ;>:= %#s*'ns#, T%itt i n't #1#n a$0n'@l#2# %#$#i*t 'f

t(# Ma& ;>, ;>:= Al . Ja+al #$la%ati'n, l#t al'n# t(at it t'tall& #'n#%at#

Plaintiff. #% %#s*'ns# t' Plaintiff @as, ;>:= an in1#sti2at'% f%'+ )OC Offi$# 'f S*#$ial

In1#sti2ati'ns OSID, Lt. /%ian Ta&l'%, int#%1i#@# Till#%& at l#n2t(. T(# OSI

in1#sti2at#s staff $'%%*ti'n an in+at# as#. T(is in1#sti2ati'n @as $'n$t#

'n t(# at('%it& 'f S#$%#ta%& !#t#l in %#s*'ns# t' t(# l#tt#% s#nt t' !#t#l

'4#$tin2 t' t(# %#taliat'%& t%ansf#% an fals# +is$'n$t $(a%2#s an )C ti+#

2i1#n t' Till#%& f'% (is #f#ns# 'f M+ia A-Ja+al an 't(#% ##%$is#s 'f (is

Fi%st A+#n+#nt %i2(ts.

::9. Lt. Ta&l'% $'n$t# a fll %#1i#@ 'f Till#%&3s (ist'%& in t(# P#nns&l1ania

*%is'n s&st#+. T(is in$l# Plaintiff3s +#i$al $'+*laints, in$lin2 t(# la$0 'f

$a%# f'% (is s#1#%# s0in $'niti'n, la$0 'f +#i$al #i*+#nt an s('#s. # als'

%#1i#@# t(# fals# s#*a%ati'ns an $(a%2#s t(at a%# still 0#*t in (is fil#s an a%#

s# t' in$'%%#$tl& $lassif& (i+.

::. Lt. Ta&l'% %#1i#@# all Till#%&3s +#i$al an s#$%it& stats 2%i#1an$#s as

@#ll as t(# t('s# in$l# in t(# l#tt#%s s#nt & att'%n#& !'l0#nst#in 'n A*%il 8,

;>:= #tailin2 t(# #%%'%s in (is s#$%it& #si2nati'n as an #s$a*# %is0, an 'n

A*%il :9, ;>:= statin2 t(# %#taliat'%& asis 'f MT3s t%ansf#% t' SCI F%a$01ill#

25


26/41

#$as# 'f a1'$a$& 'n #(alf 'f M+ia A-Ja+al an 'n Ma& ;7, ;>:=

*%'1iin2 n#@ #1i#n$# @it( t(# #$la%ati'n 'f Al A. Ja+al t(at t(#

+is$'n$t $(a%2#s a2ainst Plaintiff @#%# fals# an a s#t-* & *%is'n 'ffi$ials

an in %#taliati'n f'% Till#%&3s ##%$is# 'f Fi%st A+#n+#nt %i2(ts.

::=. Lt. Ta&l'% as0# Plaintiff if (# @ant# t' @%it# an't(#% @%itt#n stat#+#nt

an Till#%& %#s*'n# t(at (is 2%i#1an$#s an att'%n#& !'l0#nst#in3s l#tt#%s

$'nstitt# (is @%itt#n stat#+#nt. T(is @as a$0n'@l#2# & Lt. Ta&l'%.

::?. Lt. Ta&l'% t'l Plaintiff t(at T%itt an SCI F%a$01ill# *%is'n 'ffi$ials (a1#

n' *%''f t(at (# $'++itt# t(# +is$'n$ts, t t(at Till#%& (a n' *%''f it @as a

s#t *.

::7. On Jn# :;, ;>:= Till#%& %##st# a l#2al $all t' (is att'%n#&. T%itt

%#s*'n# t(at n### t' # a%#ss# t' t(# PRC. T(# PRC #ni# t(# l#2al

*('n# $all.

::8. On Jn# ;=, ;>:= Plaintiff %#$#i1# a R#s*'ns# t' a**#al 'f Final

R#1i#@ 'f Mis$'n$t N'. /7;997;, *#% )C-A)M 8>:, s#$ =, C.?D, si2n# &

)OC )#*t& C(i#f C'ns#l Ranall N. S#a%s, statin2:= Plaintiff @as %#l#as# f%'+ )C stats &

S*#%int#n#nt T%itt. A$$'%in2 t' a )C-::, Pa%t %#*'%t, a )is$i*lina%& Cst'&

%#1i#@ @as (#l 'n A2st ;7, ;>:= an a #$isi'n +a# & PRC +#+#%s t'

%#l#as# in+at# Till#%& t' G#n#%al P'*lati'n #ff#$ti1# t(# @##0 'f A2st 9:st.

