Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7The Seven Deadly
��������� ��� �������
�������
J o h n H . F i s h e r
Is it worth anhour of yourtime to avoid themistakes that mostmalpracticevictims make?
�������������� �������
��� �������������� �
�������������� �������
��� �������������� �
John H. Fisher
Copyright © 2010 by John H. Fisher
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission of the author. Published 2010.
Printed in the United States of America.
ISBN: 978-1-59571-583-8
Designed and published by
Word Association Publishers205 Fifth AvenueTarentum, Pennsylvania 15084
www.wordassociation.com1.800.827.7903
����������������������� !�"���#$� %��&�'����(������"%���)(
��������
�����*�����
������������ ��������������
������ ��������������
���� ����� ���������������� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �
���� ������+,
������������������������ ���������������������������������� ������ � �� �� �� �� �
���� ������+-
���������������������������������� �����������������!� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� ��"#
���� ������+.
����������������������������������������� ������ �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �$%
���� ������+/
����� ������ ������������������������ ��������� ��������������� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� ���
���� ������+0
����������������������������������� ������������������ � �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �%$
���� ������+1
������������������������������������ ������ �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� ��&�
���� ������+2�
���������������������������������������� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� ��&�
�����*���� � �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �#$
������������ � �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� ��#�
3�*��&���� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� �##
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 1
�����*�����
�������3��� ����� ������4���������5��*��������������
������� ����
�'(� )(*+,-.� /*01(� 23� *//,+(-4*)� +(*4'� ,-� �5(6,/*7� �(+,/*)�
5,14*8(1���26(�9(29)(�+,(�(*/'�52-4'�3625�96(:(-4*;)(�5(+,/*)�
(66261�4'*-�+,(+�,-�4'(�#<���4(6626,14�*44*/81���'(�-*4,2-*)�+(*4'�
6*4(�3625�96(:(-4*;)(�5(+,/*)�(66261�,1�=34((-�4,5(1�',.'(6�4'*-�
4'(�-*4,2-*)�506+(6�6*4(�
�-� �###>� *� 6(9264� 3625� 4'(��-,4(+� �4*4(1� �-14,404(�23��(+,/,-(�
320-+� 4'*4� '219,4*)� (66261� /*01(+� *1�5*-?� *1� #&>@@@� +(*4'1� *�
?(*6� ,-� 4'(��-,4(+��4*4(1>�/214,-.�4'(�-*4,2-�A"#�;,)),2-���',1� ,1�
B014�4'(�4,9�23�4'(�,/(;(6.��5*-?�526(�9(29)(�*6(�1(:(6()?�,-B06(+�
,-�4'(�'219,4*)>�26�+,(�2041,+(�23�4'(�'219,4*)>�+0(�42�96(:(-4*;)(�
5(+,/*)�(66261���:(-�12>�4'(�+(*4'1�,-�'219,4*)1�3625�96(:(-4*;)(�
5(+,/*)�(66261�*6(�4'(�-*4,2-�1�1,C4'�)(*+,-.�/*01(�23�+(*4'�*-+�
(C/((+� +(*4'1� 3625� 52426� :(',/)(� D6(/81>� ;6(*14� /*-/(6� *-+�
�� �>�*//26+,-.�42�4'(�140+?�(-4,4)(+� ������������ �!
�2��66��1��05*-!�/*))(+�326�*�5*-+*426?�-*4,2-D,+(�6(9264,-.�
1?14(5�326�5(+,/*)�(66261���'*4�-(:(6�'*99(-(+���-)?�"@�14*4(1�
9)01� 4'(� ,146,/4� 23��2)05;,*� 6(E0,6(�5(+,/*)� (6626� 6(9264,-.>�
;04�4'(�(:,+(-/(�1'2D1�4'*4�(:(-�,-�4'21(�5*-+*426?�6(9264,-.�
14*4(1>�'219,4*)1�6(9264�2-)?�*�4,-?�9(6/(-4*.(�23�4'(,6�5,14*8(1��
2 John H. Fisher
�(*6)?�*�+(/*+(�*34(6�4'(��-14,404(�23��(+,/,-(�6(9264>�96(:(-4*;)(�
(66261� 6(5*,-� 1'2/8,-.)?� /2552-�� �219,4*)1� *//20-4� 326� 4'(�
)*6.(14�1,-.)(�1),/(�23�4'(�-*4,2-�1�5(+,/*)�19(-+,-.>�$��9(6/(-4>�26�
*;204�AF�@�;,)),2-�,-�"@@%>�*//26+,-.�42��(+,/*6(>�*-+�4'(�424*)�
/2141�23�96(:(-4*;)(�5(+,/*)�(66261�,1�;(4D((-�A�%�;,)),2-�*-+�A"#�
;,)),2-�9(6�?(*6���-�,41�"@@&�*--0*)�6(9264�42��2-.6(11>�4'(��.(-/?�
326��(*)4'/*6(��(1(*6/'�*-+�G0*),4?>�9*64�23�4'(� (9*645(-4�23�
�(*)4'�*-+��05*-��(6:,/(1>� 6(9264(+� 4'*4�96(:(-4*;)(�5(+,/*)�
,-B06,(1�*6(�.62D,-.�(*/'�?(*6�;?�2-(�9(6/(-4�
�2426� :(',/)(� +(*4'1� *6(� 4'(� -05;(6� 2-(� /*01(� 23� *//,+(-4*)�
+(*4'�,-�4'(��-,4(+��4*4(1>�D,4'�526(�4'*-�H$>F@@�+(*4'1�,-�"@@F>�
*//26+,-.� 42� 4'(� �(-4(6� 326� ,1(*1(� �2-462)���'(� -(C4� 4'6((�
/*01(1I92,12-,-.>�=6(*651�*-+�3*))1I*//20-4�326�#@>@@@�+(*4'1>�
/25;,-(+���2D(:(6>�,3�5(+,/*)�(66261�*-+�,-3(/4,2-1�D(6(�;(44(6�
46*/8(+>�4'(?�D20)+�(*1,)?�429�4'(�),14�
�'(6(� ,1� *� '0.(� :*6,*4,2-� 23� E0*),4?� *-+� 1*3(4?� ,-� 4'(� 1?14(5��
�-32640-*4()?>�4'(��-,4(+��4*4(1�'*1�-2�3(+(6*)�*.(-/?�6(192-1,;)(�
326�'219,4*)�2:(61,.'4�� �-14(*+>� ,4�6(),(1�2-�*�9*4/'D268�23�14*4(�
'(*)4'� +(9*645(-41� *-+� *� -2-J962=4� .6209� /*))(+� 4'(� K2,-4�
�255,11,2-� 4'*4� 1(41�;*1,/� 14*-+*6+1� 326� 4'(�-*4,2-���219,4*)1�
*6(� 6*6()?� /)21(+� 26� ',4� D,4'� 1,.-,=/*-4� =-*-/,*)� 9(-*)4,(1� 326�
'064,-.�9*4,(-41�
�-?�(33264�42�5*,-4*,-�-*4,2-*)�14*-+*6+1�,1�)(34�)*6.()?�42��(+,/*6(�
*-+�4'(�K2,-4��255,11,2->�*�-2-J962=4�.6209�4'*4>�*)2-.�D,4'�4'(�
14*4(� '(*)4'� +(9*645(-41>� /(64,=(1� 4'*4� '219,4*)1� *6(� 29(6*4,-.�
1*3()?���,4'�3(D(6�4'*-��>@@@�(59)2?((1>�4'(��255,11,2-�*//6(+,41�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 3
*-+�1(41�9*4,(-4�1*3(4?�.2*)1�326��%>@@@�'219,4*)1>�-061,-.�'25(1>�
*-+�*11,14(+�),:,-.�962:,+(61�-*4,2-*))?�
�4*4(� 5(+,/*)� ;2*6+1� *6(� 109921(+� 42� +,1/,9),-(� +2/4261� D'2�
:,2)*4(� 14*-+*6+1� 23� /*6(�� �2D(:(6>� )(11� 4'*-� #L� 23� +2/4261�
D'2� 5*8(� 50)4,9)(� 5*)96*/4,/(� 9*?5(-41� *6(� (:(6� 10;B(/4� 42�
5(+,/*)�;2*6+�+,1/,9),-(��������������������������������������������
����������������� ������� ������������� ����������
�'(�90;),/�9(6/(94,2-�,1�4'*4�:,640*))?�(:(6?2-(�,1�10,-.�326�(:(-�
4'(�5214�5,-26� ,-B06,(1�26�;*1()(11�/259)*,-41���',)(� 4'*4�/*-�
2//06>�4'(�6(*),4?�,1�4'*4�5214�:,/4,51�23�5*)96*/4,/(�*6(�-24�(:(-�
*D*6(� 4'*4� 4'(?� D(6(� ,-B06(+� 4'620.'� *� 96(:(-4*;)(� 5(+,/*)�
5,14*8(����140+?�/2-+0/4(+�;?��*6:*6+�1��/'22)�23��0;),/��(*)4'�
320-+�#%L�23�5(+,/*)�5*)96*/4,/(�/)*,51�'*+�5(6,4>�962:,-.�2-)?�
4'21(�D,4'�6(*)�,-B06,(1�1((8�*-?�6(/2061(�
�40+,(1�1'2D�4'*4�2-)?�2-(�,-�(,.'4�5*)96*/4,/(�:,/4,51�D,))�;6,-.�
*� /)*,5������� ��� �� ����� ���� ���������� �� �� ������ ��� ������������
�������� �����!�� ���������"
�-2D)(+.(�,1�92D(6���3�?20�8-2D�?206�6,.'41>�?20�D,))�;(�*�50/'�
526(�92D(630)�*+:2/*4(�326�?206�3*5,)?�1�5(+,/*)�/*6(�D'(-�4'(?�
*6(�1,/8���',1�;228�D,))�.,:(�?20�*-1D(61�*;204�?206�6,.'41�*1�*�
9*4,(-4�26�*�9*4,(-4�1�*+:2/*4(�*-+�D'*4�?20�/*-�+2�D'(-�*�+2/426>�
-061(>�'219,4*)�;06(*0/6*4�26�)*D?(6�,1�,.-26,-.�?206�6,.'41�
4 John H. Fisher
��D624(� 4',1�;228�12�?20�D,))�8-2D�D'*4�E0(14,2-1� 42�*18� 4'(�
9'?1,/,*-1>�-061(1�*-+�?206�)*D?(6>�*-+�'2D�42�.(4�*-1D(61�4'*4�
-2�2-(�()1(�D,))�.,:(�?20��
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 5
���� ������+,
�����5�����6���5��6���7��8�����������������*�������*�
�������9
������������� ������������
�'(�)*D�=651�4'*4�*+:(64,1(�2-����*6(�010*))?�4'(�D2614�)*D�=651>�
D,4'�),44)(�42�-2�46,*)�(C9(6,(-/(���'(1(� ���)*D�=651!�962524(�
4'(51():(1�*1�4'(� '25(�60-�',44(61!�26�4'(� 429�+2.1!��26�125(�
24'(6�4*/8?�;04�/*4/'?�-,/8-*5(�>�;04�4'(?�6*6()?�'*-+)(�),4,.*4(+�
/*1(1�*-+�,3�4'(�-((+�42�),4,.*4(�*�/*1(�*6,1(1>�4'(?�6(3(6�4'(�/*1(�
42�*�46,*)�)*D�=65��
�'(� ���)*D�=65!�'*1�3265(6�/)*,51�*+B014(61�D268,-.�326�4'(5>�
*-+�*�6()*4,:()?� 15*))�-05;(6�23�(C9(6,(-/(+� )*D?(61M� 10/'� )*D�
=651�234(-�2-)?�'*:(�2-(�428(-�46,*)�)*D?(6�2-�4'(,6�(-4,6(�14*33�
*-+�*�+2N(-�26�526(�/)*,51�*+B014(61���'(�2-)?� ,-4(6(14�23� 4'(�
���)*D�=65!�,1�1(44),-.�?206�/*1(>�234(-�*4�*�14((9�+,1/20-4�42�
4'(�460(�:*)0(�23�?206�/*1(���3�4'(?�/*-�4�1(44)(�?206�/*1(>�4'(?�D,))�
6(3(6�?206�/*1(�42�*�)*D�=65�4'*4�'*1�(C9(6,(-/(+�46,*)�)*D?(61��
�'(� ���)*D�=65!�D,))�14,))�.(4�2-(�4',6+�26�526(�23�4'(�)(.*)�3((�
*34(6�4'(?�6(3(6�?206�/*1(�42�4'(�(C9(6,(-/(+�46,*)�)*D?(61�
�
�'(� /2-105(61�D'2� ',6(� 4'(� ��� )*D� =65!� +(+,/*4(� -2� 4,5(�
42� 6(1(*6/',-.� )*D�=651�� �3� 4'(?�+,+� 4'(,6� 6(1(*6/'>� 4'(?�D20)+�
+,1/2:(6�4'*4�4'(�)*D?(61�3625�4'(� ���)*D�=65!�19(-+�3*6�526(�
6 John H. Fisher
4,5(�,-�362-4�23����/*5(6*1�*-+�5*68(4,-.�4(*51�4'*-�4'(?�+2�,-�*�
/20646225���*-?�23�4'(�)*D?(61�D'2�*+:(64,1(�*1�4'(� '25(�60-�
',44(61!�26�4'(� 429�+2.!�'*:(�-(:(6�*/40*))?�;((-�,-�*�/20646225�
*-+�D20)+�-24�8-2D�D'*4�42�+2�,3�4'(?�'*+�42�96(1(-4�*�/*1(�42�
*�B06?�
�'(�1*+�3*/4�,1�4'*4�5214�9(29)(�19(-+�3*6�526(�4,5(�6(1(*6/',-.�
01(+�/*61�4'*-�4'(?�19(-+�46?,-.�42�=-+�4'(�6,.'4�9(612-*)�,-B06?�
)*D?(6�� 2�?20�D*-4�*�/)*,51�*+B014(6�'*-+),-.�?206�/*1(>�26�*-�
(C9(6,(-/(+�46,*)�)*D?(67��',1�+(/,1,2-�D,))�*33(/4�?206�6(/2:(6?�
526(�4'*-�*-?�24'(6�,-3265*4,2-�/2-4*,-(+�,-�4',1�;228�
���������������������������������������
�0-�*-+�',+(���3�*�)*D?(6�*181�326�52-(?�3625�?20�42�9*?�326�4'(�
/2141� 23� ?206� /*1(>� ?20� 1'20)+� =-+� *� -(D� )*D?(6� 962-42O� #���
$�����%����� ����� ���������������������� ������ ������������������� ���
����������������%�� ��������������������4�,1�*�/214�23�+2,-.�;01,-(11�
326�5*)96*/4,/(� )*D�=651�42�9*?�326�4'(�/2141�23�',6,-.�5(+,/*)�
(C9(641>�2;4*,-,-.�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1>�9*?,-.�326�+(921,4,2-1>�(4/�
*D?(61�D'2�*18�?20�42�9*?�326�4'(�/2141�23�?206�/*1(�;(326(�
4'(�/*1(� ,1� 6(12):(+�'*:(�-2�;01,-(11� ,-�5*)96*/4,/(� ),4,.*4,2-�
*-+�?20�1'20)+�4*8(�10/'�*�6(E0(14�*1�*-�06.(-4�D*6-,-.�42�=-+�
*�-(D�)*D?(6�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 7
������������������������������������������������������
�206�=614�E0(14,2-�42�?206�)*D?(6�1'20)+�;(��D'*4�,1�4'(�14*404(�
23�),5,4*4,2-1�326�5?�/*1(�*-+�D'(-�+2���'*:(�42�=)(�5?�)*D10,47��
�3� ?206� )*D?(6� /*--24� *-1D(6� 4'(1(� E0(14,2-1>� 60-� 326� 4'(��
-(*6(14�+226��
�3�4'(�14*404(�23�),5,4*4,2-1�2-�?206�/*1(�*99(*61�42�'*:(�(C9,6(+>�
4'(-�*18�?206�*4426-(?�*;204�4'(� /2-4,-0201�46(*45(-4!�+2/46,-(��
�'(� /2-4,-0201� 46(*45(-4!� +2/46,-(� ,1� *� 96,-/,9)(�23� )*D� 4'*4�
.,:(1�?20�526(�4,5(�42�;6,-.�*�)*D10,4�,3�?20�'*:(�/2-4,-0(+�42�
46(*4�D,4'�4'(�924(-4,*)�+(3(-+*-4�326�4'(�1*5(�,-B06?�*34(6�4'(�
5*)96*/4,/(�2//066(+��
�26�(C*59)(>�,3�?20�*))(.(�4'*4�?206�264'29(+,/�106.(2-�;24/'(+�
?206�8-((�106.(6?�4'6((�?(*61�*.2>�4'(�4D2�?(*6�*-+�1,C�52-4'�
14*404(�23�),5,4*4,2-1�'*1�*)6(*+?�(C9,6(+���3>�'2D(:(6>�?20�/2-4,-0(+�
42�46(*4�D,4'�4'(�264'29(+,/�106.(2-�326�?206�8-((�,-B06?�326�1,C�
52-4'1�*34(6�4'(�29(6*4,2->�4'(-�4'(�14*404(�23�),5,4*4,2-1�+2(1�
-24�;(.,-�0-4,)�?20�1429�46(*45(-4�D,4'�4'(�9'?1,/,*-��
�',)(�?20�5*?�*1105(�?206�)*D?(6�,1�/*6(30))?�8((9,-.�46*/8�23�
4'(1(�+(*+),-(1>�5*-?�)*D?(61�+2�-24���'(�5214�/2552-�;*1,1�326�
*�)(.*)�5*)96*/4,/(�/*1(�,1�4'*4�4'(�)*D?(6�3*,)(+�42�=)(�4'(�)*D10,4�
;(326(�4'(�14*404(�23�),5,4*4,2-1�(C9,6(+���3�?20�',6(�*-�*4426-(?�
D'2�+2(1�-24�+(:24(�',1�96*/4,/(�42�5*)96*/4,/(�),4,.*4,2->�'(�5*?�
-24�(:(-�;(�*D*6(�23�4'(�/266(/4�14*404(�23�),5,4*4,2-1>�26�D'(-�
?206�6,.'41�D,))�(C9,6(���',1�,1�6(*))?�9)*?,-.�D,4'�=6(�
8 John H. Fisher
�4�4'(�=614�5((4,-.�D,4'�?206�)*D?(6>�*18�',5�42�19(/,3?�4'(�+*4(�
4'*4�4'(�14*404(�23�),5,4*4,2-1�D,))�(C9,6(�2-�?206�/*1(�*-+�*18�',5�
42�4())�?20�D'(-�'(�D,))�.,:(�?20�*�+(/,1,2-�D'(4'(6�'(�D,))�*//(94�
4'(�/*1(�� 2�-24�*//(94�0-/)(*6�26�:*.0(�*-1D(61���3�?206�)*D?(6�
/*--24�.,:(�?20�/)(*6�*-1D(61�42�4'(1(�1,59)(�E0(14,2-1>�,4�,1�4,5(�
42�=-+�*�-(D�)*D?(6�
�3�?206� )*D?(6�/*--24�5*8(�*�+(/,1,2-�D'(4'(6� 42�*//(94�?206�
/*1(�*-+�;(.,-�4'(�)*D10,4�D,4',-�4'6((�52-4'1>�4'(-�?20�1'20)+�
=-+�204�D'?���'(6(�5*?�;(�*�+(/(-4�(C9)*-*4,2->�;04�234(-�4'(�
4604'�,1�4'*4�4'(�)*D?(6�,1�+2,-.�-24',-.�D,4'�?206�=)(�
�����!���������������������������"������"����������#���
�3�?206�)*D?(6�+2(1�-24�*-1D(6�?206�9'2-(�5(11*.(1�*-+�D,))�-24�
5((4�D,4'�?20�42�+,1/011�4'(�14*401�23�?206�924(-4,*)�/*1(>�2-(�23�
4D2�4',-.1�,1�),8()?��4'(�)*D?(6�,1�422�;01?�326�?206�/*1(>�26�'(�,1�
),44)(�42�-2�,-4(6(14�,-�?206�/*1(>�26�9211,;)?�;24'���,4'(6�D*?>�4',1�
,1�;*+�-(D1�326�?20��
�206� ;*1,/� 6,.'41� ,-� 4'(� *4426-(?J/),(-4� 6()*4,2-1',9� ,-/)0+(�
*-1D(61�3625�?206�*4426-(?�*1�42�D'*4�'(�'*1�+2-(�D,4'�?206�
/*1(�� �26� (C*59)(>� ?206� *4426-(?� 1'20)+� '*:(� 2;4*,-(+� ?206�
5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�D,4',-�4D2�42�4'6((�D((81�*34(6�?20�962:,+(�',5�
D,4'�6()(*1(�*04'26,N*4,2-1���,4',-� 3206� 42�1,C�D((81�*34(6�?20�
6(4*,-�?206�)*D?(6>�'(�1'20)+�'*:(�1(-4�?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�42�
*�5(+,/*)�(C9(64�*-+�/2-10)4(+�D,4'�4'(�(C9(64�*;204�?206�/*1(��
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 9
�206�)*D?(6�1'20)+�;(�96(9*6(+�42�+,1/011�4'(�5(6,4�23�?206�/*1(�
D,4',-�1,C�D((81�*34(6�?20�=614�/2-4*/4�D,4'�',5�
�20�5*?�D*-4�42�*18�?206� )*D?(6���*:(�?20�2;4*,-(+�*))�23�5?�
5(+,/*)�6(/26+17��*:(�?20�1(-4�5?�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�42�*�5(+,/*)�
(C9(647��*:(�?20�1928(-�D,4'�*�5(+,/*)�(C9(64�*;204�5?�/*1(7�
�'*4�29,-,2-1�+,+�?206�5(+,/*)�(C9(64�4())�?20�*;204�5?�/*1(7�
�1� ?206�5(+,/*)� (C9(64�D,)),-.� 42� 4(14,3?� ,-� /2064� 6(.*6+,-.� ',1�
29,-,2-17� �3� ?206� )*D?(6� /*--24� *-1D(6� 4'(1(� E0(14,2-1�D,4',-�
3206�42�1,C�D((81�*34(6�?20�6(4*,-�',5>�,4�,1�),8()?�4'*4�?206�)*D?(6�
,1�+2,-.�:(6?�),44)(>�26�-24',-.>�D,4'�?206�/*1(�*-+�?20�1'20)+�=-+�
*�-(D�)*D?(6�
�3�?206�)*D?(6�.,:(1�?20�:*.0(�*-1D(61�*;204�4'(�14*401�23�?206�
/*1(>�?20�-((+�42�*18�D'?�'(�/*--24�962:,+(�*-1D(61���3�4'(�)*D?(6�
/*--24�*-1D(6�10/'�E0(14,2-1>�?20�-((+�42�=-+�*�-(D�)*D?(6�
����������������������
�'(�)2-.(6�?20�4*8(�42�/2-4*/4�*�)*D?(6>�4'(�)(11�),8()?�*�)*D?(6�D,))�
*//(94�?206�/*1(���'(6(�*6(�5*-?�6(*12-1>�;04�4'(�5214�,59264*-4�
6(*12-P4'*4� ���� �������������� ����P,1� /*))(+� 4'(� 14*404(�
23�),5,4*4,2-1�!�
�'(� 14*404(� 23� ),5,4*4,2-1� ,1� *� 60)(� 4'*4� 6(E0,6(1� ?20� 42�
;6,-.� ?206� )*D10,4� D,4',-� *� 19(/,=/� +(*+),-(�� �-� �(D��268>� *�
)*D10,4� 326� 5(+,/*)� 5*)96*/4,/(� 5014� ;(� 14*64(+� D,4',-� 4D2�
?(*61� *-+� 1,C�52-4'1� *34(6� 4'(� +*4(� 23� 4'(�5*)96*/4,/(>� *-+� ,3�
10 John H. Fisher
4'(� 9*4,(-4� +,(1� *1� *� 6(10)4� 23� 4'(� 5*)96*/4,/(>� 4'(� 14*404(�
23� ),5,4*4,2-1� ,1� 4D2� ?(*61�� �3� ?20� '*:(� *� /*1(� *.*,-14� *� 3(+(6*)�
*.(-/?>� 26� *� 14*4(>� /,4?� 26� /20-4?� '219,4*)>� ?206� +(*+),-(��
,1�(:(-�1'264(6�
�-�/)*,51�*.*,-14�*�/20-4?>�14*4(�26�/,4?�'219,4*)>�?20�5014�=)(�*�
)(.*)�+2/05(-4�8-2D-�*1�*� -24,/(�23�/)*,5!�D,4',-�#@�+*?1�*34(6�
4'(�5*)96*/4,/(���3�?206�)*D?(6�+2(1�-24�=)(�4'(�-24,/(�23�/)*,5>�
?20�5*?�)21(�?206�6,.'41�
�'(6(�,1�-24',-.�*�)*D?(6�/*-�+2�326�?20�2-/(�4'(�14*404(�23�),5,4*4,2-1�
2-�?206�/*1(�(C9,6(1���206�6,.'41�:*-,1'O��3�?20�'*:(�4'(�1462-.(14�
5*)96*/4,/(�/*1(�(:(6>�,4�,1�5(*-,-.)(11�,3�4'(�14*404(�23�),5,4*4,2-1��
'*1�(C9,6(+�
�$���%��������!����
�(1���3�?20�*18�42�6(:,(D�?206�=)(>�*-+�?206�)*D?(6�6(301(1>�*)*651�
1'20)+�.2�233�,-�?206�'(*+���3�?206�)*D?(6�,1�-24�D,)),-.�42�)(4�?20�
1((�?206�=)(>�'(�5*?�;(�',+,-.�125(4',-.�
�20�1'20)+�6(E0(14�*�5((4,-.�D,4'�?206�)*D?(6�D'(6(�?20�/*-�1,4�
+2D-�D,4'�',5�26�'(6�*-+�6(:,(D�*))�23�4'(�9*9(6D268�,-�?206�=)(��
(44(6�?(4>�*18�?206�)*D?(6�42�1(-+�?20�*�� �/2-4*,-,-.�*))�23�4'(�
=)(�5*4(6,*)1�,-�?206�/*1(���',1�D,))�5*8(�?20�*�;(44(6�,-3265(+�
/),(-4>�*-+�'()9�?206�)*D?(6�422>�1,-/(�'(�D,))�'*:(�3(D(6�9'2-(�
/*))1�*-+�E0(14,2-1�42�*-1D(6�*34(6�?20�;(/25(�;(44(6�*/E0*,-4(+�
D,4'�4'(�=)(�5*4(6,*)1�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 11
��������������������������������������������������#���
�4� *-?� 525(-4� ,-� 4,5(>� ?20� 1'20)+� 8-2D� 4'(� 14*401� 23� ?206�
/*1(�� �26� (C*59)(���'(-� D,))� 4'(� +(921,4,2-1� ;(� '()+7� �*:(�
4'(� *4426-(?1� /259)(4(+� 4'(� (C/'*-.(� 23� 9*9(6� +,1/2:(6?>� ,�(�>�
+,1/2:(6?� +(5*-+1� *-+� 6(192-1(17��,))� 4'(6(� ;(� *� +(3(-1(�
5(+,/*)�(C*5,-*4,2-�23�?20�*-+�,3�12>�D'(-7��'(-�D,))�4'(�46,*)�
;(�1/'(+0)(+�;?�4'(�/20647
�3� ?20� /*--24� *-1D(6� 4'(1(� E0(14,2-1>� 4'(-� ?206� )*D?(6� ,1� -24�
8((9,-.� ?20� ,-3265(+� *;204� 4'(� 14*401� 23� ?206� /*1(���20� -((+�
*-1D(61O� 2�-24�*//(94�(J5*,)1�*-+�9'2-(�5(11*.(1I?20�*6(�
(-4,4)(+�42�*�5((4,-.�D,4'�?206�)*D?(6���3�?206�)*D?(6�,1�422�;01?�
42�5((4�D,4'�?20>�?20�1'20)+�=-+�*�-(D�)*D?(6�
�-�*�1(-1(>�?20�*-+�?206�)*D?(6�;(/25(�9*64-(61���'(�/2-4,-.(-4�
3((� 1?14(5� 1(6:(1� *-� ,59264*-4� 30-/4,2-� ,-� .,:,-.� )*D?(61�D'2�
'*:(�-2�.0*6*-4((�23�/2))(/4,-.�*�3((�*-�,-/(-4,:(�42�46?�'*6+�326�
,4>�D,4'�4'(�/),(-4�4'(�5*B26�;(-(=/,*6?��
�'(�526(�/2-4*/4�?20�'*:(�D,4'�?206�)*D?(6>�4'(�;(44(6>�*1�?20�
D,))�;(�,-3265(+�*;204�4'(�14*401�23�?206�/*1(�*-+�?206�)*D?(6�
D,))�'*:(�09+*4(1�*;204�?206�5(+,/*)�46(*45(-4�
12 John H. Fisher
� ���#���%�"���������������������#�������������
�'(� D(;1,4(� 23� 4'(� �(D��268� �4*4(� �-,=(+� �2064� �?14(5�
�'449�<<,*991�/20641�14*4(�-?�01<�(;/,:,)��962:,+(1�2-),-(�*//(11�
42�,-3265*4,2-�*;204�/*1(1�,-��096(5(��2064���(D��268�1�46,*)�
)(:()� /2064�� ,-� *))� F"� /20-4,(1�23��(D��268� �4*4(���(;�,:,)� ,1�
962:,+(+�*1�*�36((�90;),/�1(6:,/(�;?�4'(��(D��268��4*4(��-,=(+�
�2064��?14(5�� 2/05(-41�4'*4�'*:(�;((-�()(/462-,/*))?�=)(+�5*?�
;(�:,(D(+�;?�/),/8,-.�2-�4'(� 1'2D�(J�,)(+� 2/05(-41!�;0442-�
,-� 4'(��*1(� (4*,)� �/6((-�� �3� 4'(� +2/05(-41� *6(� -24� *:*,)*;)(�
2-),-(>�?20�1'20)+�/2-4*/4�4'(�23=/(�23�4'(��20-4?��)(68�,-�4'(�
/20-4?�D'(6(�?206�/*1(�,1�;(,-.�'(*6+���20�/*-�1(*6/'�326�/*1(�
,-3265*4,2-�;?� 4'(�-*5(�23� 4'(�9)*,-4,33�26�+(3(-+*-4�26� )228�
09�/*1(1�;?�4'(��4426-(?<�,65�-*5(�*-+�:,(D�4'(�/*)(-+*61�326�
(*/'�/2064�
�
�,4'��(;�,:,)>� *-?2-(� /*-� /6(*4(� *-� (J�6*/8� *//20-4>� D',/'�
D,))�962:,+(�?20�D,4'�(J5*,)�09+*4(1�*-+�*99(*6*-/(�6(5,-+(61�
326� �096(5(��2064� /*1(1���*1(� 09+*4(1� *6(� (J5*,)1�D',/'� *6(�
*0425*4,/*))?�.(-(6*4(+�(:(6?�4,5(�4'(�/2064�14*33�09+*4(1�*�/*1(�
,-�4'(,6�/25904(6�1?14(5���))�/20641�,-��(D��268�*6(�09+*4(+�*4�
)(*14�2-/(�*�+*?>�12�?20�1'20)+�.(4�/066(-4�,-3265*4,2-�*;204�?206�
/*1(���20�/*-�1(-+�E0(14,2-1�42�(/20641Q/20641�14*4(�-?�01�
�
�20�/*-�*)12�01(��(;�,:,)� 42�/'(/8�4'(�14*401�23�*�+(3(-+*-4�1�
)*D10,4>�10/'�*1�4'(�9'?1,/,*-�,-:2):(+�,-�?206�/*1(�� (/,1,2-1�2-�
24'(6�)*D10,41�5*?�'*:(�*�;(*6,-.�2-�?206�/*1(>�12�,4�9*?1�42�8((9�
09J42J+*4(�2-�/*1(1�,-:2):,-.�?206�9'?1,/,*-�26�'219,4*)�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 13
�%��������������&�����#���%������������
�,6(�',5O��20�'*:(�4'(�6,.'4�42�=6(�?206�)*D?(6�*4�*-?�4,5(�*-+�
326� *-?� 6(*12-���'(� 6(4*,-(6� *.6((5(-4� 4'*4� ?20� 1,.-(+� +2(1�
-24�6(E0,6(�4'*4�?20�8((9�?206� )*D?(6�� �3�?206� )*D?(6�'*1�;((-�
+,1'2-(14�26�',+,-.�,-3265*4,2-�3625�?20�*-+�?20�3(()�4'*4�4'(6(�
,1� -2� 46014� )(34� ,-� ?206� *4426-(?J/),(-4� 6()*4,2-1',9>� 4'(-� ;?� *))�
5(*-1�=6(�4'(�)*D?(6�*-+�4*8(�4'(�4,5(�42�=-+�4'(�6,.'4�)*D?(6�
326�?206�/*1(�
�$�������������!�����'�������������������
�����������'�������������������������
�2O��206�)*D?(6�/*--24�1,59)?�(-+�4'(�)*D?(6J/),(-4�6()*4,2-1',9�
2-/(�4'(�)*D10,4�,-�?206�/*1(�'*1�;((-�=)(+���206�)*D?(6�5014�=614�
6(E0(14�?206�9(65,11,2-�42�(-+�4'(�*4426-(?J/),(-4�6()*4,2-1',9>�
*-+�,3�?20�+2�-24�/2-1(-4>�4'(�)*D?(6�D,))�'*:(�42�.(4�9(65,11,2-�
3625�4'(��2064�42�4(65,-*4(�4'(�6()*4,2-1',9�
� ������%���#�������"���������������#�����
�3� ?20� '*:(� 42� 0-+(6.2� *� ;6*,-� 29(6*4,2->� D20)+� ?20� D*-4� *�
'(*64�106.(2-7��3�/2061(�-24O��'(�'(*64�106.(2-�5*?�;(�D26)+�
6(-2D-(+�*-+�(C46*26+,-*6,)?�18,))(+�*4�29(6*4,-.�2-�4'(�'(*64>�
;04�D'*4�+2(1�'(�8-2D�*;204�29(6*4,-.�2-�4'(�;6*,-7��',1�1*5(�
96,-/,9)(�*99),(1�42�)*D?(61�
14 John H. Fisher
�3�?206�/*1(� ,-:2):(+�;6*,-�+*5*.(�42�*�;*;?�/*01(+�;?�46*05*�
*4�;,64'>�4'(-�,-4(6:,(D�)*D?(61�*-+�*18�4'(5���2D�5*-?�;6*,-J
+*5*.(+� ;*;?� /*1(1� '*:(� ?20� '*-+)(+7��'*4� 9(6/(-4*.(� 23�
?206�)*D�96*/4,/(�,1�+(:24(+�42�5(+,/*)�5*)96*/4,/(�/*1(7��'*4�
9(6/(-4*.(�23�?206�)*D�96*/4,/(�,1�+(:24(+�42�6(96(1(-4,-.�/',)+6(-�
'*65(+�*4�;,64'7��*:(�?20�'*-+)(+�46,*)1�,-:2):,-.�;*;,(1�,-B06(+�
*4� ;,64'7��'*4� ,1� 4'(� 424*)� -05;(6� 23� /*1(1� ?20� '*:(� '*-+)(+�
,-:2):,-.�;*;,(1�,-B06(+�*4�;,64'7
�'(� )*D?(6� 5*?� 6(192-+� 4'*4� '*)3� 23� ',1� 4,5(� ,1� +(+,/*4(+� 42�
5*)96*/4,/(�/*1(1�*-+�4'(�24'(6�'*)3�,1�19(-4�2-�/6,5,-*)�+(3(-1(�
/*1(1���'*4�1�-24�;*+>�;04�'(�,1�-24�4'(�;(14�*4426-(?�326�?206�/*1(��
�'(�,+(*)�*-1D(6�4'*4�?20�D*-4�3625�4'(�)*D?(6�,1���?�96*/4,/(�,1�
+(:24(+�(C/)01,:()?�42�5(+,/*)�5*)96*/4,/(>���'*:(�'*-+)(+�+2N(-1�
23� ;6*,-J+*5*.(+� ;*;?� /*1(1� ,-� 5?� /*6((6� *-+� �� *5� /066(-4)?�
'*-+),-.�1(:(6*)�;6*,-J+*5*.(+�;*;?�/*1(1���',1�,1�?206�5*-O
�26�?(*61>� 4'(� 1)2.*-�23��(-40/8?��6,(+��',/8(-�'*1�;((-� 4'*4�
4'(?� +2� 2-)?� 2-(� 4',-.�� /',/8(-���'(� 1*5(� 96,-/,9)(� *99),(1� 42�
?206�1()(/4,2-�23�*�)*D?(6���,-+�125(2-(�D'2�19(/,*),N(1�,-�4'(�
*6(*�?20�-((+�
�-106*-/(� /*66,(61� 8-2D� 4'*4� 4'(� ��� )*D� =651!� *6(� .2,-.� 42�
1(44)(�326�9(--,(1�2-�4'(�+2))*6>�*-+�4'(?�*)12�8-2D�4'*4�6(904*;)(�
),4,.*4,2-�=651�D,))�46?�42�5*C,5,N(�4'(�:*)0(�23�4'(�/*1(�;?�.2,-.�
42�46,*)��(112-���,6(�4'(� ���)*D�=651!�*4�?206�2D-�9(6,)�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 15
��������%��������������������������������������
�*-?�)*D?(61�D,))�9625,1(�*�'0.(�1(44)(5(-4�42�4'(,6�-(D�/),(-41�
326�2-(�6(*12-��4'(?�D*-4�4'(�-(D�/*1(�*-+�4'(,6�9625,1(1�23�',.'�
+2))*6�=.06(1�*)D*?1�,596(11�-(D�/),(-41���(D�/),(-41�*6(�*)D*?1�
,596(11(+�;?�4'(�',.'�=.06(1�4211(+�*620-+�;?�4'(,6�)*D?(6�*-+�
4'(?�)(*:(�4'(�=614�5((4,-.�D,4'�4'(,6�)*D?(6�/2-:,-/(+�4'*4�4'(?�
D,))�D,-�4'(�B*/8924�
�3�4',1�'*99(-1�42�?20>�60-�326�4'(�+226O��4�,1�,59211,;)(�326�*�)*D?(6�
42�(14,5*4(�4'(�:*)0(�23�?206�/*1(�D'(-�?20�=614�5((4�D,4'�',5��
�'(�)*D?(6�,1�*)5214�*)D*?1�0-*;)(�42�*11(11�4'(�9(65*-(-/?�23�
?206�,-B06,(1>�D'(4'(6�?20�D,))�'*:(�)2-.J4(65�/259),/*4,2-1�*-+�
+,3=/0)4,(1>� D'(4'(6� 4'(6(� D,))� ;(� 962;)(51� 962:,-.� -(.),.(-/(�
*.*,-14�4'(�D62-.+2(6�*-+�'(�,1�010*))?�0-*D*6(�23�4'(�+(3(-+*-41��
),*;,),4?� ,-106*-/(� /2:(6*.(���))� 23� 4'(1(� 4',-.1� D,))� *33(/4� '2D�
50/'>�,3�*-?>�52-(?�D,))�;(�6(/2:(6(+�,-�?206�/*1(�
�22+�)*D?(61�D,))�-(:(6�4())�-(D�/),(-41�'2D�50/'�52-(?�4'(?�
/*-�(C9(/4�42�6(/(,:(� 3625�4'(,6�/*1(���',1� ,1� ,66(192-1,;)(�*-+�
+(1,.-(+�42�*//259),1'�2-(�4',-.��/2-:,-/(�?20�4'*4�4'(�)*D?(6�
,1�4'(�6,.'4�9(612-�42�'*-+)(�?206�/*1(��(�:(6?�D*6?�23�)*D?(61�
D'2�9625,1(�?20�4'(�522-���'(6(�*6(�-2�.0*6*-4((1�,-�9(612-*)�
,-B06?�),4,.*4,2-�
16 John H. Fisher
�%����������������������������&�(����)������������������������*�������������
�'(�5214�/2552-�4',-.�4'*4���'(*6�3625�/),(-41�,1�� ��*5�-24�4'(�
4?9(�23�9(612-�42�10(>�;04R�!��'(� 3*/4� ,1� 4'*4�:(6?� 3(D�9(29)(�
*6(�4'(� 4?9(�23�9(612-�D'2�10(1>!�*-+�4'(�9(612-1�D'2�D*-4�42�
),4,.*4(�2:(6�5,-26�,-B06,(1�*-+�+,1904(1�*6(�-24�4'(�/),(-41�4'*4���
D*-4�42�6(96(1(-4��
#&L� 23� 4'(� 9290)*4,2-� ,1� -24� 4'(� 4?9(� 23� 9(612-� 42� 10(�!�
�2D(:(6>� D'(-� ?20� 26� ?206� )2:(+� 2-(� '*1� ;((-� ,-B06(+�
4'620.'� 4'(� -(.),.(-/(� 23� *-24'(6� 9(612->� ?20� '*:(� ;*1,/�
6(192-1,;,),4,(1� 42� (-106(� 4'*4� 5(+,/*)� ;,))1� *6(� 9*,+>� )214�
D*.(1� *6(� 6(/2:(6(+>� 30406(� 5(+,/*)� (C9(-1(1� *6(� 9*,+I
*-+� ,3� 4'(6(� ,1� *� 9'?1,/*)� +,1*;,),4?>� ?20� 5014� (-106(� 4'*4� ?20�
26� ?206� )2:(+� 2-(� ,1� /259(-1*4(+� 326� 4'(� +6*5*4,/� /'*-.(��
,-�?206�),3(�
��������������������������"��
�26� "@@F� 9'?1,/,*-� 5(+,/*)� 5*)96*/4,/(� 9*?5(-41>� 4'(� 5(*-�
+()*?� ;(4D((-� *-� ,-/,+(-4� 4'*4� )(+� 42� *� 9*?5(-4� *-+� 4'(�
9*?5(-4� ,41()3� D*1� H�&&� ?(*61>� *//26+,-.� 42� +*4*� 3625� 4'(�
�*4,2-*)� �6*/4,4,2-(6� *4*� *-8�� �,:(� ?(*61� ,1� *-� *D30))?�
)2-.� 4,5(� 42� D*,4� 326� ?206� /*1(� 42� ;(� 6(12):(+>� (,4'(6� ;?��
1(44)(5(-4�26�46,*)��
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 17
�'(6(� *6(� *� -05;(6� 23� 3*/4261� 4'*4� (C9)*,-� 4'(� +06*4,2-� 23� *�
)*D10,4>� ;04� 4'(� 4D2�;,..(14� 6(*12-1� *6(�� ���� 4'(� ,-106(6�23� 4'(�
+(3(-+*-4�D*-41� 42� +6*.� 204� ),4,.*4,2-� *1� )2-.� *1� 9211,;)(� *-+�
D*,4�0-4,)�4'(�)*14�525(-4�;(326(�4'(?�'*:(�42�+(/,+(�D'(4'(6�42�
1(44)(�4'(�/*1(M�*-+��"��125(�/20-4,(1�'*:(�D*?�422�5*-?�/*1(1�
6()*4,:(�42�4'(�-05;(6�23�B0+.(1>�6(10)4,-.�,-�)2-.�+()*?1�,-�.(44,-.�
/*1(1�1/'(+0)(+�326�46,*)���20�5*?�*18�4'(�/2064�326�*�46,*)�+*4(�*-+�
6(/(,:(�*�+*4(�326�4'(�46,*)�4'*4�,1�*�?(*6�26�526(�+2D-�4'(�62*+�
�'(6(� ,1� 2-(� 1,59)(� *-1D(6� 42� 4',1� 962;)(5�� =)(� 4'(� )*D10,4�
*1�122-�*1� ,4� ,1�+(4(65,-(+�4'*4� 4'(�/*1(�'*1�5(6,4�*-+�5*8(�
106(� 4'*4� 4'(� /2064� ,5921(1� +(*+),-(1� 326� (:(6?� 14(9� 23� 4'(�
)*D10,4>�10/'�*1�19(/,=/�+*4(1� 326�+(921,4,2-1>�+(3(-1(�5(+,/*)�
(C*5,-*4,2-1� *-+� 4'(� (C/'*-.(� 23� +,1/2:(6?� 6(192-1(1���',1�
D,))�96(:(-4�4'(�)*D10,4�3625�4'(�,-(:,4*;)(�+()*?1�96(1(-4(+�;?�
+(3(-1(�*4426-(?1�*-+�4'(,6�,-106(61�*-+�8((9�4'(�/*1(�2-�4'(�
962:(6;,*)� 3*14�46*/8!�42�46,*)�
�((9�4',1�,-�5,-+��4'(�+(3(-1(�D,))�-24�1(44)(�?206�/*1(�0-4,)�?20�
.(4�42�46,*)���3�?20�4',-8�4'(�+(3(-1(�D,))�D*-4�42�1(44)(�*1�122-�*1�
?206�)*D10,4�,1�=)(+>�26�*34(6�4'(�+(921,4,2-1�'*:(�;((-�/259)(4(+>�
326.(4�,4O��26�4',1�6(*12->�?20�-((+�42�5*8(�106(�4'*4�?206�)*D?(61�
8((9�?206�/*1(�2-�4'(�3*14�46*/8�42�46,*)�*-+�32/01�2-�6(96(1(-4,-.�
?20�*4�4'(�46,*)I-24�1,59)?�1(44),-.�326�D'*4(:(6�4'(?�/*-�.(4�
18 John H. Fisher
� ������%�����������������������*���������#�����
�*-?� ���)*D�=651!�*//(94�'0-+6(+1�,3�-24�4'201*-+1�23�/*1(1>�
D,4'� 4'(� .2*)�23� 1(44),-.� 4'(� /*1(1� ,-� :(6?� ),44)(� 4,5(� *-+� 326� *�
5,-,5*)�105�23�52-(?���',1�1?14(5�,1�*�52-(?J5*8,-.�5*/',-(�
326�4'(� ���)*D�=651�!��'(� ���)*D�=651!�19(-+�),44)(�4,5(�*-+�
52-(?�2-�4'(,6�/*1(1�*-+�*1�*�6(10)4>� 4'(?�'*:(� ),44)(� 42� )21(� ,3�
4'(?�*6(�0-*;)(�42�1(44)(�*�/*1(���-�5*-?�/*1(1>�4'(� ���)*D�=65!�
D,))�1(44)(�?206�/*1(�326� 9(--,(1�2-�4'(�+2))*6>!�26�*�36*/4,2-�23�
4'(� 460(�D264'�23�?206�/*1(���)4,5*4()?>� ,3� 4'(� ��� )*D�=65!� ,1�
0-*;)(�42�1(44)(�*�/*1(>�4'(?�6(3(6�,4�42�*�),4,.*4,2-�)*D�=65�4'*4�,1�
(C9(6,(-/(+�;6,-.,-.�/*1(1�42�46,*)�*-+�5*C,5,N,-.�4'(�:*)0(�23�
4'(,6�/*1(1�
�'(� ),4,.*4,2-� )*D� =65� ,1� 3*6� +,33(6(-4� 3625� 4'(� ��� )*D� =65!�
,-� *� 5*B26� 6(19(/4�� ),4,.*4,2-� )*D� =651� .(-(6*))?� � ����� 52-(?�
,-� 4'(,6� /*1(1>� =-+,-.� 4'(� ;(14� (C9(64�D,4-(11(1� *-+� 96(9*6,-.�
+(52-146*4,:(�(C',;,41�*-+�/25904(6�*-,5*4,2-1�326�46,*)��
�3� ?20� D*-4� 42� =-+� 204� ,3� ?206� )*D?(6� /*6(1� *;204� ?206� /*1(>�
*18� ',5� 326� *� ),14� 23� 4'(� (C9(-1(1� �/*1(� (C9(-1(1� *6(� /*))(+�
+,1;061(5(-41!�>�4'*4�'(�'*1�,-/066(+�D',)(�'*-+),-.�?206�/*1(��
�4� 4'(�(-+�23� 4'(�/*1(>�?20�*6(�6(192-1,;)(� 42�6(,5;061(�?206�
)*D?(6�326�',1�(C9(-1(1>�*-+�4'(6(326(>�?20�*6(�(-4,4)(+�42�.(4�*-�
,4(5,N(+� ),14�23� /*1(�(C9(-1(1� 3625�?206� )*D?(6�D'(-(:(6>� *-+�
*1� 36(E0(-4)?>� *1� ?20�D*-4�� �3� 4'(� )*D?(6� 6(301(1� 42� .,:(� ?20�*-�
,4(5,N(+�),14�23�4'(�(C9(-1(1>�,4�,1�4,5(�42�=-+�*�-(D�)*D?(6�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 19
�3�?20�.(4�*-�,4(5,N(+�),14�23�4'(�)*D?(6�1�(C9(-1(1�2-�?206�/*1(>�
/'(/8�42�1((�'2D�5*-?�(C9(64�D,4-(11(1�4'(�)*D?(6�'*1�6(4*,-(+>�
*-+�4'(�52-(?�4'*4�'(�'*1�19(-4�2-�?206�/*1(���3�4'(�)*D?(6�'*1�
19(-4�*�:(6?�15*))�105�23�52-(?�2-�?206�/*1(>�26�4'(6(�*6(�)2-.�
9(6,2+1�23�4,5(�D'(6(�-2�52-(?�'*1�;((-�19(-4�2-�?206�/*1(�
�,�(�>�3206�52-4'1�26�)2-.(6�>�'(�,1�0-D,)),-.�42�,-:(14�,-�?206�/*1(�
*-+�?20�1'20)+�=-+�*�-(D�)*D?(6���20�D*-4�*�)*D?(6�D'2�,1�D,)),-.�
42�,-:(14�,-�?206�/*1(I4',1�5(*-1�4'*4�4'(�)*D?(6�),8(1�?206�/*1(�
*-+�;(),(:(1�?20�D,))�0)4,5*4()?�6(/2:(6�52-(?�4'*4�D,))�9*?�',5�
;*/8�,-�19*+(1�
����������������#���������������������
�20�+2O��206�)*D?(6�,1�1,59)?�*/4,-.�*1�?206�*.(-4�*-+�'(�/*--24�
326/(� ?20� 42� 1(44)(� ?206� /*1(�� �3� ?206� )*D?(6� ,1� 326/,-.� ?20� 42�
1(44)(>�?20�1'20)+�=-+�*-24'(6�)*D?(6�
��D*6-,-.�1,.-�4'*4�?20�5*?�-((+�*�-(D�)*D?(6�2//061�D'(-�4'(�
)*D?(6�*181�?20�42�9*?�326�4'(�/2141�23�?206�46,*)>�10/'�*1�4'(�/214�
23�*�5(+,/*)�(C9(64���',1�,1�*�6(+�S*.O��22+�)*D?(61�D,))�-24�*18�
?20�42�9*?�326�4'(�/2141�23�?206�/*1(�,-�*+:*-/(�� �3�4'(?�+2>�?20�
1'20)+�*18�4'(�)*D?(6�D'?�4'(?�D*-4�?20�42�9*?�326�4'(�/2141�23�
4'(�(C9(64�-2D>�;04�-(:(6�42)+�?20�4'*4�?20�D20)+�;(�6(192-1,;)(�
326�4'(�/2141�D'(-�?20�=614�5(4�D,4'�',5���4�,1�:(6?�),8()?�4'*4�?206�
)*D?(6�-2�)2-.(6�D*-41�42�'*-+)(�?206�/*1(��962;*;)?�;(/*01(�'(�
/20)+�-24�1(44)(�,4��*-+�'(�D*-41�?20�42�*//(94�*�15*))�1(44)(5(-4�
233(6�12�'(�/*-�52:(�2-�42�24'(6�/*1(1�
20 John H. Fisher
� ���������*����������#������#��������'(6(�*6(�4'6((� 3*/4261�� �*��1(:(6,4?�23� 4'(� ,-B06?��326�(C*59)(>�
4'(� )211� 23� *-� *65� ,1� 526(� 1,.-,=/*-4� 4'*-� *� 196*,-(+� D6,14�M�
�;��+06*4,2-�23�4'(� ,-B06?��*�9(65*-(-4>� ),3(J)2-.� ,-B06?� ,1�526(�
1,.-,=/*-4� 4'*-� *� 4(5926*6?� ,-B06?� 4'*4� 6(12):(1�M� *-+� �/�� 4'(�
/2-1(E0(-/(1�23�4'(�,-B06?>�10/'�*1�*�424*)�,-*;,),4?�42�D268�*-+�
9)*?�/259*6(+�42�*�9*64,*)�),5,4�23�?206�*;,),4?�42�D268�
�� 4*8(� ,-42� /2-1,+(6*4,2-� 4'(� (/2-25,/� )211(1>� 10/'� *1� )211� 23�
D*.(1�*-+�9*14�*-+�30406(�5(+,/*)�(C9(-1(1>�*-+�-2-J(/2-25,/�
)211(1���',)(�(/2-25,/�)211(1�/*-�;(�10;14*-4,*)>�9*64,/0)*6)?�D'(-�
*�;*;?�1033(61�9(65*-(-4� ,-B06,(1�*4�;,64'>� 4'(�5214�5(*-,-.30)�
)211�,1�4'(�/'*-.(�,-�E0*),4?�23�),3(����/',)+�1033(6,-.�3625�19*14,/�
E0*+6,9)(.,*� 3*/(1�*� ),3(� ,-�*�D'(()/'*,6� *-+�D,))�-(:(6�9)*?�;*))�
D,4'�',1�36,(-+1>�.2�42�*�9625�+06,-.�',.'�1/'22)>�26�D*)8�+2D-�
4'(�*,1)(�*4�*�D(++,-.���'(1(�*6(�4'(�6(*)�)211(1�
�'(� 5(+,*-� *-+� 5(*-� 5(+,/*)� 5*)96*/4,/(� 9*?5(-4� *520-41�
326�9'?1,/,*-1�,-�"@@F�D(6(�A�%�>@@@�*-+�A$��>#F�>�6(19(/4,:()?��
�(-(6*))?� 326�5*)96*/4,/(�9*?5(-4�+*4*� 4'(�5(+,*-� ,1� *�;(44(6�
,-+,/*426�23� 4'(� *:(6*.(!�26� 4?9,/*)�9*?5(-4� 4'*-� ,1� 4'(�5(*-�
1,-/(�4'(�5(*-�,1�18(D(+�;?�*�:(6?�3(D�)*6.(�9*?5(-41�
������������������������������%�#������������
�(+,/*6(� *-+��(+,/*,+�D,))� ),8()?� '*:(� 4'(,6� '*-+1�204� 326� 4'(,6�
52-(?�,3�?20�6(/2:(6�52-(?�,-�?206�/*1(��
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 21
?�3(+(6*)� )*D>��(+,/*6(�*-+��(+,/*,+�'*:(�*� ),(-�42�6(/2:(6�*-?�
(C9(-1(1� 4'(?� '*:(� 9*,+� 6()*4,-.� 42� 4'(� ,-B06,(1� 4'*4� ?20� 1014*,-�
*6,1,-.�3625�5*)96*/4,/(���',1�5(*-1�4'*4��(+,/*6(�*-+<26��(+,/*,+�
D,))�),8()?�D*-4�*�9,(/(�23�4'(�52-(?�4'*4�?20�6(/2:(6�,-�?206�)*D10,4�
,3�4'(?�'*:(�(C9(-+(+�52-(?�326�?206�5(+,/*)�(C9(-1(1�
�-14(*+�23�D*,4,-.�0-4,)�4'(�(-+�23�?206�/*1(�42�*++6(11�),(-1>�?206�
)*D?(6�1'20)+�D268�2-�=-+,-.�204�D'(4'(6�4'(6(�D,))�;(�*�),(-�*-+�
4'(�*520-4�23�4'(�),(-�(*6)?�,-�?206�/*1(���20�1'20)+�*18�?206�)*D?(6��
�6(�4'(6(�*-?�),(-1�*-+�,3�12>�'2D�50/'�*6(�4'(?7��20�D*-4�42�8-2D�
'2D�50/'�?20�D,))�'*:(�42�9*?��(+,/*6(�*-+��(+,/*,+�*4�4'(�(-+�23�
?206�/*1(���3�?206�)*D?(6�,1�0-*;)(�42�*-1D(6�4'(1(�E0(14,2-1>�?20��
1'20)+�;(�/2-/(6-(+�
�����������"��������������+������������#�*���
�206� ��� ��������� ,1� 4'(�2-)?� 4',-.� 4'*4� 460)?�5*44(61���206� -(4�
6(/2:(6?!�5(*-1�4'(�*520-4�23�52-(?�4'*4�.2(1�,-�?206�92/8(4�
*34(6�4'(�9*?5(-4�23�)(.*)�3((1>�(C9(-1(1>�*-+�),(-1���3�4'(�)*D?(61�
*-+�'(*)4'�,-106(61�.(4�9*,+�D,4'�),44)(�)(34�326�?20>�4'(�),4,.*4,2-�
'*1�3*,)(+�
�'(-�?206�)*D?(6�4())1�?20�*;204�*�1(44)(5(-4�233(6>�?20�1'20)+�
*18� ',5���'*4�D,))� ;(�5?� -(4� 6(/2:(6?!� ,3� �� *//(94� 4',1�233(67�
�20� 1'20)+� *18� 4'(� )*D?(6� 326� 4'(� *520-4�23� 4'(� �*�� )(.*)� 3((>�
�;��/*1(�(C9(-1(1>�*-+��/��*-?�),(-1�D',/'�5014�;(�9*,+�3625�4'(�
1(44)(5(-4�52-(?���34(6�+(+0/4,-.�4'(�)(.*)�3((>�/*1(�(C9(-1(1�*-+�
22 John H. Fisher
*-?�),(-1�3625�4'(�1(44)(5(-4�233(6>�?20�D,))�;(�*;)(�42�+(4(65,-(�
4'(�*520-4�23�?206�-(4�6(/2:(6?���'(�-(4�6(/2:(6?� ,1� 4'(�2-)?�
-05;(6� 4'*4� 1'20)+�5*44(6� 42� ?20>� 12�5*8(� 106(� ?206� )*D?(6�
962:,+(1�4'*4�=.06(�42�?20�D'(-(:(6�*�1(44)(5(-4�233(6�,1�5*+(�
�%�%�!������������'����%��������*�����������������#���"���������"���������������������#�����
�2O� �3� ?20� =6(� ?206� )*D?(6>� ?20� '*:(� 4'(� 6,.'4� 42� ,-1,14� 4'*4�
4'(� )*D?(6�962:,+(� ?20�D,4'� *-� ,4(5,N(+� ),14� 1'2D,-.� 4'(� )(.*)�
1(6:,/(1�9(63265(+�;?�4'(� )*D?(6�2-�?206�/*1(���'(-�?20�=6(�
4'(�)*D?(6>�?20�'*:(�4'(�6,.'4�42�+(4(65,-(�D'(4'(6�4'(�)*D?(6�
,1�9*,+�*//26+,-.�42�4'(�424*)�-05;(6�23�'2061�D268(+�2-�?206�
/*1(��4',1� ,1�/*))(+�4'(� 9(6�+,(5�6*4(!�>�26�*�9(6/(-4*.(�23�4'(�
)(.*)�3((�
�-�*)5214�(:(6?�/*1(>�4'(�3265(6�*4426-(?�D,))�,-1,14�4'*4�',1�D268�
6(10)4(+�,-�4'(�5214�,59264*-4�/2-46,;04,2-1�42�?206�/*1(�*-+�4'*4�
'(�,1�(-4,4)(+�42�*�)*6.(�9(6/(-4*.(�23�4'(�424*)�)(.*)�3((�*4�4'(�(-+�
23�?206�/*1(���20�'2)+�*))�23�4'(�/*6+1�D'(-�?20�=6(�?206�)*D?(6�*-+�
?20�1'20)+�,-1,14�4'*4�'(�962:,+(�4'(�,4(5,N(+�),14�23�)(.*)�1(6:,/(1�
4'*4�'(�9(63265(+�*-+�4'*4�?20�D*-4�42�9*?�4'(� 9(6�+,(5�6*4(!��
326�4'21(�1(6:,/(1�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 23
�%�%���������#���'����%��������������������
�4� +(9(-+1���'(� 6(4*,-(6� *.6((5(-4� 4'*4� ?20� 1,.-� D,))� 19(/,3?�
D'(4'(6� ?20� *6(� 6(192-1,;)(� 326� 6(,5;061,-.� ?206� )*D?(6� 326�
',1�(C9(-1(1�*4�4'(�(-+�23�4'(�/*1(���'(�6(4*,-(6�*.6((5(-4�5*?�
14*4(� 4'*4� ?20� *6(� 6(192-1,;)(� 42� 6(,5;061(� 4'(� )*D?(6� *4� 4'(�
(-+�23�4'(�/*1(�6(.*6+)(11�23�D'(4'(6�?20�D,-�26�)21(�?206�/*1(��
�',1� /20)+� ;(� +(:*14*4,-.� 326� ?20>� *1� 4'(� /*1(� (C9(-1(1� 234(-�
(C/((+�A�@>@@@>�*-+�?20�5*?�-24�;(�*;)(�42�*3326+�A�@@>�50/'�
)(11�A�@>@@@�
�214�/),(-41�1,59)?�1,.-�4'(�6(4*,-(6�*.6((5(-4�D,4'204�6(*+,-.�,4�
*-+�4'(-�)21(�4'(�6(4*,-(6�*.6((5(-4���20�1'20)+�8((9�*-�26,.,-*)>�
30))?�1,.-(+�6(4*,-(6�*.6((5(-4�,-�*�1*3(�)2/*4,2->�(�.�>�1*3(4?�+(921,4�
;2C>�4'620.'204�4'(�)*D10,4���4�4'(�(-+�23�4'(,6�/*1(>�/),(-41�*6(�
234(-�0-*D*6(�23�4'(�9(6/(-4*.(�23�4'(�)(.*)�3((��5214�*1105(�,4�
,1�2-(J4',6+�)(.*)�3((>�D',/'�,1�962',;,4(+�,-�5(+,/*)�5*)96*/4,/(�
/*1(1�,-��(D��268��*-+�4'(?�*6(�-24�*D*6(�23�'2D�4'(�)(.*)�3((�
,1�/*)/0)*4(+���'(�*-1D(61�42�4'(1(�E0(14,2-1�/*-�;(�320-+�,-�4'(�
6(4*,-(6�*.6((5(-4�
�20� 5014� 6(*+� 4'(� 6(4*,-(6� *.6((5(-4� :(6?� /*6(30))?���'(-�
?20� 6(*+� 4'(� 6(4*,-(6� *.6((5(-4>� 5*8(� 106(� 4'*4� 4'(� 6(4*,-(6�
*.6((5(-4�,1�/6?14*)�/)(*6�*1�42�D'(4'(6�?20�D,))�;(�6(192-1,;)(�
326�/*1(�(C9(-1(1�(:(-�,3�?20�+2�-24�D,-�?206�/*1(�
�4426-(?1� ,-��(D��268�*6(�(4',/*))?�9(65,44(+�42�14*4(� ,-�4'(�
6(4*,-(6�*.6((5(-4�4'*4�4'(�*4426-(?�D,))�*+:*-/(�4'(�(C9(-1(1�
23�4'(�/*1(�D,4'204�*-?�(C9(/4*4,2-�23�6(,5;061(5(-4�3625�4'(�
24 John H. Fisher
/),(-4�,-�4'(�(:(-4�4'(�/*1(�,1�)214���3�10/'�*�/)*01(�,1�/2-4*,-(+�
,-�?206�6(4*,-(6�*.6((5(-4>�?20�/*--24�;(�'()+�6(192-1,;)(�326�
4'(�/*1(�(C9(-1(1�,3�4'(�/*1(�,1�)214���3>�2-�4'(�24'(6�'*-+>�4'(�
6(4*,-(6�*.6((5(-4�962:,+(1�4'*4�?20�*6(�0)4,5*4()?�6(192-1,;)(�
326�4'(�/*1(�(C9(-1(1>�D,-�26�)21(>�4'(-�4'(�)*D?(6�/*-�*18�?20�
42�9*?�326�4'(�/2141�*4�4'(�(-+�23�4'(�46,*)>�(:(-�,3�?20�)21(�*-+�
'*:(�-2�52-(?��
�������������������������������������#�����,�������-���������������
(326(�?20�+2�*-?4',-.>�6(*+�4'(�6(4*,-(6�*.6((5(-4�/*6(30))?���3�
4'(�6(4*,-(6�*.6((5(-4�14*4(1�4'*4�?206�*4426-(?�5*?�*18�?20�42�
9*?�4'(�(C9(-1(1�23�4'(�46,*)>�4'(-�4'(�*4426-(?�/*-�*18�?20�42�9*?�
4'(�/2141�23�5(+,/*)�(C9(641�*-+�24'(6�/2141�23�4'(�46,*)��
�3� 4'(� 6(4*,-(6� *.6((5(-4� +2(1� -24� 14*4(� 4'*4� ?20� 5*?� ;(�
6(192-1,;)(�42�9*?�� ����� ���4'(�/2141�23�4'(�46,*)>�4'(�*4426-(?�
/*--24�*18�?20�42�9*?�4'(�;,))��
��������������������)�����������������#��������'(6(�5,.'4�;(�*�.22+�6(*12-�� �3� 4'(� )*D?(6� ,1�;01?� ,-� 46,*)�2-�
*-24'(6�/*1(>�?20�D*-4�4'(�)*D?(6�42�;(�/259)(4()?�32/01(+�2-�
4'*4�/*1(>�*-+�'(�1'20)+�-24�;(�6(406-,-.�9'2-(�5(11*.(1�+06,-.�
4'(�46,*)�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 25
�0..(14,2-���3�?20�*6(�'*:,-.�4620;)(�.(44,-.�?206�)*D?(6�42�6(406-�
?206�9'2-(�5(11*.(1>�*18�326�*-�*992,-45(-4�42�5((4�D,4'�?206�
)*D?(6�3*/(�42�3*/(�*4�',1�23=/(���22+�)*D?(61�010*))?�5((4�D,4'�
4'(,6�/),(-41>�26�*4�)(*14�19(*8�2:(6�4'(�9'2-(�D,4'�4'(,6�/),(-41>�*4�
)(*14�2-/(�(:(6?�4D2�26�4'6((�52-4'1�42�.(4�09+*4(1�*;204�4'(,6�
/),(-4�1�5(+,/*)� 46(*45(-4�� �3�?206� )*D?(6� ,1�-24�D,)),-.� 42�5((4�
D,4'�?20>�?20�1'20)+�=-+�*�-(D�)*D?(6�
�4�4'(�5((4,-.�D,4'�?206�)*D?(6>�*18�',5�42�.,:(�?20�*-�09+*4(�
*;204�(:(6?4',-.�4'*4�'(�'*1�+2-(�D,4'�?206�=)(�1,-/(�?20�)*14�
1928(���20�5*?�D*-4� 42� *18���*:(� +(921,4,2-1� ;((-� 1/'(+0)(+�
*-+�,3�12>�D'(-�D,))�4'(?�;(�'()+7��*:(�*))�+,1/2:(6?�+(5*-+1�*-+�
6(192-1(1�;((-�(C/'*-.(+�*52-.�4'(�*4426-(?17��'(-�D,))�?20�
=)(�*�-24(�23�,110(�6(E0(14,-.�*�46,*)�+*4(7��3�4'(�)*D?(6�+2(1�-24�
.,:(�/)(*6�*-1D(61�42�4'(1(�E0(14,2-1>�?20�-((+�42�=-+�204�D'?�
;(/*01(�,4�5*?�;(�4,5(�42�=-+�*�-(D�)*D?(6�
�20�1'20)+�*18�?206�)*D?(6�42�962:,+(�?20�D,4'�*))�23�4'(�+,1/2:(6?�
6(192-1(1� *-+� +(5*-+1� 4'*4� '*:(� ;((-� (C/'*-.(+� *52-.� 4'(�
)*D?(61���20� *6(� (-4,4)(+� 42� 4'(1(� +2/05(-41>� *-+� 4'(� )*D?(6�
1'20)+�;(�.6*4(30)� 4'*4�?20�D*-4� 42�8-2D�*1�50/'�*1�9211,;)(�
*;204�?206�/*1(����D())J,-3265(+�/),(-4�'*1�3*6�3(D(6�-((+1�*-+�
9)*/(1�3(D(6�+(5*-+1�092-�4'(�)*D?(6�
���������������������������%���#�*����
�-� 4'(� :*14�5*B26,4?� 23� /*1(1>� 9(612-1�D'2� 10++(-)?� 6(/(,:(� *�
10;14*-4,*)�105�23�52-(?>�+2�(C*/4)?�4'(�1*5(�4',-.��4'(?�.2�2-�*�
26 John H. Fisher
19(-+,-.�196((�*-+�'*:(�-24',-.�D,4',-�*�?(*6>�.,:(�26�4*8(�*�3(D�
52-4'1���3�/2061(>�-2�2-(�4',-81�4',1�D,))�'*99(-�42�4'(5���2D�
5*-?�4,5(1�'*:(���'(*6+>� ��5�-24�4'*4�8,-+�23�9(612-!>�26� �'*4�
D2-�4�'*99(-�42�5(�!��())>�.0(11�*.*,->�,4�D,))�'*99(-�42�?20�
�*-?� )*D?(61�D,))� 1,59)?� '*-+� ?20� *� /'(/8�D'(-� ?206� /*1(� ,1�
2:(6�*-+�1(-+�?20�2-�?206�D*?���',1�,1�*�.6211�+,11(6:,/(�42�?20�
,-�5214� /*1(1>�;(/*01(� 4'(�:*14�5*B26,4?�23�5?�/),(-41�'*:(�-2�
=-*-/,*)�129',14,/*4,2-�*-+�4'(�2-)?�4',-.�4'(?�4',-8�42�+2�D,4'�
4'(,6�52-(?� ,1� 19(-+� ,4���3� /2061(>� 4'(�52-(?�;()2-.1� 42� ?20�
*-+�?20�*6(�4'(�2-)?�9(612-�D'2�/*-�+(/,+(�'2D�*-+�D'(-�4'(�
52-(?�,1�,-:(14(+�26�19(-4�
�
�?�.2*)�326�5?�/),(-41�,1�:(6?�1,59)(�2-/(�4'(?�6(/2:(6�52-(?�
3625� 4'(,6� )*D10,4� *-+� /*-� ;(� +(=-(+� D,4'� 4'6((� D26+1��
�������������������������?� B2;� ,1�42�5*8(�106(�4'*4�5?�
/),(-41� '2)+� 2-42� 4'(,6� 52-(?� *-+� '*:(� 4'(� ;(-(=41� 23� 4'(,6�
1(44)(5(-4� 2:(6� 4'(� /2061(� 23� 4'(,6� ),3(4,5(���',1� ,1� (19(/,*))?�
,59264*-4�326�+,1*;)(+�/),(-41>�D'2�D,))�-((+�*�14(*+?�146(*5�23�
,-/25(�42�9*?�326�'201('2)+�(C9(-1(1>�19(-+,-.�52-(?>�5(+,/*)�
;,))1�*-+�106.(6,(1��
�26�##L�23�/),(-41>� ,4� ,1�-24�(-20.'�42�1,59)?�9)*/(�4'(,6� 30-+1�
,-� *� 1*:,-.� *//20-4� *4� *� ;*-8���'(� 4(594*4,2-� ,1� B014� 422� .6(*4�
42� 4*8(� 4'*4� +6(*5� :*/*4,2-� 42� K*5*,/*>� 26� 906/'*1(� 4'(� -(D�
�(6/(+(1J(-N���'(�30-+1�5014�;(�1(/06(+�D'(6(�4'(?�*6(�1*3(�
3625�/6(+,4261>�;04�526(�,59264*-4)?>�1*3(�3625�4'(�4(594*4,2-�23�
4'(�/),(-4�42�6*,+�4'(5�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 27
�'(�*-1D(6�326�5*-?�23�5?�/),(-41�,1�*�1460/406(+�1(44)(5(-4�4'*4�
9)*/(1�4'(�30-+1�,-�*�)2-.J4(65�46014�26�*--0,4?�4'*4�D,))�962:,+(�
*�146(*5�23�52-4')?�,-/25(�*1�)2-.�*1�4'(�+,1*;)(+�/),(-4�,1�*),:(��
�0/'� 30-+1� *6(�-24� 10;B(/4� 42�S0/40*4,2-1� ,-� 4'(� 142/8�5*68(4�
*-+�962:,+(�*-�*1106*-/(�42�4'(�/),(-4�4'*4�'(�D,))�-(:(6�60-�204�
23�52-(?����1460/406(+�1(44)(5(-4�D,4'�*�46014�26�*--0,4?�,1�4'(�
1*3(14�*-+�;(14�D*?�42�(-106(�4'*4�5?�/),(-41�.2�42�;(+�*4�-,.'4�
8-2D,-.�4'*4�4'(,6�30-+1�D,))�-24�;(�.2-(�4252662D��
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 29
���� ������+-
��*����5��������*������� �������:��������5�������5;
�-106*-/(�/259*-,(1�29(6*4(�0-+(6�4'6((�;*1,/�96,-/,9)(1��(���'�
(���������(�������-/(�?20�*//(94�4',1� 3*/4>�?20�D,))�;(.,-�
42�0-+(614*-+�'2D�4'(�,-106*-/(�/259*-?�D,))�'*-+)(�?206�/*1(�
.����/0�������%������#��$������+�����
2/4261� *-+� '219,4*)1� *)5214� -(:(6� *+5,4� 3*0)4>� (:(-� ,-� 4'(�
5214�2;:,201�5(+,/*)�(66261���4�,1�(C46(5()?�6*6(�4'*4�*�+2/426�
26� '219,4*)�D,))� *+5,4� 3*0)4� *-+�233(6� 42� 6(12):(� ?206� /*1(���20�
D,))�D,-�5,)),2-1�,-�4'(�)244(6?�;(326(�*�9'?1,/,*-�D,))�*+5,4�42�*�
5(+,/*)�(6626��
�'(�+2/4261�*-+�'219,4*)1�,-�5*)96*/4,/(�)*D10,41�234(-�/2-19,6(�
-24� 42� ;)*5(� (*/'� 24'(6�� �0/'� 96,:*4(� *.6((5(-41� *52-.�
4'(� +2/4261� D,))� ;(� /2-/(*)(+� 3625� ?20�� �2D(:(6>� ,4� ,1� *� 1*3(�
*110594,2-� 4'*4� (:(-�;(326(� ?20�=)(� ?206� )*D10,4>� 4'(�+2/4261�
*-+�4'(,6�)*D?(61�*6(�5((4,-.�,-�96,:*4(�42�*.6((�092-�*�146*4(.?�
326�+(3(*4,-.�?206�/*1(�
&�� � �"� �25(� +2/4261� D,))� *)4(6� 4'(� 5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1� D,4'�
-24*4,2-1�8-2D-�,-�4'(�5(+,/*)�=()+�*1� ���>!�5(*-,-.� �2:(6�
�206��11�!��0/'�����-24*4,2-1�,-�4'(�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�/2552-)?�
;)*5(� 4'(� 9*4,(-4� 326� (:(6?4',-.� 4'*4� '*99(-(+>� ,�(�>� 9*4,(-4�
30 John H. Fisher
6(301(+�*+:,/(�42�.2�42��5(6.(-/?��225>!�26� 9*4,(-4�6(301(1�42�
4*8(�5(+,/*4,2-�!�
�',)(�10/'�����-24*4,2-1�5*?�;(�)(.,4,5*4(�,-�125(�/*1(1>�4'(?�
*6(�234(-�*++(+�42�4'(�9*4,(-4�1�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�,55(+,*4()?�*34(6�
4'(�9*4,(-4� ;6,-.1� *�5*)96*/4,/(� )*D10,4>� 26�D'(-� 4'(�9'?1,/,*-�
;(),(:(1�4'*4�*�)*D10,4�,1�),8()?�326�4'(,6�5(+,/*)�(6626�
�6(1(6:,-.� 4'(�5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1� *-+�+(4(/4,-.� 4'(� *)4(6*4,2-�23�
5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1� ;?� +2/4261� *-+� -061(1� ,1� /60/,*)���'(�5(+,/*)�
6(/26+1�5014�;(�2;4*,-(+�6,.'4�*D*?� 3625�*))�23� 4'(�9'?1,/,*-1�
*-+�'219,4*)1�D'(6(�4'(�9*4,(-4�6(/(,:(+�5(+,/*)�46(*45(-4���-/(�
4'(�)*D10,4�14*641>�4'(�),8(),'22+�4'*4�4'(�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�D,))�;(�
*)4(6(+�42�;)*5(�4'(�9*4,(-4�,-/6(*1(1�
.����/1�������%������#��$������+�����
�'(�,-106*-/(�/259*-?�D,))�46?�42�+()*?�?206�/*1(�*4�(:(6?�2992640-,4?���',1�,1�D'?�,4�234(-�4*8(1�526(�4'*-�4D2�?(*61�3625�4'(�;(.,--,-.�23�4'(�)*D10,4�0-4,)�,41�/2-/)01,2-�
����� ��� ��� � � ���� �������,4'� :(6?� ),5,4(+� (C/(94,2-1� 10/'� *1�
D62-.30)�+(*4'�*/4,2-1>�+2/4261�*-+�'219,4*)1�+2�-24�9*?�,-4(6(14�
2-� 52-(?� 962:,+(+� 42� *� 9*4,(-4� ,-� *� 1(44)(5(-4� 26� :(6+,/4��
�',1� 5(*-1� 4'*4� +2/4261� *-+� '219,4*)1� '*:(� (:(6?� ,-/(-4,:(�
42� *+B206-� *-+� +()*?� ?206� /*1(� 0-4,)� ,4� ,1� 1,59)?� ,59211,;)(� 42��
+()*?�3064'(6�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 31
�:(-�+*?1�;(326(�?206�)2-.J*D*,4(+�46,*)>�4'(�,-106*-/(�/259*-?�
234(-�1((81�42�921492-(�4'(�46,*)�,3�,4�;(),(:(1�?20�*6(�0-D,)),-.�
42�1(44)(�2-�,41�4(651���:(6?�(C/01(�,5*.,-*;)(�D,))�;(�233(6(+�42�
4'(� B0+.(�42�*+B206-�?206�46,*)���'(�2-)?�6(192-1(�42�4'(�+()*?�
146*4(.?� 23� 4'(� ,-106*-/(� /259*-,(1� ,1� 42� 96(11� ?206� /*1(� *1�
*..6(11,:()?�*-+�*1�E0,/8)?�*1�9211,;)(���'*4�,1�D'?�4'(�1()(/4,2-�
23�4'(�6,.'4�)*D?(6�,1�4'(�5214�/6,4,/*)�4',-.�?20�+2�
.����/2�������%������#��$������+������
�'(� ,-106*-/(� /259*-?�D,))� 46?� 42�;)*5(� 4'(�9*4,(-4� 326�D'*4�
'*99(-(+�� �3�?20�+,+�-24�4*8(�4'(�96(1/6,;(+�5(+,/*4,2-�*4� 4'(�
6,.'4�525(-4>�?20�*6(�12)()?�42�;)*5(�326�(:(6?4',-.�4'*4�'*99(-1�
42�?20�
�'(-�4'(�,-106*-/(�)*D?(61�5((4�42�+,1/011�?206�/*1(>�4'(�=614�
4'20.'4�,-�4'(,6�/2))(/4,:(�'(*+1�,1���2D�/*-�D(�;)*5(�4'(�9*4,(-4�
326�D'*4�'*99(-(+7��4�,1�*)5214�*)D*?1�4'(�/*1(�4'*4�4'(�5(+,/*)�
6(/26+1�D,))�1'2D�*�5,11(+�*992,-45(-4�26�*�-24*4,2-�4'*4�4'(�
9*4,(-4�1'20)+�'*:(�*�32))2D�09�*992,-45(-4�,-�2-(�42�4D2�+*?1�
*34(6�*-��5(6.(-/?��225�:,1,4�
�'(� 5214� /2552-� *-+� ),8()?� +(3(-1(� ,-� 5*)96*/4,/(� ),4,.*4,2-�
,1� 4'*4� 4'(� 9*4,(-4� 3*,)(+� 42� 32))2D� 4'(� *+:,/(� *-+<26� +,1/'*6.(�
,-1460/4,2-1�.,:(-�;?�4'(�+2/426���5(6.(-/?��225�9*4,(-41�*6(�
6204,-()?�6(E0,6(+�42�1,.-�+,1/'*6.(� ,-1460/4,2-1�4'*4�14*4(�4'*4�
4'(?� *6(� 42� 32))2D�09�D,4'� 4'(,6� 96,5*6?� /*6(� +2/426�D,4',-� *�
2-(�42�4D2�+*?1���'(1(�;2,)(69)*4(�32651�*6(�6(E0,6(+�326�(:(6?�
32 John H. Fisher
�5(6.(-/?��225�9*4,(-4�*-+�4'(�-061(1�6*6()?�6(*+�4'(�+,1/'*6.(�
,-1460/4,2-1�42�4'(�9*4,(-41�
5(6.(-/?�5(+,/,-(�9'?1,/,*-1�234(-�;)*5(�4'(,6�9*4,(-41�326�3*,),-.�
42� 1((8� 32))2DJ09� 46(*45(-4�D,4'� 4'(,6� 96,5*6?� /*6(� 9'?1,/,*-�
*34(6� *-� ��� :,1,4� 42� *� '219,4*)���'(� +,1/'*6.(� ,-1460/4,2-1� D,))�
/2-4*,-�14*-+*6+�)*-.0*.(�14*4,-.��
����J����������'(�9'?1,/,*-�;()2D�D,))�;(�
962:,+,-.� 32))2DJ09� /*6(� 326� ?20�� �4�1� ,59264*-4�
4'*4� ?20� 1((� ',5� *1� ,-1460/4(+�� �3� 4'(6(� ,1� *-?�
962;)(5>� 9)(*1(� /2-4*/4� 01�� ��<"� �����"�
=����� ����� !�<� ���<��� ��� ���$� =�"� "�>
�?�'�$����$� ��'�""� (� �*))� 4'(� -05;(6�
;()2D�326�*-�*992,-45(-4�
�4�46,*)>�4'(�(5(6.(-/?�5(+,/,-(�9'?1,/,*-�D,))�1((8�42�9)*/(�*))�
23� 4'(�;)*5(�2-�4'(�9*4,(-4� 326� 3*,),-.� 42� 32))2D�4'(� 32))2DJ09�
/*6(!�9)*-�4'*4�'(<1'(� (C9)*,-(+�,-�.6(*4�+(4*,)�42�4'(�9*4,(-4!��
�3�/2061(>�D'*4�4'(�9'?1,/,*-�D,))�-24�5(-4,2-�,1�4'*4�(C*/4)?�4'(�
1*5(� )*-.0*.(� ,1� /2-4*,-(+� ,-� 4'(� +,1/'*6.(� ,-1460/4,2-1� .,:(-�
42�(:(6?�9*4,(-4�*4�4'(�'219,4*)���:(-�,3�?20�:,1,4�4'(��5(6.(-/?�
(9*645(-4� 326� *� 6204,-(� /2)+>� 4'(� +,1/'*6.(� ,-1460/4,2-1�
D,))� ),8()?�D*6-�?20�4'*4� ?206�+2/426� 3(()1� 4'*4�?20�1'20)+�;(�
1((-� 326�6(J(C*5,-*4,2-�4252662D!���'(�+,1/'*6.(� ,-1460/4,2-1�
*6(� 4'(�T�� /*6+� 9)*?(+� ;?� 4'(� +(3(-1(� ,-� *44(594,-.� 42� ;)*5(��
4'(�9*4,(-4�
�'(� 1(/2-+� 5214� /2552-� +(3(-1(� ,-� 5(+,/*)� 5*)96*/4,/(�
),4,.*4,2-� ,1� 4'*4� 4'(� 9*4,(-4�1� ;*+� 204/25(� D*1� *� 8-2D-� *-+�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 33
0-*:2,+*;)(� /259),/*4,2-� 26� 6,18� 23� 4'(� 46(*45(-4�� (326(� *-�
29(6*4,2->�9*4,(-41�*6(�*18(+�42�1,.-�.(-(6*)�/2-1(-4�32651�4'*4�
),14�4'(�6,181�*-+�/259),/*4,2-1�23�4'(�29(6*4,2-�D,4'�:(6?�.(-(6*)�
)*-.0*.(�� �26� (C*59)(>� *� .(-(6*)� /2-1(-4� 3265� *4� 4'(��);*-?�
�(+,/*)��(-4(6��219,4*)�14*4(1>�,-�9*64�
�� 0-+(614*-+� 4'*4� -2� *1106*-/(� /*-� ;(� 5*+(�
/2-/(6-,-.� 4'(� 6(10)41� 26� 204/25(� 23� *-?�
(C*5,-*4,2-� 26� 46(*45(-4�� �� 6(/2.-,N(� 4'*4� -2�
(C9)*-*4,2-� 23� (C*5,-*4,2-� 26� 46(*45(-4� /*-�
;(�(C'*014,:(>�*-+�4'(6(�5*?�;(�24'(6�6,181�*-+�
/259),/*4,2-1����'*:(�'*+�'*+�4'(�2992640-,4?�42�
*18�E0(14,2-1>�*-+�E0(14,2-1�'*:(�;((-�*-1D(6(+�
42�5?�1*4,13*/4,2-�� ��5*?�6(E0(14�526(�+(4*,)(+�
,-3265*4,2-�26�(C9)*-*4,2-1�*4�*-?�4,5(�
�'(�.(-(6*)�/2-1(-4�32651�234(-�),14� +(*4'!�*1�2-(�23�4'(�6,181�
26� /259),/*4,2-1� 23� *-� 29(6*4,2->� (:(-� ,-� 4'21(� 29(6*4,2-1�
/2-1,+(6(+�6204,-(�26�5,-26���26�(C*59)(>�4'(� ,-3265(+�/2-1(-4�
326�*-(14'(1,*!�*4�4'(��);*-?��(+,/*)��(-4(6��219,4*)�14*4(1�4'*4�
4'(�6,181�23�*-(14'(1,*�*6(�4'(�32))2D,-.��
������� �� 0-+(614*-+� 4'*4� 4'(� *+5,-,146*4,2-� 23�
*-(14'(1,*�,-:2):(1�+60.1�*-+�962/(+06(1�D',/'�
*6(�924(-4,*))?�'*6530)����'���<��$��������=�
���� @�������� "��#�� �$�� ��'@�������$��
�"���R9(65*-(-4�26�4(5926*6?�-05;-(11�*-+<
26�9*6*)?1,1>�14628(R/25*�26�+(*4'R�
34 John H. Fisher
�'(� +(3(-1(� )*D?(61� 6()?� '(*:,)?� 2-� 4'(� ,-3265(+� /2-1(-4!�
+2/05(-41� 1,.-(+�;?�9*4,(-41� ,-� *6.0,-.� 4'*4� 4'(� 6,18�23� *� ;*+�
204/25(�D*1�(C9)*,-(+�42�4'(�9*4,(-4�*-+�4'(�9*4,(-4�*//(94(+�
4'(�6,18�23�0-42D*6+�/2-1(E0(-/(1���',1�,1�*�36(E0(-4�*-+�/2552-�
+(3(-1(�,-�5(+,/*)�5*)96*/4,/(�),4,.*4,2->�9*64,/0)*6)?�D'(-�4'(6(�
,1�*�;*+�204/25(�32))2D,-.�*-�29(6*4,2-��
�������"�����������������������
�-� /*1(1� ,-:2):,-.� 2;:,201� *-+� /)(*6� 5(+,/*)� 5*)96*/4,/(>�
/),(-41�234(-�4',-8�4'(�+(3(-+*-4�9'?1,/,*-�D,))�*+5,4�3*0)4�*-+�
4'(�5*)96*/4,/(� ,-106*-/(� /*66,(6�D,))�D*-4� 42� 1(44)(� 4'(� /*1(�
,-�4'(�(*6)?�14*.(�23� 4'(� )*D10,4>�26�(:(-�;(326(�4'(� )*D10,4� ,1��
=)(+�������O
�:(-�,-�4'(�/*1(1�23�.6211�*-+�2;:,201�5*)96*/4,/(>�4'(�,-106*-/(�
/*66,(6�D,))� *)5214�-(:(6� 1(44)(� (*6)?� ,-� 4'(� )*D10,4� *-+� ,-� 3*/4>�
4'(� ,-106*-/(�/*66,(6�D,))�*)5214�*)D*?1�D*,4�0-4,)� 4'(�:(6?� )*14�
525(-4� 42�5*8(� *� 1(44)(5(-4� 233(6���'(� =614� 1(44)(5(-4� 233(6�
5*?�/25(�*�+*?�;(326(�46,*)>�+06,-.�4'(�46,*)�26�(:(-�525(-41�
;(326(�4'(�B06?�6(-+(61�,41�:(6+,/4���'?7
�'(�E0(14,2-�,1�1,59)(��,-��(D��268>�4'(�+(3(-+*-4��9'?1,/,*-�26�
'219,4*)��9*?1�-2�,-4(6(14�0-4,)�4'(�K0+.5(-4�,1�6(-+(6(+�;?�4'(�
/2064�D,4'� 4'(� (C/(94,2-�23� )*D10,41� ;*1(+�2-�D62-.30)� +(*4'��
�',1� 5(*-1� 4'*4� 4'(� 5*)96*/4,/(� ,-106*-/(� /*66,(6� '*1� (:(6?�
,-/(-4,:(� 42�+()*?� 1(44)(5(-4�-(.24,*4,2-1�0-4,)� ,4�'*1�-2�24'(6�
D*?�42�921492-(�4'(�/*1(���'(�,-106*-/(�/*66,(6�/*-�+()*?�9*?,-.�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 35
4'(�,-B06(+�:,/4,5�0-4,)�*�K0+.5(-4�,1�6(-+(6(+�;?�4'(�/2064�*34(6�
4'(�46,*)>�D',/'�5*?�;(�?(*61�*34(6�4'(�)*D10,4�,1�=)(+���'(�,-106*-/(�
/*66,(6�/*-�1*:(�924(-4,*))?�'0-+6(+1�23�4'201*-+1�23�+2))*61>�26�
526(>�1,59)?�;?�'2)+,-.�204�0-4,)�4'(�)*14�9211,;)(�525(-4�
�'(�,-106*-/(�/*66,(61�D*-4�42�'2)+�2-42�4'(,6�52-(?�0-4,)�4'(?�
'*:(�-2�24'(6�/'2,/(�*-+�*�B06?�326/(1�4'(5�42�9*64�D,4'�,4���26�
4',1� 6(*12->� 5*)96*/4,/(� ,-106*-/(� /*66,(61� *)5214� -(:(6� 5*8(�
1(44)(5(-4� 233(61� (*6)?� ,-� *� )*D10,4� *-+� 234(-� +2� -24�5*8(� *-�
233(6�0-4,)�4'(�:(6.(�23�46,*)�26�)*4(6��
�
�
��
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 37
���� ������+.
