26
MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC From the badlands of Ethiopia to the coasts of Florida… Whoa. Look at that little guy go. In the bones of ancient creatures, and deep inside your own DNA lies an incredible story. The story of your body, and why you’re built the way you are. You are a cutie. The shape of your hands, your rich color vision, the way you walk, and even the structure of your brain… I mean, I find that mind-blowing. …Can all be traced back to ancient primates living in an ancient forest. NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC My name is Neil Shubin. As an anatomist, I look at human bodies differently from most people. Within us, I see the ghosts of animals past. Distant ancestors who shaped our anatomy in surprising ways. Prepare yourself for a trip back to an ancient world. If you really want to know why you look the way you do, it's time to meet your inner monkey. MUSIC OUT MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary past. But if you know how to look, there’s a story written in the bodies of these skaters, and every one of us. Anyone who’s fallen on the ice knows there’s one bit of your body you don’t want to land on. It’s a remnant from a time when our ancestors looked like monkeys, complete with tails. Each of us have a vestige of our tail inside of us, we call that the coccyx. And that sits at the base of our spine. When we fall on that, it really can hurt. And the coccyx is just the beginning. Inside all of us is a record of our ancient primate past, what I like to call an inner monkey. The way we see the world, the way we walk, and even the way we think, can all be traced back to a time when our ancestors lived in the trees. MUSIC OUT MUSIC IN NEI SHUBIN VO If you have a hard time believing we have an inner monkey, try meeting modern day monkeys face to face. In a sense, these guys, squirrel monkeys, are our distant cousins. That is so cool. Hey, bub. I mean, it's hard not to look at these guys and feel a deep connection, in a way that you don’t feel to fish. When you look in their eyes, when you see their hands, you see the little nails and how they grab this little nut, just like I'm holding it here. I mean, it's hard not to feel something powerful connecting you. But the power of that is also scientific, the power of that is in the anatomy, in the bones, and also in the fossils that show us the history we share with them. We’re primates, monkeys and apes and people. But we’re all part of the same branch of the tree of life, and all primates are different from other mammals… MUSIC OUT NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC

MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

MUSICINNEILSHUBINVO/OCFromthebadlandsofEthiopiatothecoastsofFlorida…Whoa.Lookatthatlittleguygo.Inthebonesofancientcreatures,anddeepinsideyourownDNAliesanincrediblestory.Thestoryofyourbody,andwhyyou’rebuiltthewayyouare.Youareacutie.Theshapeofyourhands,yourrichcolorvision,thewayyouwalk,andeventhestructureofyourbrain…Imean,Ifindthatmind-blowing.…Canallbetracedbacktoancientprimateslivinginanancientforest.NEILSHUBINVO/OCMynameisNeilShubin.Asananatomist,Ilookathumanbodiesdifferentlyfrommostpeople.Withinus,Iseetheghostsofanimalspast.Distantancestorswhoshapedouranatomyinsurprisingways.Prepareyourselfforatripbacktoanancientworld.Ifyoureallywanttoknowwhyyoulookthewayyoudo,it'stimetomeetyourinnermonkey.MUSICOUTMUSICINNEILSHUBINVO/OCIfyougodowntoyourlocalicerink,youmightnotexpecttofindevidenceofyourancientevolutionarypast.Butifyouknowhowtolook,there’sastorywritteninthebodiesoftheseskaters,andeveryoneofus.Anyonewho’sfallenontheiceknowsthere’sonebitofyourbodyyoudon’twanttolandon.It’saremnantfromatimewhenourancestorslookedlikemonkeys,completewithtails.Eachofushaveavestigeofourtailinsideofus,wecallthatthecoccyx.Andthatsitsatthebaseofourspine.Whenwefallonthat,itreallycanhurt.Andthecoccyxisjustthebeginning.Insideallofusisarecordofourancientprimatepast,whatIliketocallaninnermonkey.Thewayweseetheworld,thewaywewalk,andeventhewaywethink,canallbetracedbacktoatimewhenourancestorslivedinthetrees.MUSICOUTMUSICINNEISHUBINVOIfyouhaveahardtimebelievingwehaveaninnermonkey,trymeetingmoderndaymonkeysfacetoface.Inasense,theseguys,squirrelmonkeys,areourdistantcousins.Thatissocool.Hey,bub.Imean,it'shardnottolookattheseguysandfeeladeepconnection,inawaythatyoudon’tfeeltofish.Whenyoulookintheireyes,whenyouseetheirhands,youseethelittlenailsandhowtheygrabthislittlenut,justlikeI'mholdingithere.Imean,it'shardnottofeelsomethingpowerfulconnectingyou.Butthepowerofthatisalsoscientific,thepowerofthatisintheanatomy,inthebones,andalsointhefossilsthatshowusthehistorywesharewiththem.We’reprimates,monkeysandapesandpeople.Butwe’reallpartofthesamebranchofthetreeoflife,andallprimatesaredifferentfromothermammals…MUSICOUTNEILSHUBINVO/OC

Page 2: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

…inhavingcertainfeaturesthatothermammalsdon’thave.Wehaveacertainshapetoourskull,oureyesfaceforward.Wehaveaparticularkindofhandthatcangrasp.Weshareanevolutionaryrelationshipwiththem.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVOToseewhatImean,imaginealllifethathaseverexistedonagiantfamilytree,fromthefirstmicroscopiclifebillionsofyearsago,toallanimalsalivetoday.Wedidn’tevolvefrommodernmonkeys.But,ifyoutraceourancestrybackintime,eventuallywereachapointwherethehumanlineandthelinesofallprimatesmeet.Thisiswhereourstorybegins.Ourcommonancestor.Theancestorofeverymonkey,apeandhumanalivetoday.Sowhatdidthatcommonancestorlooklike?Andhowhasitshapedourownbodies?MUSICOUTMUSICINNEILSHUBINVO1870.Asurgeonfromthecivilwarhasreturnedtohispre-warpassion:huntingfossilsintheWildWest.InWyomingterritory,hefindsajawbonehethinksmightbelongtosomethinglikeasmallraccoon.Infact,he’sfoundacreaturethatlivedsome50millionyearsago,andoccupiedaplaceonourfamilytreeveryclosetothefirstprimates.NEILSHUBINVOI’vecometomeetthiscreature,callednotharctus.Andascientistwhoknowseveryinchofitsbones,JonathanBloch.JONATHANBLOCHOCThisisa50million-year-oldprimateskeleton.Itgivesusawindowstraight…MUSICOUTJONATHANBLOCHOC/VO…intotheworldofwhattheearliestprimateswouldhavebeendoing,howtheywouldhavebeeninteractingwiththeirenvironment.NEILSHUBINVOWow.JONATHANBLOCHOCThat’stherealthing.NEILSHUBINVO/OCThisistherealdeal.MUSICINJONATHANBLOCHOCRight.NEILSHUBINVO/OCThatisabsolutelyexquisite.

