Mobile Platform Security (ﬁnish) - University of … · Mobile Platform Security (ﬁnish) Fall 2016 Ada ... countries with fake packing slips ... – User approval of permissions

CSE484/CSEM584:ComputerSecurityandPrivacy

MobilePlatformSecurity

(finish)

Fall2016

Ada(Adam)[email protected]

ThankstoFranziRoesner,DanBoneh,DieterGollmann,DanHalperin,YoshiKohno,JohnManferdelli,JohnMitchell,VitalyShmatikov,BennetYee,andmanyothersforsampleslidesandmaterials...

SecurityMindset:Customs

•  ExchangeonRedditcommentthread•  Startedwithanobservationabouttheworld:– “ItriedtoshipsomethingtoVenezuela,butitwouldhavecost$80shippingand$1420intaxesanddutyimportfees!”

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 2

SecurityMindset:Customs

•  Problem:Extremelyhighcustomsfees.

•  Solution?

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 3

Lieaboutthevalueoftheitem,or,better,claimit’sbroken!

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 4

“Thatwon’tmakeitpastthecustomsinspection.Theysnatchitupinaheartbeatthenthrowtherecipientinjailforfraud.”

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 5

“Thatcan’tberight.OtherwiseIcouldjustsendpackagesofpeopleIdon’tlikeinothercountrieswithfakepackingslipstohavethemarrested.”

MobileMalwareAttackVectors

•  Uniquetophones:–  PremiumSMSmessages–  Identifylocation– Recordphonecalls–  LogSMS

•  Similartodesktop/PCs:–  Connectstobotmasters–  Stealdata–  Phishing– Malvertising

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 6

MobileMalwareExamples“ikeeisnevergoingtogiveyouup”

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 7

(Android)MalwareintheWild

Whatdoesitdo?Root

ExploitRemoteControl FinancialCharges InformationStealing

Net SMS PhoneCall

SMS BlockSMS

SMS Phone# UserAccount

#Families

20 27 1 4 28 17 13 15 3

#Samples

1204 1171 1 256 571 315 138 563 43

[Zhouetal.]

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 8

What’sDifferentaboutMobilePlatforms?

•  Applicationsareisolated–  Eachrunsinaseparateexecutioncontext–  Nodefaultaccesstofilesystem,devices,etc.–  DifferentthantraditionalOSeswheremultiple

applicationsrunwiththesameuserpermissions!•  AppStore:approvalprocessforapplications

– Market:Vendorcontrolled/Open–  Appsigning:Vendor-issued/self-signed–  Userapprovalofpermissions

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 9

TwoTypesofAppWeWanttoDefendAgainst

•  Malware•  Legit,butprivacyinvasive

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 10

(1)PermissionGrantingProblem

Smartphones(andothermodernOSes)trytopreventsuchattacksbylimitingapplications’accessto:

–  SystemResources(clipboard,filesystem).–  Devices(camera,GPS,phone,…).

Howshouldoperatingsystemgrantpermissionstoapplications?

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 11

StateoftheArtPrompts(time-of-use)

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 12

StateoftheArtPrompts(time-of-use) Manifests(install-time)

Disruptive,whichleadstoprompt-fatigue.

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 13

StateoftheArtPrompts(time-of-use) Manifests(install-time)

Outofcontext;notunderstoodbyusers.

Inpractice,bothareoverlypermissive:Oncegrantedpermissions,appscanmisusethem.

Disruptive,whichleadstoprompt-fatigue.

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 14

AreManifestsUsable?

Douserspayattentiontopermissions?

[Feltetal.]

…but88%ofuserslookedatreviews.

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 15

Dousersunderstandthewarnings?

AreManifestsUsable?[Feltetal.]

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 16

Dousersactonpermissioninformation?

“Haveyouevernotinstalledanappbecauseofpermissions?”

AreManifestsUsable?[Feltetal.]

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 17

Over-Permissioning

•  Androidpermissionsarebadlydocumented.•  ResearchershavemappedAPIsàpermissions.www.android-permissions.org(Feltetal.),http://pscout.csl.toronto.edu(Auetal.)

[Feltetal.]

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 18

WhyisOver-PermissioningBad?

•  Over-permissioning:apphaspermissiontoaccessresourcesbutneveraccessesthem.

•  Iftheappneverusestheextrapermissions,whyisitbadthatithasthem?

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 19

Manifestsrelyontheusertomakegoodchoicesatinstalltime

•  It’snotclearthatusersknowhowtomaketherightchoice–orthatthereISarightchoice.

•  Idon’twantANYapptoaccessmycameraatalltimes.Ijustwantappstoaccessmycamerawhentheyneedtoforlegitimatepurposes!

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 20

Android6.0:Prompts!

