Ontario Court of Appeal - McCarthy Tétrault · – Negotiable instruments and bills of exchange – Negotiation – Appeal by plaintiff from trial judgment dismissing her claim for

Page 1

The French version will be available soon.

Ontario Court of AppealAppellate Cases Argued by Active McCarthy Tétrault Lawyers

NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR

REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY

LEGAL ANDINDUSTRYFOCUS

1. ONCA Bancroft-Snell v. VisaCanada Corp,

11/28/16 [2016] O.J. No.6109, 2016ONCA 896

Lonsdale,Christine

Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation – civilprocedure – class orrepresentative actions –class counsel - fees –appeal by class actionplaintiffs from orderregarding fee sharingagreement dismissedwith limited exception

2. ONCA Barber v. HumberRiver RegionalHospital

11/18/16 [2016] O.J. No.6107, 2016ONCA 897

Baron, EricaRogers, SamKatz, Jordan

Appellant ON Appeal Health law – Healthcare professionals –Liability (malpractice) –Negligence – Failure todiagnose – Standard ofCare -

3. ONCA Khosroabadi v. TDCanada Trust Branch241

10/06/16 [2016] O.J. No.5156, 2016ONCA 733

D’Souza,Shane

Respondent ON Appeal Banking and finance law– Negotiableinstruments and bills ofexchange – Negotiation– Appeal by plaintifffrom trial judgmentdismissing her claim fordamages resulting fromcheque allegedlynegligently negotiatedby respondent bankdismissed

4. ONCA Mask v. SilvercorpMetals Inc.

08/24/16 [2016] O.J. No.4436, 2016ONCA 641, 132

Peebles, DanaLam, MirandaDavis, Paul

Respondents ON Appeal Civil litigation – class orrepresentative actions –procedure - Appeal by

Page 2



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


O.R. (3d) 161,269 A.C.W.S.(3d) 579, 352O.A.C. 380,2016CarswellOnt13364

Mask from decisiondismissing Mask'smotion for leave to bringclass action forsecondary marketmisrepresentation, anddismissing motion tocertify action as classaction dismissed

5. ONCA Galota v. Festival HallDevelopments Ltd.

07/21/16 [2016] O.J. No.3906, 2016ONCA 585, 58C.C.L.I. (5

th) 78,

268 A.C.W.S.(3d) 659, 53C.L.R. (4

th) 175,

352 O.A.C.140, 2016CarswellOnt11684

Scott, William Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation –limitation of actions –when time begins to run– appeal by landlordfrom dismissal ofsummary judgmentmotion dismissed –occupiers’ liability

6. ONCA Covata Durham YorkRenewable EnergyLimited Partnership v.Barton-MalowCanada Inc.

07/11/16 [2016] O.J. No.3747, 2016ONCA 558,2016CarswellOnt10844, 368A.C.W.S. (3d)16, 53 C.L.R.(4

th) 18, 91

C.P.C. (7th

)332, 351O.A.C. 177, 56B.L.R. (5

th) 1

Parla, JulieKalamut,Andrew

Moving Party ON Moving Party Alternative disputeresolution – bindingarbitration – practiceand procedure – motionby respondent to quashappeal allowed -

7. ONCA Groia v. Law Societyof Upper Canada

06/14/16 [2016] O.J. No.3094, 2016ONCA 471, 1Admin. L.R.

Templer,Deborh

Intervener ON Appeal Legal profession – lawsocieties and governingbodies – Disciplinaryproceedings – what

Page 3



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


(6th

) 175, 266A.C.W.S. (3d)991, 358C.R.R. (2d) 1,131 O.R. (3d)1, 352 O.A.C.210, 2016CarswellOnt9453

constitutes misconduct– professional andethical standards

8. ONCA Fram Elgin Mills 90Inc. v. RomandaleFarms Ltd.

05/26/16 [2016] O.J. No.2791, 2016ONCA 404, 131O.R. (3d) 455

Batner, Sarit Moving Party ON Motion toQuash

Civil litigation – civilprocedure – appeals –motion to quash –judicial review

9. ONCA Fennell v. Deol 04/05/16 [2016] O.J. No.1745, 2016ONCA 249, 265A.C.W.S. (3d)1029, 97M.V.R. (6

th) 1,

2016CarswellOnt5046

Scott, William Appellant ON Appeal Civil litigation –limitation of actions –damages – proceedings– practice andprocedure

10. ONCA Labelle v. CanadaBorder ServicesAgency

03/07/16 [2016] O.J. No.1166, 2016ONCA 187, 264A.C.W.S. (3d)86, 346 O.A.C.155, 2016CarswellOnt3374

Scott, William Appellants ON Appeal Civil procedure –disposition without trial– dismissal of action –delay for failure toprosecute

11. ONCA Pollari v. FamousPlayers LimitedPartnership

03/01/16 [2016] O.J. No.1059, 2016ONCA 180

Scott, William Appellant ON Appeal Civil procedure – didn’tadvance evidence torebut presumption -appeal dismissed

Page 4



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


12. ONCA Yasmin v. Alexander 02/29/16 [2016] O.J. No.1057, 2016ONCA 165

Scott, William Appellant ON Appeal Civil litigation –limitation of actions –appeal by pedestrianinjured in 2008 accidentfrom dismissal of actionagainst drive as statute-barred dismissed

13. ONCA Teva Canada Ltd. V.Bank of Montreal

02/02/16 [2016] O.J. No.581, 2016ONCA 94, 344O.A.C. 344, 52B.L.R. (5

th) 171,

2016CarswellOnt1483, 262A.C.W.S. (3d)176, 394 D.L.R.(4

th) 298, 129

O.R. (3d) 1

McLaughlin,Frank

Appellant ON Appeal Banking and finance law– negotiableinstruments and bills ofexchange –presentment forpayment – liabilities ofparties -

14. ONCA Goldsmith v. NationalBank of Canada

01/13/16 [2016] O.J. No.146, 2016ONCA 22, 2016CarswellOnt249, 128 O.R.(3d) 481, 344O.A.C. 204,261 A.C.W.S.(3d) 481, 394D.L.R. (4

th) 212

Steep, PaulBlock, EricShaw, ByronLaham,Jessica

Respondent ON Appeal Securities regulation –Civil liability – publicstatements or release ofdocuments by influentialpersons – plaintiff’sburden of proof

15. ONCA McLean v. Boettcher 01/05/16 [2016] O.J. No.112, 2016ONCA 14

Scott, William Appellants ON Appeal Civil litigation –disposition without trial– delay for failure toprosecute – prejudice todefendant – appeal byplaintiffs from refusal toset aside administrativedismissal dismissed

Page 5



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


16. ONCA König v. Hobza 12/15/15 [2015] O.J. No.6632, 2015ONCA 885, 84C.P.C. (7

th) 24,

129 O.R. (3d)57, 2015CarswellOnt19169, 261A.C.W.S. (3d)542, 343O.A.C. 331

Batner, SaritIvanov,Vladimira

Respondents ON Appeal Civil litigation – civilprocedure – costs –offer to settle – amountof offer v award – timeof offer – appeal byplaintiff from costsaward dismissed

17. ONCA Leong v. Ryabikhina 12/11/15 [2015] O.J. No.6955, 2015ONCA 886

Hubbard,ChristopherBooth,Katherine

Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation – civilprocedure – vexatiouslitigants – appeals -

18. ONCA Carriere IndustrialSupply Ltd. V.Toronto-DominionBank

12/07/15 [2015] O.J. No.6416, 2015ONCA 852,2015CarswellOnt18517, 14E.T.R. (4

th) 201,

261 A.C.W.S.(3d) 767

Hall, GeoffLizius, Richard

AppellantRespondentfor cross-appeal

ON Appeal Banking and finance law– accounts – obligationsof bank – trust accounts– appeal by bank fromfinding of liability toclient’s customers forknowingly assisting inclient’s breach of trustdismissed

19. ONCA Whiteman v.Iamkhong

07/29/15 [2015] O.J. No.4017, 2015ONCA 564

Hubbard,ChristopherPiovesan,Carole

Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation – appealby plaintiff fromsummary judgmentdismissed – plaintiffalleged former wifeinfected him with HIV in2003 and failed todisclose condition toobtain immigrationsponsorship in 1995

Page 6



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


20. ONCA Glasford v CIBC 07/09/15 [2015] O.J. No3622, 2015ONCA 523

Shaw, Byron Respondent ON Appeal Conflict of laws – forumconveniens – appeal byplaintiff from finding thatOntario had nojurisdiction to tery herisrepresentation actiondismissed

21. ONCA Fairmont Hotels Inc.v. Canada (AttorneyGeneral)

06/17/15 [2015] O.J. No.3172, 2015ONCA 441

Chua, Chia-yiHall, Geoff

Respondents ON Appeal Corporations,partnerships andassociations law –Rectification of records– appeal by Crown fromjudgment grantingrectification of corporaterecords dismissed

22. ONCA Buik Estate vCanasia Power Corp.

05/15/15 [2015] O.J. No.2511, 2015ONCA 352, 9E.T.R. (4

th) 1,

73 C.P.C. (7th)

235, 253A.C.W.S. (3d)826, 2015CarswellOnt7061

Rosenberg,MichaelWadsworth,Christine

Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation –extension, interruption,suspension andinapplicability –acknowledgement orpart payment – appealby defendant debtorfrom judgment in favourof plaintiff creditor forrepayment of debtdismissed

23. ONCA Hrycko v Miller Estate 04/30/15 [2015] O.J. No.2187, 2015ONCA 296

Scott, William Appellants ON Appeal Damages – appeal byMiller’s trustee fromassessment of damagesagainst lawyerdismissed

24. ONCA Ostrander Point GPInc. v. Prince EdwardCounty FieldNaturalists

04/20/15 [2015] O.J. No.1988, 2015ONCA 269

Finkelstein,NeilHamilton,DouglasKain, Brandon

Respondent ON Appeal Environmental law –approvals licences andorders – amendment,revocation orsuspension – appeal

Page 7



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


and cross-appeal byparties from DivisionalCourt ruling allowed inpart

25. ONCA Keatley SurveyingLtd. v Teranet Inc.

04/14/15 [2015] O.J. No.1828, 2015ONCA 248

Morrison, PaulParla, JulieD’Souza,Shane

Appellant ON Appeal Civil litigation – commoninterests and issues –appeal by land registrymanager fromcertification of action asclass proceedingdismissed

26. ONCA Westerhof v. GeeEstate

03/26/15 [2015] O.J. No.1472, 2015ONCA 206

Black, William Intervener ON Appeal Civil litigation – opinionevidence – expertevidence – criteria foradmissibility – appeal byWesterhof from rulingthat opinion evidenceregarding history,diagnosis and prognosisfrom medicalpractitioners who wereeither participantexperts or non-partyexperts wasinadmissible for failureto comply with Rule53.03 allowed

27. ONCA H.B. Fuller Co. v.Rogers (c.o.b.Rogers Law Office)

03/16/15 [2015] O.J. No.1260, 2015ONCA 173,2015CarswellOnt3337, 250A.C.W.S. (3d)591, 330O.A.C. 378,386 D.L.R. (4

th)

Templer,Deborah

Appellants ON Appeal Civil litigation –disposition without trial– delay or failure toprosecute – prejudice todefendant – appeal byplaintiff from dismissalof claim for delayallowed

Page 8



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


262

28. ONCA Parsons v CanadianRed Cross Society

03/13/15 [2015] O.J. No1257, 2015ONCA 158

Zayid,CarolineRosenberg,Michael

Intervenor ON Appeal Civil litigation – appealby Attorney General ofOntario from rulingpermitting Ontariosupervising judge forCanada-wide classaction to sit outsideOntario with two othersupervising judges inconsidering issuesrelating to pan-Canadian settlementallowed in part

29. ONCA Dynasty FurnitureManufacturing Ltd. vToronto-DominionBank

03/02/15 [2015] O.J. No.945, 2015ONCA 137

Hall, GeoffSirivar, Junior

Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation – appealby TD from ordergranting Dynasty leaveto amend statement ofclaim quashed

30. ONCA Salasel v.Cuthbertson

02/20/15 [2015] O.J. No.772

Baron, Erica Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation –disposition without trial– dismissal of action –action unfounded in law– estoppel by record(res judicata) – issueestoppel -

31. ONCA Moore v. Getahun 01/29/15 [2015] O.J. No.398, 2015ONCA 55

Black, William Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation – opinionevidence – appeal bydefendants frommedical malpracticejudgment dismissed –practice and procedure– appeal by defendantsfrom medical

Page 9



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


malpractice judgmentdismissed

32. ONCA Abarca v Vargas 01/07/15 [2015] O.J. No37, 2015 ONCA4

Scott, William Appellants ON Appeal Civil litigation – strikingout pleadings orallegations – False,frivolous, vexatious orabuse

33. ONCA Larman v. MountSinai Hospital

12/24/14 [2014] O.J. No.6167, 2014ONCA 923

Grace, Kerry Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation –summary judgments –no triable issue – appealby plaintiff fromsummary judgmentdismissing medicalnegligence actiondismissed

34. ONCA Cash Store FinancialServices (Re)

11/25/14 [2014] O.J. No.5624, 2014ONCA 834

Meredith,Heather

Monitor ON Appeal Bankruptcy andInsolvency law –Companies’ CreditorsArrangement Actmatters – Compromisesand arranagements –appellants advancedfunds to payday lendingcompany now undercreditor protection

35. ONCA Holley v. NorthernTrust Co. Canada

10/21/14 [2014] O.J. No.4908, 2014ONCA 719

Lonsdale,ChristineLizius, Richard

Respondent ON Appeal Bankruptcy andinsolvency law –Companies’ CreditorsArrangement Actmatters – Appeal byHolley from summarydismissal of claimagainst trust companiesinvolved with Nortelprior to CCAA

Page 10



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


proceedings dismissed

36. ONCA Konig v. Hobza 10/09/14 [2014] O.J. NO.4791, 2014ONCA 691

Batner, Sarit Appellants ON Appeal Corporations,partnerships andassociations law –oppression remedy –oppressive or unfairlyprejudicial conduct –payment to securityholder

37. ONCA Collins v. Cortez 10/07/14 [2014] O.J. No.4753, 2014ONCA 685

Scott, William Appellant ON Appeal Civil litigation – appealby plaintiff fromsummary judgmentdismissing actionallowed

38. ONCA Muskoka Lakes(Township) v. Ontario(Minister of NaturalResources)

07/21/14 [2014] O.J. No.3434, 2014ONCA 557

Finkelstein,NeilBlock, EricD’Souza,Shane

Respondent ON Appeal Natural resources law –navigable water –appeal by Township ofMuskoka Lakes fromdismissal of applicationfor judicial reviewdismissed – Ministerprohibited access toCrown lands adjacent towaterfall site

39. ONCA Patterson (Litigationguardian of) v Ontario(Minister ofTransportatio)

06/24/14 [2014] O.J. No.2980, 2014ONCA 487

Scott, William Appellants ON Appeal Civil litigation – afterexpiry of limitationperiod – appeal bydefendant, DaimlerChrysler, from dismissalof motion for summaryjudgment dismissed

40. ONCA Fowlow v SouthlakeRegional HealthCentre

03/14/14 [2014] O.J. No.1196, 2014ONCA 193

Baron, EricaShaw, Byron

Respondent ON Appeal Health law – appeal byplaintiffs from dismissalof medical malpractice

Page 11



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


claim dismissed

41. ONCA Fowlow v. SouthlakeRegional HealthCentre

03/04/14 [2014] O.J. no.1196, 2014ONCA 193

Baron, EricaShaw, Byron

Respondent ON Appeal Health law – liability(malpractice) –negligence – causation– appeal by plaintiffsfrom dismissal of medialmalpractice claimdismissed

42. ONCA Green v CIBC 02/03/14 [2014] O.J. No.419, 2014ONCA 90

Steep, PaulPeebles, Dana

Appellants ON Appeal Civil litigation –extension, interruption,suspension andinapplicability - threeappeals by plaintiffs anddefendants from rulingsin separate classproceedings – in eachaction plaintiffs failed toobtain leave tocommence statutoryaction within limitationperiod

43. ONCA Central Sun Mining vVector EngineeringInc.

10/02/13 [2013] O.J. No.4506, 2013ONCA 601

Black, WilliamHubbard,Christopher

Appellant ON Appeal Conflict of laws –jurisdiction – wherecause of action arose –appeal by plaintiff fromorder staying actionbecause Ontario courthad not jurisdiction overrespondents allowed

44. ONCA Apotex Inc. v. AbbottLaboratories Ltd.

09/12/13 [2013] O.J. No.4144, 2013ONCA 555

Mason, StevenTait, David

Respondent ON Appeal Intellectual property law– appeal by plaintifffrom partial summaryjudgment dismissed –judgment under appeal

Page 12



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


dismissed unjustenrichment claim fordisgorgement ofrespondents’ profits orrevenues

45. ONCA Assn. of Justices ofthe Peace of Ontariov. Ontario

08/30/13 [2013] O.J. No.3911, 2013ONCA 532

Kapur, Sanil Respondent ON Appeal Administrative law –judicial review andstatutory appeal –matters not subject toreview – masters orjustices of the peace –Appeal by Associationfrom dismissal ofapplication for review ofregulation implementingsalary increase forjustices of the peacedismissed

46. ONCA Anten v. Bhalerao 07/29/13 [2013] O.J. No.3459, 2013ONCA 499

Taylor,Kiersten

Respondent ON Appeal Wills, estates and trustslaw – mentalincompetency –committal – involuntary– treatment – appeal bythe plaintiff from thedismissal of her appealfrom a Consent andCapacity Board decisionupholding a finding ofincapacity made by therespondent doctorallowed

47. ONCA Goodyear CanadaInc. v. AmericanInternationalCompanies

06/13/13 [2013] O.J. No.2746, 2013ONCA 395, 306O.A.C. 235,115 O.R. 93d)728

Scott, WilliamG.Mogil, Eli D.

Appellant ON Appeal Conflict of laws –foreign laws – laws offoreign state or territory– application –exceptions – appeal byinsured from refusal to

Page 13



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


adopt Stonewallprinciple or proratedeductibles dismissed

48. ONCA Kang v. Sun LifeAssurance Co. ofCanada

06/11/13 [2013] O.J. No.2676, 2013ONCA 387

Morrison, F.PaulBurt, GlynnisMeredith,Heather L.

Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation – Costsprocedure

49. ONCA Nissar v. TorontoTransit Commission

06/04/13 [2013] O.J. No.2553, 2013ONCA 361, 115O.R. (3d) 713

Scott, WilliamG.

Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation – civilprocedure – dispositionwithout trial – dismissalof action – delay orfailure to prosecute –prejudice to defendants– appeal by plaintifffrom motions judge’sdecision refusing torestore action to trial listdismissed

50. ONCA Manary v. Strban 05/14/13 [2013] O.J. No.2196, 2013ONCA 319

Batner, SaritE.Mogil, Eli D.

Appellant ON Appeal Civil litigation – civilprocedure – costs –appeal by defendantHalmo from costs awardof $400,000 against himdismissed

51. ONCA Mauldin v. CasselsBrock & BlackwellLLP

05/08/13 [2013] O.J. No.2045, 2013ONCA 307

Batner, SaritE.Graham, MoyaJ.

Appellant ON Appeal Civil litigation – civilprocedure – costs –assessment of fixing ofcosts – considerations –particular orders – partyand party or partialindemnity – appealcosts

52. ONCA Stevens v. Stevens 04/29/13 [2013] O.J. No.1912, 2013ONCA 267

Kerr, Gillian Respondent ON Appeal Family law – domesticcontracts and separateagreements – types –

Page 14



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


prenuptial and marriagecontracts – consensus,lack of – mistake –unconscionabletransactions

53. ONCA Kang v. Sun LifeAssurance Co. ofCanada

02/25/13 [2013] O.J. No.768, 2013ONCA 118

Morrison, F.PaulBurt, GlynnisMeredith,Heather L.

Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation – civilprocedure – parties –class or representativeactions – pleadings –striking out pleadings orallegations – grounds –failure to disclose acause of action ordefence

54. ONCA Direk v. Kryshtalskyj 01/11/13 [2013] O.J. No.97, 2013 ONCA14

Parla, Julie Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation – civilprocedure – pleadings –striking out pleadings orallegations – grounds –failure to disclose acause of action ordefence

55. ONCA Hammond v. StateFarm MutualAutomobile InsuranceCo.

10/19/12 [2012] O.J. No.4926, 2012ONCA 704

Scott, WilliamG.

Appellant ON Appeal Insurance law – Actions– Practice andprocedure – Appealsand judicial review –Limitation periods –Appeal by plaintiff fromdismissal of claimdimissed

56. ONCA Roque v. PilotInsurance Co.

05/14/12 [2012] O.J. No.2098, 2012ONCA 311

Scott, WilliamG.

Appellant ON Appeal Civil litigation –Limitation of actions –Time – When timebeings to run – Expiry oflimitation periods –Effect of – Appeal byplaintiff from dismissal

Page 15



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


of action against insurerdismissed

57. ONCA Ryabikhina v. St.Michael’s Hospital

05/01/12 [2012] O.J. No.1870,2012ONCA 278

Hubbard,Christopher

Respondents ON Appeal Civil litigation – Securityfor Costs

58. ONCA MacGregor v. Potts 04/11/12 [2012] O.J. No.1580, 2012ONCA 226

McLaughlin,Frank J.

Appellant ON Appeal Tort law – Negligence –Duty and standard ofcare – Emergencies –Causation – Appeal byobstetrician fromsuccessful action byinfant plaintiff againsthim for medicalnegligence dismissed

59. ONCA 1540039 Ontario Ltd.v. Farmers’ MutualInsurance Co.(Lindsay)

03/30/12 [2012] O.J. No.1380, 2012ONCA 210

Scott, WilliamG.

Respondent ON Appeal Insurance law – insurers– Duties – Duty todefend – Appeal byplaza owner fromdismissal of applicationfor declaration thattenant’s insurer hadduty to defenddismissed

60. ONCA Bolohan v. Hull 02/22/12 [2012] O.J. No.749, 2012ONCA 121

Scott, WilliamG.

Appellant ON Appeal Civil litigation – civilprocedure - dispositionwithout trial – dismissalof action – delay orfailure to prosecute

61. ONCA Graham v.Vandersoot

01/31/12 [2012] O.J. No.353, 2012ONCA 60

Scott, WilliamG.

Appellant ON Appeal Civil litigation – civilprocedure – trials –conduct of -adjournments

Page 16



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


62. ONCA Langenecker v.Sauvé

12/19/11 [2011] O.J. No.5777, 2011ONCA 803

Parla, Julie K.Kerr, Gillian

Respondents ON Appeal Civil litigation — civilprocedure — dispositionwithout trial — dismissalof action — delay orfailure to prosecute —prejudice to defendant

63. ONCA Goorbarry v. Bank ofNova Scotia (c.o.b.Scotiabank)

12/16/11 [2011] O.J. No.5770, 2011ONCA 793

Scott, WilliamG.

Appellant ON Appeal Civil litigation —insurance law —practice and procedure— limitation period —time — when timebegins to run

64. ONCA Combined AirMechanical Servicesv. Flesch

12/05/11 [2011] O.J. No.5431, 2011ONCA 764

Batner, SaritGraham, Moya

Appellant ON Appeal Civil litigation — civilprocedure — summaryjudgments —uncertainty overinterpretation and use ofpowers under amendedRule 20

65. ONCA Sabre Inc. v.International AirTransport Assn.

11/30/11 [2011] O.J. No.5364, 2011ONCA 747

Mercer,Malcom M.Mason, StevenGraham, Moya

Appellants ON Appeal Information technology— trade secrets andconfidential information— breach of confidence— nature of confidentialinformation — rightsand obligations

66. ONCA Suwary (Litigationguardian of) v.Women's CollegeHospital

10/31/11 [2011] O.J. No.4780, 2011ONCA 676

McLaughlin,Frank

Respondent Health law — healthcare professionals —liability (malpractice) —professionalresponsibility —negligence —causation — standard ofcare

Page 17



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


67. ONCA Salter v. Hirst 09/23/11 [2011] O.J. No.4207, 2011ONCA 609

Hubbard,Christopher

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to the SCCdismissed, 2012CanLII 41193(SCC)

Health law — liability(malpractice)negligence — causation— failure to meetstandard of care

68. ONCA Velasco v. North YorkChevrolet OldsmobileLtd.

07/19/11 [2011] O.J. No.3314, 2011ONCA 522

Scott, WilliamG.

Appellant ON Appeal Limitation of actions —discoverability — appealof summary judgmentdismissing action asstatute—barred allowed

69. ONCA Labatt Brewing Co. v.NHL EnterprisesCanada and MolsonCoors andMillerCoors

07/12/11 [2011] O.J. No.3207, 2011ONCA 511

Steep, PaulSutton,ThomasShip, Adam

Appellant ON Appeal Contracts —proceedings in contract

70. ONCA St. Andrew GoldfieldsLtd. v. NewmontCanada Limited

05/13/11 [2011] O.J. No.2147, 2011ONCA 377

Sirivar, Junior Respondent ON Appeal Contracts —interpretation — generalprinciples

71. ONCA Ryabikhina v. Leong 03/22/11 [2011] O.J. No.1212, 2011ONCA 221

Hubbard,Christopher

Respondent ON Appeal Defamation — civilprocedure — standing

72. ONCA Lawless v. Anderson 02/08/11 [2011] O.J. No.519, 2011ONCA 102

Sutton,Thomas N.T.

Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation —limitation of actions —time — discoverability— health law — healthcare professionals —liability (malpractice) —tort law — negligence— professionalresponsibility — self-governing professions— plastic surgery

73. ONCA In MotionInvestments Limitedv. Theravitae Inc.

12/21/10 2010 ONCA892, [2010] O.J.No. 5574

McLaughlin,Frank J.Block, Eric S.

Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation — civilevidence —documentary evidence

Page 18



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


— affidavits —sufficiency or validity

74. ONCA Liu v. Silver 11/02/10 [2010] O.J. No.4636, 2010ONCA 731

Lonsdale,Christine L.

Respondent ON Appeal Medical malpractice —negligence — civilprocedure — summaryjudgment

75. ONCA Echo Energy CanadaInc. v. LencznerSlaght RoyceSmith Griffin LLP

10/27/10 [2010] O.J. No.4560, 2010ONCA 709, 269O.A.C. 382, 92C.P.C. (6th) 1,325 D.L.R. (4th)518, 2010CarswellOnt8065, 194A.C.W.S. (3d)999

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealfiled, on December24, 2010 ([2010]S.C.C.A. No. 484;[2010] C.S.C.R. no484)

Legal profession —barristers and solicitors— compensation —fees and disbursements— taxation orassessment of accounts

76. ONCA Galustian v. Skylink 10/04/10 [2010] O.J. No.4168, 2010ONCA 645, 268O.A.C. 157

Ship, Adam Respondent ON Appeal Civil procedure —security for costs

77. ONCA Lomas v. Rio AlgomLimited

10/03/10 2010 ONCA175, [2010] O.J.No. 932, 99O.R. (3d) 161,316 D.L.R. (4th)385, 259O.A.C. 333, 81C.C.P.B. 1, 186A.C.W.S. (3d)665, 2010CarswellOnt1327

Finkelstein,Neil

Appellant ON Appeal Pension plan — wind upproceedings — trust —benefits — employer —administrator

Page 19



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


78. ONCA StrassleInformationssystemeHoldings GmbH(Trustee of) v. Sieber

09/20/10 [2010] O.J. No.3926, 2010ONCA 604

Hall, Geoff R. Appellant ON Appeal Civil litigation —settlements — civilprocedure — conflict oflaws — foreignjurisdiction —enforcement

79. ONCA Miranda v. LakeShore Gold Corp.

09/17/10 [2010] O.J. No.3886, 2010ONCA 597, 324D.L.R. (4th) 36,268 O.A.C.162, 75 B.L.R.(4th) 88, 193A.C.W.S. (3d)1154, 2010CarswellOnt6887

Lawson,Trevor

Respondent ON Appeal Labour and employment— contracts —interpretation — generalprinciples — ordinarymeaning — businessefficacy

80. ONCA Dynasty FurnitureManufacturing Ltd. v.Toronto-DominionBank

07/20/10 [2010] O.J. No.3101, 2010ONCA 514, 321D.L.R. (4th) 334

Hall, Geoff R.Sirivar, Junior

Respondent ON Appeal Banking — finance law— tort law —negligence — duty ofcare — civil litigation —adding or striking aclaim

81. ONCA Dhaliwal v. Lindsay 07/09/10 [2010] O.J. No.2907, 2010ONCA 493

Leonard,David EGrace, KearyF.

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SCCdismissed ([2010]S.C.C.A. No. 401,03/10/2011)

Limitation of actions —equity — discoverability— fraudulentconcealment

82. ONCA Dean v. MisterTransmission(International) Ltd.

06/16/10 [2010] O.J. No.2536, 2010ONCA 443, 267O.A.C. 67, 87C.P.C. (6th)205, 95 M.V.R.(5th) 166, 2010CarswellOnt

Black, WilliamD.

Respondent ON Appeal Class actions — civillitigation — commerciallaw — consumerprotection — franchises

Page 20



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


3979

83. ONCA Abdulrahim v. AirFrance

06/04/10 [2010] O.J. No.2388, 2010ONCA 403

Brown, JohnP.

Appellant ON Appeal Civil litigation — civilprocedure — parties —class actions

84. ONCA Wellwood v. OntarioProvincial Police

05/28/10 12 O.R. (3d)555, 2010ONCA 386

Scott, William Respondent ON Appeal Civil procedure —dismissal for delay

85. ONCA Vandergiessen v.Mississauga Hospital

05/26/10 2010 ONCA379, [2010] O.J.No. 2187

Mogil, Eli Respondent ON Appeal Health law — healthcare professionals —liability (malpractice) —negligence — standardof care — practice andprocedure

86. ONCA Grant ForestProducts Inc. (Re)

05/14/10 [2010] O.J. No.1993, 2010ONCA 355, 101O.R. (3d) 383,318 D.L.R. (4th)598, 67 C.B.R.(5th) 23, 2010CarswellOnt3001

Hall, Geoff R. Appellant ON Appeal Contracts — remedies— equity — taxation

87. ONCA Finlay v. Paassen 03/18/10 101 O.R. (3d)390, 2010ONCA 204

Scott, William Appellant ON Appeal Civil procedure —dismissal for delay —setting aside

88. ONCA Bafaro v. Dowd 03/12/10 2010 ONCA188, [2010] O.J.No. 979, 260O.A.C. 70

Batner, SaritE.

Respondent ON Appeal Medical — health law —negligence — healthcare professionals

89. ONCA Admassu v. Wedge 03/10/10 2010 ONCA189, [2010] O.J.No. 938

Ship, Adam Respondent ON Appeal Civil procedure —summary judgments —non-triable issue —

Page 21



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


physicians and hospitals— children — Children’sAid Society — plaintiffalleged doctor hadconspired withChildren’s Aid Society todeprive him of custodyof his daughter

90. ONCA KipfinchDevelopments Ltd. v.Westwood Mall(Mississauga) Ltd.

01/22/10 [2010] O.J. No.211, 2010ONCA 45, 260O.A.C. 110, 65B.L.R. (4th)198, 48C.E.L.R. (3d) 1,87 R.P.R. (4th)161, 2010CarswellOnt297

Hall, Geoff R.Ship, Adam

Respondent ON Appeal Real property — sale ofland — breach ofcontract — damages

91. ONCA Kurdina v. TorontoPolice ServicesBoard

12/18/09 2009 ONCA906, [2009] O.J.No. 5421

Shaw, Byron Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SCCdismissed, 2010CanLII 20530(S.C.C.)

Civil procedure —amendment ofpleadings — statementof claim — failure todisclose a reasonablecause of action —failure to comply withrules — physicians andsurgeons

92. ONCA Inforica Inc. v. CGIInformation Systemsand ManagementConsultants Inc.

09/11/09 [2009] O.J. No.3747, 2009ONCA 642, 97O.R. (3d) 161,311 D.L.R. (4th)728, 254O.A.C. 117, 97Admin. L.R.(4th) 159, 80

Morrison, F.PaulHubbard,Christopher

Appellant ON Appeal Security for costs —jurisdiction to entertainthe application —procedural — award —agreement

Page 22



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


C.P.C. (6th)197, 2009CarswellOnt5276

93. ONCA Gore v. College ofPhysicians andSurgeons of Ontario

07/07/09 [2009] O.J. No.2833, 2009ONCA 546, 96O.R. (3d) 241,310 D.L.R. (4th)354, 251O.A.C. 49, 95Admin. L.R.(4th) 99, 2009CarswellOnt3887

Matheson,Andrew B.

Appellant ON Appeal Health law — healthcare professionals —discipline —investigation —investigatory powers ofgoverning body — toinspect premises,equipment, materials —appeal or judicial review— particular professions— doctors — appealsby three physicians fromthe dismissal of theirapplications for judicialreview of decisions ofCollege of Physiciansand Surgeons ofOntario

94. ONCA Dunn v. ChubbInsurance Co. ofCanada

07/02/09 [2009] O.J. No.2726, 2009ONCA 538, 266O.A.C. 1, 75C.C.L.I. (4th) 292009,CarswellOnt3715, 97 O.R.(3d) 701

Sirivar, Junior Appellant ON Appeal Insurance law —insurers — duties —duty to defend —interpretation ofinsurance contracts —legal defence costs

95. ONCA 6436145 CanadaLimited v. RockwestProperty Inc.

06/18/09 2009 ONCA496

Hall, Geoff R. Appellant ON Appeal Landlord and tenant —lease — termination andrenewal — commercialtenancy

Page 23



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


96. ONCA Kuwabara PayneMcKenna BlumbergArchitects v. Ontario(Minister of Finance)

06/18/09 [2009] O.J. No.2523, 2009ONCA 493, 79C.L.R. (3d) 1752009,CarswellOnt3477, 250O.A.C. 325,[2009] 5 C.T.C.303, 96 O.R.(3d) 385

Pel, Brian C. Respondent ON Appeal Tax — retail sales tax— exemptions

97. ONCA Gore v. College ofPhysicians andSurgeons of Ontario

04/08/09 [2009] O.J. No.1400, 2009ONCA 294, 176A.C.W.S. (3d)1178

Matheson,Andrew B.

Appellant ON Appeal Affirmed by Courtof Appeal [2009]O.J. No. 2833;2009 ONCA 546;96 O.R. (3d) 241;310 D.L.R. (4th)354; 251 O.A.C.49; 95 Admin. L.R.(4th) 99; 2009CarswellOnt 3887

Health law — healthcare professionals —discipline —investigation —investigatory powers ofgoverning body —motion by threecosmetic surgeons for astay precluding college'sinvestigator fromobserving them insurgery pending theirappeal from judicialreview decision allowed— appellants wereinvestigated forprofessional misconduct

98. ONCA MacKinnon v. GrandRiver Hospital

03/27/09 2009 ONCA265, 247O.A.C. 167,[2009] O.J. No.1255, 247O.A.C. 167, 64C.C.L.T. (3d)173, 176A.C.W.S. (3d)

Cruz, Darryl A.Baron, Erica J.

Appellant ON Appeal Medical — negligence— professionalresponsibility — tort law

Page 24



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


261, 2009CarswellOnt1741

99. ONCA Bathgate v. NationalHockey LeaguePension Society

02/17/09 1994 CanLII1427, 16 O.R.(3d) 761, 110D.L.R. (4th)609, 2 C.C.E.L.(2d) 94, 69O.A.C. 269,[1994] O.J. No.265, 1 C.C.P.B.209, 2 E.T.R.(2d) 1, 45A.C.W.S. (3d)1154

Finkelstein,NeilVegh, George

Appellant ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal atthe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed(Bathgate v.National HockeyLeague PensionSociety, [1994]S.C.C.A. No. 170;19 O.R. (3d); 114D.L.R. (4th) vii,07/28/1994)

Labour law — pensions— surplus — contracts— trust — entitlement topension funds

100. ONCA R. v. Stucky 02/17/09 [2009] O.J. No.600, 2009ONCA 151, 71C.P.R. (4th)402, 256O.A.C. 4, 240C.C.C. (3d)141, 303 D.L.R.(4th) 1, 65 C.R.(6th) 46, 2009CarswellOnt745, 56 B.L.R.(4th) 1

Porter, DavidM.Lonsdale,Christine L.

