56
1 Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria Josffa Ismail Malaysia Productivity Corporation Northern Region Office 28 February 2017

Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

  • Upload
    voxuyen

  • View
    217

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

1

Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE

Criteria

Josffa Ismail

Malaysia Productivity Corporation

Northern Region Office

28 February 2017

Page 2: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

2

CONTENT BACKGROUND ON MPC & JOURNEY 1

TEAM EXCELLENCE AWARDS 3

CONVENTION INFORMATION 4

• CRITERIA

• AWARD

WHO SHOULD BE INVOLVED 2

• TECHNICAL PREPARATION

Q & A 5

Page 3: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

1962 2008 1991

Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal Government with lLO as the executing agency

National Productivity Council (Incorporation) Act No.19 amended as the National Productivity Corporation

National

Productivi

ty Centre

National

Productivity

Corporation

Malaysia

Productivity

Corporation

Introduction

The new name Malaysia Productivity Corporation was gazetted on 21st February 2008

3

Page 4: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

OFFICES

MPC State Office Kota Bharu

MPC Northern Region

Kepala Batas

MPC State Office Kuala Terengganu

MPC East Coast Region Kuantan

MPC HQ Petaling Jaya

MPC PJ8 Petaling Jaya

MPC Southern

Region

Johor Bahru

MPC Sarawak Kuching

MPC Sabah Kota

Kinabalu

4

Page 5: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

The leading organisation in productivity enhancement for global competitiveness and innovation.

To deliver high impact services towards achieving performance excellence through innovation for the

betterment of life.

5

Page 6: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

6

1. Providing value-added information on productivity, quality,

competitiveness and best practices through research activities and

databases

2. Developing human capital and organizational excellence for building

a knowledge-based society through training, systems development

and best practices

3. Conducting review on regulation and promoting Good Regulatory

Practice to create a more competitive business environment

4. Nurturing innovative and creative culture for productivity and

competitiveness through partnership programmes.

Page 7: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

New Zealand

UNIK Australia EU

Singapore Thailand

Indonesia

Taiwan Agensi Inovasi Malaysia

Republic of Korea

LOCAL AND INTERNATIONAL STRATEGIC PARTNERS

7

Page 9: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

TRIZ Teambuilding

Team Excellence

Lean Management

Kaizen / 5S-QE

PLWS

MPC Northern Region Office

Facilities

9

Page 10: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

10

Facilities

10

Page 11: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

11

TEAMBUILDING ACTIVITIES

Page 12: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

TEAM EXCELLENCE INITIATIVES

MPC’s objectives:

Promote TE for continuous improvement,

Equip organizations with a system to address

the twin pillars of incremental improvements

and breakthrough achievements

Recognize excellence in teams

12

Page 13: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

13

1982 Early

1990’s Late

1990’s

2004

onwards

Quality

Control

Product

Improvement

Cross

Functional

Innovation

& Creativity

• Basic

problem

solving

•Production

line

• Extended to

product and

process

improvement

• Participation

extended to

other

personnel on

invitation basis

• Cross functional

participation

• Involvement of

executive and

managerial levels

• Focus on

value creation,

breakthrough

ideas

• New patents

• Bench

marking

Team

Excellence

2015

onwards

• Combination of

‘teamwork’ and

systematics

continuous

improvement

methodologies

• In which the

group is free to

use ‘tools’ and’

techniques’

• To solve and

improve

processes or

services

rendered and

will add value to

stakeholders

Page 14: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

TEAM EXCELLENCE

ICC SIX SIGMA

LEAN TRIZ

5S/QE KAIZEN

MCS/MFCA ADOPTED METHODS

14

Page 15: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

EXPECTED BENEFITS OF ‘TEAM EXCELLENCE’ CONVENTIONS

15

NETWORK

JALINAN

KERJASAMA

LEARN

PEMBELAJARAN

SHARE

PERKONGSIAN

EVALUATE

PENILAIAN BENCHMARK

PENANDAARASAN

Page 17: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

17

Mini TE Convention

Regional TE Convention

Department / Organisational Convention

ICQCC Convention

National TE Convention (APIC)

9 Convention Classification

Organiser? State

Convention National

Convention

International & Filtering

• IETEX, Singapura •IPQC, Indonesia •Team Excellence, USA

SUK

MPC

•5 streams (Awam, perkhidmatan, perkilangan, E&E, QE/5S) •Awards : Juara keseluruhan, Johan Stream, 10 kumpulan terbaik stream, Anugerah 2/3 bintang.