Page 3: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

NEILSHUBINVOLikemostmodernmonkeys,notharctuswasaclimber,adaptedtolifeinthetrees.Theevolutionofthiscreature,andotherslikeit,hadahugeimpactononeofthefeaturesthatmostdefinesus…NEILSHUBINVO…ourhands.JONATHANBLOCHVOOneofthethingsthat’sreallyniceaboutthishandisthatwedohaveallofthebonespreserved.NEILSHUBINVO/OCSoit'slikeajigsawpuzzle.Yougottoputitalltogethertoseehowthat…JONATHANBLOCHVOIt'sathree-dimensionaljigsawpuzzle.NEILSHUBINVOTosolvethepuzzleofnotharctus’shands,youhavetobeginevenfurtherbackintime.Over365millionyearsago,ancientfishusedtheirfinstocrawloutofthesea.Thosefinsevolvedintothefeetofreptiles,andlaterintothepawsofmammals,withshortfingersthatallpointedthesameway,andclaws.Earlyprimateslikenotharctustookthemammalianhandtoawholenewlevel,onethatseemsveryfamiliartous.JONATHANBLOCHVOWhenyouactually…MUSICOUTJONATHANBLOCHVO/OC…articulatealloftheseboneswhatyouseeisthat,thethumbisdivergent,thatisitformsananglewiththeindexfinger.Andsothatshowsyouthatitcouldbringitsthumbintooppositionwiththerestofthedigits.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVONotharctusalsohasunusuallylongfingersandnailsinsteadofclaws.Thisisoneofthefirsttimesinthefossilrecordthatweseeahandthatlookslikeourown,thehandofaprimate.NEILSHUBINVOIt’saturningpointinthestoryofthehumanbody,ananatomicalchangethatwouldeventuallyletusshapetheworldaroundus.Sowhatwereearlyprimatesdoingwiththesenewhands?JIMVOJustpullituplikethat.MUSICOUT

Page 4: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

NEILSHUBINVOTofindout,I'mgoingupintothehabitatwheremyancientancestorsactuallylived,upinthetrees.Thankfully,I'vegotropes,myinnermonkey’snotwhatitusedtobe.Okay,ready?JIMVO/OCYeah.Areyou?Yougotit,natural.NEILSHUBINVOWhoo-hoo.Alittleknottyuphere.JIMVOJustpushyourhandjammerabithighersoyoucanpulltheropethroughyourcrawl.NEILSHUBINOC/VOWhoo-hoo.Thankyou,Jim.MUSICINNEILSHUBINOCThisisutterlywild.Imean,Iwasneverarealclimberasakid,andIhavetoadmitI'malittlescaredofheights,anduncomfortableintrees.Butthesecreaturesaresounbelievablyagileallthroughhere,thisistheirhome.Theyareabletoliveonsmallbranches,bigbranchesthroughoutthetree.Theycanjumpbranchtobranch.Youknowwhenyou’reinthetree,whatyouseeisthatthecanopyisnotoneplacetherearelotsofenvironments,lotsofnichesuphere,andonespecialoneisontheendsofthebranches,becauseit’stherewheretheflowersandthefruitsandtheinsectsare.Sotherewardsaregreattobeoutthere.Wecallitthe‘finebranchniche’.Andfortheearliestprimates,beingabletogetouttherewouldhavebeenreallyimportant.Andthatgivesusaclueastowhytheirhandsandfeetevolvedtobesodifferentfromwhatcamebefore.Creatureswithreallyshortfingersandclaws,they’rereallygreatatcrawlingthesebigthickbranches,butnotsomuchwhenyougettotheendsofthebranches.That’sbecausethissortofhandcan’tgrasp.Lengtheningthefingers,andbetterstilladdingadivergentthumb,meansyoucancurlyourfingersaroundeventhethinnestbranches,graspthemtight,andremainstable.Wethinkthat’swhythehandsandfeetofearlymammalschanged.Whatyouendupwithareprimatehands,wonderfullyadaptedtomovingaroundthefinebranchesoftrees.Embeddedinourbodiesisourdistantpast.ThehandIusetowritewith,totypeonthecomputer,tothrowabaseball,thathandhasalongevolutionaryhistory,andoneimportantpointinthathistory,washereinthetreesonthefinebranches,thatmadeahandwithlongerfingersandathumb.NEILSHUBINVOLifeinthetreeswouldleadtoanothercriticalchangeinourancestors’bodies.Achangedeepwithintheireyes,astheybegantoseetheworld,inrichcolor.MUSICOUTNEILSHUBINIfirstgotinterestedintheevolutionofcolorvisionbackin2009.IwaswatchingmytwokidsNathanielandHannah,playingagamecalledHisswheretheymatchedcardsofacertaincolortomakeasnake.NathanielisaboutthreeandahalfyearsolderthanHannah,soheshouldwhupher,right?Butheconsistentlylost.Andhewouldlosebecausehe’dmakemistakeswithonekindofcard,whichwaspurpleandblue.NATHANIELAw.

Page 5: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

NEILSHUBINVOAndthenwerealizedNathaniel'slikelycolorblind.Inasense,heseestheworldlikeearlyprimatesdidbeforetheyevolvedourrichcolorvision.Nathanielcanonlyseealimitedrangeofyellowsandblues,andcan’ttellthedifferencebetweenreds,greensandpurples.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVOThismeanshe’snotsogreatatgameslikeHiss.Butitdoesn’taffecthislifemuchmorethanthat,anditcertainlydoesn’taffecthisabilitytofindfood,ortosurvivetoadulthood.Thatwasn’t…NEILSHUBINVO…thecaseforourprimateancestors.Formillionsofyears,they’dbeenunabletotellthedifferencebetweenfineshadesofredandgreen.Then,about23millionyearsago,onegroupofprimatesevolvedtheabilitytoseemanymorecolors.Nowtheycouldtellthedifferencebetweenriperedfruits,andunripegreenfruitsandspotthemostnutritiousleaves.Intheevolutionarybattleforsurvival,thiswouldhavebeenabigadvantage.Sowhathappenedtotheeyesofourancestors?Howdidourrichcolorvisionevolve?NEILSHUBINVOTohelpmeanswerthosequestions,I'vecometoSeattle,tomeetoneoftheworld’sexpertsoncolorvision,JayNeitz.NEILSHUBINVOOh,hey.NeilShubinhere.JAYNEITZOCHey,greattomeetyou.MUSICOUTNEILSHUBINOCGoodtoseeyou,well,greattobeinthecolorlab.JAYNEITZOCWell,thankyou.NEILSHUBINOCWell,Ithinkwe’reofftoarockingstartwiththesewalls.Ohmy,thisisthecolorlab.JAYNEITZOCYesitis.NEILSHUBINVOSowhat’sthedrillhere?Jay’sbeenstudyingcolorvisionforthelast25years.Hecombinescuttingedgegeneticswithstudiesonhumansandotherprimates.JAYNEITZOCEverythingiscoolaboutcolor.JAYNEITZVO

