Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
NOTE: MIL-STD-1628 has been redesignated as a Test Method Standard. The coverpage has been changed for Administrative reasons. There are no other changesto this Document.
MIL-STD-1628 (SHIPS) 28 JUNE 1974
AMSC N/A FSC 3439
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A. Approved for public release; distribution isunlimited.
DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSETEST METHOD
FILLET WELD SIZE, STRENGTH,AND EFFICIENCY DETERMINATION
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTo-1628 (SHIPS)28 June 1974
DEPARTFUXJT OF THE NAVY
NAVAL SHIP ENGINEER1!IG CEIJTER
HYATTSVILLE, MARYLAND 20782
Fillet Weld Size, Strength,and Efficiency Determination
MIL-sTD-1628 (SHIPS)
1. This Milltary Standard is approved for use by all activities under the cognizanceof the Naval Ship Systems Command.
2. For contracts or procurement orders which ~nvoke ex~sting fabrication documentswhich have self-contained fillet weld efficiency requlremcnts, the contractor or vendorshall not use this standard without prior contractual approval.
3. Repair ships, Tenders, Repair Facilities, Supervisors of Shlpbuildlng and NavalShipyards may use this standard in lieu of other criteria in various fabrication documentsnow invoked by Chapter 9920 [NAVSHIPS 0901-920-0003) of the Naval Ships Technical Manualfor alteration and repair.
4. Any conflicts noted w~thin this standard or between this standard and referenceddocuments should be brought to the attention of the Naval ship Engineering Center (NAVSEC),Department of the Navy, Center Building, Prince Georqe’s Center, Ilyattsville, Maryland20782. In addition, recommended corrections, additions, or deletions should also be sentto the above address.
ii
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTI)-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FOREWORD
1. This standard was prepared for tne purpose of comblnlng, updating and expandingduplicate fillet weld shear strength information now contained in a number of fabricationstandards. The duplication of information increases the possibility of confusion andconflicting data. It is the intent of this standard to contain all of the fillet weldshear strength, and efficiency data acceptable for use In construction and repair of Navalships.
2. Information contained in this standard was obtained by actual shear testing ofrepresentative filler metal and base metal combinations welded in accordance with goodfabrication practices. The resulting welds were similar in quality to those actuallyproduced during production fabrication. Tables and figures (charts) were prepared tosimplify and condense presentation of the information. In addition to the tables and charts,the formulas and methods used to develop the charts are also presented.
3. Existing data obtained from shear testinq has been reviewed for accuracy. Sometest samples yielding questionable results have been retested to verify the data. Additionalshear testinq may be accomplished to further expand the selection of filler metal and basemetal Comblnatlons.
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
J41L-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
1.2.3.4.4.45.5.15.1.15.1.25.1.35.1.45.1.5
5.2
5.2.15.2.25.2.35.2.45.35.45.4.15.4.25.4.35.55.5.15.5.25.5.35.5,46.
III
111
1213141516171819202122232425262728
CONTENTS
SCOPE.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . “ “ “.””REFERENCED DOCUMENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .TERMS, DEFINITIONS, MD SYmLS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .GENHWLREQUIR=NTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . Q . . . “ “ - “
Appl~cabillty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .DETAIL REQUIREMENTS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . “
Fillet weld table and chart description and usage . . . .General . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . s . . . . 0 “Base metal ultimate tensile strength . . . . . . . . . . .Filler metal strength . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Index to efficiency charts and computation factors . . . .Fillet weld size and efficiency charts (figures 1through 40) . . . . . . . 0 . . . . . . . 0 . . . . . . -
Direct calculation of fillet weld strength, computationfactors, fillet weld size and efficiencies . . . . . . .
Calculation of fillet weld strength . . . . . . . . . . .Calculation of computation factors . . . . . . . . . . . .Computing fillet weld size . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Computing fillet weld efficiency . . . . . . . . . . . . .partial penetration groove tee welds . . . . . . . . . . .Sample calculations . . . . . . . . . . . . 0 . . . . G .partial penetration groove tee welds . . . . . . . . . . .Strength of fillet weld joints . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Fillet weld size and efficiency . . . . . . . . . . . . .Continuous double fillet weld effic~ency chart developmentGeneral . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0 0 .Derivation of equation for fillet weld size . . . . . . .Efficiency chart drawing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Developmentof shear data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
NOTES INotapplicabie) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
TABLES
~
. . 1
. . 1
. . 1,. 2. . 2. . 2. . 2. . 2. . 2. . 3,. 4
,. 11
. . 11
. . 11
. . 11
. . 12
. . 12/13
. . 13
. . 13
. . 13
. . 14
. . 15
. . 17
. . 17
. . 17
. . 18
. . 18
. . 18
Base metal tensile strength . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3Filler metal strength values . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4Index to efficiency charts and computation factors . . . . . . . . ;-i~
FIGURES
