Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
OT3bIBHa aBrope(Fpar Al{cceprarlru T.A. Manrrrueeofi
na revry
npaBoBoro perynr4poBaHr4r. yKa3aHHbre Qar
3
rrepeMerrleHr4r ToBapoB B r{ensx ycTpaHeEvs nocJreAcTBrrfi cTr.rxr.riHbrx IertcTBr4i[.,
TexHofeHHr,rx u r.rH6IX KaTacTpoQ, BoeHHbrx KoHOII4KToB t\ Ilpoq., npoI,I3oIxeAIIII4e
nocre HaqaJIa $ynxrlrzoHuposaHur TaN4oNeHHoro colo3a 14 BcrylneHr.rq B crrJry
aKToB 3aKoHoAareJlbcrBa Tarraoxennoro coro3a (TalroNeHHoro KoAeKca
Tauoxennoro coro3a, MexAyuapoAHr,rx AoroBopoB rocyAapcrB-qneHoB
Tauoxennoro coro3a, perxeHrafi Korvracczu Talroxennoro coro3a r,r Enpasvficrofi
9KOHOMIIqeCKOI4 KOMI,ICCI{Ir, aKTOB HaqrioHajr6Hofo 3aKoHoAaTeJrbcTBa
rocyAapcrB-qneHoB TauoNennoro corosa). Pe:ynrrarrr aHaJwBanpaBorlpl,IMllutlrenrnofi npaKTraKrr aKToB 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBa KaK rocyAapcrB-
rrJreaoB Tavoxennoro coro3a, TaK u Poccuu [o3Bonr{n[ c$oprraynrzponarrcorl cKaTeJrro fipeAno]r{eHr4rr IIo coBeprrreHcTBoBaHr]ro Qr{HaHcoBo-[paBoBoroperynr4poBaHr,rs, opraH[3arlrroHHbrx ocHoB oKa3aHus. ryMaHr4TapHofr noMorrl]r
[ocpeAcTBoM TpaHcfpaHl,IqHoro [epeMeIrIeHI4rI ToBapoB.
flo4nxrue B Arrcceprarl[ri Borrpocbl uMelor reoperrrrlecKoe 3HarIeHIre,
[ocKoJrr,Ky 3arparfiBaror qenrri px4 Hepe[IeuHbrx acrreKToB, BHyrpeHHr.Ix
r
4
nrrKBu4arJvttr nocneAcrBr4il crvxr4 fiHbrx 6epnvui; rexHofeHHr,rx r4 lrHhrxraracrpoQ, BoopyxeHHrrx rou$maxroa, Koropr,re paccMarpr4Barorcr B KaqecrBe
ryrraauzrapuofi noMoulu. C:re4onareluro, B KarlecrBe peKoMeHAarIulIMam,Iuresofi T.A. uoxso [peAnoxr4 rr, npoAonxrir; rrccreAoBaHrrr Bo[pocoB
rrepeMerleHr4r ryuanurapHoi noMorrlu c noszqnft Mex.4yHapoAHoro npaBa r{ c
f{eroM oco6ennocrefi 3aKrror{eHus MexAyHapoAHr,IX AoroBopon Pocczicrofi
@e4epaqran s o6racrn raMox(eHHoro AeJra.
Tarlru o6pasoM, Arrccepraqz-a Malrrurenofi T.A. npegcraa:rxer co6ofi
uccJIeAoBaHIie TeopeTI'IqecKuX [pooJIeM QLIHaHcoBo-npaBoBoro pefynl4poBaHl,It
flepeMerleHrr{ ryuanrarapnof fioMorqu qepe3 TzrMox{eHrryro rpalrzrly TauoNennoro
coro:a. llo:ryreHHbre pe3ynlTarbt u BrrBoAbI aBTopa rro3BoJrrror roBopnrr o roM,
rITo rlpe,qcraB:reuuHft Tpy,q fBnrercr caMocrofrerbHblM 3aKoHqeHHbrM Haf{HbIM
rrccJreAoBaHzeM, coAepxaql,IM perueHue ar
Orssreo6 arropeeepare Arrcceprarluu Ha coucKaHrre
yrieHofr creneHu KaHArrAara ropnAur{ecKux Hayr( T.A. Ma,rr.luenolr_ (IIepeMerqeri He ryMaHr{TapHofi noMoulu qepe3 TaMor{er{Hyto rpaHr.tqyTavoxeuuoro corc3a: oco6eHuocrn Qlruaucono-upaBoBoro peryJrIrpoBaHIta)
ro cneqra!'rbsocrn 12.00.04 _ ennauconoe npaBo; Ha.,roroBoe rrpaBo;6rogrxernoc nparo (Capar on, 2014)
flpe4craa,reHuoe !i4ccepraHToM r{ccJreAoBaHr4e Ha reuy
oKa3aHarr fyMaHHTapHot floMorrlu B focyAapcrBax-qJrer]ax TavoNeuuoro coro:a
