Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Mega!phon Child and youth participation
Have a say, help with the design, contribute ideas, exert an influence, find solutions, work creatively, take part.
Mega!phon creates opportunities for children and young people in Zurich to be involved.
CfC Participation, Wirkungsevaluation1. März 2010, Seite 2
Stadt ZürichSoziale Dienste
Child/youth participation in the City of Zurich
Schools
Promotion of structures Support of school staff Providing
specialist/methodical resources
Extracurricular areas
Promotion of child/youth participation
Implementation/support of participatory planning
Representation of interests Coordination of children’s
political activities
Taking part at schoolSchool and sports department
Strategic/organisational development
Mega!phonDepartment for Social Affairs
Social services
CfC Participation, Wirkungsevaluation1. März 2010, Seite 3
Stadt ZürichSoziale Dienste
Initial evaluation
Basic, strategic questionsSpecifically on the subject of the design of public spaceswith the help of key projects
What effect does our work have?
What distinguishes the results of our work?
Do we meet our strategic targets with our activites?Of Mega!phon, the play area planning department, City of Zurich
Focus themes Product Process Division into 4 categories Sustainability
CfC Participation, Wirkungsevaluation1. März 2010, Seite 4
Stadt ZürichSoziale Dienste
4 Evaluation areas (1)
Product quality Enrichment through
innovation
Attractiveness to target groups
Play and recreational quality
Aesthetic implementation
Sustainability Violence and vandalism
Establishment in the district
Stimulus for the district
Paving the way for participatory planning
Interdepartmental/ interdisciplinary collaboration
CfC Participation, Wirkungsevaluation1. März 2010, Seite 5
Stadt ZürichSoziale Dienste
4 Evaluation areas (2)
Efficiency Disruption to planning
processes
Maintenance expenditure
Costsconstruction / maintenance
Image District
Children
Municipality
Participating organisations
CfC Participation, Wirkungsevaluation1. März 2010, Seite 6
Stadt ZürichSoziale Dienste
Evaluation process
CfC Participation, Wirkungsevaluation1. März 2010, Seite 7
Stadt ZürichSoziale Dienste
Important factors (1)
Questions
In advance Have a clear knowledge of
the questions Operationalisation /
definition of criteria
Sources of information
Designate information carriers
Include different perspectivesPlanners – children – district – maintenance, etc.
Formulate questions so that they are suitable for the target groups
CfC Participation, Wirkungsevaluation1. März 2010, Seite 8
Stadt ZürichSoziale Dienste
Important factors (2)
Survey methods
Choice of suitable methods Mixture of methods:
Structured interview, poss. on siteQuestionnaireVisualisation (posters)also changing within groups
Implementation/media, relationship level:FormalPersonalPlayful-interactive
Impartiality
Objective approach Prevent those surveyed
from being biased External specialist support
Thank you for your attention.
I will be happy to answer any questions.
Pascal Kreuer
Tel. +41 43 336 12 10Email [email protected]
Mega!phon Child and youth participation
