Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    1/27

    5

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    FLBE[ K. YFE]F JJJ, F]U. ]KA 56::5:HER G@@JMF] G@ FLBE[ K. YFE]F JJJ50;66 PFA\V[E KHPL., ]VJ\F 29) :>5-;;99@emsjdjhf3 (>5>) :>5-;;95

    Fdejh3 flberpfesfIbdejh.mgd

    Ettgrafy `gr Lf`faleatsNFEH \NF RG[HL @GVALE\JGAeal VAJ\FL @HFF\

    VAJ\FL ]\E\F] LJ]\[JM\ MGV[\

    MFA\[EH LJ]\[JM\ G@ MEHJ@G[AJE

    CGNA B. K[EAME, ]pfmjehEldjajstretgr g` tnf Fstetf g`Djmnefh Cemosga? CGNA DMMHEJA,]pfmjeh Eldjajstretgr g` tnf Fstetf g`Djmnefh Cemosga? \[JVDYN JA\F[AE

    \JGAEH, JAM. e Mehj`graje mgrpgretjga,

    Yhejatj``s,

    NFEH \NF RG[HL @GVALE\JGA, eMehj`graje mgrpgretjga? VAJ\FL @HFF\,e Mehj`graje mgrpgretjga? eal LGF] 5-59, jamhusjvf,

    Lf`faleats.

    ))))))))))))))))

    Mesf Ag.3 MP 9:-929>< LDB (YHEx)

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA],LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    \jdf3 :3=9 EDLetf3 Eprjh >, ;955Yhemf3 Mgurtrggd 2Culbf3 Nga. Lghhy D. Bff

    \G \NJ] NGAG[EKHF MGV[\ EAL EHH JA\F[F]\FL YE[\JF]3

    Lf`faleats Nfeh tnf Rgrhl @gualetjga eal Vajtfl @hfft nfrfky sukdjt

    tnfjr wjtafss DFH RJH]GA] fxfmutfl lfmheretjga ja Hjfu g` ljrfmt tfstj-

    dgay.

    Mesf ;39:-mv-929>

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    2/27

    ;

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    J, DFH RJH]GA, ualfr pfaehty g pfrcury, nfrfky lfmherf tnet J wjhh eppfer et

    trjeh eal tfstj`y tnf `ghhgwjab ja`grdetjga tg kf truf, emmuretf eal mgrrfmt3

    5. J, DFH RJH]GA stertfl wgrojab es e vghuatffr wjtn DfhjsseCgnasga ja ;995, mgamfrajab nfr prgpgseh tg rfvjvf Nfeh tnf Rgrhl

    @gualetjga, rfturajab jt tg jts mgrf djssjga g` nfhpjab tnf dgst

    vuhafrekhf. Dfhjsse nel lfvfhgpfl e wey `gr Djmnefhs mnerjty tg prgvjlf

    tnf tgghs eal rfsgurmfs afflfl tg brgw fxpgafatjehhy wgrhlwjlf, vje ea

    jajtjetjvf snf mehhfl Djmnefhs Erdy (Djmnefhs Erdy js ea jajtjetjvf lfvfh-

    gpfl ky Cgnasga tnet wguhl rfmrujt N\R@ vghuatffrs, lfvgtfl tg mnerem-

    tfr jdprgvfdfat eal mgdduajty sfrvjmf.)

    ;. Ky ;995, J nel mgdphftfl e destfrs lfbrff ja pukhjm eldja-jstretjga eal mngsf es dy `gmus aga-prg`jt wgro. Lurjab dy stulfat

    yfers J wes emtjvfhy javghvfl ja djmrgmrfljt eal sfrvfl e tjdf es e wfk

    lfvfhgpfr `gr e stulfat brgup mehhfl NFHY. \njs grbeajzetjga sfat deay

    lgzfas g` stulfats lgwa tg verjgus Hetja Edfrjmea mguatrjfs tg ejl ja e

    verjfty g` pgvfrty ehhfvjetjga prgcfmts. \nf wgro Dfhjsse Cgnasga wes

    lfvfhgpjab tg prgpgsf tg Dr. Cemosga `gr njs mnerjty, wes ehgab tngsf

    sedf hjafs, sg J rfeljhy ebrffl tg vghuatffr wjtn nfr ja tnf prgcfmt.

    =. Ehsg ja ;995, J wjtafssfl Drs. Cgnasga lg sgdf elvgmemywgro ja Resnjabtga L.M., eal es sumn, wf wfrf ekhf tg dfft ]faetgrs

    Nerry [ffl eal Cgna Fasjba, (sff fx. E, e truf eal mgrrfmt mgpy ettemnfl

    Mesf ;39:-mv-929>

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    3/27

    =

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    nfrftg) eal famgurebfl tnfd tg pusn tg nevf dgrf `uals ehhgmetfl tg tnf

    `grfjba ejl kulbft, `gr pgvfrty ehhfvjetjga.

