Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
ML Consulting GroupBusiness Strategy & Engineering Planning and Implementation for Electric Smart Grid
1
Agenda1. Introduction (10)2. Work Products from Transmission WG (20)3. Paper presentation (100)
Control of DER for renewable integration with fast DR in Japan by Hiroshi Asano (20)
4. Power System Planning Issues & Proposed Programs (140) Energy Forecasting by Tao Hong Conventional & Renewable Energy Supply Planning by Joseph Yan Transmission System Planning by Mike Henderson Modern & Future Distribution System Planning by Luis Nando Ochoa Integrated Intelligent Customer System Planning by Heber Weller Assessment of Power System Flexibility by Eamonn Lannoye Asset Management by Tony McGrail
5. Business Meeting (administrative) (10) Awards & Recognition Subcommittee (Wenyuan Li) Program for GM2015 (Denver) Technical Council Meeting at GM2013 & JTCM 2014 at New Orleans Quadrennial Energy Report (QER) by USDOE Smart Grid Roadmap by IGCC Technical Committee Scope Restructuring/Realignment – Technology
Mapping Task Force6. Adjourn
2
PSPI Committee
ML Chan, Chair
Transmission System
Planning WGMike Henderson
Modern & Future Distribution
System Planning WG
Luis Nando Ochoa – Chair
Robert Saint – Vice Chair
Integrated Intelligent Customer System Planning WG
Heber Weller
Asset Mgmt. WG
Tony McGrail
Conventional & Renewable
Energy Supply Planning WG
Chair: Joseph Yan
Secretary: Amy Li
Liaison to Energy Policy Development Coord. Comm. – Anil Pahwa
Liaison to Wind & Solar Power Coord. Comm. – ?
Liaison to Emerging Technologies Coord. Comm – Fran Li
Secretary
Fran Li
Vice Chair/TCPC
Anil Pahwa
Award & Recognition Subcomm. – Wenyuan Li
Liaison to Intelligent Grid Coordinating Comm. – Fran
Li
IEEE Fellows Comm. –Ron Chu
Energy Forecasting WG
Tao Hong – Chair
Shu Fan –Vice Chair
Assessment of Power System Flexibility WG
Chair: E. Lannoye
Vice Chair: H. Johal
3
Programs for GM2014
4
New Power System Planning (NewPSP) Issues
Smart Grid era Integrating information technology, DERs,
automation, renewable, microgrids into an electric grid to operate in a deregulated market environment, subject to federal and state regulations and policies
5
Power System Planning Forces - NewPSP
Risk Management & Uncertainties
6
Energy & Resource Forecasting
Load profile forecasts End-use load forecast Renewable resource forecasts; short term (even minute
basis), medium term, and long term Energy market price forecasts Small area load forecasts Transmission region load and resource forecasts Data quality and data scrubbing
7
Electricity Supply Planning Optimal portfolio planning Renewable, customer resources (DER, DR, microgrid),
renewable, EVs Integration with transmission system planning Resource Adequacy Regulatory climate to provide a stable environment for
investment Stochastic planning under uncertainties and risk
management Incorporation of system flexibility
8
Transmission System Planning Regulatory uncertainties (e.g., FERC Order 1000, 764, 784) Integrated with Distribution System Planning Integrated Resource Planning (e.g., DER, DR, etc.) Resource uncertainties; planning for intra-hour (or even
more granular) Ancillary Services & Energy Imbalance Market
Risk management & uncertainties Synchrophasor technology and FACTS for enhancing
capacities at different congestion points Incorporation of energy storages, peaking plants and DR to
combat resource volatility and introduce system flexibility; a transmission asset?
9
Distribution System Planning Active Circuit Planning Integration with transmission system planning Integrated Resource Planning, incorporating DER, DGs,
DR, EVs, energy storage and microgrids System service reliability, voltage profile maintenance,
power quality harmonics Anti-islanding per IEEE P1547.7; smart inverters for solar
PVs; Adaptive protective relay settings using PMUs Asset condition monitoring for asset management to assure
lifecycle economics and system reliability Stochastic modeling of uncertainties and risk
management, and incorporation of system flexibility
10
Customer Resource Planning AMI meters with HAN for interface to customer resources (e.g.,
rooftop solar PV) TLMS EV charging stations at homes and commercial buildings End-use load modeling by incorporating stochasticity for DR
and building energy management Renewable resource forecasting Integration with enterprise IT system to provide customer choice
of energy services Microgrid planning and operations, including agent-based
marketing Integration with energy storage, building energy management
and energy feed to the grid; HAN with Zigbee, Homeplug, Z-Wave using SEP 2.0
Interface with Energy Aggregators and/or with DMS; OpenADR DC power systems Utilities entering into the customer energy resource market
11
Prof.Dr.Hiroshi AsanoDeputy Associate Vice President, CRIEPIVisiting Professor, The University of Tokyo
July 2014New Power System Planning Combo Session2014 IEEE Power and Energy Society General Meeting
12
Renewable Generation in JapanFIT qualified capacity 68.5GW in March 2014•PV: 12.4 GW in March 2014
Roof-top: 7GW•Wind power: 2.7GW in Dec.2013
Wind power is favorable in Hokkaido, Tohoku and Kyushu.
•Geothermal: 536 MW•Biomass: 2.2 GW in March 2013•Small & mid hydro: 9.6GW
13
Current Electricity Supply System
GenerationWholesale
Network
Sales
Non-eligible Users(Households) Eligible Users
Wholesale Electricity Utilities (J-POWER etc.) and
Wholesale Suppliers (IPPs, etc.)