Respondent ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SCCdiscontinued (R. v.Stucky, [2009]S.C.C.A. No. 186,09/02/2009)

Criminal law — statutoryinterpretation —Competition Act

101. ONCA Metropolitan TorontoPolice Widows andOrphans Fundv.TelusCommunications Inc.

02/02/09 [2009] O.J. No.455, 2009ONCA 111, 55B.L.R. (4th) 12,2009CarswellOnt577

Parla, Julie K. Respondent ON Appeal Civil litigation — civilprocedure — interest —calculation of — post-judgment interest —pre-judgment interest —appeal by defendantfrom award of pre andpost judgment interest

Page 25



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


on a compounded basisfor breach of contract —appeal dismissed —trial judge's finding thatthe appellant knew thatthe funds in questionwould be reinvested bythe respondentbondholders to earncompound return wasopen to him

102. ONCA Franklin v. Tymianski 12/15/08 [2008] O.J. No.5083, 2008ONCA 850, 173A.C.W.S. (3d)435

Baron, Erica J. Respondent ON Appeal Medical — professionalresponsibility — civilprocedure

103. ONCA St. Jean (Litigationguardian of) v.Cheung

12/03/08 2008 ONCA815, [2008] O.J.No. 4862, 94O.R. (3d) 359,304 D.L.R. (4th)619, 244O.A.C. 160

Batner, SaritE.

Respondent ON Appeal Medical malpractice —limitations — negligence— civil litigation —health careprofessionals

104. ONCA SmithEstate v. NationalMoney Mart Co.

11/03/08 [2008] O.J. No.4327, 2008ONCA 746, 61C.P.C. (6th) 72,243 O.A.C.173, 2008CarswellOnt6415, 170A.C.W.S. (3d)452, 92 O.R.(3d) 641, 303D.L.R. (4th) 175


Appellant ON Appeal Civil litigation — civilprocedure — parties —class or representativeactions — certification— decertification —estoppel — estoppel byrecord (res judicata) —issue estoppel — resjudicata as bar tosubsequentproceedings

Page 26



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


105. ONCA Apotex Inc. v. Sanofi-aventis

10/23/08 [2008] O.J. No.4140, 2008ONCA 724, 60C.P.C. (6th) 1,2008CarswellOnt6344, 170A.C.W.S. (3d)741

Morrison, F.P.Burt, GlynnisP.

Respondent ON Appeal Forum non conveniens

106. ONCA Paxton v. Ramji 10/14/08 2008 ONCA697, 92 O.R.(3d) 401, 299D.L.R. (4th)614,242 O.A.C. 34,[2008] O.J. No.3964, 59C.C.L.T. (3d)179, 170A.C.W.S. (3d)649, 2008CarswellOnt5983

Cruz, Darryl A.Batner, SaritE.

Respondent ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed (Paxtonv. Ramji, [2008]S.C.C.A. No. 508,23/04/2009)

Medical malpractice —health law —professionalresponsibility —negligence — tort law— duty of care

107. ONCA Beth v. AdvancedMicro Devices, Inc.

10/09/08 [2008] O.J. No.3911, 2008ONCA 686, 242O.A.C. 136, 69C.C.E.L. (3d)100, 169A.C.W.S. (3d)1023, 2008CarswellOnt5917

Lawson,Trevor

Appellant ON Appeal Employment law —wrongful dismissal —reasonable noticeperiod or wages in lieu— inducement in hiring

108. ONCA Hanis v. Teevan 10/08/08 [2008] O.J. No.3909, 2008ONCA 678, 69C.C.E.L. (3d)

Scott, WilliamG.

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SCCdismissed ([2008]S.C.C.A. No. 504,

Insurance law —insurers — duties —duty to defend —jurisdiction — civil

Page 27



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


86, 241 O.A.C.303, 2008CarswellOnt5867, [2008]I.L.R. I-4748,92 O.R. (3d)594, 67 C.C.L.I.(4th) 196, 169A.C.W.S. (3d)970

03/26/2009);Costs: 2008ONCA 793

procedure — costs

109. ONCA Metcalfe & MansfieldAlternativeInvestments II Corp.(Re)

08/18/08 92 O.R. (3d)513

Meredith,Heather

Respondent ON Appeal Debtor and creditor —Companies’ CreditorsArrangement Act —inclusion of third partyreleases

110. ONCA Mulligan v.Laurentian University

06/30/08 [2008] O.J. No.2570, 2008ONCA 523, 241O.A.C. 11, 302D.L.R. (4th)546, 174A.C.W.S. (3d)139

Sutton,Thomas N.T.

Respondent ON Appeal 2007 CanLII33761 (ONS.C.D.C.)

Education law —universities andcolleges — admissionstandards — appealsand judicial review —deference to expertiseof decision maker —funding policy —students — admission— graduate — researchgrants

111. ONCA Detchev v. Gorman 05/21/08 [2008] O.J. No.1969, 2008ONCA 400, 168A.C.W.S. (3d)491

Block, Eric S. Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealrefused [2008]S.C.C.A. No. 310,10/30/2008

Civil procedure — civillitigation

112. ONCA Cugliari v. White 04/23/08 1998 CanLII5505, 38 O.R.(3d) 641, 159D.L.R. (4th)254, 109

Finkelstein,Neil

Appellant ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed

Pensions — damages— deductions forpayments or assistanceby third parties — bystatute or government

Page 28



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


O.A.C. 109,[1998] O.J. No.1628, 21 C.P.C.(4th) 213, 79A.C.W.S. (3d)292

(Cugliari v. White,[1998] S.C.C.A.No. 302,12/10/1998)

— Canada PensionPlan — disability

113. ONCA York BremnerDevelopmentsLimited v. FHRProperties Inc.

04/21/08 [2008] O.J. No.1527, 2008ONCA 308,2008CarswellOnt2248, 165A.C.W.S. (3d)837, 67 R.P.R.(4th) 194

Sinha,Awanish

Respondent ON Appeal Prepayment — shoring— permit — payable —amount

114. ONCA Quick Motion Ltd. v.New United GroupCo. (c.o.b.All 99 Cents Centre)

04/08/08 [2008] O.J. No.1331, 2008ONCA 262

Matheson,Andrew B.

Appellant ON Appeal Viva voce evidence —procedural unfairness

115. ONCA IBM Canada Ltd. v.Ontario (Minister ofFinance)

04/01/08 [2008] O.J. No.1168, 2008ONCA 216, 89O.R. (3d) 641,235 O.A.C.161,165 A.C.W.S.(3d) 182

Chua, Chia-yi Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SCCdismissed (IBMCanada Ltd. v.Ontario (Ministerof Finance), [2008]S.C.C.A. No. 255,10/09/2008)

Taxation — businesstax — exemptions

116. ONCA Workgroup DesignsInc. (Re)

03/31/08 [2008] O.J. No.1147, 2008ONCA 214, 90O.R. (3d) 26,292 D.L.R. (4th)185, 234O.A.C. 166, 40C.B.R. (5th) 1,164 A.C.W.S.

Hall, Geoff R. Respondent ON Appeal Bankruptcy andinsolvency — proposaltrustee

Page 29



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


(3d) 741, 2008CarswellOnt1656

117. ONCA 365 Bay NewHoldings Ltd. v.McQuillan LifeInsuranceAgencies Ltd.

02/13/08 [2008] O.J. No.472, 2008ONCA 100, 64R.P.R. (4th)44,233 O.A.C.299, 164A.C.W.S. (3d)328, 2008CarswellOnt688

Hall, Geoff R. Respondent ON Appeal Landlord and tenant law— the lease —agreement to lease —terms — variation oralteration

118. ONCA Proctor & GambleInc. v. Ontario(Minister of Finance)

11/16/07 [2007] O.J. No.4441, 2007ONCA 784, 230O.A.C. 246,[2008] 2 C.T.C.187, 2008G.T.C. 1367,161 A.C.W.S.(3d) 1020

Chua, Chia-yi Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SCCdiscontinued([2008] S.C.C.A.No. 7, 01/11/2008)

Taxation — sales andservice taxes —assessments —exemptions

119. ONCA R. v. R.J. ReynoldsTobacco Co.(Delaware)

10/29/07 [2007] O.J. No.4252, 2007ONCA 749, 230O.A.C. 89, 230C.C.C. (3d) 72,77 W.C.B. (2d)138

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Respondent ON Appeal Criminal law —compelling appearance,detention and release— summons — validity— appeal by Crownfrom order quashing anorder validating serviceex juris (in the U.S.) onrespondents ofsummonses in relationto charges of fraud andconspiracy to commitfraud and prohibitingany judge of the OntarioCourt of Justice from

Page 30



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


proceeding againstthem

120. ONCA Waterloo (City) v.Wolfraim

10/23/07 2007 ONCA732 (CanLII)

Sirivar, Junior Respondent ON Appeal 2010 ONSC 179,2010 CLB 1347,184 A.C.W.S. (3d)619 , (Ont. S.C.J.,January 6, 2010)

Civil procedure —settlements — releases— striking out pleadingsor allegations —grounds — false,frivolous — abuse ofprocess — clearest —motion — release —inclusive

121. ONCA Grass (Litigationguardian of) v.Women's CollegeHospital

07/26/07 2007 ONCA542, [2007] O.J.No. 2918, 159A.C.W.S. (3d)201, 2007CarswellOnt4804

Baron, Erica J. Appellant ON Appeal Medical — evidence —civil procedure

122. ONCA R. v. H.A. 06/17/07 2007 ONCA530, [2007] O.J.No. 2764, 74W.C.B. (2d)710

McKendry,Jennifer A.

Respondent ON Appeal Criminal law —information that couldidentify — published inany document —witness — broadcast —transmitted

123. ONCA Huisman v.MacDonald

05/25/07 [2007] O.J. No.2037, 2007ONCA 391,280 D.L.R. (4th)1, 224 O.A.C.176, 37 B.L.R.(4th) 198, 158A.C.W.S. (3d)323, 2007CarswellOnt3315

Sinha,Awanish

Appellant ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed ([2007]S.C.C.A. No. 428,12/06/2007).

Health law —professions —malpractice —negligence

Page 31



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


124. ONCA Silber v. DDJ HighYield Fund

04/26/07 [2007] O.J. No.1581, 2007ONCA 315, 27B.L.R. (4th)171, 157A.C.W.S. (3d)201, 2007CarswellOnt2541

Peebles, DanaM.

Respondent ON Appeal Corporate law —shareholders — appealfrom Rule 21 Motion —statement of claim didnot disclose areasonable cause ofaction

125. ONCA Reynolds v. The Cityof Kingston PoliceServices Board etal.

03/14/07 [2007] O.J. No.900, 2007ONCA 166, 84O.R. (3d) 738,280 D.L.R. (4th)311, 221O.A.C. 216, 45C.C.L.T. (3d)19, 155A.C.W.S. (3d)847, 2007CarswellOnt1424

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Respondent ON Appeal Civil procedure —parties — capacity tosue or be sued

126. ONCA McDonald-Wright(Litigation Guardianof) v. O'Herlihy

02/13/07 [2007] O.J. No.478, 2007ONCA 89, 220O.A.C. 110,155 A.C.W.S.(3d) 379

McLaughlin,Frank J.

Respondent ON Appeal Tort law — negligence— professional —medical liability —wrongful life claim

127. ONCA Royal Bank ofCanada v. SociétéGénérale (Canada)

12/21/06 2006 CanLII42545, [2006]O.J. No. 5081,219 O.A.C. 83,31 B.L.R. (4th)63, 154A.C.W.S. (3d)72, 2006CarswellOnt

Steep, R. PaulMeredith,Heather L.

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed,September 6, 20([2007] S.C.C.A.No. 87; [2007]S.C.C.A. No. 88)

Civil procedure —judgments and orders— summary judgments— for part of claim —appeal from thedismissal of some of theappellant's claims in acomplex fraud case —banks — financial

Page 32



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


8091, [2007]O.J. No. 1496,2007 ONCA302, 31 B.L.R.(4th) 83, 157A.C.W.S. (3d)40, 2007CarswellOnt2370

institutions

128. ONCA Debora v. Debora 12/06/06 [2006] O.J. No.4826, 83 O.R.(3d) 81, 275D.L.R. (4th)698, 218O.A.C. 237, 33R.F.L. (6th)252, 52 R.P.R.(4th) 191, 153A.C.W.S. (3d)648

McKendry,Jennifer A.

Respondent/Appellant incross-appeal

ON Appeal Family law — maritalproperty — equalization— valuation of assets —appreciation ordepreciation —matrimonial home —what constitutes —piercing corporate veil— maintenance andsupport — child support— income over$150,000 — monthlyaward of $10,000 plus— quantum — payor'sannual income —retroactive award —costs

129. ONCA C. and M. HoldingsLtd. v. Tiffany GateLtd.

11/22/06 2006 CanLII39453, [2006]O.J. No. 4696,153 A.C.W.S.(3d) 443

Morrison, F.PaulBatner, SaritE.

Respondent ON Appeal Real estate — landlordand tenant law —repairs andimprovements

130. ONCA Ahmed v. Stefaniu 10/20/06 2006 CanLII34973, [2006]O.J. No. 4185,275 D.L.R. (4th)101, 216O.A.C. 323,

Black, WilliamD.Parla, Julie K.

Appellant ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed (Ahmedv. Stefaniu, [2006]

Health law — medicalmalpractice —negligence — causation

Page 33



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


155 A.C.W.S.(3d) 457

S.C.C.A. No. 498,05/04/2007)

131. ONCA Ivaco Inc. (Re) 10/17/06 [2006] O.J. No.4152, 83 O.R.(3d) 108, 275D.L.R. (4th)132, 26 B.L.R.(4th) 43, 25C.B.R. (5th)176, 56C.C.P.B. 1, 151A.C.W.S. (3d)1004, 2006CarswellOnt6292

Hall, Geoff R. Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal toSCC discontinued(Ontario(Superintendent ofFinancialServices) v.National Bank ofCanada, [2006]S.C.C.A. No. 490,10/31/2007)

Commercial law —bankruptcy andinsolvency — creditor —debtor — pension

132. ONCA Baldwin v. Daubney 09/27/06 [2006] O.J. No.3824, 83 O.R.(3d) 308, 275D.L.R. (4th)762, 216O.A.C. 72, 20B.L.R. (4th)204, 2006CanLII 32901,151 A.C.W.S.(3d) 734, 2006CarswellOnt5783

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed, May 3,2007 ([2006]S.C.C.A. No. 475)

Commercial law —banking — financialinstitutions — liability tocustomers — loans —loan agreement

133. ONCA Assessmed Inc. v.CanadianBroadcastingCorporation

06/06/06 2006 CanLII18619 (ONC.A.), [2006]O.J. No. 2226,211 O.A.C.240, 39C.C.L.T. (3d)201, 2006

Stephenson,Jenny P.

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal toSCC refused,(S.C.C.,December 14,2006)

Tort law — libel andslander — defamation— defences —broadcasting — massmedia

Page 34



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


CarswellOnt3392

134. ONCA Smith v. NationalMoney Mart Co.

05/05/06 [2006] O.J. No.1807, 80 O.R.(3d) 81, 266D.L.R. (4th)275, 209O.A.C. 190, 18B.L.R. (4th) 22,28 C.P.C. (6th)34, 147A.C.W.S. (3d)748, 2006CarswellOnt2774


Appellant ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed,October 12, 2006([2006] S.C.C.A.No. 267)

Civil procedure —appeals — class action— commercial law —banking — loans —interest — internationallaw and conflict of laws— conflict of laws —service out ofjurisdiction (ex juris)

135. ONCA Stelco Inc. (Re) 01/26/06 [2006] O.J. No.249, 14 B.L.R.(4th) 15, 17C.B.R. (5th)101, 145A.C.W.S. (3d)368, 2006CarswellOnt335

Hall, Geoff R. Respondent ON Appeal Civil procedure —pleadings — striking outpleadings or allegations— grounds

136. ONCA Stelco Inc. (Re) 11/17/05 [2005] O.J. No.4883, 78 O.R.(3d) 241, 261D.L.R. (4th)368, 204O.A.C. 205, 11B.L.R. (4th)185, 15 C.B.R.(5th) 307, 144A.C.W.S. (3d)15, 2005CarswellOnt

Hall, Geoff R. Respondent ON Appeal Creditor and debtor —insolvency —Companies' CreditorsArrangement Act —class

Page 35



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


6818

137. ONCA Stelco Inc. (Re) 11/04/05 [2005] O.J. No.4733, 78 O.R.(3d) 254, 204O.A.C. 216, 15C.B.R. (5th)288, 2005CanLII 40140,143 A.C.W.S.(3d) 419, 2005CarswellOnt6283

Hall, Geoff R. Respondent ON Appeal Creditor and debtor —insolvency — courtapproval

138. ONCA Veltri Metal ProductsCo. (Re)

07/29/05 [2005] O.J. No.3217, 201O.A.C. 79, 16C.B.R. (5th)289, 48 C.L.R.(3d) 161, 141A.C.W.S. (3d)709, 2005CarswellOnt3326

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Construction law —liens — priorities —creditors and debtorslaw — legislation —debtors' relief —Companies’ CreditorsArrangement Act —creditors — priorities —security — liens —priorities — insolvencylaw — receivers,managers and monitors— property — sale of —claims — priorities —statutory liens andcharges — securedcreditors — statutoryliens

139. ONCA Stetler v. Agriculture,Food and RuralAffairs AppealTribunal

07/08/05 [2005] O.J. No.2817, 76 O.R.(3d) 321, 200O.A.C. 209,36 Admin. L.R.

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed,February 16, 2006([2005] S.C.C.A.No. 428)

Administrative law —judicial review andstatutory appeal —when available — errorof law

Page 36



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


(4th) 212, 141A.C.W.S. (3d)157, 2005CarswellOnt2877

140. ONCA McDougald Estate v.Gooderham

06/15/05 2005 CanLII21091, 255D.L.R. (4th)435, 199O.A.C. 203,[2005] O.J. No.2432, 17 E.T.R.(3d) 36, 140A.C.W.S. (3d)220, 2005CarswellOnt2407

Baron, Erica J. Respondent ON Appeal Will, estates and trustslaw

141. ONCA Van Dyke v. GreyBruce RegionalHealth Centre

06/03/05 [2005] O.J. No.2219, 255D.L.R. (4th)397, 197O.A.C. 336, 33C.C.L.T. (3d) 1,139 A.C.W.S.(3d) 1102

Sutton,Thomas N.T.

Appellant ON Appeal Leave to Appeal toSCC refused,[2005] S.C.C.A.335 (S.C.C.,August 9, 2005)

Professionalresponsibility — tort law— health law — healthcare professionals —medical malpractice —negligence — causation— failure to inform —administration andprescription of drugs —treatment, authorizationfor — consent —informed consent —civil procedure

142. ONCA Ferenczy v. MCIMedical Clinics

05/26/05 2005 CanLII18186, 198O.A.C. 254,[2005] O.J. No.2076, 139A.C.W.S. (3d)379

Black, WilliamD.

