Minutes of 160 - environmentclearance.nic.inenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Online/... · Minutes of 160th meeting of Expert Appraisal Committee for projects related to

1

Minutes of 160th meeting of Expert Appraisal Committee for projects related to Infrastructure Development, Coastal Regulation Zone, Building/Construction, Industrial

Estate and Miscellaneous projects held on 28 - 29 June, 2016 Tuesday, 28th June, 2016 Time: 10.00 AM 1. Opening Remarks of the Chairman. 2. Confirmation of the minutes of the 159th meeting of the EAC held on 30-31 May,

2016 at New Delhi. The EAC, after detailed discussions on minutes of 159th meeting held on 30-31 May,

2016, and having taken note that none of the members has sent any comments, confirmed the same with the correction of a typographical error relating to APPCB.

3. Consideration of Proposals

3.1 Development of Petroleum, Chemical and Petro-chemical Investment Region (PCPIR) at Dahej, Vagra, District Bharuch (Gujarat) by M/s Gujarat Industrial Development Corporation - Environmental and CRZ Clearance – [F.No.21-49/2010-IA-III]

3.1.1 The project proponent made a presentation and provided the following information to the Committee:- (i) The proposal involves development of Petroleum, Chemical and Petro-

chemical Investment Region (PCPIR) at Dahej, Vagra, District Bharuch (Gujarat) by M/s Gujarat Industrial Development Corporation (GIDC).

(ii) The proposed PCPIR spread over 33 villages of Taluka Vagra and 11 villages of Taluka: Bharuch District Bharuch an area of 453 sq km. The total area under development will be 45298.59 ha.

(iii) More than 60% of land is under cultivation with crops like millet, wheat, jowar, bajra and paddy etc. Other crops such as sugarcane, groundnut, pulses and cotton are also grown in the study area. The study area is covered with 7% irrigated land whereas forest land is only about 1% of the total land area.

(iv) Out of 45298 ha area of PCPIR, 50.79% area i.e. 23005.97 ha area of land shall be developed as processing area which includes GIDC estates, medium and large scale PCP industries, engineering industries, port/ship building, salt pans, warehousing, oil terminals, logistics etc. Further 49.21 % area i.e. 22292.05 ha area of land shall be developed as a non-processing area which includes residential, commercial, institutional, recreational, specific mix zone, Eco-park, Eco-zone, Forest, agriculture, gamtal including gamtal buffer, Roads (30-150 m Row), proposed Kalpasar canal and water bodies like (pond, lake, developing pond, bhukhi khadi, bhukhi khadi nala).

(v) Forest land: Total of 853.41 ha area is reserved forest in PCPIR. (vi) Water requirement: Major source of raw water is Intake well at Narmada River

and Narmada canal. Present utilization of water in GIDC estates of PCPIR is approximately 28 MGD for which the approval has been taken from State Irrigation department. The said PCPIR will be developed phase wise up to 2040 and a total of 175 MGD water demand has been forecast and will be met

11

3.5.2 While deliberations, the EAC noted the following:- (i) The proposal has been designated as Package V of Nagpur Mumbai Expressway (80.2 km long) starting from Talegaon village, Igatpuri Taluka, Nashik District to Vadape village, Bhiwandi Taluka in Thane District (chainage km 626.00 to 706.20 i.e. 80.2 km). (ii) The protected areas within 10 km from the project boundary are Tansa Wildlife Sanctuary (2 km) and Tungareshwar National Park at a distance of 6.50 km, and as such due to applicability of general conditions, the proposal is covered under Category A in terms of the EIA Notification, 2006. (iii) The project involves 156 ha of forest land and thus requires its prior diversion for non-forestry use for implementation of the project. (iv) The proposal would also affect 90 nos of residential/commercial buildings, and thus requires their resettlement. (v) MSRDC is developing package V for the Nagpur-Mumbai Expressway to divert and redistribute heavy traffic on existing corridor. The MSRDC considered five options and ranked the feasibility based on minimising forest areas, avoiding habitation railway over bridges structures, tunnel length and project cost. Considering all the options the project proponent has opted for option 1(C) alignment which is having a total length of 80.2 km covering Talegaon, Taluka Igatpuri to Vadape, Taluka Bhiwandi.

3.5.3 The Committee, after detailed deliberations, recommended the proposal for grant of Terms of Reference, specified by the Ministry in April, 2015 as Standard ToR for the said project/activity, and for preparation of EIA/EMP reports after public consultation. The Committee also restricted the facilities likely to be provided along the alignment, which would only include highway tourism, auto and auto ancillary hub, logistic park and convenience shopping in keeping with the given charter of MSRDC.

