60
OCEAN PLASTICS Marco, Alex, Mariana & Sam https://www.projectaware.org/news/were-now-million-plastic-bottles-minute-91-which-are-not-recycled

OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    12

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

OCEAN PLASTICS

Marco, Alex, Mariana & Samhttps://www.projectaware.org/news/were-now-million-plastic-bottles-minute-91-which-are-not-recycled

Page 2: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

● 8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020

● 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics

● Marine life at risk● In 2015, only 9.1% of plastic was recycled

Ocean Plastics are a Serious Problem

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

www.coastalseekers.com/story/reducing-plastic-pollution-in-our-oceans-world-environment-day/

Page 3: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

● PET and PE together account for up to 30% of all plastics, with some of the most common applications being bottles and product containers

● Both show negligible marine degradation○ Micro and nano plastics

● Both have been shown to lead to high rates of sorption of POPs○ Large surface area

Current Plastics are Inadequate

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 4: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 5: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

● Goal: If plastics reach the ocean, they will break down in the environment in as little time as possible○ Breakdown products will not pose

hazards to the marine environment○ Products will not pose health hazards to

humans

https://www.pinterest.com/pin/60939401183116790/?lp=true

Approach: Reduce Impact of Method Products

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 6: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Mechanical Thermal UV/Radical Hydrolytic Biological

Synthetic Polymer Degradation Processes

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 7: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Modern plastics degrade slowly in nature

A large number of polymers degrade readily in the environment due to bacterial and fungal processes:

1. Cellulose (polysaccharides)2. Keratin (proteins)3. DNA (nucleic acids)

Our goal was to find polymers with these same properties- high durability but susceptible to enzymatic degradation- that also maintained thermoplastic properties

https://www.flickr.com/photos/jsjgeology/27105228293

https://da.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tr%C3%A6_(materiale)#/media/File:Egeved.JPG

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:DNA_Structure%2BKey%2BLabelled.pn_NoBB.png

Inspiration: Natural Polymers

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 8: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Technical Performance

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 9: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Technical Performance: Strategies

Biopolymers as Thermoplastic

Alternatives

Polymer Crystallinity and Biodegradation

Non- Thermoplastic

Alternatives

Biodegradation Enhancing Additives

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 10: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

ThermoplasticsThermoplastics soften when heated and harden when cooled. This allows them to be remolded and recycledAdvantages:

● Recyclable● Reshaping capabilities● Chemical resistant● Hard crystalline or rubbery surface

Thermoplastic Disadvantages:

● Expensive● Can melt if heated

Before After

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Plastic_bottle.jpg

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 11: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Technical Performance

Barrier PropertiesWater Permeability

Thermal Properties Glass transition and melting

temperatures

Tensile Properties Strength, elongation at break

Moisture and product dehydration

Resistance and flexibility

Polymer compatibility and stability

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 12: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Technical Performance

Polymer Barrier Properties Tensile Properties Thermal PropertiesH2O Permeability

(g mm/m2 day atm)Elongation at

break (%)Tensile

Strength (MPa) Tm (°C) Tg (°C)

PET 0.5-2 300 55 260 67-81PE 0.5-2 298 22-29 115–135 < -50

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 13: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Environmental Performance- % Degradation

1. Standardized biodegradation (based on ASTM standards): 90% converted to CO2 after 180 days at 30°C in seawater with indigenous microbial culture

2. Abiotic degradation (chemical hydrolysis only): relevant to aquatic environments with diluted microorganism concentrations

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Brannigan et. al. (2016)

Page 14: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Polylactic acid (PLA)

NatureWorks®-Cargill Dow (USA) and Galacid®-Galactic (Belgium)

● 10% of total biopolymer production capacities in 2013

● Made from renewable sources-100 % Bio-based content

● High transparency, high molecular weight, and good resistance to acids and oils

Biodegradable Polymers

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

http://www.worldcentric.org/biocompostables/cups/pla-cold-cups

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Polylactid_sceletal.svg

Page 15: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Environmental Performance● PLA will compost in industrial

facilities. Hydrolysis needs higher temperatures

● Degradation according to ASTM standards: 3.11% in 180 days

● Abiotic degradation 14% after 18 weeks

PLA Performance

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Technical Performance

Medium water barrier

Similar strength to PET

Low elongation at break, brittle

Tm and Tg similar to PE & PET

Page 16: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Biodegradable Polymers

Polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHAs)Produced by the bacterial fermentation of sugars and lipids and are synthesised by a very wide range of microorganisms

Made up 1.6% of total biopolymer production capacities in 2013

PHBHx (Kaneka) and PHBO (Nodax by P&G) show greater biodegradation rates

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyhydroxyalkanoates#/media/File:Poly-(R)-3-hydroxybutyrat.svg

PHA R

PHB -CH3

PHBV (BiopolTM) -CH3 and -CH2CH2CH3

PHBHx (Kaneka) -CH3 and -CH2CH2CH3

PHBO (Nodax) -CH3 and -(CH2)4CH3 Noda et. al. (2018)

Page 17: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Environmental Performance

PHBHx-Performance

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Technical Performance

Good water barrier

Similar strength to PE

Good elongation at break, ductile

Tm and Tg similar to PE & PET

Polymer Degradation according to ASTM standards

Abiotic degradation

PHA (Nodax) 45% in 180 days

PHB 89% in 43 days ~8.5% in 1 year

PHBHHx 88.1-89.4% loss 149 days at 30 °C

Page 18: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Biodegradable Polymers

Polycaprolactone (PCL)

CAPA®- Solvay (Belgium), Tone®- Union Carbide (USA) or Celgreen®-Daicel (Japan)

● Non-renewable feedstock (fossil fuel based)

● Used in medical applications for long-term implants and controlled drug release applications

● Not widely used in packaging because of large costs

● Good chemical resistance to water, oil, solvent and chlorine

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polycaprolactone#/media/File:Polycaprolactone_structure.png

Page 19: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Environmental Performance● Degradation according to ASTM

standards 80% in 56 days at RT● Abiotic degradation <2% after 18

weeks● Slow hydrolytic degradation time

because of its hydrophobicity● PCL degrading microorganisms

were found in deep water (high pressure, low temperature)-these were not able to degrade PHAs or PLA

PCL Performance

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Technical Performance

Poor water barrier

Similar strength to PET

Low Tm Good elongation at break, ductile

Page 20: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Biopolymer BlendsBlends can improve:

1. Biodegradation

2. Material properties● PLA/PHA, PHA acts as

lubricant and plasticizer● PLA/PCL improved

mechanical properties, little degradation

3. Cost ● PCL +starch (plastic bags)

Sashiwa et. al. (2018)

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Entry PHBHHx/PLA (wt/wt) Form Average Particle

Size (µm)

1 100/0 Powder 440 342 80/20 Powder 420 333 60/40 Powder 430 324 40/60 Powder 440 265 0/100 Powder 490 1

Page 21: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Amylose, Cellulose, or Starch:- improve degradation times by up to 70% with minimal changes to physical properties. -Polysaccharide believed to initiate bacterial growth, leading to co-polymer breakdown

Polymer Additives: Sacrificial PolymersConfounding issues:● Little data available in

biopolymers● Very few studies

available using similar metrics to those used in biopolymer comparisons

● Polymer dependent effects are hard to predict

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/52/219_Three_Important_Polysaccharides-01.jpg

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 22: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Photosensitizing compounds:● Primarily Fe or Ca Stearate, Cu

Phthalocyanine-added at <1% level● Generate singlet oxygen- leads to radical breakdown

of polymer chains. ● Up to 95% decrease in Mw, 40% decrease in weight

Polymer Additives: PhotosensitizersConfounding issues:● Little data available in

biopolymers● Very few studies

available using similar metrics to those used in biopolymer comparisons

● Polymer dependent effects are hard to predict

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 23: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Crystallinity & Polymer Degradation Processes

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/72/Amorphous_vs_Crystalline.jpg

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 24: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Crystallinity & Polymer Degradation Processes

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/72/Amorphous_vs_Crystalline.jpg

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 25: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Crystallinity & Polymer Degradation Processes● Lower crystallinity leads to faster

degradation● This holds true for many polymers● Relative impact is polymer dependent and

affected by polymer molecular weight● Decreasing crystallinity affects mechanical

properties- less brittle- less stable● Barrier properties altered with crystallinity,

particularly water and oxygen permeability● Maximum impact is 2% increase in

degradation per 1% change in crystallinity

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 26: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Nature already contains attractive solutions for fluid containment