Power Producer
and Supplier (PPSs)
Self Generators
Self Consumption
Special Electric Utilities
Customers in
Designated Service Districts
Users
Wholesale Power Exchange Market (JEPX)
General Electricity UtilitiesTransmission/Distribution NetworkESCJ Supervision
Power Plants
Supply Supply
Sale and Purchase
Supply
Power Producer
and Supplier (PPSs)
Sale WheelingSale
Sale
Supply
ESCJ: Electric Power System Council of Japan
14
Purpose of the electricity reform: 2013-2020
Securing the stable supply of electricity More electricity interchange between regions Utilizing DER and demand response (DR) More integration of DER for RE integration
Suppressing electricity rates Promoting competition: both wholesale and retail Optimizing investments through DR
Expanding choices for consumers and business opportunities Responding to the various needs of consumers: green power, new
value-added services Innovation in generation and DR by new entrants as new customer
services
15
Demand-side resources for Supporting High Penetration of Renewables
The increasing need for fast ramp resources to create multiple strategies for advancing the grid's ability to assimilate renewable, variable generation resources.
These include implementing market and operational enhancements, defining a new category of flexibility products, and incorporating intra-hour market pricing.
Integrated control of Distributed Energy Resources
16
Electric utilities and transmission grid
Ten privately-owned vertically integrated utilities (so called general electric utilities, GEUs) focus on their native load in their service territory
There is a difference in frequencies between the east (50Hz) and the west (60 Hz)
17
Load Frequency Control by Commercial Air Conditioners Power Consumption Control
Large integration of intermittent renewable energy generation causes the system frequency fluctuation.
More frequency control resources will be required. Air conditioners of commercial buildings are one of the
potential resources as controllable load(DER). Model of coordinated LFC system that considering
transient power consumption characteristics of commercial air conditioner
Analyze the effect of frequency fluctuation suppression by air conditioners power consumption control.
18
Response of air conditioner at an experimental facility
Control
Dead Time[s
]
Power Consumption Changing Rate [%MW/sec]
UP 520< PC ≤
0.750.75< PC≤ 0.85
0.85< PC≤ 1.0
0.08 0.35 0.11DOWN 7 -3.5
Example of response: model vs experiment
19
LFC with commercial AC
Tohoku : large potential area for WT & PV
20
Coordinated control of AC for integration of RE
MaximumDeviation
[Hz]RMS
value[Hz]
Probability of Frequency Deviation
within ±0.1Hz [%]
w/o ACDR 1.001 0.140 84.2
w/ ACDR 0.844 0.130 82.6
21
Inverter capacity vs. maximum deviation of frequency
22
Demonstration Project for the Fast Demand-Response Program:
The Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (METI) sponsors a Demonstration Project for the Fast Demand-Response Program
Test started operation since February 2014. TEPCO and DR aggregators: Marubeni-EnerNOC Japan,
Schneider, etc 10-minute reserve 30-minute reserve 60-minute reserve Based on Open ADR2.0B Participants: total demand is 10 MW order Various baselines are verified
23
Fast DR Pilot
System operator
Aggregator
End-users
A/C Lighting DG battery
Auto DR or BEMS
24
Load curve of air-conditioning of commercial buildings: Tokyo and Tohoku area
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Dem
and（
GWh/
h)
Hour
Summer peak daysSummer weekdaysWinter weekdaysSpring&autumn weekdaysSummer weekendsWinter weekendsSpring&autumn weekends
Source: CRIEPI Report Y13030
25
Summary Intermittent RE growing rapidly in Japan
Need more LFC capability
Integrated control of DER is promising
Evaluate potential LFC capability of commercial air-conditioners
Coordinated control of AC and storage battery is effective
Fast DR pilot has started 2014
26
Thank you! Hiroshi Asano
IEEE 2014
Floating wind power in Nagasaki
Smart charging for RES integration
Chair: Dr. Tao Hong, University of North Carolina at Charlotte, USAVice Chair: Shu Fan, Monash University, Australia Secretary: Dr. Hamid Zareipour, University of Calgary, Canada
28
Established Since PESGM2011
ActivitiesPanel GEFCOM Tutorial
2011 (GM) 1
2012 (GM, TD) 2
2013 (GM) 1 1 1
2014 (TD, GM) 3 1
Total (2011 – 2014) 7 1 2
Organized sessions: 1. "Load Forecasting: the State of the Practice", PESGM 20142. "Integrating Energy Forecasts into Utility Planning and Operations: Perspectives from Market Operators", T&D 20143. "Integrating Energy Forecasts into Utility Planning and Operations: Perspectives from Market Participants", T&D 20144. "Energy Forecasting: the State of the Art", PESGM 20135. "Global Energy Forecasting Competition Final Presentations", PESGM 20136. "Demand Response: Analytics, Practice, and Challenges in Smart Grid Environment", PESGM 20127. "Load Forecasting Methodologies and Applications in Operations and Planning", PESGM 20128. "Practical Aspects of Electric Load Forecasting", PESGM 2011
30
Activities
31
Activities
32
Panel & WG Meeting @ GM’14 "Preparing EKPC’s Load Forecasting Process for PJM Integration" --
Jamie Hall, Global Economic Consulting Associates, USA "Local Short and Middle Term Electricity Load Forecasting with Semi-
Parametric Additive Models" -- Raphael Nédellec, EDF R&D, France "Long-term Load Forecasting at ERCOT" -- Calvin Opheim, ERCOT,
USA "Data Issues in Spatial Electric Load Forecasting" -- Edgar Manuel
Carreno Franco, UNIOESTE, Brazil "Supply and Demand Forecasting in Competitive Markets: The Case of
Alberta" -- John Esaiw, Alberta Electric System Operator, Canada "Combining Load Forecasts from Multiple Vendors" -- Tao Hong,
University of North Carolina at Charlotte, USA Working Group Meeting – Global Energy Forecasting Competition
2014
33
GEFCom2014Important Dates:• 15 August 2014 -- Historical data release (competition starts)• 24 August 204 -- Trial period starts• 14 Sept. 2014 -- Evaluation period starts• 10 Oct. 2014 -- Registration deadline• 6 Dec. 2014 -- Evaluation period ends• 15 Dec. 2014 -- Final report and code due (competition ends)
Institute prize: $500
Team prize:1st place - $2500 USD2nd place - $1000 USD3rd place - $500 USD
34
Proposed Activities @ GM’15 Tutorial
Energy Forecasting in the Smart Grid Era Panel session
GEFCom2014 Combo Session
Energy Forecasting Reception
35
Details of GEFC 2014 Panel Session: Global Energy Forecasting Competition 2014 Final
Presentations
DescriptionIn today's competitive and dynamic environment, more and more decision making processes in the power and energy industry are relying on probabilistic forecasts. The applications of probabilistic energy forecasts spread across planning and operations of the entire energy value chain. The Global Energy Forecasting Competition 2014 (GEFCom2014) brings together state-of-the-art techniques and methodologies for probabilistic energy forecasting. GEFCom2014 features four tracks: Probabilistic Electric Load Forecasting, Probabilistic Electricity Price Forecasting, Probabilistic Wind Power Forecasting and Probabilistic Solar Power Forecasting. This session includes the presentations from the winners and organizers of GEFCom2014 to discuss the findings and insights.
