NAVAJO NATION LONG RANGE COMPREHENSIVE SOLID … files/ExhibitA-MapsFigures.pdf1999 were unlined. The 1999 permit specifies lined cells using HDPE. Daily cover is achieved by using

NAVAJO NATION LONG RANGE COMPREHENSIVE SOLID WASTE

MANAGEMENT PLAN

TASK VII – FINAL REPORT SOLID WASTE FIGURES

For

SOLID WASTE COMPLIANCE LANDFILLS, TRANSFER STATIONS, AND COLLECTION POINTS AVAILABLE TO NAVAJO NATION


MANAGEMENT PLAN

TASK VII – FINAL REPORT APPENDIX I

For

SOLID WASTE FACILITY, RCRA

SUBTITLE D PERMIT SURVEY INFORMATION

APPENDIX I SOLID WASTE FACILITY, RCRA SUBTITLE D PERMIT

SURVEY INFORMATION LANDFILL : Blue Hills Regional Landfill LOCATION : Three (3) miles east of St. Johns, Arizona on State Highway 191 STATE : Arizona COUNTY: Apache OWNER : Apache County OPERATOR : Blue Hills Environmental Association CONTACT : Blue Hills Environmental Association P. O. Box 175 St. Johns, Arizona 85936 (928) 337-4019 PERMIT HOLDER : Arizona Department of Environmental Quality OPERATIONAL SCHEDULE: Five (5) days per week (Tuesday - Saturday)

Facility Size Average Daily Waste Accepted Tipping Fee/Scale Available 161 acres 20 to 25 tons per day $50.00 per ton

OTHER WASTES ACCEPTED: Construction and demolition debris, petroleum

contaminated soil. RECYCLING OFFERED: Tires, some cardboard and plastics are collected at

the transfer stations. TRANSFER STATIONS: Round Valley (scales available), Sanders, Alpine,

Concho, Nutrioso, and Vernon, Arizona. SURVEY NOTE: The Blue Hills Environmental Association is a non-profit association formed to operate the Blue Hills Landfill and transfer stations on behalf of Apache County. The landfill is located on a low permeability clay section and as a result the State has waived the need for a liner.


SURVEY INFORMATION LANDFILL : Cerro Colorado Landfill (Commercial Haulers Only) LOCATION : South of I-40, and 20 miles west of Albuquerque (I-25 & I-40) STATE : New Mexico COUNTY: Bernallilo OWNER : City of Albuquerque, New Mexico OPERATOR : City of Albuquerque, Solid Waste Management Department, NM CONTACT : City of Albuquerque Administration Office (505) 761-8300 PERMIT HOLDER: New Mexico Environment Department (20-year Permit in 2000);

EPA; NPDES; and Title V Air Quality Permit OPERATIONAL SCHEDULE: Open seven days as week

Facility Size Average Daily Waste Accepted Tipping Fee/Scale Available 0-50 lbs. = $6.60

501-1000 lbs. = $13.20 1001-1500 lbs. = $19.80 1501-2000 lbs. = $26.40

192 acres permitted for

disposal.

Total land: 860 acres

1600 to 1700 tons during weekdays and

300 tons on weekends

$25.00/Ton (Municipal Waste) $34.20/Ton (Special BurialWaste) $75.00/Ton (Petroleum Contamin. Soils)

$100.00/Ton (Used Tires) OTHER WASTES ACCEPTED: Petroleum contaminated soil WASTE NOT ACCEPTED: Construction and demolition wastes, hazardous waste

(RCRA), toxic waste (TSCA), Radioactive waste, infectious (Biomedical) waste, pesticides or herbicides (FIFRA), automotive batteries, PCBs or bulk liquids, motor oil, asbestos, or ash; and other determined waste.

RECYCLING OFFERED: Tires for their tire bailer (4 tires per visit only at a center). CURBSIDE RECYCLING: City of Albuquerque, New Mexico SURVEY NOTE: Cerro Colorado Landfill accepts wastes from outside the City of Albuquerque but the vast majority of solid waste at the landfill comes from the City. Individual waste cells are 20 acres in size and are lined with HDPE.