2nd Day - Wednesday, 29th June, 2016

3.6 Expansion of Industrial Area Kuber at Village Ranpur in Tehsil Ladpura of District Kota (Rajasthan) by Rajasthan State Industrial Development and Investment Corporation Ltd. (RIICO) - Further consideration for Environmental Clearance - [F.No.21-2/2014-IA-III]

3.6.1 The proposal was earlier considered by the EAC in its meeting held on 27-28 April, 2016 wherein the EAC noted that the proposed industrial project is 8.5 km from the National Chambal Sanctuary and 6.5 km from the Mukandara Hills Tiger Reserve. The steel re-rolling, stone cutting and processing industries are expected to generate sound and particulate matter, dust pollution in the vicinity of an eco-sensitive zone. The project proponent should carry out studies to assess the expected levels of pollution and mitigation barrier as well as threshold.

user2

Highlight

12

3.6.2 The project proponent made a presentation and provided the following information to the Committee:- (i) The proposal is for expansion of the existing Kuber Industrial area at Ranpur

Village, Tehsil Ladpura, District Kota (Rajasthan). (ii) The proposed expansion would involve an additional area of 228.86 acre,

comprising a total number of 91 plots, in Ranpur village, Ladpura Tehsil of Kota district, Rajasthan and now envisaged to house stone processing (polishing, cutting, splitting etc.), steel re-rolling units falling under Category B. General engineering, stone processing (polishing, cutting & Splitting etc), Agro Food processing units, service and ancillary industries, agro and food processing industries, non-polluting industries etc are the ones housed in this expansion.

(iii) The existing Industrial area of Kuber, Ranpur has been developed in phases between 1997 and 2006 in a total area of 536.75 acres. It consists of four different parks like (i) Industrial area (Kuber), (ii) Institutional Area, Ranpur, (iii) Agro Food Park phase-I and (v) Agro Food Park phase-II; Ranpur. The agro food park had come up under a scheme of Ministry of Food Processing, Government of India.

(iv) Water requirement: During operation phase, estimated total water demand for Kuber expansion about is 962.5 KLD. The prime source of water will be Chambal River and supply provided from Public Health Engineering Department (PHED) Government of Rajasthan has agreed to supply piped water to this industrial area on seniority basis from Akhailgadh. RIICO agreed and deposited required amount with PHED for execution of the scheme at the earliest.

(v) Waste water quantity, treatment capacity, detail: Low water intensive units are envisaged in the proposed expansion. Hence wastewater generation would be either nil or very minimum. Thus, the individual units will have their own effluent treatment plants for treating their effluents and recycling the same in their units. These units will achieve Zero Liquid Discharge.

(vi) Solid waste management: Since the proposed industries, mainly, are of stone grinding, polishing and general engineering in nature the anticipated industrial solid wastes are of inert and non-toxic in character. Individual units in accordance with the directions and guidelines of State Pollution Control Board/Central Pollution Control Board will handle and manage these wastes.

(vii) Hazardous Waste Management: Used waste oil and Lead acid batteries are the anticipated hazardous wastes in the proposed expansion. Individual units shall collect their used oil and store in a secured place as per the guidelines of the pollution control board and periodically sell to the authorised recyclers in accordance with the Hazardous Waste (Management, Handling and Transboundary) Rules, 2008. The used lead acid batteries will be managed and handled in accordance with the Batteries (Management and Handling) Rules, 2001.

(viii) Water bodies: Chambal River is the nearest water body from project site; river bank from proposed project site is at about 8.5 km.

(ix) Green belt development: For the purpose of green belt 10.12% of the total project area is earmarked. The total number of trees to be planted is about 12,000.

(x) Investment/Cost: Rs. 5269.40 Lakhs. (xi) Wildlife issues: The project site is located at 8.5 km from National (Ghariyal)

Chambal Sanctuary, and 6.5 km from the buffer area of Mukandra Tiger Reserve. The project proponent has applied for necessary wildlife clearance from the Standing Committee of NBWL. In view of the given location of the project site, the project requires appraisal under Category A by the EAC in the Ministry.

user2

Highlight

13

(xii) Employment potential: The impact of the project on economic aspects can clearly be observed. The proposed project activities will provide employment to persons of different skills and trades. The employment potential will ameliorate economic conditions of low income families directly and provide employment to many other families indirectly who are involved in business and service oriented activities.

(xiii) Benefits of the project: Proposed project will result in considerable growth, stimulating the industrial and commercial activities in the region. Small and medium scale industries may be further developed as a consequence.

(xiv) The ToR for the proposed development was accorded on 18th September, 2014.

(xv) Public hearing for the project was conducted on 26th June, 2015.

3.6.3 During deliberations, the EAC noted the following:- (i) The area surrounding the proposed project area is highly sensitive from the environmental point of view. The Mukandara Hills Tiger Reserve is at a distance of less than 9 km from the project site. The Chambal Gharriyal Sanctuary is at a distance of 8.5 km. The project proponent has failed to submit the boundary of the protected areas. (ii) The proposal involves setting up of industrial units (on 91 identified plots) in an additional area of 228.86 ha, and as such, it would be the expansion of existing Kuber Industrial Area in an area of 536.75 ha. Different proposed industrial units/activities would include steel re-rolling units viz. non-toxic metallurgical processing industry of capacity > 5000 tonnes per annum. As such, the proposal is covered under category B. (iii) The base line air quality values monitored during May, 2016 being on much lower side, the Committee was not convinced about the reliability of the ambient air quality, where PM10 levels are almost half of the NAAQ standards. Such values in a State like Rajasthan (supposed to be higher background PM10 levels) in the month of May need to be crosschecked by a third party for its authenticity. (iv) The Committee is of the view for the proposed industries could be high noise and dust emitting industries to confine these activities only to day time operation. The sensitive wildlife in the close vicinity of the area could be endangered. The Committee is of the considered view for the Ministry may like to get the background PM 10 study done through a third party if the project proponent wishes to pursue the request for EC any further. The Committee was informed that the project proponent has moved the National Wildlife Board for obtaining necessary clearances.

