53
-A176 813 OPTIMIZATION OF THdE FINNIGAN NAT 51U CAPILLARY GAS 1' C14ROMATOGRAPH-MASS SP..(U) DEFENCE RESEARCH ESTABLISHMENT ATLANTIC DARTMOUTH (NOVA SCOT!, LIILTZ ET AL NOV 86 DRER-TM-86/222 F/6 7/3 "III"""mom

OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

-A176 813 OPTIMIZATION OF THdE FINNIGAN NAT 51U CAPILLARY GAS 1'C14ROMATOGRAPH-MASS SP..(U) DEFENCE RESEARCHESTABLISHMENT ATLANTIC DARTMOUTH (NOVA SCOT!,

LIILTZ ET AL NOV 86 DRER-TM-86/222 F/6 7/3

"III"""mom

Page 2: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

1.3j, Q -L3 6

u~n1.2 1.4.

_L.2

e ..

1q

Page 3: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

UNLIMITED DISTRIBUTION

National Defence Defense nationaleResearch and Bureau de rechercheDevelopment Branch et d~veloppement

TECHNICAL MEMORANDUM 86/222November 1986

(0

OPTIMIZATION OF THE FINNIGAN MAT 5100

CAPILLARY GAS CHROMATOGRAPH-MASSSPECTROMETER FOR THE ANALYSIS OF

POLYCHLORINATED BIPHENYLS

J.A. Hiltz - J. Power

,¢.,DJ :

.,:.JAN 1 4 1937

Defence Centre de%"j

Research Recherches pour la

Establishment Defense

, Atlantic > Atlantique

Canaa

87 1 13 027

Page 4: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

DEFENCE RESEARCH ESTABLISHMENT ATLANTIC CENTRE DE RECHERCHES POUR LA DfFENSE ATLANTIQUE ~

9 GROVE STREET P 0 BOX 1012 9 GROVE STREET c P 1012

DARTMOUTH, NS TELCPHONEZ DARTMOUTH N E

02Y 3Z7 (902) 42f, 3100 B2Y 3Z7

','

A'-.,.-. .,,.:,.:.- -. ". . 'x- . .;; - J; ;;; %. - .. ' .s .,,?.... .'-,'. .,.. .--

Page 5: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

UNLIMITED DISTRIBUTION

- i-National Defence Defense nationalsResearch and Bureau do rechercheDevelopment Branch et d~voloppemnent ., .'

OPTIMIZATION OF THE FINNIGAN MAT 5100CAPILLARY GAS CHROMATOGRAPH-MASSSPECTROMETER FOR THE ANALYSIS OF

POLYCHLORINATED BIPHENYLS

J.A. Hiltz - J.J. Power

November 1986

Approved by B.F. Peters A/Director/Technology Division 5

DISTRIBUTION APPROVED BY

AID/TO

TECHNICAL MEMORANDUM 86/222 --

is~ I.*.

Defence Centre deResearch Recherches pour [aEstablishment WWU~enseAtlantic Atlantique

Page 6: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with aquadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This isfollowed by the description of the optimization of a Finnigan MAT5100 gas chromatograph-mass spectrometer-data system (GC/MS/DS)for the detection and identification of PCBs. In particular, theeffects of increasing electron multiplier voltage and the use ofmultiple ion detection (MID) scan sequences on the sensitivity ofthe quadrupole mass spectrometer are investigated. Bothincreasing the electron multiplier voltage and the use ofspecialized MID scan sequences were found to result in an improveddetector response.

RESUME

On eamie lepricip d'u chomaograhe n pase azese

colone apilair couI6 vec in pecrom~re e mase uadrpolire

qui ertde dteceur.On ~crt enuit 11otimlisaiond'u

Oexmnlepiipdunchromatoraphe en phase gazeuse FingnMT50 ve pcrmted

masse et systime de traitement des donn~es (CG/SM/TD), qui servira i lad6tection et i 11identification des PCB. On a 6tudi6, en particulier,les effets de 1'augmentation de la tension appliqu~e au multiplicateurd'6lectrons et de l'utilisation de s~quences de balayage pour lad~+tection d'ions multiples (DIM) sur la sensibilit6 du spectrom~tre demasse quadripolaire. On a ainsi constat6 que le fait d'augmenter latension appliqu6e au multiplicateur d'6lectrons et d'utiliser des -

sequences de balayage sp~cialis~es pour la DIM permettait d'am~liorer lar~ponse du d~tecteur.

.... .-----.....

NN

PPAJ%; A Ll*r

Page 7: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

Table of Contents

1.0 Introduction1

2.0 Instumentat:Lon - The Capillary GC/MS 3

2.1 Capillary GC 3

2.2 Mass Spectrometer 3

2 .2 .1 1e ieccron Impact Ionization Source 3

2.2.2 Quadrupole Mass Filter 4

2.2.3 Electron Multiplier 6

2.2.4 Soairces of Noise 6

3.0 Experimental 7

3.1 Equipment 7

3.2 Standards7

3.3 Scan Sequences 8

4.0 Results and Discussion 9

4.1 Multiple Ion Detection 9

4.2 Effect of Varying Electron Multiplier Voltage 11/

5.0 Summary 11 /.~~Tables 13

Figures 18

* Appendices 3

References 41

% I0'8Y I. I%~

Page 8: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

NOTATION PAGE

AXy multiple ion detection descriptor that is a part of the scansequence Al

Al multiple ion detection scan sequence

amu atomic mass unit

B baseline subtract

C135 chlorine atom with nominal mass 35

C137 chlorine atom with nominal mass 37

dc direct current

dm mass interval

DS data system

e charge on an electron, 1.602 X 10 -19 Coulombs

EC electron capture

EI electron impact

EPA Environmental Protection Agency

EX extractor (voltage)

EZ electrometer zeroing routine

eV electron volt

FeCl 3 ferric chloride

GC gas chromatograph

GC/MS gas chromatograph-mass spectrometer

... IE ion energy

IP ion programming

L lens (voltage)

m mass

iv%

IV%

Page 9: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

m/e mass to charge ratio

M minimum peak area

MID multiple ion detection

M molecular or parent ion

PCB(s) polychlorinated biphenyl(s)

ppm parts per million

Q1 multiple ion detection scan descriptor

RIC reconstructed ion chromatogram

RH resolution high (mass)

RL resolution low (mass)

rf radio frequency

r0 radius of cylinder defined by quadrupole rods

T threshold

t time

period ((0t/2)

V volt

Vac radio frequency voltage

Vdc direct current voltage

W minimum peak width

(0) frequency of the rf voltage in radians/second

V

% %*'. . M ,A ., . - •"• " ". ' " " , - , ", ' • " " •" - , " ' - . i ., ' • -u " " -V

' "''" " " F', " -','. .i ,,. -... ' L'..' -,' - . , - ", 'e,, , . ,',,'..<.', ., , , '. '- ,., .. ,, <. ,- . .4 ,, . ..,.,p ,

Page 10: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

1.0 INTRODUCTION

The use of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) as dielectric fluids in

electrical transformers and capacitors has been commomplace over the last

fifty years. PCBs, first commercially produced in the 1920s, areexcellent dielectric fluids as a result of their thermal stability, lowflammability, favorable dielectric constant and resistance to oxidation

and hydrolysis. They are generally produced by the chlorination of

biphenyl using anhydrous chlorine and ferric chloride (FeCI3 ) . The numberand percentage of each of the polychlorinated biphenyls produced depends

upon the time the reaction is allowed to proceed. Table 1 lists the ten

chlorinated biphenyls, from the mono to the deca chloro compounds, and thenumber of structural isomers possible for each of these chlorinated

biphenyls.