•  First-usepromptsforsensitivepermission(likeiOS).•  Bigchange!Nowappdevelopersneedtocheckfor

permissionsorcatchexceptions.

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 21

Prompsrelyontheusertomakegoodchoicesatusetime

•  It’snotclearthatusersknowhowtomaketherightchoiceatusetimeeither.

•  Stillonlychecksonfirstuse–theappcanstillusetheresourceforanyreasonitwants,atanytimenoworinthefuture.

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 22

ImprovingPermissions:AppFence[Hornyacketal.]

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 23

Let this application access my location now.

Insight: A user’s natural UI actions within an application implicitly carry permission-granting semantics.

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 24

ImprovingPermissions:User-DrivenAccessControl

[Roesneretal.]

Let this application access my location now.

Insight: A user’s natural UI actions within an application implicitly carry permission-granting semantics.

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 25

Study shows: Many users already believe (52% of 186) – and/or desire (68%) – that resource access follows the user-driven access control model.

ImprovingPermissions:User-DrivenAccessControl

[Roesneretal.]

NewOSPrimitive:AccessControlGadgets(ACGs)

Approach:Makeresource-relatedUIelementsfirst-classoperatingsystemobjects(accesscontrolgadgets).

•  Toreceiveresourceaccess,applicationsmustembedasystem-providedACG.

•  ACGsallowtheOStocapturetheuser’spermissiongrantingintentinapplication-agnosticway.

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 26

MiscThoughtsFromMobileSecurity

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 27

PermissionRe-Delegation

•  Anapplicationwithoutapermissiongainsadditionalprivilegesthroughanotherapplication.

•  Settingsapplicationis deputy:haspermissions, andaccidentallyexposesAPIsthatusethose permissions.

API

Settings

Demo malware

toggleWifi()

pressButton(0)

Permission System

toggleWifi()

[Feltetal.]

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 28

AndroidFragmentation

•  ManydifferentvariantsofAndroid(unlikeiOS)– Motorola,HTC,Samsung,…

•  Lesssecureecosystem–  Inconsistentorincorrect

implementations–  Slowtopropagatekernel

updatesandnewversions

[https://developer.android.com/about/dashboards/index.html]

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 29

USABLESECURITY

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 30

PoorUsabilityCausesProblems

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 31

si.edu

ImportanceinSecurity

•  Whyisusabilityimportant?–  Peoplearethecriticalelementofanycomputersystem

•  Peoplearetherealreasoncomputersexistinthefirstplace

–  Evenifitispossibleforasystemtoprotectagainstanadversary,peoplemayusethesysteminother,lesssecureways

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 32

Today

•  3casestudies– Phishing– SSLwarnings– Passwordmanagers

•  Stepback:rootcausesofusabilityproblems,andhowtoaddress

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 33

CaseStudy#1:Phishing

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 34

ATypicalPhishingPage

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 35

WeirdURLhttpinsteadofhttps

SafetoTypeYourPassword?

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 36


11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 37


11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 38


11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 39

“Picture-in-pictureattacks”Trainedusersaremorelikelytofallvictimtothis!

ExperimentsatIndianaUniversity

•  ReconstructedthesocialnetworkbycrawlingsiteslikeFacebook,MySpace,LinkedInandFriendster

•  Sent921IndianaUniversitystudentsaspoofedemailthatappearedtocomefromtheirfriend

•  Emailredirectedtoaspoofedsiteinvitingtheusertoenterhis/hersecureuniversitycredentials–  Domainnameclearlydistinctfromindiana.edu

•  72%ofstudentsenteredtheirrealcredentialsintothespoofedsite

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 40

MoreDetails

•  Controlgroup:15of94(16%)enteredpersonalinformation

•  Socialgroup:349of487(72%)enteredpersonalinformation

•  70%ofresponseswithinfirst12hours•  Adversarywinsbygainingusers’trust

•  Also:Ifasitelooks“professional”,peoplelikelytobelievethatitislegitimate

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 41

PhishingWarnings

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 42

Passive(IE)

Active(IE)

Active(Firefox)

ArePhishingWarningsEffective?

•  CMUstudyof60users•  AskedtomakeeBayandAmazonpurchases•  Allweresentphishingmessagesinadditiontothe

realpurchaseconfirmations•  Goal:compareactiveandpassivewarnings

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 43

[Egelmanetal.]

•  Activewarningssignificantlymoreeffective–  Passive(IE):100%clicked,90%phished–  Active(IE):95%clicked,45%phished–  Active(Firefox):100%clicked,0%phished

Activevs.PassiveWarnings

Passive(IE) Active(IE) Active(Firefox)11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 44

[Egelmanetal.]