Efficiency chart for computation factor of 0.30 . . . . . . . . . . 19Efficiency chart for computation factor Of 0.35 . . . . . . . . . . 20Efficiency chart for computation factor of 0.40 . . . . . . . . . . 21Efficiency chart for computation factor of 0.45 . . . . . . . . . . 22Efficiency chart for computation factor of 0.50 . . . . . . . . . . 23Efficiency chart for computation factor of 0.55 . . . . . . . . . . 24Efficiency chart for computation factor of 0.60 . . . . . . . . . . 25Efficiency chart for computation factor of 0.65 . . . . . . . . . . 26Efficiency chart for computation factor of 0.70 . . . . . . . . . . 27Efficiency chart for computation factor of 0.75 . . . . . . . . . . 28Efficiency chart for computation factor of 0.80 . . . . . . . . . . 29Efficiency chart for computation factor of 0.85 . . . . . . . . . . 30Efficiency chart for computation factor of 0.90 . . . . . . . . . . 31Efficiency chart for computation factor of 0.95 . . . . . . . . . . 32Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.00 . . . . . . . . . . 33Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.05 . . . . . . . . . . 34Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.10 . . . . . . . . . . 35Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.15 . . . . . . . . . . 36Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.20 . . . . . . . . . . 37
Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.25 . . . . . . . . . . 38
Efficiency chart for computation fiSCtO?of 1.30 . . . . . . . . . . 39
Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.35 . . . . . . . . . . 40Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.40 . . . . . . . . . . :;Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.45 . . . . . . . . . .Efficiency chart for computation faCtO? of 1.50 . . . . . . . . . . :;Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.55 . . . . . . . . . .Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.60 . . . . . . . . . . 45Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.65 . . . . . . . . . . 46
iv
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
29303132333435363738394041
MIL-sTD-1628 (SHIPS)28 June 1974
CONTENTS (Cent’d)
FIGURSS (Cent’d)
Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.70 . . . , . . . . .Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.75 . . . . . . . . . .Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.80 , . . . . . . . . .Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.85 . . . . . . . . . .Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.90 . . . . . . . . , .Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.95 . . . . . . . . . .Efficiency chart for computation factor of 2.00 . . . . . . . . . .Efficiency chart for computation factor of 2.05 . . . . . . . . . .Efficiency chart for computation factor of 2.10 . . . . . . . . . .Efficiency chart for computation factor of 2.15 . . . . . . . . . .Efficiency chart for computation factor of 2.20 . . . . . . . . . .Efficiency chart for computation factor of 2.25 . . . . . . . . . .Partial penetration groove tee welds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
~
47484950515253545556575B59
v/vi
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628 (SHIPS)28 June 1914
1. SCOPE
1.1 This standard contains the necessary data for selecting or calculating continuousdouble fillet weld sizes t!tatwill !>rovidc the required joint efficiency and yet beeconomical for the application involved.
1.2 The base metal and WCIU metal tcnsllc strenqths of tables I and II, respectively,are based on mninur. procurement s~wclflcatlon values unless othezvlsc specified herein, Theweld metal longitud~nal shear strength values In table II arc based on actual testinq. ThCcomputation factors of table III arc calculated based on the specific strength values of thebase metal/weld metal conhination being consldcrecl. Fiqures 1 through 40 depict fillet weldefficiency charts based on the various computation factors. Accordingly, fillet weldstrength, size, or efficiency can be determined for a specific material combination andthickness. Weld sizing formulas for partial penetration groove tec welds are elso included.
1.3 This standard is intended to furnish continuous double fillet WCld sizing criteriabased on specific design requirements; it is not intended to furnish strength values foruse in determining design or allowable working loads.
2. REFERENCED DOCUMENTS
2.1 The issues of the followlng documents in effect on the date of invitation forbids form a part of this standard to the extent specified herein.
GOVER1W4EIJTAL
STANDARDMIL-STD-418 - Mechanical Tests for Welded Joints.
(Copies of specifications, standards, drawings, and publications required by suppliersin connection with specific procurement functions should be obtained from the procuringactivity or as directed by the contracting officer. )
NONGOVERNMENTAL
PUBL1CA’I’1ON
AMERICAN WELDING SOCIETY (AWS)A3.O - Terms and Definitions.
(Application for copies should be addressed to the American Weldlng Society, Inc.United Engineering Center, 345 Last 47th Street, New Yori.,ilY10017.)
(Technical society and teclmical association specifications and standards are generallyavailable for reference from libraries. They arc also distributed among technical groupsand using Federal agencies. )
3. TERNS, DEFINITIONS, AIIDSY!IBOLS
3.1 The terms and definitions of AWS A3.~ apply to this standard.
3.2 The following symbols arc used in this standard:
‘1 - Area of base metal subjected to Fl, square inches.
‘2- Area of weld subjected to F2, square inches.
B- Base leq or depth of bevel, inches.
CF- Computation factor.
D- Defective width of the weld in shear, inches.e- efficiency of joint.
‘1- Transverse force on base cetal, pounds.
‘2- I.anqitudinal force on welds, pounds.
‘3- Fillet weld strcnqth per linear inch, pounds/incll.
L- Lenqth of welded ]oint, inches.
‘1- Ultimate tensile strenath of weaker menLer, pounds per s{uare inch (psi).
‘2- Shear strength of weld metal, psi.
1
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628 (SHIPS)28 June 1974
s - Fillet Weld size.
‘1- Thickness of weaker metier (T or TB), inches.
T- Thickness of passing member, inches.
‘B - Thickness of web member, inches.
z- Land width (to nearest 1/16), inc}les.
4. GENEIWL REQUIRE!lEIJTS
4.1 Joint efficiency shall be based on the strenqth of tileweaker member being joined(that member which has the lowest product of thickness times ultimate tensile strength).
4.2 The strength of continuous double-fillet welded joints shall always be based onthe longitudinal shear strength of the base metal-filler metal combination. Where acceptablematerials are used which are not covered lJythxs standard, testing and utilization shall bein accordance with 5.1 through 5.1.5.2 and 5.5 through 5.5.4.1.5.