Fruits as Containers

https://www.flickr.com/photos/35832540@N03/3330701660

Coconuts represent a 2 part containment: cellulose exterior with a fatty/ waxy interior to hold fluid

Tomatoes use a thin hydrophobic barrier coupled with interior structures to contain fluid. Biological degradation rapidly eliminates

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Tomato-cut_vertical.png

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 27: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Calcium Alginate:

Non-Thermoplastic Alternatives: Alginate

● Alginate is a linear polysaccharide extracted from brown algae

● Calcium reduces the solubility in water of alginate films, as well as their flexibility

● Modifying the Ca2+ counterion (eg. lactate) improves barrier properties

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Perles_d%27abricot_et_feuille_de_basilic.jpg

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 28: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Composite packaging:

Non-Thermoplastic Alternatives: Composites

● Alternating layers of polymer, paper, and optional metal film

● Reduces polymer required by supplementing paper/cellulose

● Difficult to recycle due to combination of materials preventing separation

● Cellulose acts as a natural sacrificial polymer

https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:TBA_packaging_components.gif#/media/File:TBA_packaging_components.svg

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 29: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Alginate performance metrics:

Composite packaging performance metrics:

Performance of Non-Thermoplastic Alternatives

Barrier Properties H2O Permeability(g mm/m2 day atm) <12500

Tensile PropertiesElongation at break (%) 11.5Tensile Strength (MPa) 59.7Tensile Modulus (GPa) 0.6

Barrier Properties H2O PermeabilityDependent on polymer .5-300

Thermal Properties Tg(°C) 10-150

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Poor water barrier

Good water barrier

Page 30: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Health Performance Overview

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 31: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

● Primary toxicological pathways1. Micro & nano plastic toxicity 2. POP exposure through plastic sorption 3. Direct toxicity in products

Health Performance Overview

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 32: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Microplastic Exposure is a Threat

● 2 potential exposure routes:○ Directly in Method

products○ Marine organisms

→ trophic transfer

Lusher et al. 2017.

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 33: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

● Micro and nano plastics causes significant toxicological outcomes

Lusher et al. 2017.

Micro and Nano Plastics Health Impacts

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Microplastics> 150 µm no absorption< 150 µm110 µm in portal vein

≤ 20 µm

Biological Level Polyethylene size Effect

Macromolecules 110nm - 30µm DNA damage, changes in gene and protein expression

Cells 300nm - 10µm Cell clotting, necrosis, apoptosis, oxidative stress

Tissues 600nm - 21µm Inflammation and bone osteosis

Page 34: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Exposure to POPs through microplastics in seafood constitutes a small proportion of total dietary intake of POPs

Smith et al. 2018.

Human Exposure to POPs through Microplastics

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Compound Ratio Intake Microplastic/Total Dietary Intake (pg/kg bw/day) (%)

Non-dioxin like PCBs 0.03 - 0.007

DDT 0.1 - 0.02

PAHs 0.004 - 0.0000002

BPA 0.00002 - 0.000005

PBDEs 0.003 - 0.0007

Page 35: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Health Impacts of POPs

● Human health outcomes linked to POP exposure through micro/nano plastics is limited

● Chronic exposure is a concern○ Epigenetic alterations○ Neurobehavioral deficits ○ Altered insulin secretion

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:DDT_chemical_structure_highres.png

DDT

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 36: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

● Exposure in Method products will typically be dermal

● Group 1 endpoints○ Chronic and/or life threatening endpoints○ Potentially induced at low doses○ Trans-generational potential

● Group 2 endpoints ○ Endpoints that can typically be mitigated

Direct Toxicity Health Exposure & Endpoints

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 37: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Direct Toxicity Methodology

3 = Low Risk No (+) studies, no (+) modeling, or stated by AL2= Moderate Risk 1 (+) study or prediction, or stated by AL1 = High Risk 2+ (+) studies, or stated by AL

Unknown Following extensive review of the literature, no significant evidence could be found

Data Gap As labeled in GreenScreen or authoritative body

LegendPrimary Chemical

Breakdown Product

Additives/ contaminants

Monomer

Hazard tables for each chemical is generated

through literature review & toxicity modeling

ChemicalGroup I Human Endpoints Group II and Group II* Endpoints

Carcinogenicity/Mutagenicity

Developmental/Reproductive

Toxicity

Endocrine Activity Acute Toxicity Systemic

Toxicity (acute)Systemic Toxicity

(C)Neurotoxicity

(A)Neurotoxicity

(C)Skin, Eye, Respiratory

Irritation (A)