•  Somefailtonoticewarningsentirely–  Passivewarningtakesacoupleofsecondstoappear;if

userstartstyping,hiskeystrokesdismissthewarning

•  Somesawthewarning,closedthewindow,wentbacktoemail,clickedlinksagain,werepresentedwiththesamewarnings…repeated4-5times–  Conclusion:“websiteisnotworking”–  Usersneverbotheredtoreadthewarnings,butwere

stillpreventedfromvisitingthephishingsite–  Activewarningswork!

UserResponsetoWarnings[Egelmanetal.]

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 45

•  Don’ttrustthewarning–  “Sinceitgavemetheoptionofstillproceedingtothe

website,Ifigureditcouldn’tbethatbad”

•  Ignorewarningbecauseit’sfamiliar(IEusers)–  “Oh,Ialwaysignorethose”–  “LookedlikewarningsIseeatworkwhichIknowto

ignore”–  “Ithoughtthatthewarningsweresomeusualones

displayedbyIE”–  “MyownPCconstantlybombardsmewithsimilar

messages”

WhyDoUsersIgnoreWarnings?

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 46

[Egelmanetal.]

TheLockIcon

•  Goal:identifysecureconnection–  SSL/TLSisbeingusedbetweenclientandserverto

protectagainstactivenetworkattacker

•  Lockiconshouldonlybeshownwhenthepageissecureagainstnetworkattacker–  Semanticssubtleandnotwidelyunderstoodbyusers– Whosecertificateisit??–  Probleminuserinterfacedesign

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 47

WillYouNotice?

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 48

[MoxieMarlinspike]

⇒

Cleverfaviconinsertedbynetworkattacker

SiteAuthenticationImage(SiteKey)

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 49

Ifyoudon’trecognizeyourpersonalizedSiteKey,don’tenteryourPasscode

DoTheseIndicatorsHelp?

•  “TheEmperor’sNewSecurityIndicators”–  http://www.usablesecurity.org/emperor/emperor.pdf

Usersdon’tnoticetheabsenceofindicators!

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 50

CaseStudy#2:BrowserSSLWarnings

•  Designquestion:Howtoalerttheuserifasite’sSSLcertificateisuntrusted?

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 51

Firefoxvs.ChromeWarning

33%vs.70%clickthroughrate

[Feltetal.]

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 52

Experimentingw/WarningDesign[Feltetal.]

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 53


11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 54


11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 55


11/30/16 56CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016


11/30/16 57CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016

OpinionatedDesignHelps!

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 58

[Feltetal.]

Adherence N30.9% 4,551

OpinionatedDesignHelps!

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 59

Adherence N30.9% 4,55132.1% 4,075

[Feltetal.]

Adherence N30.9% 4,55132.1% 4,07558.3% 4,644

Challenge:MeaningfulWarnings

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 60

[Feltetal.]

PasswordManagers

•  Separateapplicationand/orextensioninyourbrowser.

•  Remembersandautomaticallyenterspasswordsonyourbehalf.

•  Seemspossiblyeasierthanrememberingallyourpasswords.Isitmoresecure?

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Fall2016 61

Question

•  Q.Whataretherootcausesofusabilityissuesincomputersecurity?

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 62

Issue#1:Complexities,LackofIntuition

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 63

Wecansee,understand,relateto. Toocomplex,hidden,nointuition.

RealWorld ElectronicWorld

SSL/TLSRSA

XSS

SpywarePhishing

Bufferoverflows

Issue#1:Complexities,LackofIntuition

•  Mismatchbetweenperceptionoftechnologyandwhatreallyhappens–  Publickeys?–  Signatures?–  Encryption?– Messageintegrity?–  Chosen-plaintextattacks?–  Chosen-ciphertextattacks?–  Passwordmanagement?–  ...

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 64

Issue#2:Who’sinCharge?

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 65

Complex,hidden,andusersmanage

RealWorld ElectronicWorld

SSL/TLSRSA

XSS

SpywarePhishing

Bufferoverflows

Whereanalogybreaksdown:Adversariesintheelectronicworldcanbeintelligent,sneaky,andmalicious.

Userswanttofeellikethey’reincontrol.

Complex,hidden,butdoctorsmanage

Issue#2:Who’sinCharge?

•  Systemsdevelopersshouldhelpprotectusers–  Usableauthenticationsystems–  Usableprivacysettings(e.g.,onsocialmedia)–  User-drivenaccesscontrol

•  Softwareapplicationshelpusersmanagetheirapplications–  Anti-virussoftware–  Anti-webtrackingbrowseradd-ons–  PwdHash,Keychainforpasswordmanagement–  Somesay:Canwetrustsoftwareforthesetasks?