IIo3BOJ'II'IJI aBTOpy BbrrrBI'ITL no,[ox{eHhr, rpe6yrorqne 3ar(oHoAarenbHoro3aKpe[neHl4t KaK Ha HaUVOHaJIbHOM, TaK U COTO3HOM ypOBHe. OceeqeHHHe n
AXCCepraut4r{ acnet(Tbr o6,raAator reoperr4qecKoi luaqr.iuocrrto, rocKonbKy
3arparaBaror npo6leirasr HeoAHo3Har{HOfO TonKoBaHrrr HopM, pefrraMeHTrzpyrcuux
npaBoBr,re ocHoBbr rrepeMe[IeHr'tr ryuauarapnofr rroMorr]r.I qepe3 TaMoxeHHyrorpaHI4IIy TauoxeHHoro coro3a. llparruuecruu xapaKTepoM o6,,ra4arorfioJloxeHu{, BbIHocl4MbIe Ha 3au,ll4Ty, conepxaxll4e npelnoxeHl4q o co3AaHulirouuccrzfr I1o BonpocaM fyMaHr4TapHofi noMou]ti Ha ypoBHe seAepanrnrrxoKpyfoB r.r cy6:beKToB, a raKxe lenap'rair,reura no BorrpocaM oKa3aHz,ryuauurapuoi.i noMotua Ha reppuropltn TalroNerlHofo coro3a B Kar{ecrBecrpyKTypHofo noApa3AeJ.IeHlra e Etpa:zficxofi axouorvruqecxoi rorvrlrccptu.
[ucceptagux T.A. Manrnueeofi
OT3hIB
Ha aBTope+epar Arrcceprarlflfi MaJrbrrrreBofi TarrqHsr A.nerccangponnrr,
n peAcTaBJreHHoft Ha co[cKaHrre yuenofr crerleHll KaHAITAaTa rcp[Ar{qecr(ux
HayK Ha reMy:
KoHTporq. C.negyer orMerrirL, qro [peAJraraevas T. A. MalsuueeoftapryMeHTarlr4rr oco6oro noprAxa nepeMenleHr4rr irepe3 TaMoxeHHyro rpaHr4rly
Tavoxennoro coro3a ryMaHrrrapHoft nonrorqra, [peAcraBJrrercr BloJrHe
irepe3
Oco6o cJreAyer orMer[Tb, qro A[ccepraHT uccJreAyer npo6.nevy
o6ocnoeaHHofi . Pearuga\ut npe,4roxenzfi, co.qep)Karquxcr e anrope$epare, rro
HarrreMy MHeHrdro, rro3BoJrr4T ycrpaHr4Tb nrraerorqufcx npanoeoft npo6el n
MexaHr43Me rrpaBoBoro peryJrupoBaHr4r flepeMelleHr,rs roBapoB
TaMOXeHHyIO tpaHl{qy Tarraoxennoro coroga.
cneAyroqee. coucxareffi
OKa3aHlIt rynrauzrapnOft
KaqecrBe cTpyI(TypHoro
oco6eHuocrefi Qunancono-npaBoBoro perynfipoBaHn r rrepeMeuleHr,rtr-ylraHrrrapHofi norraorqu qepe3 TaMoxeHHyro rpaHuuy TaMox(euuoro coro3a
KOMIJreKCHO, qro rrO3BOJrreT efi npH lpOprrayrupoaaur{r{ flpeAJrox{en[fi oxsa'rr4rl
AOCTaTOqHO ruVpoKr4r,r CIIeKTp HOpMaTr.rBHbrx npaBOBbIX aKTOB, TaKr4X KaK
Tarr,roxennrrfi Ko.ueKc Tanaoxennoro coroga, Haroronrrft xoAexc Poccuficxofi
@e4epaqr.rr.r, px4 $e4epzurbHLlx 3aKoHoB rI noA3aKoHHbrx aKToB. llpu raxolrKoMnJreKcHoM aHaJur3e T. A. Manrrrueea r4ccJreAyer He roJrrKo3aKOHOAaTeJTLCTBO POCCUfiCTOft @e4epaqtrtr., Ho lr 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBo ,{pyflrx
rocyAapcTB - qreHoB Tavoxennoro colo3a, qro [o3BoJlter efr npe4noxurrI{CnOJIL3OBaTb I4X [O3rrrrltBHblfi OnUr [paBOBOfO perynr4poBaHlrrl.
llpe4crann-arorcf BaxHbrMu u 3acJryxo,IBaIorII4MIr BHI,IMaHI4I aBTopcKI4e
AelplrHr{rlr4n TaKIIX IIOH{TI{14 KaK (qeJreBoe
r{cloJrb3oBaHr.re ryMaHr4TapHoft lloMolqu), (oKa3aHI,Ie ryMaHl4TapHofr nououltl>>,
a raK xe npeAJroxeHHblfi AuccepraHroM KoM[JIeKc Qyurquu Qunaucono-[paBoBhrx JrbroT, IIpeAocTaBIseMbIx B npoqecce oKa3aHI]{ ryMaHr'ITapHolIrroMoIrIt4.
