Nationaal Studie Comité B3 Hoogspanningsstations

23 maart 2013 Thema dag Nationaal SC Cigré

Topics:

1. Leden Studie Nationaal Comité B3 2. Actieve werkgroepen 3. Brochures 4. Tutorials 5. Strategic plan B3 6. Thema dag B3 “Het onderstation de

betrouwbare Hub” 7. Activiteiten nationaal comité 2013/2014 8. Opmerkingen

23 maart 2013 Thema dag Nationaal SC Cigré

Leden Studie Nationaal Comité B3

K.P. Knol ( voorzitter) Liandon B.V.

F.L. Baldinger Locamation Control Systems B.V.

H. Eleveld (secretaris) KEMA CONSULTING

D. Boender Stedin Netbeheer B.V.

T van Rijn Alliander N.V.

A.J.P.M Geraerds Essent Energie

E.C. (Bert) Wervers TenneT

J.J.M. Langedijk Siemens Nederland N.V.

M. van Meggelen Alstom Grid Nederland

E de Meulemeester KEMA CONSULTING

M.T. Rienks TenneT

T.G. Spriensma Eurovolt Consultancy BV.

S. J. Rotsteeg ABB Energie B.V.

A. Visser SBI Connectors Espana S.A

J.A. Wiersma Stedin Netbeheer BV.

J.J Smit TU Delft

23 maart 2013 Thema dag Nationaal SC Cigré

Actieve werkgroepen

B3.35 Substation earthing system design

optimisation through the application of risk analysis

B3.25 SF6 analysis for AIS, GIS and MTS

condition assessment

B3.30 Guide to minimize the use of SF6 during

routine testing of electrical equipment

B3.29 Field test technology on UHV substation

construction and operation

B1/B3.33 Feasability of a common dry type

interface for GIS and Power cables of 52 kV and above

WG B3.24 Benefits of PD diagnosis on GIS

condition assessment

B3.23 Guidelines for uprating and upgrading

of substations

B3.36 AC Collector Systems and Substations associated with HVDC connected Wind

Powers Plants

B3.34 Expected impact of future grid concept

on substation management

B3.31 Air insulated substations design for

severe climate condition

B3.32 Saving through optimized maintenance

of Air insulated Substations

B3.13 Reducing replacement time of HV

Equipment

B3/C1/C2.14 Circuit Configuration Optimisation

JWG B3/B1.27 Factors for investment decision GIL vs.

Cables for AC Transmission

Internal arc effects in medium voltage switchgear

B3.XX

B3:36 Sidney Wijnbergen Piet Knol

B3:32 Theo van Rijn B3:XX Yvette Peterman-Gunther

B3:34 Johan Smit

Actieve werkgroepen Area 2

WG Nr. WG Title2013 20142012

JulJul Jul

1 Residual Life Aspects Applied to HV GIS Switchgear

2 SF6 -analysis for AIS/GIS and MTS Condition Assessment

3Guide to minimize the use of SFduring routine testing of electrical equipment

10

JanFebMar AprMayJun AugSepOctNovDecJanFebMar AprMayJun AugSepOctNovDecJanFebMar AprMayJun AugSepOctNovDec

7

5

4

6

B3.17

8

B3.25

B3.30

B3.29

B1. 33 /B3. 33B1.27/B3.27

B3.24

Field Tests Technology on UHV Substation during construction and operationCommon dry type interfaces for GIS connections above 52 kV for Extruded AC cablesFactors for investment decision GIL vs. Cables for AC TransmissionBenefit for Partial Discharge diagnosis on GIS condition assessment

WG TitleWG Nr.