• Limited to 2 groups/states, 2 groups/ministries

•2 Category : Technical & Management

• Condition : 10 best groups from each stream in APIC

Yes

No

Internal

External

Award : Gold, Silver, Bronze

(Public Sector) Others

• Convention for IPTA • Covention for Libraries • Hari MEKAR Johor Corporation

Ministry/

Award : Gold, Silver, Bronze

Page 18: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

GOING GLOBAL…

18

Page 19: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

GOING GLOBAL…

19

1) International Exposition of Team Excellence (IETEX), Singapore (September 2017)

2) International Convention on QC Circle (ICQCC) rotation by 13 countries – 2017 in Philippines (24-27 Oktober 2017)

3) International Quality and Productivity Convention (IQPC) – 2017 in Indonesia (November 2017)

Page 20: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

20

CONVENTION AWARD

Page 21: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

ANNUAL PRODUCTIVITY & INNOVATIVE

CONFERENCE AND EXPOSITION

(APIC) WINNERS 2016

1. Johan Keseluruhan:

Rapid Rail Sdn. Bhd.

(Team : GTRS)

2. Anugerah Ketua Pengarah:

KPJ Healthcare Berhad

3. Anugerah Pengerusi MPC:

HP Malaysia Manufacturing Sdn. Bhd.

(TEAM : HP Lean Machine) 21

Page 22: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

2016 CATEGORY AWARDS: TE

1. ELECTRICAL/ELECTRONIC SECTOR

1ST : JUMP START

(ST MICROELECTRONICS SDN BHD)

2ND : WARRIORS

(RENESAS SEMICONDUCTOR (M) SDN BHD)

3RD : 7 HEARTS

(FLEXTRONICS SHAH ALAM SDN. BHD.)

22

Page 23: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

2016 CATEGORY AWARDS: TE

1. MANUFACTURING SECTOR

1ST : A’AROMATIC

(PETRONAS PENAPISAN TERENGGANU SB.)

2ND : SPYDER

(MODENAS)

3RD : SPEEDY RATE RECOVERY (S2R)

(PETRONAS CHEMICAL LDPE SDN. BHD.)

23

Page 24: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

2016 CATEGORY AWARDS: TE

1. ELECTRICAL/ELECTRONIC SECTOR

1ST : JUMP START

(ST MICROELECTRONICS SDN BHD)

2ND : WARRIORS

(RENESAS SEMICONDUCTOR (M) SDN BHD)

3RD : 7 HEARTS

(FLEXTRONICS SHAH ALAM SDN. BHD.)

24

Page 25: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

2016 CATEGORY AWARDS: TE

1. SERVICES

1ST : GTRS

(RAPID RAIL SDN BHD)

2ND : BOLDS

(PETRONAS DAGANGAN BERHAD)

3RD : TECHNOVATORS (KL-KUALA SELANGOR EXPRESSWAY BERHAD (LATAR)

25

Page 26: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

2016 CATEGORY AWARDS: TE

1. AWAM

1ST : SAISOKU

(PUSAT KESIHATAN UiTM)

2ND : GENIUS ELEVEN

(KAMPUS KESIHATAN USM)

3RD : GERMINATION 2 (DEWAN BANDARAYA KUALA LUMPUR (DBKL))

26

Page 27: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

2016 CATEGORY AWARDS: QE

1. AWAM

1ST : QE MYSys

(MAJLIS PERBANDARAN AMPANG JAYA)

2ND : X-GO

(INSTITUT LATIHAN PERINDUSTRIAN JITRA)

3RD : PARASITE - EVO

(PUSAT PERUBATAN UKM)

27

Page 28: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

2016 CATEGORY AWARDS: QE

1. SWASTA

1ST : OZONE

(FINISAR MALAYSIA SDN. BHD.)

2ND : TEAM APOTHECARIST

(KPJ DAMANSARA SPECIALIST HOSPITAL)

3RD : DIAMOND

(KPJ AMPANG PUTERI SPECIALIST HOSPITAL)

28

Page 29: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

UNDERSTANDING THE CRITERIA

..and how it aligns with the

story of the project

Transformation. Innovation.Partnership. 29

Page 30: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

MINI & REGIONAL TEAM EXCELLENCE (ICC) CRITERIA

30

No Criteria No. of

subcriteria

Total Scores

I Introduction 2 50

II Project Selection & Definition 3 150

III Improvement Opportunities Analysis 3 250

IV Creative & Innovative Solutions /

Implementation

4 200

V Monitoring & Standardization 4 100

VI Achievement 5 200

VII Presentation 2 50

Total 23 1000

Presentation Time : 20 Minutes

Q&A : Yes (5 minutes)

