6857 Computer and Network Security Lecture 5

Admin Problem Set 1 due in Lecture 6 Problem Set 2 out Lecture 6 Next lecture by TA (secret sharing and bitcoin) Submit passwords (not real ones) for problem set 2

Project Ideas ldquoFormat-Transforming Encryptionrdquo Shrimpton 2014 Real-World Crypto talk Also see httpsfteproxyorg

Today Crypto hash functions applications and constructions Applications

o Signatures o Commitments o Merkle trees o Payword o Hash-cash

Construction o Merkle-Damgard o Sponge function

1

JJ gt1_tlA_____

IVC

mdash

________~-~____p ~~~~~~~~~_=~~~~~~__ if f UNDfp

rtn-( p

___~_J I~~~ __--I i~

_ -

LS2LS2 ]1 =

1 3 tDl~ 4 ~~~ I ( l hll ISJ ~ I ) - -shy

I--t---r=S-j h~s s ~t - iw IStJ I- - I~-J-- I----l

1- h ~ r-- ~--lVeW~ ~_ [ ri Iv I( N ~J lA _t_lTr _oJ h~ _SCIJ_

-- --- c c -

_T~rs-I1W4I1R t- _~ Q SMn~ f4 l lt tFr~

- ~ ci= ~ S~ 1 if I]i~J~

1- - I-- - - - - -- iI fo- i rl -- ishy

~p- jS~~iI- r ~ lIi--ArJlY- roM It +- -- i r UJ~e 1 poundf5 ~-j~ A~ ~ ~rlfVl ~ at~l~ l

j - j X - 1 - - J_ - -~ ~ t- I ~~ h~ r ll)Jr)P( lt-I i _

I - JI -1- ~ yen-il ~ k 4~J shye bull PC tI ~ 1~ d DitJ eO hmiddotl~~ r-t IfgtQk e e r --

- -- r- shyI--t---t - r- - f--e - - ~ --- - -I -- i-+-+--+-I I- - -- -I--l-ll--l--I--J- -I--e +------4- I I- f- --I-l-~

f- f--I- I- I -L i- - -- ishyI- c--t-- f- t-~ +-I--Imiddot--f--middot i-+- _ - -fshyr-- f-- - e- - 1--- r

1--+-- t-- - -W - -I- t- --- - lshy- - t--- +-I--i ---- ~ 1--I

1--1-I-- - - f-- --t-T ~-

- 1-1 I-I- -- +-~I---+-+-+- +--+-+-l-l--+----j-f-- i- I- i- -+l- 1--+ I-shy

I --1-- - ~i--4--+-+-I---- - +- - shy

-f--+-+-+-+-l-l--+--t-t- -+-+--1--1--4--1- -f-~jl-+-t trsquos r

I I L

~1 l_t~L_ J LJ--J-1 i -

2

___ __mdash___ ____

- -

zThu

~-~ cj+ -=- [ __ L-IL-L~_ - J _ I

r- shy-_-+shy

j

i mdash

A(OU mdash rrsquorsquo bull

roIcsJI iiA4 -f Imdash

0 rne4 t4- bullVI

mdashi 2 n I I ----S wi lsquo4 mi -F 4lsquoj4Nbull

Vy )bTi1rsquoErdquordquoIt-

lsquoIMOH mdash _bull mdash Imdash mdash -

V r

[bullO lsquo19rdquoUrdquordquodegN Pl4fl$4h4P

r Irsquo 4) I

i_IP10 para11grsquo 7 Uejn crdquo1) Apnc

rr r + 2J0W jXJ mdashi1 r

Uf para0 2q 4Laoslash lsquo(V t+rndkld uqi

E lsquoiJsaiJ 04 0+ 092 aijrsquo bv1fJq ldquoflPErsquoEwrdquo flbS lsquoM lsquo i()p pijrsquoc