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    4/27

    . Ga ;/5>/59, ja Yhejatj``s AG\JMF G@ DG\JGA EAL DG\JGA@G[ Y[FHJDJAE[Z JACVAM\JGA, tnf Yhejatj``s eal tnfjr wjtafss, Fvea

    ]pjfbfh, wng bjvfs e lfmheretjga ja tnf dgtjga, tfstj`y ualfr pfaehty

    g` pfrcury tnet3

    Rnfa jt kfmedf mhfer tg Ds. Cgnasga tnet Dr. Cemosga wes agt jatfrfstfl

    ja wgrojab wjtn nfr, snf uhtjdetfhy ebrffl tg treas`fr tnf lgdeja aedfs tg

    Dr. Cemosga `gr tnf sud g` $;0,2;0.

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    7/27

    2

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    pfrsgaeh semrj`jmf, ehh tg emqujrf eal prgtfmt, ga nfr gwa tjdf eal et nfr

    gwa fxpfasf, tnf JY prgpfrty, `gr tnf seof g` tnf mnerjty? afvfr esojab e

    pfaay, agt fvfa tg rfjdkursf nfr `gr nfr gwa mgsts gvfr tnf yfers.

    Cemosga/Cgnasga mgatremt mga`jrds tnjs eal seys3Cgnasga, upga

    nfr gwa jajtjetjvf, et nfr gwa tjdf eal fxpfasf, eal wjtngut eay ljrfmtjga

    `rgd Cemosga gr DCC prglumtjgas(Fx. L sfmtjga ;.5, e truf eal mgrrfmt

    mgpy ettemnfl nfrftg)

    55. J wes tnfrf wjtn Dfhjsse wnfa tnf ebrffdfat wes delf kyDr. Cemosga, tg teof gwafrsnjp g` tnf lgdejas eal pertafr wjtn Dfhjsse

    tg prgtfmt tnf mnerjty prgpfrty `rgd tnf gpfa pukhjm.

    \nf Cemosga/Cgnasga ;99= mgatremt rfels3 Cemosga lfsjrfs tg prg-

    tfmt tnf f``grts g` Cgnasga tg prgtfmt tnf lgdeja aedfs `rgd tnf gpfa

    deroft (Fx. L sfmtjga ;.

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    8/27

    >

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    agt tg fal prjgr tg, Dey 5, ;990 \NF(=)ZFE[ DJDJAVD DEJA\FA\EAMF

    YF[JGL...(Fx. L sfmtjga =.

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    9/27

    :

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    bfh, tg rfafw tnf prgpfrty femn yfer nf wes mgatremtfl tg lg sg ga Dr.

    Cemosgas kfneh`? jf. ;99=-;990. \nf ;99= Cgnasga/Cemosga mgatremt

    mhferhy prgvfs tnjs, es tnf dgafy pejl gut, js emtuehhy hjstfl ja tnf mga-

    tremt, mjtjab fxemthy wnfrf tnf dgafy wfat eal wng jt wes pejl

    ljrfmthy tg, aedfhy, Dfhjsses sjstfr, Metnfrjaf Rnjpphf eal nfr `gstfr

    Dgtnfr, Kfryh ]ehtfr eal agt e pfaay wfat tg Dfhjsse Cgnasga. (sff Fx.

    L, sfmtjga =.;, =.;.5-=.=, e truf eal mgrrfmt mgpy ettemnfl nfrftg )

    \nf Cemosga/Cgnasga ;99= mgatremt rfels3 DCC buereatff tnet jt

    snehh pey gr meusf tg kf pejl tg Cgnasga, e _rfjdkursfdfatT, ja tnf tgteh

    ebbrfbetf edguat g` \wfaty-sjx \nguseal ]fvfa nualrfl twfaty sjx Lgh-

    hers eal `grty-\wg Mfats ($;0,2;0.