3.6.4 The proposal was, therefore, deferred.

3.7 Development of Industrial estate of HSIIDC at Sector 30, 30-A, 31 & 32 at Manakpur (Jagadhari), Haryana by M/s HSIIDC Ltd - Further consideration for Environmental Clearance - [F.No.21-1045/2007-IA-III]

3.7.1 The proposal was earlier considered by the EAC in its meeting held on 24-26 June, 2015 wherein the Committee noted the information presented by the PP and observed that there is no demarcation of green belt area and the parking space is inadequate. After detailed deliberation the Committee sought the following additional information

user2

Highlight

user2

Highlight

user2

Highlight

user2

Highlight

user2

Highlight

19

List of the EAC members attended the meeting

1. Shri Anil Razdan, IAS (Retd.), Chairman, C-6, Friends Colony East, New Delhi – 65

2. Dr. M.L. Sharma, IFS (Retd.), 79A, Sector-8, Gandhi Nagar – 382008 (Gujarat) 3. Sh. R. Radhakrishnan, 2/586, 1st Cross Street, Singaravelan Salai, Neelangarai,

Chennai - 600 041 4. Dr. M.V. Ramana Murthy, Project Director, (Scientist ‘G’), Offshore Structures and Island

Desalination, NIOT Campus, Pallikarai, Chennai – 600 100

5. Dr. R. Prabhakaran, No.1, Besent Road, Royapettah, Chennai 6. Dr. Anuradha Shukla, Central Road Research Institute (CRRI), CRRI, Mathura Road,

New Delhi - 25

7. Ms Mita Sharma, Scientist ‘E’, Central Pollution Control Board, Parivesh Bhawan, CBD-Cum Office Complex, East Arjun Nagar, Delhi -110 032

8. Shri S.K. Srivastava, Additional Director (IA-III), Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, Indira Paryavaran Bhawan, 3rd Floor, Vayu Wing, Jor Bagh Road, Aliganj, New Delhi-110 003.

EAC Observations in its 160th meeting for the project “Expansion of Industrial Area Kuber at Village Ranpur in Tehsil Ladpura of District

Kota (Rajasthan) by Rajasthan State Industrial Development and Investment Corporation Ltd. (RIICO)” ‐ [F.No.21‐2/2014‐IA‐III]

1

Compliance to EAC Observations

(i) The area surrounding the proposed project area is highly sensitive from the environmental point of view. The Mukandara Hills Tiger Reserve is at a distance of less than 9 km from the project site. The Chambal Gharriyal Sanctuary is at a distance of 8.5 km. The project proponent has failed to submit the boundary of the protected areas.

Reply:

The boundaries of the protected areas duly demarcating the same based on wildlife NOC

application to NBWL/SBWL were submitted. The same is enclosed again for perusal. The

map is presented in Figure -1.

Chambal Gharriyal Sanctuary with 1000m on either side of the banks of the

Chambal River from Jawahar Sagar Dam to Kota Barrage among others was

notified vide G.S.R.90 dated July, 20th 1983 under WLP Act 1972.

The boundary of the project site is 8.9698 km from the core boundary of the

Chambal Gharriyal Sanctuary and 6.5166 km from buffer boundary of Mukundara

Hills Tiger Reserve.

Thus the boundary of the project site is outside the buffer zone of Mukundara Hills

Tiger Reserve.

Since, the boundary of said project falls within 10km from the boundaries of Mukundra Hills

Tiger Reserve and Chambal Gharriyal Sanctuary, RIICO had applied for Wildlife Clearance

for "Expansion of Industrial Area Kuber located at Ranpur Village, Tehsil Ladpura of Kota

District" from NBWL/SBWL during October 2012 itself. The Forest Department (Wild Life) examined the application at different stages and finally the project is being recommended by State Board for Wild Life. The present status of the NBWL clearance

is as below.



2

Proposal received date at each stage of flow.

Submitted by

User Agenc

y

Query for Shortcoming(if any) by Wildlife Warden

Resubmission of Proposa

l by User

Agency

Query by

Wildlife

Warden for

submitting Hard

Copies

Uploading(by

U.A.) of copies

of receipt received from Wildlife Warden

Wildlife

Warden

Chief Wildlife Warden

State Government/

SBWL NBWL/MoEFCC(WL)

20/09/2016

28/09/2016 18/10/2016 09/11/2016

10/11/2016

20/10/2016

25/10/2016

:02/12/2016

Rajasthan: 13/02/2017

Rajasthan:07/09/2017

Essential Details Sought History

Communication between MoEFCC,New Delhi &

State Government

Communication between State Government & Chief

Wildlife Warden

Communication between Chief Wildlife Warden &

Wildlife Warden

Communication between Wildlife Warden & User

Agency

Query raised by Chief Wildlife Warden (Rajasthan)

on:25/03/2017 Replied by Wildlife

Warden(Kota Wildlife) on:29/05/2017

NOTE:- Proposal is pending at SBWL (State Board for Wildlife) .

EAC Observations in its 160th meeting for the project “Expansion of Industrial Area Kuber at Village Ranpur in Tehsil Ladpura of District Kota (Rajasthan) by Rajasthan State

Industrial Development and Investment Corporation Ltd. (RIICO)” ‐ [F.No.21‐2/2014‐IA‐III]

3

Figure 1:Map showing distances from Project site to Mukundra Hills Tiger Reserve and National Chambal Gharriyal Sanctuary



4



5

(ii) The proposal involves setting up of industrial units (on 91 identified plots) in an additional area of 228.86 ac, and as such, it would be the expansion of existing Kuber Industrial Area in an area of 536.75 ac. Different proposed industrial units/activities would include steel re-rolling units viz. non-toxic metallurgical processing industry of capacity > 5000 tonnes per annum. As such, the proposal is covered under category B.