The chemical inertness of polychlorinated biphenyls led to their

accumulation in the environment. In 1966, the detection of PCBs that had

accumulated in envirnr ntal samples led to a renewed interest in the -analysis and toxicit ise compounds(l). As concerns over the adverse

effects of PCB- .life and humans increased, their commercial

production slop a.. was finally banned in the USA in 1977 (2)Nonetheless, it is estimated that over 80 percent of the PCBs manufactured

for electrical applications in transformers and capacitors remained in

service. In Canada, the total PCBs still in service were estimated at17,000,000 kg in 1982 (3).

In closed systems such as transformers and capacitors, PCBs are

disposed of when the equipment containing them is taken out of service or

when the dielectric fluid is replaced during routine maintainance. PCBsare then destroyed through incineration or are stored in a secure chemical

landfill. The proper disposal of PCB contaminated wastes is described in

Reference 3.

Often it is not obvious if a transformer or capacitor fluid contains

or is contaminated with PCBs. At present, a PCB contaminated material is

defined as a liquid or solid containing in excess of 50 parts per million(ppm) PCBs (3,4). Solutions containing less than 50 ppm PCBs have been

treated in a legal sense as if they contained no PCBs (4). This has been

"4 challenged in the courts in the USA. The EPA criteria was deemed. arbitrary and the final allowable limit will undoubtably be less than 50

ppm. More recently, it has been suggested that the identification andquantitation of PCBs should be directed towards determining the levels of

a certain of the more toxic individual PCB isomers (5,6). Therefore, the

ability to identify and quantitate PCBs in general and individual isomers

in particular at levels below 50 ppm will be necessary and desirable.

The concern for the safe handling and disposal of PCBs and PCB

contaminated materials has necessitated the development of analytical

.4.! m1

Page 11: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

I

techniques that allow the detection of PCBs, often at trace levels. PCBshave been detected using packed column gas chromatography (GC) withelectron capture (EC) detection (7-10), capillary column GC with ECdetection (8-11), and GC (either packed or capillary column) coupled witha quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector (5,9,12).

" The use of a mass spectrometer (MS) as a detector for a gas

chromatograph has several advantages over the standard gas chromatographicdetectors (such as the electron capture detector, flame ionizationdetector, or thermal conductivity detector). For instance, standard gas

chromatographic detectors cannot positively identify the chemicalcompounds giving rise to the peaks in a chromatogram when a single columnis used. Samples received for PCB analysis are often dissolved inmatrices such as hydrocarbon based oils that may contain compounds withretention times and response factors similar to those of polychlorinated

biphenyls. Matrix interferences can suggest the presence of PCBs whenthey are not present. To ensure that PCBs are present requires the use ofa second column with a different packing. Further, standards similar tothe sample being studied are needed to provide a basis on which toidentify the chromatographic peaks, i.e., injections of the sample andstandard are made on two different columns to ensure that the sample andstandard match is not fortuitous on any one column. Gas

chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC/MS) not only gives the basicchromatographic information on a mixture of compounds, i.e., retentiontime, size, shape, and number of peaks, but also allows positiveidentification of the compounds in the mixture by way of their massspectra. In qualitative analysis no standards are required to confirm thepresence of a compound as the mass spectra of the compounds eluting fromthe column provide the basis for identification because mass spectra arespecific for individual compounds.

Commercially available PCB mixtures contain a number of PCB isomers.The ability to positively identify the polychlorinated biphenyls givingrise to the peaks in the chromatogram greatly facilitates the unambiguousinterpretation of results for aged or weathered samples, where the morevolatile and water soluble isomers may be reduced in concentration with

respect to the other isomers. Such identification was difficult withGC/EC detection as standard PCB mixtures were often used to generatefingerprint data; that is, retention times, shape and number of peaks, forthese compounds. If the peaks corresponding to the lighter PCBs arediminished in intensity or are not seen at all due to weathering of thesample, then matching of fingerprints for sample and standard becomes moredifficult and the identification less certain. The use of fingerprint

is information becomes much less important with MS detection as each peak can

be used to generate the mass spectra of the compound that gave rise to it.The mass spectral fragmentation pattern of a compound is characteristic ofthat species and allows its positive identification.

-5.

This paper describes the operation of a Finnigan MAT 5100 gas

5--,2

% .

- .*i, %~Si ~ ~ - 5 ~C~ro

S

Page 12: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

chromatograph-mass spectrometer-data system (GC/MS/DS) and itsoptimization for the detection and identification of polychlorinatedbiphenyls (PCBs) . The effect of increasing the electron multipliervoltage and using several scanning procedures, i.e., full and multiple iondetection (MID) scans, on the sensitivity of the mass spectrometer as aPCB detector is investigated and discussed.

2.0 INSTRUMENTATION - THE CAPILLARY GC/MS

2.1 Capillary GC

A capillary gas chromatograph is shown diagrammatically in Figure 1.It consists of an injection port where the sample to be analysed isintroduced, a column where the components of the sample are separated, and -.

the plumbing to allow a carrier gas to transport the sample components4 through the column. ..

The components of the mixture are separated on the column as a resultof their partitioning between the stationary phase on the column and thecarrier gas. The preference of individual compounds for the stationary %phase or the carrier gas is governed by distribution coefficients whichare characteristic of a particular compound and vary from one compound toanother. Thus a mixture of compounds is separated as it moves through thecolumn and its constituents arrive at the detector at different times.

Separations on capillary columns are characterized by good resolutionand narrow peak profiles. The resolution is due to the the length of thecolumn, generally between 15 and 60 m in length, which results in a largenumber of theoretical plates.

2.2 Mass Spectrometer

The three major components of the Finnigan MAT 5100 quadrupole massspectrometer, i.e., the electron impact (EI) ionization source, thequadrupole mass analyser, and the electron multiplier, are described in

the following sections.

2.2.1 The Electron Imoact Ionization Source

As a compound elutes from the capillary column of a GC/MS system, itenters the ionization source. For this work, an electron impact (EI)ionization source was used. An EI ionization source consists of afilament and reflector, collector, ion volume, extractor, and lens, and isshown diagrammatically in Figure 2. A brief description of the EI source

follows.

3

, . ." -. .- -. . " " -.%

Page 13: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

The filament provides a source of electrons which impact themolecules eluting into the ion volume. These electrons, which areproduced by the thermionic emission of an electrically heated filamentwhich is kept at a negative potential (generally -70 eV) relative to thewalls of the ion source, have an energy approximately equal to the

negative potential on the filament.

The collector, located opposite the filament, is kept at a constant+30 V to attract electrons from the filament through the ion volume. As

the electrons move through the ion volume they impact the molecules thathave eluted from the column causing the molecules to lose electrons and

form positive ins. The masses and number of the ions produced is afunction of the bond strengths of the molecule being impacted. The wallsof the ion source are positively charged so that the positive ionsproduced form a cloud in the middle of the ion volume. The potential

applied to the ion volume is termed the ion energy (IE) . As it is . .important that all ions enter the quadrupole filter with the samevelocity, the ion energy is programmed to increase as the mass range isscanned from low to high masses. The programmed increase in the ionenergy is referred to as ion programming (P).

The side of the ion volume closest to the quadrupole mass filter is

the extractor (EX) and it is kept at a positive potential lower than thatof the ion volume to create a voltage gradient. The gradient between theextractor and the ion volume causes the positive ions to move towards theextractor. The lens (L), which lies behind the extractor and outside theion volume, is negatively charged and focuses the ion beam for optimum

entrance into the quadrupole mass filter.

2.2.2 Quadrupole Mass Filter

The Finnigan MAT 5100 GC/MS utilizes a quadrupole mass filter as itsdetector. The formal theory of the quadrupole mass filter is based onfield forming surfaces which are hyperbolic cylinders. A briefdescription of the formal theory of this detector follows.