Existing ChemicalsPET 2, L U 2, L 3, L U U U U 2, LEthylene glycol 3, H 1, H 3, L 2, H 1, H 1, H 1, H 3, H 2, HTerephthalic acid 2, L 2, H 2, L 3, H 2, H 1, H 2, H 3, H 2, HPhthalic acid 2, L 2, L 3, L 2, L 2, L U U U 1, LPolyethylene (PE) 1, L U U 3, M U 3, M U U 2, HEthylene 2, H 3, L 3, L 2, L 2, L U 2, L 1, L 2, L

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 38: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Direct Toxicity Methodology cont. ● Final evaluation, based on Faludi et al. (2016)

○ Weighted average across monomers & polymers ○ Averages & Ranges → worst case & best case ○ Limitations & Assumptions

■ Weights ■ Unknowns & data gaps → scoring ■ Successful evaluation of the literature ■ Scores impacted by # monomers/breakdown products included■ Toxicity of monomers/breakdown as significant as parent compound

Note that numerically low scores indicate a higher hazard

Carc/Mut Dev/Repro/ED Acute ST/N/Ir Chronic ST/N Overall Hazard ScorePET range 2-3 (1 U) 1-3 (1 U) 1-3 (3 U) 1-3 (3 U) 1.26-3PET average 2.25 2.14 1.92 2.2 2.14weighting coefficient 0.2625 0.2625 0.2125 0.2625

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 39: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Direct Toxicity Methodology cont. ● Graphs represent the weighted

range and weighted average of the hazard score for each chemical

Note that numerically low scores indicate a higher hazard

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Chemical Overall Hazard Score Range

Existing ChemicalsPET 1.26-3 2.14PE 1.74-2.74 2.17

Page 40: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Guiding principles:● If a compound is good at

concentrating Persistent Organics (POPs) but has a short lifetime, it can still be a good option

● Absolute data is rare, hard to assign confidence rating

● Hydrophobicity has non direct correlation to sorption rate

Risk Assessment Degradation time Sorption of POPs

Low Risk <6 months with some hydrolytic <50 ug/g polymer

Moderate Risk 6 months to 1 year 50 to 300 ug/g polymerHigh Risk > 1 year >300 ug/g polymer

Unknown Following extensive review of the literature, no significant evidence could be found

Data Gap As labeled in GreenScreen or other authoritative body

Environmental Performance: Methodology

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 41: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Guiding principles:● If a compound is good at

concentrating Persistent Organics (POPs) but has a short lifetime, it can still be a good option

● Absolute data is rare, hard to assign confidence rating

● Hydrophobicity has non direct correlation to sorption rate

Risk Assessment Degradation time Sorption of POPs

Low Risk <6 months with some hydrolytic <50 ug/g polymer

Moderate Risk 6 months to 1 year 50 to 300 ug/g polymerHigh Risk > 1 year >300 ug/g polymer

Unknown Following extensive review of the literature, no significant evidence could be found

Data Gap As labeled in GreenScreen or other authoritative body

Environmental Performance: Methodology

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Existing Chemicals Particle Degradation Sorption of POPsPolyethylene terephthalate(PET) High Risk Low Risk

Polyethylene(PE) High Risk Moderate Risk

Page 42: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Strategy #1

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 43: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Strategy 1: Bio-polymers● Our goal is to provide a potential solution with limited health effects

that exhibit fast degradation times and promising mechanical properties

● PCL and PHAs (PHBHx) exhibit fast degradation times in seawater systems with microbial cultures present

● PHBHx has the best barrier and tensile properties among the biopolymers

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Chemical Overall Hazard Score Range

Overall Score Average

Particle Degradation

Sorption of POPs Barrier Tensile

PropertiesPHA 2.05-2.79 2.55 Low Risk Moderate GoodPHBHx 2.05-2.78 2.59 Low Risk High Risk Good GoodPLA 2.56-2.99 2.81 High Risk Low Risk Moderate ModeratePCL 2.31-2.99 2.71 Moderate Risk High Risk Poor Moderate

Page 44: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Strategy 1: Bio-polymers

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Chemical Overall Hazard Score Range