Reply:

The type of industries are mainly sand stone cutting, polishing, processing units,

motor vehicle work shop, re-rolling mills and IIIT (IIIT in 35 ac).

(iii) The base line air quality values monitored during May, 2016 being on much lower side, the Committee was not convinced about the reliability of the ambient air quality, where PM10 levels are almost half of the NAAQ standards. Such values in a State like Rajasthan (supposed to be higher background PM10 levels) in the month of May need to be crosschecked by a third party for its authenticity.

Reply:

In accordance with the observations of EAC in its 158th meeting held on 28th April 2016, the

samples for PM10 were collected during May 2016 and the results were presented in 160th

EAC meeting held on 29th June 2016.

PM10 values as monitored and presented are given in Table1 below.

Table 1:

S. No Date of monitoring Location PM10 Results µg/m3

Distance and direction

1 12-5-2016

Project Site 48 ……..

2 Mukundara Tiger Reserve 35 6.3km SW

3

13-5-2016

National Chambal

Sanctuary

31 8.5 km NW

4 Dharampura 56 3.8 km W

5 14-5-2016 Daulatganj 54 6.3 km NW



6

6 Panchkui 58 6.3 km SW

NAAQ Standards 100

In the light of the observations of EAC in its 160th meeting, an attempt has been made to

verify the same for the Month of May 2016 from the secondary data available online from

NAMP executed under CPCB. Since, non availability of NAMP data for the month of May

2016, the current available May 2017 data has been considered for comparison. The

current location is one of the 683 operating stations covering Three Hundred (300)

cities/towns in twenty nine (29) states and six (6) Union Territories of the country Under

National Air Quality Monitoring Programme executed under CPCB.

The station RTU (Rajasthan Technical University) is taken for comparison, monitored

during May 2016 for the proposed project & May 2017(NAMP). The said station falls within

ESZ of National Chambal Gharriyal Sanctuary, Kota and the results are as submitted in

Table 2.

NAMP Report is annexed as Annexure1.

Table 2:

S.No NAMP data during May 2017 (CPCB)

Distance from Project site

Monitored data during May 2016 under proposed project

Distance from Project site

Location Date PM 10

µg/m3

8.5 km

Date PM 10 µg/m3

1)

RTU

2/05/2017 98

2) 5/05/2017 186

3) 9/05/2017 125

4) 12/05/2017 84 13/05/2016 31 8.8km

5) 16/05/2017 210

6) 19/05/2017 90



7

Source: http://164.100.222.210/NAMP_Report.aspx

It is evident from the NAMP data of May 2017, there is a large variation between minimum

and maximum values of PM10 ranging from 65µg/m3 to 210µg/m3.

Now referring to the observation of 160th EAC meeting, RSPCB has been appointed as a

third party monitoring agency by the proponent to carryout PM10 monitoring at the close

vicinity of the boundary of the sensitive wildlife areas.

Three sampling stations were chosen based on their sensitivity, location and in consultation

with RSPCB. The monitoring has been carried out for a month with 24 hourly samples

collected once in a week for 4 weeks at each location.

1. Project site : coordinates – 25.0650 N, 75.850 E

2. Rajasthan Technological University – 25.1432 N, 75.8068 E – chosen due to its

proximity to National Chambal Gharriyal Sanctuary, 8.5km NNW

3. Modi Institute of Technology – 25.1169 N, 75.7908 E – chosen due to its proximity to

Mukundara Hills Tiger Reserve Boundary.7.3 km WNW

Third party Monitoring Results- RSPCB given in Table 3.The Reports are annexed as

Annexure 2.

Table 3:

S. No Sampling location Date PM10 µg/m3

1 RIICO Office building 27/12/2016 150 2 2/1/2017 248

7) 23/05/2017 97

8) 26/05/2017 75

9) 30/05/2017

65

National Ambient Air Quality standards (24 hours) as per CPCB notification dt 18/11/2009

100 µg/m3



8

3 12/1/2017 82 4 17/1/2017 111 Avg 147.75 1 Rajasthan Technical

university office building 28/12/2016 126

2 4/1/2017 169 3 11/1/2017 92 4 18/1/2017 153 Avg 135 1 Modi institute of technology 29/12/2016 140 2 3/1/2017 293 3 9/1/2017 112 4 19/1/2017 74 Avg. 164.333

The locations monitored in the month of May 2016 and December 2016-January 2017 are

marked and shown on Google Imagery as Figure 2.

EAC Observations in its 160th meeting for the project “Expansion of Industrial Area Kuber at Village Ranpur in Tehsil Ladpura of District Kota (Rajasthan) by Rajasthan State

Industrial Development and Investment Corporation Ltd. (RIICO)” ‐ [F.No.21‐2/2014‐IA‐III]

9

Figure 2: Google Imagery with monitoring locations

(Cyan colour: May 2016, Red colour: December 2016-January 2017)



10

(iv) The Committee is of the view for the proposed industries could be high noise and dust emitting industries to confine these activities only to day time operation. The sensitive wildlife in the close vicinity of the area could be endangered. The Committee is of the considered view for the Ministry may like to get the background PM 10 study done through a third party if the project proponent wishes to pursue the request for EC any further. The Committee was informed that the project proponent has moved the National Wildlife Board for obtaining necessary clearances.

