Upload
lauren-lee
View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
1/20
NAME : LEE JIA TONGENGLISH LITERATUREUNIT 4 COURSEWORK
Misfits in society : are they victims of willful choiceor social dictates ?
an exploration of 3 texts
According to Aristotle, man is by nature,
animal designed for living in states. One who
by nature, does not belong to a union is either
an inferior creature or better than mere
human being.Like criticized by Homer, misfits
are people " without a clan, without law, and
without a home ". Such a person also has an
indignation for war ; he is on his own, being at
war with the society he is in. (432) Such man
cannot conform to societal norms - to
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
2/20
sublimation, duty and structure. So where do
misfits stand ? On their own grounds of
isolation, creating their own troop of army out
of their own fortitude , defending themselves
through ego defense mechanisms - by
projecting negative self-concepts towards
others to avoid facing negative self-concepts
about their own behaviors. This self conflict
within themselves make them a misfit. As
defined by the Oxford dictionary, a misfit is a
person whose behavior or attitude sets them
apart from others in an uncomfortably
conspicuous way : a motley collection of
social misfits. In this essay, I am going to
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
3/20
explore towards these points, where misfits fit
into their category by willful choice, and later,
man become misfits through social rejection
(________) and lastly, I am going to explore
into the sentiment of an outsider trying to get
into the society and the insider trying to get
out of it. With this, I am going to discuss in
relation of two texts - Animal's People by Indra
Sinha and The Stranger, by Albert Camus and
The Outsider by Colin Wilson will set as my
literary criticism.
By nature, misfits will willfully distance
themselves from the soccer because they are too
painfully aware of their freakishness. People may
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
4/20
become a misfit through a paradoxical sense of
superiority which in the first place arises from deep
seated feeling of inferiority. This may be cultivated
through the sense of personal dignity, where they
want to feel that they have power in their own
hands, and reject society before they are rejected
by the society. Take 'The Stranger' as an example,
Meursault, our main character, has an established
societal role, where he is well employed and is very
much within the society physically, but however,
his spirit is not. For instance, the death of his
mother did not affect him at all, like how it would
have affected normal people. The text began with ,
' MOTHER died today. Or, maybe, yesterday; I cant
be sure. ' - this shows how ignorant he is towards
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
5/20
the news ; he is so very much psychologically
detached from the world around him that major
events of life mean nothing to him. He seems to be
psychologically eccentric, by displaying this
indifferences, he challenges society accepted
moral standards, which dictate that one should
grieve over death (1) . As a juxtapose, Animal from
the book Animal's People is different from
Meursault in the sense that he is a misfit in the
society because of his physical deformities, where
he walks on all fours. He goes around doing odd
jobs and finds it difficult to conform to societal
roles, where this animalistic nature is internalized
within him, which I think is very true of when
Aristotle spoke of humans as political
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
6/20
animals - [[ we are the only animals with freedom
of speech. where man, when he is at the goal of his
development, is the best of all animals : but he is
the worst of all when he is detached from customs
and justices. (433) ]] We all have that animal
instinct in us and this is very much exemplified in
Animal because this instinct seems to dominate his
human nature. " Let me be as I am, My name is
Animal. I'm not a fucking human being, I've no
wish to be one. " - this shows how Animal feels he
is not a part of the society because he looked
different and as a self defense mechanism, he
rejects the society before they get the chance to
judge him. The title of the book, ' Animal's People' :
which means generally, that humans belong to
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
7/20
animals, is of total opposite in the social order .
This title presents how 'animals' in this book
dominates human being, how the sense of
superiority is erected through how Animal sees the
society, that he is one step ahead of them - he
rejects them before they even have the chance to
scrutinize for themselves. Man, as Aristotle sees,
are the only animals with freedom of speech.
[[ Where man, when at the goal of his
development, is the best of all animals : but he is
the worst of all when detached from customs and
nature ]].
are there conditions that humans couldnt adapt to because it would be contraryto their nature?Fromm comes down in favour of the second view. Humans aresocial animals, and we need each other not only practically so as to collectivelyproduce the material things we need to live but also psychologicallywe need tofeel part of a group, of a community. From which it follows that any society whichdoes not satisfy this psychological need, or which actively works to prevent itbeing satisfied, is incompatible with human nature.