Overall Score Average

Particle Degradation

Sorption of POPs

PET 1.26-3 2.14 High Risk Low RiskPE 1.74-2.74 2.17 High Risk

Chemical Overall Hazard Score Range

Overall Score Average

Particle Degradation

Sorption of POPs Barrier Tensile

PropertiesPHA 2.05-2.79 2.55 Low Risk Moderate GoodPHBHx 2.05-2.78 2.59 Low Risk High Risk Good GoodPLA 2.56-2.99 2.81 High Risk Low Risk Moderate ModeratePCL 2.31-2.99 2.71 Moderate Risk High Risk Poor Moderate

Page 45: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Strategy #2

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 46: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Strategy 2: Additives

Chemical Overall Hazard Score RangeO Particle

DegradationSorption of

POPsIron stearate 2.00-2.21 2.21 Low RiskCopper phthalocyanine 3 3 Low RiskCellulose 2.00-3.00 2.5 Low Risk

● UV sensitizers decrease the time required to take plastics below the 10,000 MW cutoff for efficient biodegradation

● Relatively low concentration (<1% by mass) and low toxicity make for promising alternatives

● Sacrificial polysaccharides can be added with minimal decreases in performance while promoting bacterial growth and breakdown

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 47: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Strategy 2: Additives

Chemical Overall Hazard Score RangeO Particle

DegradationSorption of

POPsIron stearate 2.00-2.21 2.21 Low RiskCopper phthalocyanine 3 3 Low RiskCellulose 2.00-3.00 2.5 Low Risk

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Chemical Overall Hazard Score Range

Overall Score Average

Particle Degradation

Sorption of POPs

PET 1.26-3 2.14 High Risk Low RiskPE 1.74-2.74 2.17 High Risk Risk

Page 48: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Strategy #3

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 49: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Strategy 3: Non-Thermoplastics

Non- Thermoplastic Alternatives

● Non-thermoplastics provide an attractive model that breaks from traditional packaging styles

● Composite packaging utilizes all of the methodologies from thermoplastics to ensure the hydrophobic layer degrades rapidly

● Alginate packaging is as a fun new direction for consumers and represents the most attractive solution in terms of degradation rate and potential health impact

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Chemical Overall Hazard Score Range

Overall Score Average

Particle Degradation

Alginate 2.00-3.00 2.57 Low RiskCalcium lactate 1.73-2.74 2.46 Low Risk

Page 50: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Strategy 3: Non-Thermoplastics

Non- Thermoplastic Alternatives

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Chemical Overall Hazard Score Range

Overall Score Average

Particle Degradation

Alginate 2.00-3.00 2.57 Low RiskCalcium lactate 1.73-2.74 2.46 Low Risk

Chemical Overall Hazard Score Range

Overall Score Average

Particle Degradation

PET 1.26-3 2.14 High RiskPE 1.74-2.74 2.17 High Risk

Page 51: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Strategy #4

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 52: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Strategy 4: Combinatorial Strategy

Crystallinity

● Each of the three strategies could be used in combination to fine tune polymer properties

● This solution represents a new set of dials to adjust when designing new packaging

AdditivesBiopolymers

+ +

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 53: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Conclusion

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 54: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Health/Technical Performance EvaluationChemical Health Hazard

RangeHealth Hazard

AverageParticle

DegradationSorption of

POPsExisting Chemicals

PET 1.26-3 2.14 High Risk Low RiskPE 1.74-2.74 2.17 High Risk Moderate Risk

Alternative BiopolymersPHAs 2.05-2.79 2.55 Low RiskPHBHx 2.05-2.78 2.59 Low Risk High RiskPLA 2.56-2.99 2.81 High Risk Low RiskPCL 2.31-2.99 2.71 Moderate Risk High Risk

Alternative Non-thermoplasticsAlginate 2.00-3.00 2.57 Low RiskCalcium lactate 1.73-2.74 2.46 Low Risk

Alternative AdditivesIron stearate 2.00-2.21 2.11 Low RiskCopper Phthalocyanine 3 3 Low RiskCellulose 2.00-3.00 2.5 Low Risk

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 55: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Direct Toxicity of Current Chemicals & Alternatives

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Existing Chemicals Particle Size