Respondent ON Appeal Medical malpractice —civil procedure — healthlaw — liability —negligence — standardof care

Page 37



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


143. ONCA Stelco Inc. (Re) 04/26/05 [2005] O.J. No.1575, 253D.L.R. (4th)524, 197O.A.C. 1, 9C.B.R. (5th)307, 21 C.C.L.I.(4th) 1, [2005]I.L.R. I-4430, 7P.P.S.A.C. (3d)281, 138A.C.W.S. (3d)949, 2005CarswellOnt1537

Hall, Geoff R. Respondent ON Appeal Commercial law —personal property —security interests —registration — insurancelaw

144. ONCA Shams v. Rotstein 04/20/05 [2005] O.J. No.1482, 138A.C.W.S. (3d)751

McLaughlin,Frank J.

Respondent ON Appeal Health law — healthcare professionals —liability (malpractice) —negligence

145. ONCA Ontario (Children'sLawyer) v. Ontario(Information andPrivacyCommissioner)

04/18/05 [2005] O.J. No.1426, 75 O.R.(3d) 309, 253D.L.R. (4th)489, 196O.A.C. 350, 29Admin. L.R.(4th) 86, 17R.F.L. (6th) 32,2005 CanLII11786, 138A.C.W.S. (3d)778, 2005CarswellOnt1419


Friend of theCourt

ON Appeal Administrative law —boards and tribunals —reasons — privacy law— solicitor-clientprivilege

146. ONCA Grass (Litigationguardian) v. Women'sCollege Hospital

04/15/05 [2005] O.J. No.1403, 75 O.R.(3d) 85, 196

McLaughlin,Frank J.

Appellant/Respondent incross-appeal

ON Appeal SCC refused leaveto appeal: 196O.A.C. 201;

Civil procedure —appeals — grounds forreview —

Page 38



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


O.A.C. 201, 30C.C.L.T. (3d)100, 138A.C.W.S. (3d)752

additional reasons:2005 CarswellOnt1701

misapprehension of orfailure to considerevidence — orderingnew trial — health law— health careprofessionals —particular professions —doctors — liability(malpractice) —negligence — failure toprovide care —causation —professionalresponsibility —professions — healthcare — doctors — tortlaw — negligence —causation — causalconnection

147. ONCA Celanese CanadaInc. v. CanadianNational Railway Co.

03/30/05 [2005] O.J. No.1122, 196O.A.C. 602005 CanLII8663, 138A.C.W.S. (3d)23

Scott, WilliamG.Hubbard,Christopher

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealdenied: [2005]S.C.C.A. No. 245

Civil procedure — costsappeal

148. ONCA BNY Capital Corp. v.Katotakis

02/23/05 2005 CanLII3979, [2005]O.J. No. 640,194 O.A.C.353, 1 B.L.R.(4th) 168, 137A.C.W.S. (3d)744

Steep, R. PaulBlock, Eric

Respondent ON Appeal Corporations andassociations law —corporations —shareholder agreements— lockup or tenderagreement — rights —purchase option andright of first refusal —financial services

Page 39



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


149. ONCA Toronto Blue JaysBaseball Club v.Ontario (Minister ofFinance)

02/15/05 [2005] O.J. No.485, 250 D.L.R.(4th) 63, 194O.A.C. 312,2005 D.T.C.5360, 137A.C.W.S. (3d)446

Chua, Chia-yi Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed ([2005]S.C.C.A. No. 181,09/22/2005)

Civil procedure —appeals — statutoryinterpretation —statutes — construction— legislative intent

150. ONCA Ontario (Ministry ofCorrectionalServices) v. Ontario(Information andPrivacyCommissioner)

01/14/05 [2005] O.J. No.66


Respondent ON Appeal Reversed by theSCC ([2006]S.C.J. No. 31;[2006] A.C.S. no31; 2006 SCC 31;2006 CSC 31;[2006] 2 S.C.R.32; [2006] 2R.C.S. 32; 271D.L.R. (4th) 407;350 N.R. 154; J.E.2006-1357; 148A.C.W.S. (3d) 832;EYB 2006-107360)

Access to information —access to records —exemption — solicitor-client privilege

151. ONCA Mussani v. CPSO 12/29/04 [2004] O.J. No.5176, 74 O.R.(3d) 1, 248D.L.R. (4th)632, 193O.A.C. 23, 22Admin. L.R.(4th) 53, 125C.R.R. (2d)340, 136A.C.W.S. (3d)156, 2004CarswellOnt5433

Ortved, W.Neils F.

Appellant ON Appeal Medicine — disciplinefor professionalmisconduct —professional misconductor conduct unbecominga member — sexualimproprieties —punishments —revocation of licence —judicial review (appeals)— civil rights — liberty— security of the person— trials, due process,fundamental justice and

Page 40



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


fair hearings — void forvagueness doctrine —overbreadth principle —cruel and unusualtreatment or punishment— freedom ofassociation —limitations on —Canadian Charter ofRights and Freedoms —application

152. ONCA J.B. Printing Ltd. v.829085 Ontario Ltd.,

12/09/04 2004 CanLII46220 (ONC.A.), [2004]O.J. No. 5014,192 O.A.C.313, 135A.C.W.S. (3d)957

Steep, R. Paul Appellant ON Appeal Tort law — negligentmisrepresentation —printing business —liability

153. ONCA Kennedy v.Jackiewicz


Cruz, Darryl A.Batner, SaritE.

Respondent ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed(Kennedy v.Jackiewicz, [2005]S.C.C.A. No. 27,28/04/2005)

Medical liability —health law — civilevidence — health careprofessionals —negligence — causation— standard of care

154. ONCA Chippewas ofMnjikaning FirstNations v. CHCCasinos Canada Ltd.


Grace, Keary Appellant ON Appeal Contracts — terms —interpretation — gamingand betting — casinos

155. ONCA D.W. v. White 08/23/04 [2004] O.J. No.3441, 189O.A.C. 256,


Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SCCdismissed ([2004]

Appeals — new trials —lack of or incompetenceof counsel at trial —

Page 41



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


133 A.C.W.S.(3d) 217

S.C.C.A. No. 486,03/24/2005)

bars — settlements —barristers and solicitors— negligence

156. ONCA Shaw v. BCE Inc 07/23/04 2004 CanLII4327,[2004] O.J. No.3109, 189O.A.C. 9, 49B.L.R. (3d) 1,132 A.C.W.S.(3d) 478

Morrison, F.PaulPeebles, DanaM.

Appellant ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed, March3, 2005 (Shaw v.B.C.E. Inc., [2004]S.C.C.A. No. 419,03/03/2005)

Civil procedure —pleadings — striking outpleadings or allegations— grounds — failure todisclose a cause ofaction or defence —corporations andassociations law —corporations — actions— against corporationand directors —oppressive conduct

157. ONCA Mussani v. College ofPhysicians andSurgeons ofOntario

06/24/04 [2004] O.J. No.5176, 74 O.R.(3d) 1, 248D.L.R. (4th)632, 193O.A.C. 23, 22Admin. L.R.(4th) 53, 125C.R.R. (2d)340, 136A.C.W.S. (3d)156, 2004CarswellOnt5433

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Appellant ON Appeal Medicine — disciplinefor professionalmisconduct —professional misconductor conduct unbecominga member — sexualimproprieties —punishments —revocation of licence

158. ONCA Markandu (Litigationguardian of) v.Benaroch

06/21/04 [2004] O.J. No.2608, 71 O.R.(3d) 377, 242D.L.R. (4th)101, 187O.A.C. 387, 50C.P.C. (5th)279, 131

McLaughlin,Frank J.

Respondent ON Appeal Conflict of laws —actions — jurisdiction —forum conveniens —considerations

Page 42



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


A.C.W.S. (3d)1060

159. ONCA Canada CashAdvance Inc. (Re)

06/11/04 [2004] O.J. No.2476, 187O.A.C. 332,131 A.C.W.S.(3d) 585

Hall, Geoff R. Appellant ON Appeal Bankruptcy — receivingorder — evidence

160. ONCA D. P. v. Wagg 05/18/04 [2004] O.J. No.2053, 71 O.R.(3d) 229, 239D.L.R. (4th)501, 187O.A.C. 26, 184C.C.C. (3d)321, 46 C.P.C.(5th) 13, 120C.R.R. (2d) 52,2004 CanLII39048, 130A.C.W.S. (3d)1098

Batner, SaritE.

Respondent ON Appeal Evidence — disclosureand production ofdocuments — medicallaw — health careprofessionals

161. ONCA MacMillan v.McDermid

03/11/04 [2004] O.J. No.937, 70 O.R.(3d) 252, 129A.C.W.S. (3d)205

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Respondent ON Appeal Civil procedure —appeals

162. ONCA R. v. Li 02/26/04 [2004] O.J. No.718, 184O.A.C. 117,183 C.C.C. (3d)48, 60 W.C.B.(2d) 557

Porter, DavidM.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law — newtrials — grounds, errorby trial judge on juryselection — grounds,misdirection by trialjudge

163. ONCA UPM-KymmeneCorp. v. UPM-Kymmene Miramichi

02/20/04 2004 CanLII9479, [2004]O.J. No. 636,

Steep, R. Paul Respondent ON Appeal Oppression remedy —shareholders —contract — allegations

Page 43



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


Inc., 250 D.L.R. (4th)526, 183O.A.C. 310, 42B.L.R. (3d) 34,32 C.C.E.L.(3d) 68, 40C.C.P.B. 114,137 A.C.W.S.(3d) 742, 2004CarswellOnt691

of fraud —reasonableness

164. ONCA Montague v. Bank ofNova Scotia

01/07/04 [2004] O.J. No.13, 69 O.R.(3d) 87, 180O.A.C. 381, 30C.C.E.L. (3d)71, 128A.C.W.S. (3d)93

Leonard,David E.


Employment —wrongful dismissal —notice — civil procedure— offer to settle

165. ONCA Mirembe v. Tarshis 12/08/03 [2003] O.J. No.4753, 179O.A.C. 260,127 A.C.W.S.(3d) 559

Sutton,Thomas N.T.

Respondent ON Appeal Professionalresponsibility — tort law— negligence —medical malpractice —causation — practice —evidence and proof

166. ONCA Felde v. Vein andLaser Medical Centreet al

12/03/03 [2003] O.J. No.4654, 68 O.R.(3d) 97, 179O.A.C. 154, 21C.C.L.T. (3d)81, 127A.C.W.S. (3d)362

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Appellant ON Appeal Medical malpractice —assumption of risk

167. ONCA Nichols v. Young 11/20/03 2003 CanLII2917, [2003]O.J. No. 4376,

Cruz, Darryl A. Respondent ON Appeal Torts — negligence —standard of care —causation — medical —

Page 44



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


126 A.C.W.S.(3d) 1033

health professional

168. ONCA 1497777 Ontario Inc.v. Leon’s FurnitureLtd.

09/24/03 [2003] O.J. No.3708, 67 O.R.(3d) 206,232 D.L.R. (4th)552, 176O.A.C. 380, 13R.P.R. (4th) 1,125 A.C.W.S.(3d) 504

Hall, Geoff R. Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed(1497777 OntarioInc. v. Leon’sFurniture Ltd.,[2003] S.C.C.A.No. 506,07/08/2004)

Landlord and tenant —sublease — termination— landlord's consent

169. ONCA Compugen SystemsLtd. v. MFPTechnology ServicesLtd.


Steep, R. PaulAwanish,Sinha

Appellant ON Appeal Contracts —interpretation — impliedterms — performance orbreach — breach —remedies and damages— appeals — computerproducts — cross-appeal — supply —incremental — value-added reseller

170. ONCA Morgis v. ThomsonKernaghan & Co.

06/24/03 2003 CanLII5999, 65 O.R.(3d) 321, 35B.L.R. (3d) 14,174 O.A.C.104, [2003] O.J.No. 2504, 19C.C.L.T. (3d)238, 123A.C.W.S. (3d)1166

Cruz, Darryl A.Baron, Erica J.

Appellant ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed (Morgisv. ThomsonKernaghan & Co.,[2003] S.C.C.A.No. 400,08/04/2004)

Civil liability —negligence — tort law— associations —economic interests

171. ONCA Williams v. MutualLife Assurance Co.;Zicherman v.

04/08/03 [2003] O.J. No.1160, 226D.L.R. (4th)

Morrison, F.PaulPeebles, Dana

Respondent ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe Supreme

Class actions —competition law —negligence — appeal

Page 45



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


Equitable LifeInsurance Co.of Canada (appeal byKumar)

112, 170O.A.C. 165, 47,C.C.L.I. (3d) 43,[2003] I.L.R. I-4181, 121A.C.W.S. (3d)1001

M. Court of Canadadismissed,January 22, 2004([2003] S.C.C.A.No. 283)

from divisional courtorder dismissing appealfrom failed certificationmotion — too manyindividual issues forclass proceeding

172. ONCA Paletta InternationalCorp. v. Canada LifeMortgage ServicesLtd.

04/02/03 [2003] O.J. No.1107, 170O.A.C. 5, 9R.P.R. (4th) 1,121 A.C.W.S.(3d) 850

Hall, Geoff R. Appellant ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed (PalettaInternational Corp.v. Canada LifeMortgage ServicesLtd., [2003]S.C.C.A. No. 260,02/26/2004)

Commercial law —contracts —interpretation —jurisdiction

173. ONCA Ford v. F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd.

03/13/03 [2003] O.J. No.868, 223 D.L.R.(4th) 445, 30C.P.C. (5th)107, 23 C.P.R.(4th) 454, 121A.C.W.S. (3d)425

Houston,DonaldMorrison, F. P.

Appellant ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SCCdismissed ([2003]S.C.C.A. No. 245,11/11/2003)

Practice — discovery —production andinspection of documents— respecting foreignactions

174. ONCA Rive v. Newton 02/14/03 2003 CanLII48370, [2003]O.J. No. 398,[2003] G.S.T.C.49, 120A.C.W.S. (3d)730

Batner, SaritE.

Respondent ON Appeal Practice — costs

175. ONCA Algoma Steel Inc. v.Union Gas Ltd.

01/17/03 [2003] O.J. No.71, 63 O.R.(3d) 78, 168O.A.C. 89, 39C.B.R. (4th) 5,119 A.C.W.S.

Hall, Geoff R. Respondent ON Appeal Creditors and debtors— Companies’Creditors ArrangementAct — arrangement,set-off

Page 46



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


(3d) 520, 2003CarswellOnt115

176. ONCA Commisso (Litigationguardian of) v. NorthYork BransonHospital

01/13/03 [2003] O.J. No.20, 168 O.A.C.100, 119A.C.W.S. (3d)491.

McLaughlin,Frank J.

Respondent ON Appeal Medicine — liability ofpractitioners —negligence or fault

177. ONCA Sambrook v. AltamiraManagement Ltd.

09/24/02 2002 CanLII45077, [2002]O.J. No. 3607,19 C.C.E.L.(3d) 184, 117A.C.W.S. (3d)92

Steep, R. Paul Appellant ON Appeal Contract interpretation— delivery and sale ofshares — optionagreements — contract— cross-appeal —shares — proferentum— delivery

178. ONCA Amhil EnterprisesLtd. v. Select Inc.,

04/05/02 2002 CanLII41071 (ONC.A.), [2002]O.J. No. 1232,112 A.C.W.S.(3d) 854

Sutton,Thomas N.T.

Respondent ON Appeal Civil procedure —summary judgment —pleadings doctrine ofequitable set-off — stayof execution pending —sceptical — amount —timeframes —enforcement ofjudgments

179. ONCA EdperBrascan Corp.v. 177373 CanadaLimited

03/04/02 2002 CanLII17624 (ONC.A.), 22 B.L.R.(3d) 42, [2002]O.J. No. 759,112 A.C.W.S.(3d) 263, 2002CarswellOnt698

Steep, R. PaulHall, GeoffFinkelstein,Neil

AppellantRespondent

ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadiscontinued(EdperBrascanCorporation v.177373 CanadaLimited, et al.,[2002] S.C.C.A.No. 184,08/12/2002)

Contracts —performance or breach— practice — summaryjudgment — liquidateddemand

Page 47



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


180. ONCA Delrina Corp. (c.o.b.Carolian Systems) v.Triolet Systems Inc.

03/01/02 [2002] O.J. No.676, 58 O.R.(3d) 339, 156O.A.C. 166, 23B.L.R. (3d) 231,17 C.P.R. (4th)289, 112A.C.W.S. (3d)141

Morrison, F.PaulSookman,Barry

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal toSCC dismissed onNovember 28,2002 ([2002]S.C.C.A. No. 189)

Copyright — rate —hour — copying —injunction — similarities— abstraction filtrationcomparison method

181. ONCA Marshall v. WatsonWyatt & Co. (c.o.b.Watson WyattWorldwide

01/17/02 [2002] O.J. No.84, 57 O.R.(3d) 813, 209D.L.R. (4th)411, 155O.A.C. 103, 16C.C.E.L. (3d)162, 2002CanLII 13354,111 A.C.W.S.(3d) 75

Hall, Geoff R. Appellant ON Appeal Civil procedure —evidence —employment— wrongful dismissal —damages

182. ONCA Liuni (Guardian of) v.Peters,

12/04/01 2001 CanLII5153, [2001]O.J. No. 4724,151 O.A.C.389, 8 C.C.L.T.(3d) 207, 110A.C.W.S. (3d)381

Steep, R. PaulReddon,Andrew J.

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SCC refused,169 O.A.C. 196 n,300 N.R. 195 n,[2002] 2 S.C.R. vii(S.C.C., April 18,2002)

Tort law — medicalmalpractice — liability ofpractitioners —negligence or fault —standard of care —prenatal care —emergency caesarean— sign of foetal distress

183. ONCA Rio Tinto CanadianInvestments Ltd. v.Labrador Iron OreRoyalty Income Fund(Trustee of)

09/10/01 [2001] O.J. No.3499, 41 E.T.R.(2d) 283, 107A.C.W.S. (3d)1130

Steep, R. PaulAlexander,Anthony

Appellant ON Appeal Trusts — administration— powers of trustee —alteration of terms oftrust — variation oftrusts — grounds forvariation — unit holderrights plan —shareholder rights

Page 48



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


184. ONCA Wight Milling Ltd. v.Bloomfield (Village of)

08/28/01 149 O.A.C.293, 2001CanLII 12599,[2001] O.J. No.3423, 21M.P.L.R. (3d)181, 107A.C.W.S. (3d)892

Sutton,Thomas N.T.