In a hyperbolic field the motion of ions in the x and y directions aredescribed by the Mathieu equations (11), which are as follows:

d 2 x/ d2 t + (a+ 2q cos 2T ) x = 0..,

d2y /d2 - (a + 2q cos 2) y = 0 --

2 22where a = 8 eVdc/mro 0 , q = 4eVac/mroQ 2 , = wt/2, Vdc is the dc

voltage, Vac is the rf voltage, e is the charge of an electron, ro is the :radius of the cylinder defined by the quadrupole rods, and 0 is thefrequency of the rf voltage. These equations are characterised by regions -

of stability and instability, i.e., the amplitude of x or y remains

p.~4

- -> . , < . . . . '.

Page 14: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

.-.

bounded in the former case and increases without limit in the latter.Whether the trajectory of an ion is stable or not depends solely on thevalues of a and q. For an ion to pass through the quadrupole mass filterand arrive at the electron multiplier, its trajectory must be stable forboth x and y components of velocity. In adition, its amplitude ofoscillation must be less than ro. It has been found that round cylinders,in place of hyperbolic cylinders, provide a suitable compromise to thedifficulty in constructing hyperbolic cylinders. Round cylinders are usedin the the quadrupole MS at DREA.

A combination of radio frequency (rf) and direct current (dc)voltages is applied to each diagonally paired set of rods and both the rfand dc vcnitnq 4r- ramped functions which vary with time. The rfvoltages applied to each pair of rods are 180 degrees out of phase. For a

given ratio of the dc and rf voltages, a line can be drawn through theorigin of a q versus a plot (see Figure 3). Each point on this linecorresponds to a particular value of the mass-to-charge ratio (m/e) of theions being produced in the source. The interval, dm, of this value whichlies within the stable part of the q versus a plot corresponds to theions of masses with stable trajectories. If the ratio of dc to rfvoltages is increased, the slope of the scan increases and passes closerto the apex of the stability diagram. The interval (dm/m) then decreasesand the resolving power of the spectrometer (m/dm) increases.

At any given time, t, a particular set of rf and dc voltages are beingapplied to the quadrupole rods. Under this particular set of conditionsonly ions of a certain m/e value can oscillate through the rods and reachthe detector. All other ions with m/e values different from thisparticular mass to charge ratio undergo unbounded oscillations and strikethe quadrupole rods.

The quadrupole mass filter operates in a scanning mode. By rampingthe rf and dc voltages all ions in a specified mass range (m/e) are tunedthrough the detector in a scan. The resulting detector trace, called areconstructed ion chromatogram (RIC), is a plot of the total ion currentarriving at the electrometer during each scan against the retention timeof the compound or compounds eluting from the column that gave rise tothose ions.

The sensitivity of the mass spectrometer for a particular compoundis directly related to the amount of time that the detector is tuned toobserve the ions that are characteristic of the mass spectralfragmentation of that compound. If the quadrupole mass spectrometer scansfrom 40 to 400 atomic mass units (amu) in 2 seconds, then each mass istuned through the rods for 2/360 seconds. This procedure is somewhat

inefficient. For example, if the mass spectrum of the compound ofinterest is well known, then masses of the ions of greatest intensity forthat compound can be determined. Then instead of scanning the mass rangefrom 40 to 400 amu, the quadrupole mass analyzer can be programmed to look

J.5

%

Page 15: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

for ions in a narrower range or ions of a particular mass. Such scansare termed multiple ion detection (MID) scans and are used to increase thesensitivity of the mass spectrometer as a detector. The ions reaching theelectrometer during a MID scan are those that are characteristic of thecompound of interest and proportionately more time during each scan isavailable for the detection of the compound of interest.

2.2.3 Electron Multiplier

The electron multiplier in the Finnigan MAT 5100 GC/MS consists ofthree components: a conversion dynode, a voltage dropping resistor, and acontinuous dynode electron multiplier. It is shown diagrammatically inFigure 4. The voltage on the electron multiplier assembly, which can becontrolled by the operator of the GC/MS, is applied to the conversiondynode and to the electron multiplier by way of a voltage droppingresistor. The negative potential on the conversion dynode attractspositive ions which have been tuned through the quadrupole massspectrometer. When these positive ions strike the dynode surface,electrons are released by impact ionization and are forced by the field

gradient into the cathode of the electron multiplier.

The cathode of the electron multiplier acts to amplify the currentproduced by the electrons coming from the conversion dynode. The gain of

, ., the electron multiplier can also be controlled by the operator of theGC/MS. It is generally set at 10 , although it can be set at 106 or 108.

By varying the voltage on the conversion dynode, the kinetic energy ofthe ions striking the conversion dynode is varied. Increasing the kineticenergy of the ions striking the dynode increases the number of electronsreleased by the dynode. Consequently the response of the detector isincreased. For a given concentration of compound entering the ion volumethe response of the GC/MS as a detector can be maximized by finding theoptimum electron multiplier voltage.

2.2.4 Sources of Noise

The noise found in chemical instrumentation is characterized by spikesin the acquired data and is generally short in duration and low inintensity. It can be the result of power supply problems, vibration,aging of the electrical components including the electron multiplier andpreamplifier, and X-ray radiation that passes the shield to the electronmultiplier. Noise can be removed or minimized in two ways: by hardwarezeroing and/or software zeroing.

On the Finnigan MAT 5100 GC/MS/DS the hardware zero can be set eithermanually or automatically. The hardware zero acts to eliminate noise fromthe mechanical and electronic parts of the system by setting the responsebaseline above the mean noise in the system. It is reset whenever the

electrometer range is changed.

6

Page 16: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

- .. • . 7 z T - ; . ! ------------ *

The software zero acts in conjunction with the hardware zero. Itdefines the criteria used by the computer (data system) to determinewhether a response should be seen as a peak and recorded or as noise andeliminated. These criteria, which are operator defined, are:

-the threshold below which all data is eliminated,-the baseline subtract value that eliminates data below that value,-the minimum width of a response that is seen as a peak, and-the minimum peak area that is read as a peak.The threshold does not eliminate peaks that exceed it in value, i.e.,

if a peak exceeds the threshold value then the entire peak is retained.By proper selection of these variables, spurious responses that are mostoften the result of noise can be minimized. .

3.0 EXPERIMENTAL-

All GC/MS analyses were carried out on a Finnigan MAT 5100 gaschromatograph/mass spectrometer with a SuperIncos data system. A Finniganmodel 9611 capillary gas chromatograph with a Durabond-1 (30 meter long x0.25 millimeter inside diameter) capillary column (100% methyl silicone)was used for all separations. The GC oven was temperature programmed asfollows: 800 C for two minutes, then ramped to 150 0 C at a rate of20°C/minute and finally ramped to 300 0 C at a rate of 40C/minute. Thetemperature program is shown graphically in Figure 5.

The mass spectrometer was run in the electron impact (EI) mode usingan ionizing voltage of 70 electron volts (eV). Typical values of the ionenergy (IE), ion program (IP), lens voltage (L), extractor voltage (EX),and resolution settings (RL and RH) are shown in Table 2 along with therange of values that these parameters can assume. Hardware zero was setautomatically with the program EZ, while the software zeroes, i.e.,threshold (T), baseline subtract (B), minimum peak width (W), and minimumarea (M), were set to the values shown in Table 2.

The spectrometer was generally tuned so that sensitivity was favoredover resolution, i.e., the ratios of the intensities of the 219, 414, and502 peaks of the calibration gas (perfluorotributylamine) wererespectively at least 30%, 1.4% and 0.8% of the intensity of the 69 peak.