4.3 Where it can be shown from a desiqn standpoint that the thickness of the weakermember joined is greater than that required to provlcle the necessary strengthweld size may be reduced accordingly to provide a weld joint efficiency basedrequired weaker member thickness.
4.4 Applicability. This standard contains information pertaining to fi.base metal comb lnatlons not covered by all fabrication documents. Therefore,fabrication document shall specify or govern the acceptability of filler meta,metal cotiinations.
5. ULTAIL REOUI1:L!WNTS
5.1 Fillet weld table and chart description and usage.—. —— — —
the filleton the actual
ler metal andthe applicableand base
5.1.1 General. Tables I through III and a group of charts (figures 1 through 40) areprovided for determining base metal strength, filler metal strenqth, computation factors,and weld size for a given base metal and filler metal combination.
5.1.1.1 Continuous double fillet weld sizes for a given joint efficiency are basedupon tl]cload carrying capacity of tlkeweaker member and the shear strength of the fillerk-tal (tli~ weaker mefibet beinq tilebase metai with tllcsmallest product of ultimate tensilestrength times thickness). The base metal combinations listed in table III are listed withthe weaker member dcsiqnated first; therefore, each Last metal combination is listed twice.
5.1.1.2 The computation factors shown on the figures are analogous to a consnonde-nominator and permit the use of fewer efficiency charts as the charts are drawn for a compu-tation factor rather than a base metal and filler metal combination. AS can be seen, anumber of base inctal/filler metal combinations have equivalent computation factors.
5.1.1.3 Fillet weld strenqths, sizes, and efficiencies given in table III and figures1 through 40 are for continuous doul,le fillet welds of qood production quality.
5.1.2 Base metal ultimate tensile stren th. Table I lists the ultimate tensile strengthof the base =l~ercc? in this standble I is intended to be used in computingthe weaker member of the base metal combination to be joined. The values given in table Iare common minimum plate values for each type of material represented. Certain materialspecifications may have differing minimum values. If large differences are encountered,‘,efer to 5.2 for figurinq fillet weld sizes and efficiencies by direct calculation.
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628 (SHIPS)28 June 1974
Table I - Base metal tensile strength.
Base material typeMinimum tensile
strength (psi)~’
[Quenched and tempered alloy steel (IIY-130) ~ 137,000 I
Quenched and tempered alloy steel (1IY-1OO) 114,000
Quenched and tempered alloy steel (HY-80) 96,000
Special treatment steel (STS] 105,000
High tensile steel (IITS) 75,000
Mild steel (MS) 60,000
Austenitic stainless steel (SS) 75,000
Nickel-copper alloy (NiCu) 70,000
Copper-nickel alloy (CuNi) 45,000
Aluminum alloy 5456 45,000
Aluminum alloy 5454 36,000
Aluminum alloy 5086 38,000
/Aluminum alloy 5083 I 40,000 I
~’The most common minimum ultimate tensile strength used inmaterial specifications has been used for the minimum tensilestrength. In the caee of quenched and tempered alloy steels,the tensile strength has been based on a statistical analysisof 38 test certificates to develop a relationship betweenLensile sLrerJgLh [TS) aridyield strength ;YS).
TS = 1.20 YS for HY-80TS = 1.15 ys for Hy-100TS - 1.05 YS for HY-130
5.1.3 Filler metal stren th.“+
Table II lists the ultimate tensile strenqth, averaqeshear streng~d average s ear strength per inch for each filler metal type covered inthis standard. The shear strength (per inch) values given in table 11 can be used todetermine the overall load carrying capacity of a given size double fillet weld by multiply-ing the shear strength (per inch) value by the length of the weld (in inches). The averagerehearstrength values givan can be used to determine weld size and efficiency by directcomputation.
3
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
\jlL-5TIp1628(S1.11’S)
28 June 1974
5.1.4 Index to cfflclcncv c)~artsand com~~utation factors..—— ——
5.1.4.1 Table III lists the proper cfflcicncy chart flqurc number for each base metaland flllor metal comifination covered by this standard. A blank space in the table meansthat the flllcr met.zland base nctal conblnation has not been tested or is not applicable.
w.eak~”i~%gr%~~rw’{ea. tim f,q.re number for the roper filler metal. The weldLoo).up tileclcsircd base metal combination (material of
size for a spcclflc Joint cfflcicncy may then l~cdctcrmincd by referring to the figureqiven in table III or by d~rcct computation using the computation factor designated on theappropriate fiqurc rcfercnce(] in tai,l~ III.
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628 (SHIPS)28 June 1974
Table III - Index to efficiency c!~arts andcomputation factors,
Filler metal typeProcess
Basemetalcombination~l :
L4i] HY-130 to HY-130 I 16
] HY’-13Oto HY-1130I 16] HY-130 to }{Y-80 [16
\ HY-130 to Ms I 16
I HY-130 to Ss I
I HY-130 t-oNiCu ]
I
t HY-1OO to HY-130 /121
I HY-1OO to HY-1OO /12I
I HY-1OO to HY-80 I12I
I HY-loo to S1’s 1121
Shielded metal-arc lGas metal-arc ~A
A’Weaker member listed first (see 5.1.1.1).
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
F41L-sTD-1628(StIIPS)28 June 1974
Table III - Index to effic~cncy cl)arts and computationfactors (cent’d.)
~lweake~t mc~r listed first (see 5.1.1.1).
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628 (SHIPS)2B June 1974
Table 111 - Index to efficiency charts and computationfactors (cent’d.)
