33
Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen Peter Eecen CWI, 11 november 2010

Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

www.ecn.nl

Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen

Peter Eecen

CWI, 11 november 2010

Page 2: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

2 11-11-2010

Outline

• Introduction to ECN

• Introduction to Wind Energy

• Examples of research activities- Rotor aerodynamics – dedicated codes- Wind farm aerodynamics CFD developments- Rotor aerodynamics – Ansys CFX

Page 3: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

3 11-11-20103

Petten: Energy research capital of Europe

ECN (680)

NRG (340)COVIDIEN (290)

JRC-IE (275)

Page 4: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

4 11-11-2010

ECN: Mission

Mission: ECN develops and brings to market high-quality knowledge and technology for a sustainable energy system

Universities IndustryProduct

Page 5: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

5 11-11-20105 11-11-2010

ECN: Trias energetica

Solar Energy Wind Energy

Policy StudiesH2 & Clean Fossil Fuels

Efficiency & Infrastructure

Biomass

Engineering & Services

Page 6: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

6 11-11-2010

Why Wind Energy ?

Page 7: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

7 11-11-2010

Page 8: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

8 11-11-2010

Why Wind Energy ?

And……….

Page 9: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

9 11-11-2010

….because wind energy is beautiful

Page 10: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

The Facts

Global cumulative installed capacity

Global annual installed capacity

From: GWEC –Global Wind 2009 Report

10 11-11-2010

Page 11: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

The Facts

From: GWEC – Global Wind 2009 Report

11 11-11-2010

Page 12: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

The Facts

• New installed capacity and de-commissioned capacity in EU 2009 in MW.

• Total 25,963 MW

From: Wind Energy FactsheetsBy the European Wind Energy

Association – 2010www.ewea.org

12 11-11-2010

Page 13: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

The Facts – employment

13 11-11-2010

Wind Energy Factsheets By the European Wind Energy Association – 2010, www.ewea.org

Page 14: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

Size evolution of wind turbines over time

14 11-11-2010

In 25 years wind energy technology has developed enormously. With more R&D investment it can continue to become even more efficient and high performing.

From: Wind Energy FactsheetsBy the European Wind Energy Association – 2010www.ewea.org

Page 15: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

Blade sizes of today (61.5 m)

Sheet from Gijs van Kuik

Page 16: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

16 11-11-2010

• Rotor- and Farm Aerodynamics• Integrated Wind Turbine Design (software)• Operation & Maintenance (Condition monitoring / O&M Tool)• Material research (WMC)

Research Programme

Page 17: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

Rotor aerodynamics• Theoretical and experimental research• Use of CFD • Development of industrial codes

Wind farm aerodynamics• Theoretical modelling• Use of CFD• Experiments (wind tunnels, scaled wind farm, full scale)New ideas• Strip on blade root• Wind Farm control strategies• Synthetic jets

Research line: Rotor & Farm Aerodynamics

17 11-11-2010

Page 18: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

18 11-11-2010

Research infrastructure

Page 19: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

The ECN AWSM code

• Numerical code based on the Generalized Prandtl’s Lifting Vortex Line Method

Able to include:• Analysis of multi-body configurations• General-shape geometries• Steady and unsteady analysis• Yaw, pitch misalignments• Non uniform wind conditions (local gusts and wind

shear)

Coupled to ECN Aeromodule

19 11-11-2010

Arne van Garrel: Development of a wind turbine aerodynamics simulations tool, ECN report

AWSM developed by: Arne van GarrelExtended and used by: Francesco Grasso

Page 20: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

Shear Effect

Uniform wind

Wind shear

No ground

Ground

Ground Effect

Work by: Arne van GarrelFrancesco Grasso

Page 21: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

Non conventional configurationsWinglets

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2

2y/b

Cl

winglet no winglet

-0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2

r/R

circ

ulat

ion

no winglet winglet

Work by: Arne van GarrelFrancesco Grasso

Page 22: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

22 11-11-2010

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

r/R

Cl

no sweep sweep

Non conventional configurationsSwept blades

NREL Phase VI Turbine

Work by: Arne van GarrelFrancesco Grasso

Page 23: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

ROTORFLOW - development• Engineering tools: not accurate enough

Blade Element Momentum (BEM), Vortex line method (AWSM), XFOIL, RFOIL

• CFD tools (CFX): too expensive, too much time- Several weeks on cluster

Work by: Hüseyin ÖzdemirArne van GarrelHenny Bijleveld

Page 24: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

24 11-11-2010

Development of RotorFlow code

• Boundary Layer:- Integral boundary layer method (IBL)

• Potential outer layer:- Panel method

• Viscous – Inviscid Interaction (VII):- Strong quasi-simultaneous interaction scheme

boundary layerouter non-viscous flow

3D

2D

Work by: Hüseyin ÖzdemirArne van GarrelHenny Bijleveld

Page 25: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

RotorFlow VII: Quasi-simultaneous interaction

• Combines advantages of direct and simultaneous method• Interaction law (I): approximation of inviscid flow (E)

solved together with the boundary-layer equations (V)• Interaction law is an algebraic equation

inviscid flow

inviscid flow

viscous flowu

interaction

E

I+V

ueδ*

University of Groningen

25 11-11-2010

Page 26: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

Preliminary results

26 11-11-2010

Turbulent flow over a flat plate, Re=1e72nd order DG

Flow over dented plate: Re = 11.5 106

Separation in middle of the dent

Panel code: lifting wing

Work by: Hüseyin ÖzdemirArne van GarrelHenny Bijleveld

Page 27: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

Development of a wind farm CFD code

27 11-11-2010

Physical phenomenon

Numerical model

Wake model Energy conserving discretizationand Large Eddy Simulation

Turbine model Actuator method

Atmospheric inflow

Precursor simulation

Terrain Immersed boundary method

Work by: Benjamin Sanderse

Page 28: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

Energy conserving discretization of fluid flow

• Wakes are important to wind farm aerodynamics• Dissipation must be limited to ‘keep’ the wakes

28 11-11-2010

Code to be developed is dedicated to task- Energy conserving discretization- LES approach- actuator method- Atmospheric inflow: Precursor simulation- Terrain by immersed boundary method

Work by: Benjamin Sanderse

Page 29: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

Wind farm aerodynamics CFD code• Development CFD tool requires work in many areas:

- Suitable discretization schemes- Turbulence models- Terrain modeling- Actuator modeling

• Atmospheric turbulent inflow, coupling with mesoscale model

29 11-11-2010

To answer simple questions:Optimum distance between turbinesOptimum wind farm lay-outInfluence of wind farm on local climateAssessment of control strategiesFarm-Farm interactionDesign specifications (mechanical loads in farm)

Page 30: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

Use of commercial software Ansys-CFXAnalyses of 2D configurations

C-grid O-grid

Reference airfoil

NACA 642418

30 11-11-2010

Work by: Marc van Raalte

Page 31: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

•First cell thickness : 1mm

Use of commercial software Ansys-CFXAnalyses of 3D rotating configurations

• MEXICO rotor – mesh setup

31 11-11-2010

Work by: Marc van Raalte

Page 32: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

Visualisations – Ansys-CFX results

32 11-11-2010

Work by: Marc van Raalte

Page 33: Ontwerpsoftware voor windenergietoepassingen · 11/11/2010  · 3. 11-11-2010. Petten: Energy research capital of Europe. ECN (680) NRG (340) COVIDIEN (290) JRC-IE (275)

33 11-11-2010

Wind Energy contributes to CO2 - reduction ambitions.

QUESTIONS?