Page 31: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

1.0 INTRODUCTION

No Criteria Assessment Criteria

1.1

Background of the company

and group. Selection of

group members

(20 points)

Introduction of company- background, location, nature of

business and organizational structure, vision, mission, client

charter, company policy, strategy &

objectives

Introduction of group -members selection are based on

criteria that align to the problem, personal attributes

Project contribution to the overall organizational/

departmental objectives

1.2 Evidence of participation ,

effective communication

among group members and

effective planning

(30 points)

Meetings held regularly with suitable interval and well

structured with ≥95% attendance

Activities are well distributed among group members and

evidence of task executed shown

Evidence of idea generation process shown

Detail explanation on

problem solving methods used and milestone chart output

31

Page 32: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

2.0 PROJECT SELECTION & DEFINITION

No Criteria Assessment Criteria

2.1 The team clearly explained

how and why the project was

selected.

(80 points)

Clear explanation on project selection process and

techniques used which links to organizational goal, customer

input, and stakeholders , supported by appropriate historical

and comparative data.

Clearly explain on impact of the project to the organization’s

goal in terms of cost, image, policy, customer, stakeholders etc.

2.2 The project and

terminologies used were

clearly defined and

explained.

(40 points)

Problem is clearly and systematically defined, supported with

flow chart, photos, models, etc.

All terminologies used were clearly explained and supported

with example, photos, models, glossary etc.

2.3 Target setting was explained

and justified based on

appropriate analysis or

benchmark data/

information.

(30 points)

Clear explanation on target setting process based on

appropriate benchmark.

Stretch target set with strong justification (measurable and

within time-frame and group capability)

32

Page 33: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

3.0 IMPROVEMENT OPPORTUNITIES ANALYSIS

No Criteria Assessment Criteria

3.1 Improvement opportunities

were identified based on

sufficient data/ information

which is gathered through

various means and

appropriate tools.

(80 points)

Comprehensive and systematic data/ information gathering

using multiple sources/ tools.

Validity and verification of data established.

Appropriate time frame allocated for data collection.

3.2 Systematic analysis and

evaluation of potential causes

were conducted to identify

root causes with appropriate

use of tools.

(120 points)

There is a systematic and exhaustive attempt to find the

causes of the situation/problem.

The most probable causes were identified through concrete

and logical sequence systematic analysis.

Effective used of tools and graphical presentation to explain

the causes.

Probable root cause identified and supported with relevant

data

33

Page 34: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

3.0 IMPROVEMENT OPPORTUNITIES ANALYSIS

No Criteria Assessment Criteria

3.3 Verification and validation of

selected improvement

opportunities/root causes

were carried out using

various methods.

(50 points)

Improvement opportunities/ root cause were verified using

sufficient references and tools.

Comprehensive evidence of verification for improvement

opportunities/ root cause.

Documents (hard copy) provided to support validation ,

with endorsement by management

34

Page 35: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

4.0 CREATIVE & INNOVATIVE IMPLEMENTATION/SOLUTIONS

No Criteria Assessment Criteria

4.1 The team has identified

various potential creative and

innovative actions/solutions.

(50 points)

Appropriate quality tools and statistical used. Root cause

analysis data were integrated to identify

potential creative and innovative actions/ solutions.

Multiple alternative solution identified

Extensive detail analysis was carried out for each solution

(external benchmark data was highly utilized)

4.2 The team has carefully

evaluated each alternative

solution prior to the final

selection based on

appropriate criteria

(advantages and

disadvantages were

considered).

(70 points)

35

Page 36: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

4.0 CREATIVE & INNOVATIVE IMPLEMENTATION/SOLUTIONS

No Criteria Assessment Criteria

4.3 The team has assessed

the final creative and

innovative solution(s)

against targeted

objectives.

(30 points)

Systematic evaluation with advanced analysis suitable

tools/techniques used to select final creative and innovative action

or solution.

Multiple criteria were used to identify the final creative and

innovative action or solution.

Systematic justification to verify/validate the impact of the

solution on the opportunity for improvement.

Team conducted a pilot tests/experiment to ensure that the

creative and innovative solution(s) selected would eliminate

identified root cause as expected.

Reconciliation of project goal/target was carried out.

4.4 The team has carried out

and implemented

creative and innovative

solution successfully.