7
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628 (SHIPS)28 June 1974
‘Table 111 - Index to efficiency charts and computationfactors (cent’d.)
FJller metal typeProcess
Shielded metal-arc I Gas metal-arc
x xx x
I N 04Base A d 2 m
0 s z :metal m m z m E ~comblnation~’ A A !a A A .3
u M 1+ )4 u uz z x z x ~
Ss to HY-130 13 13 12 14 11
55 to 1IY-1OO 13 13 12 14 11
SS to llY-80 13 13 12 114~111 I I ]
SS to STS 13 13 12 14 11
ss to liTS 13 13 12 14 11
Ss to )1s 13 13 12 14 11
Ss to Ss 13 13 12 14 11
SS to NiCu 12 14
SS to Cutli 12 14
I13
131 ,r
13,1
13 I
3
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
:!IL-sTD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
Table 111 - Index to eff~c~ency C!,iirt:i a]ldcomputation factors lcc)nt’(:.)
I Filler metal t:fpcProcess
Shieldeclmetal arc
CuNi to HY-13CI 5 0
CuNi to 1IY-1OO 5 9
CuNi to IIY-80 5 9
CuNi to ST5 5 9
CulJito llTS 5 9
CuNi to :1S 5 ?
CuHi to SS 5
Cullito NiCu 1519
Cu:lito Cu:Ji 1519
=K5456 to 5456
5456 to 5454—— .—
5456 to 5086
5456 to 5083
5454 to 5456 1!
5454 to 5454 II
5454 to 5006 II
5454 to 5083 II
—=
.-. .—-
—
Gas nctal-arc
‘Weakest ?nembcr listed first (see 5.1.1.1).
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628 (SHIPS)28 June 1974
10
Table III - Index to efficiency charts andcomputation factors (cent’d.)
pi~ler metal type
Process. Gas metal-arc
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
5.1.5 Fillet weld size and efficiency charts—— ——
5.1.5.1 Figures 1 through 40 are fillet weld
MIL-STD-1628 [SIIIPS)28 June 1974
(figures 1 through 40).—
size and efficiency charts for doublecontinuous fillet welds. ~ch chart is a graph of base metal thickne~s, fillet weld sizeand joint efficiency drawn using log-log axes for a specific computation factor rather thanfor a specific base metal and filler metal combination. For a given base metal thickness(weaker member), a fillet weld size and corresponding efficiency can be taken directly fromthe chart. Or, if any two (weld size, base metal thickness, or efficiency) are known, thethird can be read from the chart.
5.1.5.2 When the intersecting point of the plate thickness and joint efficiency ~sbetween two fillet weld sizes, the larger fillet weld size shall be used.
5.2 Direct calculation of fillet weld strength, computation factors, fillet weld sizeand effici-.
.— — —— —.
5.2.1 Calculation of fillet weld stren th. Calculation of continuous double filletweld strength per as An table 11, shall be accomplished using thelmear%~-) -
following formula:
Example:
5.2.2through 40,
‘2= 1.414 S R2 L
~= 1.414 S R2
L
F3 = 1.414 S R2
Determine the streng~h of a l/2-inch double fillet weld deposited withMIL-14018.
S = l/2-inch
‘2= 94,000 psi [kabie ii)
F3 s 1.414 x 1/2 ~ 94,000
‘3 = 66,000 pounds per linear inch of double fillet weld
Calculation ~ com utation factors. Computation factors, as shownaha11 be calculht~owing formula:
on figures 1
CF = %
1.414 R2
Example: Determine the computation factor for welding HTS plate to HTS plate withMIL-9018M electrode.
RI w
‘2 =
Cp =
CF -
CF .
75,000 psi (table I)
69,000 psi (table 11)
75,000 psi
1.414 X 69,000
0.769
0.75 (to nearest 0.05)
11
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTL)-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
5.2.3 Cornutin fillet weld size. The fillet weld sizes shown on figures 1 through 40shall be calas~e~l=a formula:
e ‘1 ‘1‘=e TICFOrs=—1.414 R2
Lxample: Determine the fzllct weld size that will give 100 percent jointefficiency when l/2-inch thick HY-80 plate is welded to l/2-inch thickHTS witl”~MIL-901BM electrode.
e = 10flpercent = 1.00
‘1 = l/2-inch (IITSweaker member)
CF= 0.75 (table III, figure 10)
s = 1.00 x 1/2 x 0.75
s = 0.375
S = 3/8-inch
or
e = 100 percent = 1.00
‘1= l/2-inch
‘1= 75,000 psi (table I for llTS)
‘2= 69,000 psi (table II)
s = 1.00 x 1/2 x 75,000 .
1.414 X 69,000
S = 0.384
S = 3/B-inch (to nearest 1/16)
5.2.4 Cornutin fillet weld efficienc .as .9ho*cJiiRZi7 ZU.
The efficiency of continuous double filletwelds, +,1 be calculated using the following formula:
or e - 1.414 S R2e=S
‘1 CF ‘1 ‘1
Example: Determine the fillet weld efficiency for l/2-inch HTS plate welded tol-inch }1Splate using HIL-9018M electrode and a 3/8-inch fillet weld.