3.2 St-andrd

Commercial PCB mixtures: Aroclor 1232, Aroclor 1242, Aroclor 1248,Aroclor 1254, and Aroclor 1260, were obtained from PolyScienceCorporation, Niles, Illinois, USA, as 100 ppm solutions in hexane. Onemicroliter injections of the PCBs were introduced into the column in themodified splitless mode. Capillary gas chromatographs can be operated inthe split or splitless mode. In the split mode the injector is swept by

VV

%7

%'

Page 17: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

V . V -

a split gas which carries away some of the sample and reduces the amount Iof sample introduced onto the column. However, in the splitless mode thesplitter is turned off. This results in a much greater amount of thesample being introduced to the column for analysis. In the modifiedsplitless mode, the split valve was turned off until 45 seconds after theinjection which allows a greater percentage of the sample to be swept intothe column by the carrier gas.

The Aroclor mixtures, produced by Monsanto, are identified by a fourdigit code. For example, the 1232 designation of Aroclor 1232 refers totwo things: the first two digits indicate biphenyl and the last two digitsindicate the average weight percent of chlorine in the PCB mixture. Theaverage molecuiar compositions (weight percent) of the five Aroclormixtures used in this work are listed in Table 3a, while Table 3b lists

some characteristics of these Aroclor mixtures.

3.3 Scan Sequences

GC/MS data were acquired for the five standard PCB solutions using

three scan sequences.

The first utilized a scan from 50 to 500 atomic mass units (amu) in 2

* seconds. The average percentage of mono, di, tri, tetra, penta, hexa, ehepta, octa, and nonachlorobiphenyls in Aroclors 1232, 1242, 1248, 1254,and 1260 are shown in Table 3a. By displaying the mass spectrum of the

peaks of the reconstructed ion chromatogram (RIC) for each of theAroclors, it was possible to determine the major ions of the electron

- ionization mass spectra and to measure a range of retention times for thevarious PCB groups, i.e., the mono, di, tri. .... and nonachlorobiphenyls.Once the major ions and retention times of the individual PCBs were known,multiple ion detection (MID) sequences could be written which greatly

enhanced the sensitivity of the mass spectrometer as a detector.

The second scan sequence, designated Q, was comprised of a single MID

scan. Instead of scanning over a range of m/e values, the mass selective

analyser was set to tune through ions of m/e values characteristic ofV PCBs. Q1 scanned for the most abundant ions of the various PCBs, i.e.,

the mono, di, tri,...and nonachlorobiphenyls which were taken from themass spectra acquired using the full scan mode from 50 to 500 amus. MIDQ1 is shown in Figure 6. The blocked areas represent the masses that are

'% " :tuned through the quadrupole mass filter during each scan.

The third scan sequence, designated Al, is comprised of several MIDscans similar to Q1. One of the MID scans is shown in Figure 7 while theothers are listed in Appendix A. The MID scan that is operative varies asthe GC run procedes. Sequence Al acts to change the masses that are tunedthrough the quadrupole by activating the MID scans sequentially as theretention times of the isomers in a PCB mixture increase, i.e., sequence

Al is composed of MID scans which tune through ion fragments particular to

8I

Page 18: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

the PCBs eluting from the capillary column at a given time during the GCrun.

4.0 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Reconstructed ion chromatograms (RIC) of five standard Aroclors, i.e.,Aroclor 1232, A-roclor 1242, Aroclor 1248, Aroclor 1254, and Aroclor 1260,are shown in Figures 8a through 8e respectively. The chromatograms arethe result of 1 microlitre injections of 100 ppm solutions of theAroclors in hexane acquired using a full scan from 50 to 500 amu. It canbe seen that the retention time envelope, i.e., the times of elution ofthe first and last PCBs in a mixture, of the polychlorinated biphenyls inthe various t rncinrs moves to longer retention times as the weight percentof chlorine in the PCB mixture is increased, i.e., from 32 to 42 to 48 to54 to 60% for Aroclors 1232, 1242, 1248, 1254, and 1260 respectively.

Two MID sequences are described in the following section and theresulting increase in sensitivity for the detection of PCBs discussed.

4.1 Multiple Ion Detection

As indicated in the Introduction, the sensitivity of the massspectrometer as a detector for a particular compound or compounds isdirectly related to the amount of time during a scan sequence that ionscharacteristic of the compound or compounds are tuned through thedetector. In the full scan mode, for instance over the mass range from 50to 500 amu, a large percentage of the scan time is spent looking for ionsthat are not characteristic of the species of interest.

Mass spectra of typical PCBs, from the mono to the deca chlorinated

compounds, acquired on the Finnigan MAT 5100 GC/MS are shown in AppendixB. The molecular ion (M + ) or parent ion, i.e., the ion formed when thecompound loses an electron, is the ion of greatest intensity (base ion)for the majority of PCBs. The most noticeable effect in the mass spectraof PCBs is due to the isotopic abundance of chlorine, i.e.,monochlorobiphenyl is characterised by M+ and (M+2)+ peaks in a ratio of3:1 as a result of the natural abundance of the Cl and Cl atoms.

Similarly, dichlorobiphenyl, which contains two chlorine atoms, displayspeaks at M+2 and M+4 in addition to M +, trichlorobiphenyl peaks at M+2,

+M+4, and M+6 in addition to M and so on. The relative intensity of thesepeaks can be determined from the natural abundances of the Cl and Cl37

atoms.

As the mass fragmentation patterns of the polychlorinated biphenylsare known, selection of single ions or ions in smaller mass ranges thatare characteristic of the electron impact fragmentation of PCBs allows a

greater percentage of the fragment ions to be detected. Both approaches,i.e., more selective mass ranges and multiple ion detection, have beentrialed and the results are discussed below.

9%

_Y ?-- - - -

Page 19: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

..... !M w 97 - . -1 ..

The MID descriptor Q1 is shown diagrammatically in Figure 6.

Descriptor Q1 instructs the quadrupole mass spectrometer to scan for ionfragments with m/e values between 148 and 152, 182 and 192, 218 and 228,253 and 262, 289 and 297, 323 and 336, 357 and 370, 381 and 396, 425 and442, and 460 and 478 amus. These mass ranges are typical of the molecularor parent ions of the mono, di, tri, ... octa and nonachlorobiphenylsrespectively.

The RICs for Aroclors 1232, 1242, 1248, 1254, and 1260 acquired usingMID Q1 are shown in Figures 9a through 9e respectively. A 1 microlitreinjection of a 100 ppm solution of each of the Aroclors was used to obtainthese RICs. Comparison of the RICs for Aroclor 1232, acquired using afull scan from 50 to 500 amu and that from the MID sequence Q1 are shownin Figures 8a and 9a respectively. The mass spectrometer detected thesame PCBs coming off the capillary column when either the full scan or MIDQ1 was used, but the response for the individual PCBs of Aroclor 1232 wasenhanced with MID Q1 as compared to that with the full scan from 50 to 500amu, i.e., the count numbers in the upper right hand corner of the Figuresare much larger when Q1 is used (44416 versus 5808 for the most intensepeak), indicating that more ions are being detected.

Although the scan descriptor Q1 increases the amount of time during

* %Ieach scan that is spent on detecting ions characteristic of PCBs (ascompared to a full scan from 50 to 500 amu), it does not take fulladvantage of the multiple ion detection capabilities of the GC/MS/DS. Forinstance, if a dichlorobiphenyl is eluted from the column, ionized, thefragment ions tuned through the quadrupole mass spectrometer and detected,the time the analyser spends looking for ion fragments greater than themolecular weight of a dichlorobiphenyl is wasted.

A MID descriptor, written to consider retention time ranges of thevarious PCBs, could eliminate scanning mass ranges or masses that are notcharacteristic of the PCBs eluting from the column at that particulartime.

Development of this MiD descriptor sequence involved determining theretention times of the various PCB isomers on the capillary column. Thisinformation allowed time windows to be defined where groups of PCBisomers were most likely to elute. As there was some overlap of retentiontimes, i.e., some dichlorobiphenyls were found to elute after some of thetrichlorobiphenyls, the individual MID descriptors that constituted theMID descriptor sequence had to include m/e values for the PCBs that might

elute during a particular time range.

