notice judge

8/14/2019 notice judge

1/11

Case No. RG 06301644

NOTICE OF ENTRY OF JUDGMENT

[VIA FACSIMILE]

AUG-26-2008 TUE 04:03 PM Sanger & Olson FAX NO. 415 693 9322 P, 02

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

1 2

1 3

1 4

1 5

1 6

17

18I

19I

20

21

22

23

24'

25

26

27

28

FILED BY FAXALAMEDA COUNTY

August 27, 2008

CLERK OFTHE SUPERIOR COURTBy R obbi McIntosh, Deputy

CASE NUMBER:

RG06301644

\\\

\\\

\\\

1 1 1

JOHN M. SANGER, ESQ. (SBN 49758)CHARLES R. OLSON, ESQ. (SBN 130984)SANGER & OLSON, A Law Corporation576 Sacramento Street, Seventh FloorSan Francisco, CA 94111-3023

Telephone: 415-693-9300Facsimile: 415-693-9322

CHARLES F. ROBINSON, ESQ. (SBN 113197)E R I C K . B E H R E N S , E S Q . ( S B N 79440)KELLY L. DRUMM, ESQ. (SBN 172767)UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA1111 Franklin Street, 8th FloorOakland, CA 94607-5200Telephone: 510-987-9800Facsimile: 510-987-9757

Attorneys for Respondents,

THE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA;UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY; andEDWARD J. DENTON, in his official capacity

PANORAMIC HILL ASSOCIATION, anon-profit corporation,

Petitioner,

V .

THE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OFCALIFORNIA, an agency of the State ofCalifornia,

Respondent.

SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOR THE COUNTY OF ALAMEDA

Cacn Nn. RG 06301644: NOTICE+ OF ENTRY OF JUDGMENT


2/11

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

1 0

1 1

1 2

1 3

1 4

1 5

1 6

1 7

1 8

1 9

20

2 1

22

2 3

24

25

26

27

28

AUG-26-2008 TUE 04:03 PM Sanger & Olson FAX NO, 415 693 9322 P. 03

CITY OF BERKELEY, a municipal )corporation,

Petitioner/Plaintiff, ))

v. )

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA,BERKELEY; REGENTS OF THE )UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA; and DOES)2 THROUGH 50, inclusive )

)Respondents/Defendants. )

))

))

CALIFORNIA OAK FOUNDATION, SAVE )

THE OAKS AT THE STADIUM, )MCGEE-SPAULDING-HARDY HISTORIC )INTEREST GROUP, DONA SPRING, )DOUG A. BUCKWALD, SARAHSHUMER, HENRY LINDSAYVUREK, PATRICIA EDWARDS, ANNA )MARIE TAYLOR, STAN SPRAGUE, and )CA E SPRAGUE, )

)Petitioners/Plaintiffs, )

)v. )

)

THE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF )CALIFORNIA, an agency of the State of )California, and DOES II-XX, )

)Respondents/Defendants, )

)and )

)DOES XXI-XXX )

)Real Parties in Interest. )

Case No. RG 06301644: NOTICE OF ENTRY OF JUDGMENT


3/11

AUG-26-2008 TUE 04:03 PM Sanger & Olson FAX NO. 415 693 9322 P. 04

1 TO ALL PARTIES AND THEIR COUNSEL:

2 Please take Notice that on August 26, 2008, the i

3 hereto a xhibit A.

4 Dated: 2008 S A N GA LAW

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

the Judgment attached

3y111171. ..r 14L4 ,J j.

Att net's or Respondents

T - REGENTS OF THE

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA;

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA,

BERKELEY; and EDWARD J.DENTON, in his official capacity

K:IDOCI 01ffiI1IDZT1 ouTue[-TrinlApcnl\Filu58s in Tnul CourLNgire ofEnuy oflndgmcn.DOC 1

Case No. RG 06301644: NOTICE OF ENTRY OF JUDGMENT


4/11


EXHIBIT A

DmumW508/2N20084:0


5/11

AUG-26-2008 TUE 04:03 PM Sanger & Olson

98/26/2098 15:55 5196992759

AUG-20-2008 NED10 - 63 AMSan .r &Ol s o0

FAX NO. 415 693 9322

DEPT52E

FAX NO. 415 803 9322

P. 06

PAGE 02/07 -^

1

2'