S = 3/8-inch
‘1 = l/2-inch (IITSweaker member)
CF= 0.75 (table III, figure 10)
e = 3/8
1/2 x 0.75
e = 1.00
e = 100 percent
or
S = 3/8-inch
‘1= l/2-inch (liTSweaker member)
RI - 75,000 psi (table I for KTS)
12
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
M2L-sTD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
R2 = 69,000 psi (table II)
e = 1.414 x 3/8 x 69,000
1/2 x 75,600
e = 0.9B
e = 100 percent (to nearest 5 percent)
5.3 Partial penetration groove tee welds..—
5.3.1 Partial penetration groove tee weld dimensions, as shown on figure 41, shall becomputed as specified in 5.3.1.1.
5.3.1.1 The effective width of the weld in shear (D) shall be computed using thefollowing equation:
~ - e Tl RI
2 R2
5.3.1.2 There are two equations for the base leg or depth of bevel (B).
5.3.1.2.1 When “D” is not greater than 0.707-inch, the equation for ‘D” shall be:
B=D
1.414
5.3.1.2.2 When ‘n” is greater than 0.707-inch, the equation for “B” shall be:
B=fi
5.3.1.3 The land width (Z) shall he calculated using the followinq equation:
Z=TB-2B
5.3.1.4 The size of the reinforcing fillet (S) shall be determined by the followinqequation:
S=B
where “B” is rounded-off to the next larger l/16-incll.
5.3.1.4.1 The reinforcing fillet (S) shall be at least l/4-inch and should not begreater than l/2-inch.
5.4 Sample calculations.
5.4.1 Partial penetration groove tee welds..—
5.4.1.1 The sample calculations specified in 5.4.1.2 ara presented to show how theeffective width of weld in shear (D), land width (Z), depth of bevel (D), and reinforcingfillet size (S) are calculated using the equations given In 5.3.
5.4.1.2 Sample calculation. The following sample calculations for partial penetrationgrcove tee welas are based on a joint containing l-inch IIY-1OO plate as the passinq member(T), 2-inch HY-80 plate as tha web metier (TB), NIL-11OI8?4 as the electrode, and 80 percentjoint efficiency:
(a) Determine the structurally weaker member (Tl):
HY-1OO : T x (tensile strength)1 x 114,000114,000 lbs/in
HY-80: TB x (tensile strength)
2 X 96,000192,000 lbs/in
13
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628 (SNIPS)28 June 1974
114,000-= 192,000
‘1= T or liY-100
{b) Determine the effective
Il=e TIRl2 R2
E = 80 percent = 0.
width of weld in shear (D):
80
‘1= l-inch (liY-100weaker member)
‘1 = 114,000 psi (table I)
‘2= 87,000 psi (table II)
D = 0.80 X 1 X 114,000
2 x 67,000
D = 0.524-inch (to nearest 0.001)
(c) Determine the depth of bevel (B):
B=D (D is not greater than 0.707)
1.414
D = 0.524
D = 0.524
1.414
D = 0,371-incll
B= 3/8-inch (to nearest 1/64)
D = 3/8-inch (to next larger 1/16)
(d) Determine the width of land (Z):
z = TB- 2 B
B = 3/8-inch
‘B= 2-inches (web thickness)
z=2- (2 X 3/8)
Z = l-1/4-inches
(e) Determine size of reinforcing fillet (S):
S = B (see 5.3.1.4)
B = 3/8-inch
S = 3/8-incl~
5.4.2 Strength of fillet weld joints.—— .
5,4.2.1 The two sample calculations specified in 5.4.2.1.1 and 5.4.2.1.2 for determiningthe strength of a continuous double fillet weld joint arc based on a joint containing l-inchHY-80 plate as the passing member, l-inch HTS plate as the web member, MIL-90181~ as theelectrode, l/2-inch as the weld size, and 8-inches as the length of double fillet weld.
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
5.4.2.1.1 Table method. Determine the strength of a continuousas follows: — —
‘2= F3L (see 5.2.1)
‘3= 49,000 psi (table II)
L= 8-~nchcs
‘2= 49,000 X 8
F2 = 392,000 lbs/~n
‘2= 390,000 lbs/in (to nearest 5,000)
5.4.2.1.2 Direct calculation method. Determine tl]estrength offillet weld as fo~:
:lIL-sTD-1626(SHIPS)28 June 1974
double fillet weld
a continuous double
‘2 = 1.414 S R2 L
S = l/2-inch
‘2= 69,000 psi (table II
L = 8-inches
‘2 = 1.414 X 1/2 X 69,000
‘2 = 390,000 lbs/in
5.4.3 Fillet weld size and efficiency.—— .—
XB
5.4.3.1 The sample calculations specified in 5.4.3.1.1 throuqli 5.4.3.1.2.2. fordetermining continuous double fillet weld size and efficiency are based on a ]oint containingl-inch thick HTS plate as the passinq member, l/2-inch thick HY-80 plate as the web member,and MIL-9018N as the clcctrodc.
5.4-3.~-~ Table and rhart method.—— ——
5.4.3.1.1.1 Determine the fillet size for a joint efficiency of 80 percent as follows:
step 1 - Determine weaker member:
step
Step
IiTS: T x (tensile strength)1 x 75,00075,000 lbs/in
HY-80: TB x (tensile strenwth)
1/2 X 96,00048,000 lbs/in
4ii,ooo<75,0nrl
T1 = TB or HY-80
2 - Determine efficiency chart:
Table III references figure 15 for the base metal and filler metalcombination (iiY-80to HTS using MIL-9018M).