Page 6: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

It’sasilentlanguagethatspeaks……toouremotionsandit’sjustfascinating.NEILSHUBINVOThisistheplacehuh?JAYNEITZYup.Thisiswherewetestcolorvisioninthemonkeys.NEILSHUBINVOHisworkhelpedscientistsfigureoutthatmostmammals,includingmostprimates,seealimitedrangeofcolors.JAYNEITZVOThisisKramer.NEILSHUBINVOHiKramer.JAYNEITZVO/OCAndKramer'sredgreencolorblind,buthehasgoodblueyellowcolorvision.Inordertotrainthem,weusethecolorsthattheycansee,soasyoucanseethathere’sthisyellowblobagainstagraybackground.Kramer,canseethataswellaswecan.Iftheygetitright,theygetalittlereward,andtheyalsogetaclickingsound.NEILSHUBINVO/OCOhheclearly,hewastryingtokissitthere.Hereallydid,hewentbop.JAYNEITZVOYoucanseehowgoodheisatit.NEILSHUBINVO/OCYeah,heis.Krameracesthisfirsttest.You’vedonereallywellthereKramer.Butchangethecolorstoredandgreen,andit’sawholedifferentballgame.JAYNEITZVOIfyoudon’thaveanycolorvision,thisiscompletelyinvisible.Ifyoucan’tseeredorgreen,thisjustlookslikeatotallygraybackground.NEILSHUBINVOMosthumanscanclearlyseethisredblob,butKramercan’t.LikemysonNathaniel,hecan’ttellthedifferencebetweenredsandgreens.JAYNEITZVOOkay,Kramer,youwereastar.NEILSHUBINVOSowhyisthishappening?Whydoesn’tKramerseetheworldlikewedo?MUSICIN

Page 7: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

NEILSHUBINVOKramer’seyes,likealleyes,relyonspecialproteinscalledopsinstodetectcolor.NEILSHUBINVOThey’reheldinthousandsofspecialcellsintheretinainthebackoftheeye.Kramer’sgottwotypesofopsin,eachtunedtospecificwavelengthsoflight.Signalsfromtheseopsinsaretheninterpretedbythebrainwhichallowsustoperceivecolor.Buttoseecolorlikewedo,Kramerwouldneedathirdopsin,tunedtodifferentwavelengthsoflight.NEILSHUBINVOWethinkourearlyprimateancestorswerelikeKramer,theyhadjusttwoopsinsaswell.Sohowdidtheyevolveathirdopsin?TheanswerisinourDNA.NEILSHUBINVOEachopsinisencodedbyasinglegene.Andwhenscientistscomparedthesegenes,theyfoundthatthegenefortheneweropsinsitsrightnexttooneoftheoldones,andsignificantly,theyareincrediblysimilar.Bothfactsaretelltalecluesastohowtheextrageneevolved.Theoldopsingenemusthavebeenduplicated,andoneofthesecopiesthenacquiredasmallnumberofmutationsthatallowedittodetectdifferentwavelengthsoflight.Butthere’sonemorequestion.Couldourrichcolorvisionresultfromjustduplicatingagene,orwouldtherehavetobechanges…NEILSHUBINVO…tothebrainaswell?Tofindout,Jayhastriedtoreplicatewhathappenedinnatureinhislab.JAYNEITZVO/OCIt’sactuallyagreatevolutionaryquestion,howdidcolorvisionevolve?Howcansomethingsocomplicatedevolve?NEILSHUBINVOJayimplantedathirdopsingenefromahumandirectlyintotheretinasofacolor-blindsquirrelmonkeycalledSam.JAYNEITZOCWhatwedidisreallyatesttoseewhat’stheminimalthingyoucandoinordertogiveananimalcolorvision.NEILSHUBINVOTheresultswereincredible.LikeKramer,Samusedtofailthistest,nowhecaneasilytellthedifferencebetweenredsandgreens.Jayhasrecreatedevolutionaryhistory,andgivenSamhuman-likecolorvision.JAYNEITZVO/OCYoumightthink,ohitwouldtakehimalongtimetolearnthisnewpatterninthebrain,butassoonasthegenewasturnedon,theanimalbegantomakethesediscriminationsthattheycouldn’tmakebefore.Thebrainwasalreadyreadysomehow.Andsoinone,youknow,veryshortevolutionarystepitgoestothistotallydifferentworld.Yougofrom…JAYNEITZVO…justhavingstrictly,let’ssay,fivecolors,gray,black,white,blueandyellow,tohundredsofdifferentcolors,thatareallofthebluesandgreensandpurplesandoranges.NEILSHUBINOnesimpleshiftopensawholeuniverseofcolor.JAYNEITZVOYeah,that’stheamazingthing,it’slikethere’ssomethingalmostmagical.It’samultiplicativeeffect.

Page 8: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

NEILSHUBINVOFortheearlyprimatesthatevolvedthisability…MUSICOUTNEILSHUBINVO…itwasahugeadvantageonethatwouldeventuallybepassedontous.NEILSHUBINVOAndcolorstillplaysahugepartinourlivestoday.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVOColorhelpsuscommunicate,attractattention,andevenexpressemotions.Weoftentakeitforgranted,butitmassivelyenrichesourexperienceoftheworld.NEILSHUBINVOGoodboy.NEILSHUBINVO/OCButourfocusonvisionhascomewithsometradeoffs,namely,ourpoorsenseofsmell.LikemosthumansI'mexperiencingthiswonderfulvistaherewithmyeyes.Butthedog’sexperiencingthisinaverydifferentway.Hisisaworldofsmells.Wethinkthatadog’ssenseofsmellisanywherefromathousandtoamilliontimesbetterthanours.Likemanymammalsit’shismainwayofunderstandingtheworldaroundhim.ThisfundamentaldifferenceinoursenseofsmellisalsoreflectedinourDNA.Adoghasaboutathousandgenesthataredevotedtodetectingodors.Wehaveroughlythesamenumber,butabout600ofthemdon’tworkanymore,they’rerelics.It’sasimilarstoryinotherprimateswithcolorvision.Thesebrokengenesrevealanotherlegacyofourprimatepast.Asourdistantancestorsgainedthiswonderfullyrichsenseofcolorvision.Whathappenedwasoursenseofsmellbecamelessimportantandintheevolutionaryworldit’suseitorloseit.Andthat’sexactlywhathappenedtooursenseofsmell.Itdiminishedovertime.NEILSHUBINVOSowhilewecanthankourinnermonkeyforourwonderfulcolorvisionwecanalsoblameitforourlousysenseofsmell.NEILSHUBINVO/OCOfcourse,wehumanshavealsomadesomeradicalchangestotheancientprimatebodyplan.Unlikemonkeys,westanduponourowntwofeet.Youknowanimalshavebeenwalkingonthisplanetforover365millionyears,andforthemostpart,thatwalkinghasbeenonfourlegs.Walkingontwolegsisafundamentallystrangewaytogetaround.Nootherprimate,andveryfewothermammals,movethisway.It’sachangethathadprofoundeffectsonthehumanbody.Whichbegsthequestion,howonearthdidithappen?NEILSHUBINVO