T%itt a**%'1# t(# %#l#as# t' *'*lati'n 'n S#*t#+#% 7, ;>:=. E(iit D

:;9. Until t(# %#taliat'%& s#t * 'n A*%il 9>, ;>:=, Till#%& in3t (a1# a

+is$'n$t intwelve years.n is 4/ years in prison Tillery didn5t ave even one

misconduct "or drugs or dirty urine.

27


28/41

:;. T(#s# s#t-* +is$'n$ts f'% *'ss#ssi'n 'f a $'nt%'ll# sstan$# an

+iss# 'f t(# +ail a%# %#taliat'%&. T(# i++#iat#l& f'll'@# Till#%&3s $'ntin#

a1'$a$& f'% M+ia A-Ja+al an (is '@n $'ntin# filin2 'f 2%i#1an$#s t'

'tain +#i$al t%#at+#nt an t' $(an2# a fals# s#$%it& $lassifi$ati'n. T(#

+is$'n$ts n'@ in Till#%&3s %#$'% t(%#at#n (is $'ntin# ('sin2 in 2#n#%al

*'*lati'n. If a *%is'n#% is #li#1# t' # int%'$in2 %2s int' t(# institti'n, (#

$an # $'nsi#%# a an2#% t' t(# s#$%it& 'f t(# institti'n an # s# t' *la$#

t(# in+at# in in#finit# s'lita%& $'nfin#+#nt 'n t(# R#st%i$t# R#l#as# List.

:;=. Alt('2( sin$# S#*t#+#% ;, ;>:=, Till#%& is $'nsi#%# t' # in 2#n#%al

*'*lati'n @it( &a%-ti+#, $'++issa%&, TV, *('n# $alls an $'nta$t 1isits, (# is

a$tall& ('s# in t(# RU Ann#. T(is is a %#st%i$t# ('sin2 nit $#lll'$0

t(at n'@ (as 'n# ti#% 'f $#lls @it( 2#n#%al *'*lati'n *%is'n#%s. T(# ti#% a'1# (as

)C *%is'n#%s @(' a%# n't all'@# an& *%i1il#2#sn' *('n# '% $'nta$t 1isits, n'

TV, n' $'++issa%&. T(#s# +#n a%# ist%a2(t an l'.

:;?. Plaintiff (as ##n s##n & a *s&$('l'2ist, Ms. S+it( f'% (is #*%#ssi'n

an ani#t& @(' %#$'++#n# (# # +'1# t' a %#2la% $#lll'$0 @it(in G#n#%al

P'*lati'n. T(is @as #ni# & )'@ns an Mill#% f'% n' %#as'n #$#*t t' *#nali#

an $'ntin# %#taliati'n a2ainst MT. E(iit IID

Retaliatory -edical !eglect and -istreatment at S+ *rackville

:;7. !(#n Till#%& @as t%ansf#%%# t' SCI F%a$01ill# A*%il 8, ;>:= (# @as

#ni# (is #t%a +att%#ss, '%t('*#i$ s('#s an a$0 %a$#. # (a '%t('*#i$

s('#s an a a$0 %a$# f'% '1#% t#n a%s, in *%is'ns in NJ as @#ll as P#nns&l1ania.

28


29/41

is *'tassi+ s**l#+#nt tal#ts @#%# n't %#fill#. On Ma& 6, ;>:= Plaintiff fil#

G% =??769. T(#s# 2%i#1an$#s @#%# #ni# & Stanis(#fs0& an N#@#%%& @it(

fals# stat#+#nts an @it('t l#2iti+at# +#i$al %#as'ns. E(iit JJD

:;8. On A*%il 9>, ;>:= Till#%& @as *t int' is$i*lina%& $st'& in t(#

%#st%i$t# ('sin2 nit RUD 'n t(# fals# an %#taliat'%& +is$'n$ts. # @as

#ni# (is +#i$ati'ns *t 'n %#$# f'' %ati'ns, +'stl& sl'*, #ni#

$'++issa%& an $'nta$t 1isits, an all'@# 1#%& li+it# 't''% ##%$is# ti+#.