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    10/27

    59

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    Ja tnf afbgtjetjgas prfmfljab tnf lgdeja treas`fr, Ds. Cgnasga ebeja

    emoagwhflbfl tnf `emt tnet snf nes ag rfhetjgasnjp wjtn Dr. Cemosga3 mjtjab

    ea fdejh `rgd Cgnasga tg ]pjfbfh ja ;99; tnfy qugtf tnf fdejh. fx.@

    Yhejatj``s qugtf Cgnasga ja tnf fdejh3 Zgu nevf kgtn tghl df tnet

    DCC wjhh agt fvfr lfeh wjtn df ljrfmthy eal j` tnet js tnf mesf,(wnjmn J kf-

    hjfvf tg kf nggfy) tnfa snedf ga tnfd eal J wjhh kf vfry bhel tg wejt `gr

    Dr. Cemosgas mehh pfrsgaehhy.fx.@

    56. Yhejatj``s erf djshfeljab tnf mgurt, ky qugtjab `rgd e 6-52-;99; fdejh, tg hfel tnf mgurt tg kfhjfvf tnfy wfrf sngwjab fvjlfamf tnet

    neppfafl gvfr e yfer hetfr, ja Cuaf g` ;99=, wnfrfja, `ehsfhy sngwjab

    Dfhjsse wguhl kf eldjttjab snf nel ag rfhetjgasnjp tg Dr. Cemosga, ja

    pertjmuher, et tnf tjdf g` tnf Cemosga/Cgnasga Yertafrsnjp ebrffdfat ja

    ;99=, wnfrf Dfhjsse nel prgvjlfl tnf mgurt, e mgpy g` e ;99= mgatremt

    prgvjab tnfrf wes e dutuehhy `rjfalhy rfhetjgasnjp ky tnjs tjdf.

    \nf Fstetf mgatjaufs ga tg stetf3 Ja tnf afbgtjetjgas prfmfljab tnf

    lgdeja treas`fr,_tnfy erf rf`frrjab tg tnf ;99= lgdeja treas`frT Ds.

    Cgnasga ebeja emoagwhflbfl tnf `emt tnet snf nes ag rfhetjgasnjp wjtn Dr.

    Cemosga._tnfa tnfy rf`frfamf e ;99; fdejh es fvjlfamf g` e mgdphftfhy

    lj``frfat lgdeja treas`frT (Fx.@ Yb.50, e truf eal mgrrfmt mgpy ettemnfl

    nfrftg)

    50. Agw tnfrf wfrf twg lj``frfat tjdf `redfs wnfa Dfhjsseebrffl tg lgaetf tnf lgdeja mghhfmtjga tg Dr. Cemosgas mnerjty eal J

    wes prfsfat lurjab kgtn jasteamfs. Gaf wes ja Eprjh ;99; eal gaf wes

    Mesf ;39:-mv-929>

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    11/27

    55

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    ja Cuaf ;99=. Kgtn nel vfry lj``frfat gutmgdfs eal femn nel e tjdf

    wnfa Dfhjsse nel lj``frfat rfhetjgasnjp wjtn Dr. Cemosga. Ja Eprjh g`

    ;99;, Dfhjsse nel kffa mgatemtfl ky Brfb Mnedkfrheja `jrst (e buy wng

    deabfl verjgus lgdejas `gr Cemosga), tnea Dr. ]pjfbfh, eal Mnedkfr-

    heja eal ]pjfbfh kgtn weatfl Dfhjsse tg wgro wjtn tnfd ga

    kfneh` g` Cemosga, agt tnf gtnfr wey ergual. Dfhjsse treas`frrfl tnf

    Cemosga aedf eal e `fw gtnfrs tg Mnedkfrheja, et ag mgst. \nfa Dr.

    ]pjfbfh epprgemnfl Dfhjsse tg kuy tnf fatjrf mghhfmtjga, ebeja, Dfhjsse

    tghl ]pjfbfh snf wguhl bjvf tnfd tg Dr. Cemosga et ag mgst. \nf afbgtj-

    etjgastnfy rf`fr ja tnf `grbgjab, wfrf strjmthy ja ;99; eal nel agtnjab

    tg lg wjtn bjvjab Dfhjsse eay dgafy, es tnfy hfel tnf mgurt tg kfhjfvf.

    52. Dr. ]pjfbfhs lfmheretjga gr Yhejatj``s Yrfhjdjaery jacuamtjga,wnfrf nf stetfs3

    E`tfr jt kfmedf mhfer tg Ds. Cgnasga tnet Dr. Cemosga nel ag

    jatfrfst ja mghhekgretjab wjtn nfr gr nfr grbeajzetjga, snf snj`tfl nfr

    `gmus tg sfhhjabtg Dr. Cemosga, tnf deay nualrfls g` tgp-hfvfh lgdeja

    aedfs snf nel rfbjstfrfl wjtngut eutngrjzetjga..ettemnfl nfrftg js Fx-

    njkjt @rfberljab tnf treas`fr g` tnf lgdeja aedfs.(Fx. @ Yb.50, 55-5;,

    e truf eal mgrrfmt mgpy ettemnfl nfrftg)

    Et tnf tgp g` njs Fxnjkjt @, Dr. ]pjfbfh js rf`frrjab tg, tnf letfjs

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    12/27

    5;