Page 9: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

ThebestplaceintheworldtoanswerthisquestionisinAfrica.Asitewherethegreatriftvalley…NEILSHUBINVO…cutsdeepintoancientrocks,exposingfossilsfromourdistantpast.ThesearetheremotebadlandsofnorthernEthiopia.Lookatthoserocks.Boom,boom,boom,boom,boom,justtotallystretchedout.Asapaleontologist,thatiswhatIdreamabout.Thisistrulyinthemiddleofnowhere.DONJOHANSONVO/OCNowyouseethatvolcanicashcroppingout?That’s3.4millionyearsold.NEILSHUBINVOThatisincredible.MyguideisDonJohanson,oneofthefirstpeopletohuntforfossilsherebackintheearly‘70s,andachildhoodheroofmine.DONJOHANSONVOThere’sthecamp.NEILSHUBINVOThereonthefarsideoftheriverrightthere.DONJOHANSONVOFabulous.NEILSHUBINVOTwoofthemostimportantfossilsforunderstandingtheoriginsofbipedalismhavebeenfoundinthissmallregionofEthiopia.Don’stakingmetoseewherethefirsticonicfossilwasfound.A3.2million-year-oldhumanancestorknownasLucy.DONJOHANSONVO/OCItwasaSundaymorningbackin1974.SoIcameupherelookedatthishadnoideawhatwaswaiting.Iwasrightinthisarea,righthere.WhatIsawwasafragmentofbone,andIlookedatit,andalmostinstantaneouslysaid,"That’sahominid."NEILSHUBINVOWow.Lucymadeheadlinesaroundtheworld,becausealthoughshelookedlikeanape,shewalkedontwolegs.Shewasabiped,atthatstagethemostancientanyonehadfound.DONJOHANSONVO/OCOncewebrokethatthreemillionyearbarrieritwasawholenewpictureofwhatourearliestancestorslookedlike.Oneofthemostexcitingmomentsofmyentirecareer.NEILSHUBINVOSinceDonfirstcamehereinthe‘70s,scientistshaveorganizedexpeditionsheremostyears.They’vefoundover400individualfossilsfromLucy'sspecies.Butit’sLucyImostwanttomeet.Herbonesaresomeofthebestevidencewehaveforwhatearlybipedslookedlike.DONJOHANSONVO/OCNowofcourseifthiswereallarticulatedproperly,youknow,thevertebrae…MUSICOUT

Page 10: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

DONJOHANSONOC…ontopofoneanother…NEILSHUBINVOYou'dseeit.DONJOHANSONOC/VO…she’dbeaboutthreeandahalffeettall.Youdon’tseethat.NEILSHUBINYeah,youdon’tgetthat.DONJOHANSONOCHere’sthefemur.NEILSHUBINOCThat’stheleft.DONJOHANSONOCTopendofthethighbone.NEILSHUBINVO/OCAndthisonealsowhenyouputitalltogether,nowyouhave,youknow,thisistellingbipedal,thisisgivingahintofbipedal.DONJOHANSONOC/VORight.Thiscertainlytellsitwasbipedal.Thatcantsinlikethat,whichisverycharacteristic.Ourkneesareclosetogetherandtheycomeuptotheside,chimpscomestraightup.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVOHavingtheupperandlowerleginastraightlineisnogoodforabiped,itmakesforanawkward,waddlinggait.Lucy’slegsformedanangle,herkneeswereclosertogether,justlikeourownkneesthispositionsthefeetdirectlyunderneaththebody,makingwalkingeasier,andmoreefficient.DONJOHANSONVOThereweare.NEILSHUBINVO/OCTherewego.SoLucywalkedmuchlikeus.Butshewasn’thuman.Shehadmanyprimitivefeatures,too.Nowthisisarealmix,youknow.MUSICOUTDONJOHANSONOCThisisarealmix.

Page 11: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

NEILSHUBINYeahit’samazing.DONJOHANSONOCYeah.NEILSHUBINOCThisisveryprimitive,right?DONJOHANSONOCApe.NEILSHUBINOCApelike,apelike.DONJOHANSONOCVerysmallbrain.Andveryapelikeproportions.NEILSHUBINApelike.Butbipedal.DONJOHANSONOCButbipedal.NEILSHUBINOCCool.DONJOHANSONOCAndthesehandswouldhavestretcheddowntoabouthere.NEILSHUBINOCSodown.Yeah,it'sthekneealmost.NEILSHUBINVOItisjustsoutterlyfabulous.DONJOHANSONVO/OCIsn’titinterestingtohavethepileofbones,youputherhere,andallofasuddenyoucanseethatitwasalivingperson.NEILSHUBINVOShe’sbeautiful.DONJOHANSONOCYep.Thankyou.MUSICOUTGROUPVO<Singing>.

Page 12: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

DONJOHANSONVOWenamedherafterthepeopleandtheland.WenamedherAustralopithecusafarensis,fromtheAfarregion.GROUPVO<Singing>.NEILSHUBINVOSoimagineifLucywasherewithusrightnow,whatwouldshelooklike?DONJOHANSONOC/VOWellshe’dbeshort.Shewasonlyaboutthreeandahalffeettall.Andtheonethingthatwouldbefamiliartous,shewouldbewalkingupright.Withthoselongarms,reachingalmostdowntoherknees,she’dprobablyhaveaveryoddgait.Andasshegotcloserwe’dseethatshehadaveryapelikeface.Idon’tthinkyouwouldseemuchofaglimmerofphilosophicalthoughtinhereyes.Ithinkinmanywaysshe’dlookliketheapethatstoodup.NEILSHUBINOCYeah.DONJOHANSONOCYouknow?NEILSHUBINVOYeah,that’samazing.GROUPVO<Singing>.NEILSHUBINVOLucytellsusthatby3.2millionyearsago,ourancestorshadfullycommittedtowalkingontwolegs.Whatshecan’ttellus,ishowourancestorsfirststartedwalkingupright.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVOToanswerthatquestion,weneedtomeetasecondiconicfossil,foundjust50milesfromtheLucysite.Thisfossil,calledArdipithecus,hasturnedourideasabouthowwebecamebipedalontheirhead.NEILSHUBINVOI’vecometoBerkeley,California,tomeettheguywholedtheteamthatdiscoveredArdi,anoldcolleagueofmine,TimWhite.NEILSHUBINVOTim’soutinthefieldinEthiopiamostyearsandhedocumentshisworkmeticulouslywithavideocamera.Theserarelyseenfield-tapesdatefromtheearly‘90s.TIMWHITEVOWhatwewantedtodowastoplumbtheunknown.TIMWHITEOC