PET Moderate Risk

PE

Alternate Chemicals

PHAs Low Risk

PHBH

PLA

PCL

Alginate Low Risk

Cellulose Low Risk

Page 56: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

Alternatives’ Improvements

● Improves on technical/environmental performance by:1. Fast degradation leading to little accumulation2. Bypassing recycling barrier by making everything degradable/

compostable3. Renewable feedstocks available for most polymers

● Improve on health safety by:1. Decreasing direct toxicity compared to PE and PET2. Decreasing nano, micro & macroplastic exposure3. Potential decrease in POP exposure due to increased degradation time

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 57: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

● Further steps:○ Evaluate impact of combinatorial solutions ○ Photo-oxidants must be evaluated to determine

impact on aquatic degradation of biopolymers○ Health & environment impacts of biopolymer

production ● Scale of marine plastics● Understand link between human health outcomes

and bioaccumulation

Future Directions

Background Approach Inspiration Technical Performance Overview

Health Overview Strategies Conclusions

Page 58: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

ANY QUESTIONS?https://www.projectaware.org/news/were-now-million-plastic-bottles-minute-91-which-are-not-recycled

Special Thanks to:Kaj JohnsonMichelle ByleRyan Williams

Meg SchwarzmanDavid FaulknerBilly Hart-CooperTom McKeag

Page 59: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

1. Abrusci, C. et al. Biodegradation of photo-degraded mulching films based on polyethylenes and stearates of calcium and iron as pro-oxidant additives. International Biodeterioration & Biodegradation 65, 451–459 (2011).

2. Marine anthropogenic litter. (Springer, 2015).3. Chenoweth, M. B. The Toxicity of Sodium Alginate in Cats. Ann Surg 127, 1173–1181 (1948).4. Chmiel, C. T. & Long, F. A. The Hydrolysis of Esters of Some Substituted Benzoic Acids in Strongly Acid Aqueous Solutions1. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 78, 3326–3330 (1956).5. Chmiel-Perzyńska, I., Kloc, R., Perzyński, A., Rudzki, S. & Urbańska, E. M. Novel aspect of ketone action: β-hydroxybutyrate increases brain synthesis of kynurenic acid in vitro. Neurotox Res 20, 40–50 (2011).6. Cinelli, P., Chiellini, E., Gordon, S. H. & Imam, S. H. Characteristics and degradation of hybrid composite films prepared from PVA, starch and lignocellulosics. Macromolecular Symposia 197, 143–156 (2003).7. Corti, A., Muniyasamy, S., Vitali, M., Imam, S. H. & Chiellini, E. Oxidation and biodegradation of polyethylene films containing pro-oxidant additives: Synergistic effects of sunlight exposure, thermal aging and

fungal biodegradation. Polymer Degradation and Stability 95, 1106–1114 (2010).8. EFSA Panel on Food Additives and Nutrient Sources added to Food (ANS) et al. Re‐evaluation of propane‐1,2‐diol alginate (E 405) as a food additive. EFSA Journal 16, (2018).9. Fattahi, M. J. et al. Preclinical assessment of β-d-mannuronic acid (M2000) as a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug. Immunopharmacology and Immunotoxicology 37, 535–540 (2015).

10. Faludi, J et al. Aiding alternatives assessment with an uncertainty tolerant hazard scoring method. Journal of Environmental Management 182, (2016).11. Gallo, F. et al. Marine litter plastics and microplastics and their toxic chemicals components: the need for urgent preventive measures. Environmental Sciences Europe 30, (2018).12. Guohua, Z. et al. Water resistance, mechanical properties and biodegradability of methylated-cornstarch/poly(vinyl alcohol) blend film. Polymer Degradation and Stability 91, 703–711 (2006).13. Harrison, J. P., Boardman, C., O’Callaghan, K., Delort, A.-M. & Song, J. Biodegradability standards for carrier bags and plastic films in aquatic environments: a critical review. Open Science 5, 171792 (2018).14. Heimowska, A., Krasowska, K. & Rutkowska, M. Degradability of Different Packaging Polymeric Materials in Sea Water. 1115. Higgins, T. F. & Borron, S. W. Coma and respiratory arrest after exposure to butyrolactone. J Emerg Med 14, 435–437 (1996).16. Huang, Y. et al. Acute toxicity and genotoxicity studies on poly(ɛ-caprolactone)-poly(ethylene glycol)-poly(ɛ-caprolactone) nanomaterials. Mutation Research/Genetic Toxicology and Environmental Mutagenesis