Reply:

As submitted in preceding paragraphs, RSPCB has been appointed as a third party

monitoring by the proponent to carryout PM10 monitoring in the close vicinity of the

boundary of the sensitive wildlife areas and the monitoring results were submitted in

reply (iii) above. Based on the RSPCB data, it is to infer that, the PM10 values in and

around Kota is varying from minimum 74µg/m3 to maximum 293µg/m3 based on

various background scenarios/conditions. Further, since the air pollution control

equipment will be installed by the proposed industry and hence the pollution levels of

PM10 may be much lesser and hence may not have impact on Mukundra Hills Tiger

Reserve/Chambal Gharriyal Sanctuary.

The high noise generating operations of these units will be restricted to day time

only.

Since, the said project falls within 10km of Mukundra Hills Tiger reserve and

Chambal Gharriyal Sanctuary, the application for NOC from NBWL (was submitted

during 20-09-2016.

The proposal submitted online is currently pending with SBWL as submitted in Reply

(i) above.

Annexure 1Rajasthan State Pollution Control Board

National Air Monitoring Programme (NAMP)

ReportType Average Format

Printed On: 12/09/2017

Station Name: Rajasthan Technical University,Rawatbhata Road, Kota Station Code: 832

From / To Date: 01/05/2017-31/05/2017

Sampling Date NitrogenDioxide(NO2)ug/M3

Particulate Matter sizeless than 10um or PM10(RSPM) ug/M3

SulphurDioxide(SO2)ug/M3

02/05/2017 19.02 98 10.4805/05/2017 14.35 186 10.4509/05/2017 17.73 125 10.9812/05/2017 19.6 84 8.8516/05/2017 21.9 210 8.7719/05/2017 25.1 90 6.7723/05/2017 22.28 97 7.6726/05/2017 19.68 75 9.7530/05/2017 17.07 65 9.1National Ambient Air Qualitystandards (24 hours) as per CPCBnotification dt 18/11/2009

80 ug/M3 100 ug/M3 80 ug/M3

Print Close

:w,r

REGIONAL OFFICE rele: 07{l -2{e0873ei*q orqi-mtr

RAJASTHAN STATE POLLUTION CONTROL BOARDIroreIFI lrflt IWur fttiTsI Crgd

Plot No.2.4, Road No. 6,Indraprastha lndustrial Area, Kota (Rajasthan)

RPCBTROK'LabrGen.42, \.lt tlt-l l)arc - --, , '., I '1,'/''1The Managing DirectorM/s Vitya Consultants Pvt Ltd4'h Floor, Laxmi Plaza. Beside Sheno) Nursing llonrc.East Manedpalll', Secunderabad-500026

fo[pgf - Analysis Report of ambient air monitoring (PM16) on paynrent basis.

Reference: - Your letter dated on 19/09/2016,0l ll l /2O16 and 29ll2l20l6.

Sir

Please find enclosed herewith the analysis repon bearing no. I to ll l'or lbr kindperusal & necessary action.

Yours laithl!llr

Lir(Amit Sharrrr! l

Ilegional Olllccr

\itrzi,\trz

REGIONAL OFFICE I el(: 07J{ -2{e0tt73et+r inrdtFro

RAJASTHAN STATE POLLUTION CONTROL I}OARI)wNqrJI {w cwq frtiilr q!-s.d

Plot No.2,A., Road No.6, Indraprastha Industrial Area, Kota (Raj8sthan)

RAJASTHAN STATE POI,LUTION CONTROL BOART)REPORT OF THE LAB INCHARGE

Finnl Report

Repon No: IReporr On: 20/01/2017I hereby cenify that I K K Jethslya. Lab lnchargc rcccivcd on the 2lil12/2016 li,, l)r sal\tl\rtrSingh, JSO and Shri MC Soni, Lab Assistaol. RSI'CB. Kola a sJmplc ol ,\mbirfll \ir Qunlil\of M/S Vitya Consultanls Pvt Lld. Secunderabad ( ollcclcd liorir Anhienl ,\ir Uonitorin,r nlRIICO omce Building Rsnpur Kotr Collecled on 2711212016. The samllc \\as in a conditr(\n lirfor analysis as reponed below:-

I funher cenify ihat I have analyzed the alilrerncntioned \anrplc ( 2{}/(}l/2(lll Ir(i d..llrr 1h(

result ofthe analysis to be as below:-

S.No Paramelers IlcsultI Respirable Suspended Paniculale Maner Jlr/M' 150

The condition ofthe seals, fastening and container on rqceipt was as tbllorvs: IntrctSigned this on 20/0U2017.

HDq-t. \t| t\( ll \ R(;t'

{lr7

REGIONAL OIFICE rele: 074'l -24e0t71

ffu 6rtds

RAJASTHAN STATE POLLUTION CONTROL BOART)

wl$rc trfll r(sq FFjTq qrgH

Plot No' 2A' Road No' 6, Indraprasthaindustrial Area' Kota (Rajssthan)

RAJASTHAN STATE POT'LUTION CONTR.OL ROARD

REPORT OF THE I,AB INCI{AR(;I]Final RePorl

Repon No: 2

Renon on: 20/01/2017 lnchrrlcrucer\crt,,nrhc29,tz/20trrr.,r'l)r \hhr('xr::.