Page 13: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

TofigureoutwhatcamebeforetheLucyspecies.TIMWHITEVOWejustliterallydidn’tknowwhatwewouldfind.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVOSince1992,theteamhasrunannualexpeditionstoaremotesitecalledtheMiddleAwash.SomeoftherockshereweremillionsofyearsolderthanthenearbyLucysite.TIMWHITEVOYouseethetworesistantbands,upthereonthehill…NEILSHUBINVORight.TIMWHITEVO…they’rediggingintothelowerband,bothofthesearedatedto4.4million.NEILSHUBINOCThiswasreally…TIMWHITEOC/VOWenailedit,soanythingbetweenthatis4.4millionyears.NEILSHUBINVOThisbandofancientrockyieldedsometantalizingfragments.Sotheyscouredthislayerformonthsonend.Thebreakthroughfinallycamein1994.AnEthiopiangraduatestudent,YohannesHaile-Selassie,foundafragmentofhandboneinthatsamelayer.TIMWHITEVOHepickedup…TIMWHITEOC…andsaidthislookslikeahominid,TIMWHITEVO/OC…sowescrapedandbrushedthatsurfaceandwefoundsomeofthesehominidhandandfootbonesinplace.Andsowefocusedonthatlittlehill.Andweturnedthevideocameraonanddug.NEILSHUBINOhwow.TIMWHITEVOThisisthewaywetookitoffvirtuallyamillimeteratatime.Yougottobereallycareful.Youknow,youscratchthatyouputyoursignatureonitforever.Herecomesthemandible,caninesoffonthelefthandsiderightthere,herearetheteethcomingout.NEILSHUBINOC/VO

Page 14: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

Youknow,soasapaleontologist,you’rethefirstpeopleintheentireplanettoseethat.TIMWHITEOCThat’sbeenburiedfor4.4millionyears.NEILSHUBINOC/VOThiswasahugelysignificantfind,anewspeciesofhominidatacriticalmomentinhumanevolution.Atimewhenourancestorswerejustbeginningtowalkontwolegs.Sowhiletheywerestillinthefield,MUSICOUTNEILSHUBINVO…TimwantedtocollectasmuchinformationashecouldaboutArdi’sworld.MUSICINTIMWHITEVOWhatwe’reout…TIMWHITEOC…todoistounderstandeverythingwecanaboutthattimeslice,andat4.4millionyears,anythingwelearnisnew.TIMWHITEVOAndsothatmeansbringinginsedimentologistswhounderstandwhatkindofasetting,wasitariver,wasitafloodplain.Bringinginpaleontologistsexpertintheplants,inthebirds,intheshrews.NEILSHUBINVOWherevertheyfoundArdi’sspecies,theyfoundwoodlandcreatures–parrots,monkeys,andpeacocks,aswellaswoodlandplants.TIMWHITEVO/OCItwasawoodland,notanopensavannahsetting.NEILSHUBINOC/VONowthat’sasurprise.TIMWHITEThesewerewoodlandanimals.NEILSHUBINVO/OCThatrunscountertosomuchofwhatpeopleexpected.TIMWHITEVO/OCItrunscounterallthewaybacktothe1800s.NEILSHUBINVOForoverahundredyearsthere’sbeenonemaintheoryofhowourancestorsstartedtowalkontwolegs.Thetheorygoeslikethis:westartedoutasapesthatlivedinthetrees.Welookedlikechimpanzees,andwalkedonallfoursusingtheknucklesofourhands.Buttheclimatechanged,andonlyafterforesthadturnedtosavannah,didwestart

Page 15: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

walkingontwolegsinsteadoffour.Arditellsaverydifferentstory.Shewasalreadywalkinguprightwhilelivinginthewoodlands.NEILSHUBINVOArdi’sskeletonrancountertotheoldtheorytoo.Itwasunlikeanythinganyonehadseenbefore.Ittookateamofexperts15yearstofullypiecehertogether.Sohowdoweknowshewasbipedal?ThemaninchargeoffiguringouthowArdimighthavemovedwasanatomistOwenLovejoy.MUSICOUTC.OWENLOVEJOYVO/OCThecriticalthinginbipedalityisthestructureofthepelvis.Andatfirstwhenyoulookatthisboneyoumightthinkthatthere’snotmuchinformationhere,butactuallythere’sanenormousamountofinformationthattellsyouagreatdealaboutwhattheoriginalbonelookedlike.NEILSHUBINVOUsinginformationfromthisdeformedbone,theteamwasabletoreconstructArdi’sentirepelvis.C.OWENLOVEJOYVOThisisaplasticstructurethat’sproducedbyathreedimensionalprinter.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVOThetoppartofArdi’spelvislooksmorehuman.Thehip-boneisshortandbroad,akeyindicatorofbipedalism.Butthelowerhalfismuchlongerthanahumanpelvis,moreusefulforclimbing.TIMWHITEVOWhenyou…TIMWHITEOC…gottothatdetail,yourealizeditwasamosaicofanatomythathadneverbeenencounteredbefore.NEILSHUBINVOItsuggeststhatArdicouldwalkontwolegs,butnotaswellaslaterhominidslikeLucy.Andtherestofheranatomyheldsurprisestoo.TIMWHITEVO/OCNeitherLucynorhumanshavetheabilitytograspwiththeirbigtoe,butthisthinghadfullgraspingability.NEILSHUBINOCSoshehasagraspingfootthatcanwalk.C.OWENLOVEJOYOCYes.MUSICOUTNEILSHUBINVO

Page 16: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

Eventhehandswereamosaic,incrediblylongfingers,goodforclimbing,butashorter,humanlikepalm.Andthebonesshownoneofthetelltalesignsthatshewalkedonherknuckleslikeachimpanzee.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVOSowenowhaveadetailedpictureofthecrucialtimewhenourancestorshadjuststartedwalkingontwolegs.NEILSHUBINVOArdiwassmall,aroundfourfeettall;agoodclimber,shemovedonallfourswheninthetrees,butshewalkeduprightwhenontheground.Sheblowstheoldtheoryofhowwebecamebipedaloutofthewater.Notonlydidourancestorsstartwalkingontwolegswhenstilllivinginthewoods,theyneverlookedormovedlikeourclosestlivingrelative,thechimpanzee.Somescientistsdon’tacceptthisinterpretation.TheythinkArdiisn’tahumanancestoratall,buttherelicofanextinctape.NEILSHUBINVOButTim’sspentyearsstudyingmanyspecimensofArdipithecus.MUSICOUTNEILSHUBINVOAndhethinkstheevidenceisclear.TIMWHITEVOWhenwelookedattheArdicraniumwesawverysmallcanines.Nootherape,livingorfossil,hassuchreducedcanines.TIMWHITEOCThat'sagoodindicatorshe'scomeinourdirectionabit.Gotothepelvis.MUSICINTIMWHITEVOSamething.AuniqueadaptationsharedbyhumansandLucy.NEILSHUBINVOWe’restillnotsureexactlywhyawoodlandclimberneededtowalkontwolegs.ButthankstoArdiwenowhaveasnapshotofoneofthemostdramatictransformationsinthehistoryofourspecies;thetransitionfromwalkingonfourlegs,towalkingontwo.Thismajorchangetoourancestralbodyplanhasseriousconsequencesforustoday.MUSICOUTMUSICINNEILSHUBINVOTheseconsequencescanbeseenwithinourownbodies,andthey’renotallgood.ThisvaultinthebowelsoftheClevelandMuseumOfNaturalHistoryistheplacetogoifyouwanttofindoutwhatcangowrongwiththehumanskeleton.Dr.BruceLatimerisananthropologistandanatomistwhowasacuratorhereformanyyears.BRUCELATIMERVO/OC