B ra.recrse 3aMeqaHLIt, rpe6yroqero yroqHeHr4t, MoxHo orMerI'ITb
lpeAnameT co3Aarb ,{enaptavenr IIo BonpocaM
rroMorqu Ha reppI4Topl4Ia Tauoxenuoro colo3a, B
noApa3AeneHr.rr Eepaar.lficrcoft lttoHovrqecrofi
KoMrrccrrr4 (C. l2). Ha sarqute AaHHoe npeAJIoxeHI,Ie rpe6yer AorlonHl4renbHofi
apryMeHTarll,Ifi. Teu ue MeHee, AaHHoe 3aMeqaHI,Ie HeAOCraroK He BJII4'eT Ha
HarrpaBneHHocrb rr MoxeT HaiTI4 [pr.rMeHeHl,re B rlpenoAaBaHr4r.r r{e6HLrxArrcrlr4rrJrr4H ,
rrpaBo)), cooTBercrByroLqux clellKypcoB.
.{uccepraqnoHuoe uccJIeAoBaHIte BbIIIOJIHCHO
Teoperr4 qecKoM ypoBHe r{ oTBeqaeT BceM 'IpeooBaHI,I.tM, npeAs.sBr.seMblM K
raxzu pa6orau. AetopeQepar HarII4caH xoponr{M JILITeparypHbIM t3brKoM I4
oTpaxaer cyrb AI4ccepTaIIIroHHoro [ccJreAoBaHI4t.
florararo, qro aerope$epa'r Ar4cceprarltrrr Marrrlreeoi Tarr-sHrrAlexcan4pornbr Ha collcKaHl4e yqeuofr crerIeHI,I KaHAIrAara rcpl4AuqecKllx HayK
Ha reMy
OrsHeo6 arropeQepare Aucceprarlnn Ha cor{cKaHrre
y.renofi crenenu KaEAuAara roptlA[rrecKux HayK T.A. Ma.ilrlmesofi_
L
O(A3AHI,I,{ ry'I\4AHI,ITAPHOfi NOMOUII. CAUIrIrr,r 3HAqI,IMbIMI4, HA HAII] B3IJI{A.rBJnrroTc{ cneA}arorrlkre rro3l4ql.Iv:
- BHeCeHr.re e m. 25 Ha:rorosoro KoAeKca p(D nopuu, ycralran {rarorqeftBo3MoxHocrE lloJlf{eHr4t HaJIofoBLrx Br'IiIeroB opraF'LBa\LrAM[, oKa3blBarorur4Ml4
ryManrrrapr{yrc troMorrlb s Poccr.rficrofi (De4epaqua;
- 3aKpe[JreHrre B cr. 8 6ro4xernoro KoAeKca p@ npana cy6lerra p@ saco3AaHr4e rleJreBoro 6ro4xernoro (foH4a, cpeAcrBa Koroporo 6yayrpacxoAoBarEcfl Ha ona3auvre fyManr4TapHofi nolroullr;
- ycraHoBJreHr4e e q. 16.20 KoArI p
Quuancoeoro flpaBa peryJrr.rpyrorcq rtreJrbrM prlroM KoAeKcoB, B ToM rrr4cJrefpaxAaHcKrrM, HanoroBbrM, 6ro4xerHlru. Bonpoc o lpopuzpoeanrau Qunancoaoro3aKOHOAareJILCrna, 6esycloBHo, 3aKOHOMepeH, HO rroKa oH HaxoAI4TCt B CTanL 4
oocyxAeHn{ u obocHoBaHrzr.
Te xe flpereH3rilr MoxHo 3aflBr4Tb u r< $opuynr{poBKe o6rerraIICCNCAOBAHI{'. KAT( NPE4CTABIIfrETCI,, ABTOP PACCMATPI4BAET B AI4CCEPTAIIruQauanconue fipaBoorHorrreHnr, To ecrb rroHJrrrze, ycrorBrueecr cSepeQaqanconoro rz raMoxeHqoro lpaBa. Erqe pas noAirepKHeM, rrro BbrcKa3anHbrecyxAeHr4rr Hocrr 4zcryccrzonuufi xapaKTep r,r He BJrlrtror Ha oounro[oJroxv reJrbHyro orIeHKy AaHHOTO Hay{Horo rpyla.