Respondent ON Appeal Municipal law — powersof municipalities

185. ONCA P.I.A. InvestmentsInc. v. DeerhurstLimited Partnership

08/01/01 [2000] O.J. No.3291, 20 C.B.R.(4th) 116

Hall, Geoff R. Respondent ON Appeal Receivers — property— equity trusts

186. ONCA Myers v. CanadianBroadcasting Corp.

06/12/01 2001 CanLII4874, [2001]O.J. No. 2228,54 O.R. (3d)626, 54 O.R.(3d) 633, 147O.A.C. 310, 6C.C.L.T. (3d)112, 105A.C.W.S. (3d)1172

Leonard,David E.


Torts — libel andslander — qualifiedprivilege — faircomment — malice —damages

187. ONCA Leenen v. CanadianBroadcasting Corp.

06/12/01 [2001] O.J. No.2229, 54 O.R.(3d) 612, 147O.A.C. 317, 6C.C.L.T. (3d)97, 2001 CanLII4997, 105A.C.W.S. (3d)977



Torts — libel andslander — defences —fair comment —qualified privilege —malice — damages

188. ONCA Ontario (Speaker ofthe LegislativeAssembly) v. Ontario(Human Rights

06/08/01 2001 CanLII8549, 40C.H.R.R. 246,[2001] O.J. No.

Finkelstein,Neil

Respondent ON Appeal Constitutional law —parliamentary privilege— human rights —jurisdiction of Human

Page 49



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


Commission) 2180, 54 O.R.(3d) 595, 201D.L.R. (4th)698,146 O.A.C.125,33 Admin. L.R.(3d) 123, 85C.R.R. (2d)170,105 A.C.W.S.(3d) 841

Rights Commission —discrimination

189. ONCA R. v. Inco Ltd. 06/06/01 [2001] O.J. No.2098, 54 O.R.(3d) 495, 146O.A.C. 66, 155C.C.C. (3d)383, 41C.E.L.R. (N.S.)9, 83 C.R.R.(2d) 189, 50W.C.B. (2d)225

Hamilton,Doug

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed by theSupreme Court ofCanada (R. v. IncoLtd., [2001]S.C.C.A. No. 436,160 O.A.C. 198,45 C.E.L.R. (N.S.)5, 03/07/2002)

Environmental law —Canadian Charter ofRights and Freedoms —statutes —interpretation — OntarioWater Resources Act

190. ONCA RTO AssetManagement Inc. v.Brewers Retail Inc.

05/11/01 [2001] O.J. No.1769, 145O.A.C. 378,105 A.C.W.S.(3d) 845

Hall, Geoff R. Appellant ON Appeal Contract — option —mechanism

191. ONCA Joncas v. SpruceFalls Power andPaper Co.

04/26/01 [2001] O.J. No.1505, 144O.A.C. 289, 15B.L.R. (3d) 1,104 A.C.W.S.(3d) 865, 2001CarswellOnt1401

Scott, WilliamG.

Respondent ON Appeal Company law —oppression remedy

Page 50



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


192. ONCA 978011 Ontario Ltd.v. CornellEngineering Co.

04/20/01 [2001] O.J. No.1446, 53 O.R.(3d) 783, 198D.L.R. (4th)615,144 O.A.C.262, 12 B.L.R.(3d) 240, 8C.C.E.L. (3d)169, 104A.C.W.S. (3d)676

Brown, JohnP.

Respondent ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed (978011Ontario Ltd. v.CornellEngineering Co.,[2001] S.C.C.A.No. 315; 158O.A.C. 195,11/01/2001)

Commercial law —contracts — terminationclause

193. ONCA Sharwood & Co. v.Municipal FinancialCorp.

03/20/01 [2001] O.J. No.927, 53 O.R.(3d) 470, 197D.L.R. (4th)477, 142O.A.C. 350, 12B.L.R. (3d) 219,104 A.C.W.S.(3d) 6

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Appellant ON Appeal Commercial law —breach of agreement —claim in contract —unjust enrichment

194. ONCA Komperda v. HongKong Bank ofCanada

03/01/01 [2001] O.J. No.659, 141O.A.C. 373

Brown, JohnP.

Respondent ON Appeal Banking — summaryjudgment — practice —civil litigation

195. ONCA Toronto-DominionBank v. Usarco Ltd.

02/28/01 [2001] O.J. No.649, 196 D.L.R.(4th) 448, 142O.A.C. 70, 24C.B.R. (4th)303, 17M.P.L.R. (3d)57, 103A.C.W.S. (3d)740

Morrison, F.PaulLeonard,David E.

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed,September 20,2001 ([2001]S.C.C.A. No. 217)

Real property tax —enforcement —receivers — claims —priorities — securedcreditor v. municipality

Page 51



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


196. ONCA Stegor Consultants(1988) Limited v.Mader

02/09/01 2001 CanLII24002, [2001]O.J. No. 376

Black, WilliamD.

Appellant ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed (StegorConsultants(1988) Ltd. v.Mader, [2001]S.C.C.A. No. 222,08/11/2001)

Equity — confidentialrelationships —fiduciary duty —misrepresentation

197. ONCA R. v. MacDiarmid 01/30/01 [2001] O.J. No.243, 140O.A.C. 287, 48W.C.B. (2d)495

Porter, DavidM.

Appellant ON Appeal Health law — criminallaw — fraud —sentencing —availability of fine

198. ONCA Canadian CommunityReading Plan Inc. v.Quality ServicePrograms Inc.

01/26/01 [2001] O.J. No.205, 141O.A.C. 289, 10B.L.R. (3d) 45,10 C.P.R. (4th)481, 102A.C.W.S. (3d)830

Houston,Donald

Respondent ON Appeal Torts — interferencewith economic relations— conspiracy —contracts — inducing orprocuring breach ofcontract

199. ONCA Dunn v. ChubbInsurance Co. ofCanada

01/18/01 [2011] O.J. No.296, 2011ONCA 36

Scott, WilliamG.

Respondent ON Appeal Corporations,partnerships andassociations law —insurance law — liabilityinsurance — directorsand officers insurance

200. ONCA Hi-Tech Group Inc.Sears Canada Inc.

01/11/01 [2001] O.J. No.33, 52 O.R.(3d) 97, 141O.A.C. 56, 11B.L.R. (3d) 197,4 C.P.C. (5

th)

35, 2001 CanLII

Wortzman,Susan

Respondent ON Appeal Civil procedure –summary judgment -

Page 52



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


24049, 2001CarswellOnt 9,102 A.C.W.S.(3d) 79,

201. ONCA Gryba v. MonetaPorcupine Mines Ltd.

12/20/00 5 C.C.E.L. (3d)43, 139 O.A.C.40, 2000 CanLII16997, [2000]O.J. No. 4775,26 C.C.P.B.108, 101A.C.W.S. (3d)1128

Cruz, Darryl A. Appellant ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed (Grybav. MonetaPorcupine MinesLtd., [2001]S.C.C.A. No. 92,09/08/2001)

Mining — labour andemployment —mitigation — stockoptions — dismissal

202. ONCA Marchand v. PublicGeneral HospitalSociety of Chatham

11/27/00 [2000] O.J. No.4428, 51 O.R.(3d) 97, 138O.A.C. 201, 43C.P.C. (5th) 65,101 A.C.W.S.(3d) 634

Ortved, W.Niels F.


Medical malpractice —negligence

203. ONCA Mississauga (City) v.Greater TorontoAirports Authority

11/03/00 [2000] O.J. No.4086, 50 O.R.(3d) 641, 192D.L.R. (4th)443, 138O.A.C. 1, 16M.P.L.R. (3d)213, 100A.C.W.S. (3d)790, 2000CanLII 16948

Brown, JohnP.

Appellant ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt ofCanada dismissed([2001] S.C.C.A.No. 83,06/14/2001)

Municipal law —interjurisdictionalimmunity —constitutional law —distribution of legislativeauthority — aeronautics— federal publicproperty

204. ONCA Bonfoco v. Dowd 10/17/00 2000 CanLII16885, [2000]O.J. No. 3799,136 O.A.C.

Steep, R. Paul Respondent ON Appeal Torts — medicalmalpractice — personalinjury — negligence —standard of care,

Page 53



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


339, 100A.C.W.S. (3d)244

particular persons andrelationships — medicaldoctors and medicalpersonnel — damages— where special skill orcompetence required —ureter — sutures —ovary

205. ONCA Christian Brothers ofIreland in Canada(Re)

10/04/00 2000 CanLII5712, 47 O.R.(3d) 674, 184D.L.R. (4th)445, 6 B.L.R.(3d) 151, 17C.B.R. (4th)168, 132O.A.C. 271,[2000] O.J. No.1117, 47 O.R.(3d) 674, 33E.T.R. (2d) 32,95 A.C.W.S.(3d) 1183

Finkelstein,Neil

Intervenor ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed(VancouverCollege Limited, etal. v. The ChristianBrothers of Irelandin Canada (inliquidation), et al.,[2007] S.C.C.A.No. 227,05/23/2002)

Trusts — charity —assets — immunity —tort — property law

206. ONCA R. v. Reeve 09/26/00 [2000] O.J. No.3538, 136O.A.C. 292, 14M.P.L.R. (3d)256, 99A.C.W.S. (3d)1062, 47W.C.B. (2d)374

Matheson,Andrew B.

Appellant ON Appeal Municipal law — bylaws— enforcement orprosecution — standardof proof — defences,legal nonconforminguse — practice — stayof proceedings, abuseof process

207. ONCA CorporacionTransnacional deInversiones v. StetInternational

09/15/00 49 O.R. (3d)414, 136O.A.C. 113,[2000] O.J. No.3408, 99

Sutton,Thomas N. T.

Appellant ON Appeal SCC refused leaveto appeal: [2000]S.C.C.A. No. 581

Internationalcommercial arbitration— model law —principles offundamental justice —

Page 54



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


A.C.W.S. (3d)537

agreements —arbitration — rogatory— confidentialityagreements

208. ONCA Moin v. BlueMountains (Town)

08/22/00 [2000] O.J. No.3039, 135O.A.C. 278, 13M.P.L.R. (3d) 1,99 A.C.W.S.(3d) 335

Reddon,Andrew J.

Respondent ON Appeal Municipal law —negligentmisrepresentation

209. ONCA Entrop v. Imperial OilLimited

07/21/00 [2000] O.J. No.2689, 50 O.R.(3d) 18, 189D.L.R. (4th) 14,137 O.A.C. 15,2 C.C.E.L. (3d)19, 98A.C.W.S. (3d)418, 2000CanlII 16800

Ortved, W.Niels F.Stephenson,Jenny P.

Appellant ON Appeal Human rights —discrimination —employment — on thebasis of physical ormental handicap —adverse effectdiscrimination — duty toaccommodate —exceptions, bona fide orreasonable occupationalrequirement orqualification

210. ONCA Wildenburg HoldingsLtd. v. Ontario(Minister of Revenue)

06/02/00 [2000] O.J. No.2053, 132O.A.C. 216,[2000] 3 C.T.C.148, 2001D.T.C. 5145,97 A.C.W.S.(3d) 565

Chua, Chia-yi Respondent ON Appeal Income tax —partnerships — losses— agreementsrespecting sharing ofloss

211. ONCA Cowper v. AtomicEnergy of CanadaLtd.

05/19/00 [2000] O.J. No.1730, 132O.A.C. 178, 1C.C.E.L. (3d)180, 96A.C.W.S. (3d)

Scott, WilliamG.

Appellant ON Appeal Employment law —damages — mitigation

Page 55



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


795

212. ONCA Shah v. XeroxCanada Ltd.

03/20/00 49 C.C.E.L.(2d) 166, 131O.A.C. 44,2000 CanLII231, [2000] O.J.No. 849, 95A.C.W.S. (3d)502

Cruz, Darryl A. Appellant ON Appeal Labour and employment— constructivedismissal

213. ONCA Robinson v.Sydenham DistrictHospital Corp.

03/09/00 [2000] O.J. No.703, 130O.A.C. 109, 95A.C.W.S. (3d)392

Mercer,Malcolm M.Hall, Geoff R.

Appellant ON Appeal Medicine — liability ofpractitioners —negligence or fault —standard of care —orthopaedic surgeons— burden of proof —damages — generaldamages — generaldamages for personalinjury — pre-trial loss ofwages or earnings

214. ONCA 607648 Ontario Ltd.(c.o.b.TelecommunicationsInternational/TCI) v.UnitelCommunications Inc.

02/18/00 [2000] O.J. No.496

Cruz, Darryl A. Respondent ON Appeal Breach of contract —practice — judgmentsand orders

215. ONCA Provincial SchoolsAuthority v.Federation ofProvincial SchoolsAuthority Teachers

02/15/00 [2000] O.J. No.345

Kapur, SunilRatelband,Ben

Respondent ON Appeal Labour law — industrialrelations — collectiveagreement,enforcement —jurisdiction or powers ofarbitrator or board —grievances

Page 56



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


216. ONCA ExtendicareInternational Inc. v.Ontario (Minister ofRevenue)

02/08/00 [2000] O.J. No.274, 47 O.R.(3d) 1, 129O.A.C. 154, 94A.C.W.S. (3d)1029

Chua, Chia-yi Respondent ON Appeal Taxation — sales tax —lessee unable to makepayments

217. ONCA NBD Bank, Canadav. Dofasco Inc.

12/15/99 1999 CanLII3826, 46 O.R.(3d) 514, 181D.L.R. (4th) 37,15 C.B.R. (4th)67, 127 O.A.C.338, [1999] O.J.No. 4749, 1B.L.R. (3d) 1,15 C.B.R. (4th)67, 47 C.C.L.T.(2d) 213, 93A.C.W.S. (3d)391

Burt, GlynnisP.

Appellant ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed (NBDBank, Canada v.Dofasco Inc.,[2000] S.C.C.A.No. 96,04/06/2000)

Commercial law — torts— liability — negligentmisrepresentation

218. ONCA 706434 Ontario Ltd.v. Krawec

12/02/99 [1999] O.J. No.4498

Freedlander,Jeffrey

Respondent ON Appeal Practice — pleadings —statement of claim —joinder — limitations —torts — negligence —company law

219. ONCA Wood v. CobourgDistrict GeneralHospital

10/21/99 [1999] O.J. No.3889, 125O.A.C. 370, 91A.C.W.S. (3d)1047

Peebles, Dana Appellant ON Appeal Causation — medicalmalpractice —negligence

220. ONCA ProgressivePackaging Ltd. v.Ontario (Minister ofFinance)

09/27/99 [1999] O.J. No.3613, 131O.A.C. 70, 95A.C.W.S. (3d)399

Chua, Chia-yi Respondent ON Appeal Income tax —computation of tax,rules for corporations —health tax

Page 57



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


221. ONCA Heynen v. Frito LayCanada Ltd.

09/27/99 [1999] O.J. No.3560, 45 O.R.(3d) 776, 179D.L.R. (4th)317, 124O.A.C. 341, 46C.C.E.L. (2d) 1,91 A.C.W.S.(3d) 261, 199CanLII 1386(ON C.A.)

Cruz, Darryl A. Respondent ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed(Heynen v. FritoLay Canada Ltd.,[1999] S.C.C.A.No. 569,03/08/2000)

Labour and employment— wrongful dismissal —termination —severance pay

222. ONCA Styres v. Ontario(Ministry of Finance)

09/24/99 [1999] O.J. No.3522, 43W.C.B. (2d)390

Chua, Chia-yi Appellant ON Appeal Sales and service taxes— tobacco tax —collection andenforcement — searchand seizure

223. ONCA Toronto-DominionBank v. LeighInstruments Ltd.(Trustee of)

09/13/99 [1999] O.J. No.3290, 45 O.R.(3d) 417, 178D.L.R. (4

th) 634,

124 O.A.C. 87,50 B.L.R. (2d)64, 1999 CanLII3778, 91A.C.W.S. (3d)125, 1999CarswellOnt2812

Wortzman,Susan

Respondents ON Appeal Appeal – letters ofcomfort

224. ONCA Teck Corp. v. Ontario(Minister of Finance)

09/09/99 [1999] O.J. No.3240, 124O.A.C. 58,90A.C.W.S. (3d)806

Chua, Chia-yi Respondent ON Appeal Mines and minerals —taxation — exemptions— statutes —interpretation

225. ONCA Ontario PublicService Employees'Union v. Ontario

08/24/99 [1999] O.J. No.3200

Kapur, Sunil Respondent ON Appeal Labour law — publicservice labour relations— grievances —

Page 58



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


(Management BoardSecretariat)

practice and procedure

226. ONCA R. v. Leatherdale 08/17/99 [1999] O.J. No.2990, 123O.A.C. 315, 43W.C.B. (2d)263

Porter, DavidM.

Appellant ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SCCdismissed ([1999]S.C.C.A. No. 490,04/23/2000).

Criminal law —jurisdiction ofpreliminary inquiry judge— improper weighing ofevidence whendetermining whetheraccused should becommitted to stand trial

227. ONCA Tamimi v. TorontoHospital (WesternDivision)

07/13/99 [1999] O.J. No.2632, 123O.A.C. 182,89 A.C.W.S.(3d) 1071

McLaughlin,Frank J.

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed, May 3 -2000 ([1999]S.C.C.A. No. 464)

Medicine — liability ofpractitioners — relationwith patient — consentto treatment —negligence or fault, dutyof the treating doctor toinform patient

228. ONCA Anderson v. Wilson 07/07/99 1999 CanLII3753, [1999]O.J. No. 2494,44 O.R. (3d)673, 175 D.L.R.(4th) 409,122O.A.C. 69,36 C.P.C. (4th)17, 89A.C.W.S. (3d)441

Leonard,David E.


Procedural law — civilprocedure — classactions

229. ONCA Chan v. Chiasson 06/23/99 1999 CanLII1985, [1999]O.J. No. 2356

Black, WilliamD.

Respondent ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed (Chanv. Chiasson,[1999] S.C.C.A.