:;6. In an't(#% a$t 'f (a%ass+#nt an %#taliati'n, 'n Ma& ;;, ;>:= t(# 2a%

*t a i%t& t'il#t %s( in (is f'' t%a&, t' # s# t' $l#an (is $#ll. Till#%& fil#

G%i#1an$# =?7?89 statin2 t(is is a 1i'lati'n 'f (is (#alt( an saf#t&. T(is @as

#ni# & N#@#%%&. E(iit KKD

:9>. On Ma& ;8, ;>:= Till#%& fil# 2%i#1an$# =?67>? aft#% Pan&a %#fs# t'

(#l* @it( (is s#1#%# a$0 *ain an *ain @(#n @al0in2, $'ntinin2 t' #n& Till#%&

(is a$0 %a$# an '%#% an't(#% +att%#ss. Pan&a $'+*lain# t(at Till#%& @as

n't $''*#%atin2 & $%#atin2 nn#$#ssa%& @'%0 an +'n#& & $'+*lainin2 @it(

2%i#1an$#s. T(is @as #ni# & Stanis(#fs0& an N#@#%%&. E(iit LLD

:9:. /t 'n Ma& ;6, ;>:=, Till#%& @as 2i1#n a +#i$al @'%0-* in$lin2

%ai'l'2& 'f (is s*in#, (i*s an f##t. On Jn# :>, ;>:=, t(# sa+# a& as t(# 1isit

& Lt. Ta&l'% f%'+ $#nt%al 'ffi$# Plaintiff 2't (is a$0 %a$#. T(is @as t@' +'nt(s

aft#% t(is %#taliat'%& t%ansf#% t' SCI F%a$01ill#.

:9;. On Jn# :?, ;>:=, Till#%& fil# G%i#1an$# =7:??:, 'n Jl& ;, ;>:= (#

fil# G%i#1an$# =7>8, Till#%& %#*#at# a2ain an a2ain t(# fail%# t' t%#at (is

29


30/41

*ainfl s0in %as( f'% '1#% nin# +'nt(s t(at (a n'@ #1#l'*# '*#n infla+#

s'%#s 'n (is l#2s, @it( *s %nnin2 'nt' (is s(##ts. # stat# t(is @as #li#%at#

iniff#%#n$# t' Till#%&3s (#alt( an n### +#i$al $a%#. T(# *%is'n %#fs# t'

*%#s$%i# an 'int+#nt t(at @as (#l*in2 #$as# it $'st t'' +$(. #ta+#t(as'n#

i*%'*i'nat# 'int+#nt. E(iit MMD

:99. On Jn# :7, ;>:= G%i#1an$# =7:??: @as #ni# & N#@#%%& an 'n

Jl& ;7, ;>:= G%1. =7>8 @as #ni# & Stanis(#fs0&. E(iit NND

:9. On Jl& ;6, ;>:= Till#%& s+itt# a s*#$ial %##st f'% t%#at+#nt t'

Pan&a f'll'@# & an't(#% G%i#1an$# =8>?6= 'n A2st , ;>:= $itin2

1i'lati'ns 'f t(# A+#%i$ans @it( )isailit& A$ts an Ei2(t A+#n+#nt $lai+s 'f

#li#%at# iniff#%#n$# t' (is +#i$al $'niti'n, statin2 in *a%t:= Till#%& fil# an a**#al 'f t(# #nial 'f G%1. =7>8 t'

T%itt, statin2 Stanis(#fs0i +isstat#s (is +#i$al $'niti'n (# (as s'%#s 'n (is l#2s

an t(# %as( (as s*%#a '1#% 8 +'nt(s. On A2st ?, ;>:= T%itt #ni# t(is a**#al,

n#i1'$all& s**'%tin2 Stanis(#fs0i3s fals# %#*'%t. E(iit PPD

:9?. A s%2i$al s0in i'*s& f%'+ Till#%&3s l#ft s(in @as 'n# an t(# %#slts

at# A2st ;>, ;>:= %#1#als a %a%# fn2al '%2anis+, t(at is 't(#%@is# n't

30


31/41

ia2n's#. E(iit 55D T(is is n't #in2 t%#at# & +#i$al staff at SCI

F%a$01ill#.