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
8/20
Man has been called the "social animal." By this is meantthat he must meet advances from and make advances tohis fellowman. "No man liveth to himself alone," the
scriptures tell us. If you are habitually unsocial, inclined tobe a bit self-righteous, you will find yourself to be a misfitwherever you are.
What are societal norms, really? Do we perceivepeople by who they are ? or by what they are ? Thetexts ' The Outsider ' by Colin Wilson and an essay by
Albert Camus, ' The Stranger ', explores into theinsights of characters that could not find a place in thesociety they are in. It deals with the struggles andendurances the characters went through just to be apart of the society , and also deals with the limitationsthe characters face due to their '' differences '' . Also,do we grow up and get prepared to face the societybeforehand, or do we get 'prepared' by the societylater on ? In this essay, we are going to explore inrelations of these three texts, of what it means to be amisfit, and is it internal, or just external. Is it them thatmentally categorize themselves as different or do theyfeel so because people treated them differently in thefirst place? Do the misfits actually refuse to be a partof the society, or they are forced to shun away by
society's will ?
Acceptance of self has been a stigma among
us, as the saying goes, if you do not love yourself,
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
9/20
how do you expect others to love you ? This inevitably
apply to our main text,Animal's People. Animal, the
main protagonist, introduced himself as 'Animal ' to
everyone because he walks on all fours, and just so
that people do not call him that behind his back. His
self acceptance divulges from scorn towards the
society, his anger towards the society - because they
looked at him differently and he has none to blame for
his deformities, but at the same time, he blames
everything and everyone. Fact is, he despises
everyone else because they are the same, they are
humans, and they are normal - " I'm not fucking
human being, I've no wish to be one" : he clearly
states here he does not wish to be among them, more
like because he looked different because the others
walked on two feet. As a juxtapose, Colin Wilson
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
10/20
defined an Outsider as a man who knows he is sick in
a civilization that does not know it is infected. He
simply has more self-awareness about the human
condition as opposed to the vast majorette of
humanity, who is not even aware that they're trapped
under limiting circumstances.
This raises the question to whether is
the society at wrong for not being accepting enough
or it is the individual that protrudes a self defense
mechanism to hold their heads above the water, when
dealing with the community they are in. We grow up
learning to deal with the society that we are about to
face when the future comes, it is been ingrained in us,
that one has to conform to the society, to 'fit in'. But
is it really about fitting in, or just being apart of
everyone, like parasites, who lives on the hospitality
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
11/20
of others. If say, every individual in the society was
different, was special, it would not be called a society
anymore, as the saying goes, a society is one where
the condition of those living in companionship with
others, or in community, rather than in isolation. I
would not conclude that everyone in the society is the
same, but rather, we do the similar things to be alike.
The Outsider has his mind set that he is too special to
be in the common -"...the Outsider is a man who cannot live in
the comfortable, insulated world of the bourgeois, accepting what he
sees and touches as reality. He sees too deep and too much, and what
he sees is essentially chaos." .This chaos, which later leads
to insanity, led the individual to believe he does not
belong, and hence the ejection. They see so much of
the filth, that they'd rather not be apart of it. Misfits
usually regard themselves as geniuses, or rather,
geniuses freaks - they conclude they know more about
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
12/20
the society than the members in it does, talk about
mothers who see much more in their daughters than
the daughters see in themselves. " People see the
outside, but it's the inside where the real things
happen, no one looks in there, maybe they don't dare.
" ( 11 ) - true enough, the common looks at the
society on its surface : socializing, conforming to
morals and ethics, pretty much doing things that
everyone else does. The society is so comfortable with
the dictate they grew up in that they do not intend to
enter the "danger zone" - where they look at the
society from a different perspective and alienate
themselves. For a society to exist and function, the
members must abide and conform to its norms,
internalizing social norms and values that dictate what
is "normal" for the society. If this internalization and
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
13/20
socialization were to fail to produce conformity, the
individual is automatically categorized as a misfit, an
outsider. In Camus' 'The Stranger', he portrayed a
protagonist, namely Meursault, who at the same time,
seems totally ignorant towards the community he is
in. Psychologically and emotionally isolated from the
world around him, he implicitly challenges society's
accepted moral standards : and that caused the
society to see him as an outsider, a threat, where at
major events such as his mother's funeral, he does
not shed a tear or when threatened to be hanged for a
crime, he does not flick and go along with it. But
really, what he thinks is that being indifferent is just
not making the distinction between good and bad : he
simply practices amorality. His refusal to conform to
the social moral dictates makes him a misfit, and thus,
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
14/20
over these courses, we unfold characters that exclude
themselves from the society, making a misfit out of
their own accord.