3- Determine weld size:
Using the efficiency chart of figure 15, locate the intersecting pointfor a plate thickness of l/2-inch and 80 percent efficiency. Sincethe plate thickness and efficiency intersecting point is between 3/8and 7/16 (diagonal lines), the required fillet size is 7/16-incll.
15
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
H2L-STD-162B(SHIP5)28 June 1974
S.4.3.1.1.2 Determinefollows :
Step 1 and 2
the efficiency for a joint with a l/2-inch fillet weld as
Same as steps 1 and 2 of 5.4.3.1.1.1.
Step 3 - Determine joint efficiency:
Using the efficiency chart of fiqure 15, locate the intersecting pointfor a plate thickness of l/2-inch and a weld size of l/2-inch. Readthe efficiency by moving the plate thickness and weld size intersectingpoint horizontally to the left until it crosses the efficiency scale(100 percent).
5.4.3.1.2 Direct computation method.
5.4.3.1.2.1 Determine the fillet size for a joint efficiency of 80 percent as follws:
Step 1 - Determine weaker member:
HTS : T x (tensile strength)1 x 75,00075,oOO lbs/in
HY-BO: TB x (tensile
1/2 X 96,0004B,000 lbs/in
strength)
48,000 <75,000
‘1= TB or }{Y-BO
Step 2 - Determine computation factor:
Table III references figure 15 for the base metal and filler metalcombination (HY-80 to HTS using MIk~O18M). The figure 15 efficiencychart has a computation factor of 1.00.
or
The computation5.2.2.
factor may be calculated by using the formula from
‘1cF=—1.414 R2
CF= 96,000
1.414 X 69,000
CF = 0.98
CF= 1.00 (to nearest 0.05)
Step 3 - Determine weld size~
Using the formula from S.2.3, calculate the fillet size as follows:
‘=eTlcF
s = 0.80 x 1/2 x 1.00
s = 0.400
s = 7/16-inch (to next larger 1/16)
16
or
s=eT1 ‘1
1.414 R2
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
s=
s .
s .
O.BO x 1/2 x 96,000
1.414 X 69,000
0.394
7/16-inch (to next larger 1/16)
5.4.3.1.2.2 Determine the efficiency for a joint with a l/2-inch fillet weld asfollows:
Steps 1 and 2 - Same as steps 1 and 2 of 5.4.3.1.2.1.
Step 3 - Determine joint efficiency:
Using the formula from 5.2.4, calculate the joint efficiency as follows:
e=
e=
e=
e=
or
c=
e =
e=
e=
~
‘1 CF
1/2
1/2 x 1.00
1.00
100 percent
1.414 s 112
‘1 ‘{1
1.414 x 1/2 x 69,000
1/2 X 96,000
1.02
100 percent (to nearest 5 percent)
5.5 Continuous double fillet weld efficiency chart development.—— .
5.5.1 General.
5.5.1.1 Fillet weld efficiency charts shall be calculated by equating tiletensilestrenqttlof the base metal to the longitudinal shear strength of the weld metal.
5.5.1.2 l’hcultimate tensile strengtl] of the structurally weaker member shall be usedto deternunc fillet weld size and efficiency since tl~eweld only needs to bc as strong astlie weaker member.
5.5.1.3 ‘ihe longitudinal shear strenqt}l of the fillet weld s}~allbe used because aweld i~ \?eakest when loaded in longitudinal shear.
5.5.2 Derivation of equation for fillet weld size.—. . . .— . .
5.5.2.1 The following derivation illustrates how tk,cequation for plate thicknessfor each fillet size is derived:
‘1 = ‘2
I’l=‘1 ‘1 : ‘2 = 1~27’2
‘1 “1 = 1:2‘2
eml-i1 “1 L ; “12
= 1.414 S L
17
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sT*1628 (SHIPS)28 June 1974
‘1 ‘1L= 1.414 h? SL.
‘1 ‘1= 1.414 ;/2 s
1.414 1?2 s
‘1 =!:l
.
.= ‘k1 .i CrT1
1.414 1.2
s = T1 (+
‘=eTICF
=s‘1 —
eCF
5.5.3 Lfflciencv chart dra~:in~.— .
5.5.3.1 An efficiency c}~arttillallm dralm forlog-log scale for the cffzclency and plate thickness
5.5.3.2 The charts shall Lc ~nit~ated Ly cstab
cac,:computation factor [,:rClxcs.
100 percent efficiency for each weld SIZC (s). ‘rhc.cl]arts shall be“T “
1for other efficiency values.
5.5.3.3 The efficiency charts conta~ncd IIerclnmay be aoplledwe~d metal combination which !~asa com[wtatlon factor c,]uivalcnt to
5.5.4 Development of shear data..— —
l~!llng the plate thickness Tl) for
cstat>lishingcompleted hy
to any l,ascmetal andtlioscshown herein.
5.5,4.1 Fillet weld shear strength data shall l>coi,taincd by performing four longitudinalfillet weld tests for eac}~ filler metal type to be ~ncorporatcd into tt,isstandard.
5.5.4.1.1 The tests shall be conducted in accordance with MIL-STD-418.
5.5.4.1.2 The tests shall include two specimens of each fillet s~ze (1/4-inch and3/8-inch).
5.5.4.1.3 Test specimens with the sane fillet size sl]allbe welded with a differentheat of filler metal.
5.5.4.1.4 The average actual throat of the fractured fillet weld test specimen shallbe measured and used to calculate the shear strength.
5.5.4.1.5rounded-off to
6. NOTES
The shear strength values for the four test specimens shall be averaqed andthe nearest thousand prior to incorporation into table II.