:97. On A2st ;7, ;>:= Stanis(#fs0i #ni# G%1. =8>?6= $'+*lainin2 'f 2

t(# n+#% 'f +#i$al %##sts +a# & Till#%& an t(at #nial 'f G%1 =7>8

@as as# 'n $lini$al ia2n'sis t(at is $'nfi%+# & a s0in i'*s&. '@#1#%, t(#%#

is n' %#f#%#n$# t(at t(at s0in i'*s& %#f#%%# t' a %a%# fn2al '%2anis+ t(at @as

n't #in2 t%#at#. E(iit RRD

:98. Plaintiff still sff#%s f%'+ a s0in %as( t(at is s' it$(& (# $an3t sl##* an is

*#%i'i$all& infla+# an inf#$t#.

:96. F%'+ A*%il 9>, ;>:= t(%'2( A2st :;, ;>:= 'in2 )C ti+#, Till#%&

@#nt f%'+ ;>= *'ns '@n t' :8= *'ns.

:>. On O$t'#% ;?, ;>:=, aft#% a&s i2n'%in2 Plaintiff3s $'+*laints t(at (#

@as sff#%in2 f%'+ a '@#l 'st%$ti'n, (# @as ta0#n t' a G#isin2#% M#i$al

C#nt#% fa$ilit&, !&'+in2 Vall#& M#i$al C#nt#%. Till#%& 0n#@ t(# s&+*t'+s 'f

'@#l 'st%$ti'n sin$# (# (a t(is t(%## ti+#s #f'%#.

::. Att#+*ts t' 'tain i%#$t +#i$al inf'%+ati'n a't Till#%&3s $'niti'n

'% t' s*#a0 @it( (i+ 1ia t#l#*('n# & Till#%&3s a2(t#% Ka+ila( I##n @(' (as

MT3s +#i$al at('%iati'n @as #ni# & T%itt @(' sai Till#%&3s ('s*italiati'n

f'% t(is s#%i's 2ast%'int#stinal *%'l#+ @as 4st a %'tin# a+issi'n.

:;. Ms. I##n +a# %#*#at# $alls t' t(# n%s# at SCI F%a$01ill# t' 'tain

+#i$al *at#s. An @(#n s(# @as al# t' %#a$( t(# n%s#, t(# %#*'%ts @#%#

*a%tial. On inf'%+ati'n an #li#f, @(il# at t(# ('s*ital Till#%& (a a $ats$an, @as

31


32/41

'n IV flis an (a a nas'2ast%i$ t# 2'in2 int' (is st'+a$( t' (#l* s$0

an&t(in2 't 'f st'+a$( an t' 0##* t(# st'+a$( #+*t& s' t(# '@#ls $'l %#st.

T(# last %#*'%t 'n a F%ia& +'%nin2 @as t(at s%2#%& +i2(t # n#$#ssa%&.

:9. Plaintiff @as is$(a%2# aft#% fi1# a&s 'f ('s*italiati'n 'n Sat%a&

#1#nin2. # @as ta0#n t' SCI )allas an *t in t(# ('l#. Offi$iall&, Till#%& @as

s#nt t' SCI )allas infi%+a%&, t in fa$t (# s*#nt a ni2(t an a a& @it('t an&

+#i$al att#nti'n, in a %aft& $#ll @it('t a#at# lan0#ts.

:. Plaintiff @as t%ans*'%t# a$0 t' SCI F%a$01ill# M'na& #1#nin2,

N'1#+#% ;, ;>:=. SCI F%a$01ill# 2a1# Till#%& a %in# t#st f'% %2s @(#n (#

%#t%n# t @as n't 2i1#n a *'st-('s*italiati'n i#t '% an& f'll'@-* +#i$al

t%#at+#nt.

:=. Plaintiff %#+ain# in *ain, @as nas#'s an 1'+it# * @(at (# at#

'1#% t(# n#t s#1#%al a&s. /t Till#%& @as n't s##n & an& +#i$al *#%s'nn#l ntil

N'1#+#% , ;>:=.