I hereby cenirl rhar lK K rerhalra ' ".1;l: ;iii;.,i,:'*;;^ i, -.,,r,rr( .,r \r,r,,rnr \,r (J,,i,r,r\

Jso a;d shri RP N.srr. L1h l':''illl:i"i,J;r,t'i,,i,*i..r ,,.,,i, \,,,r,(nr \,, \r',,,,r .,,,r x,

H'."ilff[:l'.',1f".]X'l]l',!'l;ll"illilill?")" i"i'i"";"" x'r2/20r6 rhc sampre $a' rn

" clndirion fit for analysis as rcpofled belos:'

I further certify that I have analyzed lhe aforementioncd sample on 20/01/201? and dcclarc thc

result ofthe analysis to be as below:_

The condition ofthe seals, fastening and container on reccipi Nas as lirlk)\\ s: lnlllcl

Signed this on 20/01/2017'

Y^Dt..ruT-v tt rtrt;

Paniculate Matter

l{l-rtE\ta,

REGIONAL OFFICE rele: 0744 -24e08?3et*q orqiilq

RAJASTHAN STATE POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD{lntrFr Yrflr rwr ff{iTur q!-gd

Plot No, 2A, Road No.6, lndraprastha lrdustrial Area. Kota (Rajasthan)

RAJASTHAN STATI' POI,I,TJ'I'ION CONTROl, BOARI)REPORT OF TIII I,AR IN('IIAR(;E

Final Reflrrl

Report No: JReport On: 20/01/2017I hcreby certifr that I K K Jeth.lya. Lab lncharge reccived on the 30/1212016 from Dr RinkuSinghal, JSO ard Shri Kailash Makr ana, l,ab Assistant, RSPCB, Kola a \ample of AmbienlAir Qu.lity of M/S Vitye Consultonts Pvt Ltd, Secunderabsd Collecred lionr Amhient AirMonitoring at Modi Institute ofTechnology omce Building Ra\.albhala Road Kolr Collccrcdon 2911212016. The sample was in a condition llt for analysis as reponed beloL\:-

I lurther ceniJ) that I have analyzed the aforernenrioned sample on 20/01/2017 and declarc rhe

result ofthe anahsis to be as belo\:-

The condition ofthe seals. fastening and container on reccipl Nas as lirllo$ s lntactSigned this on 20/01/2017.

l.tr.ulll(r

,^$Hs

\el,,

REGIONALOFFICE relc:07{{ 21e081.r

etffs oTqioq

RAJASTH^A,N ST^A,TE POLLUTION CONTROL BOARI)mralFt 1tfll c-$q fr{ifl qrgd

Plot No.2A, Road No.6, Indraprastha lndustrial Area, Kol{ (laajasthan)

RAJASTHAN STATf, POLLUTION CONTROL BOARDREPORT OF THE LAB INCHARGE

Final Repott

Report No: 4

Repo( On: 20/01/2017I hereby certify that I K K Jethalya. Lab lncharge received on the 03/0120t7 from Dr Setvaran

Singh, JSO {nd Shri MC Soni, Lsb Assistant, RSPCB, Kota a sample ot'Ambient Air Qualittof lr/S Vitya Consultants Pvt Ltd, Secunderabad Collected from Ambient Air lltonitoring alRUCO omce Building Ranpur Kola Collecled on 02/01/20l7 lhe samPl( $tr\ in r conrl tion llt

lbr analysis as reported below:'

I further cenil,v thar I havc analyzed the albremenlioncd samplc (tr 20/01/201? itnd,lc(Lrc lhr

result olthe anal)sis to bc a\ helo\r:-

The condition ofthe seals, fastening and container on receipt was as follows: lntactSigned this on 20/01/2017.

.^,HPF

#\rtl

IU,t(;I L Ot.-t;t( tl I.lc: l)l.lJ :Jql)8'.r

RAJASTHAN STATE POLLUTION CONTROL I}OAIII)$!NqIH {W C'$er ft{iTvl qrsd

Plot No.2,4., Road No.6, lndraprastha Indrslrial Area, Kota (Rajaslhan)

RAJASTHAN STATE POLLUTION CONTROL BOARI)REPORT OF THE LAR INCHARGE

FinalReport

Repon No: 5

Repo( On: 20/01/2017I hereby certify that I K K Jcthalys. Lah lncharge rcccired on thc 0l/01/2017 {i,nn l)r liinLSingh.l, JSO and Shri Kailash Mskwana, l,ab Assisl.nt. RSP( B, Kot{ l \rrrrflc (,l ,^mhirnlAir Quality of M/S Vitye Consullants I'vt Ltd. Secunderabad (ollccled ,rom Amhirrl .\irMonitoring at Modi Inslilute ofTechnology office Iluilding Rawathhala laoad Kr)la ( ol1.jit.(lon 03/01/2017. The sample was in a condition llt lbr anallsis as reported bclo\:-

I firrther certify that I have analyzcd the aforcmentioned sample on 20/01/201? and declare thcresult ofthe analysis to be as below:.

Parnmelers

The condition ofthe seals. fastening and container on receipi was as follo\lsi lnt0clSigned this on 20/01/2017.