(Difficulties/ barriers and

how they were overcome,

if any were explained).

(50 points)

The team worked closely with its stakeholders, involving them in

the implementation of the creative and innovative/ solution and

mitigation actions developed for each area of potential barriers.

Action plan was carried out to solve the anticipated barriers /

difficulties.

A plan to prevent recurrence state & explained.

36

Page 37: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

5.0 MONITORING AND STANDARDIZATION

No Criteria Assessment Criteria

5.1 The team has carried out

a systematic and sufficient

monitoring to ensure the

improvement action is in

place.

(50 points)

Existence of team revision plan and system tracking analysis

sheet.

(Allocation of resources established)

The usage of appropriate tools and techniques. (e.g. Graphical

presentation, control chart, line chart)

Monitoring duration is suitable according to the need of the

project implementation.

Rationale given for any deviation shown.

5.2 The team is able to make

appropriate adjustments

to ensure the

improvement is in place

and maintained

(20 points)

Usage of KPIs, visual and graphical analysis were shown to

support the monitoring activities.

e.g. turnaround time, lead time, PDPC etc.

Documented review process was presented,

e.g. Review timetable, assignment form, management review

minute etc.

Contingency plan was well established

Reconciliation of main objective/target was shown using visual

and graphical tools. 37

Page 38: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

5.0 MONITORING AND STANDARDIZATION

No Criteria Assessment Criteria

5.3 Steps were taken to ensure

that the new procedures

were endorsed, adopted,

documented and shared.

(20 points)

Approved by authority, accepted by all and successfully

disseminated as a new operating procedure

Evidence of approved and implemented as new written

instruction/SOP, instruction manual, evidence of revised

document and letter of endorsement etc were shown.

Measuring criteria was established to gauge under-

standing and usage of the new procedures.

5.4 Actions were taken to

ensure that the new adopted

procedures were

standardized and

maintained.

(10 points)

There is a follow-up action to make sure the SOP is

followed and maintained.

Evidence of written instructions have been adopted and

followed via current status report.

Availability of training schedule to train other staff on new

procedures.

Development of training materials.

Evidence of adoption via minutes of meeting /feedback

report. 38

Page 39: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

6.0 ACHIEVEMENT AND VALUE CREATION

No Criteria Assessment Criteria

6.1 Description of the types and

quantum of achievement and

value creation.

(70 points)

Major improvement of existing process

Uniqueness and have market potential

Achievement was stated with explanation on cost incurred

Additional benefits of the value created were identified,

enumerated and illustrated.

Major impact on company bottom line.

Relating achievement to company’s objectives and

strategies.

6.2 Reconciliation of target and

actual achievement were

made (cost incurred

explained).

(30 points)

6.3 The solution selected is

recognized for its uniqueness

at company/ industry/ national

and international levels.

(40 points)

Achievements and value creation was recognized and

transform to new and best practices shared within the

industry

Impact are shown to be greatly beneficial to company,

industry and national ( with evidence)

39

Page 40: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

6.0 ACHIEVEMENT AND VALUE CREATION

No Criteria Assessment Criteria

6.4 The impacts of the

achievement and value

creation to the environment,

community and team

members was stated.

(30 points)

A positive impact shown of achievement on environmental/

community/social , in line with company strategies.

Evidences of members personal achievement in term of

improve learning/knowledge and career advancement

Benefits were explain, and illustrated using appropriate tools

(e.g. radar chart, questionnaires and checklist).

The team has specific plan to improve its own knowledge,

skills, and team spirit.

6.5 The team provided evidence

of verification and validation

of achievement and value

creation.

(30 points)

Validated achievements and value creation transform to

new and best practices shared within the industry

40

Page 41: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

7.0 PRESENTATION

No Criteria Assessment Criteria

7.1 Well organised presentation

with logical sequence that

conforms to stipulated time.

(30 points)

Presentation in logical and well planned sequence,

informative and within appropriate time allocation

Interesting and creative presentation

7.2 Clear presentation, effective

usage of visual aids and good

public speaking.

(20 points)

Communicate a clear message in a fluent and empathic

manner, especially in creative and innovative way

Presentation aids are effective, enliven and assist listener

Clear voice and correct precise pronunciation of terms.