SURVEY INFORMATION LANDFILL : Cinder Lake Landfill LOCATION : 12 miles northeast of Flagstaff, Arizona on State Highway 89 STATE : Arizona COUNTY: Coconino OWNER : City of Flagstaff OPERATOR : City of Flagstaff CONTACT : City of Flagstaff 211 West Aspen Flagstaff, Arizona 86001 (928) 779-7685, extension 276 PERMIT HOLDER: Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (Permit in 1999) OPERATIONAL SCHEDULE: Six (6) days per week

Facility Size Average Daily Waste Accepted Tipping Fee/Scale Available 270 acres


430 tons per day

$31.10 per ton, and fee to increase by 12/02 or

01/03 to $32.20 per ton OTHER WASTES ACCEPTED: Clean construction and demolition debris, petro-

leum contaminated soil, and non-friable asbestos. WASTE NOT ACCEPTED: Tires. RECYCLING OFFERED: Household hazardous waste offered every April

with Coconino County, and other recycling event days for other recyclable products (i.e., wood).

TRANSFER STATIONS: Leupp, Tuba City, Cameron, Tonalea (Red Lake),

Kaibeto, Gap/Bodaway (all within Navajo Nation), and other stations, such as, Page, Arizona.

SURVEY NOTE: The landfill has been in existence since 1969, and previous cells since 1999 were unlined. The 1999 permit specifies lined cells using HDPE. Daily cover is achieved by using paper waste sludge. Wood recycling is achieved using a tub grinder to chip lumber and yard waste. Clean construction and demolition goes into a separate site to reclaim old cinder pits.


SURVEY INFORMATION LANDFILL : Crouch Mesa Landfill LOCATION : Six (6) miles east of Farmington toward Aztec on Crouch Mesa STATE : New Mexico COUNTY: San Juan OWNER : San Juan County, New Mexico OPERATOR : Waste Management CONTACT : Waste Management (505) 334-1121 PERMIT HOLDER: New Mexico Environmental Department; prior permit with State. OPERATIONAL SCHEDULE: Open seven days as week Facility Size Average Daily Waste Accepted Tipping Fee/Scale Available

San Juan County Resident: $3.57 per cubic yard –uncompacted $4.21 per cubic yard – compacted

160 acres

3,000 cubic yards per day or ~750 tons per day Non-resident:

$4.68 per cubic yard - uncompacted $5.21 per cubic yard - compacted

OTHER WASTES ACCEPTED: Construction and demolition debris (letter proving

asbestos free debris), killing plant offal. WASTE NOT ACCEPTED: Asbestos, ash, non-hazardous medical waste,

petroleum contaminated soil, paints, oil, automobile bodies, roofing tar, florescence tubes

TRANSFER STATIONS: Shiprock, Upper Fruitland and Lake Valley (all

within Navajo Nation) RECYCLING: Cardboard, newspaper print, aluminum cans, etc. SURVEY NOTE: Original cells were unlined. Cells constructed since 1993 have HDPE liner. San Juan County sets tipping fees, currently Navajo Nation contributes to San Juan County for free household waste disposal at all transfer stations. Waste Management also brings in solid waste from Colorado via the Durango transfer station.


SURVEY INFORMATION LANDFILL : Montezuma County Landfill LOCATION : Three (3) miles southeast of Cortez on County Road F STATE : Colorado COUNTY: Montezuma OWNER : Montezuma County, Colorado OPERATOR : Montezuma County, Colorado CONTACT : Montezuma County 26100 Road F Cortez, Colorado 81321 (970) 565-9858 PERMIT HOLDER: Colorado Department of Public Health and Engineering. OPERATIONAL SCHEDULE: Open six (6) days as week Facility Size Average Daily Waste Accepted Tipping Fee/Scale Available

San Juan County Resident: $7.00, 0 to 560 pounds $25.25 per ton

60 acres


70 to 80 tons per day and have

handled 125 tons per day Construction (compacted): $22.00 per ton

OTHER WASTES ACCEPTED: Clean construction and demolition debris, compost

waste, dead animals, petroleum contaminated soil. WASTE NOT ACCEPTED: Asbestos, ash, non-hazardous medical waste,

petroleum contaminated soil, paints, oil, automobile bodies, roofing tar, florescence tubes

RECYCLING: Metal, white goods SURVEY NOTE: The Landfill operates through a bale-fill system. Waste is inspected prior to bailing. The Landfill is looking for additional sources of solid waste, and has previously accepted solid waste from the States of Utah, Arizona, and New Mexico.