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    5>. \nfsf ettfdpts ]pjfbfh deofs tg djtjbetf tnf pertafrsnjpDfhjsse nel wjtn Dr. Cemosga ja ;99=, ky krjabjab fvjlfamf ja `rgd

    ;99;, wes cust gaf fxedphf wnfrf Dr. ]pjfbfh djshfels tnjs mgurt ky

    deajpuhetjab tnf mgatfxt g` tnf fvjlfamf nf qugtfl. Dr. ]pjfbfh deofs

    rf`frfamf tg Dfhjsses ettfdpts ja sfhhjabtg Dr. Cemosga, nualrfls g`

    lgdejas eal tnfa bjvfs njs Fxnjkjt @, es ea fxedphfg` Dfhjsse tryjab tg

    sfhhtnf lgdeja mghhfmtjga tg Dr. Cemosga, wnjmn js e lfhjkfretf lfmfp-

    tjga. \nf fxnjkjt @ wes dfrfhy ea ettemndfat tg e

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    13/27

    5=

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    neh` g` Dr. Cemosga, wf bevf tnfd tnjs hjst g` lgdeja aedfs wf nel agt

    yft emqujrfl eal stjhh afflfl tg kf emqujsjtjgafl tg mgdphftf tnf mnerjty

    mghhfmtjga. Dfhjsse esofl tnfd tg purmnesf tnfsf mfrteja djssjab lg-

    deja aedfs, agt `rgd nfr, (snf ljl agt yft gwa tnfd) kut `rgd tnf rfbjs-

    trer eal/gr lgdeja krgofrs sfhhjab tnf aedfs.

    Ja ]pjfbfhs Fxnjkjt @ (fx.C) jt js stetfl3..tnf lgdeja aedfs affl-

    fl. js e hjst ja tnf hfttfr eal dgst g` tnf lgdeja aedfs erf .tv

    aedfs, es Dfhjsse gwafl tnf .mgd, .aft eal .grb eal weatfl tg mgdphftf

    tnf sft wjtn tnf fxpfasjvf .tv. vfrsjga. Fx.C

    Ja tnjs sedf hfttfr, Dfhjsse seys3

    Deof surf tnet ygu lg agt pey gvfr $=6.99 `gr tnf lgt \P aedfs

    59.99 `gr tnf mgd, aft, grb. Dfhjsse wes rf`frrjab tg rfbjstrers tnet

    mnerbf $69.99 `gr lgt \P aedfs eal sgdf phemfs wguhl bg es hgw es

    $=6.99 eal jastfel g` $=6.99 `gr e lgt mgd, tnfy mguhl pey wnghfsehf `gr

    $59.99. Agt tg nfr! @gr tnfdsfhvfs! fx. C

    ]nf mgatjaufs ja njs fxnjkjt @3 Eal tnf 099+ aedfs wjhh gahy mgst

    $59.99 tg treas`fr tnf fatjrf hgt. Fx.C. Dfhjsse wes rf`frrjab tg tnf 099

    lgdejas snf wes bjvjabtg Dr. Cemosga `gr njs mnerjty. ]nf nel afbgtj-

    etfl Dr. Cemosga wnghfsehf retfs `gr tnf treas`fr/rfafweh mgst. \nfrf

    wes afvfr e sehfg` eay lgdeja `rgd Cgnasga tg Cemosga, kut ]pjfbfh

    eal tnf Fstetf weatfl tnf mgurt tg kfhjfvf tnjs Fxnjkjt @ hfttfr, wes

    dfeat es afbgtjetjgas`gr ea fxtgrtjga ettfdpt gr sehf, wnfa jts truf

    purpgsf wes gaf g` bggl jatfat ga Cgnasgas pert.

    Mesf ;39:-mv-929>

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    14/27

    5-;99= nf stetfs3

    dy essjsteat Flljf, cust trjfl mehhjab ygueal J wjhh mehh ygu ga

    Rflafsley, >-5

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    16/27

    50

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    mea kf sffa ky gaf g` tnf treas`fr mgatremts kftwffa tnfd. (]ff Mned-

    kfrheja mgatremt fx. N, e truf eal mgrrfmt mgpy ettemnfl nfrftg)

    \nf mgatremt sngws3Dfhjsse Cgnasga sjbas tg treas`fr tnf lgdeja

    aedf Djmnefhcemosga.tv, ga

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    17/27

    52

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    ;

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    18/27

    5>

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    ;2. Ja rfspgasf tg tnf Fstetf rfvfehjab nfr prjvetf fdejhs, J meagahy tfstj`y tg wnet J oagw ekgut tnfd. Gaf g` tnfd, J wes prfsfat wnfa