se Iw x paralsquoI lsquoI4rsquo

I I

F

-V

I-

I

L t-~r- - ---~

-- -- - I t r- L -+l -

~ -l shy-r - - t-- shy~

iO~Hl-_middot___

3IdOj

~~~_bull~~~~~~____~~_-- lOAnIO__==~=~==~~~_=~~___~~_-i IDAIf

-

- J =l Ij_fjL_rl_____~_______~___J rI_f lsquoiJ1r111 -Vj AGf 1~q~TI3-----==-1~- L 53

3

____

----

__ _ __ __ _

U bull

U

-bull--

lsquo3 V

mdash

a lsquoIU

4

S

T

C mdash

-4

I 61

bulllsquobullJ

Si I

I

bull I LS~rI lsquoIrsquo

Jr

J 11U _ ~_ _ I~~~_~~~~~~~_~_~-l lAff-I x u _ =_=

jPfiGi- L-shyLIFlt~e~U_P~_~______________---Jl I

mdash

mdash

-

-D5

Ursquo

I arsquo

Imdash

3-

irsquoai-c

zrirsquo

ekt

-lsquoI bull

4

-bull1bull

mdash pound -

4mdash

-r

I

-a

lsquo

t

aZ

a

a C

I-fl

a

44 it

dt

rt I

lsquo5rsquosaZ t

44

I iI

Iramp

t ii

pc U

mdash -mdash

mdashIrsquo 4-

rt a

lsquoCmdash

-

-

-ccedil -q

LIt

a

lsquoI

a-

StlsquoI

I I

4 IL

IEZ

EZ

S

It

I

-0

as

I I

Ji

ii

i-I I

I

t

1 __

+--f--

~- -H-+-+---I-+-I-+-+- t- f-t-t-t-t shy -I--t--t shylshy1shyI- t- - 1shy

l-~- e-c- 1- -1shy f--+--r- ishy- 1--1--- 1-- -- shy

I I-- I-f---I- I middot--~ c- +--H-t--+-t--+ -+ j- I-- middot1 - -1----1-I r- ~ c-1----+-1-- +-t---i-l--t--+- +-t----H-t-- - + f-f-- shy

1 ~ -

I

-I

+--1-1---1---+ -+-+--+-+--T--f-+--+-+ -- --LJ-_I

zI

4

---------------i----- -- shy----_~

1

L

___ __mdash___ ____

- -

zThu

~-~ cj+ -=- [ __ L-IL-L~_ - J _ I

r- shy-_-+shy

j

i mdash

A(OU mdash rrsquorsquo bull

roIcsJI iiA4 -f Imdash

0 rne4 t4- bullVI

mdashi 2 n I I ----S wi lsquo4 mi -F 4lsquoj4Nbull

Vy )bTi1rsquoErdquordquoIt-

lsquoIMOH mdash _bull mdash Imdash mdash -

V r

[bullO lsquo19rdquoUrdquordquodegN Pl4fl$4h4P

r Irsquo 4) I

i_IP10 para11grsquo 7 Uejn crdquo1) Apnc

rr r + 2J0W jXJ mdashi1 r

Uf para0 2q 4Laoslash lsquo(V t+rndkld uqi

E lsquoiJsaiJ 04 0+ 092 aijrsquo bv1fJq ldquoflPErsquoEwrdquo flbS lsquoM lsquo i()p pijrsquoc

se Iw x paralsquoI lsquoI4rsquo

I I

F

-V

I-

I

L t-~r- - ---~

-- -- - I t r- L -+l -

~ -l shy-r - - t-- shy~

iO~Hl-_middot___

3IdOj

~~~_bull~~~~~~____~~_-- lOAnIO__==~=~==~~~_=~~___~~_-i IDAIf

-

- J =l Ij_fjL_rl_____~_______~___J rI_f lsquoiJ1r111 -Vj AGf 1~q~TI3-----==-1~- L 53