Chair: Tao Hong ([email protected]) UNC Charlotte Totally 9 speakers with 5 unknown until early next year:
36
Happy Forecasting!
www.drhongtao.com/ieee-wgefblog.drhongtao.com/search/label/IEEE-WGEF
www.gefcom.orgblog.drhongtao.com/search/label/GEFCOM
37
Chair: Joseph Yan, SCE
38
Conventional & Renewable Energy Supply Planning
Joseph Yan, Ph.D.Principal Manager of Fundamental of Modeling & Analysis
Southern California Edison
Provide an opportunity for all the industrial and academic experts to promote, share and discuss various state-of-the-art technique and development in the field of energy supply, renewable integrations and ISO/RTO Markets, and provide panel/paper sessions, forums and tutorials during the IEEE technical meetings involving the following topics:
• Discussing and analyzing major issues of ISO/RTO market related to energy supply and renewable integration
• Discussing the issues, opportunities and challenges related to the renewable integration and DGs
• Discussing the issues related to generation resource adequacy and planning
Required Ramping Capability Creates Reliability Challenges
* Flexible Ramping Products, Second Revised Draft Final Proposal, CAISO, Oct 24, 2012.
The system ramping needs based on net load may triple during evening peak hours with solar output dropping while load increasing. The system ramping needs may reverse direction in early morning ramping hours.*
Required Frequency Control Creates Reliability Challenges
Solar PV Generation Over 1 Day (Arizona)
1. How do we define, quantify and estimate the need for flexibility in the short and long term?
2. How the long-term capacity market (or equivalent non-market process) should be set up to incentivize appropriate grid-scale and distributed generation, energy storage, energy efficiency and demand response program investment that will lead to a flexible, sustainable, efficient and reliable power system?
3. How should the DA/RT market be redesigned to send appropriate price signal to resources that provide additional flexibility to accommodate increased penetration of intermittent resources?
4. What role renewable resources could play in reducing the volatility in net load and needs for additional products that provide “flexibility” to the system operator?
1. Katie Sloan (SCE), “Looking to the Future: Procuring and Integrating Renewables.”
2. Jim Price (CAISO), “Value of Conventional Generation Resources in the ISO/RTO Markets with the Penetration of Intermittent Renewable Resources.”
3. Li Zhang (MISO), “Power Grid Planning and Operation with Higher Penetration of Intermittent Resources and EPA Rules – MISO Perspective.”
4. Paul Sotkiewicz (PJM), “Value of Conventional Generation Resources in RTO Markets with Penetration of Intermittent Renewables: Market Design Considerations.”
5. George Gross (UIUC), “The Economic Assessment of the Explicit Representation of Ramping Requirements on Conventional Generators in Systems with Integrated Intermittent Resources.”
• Continue the panel session for 2015 Invite IPPs and state/federal regulators
• Extend the Working Group Meeting to combine paper presentations for 2015
Chair: Mike HendersonISO-NE
46
47
48
49
Dr Luis(Nando) OchoaThe University of Manchester
Wednesday, 30th July 2014 – Washington DC, USA
IEEE PES General Meeting 2014
50
Outline Context for Distribution (UK example)
Challenges Examples of Industrial and Research Projects
Working Group Structure Activities
51
The UK Context for Distribution Business regulated by Ofgem
Assets account for 50%+ of the value of GB electricity networks
A significant part of the assets installed during the 1950s and 60s
UK Distribution Networks
Source: Energy Networks Association
Examples of LV Networks in the UK Topology of urban networks (Courtesy of ENWL)
Traditionally not monitored and not
controlled
The UK Context for Distribution
Legally-binding target of 15% of energy demand to be sourced by renewables by 2020
Expectation by 2020: more than 30% of electricity generated from renewables
Towards a Low-Carbon Society Government incentives for renewable generation Government incentives for micro/small-scale PV generation Government incentives for people to buy electric vehicles (EVs) Full smart meter rollout by 2020 Electrification of heat, advent of smart appliances?
The Challenges LV Distribution Networks (400V)
Voltage rise/drops due to PV panels/EVs Thermal limits: Are the wires fit for purpose? More unbalances? etc.
HV Distribution Networks (6.6, 11 and 33kV) Voltage rise due to wind power (rural networks) Increase in short circuit level (urban underground) Power quality, “Islanding” and Protection Increased energy losses? Variability?
EHV Distribution Networks (132kV) Thermal limits Stability and reserve requirements Variability?
Voltage Management
Observability
Controllability
Thermal, Fault Mgmt
Integration of Solutions
...
Storage: Changes Everything
The ‘holy grail’ of power systems Technologies: batteries, flywheels, compressed air, etc. Applications:
Frequency control Peak shaving Constraint management (voltage, thermal)
active and reactive support
Intentional islanding? Ancillary services? SSE: Shetland
NaS Battery 1MW, 6MWhr
The Context
Transmission
EHV Distribution
HV Distribution
LV Distribution
Unr
espo
nsiv
e D
eman
d, n
o St
orag
e
Conventional Generation
TODAY
Security
AgingAssets
Technology
Markets
ClimateChange
People
Transmission++ HVDC
EHV Distribution
HV Distribution
LV Distribution Act
ive,
Res
pons
ive
Dem
and
and
Stor
age
Conv. Generation++ RES
FUTURE (Smart Grid)
DG100 MW
DGMW
DGMW
EV EHP
Source: EU Smart Grid Platform
Our Power System Tomorrow
the electricity delivery systemand the backbone?