5

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

is

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

FILED BY FACSIMILE

JOHN M. SANGE E S Q . ( SBN 49758)C H A R L E S R . O L S O N . ESQ . (SBN 1 30984)S A N G S R & O L S O N , A Law ooration576 Sacramento Sk oat, Seventh FloorSon Francisco, CA 94111-3023Tele ane; 4I5-693-9300Fecsile: 415-693-9322

CRA,RLES F . ROBINSON , S ^i(SBN 113197)ERIC K. BEHR NS ESQ. SBN 79440)KE L L Y L . DR UM I V, E S Q. (SEN 172767)UN I VE R S I T Y O F C A L I F 0 1 tN I A1111 Fraklin Std, 8th FloorOakland, CA 94607-5200Telephone: 510.987-9800Facsimile: 510-987-9757

At arseya forg ondents,T HE R O E ! ''T S OF THUN I VE R S I T Y O F C A L I F O R N I A ;L I N T VE R S I T Y O F C A L I F O R N I A B E R KE L E Y; a n dE D W A R D I. D E N T ON, in his of tfcial capacity

SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOR T1 E COUNTY OF ALAMEDA

PANORAMIC HILL ASSOCIATION, a FILED BY FACSIMILEaeon-profi t corporat ion,

C a se No,RU 06301644Pet i t ioner,

RESPONDENTS' Prv. AMENDED JUDO NT

THE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OFCALIFORNIA, an agency o f th o State of Date : 2008California, De t: 512

Tu Hon. E a r be ra M t1 1 c rRespondent.

tic

lac

FILEDALAMMA{'.a;O7i

A U G 2 6 2 0 0 8

CLERK 'ffiBUP..RI(


6/11


08/26/2008 25:55 510E902759 D T52PAGE 03/87

A 20-2008 WED 10:63 AN g l o r & Olson FAX NO. 41$ 693 9322 P. 03

\\\

CaY OF BERKELEY, a municipalcorporation,

Mfi=MItiff,

v,

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA,1 3 E E Y . REGENTS OF TM

VM

,

OF CAL IFORNIA; and DOES2 OUGH 50, inclusive

CALIFORNIA OAK FOUNDATION, SAVETHE O S AT THE STADIUM,MCGU-SPA=MG-H Y UI S T ORI CINTEREST GROUP DONA SPRING,DOUG A. BUCKW D, SARAH

H E N R YSHUM NOM,SAYPA TR IC IAVURBIC,

M A R I E T A Y L O R , STAN SPRAGUE, andC R

v.

OBNTSO F M UNIVERSITY OFCALIFO R N IA an agency Oft Stake ofWo =d DOES

Respndo dm%

DOES XXI-

heal P ro in Int t,

tilt

ul

\

Cow No. RG 06301W; REMMEN TROMEDI MGM=

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

1 1

12

1 3

14

15

1 6

17

l8

19

20

21

22

2 3

24

25

26

27

25


7/11

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

1 0

1 1

12

13

1 4

IS

1 6

1 7

/8

1 9

20

21

22

23

24

25

2627

28

AUG-26-2008 TUE 04:04PMSanger &Olson FAX NO, 415 693 9322 P. 08

PAGE 04/07

F. 04

08/26/2008 15:55 5106902759

AUG-20-2008 MD 10:63 AN Svger & Olson

Having considered the issues flramed by the operative pleadings, the administratly

mo filed by the parties in these partially consolidatedactions; having beard

argument by counsel for 41 parties in these matters; and having issued on June 18, 2008 an

Granting iu Pm and Den g in Part Petitions for Writ of Mandate (" " ),

IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that:

1 . Insofar as petitioners' California Environme tai Quality A

(Pub. Resources Code, 21000 at w,) ("CEQA") we conoem4 the Petitions for Writ

Maaciate filed by petitioners Panoramic Hill AnwomCity of Berkeley and California 0

Foundation, at 4 ("Petitioners") are panted solely on the groundthat the record

far findings and w ns in the that doublingthe nunnber of capaoity events at th

Califarnla Memorial Stadium ("CMS") as part of Phase 2 of the CMS Seismic Corrections