    Dfhjsse wrgtf jt, jt wes tg [eydgaf Keja eal snf mgpjfl eal sfat jt tg Eh

    Dehajo es wfhh, (kgtn Cemosga rfps wng nel gr wguhl sfrvf tjdf ea njs

    deaebfrs) fxphejajab tnet Cemosga djbnt kf mgd`grtfl ja sgdf

    oagwhflbf snf nel, j` tnfy wguhl rfhey tnf mgatfat g` nfr fdejh. (Fx. O,

    e truf eal mgrrfmt mgpy ettemnfl nfrftg)

    ;>. Dfhjsse wrgtf ja 5-5;-96 (`jvf dgatns kf`grf tnf vfrljmt)3J cust weat njd tg oagw tnet nf wjhh agt kf mgavjmtfl. Uujtf tnf gppgsjtf ja

    `emt, es nf wjhh kf mgdphftfhy fxgafretfl kgtn hfbehhy eal ja tnf fyfs g` tnf

    pukhjm. J oagw jt `gr e `emttnet DC wjhh agt kf `gual bujhty Fx. O

    ]nf mgatjaufs ga3.J cust weat njd tg oagw. J weat njd tg nevf

    sgdf pfemf. J` tnfrf wes ea guamf g` lgukt ja dy djal, J wguhl afvfr tgy

    wjtn sgdftnjab sg sfasjtjvf es sgdfgafs hj`f ea g``fr up pgssjkhf `ehsf

    ngpfs. J nevfag lgukt ekgut tnjs eal tnet js wny J `ffh go ekgut tfhhjab

    njd. J wgat kf wrgab. (Fx. O, e truf eal mgrrfmt mgpy ettemnfl nfrftg)

    ;:. J sew nfr bg gut ga e hjdk et tnjs lj``jmuht tjdf g` Dr. Cemo-sgas hj`f eal wes tnfrf wnfa snf lfmherfl ja Ceauery ;996, `jvf dgatns

    kf`grf Dr. Cemosga wes `gual agt bujhtyga ehh tfa mguats ebejast njd,

    tnet nf wguhl agt kf `gual bujhty g` e sjabhf mnerbf gr mguat ebejast njd

    eal tnjs wes kf`grf Cemosgas trjeh stertfl eal ja tgteh mgatrest tg e

    brgwjab dflje eal pukhjm sfatjdfat et tnf tjdf? es dgst kfhjfvfl Cemo-

    sga wguhl kf mgavjmtfl g` sgdftnjab, et hfest e mguphf g` hfssfr mnerbfs.

    Mesf ;39:-mv-929>

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    19/27

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    20/27

    ;9

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    khf ja tnfjr eldjssjgas, kut tnfy wfrf ehsg tneao`uh `gr tnf ljsmhgsurf.

    Jts dy vjfw tnet mfrteja pfgphf nevf bj`ts, eal tngsf bj`ts erf pgssfssfl

    ky e hjst dumn sngrtfr tnea tngsf wng mhejd tg nevf tnfd. Cgnasga,

    ngwfvfr, js njbnhy premtjmeh, brgualfl eal jalustrjgus. ]nf lgfs agt sjt

    ja e mgrafr wjtn fyfs rghhfl kemo duttfrjab sgdftnjab ualfr nfr krfetn.

    Afjtnfr lgfs snf prfsfat nfrsfh` es e buru wng affls `ghhgwfrs. Jastfel

    Jvf gksfrvfl nfr `ghhgwjab \ngdes Fljsgas dumn-qugtfl pjfmf g` elvjmf3

    Bfajus js gaf pfr mfat jaspjretjga, ajafty-ajaf pfr mfat pfrspjretjga.

    =5. Dfhjsse eal J wfrf tghl ky e Cemosga deaebfr, Dr. Ehfxea-lfr, tnet Dr. Cemosga nel njs gwa spjrjtueh elvjsgr ga tnf peyrghh eal nf

    kfhjfvfl, hjof djhhjgas g` gtnfrs, tnet sgdf pfgphf pgssfss mfrteja bj`ts

    eal snf wes agt wrgab tg kfhjfvf tnet Dr. Cemosga dey kf gpfa tg tnf

    pgssjkjhjty tnet snf nel ea eutnfatjm spjrjtueh fxpfrjfamf ja 5::=,

    rfhetjab tg nfr jaspjretjga `gr nfr wgro mgamfrajab N\R@. J nevf wjt-

    afssfl deay jasteamfs gvfr tnf yfers tnet Dfhjsse wes g`tfa rjbnt (fvfa

    tngubn nfr essfrtjgas ekgut tnf `uturf rea mgatrery tg tnf glls, eal

    pgpuher kfhjf` et tnf tjdf) es mgavfyfl ja tnf fdejhs rf`frfamfl ekgvf, e

    bggl mehh snguhl agt kf mneremtfrjzfl es e mneremtfr `hew.