ONAe1*1

\Ddi-t,Ali t\( [ \ I.l (; l]

ResDirable SusDended Paniculate Matter

l6tzi,\t17fiSq 6rqi-dq

RAJASTHAN ST.A,TE POLLUTION CONTROL BOARDINrq+IH Tal rpur f*inur rrca

Plot No. 2A, Road No.6, Indraprastha Industrial Area, Kota (Rajasthan)

RAJASTHAN STATT, POI,Lt]TION CoNTRoI, Bo\ III)REPORT OF TIIE I,AB IN('HAR(;F,

l'inal Report

Report No: 6Report On: 20/01/2017I hereby cenify that I K K Jethslya. Lab lncharge reccived on thc 06/01/20t7 litnn l)r ,\hhi (;arg.JSO rnd Shri Kailash Makwana, Lab Assistrnt, RSPCB, Kota a sample of Ambienl AirQuality of M/S Vitya Consultants Pvt Ltd, Secunderabad Collccted iiorn Ambient AirMonitoring at Rajasthon Technical Univrsity office Buitding Kota Collecled on 04/01/2017.The sample was in a condilion fit lbr analysis as reported below:-

I funher certily thal I have analyzed the aforemenrioned sample on 20/01/201? and declare theresult ofthe anal)sis to bc as below:-

REGIONAL OFFICE Tele: 07{.1 -2{908?3

ll!\ull

The condition ofthe seals. fastening and container on .eceipl \\as as lblloN \: lnta(tSigned rhis on 20/012017,

I'arirmclrrsed Pa(iculatc Ma cr

l_,\B t\( lI,\ R(; [_

taL-.Y\t17

REGIONAL OFFICE rete: o74c -24e08?JoHq orqtdq

RAJASTHAN STATE POLLUTION CONTROL BOART){NrRrFr $et cwq firirur qv-qd

Plot No.24, Road No.6, Indraprastha lndustrial Area. Kola (ltajasthar)

RAJASTHAN STATF, POI,LI]TION CONTROI, BOAI{I)REPORT OF T}IE I,AB INCHARCT]

Final Report

Repon No: 7

Repon Onr 20/0U201?I hereby certiry that I K K Jethrly.. Lab lncharge received en rhc 10/01/20!7 tiom Dr RirkuSinghsl, JSO and Shri Kaihsh M0kwana, l,ab Assistant, RSPCB, Kota a sample of AmhienlAir Qu.lity of M/S Vitya Consultants Pvt Ltd, Secunderabad Collecred liom Amhicnt AirMonitoring rt Modi Inltitute of T€chnology offlce Brilding Rawatbhata Road Kot, ( ollcclcdon 09/01/2017. The sample ua\ in a condition tl tor anah.i, a. ren,'nc.j tt,,r

I tinher cenily that I have analyzed the atbrcmentioned sample on 20/01/2t)t? .n(l dcllrr. th!.resull ofthe analvsis to be as trelow:-

llc\ulll]l

The condition ofthe seals, fastening and conlainer on receipt was as follor,s: IntactSigned this on 20/01/2017.

LL--i,\trz

REGIONAL OFFICE .l clc: lr7{l zle(187.1

d-iq 6rqi-dq

RAJASTHAN STATE POLLUTION CONTROL BOARDvlneilq lrwl l-wur fttFqI {!-6d

Plot No.2A, Road No.6, Irdraprsstha Industrial Are8, Kota (Rajsslhan)

RAJASTHAN STATE POLLUTION CONTROL BOART)REPORT OF THE LAB INCHARGE

FinalReporl

Repon No: 8Report On: 20/01/2017I hereby cenify that I K K Jethalya, Lab lncharge reccived on thlj l2101/2017 liom l)r Ahhi (;arg.

JSO, RSPCB, Kota a sample of Ambient Air Qulliq of M/s virr-a ( onsrllanls l\l l.l(1.

S€cunderabad Collected from Ambienl Air Moniloring at lhiasthan -l((hnical t nirr\iho{Iic€ Building Kota Collected on ll/01/2017. fhc sample was in a condition ill lirr alralr.i. rs

reported below:-

I furrher cenif) lhat I have analyzed thc albremenli()ncd samplc (!n 20{ll/2011 ;tnJ ,l!.lrr. lh.

result ofthe analvsis to be as below:-

The condition ofthe seals, tastening and conlainer on receipt was as lbllowsl IntlctSigned this on 20/01r017.

l{esnll,D

llh (; I I- Or.'l'rCr.l l clc: 0'll 2ltlllS'J

R,A.JASTHAN STATE POLLUTION CON'I'ROI, I}OA R1)

lNnqFI rrEr rlwr ffiiew waaPlot No.2A, Road No.6, Indrrprastha Industrial Area, Kota (Rajasthan)

RAJASTHAN STATE POLLU'I]ON CONTROL BOARDREPORT OF THE LAB INCIIARCE

l.inrl Reporl

Report No: 9Report On: 20/01/2017I hereby cenify thal I K K.Ielhalya. L-ah lnchargc rcccirrd on lhc lJ/01/2(ll; lr,'nr l)r Sil\nrnnSingh, JSO and Shri Kailash Makwrn{, l,sb Assistanl, RsP( ll. Nota a \rrrplr ('l \mbi(rt \irQuality of M/S Viiya Consultanls I'!1 l-td, Secrndcral)n(l (ollcclcl lr,,rr \nhicnl \irMoniaoring at RIICO office Building Rsnpur Kota (bllccted on l2l0l/2lll7. lhc sanrple rriN rrr

a condition fit for analysis as reported below:-

I further certify that I have analyzed Ihe aforementioned sample on 20/01/2017 and declare theresult ofthe analysis to be as belorv:-

The condition ofthe seals. fastening and conlainer on receipt $!\ as lirllos s: lntrrctSigned this on 20/01/2017.