Such a MID descriptor sequence has been developed. It changes the

m/e values of the ions that are tuned through the detector as a function r.of the retention times of the various PCB isomers. The MID descriptorsequence is listed in Table 4 and the individual MIDs shown

10

e .. . .. . . .

~4

Page 20: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

diagrammatically in Figure 7 and Appendix A. The individual MIDs thatconstitute the final sequence are identified by subscripts that refer tothe number of chlcrine atoms in the PCBs being detected, i.e., A13 scans lfor m/e values characteristic of mono, di, and trichlorobiphenyls and A45for tetra and pentachlorobiphenyls.

The RICs for Aroclors 1232, 1242, 1248, 1254, and 1260 acquired using <A

MID descriptor sequence Al are shown in Fiqures 10a to 10e respectively.Again, it can be seen that the RICs are similar to those produced using ascan from 50 to 500 amus or the MID descriptor Q1. However, the response ".has increased over that found with Q1 for example. The RICS for Aroclors1242 and 1260, acquired with the three scan modes, are compared in Figureslla and llb rppectively. The scale of the y-axis has been normalized tothat found using MID descriptor sequence Al so that the variation indetector response for a 100 ppm solution of an Aroclor, as the scan modeis changed from the full scan mooe to MID descriptor Ql to MID descriptorsequence Al, can be seen. The responses of the various isomers in thesetwo Aroclors increase significantly aR the quadrupole mass analyser isinstructed to tune through ions with m/e values that are characteristic ofthe PCBs eluting from the capillary cciumn.

4.2 Effect of Varying Electron Multilier Voltae-

Figures 12a to 12d show the RICs of one microlitre injections of 100ppm solutions of Aroclor 1254 in hexane where the electron multipliervoltage has been varied from 1300 to 1900 volts in 200 volt increments.The chromatograms were acquired in the full scan mode (50 to 500 amus in 2seconds) and the responses normalized to that for the scan with theelectron multiplier voltage set at 1900 volts. It can be seen that theresponse of the detector increases monotonically as the electronmultiplier voltage is increased from 1300 to 1900 volts.

However, as the voltages on the conversion dynode and the cathode ofthe electron multiplier are increased further, a point is reached wherethe detector is saturated. Analysis of saturated data can lead to rapiddeterioration of the electron multiplier assembly and subsequent failure. .The final magnitude of the voltage applied to the electron multiplier isdictated by the amount (concentration) of the material to be analysed. Ifmaximum sensitivity is required, the voltage on the electron multipliercan be increased to the point where the data becomes saturated. If moreconcentrated samples are available the voltage can be turned down to alower level. The critical factor is that increased sensitivity results inaccelerated deterioration of the electron multiplier assembly.

5.0 SUMMARY'.

The optimizatior of the Finnigan MAT 5100 GC/MS/DS for the detectionof PCBs has been described. It has been shown that the sensitivity of the

I', " w w " ,' , - ,, - ,- ,- , - . - " . • , . - . -, . " - , . . , . . . . - . . - • - - • - ' - ' ' ' - - - - '

Page 21: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

mass spectrometer as a detector for PCBs can be greatly enhanced throughthe use of multiple ion detection and multiple ion detection sequencesover that achieved through the use of full scan modes. Further, thesensitivity of the detector can be increased by selection of an optimumelectronmultiplier voltage when working with samples containing traceamounts of analyte.

1.

L?..L.

'..o

%"F.%" .,

5' 4

Page 22: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

The number of isomers possible for each of the ten

chlorinatedbiphenyls(Cl 2Hl0 _nCln). The molecular weight of

each of the ten chlorinatedbiphenyls is also listed.

Sof isomers M.W.

1 monochlorobiphenyl 3 188.7

2 dichlorobiphenyl 12 223.1

3 trichlorobiphenyl 24 257.6

4 tetrachlorobiphenyl 42 292.0

5 pentachlorobiphenyl 46 326.4

6 hexachlorobiphenyl 42 360.9

7 heptachlorobiphenyl 24 395.3

8 octachlorobiphenyl 12 429.8

9 nonachlorobiphenyl 3 464.2

10 decachlorobiphenyl 1 498.7

* M.W. - molecular weight

13%6NE,

Page 23: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

Table 2

Typical values of the instrument parameters (electron impact

source and software zeroes) used for the Finnigan MAT 5100

GC/MS.

electron 4impact ionizing voltage (El) -70.0 eV

ion programnming voltage (IP) 9.4 V

extractor voltage (EX) 7.0 V

resolution setting - low (RL) 129

- high (RH) 136

electron multiplier voltage (ES) 1600 V

threshold (T) 8

baseline subtract (B) 0

minimum peak width (W)

minimum peak area (M) 3

*~ %.

% % I, % % %

* a.

Page 24: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

4.

,.

The average make-up (weight percent) of the five Aroclors used in

this study (n refers to the number of chlorines on the biphenyl

molecule).

1 261

3 24 45 21

4 15 31 49 15,-

0 6

1 26 2

7 24 45318

N'' A 15 314911

% %'

. *1e

e.7 fLME'r-V

Page 25: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

Some characteristics of Aroclor mixtures. -'

Aroclor -

2;)1242 1248 1254 1260"

densiy i. 26 1.38 1. 44 1.54 1.62

(g/cm 3 @ 20'C)_

viscosity 31-32 34-35 36-37 44-58 72-78 e

(Saybolt 100°C)

distillation 270-325 325-366 340-375 365-390 385-420 - '

range (°C)

vaporization

rate (g/cm2/h) 874 338 152 53 13 ..

x 1 0 i"

i solubility in

H20 (250C) rrg/L 24 5.2 1.2 0.3.

12

-. 4-

"%°

,:

164

Page 26: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

-w

--

-4 4

The times that the various MID descriptors that comprise the sequenceAI are engaged during a GC/MS run.

Window # MID descriptor Snan cycles Time on T

1 * 60 0 .0 0 a 2:00

2 A12 290 2.00 11:40

3 A23 90 11.40 14:40

4 A34 120 14.40 18:40

5 A45 70 18:40 21:00

6 A56 80 21:00 23:40

7 A67 150 23:40 28:40

8 A78 340 28:40 40 : 00

* - filament and electron multiplier turned off for the first two

minutes of the run.

N a - times listed as minutes and seconds

"1:7

177Sd.

5'.

4 •5 J'J' - * d* 5 5 . - " . .- . •. ... .. . •. . -* - .' . -.. .... S -. " .". . . ." " ., .- - ",

Page 27: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

Injection port Heated transfer line

To mass7 Spectrometer

Capillary column

Carrier gas GC oven

Figure 1 -Diagrammatic representation of a capillarygas chromatograph.

18

%2 %t

Page 28: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

ion volume

reflector

A

4-collector

filament

~ 4-- extractor

~ 4 lens

liii liii 4-- quadrupole rods

Figure 2: Diagrammatic representation (exploded view)of the electron impact (El) source of aFinnigan MAT 5100 GC/MS.

19

. . . ...............................- %

.. - .. - - 5 ..- %~~~5P .5

Page 29: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

1.00.24 .9

(1-0.22 .2

0.20 .3 X UNSTABLE~0.20 \ .4

Y UNSTABLE0.18I

0.16

0.14

0.12

A0.10 .

0.08

0.06 .7.3

0.04 .8

0.02

00 0.1 0.2 0.3 04 0.5 0.6 0 .7 0.8 0.90= 8Vdc _ e 4 vdce

-Mr, 2 w 2 q Mr2 w 2

F r - A q versus a plot showing the stable and unstableregions of the x and y components of the ionstrajectory through the quadrupole mass filter. Theinterval of the scan line that lies within the stable

portion of the q versus a diagram corresponds tomasses with stable trajectories.