    =;. \g sngw cust e `fw fxedphfs, J agtjmfl ja tnf hfttfr tnet Dr.]pjfbfh prfsfatfl tg tnf mgurt, spfmj`jmehhy, njs fxnjkjt @, (fx. C, e truf

    eal mgrrfmt mgpy ettemnfl nfrftg) tnet wnjhf snf wes tryjab tg fxpheja

    wny Dr. Cemosga eal njs mnerjty snguhl purmnesf up ehh lgdeja aedf

    Mesf ;39:-mv-929>

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    21/27

    ;5

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    prgpfrty rfhetfl tg njs aedf eal jajtjehs, DCsnf dey nevf fxphejafl ja

    ;99;, tnf `rfazy `gr njs dfrmnealjsf `ghhgwjab njs lfetn.

    Ja ]pjfbfhs fxnjkjt @ (fx. C) Cgnasga stetfs ja ;99;3

    @urtnfr, J oagw tnet N\R@ eal Dr. Cemosgas aedf eal ehh rfhetfl

    prgcfmts erf bgjab tg kf jatfraetjgaehhy lfsjrfl eal tnf lfdeal `gr eay-

    tnjab DC js bgjab tg kf mgasjlfrfl ea jasteat eal njbnhy vehufl mgddgljty.

    \nf DC aedf wjhh kf kjbbfr tnea tnf kffthfs rebfg` tnf sjxtjfs eal wjhh

    kf dgrf jatfraetjgaehhy deroftfl tnea F\ gr ]ter wers mgdkjafl. Zgu dust

    kuy up fvfry verjeat g` DC eaytnjabvjrtueh rjbnt agw, es ygu nevf ag

    jlfe wnet ygu dey affl tg deroft gahjaf (tnf `estfst brgwjab jatfraetjgaeh

    dfljud ja Njstgry) ja tnf `uturf. fx.C.

    ==. Cemosga wes rjbnt tg phemf njs mga`jlfamf ja Cgnasga,wnftnfr gr agt snf oafw e tnjab gr twg ekgut tnf `uturf, snf prfsfrvfl

    vehuekhf Cemosga prgpfrty `gr Djmnefh Cemosga, afvfr teojab e pfaay `gr

    nfr f``grts eal usfl nfr gwa dgafy tg lg jt. Rnjhf J hferafl tnet Cgna

    Kreame ga tnf gtnfr neal, delf djhhjgas `rgd Cemosga, wnjhf `ejhjab tg

    Yrgtfmt 526 \rjudpn trelfderos `rgd kfjab ekealgafl kftwffa Agvfd-

    kfr 5::= eal Agvfdkfr 5::6 eal Cgnasga sfmurfl gvfr -]fpt ;99:, tnf vfry sedf

    kreals tnet wfrf ekealgafl ga Kreames wetmn. E`tfr Cemosgas lfetn,

    njs pejl fdphgyffs mgatjaufl tg lg agtnjab tg prgtfmt tnf kreals eal J

    pfrsgaehhy nfhpfl tnf mnerjty sfmurf ea javfstgr tg prgtfmt ea elljtjgaeh

    =

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    22/27

    ;;

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    =).

    =6. J wjtafssfl Dfhjsse semrj`jmjab nfr pfrsgaeh mgd`grt eal `j-aeamjeh sfmurjty tg teof ja ngdfhfss dgtnfrs eal tnfjr mnjhlrfa, cust kf-

    meusf snf mguhl agt kerf tg sff tnfd su``fr. @gr e lfmelf J nevf gk-

    sfrvfl nfr usjab nfr gwa dgafy tg treasjtjga tnfsf sedf pfgphf jatg e`-

    `grlekhf ngusjab, eal sgdftjdfs tg sft tnfd up wjtn e mer eal cgk, tgg.

    J kfhjfvf tnet nfr neals-ga styhf nes prfperfl eal sfasjtjzfl nfr `gr nfr

    murrfat rghf tg rua Nfeh tnf Rgrhl @gualetjga wjtngut jts `gualfr, Dr.

    Cemosga.

