2
Peru is a country with mineral wealth to rival any other territory. The Andes mountain range runs from northern to southern border, providing the deposits that have led the nation to rank number 1 globally in silver production, second in copper and zinc and sixth in gold. Mining is not a new activity in Peru, but it has changed significantly in recent years in terms of tax regulation, environmental controls and investment girth. The different national governments in power over the last 20 years have maintained policies to encourage business and foreign direct investment. As in many other countries, mining has fattened Peru’s export revenues and GDP and brought economic activity and infrastructure to some of the poorest, most isolated areas. But with US$35bn worth of projects sitting in the pipeline, Peru is suffering a serious case of discord. The national government’s pro-mining policies often clash with the fears of those who live near a mining project that their livelihoods and customs will be affected, that the mine will have detrimental effects on the environmental and that they will not really perceive significant economic benefits from its presence. While the country has numerous mechanisms in place that attempt to ensure that none of this happens, convincing the locals is not always easy. Mining companies often fall short in their communicational strategies, local authorities oppose mine projects as a political technique and a multitude of NGOs and community organizations with different agendas serve mainly to confuse. A lack of effective institutional framework for structuring dialogue is one explanation for these problems afflicting the social license process. Of course, each case is different and a number of miners operating in Peru have been highly successful in getting the local population on board with their projects. But most experts agree that this country of 29mn inhabitants, where some 36% live in poverty, needs to have a serious think about mining’s role in its future and reach a common agenda for going forward. To subscribe to BNamericas, please contact us at [email protected] or +56-2 941 0300. For sponsorship opportunities, please contact the Advertising Account Manager, Ana Suárez, at [email protected] or +56-2 941 0404. April 2010 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY THIS MONTHS SERIES: Social license in Peru: Exploring the roots of discord Points of conflict The main tangible issue at play in the social license process is water. Multiple projects have stalled over water sourcing and fears of contamination, the current subject of attention being Southern Copper’s Tía María project in Arequipa province. Lack of framework NGOs, community organizations, local politicians, state government and company representatives all have a role in the dialogue process, but in some cases roles are poorly defined or not adhered to. Peru’s institutional framework is largely inadequate in guiding the process, often leading to communicational chaos, negative sentiment toward a project and protests. What’s in it for me? Peru has very specific systems for sending mining wealth back to the communities where the mines are, but what happens with this money once it is back in local hands is a different story. Communities often believe that mining does not economically benefit them. Tintaya The Tintaya mine in Cuzco region has had to work hard on social license like any other project, but thanks to certain strategies has become one of Peru’s main success stories in community relations. 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 Jan 08 Feb 08 Mar 08 Apr 08 May 08 Jun 08 Jul 08 Aug 08 Sep 08 Oct 08 Nov 08 Dec 08 Social conflicts at end-2008, by type Source: Instituto del Perú (USMP) Socio-environmental 93 Local government issues 28 Regional government issues 8 National government issues 19 Municipal issues 11 Union/labor 15 Land demarcation 9 Electoral 6 Illegal coca farming 4 Other 4 Total 197 Active Latent Resolved

Mining Intelligence Series: "Social license in Peru: Exploring the roots of discord"

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Mining Intelligence Series: "Social license in Peru: Exploring the roots of discord"

Peru is a country with mineral wealth to rival any other territory. The Andes mountain range runs from northern to southern border, providing the deposits that have led the nation to rank number 1 globally in silver production, second in copper and zinc and sixth in gold. Mining is not a new activity in Peru, but it has changed significantly in recent years in terms of tax regulation, environmental controls and investment girth. The different national governments in power over the last 20 years have maintained policies to encourage business and foreign direct investment. As in many other countries, mining has fattened Peru’s export revenues and GDP and brought economic activity and infrastructure to some of the poorest, most isolated areas.

But with US$35bn worth of projects sitting in the pipeline, Peru is suffering a serious case of discord. The national government’s pro-mining policies often clash with the fears of those who live near a mining project that their livelihoods and customs will be affected, that the mine will have detrimental

effects on the environmental and that they will not really perceive significant economic benefits from its presence.

While the country has numerous mechanisms in place that attempt to ensure that none of this happens, convincing the locals is not always easy. Mining companies often fall short in their communicational strategies, local authorities oppose mine projects as a political technique and a multitude of NGOs and community organizations with different agendas serve mainly to confuse. A lack of effective institutional framework for structuring dialogue is one explanation for these problems afflicting the social license process.