SURVEY INFORMATION LANDFILL : Painted Desert Landfill (Commercial Haulers Only) LOCATION : Three (3) miles north of Joseph City, Arizona on Porter Road STATE : Arizona COUNTY: Navajo OWNER : Waste Management of Arizona, Inc. OPERATOR : Waste Management of Arizona, Inc. CONTACT : Waste Management of Arizona, Inc. (602) 454-2045 or (602) 470-0225 PERMIT HOLDER : Arizona Department of Environmental Quality OPERATIONAL SCHEDULE: The Landfill is not open to the general public, and

businesses arrange their own schedule.

Facility Size Average Daily Waste Accepted Tipping Fee/Scale Available N/A N/A $26.00 per ton

WASTES ACCEPTED: Construction and demolition debris. RECYCLING OFFERED: N/A SURVEY NOTE: The Landfill was previously known as Pen-Rob Landfill, and cells are lined. It is unknown if Pen-Rob had previously accepted hazardous waste for disposal prior to purchase by Painted Desert.


SURVEY INFORMATION LANDFILL : Red Rocks Regional Landfill LOCATION : Six (6) miles northeast of Thoreau on State Highway 371 STATE : New Mexico COUNTY: McKinley OWNER : Northwest New Mexico Regional Solid Waste Authority OPERATOR : Northwest New Mexico Regional Solid Waste Authority CONTACT : Northwest New Mexico Regional Solid Waste Authority P. O. Box 1330 Thoreau, New Mexico 87323 (505) 862-8402 PERMIT HOLDER: New Mexico Environment Department OPERATIONAL SCHEDULE: Open weekdays, and half day Saturday

Facility Size Average Daily Waste Accepted Tipping Fee/Scale Available 29.4 acres Total land: 600 acres

350 tons

$4.50 per even truck bed load $25.00 per ton

OTHER WASTES ACCEPTED: Special industrial waste, petroleum contaminated

soil, non-friable asbestos, and dried water based paints (no liquid at all).

RECYCLING OFFERED: Tires for their tire bailer. TRANSFER STATIONS: Breadsprings (within Navajo Nation), Gallup, and

Milan, New Mexico SURVEY NOTE: The Authority represents McKinley and Cibola Counties, the Cities of Gallup and Grants, and the Village of Milan. They operate walking floor trailers to haul waste from the transfer stations to the Landfill. And, operate smaller convenience stations and has a system of bins and roll-off trucks for commercial service. The Landfill has 800 by 200 foot cells lined with HDPE and GCL.


SURVEY INFORMATION LANDFILL : Rio Rancho Landfill LOCATION : Located between Rio Rancho and Bernalillo, west of State Highway 528 STATE : New Mexico COUNTY: Sandoval OWNER : Waste Management of New Mexico OPERATOR : Waste Management of New Mexico CONTACT : Waste Management of New Mexico (505) 892-2055 PERMIT HOLDER: New Mexico Environment Department OPERATIONAL SCHEDULE: Open weekdays, and half day Saturday Facility Size Average Daily Waste Accepted Tipping Fee/Scale Available

N/A 4,500 cubic yards per day (~1,200 to 1,300 tons per day)

$4.24 per cubic yd - uncompacted $5.30 per cubic yd – compacted

OTHER WASTES ACCEPTED: N/A. RECYCLING OFFERED: N/A SURVEY NOTE: Waste Management would not provide additional information on this landfill, and this Landfill is immediately adjacent to Sandoval County Landfill.


SURVEY INFORMATION LANDFILL : Sandoval County Landfill LOCATION : Located between Rio Rancho and Bernalillo, west of State

Highway 528 on Iris Road STATE : New Mexico COUNTY: Sandoval OWNER : Sandoval County OPERATOR : Sandoval County CONTACT : Sandoval County 2700 Iris Road Rio Rancho, New Mexico (505) 867-0816 PERMIT HOLDER: New Mexico State Environmental Quality OPERATIONAL SCHEDULE: Open seven days as week Facility Size Average Daily Waste Accepted Tipping Fee/Scale Available

165 acres

2000 cubic yards per day $3.50 per cubic yard –uncompacted $4.00 per cubic yard - compacted

Concrete = $8.00 OTHER WASTES ACCEPTED: Clean construction and demolition debris, and pre-

approved sludge. WASTE NOT ACCEPTED: Special wastes or tires. RECYCLING OFFERED: Coordinated with private firms in the City of

Albuquerque, and not at the Landfill. TRANSFER STATIONS: Cuba, Jemez, and Pena Blanca SURVEY NOTE: This Landfill has been operating for 18 years, and currently operate a seven acre cell and their facility has a current life of 20 years. They have another site to move to when this facility is full. Sandoval is continuing to pick up waste in the Torreon-Counselor area (within Navajo Nation), and send a dump truck to the Torreon area on a weekly basis.