    =0. Ja @fk, ;996, Dfhjsse tghl df tnet Dr. Cemosga nel bjvfanfr Nfeh tnf Rgrhl @gualetjga, eal aedfl nfr es ljrfmtgr tg rfphemf

    njd. Kut tnf eutngrjzetjga jtsfh` wes pfrsgaehhy eatjmhjdemtjm sjamf J wes

    Mesf ;39:-mv-929>

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    23/27

    ;=

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    ewerf `rgd Cgnasga tnet (5) Cemosga wes tryjab tg put njs `jaeamjeh

    ngusf ja grlfr, puttjab gtnfrs ja mnerbf g` njs kusjafss e``ejrs, cust ja

    mesf ea ua`evgrekhf vfrljmt wes nealfl lgwa hetfr ja ;996. Eal (;),

    pgssjkhy `gr tnf `gualetjga tg heuamn ga e breal smehf, dgafy wes affl-

    fl tg `ual jts verjgus jajtjetjvfs (f.b. Djmnefh Cemosga \fhftnga,Dj-

    mnefhs Erdy,eal DC Debezjaf) eal e neals-g`` rghf ky Cemosga jalj-

    metfl tnet Cgnasga eal J wguhl nevf tg mgatjauf tg snguhlfr tnf

    `jaeamjeh kurlfa ehgaf, eal, (=), J wes ehsg kurlfafl ja tnf kfhjf` tnet

    sfmurjab mnerjty trelfderos ga tgp g` yferhy lgdeja mgsts wguhl sjdphy

    krfeo kgtn g` us `jaeamjehhy. Lfspjtf ehh tnjs, Cgnasga eal J stjhh prfssfl

    `grwerl rf`jajab tnf jajtjetjvfs eal usjab nfr ngdf es e neh`-wey ngusf

    tg faemt ga e dumn sdehhfr smehf tnf mnerjtys sfrvjmf bgehs.

    =2. Ehtngubn wf nel tg wejt `gr Cemosgas `jaeamjeh suppgrt ealljrfmt javghvfdfat tg heuamn tnf herbfr jajtjetjvfs, stjhh wf deaebfl tg

    smehf up jts DC Rfk jajtjetjvf, ky prgvjljab e rgkust duhtjdflje eal

    `grud-kesfl wfksjtf kf`grf Cemosgas pessjab. \njs sjtf `gr dgatns

    kfmedf, edgabst gtnfr tnjabs, e sgualjab kgerl `gr brjfvjab `eas uatjh

    tnf Cemosga Fstetf eldjajstretgrs `jhfl tnfjr hewsujt ebejast tnf mnerjty

    ja ]fptfdkfr ;99:, snrflljab gut mrfljkjhjty ja tnf fyfs g` Cemosga

    suppgrtfrs, deay g` wngd hekfhfl us tnjfvfs. Rjtn lgaetjgas agw stgp-

    pjab, tnf sjtuetjga bgt jamrfesjab wgrsf, deojab jt afer jdpgssjkhf tg vjb-

    jheathy `jbnt tnjs hewsujt.

    Mesf ;39:-mv-929>

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    24/27

    ;. J wgrofl lejhy wjtn Dfhjsse Cgnasga lurjab ;996 eal J sfatverjgus N\R@ mgrrfspgalfamf eal upletfl kggos tg Cemosga vje Krjea

    Gxdea tg upletf Cemosga ga tnf mnerjtys fvghvjab jajtjetjvfs. Ja tnf

    ferhy 5::9s Djmnefh Cemosga jastjtutfl tnf Rgrhl Mgabrfss g` Mnjhlrfa

    (RMM) wngsf ygutn edkesselgrs wfrf mgddjssjgafl tg jlfatj`y tnf

    uajquf prgkhfds tnet mguhl kf `gual ja tnfjr pert g` tnf wgrhl eal tg rf-

    pgrt kemo tg N\R@. Ja 5::6, `grty sjx mnjhlrfa `rgd fjbntffa mguatrjfs

    dft `gr tnrff leys g` trejajab sfdjaers eal dfatgrjab et Afvfrheal

    [eamn. J nevf kffa jastrudfateh ja mrfetjab ea N\R@ Zgutn Kgerl g`

    Elvjsgrs (ZKE) tnet js tnf bgvfrajab kgly g` tnf RMM, wnjmn wjhh kf rf-

    jastjtutfl sgdftjdf e`tfr tnjs hewsujt js gvfr. Djmnefh Cemosgas mnjh-

    lrfa eal tnrff gtnfrs nevf kffa ga tnf ygutn kgerl sjamf Cuhy ;959. J

    pertjmjpetfl ja e dfftjab wjtn Oetnfrjaf Cemosga tnet eutngrjzfl tnf

    mnjhlrfas pertjmjpetjga ja tnf mnerjty. Dy pheas erf tg deof surf tnet

    N\R@ js agt gahy e mnjhlrfas mnerjty kfmeusf jt sfrvfs mnjhlrfa, kut kf-

    meusf mnjhlrfa emtjvfhy snepf tnf `gualetjgas `uturf, stffrjab pukhjm

    suppgrt tgwerls jts jajtjetjvfs eal sfesgaeh prgcfmts.