:?. Till#%& is a $(%'ni$ $lini$ *ati#nt an is #ntitl# t' +#i$ati'ns an t#sts

@it('t $'st. is l#2 %as( (as ##n #t%#+#l& it$(& an 'ft#n infla+# f'% '1#% a

a%. # (as n't ##n *%'*#%l& t%#at# an ##n f'%$# t' *a& f'% +#i$ati'ns t(at

s('l # *%'1i# t' (i+ in %#taliati'n 'f (is Fi%st A+#n+#nt %i2(ts.

nter"erence wit access to courts by obstructing attorney visitation and

consultation:

:7. In S#*t#+#% ;>:, aft#% Till#%&3s %#l#as# int' 2#n#%al *'*lati'n at SCI

Ma(an'&, (# %#s+# #ff'%ts t' '1#%t%n (is $'n1i$ti'n an s'2(t l#2al

32


33/41

assistan$#. C'nsltati'n @it( l#2al $'ns#l @as 'st%$t# an #la & Cla%0

@(' %#fs# t' i++#iat#l& *%'$#ss Till#%&3s %##st t' *t att'%n#& !'l0#nst#in

'n (is l#2al 1isit'%s list in 1i'lati'n 'f #*li$it )OC %#2lati'ns.

:8. Till#%&3s a$$#ss t' *('n# $alls an 1isits @it( $'ns#l @as int#%f#%# @it(

an 'st%$t# aft#% (# @as t%ansf#%%# f%'+ SCI Ma(an'& t' SCI F%a$01ill# in

A*%il ;>:= an t(#n fals#l& $(a%2# @it( +is$'n$ts an *t int' )is$i*lina%&

Cst'& in %#taliati'n f'% (is filin2 2%i#1an$#s an a1'$atin2 'n #(alf 'f M+ia

A-Ja+al.

:6. T(is int#%f#%#n$# an 'st%$ti'n in$l#< :D #n&in2 att'%n#& $alls @(il#

Plaintiff @as in )is$i*lina%& Cst'&, ;D #n&in2 a $'nfi#ntial l#2al 1isit 'n Ma&

:;, ;>:= in t(# A+inst%ati1# Cst'& 1isitin2 %''+, 9D %#st%i$tin2 att'%n#& 1isits

t' 'n# ('% 'n Ma& ;;, ;>:= an Jl& 9:, ;>:= #1#n t('2( s*#$ifi$ %##sts

@#%# +a# & t(# att'%n#& f'% 1isits 'f t@' ('%s an t(# att'%n#& t%a1#l# f%'+

NYC f'% t(# 1isit, an D #in2 initiall& #ni# *#%+issi'n t' %in2 #1#n a *#n

an *a int' a l#2al 1isit 'n N'1#+#% 9, ;>:= aft#% Till#%&3s %#t%n t' SCI

F%a$01ill# aft#% #+#%2#n$& ('s*italiati'n.

:=>. T(#s# a$ts 'f int#%f#%#n$# an att#+*t# 'st%$ti'n @#%# $a%%i# 't n#%

t(# at('%it& 'f T%itt an Mill#%.

:=:. Till#%& fil# G%i#1an$# =8>9>8 '4#$tin2 t' t(# %#st%i$ti'ns in att'%n#&

1isitati'n 'n Ma& ;;, ;>:= an Jl& 9:, ;>:=. T(is @as #ni# A2st 8, ;>:= &

Lt. R#i$(a%t.

33


34/41

:=;. On A2st :;, ;>:= Till#%& s+itt# In+at# A**#al t' Final R#1i#@:= Fa$ilit& Mana2#% R#s*'ns# /. T%ittD *(#l t(# #nial

'f t(# 2%i#1an$# #nial @(il# $'nfi%+in2 t(at )OC %#2lati'ns 2i1# at('%it& t'

*%is'n 'ffi$ials t' 2%ant l#2al 1isitati'n l'n2#% t(an 'n# ('%. E(iit SSD

:=. T%itt %#1#%s# t(# #nial 'f all'@in2 $'ns#l t' %in2 a *a an *#n int'

t(# l#2al 1isit *%i'% t' att'%n#&3s a%%i1al at SCI F%a$01ill#.

()austion o" $dminstrative Remedies:

:==. Plaintiff (as #(ast# (is a+inist%ati1# %#+#i#s & filin2 2%i#1an$#s

t(%'2( t(# a**#al *%'$#ss as s#t f'%t( & )OC %#2lati'ns. Aiti'nall&, Till#%& is

in sstantial $'+*lian$# in t(at all iss#s #istin2 *%i'% t' Jn# :>, ;>:= an a%#

%ais# in t(is $'+*laint @#%# is$ss# i%#$tl& @it( a %#*%#s#ntati1# 'f t(# )OC

Offi$# 'f S*#$ial In1#sti2ati'n, Lt. Ta&l'% 'n Jn# :>, ;>:= an n' %#+#ial#

a$ti'n @as ta0#n & t(# )OC. T(# #$isi'n 'f )#*t& C(i#f C'ns#l, Ranall

S#a%s 'n Jn# ;=, ;>:= %#4#$t# t(# Plaintiff3s '4#$ti'ns t' t(# s#t-* %#taliat'%&

is$i*lina%& $(a%2#s.