3

____

----

__ _ __ __ _

U bull

U

-bull--

lsquo3 V

mdash

a lsquoIU

4

S

T

C mdash

-4

I 61

bulllsquobullJ

Si I

I

bull I LS~rI lsquoIrsquo

Jr

J 11U _ ~_ _ I~~~_~~~~~~~_~_~-l lAff-I x u _ =_=

jPfiGi- L-shyLIFlt~e~U_P~_~______________---Jl I

mdash

mdash

-

-D5

Ursquo

I arsquo

Imdash

3-

irsquoai-c

zrirsquo

ekt

-lsquoI bull

4

-bull1bull

mdash pound -

4mdash

-r

I

-a

lsquo

t

aZ

a

a C

I-fl

a

44 it

dt

rt I

lsquo5rsquosaZ t

44

I iI

Iramp

t ii

pc U

mdash -mdash

mdashIrsquo 4-

rt a

lsquoCmdash

-

-

-ccedil -q

LIt

a

lsquoI

a-

StlsquoI

I I

4 IL

IEZ

EZ

S

It

I

-0

as

I I

Ji

ii

i-I I

I

t

1 __

+--f--

~- -H-+-+---I-+-I-+-+- t- f-t-t-t-t shy -I--t--t shylshy1shyI- t- - 1shy

l-~- e-c- 1- -1shy f--+--r- ishy- 1--1--- 1-- -- shy

I I-- I-f---I- I middot--~ c- +--H-t--+-t--+ -+ j- I-- middot1 - -1----1-I r- ~ c-1----+-1-- +-t---i-l--t--+- +-t----H-t-- - + f-f-- shy

1 ~ -

I

-I

+--1-1---1---+ -+-+--+-+--T--f-+--+-+ -- --LJ-_I

zI

4

---------------i----- -- shy----_~

1

L

____

----

__ _ __ __ _

U bull

U

-bull--

lsquo3 V

mdash

a lsquoIU

4

S

T

C mdash

-4

I 61

bulllsquobullJ

Si I

I

bull I LS~rI lsquoIrsquo

Jr

J 11U _ ~_ _ I~~~_~~~~~~~_~_~-l lAff-I x u _ =_=

jPfiGi- L-shyLIFlt~e~U_P~_~______________---Jl I

mdash

mdash

-

-D5

Ursquo

I arsquo

Imdash

3-

irsquoai-c

zrirsquo

ekt

-lsquoI bull

4

-bull1bull

mdash pound -

4mdash

-r

I

-a

lsquo

t

aZ

a

a C

I-fl

a

44 it

dt

rt I

lsquo5rsquosaZ t

44

I iI

Iramp

t ii

pc U

mdash -mdash

mdashIrsquo 4-

rt a

lsquoCmdash

-

-

-ccedil -q

LIt

a

lsquoI

a-

StlsquoI

I I

4 IL

IEZ

EZ

S

It

I

-0

as

I I

Ji

ii

i-I I

I

t

1 __

+--f--

~- -H-+-+---I-+-I-+-+- t- f-t-t-t-t shy -I--t--t shylshy1shyI- t- - 1shy

l-~- e-c- 1- -1shy f--+--r- ishy- 1--1--- 1-- -- shy

I I-- I-f---I- I middot--~ c- +--H-t--+-t--+ -+ j- I-- middot1 - -1----1-I r- ~ c-1----+-1-- +-t---i-l--t--+- +-t----H-t-- - + f-f-- shy

1 ~ -

I

-I

+--1-1---1---+ -+-+--+-+--T--f-+--+-+ -- --LJ-_I

zI

4

---------------i----- -- shy----_~

1

L

--

--

--

ITOPIC

===shyFILE UNDER

r~JI8JIibull

rrr-~Jc8JJ~ II GF L5 ~GEL5

~==~ Si 4 I

I

t

V

IA

-q

41 C

U E a

C

-Il C

it 4fri

0

C-

a

1

4mdash

S1)