Medical malpractice —summary judgment —negligence

Page 59



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


No. 447,18/05/2000)

230. ONCA R. v. Bingley 06/11/99 [1999] O.J. No.2037

Matheson,Andrew B.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law —summary convictionproceedings —informations — validity

231. ONCA Z-Mark InternationalInc. v. Leng NovakBlais Inc.

06/10/99 [1999] O.J. No.2014, 122O.A.C. 341, 88A.C.W.S. (3d)1109

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Practice — appeals —dismissal of appeals —foundations —thereafter — delivery —reasons — damage

232. ONCA Ontario Hydro v.Canada (Minister ofNational Revenue)

05/19/99 [1999] O.J. No.1723, 44 O.R.(3d) 1, 120O.A.C. 184, 99G.T.C. 7157,88 A.C.W.S.(3d) 507

Chua, Chia-yi Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SCCdismissed ([1999]S.C.C.A. No. 375,04/06/2000)

Taxation — statutes —interpretation —assessment — retailsales tax act

233. ONCA Ruggeberg v.Bancomer, S.A.

04/29/99 [1999] O.J. No.1432, 122O.A.C. 310,87 A.C.W.S.(3d) 910

Brown, JohnP.

Respondent ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed(Ruggeberg v.Bancomer, S.A.,[1999] S.C.C.A.No. 289,03/16/2000)

Conflict of laws —contracts — choice oflaw

234. ONCA R. v. Genereux 04/27/99 1999 CanLII1874, 44 O.R.(3d) 339, 136C.C.C. (3d)338, 119O.A.C. 102,[1999] O.J. No.

Burt, GlynnisP.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law —sentencing — medical

Page 60



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


1387, 42W.C.B. (2d)105

235. ONCA Kitakufe v. Canada 04/06/99 [1999] O.J. No.5546, 135C.C.C. (3d)255, 65 C.R.R.(2d) 189, 42W.C.B. (2d)173

Matheson,Andrew B.

Appellant ON Application Extradition — surrenderto demanding country— conditions precedent— immunity respectingother crimes committedbefore surrender (rule ofspecialty)

236. ONCA Robinson v. TheSisters of St. Josephof the Diocese ofPeterborough

02/26/99 [1999] O.J. No.530, 117O.A.C. 331,29 C.P.C. (4th)184, 86A.C.W.S. (3d)221

Scott, WilliamG.

Appellant ON Appeal Medical malpractice —expert evidence

237. ONCA Belsat VideoMarketing Inc. v.AstralCommunications Inc.,

02/12/99 1999 CanLII1092, [1999]O.J. No. 343,118 O.A.C.105, 86 C.P.R.(3d) 413, 86A.C.W.S. (3d)65

Steep, R. Paul Respondent ON Appeal Civil practice —pleadings —amendment ofpleadings — abuse ofprocess — summaryjudgment — trackjobbing —noncompetition —warehousing

238. ONCA Rashwan v. Marzouk 01/27/99 1999 CanLII1450, [1999]O.J. No. 208

Burt, GlynnisP.

Respondent ON Appeal Applications forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed(Rashwan v.Marzouk, [1999]S.C.C.A. No. 189,and [1999]S.C.C.A. No. 190,

Medical — practice —dismissal of action —delay

Page 61



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


12/02/1999)

239. ONCA Gerry's DistributorsLtd. v. Itwal Ltd.

01/22/99 [1999] O.J. No.170, 85A.C.W.S. (3d)339

McLaughlin,Frank J.

Respondent ON Appeal Sale of goods — breach— remedies of buyer —set-off, when available— equity — equitabledefences — set-off

240. ONCA Lukowski v. HatchAssociates Ltd.,

12/21/98 [1998] O.J. No.5345, 118O.A.C. 147,39 C.C.E.L.(2d) 177, 84A.C.W.S. (3d)908, 1998CanLII 5869

Steep, R. Paul Appellant ON Appeal Employment law —dismissal without cause— notice of dismissal —reasonable notice,calculation of length ofservice — damages —punitive damages

241. ONCA Kucor Construction &Developments &Associates v.Canada LifeAssurance Co.

11/13/98 [1998] O.J. No.4733, 41 O.R.(3d) 577, 167D.L.R. (4th)272, 114O.A.C. 201, 43B.L.R. (2d) 136,21 R.P.R. (3d)187, 83A.C.W.S. (3d)852

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Respondent ON Appeal Mortgages — paymentof mortgage —prepayment, statutoryrights

242. ONCA Furler v. Hagen 10/26/98 [1998] O.J. No.4402

Hall, Geoff R. Appellant ON Appeal Trial judge — reasonsfor judgment

243. ONCA Hatch Associates Ltd.v. Dual RemovalSystems Ltd.

10/23/98 1998 CanLII4840, [1998]O.J. No. 4353

Black, WilliamD.

Respondent ON Appeal Contracts — estoppel— company law —guarantee andindemnity

Page 62



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


244. ONCA Pente InvestmentManagement Ltd. v.Schneider Corp.

10/20/98 [1998] O.J. No.4142, 42 O.R.(3d) 177, 113O.A.C. 253,44 B.L.R. (2d)115, 83A.C.W.S. (3d)51

Steep, R. Paul Respondent ON Appeal Company law —fundamental changesand shareholders' rights— takeover oracquisition of control

245. ONCA Flaska Estate (Re) 10/20/98 [1998] O.J. No.4171, 83A.C.W.S. (3d)532

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Respondent ON Appeal Supplementaryendorsement([1998] O.J. No.4171)

Executors andadministrators —compensation —amount ofcompensation —calculation — appeals

246. ONCA Eagleson v.Dowbiggan

10/01/98 1998 CanLII7181, [1998]O.J. No. 3919,113 O.A.C.195, 31 C.P.C.(4th) 181, 82A.C.W.S. (3d)1038

Leonard,David E.

Respondent ON Appeal Media law — libel andslander — defamation

247. ONCA Brewers Retail Inc. v.Great Lakes BrewingInc.

09/18/98 [1998] O.J. No.3702

Stephenson,Jenny P.

Respondent ON Appeal Promissory estoppel —civil practice — pre-judgment interest —appeals

248. ONCA AD Technologies Inc.v. Algoma Steel Inc.

09/03/98 [1998] O.J. No.3486

Burt, GlynnisP.

Appellant ON Appeal Practice — software —contracts

249. ONCA Hulme v. CadillacFairview CorporationLimited

08/12/98 [1998] O.J. No.3237

Scott, WilliamG.

Respondent ON Appeal Employment —wrongful dismissal

250. ONCA Hanis v. Teevan 06/18/98 [1998] O.J. No.2560, 162D.L.R. (4th)

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Respondent ON Appeal Education — wrongfuldismissal —employment contract —

Page 63



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


414, 111O.A.C. 91, 39B.L.R. (2d) 66,37 C.C.E.L.(2d) 1, 81C.P.R. (3d)496, 80A.C.W.S. (3d)573

copyright infringement

251. ONCA Assn. of ProfessionalEngineers of Ontariov. Hafeez

06/03/98 [1998] O.J. No.2270

Peebles, DanaM.

Appellant ON Appeal Contempt — motionjudge erred in failing tomake contempt order

252. ONCA Lakeport BrewingCorp. v. BrewersRetail Inc.

05/15/98 [1998] O.J. No.1996

Steep, R. Paul Respondent ON Appeal Civil practice — appeals— evidence on appeal— admission of newevidence

253. ONCA R. v. Bechard 04/17/98 [1998] O.J. No.1591

Matheson,Andrew B.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law — appeals— appeals fromconviction

254. ONCA Trans EasternLumber Corp. v.Kingston MunicipalNon-ProfitHousing Corp.

04/16/98 [1998] O.J. No.1575

Reddon,Andrew J.

Respondent ON Appeal Trusts — lien

255. ONCA Tsopotos (Guardianof) v. Tepperman

04/15/98 1998 CanLII4121, [1998]O.J. No. 1571

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Medicine — liability ofpractitioners —negligence or fault —obstetrical orgynaecological care

256. ONCA Aucoin v. St.Catharines GeneralHospital

03/23/98 [1998] O.J. No.1194

Brown, JohnP.

Appellant ON Appeal Medicine — liability ofpractitioners —negligence or fault

Page 64



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


257. ONCA Guarantee Co. ofNorth America v.Gordon Capital Corp.

03/23/98 [1998] O.J. No.1197, 38 O.R.(3d) 563, 157D.L.R. (4th)643, 108O.A.C. 46, 3C.C.L.I. (3d)202, [1998]I.L.R. I-3555,78 A.C.W.S.(3d) 367

Steep, R. Paul Appellant ON Appeal Reversed by theSCC ([1999]S.C.J. No. 60;[1999] A.C.S. no60; [1999] 3S.C.R. 423; [1999]3 R.C.S. 423; 178D.L.R. (4th) 1; 247N.R. 97; 126O.A.C. 1; 49B.L.R. (2d) 68; 15C.C.L.I. (3d) 1; 39C.P.C. (4th) 100;[2000] I.L.R. I-3741; 1999CanLII664; 91A.C.W.S. (3d)796)

Insurance — actionsagainst insurer —limitations —repudiation

258. ONCA Ruscetta v. Graham 03/23/98 [1998] O.J. No.1198, 114O.A.C. 320,36 C.C.E.L.(2d) 177, 78A.C.W.S. (3d)297, 1998CanLII 2118

Leonard,David E.


Labour law — collectiveagreement,enforcement — civilaction

259. ONCA Palmeri v. DiPoce 03/19/98 1998 CanLII2712, [1998]O.J. No. 1164

Cruz, Darryl A. Respondent ON Appeal Barrister and solicitor —negligence — damages

260. ONCA Bryars v. TorontoGeneral Hospital

02/25/98 [1998] O.J. No.785, 38 O.R.(3d) 460,158 D.L.R. (4th)121, 108O.A.C. 396,1C.C.L.I. (3d)297, 77

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Damages — deductionsfor payments orassistance by thirdparties — by statute orgovernment —government insurancebenefits — hospital andmedical care — practice

Page 65



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


A.C.W.S. (3d)1191

— appeals — effect oncosts

261. ONCA R. v. K.A.G. 02/20/98 [1998] O.J. No.731

Matheson,Andrew B.

Appellant ON Appeal Evidence — witnesses— credibility — oath-helping

262. ONCA Nairne v. WagonWheel Ranch Ltd.

02/12/98 [1998] O.J. No.533, 77A.C.W.S. (3d)1119

Stephenson,Jenny P.

Appellant ON Appeal Tort law — negligence— doctrine of volentinon fit injuria

263. ONCA Martins v. Barsoum 02/04/98 [1998] O.J. No.441

Leonard,David E.

Respondent ON Appeal Medicine — relationwith patient — consentto treatment

264. ONCA Burt v. Tony's LinenDry Goods Ltd.

01/21/98 [1998] O.J. No.226

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Appellant ON Appeal Practice — appeals

265. ONCA R. v. Alfred 01/08/98 [1998] O.J. No.70, 105 O.A.C.373, 122C.C.C. (3d)213, 37 W.C.B.(2d) 192, 1998CarswellOnt 39

Porter, DavidM.

Respondent ON Appeal Criminal law — medicalprofessional — Crownappeal of sentence fromconviction of indecentassault and sexualassault

266. ONCA R. v. Hollingshead 12/02/97 [1997] O.J. No.4865

Arbuck, Ava Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law –Sentencing – Appeals,variation of sentence

267. ONCA Canadian Pacific Ltd.v. Canada (Directorof Investigation andResearch)

09/19/97 1997 CanLII3618, 103O.A.C. 310,[1997] O.J. No.3762

Finkelstein,Neil

Appellant ON Appeal Appeal to theSupreme Court ofCanadadiscontinued(Canadian PacificLtd. v. Canada(Director ofInvestigation and

Trade regulation —competition —Competition Act —appeal from ordersmade at investigatorystage

Page 66



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


Research) [1997]S.C.C.A. 584,[1997] S.C.C.A.585, [1997]S.C.C.A. 586,[1997] S.C.C.A.587, [1997]S.C.C.A. 588)

268. ONCA Bryars Estate v.Toronto GeneralHospital

09/17/97 [1997] O.J. No.3727, 152D.L.R. (4th)243, 103O.A.C. 53, 73A.C.W.S. (3d)1054

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Costs ([1998] O.J.No. 785; 38 O.R.(3d) 460; 158D.L.R. (4th) 121;108 O.A.C. 396; 1C.C.L.I. (3d) 297;77 A.C.W.S. (3d)1191)

Medicine — liability ofpractitioners —standard of care —anaesthesia —evidence and proof

269. ONCA Moin v. Collingwood(Township)

09/11/97 [1997] O.J. No.3615

Reddon,Andrew J.

Appellant ON Appeal Retrial of case:[1998] O.J. No.6699

Negligence — breach ofcontract — summaryjudgment

270. ONCA Sheng v. Toronto(Metropolitan) PoliceServices Board

09/02/97 [1997] O.J. No.3503

Leonard,David E.

Respondent ON Appeal Pleadings —amendment ofpleadings — statementof claim

271. ONCA CIBC Mortgage Corp.v. Chopra

08/29/97 [1997] O.J. No.3458, 35 O.R.(3d) 362, 149D.L.R. (4th)761, 103O.A.C. 138, 11R.P.R. (3d)123, 73A.C.W.S. (3d)527

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Respondent ON Appeal Mortgages — mortgageactions — action forforeclosure and sale —practice — service

272. ONCA Wall v. McCleary 07/31/97 [1997] O.J. No.3178

Leonard,David E.

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SCCdismissed ([1997]

Negligentmisrepresentation —new evidence —

Page 67



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


S.C.C.A. No. 477,12/18/1997)

medical malpractice

273. ONCA R. v. Kotyk 06/16/97 [1997] O.J. No.2432

Matheson,Andrew B.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law —sentencing — appeals,variation of sentence —grounds for varyingsentence

274. ONCA 1088163 Ontario Ltd.v. 9014-7661 QuebecInc.

05/16/97 [1997] O.J. No.2022

Hall, Geoff R. Respondent ON Appeal Conflict of laws —actions — forumconveniens

275. ONCA LCI International Inc.v. STN Inc.

05/08/97 [1997] O.J. No.1948

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Respondent ON Appeal Bankruptcy — propertyof bankrupt — particularproperty — customercontracts — creditors —claims — interest inbankrupt's assets,determination of

276. ONCA Hong v. Onica 04/03/97 [1997] O.J. No.1331

Hall, Geoff R. Appellant ON Appeal Practice — appeals

277. ONCA Canada Packers Inc.v. Medical TextilesMarketing Inc.

03/27/97 [1997] O.J. No.1285

Black, WilliamD.

Respondent ON Appeal Contracts — formationof contract —consensus oragreement — terms

278. ONCA R. v. Jones 02/19/97 [1997] O.J. No.613, 32 O.R.(3d) 365, 97O.A.C. 290,113 C.C.C. (3d)225, 5 C.R. (4

th)

364, 34 W.C.B.(2d) 4

Arbuck, Ava Appellant ON Appeal Civil rights – detentionand imprisonment – bailand interim release –right to have validity ofdetention determined byway of habeas corpus –right to bail hearing

Page 68



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


279. ONCA Warneke Inc. v.(c.o.b. KWIConstruction) v.LaurentianCasualty Co. of

Canada

01/20/97 [1997] O.J. No.223

Scott, WilliamG.

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed: [1997]S.C.C.A. No. 193

Insurance law — thirdparty claimant

280. ONCA L'Agence Monitairede Qatar v. Himadeh

12/20/96 [1996] O.J. No.4467

Houston,Donald

Appellant ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed ([1997]S.C.C.A. No. 110,02/17/1997)

Practice — appeals —duty of appellate courtre: findings of credibilityby trial judge —evidence — paroleevidence rule

281. ONCA R. v. Verma 12/17/96 [1996] O.J. No.4418, 31 O.R.(3d) 622, 96O.A.C. 63, 112C.C.C. (3d)155, 33 W.C.B.(2d) 116

Porter, DavidM.

Respondent ON Appeal Criminal law — medicalprofessional — Crownappeal of acquittal —statutory interpretationof Narcotic Control Act

282. ONCA R. v. Potvin 11/18/96 [1996] O.J. No.4035

Arbuck, Ava Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law – Sentence– Sentence, particularoffences – Fraud –Appeal, variation ofsentence – Grounds forvarying sentenceimposed by trial judge -Probation

283. ONCA Litowitz v. StandardLife Assurance Co.(Trustee of); Vale v.Sun Life AssuranceCo. of Canada; Valev. Sun Life AssuranceCo. of Canada; Gliedv. Confederation LifeInsurance Co.

10/31/96 [1996] O.J. No.3816, 30 O.R.(3d) 579, 143D.L.R. (4th) 77,94 O.A.C. 274,5 R.P.R. (3d)161, 68A.C.W.S. (3d)755

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Appellant ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed, April17, 1997 (SCCFile No. 25692(Litowitz). SCCBulletin, 1997, p.702. SCC File No.25714 (Vale). SCCBulletin, 1997, pp.

Mortgages — paymentof mortgage —prepayment — rights ofbeneficial owners —interest

Page 69



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


703)** Notice ofdiscontinuance ofapplication forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadafiled March 13,1997. SCC FileNo. 25720. SCCBulletin, 1997, p.526

284. ONCA Ordon Estate v. Grail 10/22/96 [1996] O.J. No.3659, 30 O.R.(3d) 643, 140D.L.R. (4th) 52,94 O.A.C. 241,66 A.C.W.S.(3d) 273

Hall, Geoff R. Respondent ON Appeal Affirmed by theSupreme Court ofCanada ([1998]S.C.J. No. 84;[1998] A.C.S. no84; [1998] 3S.C.R. 437; [1998]3 R.C.S. 437; 40O.R. (3d) 639; 166D.L.R. (4th) 193;232 N.R. 201; J.E.98-2410; 115O.A.C. 1; 1998CanLII 771; 83A.C.W.S. (3d) 897;REJB 1998-09407)

Courts — jurisdiction —actions in personam —personal injury actions— boating accidents onprovincial inland waters— applicable legislation

285. ONCA ConfederationFinancial Services(Canada) Ltd. v.Zurich Indemnity Co.of Canada

09/10/96 [1996] O.J. No.3041

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed, March13, 1997 ([1996]S.C.C.A. No. 537)

Evidence — practice —appeals — trial de novo

286. ONCA Toronto-DominionBank v. FederatedFoods Ltd.

08/22/96 1996 CanLII2451, [1996]O.J. No. 2871

Hall, Geoff R. Appellant ON Appeal Leave to appealrefused: [1996]S.C.C.A. No. 508

Contract —interpretation — royaltypayment

Page 70



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


287. ONCA Skinner v. RoyalVictoria Hospital

07/18/96 [1996] O.J. No.2590

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Appellant ON Appeal Medicine — liability ofpractitioners —negligence or fault

288. ONCA Bloudoff v. Dolezel 04/24/96 [1996] O.J. No.1447

Burt, GlynnisP.