34


35/41

CAUSES OF ACTION

As and for a First Cause of Action:

Retaiation for E!ercise of First A"end"ent Ri#$ts to Freedo" of S%eec$&Association and Access to Courts C$aen#in# Medica and Ps'c$oo#ica

Treat"ent at SCI Ma$ano'

:=?. Plaintiff Till#%& %#-all#2#s *a%a2%a*(s :- :== as if fll& stat# (#%#in.

:=7. )#f#nants !#t#l, K#%#st#s, St#in(a%t, Lisia0, 'll&, )a+'%#, Cla%0 an

G%iffin 1i'lat# Till#%&3s Fi%st A+#n+#nt Ri2(ts t' F%##'+ 'f S*##$(,

Ass'$iati'n an A$$#ss t' C'%ts & %#taliati'n a2ainst Till#%& f'% filin2

2%i#1an$#s @(il# i+*%is'n# at SCI Ma(an'& a2ainst t(# #nial 'f *s&$('l'2i$al

$a%# f'll'@in2 (is %#l#as# int' 2#n#%al *'*lati'n f%'+ a%s 'n t(# RLL an in

s'lita%& $'nfin#+#nt, an f'% filin2 2%i#1an$#s an '4#$tin2 t' *%is'n 'ffi$ials,

in$lin2 t(# +#i$al staff an K#%#st#s, f'% #n&in2 anH'% #la&in2 +#i$al

t%#at+#nt f'% a s0in %as( aff#$tin2 (i+s#lf an 't(#% *%is'n#%s in$lin2 M+ia

A-Ja+al.

:=8. In %#taliati'n f'% Plaintiff3s ##%$is# 'f (is Fi%st A+#n+#nt %i2(ts

)#f#nants f%t(#% #la '% #ni# +#i$al t%#at+#nt an +#i$al #i*+#nt t'

Ma4'% Till#%&, s4#$t# Till#%& t' $#ll s#a%$(#s, t'ss# (is *%'*#%t& an s#i# (is

l#2al *a*#%@'%0, t#%+inat# (is 4' as a *##% s*#$ialist, an t%ansf#%%# Plaintiff

f%'+ SCI Ma(an'& t' SCI F%a$01ill# @it('t l#2iti+at# *#n'l'2i$al %#as'n

t(#%#& $asin2 Till#%& t' sff#% *(&si$al an *s&$('l'2i$al *ain, an l'ss 'f

in$'+#.

35


36/41

As and for a Second Cause of Action:

Retaiation for E!ercise of First A"end"ent Ri#$ts to Freedo" of S%eec$&

Association and Access to Courts for Fiin# (rie)ances O*+ectin# to Ce

Searc$es and Tossin# of $is Persona Pro%ert'& Ter"ination of $is Jo* andErroneous Securit' Status at SCI Ma$ano'

:=6. Plaintiff Till#%& %#-all#2#s *a%a2%a*(s :- :== as if fll& stat# (#%#in.

:?>. )#f#nants !#t#l, K#%#st#s, )a+'%#, Cla%0 an G%iffin 1i'lat# Plaintiff3s

Fi%st A+#n+#nt Ri2(ts t' F%##'+ 'f S*##$(, Ass'$iati'n an A$$#ss t' C'%ts

& %#taliati'n a2ainst Till#%& f'% filin2 2%i#1an$#s @(il# i+*%is'n# at SCI

Ma(an'& '4#$tin2 t' t(# s#a%$( an t'ssin2 'f (is $#ll an %#+'1in2 l#2al *a*#%s

@it('t l#2iti+at# $as# '% at('%it& f'% filin2 a 2%i#1an$# a2ainst t(# t#%+inati'n

'f (is 4' as *##% s*#$ialist @it('t $as# an t%ansf#% t' a iff#%#nt $#ll l'$0 an

f'% $(all#n2in2 (is #%%'n#'s s#$%it& stats as an #s$a*# %is0.