ONAr$s

Prr:rnrctcrsble Suspcnded Particulate Matter

Yri-.ri,\trz

Itrsu lt

,r,,w

#\t7l

IIEGIONAI, OFFICI' -l (:l'i: 07JJ -219(187J

e)*q flqi-frq

RAJASTHAN STATE POLLUTION CONTROL BOARDI]tr{vFI llw [(cq ff{iTql cug-d

Plot No.2A, Road No. 6, lndraprestha lndustrial Area, Kota (llt,iasthnn)

RAJASTHAN S'l'A',l'tl POI.LUI lON CONTR()1. ll()^Rl)REPOR'T OF TTIE I,AB INCTIAR(;I]

Final Rep(lrt

Repon No: l0Report On: 20/01/2017I hereby certify that I K K Jethslya, Lab lncharge received on the 18/01/201? lronr Shri MC Soni'Lab Assistant, RSPCB, Kota a sample ol Ambient Air Quality of M/S vi$a Consultants I\lLtd, Secunderabed Collected from Ambient Air Monitoring at RIICO office Ruikling RanpurKota Collected on l7l01/2017. The sample was in a condition fit lbr anallsis as rcPorled belou:'

I funher ceniry that I have analyzed the aforemenlioned sample on 20/01/2017 and declare thc

result ofthe analysis to be as belowi

irable Sus

i'r."u,"t"r. llc\rrllcrtlcil I'arriiL lute \lrllcr rL! \l

The condition ofthe seals. fastening and conlainer on reccipl $as as li)ll(\!\: lnlrtlSigned this on 20/01/2017,

,^,HH1-

\arti,\I'Z

REGIONAL OFFICE -I

d*'4 6niaq

RAJASTHAN STATD POLLUTION CONTI1IsRqH Yrw rqm fuizvt IIEaa

Tclc: {17.1{ -21908?l

NTROL t]oA lll)

Plot No. 2A, Road No.6, lndraprastha lttdustrial Area. Kota (Rajasthan)

RAJASTHAN STATE POI,LIJTION CON'TRoL BOARI)REPORT OF THE LAB INCHARGE

Final Report

Reporl No; I I

Report On: 20/01/2017t h;reby certily that I K K Jethalya. Lab lncharge received on lhe 19/01/2017.l'rom Dr Abhi (;arg'

JSO a;d Shri RP Nagar, Lab Assistant, nSPCB, Kot, a sample ol Ambient Air Qualiil'ol'M/S Vitya Consultanl p"t l,tO, Secunderab0d Collected liolrr Ambient Air Monihring al

Rrjasthan Technical Univrsity oIfice Building Kots Collected on I8/01/20l7 Ihe sample \\a\ i'l

a condition fit for analysis as reported belo\\:-

I funher certify thal I have analyzed the aibremtnlioncd sample on 20/01/2llll 'rrrJ d'!l'rr( I r!

result ofthe analysis to be as belo$:-

llt\rrlrlri

The condition ofthe seals, fastening and container on rcceipt was as follors: Intact

Signed this on 20101/2017.

Pnramclcrsa.a Panicutot. Vanct

\\ELAR IN( ll,\ll(;ll

=l-.r1,\trz

RE(;IONAL OFFICI' l rlc: (l:{l :.lr)ll,l1.}

e\*n i6ru1aq

RAJASTHAN STATE POLLUTION CONTROL BOARI)rNnerHwq rwfuiflr qv-gd

PIot No.2A, Road No.6, Indraprasths Industrial Area, Kota (Rajasthan)

RAJASTHAN STATE POLLUTION CON'I'RO1, BOARI)REPORT OF THE LAB INCHAR(;E

Fin{l R€port

Report No: 12

Repon On: 20/01/2017I hereby certify thal I K K Jelhalya. t,ab lnchargc reccir'cd rnr lhe 2ll/01/20t7 ll.\,rr llr l{intl'Singhal, JSO and Shri Kailash Makwsnll, l,ab Assislant, llSP( lt. Kota n \nrrptc,)t \llrhi(rlAir Quality of M/S Vitya Consultants I,vt Ltd, Secunderabad (()llccted liorn Ambigflt ,\irMonitoring at Modi lnslitute ofTechnokrgt office Building Re$rtbhnlr tio{d Kola ( r,lterlcJon l9l01/2017. The sample was in a condirion lil tbr anall sis as rcponcd bclLrr '.

I funher ceniii that I have analyzed the albremenlioned sanrplc on 20/01/2t)t7 lnd dclLrrc lh.resuh oflhe analvsis to be as below:-

irahle Sus nded Pal1iculatc Matlcr

The condition ofthe seals. fastening and container on receipt was as Iollorr s: IntactSigned this on 20/01/2017.

1.,\ li l\( I I \ta(il;

X-iD

Result74

Documents

Minutes of 160 - environmentclearance.nic.inenvironmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Online/... · Minutes of 160th meeting of Expert Appraisal Committee for projects related to