    =:. Rnfa tnf Cemosga Fstetf eldjajstretgrs rfmfathy ettemofltnf mnerjtys f``grts tg krjab aetjgaeh ettfatjga tg ea HE ngdfhfss snfhtfr

    (eal tnus snfhtfrs ja bfafreh), tnfy agt gahy falfl up ljsperebjab gaf g`

    tnf kfaf`jmjerjfs wng js ehsg e kgerl dfdkfr g` Nfeh tnf Rgrhl, kut ehsg

    ljssuelfl vjfwfrs `rgd lgaetjab tg gr sfrvjab tnfjr hgmeh ngdfhfss snfh-

    tfrs.

    Mesf ;39:-mv-929>

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    25/27

    ;6

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    ,

    Dfhjsse esofl df `gr 6,999 tg mgvfr e kuamn mnerjty trelfderos snf

    weatfl tg epphy `gr. Et tnf tjdf snf nel ehrfely epphjfl gr sfvfa nfeh

    tnf wgrhlderos (rf`frrjab tg trelfderos rfhetfl tg tnf mnerjtys aedf3

    Nfeh tnf Rgrhl @gualetjga, Nfeh tnf Rgrhl gr N\R@) eal tnrff mnerjty

    jajtjetjvf deros (rf`frrjab tg trelfderos rfhetfl tg tnf mnerjtys jajtje-

    tjvfs3 Djmnefh Cemosga, Djmnefh gr DC). ]nf tghl df snf weatfl tg epphy

    `gr e mguphf g` dgrf mnerjty aedf deros eal e kuamn g` mnerjty jajtjetjvf

    deros. Et tnf tjdf, nevjab `jvf kgys (eal gaf ga tnf wey) fetjab df gut

    g` ngusf eal ngdf, ehgab wjtn fxpfasfs essgmjetfl wjtn tnf kfbjaajab

    wjtn e afw smnggh yfer, Cgnasga wes esojab dgafy `rgd tnf wrgab buy.

    Hetfr tnet yfer Cgnasga mehhfl eal tghl df sgdfgaf nel mgatemtfl nfr

    eal esofl j` tnfy mguhl kuy gaf g` tnf lgdejas. ]nf ebrffl tg lg sg j`

    nf wguhl bjvf nfr $

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    26/27

    ;0

    LF@FALEA\]RJ\AF]] DFH RJH]GA] F^FMV\FL LFMHE[E\JGA JA HJFV G@ LJ[FM\ \F]\JDGAZ

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    trelfdero hewyfr tg emqujrf ehh tnf deros wf afflfl, sg Dfhjsse kfbea

    stulyjab trelfdero hew eal epphjmetjga prgmfssjab eal snf esofl df tg

    lg sgdf lfsjba wgro `gr nfr. J wes pejl ky nfr, (fvfatuehhy) tg mrfetfl

    sgdf hgbgs, lfsjba wgro, put tnf hgbgs ga prglumts tnet snf mngsf `rgd

    mfrteja ljstrjkutgrs (ljbjtehhy) eal pukhjsn tnf mgdphftfl prglumt gahjaf.

    J ljl tnf lfsjba wgro `gr tnf trelfderos eal Dfhjsse stuljfl tnf hew eal

    `jhfl tnf epphjmetjgas wjtn tnf V]Y\G.

  • 8/7/2019 Melvin Wilson-please give doc time to load, it will show

    27/27

    ;2

    5

    ;

    =

    :

    59

    55

    5;

    5=

    5

    5:

    ;9

    ;5

    ;;

    ;=

    ;

    kreal, kut gur jatfatjga wes afvfr tg offp jt `rgd tnf Fstetf. Ngwfvfr,

    gamf tnfy ettemofl us pukhjmhy ja tnf dflje ga >-55-;99:, `ehsfhy mhejd-

    jab tg tnf wgrhl wf nel ag mgaafmtjga wnetsgfvfrtg Cemosgas medp,

    wf mguhl ag hgabfr rfdgvf Cemosgas aedf g`` gur wfksjtfs, pfr tnfrf

    rfqufst gahy leys hetfr. \njs wguhl nevf hfl tnf pukhjm tg kfhjfvf tnet wf

    wfrf ebrffjab tnet wf wfrf `reuluhfat, es mhejdfl ky tnf Fstetf. Jrrfpe-

    rekhf nerd wguhl mgdf tg gur mnerjty eal tnfrf`grf, wf vgtfl tg offp njs

    aedf eal hjofafss up gahjaf.