Speaking style is attentive, confidence and enthusiastic

41

Page 42: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

42

#1 Comparison : QC Story Vs. TE Criteria

QC Story Content No. Criteria (Mini & Regional)

Kenalpasti Masalah /

Problem Identification

1 Pengenalan / Introduction

Definisi & Latar Belakang Masalah /

Problem Background & Definition

2 Pemilihan Projek & Definisi / Project

Selection & Definition

Penetapan Sasaran /

Target Setting

3 Analisis Peluang Penambahbaikan /

Improvement Opportunities Analysis

Analisis

Punca Masalah /

Root Cause Analysis

4 Penyelesaian/Pelaksanaan kreatif dan

Inovatif / Creative & Innovative

Solutions

Cadangan Penyelesaian / 5 Pemantauan & Penyeragaman /

Monitoring & Standardisation

Pelaksanaan / Implementation 6 Pencapaian & Penciptaan Nilai /

Achievement & Value Creation

Pemeriksaan / Checking 7 Persembahan / Presentation

Pemantauan & Penyeragaman /

Monitoring & Standardisation

8

Page 43: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

No MINI & REGIONAL Score APIC Score

1. Pengenalan/ Introduction (2) 50 1. Introduction of Problem (3) 100

2. Pemilihan projek & definisi/

Project Selection & Definition (3)

150 2. Creative & Innovative Final

Solutions (3)

250

3. Analisis Peluang Penambahbaikan/ (3)

Improvement Opportunities Analysis

250 3. Result & Impact of the

Project (4)

280

4. Penyelesaian dan pelaksanaan kreatif

& inovatif / Creative & Innovative

Solutions/ Implementation (4)

200 4. Validation (1) 90

5. Pemantauan & penyeragaman

Monitoring and Standardisation (4)

100 5. Result & Sustainability (1) 130

6. Achievement & Value Creation

Pencapaian & penciptaan nilai (5)

200 6. Lesson Learned &

Presentation (4)

150

7. Persembahan/ Presentation (2) 50

No. Subcriteria : No Subcriteria :

Total Score 1000 Total Score: 1000

#2 Comparison :

Mini / Regional Vs. National Criteria

43

Page 44: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

Project Presentation Timeline Mini & Wilayah

Project Presentation

Q & A Session

5mins

20mins

Preparation/Setting Up Time

5mins

Paper Presentation

15mins

Preparation/Setting Up Time

5mins

APIC

44

#3 Comparison :

Page 45: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

45

#4 Comparison: Rating Scale

Meets Criteria

2 Points

Exceeds Expectation

3 Points

Not Covered

0 Point

Unclear

1 Point

APIC

Scale / Scores :

LEMAH / WEAK 1 - 2

SEDERHANA / FAIR 3 - 4

PURATA / AVERAGE 5 - 6

BAIK / GOOD 7 - 8

CEMERLANG / EXCELLENT 9 - 10

Mini & Regional

Note :

Marks = Score x Weightage

Page 46: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

RATING SCALE - What It Means JUDGING

OPTION

SCORE DESCRIPTION

Not Covered

0 Need we say more–just wasn’t addressed–totally missing.

Unclear

1 Touched upon, but not clear. Not enough information is

provided to determine if the team approach met or could

meet the criteria requirements

Meets

Criteria

2 Sufficient information is provided to determine that the

team’s approach met the criteria requirement

Exceeds

Criteria

3 • The team’s approach goes beyond meeting the criteria

and provides additional clarity indicating increased

accuracy in the team’s analysis, actions, and/or

conclusions.

• Integration with other criteria items is apparent and

enhances the team’s overall results.

• A “Best Practice” or “Role Model” approach.

46

Page 47: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

47

Conclusion of Criteria

1. Differences and similarities for both criterias.

2. TE Regional Criteria – harmonised with QC Story;

National TE Criteria – the other way round.

3. Most difference in scoring and weightage :

• Mini / Regional TE :

Improvement Opportunities Anaylysis (250/25%)

• National TE : Result & impact (280/28%)

4. Different scale of rating (1 to 0 & 0 to 3 points)

Page 48: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

48

Criteria Important Tips

• Some subcriteria have relationship / align with other subcriteria.

For example:

• Subcriteria I.2 – III.7

• Subcriteria I.3 – VI.14

• Subcriteria II.5 - III.10

• Subcriteria II.6 – III.8 & III.9

• Words frequently used as starter for subcriteria :

• Identify : 2x; (simple list)

• Describe: 7x; (sufficient information, pembaca mampu mengenal)

• Explain: 4x; (> sufficient information; pembaca bukan setakat

mampu mengenal, malah memahami kegunaan, implikasinya &

ke tahap menggunapakainya)

Page 49: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

NATIONAL TEAM EXCELLENCE CRITERIA

49

I. INTRODUCTION OF PROBLEM (100) Score

1. Describe what, why & how the project was selected. 50

2. Explain how the project supports/aligns with the

organization's goals, performance measures, and/or

strategies.