SURVEY INFORMATION LANDFILL : Socorro County Landfill LOCATION : Located two (2) miles south of Socorro STATE : New Mexico COUNTY: Socorro OWNER : City of Socorro OPERATOR : Socorro County CONTACT : City of Socorro Landfill Socorro, New Mexico 87801 (505) 835-4279 PERMIT HOLDER: New Mexico State Environmental Quality OPERATIONAL SCHEDULE: Facility Size Average Daily Waste Accepted Tipping Fee/Scale Available

acres $3.00 per cubic yard –uncompacted OTHER WASTES ACCEPTED: Clean construction and demolition debris, and pre-

approved sludge. WASTE NOT ACCEPTED: Special wastes or tires. TRANSFER STATIONS: Alamo (within Navajo Nation) SURVEY NOTE: The Transfer Station at Alamo Chapter has difficulties with financial accountability, and continued illegal dumping is a problem because the size of the bin at the station is small, and the round-trip disposal fee is currently charged to Alamo Chapter. The rate in 2000 was $2.25 per mile for a 120 mile round trip to the Landfill, and is currently charging the Chapter $365.00 per bin.


SURVEY INFORMATION LANDFILL : Transit Waste LOCATION : On US 550, 15 miles south of Durango, Colorado, and five (5)

miles north of the New Mexico state line. STATE : Colorado COUNTY: LaPlata OWNER : Transit Waste, LLC OPERATOR : Transit Waste, LLC CONTACT : Transit Waste, LLC 1500 E. County Road 310 Durango, Colorado (970) 247-0646 PERMIT HOLDER: Colorado Department of Public Health and Engineering OPERATIONAL SCHEDULE: Open six (6) days a week Facility Size Average Daily Waste Accepted Tipping Fee/Scale Available

27 acres Total land:

47 acres

500 cubic yards per day $10.00 per cubic yard

OTHER WASTES ACCEPTED: Clean construction and demolition debris. RECYCLING OFFERED: Metal, newspapers, cardboard, and tires SURVEY NOTE: Transit Waste operates residential pickup and roll-off trucks. They are currently not taking any waste from the Navajo Nation but are interested in both collection and having waste come to their facility from the Navajo Nation. The landfill is located on a low permeability shale section and their cells do not have to be lined.


SURVEY INFORMATION LANDFILL : White Mesa Landfill LOCATION : State Highway 191, 14 miles south of Blanding, Utah and 10 miles

north of Bluff, Utah which is a short distance south of State Highway 262.

STATE : Utah COUNTY: San Juan OWNER : San Juan County, Utah OPERATOR : San Juan County, Utah CONTACT : San Juan County P. O. Box 9 Monticello, Utah 84535 (435) 587-3225 PERMIT HOLDER: Utah Department of Environmental Quality (1994, received a

Class I Municipal Waste Permit, and renewal in 1999 for 5-years) OPERATIONAL SCHEDULE: Open five days as week Facility Size Average Daily Waste Accepted Tipping Fee/Scale Available

LANDFILL COST: $22.00 per tons

260 acres

20 cubic yards per day

TRANSFER STATION COST: $5.00 per level truck bed $15.00 per ton $12.50 for household pickup $40.00 for pickup from Businesses

OTHER WASTES ACCEPTED: Clean construction and demolition debris,

petroleum contaminated soil. RECYCLING OFFERED: Tires TRANSFER STATIONS: Bluff and Mexican Hat, Utah SURVEY NOTE: The Landfill receives additional solid waste from the Kayenta Transfer Station and Township, Oljato, and Aneth Chapters. This Landfill would like to take additional solid waste from Navajo Nation.

APPENDIX I SOLID WASTE FACILITY, NON-PERMITTED LANDFILL

SURVEY INFORMATION LANDFILL : Hopi Landfill LOCATION : North on Navajo County Route 4, then turn toward Hard Rocks,

AZ; approximately 12 miles from Cultural Center, Second Mesa, AZ off Arizona Highway 264.