20

, .. ;. ..---.-. .. • • , . ,,. : . . . .,,, " ,.% % '" N. %, . . , . .. . . , ,. ,.

Page 30: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

Conversion dynode Electron Multiplier Voltage

Shield 00

M+ /- 0

Qu4adrupole Rods

Voltage Dropping Resistor s

Anode

Current to Electrometer

Figure 4: Diagram of the electron multiplier used inthe Finnigan MAT 5100 CC/MS.

21

Page 31: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

300C

190C

TIMEO0 4.3 8.7 13 17 21 26 30 34 39 43

FROM TEMP (C) TO TEMP (C) RATE (C/M) TIME (MIN) TOTAL TIMEN(IN)

80 - 80 - 2.0 2.0

80 - 150 20.0 3.5 5.5150 - 300 4.0 37.5 43.0

Fig= - Temperature program used to control the oven of the Finnigan

9611 gas chromatograph during PCB analysis.

1~~ 22

*.~~~~~~ ~ N..- JIJ*.

Page 32: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

256

I T J I I _ _ _- 1 1 1 L- -

1000 2:100 400

I NT BEGIN END TIME (SECS) MPW MR) MA TH PL ION4#M~5 F .S EOLIEST ACTULL

1. 14 7. 5C0 152. 500 0. 200 0.165 3 80 5 1 0 Pfl52. 11. 500 192. 510 0. 200 0. 18 3e. 1 0

3. 2 117. 500 22?. 500 0. 200 0.182 3 80 5 1 0 P054. 252. 500 2 -92. 5 C0 0. 2SA 0. 165 80 5 1 0 P0O5

5. M,8500 237. 500 0.200 0. 149 3 SO 5 1 0 POS6. 2.50C, :!3 P. An 0.200 0. 231 '3 8 5 1 0 0

3% 5 S.* 07 1-0. 611 0. 200 0.2,12 PS0 1 0 PO-8. 6?.14 3-q6.618 0. 200 0. 265 380 5 1 0 P 059. 424. 27 4 42.E32 0. 200 0.149 3 8 5 1 0 P 0 S

10. 459. S:8 4 79. 64? 0.200 0.157 3 80 5 1 0- P05

Figue 6- Diagram of the MID descriptor Qi. The blocked areas indicatetemasses that are tuned through the quadrupole during each

scan. The masses or mass ranges scanned are listed below theschematic.

23

Page 33: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

1024'M

T - -

1 0 200

INT PEGMH END TIME (SE C S) MPW MFW1 MA TH BL I ON# iA CS MASS PEDUEST ACTUAL

1. 150.'394 151.394 0. 15LI 0.13-3 3 830 10 1 0 POS2. :..94 1~ 0. 150 0.133 3 80 10 1 0 POS

3. 185.?70 186.270 0.150 0.133 3 go 10 I 0 Pn,54. 1:.3E 1E-8. 368 0.150 0.131 0 80 10 1 0 P05-

5. 12 ~ 189.3 9 O.15 0.133 3 80 10 1 0 P I S05 .1 e9. Hr,, 190. P F7 0.150 0.133- 3 80 10 1 0 PCIS

N-1 c2E..34 7 "" 4 .150~ 0. 14 ?3 21'~ 1 i pol-

Figure - One of the MID descriptors (Al2) that constitutes the scansequence Al. The particular MID descriptor controllingthe quadrupole is changed as the run progresses so thatthe ions tuned through quadrupole rods are thosecharacteristic of the PCBs eluting from the capillarycolumn at a given time. The time windows when the variousMID descriptors are active is shown in Table 5 and were-determined from the RICs for the Aroclors run in the fullscan mode.

24

% % %~

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

--.4 . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...-. . . . . . . . . .

Page 34: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

I8(e) "

8(d)

8 (c) 0~

I UI

8 (b)

1%

.,

5808 8(a)

200 40C 6 JG. 43 13:20 20:0 2G- 4

Figures 8 (a)-8(e): The RIC's for Aroclors 1232, 1242, 1248, 125L. and 1260" respectively acquired using a full scan from 50 to 500' anmus in two secons.

25

N,,,,,

Page 35: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

9(e)

'I.

9(d)

'4

Ii ,i

9(c)

• '99(b)

44416 9 (a)

'!290 400 NO 9' 6:40 13: 20 20: rO 26: 40

'"-"Figures 9(a)-9(e): The RIC's for Aroclors 1232, 1242, 1248, 1254 and 1260~respectivelv acquired using the MID descriptor Q).

S626

*';. ;;;. ':.?.g '?a-'..-,-..-.',-,'..-..,'-..:....-v.. --.'¢....':v ,..:. ,:":::.'..,.,::...vv.I..

Page 36: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

10(e)

10(d)

I LI'

~q. A

10(a)

247 2 1!5

Figures ]f(a)-]n(e): The RIC's for Aroclors 1232, 1242, 1248, 1254 and 1260respectively acquired using the MID descriptor sequence

AI.

..27

I. - • . .- . ,- . , -" '"- I,'%' , %. . %,%.0 ' ",," ," ",,. " ''" " ' " " ."'* ."-.4 " * .. 2 .- .- " " "- -,

Page 37: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

Al

.-.

~~1

Qi

I Ifull scan

Figure 11(a): Comparison of the RIC's for Aroclors 1242 and 1260acquired using a full scan, MID descriptor Qi, and

MID descriptor sequence Al.

2B W-

28

Page 38: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

Al

I .

_44

I ,

4_r_____ rj 0 i j LlI

ac d u g a full scan

~I I

MID ~ ~~ fl decrporanune l

29

'0.4@0600 3, 0 "

: 4C : 20 20 . , 0 2 E:dO . ,,.,

*Figure 11(b): Comparison of the RIC's for Aroclors 1242 and 1260

. acquired using a full scan, MID descriptor QI, and "

MID descriptor sequence Al.-'-

,' 'I,-

4.? ,

,I : .: -:- - .'::':- ; -; -- ,. -I-...:'-.--- -;..- ..- - -x .- :.: : ; . . ; .: : :.: : ; :; : : .

.,I ,.' _.,..-.. , -_ ... . ...-...... - . ...... .... . .,,-_._.,.,-, , ,.., -_ ;,, - , , - .,..,

Page 39: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

12 (d) "

.4,. 4) h '

12 (c)

44 1

12(b)

12(a)

210 40.- ., .

40 2: 00C20 4

Figures 12(a)-12(d): RIC's of Aroclor 1254 acquired in the full scan -J

mode as the voltage applied to the electron

multiplier is increased. The response increases

as the voltage is increased from 1300 volts in

(a) to 1900 volts in (d) in 200 volt increments.

30 5

."l ,t .P j '.'. w.;

.t .. 2o.. " #.'.. . ' _d'a'."'

."." " . .. .# ." " . " ." '..., . ... ' . . • "€ ...

-.. " . .

,-,.* .*

Page 40: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

$ l--

APPENDIX A "-

- -A.

IHE MID DESCRIPTORS THAT, TOETHER WITH MID DESCRIPTOR

A2, CONSTITUTE THE MID DESCRIPTOR SEQUENCE Al -.

-- :,

,-?,

AAJ'q

-,.:.-

' - %. ",.",, " ". ,,.,,. v .- .. ...' .' .'. ,' ," ," .,',. .. ... , . ., .. ",.," ,., ," ,," v' # ,°.,... ., ,, . .. % . .,

Page 41: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

A23

10241

.4 ' I I I I

4

11T BEGIN END TIMlESS.I , REOIJEST 5 221.345 2'" 2 4

. 150.394 151.394 0.150 6. 2 23.343 2.343A15134 152.394 0.150 75 255.1 25C.321 0. 150

3. 185.370 186.370 0.150 . 257. 319 258.3194. 368 18 3. 368 0. 150 5. 259.318 260.318 0.150

A3"

4.'. v,

I l.I C,

: ,-. 1 50

I Il. I_

.. 22, 1I .34,1

0.m..%94 294. 254 15 0

320

. %. 1 7. 1 6.3 8 .%150" 2 " " S3 . 2 1 9 .3 4 6 2 2 0 .3 4 6 0 .1 5 0 6 , 3 2 7 2 0 2 .1292.2-'4. 1'35 .22.45 0. 150 0 29394 294. 294 5

5. 255. 321 256. 321 0.150 .