LV NetworksImpacts of Low Carbon Technologies
Alejandro Navarro (PhD Student, Univ. of Manchester)ENWL LV Network Solutions Project
Methodology
Impacts metrics: Customers with voltage problems: defined according to the
Standard BS EN 50160. Utilization level of the head of the feeder: hourly maximum
current divided by the ampacity. Daily energy losses in the feeder.
• Random allocation for each customer node.
Loads
• Random allocation of sites and sizes.
LCT• Time Series
Simulation.• 3 Phase four wire
power flow
Power Flow
Impact Assessment
Results Storage
020
4060
80 0 50 100 150 200 250 300
228
230
232
234
236
238
24 hours - 5 minutes Resolution
Voltage Profile in each load
Loads
V
This process is repeated 100 times for each feeder and penetration level
LV NetworksPotential Solutions
Dr Chao Long (PDRA , Univ. of Manchester)ENWL LoVIA Project
Voltage Control at the Busbar
OLTC-Fitted Transformer
TAPCON230 RTU
MCU MCU MCU
Logic
Effective for high penetrations of PV Requires remote monitoring
MV NetworksVoltage-Led Demand Response
Andrea Ballanti (PhD Student , Univ. of Manchester)ENWL CLASS Project
Voltage Down Power Down
Primary substation
Secondary substation
DNO’s control centre
Voltage
Unnoticeable changes to customers Aggregated changes in demand can defer
investment and be used for services
MV-LV NetworksCoordinated Control
Sahban Alnaser (PhD Student , Univ. of Manchester)EPSRC WISE PV Project
Hierarchical Control Coordination to
achieve system wide objective Network areas? Hybrid
optimisation? Control cycles? Interactions
among voltage levels?
Communication networks?
Key Remarks The are many challenges but also potential solutions
1st major challenge for DNOs is the lack of observability of their LV and MV circuits.
2nd major challenge: transition from stand alone operation of solutions towards an integrated DSO approach Reliable and cost-effective ICT is not trivial Regulatory barriers need to be overcome
R&D is essential for deployment
Dr Luis(Nando) OchoaThe University of Manchester
Wednesday, 30th July 2014 – Washington DC, USA
IEEE PES General Meeting 2014
70
Structure of the WG Chair: Luis(Nando) Ochoa, The University of
Manchester, UK Vice-Chair: Larry Trussel, DNV GL, USA Secretary: Chris Punt, Xcel Energy, Colorado, USA Awards Officer: Bo Yang, Siemens, USA
Current active members: USA, Europe, Asia
71
Activities Recently Proposed1. TF on Integration of DER
Coordinators: Loe Lei (State Grid EPRI, China) and Mo-Yuen Chow (North Carolina State Univ., USA)
Members: Jinwen Sun (HUST, China), Ram Nath(Siemens PTI, USA), Carmen Borges (UFRJ, Brazil), Mario Garcia-Sanz (Case Western Reserve Univ., USA)
Scope to be prepared in the next few months Potential Panel Session for 2015
72
Activities Recently Proposed2. TF on Smart Cities
Coordinator: JK Wang (Ohio State University, USA) Members: Janvon Appen (Fraunhofer IWES,
Germany), Mario Garcia-Sanz (Case Western Reserve Univ., USA), Larry Trussel (DNV GL, USA), Ram Nath (Siemens PTI, USA)
Scope to be prepared in the next few months Potential Panel Session for 2015
73
Activities Recently Proposed3. Panel Session for GM 2015
“Distribution Planning in a Complex Environment” Coordinator: JK Wang (Ohio State University, USA) Topics:
Integrated electric vehicle infrastructure Impact of smart distribution on switching schemes
(reconfiguration). Reliability and capacity benefits Multiple voltage level planning Interactions between T&D
74
Panel Session “Advanced Modelling and Control of Future Low Voltage Networks”
Thursday 31st July, 1pm-4pm, Chesapeake K Techno-economical assessment of on-load tap changers in
UK LV networks Innovative Solutions to Optimise Low Voltage Electricity
Systems: Power Snap-Shot Analysis by Meters Smart Control of Low Voltage Grids Integration of Residential-Scale Photovoltaic Panels in
Brazil Household-level management of electric vehicles
considering battery degradation and price uncertainty The Customer Led Network Revolution Project
75
Integrated Intelligent Customer Systems Working Group
Key Areas of Focus Interoperability & Communications with End Points
and Systems OpenADR
Distributed Energy Storage Applications of Customer Systems Smart Water Heater transformation into energy
storage utilization
Integrated Intelligent Customer Systems Working Group
Key Areas of Focus Electric Vehicle/PHEV Issues & Opportunities Utility Smart Dispatch of Charging and Discharging
Smart Grid Application of Customer Systems VAR support from Customer Systems (Smart
Inverters) Autonomous Under Frequency & Under Voltage
Response
Integrated Intelligent Customer Systems Working Group
Eamonn Lannoye (EPRI)Harjeet Johal (GE)
WG Established in 2013Working group was established at the last IEEE PES Meeting in Vancouver under the PSPI CommitteeWorking with Wind and Solar Power Coordinating and Power System Operations Committees
It is an Emerging & Important Issue
http://energy.gov/sites/prod/files/oeprod/DocumentsandMedia/NERC_Presentation_to_EAC_10-29-10.pdf
IVGTF ERSTF
http://www.nerc.com/comm/Other/essntlrlbltysrvcstskfrcDL/ERS%20Draft%20NERC%20Staff%20Report.pdf
Flexibility in CaliforniaFlexible Resource Adequacy Must Offer Obligation
Load serving entities requirement
Linked to storage obligations Evaluation tools required PG&E lead study to look at
flexibility assessment models
FlexiRamp constraint
Operational constraint Operational requirements
need to be validated in planning time horizon
Tools and methods needed to verify constraints
82
Flexibility Deliverability Post contingency constraints in operations models Affects how flexibility is called and deployed Knock on implication for type and location of the
resources required Additional value to transmission switching /
expansion / upgrades Need to understand how transmission affects delivery
of flexibility
83
Flexibility of Energy Limited Resources Important resource for