(Not applicable).
Preparing activity:Navy - SH(Project 3439-N077)
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
~ ~
8 16100 T
90
00 \
70
60
50
40
Iz\
\
1
PLATE THICKNESS-INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR 0.30
Figure 1 - Efficiencychart for computationfactor of 0.30.
19
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(SHXPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
PLATE THic KNFSS-l NCHFs
COMPUTATION FACTOR 0.35 -
Figure 2 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 0.35.
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
PLATE THICKNESS- lNCHE~
COMPUTATION FACTOR O .40
Figure 3 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 0.40.
21
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
!lIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
1oo-
90-
eo-
70
60
50”
40 I
PLATE THICKNESS-INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR 0.45
Figure 4 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 0.45.
22
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
1-Z
ii!
s
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
I 3 j- 5 211— —8 16 4 16 I
100. 9
90 \
e~
70Y
60 L
1
50\
40;
COMPUTATION FACTOR 0.50
>2
Figure 5 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 0.50.
23
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WEI-O SIZE - INCHES
1 i I 1 1 1
100 -1
90\
8‘1
PLATE THICKNESS-INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR 0055
Figure 6 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 0.55.
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628(SHXPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE . INCHES
J_0
100 = 1 1 1 I ! I I 1
90 \
00 \ L i \ \
?0
60
50
40: \ \r I
14
PLATE THICKNESS -lNCHF~
COMPUTATION FACTOR 0,60
Figure 7 - Efficiencychart for computationfactor of 0.60.
25
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
._.—_.————
MIL-STD-1628(SliIPS)28 June 1974
1-8 ’11
\l
~AT~ THICKNESS-INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR 0.65
Figure 8 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 0.65.
26
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
J_8
PLATE THICK NESS-INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR () .70
Figure 9 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 0.70.
27
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
_—
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE- INCBES
I
50
t
PLATE THlCKNES5-lNCHE$
COMPUTATION FACTOR 0.75
Figure 10 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 0.75.
28
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628(S1iIPS)28 June 1974
COMPUTATION FACTOR 0.80
Figure 11 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 0.80.
29
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
.—
MIL-sTD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
PLATE THICKNE55-INCHE5
COMPUTATION FACTOR 0.85
Figure 12 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 0.85.
30
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628 (SHIPS)28 June 1974
-... - - . ..- . - - . --
Ii100- 1 1 I 1
90
80
70
60
\
50
40
COMPUTATION FACTOR 0.90
Figure 13 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 0.90.
31
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
.——
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE- INCHES
‘Z1 cn 1 1 \ l\ i\ 1-.
1
PLATE THICKNESS- iNCHEs
COMPUTATION FACTOR 0.95
Figure 14 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 0.95.
32
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE- INcHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR I .~
Figure 15 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 1.00.
33
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(SNIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
3 1537 1~5 > z Ii i6 i k Gr6216a48
100 -I
\
1\ \ Y
90\ \ ,
00 \\ 4
70”
60\ \
\4
\ \
50\
40 ‘A
J J ~ ~ ;; ~e 4 8 i
PLATE THICl(NESS-lNCHE~
COMPUTATION FACTOR 1.05
Figure 16 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 1.0S.
J 4
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS28 June 1974
I
FILLET WELD SIZE- INCHES
316
PLATE THICKNESS -INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR ! .10
Figure 17 - Efficiencychart for coInputationfactorof 1.10.
35
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628(SHIPs)28 June 1974
ii
FILLET WELD SIZE- INCHES
100. I I 1 1 1 I I I I I
901 \ \ \ \
eo
70-’ \
60
50
40
PLATE THICKNESS-INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR 1.15
Figure 18 - Efficiencychart for coxnputationfactorof 1.15.
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628(SH1PS)28 June 1974
ii
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
3~;$&;~16
I
PLATE THICKNESS-INCHES
cOMPUTATION FACTOR 1,20
Figure 19 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 1.20.
37
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
———-
141L-STD-162B(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE- INCHES
50It\ \\ \ \ f \ \ \
\
PLATE THlCKNES5-lNc HFS
COMPLJTATION FACTOR 1.25
Figure 20 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 1.25.
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
—
MIL-sTD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
g I \
,*I 60~ 1 / l\ N \l\’k\l
“ I I \l \lmliN
PLATE THICK NESS-INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR l.~
Figure 21 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 1.30.
39
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(S1lIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE- INCHES
100- 1 I I I I ! 1 I I 1 A~
/890 \
\
00 \
?Q”- \ \ \ \ \\
60 k \
\
50
40
PLATE THICKNESS-INCHES
-.COMPUTATION FACTOR l.~~
Figure 22 - Efficiencychart for com~utatlon factor of 1.35.
;3
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
—
MIL-sTD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
PLATE THiCKNES5-lNCHEs
COMPUTATION FACTOR I .40
Figure 23 - Efficiencychart for computationfactor of 1,40.
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
lIIL-sTD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
PLATE THICKNE SS-INCHE5
COMPUTATION FACTOR 1.45
Figure 24 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 1.4S.
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE- INCHES
PLATE TH~c KNESs-lNc HEs
COMPUTATION FACTOR 1.50
Figure 25 - Efficiencychart for computationfactorof 1.50.
43
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
COMPUTATION FACTOR 1.55
Figure 26 - Efficiencychart for computation factor of 1.55.
,,,.