Taxuv o6pa-:oM, cy.qr no aerope$epary, Avccepraqux T.A. Ma:rrrueeorl
OT3bIB
rta aa'rope$epa'r'lrncceprauuH Ha cot,lcKarrlle yueHoil c Ferr€ltpt
Ittlxi,I[IfAa'ra lopltffHtl€cKHx HayK Manuureeori Tarussu rlneKcaHgp$rlrrbl
{Io ?'eme:
B npunna.4Horl rpoprurare cJreAyer orMeruTb, qro dlucrcallual 5cf;r,6e
BbrparlieHa MoAenb {tunaHcono-npaBoBoro perynupoBa}r?ttr riepeii{eLr1r-.r-rr.rs
ryMaflH'rapuoii noMorlin qepe3 TaMoxeHHylo rpaHnr1y Tauorxeur{oro oox)ila B
'.r;lc'I'H :JJtcr{eHTots MoAenH H HX CttcTeMHbIX CSgSefi.
['] rtoloxtesltpt l, BbrHeceHHoM Ha 34il{u1'y, BKJr}oqeHH.e I(o}ITpoJrr ileJreB(}i'oucnoJlbt]oBaHut B onpeAeJrenue oKa3anlrr ryMaHpiraplroi.i iroMorurrilpeAcTiiBJrrre'rcr Becr,Ma cnopHblM, oco6eHuo B cBeTe rloJlo)r(efrtrt 6, n rGTopot'r
KoHTpoJlb ooocHonauso orHeceH K KoMrrereHrIHH opraHoB rocyAapcreeHHoiiB-qacTl.f .
Arrop o6ocnonaHrro pa3AeJrrer nonyqarerefi u Koneqribrx nc;ryualereiiryMaFru'rapHofr rrorvronlr4. OAHaro c $ucralrHux norarlufi {}crr}ercnrreqldxctAnlvlocrl, yrorllruTb
- KaK, rlo MHeHum aBTopa, AoJrxHa pa3rpaHHrruBarbcfl
tfrnnarrctrnax orBercrBeHHocrb arrlx cy6texron B cJryrralx o6rrapylrceriltlrItetlcJreBofo Ecronb3oRar{Hq ryMaHnTapuofi noMotql4.
Aurop xapar$epn:yer $anaHcoBo-npaeoeor? Hr{cruTyr tpuHaHconr"rx .irtrro'!-
'iaK MonclAoii H {roprvrnpyroutuficr. llonaraeu, qro 3To'r re3r,rc He roqen,
nocKoJrbKy $nuauconue Jrbr-orbl HHcrpyMeHT. flpprMeFrrroutr.licll B
oregeclngHlroM rrpaBe B pa3Jlrrrrnrtx rvrogr,r$nKauHrx c MoMeHTa rilopn.rr.rlloBanuri
i)occ p{ fi cro fi S-re.qepar{H r,r.
H noJroxelJr4n 7, BbrHocrrMoM Ha 3aIr{HTy, Bo3JIo}I(eHfle Koilrponfi :Jel
ucJreBbrM HcrroJ,b3oBaulreM't'oBapoB ryMaHuTapHofi noMouru lla ltolvtnccl4Kr [I{)
BonpocaM ryMaHuTaprrofi noMouIH f,Bnrercr KoppynrrHorenl.rhrM rparropona u rre
Ithr:ibtBae'I noAAepXKI,I, 'raK KaK OpraHv3AUUg, nepeMelqeHHt TOItapOB rloii BHJloll
' -vjvraul.rrapuo* rroMou{H Mo)Ker ycneuno HcxoAr{Tb o'r rocyAapc"t'ReI{HbIX
crpyK'ryp pa3JrnqHoro ypoBr{r.
ilplrrre4enxbre 3aMeqaHnfl orpax(aar cJro)KHocrb r,r Macurra6socrt 3a&aq.
:+a peUjeilr4e KoTopbrx B:lrrJrcr Ar4ccepTaHT, He CHH)|{aIOT OGUtytO noJl0x{tlTeJlbFlylo
oUeHKy sslnolHeuHoir lrayuuofi pa6oru a AaIoT HMnyJIbc rray.tHoii /:ltlcK)'ctrHH !l
n r,r pa6oTre B,i{anbHeii t ueivl HoI}bIX noJre3Hhlx perueu nfi .
/faccepraunn T. A. MarHilresofi
БоброваГеляховаОрловРыльскаяСаттароваНовиковDC-260-B1277A228p1DC-260-B1277A228p2DC-260-B1277A228p3DC-260-B1277A228p4