system flexibility How to value these
resources in planning models
New approaches needed to include these resource types
84
WG Structure• Identify, review, develop and disseminate methods and metrics to characterize flexibility requirements
Variability & Flexibility Requirements
• Identify, review, develop and disseminate methods and metrics which characterize the capability of each resource type to provide flexibility
Flexible Resource Capability
• Identify, review, develop and disseminate methods & metrics to determine overall ability of a system to meet flexibility requirements
System Flexibility Assessment
• Identify, review and disseminate current regulatory practices relating to flexibility and its assessment
Regulatory Issues
Working Group Activities – 2013 Working group kick-off meeting (via tele-conference) was
conducted immediately after the IEEE PES Over 25 participants from national labs, academia, and industry
from both North America and Europe Strong interest from the group to participate in technical papers
and knowledge dissemination
Panel session for the IEEE PES meeting 2014 Jointly sponsored by the PSPI and the Wind & Solar Power
Coordinating Committee
Working Group Activities - 2014 White paper on Flexibility for Power System Planning
Collaborative industry-academia forum to advance the research in the field of power system planning
Current incarnation of the document to be circulated shortly amongst group members to get initial feedback on the definition and content
Series of webcasts is planned on power system flexibility Invite speakers to share experience, recent studies, and knowledge Anticipated to start in Sep/Oct 2014 on a bi-monthly basis
Panel session for the IEEE PES GM 2015 Experiences from flexibility assessment studies
2014 Panel SessionPlanning for Near-Term Flexibility Challenges 08:00 – 10:30 Experiences and insights from:
EDF Northwest Power and Conservation Council Pacific Gas & Electric ISO New England John Hopkins University
10:30 – 12:00 : Group participation session
Thursday, 08:00 – 12:00 POTOMAC 3
88
Participation in the WG Seeking new members
Drafting of white paper / report Participation in webcast series
Come talk to Eamonn Lannoye and Harjeet Johal
89
Tony McGrail, Kenneth ElkinsonDoble Engineering Co.
90
Outline Highlights of 2014 meeting Plan for 2015
91
2014 AgendaOrder Presenter Subject
1 Tony McGrail, Doble Welcome, Introductions, Aims/Objectives
2 Siri Varadan, UISOL Investment Planning and Managing the Money
3 Gerry Sheble, EPMT Identifying Critical Components on the System
4 Kevin Corcoran, Tollgrade Cyber Security
5 Break
6 Activity 1 Asset Life Distribution and Replacement
7 Ken Elkinson, Doble Data Management
8 David Golon, Dynamic Ratings Remnant Life Estimation
9 Nic Fantana, ABB Impact of OnLine Monitoring on Asset Management
10 Johan Smit, Uni Delft Substation Lifetime Management (Cigre)
11 Break
12 Jon Brasher, Ovante Asset Specification and System Renewal
13 Chris Punt, Xcel Energy Investment Planning
14 Gomaa Hamoud, HydroOne Spares Holdings
15 John Roach, HSB AM Insurance Overview
16 Tony McGrail, Doble Closing discussion
92
Highlights 42 attendees at Asset Management Working Group
session AM WG all time high 16 presentations
Comment from attendee –
“This is where the money is”
93
Power System Planning Issues Asset Management funds the power system projects Planning typically requests funds from Asset Managers
Some pressing topics discussed include:
94
Power System Planning Issues Data Management
Lots of discussion on where data is kept, how it is transmitted
Data Security
Standards associated with Asset Management and Data Transmission
95
Power System Planning Issues Asset Health Indices
How to score asset risk
How to rank and prioritize upcoming projects
Review of new technology in monitoring
96
Power System Planning Issues Decision Support tools
Case studies & lessons learned of Asset Management implementations
ISO 55000
Warranty Management
97
Proposals Continue Asset Management Working Group format
Momentum is growing, most attendees and presentations the group has had
98
Wenyuan Li
Washington DC, USA, July 2014
PSPI Award and Recognition Subcommittee and PSPI Technical Committee Awards
• The PSPI Award and Recognition Subcommittee was formed in 2013 with the following objective, mission and tasks:
- Objective: To recognize and honor the contributions of IEEE PES members in the PSPI area
- Mission: To render IEEE PES members in the PSPI area feel appreciated for their contributions
- Tasks: 1. To select the recipients of PSPI technical awards2. Subcommittee chair to serve as a member of the
Technical Council Awards Committee
3. Subcommittee chair to serve as a member of the PESAwards and Recognition Committee
Three award levels:- Technical committee (PSPI) level (selected by PSPI award subcommittee)
1. Prize paper 2. Technical Report3. Technical Standard or Guide4. Distinguished service 5. Working group recognition award
- Technical council level (selected by TC Awards committee)1. Technical Council Distinguished Service Award 2. Technical Council Young Professional Award3. Technical Committee of the Year
- PES level 1. Major awards (each major award has a separate selection committee)2. PES prize paper/technical report/technical standard (selected by PES
Technical Awards committee)
Members of PSPI Award and Recognition subcommittee (9 members):
Wenyuan Li (chair)Anil Pahwa TCPCJohn Roach Asset Management WGHamid Zareipour Energy Forecasting WGSundar Vankataraman Transmission System Planning WGClaudia Battistelli Integrated Intelligent Customer System Planning WGHarjeet Johal Assessment of Power System Flexibility WGJoseph Yan Conventional & Renewable Energy Supply Planning WGLuis(Nando) Ochoa Modern & Future Distribution System Planning WG
Each WG has a nominator. In general, the nominator and subcommittee member are two different persons.
