National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 1

NCHRP Project 20-68A/B/C

U.S. Domestic Scan Program

AASHTO Research Advisory Committee

July 27, 2011

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 4

NCHRP 20-68: Domestic Scan Program Direction

20-68 Project Panel

• Skip Paul, LADOTD (chair)• Shane Brown, WA State University• Nancy Chinlund, CalTrans• Marsha Fiol, VaDOT• Rick Kreider, KS DOT• Glenn Roberts, NH DOT• Amy Schutzbach, IL DOT• Mark VanPortFleet, MI DOT

• “Mike” Burk, FHWA liaison• Keith Platte & Marty Vitale, AASHTO liaisons

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 5

NCHRP 20-68A: Domestic Scan History

• Apr ‘05: SCOR approved concept ($250,000 FY ’05)

• July ‘05: Business Plan completed (Cambridge Systematics, Inc.)

• Nov ‘06: Pilot scans (2) completed(reports published as web documents; FHWA support +$75,000)

• Dec ‘07: Full program initiated (Arora and Associates, Inc.; 6-yr contract)

• 5 continuations approved through CY 2010 ($500,000/yr for scans, $2.5 million total + FHWA support, $224,000)

• Feb ’11: 9 scans completed (7 reports published), 6 in process, 6 programmed

• SCOR Approved March 2011: $500,000 FY2012

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 6

NCHRP 20-68A: Domestic Scan Products

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 7

NCHRP 20-68B/C: Impact Assessment and Enhancement

FY ‘09 $200,000* NCHRP 20-68B/C

• Assess the impact, cost-effectiveness of domestic scans

• Explore alternatives to team-travel-based scan

• Enhance dissemination community of innovators, networks of innovation

* In addition to $3 million (requested) utilized for scan activities.

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 8

NCHRP 20-68B: Impact Assessment and Enhancement

First 6 scans6/12 month post scan participant

surveys6 month post scan non participant

surveysWeb conferencesImplementation report based on

surveys/web conferencesWeb site prototype

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 9

NCHRP 20-68B: Impact Assessment and Enhancement

Extension to cover final 12 scansInterview based approachWebinarSurvey for non participantsWeb site through Mar 13

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 10

NCHRP 20-68B: Scan Alternatives

Scan types:1. Scan team visits host agencies,

approximately 2 weeks of travel2. Host-agency representatives and scan

team meet in 2 to 3 central locations for group discussions, approximately 1 week of travel

3. Host-agency representatives and scan team participate in workshop or symposium, possibly linked to another event

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 11

NCHRP 20-68C: Research on Innovation Networks

Assess impact of Domestic Scan ProgramScans shape broader innovation activity

at State DOTs & how this relates to other innovation sources

Diffusion of maintenance innovations via domestic scans

Survey on maintenance activitiesTrack three maintenance innovations:

Maintenance Decision Support System; Tow Plow; Auto Pot Hole Patcher

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 12

NCHRP 20-68B/C: Scan Impact and Cost Effectiveness

Diffusion: an often crooked path

Scans bring people together

Terry

Tony

Tony’s DOT saved $10 million in the 1st year of full rollout MDSS

for winter maintenance operations

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 13

NCHRP 20-68B/C: Dissemination, Innovation Networks

To Date…

• 7+2 scans completed• 12 topics in execution

and programmed

• 94 state DOT-staff team members, from 49 states

• 35 states provided info to scan teams, hosted scans

• 6 post-scan 6-month assessments

• Scan-team social web site operational

• Innovation-tracing research ongoing

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 14

NCHRP 20-68B Domestic Scan Program Web Site

www.domesticscan.org

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 15

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 16

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 17

National Cooperative Highway Research Program

Andrew C. Lemer, SPO 18

Potential Future RAC Assistance

Scan team member post scan participation

Identification of scan team members for new scans

Dissemination of scan team findings to appropriate members of your departments

Maintenance Surveys for NCHRP 20-68C