9

Area 2 meetings

Internal arc defects in MV switchgears (1 – 52 kV) – mitigation technicsBased on CIGRÈ brochure No. 499 residual life HV GIS

B3.37

Tutorial

6

WG disbanded, Brochure No. 499

Approval on publication

Tutorial available, see B3.17

Brochure distributed for approval

1)

Legend

WG-meeting Area-meeting 1) Next meeting in Berlin/ Germany 04/2014

Final meeting Draft

Publication

Actieve werkgroepen Area 3

Legend

WG-meeting Area-meeting 1) Next meeting in Berlin/ Germany 04/2014

Final meeting Draft

Publication

JanFebMar AprMayJun OctNovDecJanFebMar Jun OctNovDecJanFebMar Jun

AugSepOctNovDecWG TitleWG Nr.

2. SecretaryWG Nr. WG Title

2012 2013 2014

Jul Jul Jul Jul

1

2

3

4

5

6

Guidelines for uprating and upgrading of substationsAir insulated substations design for severe climate condition

Saving trough optimized maintenance of Air insulated Substations

AugSepOctNovDecJanFebMar AprMayJun AugSepOctNovDecAugSepOctNovDecJanFebMar AprMayJunJanFebMar AprMayJun

B3.23

B3.31

Area 3 meetings

B3.32

1. Convener 2. Secretary

1. Hiroshi Imagawa, Japan 2. Gilles Tremouille, France 1. Mark Mcvey, US 2. John Nixon, UK 1. Hugh Cunningham, Ireland 2. Romain Migné, France

2) (WG has been disbanded)

7 Progress of work AA4 | xx Study Committee B3

AA4

B3.06.01 “Maintenance and organisation”-contracting

• Part of overview paper at Brisbane B3/D1 Colloquium • “Integrated Substation Life management and Asset Information Strategy”

• A guide is finalized, however now waits for completion with two or

more sample contracts to make it a TB • “Practical Guide for the Outsourcing of Asset Management Services”

8 Progress of work AA4 | xx Study Committee B3

AA4

• B3.06.05 “Practical application of AM information strategies”,

convener S. Läderach (CH)

• Part of overview paper at Brisbane B3/D1 Colloquium • “Integrated Substation Life management and Asset Information Strategy”

• TB submitted to SC,

• “Practical application of asset management information strategies”

• Closing TF5

23 maart 2013 Thema dag Nationaal SC Cigré

Actieve werkgroepen

10 Progress of work AA4 | xx Study Committee B3

AA4

• B3.34 Expected impact of future grid concept on substation mgt • future grid impact on substation subsystem and component management

• practical feasibility including reliability/availability

• Evaluate technical, economical and environmental aspects

• identify implications and requirements on e.g. ratings, functionality, location

• impact of providing future grid intelligence, requirements on ICT

• Members from 15 countries, internationally well distributed • Part of overview paper at Brisbane B3/D1 Colloquium

• “Integrated Substation Life management and Asset Information Strategy”

• EPRI document on grid transformation serves as guide • Members appointed to write sections • The survey is ready for processing

11 Progress of work AA4 | xx Study Committee B3

Tutorials Studie Comité B3

1. Residual life aspects on GIS (Peter Glaubitz, WG B3.17)

2. Upgrading and uprating of substations (Akira Okada, WG 3.23)

3. Obtaining value from on-line monitoring (Arthur Mackrell, WG B3.12)

4. Standardisation vs. innovation in substation design (Terry Krieg, B3.11)

5. Application Guidelines for Turn-Key Projects (Akira Okada, Gilles Tremouille)

6. Circuit Configuration Optimization (Gerd Lingner)

7. Responsible Use of SF6- Challenges and Options (Peter Glaubitz)

8. High Voltage Off Shore substations (John Finn, WG B3:26)

9. Special Considerations for AC Collector Systems and Substations associated with HVDC connected Wind Power (Douglas Ramsay B3:36)

12 Progress of work AA4 | xx Study Committee B3

Brochures Studie Comité B3

B3.11 Combining Innovation with Standardisation 389 B3.12 Obtaining value from Substation Condition Monitoring 462 B3.15 Cost Reductions of Air Insulated Substations 354

B3.10 Primary /Secondary system interface modelling for total asset performance optimization 472