STATE : Arizona COUNTY: Navajo OWNER : Hopi Tribe OPERATOR : Hopi Tribe CONTACT : Hopi Landfill (928) 734-3291 PERMIT HOLDER: USEPA Permit for small quantity compliance solid waste landfill

which meets RCRA Subtitle D Permit technical requirements of lined cells. The Landfill was facilitated on authority of the Hopi Tribe anti-dumping ordinance, which is regulated by the Hopi Environmental Office, Kykosmotovi, Arizona.

OPERATIONAL SCHEDULE: Open five days a week. Facility Size Average Daily Waste Accepted Tipping Fee/Scale Available

100 acres 150 to 200 cubic yards per day Non-Hopi Customers: $10.00 drop-off at landfill $15.00 per 90 gallon container $25.00 for each 3-cubic yard bin

OTHER WASTES ACCEPTED: Clean construction and demolition debris. RECYCLING OFFERED: Metal and Tires BURN PERMIT: Wood and cardboard. SURVEY NOTE: The Landfill receives additional solid waste from the Navajo Chapter communities of Coalmine Mesa, Hard Rock, Teestoh, and Dilkon for residences, businesses, and governmental entities because the Hopi Landfill offers curbside service. Each cell is lined, and ashes from the wood and cardboard are placed into the cells. The Navajo Nation Environmental Protection Agency does not recommend solid waste to be taken to this landfill until they are certified as a RCRA Subtitle D Landfill.

SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT PLAN


For

SOLID WASTE LANDFILL

CELL CONSTRUCTION

Typical Landfill Cell Construction Notes:

The following four figures illustrate the modeled landfill cell that was used for the

landfill cost analysis portion of this study. The cell as illustrated is the initial landfill cell

of a multi-cell landfill. Figure One shows a cell excavation diagram with two different

side slopes. The Four- percent slope would be on the perimeter side of the landfill and

the two- percent slope would be on the side where an adjoining cell would be

constructed. The location of the leachate drain is shown on the diagram. A cleanout

would be placed on the up slope side of the cell. The leachate pipe could drain to either a

manhole or sump where the fluid could be transported to an evaporation pond or to a

wastewater treatment facility. The leachate drain could also lead to an on-side leachate

evaporation pond.

Figure Two shows the plan of a single full cell and a profile section across the full cell.

Figure Three is a detail of the bottom of a landfill cell. This figure shows the placement

of the GCL underlayer, the HDPE liner and the two feet of layer of liner protection and

drainage sand that covers the liner. The French drain system for leachate removal is

shown at the bottom of the cell.

Figure Four is a profile of a completed edge cell showing the cleanout portion of the

leachate pipe. The final cover is shown by 36 inches of soil material. The cover

thickness shown may not be site specific for the recommended evapotranspiration cover.

The drawings are for illustration purposes only and are not meant for actual construction

of a landfill cell.


MANAGEMENT PLAN


For

NAVAJO NATION SOLID WASTE

AUTHORITY AND

LANDFILL/TRANSFER STATION SCHEDULING


MANAGEMENT PLAN


For

NAVAJO NATION AGENCY

INFRASTRUCTURE COST COMPARISON

NAVAJO NATION AGENCY INFRASTRUCTURE COST COMPARISON

WESTERN NAVAJO AGENCY Waste Model

Transport Costs

Off-Nation Landfill

Tipping Fees

Central Transfer Station

Tonnage Costs

Navajo Nation

Landfill Tonnage

Costs

Adminis-trative Costs

Total

Chapters to Off-Nation

$513,000.00 $546,000.00 --- --- --- $1,059,000.00

Central Transfer Station to Off-Nation

$339,000.00 $546,000.00 $182,000.00 --- $71,000.00 $1,138,000.00

Central Transfer Station to Navajo Landfills

$258,000.00 --- $182,000.00 $524,000.00 $71,000.00 $1,035,000.00

Chapters to Navajo Landfills

$412,000.00 --- --- $524,000.00 $71,000.00 $1,007,000.00

Costs based on 12,319 waste tons/year passing through Tuba City Central Transfer Station and 7,519 tons/year passing through Kayenta Central Transfer Station. Tuba City Central Transfer Station – Construction and Operational Cost - $6.87/ton Kayenta Central Transfer Station – Construction and Operational Cost - $12.94/ton Western Agency Landfill – Construction and Operational Cost - $26.42/ton Off-Nation Landfill – Current Average Tipping Fee - $27.50/ton to $29.55/ton Administrative Costs: 19,838 tons/year x $3.59/ton = $71,000.00/year Costs based on 2001 data and maybe subject to CPI rates 5% +/-