Activities of PSPI Award and Recognition subcommittee in 2013
• Formed the PSPI award and recognition subcommittee• Informed the PSPI members of the establishment of the subcommittee• Prepared a PSPI award document titled “Nomination and Selection of PSPI
Technical Committee Awards” and issued the document to officers of PSPI including chairs of WGs
• Each WG appointed a nominator • Established the nomination and selection processes
• Based on ML’s recommendation, we nominated one peer for the TC distinguished service award; Our nominee for the TC distinguished service award was approved by the TC Awards Committee
• Nominated and selected the PSPI prize paper• Nominated the PSPI prize paper as a candidate for the PES prize paper; Our
nominated paper was successfully selected as the unique PES Prize Paper for 2014. The award was announced and presented at the PES Award Dinner in the Tuesday evening.
• On behalf of PES, I have nominated the PSPI prize paper as a candidate for the IEEE W.R.G. Baker Paper Award for 2015
The two winners will be announced by ML right after my presentation.
• I would like to express my sincere appreciation to ML, Anil, subcommittee members and WG chairs for their strong support in 2013.
• I want to thank all nominators for their time and work in nominations. Without their efforts, it would be impossible for our success in recognizing our peers. If your nomination was not successful last year, you can re-nominate it this year.
• My special gratitude goes to ML for his vision in establishing the PSPI award subcommittee and recommendation for the nominee of the TC distinguished service award.
• My special thankfulness goes to the Conventional & Renewable Energy Supply Planning WG (Amy Li) for nominating an excellent paper for the PSPI prize paper. As mentioned earlier, this paper was selected to be the PES Prize Paper for 2014 in a very high competition and has been nominated by PES for the IEEE W.R.G. Baker Paper Award.
• I am expecting more supports in nomination and selection activities from all of you in 2014. Nominations will start right after the GM. I have sent the updated document “Nomination and Selection of PSPI Technical Committee Awards” to WG chairs with the nomination forms of five PSPI committee awards. The deadline for nominations is September 30, 2014.
Award Nominee Nominator Selector RestrictionPrize Paper Award
A journal or magazine paper (authors) in PSPI areas
PSPI member or PES member
PSPI Award and Recognition Subcommittee
Published within previous three years
Technical Report Award
An IEEE technical report (WG)
PSPI member PSPI Award and Recognition Subcommittee
Published in an IEEE publication
Technical Standard/Guide Award
An IEEE technical standard/guide (WG)
PSPI member PSPI Award and Recognition Subcommittee
Published in an IEEE publication
WG Recognition Award
Working group(not limited to existing WGs)
Self-nomination by WG chair or member
PSPI Award Subcommittee plus chair and vice chair of PSPI committee
The same WG cannot receive more than once
Distinguished Service Award
PSPI member PSPI member PSPI Award Subcommittee plus chair and vice chair of
The same person cannot receive more than once
PSPI Awards & Recognition Subcommittee Chair: Dr. Wenyuan Li
BC Hydro
107
Technical Council Distinguished Service Award
Tao Hong
For outstanding leadership of the Global Energy Forecasting Competition for the Power System Planning & Implementation Committee
The award will be presented at the Technical Council meeting at the lunch time today.
The PSPI prize paper
Wijarn Wangdee and Roy Billinton
“Probing the Intermittent Energy Resource Contributions from Generation Adequacy and Security Perspectives,” IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 27, no. 4, pp. 2306-2313, November 2012.
• This paper was successfully selected as the unique PES Prize Paper in 2014. The award was announced and presented at the PES Award Dinner in the Tuesday evening.
• This paper has been nominated by PES for the IEEE W.R.G. Baker Paper Award in 2015
ML Chan and Wenyuan Li
Washington DC, USA, July 2014
Announcement for PSPI Technical Committee Awards in 2014
Technical Council Distinguished Service Award
Tao Hong
For outstanding leadership of the Global Energy Forecasting Competition for the Power System Planning & Implementation Committee
The award will be presented at the Technical Council meeting at the lunch time today.
The PSPI prize paper
Wijarn Wangdee and Roy Billinton
“Probing the Intermittent Energy Resource Contributions from Generation Adequacy and Security Perspectives,” IEEE Trans. on Power Systems, vol. 27, no. 4, pp. 2306-2313, November 2012.
• This paper was successfully selected as the unique PES Prize Paper in 2014. The award was announced and presented at the PES Award Dinner in the Tuesday evening.
• This paper has been nominated by PES for the IEEE W.R.G. Baker Paper Award in 2015
113
Energy Forecasting WG
Proposed sessions for GM2015
Tutorial
Energy Forecasting in the Smart Grid Era
Combo Panel session
Panel Session: Global Energy Forecasting Competition 2014 Final Presentations
Description
In today's competitive and dynamic environment, more and more decision making processes in the power and energy industry are relying on probabilistic forecasts. The applications of probabilistic energy forecasts spread across planning and operations of the entire energy value chain. The Global Energy Forecasting Competition 2014 (GEFCom2014) brings together state-of-the-art techniques and methodologies for probabilistic energy forecasting. GEFCom2014 features four tracks: Probabilistic Electric Load Forecasting, Probabilistic Electricity Price Forecasting, Probabilistic Wind Power Forecasting and Probabilistic Solar Power Forecasting. This session includes the presentations from the winners and organizers of GEFCom2014 to discuss the findings and insights.