696, 101–106 (2010).17. Jenkins, M. J. & Harrison, K. L. The effect of crystalline morphology on the degradation of polycaprolactone in a solution of phosphate buffer and lipase. Polymers for Advanced Technologies 19, 1901–1906 (2008).18. Julian, T. N., Radebaugh, G. W. & Wisniewski, S. J. Permeability characteristics of calcium alginate films. Journal of Controlled Release 7, 165–169 (1988).19. Kato, Y., Ohta, H. & Tsuchihashi, G. Enzyme-mediated asymmetric hydrolysis of α-benzyloxycarboxylic esters. Tetrahedron Letters 28, 1303–1306 (1987).20. Kedzierski, M. et al. Threat of plastic ageing in marine environment. Adsorption/desorption of micropollutants. Marine Pollution Bulletin 127, 684–694 (2018).21. Kershaw, P. J. Biodegradable plastics & marine litter: misconceptions, concerns and impacts on marine environments. (United Nations Environment Programme, 2015).22. Kumar, R., Yakubu, M. K. & Anandjiwala, R. D. Biodegradation of flax fiber reinforced poly lactic acid. (2010).23. Laycock, B. et al. Lifetime prediction of biodegradable polymers. Progress in Polymer Science 71, 144–189 (2017).24. Lee, P. & Rogers, M. A. Effect of calcium source and exposure-time on basic caviar spherification using sodium alginate. International Journal of Gastronomy and Food Science 1, 96–100 (2012).25. Lei, L. et al. Microplastic particles cause intestinal damage and other adverse effects in zebrafish Danio rerio and nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. Science of The Total Environment 619–620, 1–8 (2018).26. Lithner, D., Larsson, Å. & Dave, G. Environmental and health hazard ranking and assessment of plastic polymers based on chemical composition. Science of The Total Environment 409, 3309–3324 (2011).27. Lusher, A. et al. Microplastics in fisheries and aquaculture. FAO.28. Lyu, S. et al. Does crystallinity affect polymer degradation rates? Society for Biomaterials. (201129. Mason, S. et al. Synthetic polymer contamination in bottled water. State University of New York.30. Matsushima, Y. et al. [Subchronic oral toxicity study of calcium lactate in F344 rats]. Eisei Shikenjo Hokoku 78–83 (1989).31. Mørch, Ý. A., Donati, I. & Strand, B. L. Effect of Ca2+, Ba2+, and Sr2+ on Alginate Microbeads. Biomacromolecules 7, 1471–1480 (2006).32. Mrowiec, B. Plastic pollutants in water environment. Ochrona Srodowiska i Zasobów Naturalnych 28, (2017).33. Nazeri, S. et al. Preclinical and pharmacotoxicology evaluation of α-l-guluronic acid (G2013) as a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug with immunomodulatory property. Immunopharmacol Immunotoxicol 39,

59–65 (2017).34. Otterlei, M., Espevik, T., Skjak-Braek, G. & Smidsrod, O. Guluronic acid polymers and use of same for inhibition of cytokine production. (1992).35. Padiyar, A. & Maheshwari, R. K. NOVEL PHARMACEUTICAL DOSAGE FORM. 1 8, 1–2 (2018).36. Pantani, R. & Sorrentino, A. Influence of crystallinity on the biodegradation rate of injection-moulded poly(lactic acid) samples in controlled composting conditions. Polymer Degradation and Stability 98, 1089–1096

(2013).

References

Page 60: OCEAN PLASTICS - WordPress.com...8 million tons of plastic deposited into ocean annually - 10x increase by 2020 80% of marine debris estimated to be ocean plastics Marine life at risk