��������5����*5������� �����3�*����*�������
�*:(�?20�(:(6�D2-+(6(+���*1�5?�+2/426�;((-�+,1/,9),-(+�;?�*�
14*4(�5(+,/*)�;2*6+7��'(6(�+,+�5?�+2/426�.2�42�5(+,/*)�1/'22)7�
�'*4� ,1� 5?� +2/426�1� 5(+,/*)� (+0/*4,2-7� �1� 5?� +2/426� ;2*6+�
/(64,=(+7��*1�5?�+2/426�1�),/(-1(�26�'219,4*)�96,:,)(.(1�(:(6�;((-�
1019(-+(+>�),5,4(+�26�6(:28(+7�
�'*4�?20�+2-�4�8-2D�/*-�8,))�?20���4�1�?206�B2;�42�=-+�204�D'2�
4'(�;*+�+2/4261�*6(>�*-+�5*8(�106(�4'*4�?20�.2�42�*�.22+�2-(�
�'(� 5*)96*/4,/(� +*4*� 3625� 4'(� �*4,2-*)� �6*/4,4,2-(6� *4*�
*-8� 1'2D1� 4'*4� H>#@H� +2/4261� (*/'� 5*+(� 4'6((� 26� 526(�
�(D� �268� 5*)96*/4,/(� 9*?5(-41� 3625� �##"� 42� "@@&� 326�
*� 424*)� 23� A��"� ;,)),2-���'*4�5(*-1� 4'*4� )(11� 4'*-� %� 9(6/(-4� 23�
125(� F">"%@� �(D��268� +2/4261� *//20-4(+� 326� '*)3� 4'(� 424*)��
5*)96*/4,/(�*520-4�
*4*� 3625� 4'(� �*4,2-*)� �6*/4,4,2-(6� *4*� *-8� ,-+,/*4(� 4'*4�
B014� F� 9(6/(-4� 23� +2/4261� *6(� 6(192-1,;)(� 326� �&� 9(6/(-4� 23�
*))� -(.),.(-/(� /)*,51�� � �'(� �6(*4� �(+,/*)� �*)96*/4,/(� �2*C��
�*4,2-*)��6*/4,4,2-(6� *4*�*-8� *4*��2-4,-0(�42��'2D��(+,/*)�
,*;,),4?� �?14(5� �62+0/(1� �*4,2-*)� �04/25(1>!� '!���� (���)� >�
K*-0*6?>�"@@%���&"�9(6/(-4�23�+2/4261�'*:(�-(:(6�'*+�*�5(+,/*)�
5*)96*/4,/(�9*?5(-4�
38 John H. Fisher
�2))2D,-.�*6(�3206�1(/6(41�4'*4�?206�+2/426�D,))�',+(�3625�?20���4�1�09�42�?20�42�.(4�4',1�,-3265*4,2-�
3�#���/0+�%��������#���������������#���!�������������#������#����'�������������������&
�3� *� +2/426� ,1� ;2*6+� /(64,=(+>� 4',1� 5(*-1� 4'*4� '(� 26� 1'(�
'*1� .6*+0*4(+� 3625� 5(+,/*)� 1/'22)>� /259)(4(+� 6(1,+(-/?�
�46*,-,-.� ,-� *� '219,4*)�>� 46*,-(+�0-+(6� 109(6:,1,2-� ,-� *� 19(/,*)4?>�
*-+� 9*11(+� *� -*4,2-*)� (C*5,-*4,2-� .,:(-� ;?� *� 5(+,/*)�
19(/,*)4?� ;2*6+�� �'(� �5(6,/*-� 2*6+� 23� �(+,/*)� �9(/,*),141�
� ���!�� *11,141� "H� *9962:(+� 5(+,/*)� 19(/,*)4?� ;2*6+1� ,-�
4'(� +(:()295(-4� *-+� 01(� 23� 14*-+*6+1� ,-� 4'(� (:*)0*4,2-� *-+��
/(64,=/*4,2-�23�9'?1,/,*-1�
2*6+�/(64,=/*4,2-�,1�*�-*4,2-D,+(�4(14,-.�962/(11�4'*4�6(E0,6(1�
9'?1,/,*-1�42�9*11�*-�26*)�*-+�D6,44(-�4(14M�4',1�4(14�(-106(1�4'*4�
?206�+2/426�'*1�4'(�;*1,/>�5,-,505�/259(4(-/(�,-�',1�5(+,/*)�
19(/,*)4?�� �3� ?206� +2/426� ,1� -24� ;2*6+� /(64,=(+� ,-� ',1� 5(+,/*)�
19(/,*)4?>�?20�1'20)+�;(�:(6?�)((6?�*;204�01,-.�',5�*1�?206�+2/426��
�*-?� '219,4*)1�D,))� -24� ,110(� *+5,44,-.� 96,:,)(.(1� 42� 9'?1,/,*-1�
D'2� *6(� -24� ;2*6+� /(64,=(+� ,-� 4'(,6� 5(+,/*)� 19(/,*)4?�� �3� ?206�
9'?1,/,*-�,1�-24�;2*6+�/(64,=(+�,-�*�5(+,/*)�19(/,*)4?>�4',1�,1�*�;*+�
1,.-�*-+�?20�1'20)+�=-+�*�-(D�+2/426�
�2�=-+�204�,3�?206�+2/426�,1�;2*6+�/(64,=(+>�/2-4*/4�4'(��5(6,/*-�
2*6+�23��(+,/*)��9(/,*)4,(1��(64,=/*4,2-��(6,=/*4,2-��(6:,/(�*4�
�J&FFJ"%�J""F%���'(�23=/,*)�����+,6(/426?�23�2*6+��(64,=(+�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 39
�(+,/*)��9(/,*),141�),141�+2/4261��-*5(1�*)2-.�D,4'�4'(,6�19(/,*)4,(1�
*-+�4'(,6�(+0/*4,2-*)�;*/8.620-+1������233(61�4',1�,-3265*4,2-�
*4� DDD�*;51�26.� �/),/8� �'2�1� �(64,=(+!�>� 26� /*))� 42))J36((� *4�
&FFJ���J���>�42�1((�,3�?206�9'?1,/,*-�,1�;2*6+�/(64,=(+�
�3�?20�'*:(�+20;41�*;204�?206�'(*)4'�/*6(�962:,+(6>�?20�1'20)+�
5*8(�106(�'(<1'(�'*1�*�:*),+��(D��268��4*4(�),/(-1(>�*-+�'*1�-24�
'*+�',1<� '(6� ),/(-1(� 6(:28(+�26� 1019(-+(+�+0(� 42�9623(11,2-*)�
5,1/2-+0/4���'(��3=/(�23�4'(��623(11,2-1�23�4'(��(D��268��4*4(�
�+0/*4,2-� (9*645(-4� ),/(-1(1� H&� 9623(11,2-*)1� ,-� �(D��268�
6*-.,-.� 3625� 9'?1,/,*-1>� +(-4,141>� 12/,*)�D268(61>�5,+D,:(1>� *-+�
9'*65*/,141���2�:(6,3?�?206�'(*)4'�/*6(�962:,+(6�1�),/(-1(�.2�42�4'(�
23=/(�23� 4'(�9623(11,2-1�D(;1,4(�DDD�29�-?1(+�.2:� 42�/2-=65�
',1<'(6�14*401���(D��268�),/(-1(�9623(11,2-*)1>�10/'�*1�9'?1,/,*-1>�
*-+�5,+D,:(1>�5014�+,19)*?�*�/066(-4����6(.,146*4,2-�/(64,=/*4(�
,-�4'(,6�23=/(�4'*4�),141�4'(�9623(11,2-*)�1�-*5(>�*++6(11>�*-+�+*4(1�
23�4'(�6(.,146*4,2-�9(6,2+�
�++,4,2-*)� ,-3265*4,2-� *;204� 9'?1,/,*-1� /*-� ;(� 320-+� 2-� 4'(�
32))2D,-.� D(;1,4(1�� �5(6,/*-� 2*6+� 23� �(+,/*)� �9(/,*)4,(1M�
�5(6,/*-� �(+,/*)� �112/,*4,2-I���� �'?1,/,*-� �()(/4>� �-),-(�
2/426� �,-+(6M� �(+(6*4,2-� 23� �4*4(��(+,/*)� 2*6+1M��(D��268�
�4*4(� (9*645(-4� 23� �(*)4'� �'?1,/,*-� �62=)(1M� *-+� �����
��20-/,)�2-�,/(-106(>��-326/(5(-4�*-+��(.0)*4,2-���
40 John H. Fisher
3�#���/1+�%��������#�������������������������������������������#�����"��������'�������������������&
�20�5014�5*8(�106(�?206�+2/426�'*1�-(:(6�;((-�4'(�10;B(/4�23�*�
+,1/,9),-*6?�962/((+,-.�26�'*1�'*+�',1�5(+,/*)�),/(-1(�1019(-+(+>�
),5,4(+�26�6(:28(+���25(�9'?1,/,*-1�5014�;(�52-,426(+�;?�*-24'(6�
+2/426�;*1(+�092-�+,1/,9),-*6?�*/4,2-1�;620.'4�*.*,-14�4'(5�;?�
4'(�14*4(�*.(-/?�4'*4�6(.0)*4(1�9'?1,/,*-1>�,�(�>�4'(��(D��268��4*4(�
(9*645(-4�23��(*)4'���2D(:(6>�4'21(�9'?1,/,*-1�D,))�-24�4())�?20�
*;204�4'(,6�962;)(51�D,4'�4'(�14*4(�),/(-1,-.�*04'26,4?���20�5014�
+2�?206�2D-�6(1(*6/'�2-�4'(�,-4(6-(4�
�259)*,-41� *.*,-14� 9'?1,/,*-1� *6(� 90;),/� ,-3265*4,2-� ,3� 4'(?�
6(10)4�,-�*�=-*)�+,1/,9),-*6?�*/4,2-���2�)(*6-�,3�*�9'?1,/,*-�'*1�;((-�
+,1/,9),-(+>�/*))������*4��J&@@JFF$JF��H�26�*//(11�4'(��(+,/*)�
�2-+0/4�D(;�1,4(�*4�DDD�'(*)4'�14*4(�-?�01��1()(/4� �-3265*4,2-�
326��2-105(61!��
�(D��268�1��*4,(-4��(*)4'��-3265*4,2-�*-+�G0*),4?��5962:(5(-4�
�/4�23�"@@@�5*+(�,4�9211,;)(�326�*))�/,4,N(-1�23��(D��268�42�.(4�
,-3265*4,2-�*;204�9'?1,/,*-1�4'620.'�4'(��4*4(��'?1,/,*-��62=)(�
D(;1,4(>�DDD�-?+2/426962=)(�/25�
�2� 1(*6/'� 326� 4'(� )*4(14� +,1/,9),-(� */4,2-1� *.*,-14� 9'?1,/,*-1>�
9'?1,/,*-1��*11,14*-41�*-+�19(/,*),14�*11,14*-41>�/'(/8�4'(�D(;1,4(�
23� 4'(� �(D� �268� �4*4(� (9*645(-4� 23� �(*)4'�1� �3=/(� 23�
�623(11,2-*)��(+,/*)��2-+0/4�*4�DDD�-?+2/426962=)(�/25���'(�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 41
�����D(;1,4(� 92141� 90;),/� +2/05(-41� 6(.*6+,-.� 9623(11,2-*)�
5,1/2-+0/4>�*-+�9'?1,/,*-�+,1/,9),-(�*/4,2-1�4*8(-��
�'(�-?+2/426962=)(�/25�D(;1,4(�962:,+(1�,-3265*4,2-�*;204�4'(�
+2/426�1�-05;(6�23�5(+,/*)�5*)96*/4,/(�9*?5(-41>�4'(�+*4(�23�4'(�
9*?5(-41>�4'(�/2064�*-+�/20-4?�D'(6(�4'(�9*?5(-41�D(6(�5*+(>�
*-+� 4'(� 1,.-,=/*-/(� 23� 4'(� 9*?5(-41!� 6()*4,:(� 42� 4'(� *:(6*.(�
1(44)(5(-4�*520-41�23�24'(6�9'?1,/,*-1�
�-� 4'(� ����� D(;1,4(� *4� DDD�'(*)4'�14*4(�-?�01>� ?20� /*-�
/),/8� 4'(� ),-81� 326� �(*6/'� 326� *� ,1/,9),-(+� �'?1,/,*-!>� �,)(� *�
�259)*,-4!� *-+� �2-4*/4�����!�� �3� ?206� 9'?1,/,*-� '*1� ;((-�
+,1/,9),-(+�;?�4'(�����>�4'(�D(;1,4(�D,))�962:,+(�,-3265*4,2-�
*;204�4'(� �,1/2-+0/4� (1/6,94,2-!�*-+� ,/(-1(��(146,/4,2-!�
*-+� *� /29?� 23� 4'(� �(*6,-.� �255,44((�1� (4(65,-*4,2-� *-+�
�6+(6>� �*/40*)� �))(.*4,2-1>� *-+� �,-+,-.1� 23� �*/4� *.*,-14� 4'(�
9'?1,/,*-�*6(�9214(+�,-�*�9+3�*44*/'5(-4��
�'(�1(/4,2-�23�DDD�'(*)4'�14*4(�-?�01�4'*4�,1�(-4,4)(+>� ,1/,9),-*6?�
�/4,2-!>�962:,+(1�*� ),14,-.�23�*))�9'?1,/,*-1>�9'?1,/,*-1��*11,14*-41�
*-+�19(/,*),14�*11,14*-41�D'2�'*:(�;((-�+,1/,9),-(+�1,-/(��##@���26�
,-3265*4,2-� *;204� 9'?1,/,*-1� +,1/,9),-(+� ;(326(� �##@>� /*))� &@@J
FF$JF��H>�(J5*,)�295/Q'(*)4'�14*4(�-?�01�26�D6,4(�42�4'(��(D�
�268��4*4(� (9*645(-4�23��(*)4'>��3=/(�23��623(11,2-*)��(+,/*)�
�2-+0/4>�H$$��,:(6��46((4>��0,4(�$@$>��62?>��(D��268��"�&@�
�33(/4,:(>� �2:(5;(6� $>� "@@&>� ;24'� 4'(� /'*6.(1� =)(+� *.*,-14� *�
9'?1,/,*-�*-+�4'(�2*6+�1� (4(65,-*4,2-�*-+��6+(6�6(.*6+,-.�*))�
/'*6.(1� *6(�5*+(� 90;),/�� �(-+,-.� 26� +,15,11(+� /259)*,-41� *-+�
42 John H. Fisher
4'(�,-:(14,.*4,:(�=)(�5*4(6,*)1�3625�*))�/*1(1�*6(�-24�*//(11,;)(�42�
4'(�90;),/�
�18�?206�+2/426�326�',1�6(105(>�*)12�8-2D-�*1�/066,/0)05�:,4*(��
�'(�+2/426�1'20)+�-24�'(1,4*4(� 42�.,:(�?20�',1�6(105(� ,3�'(� ,1�
9620+� 23� ',1� 9623(11,2-*)� *//259),1'5(-41� *-+� '*1� -24',-.�42�',+(�
3�#���/2+� %��������#������������������*���"���������������4�������
� �������������������������������������5'�������������������&�
�+5,44,-.�96,:,)(.(1�.,:(�4'(�+2/426�4'(�*;,),4?�42�*+5,4�?20�42�
4'(�'219,4*)�326�4(14,-.�*-+�52-,426,-.�*-+�106.(6?>�,3�-(/(11*6?��
H#L� 23������ '219,4*)1� '*:(� -(:(6� 6(9264(+� *� 1,-.)(� +,1/,9),-*6?�
*/4,2-�*.*,-14�2-(�23�4'(,6�+2/4261>�1,-/(�4'(��*4,2-*)��6*/4,4,2-(6�
*4*�*-8�D*1�/6(*4(+�,-��##@����--0*)��(9264>�"@@F>��*4,2-*)�
�6*/4,4,2-(6� *4*�*-8��
�219,4*)1� *6(� 6(E0,6(+� ;?� )*D� 42� 6(9264� D'(-(:(6� 4'(?�
),34� *� 9'?1,/,*-�1� 96,:,)(.(1� 326� *4� )(*14� $�� +*?1� 326� 5(+,/*)�
,-/259(4(-/(� 26� 5,1/2-+0/4�� �-� 4D2� +(/*+(1>� 106()?� 526(�
4'*-� '*)3� 23� 4'(� /20-46?�1� '219,4*)1� '*:(� 4*8(-� 10/'� */4,2-1�
*.*,-14� +2/4261�� �219,4*)1>� D',/'� 3*/(� -2� =-(� 326� 3*,),-.� 42�
6(9264>� *6(�-24�(19(/,*))?�(*.(6� 42� 406-� ,-� 4'(,6�+2/4261�� �25(�
'219,4*)1� ,5921(� 2-)?� $@J+*?� 1019(-1,2-1� 42� .(4� *620-+� 4'(��
$�J+*?�60)(�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 43
�2� 1(*6/'� 326� 4'(� )*4(14� +,1/,9),-(� */4,2-1� *.*,-14� 9'?1,/,*-1>�
9'?1,/,*-1�� *11,14*-41� *-+� 19(/,*),14� *11,14*-41>� /'(/8� 4'(� �(D�
�268��4*4(� (9*645(-4�23��(*)4'�1��3=/(�23��623(11,2-*)��(+,/*)�
�2-+0/4�'25(9*.(�*4�DDD�'(*)4'�14*4(�-?�01���'(������D(;1,4(�
92141�90;),/�+2/05(-41� 6(.*6+,-.�9623(11,2-*)�5,1/2-+0/4>� *-+�
9'?1,/,*-�+,1/,9),-(�*/4,2-1�4*8(-��
�'(� ����� D(;1,4(� 233(61� :*)0*;)(� ,-3265*4,2-� ,-� 1(/4,2-1�
(-4,4)(+>� �04J23J�4*4(� �/4,2-1!>� �066(-4� ,5,4*4,2-1!>�
�219,4*)� �6,:,)(.(� �(146,/4,2-1!� *-+� �6,5,-*)� �2-:,/4,2-1!��
�'(� ����� D(;1,4(� *)12� 962:,+(1� ,-3265*4,2-� *;204� ?206�
+2/426�1� 5(+,/*)� 1/'22)>� .6*+0*4(� 5(+,/*)� (+0/*4,2->� D'(4'(6�
4'(�+2/426�,1�;2*6+�/(64,=(+>�4'(�+*4(�23�;2*6+�/(64,=/*4,2-�*-+��
9623(11,2-*)�5(5;(61',91�
�'(� 1(/4,2-� 23� 4'(� ����� D(;1,4(� (-4,4)(+>� (.*)� �/4,2-1!>�
962:,+(1� ,-3265*4,2-� *;204� )*D10,41� 4'*4� '*:(� 6(10)4(+� ,-� *�
+(4(65,-*4,2-�*+:(61(�42�4'(�+2/426���'(������D(;1,4(�962:,+(1�
,-3265*4,2-�*;204�),/(-1,-.�*/4,2-1�4*8(-�*.*,-14�+2/4261���3�?20�
D20)+� ),8(� 42� 1((� ,3� 4'(6(� '*:(� ;((-� *-?� ),/(-1(� */4,2-1� 4*8(-�
*.*,-14�?206�+2/426�2:(6�4'(�9*14�4(-�?(*61>�4'(������D(;1,4(�
962:,+(1�4',1�,-3265*4,2-�
44 John H. Fisher
3�#���/6+�%��������#�������������������������#�#���������'�������������������&
�2-46*6?�42�90;),/�9(6/(94,2->�)*D10,41�*6(�-24�1(44)(+�;?�9'?1,/,*-1�
D'(-� 4'(� /*1(� *.*,-14� 4'(5� '*1� -2� 5(6,4�� �3� ?206� +2/426� '*1�
1(44)(+�526(�4'*-�2-(�26�4D2�/*1(1�,-�',1�/*6((6>�'(�5*?�-24�;(�*��
18,))(+�9'?1,/,*-�
�20�1'20)+�=-+�204�D'(4'(6�?206�+2/426�'*1�;((-�10(+�*-+�,3�
12>�D'(4'(6�?206�+2/426�'*+�42�1(44)(� 4'(� )*D10,4���',)(�125(�
:(6?�.22+�+2/4261�*6(�10(+>�,4�,1�2-)?�4'(�1462-.(14�/*1(1�4'*4�*6(�
1(44)(+���4�,1�526(�,59264*-4�42�=-+�204�D'(4'(6�?206�+2/426�'*1�
9*,+�52-(?�42�1(44)(�*�)*D10,4>�4'*-�42�=-+�204�D'(4'(6�'(�'*1�
;((-�10(+�
��1,59)(�*-+�(*1?�D*?�42�+(4(65,-(�,3�?206�+2/426�'*1�;((-�10(+�
,1�42�:,1,4�4'(������D(;1,4(�0-+(6�4'(�1(/4,2-�(-4,4)(+>� (.*)�
�/4,2-1!>� *-+� �04J23J�4*4(��/4,2-1!���2D(:(6>� )*D10,41� *.*,-14�
9'?1,/,*-1�*6(�234(-�-24�6(9264(+�42� 4'(��3=/(�23��623(11,2-*)�
�(+,/*)��2-+0/4�
�-24'(6�D*?�42�/'(/8�326�)*D10,41�*.*,-14�?206�+2/426�,1�42�:,1,4�
4'(��20-4?��)(68�1��3=/(�23�4'(�/20-4?�D'(6(�?206�+2/426�'*1�
',1�23=/(�*-+�,3�?20�*6(�*5;,4,201>�4'(�/20-4,(1�106620-+,-.�4'(�
/20-4?�D'(6(�?206�+2/426�'*1�',1�23=/(���'(�/25904(6�4(65,-*)1�
,-� 4'(� �20-4?� �)(68�1� 23=/(� D,))� '*:(� ,-3265*4,2-� 4'*4� *;204�
)*D10,41�*.*,-14�,-+,:,+0*)1>�*-+�2-/(�?20�2;4*,-�4'(�,-+(C�-05;(6�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 45
326�*�/2064�=)(>�?20�/*-�*18�4'(��20-4?��)(68�42�6(:,(D�*))�23�4'(�
/2064�+2/05(-41�,-�4'(�)*D10,41��
� ������%����������������������#�����
�'(� �'?1,/,*-� �62=)(� 2-� 4'(� D(;1,4(>� DDD�-?+2/426962=)(�
/25>� 962:,+(1� ,-3265*4,2-� *;204� ?206� 9'?1,/,*-�1� (+0/*4,2-*)�
;*/8.620-+>� ,-/)0+,-.� /2))(.(>� 5(+,/*)� 1/'22)>� 6(1,+(-/?� *-+�
3())2D1',9>�'219,4*)�*3=),*4,2-1>�D'(4'(6�'(�26�1'(�,1�;2*6+�/(64,=(+>�
5(+,/*)� 19(/,*)4,(1>� 9*4,(-4� 6*4,-.1� *-+� /255(-41>� *D*6+1� *-+�
+,14,-/4,2-1>�*-+�6(/(-4�/255(-41�;?�9*4,(-41���',1�,1�*�.6(*4�9)*/(�
42�14*64�?206�;*/8.620-+�1(*6/'�23�*�9'?1,/,*-�
�2�/'(/8�,3�*�+2/426�'*1�*�/066(-4)?�:*),+�),/(-1(>�?20�/*-�/'(/8�
D,4'� 4'(��(D��268� �4*4(� �+0/*4,2-� (9*645(-4>��3=/(�23� 4'(�
�623(11,2-1>� �+0/*4,2-� 0,)+,-.I"-+� �)226>� �);*-?>� �(D� �268�
�""$H>�26�/*))���&JH%HJ$&�%>�26�/'(/8�4'(��+0/*4,2-� (9*645(-4�1�D(;1,4(�*4�DDD�-?1(+�.2:<9623<9623'25(�'45�
�%������#���������#��������#�����������#���'���������������������������"������#����
�24�-(/(11*6,)?���'(6(�*6(�&�>$%@�),/(-1(+�9'?1,/,*-1�,-��(D��268�
�4*4(�23�D',/'�FH>&�&�*6(�,-�*/4,:(�5(+,/*)�96*/4,/(�,-�4'(��4*4(����
6(:,(D�23�4'(�*/4,:,4?�23��(D��268�1��3=/(�23��623(11,2-*)��(+,/*)�
�2-+0/4� ������� 3625� �##�� 4'620.'� "@@#� 6(:(*)1� *� 424*)� 23�
�>"�H�+2/4261�1*-/4,2-(+���-�"@@#>�326�(C*59)(>�4'(6(�D(6(�"#"�
+2/4261�1*-/4,2-(+�;?�4'(������204�23�FH>&�&�+2/4261�*/4,:()?�
96*/4,/,-.�,-�4'(��4*4(�
46 John H. Fisher
�-�"@@#>�4'(�-05;(6�23�+2/4261�;(,-.�1*-/4,2-(+�;?�4'(������
'*1� +(/),-(+� 42� *� =34((-� ?(*6� )2D� +(19,4(� *-� ,-/6(*1(� ,-� 4'(�
-05;(6� 23� 9'?1,/,*-1� 96*/4,/,-.� ,-� �(D��268� *-+� *� +6*5*4,/�
,-/6(*1(�,-�/259)*,-41>�*//26+,-.�42��?14(5��*,)06(�����(:,(D�23�
�(D��268��4*4(�1� 2/426� ,1/,9),-(��?14(5�90;),1'(+�;?�4'(��(D�
�268��0;),/��-4(6(14��(1(*6/'��6209�,-�K0-(>�"@�@���064'(6526(>�
*//26+,-.�42�4'(��(+(6*)�.2:(6-5(-4�1��*4,2-*)��6*/4,4,2-(6� *4*�
*-8>��(D��268�6*-81�4',6+�3625�4'(�;24425�,-�4'(�9(6/(-4*.(�23�
*/4,2-1�4*8(-�*.*,-14�,-J14*4(�+2/4261��
�'(� ;24425� ),-(� ,1� 4'*4� 4'(� �4*4(� 23� �(D��268� +2(1� -24�
(33(/4,:()?� 52-,426� 9'?1,/,*-1� 326� -(.),.(-/(� *-+� 5,1/2-+0/4��
�'(�3*/4�4'*4�?206�+2/426�'*1�*�/)(*-�+,1/,9),-*6?�6(/26+�+2(1�
-24�5(*-�50/'�
� ����������������"���������������������������
�061(J42J9*4,(-4� 6*4,21� *4� '219,4*)1� *6(� *112/,*4(+� D,4'� 4'(�
36(E0(-/?�23�9*4,(-4�,-B06,(1��4'(�3(D(6�-061(1>�4'(�',.'(6�4'(�6*4(�
23� ,-B06,(1���� 1(6,(1� 23� 140+,(1� 3625� 4'(��.(-/?� 326��(*)4'/*6(�
�(1(*6/'� *-+� G0*),4?� 320-+� 1,.-,=/*-4� *112/,*4,2-1� ;(4D((-�
)2D(6� )(:()1� 23� -061(� 14*3=-.� *-+� ',.'(6� 6*4(1� 23� 9-(052-,*>�
099(6�.*1462,-4(14,-*)�;)((+,-.>�1'2/8</*6+,*/�*66(14>�06,-*6?�46*/4�
,-3(/4,2-�*-+� 3*,)06(� 42�6(1/0(�!��40+,(1�'*:(�1'2D-�4'*4�*� )2D�
6*4,2�23�-061(1�42�9*4,(-41>�10/'�*1�2-(�42�=:(>�6(+0/(1�9*4,(-4�
+(*4'1>�*))2D1�-061(1�42�19(-+�526(�4,5(�D,4'�(*/'�9*4,(-4�*-+�
'()91�8((9�(C9(6,(-/(+�-061(1�2-�4'(�B2;��
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 47
�-��###>��*),326-,*�D*1�4'(�=614�14*4(�,-�4'(�-*4,2-�4'*4�(-*/4(+�*�
)*D�D,4'�5,-,505�-061(J42J9*4,(-4�6*4,2�23�2-(�42�=:(���'(-�4'(�
�*),326-,*�)*D�D*1�9'*1(+�,-�;(4D((-�"@@H�*-+�"@@&>�4'(�6(10)41�
D(6(�96(+,/4*;)(��4'(6(�*6(�3(D(6�-061(1�5,11,-.�/'*-.(1�,-�9*4,(-4�
/2-+,4,2-1>�4'(�-061(1�*6(�3*6�526(�),8()?�42�14*?�*4�;(+1,+(�*-+�
4'(6(�,1�)(11�;06-204�6(10)4,-.�,-�',.'(6�-061(�6(4(-4,2-��(326(�
4'(�)*D>�,4�D*1�/2552-�42�=-+�*�1,-.)(�-061(�,-�/'*6.(�23�&>��@�26�
�"�26�526(�9*4,(-41�2-�*�1',34�
�'*4�,1�4'(�-061(J42J9*4,(-4�6*4,2�*4�?206�'219,4*)7��2D�5*-?�
/*6(� 962:,+(61� *6(� 6(.,14(6(+� -061(17��2D� ?20� /*-� *18� 4'21(�
E0(14,2-1�*-+�4'(�'219,4*)�,1�6(E0,6(+�42�4())�?20�,-��(D��268�
�-��*6/'���>�"@�@>�*�-(D�)*D>�8-2D-�*1�4'(��061,-.��*6(�G0*),4?�
�624(/4,2-��/4���0;),/��(*)4'�*D�1(/4,2-�"&@�J4�>�D(-4�,-42�(33(/4�
,-��(D��268�4'*4�6(E0,6(1�'219,4*)1>�-061,-.�'25(1>�'219,/(1>�*-+�
+,*.-214,/�*-+�46(*45(-4�/(-4(61�42�5*8(�-061(J42J9*4,(-4�6*4,21�
*:*,)*;)(� 42� 4'(�90;),/���'(� )*D�*)12� 6(E0,6(1�'(*)4'� 3*/,),4,(1� 42�
6(9264�*+:(61(�(:(-41>�D',/'�5*?�6(:(*)�3*/,),4,(1�D'(6(�14*3=-.�
1'264*.(1�/2-46,;04(�42�',.'(6�6*4(1�23�5(+,/*)�(66261�
�20� -2D� '*:(� 4'(� 6,.'4� 42� 8-2D� '2D� '219,4*)1� *-+� -061,-.�
'25(1�*6(�14*3=-.�4'(,6�0-,41���'(�)*D�*)12�6(E0,6(1�'219,4*)1�*-+�
-061,-.� '25(1� 42� 6(9264� 4'(�-05;(6�23� 6(.,14(6(+�-061(1� *-+�
),/(-1(+�96*/4,/*)�-061(1����1��962:,+,-.�+,6(/4�/*6(>�4'(�6*4,2�
23�30))J4,5(�-061(1�42�9*4,(-41>�4'(�-05;(6�23�0-),/(-1(+�D268(61�
962:,+,-.�+,6(/4�/*6(>�*-+�,-3265*4,2-�2-�/259)*,-41�=)(+�*.*,-14�
4'(�'219,4*)�*-+�'219,4*)�14*3=-.�92),/,(1�
48 John H. Fisher
�-(� /*4/'�� 4'(� ,-3265*4,2-�D,))� -24� ;(� /2))(/4(+�26� 90;),/,N(+�
;?� 4'(� 14*4(���'(� )*D� 6(E0,6(1� '219,4*)1� *-+� -061,-.� '25(1� 42�
5*8(�4'(�,-3265*4,2-�*:*,)*;)(�42�*-?�5(5;(6�23�4'(�90;),/�D'2�
6(E0(141�,4�*-+�42�*-?�14*4(�*.(-/?�4'*4�109(6:,1(1�'(*)4'�3*/,),4,(1��
�'(�90;),/� /*-�*//(11� 4'(�+*4*�;?�/2-4*/4,-.� 4'(�'219,4*)1� *-+�
-061,-.�'25(1�
�3�4'(�'219,4*)�26�-061,-.�'25(�6(301(1�42�+,1/)21(�4',1�,-3265*4,2->�
?20� 1'20)+� 6(3(6� 42� 4'(� �061,-.� �*6(�G0*),4?� �624(/4,2-��/4�
��0;),/��(*)4'� *D� 1(/4,2-� "&@�J4�� *-+� ,-3265� 4'(� 3*/,),4?� 4'*4�
�(D��268� )*D� 6(E0,6(1� 4'(� +,1/)2106(� 23� 4',1� ,-3265*4,2-�� �3�
4'*4� 3*,)1>� ?20� 1'20)+�=)(� *� /259)*,-4�D,4'� 4'(��(D��268��4*4(�
(9*645(-4�23��(*)4'�
�'(� 3(+(6*)� .2:(6-5(-4� *)12� 90;),1'(1� ,-3265*4,2-� *;204�
-061(J42J9*4,(-4�6*4,21�*4�-061,-.�'25(1�*4�DDD�5(+,/*6(�.2:<
���259*6(�
�'(� �5(6,/*-� �061(1� �112/,*4,2-� D(;1,4(� ),141� 5*.-(4!�
'219,4*)1I4'21(� 5214� *446*/4,:(� 42� -061(1I26� *� /*))� 42� *�
'219,4*)�1� -061(� 109(6:,126� 1'20)+� ?,()+� 4'(� -061(J42J9*4,(-4�
6*4,21���2�42�4'(��5(6,/*-��061(1��112/,*4,2-�D(;1,4(�*4�DDD�
-061(/6(+(-4,*),-.�26.<�*.-(4<�,-+*�*.-(4�*/,),4?� 326� *� ),14� 23�
4'(�5*.-(4�'219,4*)1�4'*4�-061(1�=-+�5214�*446*/4,:(���'(6(�*6(�
�%�5*.-(4�'219,4*)1�,-��(D��268��4*4(�
�'(�D(;1,4(�23�4'(��(D��268��4*4(� (9*645(-4�23��(*)4'��DDD�
'(*)4'�14*4(�-?�01��'*1�*� 1(/4,2-�(-4,4)(+>� �219,4*)��62=)(!>� 4'*4�
962:,+(1� ,-3265*4,2-� *;204� G0*),4?� �(*106(1!>� �62/(+06(1!�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 49
*-+� �:*,)*;)(��*6(!�*;204�'219,4*)1� ,-��(D��268���'(�'219,4*)�
G0*),4?��(*106(1!�,-+,/*4(�'2D�D())�'219,4*)1�962:,+(�/*6(�42�
4'(,6�9*4,(-41�326�5(+,/*)�/2-+,4,2-1�10/'�*1�106.,/*)�96(:(-4,2->�
9-(052-,*�/*6(�*-+�'(*64�/2-+,4,2-1���'(6(�,1�*�D(;�9*.(�-*5(+>�
�2D� +2� 4'(1(� 1/26(1� /259*6(� 42� 24'(6� '219,4*)17!>�D',/'� ,1�
01(30)�326�/259*6,-.�'219,4*)1�326�E0*),4?�23�/*6(�
�'(� D(;1,4(� 23� 4'(� ����� (9*645(-4� 23� �(*)4'� *-+� �05*-�
�(6:,/(1��DDD�'219,4*)/259*6(�''1�.2:��'*1�*�D(;�9*.(�(-4,4)(+>�
�219,4*)� �259*6(!>� 4'*4� ,1� ;*1(+� 2-� +*4*� ,-:2):,-.� �(+,/*6(�
9*4,(-41� 46(*4(+� ;(4D((-� K0)?� "@@F� *-+� K0)?� "@@#���'(� 140+?�
,-/)0+(1�*:(6*.(�+(*4'�6*4(1� 326�:*6,201� ,))-(11(1>�10/'�*1�'(*64�
3*,)06(�*-+�9-(052-,*>�*-+�,-/)0+(1�6(*+5,11,2-�6*4(1�42�'219,4*)1��
�-�*:(6*.(�,-�4'(��-,4(+��4*4(1>�2-(�,-�=:(��(+,/*6(�;(-(=/,*6,(1�
+,1/'*6.(+�3625�'219,4*)1�(-+1�09�6(406-,-.�D,4',-�*�52-4'�
�20�1'20)+�=-+�4'(�'219,4*)�D,4'�4'(�)2-.(14�46*/8�6(/26+>�;(14�
106:,:*)�6*4(�*-+�4'(�',.'(14�:2)05(�2-�4'(�962/(+06(���20�+2-�4�
D*-4�42�;(�4'(�'219,4*)�1�4',6+�)0-.�46*-19)*-4�� 2�?206�6(1(*6/'�
;(326(�1()(/4,-.�4'(�'219,4*)�
� ����������������"����������"���������������������
�-�"@@�>�4'(��(-4(61�326��(+,/*6(�*-+��(+,/*,+��(6:,/(1�������
6(9264(+�42��2-.6(11�4'*4�*�+���� ��� ��������� �����, �����-������
���� ����������$��� ���������������� ���������������� �����'(��(-4(61�
326��(+,/*6(�*-+��(+,/*,+��(6:,/(1�6()(*1(+�4'(� �*4,2-*)�,14��
�061,-.��25(1��*6.(4(+�326��,.'J�,18��6(1106(��)/(6��;(+126(1��
50 John H. Fisher
*-+<26��'?1,/*)��(146*,-��5962:(5(-4!>�*-+�H>@@@�-061,-.�'25(1�
D(6(�320-+�+(=/,(-4�,-�4'(1(�4D2�,59264*-4�/*4(.26,(1�23�/*6(��
�'(�96(:*)(-/(�23�96(1106(�126(1�*-+�4'(�01(�23�6(146*,-41�*6(�
,-+,/*4261�23�-(.)(/4�*-+�,-103=/,(-4�14*33�
�'(� 15*))(6� 4'(� 0-+(69*,+� *-+� -2-J18,))(+� 14*33� ,1>� 4'(� 526(�
52-(?� 4'*4� /*-� ;(� 5*+(� ;?� -061,-.� '25(1���'(6(� *6(� 1462-.�
=-*-/,*)� ,-/(-4,:(1� 326� -061,-.� '25(1� 42� /04� /26-(61� -24� 2-)?�
,-�4'(�-05;(6�23�14*33>�;04�*)12�,-�4'(�46*,-,-.�*-+�E0*),=/*4,2-1�
23�4'(�18,))(+�14*33���214�23�4'(�6(:(-0(�23�-061,-.�'25(1�/25(1�
3625��(+,/*6(�*-+��(+,/*,+>�;04�4'(�2D-(61�23�-061,-.�'25(1�
-((+�-24�*//20-4�42��(+,/*6(�26��(+,/*,+�326�'2D�4'(?�19(-+�
4'(�52-(?�4'(?�*6(�9*,+���1�*�6(10)4>�4'(�-05;(6�23�)2D(6�9*,+>�
)(11�46*,-(+�-061,-.�*11,14*-41�'*:(�,-/6(*1(+�
�'(� -05;(6� 23� 6*4,2� 23� *,+(1<-061(1� 42� 6(1,+(-41�5*?� ;(� 2-(�
*,+�326����6(1,+(-41�+06,-.�4'(�-,.'4�*-+�,4�,1�-24�0-010*)�42�=-+�
*�)2-(�-061(�26�*,+�/*6,-.�326�*1�5*-?�*1�$@�6(1,+(-41���'(�)2D�
14*3=-.�D,))�6(10)4�,-�9226�E0*),4?�23�/*6(>�10/'�*1�5*)-046,4,2-�23�
6(1,+(-41>�;(+126(1>�06,-*6?�46*/4�,-3(/4,2-1>�6(1,+(-41�/2-=-(+�42�
4'(,6�/'*,61�26�;(+>�*-+�-(.)(/4�
�'(��(D��268��4*4(� (9*645(-4�23��(*)4'�5(*106(1�9(63265*-/(�
6*-8,-.1�23�*))�-061,-.�'25(1�,-��(D��268�*4�4'(� (9*645(-4�23�
�(*)4'�1��061,-.��25(� �62=)(� *4�DDD�-061,-.'25(1�-?'(*)4'�
.2:<-'JE0*),4?� �26� (*/'� E0*),4?�5(*106(>� 4'(� -061,-.� '25(1� ,-�
�(D��268�*6(�+,:,+(+�,-42�=:(�.62091�*//26+,-.�42�4'(,6�1/26(1>�
D,4'�620.')?�"@L�23�4'(�-061,-.�'25(1�,-�(*/'�.6209��
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 51
�'(�E0*),4?�5(*106(�9(63265*-/(�6*-8,-.1�1'2D�'2D�4'(�-061,-.�
'25(1� 6*-8� ,-� 6()*4,2-� 42� 24'(6� -061,-.� '25(1� ,-� �(D��268��
�'(6(�*6(�9(63265*-/(�6*-8,-.1�326�4'(�9(6/(-4*.(�23�6(1,+(-41�
D,4'� 06,-*6?� 46*/4� ,-3(/4,2-1>� 4'(� 9(6/(-4*.(� 23� 6(1,+(-41� D'2�
D(6(�9'?1,/*))?�6(146*,-(+>�4'(�9(6/(-4*.(�23�6(1,+(-41�D'2�'*:(�
96(1106(�126(1>�4'(�9(6/(-4*.(�23�6(1,+(-41�D'2�)21(�422�50/'�
D(,.'4>�*-+�4'(�9(6/(-4*.(�23�6(1,+(-41�D'2�'*:(�'*+�*�/*4'(4(6�
,-1(64(+�*-+�)(34�,-�4'(,6�;)*++(6�
�'(� 9(63265*-/(� 6*-8,-.� 326� 4'(� 9(6/(-4*.(� 23� 6(1,+(-41�
D,4'� 06,-*6?� 46*/4� ,-3(/4,2-� ,1� *� .22+� ,-+,/*426� 23� 4'(� 1*-,4*6?�
96*/4,/(1�23�4'(�-061,-.�'25(���214�06,-*6?�46*/4�,-3(/4,2-1�/*-�
;(� 96(:(-4(+� ;?� 8((9,-.� 4'(� *6(*� /)(*->� (594?,-.� 4'(� ;)*++(6�
6(.0)*6)?>�*-+�+6,-8,-.�(-20.'�S0,+���'(�-061,-.�'25(�14*33�1'20)+�
5*8(�106(�4'(�6(1,+(-4�'*1�.22+�'?.,(-(�
�(+,/*6(�*)12�962:,+(1�9(63265*-/(�6*-8,-.�5(*106(1�23�-061,-.�
'25(1� *4� ,41�D(;9*.(>�DDD��(+,/*6(�.2:����259*6(���4� 4',1�
01(30)� D(;1,4(>� �(+,/*6(� ),141� 19(/,=/� ,-3265*4,2-� 326� -061,-.�
'25(1� 4'620.'204� 4'(��-,4(+��4*4(1� /2-/(6-,-.�-061,-.�'25(�
14*3=-.>� E0*),4?� 5(*106(1>� *-+� '(*)4'� ,-19(/4,2-1>� *-+� ?20� /*-�
/259*6(�09�42�4'6((�-061,-.�'25(1�,-�(*/'�/*4(.26?�
����������������������*�������7���"��#��(���������
�� "@@%� 140+?� ;?� 4'(� �-14,404(� 23��(+,/,-(� 320-+� 4'*4� '219,4*)�
(5(6.(-/?� +(9*645(-41� *6(� 2:(6;06+(-(+>� 0-+(6J30-+(+� *-+�
52 John H. Fisher
,))J96(9*6(+� 42�'*-+�+,1*14(61� *1� 4'(�-05;(6�23�9(29)(� 406-,-.�
42� (5(6.(-/?� +(9*645(-41� 326� 96,5*6?� /*6(� 8((9� 6,1,-.��
�-� *5;0)*-/(� ,1� 406-(+� *D*?� 3625� *-� ��� 2-/(� (:(6?�5,-04(>�
*//26+,-.�42�4'(�140+?�
�3�9211,;)(>�*:2,+�4'(����;(4D((-�$�9�5��*-+���*�5�I4'(�;01,(14�
1',34���26�4'(�1'264(14�D*,4>�(*6)?�526-,-.�;(4D((-�H�*�5��*-+�#�
*�5��,1�4'(�;(14�4,5(�326�*�:,1,4�42�4'(����
�3�?20�/*->�14*?�*D*?�3625�'219,4*)1�+06,-.�4'(�1055(6>�(19(/,*))?�
K0)?���'*4�1� 4'(� 52-4'� D'(-� 5(+,/*)� 140+(-41� ;(/25(� ,-4(6-1>�
,-4(6-1� ;(/25(� 6(1,+(-41� *-+� 6(1,+(-41� ;(/25(� 3())2D1� *-+�
+2/4261���'(�*+B014(+�5264*),4?�6*4(�6,1(1�HL�,-�K0)?�*-+��0.014�326�
4'(�*:(6*.(�4(*/',-.�'219,4*)>�*//26+,-.�42�4'(��*4,2-*)�06(*0�23�
�/2-25,/��(1(*6/'�
�%������������������#��&�(�������������������"���
�24�-(/(11*6,)?���40+,(1�3625�;24'�4'(��--*)1�23��-4(6-*)��(+,/,-(�
*-+�4'(�6,4,1'��(+,/*)�K206-*)�+,+�-24�=-+�*�1462-.�/266()*4,2-�
;(4D((-� 9*4,(-4� 1*4,13*/4,2-� *-+� 4'(� E0*),4?� 23� /*6(�� �-� 24'(6�
D26+1>� B014� ;(/*01(� ?20� ),8(� ?206� +2/426� +2(1-�4� -(/(11*6,)?�
5(*-�'(�1�*�/259(4(-4�9'?1,/,*-�
�*4,13*/4,2-� 1/26(1� /*-� '()9� 9'?1,/,*-1� ,5962:(� 4'(,6� 9*4,(-4�
6()*4,2-1>�;04�,4�1�*�5,14*8(�42�01(�9*4,(-4�1*4,13*/4,2-�*1�*�+2/426�1�
6(9264�/*6+�2-�4'(�E0*),4?�23�4'(,6�/*6(�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 53
������������������������8�������������������������#������#����
.������!����������$��/��',1�,1�*-�*;12)04(�5014�
&���������������������� ��/��',1�D,))�)(4�?20�8-2D�D'*4�
'219,4*)�42�01(�,3�-(/(11*6?�
0����������������������� ���� �������������/��',1�,1�.22+�42�8-2D���3�?206�+2/426�1*?1�?(1>�?20�1'20)+�*18�'2D�5*-?�
'219,4*),N(+�9*4,(-41�+2(1�'(<1'(�1((�(:(6?�?(*6�*-+�D'2�/2:(61�
4'(�'219,4*)�D'(-�'(<1'(�,1�-24�*:*,)*;)(�
&���� ����������������� ���������������� �������������/��25(�96*/4,/(1�01(�*-1D(6,-.�1(6:,/(1>�D',/'�*6(�28*?>�;04�
125(4,5(1�?20�-((+�42�19(*8�D,4'�4'(�+2/426�
&���� ���� ���� ������ ����� � �� ����� �� ������!�����/��20�+2-�4�/2-462)�D'(-�?20�.(4�1,/8>�12�?20�-((+�42�8-2D�D'2�
D,))�1((�?20�*4�-,.'4�26�2-�4'(�D((8(-+�*-+�D'(6(�
1��������$ ��������������������������������� �� �����������/2��20�/*-�=-+�204�4',1�,-3265*4,2-�4'620.'�4'(�D(;1,4(>�
DDD�+2/,-32�26.>�23�4'(��3=/(�23��623(11,2-*)��(+,/*)��2-+0/4�
23�4'(��(+(6*4,2-�23��4*4(��(+,/*)�2*6+�1������>�D',/'�962:,+(1�
?20� D,4'� ,-3265*4,2-� 2-� 9'?1,/,*-1� *-+� 9'?1,/,*-1�� *11,14*-41�
),/(-1(+�,-�4'(��-,4(+��4*4(1>�,-/)0+,-.�,-3265*4,2-�2-�+,1/,9),-*6?�
1*-/4,2-1>� (+0/*4,2->� 5(+,/*)� 19(/,*)4?>� ),/(-106(� ',1426?� *-+�
)2/*4,2-1���20�/*-�*)12�6(*/'�4'(�����;?�/*)),-.�&�%J&F&JH@@@�
54 John H. Fisher
�'(�D(;1,4(>�+2/,-32�26.>�D,))�962:,+(�?20�D,4'�,-3265*4,2-�*;204�
?206�9'?1,/,*-1��5(+,/*)�),/(-1(�*-+�+,1/,9),-*6?�',1426?�,-�14*4(1�
4'620.'204�4'(��-,4(+��4*4(1>�D'(6(*1�4'(�D(;1,4(�23��(D��268�1�
�3=/(� 23� �623(11,2-*)� �(+,/*)� �2-+0/4>� DDD�-?+2/426962=)(�
/25>� ),5,41� 4'(� 9'?1,/,*-1�� ;*/8.620-+� ',1426?� 42� +,1/,9),-*6?�
*/4,2-�B014�D,4',-��(D��268�
�%�������������#�������-������"������������#�����
�,4'� *� 1'264*.(� 23� 96,5*6?� /*6(� 9'?1,/,*-1>� 5*-?� 14*4(1� *6(�
(C9*-+,-.�4'(�*04'26,4?�23�-061(�96*/4,4,2-(61���061(�96*/4,4,2-(61�
*6(�6(.,14(6(+�-061(1�D,4'�*-�*+:*-/(+�+(.6((� ,-�-061,-.>�D'2�
'*:(� 4'(� 92D(6� 42� 96*/4,/(� D,4'204� *� 9'?1,/,*-�1� 109(6:,1,2->�
96(1/6,;(�/2-462))(+�10;14*-/(1�*-+�9(63265�5214�23�4'(�1*5(�
4*181�23�*�9'?1,/,*-�
�'(��5(6,/*-��(+,/*)��112/,*4,2-�;(),(:(1�4'*4�*�+2/426�1'264*.(�
,1�-24� *� 6(*12-� 42�904�-061(1� ,-� /'*6.(� *-+�(-+*-.(6�9*4,(-41��
�061(�96*/4,4,2-(61>�2-�4'(�24'(6�'*-+>�1*?�4'(6(�,1�-2�+*-.(6�*-+�
4'*4�4'(?�*6(�*1�',.')?�46*,-(+�*-+�*1�18,))(+�*1�+2/4261�
�,))� 4'(� (C9*-+,-.� 62)(� 23� -061(� 96*/4,4,2-(61� ;(� .22+� 326�
9*4,(-417� �(-(6*))?>� -061(� 96*/4,4,2-(61� *6(� /*9*;)(� 23� 46(*4,-.�
6204,-(�*-+�/2552-� ,))-(11(1���2D(:(6>� ,3� ?20�'*:(�*�/259)(C�
5(+,/*)�/2-+,4,2-�26�*�924(-4,*))?�),3(J4'6(*4(-,-.�5(+,/*)�,110(>�
?20� 1'20)+� ,-1,14� 2-� *� +2/426�� 2/4261� 9211(11� 50/'� 526(�
46*,-,-.>�(+0/*4,2-�*-+�8-2D)(+.(�4'*-�*�-061(�96*/4,4,2-(6�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 55
���� ������+/
��*��������5������ ����������� �����������������*�����
��/2552-�1/(-*6,2�,1�4'*4�*�-(D�/),(-4�D,))�/*))�5(�D,4'�*�924(-4,*)�
/*1(�*-+�4())�5(�4'*4�'(�*)6(*+?�'*1�����23� 4'(�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1��
�'(-�4'(�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�*6(�.,:(-�42�5(�;?�5?�-(D�/),(-4>�,4�
,1�*)5214�-(:(6�4'(�/*1(�4'*4�4'(�'219,4*)�26�+2/426�1�23=/(�.*:(�
*))� 23� 4'(� 6(/26+1� 42� 4'(� /),(-4���2D� +2� �� 8-2D7��214� 23� 4'(�
4,5(�4'(6(�*6(�/6,4,/*)�6(/26+1�4'*4�*6(�5,11,-.�3625�*�14*-+*6+�
5(+,/*)�/'*64>�10/'�*1�)*;�6(92641�26�6(92641�23�,5*.,-.�140+,(1>�
*-+� ,-� 5*-?� /*1(1>� 4'(� /),(-4� 9211(11(1� 2-)?� *� 36*/4,2-� 23� 4'(��
(-4,6(�5(+,/*)�/'*64�
�),(-41�234(-�(C9)*,-�4'*4�4'(?�6(E0(14(+� (:(6?4',-.!�3625�4'(�
'219,4*)�*-+�*1105(+�4'*4�4'(�'219,4*)�/259),(+�D,4'�',1�6(E0(14��
*+� *110594,2-O� �-32640-*4()?>� (:(6?4',-.!� ,1� *)5214� -(:(6��
962:,+(+�42�4'(�/),(-4�
�',1�/*-�;(�*:2,+(+�;?�19(/,=/*))?�6(E0(14,-.�*-�*992,-45(-4�*4�
4'(�'219,4*)�26�+2/426�1�23=/(�42�/29?�*-+� ,-19(/4� 4'(�5(+,/*)�
6(/26+1�,-�4'(,6�(-4,6(4?��
� ������"����������������"����������#�����#������
�(/4,2-��&�"��23�4'(��0;),/��(*)4'�*D�6(E0,6(1�4'*4������ ���������
������������� ���3����326�*//(11�42�4'(�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1>�4'(�'(*)4'�
56 John H. Fisher
/*6(�962:,+(6�5014� .,:(� 4'(�E0*),=(+�9(612-� 4'(�2992640-,4?� 42�
,-19(/4�4'(�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1���(-/(>�?206�'(*)4'�/*6(�962:,+(6�5014�
)(4�?20�,-19(/4�26�1((�?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�D,4',-�4(-���@��+*?1�
23�?206�6(E0(14�
�0;),/��(*)4'�*D�1(/4,2-1��%�*-+��&�"��*�>�*-+��+��.,:(1�*�9*4,(-4�
4'(�6,.'4�42�,-19(/4�',1�26�'(6�5(+,/*)�,-3265*4,2-�/2-4*,-(+�,-�
4'(�/0142+?�23�*�'(*)4'/*6(�962:,+(6�*-+�42�2;4*,-�*�/29?�4'(6(23�
092-�9*?5(-4�23�6(*12-*;)(�3((1����9'?1,/,*-�/*--24�6(301(�42�)(4�
*�9*4,(-4�1((�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�;(/*01(�23�*-�0-9*,+�;,))���26�526(�
,-3265*4,2->�/2-4*/4�4'(��//(11�42��*4,(-4��-3265*4,2-��62.6*5�
*4���&JH@"J@&�H�
�$���%����#���"������������"����������#�����#�������
�2���',)(� �(D� �268� )*D� 9(65,41� *� 962:,+(6� 42� /'*6.(� *-�
,-19(/4,2-�3((!�,3�?20�1,59)?�D*-4�42�)228�*4�?206�6(/26+1>�4'(�
������ �6,:*/?� �0)(� +2(1� -24�� �,-/(� 4'(� ������ �6,:*/?� �0)(�
962:,+(1�526(�9624(/4,2-�23�?206�6,.'41>�?206�'(*)4'�/*6(�962:,+(6�
5014� 32))2D�4'(��������6,:*/?��0)(���206�'(*)4'�/*6(�962:,+(6�
/*--24�/'*6.(�?20�*-�,-19(/4,2-�3((�
�20� /*--24� ;(� /'*6.(+� *� 3((� 326� 4'(� /0142+,*-� 23� 4'(�5(+,/*)�
6(/26+1�1(*6/',-.�326�?206�6(/26+1���',1�3((�,1�125(4,5(1�/*))(+�*�
6(46,(:*)!�26� /)(6,/*)!�3((�*-+�4'(?�*6(�-24�9(65,44(+�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 57
� ������%���8�����������#�����#�������
�20� 1'20)+� /*))� ?206� '(*)4'� /*6(� 962:,+(6� *;204� ',1� 19(/,=/�
962/(+06(1�326�.(44,-.�?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1���206�9'?1,/,*-�5*?�
'*:(�*� 3265�326�6(E0(14,-.�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1���20�1'20)+�;(�*;)(�
42� =-+� ,-3265*4,2-� *;204� .(44,-.� ?206�5(+,/*)� 6(/26+� ,-� ?206�
9'?1,/,*-�1�-24,/(�23�96,:*/?�96*/4,/(1�
���������������������������#��������������8�����������#�����#�������
�4'(6�4'*-�?206�-*5(>�+*4(�23�;,64'�*-+�*++6(11>�?206�6(E0(14�
5,.'4�,-/)0+(�� *4(1�23�46(*45(-4>�D'(4'(6�?20�D*-4�4'(�(-4,6(�
6(/26+�26� B014�9*64�23�4'(�6(/26+>�19(/,=/�4(14�6(10)41>�D'(4'(6�
?20�D*-4�/29,(1�23�,5*.,-.�=)51>�10/'�*1�UJ6*?1�26����1/*-1>�*-+�
D'(4'(6�?20�D*-4� 42�1((�?206�5(+,/*)� 6(/26+>�D*-4�*�/29?�23�
?206�6(/26+>�26�D*-4�;24'��
�9��%���#�����#������������������"��������#�����#��������"���"���#����������
�2���20�'*:(�4'(�6,.'4�42�+2�;24'�
�$���%����������#�����������������#�����#�����������
�-+(6� 4'(� 3(+(6*)� 96,:*/?� 60)(� (14*;),1'(+� ;?� �����>� *�
/2:(6(+� (-4,4?!>� 10/'� *1� *� 9'?1,/,*-� 26� '219,4*)>� 5014�
58 John H. Fisher
*//2552+*4(� 6(*12-*;)(!� 6(E0(141� ;?� 9*4,(-41� 42� 6(/(,:(�
4'(� 5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1�� �',1� 5(*-1� 4'*4� *� 96*/4,4,2-(6� /*--24�
6(E0,6(� 4'(� 9*4,(-4� 42� /25(� 42� 4'(,6� 23=/(� 42� 9,/8� 09� 4'(�
6(/26+�� �3� ?20� *18� 4'*4� ?206� 5(+,/*)� 6(/26+� ;(� 5*,)(+� 26�
3*C(+>� ?206� 9'?1,/,*-� 26� '219,4*)� /*--24� 6(301(� 42� +2� 12� *1� ,4��
,1�*� 6(*12-*;)(!�6(E0(14�
��������%�����������#�����������������������������#�����#�������
�3�4'(�5(+,/*)�962:,+(6�6(301(1�42�*))2D�?20�42�1((�?206�5(+,/*)�
6(/26+1�D,4',-��@�+*?1�23�?206�6(E0(14>�?20�1'20)+�1(-+�*�)(44(6�
;?�/(64,=(+�5*,)�42�4'(�9'?1,/,*-�-24,3?,-.�',5�4'*4�?20�,-4(-+�
42�-24,3?�4'(��(D��268��4*4(� (9*645(-4�23��(*)4'�*;204�',1�
-2-J/259),*-/(�D,4'� 1(/4,2-1� �%� *-+� �&�"��*�� *-+� �$�� 23� 4'(�
�0;),/��(*)4'�*D���',1�*)5214�*)D*?1�(-106(1�*�6*9,+�6(192-1(�
3625�4'(�9'?1,/,*-�
:�*���������������#����������*����������������������������#�����#�����
�((9�,-�5,-+�4'*4�4'(�+2/426�1�23=/(�4?9,/*))?�D,))�962+0/(�2-)?�
4'(�9*9(6�/29?�23�?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1>�*-+�0-)(11�?20�*18>�?20�
D,))�-24�;(�1'2D-�4'(�()(/462-,/�6(/26+1�8(94�;?�4'(�+2/426���20�
1'20)+�19(/,=/*))?�*18�42�1((�4'(�()(/462-,/�6(/26+1�5*,-4*,-(+�
;?�4'(�9'?1,/,*-�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 59
�'(-�?20�.2�42�/29?�*-+�,-19(/4�?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1>�,4�D20)+�
;(�,+(*)�42�;6,-.�*�/2)26�1/*--(6�42�1/*-�4'(�6(/26+1�,-�/2)26��
�����������������#�����#�������
�-+(6� �@� �(D� �268� �2+(>� �0)(1� *-+� �(.0)*4,2-1� 1(/4,2-�
H@���@�*��$�>�4'(�5(+,/*)�/*6(�962:,+(61�'*:(�*�)(.*)�+04?�42�8((9�
*-+�5*,-4*,-� 4'(�5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1���'(�5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1�*6(� 4'(�
9629(64?�23�4'(�'219,4*)�*-+<26�5(+,/*)�.6209>�;04�4'(�,-3265*4,2-�
,-� 4'(� 6(/26+� ;()2-.1� 42� 4'(� 9*4,(-4>�D'2� 6(4*,-1� 4'(� 6,.'4� 42�
+,6(/4�4'(�46*-13(6�23�10/'�,-3265*4,2-��
�-+(6��(D��268� )*D>�4'(�'(*)4'�/*6(�962:,+(6�2D-1�4'(�*/40*)�
5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1�� �3� ?206� '(*)4'� /*6(� 962:,+(6� 5*,-4*,-1� 9*9(6�
5(+,/*)�6(/26+1>�?206�962:,+(6�'*1�4'(�6,.'4�42�8((9�4'(�26,.,-*)�
6(/26+���20�'*:(�4'(�6,.'4�42�1((�*-+�.(4�*�/29?�23�,4�
� ������"�����������#�������*��������8��������������������#�����#�������
�-+(6� �(D��268� )*D>� '(*)4'� /*6(� 962:,+(61� 5014� 8((9� 5(+,/*)�
6(/26+1� 326�*�5,-,505�9(6,2+�23� 4,5(���'?1,/,*-1�*-+�'219,4*)1�
*6(�6(E0,6(+�42�8((9�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�,-�4'(,6� 26,.,-*)�26�)(.*))?�
6(962+0/(+�3265!�326�*�9(6,2+�23�*4�)(*14�1,C�?(*61�3625�4'(�+*4(�
23�+,1/'*6.(�26�4'6((�?(*61�*34(6�4'(�9*4,(-4�1�*.(�23�5*B26,4?���&�
?(*61�23�*.(�,-��(D��268�>�D',/'(:(6�,1�)2-.(6�26�*4�)(*14�1,C�?(*61�
*34(6�+(*4'���@������������ 1(/4,2-�H@���@�*��H����*-?�'(*)4'�/*6(�
60 John H. Fisher
962:,+(61�8((9�4'(,6�6(/26+1�)2-.(6�4'*-�4'(�5,-,505�9(6,2+�23�4,5(�9(65,44(+�0-+(6��(D��268�)*D�
�$���%������#���"������������#�����#�������
�-+(6��0;),/��(*)4'�*D�1(/4,2-��&�&�>�(-4,4)(+� �'*))(-.(1�42�
*//06*/?!>� ?20� '*:(� *� 6,.'4� 42� 1((>� .(4� *� /29?� 23>� *-+� *5(-+�
?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+�*1�)2-.�*1�4'(�'(*)4'�/*6(�962:,+(6�'*1�,4��
�'(-�?20�6(*+�?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�*-+�?20�=-+�125(4',-.�
4'*4�,1�-24�*//06*4(>�?20�'*:(�4'(�6,.'4�42�*5(-+�?206�5(+,/*)�
6(/26+�;?�*++,-.�,-3265*4,2-�42�?206�6(/26+�42�5*8(�,4�526(�
/259)(4(�26�*//06*4(���',1�6,.'4�,1�/*))(+�4'(� 6,.'4�42�*5(-+!�
?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�
�'(6(�*6(�4D2�D*?1�42�*5(-+�?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+�������20�/*-�
D6,4(� *� 14*4(5(-4� *-+� .,:(� ,4� 42� ?206� '(*)4'� /*6(� 962:,+(6� 42�
*++�42�?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+�0-+(6��(D��268�)*D>�26��"���20�/*-�
*18�4'*4�?206�'(*)4'�/*6(�962:,+(6�*5(-+�?206�6(/26+�0-+(6�4'(�
�������6,:*/?��0)(�
�3� ?20�.,:(�?206�9'?1,/,*-�*�D6,44(-� 14*4(5(-4�/'*))(-.,-.�?206�
5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1>� ?206� '(*)4'� /*6(� 962:,+(6� 5014� 5*8(� 4',1�
14*4(5(-4�*�9(65*-(-4�9*64�23�?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+���0;),/��(*)4'�
*D�1(/4,2-��&�&��� �',1�14*4(5(-4�1'*))�;(/25(�*�9(65*-(-4�9*64�
23� 4'(� 9*4,(-4� ,-3265*4,2-� *-+� 1'*))� ;(� 6()(*1(+�D'(-(:(6� 4'(�
,-3265*4,2-�*4�,110(�,1�6()(*1(+�!���20�+2�-24�'*:(�4'(�6,.'4�0-+(6�
�(D��268� )*D�26� 4'(��������6,:*/?��0)(� 42� '*:(� ,-3265*4,2-�
6(52:(+�3625�?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 61
�3� 4'(6(� ,1� 125(2-(�D'2� */41� *1� ?206� 9(612-*)� 6(96(1(-4*4,:(>�
4'(?�010*))?�'*:(�4'(�6,.'4�42�.(4�*-+�*5(-+�?206�6(/26+�2-�?206�
;('*)3����9(612-*)�6(96(1(-4*4,:(�,1�*�9(612-�D'2�'*1�4'(�6,.'4�42�
5*8(�'(*)4'�/*6(�+(/,1,2-1�2-�?206�;('*)3�
�(-(6*))?>� *� 9*6(-4� '*1� 4'(� 6,.'4� 42� .(4� *-+� *5(-+� *� 5,-26�1�
5(+,/*)�6(/26+�6()*4(+�42�46(*45(-4���-��(D��268>�?20�'*:(�4'(1(�
6,.'41�0-4,)�?206�/',)+�406-1��&�
� ���#���%�������������#������#���"���������#�����#������
(326(�5*8,-.� 4',1� 6(E0(14>� ?20�1'20)+� ,+(-4,3?� 4'(�9*64�23� 4'(�
5(+,/*)�6(/26+�4'*4�?20�;(),(:(�,1�,-*//06*4(�26�,-/259)(4(>�*-+�
,+(-4,3?� 4'(� '(*)4'� /*6(� 962:,+(6� 4'*4� 5*+(� 4'(� (-46?� ,-� ?206�
5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�
�206�9'?1,/,*-�,1�*))2D(+�42�6(E0,6(�4'*4�?20�.,:(�',5�*�6(*12-�
4'*4�?20�D*-4�42�/'*-.(�?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+���206�6(E0(14�1'20)+�
,-/)0+(�4'(�4?9(�23�,-3265*4,2-�?20�D*-4�42�/'*-.(>�*�+(1/6,94,2-�
23� 4'(� ,-3265*4,2-�?20�;(),(:(� ,1� ,-*//06*4(�26� ,-/259)(4(>� 4'(�
,-3265*4,2-�4'*4�?20�D*-4�4'(5�42�*++�42�?206�6(/26+>�*-+�4'(�
6(*12-�D'?�4'(�,-3265*4,2-�1'20)+�;(�*++(+�
�20� +2� -24� '*:(� 4'(� 6,.'4� 42� '*:(� ,-3265*4,2-� 4'*4� ,1� ,-� ?206�
6(/26+� 6(52:(+� 26� /'*-.(+�� �20� 2-)?� '*:(� 4'(� 6,.'4� 42��
*++�,-3265*4,2-�
62 John H. Fisher
�,4',-�F@�+*?1�*34(6�?206�9'?1,/,*-�6(/(,:(1�?206�6(E0(14>�'(�5014�
(,4'(6��*++�4'(�,-3265*4,2-�42�?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+�*1�6(E0(14(+>�
26�+(-?�?206�6(E0(14�,-�D6,4,-.�
�����#���"���������#�����#��������������������������������
�3�*�3*5,)?�5(5;(6�+,(1>�*�+,146,;04((�23�4'(�+(/(+(-4>�26�4'(�'2)+(6�
23�*�92D(6�23�*4426-(?>�'*1�4'(�6,.'4�42�2;4*,-�4'(�+(/(+(-4�1�5(+,/*)�
6(/26+1�*1�)2-.�*1�'(<1'(�962:,+(1�*�/29?�23�*�/(64,=(+�/29?�23�
4'(�+(*4'�/(64,=/*4(���0;),/��(*)4'�*D�1(/4,2-��&�$��.����4�,1�-24�
-(/(11*6?� 42� '*:(� *� 9(612-*)� 6(96(1(-4*4,:(� 23� 4'(� +(/(+(-4�1�
�14*4(�*992,-4(+�,-�26+(6�42�.(4�4'(�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1��
�3� 4'(� '2)+(6� 23� *� 92D(6� 23� *4426-(?� 6(E0(141� 4'(� 5(+,/*)�
6(/26+1>�*�/29?�23�4'(�92D(6�23�*4426-(?�5014�;(�962:,+(+�D,4'�
4'(� 6(E0(14� 326� 4'(�5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1�� �(/4,2-� �&�$��.�� 962:,+(1�
4'*4�� �'(6(� 4'(� D6,44(-� 6(E0(14� 326� 9*4,(-4� ,-3265*4,2-R� ,1�
1,.-(+�;?�*�+,146,;04((�23�*�+(/(*1(+�10;B(/4�326�D'25�*�9*4,(-4�
6(96(1(-4*4,:(�'*1�-24�;((-�*992,-4(+>�26�3625�4'(�'2)+(6�23�*�
92D(6�23�*4426-(?�3625�10/'�*�+,146,;04((>�*�/29?�23�4'(�/(64,=/*4(�
23�+(*4'�23�4'(�10;B(/4�1'*))�;(�*44*/'(+�42�4'(�D6,44(-�6(E0(14�!