Page 17: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

Well,thisistheHamann-ToddCollection,whichisthelargestcollectionofitstypeintheworld.Thereareover3,000skeletonsinthisroom.Ineachoneofthesedrawersisacompletehumanskeleton.NEILSHUBINVOTheycomefromunclaimedbodiesataClevelandmorgue,datingfromtheearly1900s.Ifyoustudytheseskeletons,onethingbecomesclearprettyquickly.Thehumanbackgoeswrong.Alot.BRUCELATIMERVOThere’sanenormousamountofbackproblems.Thepainmusthavebeenphenomenal,andyoujustseethatalloverthiscollection.NEILSHUBINVOTurnsout,ourbadbacksareanunwelcomeinheritancefromourinnermonkey.MUSICOUTBRUCELATIMERVO/OCWetookaskeletonlikethisthatwasessentiallyhorizontal,westooditupright,we’vehadtochangeessentiallyeverybonetoallowustodothat,andwe’veforceditintothisnewposition.Wehaveaproblemgoingfromthiskindofanimalintothatkindofanimal…MUSICINBRUCELATIMEROC/VO…andourmainproblemisbalance.NEILSHUBINVOOnallfours,theweightofourbodyhangsdownfromourspine.Butturnthisbodyupright,andtheweightisalloutfront,itputsusoutofwhack.Totallyoutofbalance.BRUCELATIMEROC/VOInordertobalancewehadtocreatethiscurveinyourback,andthenyourheadwouldbebackherewouldn’tit,sowehadtocreate…MUSICOUTBRUCELATIMEROC/VO…anothercurvehereinthemiddleofyourchest,andthenyourheadwouldbestickingoutofthefrontsowehadtocreateanothercurveinyourneck.AndsowehavethisS-shapedcurveinourspine,andweexpectthattoholdusup.Thatisanengineeringnightmare.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVOOurS-shapedspineisuniqueamongmammals,anditcausesallsortsofproblems.Thevertebraethatmakeupthebonesofyourback,andthediscsbetweenthem,areputunderalotofpressure,particularlytheonesattheveryapexofthebiggestcurve,thethoracicvertebra.BRUCELATIMERVO/OC

Page 18: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

Ifyoutakethosethoracicvertebraeandyoupushonthemfromtheendstoohard,whathappensisthis,youendupwithwhat’scalledawedgefracture.Thatcurvehascrunchedit.Nootheranimalhasanythingevenremotelylikethis.It’saconsequenceofhowwewalk.NEILSHUBINVOAndit’snotjustfracturedvertebrae,fromslippeddiscstosciaticaourspinesgowronginallkindsofways.80percentofallAmericanswillcomplainofbackproblemsatsomepointintheirlives.Ourinnermonkeyhasalottoanswerfor.NEILSHUBINVOButIdon’twantyoutogetthewrongidea.Standingupontwolegswasn’tallbad,oritneverwouldhavehappenedinthefirstplace.Itfreedourhands,ananatomicalchangethat,combinedwithouramazingbrains,wouldeventuallyallowustomaketoolsandreshapetheworldaroundus.ThiskeymomentinourevolutionaryhistoryisonceagainvisibleintherocksofnorthernEthiopia.Sogeologicallyoneofthethingsthat’sspecialaboutthisisithaslotsoflayers.Lucy’sfromonepartofitandwe’regoingtoanother,right?BILLKIMBELVO/OCThat’sright.Wehavejustjumpedaboutsixor700,000yearsintime.NEILSHUBINVOAndthatiskindofmind-blowing.BILLKIMBELVOYeah.NEILSHUBINVOPaleontologistBillKimbelhasbroughtmetoasitewhereyoucanfindstonetoolsthatareovertwomillionyearsold,ifyouknowwhatyou’relookingfor.SowhatdoIlookfor?BILLKIMBELOCWell,youlookforflakesontheground.NEILSHUBINVOWow,isthatbone?BILLKIMBELVO/OCThatisapieceoffossilboneandhereisanotherone.NEILSHUBINOCSeeIcan’tfindtool,butIcanfindbone.BILLKIMBELOCYeah.NEILSHUBINOC/VORight.Theimportantthingabouttoolsisit’sthehandandthebrainright,it’sbothtogether.BILLKIMBELOCAbsolutely.

Page 19: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

NEILSHUBINVOYougotone?BILLKIMBELVOOh,yeah.Yougotaniceone.DONJOHANSONWell,thisisverytypically,NEILSHUBINOCThat’saniceone?Idon’tgetthisatall.DONJOHANSONOCYeah,Iknow,itlookslikesomethingfromyourdriveway.NEILSHUBINOC/VORight.ThetoolDon’sfoundwasmadebyhumanancestorscalledHomohabilis,wholivedamillionyearslaterthanLucy.DONJOHANSONOC/VOClearlysomeearlyhumantookastone,ahammerstoneandstruckitrightthere,andgotthis.NEILSHUBINVOOhyeah.Thatstriation,yeah.DONJOHANSONVO/OCAndyouseeithasthis.Feelthatedge.Youcoulduseittostripoffmeatorwhatever.NEILSHUBINOC/VOSofromthisrockyoucantellwheretheyhitit,howtheyhitit.It’salmostlikeatimemachineyouhave.BILLKIMBELVO/OCItis.It’satimemachinethattakesusbacktoaperiodwhenthefaintestglimmersofwhatitmeanstobehumanarebeginningtoemerge,theuseofthehand,thecognition,therepeatedbehaviortoproduceastylizedtool.DONJOHANSONOCIt’smind-blowing.NEILSHUBINVO/OCWow.Canwelookfortools?Iwanttofindatool.No,that’snatural.BILLKIMBELOC/VONo,thisisone.You’vefoundone.NEILSHUBINVOMakingtoolstakesexcellentvision,finemotorskills,andabrainthatcanintegratethetwo.Wehumansonlyhavethissortofbrainbecauseit’sbeenshapedbyourancientprimatepast.NEILSHUBINVO