Chair: Tao Hong ([email protected]) UNC Charlotte
Totally 9 speakers with 5 unknown until early next year:
1. Tao Hong (UNC Charlotte) 2. Shu Fan (Monash University) 3. Pierre Pinson (Technical University of Denmark) 4. Hamid Zareipour (University of Calgary) 5. Winner from load forecasting track 6. Winner from wind forecasting track 7. Winner from solar forecasting track 8. Winner from price forecasting track 9. Institute prize winner
114
Nature of the session: Panel sessionTitle: Probabilistic System Planning Primary sponsor: Power System Planning and Implementation CommitteeCo-sponsor: RRPA subcommitteeChair: Wenyuan Li ([email protected])Co-chair: Michael Henderson ([email protected])
Potential speakers: Wenyuan Li (Chongqing University, China and BC Hydro, Canada)Mike Henderson (ISO-NE, USA)Mark Lauby (NERC, USA)Armando Leite de Silva (Federal University of Itajubá, Brazil)Patricio A. Rocha Garrido (PJM, USA)Milorad Papic (Idaho Power, USA)One more professor from a university (not finalized yet)
Transmission System Planning WG
115
Here are the potential panel sessions:
1. From the WG we are likely to propose a session for the GM 2015 with a title along the lines of "Distribution Planning in a Complex Environment". This panel will aim to cover integrated vehicle infrastructure, benefits and impact from smart switching schemes, multiple voltage level planning, and interactions between T&D. Coordinator: JK Wang (Ohio State University, USA). Topics:
a. Integrated electric vehicle infrastructure b. Impact of smart distribution on switching schemes (reconfiguration). Reliability
and capacity benefits c. Multiple voltage level planning d. Interactions between T&D
2. From the TF on Integration of Distributed Energy Resources there might be a panel session - potentially for the GM 2015. This is yet to be defined as we need the coordinators to formalise the scope of the TF. 3. From the TF on Smart Cities there might be a panel session. Potentially for either GM 2015 or T&D 2015 (is there a T&D 2015?). Although the coordinator seemed to be cautious about a panel session so quick, if there's interest other members can provide support. However, this is yet to be defined as we need the coordinators to formalise the scope of the TF.
Modern & Future Distribution System Planning WG
116
Conventional & Renewable Energy Supply Planning WG
Panel Title: Challenges of Renewable Integrations: Flexible Products and Long /Short Term Market Design
Panel Chair: Joseph Yan ([email protected])
Panel Summary:
This year’s panel session will build upon the conclusions reached in the previous year’s session. The following questions will be discussed to address the questions and challenges identified in the previous year’s panel session.
A. How do we define, quantify and estimate the need for flexibility in the short and long term?
B. How the long-term capacity market (or equivalent non-market process) should be set up to incentivize appropriate grid-scale and distributed generation, energy storage, energy efficiency and demand response program investment that will lead to a flexible, sustainable, efficient and reliable power system?
C. How should the ISO day-ahead and real-time markets be redesigned and coordinated with long-term capacity market to send appropriate price signal to resources that provide additional flexibility to accommodate increased penetration of intermittent resources, minimize market power, and provide incentives for the flexible capacities that are needed to balance the grid and ensure the system reliability?
D. What role renewable resources could play in reducing the volatility in net load and needs for additional products that provide “flexibility” to the system operator?
Potential panelists:
1) Gary Stern, Southern California Edison 2) Mark Rothleder, California ISO 3) Paul Sotkiewicz, PJM 4) Li Zhang, MISO 5) Alex Papalexopoulos, ECCO 6) George Gross, UIUC
• Combo WG Meeting to extend the Working Group Meeting by having paper presentations 117
I’m still putting this together. We are shooting for qualifying for at least a combo session with our Working Group meeting.
Title: Advanced Applications of Dispatchable DER in a Smart Grid Environment
Session: Panel
Chair: G. Heber Weller, P.E.
Session Scope: This session will focus on the utilization of DR for the support of the improved reliability of the Smart Grid. These applications will focus on DR systems that are dispatchable. They can be either system wide or targeted in their design and capability. Some of the issues to be addressed are the load response characteristics (time delay, predictability of performance, etc.), Interoperability of the various DR system components and what is being done to improve this aspect of DR (OpenADR, etc.).
Presenters:
Claudia Battistelli
Hiroshi Asano
G. Heber Weller, P.E.
Phil Cleveland, P.E.
Integrated Intelligent Customer Systems WG
118
1. Title: Experiences from system flexibility studies
Type: Combo Session
Chair: Eamonn Lannoye, Harjeet Johal
Panel Description: Flexibility is increasingly being cited as a driver to justify the construction of new generation capacity and changes to operations. Several studies are currently underway to determine the flexibility of current and future power systems around the world to determine which changes, if any, are necessary. This panel session will be an opportunity for practitioners to present the results of these studies in detail and to share experiences on the modeling choices and issues which arise as part of these analyses.
Possible Participants (none approached yet):
Ken Dragoon, EcoFys, Western Electricity Coordinating Council Study
Arne Olsen, E3, Outcomes from flexibility analyses in California
Lion Hirth, Potsdam Institute, The need for balancing power in Germany
Nicolas Kitten, RTE, ENTSO-E flexibility assessment methodology development for Europe
Aidan Tuohy, EPRI, Flexibility studies in the Southeast US
Assessment of System Flexibility WG -1
119
Assessment of System Flexibility WG-21. Title: Frameworks for Integrated Grid Planning
Type: Panel Session
Chair: Eamonn Lannoye, Mike Henderson
Panel Description: As the penetration of distributed energy resources is set to grow, utility planning must take into account the potential effects of DER on the system. In order to minimize cost to the consumer, planning actions need to become more coordinated between generation, transmission and distribution networks to take advantage of the capabilities of DER and to minimize any negative effects. This must be set in the context of the prevailing regulatory constraints. In light of the need to integrate DER into a coordinated set of generation, transmission and distribution planning decisions, frameworks are emerging to enable this interaction. This session will provide an opportunity to present and discus these frameworks.
Possible Participants (none approached yet):
ISO-NE, Challenges with future DER integration in New England
RED ELECTRICA, Experience with the coordination of DER in Spain
EPRI, Integrated Grid planning for DER
Tennessee Valley Authority: Coordinating planning across utility functions
TBD ISO: Implementation of integrated grid planning frameworks in an ISO context.