Cmdashlsquo-3r

ft 0C

nl SelJu) rtcipic

~~~rof t Lldquo

-S

Fz

-C -5t) dck) hrJe f)j I ~

+ i t -n-a0I~ldS i

iVl-cl~ ( in heQck Q)

-54-tC7mdashlsquo13e 0fl)O~f w~p~yetJJ

r

G

Jmdash

-i

lsquoA CJ

C -a

g mdash

C

-Imdash q

S 0

iJIfr

-j

4-

aeC~ fo- recpieo-t- 11gt ~ ~~

o fi~s ~b)ir tvGIs solfC laquo6shy

~ 4 t bot VletJ W~

Imiddot ~bull -~

I I

~ ~r-I f--t--1-----t ----- - f-- I--- - I f----t--+--+---t--r-+--t-----lr----+ -c- t-+--+--+-+- +--+-+--+-1f----j--+--+---t--+--+-t----1f--t-I r I ~ + +f- 1 ++ ~ -

I I I I If----+-+--+-+--+--1---f-+--+- t--+--+

~

J I----l r(~ ( ~ I L

I

~

t shy

-~Jlgtegtf r V)(~

t-------

+II II

If----t--+--+---t--+--+--t----1f--t-~ 1 +-Ishy

- ~~ jH ~

I I

+ c----c 1-- Lshy+

-I- -I- ~ ~ ~ -I- ~ -I-+ bull~ ~ t- -I- I--II---f-+-+-+--+- +--+--t---j-~ -I- - ~ -r- -+ + -

I

r--t---t--t- t---+--+---+--+--+- f- +-+--f--t +--+-+-+---+ -Ishy -I- I--t- --1--+-+ - - -----tt

II I r ~-

5

__

-

-----

I

)f

mdash-

p

-C-

I

C

lsquoCe m

S

_

-

lsquoC

amdash

irmdash

b-

I

C

bull

arsquo -a

-V

I

I a

a

Krsquo

IA

a-

It

I

rO jJlf

= a bullbull--

I -l

F

1mdash

irsquo

a mdash

bullamdashIncin

-hL

c

a r

-r-

r

Si

lsquo_tt

I lsquo 3

r-t q

3

-D

mdashn

Oslashrsquo-t-

-----e

LW

3

1

3

p

tsitL

Lp

-

_

ci

aE

I V

L

3

r r 1

a 1

-ft

t

-tbull

imdash

qj----

bull _

1a

a

mdashC

Sfbull

3--a it

-1

a

L a

S

ha

mdash mdash

4---

-

t

lsquo a

V 4

+

0

Irsquo mdash

Nt

r

c rmdash

p-

LS

=mdash

mdash

Imdash

2

)arsquo

deg--

a-

I

3

1rsquo

H a

cL

0

fl

-r

rsquo

1 bull

t

a

oil

sJ arsquo-

h1137

1 it

Iii

1

lsquoP

u--J

6

___mdashmdash

----

--

--

--

- --

- -

--

--

-

_

mdash mdash

mdash mdash

mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash

mdash mdash

mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash

mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash

---mdash mdash

--

mdashj

mdash

mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash nmdash-Imdash

I lsquo4

amdash

r

d P_li-Ill 3 111

plusmn )iJrfl EZZZZ_______

j-l--f shy

Amdash r I

mdash

Ii aLlTzT [W

amdash-a-Imdash - e mdashmdash -a aa

lsquo

- shy

l-

I shy

-

I 5amp Is

a a I

f 1

-e -lsquo --

utfl wz afl

J bl lsquo r

E uuml4

lsquo AUfl

mdash

1-1-- ---I- --l shy

i- -- - shy

- - -1 I

f- -- shy--I mdash--- - E - ~

il~ E ft~il r~ i 1= l-C l i~ -c~ II

Wrsquoe s ccedilwlsquoj W ~~~E (1C iJ ~h

t_~ ~ ~) Iwl~ 1bull

~ ~lt L

u3 lsquo4E

VI ct 1~~b f--~t 1 lN br

j 1_ -4-

-4

11

-i~ 11Ie _1-_=-fl---j-I- shy _ I shy - I +---1-+ +shy10

flfr4 bullbull - -= ~

(WIllA -1 1

~i -I---- I-----fshy~- ~ shy _

IImiddot-~ Ivf ~ - 1

mdashmdash