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
—
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE- INCHES
PLATE THlCKNE~5-~NCH~s
COMPUTATION FACTOR 1.60
Figure 27 - Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.60.
45
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
~16
100 T L
90
80
yk70
60
PLATE THICKNESS- lNCHE&
COMPUTATION FACTOR 1.65
Figure 28 - Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.65.
~ti
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE- INCHES
I 100-I I I 1 1 I 1 I I I I
90 “i1
$ 80
: \
;v
$ G() 1Y
? }
uILwt-E 50
8
40 : 1m
i!PLATE THICKNESS -INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR I ●70
Figure 29 - Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.70.
47
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
PLATE THICK NFSS-INCHFS
COMPUTATION FACTOR I .75
I
Figure 30 - Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.75.
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
PLATE THICKNESS-INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR 1.m
Figure 31 - Efficienq chart for computation factor of 1.80.
49
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(Sl~IPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE- INCHES
PLATE’ THtCKNESS-tNCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR 1.85
Figure 32 - Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.85.
50
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628(sHIPs)28 June 1974
— ---- —.--.—-FILLET WELO SIZE - INCHES
IO*
90-
eo-
70-
60-
50-
40” I
PLATE THICKNESS-INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR 1.90
Figure 33 - Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.90.
51
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MxL-sTD-1628(sHIPs)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
PLATE THICKNESS-INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR ! .95
Figure 34 - Efficiency chart for computation factor of 1.9S.
52
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628(SHIPSj28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
4 16B~o~’=u’-”I I 1
100-I
90- +. \ / \ \ \\
lfl’”~\l\\l\ t/Y I I
PLATE TH~CKNE=-l NCHE~
COMPUTATION FACTOR 2.00
Figure 35 - Efficiency chart for computation factor of 2.00.
53
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
‘“-t-k\ \ 1 \ \ L \ \ 1 \ \B L a
‘(! \’i\ N k~ “\ ‘\l’\’\\\ \N\l \\
\ \ l\ \N\Yv$40 !
I / \ I \ v \ l\ \l \ 1 l\5 37,
,-j ~ ~
8 4 e k
PLATE THICKNESS-INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR 2.05
Figure 36 - Efficiency chart for computation factor of 2.05.
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE- INCHES
PLATF THICKNESS-INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR 2.10
Figure 37 - Efficiency chart for computation factor of 2.1O.
55
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE- INCHES
1oo- 1 1 1 1 1 } I I 1 1
90$16
80
70
60
\
50
40
J J ~ J ~::18 4 e 2
PLATE THICKNESS-INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR 2.15
Figure 38 - Efficiency chart for computation factor of 2.15.
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628(SliIPS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
PLATE THICKNESS- lNCHE~
COMPUTATION FACTOR 2.20
Figure 39 - Efficiency chart for computation factor of 2.20.
57
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
MIL-sTD-1628(SHIpS)28 June 1974
FILLET WELD SIZE - INCHES
‘loo - 1 1 I 1 I 1 1 1 1
90 1 , \ \
\ \ \ \ \\ \ \l \
70\
\60 ‘ 1 \ \ \ I \ \ , , \
l\l\hl
50
PLATE THICKNESS-INCHES
COMPUTATION FACTOR 2.25
Figure 40 - Efficiency chart for computation factor of 2.25.
58
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
.
I
T
●
z
) 4
MIL-STD-1628(SHIPS)28 June 1974
Doub 1e - V Tee Joint
.
z r--K
//“D’---+=
I
-B
\
Double - J Tee Joint
Figure 41 - partial penetration groove tee welds.
59
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com
STANDARDIZATION DOCUMENT IMPROVEMENT PROPOSAL [ OMB APPKWItiO. 22-R2S5L
INSTRUCTIONS: Ilre purpose of this form is to solicit beneficial comments which will help achieve procure-ment of suitable products at reasonable costand minimum delay, or will otherwise enhance use of the documenDoD contractors, government activities, or manufacturers/vendors who are prospective suppl~ers of theproducl●re invited to submit comments to the government. Fold on lines on reverse s]de, stsple in comer, ●nd send topreparing activity. Comments submitted on this form do not constitute or imply ●uthorization to waive ●nyportion of the referenced document(s) or to amend contractual requirements. Attach ●ny pertinent dat~ whichmay be of use m improvmg this document. If there are additional papers, attach to form and place both m snenvelope addressed to preparing activity.
>OCUMENT IDENTIFIER AND TITLE
4AME OF ORGANIZATION ANO ADDRESS ]c0N7RAc7 NUMBER
MATERIAL PROCURED UNOEfl A
I o DIRECT GOVERNMENT CONTRACT n 5usCONT~AC
1, HAS ANY PART OF THE OOCLIMENT CREATED PROBLEMS OR REQUIRED INTERPRETATION IN PROCUREMENT
uSE?
A. GIVE PA RAG UbDU NUMBER AND WOROING.
● . RECODAMENOATIONS FOR COm UECTING THE DEFICIENCIES
COMMENTS ON ANY DOCUMENT REQUIREMENT CONSIDERED TOO RIGID
IS THE OOCUMENT RESTRICTIVE?
o YES n NO (1( “YOB””, hl +ld W-y?)
REMARKS
U8MI TTE D BY (printed or typed rrarre md addr.ae - Optlonel) TELEPHONE NO.
DATE
S/N o?oz-014-1802REPLACES COITION 0? 9 JAN 0, WUICH MAV DC USED
Downloaded from http://www.everyspec.com