:?:. In %#taliati'n f'% t(is ##%$is# 'f (is Fi%st A+#n+#nt %i2(ts )#f#nants

t%ansf#%%# Till#%& f%'+ SCI Ma(an'& t' SCI F%a$01ill# @it('t l#2iti+at#

*#n'l'2i$al %#as'n t(#%#& $asin2 Till#%& *s&$('l'2i$al *ain an sff#%in2.

As and for a T$ird Cause of Action:


Association and Access to Courts For Co""unicatin# ,is Ad)ocac' for

Mu"ia A*u-Ja"a and .erestes/ Ne#ect of Mu"ia A*u-Ja"a/s Iness

:?;. Plaintiff Till#%& %#-all#2#s *a%a2%a*(s :- :== as if fll& stat# (#%#in.

:?9. )#f#nants !#t#l, K#%#st#s, T%itt, )a+'%#, Cla%0 an )'@ns 1i'lat#

Till#%&3s Fi%st A+#n+#nt Ri2(ts t' F%##'+ 'f S*##$(, Ass'$iati'n an A$$#ss

36


37/41

t' C'%ts f'% Till#%&3s $'++ni$ati'n t' att'%n#&s, a1'$a$& '%2aniati'ns an

ini1ials 'f (is a1'$a$& f'% M+ia A-Ja+al an K#%#st#s3 n#2l#$t 'f A-

Ja+al3s illn#ss.

:?. In %#taliati'n )#f#nant K#%#st#s an T%itt @it( t(# assistan$# 'f 'f

)a+'%#, Cla%0 an )'@ns *%#$i*it'sl& t%ansf#%%# Till#%& f%'+ SCI Ma(an'& t'

SCI F%a$01ill# @it('t l#2iti+at# *#n'l'2i$al *%*'s#, t(#%#& $asin2 Till#%& t'

sff#% a1#%s# a$ti'n int#n# t' #t#% Plaintiff f%'+ ##%$isin2 (is Fi%st

A+#n+#nt Ri2(ts.

As and for a Fourt$ Cause of Action:


Association and Access to Courts at SCI Frac0)ie For C$aen#in# $is

Erroneous Securit' Status and Continuin# to Pu*ic' Ad)ocate for Mu"ia

A*u-Ja"a

:?=. Plaintiff Till#%& %#-all#2#s *a%a2%a*(s :- :== as if fll& stat# (#%#in.

:??. )#f#nants !#t#l, S#a%s, T%itt, Mill#%, N#@#%%&, )'@ns, 1i'lat#


t' C'%ts t' fil# 2%i#1an$#s at SCI F%a$01ill# an i%#$tl& @it( t(# )#*a%t+#nt 'f

C'%%#$ti'ns t' $(all#n2# (is #%%'n#'s s#$%it& stats as an #s$a*# %is0.

:?7. )#f#nants !#t#l, S#a%s, T%itt, Mill#%, N#@#%%&, )'@ns 1i'lat# Till#%&3s

Fi%st A+#n+#nt Ri2(ts t' F%##'+ 'f S*##$(, Ass'$iati'n an A$$#ss t' C'%ts

in %#taliati'n f'% Till#%&3s $'ntin# $'++ni$ati'n t' att'%n#&s, a1'$a$&

'%2aniati'ns an ini1ials a't (is a1'$a$& f'% M+ia A-Ja+al an

K#%#st#s3 n#2l#$t 'f A-Ja+al3s illn#ss.

37


38/41

:?8. In %#taliati'n, )#f#nants s#t-* Till#%& an *(#l t(# fals# +is$'n$t

$(a%2#s 'f *'ss#ssi'n 'f a $'nt%'ll# sstan$# an +iss# 'f t(# +ail, an f'n

(i+ 2ilt& 'f t(# +is$'n$ts an 2a1# (i+ 'f si +'nt(s in )is$i*lina%&

Cst'&. Till#%& @as (#l in s'lita%& $'nfin#+#nt f'% :;? a&s @it('t a $(an2# in

n#%@#a% f'% t@#nt& a&s, #ni# $'++issa%&, *('n# $alls, an $'nta$t 1isits an

att#+*t# 'st%$ti'n 'f (is att'%n#& 1isits, an #*%i1# 'f +#i$in#s an

+#i$al #i*+#nt t' (#l* an t%#at (is $(%'ni$ +#i$al *%'l#+s in$lin2 (i2(

l'' *%#ss%#, li1#% is#as#, an a%t(%itis as @#ll as $'ntinin2 s#1#%#l& it$(& s0in

%as( t(#%#& $asin2 Till#%& #t%#+# *(&si$al an *s&$('l'2i$al *ain an

sff#%in2.