II-f-i- shy

arsquo ---

~~ ~)I-r- f=r-- f-1-1-+

- --+-+-I-f-of-- - Imiddotmiddot I

Ij---j--+-+--+ -+--+--+ - 1shy -1 bull -1- Ishy-- -+--l-I shy

-+-i~-+-i- I shy - 1shy i shy+

mdashmdashmdash--mdashmdash

I- o- -- shy- l shymdash Imdash--

mdash

mdashmdash

mdash d J t-t--t shy

I-shy_-t- -1-- 1I 1--r-

--t---I---4 -- 1-shy----+--+-+-IIt

c- i i

~ l shyr- I _ - -- middot- 1- -l--+-j f---I-i-shy-

-4-

~ 1shy- shyt-I---1--+- shy I r--1 l--II -f--- l-I--- shy - mdashmdash -mdashmdashmdash

iI- I I--+---f-+- +-1-+ -L I- shyf--I--shy 1---shy mdashf-- shy

i shyI-- i-I

-+-t-~Lt- I--+--+shyl I _- I- ---

I

iIJ I l- Ishy- -

L-

7

___

E ~

l0shy

bullbullbullbullbull

tt tt Kcca ko)a)j -

-( +-+- )

~~ ~~

--I II II

+-+- r4 00~r4~Igt-~TCC ((iii~~ryenLI-~ II I 1 1-0lt1)-- -0 ltIt)

III ii it oo NN

NC

N p-a

I II IS IS Q) ~

lsquo9

~ ~~~ -------- f---- shy---------- f---- shy

S

( +-+- ))C -V

~~

bullbullbull

r

lsquolrsquo lv mdash

Sb Ri t lsquoIrsquo

) t

C bull

I

~

(

n -lsquo

o lot

-h

+-

~ ~ Ii-8

~-~7

0 00

Uu

i I

5 3 ji II tanmdashc lsquomdashlsquo

-C p-LI

p

mdashldquoa

r s lsquoamdash o

Ursquo (

I N I I

lsquo-lsquo mdash a71-

( -h

t +- )

L jlsquo-t LI

C mdash

5 1)--

tiJlsquoI A o zc 1 Q V -1 toslashU-deg rmdashRJ

~ )

8

MIT OpenCourseWarehttpocwmitedu

1HWZRUNDQGampRPSXWHU6HFXULWSpring 2014

For information about citing these materials or our Terms of Use visit httpocwmiteduterms

__

-

-----

I

)f

mdash-

p

-C-

I

C

lsquoCe m

S

_

-

lsquoC

amdash

irmdash

b-

I

C

bull

arsquo -a

-V

I

I a

a

Krsquo

IA

a-

It

I

rO jJlf

= a bullbull--

I -l

F

1mdash

irsquo

a mdash

bullamdashIncin

-hL

c

a r

-r-

r

Si

lsquo_tt

I lsquo 3

r-t q

3

-D

mdashn

Oslashrsquo-t-

-----e

LW

3

1

3

p

tsitL

Lp

-

_

ci

aE

I V

L

3

r r 1

a 1

-ft

t

-tbull

imdash

qj----

bull _

1a

a

mdashC

Sfbull

3--a it

-1

a

L a

S

ha

mdash mdash

4---

-

t

lsquo a

V 4

+

0

Irsquo mdash

Nt

r

c rmdash

p-

LS

=mdash

mdash

Imdash

2

)arsquo

deg--

a-

I

3

1rsquo

H a

cL

0

fl

-r

rsquo

1 bull

t

a

oil

sJ arsquo-

h1137

1 it

Iii

1

lsquoP

u--J

6

___mdashmdash

----

--

--

--

- --

- -

--

--

-

_

mdash mdash

mdash mdash

mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash

mdash mdash

mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash

mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash

---mdash mdash

--

mdashj

mdash

mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash nmdash-Imdash

I lsquo4

amdash

r

d P_li-Ill 3 111

plusmn )iJrfl EZZZZ_______

j-l--f shy

Amdash r I

mdash

Ii aLlTzT [W

amdash-a-Imdash - e mdashmdash -a aa

lsquo

- shy