Respondent ON Appeal Medicine — liability —evidence and proof —causation

289. ONCA Air Canada v. Ontario(Minister of Revenue)

03/08/96 1996 CanLII2009, [1996]O.J. No. 831,28 O.R. (3d)97, 133 D.L.R.(4th) 83, 89O.A.C. 278, 4G.T.C. 6082, 61A.C.W.S. (3d)891


Appellant ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed (AirCanada v. Ontario(Minister ofRevenue), [1996]S.C.C.A. No. 222,09/26/1996)

Aviation fuel — tax —airlines — aircraft —gasoline

290. ONCA R. v. Green 03/05/96 [1996] O.J. No.796

Arbuck, Ava Appellant On Appeal Criminal law - Appeals

291. ONCA Campbell v.Campbell

02/16/96 [1996] O.J. No.570, 21 R.F.L.(4th) 283, 61A.C.W.S. (3d)335

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Appellant ON Appeal Family law —maintenance of wivesand children

292. ONCA Cronk v. CanadianGeneral InsuranceCo.

09/21/95 [1995] O.J. No.2751, 25 O.R.(3d) 505, 128D.L.R. (4th)147, 85 O.A.C.54, 23 B.L.R.(2d) 70, 14C.C.E.L. (2d) 1,95 CLLC para.210-038, 1995CanLII 814,57 A.C.W.S.

Scott, WilliamG.

Appellant ON Appeal Employment law —wrongful dismissal —damages

Page 71



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


(3d) 449

293. ONCA Gerula v. Flores 08/01/95 [1995] O.J. No.2300, 126D.L.R. (4th)506, 83 O.A.C.128, 1995CarswellOnt1683, 56A.C.W.s. (3d)996

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Motion fordirections, [1996]O.J. No. 449; 89O.A.C. 180; 61A.C.W.S. (3d) 176

Medicine — relationwith patient — consentto treatment — standardof disclosure by doctor— negligence or fault,duty of doctor to informpatient — liability ofpractitioners — breachof contract — whatconstitutes —negligence or fault —surgical operations bydoctors — damages —general damage awards— loss of earningcapacity — loss ofprospective earnings —punitive damages

294. ONCA Air Canada v. LiquorControl Board ofOntario

07/04/95 1995 CanLII979, [1995] O.J.No. 1979, 24O.R. (3d) 403,126 D.L.R. (4th)301, 82 O.A.C.81, 3 G.T.C.8215, 56A.C.W.S. (3d)452


Respondent ON Appeal Varied by theSupreme Court ofCanada [1997]S.C.J. No. 66;[1997] A.C.S. no66; [1997] 2S.C.R. 581; [1997]2 R.C.S. 581; 33O.R. (3d) 479; 148D.L.R. (4th) 193;214 N.R. 1; J.E.97-1385; 102O.A.C. 1; 5 G.T.C.7251; 72 A.C.W.S.(3d) 188

Air law — provincialliquor control — mark-ups — gallonage fees

Page 72



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


295. ONCA RichardsonGreenshieldsof Canada Ltd. v.Kalmacoff

04/07/95 [1995] O.J. No.941, 22 O.R.(3d) 577, 123D.L.R. (4th)628, 80 O.A.C.98, 18 B.L.R.(2d) 197, 54A.C.W.S. (3d)477

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed,September 28,1995 (SCC Fileno. 24758. SCCBulletin, 1995, p.1395)

Derivative action — s.339 of the Trust andLoan Companies Act

296. ONCA Diefenbacher v.Young

04/07/95 [1995] O.J. No.939, 22 O.R.(3d) 641, 123D.L.R. (4th)641, 80 O.A.C.216, 54A.C.W.S. (3d)582

Scott, WilliamG.

Respondent ON Appeal Corporation law —partnership — goodwill

297. ONCA Daniel MarkhamFarms Ltd. v. GentraCanada InvestmentsInc.(subnom.Gentra CanadaInvestments Inc. v.724270 OntarioLtd.(Receiver of))

03/25/95 1995 CanLII806, [1995] O.J.No. 771

Steep, R. PaulHall, Geoff

Appellant ON Appeal Landlord and tenant —long term leases —leasehold mortgages —termination, forfeitureand re-entry —termination — tenant’sobligations — repairs —by tenant upontermination of lease —standard of repair

298. ONCA Verdun v. Toronto-Dominion Bank

01/12/95 [1995] O.J. No.4288

Ortved, W.Niels F.Steep, R. Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Affirmed Verdun v.Toronto-DominionBank [1996] S.C.J.No. 50

Banks and banking —interpretation of BankAct — practice

299. ONCA Kempton v. Park 11/21/94 1994 CanLII627, [1994] O.J.No. 2651, 51A.C.W.S. (3d)735

Cruz, Darryl A. Respondent ON Appeal Medical — malpractice— practice — duty ofappellate court

Page 73



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


300. ONCA Bank of Montreal v.Trefal Holdings Ltd.

09/28/94 [1994] O.J. No.3484

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Respondent ON Appeal Receivers — property— sale of property —court approval

301. ONCA Standard Trust Co. v.Brillinger

09/20/94 [1994] O.J. No.2052

Reddon,Andrew J.

Appellant ON Appeal Proceeds of sale — rateof interest

302. ONCA R. v. Varga 05/25/94 [1994] O.J. No.1111, 18 O.R.(3d) 784, 72O.A.C. 141, 90C.C.C. (3d)484, 30 C.R.(4th) 78, 23W.C.B. (2d)531

Porter, DavidM.

Respondent ON Appeal Criminal law — medicalprofessional — Crownappeal of acquittal ofrape charge

303. ONCA Mernick (Re) 04/29/94 [1994] O.J. No.3664, 25 C.B.R.(3d) 225, 47A.C.W.S. (3d)476

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Respondent ON Appeal Bankruptcy —proposals — courtapproval

304. ONCA Olson v. Gullo 03/28/94 [1994] O.J. No.587, 17 O.R.(3d) 790, 113D.L.R. (4th) 42,71 O.A.C. 327,20 B.L.R. (2d)47, 54 C.P.R.(3d) 497, 2E.T.R. (2d) 286,38 R.P.R. (2d)204, 46A.C.W.S. (3d)971

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed,October 13, 1994([1994] S.C.C.A.No. 248)

Partnership — secretprofit — fiduciary —share — forfeiture

305. ONCA Arthur Andersen Inc.v. Toronto-DominionBank

03/07/94 [1994] O.J. No.427, 17 O.R.(3d) 363, 71

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed,September 15,

Banks and banking —construction liens —trust fund — contracts

Page 74



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


O.A.C. 1, 14B.L.R. (2d) 1,13 C.L.R. (2d)185, 46A.C.W.S. (3d)478

1994 ([1994]S.C.C.A. No. 189)

— interpretation

306. ONCA Ontario HomeBuilders' Assn. v.York Region Board ofEducation

02/09/94 1994 CanLII8710, 17 O.R.(3d) 103, 109D.L.R. (4th)289, 69 O.A.C.216, [1994] O.J.No. 192, 19M.P.L.R. (2d) 1,45 A.C.W.S.(3d) 881


Appellant ON Appeal Affirmed byOntario HomeBuilders' Assn. v.York RegionBoard ofEducation, [1996]S.C.J. No. 80;[1996] A.C.S. no80; [1996] 2S.C.R. 929; [1996]2 R.C.S. 929; 137D.L.R. (4th) 449;201 N.R. 81; 35M.P.L.R. (2d) 1; 4R.P.R. (3d) 1; 65A.C.W.S. (3d) 33

Constitutional law —division of powers —Canadian Charter ofRights and Freedoms —indirect taxation —regulatory scheme

307. ONCA Toronto v. Quickfall 02/01/94 [1994] O.J. No.142, 16 O.R.(3d) 665, 111D.L.R. (4th)687, 68 O.A.C.190, 88 C.C.C.(3d) 333, 20C.R.R. (2d)312, 19M.P.L.R. (2d)161, 22 W.C.B.(2d) 364


Intervenor ON Appeal Canadian Charter ofRights and Freedoms —freedom of expression— absolute ban onpostering on municipalproperty

308. ONCA Meyer v. Bright;Dalgliesh v. Green;Lento v. Castaldo

10/22/93 [1993] O.J. No.2446, 15 O.R.(3d) 129, 110

Finkelstein,Neil

Intervenor ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canada

Insurance — automobileinsurance — no faultscheme — entitlement

Page 75



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


D.L.R. (4th)354, 67 O.A.C.134, 17 C.C.L.I.(2d) 1, 48M.V.R. (2d) 1,1993 CanLII3389, 45A.C.W.S. (3d)1136

dismissed (Lentov. Castaldo, [1993]S.C.C.A. No. 540;[1994] 1 S.C.R. vi;17 O.R. (3d) xvi;110 D.L.R. (4th)vii; 71 O.A.C. 399n; 22 C.C.L.I. (2d)189 n; 3 M.V.R.(3d) 61 n; 23908,04/31/1994)

to sue — serious injury,what constitutes

309. ONCA Livingston v. ZantavLtd. (c.o.b. ZanzibarCircus Tavern)

08/13/93 [1993] O.J. No.1827

Freedlander,Jeffrey

Appellant ON Appeal Damages — special —lost income — torts

310. ONCA Wirsing v. AnneAdams Real EstateInc.

07/13/93 [1993] O.J. No.1603

Brown, JohnP.

Respondent ON Appeal Damages — liability —expert evidence

311. ONCA R. v. B.W. 06/28/93 [1993] O.J. No.1513

Porter, DavidM.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law — medicalprofessional — appeal— inadmissibleevidence and jurycharge — new trialordered

312. ONCA Ontex Resources Ltd.v. MetaloreResources Ltd.

06/04/93 [1993] O.J. No.1236, 13 O.R.(3d) 229, 103D.L.R. (4th)158, 63 O.A.C.258, 12 B.L.R.(2d) 226, 40A.C.W.S. (3d)778

Brown, JohnP.

Appellant ON Appeal Application forleave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed (OntexResources Ltd. v.MetaloreResources Ltd.,[1993] S.C.C.A.No. 370, [1993] 4S.C.R. vi, 107D.L.R. (4th) vii,166 N.R. 238, 69

Torts — commercial law— contracts —remedies — fraud —fiduciary relationships— mining

Page 76



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


O.A.C. 160, 12B.L.R. (2d) 226,23727,12/23/1993)

313. ONCA Central Capital Corp.v. 819187 OntarioLtd.

04/05/93 [1993] O.J. No.761

Peebles, DanaM.

Respondent ON Appeal Corporate law — appealfrom contempt finding— reasonableapprehension of bias

314. ONCA Lucarini v. YorkHumber Ltd.

12/21/92 [1992] O.J. No.3646

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Appellant ON Appeal Contracts — terms —return of deposit —interpretation ofcontracts

315. ONCA CanadianBroadcasting Corp. v.Dagenais

12/18/92 12 O.R. (3d)239, [1992] O.J.No. 2703, 99D.L.R. (4th)326, 59 O.A.C.310, 12 C.R.R.(2d) 229, 37A.C.W.S. (3d)630

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Intervenor ON Appeal Appeal allowed,December 8, 1994(SCC File no.23403. SCCBulletin, 1994, p.1921)

Constitutional law —Canadian Charter ofRights and Freedoms —freedom of expression— criminal law —publication bans

316. ONCA Assn. of ProfessionalEngineers of Ontariov. North Dorchester(Township)

12/09/92 [1992] O.J. No.3650

Porter, DavidM.

Appellant ON Appeal Professionaloccupations —engineers —unauthorized practiced

317. ONCA Hudson's Bay Co. v.Canada (Director ofInvestigation andResearch under theCompetition Act)

07/08/92 [1992] O.J. No.1497, 10 O.R.(3d) 89, 58O.A.C. 7, 42C.P.R. (3d)448, 34A.C.W.S. (3d)762

Finkelstein,Neil

Appellant ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed(Hudson's Bay Co.v. Canada(Director ofInvestigation andResearch,Competition Act),[1992] S.C.C.A.

Constitutional law —criminal law — divisionof powers — appeal —seizure — searchwarrants

Page 77



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


No. 335; [1993] 3S.C.R. vi; 15 O.R.(3d) xvi; 163 N.R.79 n; 67 O.A.C.158 n; 50 C.P.R.(3d) v, Docket23006,10/14/1992)

318. ONCA R. v. Town 03/11/92 [1992] O.J. No.475

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Respondent ON Appeal Criminal law — appeals— fresh evidence —sentence — sexualassault

319. ONCA Jengle v. Keetch 03/09/92 7 O.R. (3d)187, [1992] O.J.No. 425, 89D.L.R. (4th) 15,54 O.A.C. 30822 R.P.R. (2d)53, 32A.C.W.S. (3d)494

McLaughlin,Frank J.

Respondent ON Appeal Real property —easements — right ofway

320. ONCA R. v. Singh 02/07/92 [1992] O.J. No.219

Porter, DavidM.

Respondent ON Appeal Criminal law — medicalprofessional —sentencing — Crownappeal of noncustodialsentence

321. ONCA Ramsden v.Peterborough

10/22/91 [1991] O.J. No.1804, 5 O.R.(3d) 289, 85D.L.R. (4th) 76,50 O.A.C. 328,7 C.R.R. (2d)288, 7 M.P.L.R.(2d) 57, 29A.C.W.S. (3d)628

Finkelstein,Neil

Intervenor ON Appeal Affirmed by theSupreme Court ofCanada [1993]S.C.J. No. 87;[1993] A.C.S. no87; [1993] 2S.C.R. 1084;[1993] 2 R.C.S.1084; 15 O.R. (3d)548; 106 D.L.R.

Constitutional law —Canadian Charter ofRights and Freedoms —freedom of expression— postering —municipal bylaw

Page 78



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


(4th) 233; 156N.R. 2; J.E. 93-1525; 66 O.A.C.10; 23 C.R. (4th)391; 16 C.R.R.(2d) 240; 16M.P.L.R. (2d) 1;42 A.C.W.S. (3d)441

322. ONCA R. v. Dussault 10/15/91 [1991] O.J. No.1774, 50O.A.C. 358, 32M.V.R. (2d) 27,14 W.C.B. (2d)166

Porter, DavidM.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law —constitutional law —Canadian Charter ofRights and Freedoms —whether s. 10(b) right tocounsel was infringed

323. ONCA Armak ChemicalsLtd. v. CanadianNational Railway Co.

04/15/91 [1991] O.J. No.536, 3 O.R.(3d) 1, 80D.L.R. (4th)675, 46 O.A.C.292, 26A.C.W.S. (3d)1358

Morrison, F. P. Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal toSCC dismissed([1991] S.C.C.A.No. 414,02/06/1992)

Railways — damages— negligence —economic loss

324. ONCA R. v. Gesualdo 02/27/91 [1991] O.J. No.3066

Black, WilliamD.

Respondent ON Appeal Criminal law —sentencing — variationof sentence

325. ONCA Askin v. OntarioHospital Association

02/20/91 2 O.R. (3d)641, [1991] O.J.No. 211, 46O.A.C. 278, 34C.C.E.L. 11, 25A.C.W.S. (3d)1004

McLaughlin,Frank J.

Respondent ON Appeal Medicine — pensions —contributors — surplusin defined benefit plan

326. ONCA Ontario Hydro v.Ontario (LabourRelations Board)

01/28/91 [1991] O.J. No.99, 1 O.R. (3d)737, 77 D.L.R.

Finkelstein,Neil

Respondent ON Appeal Affirmed by theSupreme Court ofCanada [1993]

Labour law —constitutional law —division of powers —

Page 79



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


(4th) 277, 43O.A.C. 184, 91CLLC 12129,25 A.C.W.S.(3d) 44

S.C.J. No. 99;[1993] A.C.S. no99; [1993] 3S.C.R. 327; [1993]3 R.C.S. 327; 107D.L.R. (4th) 457;158 N.R. 161; J.E.93-1718; 66O.A.C. 241; 93CLLC 12338; 43A.C.W.S. (3d) 52

certification — labourrelations — energy

327. ONCA Earl v. Koloszar 01/17/91 [1991] O.J. No.45

Reddon,Andrew J.

Respondent ON Appeal Civil procedure —default judgment

328. ONCA Ciarlariello v.Schacter

01/11/91 [1991] O.J. No.43, 76 D.L.R.(4th) 449, 44O.A.C. 385, 5C.C.L.T. (2d)221, 24A.C.W.S. (3d)1020

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Appeal to theSupreme Court ofCanada -dismissed ([1993]S.C.J. No. 4;[1993] A.C.S. no4; [1993] 2 S.C.R.11; [1993] 2R.C.S. 11; 100D.L.R. (4th) 60;151 N.R. 133; J.E.93-868; 62 O.A.C.161; 15 C.C.L.T.(2d) 209; 39A.C.W.S. (3d)882)

Physicians andsurgeons — lack ofinformed consent for thecontinuation of anongoing angiogramprocedure

329. ONCA S & A Strasser Ltd. v.Richmond Hill (Town)

12/18/90 [1990] O.J. No.2321, 1 O.R.(3d) 243, 45O.A.C. 394, 49C.P.C. (2d)234, 24A.C.W.S. (3d)

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Appeal Costs

Page 80



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


597, 1990CarswellOnt435

330. ONCA Rothwell v. Raes 12/14/90 [1990] O.J. No.2298, 2 O.R.(3d) 332, 76D.L.R. (4th)280, 24A.C.W.S. (3d)708

Stephenson,Jenny P.

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SCC refused135 N.R. 78 n, 49O.A.C. 398 n, 79DLR (4th) vii,(S.C.C., May 23,1991)

Tort law — negligence— causation —vaccines and braindamage

331. ONCA R. v. Ellis-Don Ltd. 12/03/90 [1990] O.J. No.2208, 1 O.R.(3d) 193, 76D.L.R. (4th)347, 42 O.A.C.49, 61 C.C.C.(3d) 423, 34C.C.E.L. 130, 2C.R. (4th) 118,5 C.R.R. (2d)263, 24A.C.W.S. (3d)188, 11 W.C.B.(2d) 457

Peebles, DanaM.