As and for a Fift$ Cause of Action:


Association and Access to Courts To Fie (rie)ances at SCI Frac0)ie

O*+ectin# t$e 1Set-U%2 Misconducts and t$e 345 Da' Penat' of DC Ti"e *'Dea'in# and Den'in# Ade6uate Medica Care

:?6. Plaintiff Till#%& %#-all#2#s *a%a2%a*(s :- :== as if fll& stat# (#%#in.

:7>. )#f#nants !#t#l, T%itt, Mill#%, N#@#%%&, Pan&a, Stanis(#fs0& 1i'lat#


t' C'%ts t' fil# 2%i#1an$#s at SCI F%a$01ill# $(all#n2in2 t(# fals# +is$'n$ts

an 2i1in2 (i+ a *#nalt& 'f :8> a&s 'f )C ti+#.

:7:. In %#taliati'n )#f#nants $as# f%t(#% #la& anH'% #nial 'f +#i$al

t%#at+#nt an +#i$al #i*+#nt t' Till#%& f'% (is $(%'ni$ illn#ss#s an *ainfl

38


39/41

s0in $'niti'n t(at $'ntin#s f'% a a%, t(#%#& $asin2 (i+ *(&si$al an

*s&$('l'2i$al *ain an sff#%in2.

As and for a Si!t$ Cause of Action:


Association and Access to Courts To Fie (rie)ances at SCI Frac0)ie

O*+ectin# to t$e Lac0 of Ade6uate Medica Care and Den'in# ,i" Medica

E6ui%"ent and Medication

:7;. Plaintiff Till#%& %#-all#2#s *a%a2%a*(s :- :== as if fll& stat# (#%#in.

:79. )#f#nants !#t#l, T%itt, Mill#%, N#@#%%&, Pan&a, Stanis(#fs0& 1i'lat#


t' C'%ts t' fil# 2%i#1an$#s at SCI F%a$01ill# f'% t(# #nial 'f +#i$al $a%#,

*%#s$%i*ti'ns an +#i$al #i*+#nt t' (i+. In %#taliati'n )#f#nants $as#

f%t(#% #la& anH'% #nial 'f +#i$al t%#at+#nt an +#i$al #i*+#nt t' Till#%&

t(#%#& $asin2 (i+ *(&si$al an *s&$('l'2i$al *ain an sff#%in2

As and for a Se)ent$ Cause of Action:


Association and Access to Courts at SCI Frac0)ie *' Restrictin# and

O*structin# $is Access to Counse7

:7. Plaintiff Till#%& %#-all#2#s *a%a2%a*(s :- :== as if fll& stat# (#%#in.

:7=. )#f#nants !#t#l, T%itt, Mill#%, N#@#%%& 1i'lat# Till#%&3s Fi%st

A+#n+#nt Ri2(ts t' F%##'+ 'f S*##$(, Ass'$iati'n an A$$#ss t' $'nslt @it(

an att'%n#& an 'tain l#2al assistan$# & int#%f#%in2 @it( an 'st%$tin2 att'%n#&

1isitati'n.

39


40/41

:7?. In %#taliati'n f'% Till#%&3s filin2 'f 2%i#1an$#s, '4#$tin2 t' ina#at#

+#i$al $a%# f'% (i+s#lf an 't(#% *%is'n#%s, in$lin2 M+ia A-Ja+al,

$(all#n2in2 (is #%%'n#'s s#$%it& #si2nati'n, (is %#taliat'%& t%ansf#% t' SCI

F%a$01ill# an t(# fals# +is$'n$ts an is$i*lin# 'f :8> a&s in )C, )#f#nants

(a1# int#%f#%# @it( an att#+*t# t' 'st%$t att'%n#& 1isitati'n in 1i'lati'n 'f

Plaintiff3s $'nstitti'nal %i2(ts an )OC %#2lati'ns.

PRA8ER FOR RELIEF

!EREFORE, Plaintiff %##sts t(at t(# C'%t 2%ant t(# f'll'@in2 %#li#f a&s in )C.

/. Iss# an in4n$ti'n '%#%in2 )#f#nants an t(#i% a2#nts t':?

Documents

Major Tillery Retaliation Lawsuit Complaint