l-

I shy

-

I 5amp Is

a a I

f 1

-e -lsquo --

utfl wz afl

J bl lsquo r

E uuml4

lsquo AUfl

mdash

1-1-- ---I- --l shy

i- -- - shy

- - -1 I

f- -- shy--I mdash--- - E - ~

il~ E ft~il r~ i 1= l-C l i~ -c~ II

Wrsquoe s ccedilwlsquoj W ~~~E (1C iJ ~h

t_~ ~ ~) Iwl~ 1bull

~ ~lt L

u3 lsquo4E

VI ct 1~~b f--~t 1 lN br

j 1_ -4-

-4

11

-i~ 11Ie _1-_=-fl---j-I- shy _ I shy - I +---1-+ +shy10

flfr4 bullbull - -= ~

(WIllA -1 1

~i -I---- I-----fshy~- ~ shy _

IImiddot-~ Ivf ~ - 1

mdashmdash

II-f-i- shy

arsquo ---

~~ ~)I-r- f=r-- f-1-1-+

- --+-+-I-f-of-- - Imiddotmiddot I

Ij---j--+-+--+ -+--+--+ - 1shy -1 bull -1- Ishy-- -+--l-I shy

-+-i~-+-i- I shy - 1shy i shy+

mdashmdashmdash--mdashmdash

I- o- -- shy- l shymdash Imdash--

mdash

mdashmdash

mdash d J t-t--t shy

I-shy_-t- -1-- 1I 1--r-

--t---I---4 -- 1-shy----+--+-+-IIt

c- i i

~ l shyr- I _ - -- middot- 1- -l--+-j f---I-i-shy-

-4-

~ 1shy- shyt-I---1--+- shy I r--1 l--II -f--- l-I--- shy - mdashmdash -mdashmdashmdash

iI- I I--+---f-+- +-1-+ -L I- shyf--I--shy 1---shy mdashf-- shy

i shyI-- i-I

-+-t-~Lt- I--+--+shyl I _- I- ---

I

iIJ I l- Ishy- -

L-

7

___

E ~

l0shy

bullbullbullbullbull

tt tt Kcca ko)a)j -

-( +-+- )

~~ ~~

--I II II

+-+- r4 00~r4~Igt-~TCC ((iii~~ryenLI-~ II I 1 1-0lt1)-- -0 ltIt)

III ii it oo NN

NC

N p-a

I II IS IS Q) ~

lsquo9

~ ~~~ -------- f---- shy---------- f---- shy

S

( +-+- ))C -V

~~

bullbullbull

r

lsquolrsquo lv mdash

Sb Ri t lsquoIrsquo

) t

C bull

I

~

(

n -lsquo

o lot

-h

+-

~ ~ Ii-8

~-~7

0 00

Uu

i I

5 3 ji II tanmdashc lsquomdashlsquo

-C p-LI

p

mdashldquoa

r s lsquoamdash o

Ursquo (

I N I I

lsquo-lsquo mdash a71-

( -h

t +- )

L jlsquo-t LI

C mdash

5 1)--

tiJlsquoI A o zc 1 Q V -1 toslashU-deg rmdashRJ

~ )

8

MIT OpenCourseWarehttpocwmitedu

1HWZRUNDQGampRPSXWHU6HFXULWSpring 2014

For information about citing these materials or our Terms of Use visit httpocwmiteduterms

___mdashmdash

----

--

--

--

- --

- -

--

--

-

_

mdash mdash

mdash mdash

mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash

mdash mdash

mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash

mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash

---mdash mdash

--

mdashj

mdash

mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash mdash nmdash-Imdash

I lsquo4

amdash

r

d P_li-Ill 3 111

plusmn )iJrfl EZZZZ_______

j-l--f shy

Amdash r I

mdash

Ii aLlTzT [W

amdash-a-Imdash - e mdashmdash -a aa

lsquo

- shy

l-

I shy

-

I 5amp Is

a a I

f 1

-e -lsquo --

utfl wz afl

J bl lsquo r

E uuml4

lsquo AUfl

mdash

1-1-- ---I- --l shy

i- -- - shy

- - -1 I

f- -- shy--I mdash--- - E - ~

il~ E ft~il r~ i 1= l-C l i~ -c~ II

