Upload
jesse-parks
View
214
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a
Risk Assessment in Shipping Companies
Intertanko Vetting Seminar
Singapore29th November 2005
Anuj SahaiLloyd’s Register Asia, Singapore
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a
Risk Assessment Do the shipping companies do it well?
Risk ManagementAre shipboard risks well managed?
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a Leading indicators
Tanker trade
6.6
8.8
12.5
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
80's 90's PR00's
'10
Tn
TM
Tanker trade
6.6
8.8
12.5
9.3
7.8
3.5
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
80's 90's PR00's
'100
00 B
n T
M
a
nd
N
um
ber
of
spil
ls >
700
m/t
Source: Fearnleys, ITOPF
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a Leading indicators
• 99.99999% of oil is safely delivered.
622
6074
83
9478
4940
2617
49
0
20
40
60
80
100
1991 1997 End 02 End 03 End 05 End 10
SH* share (%)
DH share (%)
End 05, all tankers built 1982 and earlier goneEnd 10, all tankers built 1987 and earlier gonetrading beyond 2010 subject to administrations
Source: Intertanko
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a Leading indicators
Tanker accidents
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
'90 '94 '98 '02
Nu
mb
er o
f ac
cid
ents
Source: LMIS, Informa, press, INTERTANKO
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a Perception
• The risks are well managed.
• Further improvements - only incremental.
• Risk Assessments – why?
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a Risk Assessment requirements
• Deficiencies
• Critical systems and equipment
• Health risk assessments
• Management of Change
• Near misses
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a Reality
• IMO / Flag regulated
• Reactive not proactive
• Why fix it, if it ain’t broken?
• Compliance driven
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a Risk Assessments
• Still thinking about it!
• Let someone else do it!
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a Why Risk Assessments?
• ISM Code – Implicit
• OCIMF – TMSA
• Manage shipboard risks better
• Continuous Improvements
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a Suggested Approach
CompanyLevel
Shipboard Level
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a
Are your assessments being effective?
• Business or safety performance improvements?
• Can the benefits be measured?
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a Link Risk Assessment to Performance (KPI’s)
• LTIF
• LTA’s
• Non-budgeted repair costs
• PSC results
• Insurance claims
• To crews! RetentionSatisfaction
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a Business Management and Risk Management
• Shipboard Risk management is about minimizing the chance of failure – pure risk
• Effective risk management requires structured risk assessment as an input
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a Hazards Identified using Different Approaches
0
100
%
Actual Total Hazards ID from Prescriptive
ID from Structured Risk ID from Unstructured Risk
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a A Culture within a Culture
Safety ManagementCulture
Risk Based Culture
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a Summarize
• Further Training / refresher training
• Continuous Improvement
• Commitment
• Competitive Advantage
Marine Risk AssuranceL
loyd
s R
egis
ter
- A
sia
Llo
yds
Reg
iste
r -
Asi
a Building better business
Working together to improve business performance