Of course, each case is different and a number of miners operating in Peru have been highly successful in getting the local population on board with their projects. But most experts agree that this country of 29mn inhabitants, where some 36% live in poverty, needs to have a serious think about mining’s role in its future and reach a common agenda for going forward.

To subscribe to BNamericas, please contact us at [email protected] +56-2 941 0300.

For sponsorship opportunities, please contact the Advertising Account Manager, Ana Suárez, at [email protected] or +56-2 941 0404.

April 2010

EXECUTIVE SUMMARYthis month’s series:

Social license in Peru: Exploring the roots of discord

Points of conflictThe main tangible issue at play in the social license process is water. Multiple projects have stalled over water sourcing and fears of contamination, the current subject of attention being Southern Copper’s Tía María project in Arequipa province.

Lack of frameworkNGOs, community organizations, local politicians, state government and company representatives all have a role in the dialogue process, but in some cases roles are poorly defined or not adhered to. Peru’s institutional framework is largely inadequate in guiding the process, often leading to communicational chaos, negative sentiment toward a project and protests.

What’s in it for me?Peru has very specific systems for sending mining wealth back to the communities where the mines are, but what happens with this money once it is back in local hands is a different story. Communities often believe that mining does not economically benefit them.

TintayaThe Tintaya mine in Cuzco region has had to work hard on social license like any other project, but thanks to certain strategies has become one of Peru’s main success stories in community relations.

160

140

120

100

80

60

40

20

0

Jan 0

8

Feb 08

Mar 08

Apr 08

May 08

Jun 0

8Ju

l 08

Aug 08

Sep 08

Oct 08

Nov 08

Dec 08

Social conflicts at end-2008, by type

Source: Instituto del Perú (USMP)

Socio-environmental 93Local government issues 28Regional government issues 8National government issues 19Municipal issues 11Union/labor 15Land demarcation 9Electoral 6Illegal coca farming 4Other 4Total 197

Active

Latent

Resolved

Page 2: Mining Intelligence Series: "Social license in Peru: Exploring the roots of discord"

Copyright Notice All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical unless as used in the paragraph below. Any unauthorized use, sharing, reproduction, or distribution is strictly prohibited. This report does not come with ANY resale rights. Legal Notice While attempts have been made to verify information provided in this publication, neither the author nor the publisher assumes any responsibi-lities for errors, omissions, or contradictory information contained in this document. This document is not intended as legal, investment, or accounting advice. The purchaser or reader of this document assumes all responsibility for the use of these materials and information. Business News Americas assumes no responsibility or liability whatsoever on behalf of any purchaser or reader of these materials.© 2010 Business News Americas.BNamericas is a bilingual news and intelligence service that covers the most important stories in 12 different business sector throughout Latin America and the Caribbean. Business News Americas’ main office is located in Santiago, Chile, with full regional presence in Sao Paulo, Buenos Aires, Caracas and Mexico City.

Santiago Headquarters:San Patricio #2944, Las Condes, Santiago, ChileTel: +56 (2) 941-0300Fax: +56 (2) 232-9376US Voice/Fax: +1 (305) 513-5782 USA

We understand the importance of information for the development of your business

in Mining & Metals

Your business requires accurate and timelY information delivered to You dailY; bnamericas is dedicated to providing these essential business intelligence services that help keY decision makers, such as You and Your colleagues, staY informed.

CONTACT USContact us today to receive a

free 2-week trial subscription online:+56 (2) 941-0300

[email protected]

Our service is a comprehensive daily information source that covers the Mining and Metals industry in Latin America. BNamericas publishes news coverage on the business associated with the entire chain of production. The Mining & Metals newsletter also provides information and news coverage on specific issues such as regulatory and legal issues, financing, earnings reports, M&A activities, the capital markets, and environmental and social issues all from a business perspective. Coverage of the metals markets centers on the London Metal Exchange, the London Bullion Market and Comex (New York) is also included.

Mining DAILy

Written and researched by Laura Superneau

Business Intelligence

DirectorRaúl Ferro

Executive editorHenriette Iraçabal

Financial services analystMaría Alejandra Moreno

Mining analystLaura Superneau

Telecom analystPhil Anderson

Energy analystMichael LaGiglia

Financial data analystMaría José Arredondo

ResearchersGonzalo VergaraCarlos Montoya

BNamericas Mining Group

EditorDavid Roberts

BogotáHarvey Beltrán

Sao PauloFernanda de Bagio

SantiagoMark HelmantolerVíctor Henriquez

Designed byTamara Lorca