37. Peng, S.-W. et al. An assessment of the risks of carcinogenicity associated with polyhydroxyalkanoates through an analysis of DNA aneuploid and telomerase activity. Biomaterials 32 2546–2555 (2011).38. Posen, I. D., Jaramillo, P., Landis, A. E. & Griffin, W. M. Greenhouse gas mitigation for U.S. plastics production: energy first, feedstocks later. Environ. Res. Lett. 12, 034024 (2017).39. Pubchem. Ethane-1,2-diol;terephthalic acid. Available at: https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/16212789. (Accessed: 22nd October 2018)40. Pubchem. Lactic acid. Available at: https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/612. (Accessed: 22nd October 2018)41. Pubchem. Lactide, L-. Available at: https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/107983. (Accessed: 22nd October 2018)42. Revel, M., Châtel, A. & Mouneyrac, C. Micro(nano)plastics: A threat to human health? Current Opinion in Environmental Science & Health 1, 17–23 (2018).43. Rochman, C. M., Hoh, E., Hentschel, B. T. & Kaye, S. Long-Term Field Measurement of Sorption of Organic Contaminants to Five Types of Plastic Pellets: Implications for Plastic Marine Debris. Environ. Sci. Technol. 47, 1646–1654 (2013).44. Saad, B. et al. Characterization of the cell response of cultured macrophages and fibroblasts to particles of short-chain poly[(R)-3-hydroxybutyric acid]. J. Biomed. Mater. Res. 30, 429–429 (1996).45. Santana, A. A. & Kieckbusch, T. G. Physical evaluation of biodegradable films of calcium alginate plasticized with polyols. Brazilian Journal of Chemical Engineering 30, 835–845 (2013).46. Sax, L. Polyethylene Terephthalate May Yield Endocrine Disruptors. Environmental Health Perspectives 118, 445–448 (2010).47. Segale, L., Giovannelli, L., Mannina, P. & Pattarino, F. Calcium Alginate and Calcium Alginate-Chitosan Beads Containing Celecoxib Solubilized in a Self-Emulsifying Phase. Scientifica (2016) doi:10.1155/2016/506270648. Smith, M. et al. Microplastics in seafood and implications for human health. Current Environmental Health Reports 5, 375-386 (2018).49. Tabone, M. et al. Sustainability metrics: life cycle assessment and green design in polymers. Environmental Science Technology. (2013).50. Tang, X.-Q. et al. A Novel Mechanism of Formaldehyde Neurotoxicity: Inhibition of Hydrogen Sulfide Generation by Promoting Overproduction of Nitric Oxide. PLoS ONE 8, e54829 (2013).51. Tholstrup, T. Influence of stearic acid on hemostatic risk factors in humans. Lipids 40, 1229–1235 (2005).52. Tokiwa, Y. & Jarerat, A. Microbial degradation of aliphatic polyesters. Macromolecular Symposia 201, 283–290 (2003).53. Wang, S. et al. Biodegradation of Poly(3-hydroxybutyrate- co -3-hydroxyhexanoate) Plastic under Anaerobic Sludge and Aerobic Seawater Conditions: Gas Evolution and Microbial Diversity. Environmental Science & Technology 52, 5700–5709 (2018).54. Weber, A., Scherer, C., Brennholt, N., Reifferscheid, G. & Wagner, M. PET microplastics do not negatively affect the survival, development, metabolism and feeding activity of the freshwater invertebrate Gammarus pulex. Environmental Pollution 234, 181–189 (2018).55. Whiteley, M. J. & Pan, W.-P. A study of the flammability of chlorinated polyethylene under pyrolysis conditions. Thermochimica Acta 166, 27–39 (1990).56. Yeh, S.-P., Chang, C.-A., Chang, C.-Y., Liu, C.-H. & Cheng, W. Dietary sodium alginate administration affects fingerling growth and resistance to Streptococcus sp. and iridovirus, and juvenile non-specific immune responses of the orange-spotted grouper, Epinephelus coioides. Fish & Shellfish Immunology 25, 19–27 (2008).57. CALCIUM ALGINATE - National Library of Medicine HSDB Database.58. Chondrogenic differentiation of adipose-derived adult stem cells in agarose, alginate, and gelatin scaffolds - ScienceDirect.59. Evaluation of Biodegradation-Promoting Additives for Plastics - Environmental Science & Technology (ACS Publications).60. SiOx and SiOxCzHw mono- and multi-layer deposits for improved polymer oxygen and water vapor barrier properties - ScienceDirect.61. Sucrose as a Crosslinking Modifier for the Preparation of Calcium Alginate Films via External Gelation - SciAlert Responsive Version. doi:10.3923/jas.2012.727.73562. Swelling and biocompatibility of sodium alginate/poly(γ‐glutamic acid) hydrogels - Huang - 2010 - Polymers for Advanced Technologies63. TOXNET. Available at: https://toxnet.nlm.nih.gov/cgi-bin/sis/search2/f?./temp/~jsCIch:1. (Accessed: 22nd October 2018)64. COSMOS database. Available from: http://www.cosmostox.eu/what/databases/.65. Vega Hub. Available from: https://www.vegahub.eu/about-vegahub/.

References