Animal stand aloof from his community, he
goes to places where no one dares go, he roams in
places where there's not a soul - " Gone are city
noises, horns of trucks and autos, voices of women in
the Nutcracker, kids shouting, all erased by the high
wall . " ( 29 ) Animal prefers to be somewhere else , or
anywhere for that matter, away from two-legged
humans : so he is not constantly reminded that he is
in fact, different. " For I don't think I can bear to go on
being an animal in a world of human beings. " This
further proves that Animal feel differently because the
society , in the first place, freak at his presence, a
creature who looked like human but has a bent back
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
15/20
and walk on all fours ; what would you make out of
that ? This escape puts his mind at peace, the
absence of normality puts him at ease. T.S Eliot once
said of the Outsider that he sees the world as a static
place, where trivialities assumed importance as they
would in a dull country village, and how he now sees
the world as a battleground of immense forces. The
presence of self in the universe is on its own a burden
to misfits, where the only true escape is death : but
taking away your own life is considered sinful, and
thus misfits remove themselves fro the society. It
could be that as a misfit, knowing that we do not
belong in the society, survive better on our own, an
escapade to protect ourselves from the harm the
society has blindly thrown at us. Like the Stranger, we
live in our own minds to prevent from being 'common'
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
16/20
like the society already is - because common is
nowhere near appealing, and is in fact, quite
disdainful, where the realization that the society is
composed of filth, a social dictate, we are merely
puppets of puppets. Cliche always goes with 'freedom
as the release from reality', but Wilson argued that
freedom is in truth, release from unreality. The
unreality we deal with
Bruce Lee famously quoted, ' As you think,
so shall you become ' . This raises the question to
whether do misfits think they are so because they tell
themselves so? Are they to be blamed for their absurd
thoughts that the society is either not good enough
for them, or they are not good enough for the
society ? " When I say I'm an Animal, it's not just what
I look like but what I feel. " ( 87 ) , here is a boy who
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
17/20
looks down on himself before the society even has the
chance to judge him, he already feels different
because of his deformities. His inner feelings of low
self esteem made him the part, he labeled himself
before anyone has the chance to do so. We may
think , from his prudent language that he is ignorant
of how others see him, his ill humor showed so, but
his thoughts say otherwise. Likewise, misfits, like the
Outsider and the Stranger know themselves and the
scorns of the society so well that they build a solid
wall disembodying societal norms against their own
likes. Meursault's idea of isolation arose as he
concluded that human life has no redeeming meaning
or purpose, other than death - we live to die. It was
not until the end that he realizes that as much as the
universe is indifferent to him, so is he indifferent to
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
18/20
the universe too. It's much like the saying where men
comes from clay, and shall go back to the earth.
These realizations pull him away from the community,
where he finds the idea of living to be absurd, and the
societal norm is to live. On the other side of the book,
the Outsider however cites that " The man who is
interested to know how he should live instead of
merely taking life as it comes, is automatically an
Outsider." This totally juxtaposed Camus' idea of
people who has no interest in life, ' taking life as it
comes ' is a misfit : where Meursault is unlike the
people around him who is constantly searching for the
truth in life, he simply lives life without much thought
in it. Wilson stresses on that the interest to engage life
makes one a misfit , he simply cannot settle with the
methodical way of life. He commented on Van Gogh's
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
19/20
painting as having an Outsider's characteristic : it is a
laboratory refuse of a man who treated his own life as
an experiment in living; faithfully records moods and
developments of vision on the manner of a
Bildungsroman, while commenting that Cezanne's
painting is strictly pairing : removing him from the
Outsider's category. Wilson sees an Outsider as one
who seeks more to life, questions life and wants to get
more out of it, unlike the Stranger and even Animal,
who thought life was merely one of the stages of
being in the universe. While the Outsider and the
Stranger deals with worldly issues of life and death,
Animal simply deals with the society he is thrown into,
being caught in between his own world and reality.
" A grim animal living without hope, that's
how I saw myself. I asked nothing, expected less and
7/30/2019 Misfits. Unit4
20/20
was filled with anger at the world. "