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 66

Issue#3:HardtoGaugeRisks

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 67

"Irememberedhearingaboutitandthinkingthatpeoplethatclickonthoselinksarestupid,"shesays."Thenithappenedtome."Ms.Millersaysshenowchangesherpasswordregularlyandavoidsclickingonstrangelinks.(OpenDoors,byV.Vara,TheWallStreetJournal,Jan29,2007)

“Itwon’thappentome!”(Sometimesareasonableassumption,sometimesnot.)

Issue#4:NoAccountability

•  Issue#3isamplifiedwhenusersarenotheldaccountablefortheiractions–  E.g.,fromemployers,serviceproviders,etc.–  (Notallpartieswillperceiverisksthesameway)

•  Also,recallthatauser’spoorsecuritychoicesmayaffectotherpeople

–  E.g.,compromiseaccountofuserwithweakpassword,thenexploitalocal(ratherthanremote)vulnerabilitytogetrootaccess

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 68

Issue#5:Annoying,Awkward,orDifficult

•  Difficult–  Remembering50different,“random”passwords

•  Awkward

–  Lockcomputerscreeneverytimeleavetheroom

•  Annoying

–  Browserwarnings,virusalerts,forgottenpasswords,firewalls

•  Consequence:–  Changinguser’sknowledgemaynotaffecttheirbehavior

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 69

Issue#6:SocialIssues

•  Publicopinion,self-image

–  Only“nerds”orthe“superparanoid”followsecurityguidelines

•  Unfriendly–  Lockingcomputerssuggestsdistrustofco-workers

•  Annoying

–  Sendingencryptedemailsthatsay,“whatwouldyoulikeforlunch?”

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 70

IssueswithUsability

1.  Lackofintuition–  Seeasafe,understandthreats.Nottrueforcomputers.

2. Who’sincharge?–  Doctorskeepyourmedicalrecordssafe,youmanageyour

passwords.

3. Hardtogaugerisks–  “Itwouldneverhappentome!”

4. Noaccountability–  Asset-holderisnottheonlyoneyoucanloseassets.

5. Awkward,annoying,ordifficult6. Socialissues

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 71

Question

•  Q.Whatapproachescanwetaketomitigateusabilityissuesincomputersecurity?

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 72

Response#1:EducationandTraining

•  Education:–  Teachingtechnicalconcepts,risks

•  Training–  Changebehaviorthrough:

•  Drill•  Monitoring•  Feedback•  Reinforcement•  Punishment

•  Maybepartofthesolution–butnotthesolution

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 73

Response#2:SecurityShouldBeInvisible

•  Securityshouldhappen

–  Naturally–  ByDefault–  Withoutuserinputorunderstanding

•  Recognizeandstopbadactions•  Startingtoseesomeinvisibility

–  SSL/TLS–  VPNs–  AutomaticSecurityUpdates–  User-drivenaccesscontrol

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 74

Response#2:SecurityShouldBeInvisible

•  “Easy”atextremes,orforsimpleexamples–  Don’tgiveeveryoneaccesstoeverything

•  Buthardtogeneralize

•  Leadstothingsnotworkingforreasonsuserdoesn’tunderstand

•  Userswillthentrytogetthesystemtowork,possiblyfurtherreducingsecurity–  E.g.,“dangeroussuccesses”forpasswordmanagers

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 75

Response#3:“3WordUI”:“AreYouSure?”

•  Securityshouldbeinvisible–  Exceptwhentheusertriessomethingdangerous–  Inwhichcaseawarningisgiven

•  Buthowdousersevaluatethewarning?Tworealisticcases:–  Alwaysheedwarning.Butseeproblems/commonality

withResponse#2(“securityshouldbeinvisible”)–  Alwaysignorethewarning.Ifso,thenhowcanitbe

effective?

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 76

Response#4:FocusonUsers,UseMetaphors

•  Clear,understandablemetaphors:–  Physicalanalogs;e.g.,red-greenlights

•  User-centereddesign:Startwithusermodel•  Unifiedsecuritymodelacrossapplications

–  Userdoesn’tneedtolearnmanymodels,oneforeachapplication

•  Meaningful,intuitiveuserinput–  Don’tassumethingsonuser’sbehalf–  Figureouthowtoasksothatusercananswerintelligently

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 77

Response#5:LeastResistance

•  “Matchthemostcomfortablewaytodotaskswiththeleastgrantingofauthority”–  Ka-PingYee,SecurityandUsability

•  Shouldbe“easy”tocomplywithsecuritypolicy

•  “Usersvalueandwantsecurityandprivacy,buttheyregardthemonlyassecondarytocompletingtheprimarytasks”–  Karatetal,SecurityandUsability

11/30/16 CSE484/CSEM584-Spring2016 78

Documents

Mobile Platform Security (ﬁnish) - University of … · Mobile Platform Security (ﬁnish) Fall 2016 Ada ... countries with fake packing slips ... – User approval of permissions