(Link to III.7)

30

Identify the potential stakeholders (who may be

impacted by the project) and explain how they may be

impacted by the project. (Link to VI.14)

20

Penjelasan : Pemilihan masalah Definisi masalah Latar belakang masalah Sasaran penurunan masalah & justifikasinya Kenapa masalah dipilih

Pelanggan Jabatan Stakeholder Negara

Page 50: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

II. CREATIVE AND INNOVATIVE FINAL SOLUTIONS (250) SCORE

4. Explain how final solution was determined 100

5. Describe the expected benefits by implementing the

solution(s) / improvement action(s). (Link to III.10)

80

Describe the uniqueness of the solution

(Link to III.8 & III.9) 70

50

Penjelasan : Rajah Ishikawa 1 Verifikasi dan Validasi Rajah Isikawa 2 Cadangan Penyelesaian Pelaksanaan Cadangan Jangkaan Faedah Perlaksanaan Cadangan Keunikan cadangan Semakan Target Setting

NATIONAL TEAM EXCELLENCE CRITERIA

Page 51: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

51

III. RESULT AND IMPACT OF THE PROJECT (280) SCORE

7. Explain how the project has contributed to the organisation

and has helped to impact its strategic or operational

performance. (Link to I.2)

120

8. Explain how the results of the project have created spin-off for

other opportunities and/or display continual improvement.

80

Identify the opportunity or prospect of the project to be

commercialized and /or recognised. 50

The impacts and value creation of the project to the

environment and stakeholders. (Link to II.5) 30

Penjelasan : Impak Projek kepada : (link kepada 1.2 dan 1.3)

Pelangan Organisasi Stakeholders Persekitaran

Spin off Projek – multi purpose (pelbagai kegunaan) Peluang Cadangan Perlaksanaan dikomersialkan (validation).

NATIONAL TEAM EXCELLENCE CRITERIA

Page 52: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

IV. VALIDATION (90)

11. Describe the final solution (s)/ improvement action

(s) and explain how the team validated the final

solutions (s)/ improvement action (s).

(Link to II.6)

90

52

Penjelasan : Semua surat penghargaan dan

pengiktirafan yang diterima samada :

Dari dalam organisasi Pihak ketiga

NATIONAL TEAM EXCELLENCE CRITERIA

Page 53: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

53

V. RESULT AND SUSTAINABILITY (130) SCORE

12. Describe the procedure, system, or other changes that

were made to implement the solution(s)/ improvement

action(s) and to sustain the results.

130

Penjelasan : Pemantauan Terhadap Pencapaian projek vs

sasaran penurunan masalah Pembentukan SOP baru atau Perubahan kepada SOP sedia ada Penyeragaman SOP di sebarkan dan diterangkan melalui sesi perkongsian

NATIONAL TEAM EXCELLENCE CRITERIA

Page 54: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

VI. LESSON LEARNED AND PRESENTATION (150)

Describe how lesson learned were identified and

addressed.

30

Describe how the results were shared with stakeholders.

(Link to I.3)

40

15. Well organized presentation with logical sequence that

conforms to stipulated time. 40

16. Clear presentation, effective usage of visual aids and good

public speaking. 40

Penjelasan : Pembelajaran, halangan dan cara mengatasi Penerangan bagaimana projek dikongsikan dengan

stakeholders

54

NATIONAL TEAM EXCELLENCE CRITERIA

Page 55: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

55

MINI CONVENTION ON

TEAM EXCELLENCE WILAYAH

UTARA

DATE PIC

Hotel Ixora, Penang 18 April 2017 [email protected]

04-575 4709

REGIONAL CONVENTION ON

TEAM EXCELLENCE WILAYAH

UTARA

DATE PIC

Batu Feringghi , Penang 15-16 August

2017

[email protected]

04-575 4709

Page 56: Outreach on TEAM EXCELLENCE Criteria - Malaysia …€¦ ·  · 2017-02-27Joint project between the United Nations and the Federal ... (MODENAS) 3RD: SPEEDY RATE ... solution prior

Thanks

for

your

attention!

Malaysia Productivity

Corporation (MPC)

NRO

Tel: 604-575 4709

Fax: 604-575 4410

email: [email protected]

013-356 3732