B3.17 Residual Life Concepts Applied to HV GIS 499 B3.20 Mixed Technologies Switchgear MTS 390 B3.18 SF6 Tightness Guide 430 B3.21 Turnkey Substations 439 B3.22 Tech. requirements for substations exceeding 800kV 400 B3.23 Guidelines for uprating and upgrading of substations 532

B3.26 Guidelines For The Design And Construction Of AC Offshore Substations For Wind Farms

483

B3.29 Field Tests for UHV Substations (with CIGRE) B3.25 SF6 Analysis for AIS, GIS and MTS Condition Assessment

B3-C1-C2.14 Circuit Configuration Optimisation (JWG) B3.06 IT Strategies for AM of Substations-General principles

International Situation on SF6 - Regional Issues

SC B3 and SC D1 Colloquium

Brisbane Australia 9-11 September 2013

© Cigre Australia Slide 13

Peter Glaubitz SC B3 AA2 GIS, GIL, SF6

peter.glaubitz@siemens.com September 11, 2013

14 Progress of work AA4 | xx Study Committee B3

Kyoto target, worldwide (issue 1997): Reduction of greenhouse gas emissions

by 5.2% in the period 2008-2012*

Kyoto target, Europe (issue 1997): Reduction of greenhouse gas emissions in the EU by 20% in the period 2013-2020** and 80-95% until 2050 Kyoto target extended to 2020 (“provisional”) Next (19th) Conference of the Parties (COP) in Warsaw/ Poland in 2013 Till 2015 (21st) COP decision about targets starting 2020

Greenhouse Gases

Reduction

Increase

Emissions from greenhouse gases* in [%]

Luxembourg

Denmark

Germany

Austria

United Kingdom

Belgium

Italy

Netherlands

Finland

France

Sweden

Ireland

Spain

Greece

Portugal

EU -8

* 28 substances including SF6 ** Based on the emission level of 1990

15 Progress of work AA4 | xx Study Committee B3

1661

1655

2144

655

591

659

1044

665

375

505

0,0

0,1

0,2

0,3

0,4

0,5

0,6

0,7

0,8

0,9

0

50000

100000

150000

200000

250000

300000

350000

400000

03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12

Emis

sion

rat

e (%

)

YearPurchase Emission Emission rate

0.9

0.8

0.7

0.6

0.5 0.4

0.3

0.2

0.1

0.0

0.15%

Switzerland SF6 bank and emission

Source: SF6 balance of SwissMEM

SF 6

ban

ked

(kg)

16 Progress of work AA4 | xx Study Committee B3

324 323358 364 380 383

124 127

128 129132 132

0,0%

0,5%

1,0%

1,5%

2,0%

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Inst

alle

d am

ount

of S

F 6 (t

)

GIS Circuit Breakers GIS Circuit Breakers

France SF6 bank and emission (2)

1.1%

0.8%

Source: SF6 balance of the French TSO

Emis

sion

rate

17 Progress of work AA4 | xx Study Committee B3

Japan SF6 bank and emission (2)

Emis

sion

rate

(%)

0.17%

SF6 Gas Emission during operating stage in Electrical industry (Japan)

Quoted from METI data concernig SF6 Gas emission in Electrical Industry in 2012

SF6

stor

age

in fi

eld,

Em

issi

on (t

on)

23 maart 2013 Thema dag Nationaal SC Cigré

Strategic plan B3

Review processes: • Strategic Plan 2005 - 2014 • Annually reviewed by SAG, last formal revision in 2009 • SC members invited to identify issues in February 2013 • SAG final review in April 2013 Introduction to revisions: • Introduction of grid UHV AC and DC for substation design • Smart Grids and increased grid automation impacts • Higher awareness of risk of ownership, issues. • New Materials and technologies • On-going issues with existing assets: uprating, extensions

23 maart 2013 Thema dag Nationaal SC Cigré

Strategic plan B3

New Technical Directions: • Impact of new materials & plant technologies • UHV experience – operations and design • Safety, security, risk and environment • Constructability and maintainability, economic aspects