Alternative Waste Collection and Transport Models Waste Model

Transport Costs

Off-Nation Landfill Tipping

Fees


Tonnage Costs

Navajo Nation

Landfill Tonnage

Costs


Total

Tuba City Central Transfer Station *

$228,000.00 $34,000.00 $75,000.00 $495,000.00 $71,000.00 $903,000.00

Modified Chapters to

Navajo Landfills**

$378,000.00 $34,000.00 --- $495,000.00 $71,000.00 $974,000.00

Note:* Tuba City Central Transfer Station model would only have a central transfer station at Tuba City. Kayenta area Chapter waste would be hauled directly to Agency Landfill. Southern Chapters would have waste hauled to Cinder Lakes Landfill, Flagstaff, Arizona. Note:** In this model all waste with the exception of the Southern Chapters would be hauled directly to the Agency Landfill.

Western Agency Chapters to North Central Landfill Waste Model

Transport Costs


Fees


Tonnage Costs

Navajo Nation

Landfill Tonnage

Costs


Total

Southern Chapters to Off-Nation

$23,000.00 $34,000.00 --- --- $3,800.00 $60,800.00

Tuba City Central Transfer Station to Off-Nation

$107,000.00 $298,000.00 $75,000.00 --- $39,000.00 $519,000.00

Kayenta Area to Navajo Landfills

$98,000.00 --- --- $153,000.00 $28,200.00 $279,000.00

Totals $228,000.00 $332,000.00 $75,000.00 $153,000.00 $71,000.00 $859,000.00 Costs based on 10,847 waste tons/year passing through Tuba City Central Transfer Station and 7,894 tons/year from Kayenta Area Chapters to North Central Landfill. 1,097 tons per year from Southern Chapters to Cinder Lake Landfill, Flagstaff, Arizona. Tuba City Central Transfer Station – Construction and Operational Cost - $6.87/ton North Central Agency Landfill – Construction and Operational Cost - $19.43/ton Off-Nation Landfill – Current Average Tipping Fee - $27.50/ton to $29.55/ton Administrative Costs: 19,838 tons/year x $3.59/ton = $71,000.00/year Costs based on 2001 data and maybe subject to CPI rates 5% +/-


CHINLE AGENCY Waste Model

Transport Costs

Off-Nation Landfill

Tipping Fees


Tonnage Costs

Navajo Nation

Landfill Tonnage

Costs


Total


$597,000.00 $337,000.00 --- --- --- $933,000.00


$314,000.00 $337,000.00 $105,000.00 --- $55,000.00 $811,000.00


$139,000.00 --- $105,000.00 $404,000.00 $55,000.00 $703,000.00


$144,000.00 --- --- $404,000.00 $55,000.00 $603,000.00

Costs based on 15,288 waste tons/year passing through Chinle Central Transfer Station. Chinle Central Transfer Station – Construction and Operational Costs - $6.87/ton Chinle Agency Landfill – Construction and Operational Cost - $26.42/ton Off-Nation Landfill – Current Average Tipping Fee - $22.00/ton to $29.55/ton Administrative Costs: 15,288 tons/year x $3.59/ton = $55,000.00/year Costs based on 2001 data and maybe subject to CPI rates 5% +/-

North Central Landfill Alternative Waste Model

Transport Costs


Fees


Tonnage Costs

Navajo Nation

Landfill Tonnage

Costs


Total

Chapters to North

Central Landfill

$257,000.00 --- --- $297,000.00 $56,000.00 $610,000.00

North Central Landfill – Construction and Operational Cost - $19.43/ton


FORT DEFIANCE AGENCY Waste Model

Transport Costs

Off-Nation Landfill

Tipping Fees


Tonnage Costs

Navajo Nation

Landfill Tonnage

Costs


Total


$587,000.00 $854,000.00 --- --- --- $1,441,000.00


$396,000.00 $854,000.00 $224,000.00 --- $111,000.00 $1,585,000.00


$224,000.00 --- $224,000.00 $814,000.00 $111,000.00 $1,373,000.00


$320,000.00 --- --- $814,000.00 $111,000.00 $1,245,000.00

Costs BASed on 20,504 waste tons/year passing through St. Michaels Central Transfer Station and 10,296 tons/year passing through Ganado Central Transfer Station. St. Michaels Central Transfer Station – Construction and Operational Cost - $4.40/ton Ganado Central Transfer Station – Construction and Operational Cost - $12.94/ton Fort Defiance Agency Landfill – Construction and Operational Cost - $26.42/ton Off-Nation Landfill – Current Average Tipping Fee - $27.72/ton to $29.55/ton Administrative Costs: 15,288 tons/year x $3.59/ton = $111,000.00/year Costs based on 2001 data and maybe subject to CPI rates 5% +/-