Page 20: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

Monkey,apeorhuman,ourbrainsshareabasicarchitecturethat’sdifferentfrommostothermammals.Weallhaveaspecialregioninvolvedwithhand-eyecoordination.Andagreatlyexpandedvisualsystem,withasmuchas40percentofthebraininvolvedinseeing.NEILSHUBINVOOurinnermonkeyhasn’tjustshapedourbodies,it’sshapedourbrainsaswell.NEILSHUBINVOButifyoulookatthemodernworldaroundus,andeverythinghumanshavebeenabletobuild,fromsatellitestoskyscrapers,there’snodoubtwe’remoreintelligentthanmonkeys.Sowhatchanged?Whatmadeourbrainssodifferentfromthoseofotherprimates?MUSICOUTNEILSHUBINVOHi,NeilShubin.TOMBURBACHEROCHiNeil,it’sTomBurbacher,welcometotheInfantPrimateLab.NEILSHUBINOCGoodtoseeyou.Sothisisthemonkeyplace,huh?TOMBURBACHEROCThisisthemonkeyplace.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVOTomBurbacherstudiesmonkeysinordertoanswerquestionsaboutourownbrains.He’sgoingtoshowmeanexperimentthatdemonstratesanimportantdifferencebetweenourbrains,andthebrainsofamonkey.Butthedifferencesaren’twhatyoumightexpect,especiallywhenwe’reyoung.Monkeyontheset.KIMVO/OCMonkeyontheset.Neil,thisis“C.I.”she’sathree-month-oldpig-tailedmacaque.NEILSHUBINVOThisexperimenttestssomethingcalledobjectpermanence.Inotherwords,whetherthismonkeyknowsanobjectstillexistswhenshecan’tseeit.It’sadevelopmentalmilestoneforbothmonkeysandhumans.MUSICOUTKIMVO/OCYou’regoingtoputapieceoffruitonthetoyitself.You’llplaceitinthewell.NEILSHUBINVO

Page 21: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

She’slookingatit.There.KIMVOAndyou’llmovethattocompletelyhidethattoy.NEILSHUBINVOOkay.Ohwow.TOMBURBACHERVOThereyougo.Thereyougo.NEILSHUBINVOWow.Thatisimpressive.TOMBURBACHEROCObjectpermanence.NEILSHUBINOCJustboom,boom.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVO/OCThreemonthsold,andalready“C.I.”understandsobjectpermanence.“C.I.”youaregood.NEILSHUBINVOHiGeneva,howareyou?Youareacutie.Genevaisthesameageasthebabymonkey.I’mgoingtodotheexactsametestonher,undertheexperteyeofchilddevelopmentspecialist,ProfessorSusanSpieker.SUSANSPIEKERVOSheneedstoreachforthem,showthatshe’sinterested.NEILSHUBINVOOhIthinkwe’vegotinterest.SUSANSPIEKERVOOhshe’sgotagoodreach.NEILSHUBINVO/OCYoudo.Lookatyou.OhGeneva,youlikethose.Hello.SUSANSPIEKERVONow,Neil,canyougetthemaway?NEILSHUBINVO/OCOh,I'manexpertatthis.CanItakethatforasecond?Sorry,it’llbetemporary.Youaresogoodthatway.I’llpopitin.SUSANSPIEKERVOMakesureshe’swatching.

Page 22: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

NEILSHUBINOC/VOShe’swatching.Nowwe’llcoveritup,watchthis.SUSANSPIEKERVOAndshewonders,"Whatdidyoudo,Neil?"NEILSHUBINVOWhattoys?SUSANSPIEKERVOIdon’tknowwheretheywent.NEILSHUBINVO/OCWow.Thatisamazing.SUSANSPIEKERVOWheredidtheygo?NEILSHUBINOCItisincredible.Ifit’snotthereitdoesn’texist.SUSANSPIEKEROCRight.Right.NEILSHUBINOCThatisamazing.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVO/OCSohowcomeababymonkeybeatsababyhumaninthistest?Thesetestsareshowingushowrapidlyaparticularregionofourbrainiswiringupindevelopment.Andit’sshowinguscomparativelythatwewireupmuchslowerinthispartofthebrainthandomonkeys.NEILSHUBINVOComparedtootherprimates,wehumanshaveanunusuallylongchildhood,evenifyoutakethedifferentlifespansintoaccount.Thisshouldbeanevolutionarydisadvantage.Butinfact,it’soneofourgreateststrengths.Duringchildhood,ourbrainsarebeingshapedbyourenvironment,andbyourexperience.Extendingthisphasegivesuslongertolearn,andpickupnewskills.Somethinkthatthisisakeypartofwhatmakesussosmart.NEILSHUBINVOButthereareotherfactorstoo.Thebrainismadeupofvastnetworksofnervecells,calledneurons,thatcarry,processandstoreinformation.Thepartofthehumanbrainresponsibleforhigherthought,thecortex,containsmoreneuronsthanthatofanyotheranimalontheplanet,anastonishing16billion.Theseneuronsareorganizedinauniquelypowerfulway,they’reunusuallyinterconnected.Thismeanswecandothingsthatotherprimatescan’t,buildcomplextools,composesymphonies,andeveninvestigatehowourownbrainswork.NEILSHUBINVO/OC