Program Impmv=MU, whichisone component of the Southeast C amp u sIntegrated Projeo

(the "Project"), will cause significantenvironmentaleffects that are unavoidable. (Order , pp

121-122.)In insofar as Petitioners' CEQA claims are concerned, the P4

deniedand judgmentis entered favor of Respondents The Regents of the University o

California, ( ` University"),

2, Insofar as Petitioners' Claims under the A lqu Plo Earthquake Fault

Act (Public Resources 2621 at seq.) ("Alq tPfieb") are eeno , the Pet fims

granted solely on the grounds

a. The University is not exempt from the xe quirements of Mqu6t-Phol

(Order, pp, 10-17);

b. The Student Athlete High Performance Center ("S CI proj

includes the fol lowing alterat ions to the C MS within themgofAlquist-Priolo:(i) a grade beam to be installed along the taLse of the CMS west w a ll,;

(ii) alterations to hero CMS stairmes; and

- I-

No. RG 063016441 RESPONDENTS'MPOM1NDED=C

DEPT52E

FAX NO 41F 803 9322


8/11

FAX NO. 415 893 9322 P. 09

DEPT52EPACE 05/07

FAX NO. 419 893 9322 P. 05


08/26/2008 15:55 5106902759

A[G2OE2008 WED10154ANSa-osr &Olson

1 ..

1 (iii) 'ground floor slab penetrations" i n CM$ proposed tofacilitate the

2 instaliatin^,, of the SAHPC telecommunications system; ad

3 G . At the time it approved the SAHPC, the Univer sity had not determined

4 value o f the foregoing alterations to CMS identified in Paragraph 2.b. above.

5 In all other respects, Insofar as Petitioners' claims under Alquist-Priolo are cane erned,

6 Petitions are denied and judgment is entered in favor of the University.

7

81

3. The Clark of the Court erernptory Writ

91 Mandate, ordering the University to do the fallowing:

10 a. suspend the approval of the SAHPC until the University demonstrates tl

11 the cost to construct the foregoing alterations to the CMS described above in Paraga

12 2.b, is less than fifty percent of the value of the CMS, or removes such alterations

13 CMS from the SAHPC project; and

14 b. pur

suant to Public Resources Code section 21168.9(c), refrain fN

15 approving CMS Phases 2 or 3 of the Integrated Projects until the University (1) wlthdza

16 the proposal to increase the number of capacity events at the CMS as part of the Proje

17 or (ii) if the University chooses to retain them, until the University provides substani

18 evidence to support its findings and conclusions in the EIR that doubling the number

19 capacity events at the California Memorial Stadium will cause significant euvironnmen

20 effects that are unavoidable,

21

22 4. Tice Court deems the University's Response, filed Juno 27, 2008, to the Con,

23 June 18, 2008 Order as a return to the Peremptory Writ of Mandate. The University's Re apot

24 to the Order includes: (1) Luther environmental review of modifications to the Project and tl

25SAIilC set forth in items (2) and (3) below In response to the court's Order, and modification

26

CEQA findings related thereto, including a subsequent finding superseding and effective27 mooting the finding regarding unavoidable significant effects of increased capacity events; I

28 removal from the Project of the additional capacity events referred to In Paragraph 1, above, a

^2-

Case No. R(i06301 644 ; [P'ROPOSEDI


9/11

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

1 1

1 2

13

1 4

15

16

1 7

1 8

1 9

20

21

22

23

24

25

2627

28


08/26/2008 15:55 5106902759

AU0-20-2009 WED 10 : 54 AM Sager & Olson

FAX NO 415 693 9322

DEPT52t

FAXMO. 415 893 9322

P. 10

PAGE 06/07

P. 08

(3) removal ofall alterations to the CMS includedin the S C miwt referred to irk Paragraph

2.b. Such actions demonstrate the Perremptory Watt of Mandate.

5. In accordance with Code of sections 1032(a)(4), 1084.5

1095, and consistent with the &aeration that section 1032(a)(4) gives the court (seeLincoln v.