SHIPROCK AGENCY Waste Model

Transport Costs

Off-Nation Landfill

Tipping Fees


Tonnage Costs

Navajo Nation

Landfill Tonnage

Costs


Total


$597,000.00 $337,000.00 --- --- --- $933,000.00


$314,000.00 $337,000.00 $105,000.00 --- $55,000.00 $811,000.00


$139,000.00 --- $105,000.00 $404,000.00 $55,000.00 $703,000.00


$144,000.00 --- --- $404,000.00 $55,000.00 $603,000.00

Costs based on 30,233 waste tons/year passing through Shiprock Central Transfer Station and 2,688 tons/year passing through Mexican Water Central Transfer Station. Shiprock Central Transfer Station – Construction and Operational Cost - $4.40/ton Mexican Water Central Transfer Station – Construction and Operational Cost - $12.94/ton Shiprock Agency Landfill – Construction and Operational Cost - $19.43/ton Off-Nation Landfill – Current Average Tipping Fee - $21.44/ton to $29.55/ton Administrative Costs: 32,921 tons/year x $3.59/ton = $118,000.00/year Costs based on 2001 data and maybe subject to CPI rates 5% +/-

Shiprock Agency Alternative Waste Model Waste Model

Transport Costs


Fees


Tonnage Costs

Navajo Nation

Landfill Tonnage

Costs


Total

Chapters to North

Central Landfill

$163,000.00 $77,000.00 --- $572,000.00 --- $930,000.00

Waste from the Chapters in the Western portion of the Agency would be hauled by conventional means to White Mesa Landfill, Bluff, Utah. Tipping fee $22.00/ton. Waste from other Chapters would be hauled to Agency Landfill in Shiprock area.


EASTERN NAVAJO AGENCY Waste Model

Transport Costs


Fees


Tonnage Costs

Navajo Nation

Landfill Tonnage

Costs


Total


$213,000.00 $329,000.00 --- --- --- $542,000.00


$191,000.00 $329,000.00 $143,000.00 --- $52,000.00 $715,000.00


$161,000.00 --- $143,000.00 $361,000.00 $52,000.00 $717,000.00


$177,000.00 --- --- $361,000.00 $52,000.00 $590,000.00

Costs based on 6,978 waste tons/year passing through Crownpoint Central Transfer Station, and 2,824 tons/year passing through Huerfano Central Transfer Station and 3,806 tons/year passing through the St. Michaels Central Transfer Station. 541 tons/year from Tohajiilee would be hauled to Cerro Colorado Landfill from a commercial hauler as this landfill does not accept individual hauling of waste, and 406 tons/year would be hauled to Socorro County from the Alamo Chapter. Waste from Chapters west of the Continental Divide would be hauled to St. Michaels Central Transfer Station. Navajo Nation Landfill costs include tipping fees for Red Rock Regional landfill, Thoreau, NM; Crouch Mesa Landfill, Aztec, NM; Cerro Colorado Landfill, Bernalillo, NM; and Socorro Landfills, Socorro, NM. Crownpoint Central Transfer Station – Construction and Operational Cost - $12.94/ton Huerfano Cenetral Transfer Station – Construction and Operational Costs - $12.94/ton St. Michaels Central Transfer Station – Construction and Operational Costs - $4.40/ton Red Rocks Regional Landfill – Current Average Tipping Fee - $25.00/ton Off-Nation Landfill – Current Average Tipping Fee - $22.58/ton to $29.55/ton Administrative Costs: 14,555 tons/year x $3.93/ton = $52,000.00/year Costs based on 2001 data and maybe subject to CPI rates 5% +/-

Documents

NAVAJO NATION LONG RANGE COMPREHENSIVE SOLID … files/ExhibitA-MapsFigures.pdf1999 were unlined. The 1999 permit specifies lined cells using HDPE. Daily cover is achieved by using