_ . v~ v ,' ., -, -. -.' " .'< ." .', ....."..".."."-':. -. -. .."..'.'-" , ..". ." -" ." . .. -;,-."."-" ,. -...',."."-'.% ,'--"-.-': .':-." ".. -A",,.t' m. " ', .,"." % " * . * % " % ° " . ."." . " ".' . .".% "." %_ , . . "." % . % .".% " .32- w%

Page 42: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

A45

1024"

i I I I I ME

520C 3 j0

ird BE G IN END T IMDE ,,,,

IiSS IIkS S REOUEST 2291.9295 ,. . - 0. 15. "1. 219. 346 22 .346 O. 156 2 . 294 2-4. 0.150

-- :' 325. 271 -N. -

1 .:345 222.345 0.150 "3 '. 2 27. 1 532,,2. 2254. 0. 150 . I27

_ t6. - , 1,-.. 0 5 .,.,.. 2...1 256.3217 3.150 2.20 3927 .5 " -

-,5 1 ,- -,9• :3.3o. 29 0. 150

A5 6

5. 325.71 32627- 0.-Cr-__-

.. 253 -2 E. 1 2 0.-1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ " 2( I l I I ! 1 IA..'.-

I. BEGIN END TIME 7.,7.J. 271 326 0.150.MAi~SS MAlSS REQUEST ... 327. I- 70 5

1 . 2 5 3 • 32 2 2 5 4 .3 2 2 0 15 0 P7 . A":' .I . . 5,5. 2 13 ' . 1 3 3 0 . ? E -9 O , 1 0 : .7 ..

2 .2 5 .3 1 2 5 6 .3 *2 1 0 .1 5 0 8 . 3 9 " " "

3. 287.298 288.298 .. 357.249 3,58. 249 0.150

4. ,89.29 , 290.297 0.150 i. ab .48 3E0.248 0..150...311 31. 246 K2, 2.4 0.150

33

Page 43: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

A6 7

T- I t

lHT BEGIN END TIME 5. '35 8.24 9 359.248 0. 150MA S MHSS REQUEST 6. 359.248 360. 248 0. 150

1. 84 2.298 268.2'498 0.150 7. 3 61 .246 362.24 0. 1501,3328.297 290. 297 0.150 8. 362. 247 363.246 0. 150

4. 35.49 358.249 0.150o lo. 3 95.2d. A . 22 0.150

A8 7

2 Cl 300 400 500

11Td BECIN END TIMlE 4. 335.222" 396.223 0.150# MASS MAS~S REQUEST 5. 425. 201 426.202 0.150

1. 178.375 179.275 0.15 6. 427.,200 428.200 0.1502. 391.225 332. 226 0.150 7. 429. 199 430.199 0.150

3. 393.224 394.224 0.150 S. 431.197 432.197 0.150I

34

~i: ; ;2 ~ K j ~ ~ ~ ": .( <' ~ " .* *5 . (

Page 44: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

APPENDIX B

MASS SPECTRA OF SELECTED PCB's

.- .

• 4

35

-~~~~N NC~ I *.N4

%*. - %

Page 45: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

1- 8

100- 188 22400

1, I'-BIPHENYL- 2-CHLORO-

p.3

.". 152

z 50-

z

7651 63

87 14 3 12668 1 .8j- 1 136 1 162 173

60 80 100 120 140 160 180M/Z

100- 222 14736

1, I'-BIPHENYL, 3,3'-DICHLORO

152

." I-z 50-w

75

50 936 87 12 186

WL 12136 160 207

60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220M/Z

36

e -)I

Page 46: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

100- 258 1254

1,1' - BIPHENYL 2,3',5-TRICHLORO

Z50-

I-.

150

.- 5062 793 110 220 ij 22 107 196 20SL

L P'50 100 150 200 250

M/Z

100 29 719

1, 1'-BIPHENYL 2,2', 5,6'-TETRACHLORO

220

cnn

Z185

~z

0110 150 1859

18I5~ii~.Ii ~ i159~.17 205 '"I%511 711

""1

50 100 150 200 250 300M/Z

37

, 4.1o . .:',L,, :. 2:Z.'. , :y: : ;'.:-. :;;::- *z .,2 *-"-:' --:.,'-: :-"..* .: . ;:.:":::.::, ,N G ,

Page 47: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

100- 912

1,1'-BIPHENYL 2,2',4,4', 5-PENTACHLORO

z 50-

- 184 .184:Kol..... .....fa,

' I ' 1 I ' ' I ' I '

60 80 100 120 140 160 180M/Z

100- 3912

-

5254Z 50w4 218 291

""194 2)04 Ilo I a- -tI I ' I ' I I ' I I

200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340M/Z

100- 613

- 1, I'-BIPHENYL 2, 2', 3,4', 5,5' HEXACHLORO

z 50-

74 8,5 110 144 181 "-69179M 92 1.2,2 13414 158 193 207J

80 100 120 140 160 180 200M/Z

360l100- 60 -613

~290I- -

z

253 325230 ,,.,,

220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360M/Z

38,

-I--. , z ' , " - f - - 4' , . -, . . t ,' --. ",.' . . . . .,. -' . . - . ' . . ' . ,:.

Page 48: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

. 100- -138

I, '-BIPHENYL 2,2', 3,4,5, 5', 6 HEPTACHLORO

50-

M/Z

100- 324 3 138

LLz5- 252 359

287TI 281

240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400

M/Z

1004 317-1, '-BIPHENYL 2, 2', 3,3', 4.,5',6,6'

I."-

* OCTACHLOROz 50-

i-

Th 73 97 144 10 216 "

. ,z 10- 25079"!

4 80132 193 .&-h Ol 1 .1 h15 .,203 <

60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240M/Z

100- - 317

.4W_ 288 41 0r-z 509z 393

265282 325

260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440M/Z

39 "'a

-1f,'1' A 2' 7. d

Page 49: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

- 00- -82!-\

0 1,1 -BIPHENYL 2,2',3,3',4,4 ,5,5 ,671t ~ .. NONACHLORO

z 50- 8L0 85 191209

81 96o 144 181925108 161

1 .115.125 1 7 231 267

100 150 200 250M/Z

100-- 821001322 394 82

464>" 322

I-z 50-

.... -- 282429

300 350 400 450M/Z

100 214 46I, 1'-BIPHENYL 2, 213,3,94t4',24

55,6,6 DECACHLORO

z 50- 96 193S 73z 144l,.11 107 43 17L

iii ,117, 1391153'II T ' I ,%

100 150 200 250M/Z

100- -46

_ 356 498498.428

wz 50"

I. - I I I I , I I ' II I I

300 350 400 450 500~M/Z

40

,,.j " ', p. , . .. . *. . . ,*..* .., . * **5. . S I. .. % % . i .

Page 50: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

REFERENCES

1. O.Hutzinger, S.Safe, and V.Zitco, "The Chemistry of PCBs", CRCPress,Cleveland, Ohio, 1974.

". Halogenated Biphenyls, Terphenyls, Naphthalenes, Dibenzodioxinsand Related Products; Topics in Environmental Health", Vol.4,R.D.Kimbrough editor, Elsevier-North Holland, New York, N.Y.,1980.