Appellant ON Appeal Reversed by theSupreme Court ofCanada (R. v.Ellis-Don Ltd.,[1992] S.C.J. No.33, 03/21/1992)

Occupational Healthand Safety Act —constitutional law —Canadian Charter ofRights and Freedoms s.11(d)

332. ONCA MeadowfieldVentures Inc. v.Kennedy

11/19/90 [1990] O.J. No.2174, 75 O.R.(2d) 760, 42O.A.C. 319, 45C.P.C. (2d)113, 24A.C.W.S. (3d)24

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Respondent ON Appeal Civil procedure — offerto settle

333. ONCA Armoshep PropertiesInc. v. Finn

10/19/90 [1990] O.J. No.1920

Steep, R. Paul Appellant ON Appeal Real estate —agreement of purchaseand sale — Registry Act— registration –

Page 81



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


requirements —restrictive covenants —

334. ONCA Duyn Estate v.Hamilton PsychiatricHospital

09/10/90 [1990] O.J. No.1907

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Respondent ON Appeal Medical — limitationperiod — s.62 of theMental Health Act — s.9of the Mental HospitalAct

335. ONCA Chu v. 397318Ontario Ltd.

06/21/90 [1990] O.J. No.1032

Houston,Donald

Appellant ON Appeal Real estate — failure toclose — agreement ofpurchase and sale

336. ONCA Royal Trust Corp. v.Feder Estate

06/21/90 [1990] O.J. No.1517

Houston,Donald

Respondent ON Appeal Jurisdiction — appeal —interlocutory order

337. ONCA R. v. Merrett 05/17/90 [1990] O.J. No.2069

Porter, DavidM.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law — sexualoffence — sentencevaried to time served

338. ONCA R. v. Logan 05/10/90 [1990] O.J. No.2780

Houston,Donald

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law — appeals— conviction andsentence

339. ONCA R. v. Gillespie 04/20/90 [1990] O.J. No.604

Porter, DavidM.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law —sentencing — variationof sentence based onhope of reintegrationinto society

340. ONCA 447927 Ontario Inc.v. Pizza Pizza Ltd.

02/23/90 [1990] O.J. No.325, 72 O.R.(2d) 704, 69D.L.R. (4th)160, 19A.C.W.S. (3d)1168

Black, WilliamD.

Respondent ON Appeal Contracts —performance or breach— repudiation

Page 82



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


341. ONCA Capital VenturesGroup Inc. v. VulcanPackaging Inc

01/26/90 [1990] O.J. No.123, 71 O.R.(2d) 554, 65D.L.R. (4th)632, 38 O.A.C.157, 9 R.P.R.(2d) 32, 19A.C.W.S. (3d)446

Houston,Donald

Respondent ON Appeal Sale of land —agreement of purchaseand sale — registration— vacating

342. ONCA Coplen Estate v.Bauman Estate

12/13/89 71 O.R. (2d)308, [1989] O.J.No. 2160, 64D.L.R. (4th)750, 36 O.A.C.321, 44 C.P.C.(2d) 85, 18A.C.W.S. (3d)1334

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Respondent ON Appeal Family law — damages— personal injuries —dependants' claims —limitation period

343. ONCA R v. Lewis 11/17/89 [1989] O.J. No.2395

Stephenson,Jenny P.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law —provincial offences —Highway Traffic Act —absolute liability —driving with suspendedlicence — conviction setaside

344. ONCA Nathan v. Man 10/31/89 [1989] O.J. No.2264

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Respondents ON Appeal

345. ONCA Zurich Insurance Co.v. Ontario (HumanRights Commission)

10/20/89 [1989] O.J. No.3234, 70 O.R.(2d) 639

Finkelstein,Neil

Respondent ON Appeal Affirmed by theSupreme Court ofCanada [1992]S.C.J. No. 63;[1992] A.C.S. no63; [1992] 2S.C.R. 321; [1992]2 R.C.S. 321; 93

Human rights legislation— discrimination —age, sex and maritalstatus — insurance —premiums

Page 83



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


D.L.R. (4th) 346;138 N.R. 1; J.E.92-947; 55 O.A.C.81; 12 C.C.L.I.(2d) 206; [1992]I.L.R. 1879; 39M.V.R. (2d) 1; 34A.C.W.S. (3d) 665

346. ONCA Weitzman v. Hendin 08/31/89 [1989] O.J.1419, 69 O.R.(2d) 678, 61D.L.R. (4th)525, 35 O.A.C.61, 17A.C.W.S. (3d)17

Sookman,Barry B.

Appellant ON Appeal Lending — liabilityunder loans —promissory notes —investments —mortgages — null andvoid — solicitors —conflicts of interest —banking and insurance

347. ONCA Budget Car RentalsToronto Ltd. v. Petro-Canada Inc. et al.

08/17/89 [1989] O.J. No.1362, 69 O.R.(2d) 289, 60D.L.R. (4th)751, 34 O.A.C.359, 46 B.L.R.81, 6 R.P.R.(2d) 142, 16A.C.W.S. (3d)40, 69 O.R.(2d) 28

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Sale of land — landlordand tenant — option topurchase — validity

348. ONCA Schipper v. GuarantyTrust Co. of Canada

06/20/89 [1989] O.J. No.1010, 69 O.R.(2d) 386, 35O.A.C. 238, 33E.T.R. 149, 16A.C.W.S. (3d)43

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Trusts — wills —interpretation of will

Page 84



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


349. ONCA R. v. Brooks 05/04/89 [1989] O.J. No.1634

Houston,Donald

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law —sentence — probation

350. ONCA Goyal v. 619908Ontario Ltd.

04/28/89 [1989] O.J. No.650

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appealdismissed,November 16,1989 ([1989]S.C.C.A. No. 266)

Commercial law —contract — property law— real property —agreements of purchaseand sale

351. ONCA Canada Heating Ltd.v. BromptonManufacturing Ltd.

04/18/89 [1989] O.J. No.592, 33 O.A.C.399, 36 C.L.R.113, 14A.C.W.S. (3d)419

Mercer,Malcolm M.

Appellant ON Appeal Builders' liens —payment ofsubcontractor by ownerrelieving contractor ofsame obligation

352. ONCA Energy Probe v.Canada (AttorneyGeneral)

04/12/89 [1989] O.J. No.537, 68 O.R.(2d) 449, 58D.L.R. (4th)513, 33 O.A.C.39, 37 Admin.L.R. 1, 3C.E.L.R. (N.S.)262, 35 C.P.C.(2d) 201, 40C.R.R. 303, 14A.C.W.S. (3d)346

Finkelstein,Neil

Intervenor ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed (EnergyProbe v. Canada(AttorneyGeneral), [1989]S.C.C.A. No. 223,10/12/1989)

Civil procedure —standing —constitutional law —Canadian Charter ofRights and Freedoms —enforcement of rights —nuclear power

353. ONCA R. v. Rogers 03/30/89 [1989] O.J. No.459

Porter, DavidM.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law — drugtrafficking — evidence— admission ofinadmissible evidencewhether miscarriage ofjustice

354. ONCA Hausman v. O'Grady 03/17/89 [1989] O.J. No.852, 67 O.R.(2d) 735, 57

Brown, JohnP.

Respondent ON Appeal Real property — powerof sale pursuant tomortgage — market

Page 85



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


D.L.R. (4th)480, 14A.C.W.S. (3d)368

value

355. ONCA Heilig v. DominionSecurities Pitfield Ltd.

02/20/89 [1989] O.J. No.217, 67 O.R.(2d) 577, 59D.L.R. (4th)394, 33 O.A.C.229, 41 B.L.R.205, 32 E.T.R.77, 14A.C.W.S. (3d)92

Steep, R. Paul Appellant ON Appeal An addendum tothis judgment wasreleased May 18,1989. See 69 O.R.(2d) 159.

Company law —amalgamations —stockbrokers andinvestments counsellors— pensions plans —trust law — terminationof trusts — beneficiariesentitled to distribution

356. ONCA R. v. IndependentOrder of Foresters

02/07/89 [1989] O.J. No.170, 32 O.A.C.278, 26 C.P.R.(3d) 229, [1989]I.L.R. 9354,7 W.C.B. (2d)55

Finkelstein,Neil

Respondent ON Appeal Life insurance —misleadingadvertisement —competition —Combines InvestigationAct

357. ONCA R. v. Logan 08/30/88 [1988] O.J. No.1360, 65 O.R.(2d) 717, 30O.A.C. 152, 43C.C.C. (3d)567, 44 C.R.R.149, 8 M.V.R.(2d) 161, 7W.C.B. (2d) 74

Houston,Donald

Respondent ON Appeal Evidence — privilege —pending litigation

358. ONCA R. v. Lewis 03/15/88 [1988] O.J. No.320

Porter, DavidM.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law — guiltyplea — ambiguity inplea resulting in newtrial

Page 86



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


359. ONCA Mills-Hughes v.Raynor

01/19/88 [1988] O.J. No.38, 63 O.R.(2d) 343, 47D.L.R. (4th)381, 25 O.A.C.248, 38 B.L.R.211,68 C.B.R.(N.S.) 179, 19C.C.E.L. 6, 9A.C.W.S. (3d)188

Houston,Donald

Respondent ON Appeal Corporations — liability— directors

360. ONCA Samarzija v.MacIntyre

03/27/87 [1987] O.J. No.285

Freedlander,Jeffrey

Appellant ON Appeal Jury verdict — generaldamages —disproportionate

361. ONCA R. v. Morrison 12/23/86 [1986] O.J. No.1370

Porter, DavidM.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law — appealof conviction —improper admission ofevidence and prejudicialcharge to jury

362. ONCA Canadian ImperialBank of Commerce v.InternationalHarvester CreditCorp. of Canada Ltd.

12/18/86 [1986] O.J. No.1315, 19O.A.C. 397,6 P.P.S.A.C.273, 3A.C.W.S. (3d)28

Houston,Donald

Appellant ON Appeal Personal propertysecurity law —subordination ofinterests —interpretation ofsubordination provisionin debenture

363. ONCA Thurlow v. SouthamInc.

10/10/86 [1986] O.J. No.1023

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Appellant ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadadismissed(Thurlow v.Southam Inc.,[1986] S.C.C.A.No. 300,11/06/1986)

Procedural law —application by media foraccess to documentsfiled in contemptproceedings — Crownwardship proceedings

Page 87



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


364. ONCA Deacon InvestmentsLtd. v. Scarborough(City)

05/27/86 [1986] O.J. No.449

Sookman,Barry B.

Appellant ON Appeal Statutory interpretation— municipal law —landlord and tenants

365. ONCA Graham et al. v.Persyko et al.

04/16/86 [1986] O.J. No.2893, 55 O.R.(2d) 10 at 27,27 D.L.R. (4th)699 at 716

Morrison, F.Paul

Appellant/Respondent incross-appeal

ON Appeal Medical malpractice —damages

366. ONCA Consumers GlassCo. Ltd. v.Foundation Co. ofCanadaLtd./CompagnieFoundation duCanada Ltee et al.

06/03/85 [1985] O.J. No.2586, 51 O.R.(2d) 385, 20D.L.R. (4th)126, 9 O.A.C.193, 30 B.L.R.87, 33 C.C.L.T.104, 13 C.L.R.149, 1 C.P.C.(2d) 208, 31A.C.W.S. (2d)228

Sookman,Barry B.

Appellant ON Appeal Tort law — contract law— civil practice —limitations period —structural design —construction ofwatersheds —collapsed roof —engineering

367. ONCA Glivar v. Noble 04/03/85 [1985] O.J. No.80, 8 O.A.C.60, 30A.C.W.S. (2d)336

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Professional negligence— solicitors — purchaseand sale

368. ONCA Pan American WorldAirways Inc. v.Varghese et al.

02/20/85 [1985] O.J. No.2404, 49 O.R.(2d) 608, 15D.L.R. (4th)768, 30A.C.W.S. (2d)351

Morrison, F.Paul

Appellant ON Appeal Conflict of laws —foreign judgments —finality — foreign courtrendering judgment inplaintiff 's favour —parallel proceedings inwhich defendant suingplaintiff — possibility ofretrial in parallelproceedings — plaintiffentitled to enforce

Page 88



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


judgment

369. ONCA R. v. Lee's PoultryLtd.

01/11/85 [1985] O.J. No.4, 7 O.A.C.100, 17 C.C.C.(3d) 539, 43C.R. (3d) 289,12 C.R.R. 125at 127, 13W.C.B. 296

Morrison, F.PaulMercer,Malcolm M.

Respondent ON Appeal Criminal law —quashing conviction

370. ONCA Szoboszloi v.Campbell

04/13/84 [1984] O.J. No.1490

Steep, R. Paul Respondent ON Appeal Leave to Appeal toSCC refused,[1984] S.C.C.A.No. 74; 57 N.R. 80

Civil practice — trialpreparation — grantingnew trials

371. ONCA Klein v. Staples 02/08/84 [1984] O.J. No.1708

Freedlander,Jeffrey

Appellant ON Appeal Torts — negligence —vehicular accident —standard of care

372. ONCA Elliott v. Freisen et al. 01/12/84 [1984] O.J. No.3105, 45 O.R.(2d) 285, 6D.L.R. (4th)338, 1 O.A.C.376, 42 C.P.C.43

Porter, DavidM.


Defamation — Libel andSlander Act — appealfrom motion determiningpoint of law re:limitations period underLibel and Slander Act

373. ONCA Re Barnett andCadillac FairviewCorp. Ltd.

06/22/83 [1983] O.J. No.3105, 42 O.R.(2d) 461, 20A.C.W.S. (2d)406

Houston,Donald

Respondent ON Appeal Sale of land —agreement of purchaseand sale — rescission

374. ONCA R. v. Spencer 01/18/83 [1983] O.J. No.11, 145 D.L.R.(3d) 344, 2C.C.C. (3d)526, 31 C.P.C.

Houston,Donald

Respondent ON Appeal Affirmed by theSCC ([1985]S.C.J. No. 60;[1985] A.C.S. no60; [1985] 2

Evidence — witnesses— compellability

Page 89



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


162, 9 W.C.B.112

S.C.R. 278; [1985]2 R.C.S. 278; 21D.L.R. (4th) 756;62 N.R. 81; 11O.A.C. 207; 21C.C.C. (3d) 385;48 C.R. (3d) 265;[1985] 2 C.T.C.310; 85 D.T.C.5446; 15 W.C.B.65)

375. ONCA Petrofina Canada Inc.v. Ontario

01/14/83 [1983] O.J. No.2905, 39 O.R.(2d) 587, 142D.L.R. (3d) 767,18 A.C.W.S.(2d) 288

Houston,Donald

Respondent ON Appeal Leave to appeal tothe SupremeCourt of Canadarefused,(11/03/1983).

Leases — construction— lessee of servicestations

376. ONCA Doxtator v. De'Leary 12/06/82 [1982] O.J. No.180, 44 C.B.R.(N.S.) 133

Freedlander,Jeffrey

Respondent ON Appeal Insurance — motorvehicle accident —adding party — practice

377. ONCA R. v. Creaghan 11/02/82 [1982] O.J. No.164, 1 C.C.C.(3d) 449, 31C.R. (3d) 277

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Respondent ON Appeal Criminal law — mischiefoffence — interpretationof offence in information

378. ONCA 392278 Ontario Ltd.(c.o.b. Group Three)v. Miletich

09/22/81 [1981] O.J. No.907

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Contempt of court

379. ONCA Armak ChemicalsLtd. v. CanadianNational Railway Co.

06/27/80 [1980] O.J. No.3655, [1980]O.J. No. 271,29 O.R. (2d)259, 112 D.L.R.(3d) 560

Morrison, F.Paul

Respondent ON Appeal Railways — damages— negligence —economic loss

Page 90



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


380. ONCA Regina v. Crease etal (No. 2)

03/20/80 53 C.C.C. (2d)378, [1980] O.J.No. 727

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law —evidence — wiretaps —authorization

381. ONCA Dunn v. Mid-CanadaSupply & Equipment(Wentworth) Ltd.

12/11/79 [1979] O.J. No.1553

Morrison, F.Paul

Appellant ON Appeal Lease — exercise ofoption to purchase

382. ONCA R. v. J.A. 09/27/79 [1979] O.J. No.1432

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law —sentence

383. ONCA Regina v. Roy 12/12/78 [1978] O.J. No.3780, 3 W.C.B.64

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Respondent ON Appeal Criminal law — escapefrom lawful custody

384. ONCA R. v. I.D.M. 09/13/78 [1978] O.J. No.1149

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law —sentencing

385. ONCA Thordarson v.Thordarson

03/23/78 [1978] O.J. No.6, 5 R.F.L. (2d)92

Morrison, F.Paul

Appellant ON Appeal Family law — petitionfor divorce

386. ONCA Regina v. Pelletier 01/11/78 38 C.C.C. (2d)515, [1978] O.J.No. 317, 2W.C.B. 94

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law —evidence — declarationagainst penal interest

387. ONCA Regina v. Zajner 06/09/77 36 C.C.C. (2d)417, [1977] O.J.No. 736, 1W.C.B. 376

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Respondent ON Appeal Criminal law — escapefrom lawful custody

388. ONCA Regina v. Cavanaghand Donaldson

12/16/76 [1976] O.J. No.2386, 15 O.R.(2d) 173, 75D.L.R. (3d) 189,33 C.C.C. (2d)134

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law — juryinstructions —comments to jury by trialjudge

Page 91



REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL

FURTHERHISTORY


389. ONCA Re Regina v. Gorecki(No. 1)

09/14/76 [1976] O.J. No.2307, 14 O.R.(2d) 212, 32C.C.C. (2d) 129

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Respondent ON Reference Criminal law — notguilty by reason ofmental disorder

390. ONCA Reference re Reginav. Gorecki (No. 2)

09/14/76 [1976] O.J. No.2308, 14 O.R.(2d) 218, 32C.C.C. (2d) 135

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Respondent ON Reference Criminal law — defenceof insanity — expertevidence

391. ONCA R. v. R.J.L. 06/19/74 [1974] O.J. No.561

Ortved, W.Niels F.


392. ONCA Regina v. Marcon 06/18/74 [1974] O.J. No.560, 18 C.C.C.(2d) 575

Ortved, W.Niels F.


393. ONCA R. v. W.K. 03/04/74 [1975] O.J. No.250

Ortved, W.Niels F.

Appellant ON Appeal Criminal law — theft

ONCATotalAppeals:393

Documents

Ontario Court of Appeal - McCarthy Tétrault · – Negotiable instruments and bills of exchange – Negotiation – Appeal by plaintiff from trial judgment dismissing her claim for