Page 23: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

Butbeforewegettoocarriedawaywithourowncleverness,Iwanttoinjectabitofhumility.Thatmeansleavingmonkeysbehind,andgoingbacktowherethisseriesbegan,myanatomylabinChicago,andmyfavoritesubject,fish.Thebrainofafishandthebrainofahumanhavemoreincommonthanyoumightthink.Thisisatriptothebeginning,thisisasbasicasitgets,we’regoinghuman,fish,representedbyacartilaginousfish,asharkontheright.Andwhatyouhaveisyouseethemusclesandnervesandorgansinsidethesharkhead.Butimportantly,youseethisyellowtissue,thisisthefrontendofthespinalcord,it’sthebrain,itdoesn’tlooklikemuch,butit’sthesharkbrain.Thisisthehumanbrain.Thisiswhereitallhappensforus,whereourmemoriesreside,whereyouknowourfears,ourloves,ourhatesit’sallinhere.Thehumanbrain,reallyatthesurfacelevel…MUSICOUTNEILSHUBINOC/VO…looksnothinglikewhat’ssittinginsidethesharkhead.Yet,whenyouknowhowtolook,youfindaveryprofoundsimilarityandthatsimilarityliesintheoverallarchitectureofthebrainitself.Inthehumanwehaveaforebrainandthatforebrainconsistsofthisfoldedtissuehere,wheremuchofourconsciousthoughthappens.Andthenthere’samidbrain,thiswalnutsizedareinthemiddle.Andthenahindbrain.That’safundamentaldivision,weseethatindevelopmentandweseethatbasedonwherethenervesexitthebrain.Well,ifyoufollowthesimilarnervesinasharkwhatyouseeissharkstoohavethatsamestructure–aforebrain,amidbrainandahindbrain.There’safundamentalarchitecturalsimilarityamongallbrains–thebrainsofpeople,thebrainsofdogs,thebrainsofcats,thebrainsofmonkeys,lizards,frogs,salamanders,trout,bass,evensharksandfisharesimilar.Eachoneofthemhasaforebrain,andamidbrainandahindbrain,despitethefactthatthosebrainsareoftenverydifferentinfunctionandform.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVOButthat’snottheendofthestory.Thefundamentalarchitectureofourownbrainscanbetracedbackevenfurtherthanfishtoasurprisinglyprimitiveanimalthatdoesn’tevenreallyhaveabrain.ButI'vegottofindthesetinycreaturesfirst.PETERHOLLANDOCRight,okay.Well,wecanstarttryingaroundhere.NEILSHUBINOCXmarksthespot.PETERHOLLANDOCXmarksthespot.Let’sgiveitago.NEILSHUBINOC/VOThisisPeterHolland,aworld-renownedgeneticist,andHeadofZoologyatOxfordUniversityinEngland.Okay,sowhatdoIdo?PETERHOLLANDVOJustshakeit.NEILSHUBINOCShakeandbake,huh?I'llmakeitlooksoeasy.Likethat?No?PETERHOLLANDOC/VO

Page 24: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

No.They’llbeprettyobviousbecausethey’llstart,they’llreallyswimaround.Thewatermakesthediggingslightlyharder.NEILSHUBINVOItdoes.PETERHOLLANDVO/OCYougotone.There’sanamphioxus.NEILSHUBINVOWegotan.Whoa.Lookatthatlittleguygo.Hey.PETERHOLLANDVOJustdipitinthewateragain,andyou’llseeit’llflickaround.NEILSHUBINVOBoy,theyreallyflick.PETERHOLLANDVOThere,yousee?Thereheis.NEILSHUBINOC/VOHey,that’sbeautiful.Lookatthat.Whichisthefront?Itdoesn’tlooklikemuch,butthistinycreature,calledamphioxus,hasmuchtotellusaboutourownbrains.Thatiscool.Okay,thatranksascool.PETERHOLLANDVOOkay,solet’stakealookatacoupleofthese.MUSICOUTNEILSHUBINVO/OCSoI'vebroughtthisfromtheanatomylabinChicago,thisisahumanbrain.AndwhenIlookatthisIdon’tfindanyobvioussimilaritiestothat.MUSICINPETERHOLLANDVO/OCDeepinthegenesofthisanimal,inthedevelopmentofthisanimal,anddeepinthegenesofusandthedevelopmentofustherearethesimilarities.They’repretty,they’reprettyactive.NEILSHUBINOC/VOHolycow!Ohthatisbeautiful.God,they’resoclear,too.Youcanseerightthroughthem,youknow,it’samazing.PETERHOLLANDVOYeah,yeah,yeah.NEILSHUBINVOAmphioxuslivesinthesandoftheoceanfloor,filteringalgaeoutofthewater.It’sfromanincrediblyancientgroupofanimals.We’vefoundfossilsthatlookalotlikethisinrocksthatareover500millionyearsold.Theyareawindow

Page 25: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

intowhatcamebeforethefirstfish.Andcruciallytheydon’thaveanythinglikewhatwe’dcallabrain.Thesimplenervechordthatrunsthelengthoftheirbody,endswithjustatinyswellinginvisibletothenakedeye.PETERHOLLANDVO/OCIfyoulookatthefrontendofthisanimalyoudon’tseeitallexpandedintoalargeskullorbrainregion.It’sjustpointed.NEILSHUBINVOButifyoulookatthegeneticmakeupoftheseancientcreatures,youfindsomethingtrulyremarkable.NEILSHUBINVOTomaketheforebrain,midbrainandhindbrainthatwesawinourlab,youneedaseriesofcontrolgenestotellthecellswithinthedevelopingbrainwheretheyare,they’relikeazipcode.Thosesamecontrolgenesthatmakeourownbrains,areactiveinamphioxus,butherethey’resimplybuildingtheprimitivenervechord,andthetinyswellingatitsfront.Thismeansthatthegenetic…NEILSHUBINVO…rootsofourcomplexprimatebrainsexistedinmuchsimplercreaturesthatfirstaroseover500millionyearsago.PETERHOLLANDVO/OCIthinkitgivesusaglimpseintowhereourbrainscamefromintothebasicorganizationofthebrainofourancestors.NEILSHUBINOCImean,Ifindthatmind-blowing.PETERHOLLANDOCIt’sjustanexcitinganimal.MUSICOUTNEILSHUBINVOHeknowsyou’retalkingabouthim.See?He’sgoing.PETERHOLLANDOCThat’sright.He’sgoing.Youcanseethemuscleblock’sreallyworkingthere.NEILSHUBINVOExactly.PETERHOLLANDOCYouknow,andIthinktoanevolutionary.Whoa.He’sjumpedoff.NEILSHUBINVOOh,hehopped.PETERHOLLANDOCSorry.

Page 26: MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC - HHMI BioInteractive · MUSIC IN NEIL SHUBIN VO/OC If you go down to your local ice rink, you might not expect to find evidence of your ancient evolutionary

NEILSHUBINVO/OCHe’sgoingTiktaalikonus.He’sgoingland-living.He’sgonearound.PETERHOLLANDVOHe’sgoneforthenexttransition.NEILSHUBINOCExactly.He’sintheDevoniannow.MUSICINNEILSHUBINVO/OCThesearchforourinnerfishhastakenmefromhighinthearctic…Herewasthesnoutofexactlythecreaturewewerelookingfor.…totheplainsofAfrica…Yeah,Ijustwanttorundownhereandstartcollectingfossils.DONJOHANSONOCLet’sgo.NEILSHUBINVO/OC…aswellasdeepinsideourownDNA.Andtodaywesawalittletinywormlivinginthemudhereinthebaythatcontainsgenesthatwehavethatsculptourownbrains,theorganthatgivesusmanyofouruniqueproperties.We’veseenhowourdistantrelatives,fromwormstofish,fromreptilestoearlyprimateshavedefinedourbodies.Ateachnewstageofourjourneyalongthetreeoflife,ourancientanimalancestorshavereconfiguredwhat’sgonebefore.Andthat’showweendedupastheintelligent,creatureswithallourquirkyflaws,thatdominatetheplanettoday.There’ssomethingincrediblyprofound,andIthinkbeautifulintheideathatinsideeveryorgan,cellandgeneofourbodyliedeepconnectionstotherestoflifeonourplanet.MUSICOUTMUSICINMUSICOUT