3. The Canada Gazette, Part 1, pg. 9238, Dec. 11, 1982.

4. Federal Register, Vol. 44, 31514, 1979.

5. A.L.Alford-Stevens, W.L.Budde, and T.A.Bellar, Anal, Cher-., 57,2452, 1985.

6. M.P.Brown, M.B.Werner, R.J.Sloan, and K.W.Simpson, Environ. S-i.Teho. 19, 656, 1985.

7. D.A.Becker, National Bureau of Standards Special Publication 674,July 1984.

8. S.P.Levine, M.T.Homsher, and J.A.Sullivan, Journal ofChromatography, 257, 255, 1983.

9. J.D.Jung, Electrical/Electronics Insulation Conference

Proceedings, IEEE, 1981.

10. G.A.Gauger,IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems, Vol.PAS -101, July 1982.

11. J.McLachlan, "Theory of Application of Mathieu Equations",Oxford, 1947.

12. J.E.Gebhart, T.L.Hayes, A.L.Alford-Stevens, and W.L.Budde, Anal,Ch., 57, 2456, 1985.

41

r, %% % I

Page 51: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

Unclassified

DOCUMENT CONTROL DATA -A(%-IS' t¥ ci.,I.cton p1 io at body of aboliact and ndeing annoIation nosot be entered wI lafI O ova*Ill doaamesl so clawmasIoo

1ORIGINATING ACTIVITY 2. DOCUMENT SECURITY CLASSIFICATION

Unclassified2b GROUP

Defence Research Establishment Atlantic 2GRU

3 DOCUMENT TITLE

Optimization of the Finnigan MAT 5100 Capillary Gas Chromatograph-Mass Spectrometer for the Analysis of Polychlorinated Biphenyls -

4 DESCRIPTIVE NOTES (TVps of ,.post and Uic1gisV dai

S AUTIOR(SI Liii nane. foft name., middle initial)

J.A. Hiltz and J.J. Power .4

6 DOCUMENT DATE 7&. TOTAL NO. OF PAGES Th NO. OF REFSNovember 1986 48 1 12

ss, PROJECT OR GRANT NO. 9 ORIGINATOR'S DOCUMENT NUMBERIS) ,44

% .'6

DREA Technical Memorandum 86/222

8bE CONTRACT NO. 9b, OTHER DOCUMENT NO.(S) (Any othe nu stt may beaugnasswd ts document)

10 DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT

Unlimited Distribution

11 SU.PPLEMENTARY NOTES 12. SPONSORING ACTIVITY

Defence Research Establishment (A)

13 ABSTRACT

The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with aquadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is followedby the description of the optimization of a Finnigan MAT 5100 gaschromatograph-mass spectrometer-data system (GC/MS/DS) for thedetection and identification of PCBs. In particular, the effects of

increasing electron multiplier voltage and the use of multiple ion detectior .(MID) scan sequences on the sensitivity of the quadrupole mass spectrometer 4%

are investigated. Both increasing the electron multiplier voltage and theuse of specialized MID scan sequences were found to result in an improveddetector response.

434

4.J -.

% %43 "'

*.,.. ... ,. ... . -... 4-.-- : • • . .. --- . - - . . , • .. , - .. . . .. . . . . -'- -. . . -. . . .,...;..* %,,,",- 4," * 4 /" " . 4--""," K-a .4K', 4,, .- "."- .- .. ,"rKi '..'', 4 .- . '. ",'. , . . . ... """" "" .' -" " ."" " " '' - " - '---' ,..% ., .- . . . .."" " "" - . "

%.* C ( C y 4 . . ~ *.*,,4~. K~ ~~ ~- f** ~ ( * -

Page 52: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

UnclassifiedSecurity clossofIcali,;n

KEY WORDS

polychlorinated biphenyls %PCBsdetectioncapillary gas chromatographquadrupole mass spectrometersensit ivity

INSTRUCTIONS

IORIGINATING ACTIVITY Enter the name and address of the 9b. OTHER DOCUMENT NUMBER(S). If the document has beenorganization issuing the document. assigned anv other document numbers lfether by the originator

or by the sponsor). also enter this numbeejl.2,DOCUMENT SECURITY CLASSIFICATION Enter the overall

sectirity ciasstrlcation of the document including special warning 10. DISTRIB3UTION STATEMENT: Enter any limitations ontermt whenever appilicable, further dissemination of the documntt Othe then thoue imposed

by secuarity classification, using standard statements such as:2b. GROUP Enter security reclassification group number. The three

protius are defined in Appendix MWof the ORB Security Regulations. (1) -Qualified requestert may obtain copies of thisdocument from their defence documentation center."

3. D)OCUMENT TITLE. Enter the complete document titler in allcioital letters Title% in all cases should be unclassified. If a 12) "Announcement and dissemination of this documentsufficiently descriptive title cannot be selected without classils- is not authorized without prior approval fromcatron, %how title clasiication with ste usual one-capital-letter originating activity."abitweviation in parentheses immediately following the title.

-S11i. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES: Use for additional explanatory.-5.4 DESCRIPTIVE NOTES. Enter the category of document. e.g. note,.

trchmical report, technical note or technical letter. if appropri.ale, enter ts. tYoe of document. eg. interim, progress, 12. SPONSORING ACTIVITY: Enter the namne of the departmentalsummery, annual or final. Give ste inclusive dates when a project office or laboratory sponsoring the roerch andspecific reporting period is covered, development. Include addresa.

5, AUTHOR(S): Enter the name(s) of authorf ml as shown on or 13. ABSTRACT: Enter an abstract giving a brief end factualin the document. Enter last name. lirst name, middle initial. summary of the document, even though it may also appearIf military. show rank. The nme of the principal author is en elsewhere in the body of the document itself. It so highlyabsolute Minimum requirement. desirable that the abstract of clailied documents be unclosi-

is fed.Each paragraph ofthe abstract "hal end with an6 DOCUMENT DATE: Enter the dale (month, year) of indication of the security classification of the InformatIon

Establishment approval f or publication of the document. In the paragraph (unlesso the document itself is unclassified)represented as ITS), (S). IC), (R). or (U).

7a TOTAL NUMB3ER OF PAGES The total page count shouldfollow normal pagination procedures. i.e.. enter the number The length of the abstract should be lmited to 20 sengle-spacedof pages containing information standard typeswitten lines; 7%A inches long.

?b N' :VBEA OF REFERENCES Enter the total number of 14. K EY WORDS: Kay words wre technically meanringfulf toers orrefren'ces claed see lhS document. itsort phrases that characterize a document and could be helpful

ins cataloging the document. Key words should be selected soBa PROJECT OR GRANT NUMBER If appropriate, enter the that no security classification is required. Identifiers, such as

Av,lcable iese.,rch and development project or grant number equipment model designation, trade nme,. Military Project codeunder Wich the document was written. neamre, geographic location. may be used as key wordels but will

8b. CONTRACT NUMBER if appropriate, enter the applicable be loltosee by en indication of technical contest. '

nuitber under which the documlet sees written.

fi ORIG NATOR'S DOCUMENT NUMBERISI Enter ther I Il r Ilcumaet nunther by which the document wvill be,dlrrifoi,,t and controlled by she owigmnatng activity. This

s -number must be unique to this documnt.

44

*J. e ".6r %

ir*55%

is " is. % . ~ * *isis*~~$ ~

Page 53: OPTIMIZATION OF NAT CAPILLARY GAS 1' LIILTZ IIImom · The basis of operation of a capillary gas chromatograph with a quadrupole mass spectrometer as a detector is reviewed. This is

Lv eu L~uUV -ut-s C. v-v I.-. -

I0

C

-.4

4'4'

* - 4

'S

'N'N

.5.

"S..N.

.4.

.p. , NVI *5.5dm. .4., -~

4%.

"'.4',4.5~

4

~1%a N

4.'.

* V V --.- ~'sY ~ *~ . ~ ~ ~ ~

-' "'S ~ .,~-.s..