New Organisational Directions: • Maximising international profile, venue selection for meetings • Maximise Distribution involvement in WG • Maximise use and features of SC B3 website • Increasing communication opportunities using new technologies • Two green book projects: Substations and Guidebook to SF6

• Using the two Green book projects to identify missing study areas. • Enhancing the business value of CIGRE for customers go

23 maart 2013 Thema dag Nationaal SC Cigré

Thema dag B3 “Het onderstation de betrouwbare Hub”

23 maart 2013 Thema dag Nationaal SC Cigré

Thema dag B3 “Het onderstation de betrouwbare Hub”

5 10 15 20 25 30 162

TenneT / Alliander / Enexis / Stedin / DNWB / WEI / Netbeheer NL

Netbeheerders 29

ABB / Alstom / Siemens / Hapam / Eaton / Elspec / SBI / ELEQ / MetaCom-SBC / VSL / Jazo

Leveranciers 26

Joulz / Liandon / Spie / Cofely / Cegelec / BAM /

Service Providers 26

DNV Kema/ Eurovolt/ Ensol/ Movares/ HaskoningDHV/ Fluor/ Ecofy /D-Cision/ TNO/ Mott MacDonald/ Jacobs/ Arcadis/ ReimElekt

Ingenieurs-/adviesbureau's 26

Essent Energie Prod/ ProRail / NEN / Cigré /

Diversen 10

Haagsche Hogeschool (Power Minor) 19

TU Delft / studenten 13

TU Delft / Eindhoven 13

5 10 15 20 25 30

23 maart 2013 Thema dag Nationaal SC Cigré

Thema dag B3 “Het onderstation de betrouwbare Hub”

Top dag. ik zou zeggen ga maar lekker mee door. Goede locatie, goede verzorging en prima tijdstip. Duidelijke en bondige presentaties. Locatie, gekozen sprekers, gekozen onderwerpen, voedsel Strak programma met interessante onderwerpen en sprekers. Programma van een middag. Lunch en diner uitstekend. Locatie hoogspanningslab perfect; collegazaal iets minder confortabel. Inhoud en opzet van de presentaties prima.

De combinatie van lezingen, demonstratie gelegenheid om elkaar te ontmoeten.

Het bij elkaar zetten van een aantal producenten van HS componenten -Duur presentaties (3x 25 min presentaties achter elkaar) -Mogelijkheid om als deelnemer vragen te mogen stellen (met microfoon) -Lunch/avondeten Als ontwerper van MS netten zeker bruikbare raakvlakken

23 maart 2013 Thema dag Nationaal SC Cigré

Thema dag B3 “Het onderstation de betrouwbare Hub”

Powerpoint presentatie korter kunnen. "Graag zou ik de presentaties bij aanvang lezing digitaal of op papier beschikbaar willen. PDF voldoet Vragen via de microfoon is wat traag. Misschien gewoon vraag stellen zonder Meer ruimte voor vragen en discussie met de zaal. Teveel presentaties in het programma, waardoor iets teveel uitloop. De presentaties waren in het algemeen erg oppervlakkig. Meer diepgang is m.i. gewenst. Voorstellen voor toekomstvaste concepten (30 jaar) aangaande E-infra's en de daarop af te stemmmen inrichtingen / configuraties van onderstations. "Ik miste technische diepgang in de onderwerpen. Veel van de onderwerpen zijn z.g. open deuren, Ik miste echte oplossingen of een path foreward om problemen aan te pakken. De gedachte achter CIGRE is het uitwisselen van kennis om samen tot een hoger niveau te komen.

Activiteiten nationaal comité 2013/2014

• SAC/CAG/TAG Meeting 7 t/m 9 may 2014 Holland evt. Workshop//Tutorial • Voorbereidingsdag // Evaluatie dag Paris session • Participanten comités // commitment management • Certificaten workshops • Cigre promotie => industrie

23 maart 2013 Thema dag Nationaal SC Cigré

Opmerkingen