�� +,146,;04((!�,1�5214�234(-�4'(�19201(�23�4'(�+(/(+(-4>�*-+�,3�
4'(�+(/(+(-4�'*1�106:,:,-.�/',)+6(->�4'(�+(/(+(-4�1�/',)+6(-���3�4'(�
+(/(+(-4�,1�-24�106:,:(+�;?�*�19201(�26�/',)+6(->�4'(�+,146,;04((�
D,))�;(�',1<'(6�9*6(-41>�0-+(6�1(/4,2-��J"���23�4'(��14*4(1>��2D(61�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 63
*-+��60141� *D���� 6(E0(14� 326�5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1�5014� ;(�5*+(� ,-�
D6,4,-.�(,4'(6�42�4'(�,-+,:,+0*)�9'?1,/,*-�26�4'(�'(*)4'�/*6(�3*/,),4?�
���������������%�#�������������������#�����"������
�-+(6��(D��268�)*D>�?20�/*--24�;(�+(-,(+�*//(11�42�?206�5(+,/*)�
6(/26+1� ;(/*01(� ?20� *6(� 0-*;)(� 42� 9*?� 4'(� /29?,-.� 3((�� �0;),/�
�(*)4'�*D�1(/4,2-��%�� ��6()(*1(�23�6(/26+1�0-+(6�4',1�1(/4,2-�
1'*))�-24�;(�+(-,(+�12)()?�;(/*01(�23�,-*;,),4?�42�9*?�!���206�'(*)4'�
/*6(�962:,+(6�*)12�/*--24�+(-?�?206�6(E0(14�326�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�
;(/*01(�?20�'*:(�*-�0-9*,+�5(+,/*)�;,))�
�(������������#������*��������������##����������#�����#�������
�'(��(*)4'� �-106*-/(��264*;,),4?�*-+��//20-4*;,),4?��/4� ��������
6(E0,6(1� 4'*4� 9'?1,/,*-1� ,-3265� 9*4,(-41� 23� 4'(,6� 6,.'4� 42� .(4� *�
/29?�23�4'(,6�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�*-+�+(1/6,;(1�D'(-�*//(11�42�4'(1(�
6(/26+1�5*?�;(�.6*-4(+�42�24'(61�
�'(�4���������'�������'���������,1�*�-24,/(�6(E0,6(+�0-+(6�4'(�������
�6,:*/?��0)(�4'*4�),141�*�9(612-�1�6,.'4�42�2;4*,-�*-+�/266(/4�4'(,6�
5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1���'(� -24,/(� *)12� +(1/6,;(1�D'(-� *� '(*)4'� /*6(�
962:,+(6�/*-�01(�*-+�+,1/)21(�'(*)4'�,-3265*4,2-���'(��24,/(�23�
�6,:*/?��,.'41�5014� .,:(� 4'(�-*5(�*-+� 4()(9'2-(�-05;(6�23� *�
/2-4*/4� 9(612-�D'2� ,1� *;)(� 42� *-1D(6� E0(14,2-1� *;204� .(44,-.�
*-+� *5(-+,-.�5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1���� 9'?1,/,*-�5014� .,:(� *��24,/(�
64 John H. Fisher
23� �6,:*/?��,.'41� 42� *� 9*4,(-4� 2-� 4'(,6� =614� :,1,4� *-+� 092-� 4'(��
9*4,(-4�1�6(E0(14��
��������������"������������ %;99��;��*�#��.������
�'(��(*)4'��-106*-/(��264*;,),4?�*-+��//20-4*;,),4?��/4���������
�6,:*/?��0)(�*-+��(D��268�)*D1�.,:(�?20�6,.'41�42�?206�5(+,/*)�
6(/26+1�� �'(� ������ �6,:*/?� �0)(� (14*;),1'(1� 14*-+*6+1� 4'*4�
*99)?�42�6(/26+1�'()+�;?�'(*)4'�/*6(�962:,+(61�*/6211�4'(�-*4,2->�
*-+� �(D��268� )*D� 1(41� 14*-+*6+1� 326� 6(/26+1� 5*,-4*,-(+� ;?�
'(*)4'�/*6(�962:,+(61�D,4',-�4'(�14*4(���(*)4'�/*6(�962:,+(61�,-��
�(D��268�5014�32))2D�;24'�4'(��������6,:*/?��0)(�*-+��(D�
�268�)*D�
������,1�,-4(-+(+�-24�2-)?�42�9624(/4�?206�5(+,/*)�,-3265*4,2-�
3625�0-D*66*-4(+�+,1/)2106(>�;04�*)12�42�9624(/4�?206�6,.'41�*1�*�
9*4,(-4���(6(�1�'2D�?20�/*-�(C(6/,1(�4'21(�6,.'41�
$��������+� �3�?20�*6(�*�9*4,(-4� ,-�*�'219,4*)>�9(29)(�D'2�/*))�
42�2;4*,-� *� /2-+,4,2-� 6(9264�D,))� ;(� .,:(-� *�2-(�26� 4D2�D26+�
1055*6?>� 10/'� *1� 1(6,201!�26� /6,4,/*)�!� �3� ?20�+2-�4�D*-4� 4'*4�
1055*6?�.,:(->�?20�'*:(�4'(�6,.'4�42�6(E0(14�-2-J+,1/)2106(�
<����*���+� �3�?20�*6(�;(,-.�(C*5,-(+�;?�*�9'?1,/,*-�*-+�?206�
46(*45(-4� ,1�;(,-.�2;1(6:(+�;?�24'(61�D'2�*6(-�4�9*64,/,9*4,-.�
,-�?206�/*6(>�10/'�*1�1*)(1�6(96(1(-4*4,:(1>�/2-10)4*-41�26�23=/(�
*+5,-,146*4261>�?20�/*-�*18�4'(5�42�)(*:(�4'(�6225�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 65
�����+��(*+�/*6(30))?�*-?�96,:*/?�32651�?20�*6(�*18(+�42�1,.-��
�25(�32651�4'*4�*4�=614�*99(*6�2-)?�42�;(�*-�*/8-2D)(+.5(-4�23�
?206�6,.'41�*)12�962:,+(�*04'26,N*4,2-�326�1'*6,-.�23�,-3265*4,2-�
326� 5*68(4,-.� 906921(1>� D',/'� ,1� *))2D(+� 0-+(6� ��������20�
1'20)+�-24�;(�6(E0,6(+�42�1,.-�*-?�+,1/)2106(J/2-1(-4�32651�*1�*�
/2-+,4,2-�23�46(*45(-4�
3��*���+� �01425(6J1*4,13*/4,2-� 106:(?1� *6(� .,:(-� 42� 9*4,(-41�
;?�5*-?�/),-,/1�*-+�'219,4*)1���20�*6(�-24�6(E0,6(+�42�/259)(4(�
4'(5>�;04�4'(?�/*-�'()9�962:,+(61�,5962:(�9*4,(-4�/*6(��(�D*6?�
23�E0(14,2-1�*;204�?206�*.(>�,-/25(�)(:()>�;0?,-.�'*;,41�*-+�V���
/2+(���'(?�6(�526(�),8()?�42�;(�01(+�326�5*68(4,-.�906921(1�
;���#���+� �20� 1'20)+� 2;4*,-� /29,(1� 23� ?206� /*6(� 962:,+(6�1�
-24,/(�23�96,:*/?�96*/4,/(1!�*-+�4'(�-*5(�*-+�9'2-(�-05;(6�23�
4'(�962:,+(6�1�96,:*/?�23=/(6�
(������+��20�/*-�*//(11�125(�23�?206�5(+,/*)�,-3265*4,2-�*4�
-2�/'*6.(�(*/'�?(*6�3625�4'(��(+,/*)��-3265*4,2-�06(*0�
�206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�5*?�;(�+,1/)21(+�D,4'204�*18,-.�26�(:(-�
-24,3?,-.�?20���219,4*)1�D,))�'*-+�2:(6�,-3265*4,2-�6(.*6+,-.�?206�
46(*45(-4� 42� 24'(6� +2/4261>� *-+� 4'(?� D,))� 6(*+,)?� 1'*6(� 4'21(�
+(4*,)1�D,4'�,-106*-/(�/259*-,(1�326�9*?5(-4�906921(1���20.')?�
5,)),2-1� 23� (-4,4,(1� 4'*4� *6(� )221()?� ,-:2):(+� ,-� 4'(� '(*)4'� /*6(�
1?14(5�'*:(�*//(11�42�?206�'(*)4'�/*6(�,-3265*4,2-��
�'(� �(+,/*)� �-3265*4,2-� 06(*0� ����� ,1� *� /(-46*)� +*4*;*1(�
23� 5(+,/*)� ,-3265*4,2-� 1'*6(+� ;?� ,-106*-/(� /259*-,(1��
66 John H. Fisher
�9962C,5*4()?����5,)),2-��5(6,/*-1�*-+��*-*+,*-1�*6(�2-�=)(�,-�
4'(����1�/25904(61���-106*-/(�/259*-,(1�6(9264�,-3265*4,2-�42�
4'(���>�10/'�*1�/2+(1�326�19(/,=/�5(+,/*)�/2-+,4,2-1�*-+�),3(14?)(�
/'2,/(1>�,�(�>�'?9(64(-1,2->�*14'5*>�+,*;(4(1�26�+(96(11,2-�
�'(����+2(1�-24�'*:(�*�=)(�2-�(:(6?2-(��04�,3�?20�'*:(�*����
=)(>�?20�D,))�D*-4�42�;(�106(�,4�1�/266(/4���20�/*-�2;4*,-�*�/29?�
326�36((�2-/(�*�?(*6�;?�/*)),-.��&FF�F#"JF#@��26�;?�:,1,4,-.�4'(�
���1� D(;1,4(>� DDD�5,;�/25>� 26� ?20� /*-� /2-4*/4� 4'(���� *4��
4'(� �(+,/*)� �-3265*4,2-� 06(*0>� ����� 2C� �@�>� �11(C� �4*4,2->�
2142->� �*11*/'01(441� @"��">� 26� ;?� 1(-+,-.� *-� (J5*,)� 42�
,-32),-(Q5,;�/25�
(��#��������� �3� ?20� 1019(/4� ?206� 5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1� '*:(� ;((-�
,59629(6)?� 1'*6(+>� ?20� /*-� *18� 962:,+(61� 326� *-� *//20-4,-.� 23�
*))� +,1/)2106(1���-+(6������>� ?20� '*:(� 4'(� 6,.'4� 42� 6(/(,:(� *-�
*//20-4,-.�23� +,1/)2106(1� 4'*4� *� /2:(6(+� (-4,4?!>� ,�(�>� 9'?1,/,*-�
26�'219,4*)>�5*8(�23�?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�,-�4'(�1,CJ?(*6�9(6,2+�
96(/(+,-.�4'(�+*4(�2-�D',/'�4'(�*//20-4,-.�,1�6(E0(14(+�
7���#��"� %;99+� �,:,)� (-326/(5(-4� 23� �����>� D',/'� /*-�
)(*+�42�=-(1>� ,1� )(34�42�4'(��3=/(�23��,:,)��,.'41�D,4',-�4'(������
(9*645(-4�23��(*)4'�*-+��05*-��(6:,/(1���6,5,-*)�(-326/(5(-4>�
D',/'�/*-�,-/)0+(�=-(1�*-+�96,12-�4(651>�,1�'*-+)(+�;?�4'(������
(9*645(-4�23�K014,/(�
$���+��3�$&>@@@�������/259)*,-41�5*+(�*/6211� 4'(�-*4,2-� ,-�
4'(�9*14�=:(�?(*61>� 4'(��3=/(� 326��,:,)��,.'41�'*1�6(3(66(+�H$%�
/*1(1�42�4'(� (9*645(-4�23�K014,/(�326�/6,5,-*)�9621(/04,2-�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 67
<�#���+��*4,2-*))?>�3(D(6�4'*-�*�'*)3J+2N(-�/*1(1�'*:(�;((-�
9621(/04(+�� �2� /,:,)� =-(1� '*:(� ;((-� ,5921(+>� ;04� 2-(� /*1(�
6(/(-4)?� )(+�42�*�A�@@>@@@�1(44)(5(-4���2� 3*6>�9621(/04261�'*:(�
32/01(+�*)5214�(C/)01,:()?�2-� 4'(� 3(D�9(29)(�D'2�'*:(�.*,-(+�
*//(11�42�9*4,(-4�,-3265*4,2-�D,4'�4'(�,-4(-4�23�1()),-.�,4�26�01,-.�
,4�*1�9*64�23�125(�24'(6�/6,5(>�10/'�*1�,+(-4,4?�4'(34���(*)4'�/*6(�
D268(61�D'2�'*:(�2;4*,-(+�5(+,/*)�,-3265*4,2-�,59629(6)?�*-+�
4'(-�1'*6(+�,4>�36((�23�/'*6.(>�D,4'�36,(-+1�*-+�-(,.';261>�'*:(�-24�
;((-�9621(/04(+�
������������������������"������������#�����#����'� %;99����:���=���������
24'���'(��������6,:*/?��0)(>�(33(/4,:(�;(.,--,-.��96,)��H>�"@@$>�
,1� 4'(� =614� (:(6� 3(+(6*)� 96,:*/?� 14*-+*6+1� 42� 9624(/4� 9*4,(-4�1�
5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1� *-+� 24'(6� 5(+,/*)� ,-3265*4,2-�� �'(� 3(+(6*)�
96,:*/?�14*-+*6+1�(14*;),1'(+�;?�������+2�-24�*33(/4�14*4(�)*D1�
4'*4�962:,+(�*++,4,2-*)�96,:*/?�9624(/4,2-1�326�9*4,(-41��
�'(��������6,:*/?��0)(�1(41�*�-*4,2-*)� S226!�23�96,:*/?�14*-+*6+1�
4'*4�9624(/4�*))��5(6,/*-1>�*-+�*-?�14*4(�)*D�962:,+,-.�*++,4,2-*)�
9624(/4,2-1>� 10/'�*1��(D��268�1��0;),/��(*)4'�*D�1(/4,2-1��%�
*-+� �&>� /2-4,-0(1� 42� *99)?���20� /*-� 6()?� 092-�;24'� 4'(�������
�6,:*/?��0)(�*-+��(D��268�1��0;),/��(*)4'�*D�,-�*11(64,-.�*//(11�
42�?206�'(*)4'�/*6(�6(/26+1�
68 John H. Fisher
� ������%�!�����#��������������� %;99�*����������
�(6(�1�'2D�42�=)(�*�/259)*,-4�*;204�*�������:,2)*4,2-���259)*,-41�
.2�42�4'(������ (9*645(-4�23��(*)4'�*-+��05*-��(6:,/(1���3=/(�
326��,:,)��,.'41���'(��3=/(�326��,:,)��,.'41�,-:(14,.*4(1�/259)*,-41�
*.*,-14�5*-?�+,33(6(-4�4?9(1�23�(-4,4,(1>�,-/)0+,-.�-*4,2-*)�9'*65*/?�
/'*,-1>�5*B26�5(+,/*)�/(-4(61>�.6209�'(*)4'�9)*-1>�'219,4*)�/'*,-1>�
*-+� 15*))� 962:,+(6�23=/(1���2D(:(6>� 4'(�23=/(� 4())1� /2-105(61�
4'*4�,4� /*--24�)228�,-42�*))�/,:,)�6,.'41�26�96,:*/?�/259)*,-41�!
�259)*,-41�5014�;(�5*+(�,-�D6,4,-.���20�/*-�+2D-)2*+�*�/259)*,-4�
3265�3625�DDD�''1�.2:<2/6�*-+�32))2D�4'(�),-8�5*68(+� �2D�42�
=)(�*�'(*)4'J,-3265*4,2-�96,:*/?�/259)*,-4�!��259)*,-41�4?9,/*))?�
5014�;(�=)(+�D,4',-��&@�+*?1�23�*�:,2)*4,2-��
������������#���������������*�����������#�����#�����������
2-�4� ;(� 10696,1(+�� 2/4261� ,-� 15*))� 5(+,/*)� 96*/4,/(1� 234(-�
6(301(�42�*))2D�4'(,6�9*4,(-41�42�'*:(�*//(11�42�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1��
�',1�,1�D'(-�?20�*11(64�?206�6,.'41O�
�',1�;228�.,:(1�?20�/,4*4,2-1�42�4'(�)*D�4'*4�6(E0,6(�4'(�'(*)4'�
/*6(�962:,+(6� 42�*))2D�?20� 42� ,-19(/4�*-+�/29?�23� 4'(�5(+,/*)�
6(/26+1���'(�=614� 14(9� ,1� 42� *+:,1(� 4'(�'(*)4'� /*6(� 962:,+(6�23�
?206�6,.'41�0-+(6�4'(�)*D�*-+�*18�4'(�+2/426�42�(C9)*,-�,-�D6,4,-.�
D'?�'(�,1�-24�/259)?,-.�D,4'�?206�14*40426?�6,.'41���3�4',1�3*,)1>�?20�
1'20)+�-24,3?�4'(�9'?1,/,*-�4'*4�?20�,-4(-+�42�5*8(�*�/259)*,-4�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 69
D,4�4'(����� (9*645(-4�23��(*)4'�*;204�',1�6(301*)�42�9(65,4�
*//(11� 42� ?206� 6(/26+1���4� 4'*4� 92,-4>� ?20� D,))� *)5214� *)D*?1�
6(/(,:(�/229(6*4,2-�3625�4'(�9'?1,/,*-�
�������������������������������������������������"�����������
�:(6?4',-.� ,1� -(.24,*;)(>� (:(-� ?206� '219,4*)� ;,))�� �3� ?20� *6(�
*52-.� 4'(� 0-,-106(+ID'2� /*-� 9*?� 09� 42� 4'6((� 4,5(1� 526(�
326�962/(+06(1I,4�+2(1�-24�'064�42�*18�326�*�6(+0/4,2-�,-�?206�
'219,4*)�;,))���25(�'219,4*)1�962:,+(�*�H@L�+,1/20-4�326�0-,-106(+�
9*4,(-41� *-+� '219,4*)1� 36(E0(-4)?� D268� D,4'� 9*4,(-41� 233(6,-.�
9*?5(-4�9)*-1�26�+,1/20-41���-�125(�/*1(1>�4'(�'219,4*)�D,))�D*,:(�
,41�;,))�/259)(4()?�
�20� 1'20)+� )228� 326� 4'(� 23=/(� 23� 9*4,(-4� *//20-41� 26� 4'(�
=-*-/,*)�*11,14*-/(�23=/(�*4�4'(�'219,4*)���'(�14*33�,-�4',1�23=/(�
D,))�(C9)*,-�4'(�962/(+06(1�326�1((8,-.�*�6(+0/4,2-�26�D*,:(6�23�
?206�'219,4*)�;,))�
�������������������������������#����������������"�������
�'(6(� *6(� 4'6((� 19(/,=/� +2/05(-41� 4'*4� *6(� 6(E0,6(+� 2-� *))�
-061,-.�'25(�/'*641�0-+(6� 3(+(6*)� )*D�8-2D-�*1� 4'(��5-,;01�
0+.(4��(/2-/,),*4,2-��/4� ������� �3�?20�*6(�/2-/(6-(+�*;204�
/*6(� 962:,+(+� 42� ?20� 26� *� )2:(+� 2-(� *4� *� -061,-.� '25(>� ?20�
1'20)+�*18�42�6(:,(D�4'(��,-,505� *4*��(4��� ��>�4'(��(1,+(-4�
70 John H. Fisher
�11(115(-4��6242/2)�������*-+�4'(�,-+,:,+0*)��*6(��)*-�D,4'�4'(�
5(+,/*)�+,6(/426�23�4'(�-061,-.�'25(�
T��� �,-,505� *4*� �(4� �� ���� �'(� �,-,505� *4*� �(4� ,1� *�
/2596('(-1,:(�*11(115(-4�23�4'(�6(1,+(-4�1�30-/4,2-*)�/*9*;,),4,(1�
*-+�'()91�4'(�-061,-.�14*33�,+(-4,3?�'(*)4'�962;)(51���(64*,-�,4(51�
2-� 4'(� � �� D,))� ,-+,/*4(� 4'*4� *� 6(1,+(-4� ,1� *4� 6,18>� ,�(�>� 3*)),-.>�
96(1106(�126(1>�06,-*6?�46*/4�,-3(/4,2-1>�(4/���'(-�*�� ��1'2D1�*�
'(*)4'�962;)(5>�,4�46,..(61�4'(��(1,+(-4��11(115(-4��6242/2)�
T"�� �(1,+(-4��11(115(-4� �6242/2)� ��������34(6� 4'(� �,-,505�
*4*��(4� ,1�/259)(4(+>�*�6(1,+(-4�D'2�'*1�2-(�26�526(�6,181�
�*)12� 8-2D-� *1� 46,..(61!��D,))� 46,..(6� *� �(1,+(-4��11(115(-4�
�6242/2)���',1�3265�,1�42�962:,+(�/)0(1�*1�42�6,181�96(1(-4(+�;?�
6(1,+(-41�,-�-061,-.�'25(1���'(��(1,+(-4��11(115(-4��6242/2)�
,1�4'(� 320-+*4,2-�092-�D',/'�*�6(1,+(-4�1� ,-+,:,+0*)��*6(��)*-�
,1�3265(+�
T$���*6(� �)*-1���'(��*6(� �)*-� 1'20)+� /2-4*,-� ,-4(6:(-4,2-1� 42�
5,-,5,N(�,-B06,(1���C*59)(1�23�10/'�,-4(6:(-4,2-1�,-/)0+(�4'(�01(�
23�*�1,44(6�*-+�4'(�01(�23�;(+�*-+�/'*,6�*)*651�326�6(1,+(-41�*4��
6,18�23�3*)),-.�
�������#������*���������"�����"���������"���"������������#��������#��������������������������
�-�,-3265(+�/2-1(-4�+2/05(-4�,1�*�3265�4'*4�?206�+2/426�D,))�
*18� ?20� 42� 1,.-� ;(326(� ?20� '*:(� *-� 29(6*4,2-���'(� /2-4(-4� 23�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 71
4'(� ,-3265(+�/2-1(-4�+2/05(-4�:*6,(1� 326�(:(6?�9'?1,/,*-�*-+�
'219,4*)� *-+� ,-� 125(� /*1(1>� 9*64,/0)*6)?� ,-� 29'4'*)52)2.?� *-+�
9)*14,/�106.(6?>�?20�5*?�;(�D*,:,-.�?206�)(.*)�6,.'41�D'(-�?20�1,.-�
4'(�+2/05(-4���26�(C*59)(>�*�9)*14,/�106.(2-�5*?�6(E0,6(� 4'*4�
?20�1,.-�*-�,-3265(+�/2-1(-4�+2/05(-4�;(326(�?206�29(6*4,2-�
4'*4�6(*+1�*1�32))2D1�
�
�'20)+� *� 5(6,426,201� 5(+,/*)� 5*)96*/4,/(� /*1(�
26�/*01(�23�*/4,2-�;(�,-,4,*4(+�26�90610(+>����4'(�
9*4,(-4�� *-+<26�5?� 6(96(1(-4*4,:(� *.6((� 42� 01(�
����;2*6+J/(64,=(+�(C9(64�5(+,/*)�D,4-(11�(1��
,-� 4'(� 1*5(� 26� 1,5,)*6� 19(/,*)4?� *1� 6�� K2-(1�
W=/4,4,201�-*5(XR�,-*))?>�?20��4'(�9*4,(-4��*.6((�
4'*4�/20-1()�326�5(��9'?1,/,*-��1'*))�'*:(�4'(�6,.'4�
*-+�;(�36((�42�+(921(�10/'�(C9(64�D,4-(11(1�*4�
)(*14��"@�+*?1�;(326(�*-?�1/'(+0)(+�46,*)�+*4(R
�'20)+� *� ;6(*/'� 23� 4',1� �.6((5(-4� 6(10)4� ,-�
),4,.*4,2->�4'(�96(:*,),-.�9*64?�,-�4'(�),4,.*4,2-�1'*))�
;(� (-4,4)(+� 42� 6(*12-*;)(� /2141>� (C9(-1(1� *-+�
*4426-(?�3((1�*112/,*4(+�D,4'�4'(�),4,.*4,2-�
�
�'*4�1�D62-.�D,4'�4',17��-+(6��(D��268�)*D>�4'(�+(3(-+*-41�'*:(�
-2�6,.'4� 42�4*8(�*�+(921,4,2-�23� 4'(�9)*,-4,33 �1�(C9(64�D,4-(11(1�
*-+�3064'(6>�4'(�+(3(-+*-41�*6(�-24�(-4,4)(+�42�+,1/)2106(�23�4'(�
,+(-4,4?�23�?206�5(+,/*)�(C9(64�D,4-(11���064'(6526(>�,4�,1�*�;*1,/�
96,-/,9)(�23� )*D�4'*4�4'(�10//(1130)�9*64?� ,-�9(612-*)� ,-B06?�*-+�
5(+,/*)�5*)96*/4,/(�)*D10,41�,1�-24�(-4,4)(+�42�6(/2:(6�*4426-(?�
3((1�*.*,-14�4'(�)21,-.�9*64?���(-/(>�,-�4',1�/*1(>�4'(�9'?1,/,*-�,1�
72 John H. Fisher
*44(594,-.�42�+(96,:(�?20�23�;*1,/�6,.'41�;?�*18,-.�?20�42�1,.-�4'(�
,-3265(+�/2-1(-4�+2/05(-4�
�
?�1,.-,-.�4',1�,-3265(+�/2-1(-4�+2/05(-4>�?20�*6(�1,.-,-.�*D*?�
;*1,/�6,.'41�4'*4�?20�'*:(�0-+(6��(D��268�)*D���-�#�L�23�1,40*4,2-1>�
4'(� 9*4,(-4� ,1� *-C,201� *;204� ',1<'(6� 29(6*4,2-� *-+� 1,.-1� 4'(�
,-3265(+�/2-1(-4�+2/05(-4�D,4'204�6(*+,-.�,4���-�4'(�6(5*,-,-.�
�L�23� 4'(�/*1(1�D'(6(� 4'(�9*4,(-4� */40*))?� 6(*+1� 4'(� ,-3265(+�
/2-1(-4� +2/05(-4>� '(<1'(� '*1� -2� ,+(*� *;204� 4'(,6� )(.*)� 6,.'41�
0-+(6��(D��268�)*D�*-+�D,))�),8()?�*1105(�4'*4�4'(�/2-+,4,2-1�1(4�
3264'�,-�4'(�,-3265(+�/2-1(-4�+2/05(-4�*6(�6(*12-*;)(>�3*,6�*-+�
/259)?�D,4'�4'(�)*D�
�
�20�1'20)+�*18�?206�9'?1,/,*-� 42�6(:,(D� 4'(� ,-3265(+�/2-1(-4�
+2/05(-4�D,4'�?20�,-�4'(�23=/(�1(44,-.�+*?1�;(326(�4'(�29(6*4,2-�
�6*4'(6� 4'*-�2-� 4'(�526-,-.�23� 4'(�29(6*4,2-�>� 12�?20�*6(�-24�
0-+(6�96(1106(�42�1,.-�,4�*-+�/*-�*18�4'(�9'?1,/,*-�E0(14,2-1�*;204�
4'(� 6,181� *-+� /259),/*4,2-1� 23� 4'(� 29(6*4,2-���20�5*?� *18� 4'(�
+2/426�42�6(52:(�9264,2-1�23�4'(� ,-3265(+�/2-1(-4�+2/05(-4�
4'*4�?20�=-+�2;B(/4,2-*;)(�� �4�/*-�4�'064�42�*18�*-+�?20�D,))�;(�
10696,1(+�4'*4�5214�9'?1,/,*-1�*6(�-24�3*5,),*6�D,4'�4'(�3265�*-+�
'*:(�-(:(6�(C9)*,-(+�,4�42�*-?�23�4'(,6�9*4,(-41�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 73
���� ������+0�����5������������ ������6��������
���� ������������
�*-?� 5*)96*/4,/(� 46,*)1� ;2,)� +2D-� 42� 4'(� 12J/*))(+� ;*44)(�
23� 4'(� (C9(641>!� D,4'� 5(+,/*)� (C9(641� 2-� (*/'� 1,+(� 4*8,-.�
/2-S,/4,-.� 921,4,2-1�� �:(-� 4'20.'� 4'(� 3*/41� 23� ?206� /*1(� 5*?�
'*:(�2:(6D'()5,-.�(:,+(-/(�23�5(+,/*)�-(.)(/4>�4'(�B06?�,1�)(34�42�
+(/,+(�D',/'�(C9(64�,1�4()),-.�4'(�4604'I234(-�*-�,59211,;)(�4*18�
326�*�B06?�D,4'�-2�5(+,/*)�46*,-,-.�26�(C9(64,1(��
�2D�+2� ?20� 962:(� 4'*4� 4'(� +(3(-1(� (C9(64� ,1� *� ),*67��'(� =614�
14(9�,1�=),-.�*�/259)*,-4�*.*,-14�4'(�9'?1,/,*-�26�'219,4*)�D,4'�4'(�
�(D��268��4*4(� (9*645(-4�23��(*)4'���'(��3=/(�23��623(11,2-*)�
�(+,/*)� �2-+0/4� � ����!�� ,1� 6(192-1,;)(� 326� ,-:(14,.*4,-.�
/259)*,-41� *;204�9'?1,/,*-1>� 9'?1,/,*-1�� *11,14*-41� *-+� 19(/,*),14�
*11,14*-41���'(������*)12�52-,4261�96*/4,4,2-(61�D'2�'*:(�;((-�
9)*/(+�2-�962;*4,2-��
�'(� (9*645(-4�23��(*)4'>��3=/(�23��623(11,2-*)��(+,/*)��2-+0/4>�
,-:(14,.*4(1� *))� 6(92641� 23� 9211,;)(� 9623(11,2-*)� 5,1/2-+0/4� ;?�
9'?1,/,*-1�*-+�9'?1,/,*-1��*11,14*-41���-�,-:(14,.*4,2-�5*?�6(10)4�,-�
*�3265*)�'(*6,-.�;(326(�*�/255,44((�23�4'(�2*6+�326��623(11,2-*)�
�(+,/*)��2-+0/4���-3265*4,2-�6(.*6+,-.�=-*)�+,1/,9),-*6?�*/4,2-1�
4*8(-� *.*,-14� 4'(��(D��268�5(+,/*)� ),/(-1(1� 23� 9'?1,/,*-1� *-+�
9'?1,/,*-1��*11,14*-41�,1�*�5*44(6�23�90;),/�6(/26+��
74 John H. Fisher
�20�/*-�=)(�*�/259)*,-4�*.*,-14�*�9'?1,/,*-�D,4'� 4'(��(D��268�
�4*4(� (9*645(-4� 23� �(*)4'>� �3=/(� 23� �623(11,2-*)� �(+,/*)�
�2-+0/4�*4�4'(��(D��268��4*4(� (9*645(-4�23��(*)4'>��3=/(�23�
�623(11,2-*)��(+,/*)��2-+0/4>�H$$��,:(6��46((4>��0,4(�$@$>��62?>�
�(D��268��"�&@J""##���259)*,-41�5014�;(�,-�D6,4,-.���20�/*-�.(4�
,-3265*4,2-�*;204�=),-.�*�/259)*,-4�*-+�+2D-)2*+�*�/259)*,-4�
3265� *4�� DDD�'(*)4'�14*4(�-?�01<-?1+2'<295/<5*,-�'45� �20�
/*-�*)12�/*))��J&@@JFF$JF��%�42�.(4�*�/259)*,-4� 3265�26� ,3�?20��
'*:(�E0(14,2-1�
�,-+,-.1�23�5(+,/*)�-(.)(/4�,110(+�;?�4'(� (9*645(-4�23��(*)4'�
*6(�125(4,5(1�*+5,11,;)(�,-�(:,+(-/(�*4�*�46,*)>�*-+�D'(-�*+5,44(+�
,-42�(:,+(-/(>�10/'�=-+,-.1�/*-�;(�:(6?�92D(630)�,-�/2-:,-/,-.�
*�B06?�4'*4�?206�5(+,/*)�(C9(64�,1�4()),-.�4'(�4604'���'(� ;*44)(�
23�4'(�(C9(641!�,1�-2�)2-.(6�*�;*44)(�D,4'�4',1�92D(630)�(:,+(-/(�
,-�'*-+�
��������������#�����������<!#����;�����������>���#���$����#�������������"�����������#������������������
�6,44(-�/259)*,-41�*6(�6(:,(D(+�;?�4'(������,-:(14,.*4,:(�*-+�
5(+,/*)� 14*33�� �259)*,-41� 4'*4� 6*,1(� 9211,;)(�5,1/2-+0/4� ,110(1�
*6(� *11,.-(+� 42� ,-:(14,.*4261� *-+������5(+,/*)� /226+,-*4261�
962:,+(�/),-,/*)�*+:,/(�42�4'(�,-:(14,.*4261�
�?9,/*))?>� /259)*,-*-41>� +2/4261� *-+� 24'(61� ,-:2):(+� *6(�
,-4(6:,(D(+���-4(6:,(D1�5*?�;(�/2-+0/4(+�2:(6�4'(�4()(9'2-(�26�
5*?�;(�,-�9(612-���259)*,-*-41��,+(-4,4,(1�*6(�8(94�/2-=+(-4,*)�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 75
�3� *-� ,-:(14,.*4,2-� 0-/2:(61� 103=/,(-4� (:,+(-/(� 42� 10..(14�
5,1/2-+0/4>�4'(�/*1(�,1�96(1(-4(+�42�*-�,-:(14,.*4,2-�/255,44((�
/2-1,14,-.� 23� 4D2� 9'?1,/,*-1� *-+� 2-(� )*?� 9(612-� +6*D-� 3625�
4'(�2*6+�23��623(11,2-*)��(+,/*)��2-+0/4��4'(� 2*6+!����'(�
/255,44((�/*-�6(/255(-+�42�4'(� ,6(/426�*-?�23�4'(�32))2D,-.��
*�'(*6,-.>�*++,4,2-*)� ,-:(14,.*4,2->�*�+,15,11*)�23�4'(�5*44(6>�26�
-2-J+,1/,9),-*6?�D*6-,-.1�26�/2-10)4*4,2-1�
�3� 4'(� ,-:(14,.*4,2-� /255,44((� =-+1� (:,+(-/(� 10..(14,-.�
5,1/2-+0/4>� 26� ,3� 4'(� /255,11,2-(6� 26+(61� *� 1055*6?�
1019(-1,2->�/'*6.(1�*6(�=)(+�*.*,-14�4'(�9'?1,/,*-�*-+�*�'(*6,-.�
,1�'()+���3�103=/,(-4�(:,+(-/(�10..(14,-.�5,1/2-+0/4�,1�-24�320-+>�
4'(�,-:(14,.*4,2-�,1�4(65,-*4(+�*-+�4'(�/*1(�,1�/)21(+����6(/26+�
23�4'(�,-:(14,.*4,2-�6(5*,-1�,-������=)(1�326�30406(�6(3(6(-/(�
�*1(1�26+(6(+�42�'(*6,-.�.2�;(326(�*-24'(6�/255,44((�23� 4'(�
2*6+>�*)12�/2-1,14,-.�23�4D2�9'?1,/,*-1�*-+�*�)*?�5(5;(6>�D',/'�
'(*61�*-+�6(:,(D1�(:,+(-/(�3625�;24'�1,+(1���'(�9'?1,/,*-�*-+�4'(�
14*4(�*6(�010*))?�6(96(1(-4(+�;?�/20-1()�D'2�,-462+0/(�(:,+(-/(�
*-+�/*))�*-+�E0(14,2-�D,4-(11(1���'(�/255,44((�60)(1�2-�4'(�/*1(�
*-+�+(4(65,-(1�,3�*�9(-*)4?�,1�D*66*-4(+�
�'(� '(*6,-.� /255,44((� +(/,1,2-� 5*?� ;(� *99(*)(+� ;?� (,4'(6�
1,+(� 42� *-��+5,-,146*4,:(� �(:,(D� 2*6+� /25921(+� 23� 4'6((�
9'?1,/,*-1� *-+� 4D2� )*?�5(5;(61�23� 4'(�2*6+�23� �623(11,2-*)�
�(+,/*)��2-+0/4�
�'(�2*6+�23��623(11,2-*)��(+,/*)��2-+0/4�'*1�4'(�*04'26,4?�42�
4*8(�*/4,2-�*.*,-14�*�9'?1,/,*-�1�),/(-1(����9'?1,/,*-�1�),/(-1(�/*-�
76 John H. Fisher
;(�6(:28(+�26�1019(-+(+���'(�2*6+�/*-�*)12�),5,4�*�9'?1,/,*-�1�
),/(-1(M�,110(�*�/(-106(�*-+�6(96,5*-+M�26�(+0/*4,2-�26�6(46*,-,-.M�
)(:?�*�=-(M�26�6(E0,6(�/2550-,4?�1(6:,/(��
�-:(14,.*4,:(� =)(1� *6(� /2-=+(-4,*)� *-+� *6(� -24� +,1/)21(+� 42�
/259)*,-*-41�26�9'?1,/,*-1�
�-�4'(�/*1(�23�*�'219,4*)>�,3�4'(�,-:(14,.*4,2-�;?�4'(� (9*645(-4�23�
�(*)4'�10;14*-4,*4(1�4'(�*))(.*4,2-1�,-�?206�/*1(>�,4�D,))�,110(�*�3265*)�
+2/05(-4�4'*4�),141�4'(�+(=/,(-/,(1�*-+�96(:(-4*;)(�5(+,/*)�(66261M�
,-�4'(�/*1(�23�'219,4*)1>�,4�D,))�6(E0,6(�4'*4�4'(�'219,4*)�10;5,4�*�9)*-�
23�/266(/4,2-�42�(-106(�4'*4�30406(�5(+,/*)�(66261�*6(�96(:(-4(+�
����������������������%���#�����������#�������������<;>$��
�-�4'(�/259)*,-4� 3265>�?20�1'20)+�+(1/6,;(�?206�/259)*,-4�*1�
4'2620.')?� *1� 9211,;)(� *-+� ,-/)0+(� 4'(� -*5(1>� *++6(11(1� *-+�
4()(9'2-(�-05;(61�23�D,4-(11(1���'(-�96(9*6,-.�*�/259)*,-4�326�
*�/),(-4>���234(-�96(9*6(�*�5(52�1055*6,N,-.�4'(�3*/41�*-+�*--(C�
*�/29?�23�4'(�5(+,/*)�6(/26+1�42�4'(�/259)*,-4�3265�,-�26+(6�42�
/2-=65�4'(�/2-4(-4�23�4'(�/259)*,-4��
� ������%�!�����#���������"����������������
�3�?20�'*:(�*�/259)*,-4�*;204�*�'219,4*)>�?20�/*-�/*))�4'(�42))J36((�
4()(9'2-(�-05;(6>��J&@@J&@HJ�HH%>�26�?20�5*?�=)(�*�/259)*,-4�
*-+� 1(-+� ,4� 42� 4'(� �(D��268� �4*4(� (9*645(-4� 23� �(*)4'>�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 77
�(-46*),N(+��219,4*)��-4*8(��62.6*5>�H$$��,:(6��46((4>�F4'��)226>�
�62?>��(D��268��"�&@��
� ������%�!�����#���������"��������?�����#����'���#�����������'������������������#��������������
�3� ?20� 3(()� ?20� 6(/(,:(+� -(.),.(-4� /*6(� 3625� '(*)4'/*6(�
9623(11,2-*)>�10/'�*1�-061(1>�+(-4,141>�12/,*)�D268(61>�29425(46,141>�
91?/'2)2.,141>�9'?1,/*)�26�2//09*4,2-*)�4'(6*9,141>�26�92+,*46,141>�
?20� /*-� =)(� *� /259)*,-4� ;?� /2-4*/4,-.� 4'(� �(D��268� �4*4(�
�+0/*4,2-� (9*645(-4>��3=/(�23��623(11,2-*)� ,1/,9),-(>�H%���*68�
�:(-0(>��(/2-+��)226>��(D��268>��(D��268��@@�F���'(�/259)*,-4�
'24),-(� ,1��J�&@@JHH"J&�@F���20�/*-�.(4� ,-3265*4,2-�*;204�=),-.�
/259)*,-41>� .(44,-.� *� ),14� 23� 6(.,2-*)� 23=/(1� *-+� +2D-)2*+,-.� *�
/259)*,-4�3265�*4�DDD�29�-?1(+�.2:<29+�'45�26�DDD�29�-?1(+<
.2:<3*E�'45T/259)*,-�
�3� 4'(� ,-:(14,.*4,2-� ;?� 4'(� �+0/*4,2-� (9*645(-4>� �3=/(� 23�
�623(11,2-*)� ,1/,9),-(�10;14*-4,*4(1�4'(�*))(.*4,2-1�,-�?206�/*1(>�
,4� D,))� ,110(� *� 3265*)� +2/05(-4� 4'*4� ),141� 4'(� +(=/,(-/,(1� *-+�
96(:(-4*;)(�(66261�
�20�/*-�*)12�=-+�204�,3�*�+(-4,14�'*1�*-?�8,-+�23�)(.*)�*/4,2-�4*8(-�
*.*,-14�',5�26�'(6�;?�/2-4*/4,-.�4'(� (9*645(-4�23��+0/*4,2-��
�2�.(4�*�30))�/29?�23�4'(�*/4,2-1�4*8(-�*.*,-14�*�+(-4,14>�?20�5014�
1(-+� *�D6,44(-� 6(E0(14� 4'*4� ,-/)0+(1� 4'(� -*5(>� 9623(11,2-� *-+�
),/(-1(�-05;(6�23�4'(�+(-4,14�42�4'(��(D��268��4*4(��+0/*4,2-�
78 John H. Fisher
(9*645(-4>� ,:,1,2-� 23� �623(11,2-*)� ,/(-1,-.� �(6:,/(1>� �225�
$@H�>��0)406*)��+0/*4,2-��(-4(6>��);*-?>��(D��268��""$H�
� ������%�!�����#���������"�������������"�������
�'(� �(D��268� �4*4(� ,:,1,2-� 23� G0*),4?� *-+� �06:(,))*-/(� 326�
�061,-.� �25(1� *-+� �-4(65(+,*4(� �*6(� �*/,),4,(1� � G��� ,1�
6(192-1,;)(� 326� ,-:(14,.*4,-.� /259)*,-41� *-+� ,-/,+(-41� *.*,-14�
-061,-.�'25(1�,-��(D��268��4*4(���259)*,-41�*-+�,-/,+(-41�5*?�
;(� 10;5,44(+�;?� 3*C� ���&JH@&J���%��26�;?�5*,)� 42���(-46*),N(+�
�259)*,-4��-4*8(��-,4>��F�� ()*D*6(��:(-0(>� ()5*6>��(D��268�
�"@�H���20�/*-�*)12�/*))�4'(����� (9*645(-4�23��(*)4'�1��061,-.�
�25(�/259)*,-4�'24),-(�*4��J&&&J"@�JH�F$>�*:*,)*;)(�"H�'2061�*�
+*?>�%�+*?1�*�D((8�
�'(�5214�1(6,201�/259)*,-41�*-+�,-/,+(-41�6(E0,6(� (9*645(-4�
,-:(14,.*4261� 42� /2-+0/4� ,-4(6:,(D1>� 6(:,(D� 5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1>�
*-+� 24'(6� 3*/,),4?� +2/05(-4*4,2->� *-+� 9(63265� 24'(6�
*/4,:,4,(1� 2-1,4(� *4� 4'(� -061,-.� '25(�� �3� *-� ,-:(14,.*4,2-�
+(4(65,-(1� 4'*4� *-?� 23� 4'(� *))(.*4,2-1� +,+� 2//06>� 4'(-� 4'(��
*))(.*4,2-�,1�1014*,-(+�
�'(�,-:(14,.*4,2-�D,))�*)12�+(4(65,-(�D'(4'(6�*�-061,-.�'25(�'*1�
3*,)(+�42�5((4�3(+(6*)�*-+<26�14*4(�6(.0)*4,2-1���-�/*1(1�D'(6(�4'(�
(9*645(-4�23��(*)4'�+(4(65,-(1�4'*4�4'(�-061,-.�'25(�:,2)*4(+�
*�6(.0)*4,2->�4'(� (9*645(-4�D,))�,110(�*�/,4*4,2-�42�4'(�-061,-.�
'25(���'(�-061,-.�'25(�5014�4'(-�10;5,4�*�9)*-�23�/266(/4,2-�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 79
4'*4�,1�*//(94*;)(�42�4'(� (9*645(-4�23��(*)4'�*-+�/266(/4�4'(�
+(=/,(-4�96*/4,/(�
�++,4,2-*))?>� 4'(� �4*4(��3=/(� 326� 4'(��.,-.� �������(59)2?1� *-�
25;0+15*-� ,-� (*/'� �20-4?� 23� �(D��268���-� 25;0+15*-� ,1�
*-� *+:2/*4(� 326� 6(1,+(-41� 23� -061,-.� '25(1� *-+� *11,14(+� ),:,-.�
3*/,),4,(1���5;0+15*-�962:,+(� ,-3265*4,2-�*;204�'2D�42�=-+�*�
-061,-.�'25(�4'*4� ,1� 6,.'4� 326�?20�26�?206� 3*5,)?�5(5;(6�*-+�
D'*4�42�+2�42�.(4�E0*),4?�/*6(���'(�25;0+15*-�/*-�*)12�*11,14�?20�
D,4'�*�/259)*,-4�*.*,-14�*�-061,-.�'25(���'(��4*4(��3=/(�326�4'(�
�.,-.�/*-�;(�6(*/'(+�*4��J&@@J$H"J#&%��
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 81
���� ������+1����5�����5��������6������� �
��*�������
�� :*14� 5*B26,4?� 23� 9*4,(-41� )(*:(� 4'(,6� +2/4261�� 23=/(1� 26� 4'(�
(5(6.(-/?� 6225� D,4'204� 0-+(614*-+,-.� 4'(� 46(*45(-4� 4'(?�
6(/(,:(+>�26�'2D�42�/*6(�326�4'(51():(1�2-/(�4'(?�.(4�'25(���',1�
/*-�)(*+�42�5(+,/*4,2-�(66261�*-+�1(6,201�/259),/*4,2-1�4'*4�/*-�
1(-+�4'(5�6,.'4�;*/8�42�4'(�'219,4*)�
�-�*�6(/(-4�140+?>�9*4,(-41�+,1/'*6.(+�3625�(5(6.(-/?�+(9*645(-41�
D(6(�*18(+�326�4'(,6�0-+(614*-+,-.�,-�3206�*6(*1I4'(,6�+,*.-21,1>�
4'(,6� ��� 46(*45(-4>� ,-1460/4,2-1� 326� 4'(,6� ,-J'25(� /*6(>� *-+�
D*6-,-.�1,.-1�23�D'(-�42�6(406-�42�4'(�'219,4*)�
�'(�140+?>�90;),1'(+�2-),-(�;?�4'(��--*)1�23��5(6.(-/?��(+,/,-(>�
320-+� 4'*4� %&� 9(6/(-4� 23� 9*4,(-41� +,+� -24� 0-+(614*-+� *4� )(*14�
2-(�*6(*�*-+�*;204�'*)3�+,+�-24�0-+(614*-+�4D2�26�526(�*6(*1��
�*4,(-4� �2596('(-1,2-� 23� �5(6.(-/?� (9*645(-4� �*6(�
*-+� �-1460/4,2-1���6(� �*4,(-41��D*6(� 23��'(-��'(?� 2� �24�
�-+(614*-+7!� . ���� ��� ������ ��� 5����� ��� �'(� .6(*4(14�
/2-301,2-�106620-+(+�'25(�/*6(I,-1460/4,2-1�*;204�4',-.1�),8(�
5(+,/*4,2-1>�6(14>�D20-+�/*6(>�*-+�D'(-�42�'*:(�*�32))2DJ09�:,1,4��
D,4'�*�+2/426�
�'(�6(1(*6/'(61�+(1/6,;(+�*�D25*-�,-�'(6�4D(-4,(1�D'2�D(-4�42�
4'(�(5(6.(-/?�6225�D,4'�*;+25,-*)�9*,-���34(6�(C4(-1,:(�4(14,-.>�
+2/4261�4'(6(�+,*.-21(+�9():,/� ,-S*55*426?�+,1(*1(>�*�1(C0*))?�
82 John H. Fisher
46*-15,44(+�,-3(/4,2-��04�D'(-�,-4(6:,(D(+�;?�*�6(1(*6/'(6>�4'(�
D25*-� 1*,+� 4'*4� 1'(�D*1� -24� *D*6(� 23� *-?� +,*.-21,1>� 4'*4� 1'(�
+,+�-24�6(*),N(�1'(�'*+�;((-�1(-4�'25(�D,4'�*-�*-4,;,24,/��1'(�
2-)?�4228�4'(�9*,-�5(+,/*4,2-�1'(�D*1�.,:(-�>�*-+�4'*4�1'(�+,+�
-24�8-2D�1'(�1'20)+�*;14*,-�3625�1(C>�4())�'(6�9*64-(6�26�'*:(��
32))2DJ09�/*6(�
�,5,)*6� 6(10)41� '*:(� ;((-� 320-+� 326� 9*4,(-41� )(*:,-.� '219,4*)1>�
-24� B014� (5(6.(-/?� 62251�� �:(6?4',-.� ,1� (C*..(6*4(+� ,-� 4'(�
(5(6.(-/?�+(9*645(-4�� 2/4261� *6(�;01?>� 4'(?�'*:(� ),44)(� 4,5(�
42�.2�2:(6�/259),/*4(+� ,-3265*4,2-�*-+�4'(?�+2�-24�8-2D�4'(�
9*4,(-41���214� 9*4,(-41� *6(� *-C,201>� 091(4� *-+� -24� ),8()?� 42� ;(�
4',-8,-.�/)(*6)?���',1�,1�-24�4'(�;(14�(-:,62-5(-4�326�125(2-(�42�
6(5(5;(6�,-3265*4,2-�
�'(� 962;)(5� ,1� 9*64,/0)*6)?� */04(� D'(-� ,4� /25(1� 42� +60.1����
9*4,(-4J(+0/*4,2-�962.6*5�01(+� ,-��$@�'(*)4'�+(),:(6?� 1?14(51�
*/6211� 4'(�/20-46?� 320-+�4'*4�*;204�H@�9(6/(-4�23�9*4,(-41�F��
26�2)+(6� '*:(� *�5(+,/*4,2-� (6626� *34(6� 4'(?� )(*:(� 4'(�'219,4*)��
��"@@F�6(9264�;?�4'(� �-14,404(�23��(+,/,-(� 320-+�4'*4�+2/4261�
*-+�-061(1�D(6(�/2-46,;04,-.� 42� 4'(1(�(66261�;?�-24�962:,+,-.�
,-3265*4,2-�,-�*-�(33(/4,:(�D*?�
�*4,(-41� D'2� +,+� -24� 32))2D� +,1/'*6.(� ,-1460/4,2-1� *6(� 234(-�
)*;()(+� *1� -2-J/259),*-4�!� �2D(:(6>� +2/4261� *6(� -2426,201)?�
,-(94�*4�/2550-,/*4,-.�42�9*4,(-41�
�'(�-(D�140+?�320-+�4'*4�9(29)(�D(6(�-24�*D*6(�23�D'*4�4'(?�
+,+� -24� 0-+(614*-+>� 10..(14,-.� 4'*4� 1,59)?� *18,-.� *� 9*4,(-4� ,3�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 83
'(� 0-+(614*-+1� ,1� -24� (-20.'�� �)+(6� 9*4,(-41� *6(� 9*64,/0)*6)?�
:0)-(6*;)(� D,4'� /2550-,/*4,2-� ;*66,(61>� 10/'� *1� :,1,2-� *-+�
'(*6,-.�962;)(51��
�C9(641� ,-� +2/426J9*4,(-4� /2550-,/*4,2-� 6(/255(-+� *� 4(*/'�
;*/8!� *9962*/'>� ,-� D',/'� 4'(� 9*4,(-4>� 96(3(6*;)?� *//259*-,(+�
;?�*� 6()*4,:(>� 36,(-+�26�/*6(.,:(6>�'*1� 42�6(9(*4� 4'(� ,-1460/4,2-1��
;*/8�42�4'(�+2/426�
�'(-� 4*)8,-.� D,4'� ?206� +2/426>� *)D*?1� *18� ,3� ?20� +2� -24�
0-+(614*-+� 19(/,=/� D26+1� 4'(� +2/426� ,1� 01,-.� 26� D'*4� ?206�
+2/426�,1�6(/255(-+,-.�,1�-24�/)(*6���*8(�106(�?20�)(*:(�?206�
+2/426�1�23=/(�D,4'�*�/)(*6�0-+(614*-+,-.�23���*��?206�+,*.-21,1>�
�;�� ?206� 46(*45(-4>� �/�� *4J'25(� /*6(� *-+� �+��D*6-,-.� 1,.-1� 23�
D'(-�42�6(406-�42�4'(�'219,4*)�26�+2/426�1�23=/(�
�26�(C*59)(>�?20�1'20)+�*18�?206�+2/426�*-+�,-1,14�2-�*-1D(61�42�
4'(�32))2D,-.�E0(14,2-1��
&�������������� ����/�
�3�?206�+,*.-21,1�,1�0-8-2D->�*18��&������������������ ��������� ����/�.�� �����������!������� ����6����������������������� �����/
������������������������ �����������!������������ ��!�����/
&������������������������������� ������������ ����� /
84 John H. Fisher
&������ �������������!�����/
������ ��� ����%���������������������� /
�))�9*4,(-41� ,-��(D��268��4*4(�'219,4*)1�5014�6(/(,:(�*�D6,44(-�
+,1/'*6.(�9)*-�*-+�*�D6,44(-�+,1/'*6.(�-24,/(�;(326(�4'(?�)(*:(�
4'(�'219,4*)���',1�9)*-�1'20)+�+(1/6,;(�4'(�*66*-.(5(-41�326�*-?�
'(*)4'�/*6(�1(6:,/(1�?20�5*?�-((+�*34(6�?20� )(*:(�4'(�'219,4*)��
�*4,(-41� 5014� ;(� 962:,+(+� D,4'� 4'(� 2992640-,4?� 42� 1,.-� 4'(�
+,1/'*6.(�+2/05(-41�*-+�6(/(,:(�*�/29?�23�4'(�1,.-(+�+2/05(-41��
�@������������1(/4,2-�H@��#�.����>�H@��#�.��$��,��
�4�1�09�42�4'(�9*4,(-41�42�.(4�4'(�,-3265*4,2-�4'(?�-((+�� 2�-24�;(�
*36*,+�42�*18�E0(14,2-1>�/*))>�26�6(406-�42�4'(�'219,4*)�26�+2/426�1�
23=/(�,3�?20�+2�-24�0-+(614*-+�125(4',-.�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 85
���� ������+2�����������5���*����5�������
������
�� 1*:(+� 5?� 5214� ,59264*-4� 4,9� 326� )*14�� �� ����� ���������� ����� � ������O� �214� 5(+,/*)� 5,14*8(1� *6(��(*1,)?�96(:(-4*;)(�
� ������%������������"�����������������
�(D��268�1��*4,(-4�,))�23��,.'41�,1�/2-4*,-(+�,-�4'(��0;),/��(*)4'�
*D�1(/4,2-�"&@$����.�>�*-+��@������������1(/4,2-1�H@��%>�H@��%�*�
����*-+�H@��%�/����:(6?�'219,4*)�,-��(D��268�,1�6(E0,6(+�42�.,:(�*�
D6,44(-�/29?�23�4'(��*4,(-41��,))�23��,.'41�42�(*/'�9*4,(-4�*4�26�
96,26�42�4'(�4,5(�23�4'(�*+5,11,2-�42�4'(�'219,4*)���-32640-*4()?>�
4',1�,1�*)5214�-(:(6�+2-(�
�(D��268�1� �*4,(-4�,))� 23��,.'41� 14*4(1� 4'*4�� �1� *� 9*4,(-4� ,-� *�
'219,4*)�,-��(D��268��4*4(>�?20�'*:(�4'(�6,.'4>�/2-1,14(-4�D,4'�)*D>�
42!>�*52-.�24'(6�4',-.1�
(� ,-3265(+� 23� 4'(� -*5(� *-+� 921,4,2-� 23� 4'(�
+2/426�D'2�D,))�;(�,-�/'*6.(�23�?206�/*6(�,-�4'(�
'219,4*)���T��23�4'(��*4,(-41��,))�23��,.'41�
�-2D�4'(�-*5(1>�921,4,2-1�*-+�30-/4,2-1�23�*-?�
'219,4*)� 14*33� ,-:2):(+� ,-� ?206� /*6(� *-+� 6(301(�
4'(,6�46(*45(-4>�(C*5,-*4,2-�26�2;1(6:*4,2-���TF�
23�4'(��*4,(-41��,))�23��,.'41�
86 John H. Fisher
�*64,/,9*4(�,-�*))�+(/,1,2-1�*;204�?206�46(*45(-4�
*-+� +,1/'*6.(� 3625� 4'(� '219,4*)�� �'(� '219,4*)�
5014� 962:,+(� ?20� D,4'� *� D6,44(-� +,1/'*6.(�
9)*-� *-+� D6,44(-� +(1/6,94,2-� 23� '2D� ?20� /*-�
*99(*)�?206�+,1/'*6.(�� �T�H�23� 4'(��*4,(-41��,))� �
23��,.'41�
�(:,(D� ?206� 5(+,/*)� 6(/26+� D,4'204� /'*6.(��
�;4*,-�*�/29?�23�?206�5(+,/*)�6(/26+�326�D',/'�
4'(� '219,4*)� /*-� /'*6.(� *� 6(*12-*;)(� 3((���20�
/*--24� ;(� +(-,(+� *� /29?� 12)()?� ;(/*01(� ?20�
/*--24� *3326+� 42� 9*?�� �T��� 23� 4'(� �*4,(-41�� ,))� �
23��,.'41�
�259)*,-�D,4'204�3(*6�23�6(96,1*)1�*;204�4'(�/*6(�
*-+� 1(6:,/(1� ?20� *6(� 6(/(,:,-.� *-+� 42�'*:(� 4'(�
'219,4*)�6(192-+�42�?20�*-+� ,3�?20�6(E0(14� ,4>�*�
D6,44(-�6(192-1(���3�?20�*6(�-24�1*4,1=(+�D,4'�4'(�
'219,4*)�1�6(192-1(>�?20�/*-�/259)*,-�42�4'(��(D�
�268��4*4(��(*)4'� (9*645(-4���'(�'219,4*)�5014�
962:,+(�?20�D,4'� 4'(��4*4(��(*)4'� (9*645(-4�
4()(9'2-(� -05;(6�� �T�%� 23� 4'(� �*4,(-41�� ,))� �
23��,.'41�
�20�'*:(� 4'(� 6,.'4� 42�8-2D�*;204� ?206�5(+,/*)� /2-+,4,2-���20�
5014�4*)8�42�?206�+2/426�*;204�?206�'(*)4'�/*6(�E0(14,2-1�
�20�'*:(�4'(�6,.'4�42�;(�30))?�,-3265(+�*;204�+(/,1,2-1�*33(/4,-.�
?206�/*6(����������>�������
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 87
�20� '*:(� 4'(� 6,.'4� 42� +(1,.-*4(� *� 6(96(1(-4*4,:(� 42� */4� 2-��
?206�;('*)3�
�20�'*:(�4'(�6,.'4�42�6(/(,:(�*))�23�4'(�'219,4*)�/*6(�?20�-((+�326�
4'(�46(*45(-4�23�?206�,))-(11�26�,-B06?�
����)�����#���"����������������
�'2�1�,-�/'*6.(7��(44,-.�4'(�*44(-4,2-�23�4'(�6,.'4�9(612-�/*-�;(�
+,3=/0)4�,-�*�'219,4*)��
�061(1�+2�-24�6(9264�42�+2/4261>�;04�6*4'(6�42�-061(�109(6:,1261��
�25(�'219,4*)1�(59)2?� '219,4*),141!I+2/4261�D'2�*/4�*1�*�92,-4�
9(612-�42�/2-+0/4�4'(�S2D�23� ,-3265*4,2-�� �-�4'(�'219,4*)>�?20�
D,))�;(�3*/(+�D,4'�+2/4261�*-+�-061(1�D'2�?20�+2-�4�8-2D�*-+�
'*:(�-(:(6�46(*4(+�?20���'(�-(D�+2/426�*-+�-061(1�*6(�0-3*5,),*6�
D,4'�?206�5(+,/*)�;*/8.620-+>�*-+�?20�+2�-24�8-2D�D'2�42�406-�
42�326�*-1D(61�
(/*01(�23�4'(�/2-301,2-�*1�42�D'2�,1�,-�/'*6.(>�?20�1'20)+�*18>�
�'2� ,1� 4'(� ���� �� �� �������� � 326� 5(7!��'(� 4(65>� *44(-+,-.�
9'?1,/,*-!>� '*1� 19(/,*)� 5(*-,-.� ,-� *� '219,4*)�� �'(� *44(-+,-.�
9'?1,/,*-�1�-*5(�,1�),14(+�,-�;2)+�96,-4�*4�4'(�429�23�?206�5(+,/*)�
/'*64�*-+�4'(�*44(-+,-.�9'?1,/,*-�,1�0)4,5*4()?�6(192-1,;)(�326�4'(�
/*6(�962:,+(+�42�?20���-�5214�/*1(1>�?20�/*-�)(*6-�4'(�-*5(�23�
?206�*44(-+,-.�9'?1,/,*-�1,59)?�;?�)228,-.�*4�4'(�429�23�4'(�=614�
9*.(�23�?206�5(+,/*)�/'*64�*-+�,3�-24>�?20�1'20)+�*18�?206�-061(�
26�4'(�-061(�109(6:,126>� �'2�,1�5?�*44(-+,-.�9'?1,/,*-7!