Schurgln (1995) 39 Ca1.Am4th 100, 105), the court apportions costs based on the degree

which the parties have prevailed in these partially consolidated proceedings. Because th

University has prevailed on the bgk of Petitioners' claims, the Court awards the Univers

eighty-five percennt of its costs, which shall be borne by Petid s as follows: one-third by Ci

ofone-third by Panoramic Hill Association and one-third by California 0

Foundation, at at, Costs are determined in accordance with the procedures set rtlt in C oda

Civil Procedure sections 1032, 10 33 and 1033.5, md the co respou&g CaliforniaRules o

Court. Any party wishing to seek attorneyfees may do so by noticed motion.

6. On July 23, 2008, otter the Court issued its July 2Z 2008, Jud t Petitioner

filed a Motion to Vacate Judgment and forNew

7. On August 8, 2008, the Court issuedOrd er t o S how Caus e%y Court S W

Not Enter Amended Judgment

& On A us 15, 20 08, Petitioners withdrew their Motion to Vacate Judgment

for New Mg.

9. Also on August 15, 2008, Resporndents filed a Notice of Decigo

Not to File a Supplemental that would not file th

supplemental that the Court mft&Wthem to file is paragraph. 5 oftheMy 22, 2008Order After Hearing.

-3-Case NmRG MOIW:azsmmmr (PROPOSED] A n=0


10/11

FAX NO. 415 693 9322 P. 11

DEPT52 PAGE 07/07

FAXNO, 415 893 8322 P. 07


08/26/2008 15:55 5106902759

AUG-20-2008 WED 10:64 AM S' er & Olson

II . _

1 10 . On August 19, 2008, Petitioners filed a Response to Order to Show Cause.

2

3 11. . Also on August 19, 2008, Respondents flied a Response to Court's August

4 2008, Order to Show Cause.

5

6 12 . Bas ed on repro cn t at ion s Res pon d en t s wad e in t he ir Res pon s e t o Cou rt 's

78, 2008, O rder to Show Cause, the prel iminary injunct ion entered on Febnrary 9 , 2007, is

8 dissolved,

9

1 4 13 . This Amended Judgment is effective and enforceable

it ok

12DATED; 2008

1 3

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

2627

2 8

-4.


11/11

AUG-26-2008 TUE 04:05 PM Sanger & Olson FAX NO. 415 693 9322 P . 12

PROOF OF SERVICE

I, Whitney Carlson, the undersigned, declare under penalty of perjuryunder the laws ofthe State of California that the following statements are true and correct:

1. I am at least 18 years of age and am not a party to the within action.

2. My business address is Sanger & Olson, 576 Sacramento Street, Seventh Floor,San Francisco, California. My mailing address is Sanger & Olson, 576 Sacramento Street,Seventh Floor, San Francisco, California 94111-3023.

3. On August 26, 2008 I served the attached document(s) entitled:

NOTICE OF ENTRY OF JUDGMENT

on the following named persons in this action:

Michael R. Lozeau, Esq.

LOZEAU DRURY, LL P1516 Oak Street, Suite 216Alameda, California 94501Fax: (510) 749-9103

Kelly L. Drumm, Esq.

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA1111 Franklin Street, 8th FloorOakland, CA 94607-5200Fax: (510) 987-9757

Stephan C. Volker, Esq.LAW OFFICES OF STEPHAN C.

VOLKER

436 14th Street, Suite 1300

Oakland, CA 94612Fax: (510) 496-1366

Harriet A. Steiner, Esq.MCDONOUGH HOLLAND & ALLEN

PC555 Capitol Mall, 9

thFloor

Sacramento, CA 95814Fax: (916) 444-8334

XBY MAIL by placing said copy in a sealed envelope for collection and processing formailing and, being familiar with my employer's mail collection and processing practices, knowthat said mail is collected and deposited with the United States Postal Service on the same day itis dated, and know that postage thereon is fully prepaid.

BY PERSONAL SERVICE by causing the same to be personally served by on theabove-named person at the above-stated address on this date.

XBY FACSIMILE by transmitting the same by facsimile transmission to the above-namedperson at the above-stated fax number, and received a printed confirmation of successfulfacsimile transmission.

BY OVERNIGHT MAIL by causing the same to be served via overnight mail on the

above-named person at the above-stated address on this date.

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that theforegoing is true and correct. Executed this 26th day of August 2008 at San Francisco,California.

Documents

notice judge