Wrsquoe s ccedilwlsquoj W ~~~E (1C iJ ~h

t_~ ~ ~) Iwl~ 1bull

~ ~lt L

u3 lsquo4E

VI ct 1~~b f--~t 1 lN br

j 1_ -4-

-4

11

-i~ 11Ie _1-_=-fl---j-I- shy _ I shy - I +---1-+ +shy10

flfr4 bullbull - -= ~

(WIllA -1 1

~i -I---- I-----fshy~- ~ shy _

IImiddot-~ Ivf ~ - 1

mdashmdash

II-f-i- shy

arsquo ---

~~ ~)I-r- f=r-- f-1-1-+

- --+-+-I-f-of-- - Imiddotmiddot I

Ij---j--+-+--+ -+--+--+ - 1shy -1 bull -1- Ishy-- -+--l-I shy

-+-i~-+-i- I shy - 1shy i shy+

mdashmdashmdash--mdashmdash

I- o- -- shy- l shymdash Imdash--

mdash

mdashmdash

mdash d J t-t--t shy

I-shy_-t- -1-- 1I 1--r-

--t---I---4 -- 1-shy----+--+-+-IIt

c- i i

~ l shyr- I _ - -- middot- 1- -l--+-j f---I-i-shy-

-4-

~ 1shy- shyt-I---1--+- shy I r--1 l--II -f--- l-I--- shy - mdashmdash -mdashmdashmdash

iI- I I--+---f-+- +-1-+ -L I- shyf--I--shy 1---shy mdashf-- shy

i shyI-- i-I

-+-t-~Lt- I--+--+shyl I _- I- ---

I

iIJ I l- Ishy- -

L-

7

___

E ~

l0shy

bullbullbullbullbull

tt tt Kcca ko)a)j -

-( +-+- )

~~ ~~

--I II II

+-+- r4 00~r4~Igt-~TCC ((iii~~ryenLI-~ II I 1 1-0lt1)-- -0 ltIt)

III ii it oo NN

NC

N p-a

I II IS IS Q) ~

lsquo9

~ ~~~ -------- f---- shy---------- f---- shy

S

( +-+- ))C -V

~~

bullbullbull

r

lsquolrsquo lv mdash

Sb Ri t lsquoIrsquo

) t

C bull

I

~

(

n -lsquo

o lot

-h

+-

~ ~ Ii-8

~-~7

0 00

Uu

i I

5 3 ji II tanmdashc lsquomdashlsquo

-C p-LI

p

mdashldquoa

r s lsquoamdash o

Ursquo (

I N I I

lsquo-lsquo mdash a71-

( -h

t +- )

L jlsquo-t LI

C mdash

5 1)--

tiJlsquoI A o zc 1 Q V -1 toslashU-deg rmdashRJ

~ )

8

MIT OpenCourseWarehttpocwmitedu

1HWZRUNDQGampRPSXWHU6HFXULWSpring 2014

For information about citing these materials or our Terms of Use visit httpocwmiteduterms

___

E ~

l0shy

bullbullbullbullbull

tt tt Kcca ko)a)j -

-( +-+- )

~~ ~~

--I II II

+-+- r4 00~r4~Igt-~TCC ((iii~~ryenLI-~ II I 1 1-0lt1)-- -0 ltIt)

III ii it oo NN

NC

N p-a

I II IS IS Q) ~

lsquo9

~ ~~~ -------- f---- shy---------- f---- shy

S

( +-+- ))C -V

~~

bullbullbull

r

lsquolrsquo lv mdash

Sb Ri t lsquoIrsquo

) t

C bull

I

~

(

n -lsquo

o lot

-h

+-

~ ~ Ii-8

~-~7

0 00

Uu

i I

5 3 ji II tanmdashc lsquomdashlsquo

-C p-LI

p

mdashldquoa

r s lsquoamdash o

Ursquo (

I N I I

lsquo-lsquo mdash a71-

( -h

t +- )

L jlsquo-t LI

C mdash

5 1)--

tiJlsquoI A o zc 1 Q V -1 toslashU-deg rmdashRJ

~ )

8

MIT OpenCourseWarehttpocwmitedu

1HWZRUNDQGampRPSXWHU6HFXULWSpring 2014

For information about citing these materials or our Terms of Use visit httpocwmiteduterms

MIT OpenCourseWarehttpocwmitedu

1HWZRUNDQGampRPSXWHU6HFXULWSpring 2014

For information about citing these materials or our Terms of Use visit httpocwmiteduterms