120
White paper on Flexibility for Power System Planning
Collaborative industry-academia forum to advance the research in the field of power system planning
Current incarnation of the document to be circulated shortly amongst group members to get initial feedback on the definition and content
Series of webcasts is planned on power system flexibility
Invite speakers to share experience, recent studies, and knowledge
Assessment of System Flexibility WG-3
121
Asset Management WG
Continue the same panel session as in GM2014 with about 16 speakers sharing their insights on asset management in a Combo meeting
The Asset management group would like to build on this year’s efforts with another panel session at PES 2015.
Title: Sharing Experiences with Asset Management
Type: Combo Session
Chair: Tony McGrail, Ken Elkinson
Panel Description: Asset Management is formalized as a discipline and growing in application. This session reviews key topics of interest raised at the 2014 PES, including hot topics such as cyber security, asset health indices and risk ranking, condition monitoring inputs to asset management, specifications and whole-of-life costing. The topics were raised by attendees at the 2014 session and were discussed by the group, with some volunteers from a wide range of industries already stepping forward to participate.
Possible Participants – some names will change as the year progresses and we plan the session in more detail:
Siri Varadan, Alstom
Gerry Sheble, Energy Power management
Nic Fantana, ABB
Johan Smit, Delft Uni
Jared Green, EPRI
Kevin Corcoran, Tollgrade
Chris Punt, Xcel Energy
Ken Elkinson, Doble 122
July 24, 2013Vancouver, BC
123
PES Awards Technical Committee Award – Substation Committee
won based on Committee Report Service Award- Artjie Gold Award – Matt from Burns McDonnell Need to submit Committee Reports to receive
consideration for Awards
124
GM2014 In National Harbor, Washington DC in last week of July Nov 30, 2013 is the deadline for submitting paper proposal 800 is the probable quota for the number of papers to be
accepted May be asked to rank the papers as part of the review, and
then TCPC will finalize the review and ranking and Acceptance/Reject
New deadline for panel session proposals by Dec 2, the second deadline after the first acceptance during the month of November
125
Tutorial Process Sue Koval is helping tutorial process, which is headed up
by Damir Tutorials are under the charge of Technical Council Compensation via W-9 will be handled by PES $1500 fee per full-day of tutorial course; $1000 for half-day
tutorial Copyright retained by the authors Have a deadline before July each year for consideration to
be presented in the next GM Should be sponsored by a Committee Submit our two proposals; one from Energy Forecasting
WG for T&D Show and one for GM2014, and one for Transmission System Planning WGs for GM2014
126
Administrative Matters Committees that take money from IEEE for their own
operations (e.g., running conferences) need to let Jeff Nelson know; IEEE needs to know
Do not freely think that you are representing IEEE for SA matters as an ER; need to be officially approved by IEEE
All PES Technical Reports will have a brand new AND uniform template in the near future. Such resources are free to PES members.
Noel Schultz suggests to recruit new membership and succession planning Gold membership, or Women membership coordinator SA wants to be involved in the international arena IEEE sponsored the Smart Grid initiative and now wants to
move that into PES, and IGCC has been doing its own thing
127
PES Technical Council Retreat Action Items – Ron Hotchkiss Virtual Meeting software and conference call numbers
should be available to facilitate communications; Contact Sue Koval, but details will be given
Online Meeting Account Management system is available to those Committees that run their own meetings
Technology Mapping TF to match the scope of each Committee vs. technologies; just started; using “word” search (contact Bill Cassel to provide the technology mapping of PSPI) within the next few months
128
Others Admin Issues PES Leader Training is in the process of developing
videos on using the website involving SA To foster the collaboration with CIGRE, we will set up a
TF to collect names of people involved with both IEEE and CIGRE.
129
O&P Working Group Put together a generic version for SA, and each
Committee can decide whether to adopt or not. This is for SA-related functions only.
Would need to send in the updated version again for the non-SA-related O&P Manual since we are including a WG on System Flexibility
130
Technical Council & Marketing Dept. Meeting More coordinated marketing for IEEE; past focus has
been on events, but need to be more holistic approach Use webinar to reach out the potential members
131
IGCC IEEE Smart Grid Vision Document at $3000 each; too
expensive Wants to work on IGBT – solid state transformers as
“DC at Home” Had a survey of the overlaps and gaps among the
different Technical Committees
132
Wind & Solar Power Coordinating Committee New leadership team on the Vice Chair and Secretary Need to inform them of our adopting the Working
Group on System Flexibility The WG on System Flexibility is formally part of PSPI.
This is adopted by Technical Council.
133
Next Meetings JTCM at 1/12/14 at New Orleans; webex will be
available GM2014 at National Harbor, Washington, DC in the
last week of July 2014 Send emails to Bill Cassel on Technology Mapping Continue to dialog with Steve Pullins on the overlap of
scope
134
New Significant Points from JTCM at New Orleans, Jan 12, 2014
Smart Grid Technology Mapping Task Force (chaired by Doug Houseman) sent out on very short notice to receive PSPI Committee’s input, only after I have requested for an input opportunity
TF on Committee Structure is being formed to examine how to re-align the Technical Committees; plan is to submit a recommended structure to the IEEE Governing Board by the end of 2014, after a review in the PES Technical Council Retreat in Nov 2014
Reinforced the importance of Awards & Recognition Subcommittee in PSPI to appreciate the hard work of all our volunteering experts
135
Quadrennial Energy Report Demanded by President Obama, and request to seek
IEEE inputs came from USDOE Again, with all high visibility government reports, very
short lead time (~ a month) PSPI Committee volunteered to submit inputs in 5 of
the 7 areas – metrics, DG & microgrids, EV integration, aging infrastructure and renewable resources; asked all PSPI Committee officers to contribute
136
IEEE Smart Grid Roadmap Effort to determine what IEEE should do (a roadmap)
to support Smart Grid implementation in the industry; led by Intelligent Grid Coordinating Committee (IGCC)
IGCC adopted the Use Case methodology to develop the roadmap
A very short lead-time effort PSPI reviewed and submitted comments on the
roadmap document
137