88 John H. Fisher
�-/(�?20�'*:(�,+(-4,=(+�4'(�-*5(�23�?206� *44(-+,-.�9'?1,/,*-!>�
?20�4'(-�8-2D�D'2�?20�/*-�406-�42�326�*-1D(61���20�1'20)+�,-1,14�
092-� *� 3*/(J42J3*/(�5((4,-.�D,4'� ?206� *44(-+,-.� 9'?1,/,*-� *-+�
+06,-.�4'(�5((4,-.>�?20�1'20)+�*18�326�4'(�*44(-+,-.�9'?1,/,*-�1�
/())�9'2-(�-05;(6�,-�/*1(�?20�D*-4�42�19(*8�D,4'�',5<'(6�*.*,-��
�'(� *44(-+,-.� 9'?1,/,*-� D,))� /226+,-*4(� *))� 23� ?206� 46(*45(-4�
*4� 4'(� '219,4*)� *-+� '(<1'(� ,1� 4'(� 9(612-� D'2� ?20� 406-� 42��
326�*-1D(61�
�'(-� ?20� -((+� *-1D(61� 3625� 4'(� 9(612-� ,-� /'*6.(!� 23�
?206� /*6(� *4� 4'(� '219,4*)>� 5*8(� 106(� ?20� 19(*8� D,4'� ?206��
*44(-+,-.�9'?1,/,*-�
������%����"���"���������������������#���������������������������'�����#���%���������������������������������
�18� 42� 19(*8� D,4'� 4'(� �*4,(-4� �(96(1(-4*4,:(�� �'(� �*4,(-4�
�(96(1(-4*4,:(� ,1�*�5(5;(6�23�4'(�'219,4*)�14*33�D'2�1(6:(1�*1�
*� ),-8�;(4D((-� 4'(�9*4,(-4>� 3*5,)?>�9'?1,/,*-1�*-+�24'(6�'219,4*)�
14*33���'(� �*4,(-4� �(96(1(-4*4,:(� 1'20)+� ;(� *:*,)*;)(� 42� *-1D(6�
E0(14,2-1�*;204�'219,4*)�962/(+06(1>�'()9�D,4'�19(/,*)�-((+1�26�
/2-/(6-1�*-+�12):(�962;)(51���'(��*4,(-4��(96(1(-4*4,:(�1'20)+�
;(�3*5,),*6�D,4'�'219,4*)�1(6:,/(1�*-+�*11,14�?20���'(6(�,1�-2�/'*6.(�
326�1(6:,/(1�962:,+(+�;?�4'(��*4,(-4��(96(1(-4*4,:(�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 89
�$���%�����"����������������������������#�����������"�����������������
�(D��268��4*4(�'*1�*�)*D�4'*4�9(65,41�?20�42�*992,-4�125(2-(�
?20�46014>�10/'�*1�*�3*5,)?�5(5;(6�26�/)21(�36,(-+>�42�*/4�*1�?206�
�(*)4'��*6(��.(-4>� 42�*18�E0(14,2-1�23� 4'(�/*6(�962:,+(61� *-+�
+(/,+(�*;204�?206�46(*45(-4���3�?20�*18�*�-061(�*4�4'(�'219,4*)�326�
*��(*)4'��*6(��62C?��265>�?20�/*-�*04'26,N(�*�3*5,)?�5(5;(6�26�
36,(-+�42�*/4�2-�?206�;('*)3�6(.*6+,-.�?206�5(+,/*)�46(*45(-4�
��������%������%������������##������������#�����#������
�(D��268� �4*4(� *D� 6(E0,6(1� *))� '(*)4'� /*6(� 96*/4,4,2-(61� *-+�
3*/,),4,(1� 42� .6*-4� 9*4,(-41� *//(11� 42� 4'(,6� 5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1�� �3�
4'(�'219,4*)�26�9'?1,/,*-� 3*,)1� 42� */8-2D)(+.(� *-+� */4�2-� ?206�
6(E0(14>�?20�1'20)+�/259)*,-�42�4'(��(D��268��4*4(� (9*645(-4�
23��(*)4'�;?�/*)),-.��J&@@J&@HJ�HH%�
�3� ?20� '*:(� ;((-� +(-,(+� *//(11� 42� *))� 26� 9*64� 23� ?206� '219,4*)�
6(/26+1>�?20�5*?�*)12�*99(*)�42�4'(��(D��268��4*4(� (9*645(-4�23�
�(*)4'��(+,/*)��(/26+1��//(11��(:,(D��255,44((���'(�'219,4*)<
+2/426�,1�6(E0,6(+�42�962:,+(�*�3265�� ��J�#&#��4'*4�.,:(1�4'(�
6(*12-�1��326�+(-,*)�*-+�,-3265*4,2-�2-�4'(�*99(*)1�962/(11�
��������������"��������������"�������
�-+(6� 3(+(6*)� 6(.0)*4,2-1>�*))�-061,-.�'25(1�5014�'*:(�D6,44(-�
92),/,(1�4'*4�+(1/6,;(�4'(�6,.'41�23�4'(�6(1,+(-41���'(�-061,-.�'25(�
90 John H. Fisher
,1�6(E0,6(+�;?�)*D�42�5*8(�4',1�92),/?�14*4(5(-4I4'(� �061,-.�
�25(��(1,+(-4�1�,))�23��,.'41!I*:*,)*;)(� 42�*-?�6(1,+(-4�D'2�
6(E0(141�,4�
�'(�6,.'41�,-/)0+(�4'(�6,.'4�42�;(�,-3265(+�*;204�?206�5(+,/*)�
/2-+,4,2->�4'(�6,.'4�42�9*64,/,9*4(�,-�4'(�9)*-�23�/*6(>�4'(�6,.'4�42�
/'221(�?206�2D-�9'?1,/,*->�*-+�4'(�6,.'4�42�;(�36((�3625�9'?1,/*)�
6(146*,-41���92-�?206�*+5,11,2-�42�4'(�-061,-.�'25(>�?20�1'20)+�
5*8(�106(�4'*4�?20�.(4�*�/29?�23�4'(� �061,-.��25(��(1,+(-4�1�
,))�23��,.'41!>�12�?20�'*:(�*�/)(*6�0-+(614*-+,-.�23�?206�6,.'41�,-�
*�-061,-.�'25(�
� ������%����*����������#����������#�����������
��140+?�6(/(-4)?�6()(*1(+�;?��(1206/(1�326�4'(��0406(>�*�-2-962=4�
.6209�4'*4�/2-+0/41�,-+(9(-+(-4�6(1(*6/'�2-�90;),/�'(*)4'�,110(1>�
320-+� 4'*4� ,-3(/4,2-1� 23� 1(91,1� *-+� 9-(052-,*� */E0,6(+� ,-� 4'(�
'219,4*)�8,))�H&>@@@�9(29)(�(*/'�?(*6���//26+,-.�42�4'(�140+?>�4'(1(�
,-3(/4,2-1�/214�A&���;,)),2-�42�46(*4�*-+�)(*+�42�"�$�5,)),2-�424*)�
+*?1�23�'219,4*),N*4,2-���064'(6>�4'(��(-4(61�326� ,1(*1(��2-462)�
*-+��6(:(-4,2-�(14,5*4(�4'*4�;(4D((-���+� � �� 7�+� ��� ���������
����� �����3����� ������ ��� ��������������
�:(-� 42+*?>� +2/4261� 4())� 4'(,6� 9*4,(-41� 4'*4� '219,4*)J*/E0,6(+�
,-3(/4,2-1� *6(� -24� 96(:(-4*;)(� (:(-� D,4'� 4'(� ;(14� /*6(�� �-�
�&J52-4'� 140+?� ;?� K2'-1��298,-1��-,:(61,4?� '*1� 962:(-� 4',1��
4'(26?�D62-.�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 91
�26��&�52-4'1�;(4D((-�"@@��*-+�"@@F>�526(�4'*-��@@��,/',.*-�
'219,4*)1�(-62))(+�4'(,6�,-4(-1,:(�/*6(�0-,41�,-�4'(�,-,4,*4,:(�8-2D-�
*1� 4'(��,/',.*-� �(?142-(� ���� �62B(/4���'(� 962B(/4� 4*6.(4(+� *�
19(/,=/�4?9(�23� ,-3(/4,2-�4'*4�����9*4,(-41�/*-�.(4�D',)(� ,-�4'(�
'219,4*)�� /*4'(4(6J6()*4(+� ;)22+146(*5� ,-3(/4,2-1>� *-+� ,-:2):(+�
'*:,-.� ���� 9(612--()� 01(� *� =:(J14(9� 1*3(4?� /'(/8),14� D'(-�
,-1(64,-.�/*4'(4(61�,-42�9*4,(-41�
�'(� 1,59)(� =:(J14(9� /'(/8),14� 6(E0,6(+� ���� 9(612--()� 42� 4*8(�
4'(� 32))2D,-.� 14(91� D'(-� 9)*/,-.� *� /(-46*)� ),-(� /*4'(4(6�� ����
D*1'�4'(,6�'*-+1>��"��D(*6�*�5*18>�'*4>�.2D-�*-+�.)2:(1>��$��904�
14(6,)(�+6*9(1�2:(6�4'(�9*4,(-4>��H��/)(*-�*�9*4,(-4�1�18,->�*-+�����
6(52:(�4'(�/*4'(4(6�*1�122-�*1�,4�,1�-2�)2-.(6�-((+(+���'(�6(10)41��
D(6(�*5*N,-.�
�'(�=:(J14(9�/'(/8),14�:,640*))?�(),5,-*4(+�;)22+146(*5�,-3(/4,2-1�
,-�'219,4*)1��,-4(-1,:(�/*6(�0-,41�42�N(62���3�4'(��"%�,-4(-1,:(�/*6(�
0-,41�9*64,/,9*4,-.�,-�4'(�962B(/4>��@$��,/',.*-�,-4(-1,:(�/*6(�0-,41�
6(+0/(+�/*4'(4(6J6()*4(+�;)22+146(*5�,-3(/4,2-1�42�N(62�+06,-.�
4'(�=614�4'6((�52-4'1�23�4'(�140+?�*-+�09�42�FFL�1014*,-(+�4'(�
N(62�6*4(1�+06,-.�4'(��&J52-4'�140+?�9(6,2+���',1�)(+�42�4'(�-(*6�
(),5,-*4,2-�23�/*4'(4(6J6()*4(+�;)22+146(*5�,-3(/4,2-1�
�'(�;(14�D*?�42�5,-,5,N(�,-3(/4,2-1�,-�4'(�'219,4*)�,1�)2D�4(/'��
5*8(�106(�*-?2-(�D'2�420/'(1�?20�D*1'(1�',1�26�'(6�'*-+1�*-+�
32))2D1� 4'(� =:(J14(9� /'(/8),14� 01(+� ,-� 4'(��,/',.*-��(?142-(�
�����62B(/4�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 93
�����*����
�',1� ;228� *651� ?20� D,4'� 4'(� ,-3265*4,2-� ?20� -((+� 42� 5*8(�
106(�?20�*6(�-24�*-24'(6�:,/4,5�23�5(+,/*)�5*)96*/4,/(�4'*4�8,))1�
#&>@@@��5(6,/*-1�(:(6?�?(*6�,-�'219,4*)1�*/6211�4'(��-,4(+��4*4(1���
��������������������
�20�'*:(�4'(�6,.'4�*-+�4'(�6(192-1,;,),4?�42�30))?�9*64,/,9*4(�,-�*))�
+(/,1,2-1�6()*4(+� 42�?206�'(*)4'�/*6(�� �3� ?20�*6(�0-*;)(� 42� 30))?�
9*64,/,9*4(�,-�46(*45(-4�+(/,1,2-1>�?20�1'20)+�;(�6(96(1(-4(+�;?�
9*6(-41>�.0*6+,*-1�26�3*5,)?�5(5;(61�����������������������
�����G��������O
�3�?20�)(*:(�4'(�'219,4*)�D,4'204�*�/)(*6�0-+(614*-+,-.�*;204�4'(�
+,*.-21,1>�962.-21,1�*-+�9)*-�23�46(*45(-4>�?20�*6(�-24�+2,-.�?206�
B2;�� �-1,14�2-� 1((,-.� 4'(�5(+,/*)� 6(/26+1� *-+�'*:(� 4'(� 6(/26+1�
(C9)*,-(+�;?�4'(�*44(-+,-.�9'?1,/,*-���3�4'(�*44(-+,-.�9'?1,/,*-�,1�
0-*:*,)*;)(>�4())�4'(�'219,4*)�14*33�4'*4�?20�D*-4�*-�*992,-45(-4�
42�5((4�D,4'�',5<'(6�� 2�-24�*//(94�4'(�:*-,))*�*-1D(61�.,:(-�;?�
4'(�-061,-.�14*33�
�3� 4'(� *44(-+,-.� 9'?1,/,*-1� /*--24� *-1D(6� ?206� E0(14,2-1>� ?20�
1'20)+� *18� D'?� *-+� ,-1,14� 4'*4� *� 5(+,/*)� 19(/,*),14� 46(*4� ?20��
�',)(�4'(�'219,4*)�14*33�5*?�;(�*--2?(+�4'*4�?20�*6(�*11(64,-.�
?206�6,.'41>����������O��20�1'20)+�;(�92),4(�*-+�6(19(/430)�,-�
*11(64,-.�?206�6,.'41>�;04�*)D*?1�;(�=65�
94 John H. Fisher
�'(�9*4,(-4�*-+�4'(�9*4,(-4�1�3*5,)?�010*))?�'*:(�*�;(44(6�,+(*�4'*4�
125(4',-.�,1�1(6,201)?�D62-.�D,4'�4'(�9*4,(-4�4'*-�4'(�9'?1,/,*-1�
26�4'(�-061,-.�14*33����������������������O� 2�-24�)(*:(�4'(�
'219,4*)�,3�?206�.04�,-14,-/41�*6(�4()),-.�?20�4'*4�?20�*6(�-24�6(*+?�
42�;(�+,1/'*6.(+���219,4*)1�'*:(�92),/,(1�4'*4�9(65,4�?20�42�.(4�
4'(�1(/2-+�29,-,2-�23�*�'219,4*)� 6(96(1(-4*4,:(� ,3� ?20� 3(()� 4'*4�
+,1/'*6.(�3625�4'(�'219,4*)�,1�-24�*996296,*4(�
�'(� -05;(6� 2-(� 5,14*8(� 5*+(� ;?� 5*)96*/4,/(� :,/4,51� ,1� 4'(�
;),-+�*//(94*-/(�23�4'(� D,1+25!�*-+�*+:,/(�23�4'(�'(*)4'�/*6(�
962:,+(6���',)(� ,4� ,1� -*406*)� 42�D*-4� 42� ),8(� ?206�9'?1,/,*-� *-+�
46014�4'*4�?20�*6(�.(44,-.�120-+�*+:,/(�3625�',5<'(6>�4'(�3*/4�,1�
4'*4�9'?1,/,*-1�*6(�'05*-�B014�),8(�?20�*-+���*-+�5,14*8(1�-24�2-)?�
2//06>�4'(?�*6(�/2552-��
2� -24� ;),-+)?� *//(94� 4'(� D,1+25!� 23� 4'(� 9'?1,/,*-1�
*-+� -061(1�� (*6-� (:(6?4',-.� ?20� /*-� *;204� ?206� 5(+,/*)�
/2-+,4,2-� 4'620.'� 4'(� ,-4(6-(4� *-+� ;(� 96(9*6(+�D,4'� *� ),14� 23�
E0(14,2-1� 42� *18� ?206� 9'?1,/,*-�� �3� 4'(� 9'?1,/,*-� /*--24� .,:(�
?20� *-1D(61>� ?20� 1'20)+� ,-1,14� 2-� .(44,-.� *� 1(/2-+� 29,-,2-��
3625�*-24'(6�9'?1,/,*-�
����������������������O��11(64�4'(�6,.'41�4'*4�?20�'*:(�
*-+�;(� *� 962*/4,:(� *+:2/*4(� 326� ?206� '(*)4'� *-+� 4'(� '(*)4'�23�
?206�3*5,)?��
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 95
������������
�'(�/2064�'*1�1()+25�1((-�*1�4'2620.'�*�B2;�*1�D*1�+2-(�'(6(�
;?�9)*,-4,33 �1�/20-1()�!
�2-26*;)(�(*46,/(��'*,-1D,4�,-��211�:���(),*-/(
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
��D*-4�42�4'*-8�?20�326�*))�4'*4�?20�'*:(�+2-(���20�'()9(+�5*8(�
*-�0-;(*6*;)(�1,40*4,2->�(*1,(6�;?�;(,-.�1(-1,4,:(>�0-+(614*-+,-.>�
*-+�12�:(6?�'()930)����3()4�*�),44)(�1*+�42�.(4�4',1�)(44(6�*1�206�=-*)�
;01,-(11�42.(4'(6���206�'*6+�D268�*-+�+(4(65,-*4,2-�'*1�5*+(�*�
'0.(�+,33(6(-/(�,-�5?�),3(���'*-8�?20�*.*,-�*-+���D,1'�?20�*))�4'(�
;(14���29(30))?���D,))�1((�?20�*620-+���,4'�)2:(�!
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
�'*-8� ?20� 326� *))� ?206� (33264� *-+� D268� 2:(6� 4'(� 9*14�
3(D� ?(*61�� �206� +(+,/*4,2-� *-+� +(4(65,-*4,2-� )(+� 42� 206��
3*:26*;)(�204/25(�!
��(19(/,*))?�*996(/,*4(�?20�;(,-.�29(-�*-+�'2-(14�4'620.'�4',1�
962/(11���206�*11,14*-/(>�*-+�8-2D)(+.(�'*1�;((-�,-:*)0*;)(�42�5?�
;624'(61�*-+���+06,-.�4',1�962/(11�!
��D*-4�42�3265*))?�4'*-8�?20�*-+�(C4(-+�5?�.6*4,40+(�3625�5?�
3*5,)?�*-+�5(���20�6(�*�.6(*4�)*D?(6�*-+�1((5�),8(�*�.6(*4�.0?�!
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
96 John H. Fisher
�'*-8�?20�326�?206�1,-/(6(�(33264�,-�'()9,-.�5(�42�=-+�125(2-(�
42�'*-+)(�5?�/*1(����/*-�4�4())�?20�,-�D26+1�'2D�D2-+(630)�,4�,1�
42�8-2D�125(2-(�/*6(1�(-20.'�42�4*8(�4'(�4,5(�*-+�(33264� ,-�
'()9,-.�*�3())2D�'05*-�;(,-.���'*-81�*.*,-�326�?206�8,-+-(11�!
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
��'*:(� 6(/(,:(+�?206� )(44(6� *-+�9*9(6D268�� ��D*-4(+� 42�D6,4(�
*-+� /2-:(?�5?� .6*4,40+(� 326� )228,-.� ,-42� 4'(� 1,40*4,2-�� 06,-.�
206�=614�5((4,-.�?20�D(6(�/)(*6�4'*4�4'(6(�D*1�*�9211,;,),4?�4'*4�
*�/*1(�5*?�26�5*?�-24�;(�5*+(�9(-+,-.� 4'(�204/25(�23�?206�
,-:(14,.*4,2-����'*:(�;((-�E0,4(�1*4,1=(+�D,4'�4'(�D268�4'*4�?20�
*-+�?206�=65�'*:(�+2-(�!�
�'(�5(6(� 3*/4� 4'*4� ?20� )228(+� ,-42� 4'(� 1,40*4,2-� '*1� ;((-� *�
;)(11,-.���1�5(-4,2-(+�;(326(>� 6(.*6+)(11�23� 4'(�204/25(>�?206�
*11,14*-/(�D,))�6(,-326/(�4'(�'(*),-.�962/(11�!
�)(*1(� 6(,4(6*4(� 5?� D26+1� 23� 4'*-81� 42� 4'21(� ,-� ?206� =65�
D'2�'*:(�4*8(-�4'(�4,5(�42� ,-:(14,.*4(�*-+�1(E0(14(6�5(+,/*)�
6(/26+1���20�4228�4'(�4,5(�*-+�D268(+�D,4'�5(�+(19,4(�),5,4(+�
=-*-/,*)�6(1206/(1�!�
�-�;('*)3�23�5?�3*5,)?>�*-+�5?1()3�4'*-8�?20�326�*))�23�?206�'()9�
*-+�*11,14*-/(� 4'(1(� )*14�/209)(�?(*61���20�*-+�?206�=65�*6(�*�
4(14*5(-4�42�?206�9623(11,2-�!
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
��B014�D*-4(+�42�4'*-8�?20�*.*,-�326�'()9,-.�5(�)(*6-�Z�.62D�*4�
4',1�=65���20�*6(�460)?�2-(�23�4'(�5214�'*6+D268,-.>�(4',/*)�*-+�
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 97
+(4(65,-(+�)*D?(61���:(�8-2D-���4�D*1�460)?�*�9)(*106(�42�D268�2-�
/*1(1�D,4'�?20���2+�;)(11�?20�Z�,1*�Z�4'(�8,+1�!
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
�(� :2)0-4((6(+� 42� D6,4(� 4',1� '(*643()4� (-+261(5(-4� 23�
K2'-� �,1'(6�� �,1� 9623(11,2-*)>� /*6,-.>� 9624(/4,:(� *-+� *..6(11,:(�
6(96(1(-4*4,2-� 23� 206� 5(+,/*)� 5*)96*/4,/(� /*1(� (-*;)(+� 01� 42�
6(*/'� *-�204J23J/2064� 1(44)(5(-4���(�D(6(�526(� 4'*-�9)(*1(+�
D,4'�4'(�204/25(���(�6(/255(-+�',5�D,4'204�6(1(6:*4,2-���(�
2;4*,-(+�*�B014�6(10)4�0-+(6�46?,-.�/,6/0514*-/(1�!
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
K2'-ID26+1�3*))�1'264I?20�*6(�10/'�*�'*6+JD268,-.>�,-4()),.(-4>�
)*D?(6���'(�/),(-41�*6(�32640-*4(�42�'*:(�?20�Z���*5�:(6?�9620+�42�
D268�*)2-.�1,+(�?20�!
The Seven Deadly Mistakes of Malpractice Victims 99
3�*��&���
K2'-�1�96*/4,/(�23� )*D� ,1�0-,E0(� ,-� 4D2�6(19(/41�� ���� K2'-�2-)?�
96*/4,/(1�,-�4'(�*6(*�23�9(612-*)�,-B06?�*-+�5(+,/*)�5*)96*/4,/(�
*-+�'(�2-)?�6(96(1(-41�4'(�:,/4,51�23�10/'�-(.),.(-/(��K2'-�+2(1�
-24�6(96(1(-4�,-106*-/(�/259*-,(1�26�+(3(-+*-41M�*-+��"��K2'-�
),5,41�',1�96*/4,/(�42�10;14*-4,*)�*-+�/*4*14629',/�,-B06?�/*1(1��
K2'-�,1�',.')?�1()(/4,:(�,-�4'(�4?9(�23�/*1(1�4'*4�'(�*//(941�*-+�
4'(�:*14�5*B26,4?�23�/*1(1�*6(�(,4'(6�6(B(/4(+�26�6(3(66(+�42�24'(6�
/20-1()��?�*//(94,-.�*�:(6?�15*))�-05;(6�23�/*1(1>�K2'-�,1�*;)(�42�
5*8(�106(�4'*4�(*/'�/*1(�.(41�4'(�4,5(�*-+�*44(-4,2-�,4�+(1(6:(1�
�,-/(��##F>�K2'-�'*1�+(+,/*4(+�*))�23�',1�4,5(�42�4'(�6(96(1(-4*4,2-�
23� 1(6,201)?� ,-B06(+� 9(612-1�� K2'-� '*-+)(1� *))� 4?9(1� 23� 5(+,/*)�
5*)96*/4,/(� /)*,51>� ,-/)0+,-.� 5*-?� +,33(6(-4� 4?9(1� 23� ;,64'�
,-B06?�/*1(1�,-:2):,-.�/(6(;6*)�9*)1?>�;6*,-�,-B06,(1>�5,/62/(9'*)?>�
96(.-*-/?� ,-+0/(+� '?9(64(-1,2->� ;6*/',*)� 9)(C01� ,-B06,(1� *-+�
96(5*406(�+(),:(6?�
�',)(� 4'(� /*1(1� '*:(� 6*-.(+� 3625� ;6*,-� +*5*.(+� ,-3*-41� 42�
9*6*)?N(+�1(-,26�/,4,N(-1>�4'(�2-(�4',-.�4'*4�+2(1�-24�/'*-.(�,1�
4'(�.6*4,=/*4,2-� 4'*4� K2'-�.(41� 3625�5*8,-.�*�+,33(6(-/(� ,-� 4'(�
),:(1�23�',1�/),(-41���2�K2'->�4'(�96*/4,/(�23�)*D�,1�526(�4'*-�1,59)?�
*�D*?�42�(*6-�*�),:,-.>�;04�4'(�/'*-/(�42�5*8(�*�)*14,-.�+,33(6(-/(�
326�',1�/),(-41�
K2'-�'*1�;((-�6(/2.-,N(+�;?�',1�9((61�42�;(�:(6?�',.')?�6*4(+�
,-�;24'�)(.*)�*;,),4?�*-+�(4',/*)�96*/4,/(�;?��*64,-+*)(J�0;;())�1�
100 John H. Fisher
�((6��(:,(D��*4,-.�� K2'-� ,1� *�5(5;(6�23� :*6,201�9623(11,2-*)�
26.*-,N*4,2-1>�,-/)0+,-.�4'(��5(6,/*-��112/,*4,2-�326�K014,/(�*-+�
4'(��(D��268��4*4(��/*+(5?�23��6,*)�*D?(61�*-+�'*1�)(/406(+�
42�9*6*)(.*)1>�)*D�140+(-41�*-+�/,:,/�26.*-,N*4,2-1�2-�-05(6201�
2//*1,2-1��K2'-�9*64,/0)*6)?�(-B2?1�1'*6,-.�',1�(C9(6,(-/(1�*1�*�
9(612-*)�,-B06?�)*D?(6�D,4'�/2))(.(�*-+�)*D�140+(-41���D*?�3625�
D268>�K2'-�(-B2?1�19(-+,-.�4,5(�D,4'�',1�D,3(>�,1*>�4'(,6�4'6((�
/',)+6(->��)(8>��,5�*-+�,),?*>�*-+�',1�;,/'2-�36,1(>��1/*6�
K2'-� .6*+0*4(+� 3625� 4'(� �-,:(61,4?� 23� �246(� *5(� D,4'� *�
*/'()26�23��641�+(.6((� ,-��2:(6-5(-4� ,-��#&&�*-+�.6*+0*4(+�
3625� �-,:(61,4?� 23� �246(� *5(� *D� �/'22)� ,-� �##��� K2'-� ,1�
*+5,44(+�42�96*/4,/(�)*D�,-��(D��268>��2--(/4,/04�*-+��)),-2,1��
�20�/*-�)(*6-�526(�*;204�?206�6,.'41�*1�*�9*4,(-4�;?�:,1,4,-.�K2'-�1�
D(;1,4(�*4�DDD�9624(/4,-.9*4,(-46,.'41�/25>�*-+�10;1/6,;,-.� 42�
K2'-�1�;)2.�*;204�9*4,(-4�6,.'41�2-�4'(�D(;1,4(���'(� 36(E0(-4)?�
*18(+� E0(14,2-1!� 1(/4,2-� 23� K2'-�1� D(;1,4(� 962:,+(1� :*)0*;)(�
,-3265*4,2-�*;204�4'(�962/(11�23�(:*)0*4,-.�5(+,/*)�5*)96*/4,/(�
/)*,51�*-+�4'(�962/(+06(1�4'*4�/*-�;(�(C9(/4(+�*34(6�4'(�=),-.�23�
*�5*)96*/4,/(�)*D10,4��
7The Seven
Deadly��������
� ��� ��������������
J o h n H . F i s h e r
���� � �������������������������������������������
��� ����� � ���������� ����� ���������� ��� � �� ���
����������� �����������������������������������
� !!���������������"������������������������� �������
����������� ����� �� #����� ����� ������ ���� ��� �������
����������$
���� � �����������������������������%���������
�� ��& �� � ������ � ������� ��� �������" ���� �� &���
��� ������������ ����������������'�����������
��� � ���������������������������������������
���������������"��������������������&���������
����"����������&�����&�������������
'����� �������&������ ������������������������
�������� ����������������������&�������������
&�������������������������������������
7158387815959
ISBN 978-1-59571-583-851695 >
$16.95
W O R D A S S O C I A T I O N P U B L I S H E R Swww.wordassociation.com1.800.827.7903